Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Polity Matters

Polity Matters artwork

100. Happy Birthday

Sep 9, 20251 hr 1 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_10Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters. My name is Ben Ratliff, and I am joined, as always, by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg. Hey guys, how are y'all? Are you there? I am present. We have to kind of play this game a little bit. I mean, I know that a live show is the scariest thing to y'all.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, we need press processing where you don't delete anything that we say.

SPEAKER_10Well, this is lovely. Lovely, lovely, lovely. Um we are are here to celebrate our two-year anniversary, uh, which coincides with our hundredth episode. Uh it it worked out rather well, and we wanted to just have a good time and hang out with all of our friends who have been on the show before. So we're just gonna this'll this will probably be like unlike unlike any episode we've had so far. Um nothing really serious, except we're gonna announce the winners uh of our giveaway, some runners up, and the guy who uh gets away a little bit, I suppose.

SPEAKER_10Um who is gonna walk away with Almquist's commentary. But we have, I think I'm counting eleven guests with us today, which is uh we're we're setting a lot of records, one of which is to have the most guests on one episode. Um let's uh let's try to work through and introduce some of you guys. Uh what I want you to do is tell us a little bit about, you know, just remind us who you are, and maybe remind me which show you were on or when you've been on with us, because I don't remember uh every single time any of any of y'all have come on.

SPEAKER_10Um so we're gonna start off with uh my friend down here, uh Mr. Groff, Reverend Groff, Dr. Groff, I don't remember what your accolades are, but uh why don't you say hello?

SPEAKER_03Hi, I'm Zach. I'm the pastor at Old Antioch Church in Spartanburg County, South Carolina, uh, which is pretty close to Grainville. And um I was on an episode of Polity Matters, and it was uh it was a good discussion about something in the Book of Church Order, and I really enjoyed it. It was very memorable.

SPEAKER_11Vows, you were on for vows.

SPEAKER_03I'll take your word for it. That sounds right. Thanks, Jared. You're the man.

SPEAKER_10Um uh Jared or Scott, I need y'all to take over for just a second, okay? Sorry.

SPEAKER_11So, Zach.

SPEAKER_10Introduce the rest of these guys.

SPEAKER_11Oh, okay. I'll I'll go to the next one on my feed, and that would be uh Mr. Steve Dowling. Uh I wonder if you can introduce yourself and if you could remind us of uh where you're at.

SPEAKER_13Yeah, I'm in southeast Alabama, Jared, uh, both the Presbyterian and and geographically, and at uh Covenant Presbyterian Church in Auburn, Alabama. Um I have been on several episodes, two of them related to going through the BCO last year, earlier this year, I think. Um so appreciate the show.

SPEAKER_11I'm glad to be here. Very good. Uh next I have up uh Josh Torrey. Do you want to introduce yourself where you're at? Rolling Elder, teaching elder.

SPEAKER_14Yeah, rolling elder Josh Vatory here in Boston, Texas.

SPEAKER_11This is going well so far.

SPEAKER_14I'm unmiced right now. There you go. All right, rolling elder Josh Vatory in Austin, Texas. Um, I don't remember what I was on your show for. It just says Polity Matters recording. So I assume it was one of the BCO episodes, but uh I don't know at this point.

SPEAKER_11Very good. All right, Ryan. Uh Ryan has a steel trap mind. And so Ryan can remind us uh when he was on uh and what he talked about other than trains.

SPEAKER_05I was on, yeah, Ryan Beasy. I am in Tennessee Valley Presbytery, which is neither in Tennessee um nor really a valley. Um I'm in the hills of Northwest Georgia, um but not Northwest Georgia Presbytery. Uh there's so there's there's hope, there's something to hope for. Um but uh I I was on uh one time and uh kind of like uh the clown who comes to your kid's birthday party every year. I come on the Polity Matters birthday shows because I know nothing about um polity, and I'm simply an absolute clown, according to Zach Groff.

SPEAKER_11True. Always a good quality to have in the clerk of a presbytery is not knowing anything about polity. So thank you for that. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_05You know, we we aspire to something. It can be the superlative as as in the worst.

SPEAKER_11There you go. Thomas Rickard or Rickard. Can you can you correct everybody's pronunciation because everybody has pronounced it wrong?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's uh Thomas Rickard. I I think that maybe we should have a DA.

SPEAKER_11Just there we go. Is that better? I'll just introduce him. So uh Thomas um is in one of the Presbyteries of the PCA, uh pastoring one of the churches, um, and was known for coming on for the second most uh watched uh RPR episode. Are you still there, Thomas?

SPEAKER_13I'm not sure what's going on from where you're driving there, but I could hear I could hear him pong.

SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah, I could hear him and and A-OK.

SPEAKER_02Well, I don't know what else to say. I was just gonna say, I think we should have a vote at GA to be able to work out how to pronounce my last name. It's apparently very difficult, so just uh let people do that. But yeah, I was on uh the fun and exciting episode about RPR that um, you know, no one was excited about.

SPEAKER_03Pretty sure there's a guy in West Virginia pretty excited about RPR.

SPEAKER_11Yeah. You you would be surprised. Um there might be some more about that later. So um how about Fred Greco? You wanna you wanna introduce yourself? Uh when have you been on?

SPEAKER_12Sure. I'm uh I'm Fred Greco. I'm the senior pastor at Christ Church in Katy, Texas, which is West Houston. Um you'd have to tell me, Jared, I've got to be near most frequent guest with Tipton and Guy Waters. Um most recently I just did BCO 39 and uh BCO 40. So I've done a bunch of the BCO shows uh with y'all. Um enjoy doing that, enjoy having my uh my daily devotions in my brand new beautiful blue leather BCO binder.

SPEAKER_11Very nice, very nice. And you can have that um you gift that to people if they ask, is that right? No. I think you can contact Cherry Hill if you want to get one done for yourself. So that's correct. That's correct. All the all the cool kids have the leather ones, right, Matt. I think Jeremy Bird has one too.

SPEAKER_00There you go. That's there we go. Sorry.

SPEAKER_11Matt Bradley, do you want to introduce yourself since you've been invoked here?

SPEAKER_00Since I've been called upon. Matt Bradley, teaching elder in the Nashville Presbytery, pastor at All Saints Presbyterian Church in Brentwood, Tennessee. And living proof that you can buy your way onto the show. Uh, I was a guest because I brought the recording equipment to the special Twin Lakes recording. Uh, I think we were talking about church planting on that episode. It's my guess. But uh, whatever it was.

SPEAKER_11Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Glad to bring it, thank you.

SPEAKER_11Very good. Uh Jason, would you like to introduce yourself and how did how did you come on to the uh Polity Matters?

SPEAKER_08I'm pretty sure my my connection is just that Matt is my oldest friend in the world and Fred is my loudest friend in the world, and that's how I'm connected. Uh the two previous guys, uh Jason Lopoulos, senior pastor, uh University Reformed Church in East Lansing, Michigan. And uh Jared, I don't know uh how many times I've been on. I do remember the last time, uh, I think this was Polity Matters, right? When you interviewed Mel and I about Paul Settle. And um, so we got uh that was and out of all the podcasts I've had the opportunity to do that, that's by far one of my favorite to do.

SPEAKER_08Just talk about Paul and the great ministry that he had and the great life that he lived and the great impact upon the PCA. So that was just a delightful conversation with you and Mel.

SPEAKER_11Yeah, that was that was one of my favorites too. So no offense to anybody else. All right. Um, Ben, would you like to introduce yourself?

SPEAKER_01Sure. Ben Coppers. I'm the pastor of All Saints Reformed Church, not in Brentwood, but in St. George, Utah. I'm part of the Northern California Presbyterian. And I was your token evangelist. We talked about uh church planters you brought me in. So that was uh that's been my claim to fame. And you somebody just mentioned Cherry Hill, and uh he reached out to me because he'd been listening to your podcast and said, wow, they they are all jealous of your evangelist powers.

SPEAKER_01And so I've I've uh uh that's my reputation, and uh I appreciate having a chance to talk about it on the show.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, you know that uh Fred Greco actually said that your evangelist powers were illegitimate, uh, and that it was an inappropriate application of it, but maybe that's for a different day.

SPEAKER_01I remember Fred saying multiple times that I am the only person that he knows of who would fit that category. Am I right, Fred? Yep.

SPEAKER_08There are a lot of one-of-a-kind people with illegitimate being inappropriate? Yeah, illegitimate powers? The only one that fits that or fits.

SPEAKER_12You had the varsity powers, right, Ben? Not the JV powers, right?

SPEAKER_01Um I think I had JV. We actually just uh got a temporary session here lately. We're getting to be too many folks here to handle as an evangelist. That happened uh, I think just a couple weeks ago. So I I no longer fit. I understand if my uh opportunities to be on the podcast are revoked here pretty soon.

SPEAKER_11All right. Well, uh we get uh I think two more introductions here. Mel, did you want to introduce yourself?

SPEAKER_07Sure. Hey, thanks for being uh having me on tonight. Uh I enjoyed my episode with Jason. Uh participated on an episode regarding removing censures. I'm a ruling elder at Second Presbyterian Church in Greenville, South Carolina, and also Clerk Calvary Presbyterian.

SPEAKER_11All right. Sometimes I don't hear, so I'm gonna assume that everybody heard that. So all right. Uh and then moving on to Jeremy. Do you want to uh introduce yourself and say when you were on? Sure.

SPEAKER_09Yep. Jeremy Byrd, I'm a teaching elder, um, senior pastor at Christchurch PCA in Trustville, Alabama. It's good to be on with y'all. Um, and that's me contextualizing since I'm a Midwestern transplant to Alabama, you throwing in the y'all. Now I will say this too: the reason that Fred even has a blue leather BCO cover is because I went to my good friend at Cherry Hill, Dave Delfino, and said, Hey, could you make me a blue leather BCO cover?

SPEAKER_09And I don't know if Fred's has the PCA logo on it. If it doesn't, it's just a step down. And I was on, let's see, it was chapter five of the BCO on mission churches, so way back at the beginning.

SPEAKER_03And that's appropriate because you serve on the mission to North America Permanent Committee.

SPEAKER_09That is right, as do you.

SPEAKER_03You are right, sir.

SPEAKER_05Which classes of MA are you to? I believe Jeremy.

SPEAKER_03Jeremy is 2026 and I'm 2030. Is that right, Jeremy? Yeah, I think so.

SPEAKER_08High class. High class, right? Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Well, Jerry seems to be lagging behind everybody, and so what I'm going to do uh is throwing his last plan, which was not to ask you any questions about that we have already fed you. And so we are going to go back to that plan. And so I was wondering, perhaps, some of you guys, perhaps more seasoned guys, uh, what were your favorite memories at the General Assembly that you've had?

SPEAKER_04Ever oh, I'm picking on you. What has been your favorite memory of the General Assembly?

SPEAKER_12Who did you call on? Uh Mel Duncan.

SPEAKER_11The muted one who's speaking. The muted one.

SPEAKER_07You know, I've not had this much fun, I just want to say for the record, since I hosted the Miss Greenville High pageant in 1988. I I just think there's just so much talent and beauty around me. I just feel like this is going to be a great night, and I want everyone to celebrate as we come together to make memories tonight. So I just want to go on the record with that. Hey, Mel, did Dorman win in 1988? Dorman always wins, Reverend Groff.

SPEAKER_07I know that County takes its athletics more seriously than Greenville County as you know, and that's a problem. We're working on that. Um yeah, I appreciate the question. Um the the thing that I most love about General Assembly, and probably that I would say uh is a special memory, is the the opening night of worship every year, uh, where you get to be uh with God's people in an intentional way and worship God together, oftentimes in a wonderfully reformed context.

SPEAKER_07And uh and then afterwards enjoyed fellowship. And uh I can't think of a time where I'm not more optimistic than after that Tuesday evening. Um I've been I think I've been to over 30 or 35 of them at this point, and so uh lots of memories with friends like you men on the podcast tonight, uh just reminiscing, reconnecting, being together, uh celebrating the Lord's uh triumphs, and then also the sorrows in life.

SPEAKER_07Um I I have uh memories back to early uh General Assemblies in the 70s. I remember going to Grand Rapids a couple of times. I I remember uh General Assemblies in Macon and Savannah. Uh, but I think the thing that I most enjoy about those GAs are is that opening night together where it feels like we're all on the same team and we haven't squabbled yet, and we're not uh you know germain one another to death, and uh and Fred hasn't had to weigh in and correct us.

SPEAKER_07Um, but uh that that that's how I would begin that, Scott.

SPEAKER_13Was it fair that he answered with a whole category? I mean, is is that fair to everybody else here? I'm not sure.

SPEAKER_11Yeah, I think I think Scott's a t.

SPEAKER_03It was a beautiful statement of the nature of the PCA General Assembly.

SPEAKER_08I'll tell you a couple others that come to mind, Scott. Uh I agree. I mean, the opening night is just wonderful where we're all together and worshiping and taking the Lord's table, and we're hearing the outgoing moderator, which reminds us of the Lord's faithfulness through the year, and uh that yet we're entering another year as a denomination go. But there are two moments that immediately stand out to me that were just impactful. And one was during the Federal Vision debate days and when the Federal Vision Report was hitting the floor.

SPEAKER_08Uh, this was a this was a significant moment in our denomination, and it was something we had to tackle. Uh, and there was good substantive debate on the floor. And, you know, our our denominational leaders over its history, especially over the last 20 or so years, have been very careful about when they weigh into discussions and when they don't. And I think that's good for the denomination. But when R. C. Sprohl got up at that General Assembly and made a statement uh and really called the Assembly to account, uh, that was no small thing.

SPEAKER_08And it was it was a a tide kind of changing thing in in that General Assembly, and I think was an important moment, an important moment for our denomination. The other was uh was another leader in the denomination was when we had the the racial reconciliation report, and former senior pastor, first Frez Jackson, Jim Baird, got up and made a personal statement and asked for forgiveness for his lack of leading how he thought he should have led during the 1960s.

SPEAKER_08And it was a maybe one of the most grippy moments I've experienced at General Assembly, where a man, an older saint that was res is respected and was respected, uh, was confessing before the assembly and asking for the forgiveness of his brothers and just modeling by example what it looks like to continue hard after Christ in old age. And it was a great encouragement to my soul. I think it was a great encouragement to the denomination that night, and it it carried on.

SPEAKER_08Uh that that has continued to impact an awful lot of us that were there for that moment. So those two especially stand out to me.

SPEAKER_04Not everyone here is a long-seasoned Scottish Presbyterian. Some of us come from the Dutch tradition. Uh, Ben, what was perhaps the most striking thing when you transitioned from being a Dutchman, your wooden clogs for your Scottish kilt? Uh, what was the most surprising thing when you attended your first General Assembly?

SPEAKER_01A Dutchman never trades in his wooden shoes. You can't transition out of being a Dutchman. That's not how that works. But when I was engrafted into the uh tree of Presbyterianism, uh for me it was leaving the mainline church. And so coming into the General Assembly, I think I was my first kind of feeling was wow, I actually belong here. It was a sense of wow, these people were actually Christians. They're all Christians.

SPEAKER_01Like what a that was such a huge relief to walk into a place where you know we disagree around the margins, but you know, you have the heart of the gospel in common. Um, that's kind of it's always colored my perception of the PCA and gives some perspective to our squabbles. It's like these are these are intramural discussions. Uh the stuff that I grew up with and was used to, that was you were arguing about the core of the gospel. And so for me, coming into my first assembly, second assembly was just a sense of relief that this is a this is a place where Christians, where men can come and really embrace the gospel together.

SPEAKER_04Thanks, Ben. Uh moving on, perhaps, to uh maybe not your favorite moment. Have you what was perhaps the funniest thing? Presbyterians are not often known for being funny or jovial often, but what is the funniest thing you've ever seen on the floor of your Presbytery? Or maybe a past Presbytery if you don't want to, you know, throw anyone too soon under the bus.

SPEAKER_08Can we actually do one from General Assembly?

SPEAKER_04You may.

SPEAKER_08Matt Bradley's number I'm going, Matt, why don't you tell the story of what showed up on the screen at that General Assembly in Louisville?

SPEAKER_00That's not the moment I had in mind, but I know which one you're talking about, and I'll tell that quickly. But my favorite moment was Fred Greco being corrected on a question of Robert's rules at the assembly. That was absolutely one of the finest and funniest moments. Uh but uh but maybe the funniest thing that's ever happened at an assembly that I was in attendance at was when um the uh What was what was the organization's name, Jason? Uh Biologos.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, yeah, Biologos, who many of you will remember was trying to uh uh make space within Orthodoxy and the church for a uh atheistic evolutionary view. And they came to the assembly, and uh the assembly, this was Louisville, wasn't it? It was it was Louisville because uh as one of the assembly uh sort of fun things to do for families on the side, they did a tour of the uh the ark. If you guys have ever heard, you know, they've got the creation museum and the ark experience up here in Kentucky, and uh and on the big screen in the assembly hall, it announced that if you were you were participating in the tour, they would be meeting at the Bio Logos booth.

SPEAKER_00Uh there at the assembly. I thought that was fantastic. Yeah, I don't know how many were on the tour. I hope it was a hundred, but they all gathered at the Bio Logos booth.

SPEAKER_04I think one of my favorite events, or what I thought was the funniest uh discussion at General Assembly, was a few years ago. I'm only a a newly minted Presbyterian minister, and so I have not I only have recent memory. Um was during a minority report where the minority report used capitals, all capital font and bold face typeface. And I remember there being a point of order of trying to rule the report um out of order because of intemperate fonts.

SPEAKER_04And I remember that the minority speaker was uh told by the moderator at the time, I can't remember who it was, uh maybe Howie, uh, to rein it in, let's try to keep it temperate. And then uh smoke in mirrors was said from the mic, and we had to have go to a clicker vote on whether to throw out the whole minority report. And the minority report, I think, was saved by a margin of 4% votes. And so I thought, man, this is just already started on a bad foot for the minority of that.

SPEAKER_04It almost got rolled out of order in its entirety because of font choices. And so that that's about as funny as it gets, I think, for Presbyterians uh on the assembly floor.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, that was pretty good.

SPEAKER_05We did get to sing a psalm as the speaker for the minority report was uh, I guess, feverishly crossing out uh all caps and bold face in his in his speech, uh, which was an added plus.

SPEAKER_03Um you gotta commend the guy, he kept on going. I mean that's pretty much it.

SPEAKER_04Any other fun uh funny events at GA that you experienced.

SPEAKER_03I think it was the first GA I attended. Uh the Committee of Commissioners on Interchurch Relations brought a recommendation to leave the NAE against the permanent committee's recommendation to stay. And I was pretty demoralized when that motion to leave failed about 6040. And then a couple of years later, they made the same exact speech word for word with the same person presenting, and then it it passed 6040.

SPEAKER_03That's probably uh my lowest and highest point ever experienced at GA on the same issue with the same words. It's like deja vu, like Groundhog Day, PCA style.

SPEAKER_05My wife texted me that her favorite moment at GA was when Steve Dowling had a doppelganger and said, handsome devil you know, Ryan, I I looked for him this year and I didn't see him.

SPEAKER_04Perhaps uh going on a more serious note then, um sorry for the delay uh uh guys are experiencing, um, but let's uh perhaps on a more serious note, uh what perhaps are some of the challenges that you see uh in the PCA going forward as it relates to polity? So not necessarily culture issues, but polity issues within the church. What are some things if you had a crystal ball you expect that the PCA will be dealing with from a polity perspective in the next five or so years?

SPEAKER_04We've just gotten out of some controversy, but uh, where do you think we're headed?

SPEAKER_12I think the greatest challenge that we face is not a specific issue, but it is training the next generation to be Presbyterian. Um as I think all of you know, I absolutely delight now in being a grandfather and being old. And I never would have thought that I would have been kind of the old guard. But when I was first in the PCA, that old guard is now all passed on into glory. And so I and others have had to kind of step in the gap, and I'm keenly aware of my own mortality.

SPEAKER_12And uh the PCA is going to thrive as a Presbyterian and Reformed denomination. Young men need to take up the mantle and be Presbyterian. And having said that, I am very encouraged by the young ministers that I see with their desire, you know, to understand polity and to, you know, learn about these things. Uh the this show is a real blessing to a lot of folks. Um and you shouldn't underestimate how important it is because churches struggle with issues of polity.

SPEAKER_12Um, I had three phone calls today on various issues, uh, congregational meetings, rotating sessions, et cetera. And I think what you guys are doing here and what young seminarians are doing is the PCA has a very bright future, but I think we need to really lean into that.

SPEAKER_11I I know I'm one of the hosts, and hopefully nobody else is talking with the delay, but um I I think I've been most encouraged by two people that I see um that I think have blazed a trail for some of this, which is uh for some of the way that we approach polity and approach discussion, which is uh Fred Greco and Howie Donahoe. Um the I think in the past, when I first came in a little over a decade ago, there was a lot of we can't talk about this, or a lot of you have to be in your in your groups and you can't hash it out and be friends.

SPEAKER_11And uh one of the things that I've seen from from Fred and Howie is an ability to disagree but still be friends, and even to disagree in serious matters and fight for your case, and at the end of it say, but we're still in the same denomination, we're still friends. And I think that has given a bit of a different it's not that you disengage from a debate or that you are just upset and you walk away, um, or that you fight and you can't be friends, but I think um the future looks bright if we can have serious debates and discussions and still be friends at the end of it.

SPEAKER_11And so for me, that's that's the most hopeful thing that I've seen. Uh and a challenge will be to keep that going, uh, to be able to debate, disagree, and still be at the same table.

SPEAKER_03I think that one issue that that might come up with the other.

SPEAKER_11Well, I might be the only uh the host, only host left here, because I think Scott left. Um Ben had to leave for uh family uh issue, and uh I think uh for those that know know what's going on there, and so you can be in prayer for uh for them, uh for uh Ben's family. Um I actually have something here that I don't know how it's gonna work, especially with the delay, but uh this will also help tell me how long the delay is. Put your hand in front of your um your screen if you are interested in getting a trivia question related to polity matters.

SPEAKER_11Um so uh whether it's uh it'll be either on the hosts or on the guests or on the episodes, uh, but raise your hand and keep it up there if you are interested in getting a trivia question. It's trivia roulette, and so you'll pick a number and then I will ask you a question here. So I see Fred, I see Tori, I see Beezy. Anyone else that is uh that is brave here? All right. A hundred episodes is a lot of episodes, Jared.

SPEAKER_11Well, some of this will just be do you know us? So um three hosts with a lot of hosts, Jared. Yeah, well, probably the person that that knows uh I think uh Ryan's listened to more of our episodes than we have as a host. So I'm gonna ask Ryan first. Um you can pick a number between one and um I'll just do one and eleven, and uh I'm gonna ask you a question that has to do with either the hosts, the guests, or uh the episodes based on the number that you choose, and uh see if you can answer it correctly.

SPEAKER_11I might give you a couple if if it's easy at first. So give me a number.

SPEAKER_05I'll go with number seven.

SPEAKER_11Number seven. Um we'll see how you do with this one. This will be interesting. Um what hymn is played acoustically at the start of every Polity Matters episode?

SPEAKER_05I have no idea. It's not on a pipe organ.

SPEAKER_11You can only recognize hymns on a pipe organ.

SPEAKER_05Well, no, but I I'm just noting that it is not on a pipe organ. So I mean it's oh true, true.

SPEAKER_11Uh does anyone want to jump in there? Does anybody get the hymn that we play at the beginning? Steve Dowling, I see your hand up.

SPEAKER_13Yeah, I'm not sure, brother, but is it um is it Zach Gruff's uh God bless the PCA? I can't hear him. So my bad.

SPEAKER_03He asked if it was my God bless the PCA song.

SPEAKER_11Uh no, no, it is not. It should be. Do you have any other any other guests that want to guess at that? Nobody knows. It's appropriate. Yes, it's the church's one foundation. Oh, sweet. Bonus points if you know who the artist is playing that. Is it not you?

SPEAKER_11It is me, it's not a good idea. Which was even Curtis Chapman. No, it is me on guitar, which is the funniest uh uh interaction one time I think we had with Brad Isbel, who just ripped on us for really hating our intro music, not knowing that I was the one that actually played it. So um I had that happen to me.

SPEAKER_03It's great. It's wonderful, it's really good. Wait, wait, you you got you guys will like this story. It involves a PCA founding father who's driving to Memphis with Dr. Pipa for the GA, the whatever GA was, and um, and I showed him the parody songs the first time, and his first response was like, Wow, that'd be pretty good if this guy could sing, and I didn't tell him that it was me for like another hour and a half.

SPEAKER_11That's amazing. That is great.

SPEAKER_03He also didn't recognize the songs I was parodying, which was also pretty funny.

SPEAKER_11He doesn't know that new pop music. Yeah. All right. Well, I I think uh Josh Torrey, you also were uh one that said that you would be interested in a trivia question. So this is trivia roulette one to eleven. Pick a number and we can see if you can answer it. If it's a quick one, we'll do two. Three. You might need to hold it up for me to hear you. Three. Three. Okay. Um this is probably an easy one. Uh this is what one of these in fact I'll I'll ask you all three of these.

SPEAKER_11Uh which one of these things about the three co-hosts is not like the other? So which of the three co-hosts is not a northerner? Ben. Yes. How about this? Which one of the three co-hosts uh is not an RTS grad? Scott.

SPEAKER_03Wrong.

SPEAKER_11There you go.

SPEAKER_03That would be me.

SPEAKER_12I don't I don't really like you, Scott. I'm sorry. It's the closet dispensationalist.

SPEAKER_03You went to dispensationalist theological seminary.

SPEAKER_11I went to Dallas Theological Seminary and I have the charts to prove it. Yes. We goodness.

SPEAKER_00Lord bless you. If you guys knew how many Dallas guys they were on this call, you would be shocked.

SPEAKER_11Over under on three.

SPEAKER_04Bunch of fundamentalists.

SPEAKER_11They're good on my last one. Uh, which one of these three co-hosts is not like the other, which is not a member of their candidates and credentials committee? That's Scott. That's Scott, yes. So there you go. So two out of three. All right. Um, Fred, uh, you have to beat uh that. So uh do you have a number that you want to choose to do trivia roulette? About five.

SPEAKER_11Five. I think you're gonna get this. Um which two regular guests of Polity Matters have served in the Marines? That would be Steve Dowling and Steve Tipton. It is something about Steve that you're required to serve on the Marines. Uh yes. Um I give you another one. That was a little bit too easy. Do you wanna do you wanna guess another number? Four. Okay, this is uh something we've never talked about on the show, but is you can maybe guess it.

SPEAKER_11Uh Steve Tipton and myself actually talked about doing uh some sort of a polity show uh in the past about three or four years ago, and we wanted to call it Polity Matters. But Scott and Ben actually came up with the exact same title. Um how did they come up with the exact same title independently? Think Scott.

SPEAKER_12I don't know, Scott's a fan a fan of the show Family Matters? I don't know.

SPEAKER_11Scott, do you want to tell us how?

SPEAKER_04The the name of Polity Matters came into existence when ChatGPT was in its like 2.0 stage, and I asked what are some great podcast names uh for the for a polity-centered podcast. Uh because Ben wanted to call the the podcast when we first were talking about it BYOBCO. Uh, and I just thought uh that doesn't really work right, and so we have to have something better than that. And because if we have BYO BCO, we can't talk about anything but the BCO.

SPEAKER_04And so I convinced him that ChatGPT is more creative than us, and that's how we ended up with this title. I don't think I've ever talked about that before.

SPEAKER_03Hasn't ChatGPT also now composed at least one or two overtures that have been before the assembly?

SPEAKER_04Oh, yeah. I think that cannot confirm nor deny that.

SPEAKER_11Yeah. We we maybe need an overture on it.

SPEAKER_04And so now everything's foundations matter, everything matters.

SPEAKER_03And your third child is Mary Matters, right? Chat GPT, name my next kid. Kids matter.

SPEAKER_11Boom. Very nice, very nice.

SPEAKER_03Hey, I I kind of want to pitch this question to the group. I'm not the host, but it's a serious question. What's the over-under on us getting a UFO overture this year? Well, if you write it, it's there. Nah, my Presbytery doesn't care about UFOs, but I might could get Bigfoot through.

SPEAKER_05You can always have your sessions.

SPEAKER_04I would love to see a I'd love to see an overture signed by Melton Duncan about UFOs and Bigfoot.

SPEAKER_05He would too. You get voted down and then not attested by Melton Duncan.

SPEAKER_11Well, um, for those that don't know, last year we had 50 overtures, and there was rumors of one that was out there that was possibly going to come through to be overture 51 that was going to ask about some sort of study about um extraterrestrials. Uh so uh an overture 51 that has to deal with extraterrestrials. Uh we'll never have that opportunity again. So um it's a little bit of sadness.

SPEAKER_03Never say that. Never say never, but it would have been great at the 51st General Assembly, too. I mean, come on. You know, and uh go ahead, Fred.

SPEAKER_12Ben could author one. He's in the land of people living on other planets and magic underwear and all of that. So it would be very appropriate for an UFO Mormon slash UFO overture to come from Ben.

SPEAKER_01Straight from the dark side of cemetery or something.

SPEAKER_12There it is.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, he just said something, but you couldn't hear him.

SPEAKER_05I think it was something like Battlestar Galactica.

SPEAKER_11I'm gonna ask one more question just to kind of throw it out there. Um and this is maybe you just giving us content ideas. Um, what is an area of polity that we really need to have a special episode about? And you and extraterrestrials has already been taken. Uh, although how to set up a Presbytery on Mars when Elon gets there, that's mine. I think that would be really interesting. But what what's a what's a uh topic that we need to cover uh on polity matters that we have not thought of before?

SPEAKER_13A serious suggestion. Um, one of the things it actually ties in with the previous question in a way about you know what looming polity matters we have coming at us. The the denomination is getting big and the number of overtures is big, and the way that we deal with them is becoming increasingly cumbersome. So when we deal with things like uh reports from RPR in omnibus, and uh it's it's a first pass correction for presbytery minutes, uh the idea that we're gonna like pull those things out because it was your presbytery, uh, kind of is a waste of time.

SPEAKER_13I mean, the truth is you could just answer it and you could deal with it later if you have to be heard on at the next General Assembly. So we do a lot of little things like that that I know the brothers are not doing because they just maliciously want to do it or because you know it hurt their feelings because it was their presbytery and they take pride in their administrative acumen. But Fred um, I think has actually formed some stuff on things like that, and and it's that's this is not isolated. It's things that that we just sort of do that creates friction in the gears, and then everybody, you know, wants to abbreviate the time that we're together, and sometimes guys get disaffected because we've uh kind of not paid enough attention to the things that are more serious in their minds.

SPEAKER_13So I think you should do an episode, get Fred in there. Fred, I'm not trying to sign you up to more work, you know, just to make you busy. I know you're busy as could possibly be, but I I would like to hear that. I'd like to you to run through some of those things. Uh maybe do it jointly with how we where you know the expertise that you've developed, you could just educate us all better about hey, if you this has no point. You know, I I maybe not I've said this as clearly as I'd like to. Maybe you could help me make that point better, Fred.

SPEAKER_13See, then you're I not only signed him up to do an episode or a series of episodes, I then now put him in a position of having to argue that he ought to do it. Very brilliant if you think about it.

SPEAKER_12Well, that's why Steve's my friend. You know, you can you can tell who my friends are by how uh actively they make fun of me. So that's that's it's a pretty solid way to think about that.

SPEAKER_13Well, I wasn't making fun of you. I really mean that. I think that there are things that we don't know, even if you've done it for five years in a row, you don't really think about some of those things. And you've talked to me about them, Fred. I think they'd be great for an episode. Doesn't sound like I'm selling it, so I'll stop. But you know, the masses out there watching us live, maybe could do that. Button smash.

SPEAKER_08I have two suggestions, Jared. I I don't know what always been covered in a hundred episodes. Uh you guys have covered a lot, no doubt, but there are two that immediately come to mind, and that is one, it I don't know how close we are to it, but there needs to be there's gonna be a long run-up to it. But we're growing as a denomination. We continue to grow. We are taking judicial matters seriously. SJC is overloaded. There is, I think, a growing desire for more substantive debate on some issues.

SPEAKER_08And I think we have to begin discussions of what does it look like to have regional senates and how does that work with General Assembly? And I think that's that's gonna take a long discussion and a lot of discussion, and I think it's a worthy discussion uh for the long term of the PCA. The other is what you guys you just touched on not too uh a couple of questions ago, but or a couple of discussions ago. But one of the huge issues facing us, and none of us have our arms around yet, is AI.

SPEAKER_08And in particular, I'm thinking about it in reference to what's disciplinable regarding a pastor in AI. There are so many different routes uh down that path, and we don't even have our arms around what all this is gonna look like. Nobody does within the next five years. But I sure don't want us playing catch-up on everything regarding this. And it seems like some of this is just gonna require some discussion and some people that know a little bit about this realm.

SPEAKER_08And we need to be able to free up some sessions and presbyteries to begin to weigh in on some of these things with their pastors, and there needs to be discussion in seminaries about this, and uh, we're gonna have to define, no doubt, somewhere in the next five, six, seven years what what's actually allowable and what's actually disciplinable uh in relation to AI for vocational pastoring.

SPEAKER_11So Thomas has his hand raised.

SPEAKER_02I uh I would like to see more um a podcast or two kind of explaining the back end of the biblical basis of why Christ has given his church officers to be able to carry out the work of discipline and particularly how they do that, not merely just in the case-by-case polity sense of working through process, but why is discipline and discipleship so important and has always been like a mark of the church.

SPEAKER_02Um, and why is that why do we do it? And I think that we need to see that important call and uh for pastors as we're to instruct our members required to by the BCO to be able to teach them about the book of discipline, but then also as members, you know, why it is important that a pastor and the session uh carries out that process, uh, because they're not too concerned about uh you per se.

SPEAKER_02They're they're caring about your caring about your soul, and that discipline is how we carry that out, either through formal process or informal process. Um and to be able to see a little bit more of that explained, I think is just a helpful thing for uh people to understand. Uh it's the polity and the principles that we have in the BCO are all there for reason. And um, you know, uh they're biblical principles that we see working out.

SPEAKER_02And I think you do a good job of explaining that, but I'd like to be able to see a little bit more about you know why why do we follow uh a book of discipline or why do we follow um those rules of discipline and and the shepherding heart behind it.

SPEAKER_11Yeah, that's good. Um we we have uh one of our ruling elders that wants to to speak here. So Josh, and what do you got?

SPEAKER_14It it follows up immediately what Thomas just said. Um I'd I'd like to see ruling elders be encouraged uh in ways that they can support their pastors uh in understanding the book, uh specifically in procedural matters, in disciplinary matters. Um we're uh we don't have just one office of of teaching elder here guys. Ruling elders are here to support as well.

SPEAKER_14And and ways that we can encourage and uh uh improve ruling elder participation in the procedural issues that are constantly come towards sessions and presbyteries. I I'd love to see ruling elders encouraged and and educated. Um I think this would be a great uh platform for those things to to fall in line with what Thomas has already said, but specifically with respect to ruling elders.

SPEAKER_11Very good. Jeremy, you had uh a suggestion?

SPEAKER_09Yeah. Um one of the things I would love to see is a greater interest in our polity within our congregations themselves. You know, think of the audience of Polity Matters. You guys probably have a better idea what it is, but it's probably a lot of elders, really, and teaching elders and maybe some seminary guys. I would just love to see a broader interest across the just the average person in the pew.

SPEAKER_09Um, and the reason being is uh, you know, I've noticed that in talking to people, you know, even in my ministry, they just don't understand the importance of polity. To them, it's it's not very important. And really, it's it's pastoral, it's for their good to shepherd them. And um, I don't know what that would look like, how we can I mean Sunday school lessons maybe on polity would be a place to start.

SPEAKER_09Um but I just think even in the PCA, that's something we should think about is how do we communicate the the beauty of our ecclesiology of who we are as Presbyterians, why our system of governance does matter um in a way that just encourages everyone and strengthens us as Presbyterians and as a Church of the Lord Jesus Christ.

SPEAKER_11Good. Um not seeing any other hands that are up that want to uh uh do that, that maybe uh is a segue to talk uh a little bit about some of the feedback that we've gotten. Um we have heard from some people that have uh benefited from listening to Polity Matters. Uh we asked for uh how Polity Matters has um impacted you uh and for our uh giveaway. Uh I just wanted to mention a few just so um everybody can hear.

SPEAKER_11Uh hopefully this is just saying uh what I um uh what encourages us uh to keep going uh for uh this for a little while, at least get through the BCO. Uh we had some interesting uh responses. We don't just have people in the United States that are listening to us. Uh we actually had a ruling elder who and stated clerk serving in a small church in Okinawa, Japan, uh, who was telling us about uh being encouraged and helped uh in uh their um their session, uh Josh uh Diddham's.

SPEAKER_11I'm probably not pronouncing that right. Uh there was a John uh Mastis, who was a ruling elder in Hawaii, who says they now close their session meetings with Psalm 133. Uh there in fact was a uh seminarian's wife uh who wrote in that said as they came into the PCA from independence that they uh now understand our polity uh a lot better uh in that um new ruling elder actually with uh RPCNA roots, Sam Wisely or Wilsley. Um so he said he uh is using the podcast for his nine-month training uh period for his uh elders.

SPEAKER_11Um and uh so we had some other ones. One runner up uh was uh Brad Um Beinemhoff, uh longtime listener, PCA polity enthusiast, uh currently training as a deacon, uh was particularly impacted by the podcast introduction to Thomas Withero, which if um you're going back and you don't want to just listen to the BCO uh chapters, go back and listen to those uh uh podcasts in which we walked through his book, uh The Apostolic Church, which is it. And uh we actually got to talk to Johnny uh Gibson uh before we uh did that, which was uh one of my favorite uh episodes because I'd never met Johnny Gibson, so we got to uh um force a meeting with him uh by having him as a podcast guest.

SPEAKER_11That's always fun. Um But the uh the winner, uh, we did choose uh a winner uh who is going to receive uh the new BCO commentary. His name is John Roberts, which is a good Presbyterian name, uh, who's a ruling elder at Northside Presbyterian uh in Melbourne, Florida. Excited you a little bit there, but Melbourne, Florida. Uh and he says he's relied on Polity Manners uh to go through a uh difficult pastoral transition uh to figure out some of those things with some of those episodes that we had on those chapters of the BCO.

SPEAKER_11Uh so uh John Roberts, uh your uh copy uh will be coming to you shortly. Uh we did get him uh to sign it for us, ParomQuist to sign it for us. So uh I don't know if that actually takes up or down the value of the book uh with uh with resale value, but for personal um uh personal uh heirloom status, uh it will take it up for you. And maybe you can have it uh leather bound like uh Fred Greco's copy uh of the BCO. Um so uh having uh covered that, Scott, uh do you think there's anything else we we need to cover here?

SPEAKER_11Uh another thing that we've learned from this is the number of people that uh Riverside can handle somewhere under 13. Uh so the future uh notation on there for uh uh technology uh capabilities. But Scott, do you have anything else you want to uh cover or ask before uh I think Mel has something else too that he wants to say, so you can call on him.

SPEAKER_07Well, I Mel, you speak first. Thank you, Jared. Thank you, Scott. Um, just an idea. Really appreciate this. I enjoy going back and listening to episodes on specific chapters, but just an idea for you going forward. Uh over the years, I have called uh Dr. Guy Waters and Jackson, and I've asked him to tell me some church history stories related to polity. And I think that might actually be very interesting for your audience who probably are specialists in this way.

SPEAKER_07Oftentimes there's a story uh in relatively immediate or even far distant church history that kind of explains why we do what we do. And it could be something as broad as you know the two office uh question, or it could be, I think I've heard Jared, you uh get whipped up about covering the communion elements on a on a cloth and and such. Uh but I think sometimes uh when you uh interact with that, sometimes a church discipline story in church history is useful.

SPEAKER_07Um, you were talking about what are some of the barriers between PCA churches and doing church discipline. So many of them just don't do it, Jared. And if we could through this wonderful podcast of yours, just encourage people to just start practicing it. And you don't have to bite all something complicated. Just start with uh cleaning your roles up and having sessional conversations about removing people according to the stated reasons and training your administrative elders to be more active in transferring letters, and um so so much of that kind of nuts and bolts of the PCA relates to the bigger questions of polity.

SPEAKER_07But I know as a Presbytery clerk, I'm just looking to help about a third of my churches just learn how to sort of keep the scorebook for the game. And um this podcast is so good at helping people understand that. If you literally, if you can keep a scorebook for a basketball game or a baseball game, you've got the essential qualities in being a good secretary or clerk or uh learning some of these polity things.

SPEAKER_07Uh, but that there was an idea for you. I had a conversate, just to finish the thought, I had a fascinating conversation with Guy Waters this summer on a controversy between Thornwall and Smythe on the different views uh of the offices in the church. And I think things like that might be an interesting podcast for your listeners to hear.

SPEAKER_04I think that is a great place where we can um outro. Um Ben had uh jump off because of an issue with his daughter. I know that you all have probably heard that his daughter has some medical issues that they're currently working with, and they had a family emergency, and so that's why he had to jump off. Um they had to take care of little Maggie. And so uh he sends his regards to us. But I think that's all we have for tonight.

SPEAKER_04Um uh everything will be in the show notes that needs to be, and I think the best way to segue out is for you to say goodbye, gentlemen.

SPEAKER_11Goodbye, gentlemen. Goodbye, gentlemen. Goodbye, gentlemen. People are waving. The audio loves that.

SPEAKER_04Oh my goodness.

SPEAKER_03So um, you're still live.

SPEAKER_11The great part is now that Ben is not here, we have no idea how to stop this.

SPEAKER_04This is the post show that everyone sees random people talking, and then they can actually, I guess, just hear us. So don't say anything that will get you 31-2 right now.

SPEAKER_11Yeah, so uh anybody have any medical problems that they want to talk about with everybody in awkward format? No, no, no.

SPEAKER_03We're not actually at good being with you guys. All right.

SPEAKER_11I think I think if we leave, it'll stop recording, so but let it upload. Good night. Good night.

SPEAKER_05So um our I I thought there was there was uh more stuff on the agenda. I thought we were gonna talk about it.

SPEAKER_03Everyone leaves except one guy.

SPEAKER_11I'm gonna be the last one to leave to make sure Ryan doesn't hijack our entire podcast. Gonna monologue, yeah.

SPEAKER_05All right. Well, thanks for thanks for having me on my board.

SPEAKER_03Can't believe I wore a tie for this. I wore a t-shirt. Is Matt Bradley frozen?

SPEAKER_05Oh no. No, he's gone now.

SPEAKER_03Nashville Presbytery has left the room. Wow.

SPEAKER_05That's our our northwestern boundary in uh Tennessee Valley Presbytery. Yeah.

SPEAKER_11Ben Ratliff is kindly asking everybody to log off.

SPEAKER_05All right. Bye.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Maybe.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 150. You've Got to Come Visit

    Nov 17, 202642 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 149. Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    Nov 10, 202642 minAudio

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 148. From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 147. ProtoPresbytery

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 146. Broker of Relationships and Resources

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...

    Credit the people on this episode