Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Polity Matters

Polity Matters artwork

113. Worship in the EPC

Dec 30, 202553 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Go here to see resources from the EPC, including their Book of Order. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02That said after this moment, it is now liable to be on the internet. Um, so alright, well, let's get started. Uh, I'll I'll open now. Uh, welcome to Polity Matters. It's a weekly podcast that explores biblical church polity. My name is Scott Edberg, and today I'm joined with Jared Nelson. Ben is not with us. He is spending some much-needed time with family. Um, and so uh they will be uh he's not with us here today.

SPEAKER_02We do have um a special episode today as we have been interviewing different denominations, uh directory of worship. We thought it would be helpful if we met with some friends from the Evangelical Presbyterian Church and their book of worship. Um, and so today we are joined with uh Don Fortson and Walter Taylor. And so before we get any further, uh, I thought it would be helpful if we could hear a little from you guys, uh a little about yourselves, your connections to the EPC, and your current ministry.

SPEAKER_02Don, could you start? Sure.

SPEAKER_04Yes, I've uh been an ordained minister in the EPC for over 30 years now, was uh ordained in the old Southern Preacher and Church, PCUS, but my dad was in the founding generation, original founders back in the early 80s, and I joined them uh about 10 years later or so. Uh the church where I was serving uh transferred out of the PCUSA into the uh the EPC. Uh after serving at the local church level, I've been a professor of church history at uh Reformed Theological Seminary in uh in Charlotte.

SPEAKER_04And I guess one of my uh contributions to the EPC is I wrote the history of the EPC called Liberty and Non-Essentials. Um I think it was published about ten years ago. And that was a real uh joy to do that. Uh some of the founders were still alive, and it was great to be able to interview them. And I I can't say it was really exciting to go through all the uh minute books over all those years, but anyway. Um so I've been in the same presbytery over all those years, uh, although we did divide uh into three smaller ones here recently, but uh it's been a pleasure to be in the EPC.

SPEAKER_01And Walter, how about you? Um Walter Taylor. I'm the uh pastor of the pres of the EPC Church on Oak Island, North Carolina. Um I've been at this congregation now for just over 18 years. Uh when I came here, this was a and this was a PC USA church. I was a PC USA pastor. Uh came here in 2007. We were received into the EPC in 2015, so just over uh 10 years this past October.

SPEAKER_01Um so I've served um here longer than I've I've served anywhere else in ministry. Um the kind of my own background. I I grew up in the Christian church uh disciples cambelite tradition, uh, read myself into the reformed uh tradition. Um and so uh I was originally ordained in the disciples. I was still in in process of doing that.

SPEAKER_01Um since I'd grown up in that tradition, I thought I needed to make peace with it. And when I decided that the uh Campbell's biggest mistake was leaving Presbyterianism, I had to do something about it myself. So um the uh I went to um you know Milligan College for my undergraduate and then did my MVV at Vanderbilt and had the uh really the blessing, the pleasure of studying with um uh with Hughes Oliphant Old, Scotty Old at Erskine Seminary for my doctorate ministry.

SPEAKER_01So I guess that's why I'm here today. I'm sort of uh I'm uh worship is uh reform worship is sort of my uh subject that I'm most interested in.

SPEAKER_02So well, thank you guys for coming on. As as we um jump into it, I I noted that as I was reading uh your your book of church order that the EPC has a book of worship. And as we've interviewed other traditions, it's common for us to see a directory of worship. And so I guess my first question is as we discuss and think about your own book for worship, why do you call it a book of worship?

SPEAKER_04That's uh that's a good question. I don't know that I can tell you the exact answer to that, but I'll tell you what I surmise. I don't recall having that conversation with any of the founders. What we did uh when the group got together to form the EPC, they were trying to come up with a complete book of order, and they had a committee of uh five that worked together, and then their chief advisor was a man by the name of Andy Jumper.

SPEAKER_04If you studied Southern Preterian history, I'm sure Walter knows that name. Andy Jumper wrote the old books, The Uh Noble Task and Chosen to Serve on the ruling elder and the deacon. And he's uh probably the chief architect, if there is one, of our book of order. But what they did, according to the testimony of our first uh stated clerk, is they the committee got together particular on uh all the the you know, the book of government, the book of discipline, and what they uh titled the book of worship, and tried to pull together uh kind of a blending of the old PCU and what was uh at that time the UPUSA uh uh uh books.

SPEAKER_04Uh uh since I know that the PCUS always kept the uh traditional title of the Directory of Worship, I do not know this for certain, but I wonder if either the old United Preston Church or the old PCUSA before the reunion, if one of them in their uh Book of Order used that title Book of Worship. And as all of you know, the uh the old USA church back in the 40s is I think the first ones to come up with this book of common worship.

SPEAKER_04You know, that has forms and for services and that kind of thing. So I'm thinking it's probably that influence of the old Northern Presbyterian Church. I'd have to check that out to be sure. Uh but that would be my uh my take on it.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it seemed as I was reading your book of worship, it it's essentially a directory in its content. It's not a common, it's not a book of common worship. It doesn't give you the exact prayers to say or anything like that. It's very um high level in developing perhaps our doctrine of worship. And and so that that's what was just my my curiosity. I was like, this is still a directory. Um it's maybe a little both in that regard. Um, it seemed that as I was reading you your your book of worship, that it's been recently amended uh in the last 10 years or so, maybe in 2015.

SPEAKER_02Um does your does your book have constitutional status in the EPC? Do you know that? And they're nodding. I guess this is this is an audio podcast.

SPEAKER_04I was about to just go on. That's right. Yeah, that's right. Well, the brothers are in agreement here. Yes, it is. It is of uh we take our ordination vows, and it includes you know, book of government, book of uh uh discipline, and book of of worship. So it does have constitutional authority, and there are places where it uses the word shall, which uh which uh of course implies that these are things that must be followed, and so our ordination vows would be tied to our book of worship.

SPEAKER_04Walter may give you his take on it as a local church pastor.

SPEAKER_01Well that's that's how I have understood it um from the beginning. Uh the first time I ever heard that the PCA's uh directory of worship was not constitutional, or at least portions of it are constitutional, portions aren't, was something of a surprise to me because I had um, you know, previously, both in the PC USA and and in the EPC, um it was it's uh a part of the constitution.

SPEAKER_00So yeah, I think I think it's uh it's interesting though. Um you have a similar structure to some other directors we've looked at. Uh just gonna throw an appreciation in there, uh, beginning in the first section on man's chief end and noting uh the importance of worship. So I I think uh the EPC has it has something going for it in that it says uh uh you know, in giving glory to God, the Christian is to worship God as a private exercise of faith as a part of a spiritual exercise of individual families, and how you know basically you're starting with this is the most one of the most important things that we do.

SPEAKER_00So we probably better be in agreement on what it is that we're doing.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that that's the part that hurts in the PCA, is we have constitutionally binding um church government and rules of discipline, but the most important thing we do doesn't have any sort of binding influence. Um and so I'm hoping that we can rectify that. Uh uh, you know, the the EPC tends to be, I guess, less cantankerous than than the PCA. And and um, so I'm sure we'll have a fun time with that. Uh but those shalls in your book of worship, are they followed pretty regularly?

SPEAKER_02Are there any issues that ever arise uh from from those shalls?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'll I'll take a stab at that. I think um I've not known of anything to arise, at least in in my corner of the EPC, in terms of uh of any real uh controversy or uh much less any kind of um you know juridical or disciplinary action that's come about. I think, I mean, to be truthful, uh when it comes to the matter of worship, the EPC is a pretty broad denomination uh and spans a you know a very wide um span.

SPEAKER_01Our congregation would be you know very much on the kind of historic, traditional, reformed kind of worship. Um and I can probably talk more about that later when I talk about the influence that uh that Scottie Old has had on me. So um so how well known the book of worship is would be interesting to find out um in the life of a lot of our churches and pastors. Um it's something that I do make regular uh reference to in my own congregation.

SPEAKER_01Having it has saved me from uh bizarre things um being asked of me in the course of worship. Or those uh so so I've I've been grateful to have it there as a as a backdrop, and it takes the heat off the individual choice of the pastor if it's actually um known and and followed, but even in the way that it is followed, you know, even within the EPC, there's a fair amount of latitude in it. So um so that's yeah.

SPEAKER_01Don, how does how does that sound?

SPEAKER_04Yeah, well, I think Walter is certainly right. There's a there is a lot of latitude in the EPC on this. In fact, it's interesting if you hear EPC folks talk when we're asked you know about our famous motto of unity unity and essentials, liberty and non-essentials, and charity and all things, uh you know, we kind of pride ourselves on, you know, kind of trying to keep that that ethos. And and often you will hear people say that worship is one of those things that we put in the categories of non-essential.

SPEAKER_04Um and and I think they're referring there kind of to to practice and and uh it is true that you know we tend not to um uh uh shall I say uh challenge one another on these issues. Uh for example, as you guys are probably aware, from the very beginning, one of the things that the EPC did is welcome uh churches that had a charismatic background.

SPEAKER_04Some of our churches in the main line back in the you know the 60s, 70s were went through kind of the charismatic renewal. Some of them had that as a part of the ethos of their church, and so we kind of welcome them in that founding generation, and of course we had a early position paper on the Holy Spirit. Well, that has implication for worship. Now we don't have a lot of charismatic churches. We do have some, some are more expressive of that uh uh ethos they have uh than others, but we we don't trouble those churches or uh challenge them if there are you know some parts of it that some of us wouldn't be as comfortable with.

SPEAKER_04And our position paper on the Holy Spirit kind of uh makes that clear. But yeah, I think that uh this is an area of challenge for us. I would agree with Walter on that in terms of I I think the book of uh worship uh needs to have more play among us. Now I you know, being a professor at RTS, I mean we go through uh the standard, and usually it at RTS w the PCA books are what we use, although we do allow, you know, OPC EPC guys to study their their books of worship, directory of worship.

SPEAKER_04So and we have courses on worship which certainly in underscore and emphasize traditional reform worship. But uh particularly for the guys that go out and do church planting um uh which tends to be more uh eclectic uh on his worship practice, I'm not sure how many of them really uh consider the directions uh in the uh book of worship as they go forward. I can't uh you know, judge make a absolute judgment on that, but that's my sense.

SPEAKER_00It seems like it'd be good if they if they did. I mean, I was actually surprised by um uh how much of the EPC directory I found helpful. I mean, it kind of begins just like a directory, you know, um corporate worship shall include, and then lists elements, and then exactly how you go about that, it's it's pretty like, okay, you know, where are you gonna put this? You don't have a set, a rigid uh form of worship. But even within that, I I appreciated in 22b, you know, the um emphasis on the the Lord's Day and keeping of the Lord's Day.

SPEAKER_00And um, I would hope more people would would read that, even in the PCA. I feel like um sometimes I I wish more people had a high view of the the Lord's Day as the EPC's um uh book of worship does.

SPEAKER_02Uh Walter, you you talked about some like the aid of the book as perhaps a safeguard for requests in the church. Uh I found that too in our own BCO in the other two sections. Uh when someone asks an odd request of me, um I just say, hey, there's this a non-starter we have. Um we have a constitution that forbids that. Um, but how what other aids um in the book of worship are there for your church outside of that?

SPEAKER_01Um well I think that the I mean, aside from the matters of authority it lays out, um you know, it's interesting in the EPC, in the EPC book, uh the pastor really is given authority over the um the way worship is exercised, administered, um, organized. Um and I've and that's and that's one of those gifts that I think that way too many of our pastors aren't even aware of.

SPEAKER_01Um one of the one of the questions that often come across, well, you know, we we like probably a lot of you guys, we we also have our secret, you know, secret Facebook online discussions for just pastors, so we can ask these questions, you know, without uh getting in trouble. And and one of the questions that just forever, you know, astounds me when it comes up is something along the lines of, you know, hey folks, I'm serving this church. We have a worship leader that's been doing this, and and you know, the the praise team has been choosing the hymns and some of the stuff isn't appropriate and blah, blah, blah.

SPEAKER_01How do you um, you know, how do you wrestle all that back? You know, how how should I uh approach this? That's one of the questions I've seen over and over again, especially in churches that have kind of the more contemporary approach. And, you know, my my response is, you know, well, well, whoever gave that to them um because it's yours. And of course, if you're having to fix a situation you walked into, that's one thing. But uh the fact that those uh there are some great guardrails that are there uh just for the the way that worship is um is is done, period.

SPEAKER_01Um, so that it's it's more than just when you, you know, you know, uh the the Masonic order wants to you know do their little thing at the end of the of the funeral that's in the church building. And it's like, no, um, you know, not only do I have problems with this, uh, that is forbidden in our book of worship. Um, so I guess in in that way, for those who actually utilize it and make use of it and educate their people, which is the the task of the pastor to do that, it is a uh wonderful resource for keeping um keeping a good sense of order, um provided that the minister, him or herself, actually has a good working knowledge of reform worship, which is a whole nother issue.

SPEAKER_02I did appreciate that in your book of worship. Um the pastor is not just a preacher. Um, he is the one that plans and leads the worship of God's people under the oversight of the session. And so that that's um that's still a part of your book. The session seems to um that that's I think good order in any reformed church as the session comes along and aids. Um but I did I did find it very valuable um to put the pastor in that driver's seat. He's the one that has authority over the music of the church in regards to choosing songs and when they're played and and all of that.

SPEAKER_02And so I think that is just a wonderful um privilege uh of the ministry that uh pastors have. Uh as it relates, you know, the other end of that, we have pastors. What about your ruling elders? How are ruling elders typically involved in the worship of God's people in your churches?

SPEAKER_01Well, I'll I will give um um I can tell you how it is in my congregation, but and I will yield to Don. He's probably had a lot more exposure since um he's in a um professorial role. So he probably has a little more latitude on where he is on where he's in church on Sunday morning, so we might have a better uh sense of that. Um in our congregation, the we have maintained kind of the the very traditional approach to worship.

SPEAKER_01So I am I am the worship leader. Uh, of course, with the administration of the Lord's Supper, the the elders are involved in the traditional uh Presbyterian way of um administering the or serving the congregation, the uh the bread and the cup as they come forward, or in our case, from time to time at long tables or or sitting in the pews. Uh we do all three. Um so there um uh that the I would say that the the the workload of leading in worship is done uh by me and by the assistant pastor.

SPEAKER_01Um if we didn't have an assistant pastor, it might be probably more elder involvement in some of those elements of the service, whether it be you know um uh sharing in the reading of scripture or some of the other things. But given the fact, just the practicality that we have an assistant pastor in addition to a pastor, um and that person is in the is in the role of worship each week as well, um the the the elders, it's it's a little more. limited I guess you would say than it might be in other other of our congregations.

SPEAKER_04Yeah I would I would say my observation has been there'd be a diversity of practice. I mean um certainly um the ministers have the authority to do that. I think often it's is yielded to some of the musicians in the church, especially the ones that have more contemporary music the minister uh it seems check checks off on that. But one of the things our book makes clear which is great which talks about the music you know uh and that element that it should be uh you know scripturally sound consistent with our reformed heritage and I'm not so sure those boxes are always checked uh and that's where we could I think exhort one another uh in a positive way in some of those things because I think that is important.

SPEAKER_04I will if I could give one personal illustration. Um I worked for Clayton Bell I don't know if you guys know that name he was the senior pastor of Highland Park Presbytering Church I worked for him around 1980 81 at that point in time the church had 7,500 members. That's where you the PCA's Park Cities Church came out of that. But this this was a good while before the split that hadn't happened yet.

SPEAKER_04And Clayton was a great preacher and certainly had traditional worship. But I remember as a seminary intern he just he said to me he said Don the hymn book is the most important theology book you have next to the Bible. And I really took that to heart as a young man. And um I think that's one of the areas that uh we all can work on to to ensure that the music that we use is theologically sound.

SPEAKER_04Uh that it is you know consistent and that it ought really it ought to be instructing people in the faith and edifying them is and of course primarily giving glory to God. But uh I think the choice of of music is very very important and and the minister's involvement is very necessary.

SPEAKER_00Yeah the the parts on uh music were some of the ones I I highlighted in my copy here uh a few sections as emphasis should be given to the content of the hymns that all might sing with understanding and then I appreciate it where it said music is not an end in itself but should serve the whole purpose of giving glory and praise to God. Where there is a choir auxiliary to the congregation it should be remembered that it is representing the whole congregation before God and not performing for the people and then uh you were talking earlier it also has a part in there where it talks about the the pastor as a final authority which is a little bit different than some of the other uh directories that we've seen that gives it to the session and the pastor but says the pastor has final authority over all parts of the service including the music where there is a music director or some other such person serving in music that person shall always consult with the pastor concerning the music or worship.

SPEAKER_01So if there's anybody that's uh having struggles with that they could there's their place that they could point to uh and one of the things that we have done in our congregation uh really since coming into the EPC so in 2015 shortly after we made that transition we began using uh the Trinity hymnal uh since EPC doesn't have its own hymnal um and we we wanted a a solid uh hymnal and we make a copy available to each household that joins the congregation as an encouragement to them to make use of it devotionally and then in our church newsletter each month we publish the hymns that will be sung on all of the Sundays with the encouragement that people will take time to look at those.

SPEAKER_01Now whether they do that's a whole nother matter but that is um our intention and we do set that up and I have I have noticed a deepening of uh of appreciation for our hymnity um and even for that matter the singing of psalms which there's plenty of them in the Trinity hymnal um in the life of our congregation because you know we've emphasized the the same point that Clayton Bell did in which I've I've told the congregation that the after the Bible the hymn book is the most important book that they have because it puts words into your mouth.

SPEAKER_01And so that's the um so yeah so I I would underscore you know what what Don just said a moment ago.

SPEAKER_02So you you have your hymns chosen a month prior to you actually singing them.

SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_02Man Man after my own heart I'm the same same kind of guy we'll be good friends. As we've thought about uh the leading in worship and the type of music that that we sing um a common debate in the PCA is who leads worship and and that includes various elements whether it be the call to worship and benediction prayers or even singing what how are how are there any limitations for laity uh in the EPC as it relates to leading in worship or is it just as diverse as some of the other things we've talked about Don you want to tackle that one yeah I mean the um our book typically talks about ordinarily you know the minister does X, Y, and Z, but usually allows for X and it does say that people, you know, other people may be invited to to pray or to do other things.

SPEAKER_04Of course that would be up to the minister uh to der determine that. One of the things I find fascinating I don't know if you guys picked up on this where the section where it talks about the choir it implies that the peop the folks in the choir should be of exemplary character which is typically what we think about you know for the minister but the the point being they're helping lead worship the choir singing and and it talks about the the fact that the the congregation of course is primarily the choir in the church and it it has that caveat about instruments as long as the session agrees with them.

SPEAKER_04You know and allows them. Um so there is uh is an opportunity for others to you know to participate in leader.

SPEAKER_02I mean it doesn't comment about uh you know many other things but it does talk about uh you know prayer and and the music and the way others participate besides the ministry to that Walter No I think that's um I I think it'll it will vary from one uh from one place to another as to how that's um how that's administered but I I would agree with uh what Don just said when uh Don was talking about that that reminded me of my upbringing I came to faith in an RCA church and it was a very contemporary worship service and I just remember um there was this high school girl that was part of the worship praise team and one worship service she got in a fight with her boyfriend throughout the whole worship service very like they were like quiet yelling at each other whisper yelling at each other throughout the whole worship service and I sat right behind them and I was just like uncomfortable the entire time and then after you know they do the closing set and so she goes up there and she's like give like daggers with her eyes while singing um character is important.

SPEAKER_02Oh man and the leading of worship. Going back to your your book of worship though uh I did one of the my favorite parts of of your whole book is section 28C where it talks about prayer. Um oftentimes I leave myself to looking through systematic theologies to make sure that I have every type of prayer down and it's like naming the books of the Bible where you know it's like I missed one somewhere but the EPC has a pretty robust list of the just the types of prayer and um we've we've already talked about ad nauseum who could lead prayer typically and ordinarily ordinarily is one of the the best words in the English language.

SPEAKER_02But how about the sacraments? Uh what I found interesting in your book of worship is that there is uh the sacraments aren't always tied to like a corporate worship service. And so I was wondering what are some ways common ways in the EPC that you see the sacraments outside the context of a Sunday morning worship service?

SPEAKER_01Yeah I um and I appreciated getting that question uh before time because it did cause me to go back and look uh to see what the the context was and um while I can't speak for what was in the minds of the of the writers I think what that is there for is principally um for pastoral care and especially in the uh making uh the Lord's Supper available to those who cannot be in public worship, whether it be uh the folks who are shut in or who are in a nursing home, um people who are hospitalized because we do have, and I know um I've read enough to know that there is variation even among some Presbyterian churches on this, but in the EPC we're very much um uh very much in a pos have the latitude to be able to make communion available uh to those who cannot be in corporate worship.

SPEAKER_01Now we do try to do it at our best in a way that is understood as an extension of the church's gathering that day or that week in many cases. But um so I think the the biggest part of that is is for um the sacraments to be able pastorally to be served to those who are not able to be in church. I think with baptism really two things I would I would hold out for uh for baptism it provides um the ability of a pastor to be able to perform baptism in sort of an emergency situation um in a hospital again uh a child who uh may not live um some of those sorts of uh situations um also I've not seen this as much it's more the pastoral end that I've seen but the other side of that is as we look at baptism from the standpoint of the New Testament we do have to acknowledge baptism is the missionary sacrament and so most all of the baptisms if not all the well all the baptisms for the most part that we see for example in the book of Acts are outside the context of the public worship service um people you know made their profession of faith and and they were baptized and so it does uh perhaps provide us with some leeway for that.

SPEAKER_01Again I've not seen anything you know much of anything of that um from day-to-day worship we um as as a rule I've always had uh with with I think there's I've had two exceptions in my ministry on the issue of baptism um but in both cases it was with the approval of the session and representatives of the session present when it wasn't in the the regular Lord's Day service. But I think that's there to give us some uh some leeway because you know there's some hardcore Scottish Presbyterianism that did not provide the opportunity for those for the sacraments to be administered in those settings which meant I guess if you were in you know if you were cut off from the ability to be in part be be a part of uh corporate worship you know you were just sunk.

SPEAKER_01So um that that is my read on it that's really the only occasions I've seen seen it done outside the context of worship.

SPEAKER_04Don is that is that your read yeah I would say that's uh essentially it and and uh where it's just one wanted to give some leeway for those extraordinary situations where the minister has to make a judgment call. And it and it and in one I think in one place it even says that you know if the minister needs to make that decision he will report the baptism to the session. Nor is it he doesn't even have time to run it by the session.

SPEAKER_04Because those pastoral situations they're not don't come up often but it's it's wonderful to have the flexibility in in that crisis situation to be able to respond pastorally.

SPEAKER_02Yeah when I was reading that um back to the my RCA roots there was a local RCA camp and they would often have the sacraments at the camp with just the children the little children and I always thought this is just such an odd thing and so I was curious if that was what was allowing the latitude for or if it was more those extraordinary situations where you might do vesper services or something like that.

SPEAKER_00I think some one other illustration I give what made me uh think about that is um let's say on a youth retreat where the one of the associate pastors uh is with them the session might uh give uh permission for him to have communion with the teenagers over a weekend retreat it could could potentially do that I've seen that yeah I'd say in the in the PCA sometimes you see um the sacraments outside of the church building though usually there's a mentality of bringing the church to that place so you know people that have communion uh to try to bring as many of the you know opening up to the church and bring people with them to you know you can't make it to the church so the church is going to come to you kind of mentality.

SPEAKER_00So it's it's interesting how you've how it's framed.

SPEAKER_02Usually that's what I've told my session is if we're going to do something outside of the church building we need to make sure that it's the the church coming to uh together still uh in some sort of way and I think that same spirit is in is in our book of worship in that it it does talk in terms of um of uh of um the session being represented you know in addition you know in addition to the minister so that um there I think there's a a sense of that that undergirds the the the way it's laid out in our book of worship too it I I've benefited greatly from talking with the OPC ARP and and y'all just hearing the the aid of um directories and book of worships um because they are clearly an aid they offer great latitude and liberty but um they do offer a sense of unity um even in the midst of diversity um and as a place where you can put your finger and say no we intentionally allow this liberty whether it be music or or the sacraments in this way and I I think that's helpful um even if there is some disagreements or scruples um uh collegiately um that I think that's a help.

SPEAKER_02Uh Walter I thought uh since you did study under Hughes Old at Erskine I I was hoping as an aid to our conversation that you'd perhaps help us understand uh perhaps how he impacted uh you and your ministry in seminary I read a a paper on the Lord's Supper and Old has this like a really small book but also like this huge like thesaurus of like the entire history of the Lord's Supper. At least that's how I kind of uh read it and I found it to be a very uh awesome book I wish I owned it but I could not find a copy to secure myself but I was wondering uh how has um studying under old aided you uh as a minister um that leads a church in worship uh oh and and on that book on um on Holy Communion um I I you know the the high point of my academic career is appearing in four footnotes and so that's the uh that that's my pride and joy from my days of studying with uh uh with Scottie Old.

SPEAKER_01And um you know it's uh yeah I I think everything that I do I uh I still hear his voice and echo um and so much of my education was not only in class but the time I spent with him outside of it and in discussions and and years later. You know I think one of the things that I've I learned from from him and greatly appreciated is is that the reform tradition is much larger than our Presbyterian expressions of it and especially liturgically um and I think that's a very important thing.

SPEAKER_01I will throw this out there because um Scotty has gone to glory and so um he he won't get into a fight over this but um he he was one very much not given to conflict he he he wasn't looking for a fight um but I will say this because this has had a big impact in my understanding of reform worship um Scotty was not a proponent of and and did not hold to the regulative principle for worship.

SPEAKER_01He argued and I I think rightly so that the what became the the RPW which you won't really find that terminology used until the 20th century though admittedly you'll find um the position described in in in earlier um in earlier centuries he would have argued that uh the regulative principle for worship is an expression of a hard Puritan understanding of worship it was not the approach to worship that was taken by Calvin or Knox uh what Knox said a lot of things and at times Knox sounds like he's saying it but if you compare it to the actual book of of uh common order that Scott that um uh that um Knox produced it doesn't come out that way um and if you you look at um especially if and and to really get a sense of this um I would urge you to read his book on baptism which I found to be um you know it's funny a colleague of mine and I uh we once met each other and realized we'd use the same word to describe that book which probably described us we his book was riveting and and it the name of it is the the um I think it's the shaping of the reformed baptismal rite in the 16th century um which um and what he shows in that is that um the reformers were not embracing something along the lines of a regulative principle uh when they were reforming worship, but were actively looking to see how did the ancient church worship.

SPEAKER_01And and so Scotty said the the expression that he used to try to to clarify a if you were if you will a reformed understanding of what worship looks like worship according to scripture which means worship that is shaped by scripture um and certainly theologically undergirded by it but his argument was if you're gonna go down the road of a regulative principle that says that only that which is expressly commanded or expressly exhibited in worship happens, you're gonna find that you're gonna run into some real problems in the reformed tradition, infant baptism being one of them, which is why it is not the way that the reformers defended infant baptism against the Anabaptists who were utilizing something akin to a regulative principle when it came to their sacramental theology.

SPEAKER_01And I think that's I think that's an important thing to do because without ever losing the responsibility of taking worship seriously it it gives us the the the realization that worship is a lot more nuanced than simply the um what came to be known as as the RPW tradition. And while that is a part of the reformed tradition as a whole it represents a small part of it in that it represents predominantly English speaking Puritanism and it was not even the way that that worship proceeded in in the Continental Reformed churches.

SPEAKER_01And so as a result of that it has always given me a sense of um Acknowledging that we really do have a tradition within the reformed tradition, however allergic to that word we might be.

SPEAKER_00So um Yeah, I had I had a class with Dr. Old. Um I didn't I didn't study with him and I was never footnoted, but uh it was interesting to hear uh his perspective, and and I I heard him talk a little bit about that too. That's why his book is called uh Reformed According to Scripture. Right. And yeah, so he um so uh it seems like he would still affirm like Westminster confession language, but you know, as contrasted the way the the Puritans might have understood it, or maybe our RP brothers uh would understand it.

SPEAKER_00But I wonder if you ever heard his story. One of my favorite uh stories that he told was his um his church was in Lafayette, Indiana, where my uh wife lived for a while, and that he was having growth, and he had somebody come to him that was from church growth movement type uh backgrounds and you know wanted to get principles and and tips and asked what he did there. He's like, Well, we, you know, um I guess our secrets are we try to preach the Bible, uh, we worship with the sacraments, and we try to get together and pray as much as possible. And he said uh he never really heard back from them after that.

SPEAKER_01Right, yeah. That he even explains uh tells some very similar stories to that.

SPEAKER_02And uh well, Jared, do you have any additional questions?

SPEAKER_00Uh just uh I don't know if you can speak to how you've uh found uh the Book for Worship in the EPC to be helpful or how you would hope that it would be helpful to um not only people in the EPC, but as the PCA is um looking to uh revise our directory, um, anything that you think is particular to the EPC's directory that should be adopted, because we looked at like the OPC and they define their terms, the difference between if they're saying shall and these different things, or uh the ARP tried to have proof text with scripture for everything.

SPEAKER_00I know if the EPC had something uh particular to its uh book of worship that you're like, this is something that I think others should learn from.

SPEAKER_04You know, I think um given the eclectic nature of our book of worship where we we tried to glean the best from the Northern Presbyterian, Southern Presbyterian, which means it would have been a mixture of some old school and new school stuff. And it because it was based on books that had a long uh trajectory you know in American Presbyterian history, there's a lot of pastoral wisdom. And I would say one of the things that I appreciate about our book and I'd encourage the PCA to consider is not only do you want to be faithful to the tradition, but you want to use con the pastoral wisdom that's been passed down to us and uh and also be aware of the contemporary realities that we face with that.

SPEAKER_04You know, they're just uh issues that may need to be addressed that weren't addressed in the original Westminster Directory. And uh I appreciated the flexibility of the founding fathers of the EPC. They took the best of those, but you can tell in comparing those that they added some things too to to address some of the issues that were current. Now it was kept out of the 2015 um edition that you guys have seen that Walter and I, you know, used, but the original actually actually the revision took this out, but it had a little passage in there where it talked about in terms of of picking hymns and music you need to pick some of the old and some of the new.

SPEAKER_04Kind of a balance in there. And if you think about the context of the 70s or the eighties when Christian rock and roll was starting to invade the church and more contemporary music, you know, in addition to the hymns, using guitars and worship, that kind of thing, you just note a a pastoral sensitivity there. Um you know the revision didn't see that as necessary anymore, but but I just picked up on them trying to think uh you know, practically for the time in which they lived about that.

SPEAKER_04And I think that's a good balance. Tradition and the contemporary. How how are we gonna put those together in the best way we can?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I w I would uh heartily agree with with that. And um the um I think that you know when it comes to when it comes to worship um to be reformed, it seems to me that there is a danger, and we used to talk about this. I used to talk about this with Scotty Ole, there's a danger to what I call um, you know, become uh trying to become a Puritan or even a 16th-century reenactor.

SPEAKER_01Um worship, you know, being true to the Reformed tradition does not simply mean repristinating how worship was done in Geneva or in Zurich or in um or you know, or anywhere else where the Reformation went. Um because even what they were doing was that very struggle that Don is talking about. And so we need to um you know realize, yeah, we need to take the 16th century very seriously, but we don't want to find ourselves um working with our own uh tradition or the way we have always done things and necessarily and create effectively kind of what the Roman Catholics call tradition, um, that's authoritative all on its own without without a grounding in scripture.

SPEAKER_01Um you know, I I think that one of the struggles that um and I say that as somebody that would come in and look at my service and and they would see Geneva all over it. I mean, it's um, I mean, you know, communion Sundays, we we have the reading of of the law, you know, after the declaration of pardon, all of those sorts of things, and I try to educate my congregation as to why. So I don't say any of this with any kind of flippancy to the past, but um but no century should necessarily in the history of the church, not even the 16th, be given undue regard as being the one that's right, because when you do that, you've effectively created a second source of revelation, as it were.

SPEAKER_01Um we are informed by the history of the whole church, and that's something that, you know, even with my quibbles with, say, the Mercersburg end of the reformed tradition in this country, they got it right on that, that um, you know, the the the history of the church is more than just what's happened in the last 500 years among the reformed. So I think uh so in that regard, yeah, it is a it's a challenge, it's a struggle.

SPEAKER_01Um and I think there's uh engaging in that is is a is a good thing. And um so I guess I would recommend as you move forward um to reflect on that, but also um if I'm allowed to give advice, don't make and because this is always a temptation when you're rewriting something, especially in a time of conflict, don't rewrite your directory of worship to settle other matters that you might have disagreements over right now that don't need to be settled there of all places, and and I think that's just something that we have to all churches in this era have to uh uh to reflect on.

SPEAKER_02So you brought up Mercerberg. I have a just a short question for you. Was John Williamson Nevin right about Calvin on the Supper?

SPEAKER_01I think he was more right than Hodge.

SPEAKER_02I I I just I I loved reading Nevin. Um The Mystical Presence I found very, very helpful. Don't agree with a bunch of it, but the historical side of things I found very fascinating and helpful. Um and Keith Matheson had done great work in perhaps making Nevin's idea about Calvin a little more accessible in his book given for you. So well, that's all I have. Jared, do you have anything else? All right. Well, I'd like to thank you all for coming on uh to talk about the EPC um and your book of worship.

SPEAKER_02I it's been a blessing to me, and I'm sure it will be to our listeners too. Um so this podcast is over. Uh, please check the show notes, and you can find uh the EPC Book of Worship and other resources that are related to um today's episode there. Um but without further ado, uh please say goodbye, gentlemen. Goodbye. Goodbye.

SPEAKER_04God bless you.

SPEAKER_01Thank you very much. Goodbye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 150. You've Got to Come Visit

    Nov 17, 202642 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 149. Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    Nov 10, 202642 minAudio

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 148. From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 147. ProtoPresbytery

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 146. Broker of Relationships and Resources

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...

    Credit the people on this episode