Steve joins Ben and Jared to discuss BCO 21 on the Ordination and Installation of minister. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03Hello and welcome to Polity Matters. My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined today by Jared Nelson and friend of the show, Steve Tipton. We are uh we're we're sad not to have Scott with us, but Providence dictated that he be absent, and so we asked Steve at the last minute, I should mention, to jump in, and we're very grateful he's here. Steve, how you doing, man? It's good to see you.
SPEAKER_02Good to see you guys. Uh I'm a I'm a sorry stand-in for Scott Edberg, but uh I'll do my best.
SPEAKER_03Well, today the three of us are gonna dive into chapter 21 of the BCO, which starts to outline, or rather, it doesn't start, it it sort of uh does it all, uh, the essential guidelines for ordination and installation of ministers. Uh it emphasizes, as you'll we'll see, the the authority and the responsibility of the presbytery uh in the whole process of of call and uh examination and ordination of the teaching elder. Uh presbyteries function as gatekeepers is the common phrase that you hear a lot, especially when you're talking about credentials committees, but there's also a lot of shepherding work that goes into this, as is evident when we work through this chapter.
SPEAKER_03Um presbyteries have to evaluate candidates, uh, their calls, their theological soundness, their personal character. There's a lot involved in this uh endeavor, and so there's a lot of instruction here for us. Um the process can feel uh sort of overly administrative and technical, but but it's good for us to remember uh as we work into this chapter that this is all a recognition of Christ as King over the church. He's the one who calls and equips ministers, he's the one who's given them to the church for our edification, and so we're grateful to him and we try to do this as best we can.
SPEAKER_03And so that's one reason we have uh such a robust chapter on this topic. We're just gonna jump right into it in 21 uh section one, and I'm gonna let these guys kind of uh comment after we read, and we'll see where we can go. Uh 21.1 begins this way No minister, licentiate, or candidate shall receive a call from a church but by the permission of his presbytery. When a call has been presented to the presbytery, if found in order, and the presbytery deems it for the good of the church, they shall place it in the hands of the person to whom it is addressed.
SPEAKER_03Ordinarily, a candidate or licentiate may not be granted permission by the presbytery to move onto the field to which he has been called prior to his examination for licensure or ordination. Likewise, an ordained minister from another PCA Presbytery or another denomination ordinarily shall not move onto the field to which he's been called until examined and received by Presbytery. It's sad that Scott's not here because one of his favorite words occurs multiple times in this paragraph. But uh one of you guys uh should talk for a second because I've been rambling uh now for a long time.
SPEAKER_03How does this paragraph uh get us going into 21? What's it trying to set up for us?
SPEAKER_01Well, it gives real authority to the Presbytery in the question of a call. Um it's not a rubber stamp, it's not just a formality. Uh there's real work that has to go into um seeing if the the person is qualified, if the the call is in order, if all of the details are right, um, and even gives this warning that it shouldn't be presumed that it's just gonna go fine and uh to move on to the field, uh, which I take to be uh kind of two things at once, uh beginning the work.
SPEAKER_01Um if you were called to be the senior, that you're not just going there being the senior for a while and then saying, Oh yeah, Presbytery, he's been doing this for a while, why don't you formalize it? Um but it also may be uh don't buy a house there, have a mortgage payment that's going to be starting there before you get the Presbytery to approve. Um it's that's presumptuous and not wise, and so the uh BCO is giving you a little bit of uh instruction uh that's there. So broadly that's that's what we see going on in 21-1.
SPEAKER_02Well, and you know, one of the things that this is setting up is sort of there are you know three parties, uh it's a three-party system. Um but you have the the church, the presbytery, and then the individual, the man. And on the one hand, uh as we'll kind of get into some other pieces later, I mean, all three of those uh have to consent to uh to the call. Um and it's all three are in one sense of equal importance, right?
SPEAKER_02I mean, uh no presbytery can force a pastor on a church without their consent. A church and a presbytery cannot conspire against a minister uh to force him to go into a call against his will. But also the church and the and the man, even if they be entirely desirous that that call move forward, the presbytery still has the ultimate responsibility um to ordain or or install, depending upon the circumstances, and or install, I guess, depending on the circumstances. And so I think that's it's important, and and this is not a rubber stamp.
SPEAKER_02Um and especially the the moving onto the field, uh, you know, Jared and I were in a situation together at a presbytery where somebody had I don't think he'd actually moved physically, but I think he'd sold his house and purchased property and uh his exam we'll just say didn't go well. And um, you know, I was very proud of our presbytery because a lot of times that pressure of well, he's already done this or that can can weigh into that decision.
SPEAKER_02Um it it did not it did not move Jared or one iota, he went over. But um so I just I think it's a good good thing. I also thought it was interesting. Uh I mean I'm gonna be making a lot of comments from Ramsey today because I thought some of his comments on this chapter were well, I mean it's a different chapter in his book, but on this or the relevant sections were pretty interesting. Um and you know, one of those is is that the responsibility of the presbytery is for the good of the church. Um that it is uh and I think you know you could take that one of two ways, you know, the the the the the particular church, but also for the church broadly.
SPEAKER_02And I think both of those things are part of that decision that the presbytery has to make. And uh you know, presbyteries ought to be uh considering uh you know their knowledge and experience of the congregation, maybe not the man, they may not know him from Adam, but certainly the congregation, and then based upon that whole process of being willing to say, and hopefully the church being willing to receive, we really don't think this guy's a good fit for you for a number of reasons.
SPEAKER_02And again, I've had enough experiences where men have said maybe to themselves or to one another, I really don't think this guy's a good fit, but he has a call and etc. etc. And then it turns out not to have been a good fit. And you step back, you know, it's like, well, I wish I would have said something. But um you know, all the problems inherent in that, I get that, but uh, but I think it's an important piece. Uh the other thing I thought was interesting was Ramsey mentioned, I guess, in under their polity old PCUS, that um their its understanding was is that the call isn't even given to the minister until the presbytery approves it.
SPEAKER_02So the presbyter the the man would not even know that a call is being offered until the pres it it's very weird. Because almost like how do you examine a guy in order to know to give him the call? I mean, it was just it was interesting. Uh but we we take place the call in his hand as uh you've already seen it, you've already agreed to it, and we're we're handing it over.
SPEAKER_03Hey, we'd like to examine you, but we're not gonna tell you why. Just don't ask any questions. Uh do you just answer lots of them? Yeah, for real. Do y'all have provisions for any of your committees in your presbyteries about uh commission powers to give uh to grant a man permission to move before the presbytery meeting? Uh we do. I'm I'm fairly certain we do. In our case, so our credentials committee, if we have a man transferring his membership and he's a member of the PCA already, he's a teaching elder in another presbytery, we're allowed to give him permission to move, but we we try not to do that because it's always got the language of pending presbytery approval.
SPEAKER_03And Steve, you gave the example, and we've had one here, where somebody moves even before they've been given permission and then they don't do well on their exam, much less somebody who's been given permission by the committee but then doesn't give you know doesn't do well on the floor, it can be a complicated situation. You really have to be careful because Jared, you referenced it like you're uprooting your whole family, you're moving, you're you know, there's financial things involved.
SPEAKER_01Um Well well, and if there's a concern about, hey, Presbytery is not gonna happen in another three or four months, there's provision to call a meeting and to have it happen sooner. And um, so if that's really a problem, uh there's ways to alleviate that that doesn't possibly have you have to try to get out of a mortgage and lose a bunch of money.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah, that the great word ordinarily.
SPEAKER_02Well, and it's interesting. I mean, I I was gonna make this point later, but I think it actually has more bearing here. Um so in the congregational vow section during the actual ordination sless installation. Another thing Ramsey says, this is the time where a congregation can decide that it changes its mind and not take those vows. Or of a large portion refused. So you know, under his view, like you shouldn't even move on to the field until after you've been installed, man. The the ink is dry before you move on.
SPEAKER_03So uh different worlds, but man, and you want it makes you wonder what kind of situations he experienced or observed, you know, where churches backed out or presbyteries failed to approve or something. It's just what a world. Well, uh let's let's keep going then. 21 2 When an intern has completed his internship to the satisfaction of the presbytery and has accepted a call, the presbytery shall take immediate steps for his ordination.
SPEAKER_03Uh pretty basic instruction, but I'm sure there's some more particular thought behind this. Why is it important for the presbytery, once approving the call and the man being ready, why is it important for them to take immediate steps for his ordination?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think um just just the delay, um, you know, I I I think broadly speaking, the BCO, even though it makes provisions for things like assistant pastors and associate pastors, that a lot of this language is tied to, you know, a church with a what we call a solo pastor or you know, um or even a senior pastor, but um where although not a lot of senior pastors have just finished their internship and need to be ordained.
SPEAKER_02But but either way, I think the idea is that there is a church that needs the regular preaching of the gospel, which a licention can do, but also the administration of sacraments. And so if there are if there is a delay, um then that's unduly burdening the church. Um and so uh I mean I've never been in a situation, I've been in lots of situations in presbyteries where important matters are pushed to another presbytery meeting for good reason.
SPEAKER_02I've never seen an ordination exam pushed away because hey, we really have this budget we've got to approve, or well, maybe that's a bad example, but you know, there's a uh a a new uh program for you know uh Christian education that we really need to discuss and get on the table. No, this is this is really important. It needs to be done uh quickly and and immediately. And obviously immediately is in the context of a presbytery. This doesn't mean called meeting tomorrow.
SPEAKER_02This means in the regular course of their uh uh their meetings, the there there should there ought to be a step, you know, the immediate step is you proceed to ordination.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there needs to be some sense of urgency of high on the docket, but also um I know there are are certain states, and I think even the president has something we can do that's a pocket veto, where you just don't do anything and it basically vetoes it and says no. Um that's not an option for a presbytery. You can't say, like, we don't want to approve this guy, so we'll just we'll just table it indefinitely. No, you like you need to act on it. Yes or no? Give your give your answer.
SPEAKER_03It pairs really well with the previous chapter from 20 section two, where it starts off saying every church should be under the pastoral oversight of a minister, and when a church has no pastor, it should seek to secure one without delay. Uh it and so it it wouldn't make any sense for their churches to be instructed to secure a pastor quickly and then for the presbytery to drag their feet. Um also it takes a long time to do this. I mean, we've we have to have exams that you know to our committee four weeks before Presbytery, so that we can have our our recommendations to Presbytery and examinations orally to the Presbytery before, you know, three weeks before, and the guy's got a plan to come.
SPEAKER_03I mean, there's a lot involved, uh not to mention all the studying and the written exams that usually go along with this. So so immediate steps may start soon, but they they don't often finish so quickly. Twenty-three uh no, sorry, excuse me. I was looking at chapter twenty, twenty-one-three, no presbytery shall ordain any intern to the office of minister of the word with reference to his laboring within the bounds of another presbytery, but shall furnish him with the necessary testimonials and require him to repair to the presbytery within whose bounds he expects to labor, that he may submit himself to its authority according to the constitution of the church.
SPEAKER_03So it's not an uncommon situation, right, for a man to be an uh a candidate and then a subsequent intern, maybe even licentiate in one presbytery while he's going through his schooling, uh, but then to get a call from a different presbytery. And the presbytery in which he's been can't ordain him to the work he's being called to, and so there has to be some movement happening. Um you guys may have some comments on this, it's pretty straightforward, but there's some significance in here.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean I uh again the the idea that that a presbytery is, you know, for an unordained man, uh you have to have a call, you have to be ordained to a call. The call is in the bounds of another presbytery, um, and it's not well we'll we'll ordain him to that call, because how can they put the call into his I mean you end up with an uncalled minister, basically, otherwise. So I mean it seems like a pretty like a lot of warning signs you see at restaurants and and on products. Clearly, somebody tried this once before and someone said, no, we're not doing that.
SPEAKER_02So but yeah. Seems pretty simple.
SPEAKER_03That's good. Oh Jared, Jared's giving me the nod. All right. All right, uh 21-4 is is one of our, you know, it's probably the longest in this chapter. Uh, and I'm going to handle it in uh, let's see, I was gonna give y'all some instructions. We're gonna take A and B. Is that how it's listed in the actual book? I've got it numbered in front of me, but A and B, and then we'll do uh C and D, and then we'll take E through the end. So we'll kind of talk about uh it in three parts. So settle in, everybody.
SPEAKER_03Listeners, this is what you're here for the BCO audiobook. An intern applying for ordination shall be required to present a diploma of bachelor or master from some approved college or university, and also a diploma of bachelor or master from some approved theological seminary or authentic testimonials of having completed a regular course of theological studies, or a certificate of completion of an endorsement from a theological study program as approved by the General Assembly and one of the presbyteries of the PCA.
SPEAKER_03No presbytery shall omit any of these educational requirements except in extraordinary cases, and then only with a three fourths approval of the Presbytery. Whenever a presbytery shall omit any of these educational requirements, it shall always make a record of the reasons for such omission and the parts omitted. The intern shall also present satisfactory testimonials as to the completion and approval of his internship and the practice of the ministry. B. Every candidate for ordination shall ordinarily have met the requirements of the assembly's approved curriculum. Ordinarily, the intern shall have been examined in most of the following trials when he was licensed.
SPEAKER_03If the Presbytery previously approved all parts of the licensure examination, it need not re examine the intern in those areas at this time. If there were areas of weakness, which the Presbytery noted, or if any member of the Presbytery desires to do so, the intern may be examined on particular points again. Additionally, the intern shall be examined on any parts required for ordination which were not covered in his examination for licensure. In all cases he should be asked to indicate whether he has changed his previous views concerning any points in the confession of faith, catechisms, and book of church order of the PCA.
SPEAKER_03So laying out educational requirements and and sort of covering what can move with a man as he moves toward ordination from his previous exams for licensure and otherwise. Maybe just start with A. There's some extraordinary circumstances, but it lays out the basics, which is a bachelor's and a master's from a university and a theological institution. Maybe you guys want to talk about the exceptions here, the extraordinary cases that can be implemented.
SPEAKER_03Um if you've seen them implemented before. I mean, some of us have probably seen a few of these in different cases.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, I I actually just want to make a quick comment to Stephen about like bachelor's and master's degrees, um, which are not I mean, you know, you're not going to find that in scripture uh which seminary did Paul go to or whatever else. But I do think it's part of that you know sort of common to human institutions language that we see in the Westminster Confession when it comes to polity things. And um, you know, obviously times are changing and you know, questions about you know the value of a bachelor's degree anymore, um you know, depending on what it you know, what it's in, uh whether or not that is as important today um or whether you know someone at a high school potentially you know just taking a bachelor's in theology at a seminary or a bachelor's, you know, bachelor of divinity type degree um might or even not fresh out of college, maybe somebody just never went to college.
SPEAKER_02Like, why should you go to four years of university if you're a 35-year-old guy who wants to go to the ministry just then to go through three to four more years of seminary and your bachelor's degree is in what? I mean, what difference does that make? So I think that that is one area where I think an exceptional uh or sorry, an exception could be provided for an extraordinary case. Um and I know there's there's several seminaries right now that are offering you know either a bachelor's divinity or like a certificate program or something like that for those types of men.
SPEAKER_02Um but uh you know it it it it's where we are now and I don't see any of that changing anytime in the future. But but it's not it's not like a biblical requirement or necessity that you have to have had a bachelor's degree before you can go into ministry. It's just the way we've kind of set that system up.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, we have had somebody that did not have um any college education, but had been a pastor in a different denomination that didn't require that, and as he was becoming more reformed and decided to leave that, he has a lot of experience, but also needs to know some things about reformed theology and polity, and so uh was pursuing a bachelor's in um I guess divinity or theology. Uh and there's a few places that offer that. I think Greenville, um, Reformed Presbyterian Theological Seminary, I've heard.
SPEAKER_02So RTS does a certificate. Yeah. Yeah. It'll give you a degree, but you get a yeah.
SPEAKER_01It is interesting the language between shall and then here's the exception to the shall. So the shall isn't quite a shall, but I guess it's shall except in in that circumstance. Um I I think it was Enquist that noted uh somewhere else that um of course there's this three um fourths approval of the presbytery that in the OPC, if there's some sort of extraordinary circumstance clause invoked, the General Assembly has to agree to it. So um they take that pretty seriously, that it's not just like a extraordinary clause. You hear some Presbyteries that every other you know exam is let's just invoke the extraordinary clause, but um by the its very name, it it probably shouldn't be something that you regularly do.
SPEAKER_03Um I've seen this used uh in our presbytery for uh uh a Baptist minister who was ordained for you know 15 years, became convinced of Reform Presbyterian theology, uh took some more classes to beef up his education, and then so instead of him having to have the you know the theological requirements, especially, they'll they'll grant him an uh an extraordinary case ordination. Uh the the second part there that we read talking about interns and licentiates previously. So some presbyteries do it one way and some do it another way, and there's probably some stuff in the middle where there's a set of licensure exams and then there's a set of ordination exams.
SPEAKER_03And so if you've already been licensed and some presbyteries, you may have to take all of the ordination exams, even though some of them overlap. Uh when I got ordained in Heritage Presbytery, they had two whole sets, so that my ordination exams, th three of them were the same categories. As my licensure exams, but they were a whole different set of questions aimed at sort of more higher tier pastoral ministry type things. But you are allowed to use your licensure exams and if the presbytery deems it appropriate to count towards your ordination trials.
SPEAKER_03Most presbyteries, I think, are willing to do that.
SPEAKER_02Well, it it it's kind of an interesting feature of the language because this has been amended a few different times. And part of the problem is that of the language of most of the following trials, where there are actually more well when this section was originally put in the BCO, I had to do a lot of research for RPR because this came up. Sorry. But but there were uh Bible content was not included, and then that was added uh you know later by Ascension Presbytery, by the way.
SPEAKER_02But anyway, it was added in. And I think even at one point, there might have been another one that was added, but like um the idea originally was that those all of those licensure trials, even though the language is different, so like it's one is theology, the other is basic understanding of biblical doctrine. But by looking at the language of the BCO, as it was originally written before the you know, before Bible content was added, it was the intention of those men that basic understanding of biblical doctrine and theology are functionally equivalent.
SPEAKER_02Assuming the presbytery wants to take it that way, they're not required to, but they're they're certainly not prohibited from doing that. And all of the licensure exam was it was possible to take that for most of the following trials. Uh that was before obviously, again, Bible content was added in. Uh so it's just a it is an interesting feature that that it's actually no longer most because you've you know we've added two, and so it doesn't it doesn't fit it, it's it's not more than half, unfortunately.
SPEAKER_02Um so I'm I'm gonna be on a crusade one of these years to to change that to many or some or something. I don't know.
SPEAKER_03It'll be a heated debate, I'm sure. Yes, I'm sure. Uh a man if he comes for license uh comes for licensure and now is coming for ordination, needs to uh if he's if he's studied more and has any changes on his views regarding the standards, he has to bring that up at this point as well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and it gives the presbytery the option to not re-examine him and just have him do you know church history sacraments, the extra things, but um it doesn't require them. And I learned the hard way that um it doesn't if you go to a different presbytery, uh it doesn't mean that they're gonna recognize the licensure exam of another presbytery. So uh I was licensed in one presbytery and then had to take all of the um the exams over again when I went to another one to be ordained.
SPEAKER_02I had the exact same experience, Jared. I think in the exact same presbytery. But also I love the idea that while the presbytery, or even the, you know, let's say the examinations committee can make a recommendation, let's just approve his licensure. Anybody can say, no, I've got I I want to ask some more questions of this guy on theology, and they can do that. And it's not uh you know, it still protects that sort of minority uh of even of one that I want to ask more questions.
SPEAKER_02I want to I want to cover some things. So I think that's helpful.
SPEAKER_03The the next section is gonna show this, but just that comment, Steve, makes me realize how prepared a man really needs to be. Because he he might be told by the committee, hey, we're gonna do these exams, but he could get to the floor and anybody could stand up and say, Hey, I I want to talk about church history, or I want to talk about let's talk about your uh Bible content that we didn't examine you in today, but I want to go back and you know, if he's if he hasn't kept that up like he should, he could be in trouble. It's you have to be to be on on your game. Let's do C and D.
SPEAKER_03We've already kind of gotten into some of this, but we'll give a little more time to it. Uh C starts to list the trials. Trials for ordination shall consist of uh first, a careful examination as to the man's acquaintance with experiential religion, especially his personal character and family management, his knowledge of the Greek and Hebrew languages, Bible content, theology, the sacraments, church history, the history of the Presbyterian Church in America, and the principles and rules of the government and discipline of the church.
SPEAKER_03A presbytery may accept a seminary degree, which includes study in the original languages in lieu of an oral examination in the original languages. He shall prepare a thesis on some theological topic assigned by presbytery. The candidate shall prepare an exegesis on an assigned portion of scripture requiring the use of original languages, uh language or languages. He shall further be required to preach a sermon before the presbytery or committee thereof upon three-fourths vote. No presbytery shall omit any of these parts of trial for ordination except in extraordinary cases, and then only with three-fourths approval of presbytery.
SPEAKER_03And D, whenever a presbytery shall omit any of these parts, it shall always make a record of the reasons for such omissions of the trial and of the trials parts omitted. So this is this is where you if somebody's referring to ordination exams, this is the pair the main section they're talking about. Uh written exams, uh, in most cases, oral exams uh always, and and some papers uh assigned. I mean, what what stands out here? What's important for us to walk through this?
SPEAKER_03I mean, my mind goes in a thousand different directions. Perhaps one of y'all can kind of rein us in a little bit.
SPEAKER_01Something that could be helpful there is just if you have a committee that's going through this, which I think every single Presbytery does, uh, to have somebody in charge of a different area of examination uh that way, um, something that isn't given short shrift. Um so like I'm on a committee and I have church history, and so I'm gonna ask those questions. I'm gonna grade that written exam. It takes a lot more off of the chairman uh as if they have to be the only one to grade all of these things.
SPEAKER_03You have the church history part? I mean, it's you don't even enjoy that. I would I can't imagine. Golly.
SPEAKER_02Well, I also think it's interesting how it begins. Well, I think it's interesting that Jared is teaching or is grading church history exams too, but um that you know it begins with that inward that idea of sort of the inward experience, right? Uh practical experience in Christianity, and then to the areas of knowledge um with some kind of theoretical, with some practical, and then with some sort of demonstration of that. I mean, you know, so even like just the flow of it is very interesting to me.
SPEAKER_02Um but also just my own experience with the uh examination in experiential religion that uh this is I mean, Ramsey describes this again as you know the most important piece of this. And I think, you know, in one sense we would agree with that philosophically, and yet we ask, you know, a hundred theology questions and very little uh in terms of you know someone's Christian experience, experiential religion.
SPEAKER_02Particularly, you know, again, I know when I like when I teach uh elders, uh you know, when I go through elder training, it's always struck me, and I'm not the the first person who's noticed this, but you think about the the qualifications in Timothy and Titus, that there's one uh doctrinal qualification, and all of the rest of those are character qualifications. Uh so certainly Paul is putting a much deeper emphasis on the character of the individual because you know you can teach somebody theology and and Bible content, etc.
SPEAKER_02And certainly you're gonna grow in that. Um but character is something that that to a degree exists or it doesn't, and is the most in in many ways, right? I mean, it is the you know the most important marker of I can put it this way, sort of success in ministry. Um you know, the last couple of years we've seen so many guys leave the ministry because of character failures. And uh not nearly so many because of you know their they had bad uh ability to to translate Greek and Hebrew.
SPEAKER_02So it's just kind of an interesting uh well, although we don't put a lot of importance on knowledge in Greek or Hebrew languages either. Um at least that's not that's interesting.
SPEAKER_01Is I I haven't been in a presbytery that has done a written it, it all seems to be. If you took it in seminary, they accept that. Yeah. Although I've uh I've heard from OPC brothers that um if you guys ever want to take a call in an OPC church, you need to brush up on your Greek and Hebrew because they will give you a written exam on that. And so um I think I do okay in my Greek, but my Hebrew needs a lot of work.
SPEAKER_03This uh I've I've become more familiar with this section than I've ever thought I would. I shouldn't say cared to, because I I rather enjoy chairing our credentials committee at the moment. Um but we you know, just to give a few comments from my side of things, uh, for anybody that may be interested in the future of becoming an ordained teaching elder or feels a call to ministry, uh, write good papers in seminary because we might receive them. Uh in our case, we assign a theological topic uh to our candidates for a fresh paper, but we do allow them to give us an exegesis paper from seminary.
SPEAKER_03Uh, and as long as it meets our requirements, we'll receive it. We we reserve the right to assign a fresh uh topic or uh passage, but um hold on to those papers. They're they're they can be very useful for you at this point. Uh they sort of prove that Greek and Hebrew uh education you received. And then the sermon as well usually is doubled up from licensure. If you've had to pre you had to preach for licensure, and so if you have accomplished that in our case, we we never asked an ordinanced to come and preach if he's already been licensed by our presbytery.
SPEAKER_03So um it's good good to note here if a presbytery leaves anything out or doesn't want to go through any of these, they've got to say why, and they have to tell us exactly what they left out. So uh that's that's a review and control issue to make sure that things are happening appropriately.
SPEAKER_02Um we didn't feel it was necessary to examine him in Bible content or theology. Right, yeah. Well, what? Yeah. Oh, I would also mention real quick, again, for those who are maybe in uh Presbyteries church history and history of the PCA are two separate exams. Um, you know, so even if even if one runs into the other, make sure your clerk is recording them separately because they are two different exams.
SPEAKER_03We have one written exam that covers both, just because it's you know but yeah, that's a that's a good point.
SPEAKER_01You do need to So know who the first moderator was, know who Morton Smith is, maybe Paul Settle, what those four organizations are were four organizations, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So I can tell I think I could I think I can tell this story safely here. Um we have time for a story, Ben.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and quality matters is a safe a safe place for everyone. Okay.
SPEAKER_02So um when I was being ordained in ascension, they were doing the church history exam at the end. And um, I mean I was I was I actually really enjoyed my ordination exam. I know a lot of guys are like really I mean I I I was enjoying it, it was a lot of fun. And um, you know, I was answering questions left and right, and um you know, I didn't get them all right, but I you know I was doing very well, we'll just put it that way. And then the last question, sorry, but that's part of the story. The last question was in, you know, the it was in uh PCA, and the guy who was asking the question said, Okay, I have one final question for you.
SPEAKER_02You know, what is what what gift uh did the RPCNA give to uh the PCA when it came in? And like for a half second, I thought, you know, it'd be really funny if I you know make some sort of like oh sir, I I have no idea. And then when he says, you know, Covenant College and Seminary, I would I was gonna say, Oh, I'm sorry, sir, I thought you asked which gift. And then immediately I said, You stupid idiot, just get ordained. Like, it's not even funny. Just move on.
SPEAKER_02But I I was like, you know, an eighth of a second away from being saying the stupidest thing in my life. And and let me be fair, I don't believe that's true. I was just like, you know, I was just having so much fun answering questions, and uh people were like were laughing with me. I mean, I had people like you know rolling in the aisles almost, this is essential, during my ordination exam, and I was like, oh I'm just gonna ride this. And I thought, yeah, idiot, just get ordained.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, careful with humor in the middle of a uh ordination exam. Oh yeah.
SPEAKER_02You can quickly turn on you, and especially considering I think half of that Presbyteria's former RPCNA, you know, churches anyway, uh, they might have looked for pitchforks and torches. So anyway. Well here you wanted to know about me.
SPEAKER_03No, well, we had you on. We want we want to know about you. Uh you just I mean, you you talk so much more than Scott, it's just an adjustment for me and Jared, that's all. We love it. We just it's very different. I ran into a fan of the show. I I hate to say it like that, but he he described himself this way at uh at RTS a couple weeks ago. And he I said uh He anyway, he made some reference to the fact that Scott doesn't talk very much, which I haven't told Scott yet, but he'll find out when he listens to this, or when he never listens to this, I suppose. Um I I had uh said I was gonna do E to the end uh by itself, but I think I'm gonna do E on its own and give us a second to just chat and then we'll do F through I altogether.
SPEAKER_03Uh the next step is in the examination of the candidate's personal character, the Presbytery shall give specific attention to potential notorious concerns. Careful attention must be given to his practical struggle against sinful actions as well as to persistent sinful desires. The candidate must give clear testimony of reliance upon his union with Christ and the benefits thereof by the Holy Spirit, depending on this work of grace to make progress over sin and to bear fruit. While imperfection will remain, when confessing sins and sinful temptations publicly, the candidate must exercise great care not to diminish the seriousness of those sins in the eyes of the congregation, as though they were matters of little consequence, but rather should testify to the work of the Holy Spirit and his progress and his holiness.
SPEAKER_03The reason I wanted to stop and just have us give a couple comments here is because I've I feel like especially in the last couple of years, I've noticed more and more men falling to sin, uh men who are ordained, uh who have have given in to temptation, especially sexual sin of various natures. And I just think it's uh it's important for us to sort of double down and emphasize this the significance of a man's character and piety as he comes into the ministry. It does um not just damage to a man and to his family, but if if a when a pastor falls, it damages everybody connected to him.
SPEAKER_03Um he loses his job, loses his family in some cases, and the church is damaged, uh, sometimes even uh in ways that we couldn't imagine or couldn't predict, sometimes don't even see. So uh, men, prepare yourself well, uh be close to the Lord and seek him. Uh these other guys probably have better advice. They've been doing this longer than me.
SPEAKER_01Well, this came out of the the revoice controversy, so that's in the background, even if it's not explicitly stated there. Um, it's especially thinking about sexual sins. And um that was a rather tense time, and there's a lot of debate over uh amending, because this is a newer section um to 21. Um, but I think at the end of that, we had we got something that was really well um written here, and I think takes care of some of the concerns that Steve was pointing out that we have tended to examine people and their theology and just assume that they have good character.
SPEAKER_01And I think this is saying, hey, you need to pay attention to that. Um you definitely need to ask questions of character and make sure that the the work of the Holy Spirit and sanctification uh is observable and happening in this guy's life.
SPEAKER_02Well, and I do think that in many ways, like the the the best place to do this is perhaps not on the floor of Presbytery, but in a committee. Uh you know, this isn't uh we're not a confessional we're a confessional church, but you know, uh Presbytery is not a a a place of confession. Uh we're not priests, let me put it that way. Um so and it's not just like you know, sort of, I don't want to say virtue signaling, but I'll say it anyway, virtue signaling of let me list three sins that I that I struggle with.
SPEAKER_02I struggle with pride and working too hard and I struggle, you know, whatever it is, you know. Um but rather for a committee to really talk to a man about these things, um and you know, obviously it it works both ways or it has to work both ways. The committee andor presbytery has to be serious and asking questions, and the man has to be willing to be humble and open about his struggles. Um but I do think it it it's a it's an important piece of that uh that that Christian experience that we say more than you know when I came to faith and when I received a call, you know, I felt the call to ministry or and my experiences as a pastor, um, but that you have the capacity to talk about your struggle uh with sin and and your your fight against sin uh in a way that that that not just will translate necessarily to a committee, but how you speak about those things to your church uh in a in an appropriate way, but how you speak about those things is very important, isn't it?
SPEAKER_03Well, here let's finish out 21-4, starting back in F. While our Constitution does not require the candidate's affirmation of every statement andor proposition of doctrine in our confession of faith and catechisms, it is a right and responsibility of the presbytery to determine if the candidate is out of accord with any of the fundamentals of these doctrinal standards, and as a consequence, may not be able in good faith sincerely to receive and adopt the confession of faith and catechisms of this church as containing the system of doctrine taught in the Holy Scriptures. Therefore, in examining a candidate for ordination, the presbytery shall inquire not only into the candidate's knowledge and views in the areas specified above, but also shall require the candidate to state the specific instances in which he may differ with the confession of faith and catechisms in any of their statements andor propositions.
SPEAKER_03The court may grant an exception to any difference of doctrine, only if in the court's judgment the candidate's declared difference is not out of accord with any fundamental of our system of doctrine, because the difference is neither hostile to the system nor strikes at the vitals of religion. The presbytery, being fully satisfied of his qualifications for the sacred office, shall appoint a day for his ordination, which ought, if practicable, to be in the church of which he is to be the pastor. The extraordinary clauses should be limited to extraordinary circumstances of the church or proven extraordinary gifts of the man. Presbyteries should exercise diligence and care in the use of these provisions in order that they not prevent the ordination of a candidate for whom they are truly exceptional circumstances, nor ordain, nor receive from other denominations, a person who is inadequately prepared for the ministry.
SPEAKER_03Listeners, we're not trying to cruise through this without comment, but uh we have uh F and G dealing with stating differences and good faith subscription. We talked a little bit about that back in BCO 19, but I want to sort of tease for you. We have an interview coming up in just uh another couple episodes with uh Pastor David Strain from Jackson, Mississippi. He he came on with us uh for a good hour to talk about good faith subscription. So any questions you may have about those differences and stating differences and how presbyteries handle it, hopefully those will get answered in just a couple more episodes.
SPEAKER_03So we're really not gonna say a whole lot. Uh and then the H and I are more technical, just sort of telling us to move along and be aware of the extraordinary clauses. All that being said, is there anything we want to comment here, guys, on on those last four parts of BCO214?
SPEAKER_01No um RAO 163E6. That's where it lists the the how you might classify an exception. One is the candidate doesn't take an exception. Uh the other is they take an exception, but you're like, it's not really an exception. That's when you would say it's you know it's semantic. Uh the other is it it really is a difference, but it doesn't strike at the vitals, and then the final being that it strikes at the vitals and then you actually can't ordain them. But more on that in the other uh interview, but no know that reference, be able to get there in the REO 16 3.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I think just quickly, um I I think it's interesting that uh ruling elders are not required to state differences. Um even though this references 24-6 question two, which is a ruling elder question, um nowhere in 24 does it require ruling elders to state their differences. Uh but actually I I want to just say a quick thing about H. I thought that was interesting. Um that if practicable, uh you should do uh the ordination in the church of which he used to be the pastor.
SPEAKER_02Um which obviously that makes sense, right? I mean, you do the ordination there. But one of the things that again, sorry to bring up Ramsay again, but Ramsey had mentioned actually you should do you should do the examination in the church where he is to be ordained, and that the church should be invited to sort of be there for for both sides, right? Like if he totally blows it, you don't have to take our word for it. You were in the room, you saw it. Um but also if he does really well, or however he does, right, you get an opportunity to see your guy up there doing his thing.
SPEAKER_02And um, you know, all of that encouragement that that brings, uh it was just kind of interesting. So I don't know where else she would ordain a man if he's to be a pastor of in the church he is gonna be in, but whatever.
SPEAKER_00As an AI audio generator would say, this podcast is over. Thanks for joining us. We'll be back next time to finish up BCO21. If you're interested in learning more about anything we discussed, check out the show notes in your podcast player or at politymatters.org. If you have questions or comments, you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com. You can support our work directly by going to buymecoffee.com/slash Politymatters. Your contributions help us keep production going from week to week. If you enjoyed the show, follow us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters and subscribe in your podcast app of choice.
SPEAKER_00Our thanks to Steve Tipton and our listeners for joining us. Until next time, y'all take care.
Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...
Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...
Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...
Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...
Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...