Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Polity Matters

Polity Matters artwork

106. Just Let Them Go (BCO 46)

Oct 21, 202544 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Polity Manners, where we explore the importance of polity in the church. My name is Scott Edberg. I'm joined today with Jared Nelson and our special guest, uh common guest, Steve Dowling. We are currently working through the rules of discipline in the PCA Book of Church Order, and we're near the end at BCO 46 on jurisdiction. And so this is the last chapter in our ROD. And so that means the next time we discuss the BCO, it will have to do with the directory, the infamous directory of worship.

SPEAKER_00But let's not get ahead of ourselves. We're on the uh rules of discipline. But before we get there, Steve, could you perhaps remind our listeners who you are and where you serve?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'm Steve Dowling. I'm a ruling elder in Southeast Alabama Presbytery. Uh my immediate session service is at Covenant Presbyterian Church, where I've been for the last more than 20 years.

SPEAKER_00Well, as we get into the topic of jurisdiction, are there any preliminary thoughts you want to give to us or any uh what would what are some things that would help prepare us for this chapter? It seems like kind of a boilerplate trap chapter, but is there any thoughts or preliminary ideas you have, Steve, on this issue?

SPEAKER_02Two of them. Uh you know, one, uh Jared uh had said previously that this chapter hasn't changed a lot, and it hasn't, you know, it's been pretty static for a long time. You don't see a lot of overtures that are bent on changing chapter 46. Uh so that's the first thing. It's been pretty static, it's been pretty stable. Uh but the second thing is that uh it's funny uh how much uh business the SJC gets that actually relates to questions of this type of jurisdiction and transfer. And by that I mean everything from the way that erasure from the role functions to how transfers function and the duties that are associated with that.

SPEAKER_02Uh, because functionally speaking, somebody tells a session that they're leaving, a lot of these rules have become unenforceable. And uh when sessions try to act in good faith uh to meet their vows with respect to a member or even an officer leaving the church, uh, they sometimes wind up in a judicial no man's land. So on the one hand, it's been very static, very stable. You can triangulate to it. On the other, it's actually used in a way that sort of obviates the taking of vows in the first place and uh creates an escape route for people who sometimes ought to be under discipline.

SPEAKER_02So I think those two things are worth considering.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, when I was uh at RTS Jackson in a polity class with Guy Waters, Guy invited a ruling elder from FPC Jackson, uh, and it was on this sort of issue, and he said, if uh congregant renounces your jurisdiction, you just let them go. Uh otherwise you're you have the potential of facing lawsuits, civil lawsuits for your actions if you constantly pursue them. And that gets back to preliminary principles where this is a voluntary organization, and if we elect to leave, we leave.

SPEAKER_00Uh and obviously there are, you know, issues um of sin within that, but civilly speaking, uh, we are a voluntary institution, and so jurisdiction is important. Uh well, getting into BCO 46.1, then, uh, it says this when a church member shall remove his residence beyond the bounds of the congregation of which he is a member, so that he can no longer regularly attend its services, it shall be his duty to transfer his membership by presenting a certificate of demission uh from the session of the church of which he is a member to the church which he wishes to unite.

SPEAKER_00When the church of which he is a member has no session, or for other good reasons, it seems impossible for the member to secure a certificate of dismission, he may be received by the session upon other satisfactory testimonials, in which case the church of which he was a member shall be duly notified. And so perhaps a good uh introductory question as we think of the idea of jurisdiction is what is church membership? What is church membership?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think uh we would think back to the vows uh that are taken. Um uh the responsibilities of the church member, but also the responsibilities of the church is to have uh oversight over somebody. I was thinking about this um today. I went to a hospital room where uh a woman in our congregation had suffered a stroke, and I was reading to her John 10, and um just the fact that the the sheep know the voice of the shepherd and the shepherd knows uh the the sheep by name and number.

SPEAKER_01And we need to know who uh is in our care. And so um both the the elders, in a sense, take vows to have care over the sheep, and the sheep are taking vows uh to the church, and so this church membership is uh much more than just um put your name on the roll or uh um uh bookkeeping type things. Uh this is about the the care of souls and um in a group to know who your leaders are and who the leaders are responsible for.

SPEAKER_02What do we have that's a a very fine answer? Um and uh yeah, Jared, you know, my experience uh over the years has been that um it's an interesting thing that both parties that you just mentioned take vows, which are vows uh to God. I mean, those are promises to God. And yet so many times uh when people transfer, uh we really don't assiduously follow up with them, stay in contact with them, love them. Uh I can't tell you personally to my shame.

SPEAKER_02The last time I reached out to uh geography where I knew members were were moving and and uh asked a session and and linked up those two parties. And you know, I think that in that I'm not really meeting the requirements of the office. I'm not really meeting my vows, you know, because that requirement is in there. And uh why is it in there? Well, it's like you said, for the care of the sheep. But I think more prominently folks, when they leave, um they do a lot of resorting out. I mean, there may be five PCA churches in a in a geography.

SPEAKER_02There may be one. You know, maybe they go to an OPC church first. I mean, who knows what they do one way or the other, though. That year-long clock winds up running out. So um I think that that very first part uh should serve as a great reminder of our mutual responsibility. And I think you're absolutely right to focus on the vows.

SPEAKER_00And when we're thinking of jurisdiction, membership is important. It's perhaps good to remind uh our listeners that our ruling elders are members of their local churches. That's where their jurisdiction resides, along with our congregants and the deacons. Uh, the pastors, uh the teaching elders of our churches are actually members of the regional body, the presbytery. And that's where their jurisdiction um is most poignant. And we've talked about this before on our show that it is not the duty of sessions to bring disciplinary actions against the pastor, that's the duty of the presbytery.

SPEAKER_00Um, and it's the work of the presbytery to do that. And so jurisdiction is important in both of those regards. But here we're looking at church membership. Uh, when thinking about church membership, uh when this section talks about transferring to another church, is that talking about a PCA church? What kind of church is in mind in this section of the BCO?

SPEAKER_02We like to think it's PCA churches, but we actually accept other Bible-believing uh credible churches within uh uh the within the uh body of Christ at large. So it is possible for someone to disaffiliate from the PCA and go to another church in good standing, in particular to a Napark church as an example.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I think of some transfers we've had to Baptist churches, and it's always kind of funny uh because you're trying to complete a formal process that they often don't recognize. And so you're like, I'm trying to dismiss them to you. Are they members now? And they're like, We what what's membership? And so it's sometimes difficult to transfer people outside of the PCA if they have different standards for membership in general. Well perhaps what are some yeah, go ahead, Jared.

SPEAKER_01Oh, I was uh wondering about that second paragraph, which you're probably gonna ask about of like what are those situations in which it seems impossible you have two PCA churches or somebody coming from a uh PCA church or a church that should be diligent on that, and for good reasons, um either has no session or it seems impossible for the member to secure a certificate. Like I wonder what those situations would would be other than maybe the church doesn't exist anymore, like if it just folded and don't know who to contact.

SPEAKER_01Um I don't know if you guys have seen that uh in your uh in your time where it's impossible or just nobody responds. I don't know.

SPEAKER_02Two weeks ago. Actually, got a call from a pastor here in southeast Alabama, a wonderful guy who's very, very uh detail-oriented and didn't wind to what want to wind up sideways on the BCO, so he called me about that. And that was literally the situation, Jared. The church had shut down. There was no one to transfer them. And I said, brother, the the most expedient thing to do here with this uh couple that's desirous of being, you know, uh under the authority of shepherds, and uh a church that's willing to receive them like you are, you bring them into the session, you hear a uh you hear their con their uh testimony, and you transfer them in by profession of faith, and that's what they wound up doing.

SPEAKER_02But uh that's the only kind of situation I've seen where that's happened, Jared, is where the church doesn't exist anymore because by and large, folks will communicate out of any church.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we we live near an Air Force base, and so we have a lot of transfers in through the Air Force base, but sometimes their membership is outside of the United States, and you you look up the church website and there's not really any contact information and they don't have contact, and just getting a hold of people is extraordinarily difficult. Um, and and so I've seen that a few, there's been a few cases at my current call where we just have no way of reaching people um outside of the US because there's just not good contact methods.

SPEAKER_00Um and we so we take them by profession, we hear their profession and have an irregular transfer in. Any other thoughts on 46.1? All right, 46.2, it's a lengthy one. Uh BCO 46.2 says, When a church member shall remove his residence beyond the bounds of the church of which he is a member into the bounds of another, it shall be the duty of the teaching and ruling elders of the church of which he is a member, as far as possible, to continue pastoral oversight over him and to inform him that according to the teaching of our Book of Church order, it's his duty to transfer his membership as soon as practical uh practically uh practical to the church in whose bounds he is living.

SPEAKER_00It shall also be the duty of the church from whose bounds the member moved to notify the teaching and ruling elders of a church into whose bound he has moved and request them to take pastoral oversight of the member, with a view of having him transfer his membership, unless BCO 187 applies. If a member, after having thus been advised, shall neglect for one year to have his membership transferred, the session shall then proceed according to BCO 384, except in special cases such as servicemen, students, etc.

SPEAKER_00The name of any members whose residence has been unknown for one year to the session shall be removed from the role, and such names are not to be counted in the annual statistics reports, though an act of removal should be recorded in the session's minutes. If such a person at a latter date should appear or desire transfer of his or her letter, the session will inform the governing body of the inquiring church of their action in removing the person from their role. And so in this section, we have both responsibilities for the individual, the congregant, as well as the session.

SPEAKER_01Now, the the church that they're coming from also should be helping them in that, but uh it really is the responsibility of that family to be looking for a good church that they can uh attend to there. And um if I was knowing the BCO, which your average lay person is not gonna know very well, I would inquire what the uh church if they've contacted the old church. Um so knowing what I do now, I would probably contact my old church and let them know um you know what the process is and who's gonna be contacting them in case the other church doesn't do their due diligence, but um hopefully they're getting a contact from their old church where they're asking them those sorts of questions, too.

SPEAKER_00And perhaps we can divide dive a little deeper in what the session's role is. Uh I know Steve, you said that uh this is probably the hard part that we often fall short of, but what what is our responsibility as shepherds in the church to those who move away?

SPEAKER_02It's pretty explicit that we're supposed to follow up with them and treat them as though they're still under our care until they're actively under the care of another session. Um it's just functionally, I don't think that's usually the case. And one of the reasons I think that is because what we're reading here in the BCO sort of assumes a wonderful relationship, you know, where um everyone is uh engaged, the the members engaged in the work and worship of the church. Um everybody loves one another. Uh, you know, it's kind of a wonderful church situation.

SPEAKER_02And then they move, and um, you you know, everybody mutually is working toward the same goal, coming into another PCA church, being put under care and making introductions, maybe even, uh, creating some sense of continuity in their in their shepherding and uh therefore in their spiritual growth. But practically speaking, uh what really happens lots of times is people leave and they there was something they didn't like. You know, maybe they didn't like the form of the church government, uh, maybe they liked the the preaching, but they objected to some theological aspect.

SPEAKER_02You know, here in Southeast Alabama, we have a very powerful uh route sunk into uh the Baptist church, right? And so as a consequence, we've picked up a lot of people who, when they leave us, they wind up going, you know, uh that they transfer. They they may go back to a Baptist church, uh, they may go back to you know an OPC church because you know we're a college town and the music's too contemporary or whatever. And uh they haven't uh in some cases been really desirous of a lot of rudder and a lot of attention, you know, after after they've left, except insofar as you've got a personal relationship and you're just calling a friend.

SPEAKER_02So uh, you know, I I think on the one hand, uh when everything's great, this is a very natural motion to follow. When everything isn't great, or there's been some fractiousness with the the member or the member's family or something like that, uh, then you kind of have this disconnect. And I think that that's the part that needs the most attention. You know, you have to love folks even when they're not being loving. And um you do that without insistence and without trying to dominate them, harangue them, or anything else.

SPEAKER_02And that's where it really becomes hard. Because you want the best for them. I mean, if you don't, then you shouldn't be an elder.

SPEAKER_00One great story from one of my mentors, Charlie Wingard, when I was serving under him uh in Yazoo City, he would make it a point to travel to each of the state universities every semester and have dinner with the students that were from our church uh in that location. And so he would go to Ole Miss and Mississippi State once a semester and catch up with some of the students that were members of our church just to care for them and to visit them. And I just remember the families and the students themselves.

SPEAKER_00I mean, who travels, you know, two, three hours to go visit me, you know. My family doesn't even do that often unless there's a game. And so it was it was it left an impression on me. Uh, I don't do it as well as Charlie does, um, but that I think is the ideal. That's how you practically offer oversight to those who are far from you, and they don't mean to stay far, they're just at school. Um, but uh that was always so beautiful seeing the photos of him with those students and the devotion he's had to them.

SPEAKER_02I'm not surprised to hear that about Charlie. He's wonderful.

SPEAKER_00He is a wonderful man. Uh it's hard to live in his shadow even as a minister. What about the limitations here? We do have some limitations. If a member, after being thus advised, shall neglect for one year being transferred, uh, then the session shall proceed to 38-4. Um why why is the one why is there a one-year limit? Is that just arbitrary? We've kind of talked about arbitrary time frames in the BCO before.

SPEAKER_00Uh, why do we have a year here?

SPEAKER_02I think you put your finger around it. I mean, it could be six months, could be nine months, could be three hundred and sixty-four days instead of three sixty-five. Um, it's consistent with other timelines in the BCO, but I have no idea what the whether there's some sort of a a deeper component to it. Um Jared, I'd defer to you. What do you what do you know?

SPEAKER_01I think it's uh arbitrary just to have some sort of a trigger that gets everybody on the same page. Because I if you were just to ask people how long if one person says six months, another person says nine months, then you're just gonna be fighting over the time limit. Um this actually triggers, okay, guys, it's been a year. We're we're now having to trigger this thing. And same thing with somebody that's neglected being in the church, like how long do you give them? And everybody has a different number. Well, if you have a number that's set out there for action to be triggered, um, you actually start to do it.

SPEAKER_01So I think that's what it is. I I do think it's interesting and have some uh special cases. There are some times that this can't be triggered, you know, servicemen uh students. If you have somebody in the Navy that's out on a boat um and they're away or they're in a foreign country and they can't be a member of the church there, uh, that's different. Uh we had a member in our church that would go down for uh months at a time uh to a place in Central America where he told us um, you know, if he ever actually moved there, uh he would not want to transfer membership anywhere because his only choices were Mormon churches and Catholic churches.

SPEAKER_01And there's nothing else that was that was around other than that. And so he would um listen to us uh uh online on Sundays and um come back to us when he was back. But um just thought of like if you ever move there, uh there's nowhere to transfer him to.

SPEAKER_02So I think uh put your finger on. I'm sorry, please go ahead, brother.

SPEAKER_00I I think a good policy here is that you're not making an example with anyone with what you're doing. Sometimes in on church sessions, you have a situation where you don't have a policy in place, but you wish you did. Uh because now you have to make an action that you have no prior precedent for making. And so uh I think something like this is helpful in saying this is what our book says, and we're following the book. It's not a a personal act of vendetta against you. This is the law that we've been given, and this is if we want it to be different, we have to go through processes to change it, but it it makes it less of a personal act, and it it takes out the personalities from making such a decision.

SPEAKER_00There might be there, you know, that that sometimes is the case in the church. But in these circumstances, you're not making an example of someone where you want to get them off the rolls and you're just doing it because you want to do it. Well, no, this is gives you the process for how and why. Did you have something, Steve?

SPEAKER_02I was just I've got three things actually. The the first one is that 38-4 is uh disciplinary. Um it's administrative discipline, but it's disciplinary. Uh so what you don't have is uh the process where you under where you don't have a situation where you undertake process and charge a person or anything like that. But functionally you're removing their name from the role. And I think uh 384, which I don't have up in front of me, but I'm pretty sure the language is that it's uh an act of pastoral discipline. And it needs to be considered to be an act of pastoral discipline.

SPEAKER_02It means that in taking these vows that we spoke about earlier, um, you haven't really taken seriously your duty to the church writ large, or you'd be in one, and uh we would be able to transfer you, and we would know that you didn't come out from under shepherding care, and we would know that you're you know you're serious about your own life and that of your family. So I think that that it's important for people to realize that that end date is as objective as you said it was, but it's also punitive in a way. It's pastoral discipline, it's telling you you're not doing it right.

SPEAKER_02Uh the second Thing is, this exclusion of special cases. I think that that's uh ultra important because it um leaves the the discretion uh for how to deal with people who are in the kinds of situations that Jared spoke about with the session to say, no, that makes sense, and we're going to retain that membership. You know, this person wants to be bound to a church, it wants to be affiliated with one, it doesn't want to be out from under the kind of cover you get for shepherding. And uh, you know, and we get to make those decisions because it's at our discretion to do it.

SPEAKER_02And then the third thing is that the most important word here is probably, et cetera, because that really and truly does root the discretion to make a decision about any individual in the session. And we all know there are myriad circumstances that could cause people to not move for a year. We've got a minister right now shutting down uh our Korean church that meets in our building. He's got cancer, and he's going to uh my understanding is he's going to uh Durham, North Carolina, where his son's an oncology surgeon. I believe I'm getting that right.

SPEAKER_02If not, he's going there because he's a surgeon of some type and he has an oncology practice that he can tap into. But one way or the other, um, when someone goes off on something like that, you don't know what the rehabilitation period is. You don't know whether the intent is that they were going to repatriate in nine months. And uh, you know, so to go ahead and exert 38-4 when they cross over a year when their whole intent was to be back after they uh went through their period of treatment or something is ridiculous. You need to have the ability as a session to say, we will deal with that in the due course of time and let those things play out.

SPEAKER_02So I think etc. here is a really big word because it reaffirms the discretion of the session to focus on what's best for the member, what's best for the individual. So I just wanted to throw those things in there. Not sure how helpful they were, but that's my thinking on it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a good example. That's very common for us even to have church members who go on hospice or are sick, and that leads them to all sorts of interesting areas in the world, sometimes for surgeries and rehab. And so this allows for the latitude of not being needlessly burdensome upon those who are already ailing by trying to remove them quickly. We've talked about it even at Providence. I've not seen a one of our members in a long time in church because he has a issue, a health issue.

SPEAKER_00And the question was, how long do we keep him on the rolls? And it's like, well, indefinitely. You know, he's he's sick, he needs us, you know. Uh and we need to surround him as we can. Uh BCO 463, we gotta keep moving here. Uh, members of the church dismissed to join another shall be held to be under the jurisdiction of the session, dismissing them until they form a regular connection with that to which they have been dismissed. Uh, what is this teaching us about the transition process from one church to another for a member?

SPEAKER_02I'll wait in. Uh obviously the the first there's a couple components here, right? One is that the the the the people have to have joined, the person has to have joined a church where where they're going to in their destination. And then there's this administrative transaction of having released them. And so uh my view of it would be that this is this is uh concomitant to tying off a um uh an ordination or a particularization ceremony where you go through it and then it's finalized when you date and sign all the documentation.

SPEAKER_02Um I can see that that'd be a point of dissension if anybody ever disputed it. You can say, well, we've been going to church here, we went here long enough to uh decide to join it. We took our vows, we were accepted as members, we stood in front of the room, and you know, we think they've got jurisdiction over us. Um but I do think it needs to be tied off with the documentation that we're required to produce as well. Just as a matter of information, I would absolutely agree that that other church had jurisdiction for what that's worth.

SPEAKER_01I like uh Smith's uh comments, which are only like two sentences. He says this simply guarantees that the individual does not lose his membership in the church visible if for some reason he fails to join another church or is not received by another church, remains a member of his original church until received elsewhere. So this is a you didn't fall through the the crack in the paperwork if um the the church has something happen and you're not received that Sunday, you're still a member of the church, you're still on the rules.

SPEAKER_00Perhaps in likewise manner and building off of that between church relations uh is associate members. And we see that in BCO 464. Associate members are those believers temporarily residing in a location other than their permanent homes. Such believers may become associate members of a particular church without ceasing to be communicate members of their home churches. An associate member shall have all the rights and privileges of that church, with the exception of voting in a congregational or corporate meeting, and hold an office in that church.

SPEAKER_00And so in this section, there is a provision for being uh an associate member that's that is a member of two churches, one of being the associate and one being the original home church. And at the associate church, uh you have all the full rights and privileges of being a member of that church, minus two uh perhaps notable um uh issues, and that is in voting in congregational meetings and holding office uh in that church. Um it I believe associate membership is somewhat unique in the PCA.

SPEAKER_00Why does it exist?

SPEAKER_01Probably for some of those categories that we're talking about earlier, students and servicemen, uh, people that are in a place temporarily but are going back. Um maybe they're there for treatment for a season they want to be an associate member to be recognized by the rest of the church. It it is interesting when you think about what the rights and privileges. What are the rights and privileges of a of a member if they can't vote and they can't be an officer? Um, well, those include being cared for and shepherded. So there's a sense in which it's uh a learning of a church. Like you have somebody that may not officially be on your rolls, but you're responsible for them, and they have uh privileges of being shepherded, of you including them in a shepherded group, of you uh including them on your uh church email, you know, whenever you're gonna have a picnic or or whatever it may be, uh that they're included with those sorts of things.

SPEAKER_01So it's uh again another provision that we recognize in a modern world, people travel around and there are especially a couple groups that um this is this is a common uh thing. If you ever have service people in your in your congregation, you will have to um deal with having associate members. Um I find it a little bit funny too, whenever we have people come into our presbytery, Jane Eikirk will always ask them questions um at the BCO exam about associate membership. And there'll be uh technical questions that you have no idea what the answer is to, and then at the end of it, he just says, Well, I'm just wondering because I don't know exactly how it works in all the details either.

SPEAKER_01So there's a lot of cool questions that I think this doesn't answer, but it does provide for uh for some sort of provision uh to care for people.

SPEAKER_02I think it's got a lot of wisdom to it. You know, first because I spent almost three decades in the military, and there are places that you go, especially on extended deployments or unaccompanied tours overseas where you've got the chapel and that's it. And you can't first transfer membership into a chapel, and second, the way that the chaplaincy works, um Protestant pastors are all considered the same thing, and uh they conduct the services, so you really don't even have continuity in your basic theology at a chapel.

SPEAKER_02So, from a military standpoint, like Jared pointed out, uh, I've always been a fan of this uh provision, but now I live in a college town, and I can tell you that um we get a lot of people who really want to only be associate members. Well, why? Well, because the Auburn's 90 minutes from Birmingham, and you know, it's uh you know 60 minutes from Montgomery, and there's a lot of downtime. You know, you start school, then you've got fall break, then you've got the holidays for Christmas, then you've got uh at Christmas and New Year's, and then you've got spring break.

SPEAKER_02And the reality is that these folks are back at their home churches a pretty substantial amount of time. They don't really break that connection. So at least in the the local collegiate environment that I'm operating in, this is a wonderful provision to have. It enables them them to uh you know to have the relationship with us and participate while they're in school and then to go home and and be plugged right into their home church in the same way.

SPEAKER_00Well, uh moving on then, uh BCO 465 is vacated. It seems like it was merged into another section. It's just the the prior BCO 465 was dealing with removing someone after a year. And so we've already kind of talked about that in other sections of 46.5, and that was done all the way back, I believe, in the 90s, 1997. And so we'll go on to 46.6, which is when a presbytery shall dismiss a minister, licentiate, or candidate, the name of the presbytery to which he is dismissed shall be given in the certificate, and he shall remain under the jurisdiction of the presbytery dismissing him until received by the other.

SPEAKER_00And so this is dealing more broadly with uh those who are uh ordained and under the jurisdiction of the presbytery itself, but also those who are under both the jurisdiction of the presbytery in some regard with licentients and candidates, as well as the local church. And so this is a similar provision that we just read in 46-3, except it's dealing with those who have relations with um a presbytery itself. Is there anything to note here, guys?

SPEAKER_01I I think it's just something of uh you may have a presbytery that uh is going to dismiss somebody to another presbytery, and if that presbytery has problems that doesn't receive them, it doesn't mean that I think it clarifies a little bit if you're the presbytery and you're voting no, we don't recognize that as a call to the place that you're going, uh you're not uh putting them under discipline, you're not uh they're not losing their credentialing. It's they still have that held at the previous presbytery, but um you need to be able to make decisions as a receiving presbytery that the other one isn't forcing your hand.

SPEAKER_01So this just clarifies if you say no, they're still a member of the other presbytery and uh figure out what comes next after that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I think it's also worth saying that you know, in the case of these categories of men, um they've been put into that uh classification or that status by a presbytery action. Uh they've been examined, uh, you know, and and we will have received the presbytery will have received testimony about a man's internal call to the gospel ministry and things like that. And and those elevate consideration of jurisdiction and our responsibility as a church generally uh to further that continuum if it becomes necessary for a man to move.

SPEAKER_02So I'd say it's a little bit of a different requirement set that's being addressed here, and so a little bit of extra care on addressing it specifically.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's a lot of details in here, too, right? When you're a licentiate or a candidate, uh transferring includes usually transferring with something. And so often candidates will transfer from one presbytery to another. They've completed their um their internship in seminary, and so the receiving presbytery will also receive that internship completion mark, and and ministers they don't retake all the exams, they they just do transfer exams. Uh, and so there's a lot that goes with transfer.

SPEAKER_00Uh it's kind of like a chicken and egg, though, uh, because the presbyteries don't usually shake hands at the same time. Um, often the receiving presbytery receives uh the man before he's officially transferred by the other presbytery. And so there's like always a mismatch and who's shaking whose hand when. Um and so you're you're kind of stuck in in like, at least intellectually, in limbo until your sending presbytery officially signs off on you leaving. Though some presbyteries have commissions that do this very thing, and it's really tight, uh, but not all Presbyteries.

SPEAKER_00Uh moving on to 46-7. Uh, no certificate of dismission uh from either a session or presbytery shall be valid testimony of good standing for a period longer than one year, unless its earlier presentation be hindered by some providential cause, and such certificates given to persons who have left the bounds of the session or presbytery granting them shall certify the standing of such persons only at the time of their leaving those bounds. And so what does uh BCO 467 seek to clarify for us?

SPEAKER_01Maybe if you're receiving presbytery that you shouldn't wait uh too long to actually receive that person, uh or you're gonna have to go back and ask again. Um to put some sort of a time limit on it, but also make it reasonable. You may have a presbytery that only meets a couple times a year. And so you want to give an enough time for them to receive it. Uh and a year should be enough time.

SPEAKER_00A lot changes in a man's life, um, even in the you know, the time of one year. And so if if you're taking a testimony from a Presbytery from a man that they've not seen in three years and do not know, um, a lot can change in a man's life uh in that three years. And so you need up-to-date information. Uh it's even when you're thinking through references at churches or in normal jobs, uh, you want to know the the people closest to the man now, not the people he knew ten years ago.

SPEAKER_00That those might be helpful for character checks, but you want to know how he's currently doing in his work capacity, not what he was five years ago when he was an intern. And so it's helpful to have up-to-date information. And that's all that requires here is that you get a new, renewed, up-to-date uh reference check on the man. Any other comments on 46 7? Want to be conscientious of time here. 46 8. Uh, when a presbytery shall divest a minister of his office without censure or depose him without excommunication, it shall assign him into membership in some particular church, subject to the approval of the session of that church.

SPEAKER_00Perhaps we can uh start by distinguishing what is the difference between divesture and deposition. We have a SJC man on today, and so what is the distinction between those two acts?

SPEAKER_02Well, you can be divested without judicial process. Um you can also accept someone demitting their office for reasons that range from not feeling called to the gospel ministry anymore to let your imagination fly. So um, one of those I would just say it admits of the possibility of a non-judicial procedure uh for for someone no longer being ordained. Uh and the second one, the deposition, is definitely a judicial action.

SPEAKER_02Uh only it has not, in this case that's cited here, resulted in excommunication. Uh so if the man isn't cut off completely from the body of Christ, he is no longer, because he's no longer a teaching elder, under the authority of Presbytery, so he must be assigned to a session. Um there's been an awful lot of trouble with this. Uh in fact, there are three overtures that were approved last year at the General Assembly that all bear on this problem. And uh they have necessitated some uh amendments to BCO 36, really chapters four, five, and eight.

SPEAKER_02And um uh and what it does is it it on the one hand uh prevents Presbytery from having to undertake an entirely new process to elevate uh an indefinite kind of suspension for a man. Uh, or uh in this case that we've got explicitly here in 48.6, the idea that you've deposed him without excommunication. Uh who has the power to excommunicate? You'd think it would be this church to which he's been assigned, but in practicality, the presbytery has retained authority over those judicial cases.

SPEAKER_02So they've elevated the censure sometimes without process, sometimes with whole new trials and so on. And so that flurry of things that we saw this year at the General Assembly all bear on this fundamental issue and seek to bring both clarity and administrative simplicity to the process while at the same time preserving the rights of the individual who's under censure in a way that they previously hadn't been protected. But that's a long conversation. You'll have to go reswizzle and have a session on uh on all those changes to the BCO, which you'll probably do anyway, right?

SPEAKER_02After they get approved or disapproved.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we've talked about uh those amendments a little bit on the show. That was an issue that Jared's smile that no one can see except us three is because that's my Presbytery's fault that all those overtures came in, because we tried to elevate a censure without additional process. And that has led to maybe we need to clarify. Um, and and that was uh it was an interesting case because we had tried to use SJC precedent to hit a home run and to have it upheld. Uh, but the SJC decided that the prior SJC erred uh in its decision, and that's probably what has led to the amendments to the book, uh, because prior SJCs are disagreeing with current SJCs, and um, that means there's probably some ambiguity that needs further clarification.

SPEAKER_00And so I'm grateful for those amendments personally, and it will help us not make those mistakes again if ratified.

SPEAKER_02Um but with you. I I mean I think you did you guys did the church a service because the SJC truly is divided. You know, I'm of the mind that um if if you've deposed somebody and sent them off, put them under the authority of the session, in the same way that we just got done talking about how you take a licentia or a candidate and move them to a different presbytery or whatever, that the jurisdiction question is taken up at that point. And that's and you can't have mutual jurisdiction. And so the idea that someone could reach back and say, well, we're tired of waiting for that guy to repent, so we're just gonna declare him contumacious, and now he's excommunicated when he may have been faithfully going to church for two years at this new place.

SPEAKER_02We don't know. Um and yet if you do an entirely new trial, it's it's exhausting. I mean, there are all kinds of requirements, there's all kinds of cost with um having to record everything and all the rest of it. And so I think that what you guys precipitated was a really, really good conversation that landed us in a place where we do a better job now if these get approved, of protecting the rights of the individual, and at the same time, don't put an undue burden on presbytery and the dispensation of justice. So I think it was well done on y'all's part because we wouldn't have had that conversation without it.

SPEAKER_00I'm glad our errors could lead to greater purity in the church.

SPEAKER_02Uh keep being sarcastic. I can never tell.

SPEAKER_00You never know with me. Um it is helpful though, as we're thinking through divesture, demitting, and deposition. It seems that divesture is an act of the court upon the man for maybe uh for all sorts of reasons of not having a call, etc. Demitting is the act of the man himself requesting to have his credentials removed, and neither of those are caused by uh process in the church, no church court process, no trials. And then deposition is connected to trials themselves.

SPEAKER_00And so there's two ways to be removed from office without censure or trial, and that's through your self-demitting or the the court divesting you, and then one way for the court to force you uh out uh, you know, through trial and uh et cetera. And so there's those perhaps are helpful clarifications because those terms all get thrown around sometimes interchangeably, but they have perhaps different contexts. Uh any other comments or thoughts perhaps on uh this chapter as we close up?

SPEAKER_00Well, hearing none, uh thanks for joining us today, Steve. It's always a joy to have you on. Uh it's been really helpful. Uh I think this is a very helpful chapter in the ROD, and it helps us not cross swords unnecessarily. Um if you enjoyed this episode today, we encourage that you support us, follow us uh on our various uh social media accounts, um, perhaps share this episode with a friend that might find it helpful, or you can perhaps buy us a coffee, and that'll be in the link, and that helps keep everything running, keeps the lights on for us.

SPEAKER_00Uh, as our BCO experts everywhere will say, this podcast is over. Uh, please say goodbye, gentlemen. Goodbye, everyone. Goodbye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Ben Ratliff Co-host Feed-stated
  • Jared Nelson Co-host Feed-stated
  • Scott Edburg Co-host Feed-stated

Guests

  • Steve Dowling Guest Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 150. You've Got to Come Visit

    Nov 17, 202642 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 149. Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    Nov 10, 202642 minAudio

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 148. From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 147. ProtoPresbytery

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 146. Broker of Relationships and Resources

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...

    Credit the people on this episode