Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Polity Matters

Polity Matters artwork

57. 🇺🇸 (BCO 20 Part 1)

Oct 29, 202423 minAudio

Listen in as the guys begin their discussion of BCO 20 on the Election of Pastors. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Well, hello, and welcome to Polity Matters. My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined as always by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg, and we are glad to be with you today to jump into BCO Chapter 20. I was about to say 21, but it's just an even chapter 20, uh, the election of pastors. Uh, we are uh cruising along through the form of government. We've been having discussions among ourselves about what happens when we get to the rules of discipline. And at the moment, my favorite option is just to cancel the podcast and never talk about that out loud for other people to listen to because I'm terrified of getting uh past chapter 26, 27, whatever it may be, of the BCO.

SPEAKER_01My brothers may be able to convince me otherwise. We'll see what happens. Uh, we want to catch up with Scott. He has recently traveled for uh an exotic trip to a place that none of us have ever been to before, and we want to know where it was, how it went down, if you'll go back.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so yeah, last week um we had my first meeting as a member of the administrative committee. Uh the admin committee in the PCA kind of functions as the communicator between everyone. And so its main work, its main works are planning the general assembly, approving the budgets for all the agencies, and then um allowing communications between all of those agencies, whether they be the Presbyteries, MA, or others, and then it oversees some of the other works clerically as well, uh, review Presbytery records, the SJC, and so forth.

SPEAKER_02And so we oversee all of that. Um, one thing that you might be uh just the average listener might be interested to know like when you are elected one of these committees, they they pay for you to go out there. It's not on your own dime. The first thing my session asked me when I was considered for this is will we have to pay for it? And uh I said, no, you do not have to pay for it. The admin will committee will fly me out, they'll they'll feed me, they'll put me in a hotel, and and then at the end of the day, they'll they'll fly me home. And so that's what happened.

SPEAKER_02And uh we stayed just for two days, uh a Wednesday afternoon evening and to Thursday evening. And the the meeting was like any other meeting. Um, when you're preparing for General Assembly, you're sent a bunch of documents before you're expected to read them, and then you just go through an ordinary meeting. In the AC, we split up into two subcommittees, the building and management, and then the finance. And I'm on building and management. And so obviously, the finance looks at the financials and budgets, and building and uh management deals with planning uh the assemblies.

SPEAKER_02And so we're dealing with planning the current assembly coming up, but we're also looking two to three years down the line on what other places uh that we can take up. And so uh yeah, that that was it. Um Brian Chappell did an introduction for new members, and it's kind of like his introduction at GA for new commissioners, it's similar. Um, but he adds the AC motif on how the AC functions um in all of these various ministerial capacities. And so it was good. It was short, it was the shortest meeting.

SPEAKER_02I like to think it was short because I was there and I just expedited all the work. Yeah, because I'm short, you know, short men equals short meeting. And so Brian Chapel were and I were short men, and so we had a short meeting. But yeah.

SPEAKER_01I was especially glad when you dropped that secret information in our text group uh while you were there about the Honolulu uh GA in just a few more years. That's I'm especially excited about that. Can't wait. I'm just gonna go.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's news to everyone here. 2028 will be in Honolulu.

SPEAKER_00I don't have my passport though.

SPEAKER_02Uh we'll just leave people wondering for the next four years whether we're going to Honolulu or not.

SPEAKER_00Wouldn't it be interesting though, like if we actually had a GA in Canada? Because we have Canadian presbyteries. Just like how many, how many TEs actually have their passport? We'll find out. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Oh man. I don't know. I'm wondering if mine's been uh updated. Mine is out of date. I don't think mine's out yet, but um well, you know, when we were talking on our own when you were at AC, it was it was fun to consider. And I've gotten in touch with the nominations chairman of my presbytery now because I'm curious about the process of looking at maybe serving a GA level. Uh I'm what where would y'all suggest that I look into serving if I was going to serve on a permanent committee? If if I could possibly ever get elected to a permanent committee of the General Assembly, which one would I be well suited to?

SPEAKER_00I I'm thinking there could be a new one that's just in charge of ice cream socials.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, we need you on RUF for that purpose alone, no other purpose, but an advocate to get ice cream socials back on. This is the ice cream party of the PCA. Advance our interests.

SPEAKER_01Oh man. Oh man. Uh okay. Well, let's take some things seriously, perhaps. I don't know. Um BCO chapter 20, the election of pastors. We've talked through uh the doctrine of vocation, the doctrine of ordination, what it is to become a candidate for gospel ministry. We've looked at what it is to be uh an intern of a presbytery and to get license to preach the gospel regularly in a given uh presbytery. And now we're entering into this uh this this portion that that moves us along up into sort of the the teaching elder uh realm.

SPEAKER_01What is it to pursue uh a ministry in a church, uh pursue ordination, be installed as a teaching elder, as a pastor in a local church? And the first part is uh getting elected to be a pastor of a church. And so that's where BCO20 is going to take us. Um guys, just uh as we embark on this new sort of trajectory, is there anything especially prominent on your minds that uh you think about when you start thinking about elections, uh when you start thinking about ordinations?

SPEAKER_01You know, we've got a few weeks ahead of us in this content. Uh any big picture thoughts?

SPEAKER_02This will come out right before the actual U.S. election. And so when we're recording this, even now, that's what I thought of the first thing you said when you said election is well, who am I gonna vote for in a few weeks? Maybe that's a good segue into what we're actually talking about.

SPEAKER_00We'll have some accidental listeners.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, we'll have some accidental listeners.

SPEAKER_01There's gonna be American flag emojis in the tweet about this one just to see if we can get some uh That'll be the title of our this episode.

SPEAKER_02What?

SPEAKER_01American Flag Emoji. American Flag Emojis. Okay. Uh we are gonna be in uh chapter 20, paragraph one. And I was told by these guys that there are actually three, maybe even more sections than I originally thought. So we're gonna go all the way through 13, I think, uh in chapter 20, not just chapter 10. Section 10. Chapter 10, section 10. What's really the difference at this point? I mean, we're so far into this thing.

SPEAKER_0121. Before a candidate or licentiate can be ordained to the office of the ministry, he must receive a call to a definite work. Ordinarily the call must come from a church, presbytery, or the general assembly of this denomination. If the call comes from another source, the presbytery shall always make a record of the reasons why it considers the work to be a valid Christian ministry. A proper call must be written and in the hands of the presbytery prior to being acted upon by a presbytery. It must include financial arrangements such as salary, vacation, insurance, retirement, etc., between those calling and the one called, and assurance that the definite work will afford the liberty to proclaim and practice fully and freely the whole council of God, as contained in the scriptures and understood in the Westminster Confession of Faith, and shall be in accord with BCO eight.

SPEAKER_01Well, there's a lot here. I see Scott's favorite word floating around in there somewhere, so we'll have to talk about that. But uh let's talk about this idea of a definite uh a definite work, uh a call to a definite work, and they qualify it in a couple of different ways. Maybe one of y'all wants to jump in and and talk about uh what a definite work is and and how they start parsing it out.

SPEAKER_00Well, it seems to be something a call that comes from somewhere. Um I I know I at least heard at one point somebody that wanted to be pastor at large, just in the community, and it was like, but no, unless there's like some sort of church or some sort of body that is calling you, uh, you don't get to call yourself to that or um just be an indefinite work of a of an area. So there's a definite work, and then it defines uh where that call can come from, a church, a presbytery, general assembly, uh, but then also names some other source.

SPEAKER_00So at least one of the definitions of a definite work is it comes from outside of yourself from somewhere else.

SPEAKER_02And all the listeners that are pastors at large now they're going to feel seen and worry that they're gonna have their credentials removed. Because there's no definite work for them. Yeah, we've talked about uh definite work before, that you can't be ordained uh without a definite work, and you cannot be elected to a ministry uh without a definite work. And so there's uh there's something tangible about the ministry um that involves ordination, that it's not out in the ether, not uh something informal, but there's a formal work um that is required uh of the man who serves.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it doesn't necessarily have to just be a church, though. I mean, it does have the the we have that word ordinarily, but if it comes from another place, and we can think about where that might come from. Uh it may come from some court that's not in our uh jurisdiction, uh independent church, uh maybe a parachurch, maybe a missions agency. Um, I know some have considered like a university uh teaching in some aspect to be uh that sort of a call. Others have not. So you may know several college professors in the PCA.

SPEAKER_00Some of them are ruling elders, some of them are teaching elders, uh, because some have considered it a a work that the Presbytery is calling a teaching elder to, and some have not. So um that some other source would have to be defined in there too. It's not yeah, just PCA courts.

SPEAKER_01You can go back to BCO eight and and kind of there's several paragraphs in there that explain uh the different types of calls. And so you've got the outside of a local church but still inside the PCA. Um so where Scott's gonna be one day as the stated clerk of something, perhaps uh that would be a call outside the local church but inside the denomination. Um evangelists that serve as church planning sometimes uh well that that's NBCO eight. That's a that's a call that's not in a local church, right? It's it's out doing something um that might not be established yet.

SPEAKER_01And then just general out of bounds. Um outside jurisdiction of the PCA. Yeah, thank you.

SPEAKER_00I I think eight seven is important though for the Presbytery to consider too, that um they are engaged in preaching and teaching, and that they have assurances of full freedom uh to maintain and teach the doctrine of our church. In other words, that um he's not called to something where he's not able to preach, he's not able to affirm the things that uh the church believes, uh, that if he's going to be a chaplain somewhere, they're not restricting him on what he can say and what he can't say.

SPEAKER_01And that would be where a presbytery is making this distinction or making a judgment call, I suppose, on what what's considered a valid Christian ministry. Um I I don't I don't know if we want to get too far into it, but any thoughts on how how somebody might go about evaluating what a valid Christian ministry is? And maybe what you've just said, Jared, is enough that uh it's it's that preaching ministry where they can freely and fully proclaim what we've been given. Is there any more than that involved?

SPEAKER_02It's kind of dicey and hard to cut because there are people that we ordain in the PCA that aren't necessarily preaching. Um I you you can talk, you can think about RUF's ministry, chaplains and and others who we joyfully ordain, but aren't necessarily uh giving out the sacraments regularly. Um and so it it's it's mainly a wisdom issue that the presbytery itself has to discern as they as they call a man.

SPEAKER_02Um is this a work that uh necessitates um him to have ordained credentials? And in the PCA we say RUF ministers and chaplains do.

SPEAKER_01So that's good. And so this the call to these works um has to be written down, it has to be given to the Presbytery ahead of time, and it's in chapter 21. We'll talk about that call being given to the minister. But um the the call has some specifications necessary, financial arrangements, um, this assurance in the call that they can they can proclaim and practice fully and freely the whole council of God. Uh and it has to be in accord with BCO eight, um which just means sort of what we've been talking about, that it is a place suitable for a teaching elder to be working.

SPEAKER_01Um, you know, I tell guys when they come through credentials in Covenant Presbytery, I need to see your call letter. And usually if their call letter doesn't have at least four weeks of vacation written in it, I say, you need to go back to your session because I I can't approve your call, but I can certainly tell you our presbytery won't approve it without at least four weeks of vacation in it. Um there's never really been a number I've seen that I've had to send a guy back with. Uh and while that's not my primary responsibility, it's a well-known fact, at least in our circles over here, that you got to meet a certain standard in your letter or it's not gonna be approved, and the session's gonna have to the congregation, I suppose, is gonna have to adjust it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, if people are wondering, uh there is a um a call information uh sheet. I think it's is that put out by is it Geneva or is it by the foundation by the PCA? Yeah, that will uh help you walk through uh some of the things that should be in your call package and um such as vacation study time, um the the other things that are named here, such as insurance, retirement, um, salary, what's reasonable. Um, those are things that they're gonna look at. And it's a way sometimes for a presbytery to protect a pastor if they're coming in there and they're they're gonna be giving this call and they know the the budget of the church could allow them to take care of them and they're not, uh, the presbytery steps in to try to uh protect the pastor in that way.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think it's wise. This is could be wise for both sessions, public committees, and pastors themselves, is it's to have um Geneva Benefits just involved in the call structure. Um every time I get a call, which has not been often, um, I the first thing I do is I send it to Geneva Benefits. Um and they structure it um very helpfully. They show me how much I'm supposed to take out for taxes, uh, et cetera, et cetera. And so they they help structure it um in a way that's helpful for both the pastor who's coming in, but also the church as they seek to put budgeted line items um a part of it.

SPEAKER_02And so those are those are things and tools that we have. On the Presbytery Clerks page, the download page, they have like the actual like example forms for what you can use to fill out to submit to the Presbytery. But I think getting Geneva benefits involved will get you there anyway. And they they'll help you think through things you're probably not thinking about. Um, because there are ways to save your pastor money without, you know, without changing the monetary cost to them. And so using them will help help everyone involved.

SPEAKER_00Especially with housing.

SPEAKER_02Especially with housing.

SPEAKER_00I I do think it's interesting that it does say uh in order before it's acted on by the presbytery, it has to be in their hands. Um, so there's no pre-approvals and and things like that. We've we've sometimes pressured a church to be like, Presbytery is coming up, and unless you want to wait another three months, we need to have this in our hand. We can't just approve it in the abstract because we haven't seen the salary, we haven't seen um you promising um full liberty, all of these different things. So it needs to be in the hands of the Presbyterian.

SPEAKER_01I've appreciated the the the weightiness that this carries in a presbytery meeting. I've I've seen men come with a call that uh is maybe not uh the the monetary amount is not quite as high as some of the other calls in the presbytery of of of equal uh responsibility and position. And I've seen men stand up on the floor and actually ask the candidate, hey, this number seems a little off to me. Are you content with this number? And he'll name it and he'll ask, you know, what's going on. And usually more often than not, the response is, you know, the church doesn't have a lot, but I've got you know resources in another place, or I've got a small part-time job that I'm gonna take that's gonna help benefit it.

SPEAKER_01Um one guy had a wife who was a full-time nurse, and so like all of their medical insurance and things were coming from from her work, and so he didn't need as much uh to sustain the family uh in that regard, and so it was a way that he could do the work. There's just all sorts of combinations, but I've always liked that we take this pretty seriously. Um what about changes to a call? You know, uh there there's some references to it in some of our commentary material. I think Olmquist and Morton Smith both refer to some parliamentary inquiries that were made.

SPEAKER_01Um you know, if if the presbytery is in charge of approving a call, uh what what kind of changes amount to the the the need for a presbytery to get involved and to approve it? And maybe the question I'm asking is what do we read here as is the requirement, but also maybe we should talk a little bit about what we see happening more often, because I I know that I don't I don't come to Presbytery and see changes of call coming from existing ministers ever, really, unless they're moving position.

SPEAKER_01Um so you'll usually see a man well, of course, a man has to get approved if he's gonna move from assistant to associate or even if he's gonna move up to to pastor. Um that requires some special uh numbers and votes, of course. But what about changing of financial arrangements or uh you know increasing a salary or adding vacation days? How how do we read this and what do we see as practice?

SPEAKER_02I've never seen a practice that every minister has their call package updated yearly. Um I typically have a raise in some form um every year. It might be small or large, but uh I've never had it come before the presbytery, and I've never seen anyone else's come before the presbytery. I think that'd be somewhat laborious.

SPEAKER_01You're saying that most men are getting some kind of change financially, but it's I'm not speaking for everyone else.

SPEAKER_02I'm just speaking for myself.

SPEAKER_01But it's not coming to the presbytery for approval, is what you're saying.

SPEAKER_02You're you're possibly something that's done in-house, and I've always viewed this kind of pet part as like a change in like a massive transition in job description where you're doing something different even with it if it's within the same church. If you go from being the music minister to maybe the youth minister, I could see like that in a large church warranting a change.

SPEAKER_01Why either one of those would need to be an ordained teaching elders beyond me, but uh you know for example, careful now. Careful now, man. We published an episode today that I ousted youth ministers, so why not keep up the shtick?

SPEAKER_02There goes our like half of our listener base is gone.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So speaking of a laborious um, Ascension Presbytery actually has an expectation that if you have any change in salary, that it comes to the presbytery. Not that that always happens, but it is something that um some presbyteries want to be updated on, and they'll remind churches, hey, tell us when this is happening so we know kind of up to date that you are still taking care of them. Um in the age of inflation now, uh, if you have something on the books from 20 years ago of what their salary was, the presbytery may be interested to say, Hey, are you still paying them$20,000 a year?

SPEAKER_00Because you might need to up that. And oh, we did, but we never told you.

SPEAKER_01That's a good perspective too, right? Because it can seem like this is just being nitpicky, but really what it is is the presbytery trying to maintain their responsibility to uh uh to keep up with the ministers and take care of them, make sure they're being taken care of. Uh yeah, uh it's the the parliamentary in the constitutional inquiry, not parliamentary, uh, from 1983 reads that BCO 20-1 indicates that presbytery must approve the call of a pastor. The call establishes the relationship of the pastor to the calling body. But this interesting line: the BCO is silent concerning amending the call.

SPEAKER_01However, inasmuch as the initial relationship must be approved by Presbytery, it would follow that if any changes are made to that original call, the presbytery would necessarily have to approve the changes in the call for the protection of both the pastor and the calling body. So we have the the GA making an interpretive uh statement here. It doesn't say anything about amending the call, but they're they would argue that it follows that changes do need to come before the Presbytery uh to be approved. Which is interesting. See how that works out.

SPEAKER_01Well, we've done a good job at killing 20-1. This has been fun.

SPEAKER_02Uh you said you wanted to make this into a five part episode.

SPEAKER_01On the next episode, we'll start 20-2. Uh Well, dear listeners, as a call package in good order would say, this podcast is over. Don't worry though, we'll return to finish up this chapter next time. We don't really mean to cut you short, but BCO 20 was too long for one episode, and we had to split it somewhere. We figured it was more fun to do one section in an episode and twelve sections in another. If you enjoy the show, do consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters, and be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice.

SPEAKER_01If you're interested in learning more about anything we've discussed, check out the show notes in your podcast player, or you can go find those at Politymatters.org. If you have questions or comments, you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com. And don't forget you can support our work directly by going to buymeacoffee.comslash Polity Matters. Your contributions help us keep production going from week to week, and we are very grateful for many listeners' support so far. We are always glad to produce these shows for you. Thank you again for spending time with us. Y'all take care.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 150. You've Got to Come Visit

    Nov 17, 202642 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 149. Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    Nov 10, 202642 minAudio

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 148. From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 147. ProtoPresbytery

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 146. Broker of Relationships and Resources

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...

    Credit the people on this episode