Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Polity Matters

Polity Matters artwork

107. Welcome Per Almquist

Oct 28, 202535 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Scott and Jared spend some time with Per Almquist, a famliar name to the show. Buy Per's BCO Commentary Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Well, welcome to Polity Matters. I'm joined today by Scott and I'm Jared, and we are trying to pull down the fort while Ben is attending to some family business. But uh he plans to be back involved more in the future, so he's not uh dropping out uh yet, so don't be worried. Um we have a special guest that we have been uh trying to get on for a few months. So uh Polity aficionados uh have um in the past couple of months gotten a new toy, uh which is the uh commentary on the BCO that was authored by Para Omquist, and he has graciously uh agreed to come onto the show to talk a little bit about it.

SPEAKER_00So before we uh get into the book, uh can you remind us a little bit about where you're serving? Uh what is you do in the PCA? And um then we might get a little bit into why you decided to write a commentary on the BCO.

SPEAKER_01Sure. Uh so um I serve with the administrative committee of the PCA. I'm the communications and polity specialist, uh, which means that uh I manage all of the documents for for the PCA, all the official ones, the the BCO, the the minute, GA minutes, the yearbook, uh those kinds of things. Um as well as then answering the questions when you reach out to to the office with a question about uh polity or or our positions, uh usually I'm the one you end up talking with.

SPEAKER_01Uh at the same time, I continue to uh I co-pastor the church that I planted up in Lewiston, Maine. Um so continue to have some involvement there and uh serve with them and uh you know get to actually you know do real ministry a little bit.

SPEAKER_00Actually put the BCO into into practice. That's right. So uh well, first tell us a little bit about this. This is the name of the book is uh Our Bond of Union, a commentary on the book of church order of the Presbyterian Church in America. Uh tell us a little bit about what motivated you or what was in the background of uh writing a commentary uh on the BCO and uh how you may hope that it may serve the church.

SPEAKER_01Well, that was exactly you know what was behind it was uh a resource for the church. You know, there are lots of resources out there to help understand the BCO and um the historic interpretations that the the church has made through the the years and in fact through the centuries on parts of it. Um and it was partly to try and and gather gather those pieces all in one place for myself, but then also for for others who may not be aware of all of the pieces or know where to get a hold of them, even if they happen to be aware of where they are.

SPEAKER_01Um so that's really what was behind it was creating a resource for for me and for others uh to better be able to use the the tool that the the BCO is intended to be.

SPEAKER_00Um I was asked, and Scott, just jump in here if you have a question to ask at any point, but um I I was asked by somebody who knew that I had a copy of uh your new book uh what it was like. Was this an academic uh work or a technical work, or was this something that a new elder could pick up? So I wondered if you can frame the intent of who should who does this book help? And maybe put it in the context of you know um Ramsey and and Smith from the past who have written books on previous versions of the BCL.

SPEAKER_01Uh well hopefully it helps all of us. Um it was not intended primarily for uh those who were are are deeply in. Um at that point you're starting to wrestle beyond, but you know, the the hope was primarily for the average and everyday use, that um the ordinary elder or layperson uh could pick it up and use it to better understand um our constitution and our standards.

SPEAKER_01So that that was really where I aimed it, um, trying to bring in uh other resources such as Smith and Ramsey and others that are out there and you know join that line. Those are both great resources for us. Um they're also both dated, uh, you know, Ramsey being last updated in I think 1898, and Morton Smith's in in 2007. Um in the in the decade of essentially the the 20 teens, um, the PCA averaged 16 BCO amendments uh uh proposed every year and averaged approving four of them.

SPEAKER_01Which means in the time, you know, the 18 years since since Morton Smith's was last uh updated, just working off of the averages, we're talking about you know, what, 76 BCO amendments that he doesn't cover. Um the the other piece was um Morton Smith tends to rely heavily on on primarily on two sources, on Ramsey and on just his own knowledge. As the founding stated clerk of the PCA, one who was present in a part of the initial discussions, he had a just a vast trove of personal knowledge as to what was intended.

SPEAKER_01Um but you know, part of the idea was to bring in some of the other other resources with that to balance out those pieces and to flesh them out uh as well. So hopefully it it broadens even for those who are more familiar and helps to see different sides, um, adds some of that historic uh SJC cases, CCB interpretations, some of the commentary that was published around the time of our founding, um, and you know, create uh a broader understanding of even some of our older provisions.

SPEAKER_00Scott, did you have something?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh as I was thinking um through this, uh we got it at the General Assembly, and it was somewhat ironic that as we received your nice new book, uh the next day after I bought this book, I realized I just voted to change some of the content in the book. And so do you have perhaps like any timelines for future revisions? We were just talking about how the outdatedness of some of our old commentaries. And obviously, this is the most up-to-date version, but now technically out of date.

SPEAKER_02Uh, do you have any roadmaps for the future of this project?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, I mean, uh nowadays everything has planned obsolescence, right? So yeah, that's right. I actually as you say, it's it's ironic, it was not the original plan. Um due to some factors with the publisher, it got delayed. Uh we were really trying to avoid it being out of date uh pretty much the moment it was released and uh didn't manage that after all. Uh I do hope to to update it and to keep it up to date.

SPEAKER_01Um I don't think that CDM is going to let me update it every year and have a new edition like the BCO every year, um, but certainly you know, every few years, uh, you know, getting a new updated edition out that um you know brings in in the changes. You know, certainly if we get a major one, um potentially the directory for worship is that study committee uh goes through its work, um you know, certainly that would be also be a trigger, you know, because that's the kind of change you would want to see reflected relatively quickly.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, how did you uh approach it though in terms of what you're trying to do there? Do you did you feel yourself wanting to give kind of a uh here's here's kind of a broad analysis, or uh were you trying to wade into any of the um the debates that maybe go around in the in the BCO? I mean, like did you give us a definitive uh answer for what fails to act actually means?

SPEAKER_01Mostly my my intent was to offer out what is out there, the the resources to explain what is fairly settled. Obviously, nothing is purely objective, so you do get my opinions along the way. Um but it it was not intended to be um here's what I think is right on on every issue, but here's what the church has said. And in a number of those cases, it's okay. Um here's what the church has said at this point in time, and here's what the church has said at this other point in time.

SPEAKER_01And so there are arguments made in in both ways, and and then to lay out both of those sides so that you know the the individual uh and the individual courts ultimately um have the information to make their own determinations as to how do they understand it, uh, because that ultimately that's what matters.

SPEAKER_00So in uh in your study of this, I don't know if you got into this at all. Um I I'm always interested when I talk to somebody that's uh either in like the OPC or the RPCNA that's uh in our area. Uh sometimes we'll compare differences, whether you know, two office, three office, things like that. But uh do you learn anything from doing this project of uh things that are um different from perhaps other NAPARC uh BCOs that are unique to us? Uh and if so, if if that's something that actually people from the OPC or even like the you know church in uh Presbyterian Church in Brazil would want to pick it up and see if there's anything unique that we offer that uh others uh in the reform community could benefit from.

SPEAKER_01Sure. Uh I do draw draw in on a on occasion what others, um, how other books of church order from our sister churches, how they approach an issue to help um help us understand our our own and where we came from, um, especially the OPC, because we do go back to a shared book of church order. It's been since the mid-19th century um that that we went uh separated from them.

SPEAKER_01Um but some of the provisions that work their way through uh and carry over from those the early days of of our book of church order um to see, you know, how did they understand? How do they have it? How does that help flesh out our understanding of of what we have? Um is it is it it's meant to be different, or um does their you know, does their language help clarify the older language as to what was understood?

SPEAKER_01Uh you know, certainly since 1973, ours has diverged and gone its own you know its own direction from any of the others. Um and uh I think I think what we offer is you know can be um similarly another perspective. And um of the issues that we've wrestled with, you know, again go back to shared principles.

SPEAKER_01Um and we've wrestled with on a deeper level uh some of the study committees, especially uh you know, in the 80s, as we looked at um the structure of General Assembly and uh the nature of church power in the 70s as we looked at um at church office and how many offices should there be, uh, and those study papers and then how it's worked out there. And in more recent days, as we've become more procedural, some of the work simply because of scale of uh of uh size, where we've had to wrestle through some of the the more details of bringing in legal concerns into judicial process or or some of those things where um we we've nailed down more details of procedure to maintain our our principles, but in a uh modern context, and that can be pieces that that start to come in.

SPEAKER_01For example, the you know the the DASA study report and some of the changes that have been proposed and implemented based upon that, and how does some of that inform uh our discipline?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, something I found uh interesting just in talking with people from the OPC or when we started going through quality matters, starting with the preliminary principles and realizing that we seem to be one of the only uh American Presbyterian denominations that have kept those. And uh it does seem to inform our debates and when we're gonna make changes on things and um trying to be consistent with those.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, they they got dropped out um i in the early 20th century. Uh the PC USA has actually brought them back, not as preliminary principles. Uh it's in one of their early chapters, I forget exactly which one, um, but they have brought it back and actually added a few. But it was interesting to see that it left and and they they did bring them back to speak of them as um you know, as principles that are are part of this.

SPEAKER_01Um and they are important because for us, the OPC, the Bible Presbyterians, all of us that go back to the original PC USA of the the 18th and 19th centuries, um, they are foundational to our original book and how it developed through those years.

SPEAKER_00Oh, that's right on Mike. Well, um I I wanted to ask you a little bit about what you learned uh through the experience of of writing this. Uh perhaps if you um found places that you think uh have been misunderstood in the BCL or maybe where people are going to go to and where where the crease is gonna be on the spine when people are looking for a particular section. So is there is there anything that you think is uh something that's often misunderstood uh that especially you know, people are probably gonna go to your commentary for so that kind of seems like there's two questions there, Jared.

SPEAKER_01Um where will the crease be and and what is most commonly misunderstood? Um I think the crease is gonna be in judicial process. That's the one that's really is least understood um by by folks in general. It's the one where uh the where the the BCO gets much more procedural and detailed, and that carries a lot more weight. Uh so I think that's where people are going to be going a lot with it.

SPEAKER_01Um I think the the primary place where the BCO is misunderstood is actually in its very nature. Uh our book of church order was originally written and maintained this way through uh certainly through the end of the 19th century. Um it was intended to be a principial document, not a procedural one. So the original Book of Church Order that was written for the American Presbyterian Church in 1785 was only 23 chapters long, and each chapter was less than a page on average.

SPEAKER_01And it was expressly written that way, they said, um, to give the principles uh that the the local courts, the the sessions and presbyteries would then apply as they as they deemed best as the elders in the actual situation, and therefore the ones best able to determine the right way to move forward. In the 20th century, we've become much more procedural in our approach to it, looking to it as a manual to tell us here's the steps to follow.

SPEAKER_01So a great example of that is the amendment to BCO5 on mission churches that took place what was that, 2008, 2010, somewhere in that range, when we completely rewrote the chapter and it went from a principial one to what we have now, which is much more of a checklist. You get to to 5-9 and you have, okay, to particularize a church, here's what you do A, B, C, D, E, F, G. Um, and very helpful. I was in the middle of planting my church at the time, and it was great to have that.

SPEAKER_01But that wasn't the original intent of the BCL. And the more procedural we get, the more procedural we have to get, the more we have to nail down the details, and the longer it gets and the harder it gets to follow, and the the more it can become something that's just rigid and cold, applied to trying to apply the same steps to every situation when every one of us in ministry knows every situation is complicated because they all involve people.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I kind of wonder when I'm thinking through principle and procedure, is that an is that in other NAPARC denominations? Is that mostly us? When I look at other BCOs, it seems much more principle-based. But I've had friends ask me about judicial process and the URC, and I open up their their book of church order, and I'm like, there's like two pages on it. And they're like, did they violate the book? And I'm like, I don't know. There's nothing in the book, it seems, or there's so little. And so it seems that we have a more procedural mindset, maybe even compared to some of our Napark brethren.

SPEAKER_02Do you think that's the case as well?

SPEAKER_01Um, somewhat. Uh, I think part of that also comes with again, we're back to um scalability. So the PC USA Book of Church Order is far more procedural than ours. It's also a lot longer. Um you know, we're not the only ones that that add that in. We all do over time. Part of it is also that other denominations, some of them have um have other documents where they they get into those procedures that are not part of their book of church order.

SPEAKER_01And then you get into, okay, are they part of their constitution or not? Or if they're not part of their constitution, then what authority do they have because they have different authority structures. And so some of them have authoritative documents that get into that, that simply are other than their book of church order. Um, but uh I I think a lot of it has to do with size. You know, that um, for example, the SJC. The SJC was created um roughly 35 years ago, you know, right in you know, 89, 90, 91, I think it was 92, 93, when when the first SJC was um all the changes had gotten through when it was instituted and began hearing its first cases.

SPEAKER_01Until that point, we did old school, which was cases were heard by General Assembly. They would come to General Assembly and the moderator at the beginning of the assembly would you know point out you know 10 guys and say, all right, you're the commission to hear this, go off and hear it. And in fact, at that time, um, for Presbyteries and all the way up to General Assembly, they wouldn't decide them. They would hear it, take all the testimony, they would write up a statement of the case, and then General Assembly would vote on every single one, and the decision was by General Assembly itself.

SPEAKER_01Can you imagine doing that with the size that our General Assemblies are and the size the PCA is now? You can do that when you have four or five cases. It's still awkward because then guys are are voting based on something where all they have is a report from a committee that wrote it up that week um and they're being handed it to read and then vote on shortly thereafter. But you know, this past year the SJC um handled 46 cases.

SPEAKER_01You know, uh we'd spend longer than we have at GA just dealing with it on that front. And and so we have to then work out systems and and ways to to work things that weren't required before. So I I think that's a piece to it, is some of it comes with size.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and that size even deals with our overture load as well, right? Yeah. I mean, many we get kind of made fun of sometimes in Napark circles for having like 50 overtures. And the OPC is like, we had two overtures this year that we dealt with, and and we're like, oh, what if that that'd be like no business before the assembly if we had two overtures? It's just a different breed.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it is. Some of that is size, some of that is that um the mentality has changed and shifted in the PCA, and some of the others keep an older. Um there's a great quote uh that um came out in in the debates in the mid-19th century over uh amending the the rules of discipline at the time. They were proposing um you know a major revision of it, and um part of the argument was that it hadn't been done in about 25 years.

SPEAKER_01And one of the former moderators of General Assembly, in an article about it, said, you know, that's about right. Uh he said, you know, they shouldn't be amended more often than that. And he goes on to say, in fact, our people would not allow it. And that's just a completely different mindset than the PCA has at this point. Um, to to take time and to let something sit and settle and really think our way through. Um, we've shifted to a mindset of we see an issue, and all right, well, let's propose an answer and then let's debate and work our way through and work that through.

SPEAKER_01And sometimes we do it all that one year, and other times it takes a few years, you know, of perfecting and refining to get to a point where we have an amendment that um you know is generally acceptable uh and can pass to you know as to how to how to address that. But we've certainly moved to this is a living document that should be um that that should reflect the current situation and in where we are currently in a way that historically it didn't and some of our our sister churches still maintain well and having had a lot of time in working with uh the BCO, um even with the procedural aspect to it, are there are there things that are that do you think from studying it and and recommending to somebody else to study it, of course using your book probably as part of that?

SPEAKER_00Uh what do you think is uh some of the benefits of knowing the BCO? How does the BCO, um, just taking a few steps back and always listen to our podcast will pretend we're they're just listening to this interview, um, how would you encourage them to say something positive about studying the BCO for helping us work as a church together?

SPEAKER_01Well, I I think that's exactly what it is. That's where where the title of the book comes from. It comes from a statement that uh General Assembly made um that our constitution is our only bond of union. And the BCO is part of that. It's not just our Westminster standards, it's the BCO, um that it is intended to build unity by saying this is who we are. Um that same statement um uh you know refers to uh the Constitution as you know our statement of our only statement of identity.

SPEAKER_01You know, and that's what it should be. It should be a tool for us to um to express who we are as a church, to express our theological commitments um and our care for uh the church and and for our people by how we go about our shepherding, how we go about governing the church, because that's what governing the church is, is it's part of part of our shepherding ecclesiology, this this doctrine of the church expresses who God is, by who we are as his gathered people.

SPEAKER_01Um, and that's really where the BCO belongs, there, not as a law book to be studied as, you know, how do I do everything right? How do I, you know, what what mistakes did somebody else make? Um but to to give us those pieces to express our understanding of who God has revealed himself to be in scripture and and what that means, how we work that out in life together.

SPEAKER_00Well, in in light of that and the fact that we love to change the BCO so much, uh have you thought about that in doing whether it's from this research or just in your time in the PCA, and thought, is there one reform or clarification to the BCO that uh you'd like to see happen? Um and and it even can be kind of, I think Howie has said that maybe slowing down would be good, even though he's the one that's the the biggest offender on that. Or or uh I I think of the uh the OPC to give my answer first, like that I'm kind of interested in the idea of you know publishing it once every five to ten years and uh living it for a little bit.

SPEAKER_00But did you have do you have some of the things?

SPEAKER_01We actually did that in the early years. So um you know it wasn't until if you've ever wondered why the BCO in the front starts the amendments with 1982, it's because before that it was published as a printed bound thing only every few years. Um and so they didn't track the amendments because it had to do with what edition you had. And so even when I was ordained, first ordained, um, in those early years, you know, my time in seminary in the 90s, the the BCO still said um sixth edition in the front.

SPEAKER_01And we've since dropped that. And you always wonder, well, but the sixth edition of which year? And why isn't the next year the seventh edition? That goes back to those early years when we didn't publish it as a binder to be amended every year, but we saved and published an edition every few years. Um and you know, I think that may have indeed been a bit of a mistake that encouraged more frequent amendments.

SPEAKER_00Um putting on three-ring binder was uh that's what did it.

SPEAKER_01No, it's not what did it, but it certainly didn't help. Um I'm with Howie. I think we should slow down some with it. Uh but I I I think the answer to that for me comes to what we were talking about. Is what I would like to see, you know, if I could change one thing, would would see us getting back to viewing it more as laying out principles which are then to be applied by the lower courts with broad discretion and the oversight of the higher courts um returning to less of the the detailed, do I agree with your decision?

SPEAKER_01And more of that, do you follow the principles, were the rights of every you know, every party know protected? Um and the you know and I think that shift in thinking would benefit us, not just in how many amendments we make to it, but even just in in how we view and how we use it, less as a cudgel against others, um you know, and more of a tool to actually care for the church and for our people.

SPEAKER_00Um Well thinking of uh the future, um what would you like to see um the kind of future of this book, either how it's used, or did you have any final thoughts of things that you learned from this experience of uh writing this book?

SPEAKER_01It feels self-serving to say it, but I would like to see it broadly used. Um I'd like to see it spur uh other stuff. Um you know uh uh the 19th century uh was called um ecclesiology was called the the topic of our era uh by guys like Thornwell and Dabney and um Henry Adger, who who succeeded them, and actually was the architect of um the beginning of what became became distinctively the Southern Presbyterian Book of Church Order, therefore ours.

SPEAKER_01Um it was widely recognized. And then in the 20th century, we got away from talking about ecclesiology and what is the church and how does that work out in very practical ways. Um and so uh I'm frankly hopeful that this is the first of more resources on polity and on ecclesiology, what you guys are doing here with Polity Matters, um, some of the other stuff out there. Um I've got ideas bouncing around for two or three more books that I you know haven't seemed to find time to get beyond that.

SPEAKER_01Um you know, not just for me, you know, one of them being just collecting some of the writings that we have put out over the years by by men who've done a lot of thinking, David Coffin, Fred Greco, you know, Howie, Roy Taylor, um, Guy Waters, you know, um these guys, you know, Paul Gilchrist, uh, you know, T. David Gordon. Um, we have a lot of of that that's been out there um, you know, in gathering some of those and and bringing them together and publishing them in new in a new collection that makes them uh available and and uh uh brings people awareness of them again, so that we can you know rest on on the heritage that we have.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and we we've even joked about um a devotional based on the VCO. But that was one of the things that I discovered in working my way through there. There's a few places where you're like, I can do a devotional on this section of the VCO.

SPEAKER_01Uh probably not the procedural parts, but no, it and an interesting thing was uh the first General Assembly actually assigned the committee that that wrote the initial one to put um scripture citations to the entire BCO in the way that we do for the confession. Um and they started that work and they only got through the preface, and those are included, what they proposed are included in my commentary. Um, and then they just stopped.

SPEAKER_01Never really said anywhere officially why they stopped or anything else, but it would have been interesting to have seen that. And you know, as you say, the procedural, there are parts where I would struggle to find because that's part of what is left to you know human wisdom inside. But uh would have been interesting to see you know the thinking behind and and to have that scriptural piece tied to it.

SPEAKER_00All right, I'll give Scott one more chance if he has anything else.

SPEAKER_02No, I'm good.

SPEAKER_00All right. Well, if somebody wants to purchase the book, where's the best place to go for it?

SPEAKER_01The PCA bookstore. So it's published, you know, CDM is the one who who printed it, um, and they've got it available there, and um they're able to be responsive with it, hopefully.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think I've seen that as the best price too. Because I think you can find it some other places, but you don't know about shipping or if you get any kind of deal. So that's where I've seen it the best. Well, as uh maybe Ramsey uh would say, this podcast is over. Uh thank you for uh to purr for his time, uh for Scott for being here, and you can check our show notes for more information. Maybe we'll put a link where to buy the book in there. Um so if there's nothing else, uh we can just all say goodbye, gentlemen. Bye, gentlemen.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 150. You've Got to Come Visit

    Nov 17, 202642 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 149. Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    Nov 10, 202642 minAudio

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 148. From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 147. ProtoPresbytery

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 146. Broker of Relationships and Resources

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...

    Credit the people on this episode