In this episode of Podcasting Q&A, we break down why podcast downloads stall and how to pinpoint the real reason your show is not growing. We focus on three practical levers you can adjust without reinventing your whole podcast: discovery, content, and consistency. Resource Mentioned: Visual Soundbites (Audiogram) If you have questions about growing your podcast, reach out to the Podcaster Success team by emailing support@buzzsprout.com. Send us Fan Mail Have a topic or question we should address on a future episode? Text us or email the Buzzsprout Podcaster Success Team at support@buzzsprout.com. Keep podcasting!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Cara PacettiWelcome to Podcasting Q&A, brought to you by the people at Buzzsprout. I'm your host, Cara Pacetti, and I'm bringing you the best tips and strategies to keep you Podcasting with confidence. If you don't know by now, podcasting is hard work. It gets a little deflating when you put in this hard work, you've created your podcast, and your downloads are just not what you want them to be. First, I want to start out by saying this is really common, especially for new podcasters.
Cara PacettiYou kind of get into a routine and you're doing the same thing to promote your podcast, and you're just wondering where the listeners are. So don't be discouraged. Let's walk through some things you can investigate and see if there's any changes you can make. The first thing I want you to consider is whether people actually know your podcast exists. Because here's the thing: you can create incredible podcast content, but if no one knows it's there, it's really not doing them any good. And simply publishing your episodes on Apple or Spotify just doesn't guarantee that people are going to discover your podcast.
Cara PacettiSo how can you tell if discovery might be your problem? Here are a few things you can look for. What do your downloads look like when you release a new episode? Does your podcast title, description, and episode artwork clearly communicate who your podcast is for and what listeners can expect? And are you relying on the same social media template every time you release a new episode? If you're struggling to get listeners to your podcast in the first place, discovery might just be the area you need to focus on.
Cara PacettiSo what can be done? Start by thinking where your ideal listeners are already spending their time. Maybe they're searching YouTube for answers to questions you're covering. Maybe they're a part of an online community, reading newsletters or following creators who talk about similar topics. Instead of just sharing your podcast link, hoping someone clicks on it, think about how you can introduce your content in a way that meets your audience where they are. You can use things like embed players or visual sound bites to help get your podcast out there.
Cara PacettiThe last area I want you to focus on are your episode titles. When you have a clear title that really speaks to the question that is being answered or the problem that your episode is solving, it really helps for listeners to recognize which episodes really relate to them. The takeaway here is simple. If people are just failing to discover your podcast, your focus needs to be on getting your podcast in front of where your listeners are before you ever think about changing the content itself. Now let's change gears.
Cara PacettiPeople are discovering your podcast. You're seeing download spikes when you release a new episode. You are seeing some consistent downloads, but those numbers are not really building over time. It's the same consistent listeners who have been committed since the beginning. The area you might need to focus on is content. Are people coming back for more once they hear your episodes? While we are grateful for our loyal audience, the goal is often to reach more listeners because getting someone to listen to your episode is one thing.
Cara PacettiGiving them a reason to come back is another. So how can you tell if content might be your problem? Here are a few areas to investigate. Do certain episode topics consistently perform better than others? Does your podcast deliver what your title and your descriptions promise? And are you creating episodes based on what your audience actually wants to know or just what you want to talk about? I want to be careful because download numbers alone do not tell you whether someone enjoyed your episode or not, but they can help you to recognize patterns.
Cara PacettiFor example, let's say you host a podcast about personal finance, and your episodes about budgeting consistently get more downloads than your episodes about investing. That doesn't necessarily mean you should stop talking about investing, but it might tell you that budgeting is something your current audience is especially interested in. So once you've identified that it may be your content that's holding your podcast back from growth, what are the next steps? First, I want you to take a look at your podcast stats and identify which episodes are performing well.
Cara PacettiMake sure that you're comparing episodes within the same time frame. So the first seven or 30 days that the episode was released. If you're listed on platforms like Apple and Spotify, you should have access to listening retention data through those platforms. And they can give you another perspective on how people are engaging with certain parts of your episode. So once you've identified those metrics, the next step is to ask yourself what those well-performing episodes have in common. Maybe it's the topic or the title or the specific problem you're helping your listener solve.
Cara PacettiThis can give you a really helpful perspective on how your audience is engaging with certain aspects of your podcast so you can adjust accordingly. Another great way, possibly the best way, to measure how your content is performing is to go ahead and ask your audience directly. You can get creative with this. You can request some fan mail and include a call to action inside of your episodes, you can release an Instagram poll. Whatever you do, you just need to simply ask your audience, what is it that they're looking for?
Cara PacettiSo to recap, if listeners are finding your podcast, but they just aren't coming back consistently, check out your content and see if you can't make some adjustments to make listeners stick around. And the third area that I want you to look into is your consistency. Are you giving your podcast a chance to build momentum? I know we talk about consistency a lot on Podcasting Q&A, but there's a reason that it keeps coming up. Consistency helps your listeners know what to expect from you. Think about a podcast you enjoy listening to and you know episodes are released every Monday.
Cara PacettiWell, if a few weeks go by and no new episodes are released, that is a bummer. And that's really hard to compete with an industry that has 3 million podcasts out there. Listeners are likely to navigate to a podcast that they can reliably expect new content to be delivered when we say it's going to be delivered. So how can you tell if consistency is your problem? I want you to ask yourself, am I publishing on a schedule that my audience can reasonably expect? And have I taken long breaks between episodes without communicating that to my listeners?
Cara PacettiAm I consistently promoting my episodes or only when I remember to? Now, I want to make something really clear here. Consistency does not mean that you have to publish episodes every single week. If you can only produce two quality episodes a month, then that's the frequency you need to stick to. The goal is to create a realistic schedule that you can maintain, not to get as many episodes out as possible. So if you think that it might be consistency that's holding your back from podcast growth, what can we do about it?
Cara PacettiStart by choosing a publishing schedule that works for your life. Maybe that's weekly or biweekly or monthly. You can even break your podcast into seasons so you can upload episodes in advance of their release date and then take a break as you need it. Remember that consistency isn't just about how often you publish your episodes. It's about constantly showing up for your audience and delivering on the content that they came to you for. While you can mix up the topics or the delivery style, the episodes should still always fall in line with the overall goal of the podcast.
Cara PacettiIf your publishing and your promotion are unpredictable, then your goal needs to be focusing on a sustainable routine before you can expect steady growth. So if you're feeling frustrated that your podcast isn't growing, I want you to focus on these three areas. First, discovery. Is your podcast available where your target audience would be searching for it? Next is content. When people find your podcast, are you giving them a reason to come back for more? And last is consistency. Are you showing up regularly enough that you are building a relationship with your audience?
Cara PacettiAnd my biggest piece of advice is don't try to change all of these things at once. Identify an area you can start with and start with those small changes. Once you've determined the area that can be tweaked and needs the most attention, make that one your priority. And remember, podcast growth doesn't always happen overnight. Sometimes the biggest improvements come from small changes consistently over time. So now I want to hear from you. What's your biggest struggle when it comes to growing your podcast? Is it discovery, content, or consistency?
Cara PacettiYou can send us some fan mail by clicking the send us fan mail link in the show notes. And if you have a question you'd like answered on a future Podcasting Q&A episode, go ahead and send us fan mail or reach out to the podcaster success team by emailing support at buzzsprout.com. Be sure to join us every Monday to kickstart your week. Thank you so much for listening. And as always, keep Podcasting.
We answer a listener's question about selling podcast merch when your website has no e-commerce tools. We break down how to create swag your audience wants, set up a Shopify or Squarespace storefront, and drive sales...
In today's episode, we share a simple podcast growth mindset shift: What if your podcast isn't always discovered inside a podcast app? We'll walk through practical ways to bring your audio to the websites, blogs, and...
In today's episode, we answer a listener's question about recording, editing, and publishing a podcast using only a cell phone. We share a simple three-step workflow and small recording habits that make your audio sound...
Video podcasting is trending, but how does it actually work? Alban Brooke from the Buzzsprout team joins this episode to break down a listener's question about the role HLS plays in video podcasting. We discuss all...
In this episode, we break down why there is no perfect podcast episode length and how to create episodes that match what your listeners actually want to hear. We share Buzzsprout stats as a starting point, then give...