Jason Arday, Nathan Cofnas, Cambridge, Ghent and NEJM Voices
26 minAudio
The thesis that universities have lost the plot seems to be repeatedly confirmed This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.drvinayprasad.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Jason Arde, Nathan Kofnos, the Universities of Cambridge and Ghent, and the New England Journal of Medicine gets involved. I'm going to get to the bottom of all of these in today's Medicine Unpacked. There's a growing sentiment that universities have been hopelessly captured by the irrational, the crazy, the woke left. And that extends to all of the universities, Cambridge University, Oxford, Harvard, you name it. And they cannot be reformed. They just need to be defunded. And enter the Jason Arday story. I mean, the Jason Arday story, I think, is really a great example for that thesis actually being true.
SPEAKER_00Let's walk through it. Jason Arday is a troubled professor, the youngest ever black professor at Cambridge University, and I actually view him as a victim in all of this. Jason Arday was a professor of sociology whose dissertation contained plagiarism, whose own Memoir, his background is full of impossible claims. The man was riddled with impossible claims. He ran 30 marathons in 35 days. He ran 300 miles in three days. He did some of that with a broken leg.
SPEAKER_00Couldn't speak until he was 11 years old. He couldn't read until he was 18, and then he became the youngest professor at Cambridge. Had plagiarized other authors, the fact that he had a history of fabulous stories. He was still hired by the University of Cambridge, a very prestigious UK university, and heralded as one of the greatest academics. I think he was called one of the most brilliant professors ever. He was the youngest ever black professor. I think this is the key failure in this whole saga, which is how did Cambridge not vet this guy? It is Cambridge's fault 100% that they did not critically evaluate the claims
SPEAKER_00in his dissertation and CV and his other biographical claims, and they allowed this guy to be professor, and then they extolled him. And then what happens in the story is over the course of years, there have been a few people who said, hey, you plagiarized my... You plagiarized my writing. He used the police and he used the legal firm to try to fight back those claims and keep them under wraps. And then finally, the story reached the ears of Nathan Kaufness, who is a, as far as I can tell, a postdoc, an American graduate, but is a postdoc at He has some views that fall along the right,
SPEAKER_00along race and racial outcomes, and he's been ostracized by the academic community. That's why he's a postdoc at Gent University, whatever the hell that is. Of course, I know it's in Belgium, but you get the point. He's been ostracized, and he gets this story, and he writes about it in his Substack, and that ignites the media's focus on this guy, and ultimately, it leads him to resign, and then very sadly, he commits suicide. And I think there are many points to be made here, so let's start with one. One, it is always tragic when someone commits suicide. That is a deep tragedy. And my heart goes out to this gentleman and his family.
SPEAKER_00Number two, Cambridge is the 100% villain of this story. What Cambridge did to this guy to extol him as the greatest ever sociology professor was nothing short of academic misconduct. Imagine if I go to the 49ers and I just walk in there and I look up at all the other football players and I say, listen, guys, I'm actually the best football player in the world. I'm the best football player. I can bench press 92 reps on the combine. I can run 40 meter dash in 2.8 seconds if I'm running slow.
SPEAKER_00And they say, boy, you're really, really good. You know what? We're going to put you in on the first play of the game. And then there you see me. Coming in on the first play of the game, and then you see me being taken out on the stretcher because I'm going to get obliterated on that first play. Now, if this happened, who's at fault? Well, of course, I'm at fault. I wrongly said my credentials. I wrongly extolled my credentials. I wasn't really as fit as I claimed to be. But who's really at fault? Everybody who works at the 49ers, the manager, the coach, the other players,
SPEAKER_00what is going on that you're allowing me to come up with a clearly ridiculous story and make my way to the field and you're not stopping me? And that's what Cambridge is doing. They're so blind. They're blind to the obvious inconsistencies in this guy's work and in this guy's personal story that they're just pushing him out there as if he's the greatest professor when he's no such thing. They're setting this guy up to fail. They're the people lying to the emperor saying you're wearing clothes when he's naked. They really deserve to be fired. I would fire the person or demote the person who hired him. This person should have nothing to do with hiring.
SPEAKER_00And the whole department should ask themselves, what are they doing? Have they been so captured by woke ideology they can't see the forest for the trees? They can't even see if he has clothes or not. I think they have to do some soul searching. And Cambridge, really, the critics have said they are totally captured by woke ideology. They're not thinking clearly. I think the critics have a point. I mean, hiring this guy was a big mistake. Number three, Cambridge's error is not isolated. It reflects a broader error among all universities with DEI and woke politics, which has consumed everything and ultimately will affect this poor guy,
SPEAKER_00Nathan Kofnos, who blew the whistle on the whole story. What are universities doing? They've got every faculty member who teaches students going into these kind of indoctrination seminars where they hire these third-party consulting groups that tell them all sorts of unproven DEI nonsense and we're forced to nod our heads and agree and sign, you know, as if we're taking an oath, a blood oath for all sorts of things. Theories that are unproven and that frankly are not where this midpoint of America is. They're much more really like pledging allegiance to the woke doctrine.
SPEAKER_00The universities in medicine, people say medicine is different than the arts and humanities. Well, the Roth started in the arts and humanities and it certainly consumed all of medicine. The reason why the New England Journal of Medicine is writing articles on should pediatricians tell parents not to let their little kids play football, That's because the woke ideology dominates. It's not because of any medical reason. I've discussed that in other substacks. We have medical lectures on climate change. We've got a whole branch of medicine on gender reassignment that really is based on a figment of imagination and very low quality and poor quality medical evidence.
SPEAKER_00This ideology is completely taking over medicine, wellness days, mental health breaks, and all sorts of things. It's a problem. I mean, I think it's a complete problem in medicine and we're not even close to where the midpoint of the average American voter is. And yet we're asking them to give us billions of dollars in federal tax subsidies. And you may say, well, I just run a lab. I just run this. I'm not involved in that. Really, you're not, because the more you dive into it, even the hard sciences have been affected by all these things and their hiring decisions and their promotion decisions.
SPEAKER_00The lab may be running on genomics, but the claim may be some sort of grandiose claim that we're going to find genomic abnormalities by race and have Different racial treatments. At the same time, race is just a social construct. It has no biological basis. Which is it, by the way, in the biology? Which is it? I can't keep track in this biology story that they keep telling. So I think this has completely eroded the hard sciences and is emblematic of the university's broader failure. And I guess I'll go ahead and make my final point. People act surprised that the conservatives have taken over and they're running the NIH and they're trying to insert more political balance and they're saying,
SPEAKER_00well, what about the good old days when the scientists made all the decisions? Well, there was never the good old days. There were liberal scientists who have completely strong-armed the universities. They're making all the decisions in a liberal manner and then a handful of conservatives come in and they say, we need to insert some balance in this process and then the liberal scientists who've been running Four, I was actually
SPEAKER_00I was a little bit more sympathetic to this gentleman until I learned that he used the police and he used legal firms to try to suppress criticism of his clear fabrications. That to me rubs me the wrong way. Number five, Nathan Kofnos. This is the postdoc who, At the time when I first wrote my first article on this topic, he was still a postdoc at Ghent University. This guy, people are asking for him to be fired. He ultimately has been suspended in a completely ridiculous decision. I had a chance to review the suspension letter. It's full of absurd claims.
SPEAKER_00Apparently the university faults him for saying he studies whatever, one type of topic. His mandate, he was hired for a job to study the quote, future of liberalism and not whatever he told the news media he's studying. And so therefore you're misrepresenting your credentials. I've never, I've never heard of a university doing this. First of all, a postdoc is hired from a job description, but they don't They don't have a mandate. They can only talk about some topics and not others. They're allowed to study whatever the hell they want in their labs or in their research facilities. They can do whatever they want. They can certainly describe their work in whatever language they wish to describe it.
SPEAKER_00I've never heard of university policing this. The university also criticized this gentleman for being cruel towards Mr. Arday. He said he was intellectually disabled. But then I see Jason Arday's supporters say that this was a disabled guy who was able to overcome these adversity and odds. They criticized this guy because he said Jason Arday was a quote-unquote worthless scholar. And I guess I'm willing to say that that is pretty harsh language. But listen, I've been at university a long time and many people call me a worthless scholar, but you can't take it to heart because I think they're the worthless ones.
SPEAKER_00But, you know, this is just part of the business, okay? So none of the reasons why this Nathan Kaufness was fired are legitimate reasons to fire a guy or suspend a guy on his way to being fired. And... This is the biggest scandal of all this that the University of Ghent is so susceptible to sort of this woke political outrage that they're willing to suspend this guy. Everybody at the top of the University of Ghent, the two people who signed that letter, they need to be fired immediately. The United States government did something nice. I see the ambassador to Belgium put out a statement critical of the university and
SPEAKER_00in support of this U.S. graduate. That's a good thing. And that's also something that would only have happened in this political administration. Interestingly, Those of us who work at universities, we probably have a bit of protection right now because Trump's DOJ would not look favorably if anyone were to engage in this kind of retribution for blowing the whistle on somebody who's clearly false. If this happened in America, Trump's DOJ, I suspect, would be sending subpoenas and letters to that university ASAP, and they wouldn't Suspend Nathan Kofnos.
SPEAKER_00And so I actually think that Nathan Kofnos is already punished. He's punished before any of this begins. He's the postdoc at Ghent. Why is he a postdoc at Ghent? Which, by the way, is below the bottom of the totem pole in the academic university universe. Why is he in this horrible position, which, in my opinion, is already punishment enough? I'd rather go to prison for half a year than be a postdoc at Ghent. Why is he there? And it's because his views are unpopular. Let's be honest. The same woke apparatus that took Jason Arde and put him at the pinnacle is putting this poor guy at the bottom
SPEAKER_00because they don't like his opinions and ideas. I think that's not a good way to handle things. Number six, I reviewed the examples of Jason Arde plagiarizing and I believe that yes he did plagiarize but I think that misses a bigger problem with his work which is even the parts that aren't plagiarized are complete gibberish. I mean I literally can't understand what he's saying. It's all about He's a leftist rhetoric that really has no point or justification. And to be fair to him, I did something, point number seven, I did something quite interesting, which is I picked a sociology department at random in America.
SPEAKER_00I picked random faculty. I don't know who these people are. I just picked three or four names. I started to download their published works to see, is Jason Arday an outlier? And I guess I'd have to say Jason Arde is not an outlier. Actually, all the papers I read were total gibberish. And they were often along politically left themes. They were on themes of colonialism and struggles in power and climate change. They were obsessed with why we're not doing more about climate change. Climate change is like the number one thing on their radar. I started to ask myself, why isn't there a conservative department of sociology?
SPEAKER_00I mean, this looks like a democratic think tank, this sociology. And so my problem with universities isn't, it isn't that they have this department. I don't mind that they have this department. They're writing papers in a language that nobody understands. And frankly, no one reads and that's fine. They can do that. But why are they taking federal taxpayer money And not having political balance. Why are they not at the midpoint of America, but rather at one extreme? See, that's the problem. The problem isn't that there are fringe ideas in all directions. The problem is the university only caters to one fringe.
SPEAKER_00That's the problem. And yet they ask all of society to pay for their foolishness. I mean, I mean, one thing is as a taxpayer, I personally don't want to pay for either of this. I mean, I don't want to be paying for People writing thought essays on all this. If you want to get a philanthropist to donate to you painting a painting, sure, but I don't want to be paying for you to be painting a painting or certainly not writing this kind of garbage. Next point. Medical journals get involved. You know, these days, these medical journals, they're not politically neutral either.
SPEAKER_00I see the Lancet. The Lancet's telling me about Gaza and Kashmir, and it's telling me about all the things wrong with Donald J. Trump. And nature is telling me who to vote for and Science Magazine is basically the operating arm of the Democratic Party. And the New England Journal gets involved. I'm surprised, but they get involved too. New England Journal Voices. Here's their article. Jason Arday and the Perils of Being Black in Academia. The opening sentence, they're trying to kill us. This is verbatim. When black academics say this, I imagine folks outside our community think we're being hyperbolic.
SPEAKER_00We are not. I think my non-black colleagues are starting to get a taste of this as they realize how diabolically opposed to our own well-being most of the movements of our federal health agencies seem to be these days. Wow. That's the opening in the New England Journal of Medicine. Completely unfounded, first of all. I mean, can you imagine publishing this under the banner? And by the way, I'm aware this is the New England Journal of Medicine Voices. It's not the New England Journal of Medicine. It is the... The second thing is, there's
SPEAKER_00Evidenced that this political system in America right now at the federal level is doing anything that would discriminate on the basis of race. If anything, they're trying to undo prior discrimination and woke ideology in the setting of race. So that statement is also baseless. It certainly has no reference and no way to support that statement, but it's also baseless and I disagree with it. I'm not even having a problem with the New England Journal of Medicine Voices publishing this kind of woke diatribe. I think an editor might have toned it down a bit to try to try to reach the audience where they are. But why not publish an article from a conservative columnist? I don't see any conservative columnist at the New England Journal of Medicine Voices.
SPEAKER_00But then again, to be fair, I don't read garbage blogs that often. So I don't waste my time, to be honest with you. The message to black academics is clear. Come in, be great, and indeed be excellent, but don't dare dream too big. Don't dare shine too bright. That's what the author writes in this Voices article. That's not the message of the story. I feel like the message is super, super simple. It's a I'm going to give you a really simple message to anyone who wants to have a career in the public eye ever, which is keep your tall tales to a minimum, okay? Just minimize the bullshit in your stories.
SPEAKER_00Just minimize it. You can tell tall tales. Every single person tells a little bit tall tales. I think that's when you get into trouble. And when there are many, many such claims, it really speaks to the fact that the person telling those claims is a fabulist.
SPEAKER_00I mean, what does a fabulous mean? It's a type of person that just can't help themselves. They lie about everything. They lie the way people breathe. And there are lots of these people. Every once in a while, we find out in the movie Shattered Glass, this reporter was one, Jonah Lehrer. He's a writer in the New Yorker magazine. By the way, maybe about two decades ago, somebody said, you really need to work with Jonah Lehrer. And I ended up not getting around to it. And then I found out that he made up everything he wrote. So I'm glad I never worked with this dude. Similarly, this guy is a serial fabulous. This happens all the time. So the message to, I think, black or white or any color academic is clear.
SPEAKER_00Don't make up things. The second message is universities, please verify the scholarship of the people you hire. I mean, if you're in the gibberish business, verify that they didn't plagiarize the gibberish. I mean, if you're in the gibberish business, maybe just throw them a bone and hire one gibberish conservative writer. If you have 25 gibberish liberal writers, one gibberish conservative is not going to hurt you. Just invite him in, just to make it a little bit more balanced so you'll have some diversity when the political movements come to cut your funding. You see my point here? Diversity is good when it's about ideological diversity.
SPEAKER_00Another line in the New England Journal astounded me. Besides making the point that his PhD advisor in university cleared him of deliberate plagiarism allegations, I want to be clear, I don't care whether or not any of the allegations against Professor Arde were true. You don't care whether or not it was true that the guy was a serial fabulous. That's the heart of the matter. The heart of the matter is whether or not we can trust him as a scholar or if he's just making things up. It's the heart of the matter. And there's no such thing as deliberate or not deliberate plagiarism, just like there's not like deliberate or not deliberate speeding. You're either speeding or you're plagiarizing or not.
SPEAKER_00Now, you might have been trying to do it or not trying to do it. That might determine your punishment, but the act itself is the act itself. He's plagiarizing. You know, plagiarizing has been coming up lately, these days. Claudine Gay plagiarized. Plagiarizing is a unique type of academic fraud. You're literally just copying and pasting the words. I sympathize with people who think it is the worst type of academic fraud. I sympathize with those people because it's just so lazy. I just can't imagine even among all the ways in which fraud happens to be so lazy.
SPEAKER_00You can't just rewrite it in your own words. I mean, it's rewriting ideas in your own words. That's part and parcel of academics. But to actually plagiarize, that means you're so lazy you can't even move a few words around. I just don't understand plagiarism. I never did, never will. This one really got me, threw me for a loop from the New England Journal piece. In contrast, as a white man, you can rise to be president of Stanford University, and after your falsified data is found and set back an entire field of research for years, you'll only lose your job and quickly find another as the CEO of
SPEAKER_00a $1 billion biopharma startup. Beyond this single story of nauseating privilege, it is a fantasy to act like plagiarism, falsified data, and suspicious, unreproducible results are not major and common problems in academia. We have entire websites, blah, blah, blah. Everyone's doing this. So I actually agree with this writer about this key point, which is that, yeah, there's a mountain of bad research. Didn't I do that video on Theo Baker on this very channel? And haven't I written many posts saying that most academic research is not truthful or useful or both? Exactly.
SPEAKER_00This person is spot on. But there is a difference between Mark Tessier-Levine, MTL, the president of Stanford, and this guy. Shall we review the differences? MTL was the president of Stanford who did so much extremely high profile basic science in neurology. Some of that basic science was found to be irreproducible and even contained Shall we say it? Fraudulent Western blots. But no one is alleging that Mark Tessier Levine himself went down into the lab and did the pipetting late at night and photoshopped it himself.
SPEAKER_00No one thinks that's what happened. He would never be caught dead being in that lab. He's an important man who's not going to be pipetting. He's hired a lot of people and he's put a lot of pressure on them to get results and one of them decided to falsify and he looked the other way and didn't really double check. He was sort of the Cambridge of the story. Okay. So should he be punished? Absolutely. Did he do the fraud? No, he should be punished for having, putting too much pressure on people and not checking up on their work. And he was punished. He was pushed out of the university presidentship, but he's not the guy actually doing the falsifying. That's one. Two, he's not Writing only gibberish with some plagiarized gibberish,
SPEAKER_00he's actually also has some experiments that have led to FDA-approved therapies that have saved lives. So, I mean, just to put in perspective, he has actually done some good science too along the way. The next point I'd make is that he's actually never actually plagiarized, you know, so I think that that is a difference. And then the final point I would make is that his life story does not contain fantastical elements to it as well. And then the other point I'd make is that Is not making a name and he's not being appointed for what many assume to be political reasons. So all of that together means the sort of comparison is not exactly apt.
SPEAKER_00And then the next point I'd make completely separate from all this is that had Jason Arday not tragically decided to take his own life, he actually probably could have been super successful. You know, when I was growing up, there was this writer named James Frey, and he wrote a memoir called, what, A Million Little Pieces, and it was about his road to recovery, and it was full of what ultimately turned out to be false things. And he was also elevated, just like Cambridge elevated this guy, Oprah elevated James Frey. And if Oprah hadn't picked his book, nobody would care twice about it. Nobody would look twice at James Frey.
SPEAKER_00Nobody would have read that book, but Oprah did it. Oprah, Cambridge. I think that's a fair comparison. An 800-year institution, Oprah Winfrey. Lots of cultural cachet. So they both elevated these people. They found all the fraud. James Frey, humiliated. But what did he do? He started writing fiction. He made his own, I don't know, company. I looked him up. He's super rich now. He's actually quite successful. He's very happy. So what's the point here? MTL, he's running a new company. James Frey, he's doing this. You know, there's a path forward. So had Jason... Arday just continued doing his writing or maybe even started writing fiction.
SPEAKER_00I think he would have been super successful. His books would have been mega bestsellers probably just because of all the publicity on the issue. So I kind of disagree with her premise that he's getting differential treatment. Every one of these people is getting pushed out of their academic job. Okay, final point. Here's the final point, putting it all together. It doesn't interest me that one academic in a gibberish field is writing plagiarized stuff and that he's got sort of a false story. What interests me is that Cambridge University Doesn't catch any of this. What interests me is that the University of Ghent suspends this postdoc, who,
SPEAKER_00by the way, his career is already a punishment, but they want to punish him even more for bringing this out into the open, and that the New England Journal of Medicine, which last I checked is a medical journal, that they're publishing this completely garbage, crazy, unhinged, left-wing, woke article on their website. What's the unifying thesis here is exactly what people think it is. Universities have been completely politically captured by the irrational, crazy, woke left, They cannot be saved. They're not trying to have balance. They're trying to punish conservatives who work there.
SPEAKER_00They need to be defunded by conservatives if and when they're in office. Always only defund. That's what's happening. I don't understand people complaining at universities. Why is my NIH grants getting cut? Why are they not giving out money? You are not running a politically neutral organization. You're running a politically biased organization. You're persecuting the handful of faculty with different views. You're not letting them have teaching opportunities. You're making them postdoc at Ghent. And even that he's not allowed to continue. To be a postdoc in Ghent, I could think of no worse punishment than making Sisyphus push that boulder
SPEAKER_00in Ghent. And even then they say, enough boulder pushing, you're done. You're done with that boulder pushing. But still, they're totally captured. Totally captured. And the only solution is defunding them fully. And that's what the Jason Arde story proponents, people talking about it, want you to believe. And I guess everyone is falling in line. The New England Journal, can they be saved? Can they actually have a New England Journal Voices that publishes a thoughtful criticism like the post I've written on my Substack? No, they're not going to do it because there's going to be a couple of woke people in the organization who say it's dangerous.
SPEAKER_00Dangerous misinformation. Oh, you know, we can't tell people that cloth masking didn't work. That's dangerous misinformation. That's a woke idea. We can't tell them you don't need an annual COVID booster or 40 boosters in your next 40 years because that they'll contradict the woke ideology. The university The New England Journal, they're not balanced. So what are we to do? I mean, what is any sensible person to do other than to only vote for people who promise to set their budget to zero dollars and zero cents? I don't see an alternative. I really don't. I don't think they're trying to fix themselves.
SPEAKER_00In fact, they just keep doubling down. The Fauci illustrates that. Jason Arde illustrates that. Punishing this guy, Nathan Kofnas, illustrates that. These Kemi Dahl Voices op-ed illustrates that. They're not making any effort to even try to move to the center of America. And that's why this is a great 80-20 issue. If I were a political strategist, I would say you want to talk about this issue every single day because it's an 80-20 issue where the Republicans have 80% of American people behind them and the Democrats don't realize that they are hanging their hat on a crazy,
SPEAKER_00woke, extreme, And they're going to lose in an 80-20 issue. So that's why I think this story has gained so much traction on the right, because it is a winning issue that universities have lost their purpose. And it's fine to lose your purpose and be a left-wing think tank, but don't ask for taxpayer money. But they want to have their cake and eat it too. And I suspect what will happen is this administration has made some cuts, but not as drastic as I've described. It's modest. The next administration may be a democratic administration. They're going to,
SPEAKER_00you know, Just give them a ton of funding, triple the budget, whatever, something ridiculous, and then these universities are going to grow and this apparatus is going to get bigger. But then there'll be a future Republican that will cut them even harder and harsher and it's just going to be more painful for when the real correction comes. That's the dynamic that's going to play out unless somebody tries to actually strive to run a balanced university or a balanced New England Journal or a balanced Ghent, University of Ghent. So those are my thoughts on this issue.
SPEAKER_00All right, well, I'll be back with more Medicine Unpacked. Here's what you can do if you like this. If you like this video, leave a comment. Send it to someone else. Post it on another channel. That's the way to get these videos going. Follow me on Instagram. I'm at medicineunpacked. Follow me on Twitter. Subscribe to my Substack, Vinay Prasad's Observations and Thoughts. You can also listen to this audio on Plenary Session. If you disagree with me, You can try to send me an email. I read like 1% of the many, many things I get. If you actually make some good points, I might even try to read it, but usually I very rarely get that.
SPEAKER_00So if you like this video, you know what to do. Like, subscribe, comment, leave a message. Until next time.
Live episode from Youtube This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.drvinayprasad.com/subscribe
Elizabeth Holmes/ AI researchers start smoking/ Moderna vax by Plenary Session This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit...
Pope has cancer; Phase 1 trials for AI; Can AI hack cancer trials__1 by Plenary Session This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit...