My video summary of recent events This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.drvinayprasad.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Anthony Fauci pleads the Fifth Amendment over a hundred times in front of Congress, and the media is completely divided on whether or not he's a hero or a criminal. I'll get to the bottom of it in today's Medicine Unpacked. Anthony Fauci pleaded the Fifth Amendment this week in front of Rand Paul's committee when he was asked by Republican senators about COVID-19 pandemic origins and the response. This is in the wake of Rand Paul releasing a thousand pages of his diary, which RFK Jr. says they found on government servers. He was emailing it to himself.
SPEAKER_00So I just want to make one point right off the bat. People say that people should be entitled to a private diary. Absolutely, I think people should be entitled to a private diary, to writing things down and keeping them in a little book under your bed. But the moment you use your government laptop to keep your diary and you start emailing it to yourself, then I think you can't be surprised that people discover it, okay? So it is fair game, I think, what they found in his diary. The media's coverage of this has been completely inadequate. I mean, the New York Times, Washington Post, the Atlantic, they are fawning over this man.
SPEAKER_00I think you have to be honest about what is going on. I'm going to try to do that in this video. I'm going to try to be honest, but I'm also not going to go to the extreme on the other end where I think people have taken it a little too far as to what his punishment should be. And I do not agree with the most extreme punishments for this man. I think he should be judged fairly and he should receive what That deserves, which we'll talk about. So let's talk about it. Gain of function research. I think it was very clear that Fauci was funding some of the work in the Wuhan laboratory.
SPEAKER_00And I think it's also very clear that lab leak is the most likely possibility. Now, I saw in the New York Times, they said that there is no certain evidence that lab leak was the possibility or something like that. Here's why that's wrong. OK, we need to separate biological science from intelligence. OK, so if somebody comes to you and says, boy, the waiter peed in the soup. You can be a biologist and put your biologist hat on it and you can take a sample of the soup. You can run it for all sorts of testing to look for perhaps some sloughed off cells
SPEAKER_00or DNA or urea from the bladder through mass spectrometry. And you might find that it's actually very difficult to tell if there's any pee in the soup. But if you interview another waiter who says, dude, I saw him pee in the soup. That's intelligence, okay? And that's the crux of this debate. The CIA, the FBI, the other intelligence agencies have, in Fauci's own diary, apprehended transmission from the Chinese, which strongly suggests that they are aware of a lab leak incident. And that type of evidence is not biologic evidence.
SPEAKER_00It's not the furin cleavage site, although there is some of that evidence as well. This is intelligence evidence, and that is much more compelling. And Fauci describes in his diary receiving this intelligence. In January of 2020, Fauci describes in his diary that he did not believe the wet market in Wuhan was the source of the virus. And in fact, there's evidence that was circulating in China right before that he thinks that wet market event was an amplifier. So this diary is incredibly newsworthy because it shows that contemporaneously he was lying
SPEAKER_00in his public statements versus what he actually believed. Now, what do I think should be done about this? I think that Fauci clearly has a presidential pardon that covers this. I think one can ask oneself, why does he need a pardon? This is a guy who went on record saying, Maybe years before the pandemic that we ought to do gain of function research.
SPEAKER_00It is protective. I think at this point, it is very likely that the net effect of that was the loss of millions of lives. And it is a net negative strategy. I think Fauci should pay a very severe penalty in the eyes of history for having been likely the funder of the pandemic and the person who downplayed its origin. Now let's talk for a minute about why people feel so strongly against him. I think the media does a disservice. They paint his detractors as kind of people out to get him. They don't really explain why people would feel so strongly about this person.
SPEAKER_00And let me try to explain it. I don't think it's because he was wrong. Scientists are wrong all the time. In fact, many of the TV personalities were mostly wrong during the pandemic, but most people largely forgive him, forgive him of that, forgive them of being wrong. I also don't think it's because public health coerced us to do things that were, on average, debatable. Public health does that all the time. I mean, there are public health coercions that make you do something and don't make you do something, everything from don't drive drunk laws to wear a helmet laws,
SPEAKER_00and some of these laws are actually quite debatable. There's a literature on helmet laws really debating whether or not they actually do any good, because there's some literature that cars actually pass a little bit closer to somebody when they're wearing a helmet versus not, and I've written about this. It's called the Pelsman Effect in Medicine. But people largely accept that because these are movements that take decades, that take many people, that build a societal consensus, and then they implement something, and I think people largely accept that. Instead, Anthony Fauci is that rare example of the Coalescing of several factors.
SPEAKER_00Let me read them to you. This is from my substack. He, alone, or with only a small group of people, so this is key, it's just, he is really responsible for this, made decisions that B, coerced hundreds of millions of people to do and not do a series of debatable actions, which C, while he was largely incorrect about those actions, and D, unable to admit uncertainty or doubt, and E, unable to gather more evidence, even though he was the NIAID director and he controlled a large federal budget that could have been used for randomized trials, And F, while demonizing scientists who disagreed.
SPEAKER_00And now E, while keeping a diary that reveals that many times he believed the exact opposite of what he was saying. That's really a unique constellation of things that line up that make people so viscerally angry. I gave an example of a woman who said that this guy Is forever doomed in her mind because he forced her toddler to wear a, quote, dirty bacteria riddled mask for eight hours a day. No one will ever forgive him. And I think you have to at least as a news media understand how she feels
SPEAKER_00that he did in fact do that. And I think the media will say, well, he didn't have the power to do that. His diary reveals that he was actually having conversations with politicians, encouraging them to close schools and encouraging these policies, including masking. He pushed for that policy publicly and privately with politicians who trusted him.
SPEAKER_00He didn't make those decisions, I think is wrong. He did make those decisions. He pushed for those decisions. He used all his political capital to get those decisions through. And he demonized anyone who said those decisions were wrong, people like Jay Bhattacharya and others, whom he called fringe epidemiologists and worse. So, you know, he did do it. He is responsible for that. Now, some people say he just did his job as best he could. Well, the diary also shows that's wrong because he was the NIAID director, which is the director of an institute at the NIH that gives out funding.
SPEAKER_00He was not the CDC director. He was not the head of the COVID-19 task force. He had a very specific role, but he subsumed the other roles. The diary describes how HHS said, That he was doing a good job. He should be the front man, the spokesperson for these policies. He actually decided that he should start to set the policies. The diary reveals many instances where he fought with Rochelle Walensky, including in some very controversial instances, and he pushed for her to be fired from the CDC directorship. So you see a man who is taking over jobs that aren't his.
SPEAKER_00I'll come to his fame finally, but one wonders why he was so eager to take jobs that wasn't his. Okay, awards. Anthony Fauci gave out billions of dollars in federal funds over a 38-year career as director of NIAID. In his own emails and diaries, you can see... He is emailing people whom he has given significant funding for and asking them to nominate him for academic awards, some of which he got to keep the cash prize. So imagine you're the head of a federal agency.
SPEAKER_00You give someone a hundred million dollar contract, a million dollar contract, ten million dollar contract. They nominate you for a prize and you get a fifty thousand dollar check, which government ethics did allow him to keep some of these prize money. Not all, but some. That really is a loophole for bribery. That is a complete loophole for bribery. Happy to say I received no awards during my government service. No one was going to give me any awards. I didn't get any awards. I didn't get any money from awards. If I were giving out grants and receiving awards, that is almost a quid pro quo situation,
SPEAKER_00and that's what it looks like Fauci was doing. I think that is something that requires further government ethics laws, and I think History should look poorly upon a man who was repeatedly begging people to give him awards. It feeds into the final point of fame and narcissism, boosters. Now, Fauci talks about in his own diary that he was aware of evidence that COVID-19 vaccines did not halt transmission. This is really important. Between January to May of 2021, Based on the existing variants at the time and based on data from Moderna's study,
SPEAKER_00I think most people believed that the COVID-19 vaccines almost completely extinguished transmission of the virus. Then in the summertime with Provincetown and other examples, we saw escape variants emerge that made that conclusion false, that the COVID-19 vaccine, not only did it not stop transmission, it will put only the most marginal dent in transmission. It's not going to do anything for transmission and infection for everybody is inevitable. Okay, Fauci being wrong in April and May, no one follows him for that. The problem is, in his own diary, he talks about the November-October Biden mandate and the push for the mandate.
SPEAKER_00By the time the mandate deployed, there was no question the vaccines did not stop transmission. Maybe they dampened it, but by not that much. And if you take a time horizon that's a few months or a year out, that dampening of transmission is going to do nothing. Everyone's going to get COVID-19 anyway, which is what happened. Now we've all had COVID many times over. So if you're going to mandate a vaccine, one ethical prerequisite is there has to be a benefit to third parties. The benefit to a third party has to be so big it justifies taking away people's autonomy.
SPEAKER_00There cannot be a benefit to third parties if transmission is inevitable. And Fauci knows that. In his own diary, he talks about Rochelle was going to put out a statement saying transmission is inevitable. And he put great pressure on her to not put out that statement. And he writes, because this will undermine DOJ's vaccine mandate. So he is suppressing scientific information in order to push a specific Biden-era policy for political purposes and get this mandate through, which enriched the companies that made the product and didn't help people. And people paid a great societal price.
SPEAKER_00I've known nurses who were working. They got COVID while working. They recovered from COVID. They continued to work hard. They're good nurses, but they were fired because they didn't get a vaccine that, frankly, they didn't need. They'd already had COVID. Fauci was the architect of this policy. He promoted this policy internally Surely the media has to understand why people who were fired, lost their job, retired early to avoid this vaccine mandate are mad at this guy. Surely the media has to see that because he used flawed evidence and suppressed truthful evidence in order to achieve that goal. It's not that he was wrong in April.
SPEAKER_00It was that he was suppressing information in October. That's the problem. Okay, that's the problem. Masking is a similar situation. His own diary reveals that one of the reasons he flip-flopped so famously between March and April of 2020 on whether or not we should wear cloth masks, which, by the way, it's a very silly thing. They obviously don't work. There's a literature that didn't work, and nobody really thought they worked who knew anything, but he really pushed that they worked, and he tricked the public. One of his justifications was he writes in his diary, I look around, I see people doing it already. He's going based on the vibes.
SPEAKER_00He's not going based on science. He's just going with the wind. He's a weather vane. It's blown whichever direction the wind blows. That's not good enough to be the NIAID director. If you're making a pronouncement that leads 100 million people to be forced into doing something, you really need high level evidence that that's true. You can't just go off vibes. And he did. And so he should pay the price for having done that. Now, his job, I think he clearly usurped roles that weren't his. And why did he do all this? I think the diary does give one clue.
SPEAKER_00Which is this man is completely addicted to fame and narcissism. I mean, I've not read anything like this. I can't even imagine having these thoughts. If I did have these thoughts, I certainly wouldn't even write them down in pen to paper because I would be embarrassed for myself to see myself writing such things. But he wrote them all down. He was proud that a brewery named a beer after him, that he had bobblehead dolls. He writes, I may well be the most famous person in the world. He's basking in his fame. He's happy to be on the cover of magazines. Many of his diary posts say, a thousand people died today, but look how famous I am.
SPEAKER_00That's got to rub people the wrong way. And I can't see how the New York Times excuses that, how the Atlantic excuses that or downplays that. The Atlantic has a piece where they talk about how who wouldn't be writing such things if you were so famous. Actually, a lot of people would be a little bit embarrassed by that fame. And a lot of people who had such power to force Millions of people, maybe billions of people to do something would look in the mirror and really ask themselves, boy, I better be 100% sure before I deploy this vaccine mandate that I'm right. Otherwise, I'm really gonna have to eat something on the back end.
SPEAKER_00He didn't do that. He was happy to do that because the more you control people, the more fame and adulation you get, which he really loved. Man has got a portrait of himself above his own desk. That's gotta be problematic. What's my view of this guy? I think at the age of, what, 78 in 2019, had he retired from NIAD, he would have been thought to be a medical hero. He decided, like so many people, that he didn't want to let go of power and continue to work into his 80s, and everything he did after that undermined his reputation.
SPEAKER_00So should this guy be winning awards with million-dollar cash prizes as he did? No. Should he have to pay back some of the awards that appear to be quid pro quo? Yes. If universities invite him like Stanford recently did, should they be fawning over him talking about how great he is? No. Should people be posting that I read the diaries and hashtag this is a witch hunt and I stand with Fauci? No. I think people should be more honest and be like, boy, even if you like the dude, even if you think he's a nice guy, he did kind of screw up and I can understand why people don't like him.
SPEAKER_00I think that's what the Academy should be saying and the fact that universities and the Academy Now, should he face criminal penalties? Well, he does have a pardon. Are there ways to get around the pardon? I don't know. I'm not a legal expert. But I do think that pushing very hard for criminal penalties for an 85-year-old guy I think is not exactly my preferred solution. I think my preferred solution is to have a correct historical analysis of this guy
SPEAKER_00and to let him live out whatever remaining time he has in peace, but to point out that he did a very bad job. He was very likely a narcissist. His narcissism pushed him to make pronouncements and claims and recommendations that he had no evidence to support. He, although was the NIAID director and could have generated that evidence, he didn't. He engaged in a bunch of really fishy behaviors. One fishy behavior is he spoke repeatedly in his diary about an October surprise and how Trump wanted that vaccine. And then he spoke to Borla about when the results were due.
SPEAKER_00There's a big problem in the heart of this clinical trial of the Pfizer vaccine, which is that they did not follow the original statistical analysis plan. They changed it. The only reason they changed it, in my opinion, as I've spoken about before, was to delay the vaccine until after the election. That decision was a political decision. It had a human cost. It cost some lives. And I think there should be great scrutiny on that. I see none of that scrutiny from The New York Times and from other resources that should be looking into that. That is one of his failures. Gain of function is a huge failure.
SPEAKER_00Lying about masks is a failure. Pushing for booster mandates is a failure. I mean, this guy should be judged extremely poorly in history. And should not be revered as a saint. It should be a learning lesson for young people, which is retire when you can. I plan to retire at the first opportunity I'm given. And that's probably where it should end. And I disagree with some of the more stronger views on the topic. But that's just me. I tend to be forgiving. And I think that newspapers should point out that it's not that he was wrong.
SPEAKER_00It's that he forced you to do something while being wrong and really being one the few people who did it. Oh, one more point. It wasn't just that he wanted a vaccine mandate. He was one of the people that said, if you've had COVID and recovered, that doesn't count for anything. You shouldn't get any credit for that. He was one of a handful of people on a phone call that made that decision. There was a five people, according to Paul Offit's recounting of that. Well, those people need to eat a lot of crow because they were 100% wrong. And they're real people who lost their job because of this decision. So please, The New York Times and other news outlets should talk to the people
SPEAKER_00who were directly harmed by this guy's advocacy. And this guy's advocacy was not just on TV. He was dealing with politicians behind the scenes. And as such, I think he needs to pay a price in the books of history. There needs to be a correct historical telling of this topic. So those are my thoughts. Anthony Fauci pleading the fifth. I don't know what that means. I'm not sure you can plead the fifth if you've already been pardoned for a crime. I also think he could probably re-implicate himself and perjure himself now that he has telling the story again.
SPEAKER_00I think when he posts things on Twitter, pictures of himself portraying him as good versus evil and things like this, I think it's distasteful. I think The best thing he could do is probably slip away. Finally, the money he made from patents and other such things. I guess I haven't seen enough documentation of that. I am aware of the fact that by working in federal government, people do receive royalties on patents. If the patent makes a billion dollars, you don't get a billion dollars. There's a cap on how much you get per patent. But I do know that there are people with many patents and all those patents are generating a lot of money.
SPEAKER_00So he may have received a lot of money from patents on the vaccine. And that is a conflict of interest. And I think that This is a big topic. This is a big topic that goes to Beidol and lots of other things about how patents are managed at universities with federal funds, who gets the money, how much money, and that is a much bigger topic than just Anthony Fauci. So I don't, that's not the thing, the key thing for me that I'm most upset about. I'm most upset about The hubris, I mean, the arrogance to be making these proclamations and really affecting people's lives.
SPEAKER_00You know, somebody who's a two-year-old, has autism, doesn't want to wear the cloth mask, and they're removed from an airplane. This actually happened, and Fauci is the architect of making that happen. So shouldn't he bear the brunt of the fact that the cloth mask was not going to do anything, making a two-year-old do it is stupid. And this whole policy was ridiculous because airplanes actually have good filtration. So what the hell was that all about? He should own that. And I do think what would be fair is if the news covered it fairly. They're completely wrong. They're still treating him as a saint. That's not going to look good. And that's fundamentally a reason why people don't trust newspapers because they just can't be factually accurate and they no longer have a center.
SPEAKER_00Those are my thoughts. If you like this video, you need to do like, subscribe, comment, leave a message below. The comments help a lot. Recommend this video to a friend. Send the link. I'll be back with more Medicine Unpacked.
Live episode from Youtube This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.drvinayprasad.com/subscribe
Elizabeth Holmes/ AI researchers start smoking/ Moderna vax by Plenary Session This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit...
Pope has cancer; Phase 1 trials for AI; Can AI hack cancer trials__1 by Plenary Session This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit...