Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Play Therapy Parenting: Real Parenting Questions Answered by a Child Therapist

Play Therapy Parenting: Real Parenting Questions Answered by a Child Therapist artwork

S4E18 - Why Does My Child Fight Me Over Everything? (And How to Stop the Power Struggle)

Oct 22, 202614 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode, I answer a question from a mom whose six-year-old can be cooperative one minute and completely defiant the next. I explain why behavior like refusing to get in the car, undoing something positive after being praised, or digging in when asked to do something is often less about "bad behavior" and more about a child's need for power and control. When we understand what is driving the behavior, we can respond differently instead of getting pulled into the power struggle. I also share how intentional choice giving can help children feel more empowered throughout the day, even when the actual expectation is not negotiable. I walk through what that can look like in a real-life situation like getting into the car, why staying calm and neutral matters, and why encouragement is more helpful than praise when we want children to develop confidence, responsibility, and internal motivation. Ask Me Questions: Call (813) 812-5525, or email: brenna@thekidcounselor.com My New Book! Parent Companion for Play Therapy: Want to go deeper into the concepts discussed in this series? Check out Parent Companion for Play Therapy, created to help parents better understand their child, the play therapy process, and how lasting emotional growth takes place. https://www.amazon.com/Parent-Companion-Play-Therapy-Understanding/dp/B0H2D98F18/ My First Book: Device Detox: A Parent's Guide To Reducing Usage, Preventing Tantrums, And Raising Happier Kids https://a.co/d/bThnKH9 Podcast HQ: https://www.playtherapyparenting.com/ My Newsletter Signup: https://www.playtherapyparenting.com/newsletter/ My Podcast Partner, Gabb Wireless: https://www.playtherapyparenting.com/gabb/ Common References: Landreth, G.L. (2023). Play Therapy: The Art of the Relationship (4th ed.). Routledge. Landreth, G.L., & Bratton, S.C. (2019). Child-Parent Relationship Therapy (CPRT): An Evidence-Based 10-Session Filial Therapy Model (2nd ed.). Routledge.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

You're listening to the Play Therapy Parenting Podcast with Dr. Brenna Hicks. Hi, I'm Doctor Brenna Hicks, The Kid Counselor. This is the Play Therapy Parenting Podcast where I answer real parenting questions about behavior, emotions, and the parent-child relationship. In today's episode, I am answering a question from Kay. I appreciate the email, Kay, and I apologize for not getting an episode out to y'all last week. I was speaking and traveling in New Jersey and New York. So,

I know that we missed each other last week, but I'm happy to hang out with you all again and thanks for your patience as I was not home to get a podcast out. So, let me read parts of Kay's question and then we will dive in together. My six year old is very defiant. He can be an angel sometimes, but the next minute he is refusing to get in the car no matter what consequence I suggest. And sometimes when I praise him, he then undoes the good deed deliberately. How do I manage that? All right, Kay, so you and all the rest of us as parents have been in this situation.

And I think one of the most helpful things that we do when we understand that a behavior is difficult and frustrating. It's a child showing us what their pain is and what they're facing. We always focus on the doughnut, not the hole. That's our rule of thumb thumb from the parent training. What does that mean if you have a doughnut sitting in front of you? You're just excited to have a doughnut because doughnuts are good. You don't lament that the baker took a little metal metal cylinder and

removed the middle of your doughnut. You don't go, oh my gosh, well, if that was still here, if that was still here, or if that was different, or if we could change that, or if, if we could put it back, if we could put it back, if we could make that hole again, if we could. You would just enjoy the doughnut. This is what we do with kids a lot. We focus on all the things that are missing or that we wish were there or that we would fix or we would put back or we would change or we would amend in some way. And we totally miss the fact that the good kid is sitting right there.

So I think first and foremost it's helpful to understand that behavior is not reflective of the child, it's reflective of what they're trying to communicate. It is agenda driven behavior to get their needs met. It's to show you what they're struggling with. It's to show you their pain. So I think that in and of itself changes our lens and it changes our perspective on what's going on because it is extremely frustrating when a child will not get in a car and we need to leave. It's extremely frustrating when our children will not go to bed.

It's extremely frustrating when all the other behaviors that we wrestle with. But if we only focus on the behavior, we lose sight of the child, and we know that kids behave in more self-enhancing ways when they are in a positive and accepting relationship with an adult. So if we can maintain acceptance of the child in the midst of the behavior, It diffuses the intensity and it shifts things in a positive direction. So, another thing we need to think about is we're going to filter this down.

Why is your son One minute completely content, and the next minute refusing to do something. I suspect when he's content and when you claim he's an angel. He is not in a disregulated state. But maybe you told him to turn off the TV. To get in the car to leave and turning off the TV disregulated him. Or maybe he was playing with his friends and you said, OK,

time to go, and that just regulated him. Or maybe he's hungry and you say get in the car and he doesn't have the capacity to be obedient because his hunger's taking over. There are factors when kids shift their behavior like that, so the why matters and it's important for us to try to figure out is there a pattern here? What happens before these moments? Is he hungry? Is he tired? Is he bored? Is there something going on? Is there an emotional charge? Does he get disregulated?

Those are helpful cues that we can pay attention to. And then at the end of the day, when a child refuses something, It's power and control. He's 6. He has very little power and control in his life. As a matter of fact, there are a handful of things, literally 5, a handful of things over which children have control in their lives. Eating, sleeping, toileting, talking. And behavior

That's it. I ticked them off on my fingers, you couldn't see it, but there are 5 things in the world over which a child has control. That has to be really frustrating. You have no agency. You have no autonomy. You have no power. So what does that produce? A kid that's gonna take power and control wherever they can get it. So he's going to refuse to get in the car because that's one of the things over which he has some control.

If you recognize it as a power struggle, it helps reframe it. So I know I haven't technically answered your question yet, Kay. I'm getting there, I promise. But what I'm hoping that we're seeing is with the three things we've already discussed, It's a change of perspective. A new lens through which we're viewing what's going on. Because while the behavior doesn't change when we have a different lens, our response does. So we recognize this is a power struggle. Interestingly, when you say if you praise him,

then he undoes the good deed deliberately. Another power struggle. Because if you say Oh, you got in the car and you're happy about it. He's like, OK, well, I'll make sure that you're not happy now. So he is pushing back real hard to have power and control. I will not do what you do, and if I do it and you get excited about it, I'm going to turn that around real quickly. And so what that tells us is he needs to be given opportunities to have power and control

in general, not in that moment, but in general. So, OK, I'm curious. This is a proverbial question because I can't hear your answer, but what are things over which you could give him some control on a daily basis? But you can choose to have an apple in your lunch or you can choose to have an orange in your lunch. You can choose to wear your tennis shoes today or you can choose to wear your sandals today. You can choose to use the green backpack or you can choose to use the blue backpack. You can choose to

Run to the car to leave or you can choose to hop to the car to leave. You can choose to play in the backyard or you can choose to play in the front yard. We have so many choices that we can give kids throughout the day just for the sake of empowering them, just for the sake of helping them feel that they do have a measure of control over their lives, and they won't have to fight so hard in all the rest of the moments. So my suggestion would be absolutely try to give him as many choices as you can, mutually agreeable, meaning you're OK with either choice.

You would be OK if he wears sandals or sneakers. You would be OK if he goes to the front yard or the backyard. So he doesn't get carte blanche control. You're setting parameters. You're OK with the choices you're providing, so he ultimately is not in charge. But he gets to make a choice and he gets to feel empowered. In the moment If you're trying to get him in the car. It's a limit You really don't want to get in the car, but it's time to go. We're acknowledging his feelings.

And we're setting a neutral limit. You really don't want to go, but it's time to leave. You really don't want to get in the car. But it's time to go. OK, so that's the first and the 2nd step of the limit. Third is going to be offering choices. So the choice is not don't get in the car. The choice can be how he gets in the car. It can be where he sits once he's in the car. It can be what music you listen to while in the car driving somewhere. It can be what he brings in the car with him.

So we're not saying, do you want to get in the car or do you not want to get in the car? By the way, we don't ever say, do you want, it's do you choose? If we don't say the word choose 3 times, he doesn't feel empowered. Do you choose this or do you choose this? Which do you choose? Do you want? Would you like? Those are not the same things. And we certainly don't threaten. If you don't get in the car then. Kids learn nothing about self-control and self responsibility with that. So you really don't want to get in the car but it's time to go.

You can choose to listen to. Country music when we get in there, or you can choose to listen to rock music when we get in there. You would pick ones that you know he likes. I have no idea what your six year old likes to listen to. Kid bop and Veggie Tale soundtrack. I have no idea. So you're going to offer that choice. Maybe you're going to say you can choose to bring a coloring book in the car or you can choose to bring a reading book in the car. Which do you choose? Maybe it's you can choose to sit on the right side in the back seat or you can choose to sit on the left side in the back seat. Which do you choose?

And now what we're doing is we're giving him some power even though getting in the car is not one of the choices. And the key to this K is you are calm, you are calm, you are neutral, you do not get heated, you do not get escalated. There's no charge. So you say this as if you're talking about what you did today. You really don't want to get in the car, but it's time to go. You can choose to use the right side of the seat or you can choose to use the left side of the seat.

Which do you choose? And you're going to say that several times because kids need time to make choices. They are not cognitive. They are not rational. So it may take him a few rounds before he's able to make the choice, but the goal is he chooses to get in the car. And then you don't act excited, you don't act happy, you don't act happy, you don't act grateful, you don't act grateful, you don't act thank God, because that's how we feel. But we very neutrally and calmly say

you chose to bring the coloring book with you. And then you back out He needs to be validated for the choice that was made. I'm so glad, thank you so much. You're such a good kid. Oh, I'm so grateful to you. What was the choice that was made? That's the only response that we provide. And it becomes apparent to your six year old. I have some choice here. I have some choice here. I have some agency in this. Even when I don't want to do things,

I do have some power. And that diffuses the intensity of the power struggling. One final thought, I don't know if you actually meant that you praised him, if that was just the word that you used, and maybe you don't even know the difference between praise versus encouragement. For those of you that have no idea what I'm talking about, please go back and listen to earlier episodes on praise versus encouragement. But OK, it's really important that we do not praise our children because then they become crippled by needing to hear our words of validation.

So instead of saying good job, that was awesome, you're great, if it has an opposite, it's value laden. That's what praise is. Good job. You're awesome. You're so smart. You're amazing. You, whatever, those are all praises. What we do instead, we focus on what the kid contributed. So You got in the car Fast today. Not a good job.

You got in the car right when I asked. We're trying to make it clear this isn't about what I think about it. I'm focusing on what you did. That's why we say you chose to bring your coloring book. Because they're getting credit for the choice that was made, they also need to be given credit for their effort and their contribution to what's going on. So We're going to not say good job, that's awesome. You're amazing. You're amazing. You're the best kid. I love you so much.

I mean, we always say I love you, but not in a sense of thank you for doing that, now I love you. That's conditional acceptance. So we're going to eliminate praise, and we're just going to say, oh, you chose that, you did that. And that keeps it neutral, and then the child starts to go, yeah, I did. And they have a reflective appraisal of what has happened rather than thinking that what we think matters. So, Kay, thank you so much for the email. I am hopeful that that was helpful to you and everyone else because that's a struggle for every single parent.

If you all wanna reach out, I would love to hear from you. Send me a question, send me a comment, send me something you wanna cover on an episode. Say hello, all and any of the above. I welcome brenna@thekidcounselor.com. I love you all. Keep loving on your kids. We'll talk again soon. Bye. Thank you for listening to the Play Therapy Parenting Podcast with Dr. Brenna Hicks. For more episodes and just subscribe to our newsletter, please go to www.playtherapyparenting.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S4E21 - Why Is My Child Suddenly Afraid of Everything?

    Nov 13, 202615 minAudio

    In this episode, I answer a question from a mom whose 10-year-old son has recently developed an overwhelming fear of being alone, including feeling as though a shadow is following him. I explain why new fears can emerge...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S4E20 - The Dethroned Oldest: Helping Your Anxious, Rigid Oldest Child Feel Secure (A "Tattling" Follow-up Question)

    Nov 5, 202613 minAudio

    This week I'm answering a question from Doby, a mom of four boys, as a follow-up to our recent episode on tattling. She wants to know how to handle tattling when her kids are different ages: should consequences be the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S4E19 - Is My Child Misbehaving—or Just Trying to Be Heard?

    Oct 29, 202612 minAudio

    In this episode, I share an experience from a recent flight that reminded me how easy it is for parents to focus on a child's behavior while missing what the child is actually trying to communicate. I watched a young...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S4E17 - How Do I Stop My Kids From Tattling on Each Other?

    Oct 8, 202612 minAudio

    In this episode, I answer a question from a mom whose 3- and 5-year-old children are constantly tattling on each other over every little thing. I explain why telling young children to "work it out" usually doesn't work...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S4E16 - Is My Child's School Anxiety a Sign We Should Homeschool?

    Oct 2, 202616 minAudio

    In this episode, I answer a question from a mom whose 7- and 9-year-old daughters are experiencing significant anxiety around going to school. We talk about the difference between choosing homeschooling because it...

    Credit the people on this episode