Read transcript Welcome to another gloriously chaotic episode of Play Comics, where today’s adventure features everyone’s favorite lasagna-loving, Monday-hating tabby cat stumbling through the digital wasteland of Garfield: The Search for Pooky on the Game Boy Advance. Because apparently, losing a teddy bear is serious enough business to warrant an entire platforming odyssey filled with death pits, questionable physics, and mice that probably deserve their own organized crime documentary. Joining us for this tale of feline desperation and handheld gaming horrors is the phenomenally creative Ryan Estrada - artist, author, and genuine adventurer who has somehow managed to create official comics for everyone from Star Trek to Popeye to (yes, indeed) Garfield himself. When he’s not crafting award-nominated graphic novels like Banned Book Club or wandering through actual adventures that sound like they belong in their own comic series, Ryan brings the perfect blend of insider knowledge and artistic sensibility to help us navigate this particular slice of orange cat chaos. So grab your favorite plush companion (and maybe hide it somewhere safe), prepare for some seriously questionable level design choices, and settle in for an episode that explores what happens when beloved comic strip characters get translated into the unforgiving world of Game Boy Advance platforming. Will our heroes survive Garfield’s glacially-paced walking speed? Can anyone explain why this cat can leap tall buildings but still can’t find a simple teddy bear? And most importantly, does this game capture the essence of Jim Davis’s creation, or does it just make us want to curl up for a very long nap? Learn such things as: Is there anything more important than lasagna and naps? Do you ever need to grow out of your favorite stuffed friend? How do you manage when your worst enemy is your own laziness? And does that make Garfield much deeper than we ever gave it credit for? And so much more! You can find everything you could ever want to know about Ryan on RyanEstrada.com. Let’s see if anyone can pick out my favorite part. I’ll give you a hint, it’s on the home page. If you want to be a guest on the show please check out the Be a A Guest on the Show page and let me know what you’re interested in. If you want to help support the show check out the Play Comics Patreon page or head over to the Support page if you want to go another route. You can also check out the Play Comics Merch Store. Play Comics is part of the Gonna Geek Network, which is a wonderful collection of geeky podcasts. Be sure to check out the other shows on Gonna Geek if you need more of a nerd fix. You can find Play Comics @playcomics.bsky.social on Bluesky, @playcomicscaston Twitter and in the Play Comics Podcast Fan Groupon Facebook. A big thanks to The Last Comic Shop and Life, Death, & Taxonomy for the promos today. Intro/Outro Music by Backing Track, who was going to tell me something about what I’ve been saying here at the end of the show notes. And then realized that it just wasn’t worth the effort. Support Play Comics by contributing to their tip jar: https://tips.pinecast.com/jar/playcomics Check out our podcast host, Pinecast. Start your own podcast for free with no credit card required. If you decide to upgrade, use coupon code r-89f00a for 40% off for 4 months, and support Play Comics.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
I'm Josh Liston from On the Bubble. Podcast, an oral history of television fandom, part of the gunageek Network. Just like the show you're checking out now, shows on the network are individually owned and opinions expressed may not reflect others. Find other awesome geeky shows@gunageeknetwork.com. Sam.
And welcome to Play Comics, where once again, we're here looking at a video game based on a comic property and how well it represents that source material. And today, we are recording on the best day of the week, which is every day that isn't Monday, because we're here looking at Garfield, the search for Pookie. And today I have somebody that I'm really excited to have on the show. It is Ryan Estrada. Ryan, how are you today? Hello. Hello. Coming in from South Korea, where it is Monday, so. Oh, I forgot that's how you're doing.
A lot better than me. Yeah. So you're in the good zone, man. I'm here hating the world. It's Monday. Is Monday as bad in South Korea as it is over here? I think it's. I think the Monday thing is bad for anyone that has a day job, which doesn't reply to me because I'm a cartoonist and make my own schedule. And also doesn't apply to Garfield because he's a fricking cat. So who knows? So what was it that got you to be a big Garfield fan in the first place? Well, I was obsessed with Garfield. Like, came out in 78. I was born in 80, and I was into it right away. I grew up in Michigan. I got the Oakland Press, and Garfield was the first comic on the page, weeklies and Sundays. So I was obsessed. And as a young kid, I had the Garfield collection that I barely had room for a bed in my bedroom because I just had walls and walls of Garfield dolls, and I had a bookshelf with every single book ever published. And as I decided I was going to become a cartoonist, that happened very early on. I started pitching comics to newspapers when I was six years old. I've been doing this long enough to go pro. And I bothered the same newspaper until they hired me at age 16. At that point, the comic that I got published was about an orange cat who's too lazy to chase mice because my only life experience was reading Garfield and I didn't know anything else. So it was a very huge influence on me early on. And then there was a period of, like, when I got into my later teens, I was, like. I had this moment where I was like, man, Garfield isn't as funny as it used to be. And I had my whole shelf. So I'm like, let me tick back a few years. Pull out a book on the shelf. I'm like, wait, this one isn't funny. Okay, let me go back a few years. Wait, this isn't funny. Until I got back to the beginning, I'm like, was Garfield never funny? So it was like that, that period of like when you become a teenager and you start to like, rebel against your parents. Like, Garfield was so much part of my life, it was like a parent. And I all of a sudden I'm like, wait a minute, I hate Garfield now. And got rid of all my stuff. And then as you do with your parents, you grow up and you're like, wait a minute, why am I rebelling against Garfield? He gave so much to me. And now I'm of course, respect Garfield again and actually got to work on official Garfield comics. So it's been part of my life for every moment I've been alive.
What was it like knowing that you got to work on the real thing and not. Definitely not Garfield? I mean, yeah, the first time I got to work on real Garfield was kind of for this really shady company that had gotten the license. And I realized very quickly they were not going to pay me and didn't even realize they were never even going to publish it. But I'm like, I know I'm getting scammed here, but if like 6 year old Ryan Estrada were to find out that I turned down the opportunity to make an official Garfield comic, he would find a way to end time travel and come hurt for me. So I hit it. And then it never ended up being published anyway. But I still got to make it. And then years later, I got to draw official Garfield comics for Boom. I did three issues of the new series that came out. So now I've not only made an official Garfield comic, but I made an official Garfield comic that actually got released and actually got paid for. So I was excited both times.
Wait, what's the point of them even doing it if they're never gonna publish it and just scam you? I think that they lost the license for Garfield because they were a shady company who didn't pay anyone. And Jim Davis took it away from them before they ever got to publishing it. I think they were intending to, but they never got around to it. Okay, that makes more sense. But the fun thing about that one was because I realized that they weren't paying me and I wasn't sure if anyone was gonna see it, I'm like, I can get as nerdy as I want. With the Boom comic, it was very specific. I had to make it approachable to all audiences. I had to relate it to the movie. I had to include certain characters and certain prompts. But with the first one I did, I was just like, I'm gonna make the nerdiest Garfield comic anyone could make. I brought back characters who had not appeared in the comic for 20 years. I brought back like, characters that were in the back of a panel on a piece of paper. I brought back props that had appeared in one strip in 1979. And just like, hey, I'm making this. I'm making this for six year old me that would, that would love this strip of all this stuff that no one else cares about. And then so I got to make the two versions where I then made the boom comic and had to try and make it approachable to new people and people that only knew the movie.
I mean, the Boom thing is cool, and that's really cool to have something officially published, but has anyone gotten to see this nice unauthorized Garfield besides people that live in your house? Yeah, I put it on my, on my website and it's, it's like a full Sunday comics page of like various strips. And I drew Garfield in the completely different style every time because I'm like tech with it, man. I can draw. I can draw this however I want. Let's make him as off model as possible. And yeah, it's all, it's all on my site. Brought Lyman back. Everybody, everybody wants to see Lyman again, you know.
And then how did Boom come and approach you to do the official movie tie in one. Yeah, so that I just got an. At first, I just got an email that said, hey, we're doing a new Garfield series. I wonder if you'd do a backup story. So backup stories are like you read a comic book and then there's the main story in the back. There's like a little short thing by another artist that's kind of like a little extra bit for you. And so I said, sure. I was very excited. I wrote that they liked it, and they said, hey, can you do another one? I said, sure. And then they said, hey, can you write another one? And I said, sure. And then I didn't know until the press release came out that I assumed this was a long ongoing series, but it turned out to be a four issue miniseries that I wrote three issues of. And a press release came out that said I was the Main writer. And I'm like, wait, I am. Wait, how did that happen? Nobody told me. I thought I was just doing a couple backup things. And so, yeah, it kind of. I didn't know that I was the main writer for the Scarfield series until it happened.
That's a nice little surprise for you. Six year old. You must have been really excited when he looked into the future and saw that. Oh yeah, oh yeah. Every moment I'm like, I gotta make that sound. I gotta write Garfield as well as I can to make young me happy. And like, you know, with the first one, my goal was like, let's get as nerdy as possible and into the minutay. But the second one was like, let's write the Garfield that I always wanted to see. Because for me as a kid, it was always like some of the early specials where it's the Christmas special, Halloween special, were really powerful and related to the comic. But then a lot of the stuff that they do in animation is just like, the dude's whole point is he doesn't want to do anything. Let him be lazy. So I tried to get as much drama as I could out of Garfield doing absolutely nothing. And like, that was. The tension of it is like one of my stories. The plot is just, Garfield wants food, but it's all the way over there and he doesn't want to get out of bed. And like, all the drama that comes out of that destroys the house of him, like trying to find different ways to get food without getting out of bed. That's. That's the real Garfield. Don't, don't send him an adventure. Get him, like, just get as much drama as you can out of him. Not wanting to do anything.
So were you writing about Garfield or were you writing about me? Well, I think we all got a little Garfield in us. But one thing I really have to know too is, especially with the game that we're looking at, how much did you watch Garfield and Friends growing up? Oh, I was very much into Garfield and Friends. Garfield growing up. Watched it every Saturday morning and watched Vacation. Yeah, I was. You know, in the Garfield comics I did, we snuck a few characters in there that I don't necessarily know that the publisher had the rights to include them, but we didn't necessarily mention them by name in the story and just kind of drew them in the way that they might have been drawn in the. In the show.
I mean, they're just barnyard animals. It's just coincidence if they happen to look like people from that part of the show. Right. Yeah. Well, we drew. Yeah. I mean, like, we were specifically. Let's see. Should I admit. Yeah, we. We drew the ants from. There was a very famous. And also my artist on the book X or Ennius is from Mexico. And apparently the ant song from Garfield and Friends was a huge, huge deal in Mexico. And so he was very excited to draw those ant characters we didn't include in US Acres films, but I did. You know, we're gonna get to the game later. But I did notice that Roy the rooster was a major character in this. And I'm like, I know how. I know what sticklers they are for which characters you do and don't have a right to use in the Garfield comic. But, like, did they have the right to use a character from a whole different comic strip, or did they just say, hey, it's just a chicken. We're not stealing a character from another comic?
That's something I didn't even think to look up while I was getting ready for this, and I really wish I would have now. And I was trying to find episodes of Garfield and Friends online in legitimate places because I'm trying to be a good little boy here. And I couldn't find any. I think they're all. Last time I checked, they're all on Tubi, I think. But of course, every time I can't find something, it's on Tubi. Tubi's like the scrap bin, like the DVD scrap bin and the back of the dollar store that, you know, it's all. Everything's just kind of there. You got to rummage through it to find it.
But at least they have a really good selection of things. Like you. I was somebody who grew up just reading Garfield. I don't know if I ever thought it was funny, but I always enjoyed reading it. So I never really had that period where I fell out of love with Garfield. I just had that period where I stopped having access to a newspaper. So I wasn't reading Garfield as much, and the comics weren't online as much as they are now, and super easily accessible because way back, I don't want to think about how many years ago when I started going to college, they. I mean, that. That just wasn't a thing that happened. And, you know, we would go steal the Sunday paper that they threw into in front of one of the school offices because nobody ever collected it. And so we'd read the Sunday comics as long as we got there first. But that was all the Garfield I had.
Yeah. There's a moment Where I had a realization that newspaper comics and the horoscope section kind of have the same purpose in the newspaper. Whereas the horoscope, its idea is to, like, describe you and your future in a way that makes you feel, like, be just generic enough that you're like, oh, that's me. Right? That's, you know, they totally got me. But it's just, you know, it can describe anyone, whereas in the comics, it's the same thing. It's not necessarily be laugh out loud funny. It's for people to have that moment of, like, yeah, that's me. I can relate to that. Like, I hate Mondays too. I don't want to get out of bed. Also makes you chuckle just enough to, like, cut it out and put it on the refrigerator or pin it into your cubicle because you relate to it. So I think that's what a lot of comic strips are going for, is that relatability more than being the funniest thing in the world.
And because we're talking about Garfield, I just have to know, what are your feelings on lasagna? Great. You know, make it with some. Some eggplant or something. But, yeah, lasagna is good stuff. My mom makes a really good one. Sometimes that's just ricotta and spinach mostly, and then other random things like that that she'll throw in. But that was surprisingly good. I mean, I think everyone of that's been born since 1978 when Garfield came out. I think only, like, lasagna is just the Garfield food. Even if you, like, no matter how much you love it, you just think of it as, like, I'm gonna eat, like, Garfield today.
Do you eat it like Garfield, or do you use a knife and fork? I use a knife and fork. I'm not gonna. I don't unhinge my jaw like a snake until my eyes are no longer visible and throw it in the air like it's disappearing into a black hole over here. It seems like no matter what, Garfield is always around somewhere. Is it like that for you over in South Korea, too? You know, I've seen Garfield stuff here. He's obviously not as huge as he is anywhere else. When I do school visits, a lot of them don't know Garfield here. Like, of the things I've worked on Garfield, I've gotten a few recognitions. Popeye people know because there was an unofficial Popeye knack here for generations that, like, all the kids know. They don't know him as a character. They just know him as a sweetened ramen. Mascot. Nobody knows Star Trek. Yeah, it's the American comics characters aren't huge here. Although there is a newspaper. There are English newspapers here that run it. But, you know, the kids aren't reading the Korea Times. They're finding their comics in other places.
Well, on that note, we're gonna go grab a newspaper and hide under it because it's Monday for one of us, and that just sucks. Well, I dropped some promos for a few other things. Hey, welcome to the Last Comic Shop Podcast. A comic book podcast that actually talks about comics? Yep. Each week we open the shop up and read and discuss a comic. Sometimes we pair that up with comic book movies or TV shows or not. Lots of times it's just comic books and sound effects. Oh, yes, definitely.
Lots of sound effects. So tune in on all the major podcasters platforms to the Last Comic Shop podcast, or check out our library of evergreen shows@www.lastcomicshoppodcast.com. here in the forests of Borneo's tropical lowlands, a clever creature spends its day swinging from tree to tree with its long, powerful arms. What are you doing? Where are the cameras? What do you mean? I. What do you mean? We're recording the promo for Play Comics to invite his listeners to check out Life, Death, and Taxonomy, the podcast that delivers 30 minutes of interesting animal info. Like how there are ants that farm fungus and fish that fuse their faces to each other. And the podcast that delivers humorous and ridiculous size comparisons. Yes, but isn't this an audio promo? Yes.
So why are we on location in Borneo? We could have been in the deluxe studio. Because we're serious method podcasters. That's why. All right, carry on. Listen to Life, Death, and Taxonomy on itunes, Google Play, and anywhere podcasts can be found. Those are some great things to check out. But first, let's finish up here. So, Ryan, what's bringing us together today, really, is this November 2005 Game Boy advance game came out a little bit earlier other places, but 2005 works for the North American release here. Made by Interactive Vision and the Game Factory. With names like that, I should have known what we were getting into. Not so much the Interactive Vision one, that one's fine. But the Game Factory in 2005, you should have known.
Yeah. As I'm watching it, looking at this game like it. It's like, if you look at any still, it's like, oh, wow, that looks like Garfield. They really cared to make it look like Garfield. And then you realize, oh, they just literally scanned images from the newspaper comics. Cut them out. Out of context and just threw them out there without, like, having anyone on staff that could draw Garfield so he can't actually move. They just kind of alter the images from the comic in Ms. Paint in ways that do not look natural and don't look like movement.
Which when you look at them as the still images, I can really appreciate that because it just looks like they took the time to get it to look right. And then when you're playing the game, you're right. It's just. It's a weird thing. And part of that can be explained because it's a game made for children. And games made for small children in this time period were not necessarily the most carefully put together things. This one, it has a really simple plot, which I think actually works really well for being a Garfield thing, because Garfield just has really simple plots. Anyway, somebody stole Pookie, and that's just not nice. And he has to go get him back.
Yeah, it's. The plot is. Is great in that. Like, especially I was so thrilled in the. In the scene where the one where it's you making Odie look for Pookie. Like Garfield getting back to that thing of Garfield doing as little as possible. The thing here is for Garfield to point at the ground and make Odie do all the work. That's great. And all the places he travels are either, like, 10ft from his house or Jon drove him there. So I love that. That's a bit of the Garfield that I know and love. And he's easily distracted and he's passionate about this quest. But also, like, there's a whole level that's just like, hey, I heard there's a bunch of food in this building. I'm gonna hang out here for a while.
This game really made me wonder about John's house and about John's job because he has at least five stoves in his kitchen. Gotta cook all that lasagna he has. I don't want to think about how many TVs. Like, it's crazy. How rich is John just over there being a cartoonist. Yeah. And not a single drawing desk, Not a single art supply. What's this dude doing? I just assumed that he locked Garfield out of that room. And that was the one place that Garfield wouldn't want to go because Jon doesn't eat in there. So there's nothing for him.
Yeah, yeah. But. Yeah, he has. But he does have very, very tall ceilings with, like, two lights on that ceiling that would make no effect because they're like, you know, six stories above where you're standing. Essentially, this game is a giant collectathon. You have to go collect the mice or collect the spots that OD is going to dig or collect something else. And I mean, it's a game for kids. It gives you passwords. It doesn't save. It is what it is. But if I can get, like, really dorky for like 45 seconds, like, the. Just. I was talking about the way they animate it. But, like, like I said, it looked like they had one drawing of Garfield standing and then they used Ms. Paint to make it move. So, like, when he jumps, he doesn't actually jump. He just floats in the air in the exact same position. And like, they moved one leg forward with Ms. Paint. And then like, they also. When they selected things, there's an aliasing issue where when you shrink something down to that size, it doesn't just make a black line. There's little gray around it so it matches the background. But then they pop that on top of a black background and there's just white pixels all around it for no reason. And then they also, in some scenes when Garfield's in a room, they clearly took them from another place and popped them on there, but they just. They didn't get the whole line. So, like, randomly, like, the line's all jagged, like, parts of it are missing and like parts of his body don't have a black line around them. And it just looks so lazily put together and then, like, in them, like, altering it to move. Like when he opens his mouth to eat things, his mouth doesn't just open. His head actually just moves like 10 pixels up and his jaw is just like a straight black line where, like, that's not how Jaws work. You don't. Your jaw doesn't stay the same and your head float. Float up to make a black hole. It's just. It just. It just looks like they may gave. Someone doesn't know how to draw, like 35 seconds in Ms. Paint to turn one drawing into an animated sequence.
I guarantee you at least 75% of the people listening to this just started moving their mouth so they could see how their jaw moves. I found myself going through here wishing that they would have more of the Garfield characters in and then realizing that as you go through the strips, Garfield doesn't really have a lot of characters in at a time. Like, there are a lot of characters that exist, but he has his one or two or three in at a time. And Odie already takes up a slot and Jon already takes up a slot. So it's not like there's room for a bunch of other ones.
Yeah, that comic I mentioned that I worked on was bringing back all those characters because there used to be a lot of characters, and they just stopped appearing. They don't matter anymore because Jim Davis introduces and disappears so many characters. I realized there's eight different characters named Frank that have been pretty large parts of the strip at some point and then disappeared. One's a flea, one's a neighbor, one's an old college friend. So, yeah, there's a lot of characters there. But I did. One of my favorite things is when they started having the humans that walk behind things, because in games, there's a difficulty. You can't make anything too big. It all has to be a certain size. But to just put someone behind something and have them walking, it looks like there's a full person there, but it's still the same size as the Garfield model. Those things actually looked like Jim Davis drawings. And every single drawing that is clearly a Jim Davis or not. You know, Jim Davis's assistant drawing, because he doesn't actually draw it. You're like, oh, I remember that strip. I know what strip that's from. But those characters, I wasn't sure where they came from. They very much look like his drawings. But it is weird, though, looking at the difference between the things that are obviously taken from Garfield drawings and the things that aren't. Like, the wasps all over are clearly just assets they had that, like, do not look like a Garfield drawing at all. And then you'll have, like, a dude, a hairy man behind a fence that's, like. That looks straight out of, you know, an episode of Garfield and Friends.
One thing that really confused the mess out of me was, why is Garfield getting hurt by butterflies? They're butterflies. Yep. I realize we're a selection of enemies here. Yeah. And, like, I realized part of the point of that level was to get rid of the things that are distracting Odie and. Okay, Odie getting distracted by a butterfly. That makes perfect sense. But. And I realized part of it, too, is you just have to make a game that functions like a game. So there's gonna be some stuff in there that just gets weird. But you already had the wasps just use them again.
I was very excited every time I saw a character that looked like a Jim Davis drawing there. Was that the. I think he was supposed to have an eye patch, but since it was so low pixels, it just, like, looked like he had a giant hole in his head. That cat. I don't think was from anything. And it looks like they were trying to make a Garfield style drawing, but some of it just did, you know, it looked like this weird mashup of one style tacked onto another. Yeah, I was trying to figure out who that was. And the best I could come up with was was somebody got a few different cartoon cats just mixed together in their brain. And I mean, it fits perfectly well. Just don't have a Garfield name to go with it.
Yeah, yeah. And then. But the. I was very excited to see Mrs. Arbuckle. John's mom again. Hasn't appeared in the comic in a long, long time, but people know her from the specials. And then as soon as the level started, I'm like, why is she smaller than Garfiel's? Why is this woman an elf? What is going on? She's like two pixels taller than him, but she's like, so skinny that it's like he could eat her whole. Like, it's just she's so tiny. That doesn't make sense because this is.
The Halloween strip of comics and Garfield is imagining that he is bigger than everybody else. And next he is going to go take on Godzilla. Yeah, it's. Yeah, that. That was so uncomfortable. And also, like, she didn't move at all. And they just had like these two pixels of her. Two images of her legs moving. And it was like the creepiest little. It looked like a Halloween, like, puppet come to life going after him. Which is weird because if you'd done that on the nes. Makes perfect sense. If you had done it on the Super Nintendo. Okay, maybe. I mean, it would be bad, but you could understand it. But this is the Game Boy Advance. People had figured out what they were doing. Plus, the Game Boy advance is basically just a handheld Super Nintendo anyway, so they extra knew what they were doing.
And the other weird thing about that was when they. Like I said, there's that balance of things that look like they're from the comic and things that don't. Is. It was especially weird when there were things that, like we said, Garfield's a very simple comic. There's very few characters. There's very few things in it. When you see a thing that we very much know how Jim Davis draws them, like a spider. Like, and they even showed how he draws a spider in the introduction scene. And then they have like, just generic video game spiders. And it's like, that's not how spiders look. He draws one spider over and over again. And then like the paw prints that are all over and even like the health bar is a paw print. It's like, not only is. Does he have a very certain way he draws paw prints. It's the. It's so iconic to his comic that it's the logo of his company.
I really tried not to harp on things that are purely gameplay, but the way that they only use the toe beans as your health bar there and not the entire paw really messed with me because I kept looking at that. Oh, I have the whole palm left. I'm fine. And then I get hit by one thing and I die. Yep. It's a weird thing that, like, it really seems like someone cared a little bit about the story. Like, the story does feel true to Garfield and they really tried to get like. Again, it's fascinating, like, seeing all of the images they chose and being like, I remember that comic and things. But like, there are so many things that they just did not care at all about.
But overall, I do have to spoil this game for anybody who hasn't played it number one, because I doubt anybody's gonna really wanna play this one. It's just kind of super tedious. But also, I think everybody needs to know that at the end, Garfield does find Pookie. Everything is okay. Yeah, it's very sweet. He reunites. But the funny thing about the ending is that it's this huge anti climax because you introduce these, like three mysterious characters in the dark that are mice, but you can immediately picture them because you know how Jim Davis draws mice. He only knows how to draw one mouse. They all look the same. And then in the first level, you're collecting mice and you collect three mice. And it's like, oh, these are the three mice that we just saw in the opening scene. But it's like, no, we're not those three mice. The. This was someone else that did this. The whole game is going to be revealing who that was. And then you do a whole game and it's three mice that look just like the mice that were in the first level. Because there's only one way to draw a mouse in the Garfield world, except he's got a little hat and a.
Gun, which I don't remember Garfield ever having guns. Unless it's a water gun or something obviously fake like that. So that's a little weird. This is a gun that, like has a lightsaber stick out of it for a second. But we can't make it too realistic. That would just be crazy. Yeah. And it's. And it's like this. It's supposed to be this Huge climax. And it's just a mouse the size of a mouse. It's very small. And yeah, does have a gun. Mouse with a gun. But, you know, could have given us something there, something dramatic instead of, oh, here's the same thing you saw at the beginning, but with a hat and a gun.
Overall, as we're looking at this one, what do you think are the highlights for what this gets right? Looking at Garfield. Yeah, I, as I mentioned, I really love how they focus on Garfield being as simple as possible and not wanting to go on a big adventure and only doing it because he cares and still being distracted and lazy. I loved the Roy the Rooster cameo. That's, that's someone even if they didn't have, if they didn't have permission, I love it even more because that's someone being like, I'm gonna sneak that in because I care enough. I love the, whenever there was a character that looked like a Jim Davis drawing, I love those human characters walking in the background. Yeah. And I loved seeing, like, I loved seeing John's mom. I loved seeing Liz. Even though it was weird that Liz is a major character, but she's just, there's 40 of her walking down the street at the same time, same time. And four of them are visible at the same time. Like, at least make three characters so that she's not in the same on the screen all at once at the same time. But yeah, I mean, I, I did, I did think it felt like Garfield just, it felt like that tacked onto an unrelated video game.
Sometimes in a weird, meta, contextual kind of way, the tediousness of the game might maybe kind of also feel like Garfield. Because looking at a newspaper strip, you have to make it so that anybody can just jump in and know what's going on. Especially when you have a strip that, okay, maybe it's starting so, like, you can't even go get yesterday's paper and catch up on it there. So from that aspect, that's me looking way too deep into it. I also love that Garfield treated Odie like crap because even though I like Odie and I don't think he deserves that, I think it's funny when Garfield will put out the kind of effort required to treat Odie like crap like that and just use him and that they didn't shy away from Garfield being a little bit of a butt face with that.
Yeah, I, I, There are so many things that, you know, felt, felt like the Garfield that I want. And then when you see things like the fact that the Only word that's repeated at the end of every level. Congratulations. They didn't bother to spell right. That appears every single time you finish a letter. It says congratulations with two T's and all these little typos. Every time you get that the password, they spell congratulations wrong. And then there's a scene that really drove me nuts that. Okay, there's a joke that I. That I loved when Garfield's finally where he needs to be and. And he's like, ready to go save Pookie, and all of a sudden he's like 200ft away. That's a great Garfield joke in that it's been building up to this. But he's worried that he has to walk 200ft, except he's standing next to a sign that says 200 meters. And it's like you can't put. You have the same unit of measurement twice on the screen. You can't make sure they both have the same unit of measurement.
The joys of just straight up translating things. And I'm sure that we're not going to get any more of that with people dumping work onto AI at all. What do you think this one really gets wrong in the biggest ways? Looking at Garfield. Yeah. I think it's just the style of all those things that don't match. Like when he's jumping on platforms and things. It doesn't feel like Garfield when you're trying to make that look like someone's house. I feel like there. You know, it really could have. You know, I know that's the structure of a platformer. You need a lot of platforms. You need, you know, you need to look a certain way, but it just. It really clashed. When you have an image from a comic about what this room looks like, and then you cut to the gameplay where it looks nothing like that, and it just looks like they got assets from another game. And. Yeah, and just the. All the movements are so awkward. Like I said, opening the mouth. But just his attack, that scratch thing where they just. His body doesn't move, but there's like eight of his arms to make it look like he's scratching. I don't know what that's supposed to be. And it looks creepy. The fact that when he gets hit, he doesn't react in any way except for them playing a. A cat screeching sound, which I don't. You know, I know Garfield's a cat, but he's never made a cat sound in any medium. Yeah, it just. It just feels like there was someone that cared enough to put in things that relate to the character. But then other. Maybe other people involved were just like, I don't care. We have these assets. Let's just throw them in there.
The biggest thing for me is the big characters that didn't show up anywhere. You're like, where's Nirmal? How do you make a Garfield thing without Nermal at all? Yeah, we briefly got Arlene in there. That's rare. Arlene is often not in the adaptations because I guess Jim Davis is very particular about how she's portrayed. He has a weird obsession with making sure Arlene is perfectly portrayed, even though he'll do, like, a thing where Garfield's a superhero now, but, like, Arlene has to be exactly perfect. So I was surprised to see her in there, but. Yeah, no, no, normal. I mean, you got four characters that you use, so it's weird not have one of them.
Yeah, I mean, most of the problems to me are just really coming down to you had to make this a game somehow. So it's really hard to blame them for that. But if you had somebody who somehow didn't really know about Garfield, would you give them this game as part of a primer course to get them introduced to Garfield? I don't hate anybody that much. I wouldn't want to torture them. That's the main thing for me. Like, even if I wanted to show it to them for the art style, that would be, like, the only thing, because. Let me go to the end of the level to get a mouse so I can come all the way back so I can go to the. Almost the end of the level. Like, if I wanted to see Garfield do shuttle runs, I would play Snoopy sports.
Yeah, yeah, it's. It's. You know, if I wanted to show them the art style, I'd just, like, grab a random book off the shelf because, like, I think, you know, every single one of those drawings that looks like Garfield is from one of those books. So just see the real thing. And finally, you know, we really need to fix the ending of the game, because you're right. The mouse being the main bad guy is just that. I don't like that. We're going to get rid of that. It never happened. Instead, the final boss is a Muppet, which Muppet is going to be the ultimate kidnapper of Pookie.
Well, for me, if you want to make a dramatic ending, you're going to need a big Muppet. So I'd go with, like, Sweetums or something. But for me, the ideal ending of this would be, if he fought a large enemy, realize that the enemy didn't actually have Pookie and that Pookie was like three feet away from his bed, that he didn't bother, you know, he didn't walk that far to notice. He just left him there. Make it all about Garfield's laziness. All he had to do was turn around and Pookie was there the whole time. Yeah, but you know, he's like, okay, I'm gonna do his little, I gotta find Pookie, but I gotta walk all the way over there. I'm not gonna walk like two feet this way to double check if I'm gonna have to do all the walking. So, yeah, I say Pookie was there the whole time. And it's his own laziness that caused the whole adventure.
Mind blown. My goal for Garfield is always everything comes down to like, he didn't want to do something and that's why all his problems happened. I mean, it's a really good status quo to have because I know plenty of people like that and they don't change. And so neither should Garfield. Yeah, Garfield. Garfield should never change. Garfield should never. Like, when he leaves, you know, like, every adaptation is always like, well, this is the time he finally has to get up and get out and the real world and get into trouble. And it's like, yeah, you make him do that every time, though. Let's get something where he does nothing. Figure out, that's your creative challenge. How do you make it exciting and engaging while still having him do as little as possible?
Well, Ryan, it has been great talking to you about all of this. If people want to hear more from you, where else can they find you around the Internet? Go to Ryan Estrada.com, you'll find thousands of pages of free comics, including Garfield's Forgotten Friends, which is the sneaky comic I did that brought back everybody information about the later Garfield comics I did for Boom. And my graphic novels, like Banned Book Club, no rules tonight, Good old fashioned Korean spirit culted Student Ambassador series. There's all kinds of stuff you can find there. And all my social media and stuff is linked there as well. Ryan estrada.com.
And as always, we'll have links to all that down in the show notes. Because clicking links is so much easier than trying to remember how to spell things. Even when it's something pretty straightforward like Ryan Estrada, I will find a way to type it wrong. Well, it's been a pleasure talking Garfield with you. Yeah, this was not a great game. But it was fun to talk about. Well, maybe we can have you on for something better later. I'd love it. We could almost just reach down into a hat and pull something out and guarantee that it's better.
Probably. Although like I said, there were things I loved. I just, it just. I just wish they, they followed through so I could keep loving them. As always, if you want to hear more from me, the best place to do that is over on playcomics.com, where there's links to all the social media things I don't even know anymore. Social media is being weird. I'm exploring some new ones which might be some old ones we will see. But if you see me, it's usually a name related to Play Comics. And by usually I mean always. If you want to be on the show, then there's a link down in the show notes where you can find the list of things I'm looking to get booked the soonest. And there's also probably some games that I've missed. So if you look through the backlog and notice, hey, here's a game that you know, at least as of when I'm recording this came out before 2005 and I haven't done an episode on it and it's not on the list of things I'm looking to get booked. There's a chance I probably missed it. So, you know, maybe let me know about that and we can try to get that fixed. And if you want to be on that episode, then there's a pretty good chance that that can happen. If you want to help support the show, then you can be like oh no lit class or Dan McMahon and give the show money because unfortunately it does cost money to run a podcast. But you can also just share it with friends, share it with enemies, share it with family, all that fun stuff and just, you know, help me make sure that people know about the show and how much fun it is and everything. That's always what I hear people say about that show. They they like it, they think it's fun and they want to come back on. Don't forget the Play Comics is a part of the Gunageek.com network, home to such wonderful shows as Legends of Shield where we're looking at all of the Marvel things, or at least most of the Marvel things, because I can't convince anybody, including myself, that we should cover Spidey and his amazing friends. I'm sorry, I like kids shows. I can't sit there and analyze a show for three year olds even if there is ghost spider and that is the only good ghost spider representation I have found because I haven't watched the short things and you know a short little thing doesn't count. Also yes I know across the spider verse but that's a movie and I'm only worrying about TV right now. Carrington, I swear if you don't come yell at me about sugar spite and everything is fine then one of our other listeners will because that needs to get out and really all I need to do is say hey edit, go and it'll handle itself because Carrington and I are professionals. If you like the music that I'm rudely talking on top of right now, head on over to BackingTrack GG and check out all the great music over there. Maybe find something for your own project. But most of all just grab a game, grab a stack of comics and go find yourself a new favorite character.
Read transcript Tony Stark looked at a cave, a box of scraps, and the worst week of his life, and decided the answer was a flying metal suit. It’s the most confident home improvement project in history. He also holds...
Read transcript Today’s forecast for Manhattan: scattered goo, strong winds of questionable decision-making, and a one hundred percent chance that Spider-Man’s week gets worse. Spider-Man: Web of Shadows is what happens...
Read transcript I get it, movie tie ins are hard. You’ve got a development timeline dictated by by an unobservable force. Expectations that are already lower than a kid who gets all of their candy stolen before they get...
Read transcript Bruce Banner has the worst anger management plan in recorded history. Step one: don’t get angry. There is no step two, because the world is full of slow Wi-Fi, hold music, and a military that answers...
Read transcript Congratulations! You’ve been hired by the Justice League. Your title is “Hero,” your qualifications are “showed up,” and your first assignment is standing in Metropolis next to Superman while a stranger...