Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Play Comics

Play Comics artwork

TMNT Mutant Melee with Tommy Proffitt (Distant Echoes, Lee Carvallo’s Podding Challenge)

Nov 16, 202547 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Read transcript Dust off your cowabunga collection and prepare your fists for some serious turtle-powered mayhem, because this week on Play Comics we’re diving shell-first into TMNT: Mutant Melee, the 2005 arena-based fighting bonanza that took the 2003 animated series and asked the most important question: what if we just got all the turtles, their friends, AND their enemies into one room and let them beat the absolute snot out of each other? Developed by Konami for PS2, Xbox, GameCube, and PC, this isn’t your typical one-on-one fighter - it’s more like if Smash Bros and Power Stone had a shell-covered baby and that baby knew all of Splinter’s teachings. Joining us for this body-slamming brawl is the incomparable Tommy Proffitt from Distant Echoes and Lee Carvallo’s Podding Challenge, a podcast wizard who understands the intricate art of dissecting character-based chaos and canon coherence like few others can. Plus being able to bring his signature blend of gaming nostalgia and comedic precision to help us determine if this colorful chaos simulator managed to capture the spirit of its source material or if it swung its nunchucks at empty air. Together, we’ll navigate the treacherous waters of Last Man Standing mode, contemplate why anyone thought having 22 playable characters was a good idea, and investigate whether the game’s holiday-themed cosmetics (seriously - set the date to December 25th and watch the turtles rock Santa hats) are feature or bug. Learn such things as: What does it say about a game when its best feature might legitimately be the ability to unlock the original arcade game inside it? What’s the difference between a party fighter and a fighting game that doesn’t know what it wants to be? Can the 2003 cartoon’s tone can survive being translated into “everyone fights everyone all the time? And so much more! You can find Tommy on Bluesky @awkwardcomma, and his podcasts Distant Echoes and Lee Carvallo’s Podding Challenge. If you want to be a guest on the show please check out the Be a A Guest on the Show page and let me know what you’re interested in. If you want to help support the show check out the Play Comics Patreon page or head over to the Support page if you want to go another route. You can also check out the Play Comics Merch Store. Play Comics is part of the Gonna Geek Network, which is a wonderful collection of geeky podcasts. Be sure to check out the other shows on Gonna Geek if you need more of a nerd fix. You can find Play Comics @playcomics.bsky.social on Bluesky. A big thanks to Byrds Eye View Comics and There Are Houses In The Woods (brought to you by Blue Frog Den Comics) for the promos today. Intro/Outro Music by Backing Track, who’s favorite turtle is Franklin. Support Play Comics by contributing to their tip jar: https://tips.pinecast.com/jar/playcomics Check out our podcast host, Pinecast. Start your own podcast for free with no credit card required. If you decide to upgrade, use coupon code r-89f00a for 40% off for 4 months, and support Play Comics.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

I'm Anthony Bachmann from All Things Good and Nerdy, a geeky podcast part of the Gun and Geek Network. Just like the show you're checking out now, shows on the network are individually owned and opinions expressed may not reflect others. Find other fantastic geeky shows at gunnageeknetwork.

And welcome to Play Comics, where once again, we are here looking at a video game based on a comic property and how well it represents that source material. And today we're looking at some teens with attitude and some other people too, but not the teens you're probably thinking of. We're looking at the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. And I've got Tommy Profit here to help me take a look at that. Tommy, how are you today? I am doing fantastic. I'm really excited to talk about Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles with you and this game that has a lot to talk about. We'll just say that that is definitely a way to put it. Yes. So what was it that just jumped out at you about Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles being on this list?

Yeah, so it's really funny. So, like anyone our age, we grew up in a world where Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles just existed and are everywhere. Right. And you know, I was born late 80s, so I was like right at the right age for Ninja Turtles to be a thing. I was super obsessed with them, the live action movies when I was younger. But I wasn't like super into, you know, a lot of the animated cartoons or even the comics. It wasn't actually until recently that I really, really got extremely heavy into turtles media. And over the past, like, year and a half, I would say I have any given week, if you asked me what I was reading or what I was watching, it's something Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles related. And I don't know why what just clicked. But I've just been. I just got super into the most recent idw. I got super into checking out because of this game, the 2003 series, which kind of missed me when I was younger. And yeah, I've just become a pretty huge fan late in life, even though, like, I think, like I said, we've all kind of grown up with the Turtles and it's kind of hard to have not appreciated them or at least consumed some turtle media when we were younger.

Yeah, Turtles for us is. It's like Superman and Batman. It's just somebody that's there. And even if you've never watched it, if you've never read it, you still know it's four turtles named after Renaissance era painters and artists and, you know, Splinter and Shredder and you might not know all the fine details about everything, but there's a cartoon for your era. There's the chance that you probably stuck around watching the cartoons longer than you'd care to admit. And, I mean, some of us just didn't care. So, you know. Yeah, I didn't watch this one because I was too busy with track and cross country practice in high school when it was coming out.

Yeah, I don't. I mean, I really don't know why I didn't watch this one. I mean, I think probably the same thing I was. It was high school era, so I wasn't like, just sitting down to watch cartoons all the time, but I was still checking out cartoons even. Even during that time. But for some reason, this one just missed me. I have to say, I think. I think I got. I'm going to be honest, I think it was the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles repeated in between clips. And so whenever it would come on tv, it would kind of annoy the heck out of me. And I think that might have been what was like, a big turn off for me. But I. I'm not gonna lie, I have. I've binged through. I haven't finished the entire series, but I got up through, I think, season five, and it's honestly, like, it's really good. Like, I actually really like this series. I don't know if you've had a chance to check out, like, the full. The full thing, Chris, but it's. It's really fun. Like, I think it starts off kind of rocky, but once it finds its footing, it's actually really good.

I watched a little bit for the first episode in this little set of games, and I didn't watch anything new for this one for reasons that we'll get into. Okay. And I'm holding on to watching more of it for the other two games. Yeah, I. I think you'll appreciate it. The longer it goes on, the more I think. I mean, and I think this is a common refrain from people who are in the Turtles fandom is that this show, the 2003 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle show, is one of the most, or at times is the most face faithful to the Mirage comics. And so, I mean, I'm not that familiar with that comic run, but I have, like, a lot of the beats, you know, I know a lot of the storylines and stuff like that, and I do think it does a really good job of that. But it also, like, doesn't shy away from just being a little Bit more kind of adult leaning later on, even though I think it's rated, like, Y7. Like, when it's releasing, it is firmly a kid show. But there's just some stuff that happens that I'm just watching it, and I'm just like, wow, it's wild that they got away with this.

There's some crazy stuff in the early 2000s that they were getting away with with kids shows. You know, for me, everything is compared to that 86, 87 turtles series. And it's not that I'm going to go through and say, that's the best one ever made, no question. And if you're wrong, fight me. It's just that that's the one I grew up with. I mean, every Turtle show is somebody's favorite for a reason, because they're almost all worth being somebody's favorite. And the animated ones, they are all worth being somebody's favorite. Oh, yeah. But when you go in here, it's just, here's a series that knows what it's going to be, and it's going to be a little bit more adult because you're in that time frame where you had things like this. You had Avatar the Last Airbender coming out all of a sudden, having these longer storylines, more adult things going on. But it's in a kid's show. And I mean, it's done in a way that kids can handle it, but it's also pretty heavy compared to just the Saturday morning cartoons that we grew up on.

Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. And I mean, I. I also, too. I mean, I'm my. My other. My other podcast. This is not my podcast. On the podcast that I'm one of the co hosts on. It's a Star wars podcast. And we. We've talked about the Clone wars animated series, which is a little bit later, of course, than this, but it's still kind of in that early mid to late 2000s range. And even in that, there's still stuff that they try to push the envelope on a little bit. And I feel like there's a little bit of the DNA of this Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle show in that Clone wars series again, and just how they're able to get away with some of the stuff. And also some of the humor, I think is kind of present in there, too. But, yeah, honestly, at first, when I was watching through the first season, I was like, I'm just going to do this just to get through it, because I need to. To talk about this game. But then my partner kept asking me, do you have to watch the entire series for this podcast recording. And I was like, no, I just. I actually kind of want to at this point. So I just. I got hooked and I thought, I think it's really good.

And so how did. Did your partner watch it with you, or was this just kind of a. No, Tommy, you're on your own. Yeah, unfortunately, I don't. There's some things that I can kind of get them to watch with me, and we find different things to get the other to watch that is of enjoyment to one of us, but not to the other one. I don't think this was really going to be on the docket or get a cast to watch it. What's funny is they had said when I was watching it, they could recognize the kind of coming back from commercials Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles repeated over and over again because they have a younger brother who. I think it would come on all the time. I think this was on the FOX box at some point or four Kids tv. And so you would just constantly hear the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, like, playing over and over again at various different points in time. And so they were like, I know that 100%. That is burned in my brain. But, yeah, they didn't watch this one with me, Unfortunately, I've gotten my wife.

To watch this with me when I prepared for the other one. I think she was just on her phone playing around most of the time, kind of paying attention. And I think part of that must have just been because she knew I was just going to kind of be jumping around and stopping at some random point. And we're also like 800 episodes into one piece. So, I mean, that's our thing that she pays attention to. Yeah, that's. I feel like once you're that deep into one piece, going to this. This Turtle show from 2003 is kind of. It's kind of rough to say, to say the least, but kind of jumping.

Slightly into the game stuff here. Your character selection is really good for who you get to be in here. Obviously, you get to play as all the Turtles, and all the turtles are amazing because they're just turtles and they're great. But you also get to play as April and Casey. You get to fight as Shredder and Splinter, and then there's some of the monsters and the Foot Clan Ninjas and stuff. And, you know, obviously you're not going to get every single character that you want to be here in this game. Sure. But I feel like they get the big ones that definitely have to be Here.

I agree. I will say one exception in my mind that I was, when I was going over the, like, lists of all the characters that you can unlock is a huge miss, is that they don't have Karai. And I was very surprised by that, especially because Karai ends up playing a much bigger role in the show. Now, of course, this game comes out, like, I think, around, like, middle of season three. So, like, I. Karai had only just been introduced in the show, so while they're producing it, it might not even be a character that the game developers know about. But I do think that that was the one that I was. I was looking at. That was kind of a huge miss for me, especially considering you have. I think it's three different versions of Casey and April, which I'm. I'm so glad that they have April especially, and they have Casey, but it was kind of weird to have three different playable versions of them, I thought. I don't know what your. What your thoughts on that were, Chris.

I'm a big fan of just palette swaps anyway. Making a way to sneak in more characters, especially when it is actually sneaking in a different character. Obviously they're not doing that here because it's Casey and April in different clothes. Yeah. But, you know, you want to get these games in. You're having this come out on GameCube, so you have that smaller disk and the smaller amount of space that you can get everything in compared to the PS2 and the Xbox. So you kind of have to hold things back a little bit there. Or you just have gamecube with some missing characters. And neither one of those is a good choice.

Yeah. No, and that's totally fair. And I. But I agree with you. I think. I think all of the character choices that they make, I'm really glad they had traximus. That was one that I was, like, not certain if they would even get into that because it's, you know, it's. It's not one that I think if you're just like a. Someone on the periphery who knows about the Ninja Turtles is going to necessarily know. Same thing with, like, Sleek, which was a really wild pool for a character to have. And then I also love that they have just the monster from the monster movie that Mikey watches as a playable character that you can unlock. But, yeah, I mean, I think overall the character selection is. Is really well done and really good. And the characters, like, I thought personally that the characters look okay. Like, I don't think they're perfect, but I think they look Pretty good in the actual game itself, definitely for the.

Era that you're getting. You know, it's obviously based on this series, so if you don't like the way the series looks, then you're probably not going to like the way that the game looks. Right. But for making it compared to the series, it's pretty spot on with that asterisk of. Yeah, this came out in 2005. Yeah. Were there any characters that you, as a fan of, like the earlier series? Because I actually have a thought. Were there any characters that you were surprised didn't show up in this?

Honestly, I can't think of anybody right now because it's been so long. Like, yeah, I instantly am think. Did Bebop and Rocksteady even show up in this? That's one of the reasons. That's one of the ones I was thinking. I was like, it's wild to not have Bebop and Rocksteady, and I don't recall if they show up in the show. They have to show up in the show. I just. It might not be remembering if they. If they did in any of the episodes that I've watched, but that was one of the ones that I was like, this is kind of wild. And then speaking of, like, palette swaps, I was kind of expecting there to be potentially a palette swap to maybe the older kind of cartoon style or even, like, I thought it would be cool to have, like, a black and white version of the Turtles. It is very interesting that you do have some palette swaps for April and Casey and Shredder, but you don't have that for the Turtles, which I feel like is probably the one that you would most expect to have some palette swaps for. And there's opportunities to do that from the show. But also, if you're pulling from, like, the history of the Turtles, you could do that as well. Of having, like I said, like, it would be so cool if you just had, like, a black and white version of them as a callback to kind of the original comic series.

Yeah, that is something that I think would have been really good, because you could have had, you know, somebody sitting there playing with their older brother or their dad or something, and. All right, cool. I get to be the one that I grew up with. Yeah. Oh, that would have been so. That would have been so neat. But, yeah, I mean, minor. Minor nitpicks, I think, for me, in terms of the character selection. Oh, we're going to try to bury all of those minor nitpicks down in the sewers. We're going to go flush those minor nitpicks down to the sewers while I drop some promos for a few other shows. That one was much better.

I dig it. I dig it. We are Bird's Eye View Comics, an independent comic book group bringing you such genres as action, sci fi, horror and adventure. With the release of the debut series Tooth and nail in 2021, Corey Bird, owner editor in chief, ventured into the world of independent comics. He decided to expand Bird's Eye View Comics by recruiting and collaborating with other talented creators. Now, Bird's Eye View Comics has several original intellectual properties such as the Raven's Macabre, the Shadow Knight, Ugly, the Duck Warrior, and many more. As we continue to expand, we hope to entertain more fans and meet more talented creators. Collaborate, create not contenders. Find us at birdseyeviewcomics.com Facebook @bird's eye view comics, Instagram birdseyeview official and TikTok. Bird's eye view Comics Are you looking.

For the next indie comic to dive into? There Are Houses in the Woods. It's a free webtoon that's Perfect for ages 12 and up, featuring the right. Mix of spooky mystery and humor. It's written and produced by Blue Frog Den Comics follow Ren Ziggy and his spunky alien named Wim as they face supernatural threats, navigate the mysteries of the strange houses that keep appearing in the woods, and uncover the secrets within the. Town of Hollow Pines. You can read the comic free on Webtoon campus. Simply search for There Are Houses in the Woods. See you there.

Those are some great things to check out, but first let's finish up here. So, Tommy, we've already said it. We're looking at this March 20045 release came out for the GameCube, the PS2, and the Xbox. Probably Computer 2, but I don't worry about those, so I'm not worried about it here. This one was developed and published by Konami. Probably some different subsets of Konami in there on the developing, but it's still Konami, so that's as much of a distinction as I'm willing to make. So I don't have 5 billion Konami entries. Yeah, they. They do a lot of the Turtles games, huh?

Except when Ultra does it on the regular Nintendo. Oh wait, that was also Konami. Yeah, yeah, I'm trying. I'm not as familiar with all of the Ninja Turtles games, but I feel like the big ones that I know are Konami. I'm sure there's some other ones out there. But anytime you see a turtles game, it usually has the Konami moniker on. It and they seem to do it pretty well. This is a game though, that it's coming out kind of between games in the middle of the series. And it's just made to be an arena fighter, more like Smash Brothers or Power Stone than it would be like just a 1v1, like Mortal Kombat or Street Fighter. I like that touch because I really like interacting with the environments and everything. I like going and picking up items and doing that. And you know, we've already gotten a couple regular turtles fighting games. So, you know, this isn't just a rehash of something they've done. It's let's do a different kind of fighter.

Yeah, I, I think the four player kind of smash clone aspect lends itself really well to the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles because I mean that, that style of game is pretty. I mean it's, it's becoming and has become more popular at this time. And I mean, what else would you want to do but get all four turtles in the ring together, you know, with your friends and just see who the best turtle is. Like everybody picks their favorite and you just go to town. And I think, I think that they. I have some gripes with the gameplay. It's not perfect, but I think they really do a good job of how they actually set the stage for this game to make it a really fun experience.

I mean, let's just go ahead and knock the plot of the game out real quick because it's a fighting game and like most fighting games, the plot is people magically end up together and they fight. Yep. Perfect. Yeah. I mean there is the, the. Is it adventure mode, right? Yeah, that's what they call it here. Yeah, they have that and it's like. I mean that's, that's what I played most of, I'll be honest, because I played it on Emulator and so there wasn't. I didn't get a ton of like the four player action with this, which I was kind of bummed out about. But it's. The story in that is like it's. I mean, it's basically just the same fights over and over and over again until you get to the end of the story and unlock a bunch of tokens and stuff.

But also it's a fighting game and you don't really need a good plot. I just, I want them to have some kind of hand. Wavy. Here's a reason. And I don't care if the reason is really stupid. I mean, they really didn't even have to do the adventure mode, right? Like you could literally just have it be, you know, Smash Brothers and just. Well, I guess Smash has story at some point, but you know, whatever. But like you could still just have it just be all of the characters and as you play, you unlock them and you don't even have to interact with any kind of plot details, right? Because like you said, it's a fighter, it's meant to be. You sit on your couch with four other people and you just, again, you just pick your favorite turtle and see which one comes out on top.

Normally we try not to jump too much into super gameplay specific things, but this one I feel like really deserves it because there are no teams in here. At least not built into the actual structure of the game. I mean, obviously you can sit there and be like, okay, it's me and Bob against you two, but the game isn't going to control that. So I can still hurt Bob and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, they are a team. I want to have team things in here. Let me do team things in my team based game.

It's, it's so bizarre that they don't, they don't do that. And I'm not a game developer, so I don't know how easy it is to put something like that in. But I feel like there's other games that pull it off. So I feel like they could have pulled it off and. Yeah, and when you, when you're in the adventure mode and you have like your teammates or there's other team members around, you'll just have them kind of like standing on the side and you can still actually interact with them. So yeah, it's a little bizarre that they don't actually, they don't have that. Right. Like it's, I don't understand why they left that out.

I've just kind of head canned it into they're all fighting with each other and they all want to be the person who wins. Yeah, I bear, I think that, listen, again, it's a fighting game. Doesn't, doesn't really need a, a specific reason, you know, So I, I think I like that. That's, that's totally fine. And they do kind of make up for that with the different game modes that they have on there. You know, having their king of the hill spot where you just try to protect your area or your hold on to the item as long as you can kind of stuff. I mean, I like that, I like that it's not Just who's there at the end. It's actually who had it the most kind of stuff. So you don't get those cheap losses where somebody just snipes you in the final seconds.

Yeah, I, I, I do think that, I mean, listen, those are, those are fine. I think there's probably more they could do in terms of like gameplay modes. I can't think of any off the top of my head, but yeah, I think it's really. The King of the hill is great and then the keep away item one is good too. But there, there really weren't any others outside of that. Right. Other than just your standard 4v4 or 2v2 or 2v3 or whatever. Right, yeah. Because everything else was either the adventure mode or just melee mode, which is just adventure mode without the story plopped onto it.

Yeah, yeah, it's, it's a little unfortunate that there's not more that you can do with this one, but like you said, this is coming out in between games, so I have to wonder if they just left some stuff out in favor of putting it in one of the other games, because I think is Battle Nexus is one of the next ones that comes after this or is that before whatever it is. I mean, I'm sure they're trying to like keep things in different buckets so that you have a reason to buy the next game. Yeah. And this was a $20 game on release, so they're not throwing a bunch of budget at this one or a bunch of their time on it. You know, it's just, it is what it is.

Yeah. That's wild. I didn't know that it was $20 when it came out. That's, that kind of, I think, tells me a little bit more about some of the choices that happen with this game. Also. I just looked real quick. Battle Nexus was like six months or so before this one. Gotcha. Yeah. So, I mean, they're, they're just trying to, I think, again, like spread out what you can do in each of these games. I mean, that's not unheard of, right, with when you're making, you know, a bunch of games coming out at the same time with a specific IP you're going to, and I'm sure this was like another one that was kind of like maybe not rushed through development, but I'm sure they, they didn't have like a ton of time. Right. Like with this, this development timeline. And so they probably focus on what they could focus on adding like the, the amount of characters that they have, the Actual, like, adventure mode, some of the unlockables, which. Which I'm sure we'll talk about. And then they kind of left some of the. The additional battle stuff for some of the other games.

I'm glad you brought up the unlockables, because those are really, really cool. I am shocked at, like, some of, like, the unlockables that you get in this game. Like, they're. They're so rad. Like, I love everything that you can. You can actually. You can actually unlock, and it's stuff that I would never expect to have as an unlockable in a game. You get comic panels from older comics, biographies of the characters, like, toy pictures, which I think is the thing that blows my mind the most, because everything else is like, okay, you have these assets. You just get a scan of it real quick, and you're done. Like, I don't understand why they would take the time to go get the toys in their packaging here in a game.

It's. It's wild and, like, it's funny because I think it probably looked better on the actual hardware, but when you go back and you play it on an emulator, it's a little rough around the edges. But all that said, like, it's still really cool that you get that. And they give you a little bit of history, especially for, like, the comic panels and stuff like that and the. The Playmate toys. It's like, it's. It's. It's something that, like, you. They didn't have to do, but it's a really nice extra. And the way that you unlock it is through tokens, which I think you can get. I don't know if you can get them in multiplayer, but I know you can get them in the adventure mode. And so it's a little bit of an incentive to, like, kind of grind out and grind through playing through the adventure mode to be able to unlock everything. And, I mean, like, I counted. There are 12 pages for the history of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles that you can go through. And when I say pages, it's like screens, right, that you have to go through, and it's. You're just reading the history of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Probably could have found a better way to do that, but still, like, there's a lot of effort put into that, right, to give you that much detail in the history that you can. You can have in the library, which is just really, really cool.

All of these unlockables are just. They had no business being as good as they were. Like, outtakes, you know. Oh, my God. I always think that outtakes are silly in animated things because somebody made it on purpose. So I don't. Is that really an outtake? I don't know, but they're just so silly with everything. I don't care. Yeah. In the fact that they have. I mean, one of the things that's really impressive about this game is they have the voice cast from the show. And I don't know if they just scraped, you know, voice lines from the show or if they rerecorded new lines, but they have the voice cast doing the actual voices. And. Yeah, for the outtakes to, like, they are doing a lot of voices. And I think there's even like, some folks who probably who are like, developers or something, because there's some with, like, the foot where they have some of the outtakes are them with, like, a British accent and stuff like that, which is like. I mean, it's just. It's goofy. It's silly. But, like, honestly, I think the outtakes are the best part of this game, in my opinion. Just because, like, it's just fun. It's just fun, silly stuff that, again, they didn't have to put this in, but the fact that they did, I think. And also, it kind of doesn't really connect to the show necessarily, other than it's the characters. But, you know, you having the voice, the voice actors, it really connects back to the show. And honestly, like, as a product that's intended to keep people interested in the TV show, I think that is something that does a really good job of.

That just being able to go through here, play as characters we haven't normally been able to play as. I think that is one of the biggest draws for me, you know, Splinter is I really like Splinter, you know, because who doesn't like Splinter? He's right up there with Iroh. But when you actually get to play as Splinter, it's just so, so much fun to say, okay, yeah, I'm going to be the old man rat and just whale on everybody. Oh, yeah, yeah. And I mean, similarly unlocking Shredder, right? Like, when you. When you're able to play a Shredder, it's. I mean, it's like a. It's like a power fantasy, right? Like, it's like, I shouldn't be able to do this. This is. This is the Shredder I shouldn't be able to play as him. But. And then to get. To get Gold Shredder, too, like, having two different versions of Gold Shredder and a Roku Saki as a third shredder that you can play as like ah. It's just, I know that this game, I think because of the gameplay mechanics as a fighting game gets a little bit of like a bad rap. I didn't, I tried to not look up reviews when I was like first initially playing through it and then when I kind of finished playing it, I like went and looked to see what the reaction was and I was kind of a little bit surprised to see that reviews at the time were like pretty negative about this game. I don't know, I don't know about you, but Chris, but I was like, I was kind of like really like. I figured it would at least be like kind of like medium like reception wise.

I go through in the first videos, I try to find our reviews and I've got a few people that I tend to gravitate toward their videos because I just tend to think the same way. So we line up pretty well and I watch so many reviews for things that I can pretty much kind of filter out who's going to buy us on this, who doesn't, you know, kind of even everything out. But I mean, I'm with you. This is a $20 game that came out and I think part of the problem is a lot of the reviews that I ended up catching were pretty recent ones. So you're not looking at it with the context of this is basically a filler game.

Yeah. And I also think like as someone who plays, who plays like tie in media games and from various different eras, like you kind of have to put yourself a little bit in a. When you, when you sit down to play a retro game, first of all, period, you have to understand like what you're getting into to actually enjoy it or get some level of interest out of it. And so I think, I think my, I'll be honest, like I think I was going into this game initially thinking it was going to be pretty bad. Right. Like I was just expecting it to because I wasn't super familiar with the show other than like I'd seen like a few episodes here and there when I first started playing it. And so I was like, I don't know if this is like a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle show that I really like or anything like that. But so I was kind of expecting it to be a tie in thing to something that was like not that interesting. And it just ended up being neither of those things. And so I think my expectations going into it were a little bit lower. And so I had a lot more Fun with it because of that and also because I knew again, like this is a tie in game. You're only going to get, you're only going to get so much out of it, like at the end of the day, right? Like, and at the time that this came out, 2005, like, and like you said, a $20 game, like, you kind of have to set your expectations and put yourself in that mindset if you really want to sit down and enjoy it. Now if you want to just like play this and compare it to Tekken or Street Fighter 6 or whatever, like that of course, like it's not going to, it's not going to hold up. But if you're playing this, understanding that it is a GameCube game from 2005 and it's tying in in between like other games released for the Turtles, then like, I think they do a bang.

Up job with it comparing this to Tekken. And that kind of problem is a lot of why I'm doing these roughly chronologically because I don't want to have that fall into things. I mean, obviously when I miss like an Atari game, then, okay, jumping back on that is kind of jarring. But I came into this one expecting kind of middle of the road. Like, this isn't a Turtles game that I see people talking about a lot. I knew it was a fighter, but I always hear about tournament fighters and how amazing that is or Hyperstone Heist or Turtles in Time because you know, they're, they're close enough anyway with how their gameplay is. So coming into here I was like, okay, it's going to be a fighter. It's going to be all right. Probably not going to be as good as those other ones. And I mean, honestly, I don't think it is as good as those other ones, sure. But it's still pretty good. Like, I don't hate myself for playing this at all.

Yeah. And I think that like, I think the other thing too for me is like, I haven't played every single, like I said, I haven't played every single Ninja Turtles games. The ones that I have, I feel like all kind of land in a similar spot for me. And I don't think that this one is like so far outside of like the, you know, the range of like, okay for a Turtles game that like it raises like an eyebrow for me. And so again, I think that's why I'm still so shocked at like, like even at the time, like the reviews just, just kind of saying that it was not great. And I, I Do think that, like, when you start breaking down, like, the combat and stuff like that, there are some elements that, like, you know, it's not a tight fighter, right? Like, it's. There's not, like, super tight controls. There's some moments where I remember I got super frustrated with, like, the AI when I was playing against that. I do think that there is a scaling issue when it comes to the AI in this game. That said, there's enough in this game that you can. Like, when I was playing through adventure mode and I got stuck on, like, a raft level, I switched off and went and started playing through Casey's mode until I got stuck there, and then I was able to switch off and. And so, like, you can do stuff, like, right? And if you're sitting down on the couch with friends and playing, like, that's the other thing. You can always, like, change up your characters and. And so I don't know. I don't. I don't kind of see what all the reviewers say about this game of being as bad as it is, because I think it offers enough that, like, it kind of offsets a little bit of the gameplay that's a little rough around the edges.

As we start to wrap things up a little bit. What do you think are the big things that this one really gets right? Looking at Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles? Yeah, I mean, I think the big thing is, like we said, it's those. Those that other media, the outtakes that they have, I think that's something that's pretty major. I think it's having the voice talent do voice, you know, lines for. For the game, and then the. The cast of characters, I think, is also, you know, it's extremely well thought out. Like, my. Barring like, a few things here and there, it feels a lot like the 2003 show. Like, I don't think that there's. It misses the mark in that regard. Like, it really does feel like it. So, yeah, I mean, I think. I think it gets a lot right as far as Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles go, even down to, like, I. One of the things I love are the victory poses for at the end of a match. Like, it's literally just like, them flexing and, like, just, like, showing off. And I think that's. That's. So. That's a really nice touch that they added. That's just really rad that they didn't have to do. So I think that they. They get actually a lot more right than I think they get wrong in this game.

I think the other thing that I would want to add to that is the stages that they have in here. You know, these are all places that are. You mean, if they're not pulled directly from the show, it's. All right, cool. I can definitely see them going there in the show. And, you know, gameplay wise, yeah, it sucks that you can only do a certain kind of battle on that stage, but completely ignore that part because that's just a weird development quirk. The stages that are there look good, and they work for the gameplay stage that they're designed to be have played on them and everything in there. Like, there's nothing that really seems out of place for turtles.

No. Yeah, maybe. Maybe like the rocket launchers. It's always kind of a weird one when you get, like, the, the, the weapon pickups. But even those, I mean, do show up in the show. Like, it's just, it's always just weird to, like, pick up a gun as like, a Ninja Turtle. But that's not out of place either, really. What do you think this one really gets wrong? Looking at Ninja Turtles, I, I, I think you kind of hit the nail on the head with not being able to team up, because that is a big part of what is in the DNA of the Ninja Turtles. I, I think the, I think the other thing too, as much as I do like the Unloc, and this isn't like, necessarily a Ninja Turtles thing, but I do think, like, there's, they probably could have, they could have done a better job with, like, not giving you just walls of text to read. And I think that kind of carries into the adventure mode too. Like, there's all of your adventure mode story is just done in the form of text between stages. And I especially because they have some animated scenes that you can unlock. I was a little surprised that they didn't have some level of, like, an animated through line. Right. Like when you're doing adventure mode of, of cutscenes, like, there's no cutscenes really. I don't, not that I recall in the actual adventure mode. So I think that's, that's a big missed opportunity there, especially because you have the voice cast doing lines and stuff like that. So I think that that's something they could have done a little bit, A little bit better.

Yeah, I was definitely expecting at least, like, mouths moving on, portrait style of things. You know, just something. And you've got the whole cartoon that had come out at that point that you could have pulled scenes from if you didn't want to make new things for this but mostly it's the team thing. It's weird to have a turtle game where you can't like, I don't know, team up with, you know, your, your Donnie and your friends, Raph and you do like a cool move together. Right. Like, and I know that might be, it might be early timeline wise in terms of like games to do that, but like it does feel like a really big miss I think for this.

This does seem about the era where that should be starting to happen. Yeah. Like it's okay. Regular Nintendo, Super Nintendo. Okay. You're not going to have people being able to do things like that. It just. It's not going to happen. But by the time you get to PS2, Xbox GameCube, you should be able to have some team up moves for sure. Yeah, yeah. Not having team up moves, thinking about it more, I think is like kind of a big miss because can you just imagine like how cool that would be, especially in like a four player setting, even if you are like all not fighting together, if you could just do a team up move together. I don't know. I feel like that's a bigger miss than the more I think about it.

By this time you could have at least done the Marvel vs. Capcom thing where you pulled somebody in for your special move and it's just a big old animated thing there. So you didn't have to have, have any button pushing gameplay to make it happen. Once that was going like they could have had that and you would have had the team aspect there. Yeah, absolutely. I also think, I know I'm jumping back to things I liked about the game, but one other thing I wanted to note is that it does seem like the people who worked on this game were at least fans of the show because I can see a world where again, you don't get April as a playable character for a lot of unfortunate reasons. But like she in the show and in the Turtles universe is a, I mean can be a like formidable opponent at times. And so I really have to give them props for doing that and just the level of detail that they give to the characters. It really feels like this was at least a game that was made with, if not love, like a knowledge of the show at the time that you don't often see some of the times in some of this tie in media.

Oh, definitely. I mean this isn't something where somebody said, all right, cool, here's your five minute explanation of what Turtles is. Right. Go make it happen. Yeah. So I really appreciated that aspect of it a lot. If you had, I guess, an alien who didn't know what Turtles was, because everybody on Earth, I feel like, knows what Turtles is and they were trying to get into Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, would you give them this game as part of a primer course? Well, I. That's tough because, you know what? Actually, I think I would because there's. And here's the reason why there's. We already mentioned it. There's 12 pages of history in the game that you can immediately look at. So, like, if they wanted a primer course, like, the game actually has it there. That plus, like, the comic pages, being able to look at the toys, being able to see, you know, some of the, like, character biographies, although some of them are just not right, but whatever, you know, being able to see some of that stuff, I think it actually does. The library in this game does serve as a good primer course to the Ninja Turtles. Now, does the gameplay itself, like, really give you a good understanding of it? Yes and no. I mean, again, not having the. The team up aspect of it doesn't really help. But I think, like, once you're going through, you know, the adventure mode and you're getting some of those little story tidbits, I think it does provide at least a good primer for folks. So, yeah, I would. I would definitely say this would be a good primer.

Yeah, this one cheats its way in there with all that extra library of information. But, like, it's not a horrible choice. I mean, there's definitely games that would do a better job just from the gameplay aspect. And I'm sure in the future there's going to be ones that are going to be at least as good for unlockable content. Yeah. And I think, like, it also comes with the caveat of, like, if you're giving them a primer on, like, like a baseline primer of Ninja Turtles, but also mostly the 2003 show. Like, I think then it's like, yes, this is a good primer, but if you're talking about the whole world of Turtles, then, like, it gets like a little bit. A little bit maybe rougher after that. But even still, I think it still does a good job.

And finally, I mean, let's just go all out. We're going to remake this game, but we're going to have Muppets playing the roles. So who is your Turtles team? Who is Splinter and who is Shredder? Wow, this is. I knew some manner of this was coming and I didn't think of it well. Okay, so first of all, My Muppets knowledge. I need to. I probably need to Google all of the Muppet names to figure out who would be whom. Oh, my gosh. Counts if you need it to. I'm completely blanking on every single Muppet that exists right now. I'm. I'm. Oh, okay. So Splinter. Oh, man. Rizzo. I mean, is that too easy to say? Rizzo is Splinter?

No, actually, I think Rizzo would be really good because he has a lot of those moments where he's just oddly serious about things. I think Rizzo just, again, has to be Splinter Leonardo. I mean, I think you have to go with another. Another green guy, and you go with Kermit. And I think that one works really well, too, because I think there's, like, a lot of humor that you can get out of Kermit being, like, the leader of the Turtles, man. Who are the other ones, though?

I think Raph gets to be Evil Kermit. Evil Kermit. I like that. I was gonna say. I was gonna say animal as Mikey, which might be just too far, but, like, just being, like, just going completely, completely in the realm of just, like, just really out there and just goofy. But I'm sure there's a better choice for Mikey. I'm not sure there is. And then finally, okay, Donnie. Donnie's a tough one. I mean, is Beaker just because he's, like, a scientist? Like, does that work?

I mean, we're casting this. Why not? Then you literally only have, what, Kermit. And then evil Kermit are the ones that can actually talk. And then Rizzo, of course. Yeah. There it is. That's. Those are the Muppets. I think I would watch the heck out of that. I mean, yeah, it would be really. It would be fun. I think it would be a good take on. On the Ninja Turtles. Tommy, it has been great talking to you about all of this. If people want to hear more from you, where else can they find you? Around the Internet?

Yeah, absolutely. And thank you for having me. I. I love the show. It's always a lot of fun to. When you're. When you're checking out a game or property that I know. I love, just. Just dropping in. People can find me on the Internet. I am@awkward comma, on blue sky and Instagram. And then I have two other podcasts that I co host. The first one is Distant Echoes, a Star wars podcast where my partner Cass and I are going through every single Star wars television series in whatever order we please. And then my other podcast I have is Lee Carvalho's Potting Challenge, a Simpsons gaming podcast that I host with my pal Derek, who has been on Play Comics before. And we're playing through every Simpsons video game ever made. So if you like hearing folks talk about tie in media stuff, we also are going specifically into the Simpsons Game and also talking about pop culture history, Simpsons history, and a little bit of gaming history as well.

And both of those are great shows. So definitely go check those out and you can get there the easy way by clicking the links that are going to be down in the show notes. Because clicking links is so much easier than trying to remember how to spell things. Oh, absolutely. And I should also note both of those shows are on the glitterjaw Queer. Podcast collective, which I'm trying to think of. There. Is there a bad show on there? And I really don't think so. I don't think I'm allowed to say. But no, I actually, I think we, I love every single show in our network work. So I mean, you can say because legitimately it's true. They're all good.

They're all good. Yeah, I, I agree with that. As for me, the best place to find me is over on playcomics.com where there's links to all the social media things, which is basically just the blue sky social media thing because I'm too lazy to switch anything over or continue to use multiple things because I'm an old man and I have better uses for my time like preparing for this podcast. So yeah, blue sky, it's fun. But I am throwing up shorts on YouTube. I mean, they're quotes pulled straight from the show with no context, but I think those are fun. So it's fun and it's easy for me to do and I just think it's fun. So yeah, if you want to be on the show, then there is a link down in the show notes that takes you to the website to show you the list of things I'm looking to get booked the soonest. I could post a list in the show notes, I guess, but then it would be out of date by the time anybody could look at it in three years when they're listening to the episodes in three years. So instead I put a link and then there's an up to date thing and you can see it and it's great. And yeah, if you want to help support the show, then you can be like oh no lit class or Dan McMahon and give the show money. You can do that through Patreon. You can do that through Ko Fi. KO Fi. I don't know, the one that starts with a K, that kind of thing. Or you can just share the show with people that you know, people that you don't know, people that you randomly see on the street burn episodes onto a CD and throw them gently into people's cars and then pray that they have CD players in their cars. I guess that's a thing. Maybe it'd be better to put them on USB drives. Then if nothing else, people would have a USB drive that they could use. Don't forget that Play Comics is a part of The Get a Geek.com Network, home to such wonderful shows as Capes on the Couch, Spider Gwen. That's all I'm gonna say. Say if you like the music that I'm really talking on top of right now, head on over to BackingTrack GG and say, hey, did you use a BackingTrack GG song on sugar Spite? And everything is fine, which still needs to come out. Chris, what the hell are you doing? Yes, I did. And yes, I know. And that's what I'm gonna do for the rest of the weekend. Except it's not gonna take that long because I'm a loser and I need to get that thing out. But most of all, just grab a game, grab a stack of comics, and go find yourself a new favorite character.

My other podcast. This is not my podcast.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Iron Man (2008) with Perry Constantine (Superhero Cinephiles, Japan on Film)

    Nov 15, 202649 minAudio

    Read transcript Tony Stark looked at a cave, a box of scraps, and the worst week of his life, and decided the answer was a flying metal suit. It’s the most confident home improvement project in history. He also holds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Spider-Man Web of Shadows with Matt Turner (Pikaslash Plays)

    Nov 8, 202640 minAudio

    Read transcript Today’s forecast for Manhattan: scattered goo, strong winds of questionable decision-making, and a one hundred percent chance that Spider-Man’s week gets worse. Spider-Man: Web of Shadows is what happens...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Fantastic Four Rise of the Silver Surfer with Gary Jones (Divergent Comics)

    Nov 1, 202637 minAudio

    Read transcript I get it, movie tie ins are hard. You’ve got a development timeline dictated by by an unobservable force. Expectations that are already lower than a kid who gets all of their candy stolen before they get...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Incredible Hulk (2008) with Russell Moran (Kaiju ComiCast)

    Oct 25, 202650 minAudio

    Read transcript Bruce Banner has the worst anger management plan in recorded history. Step one: don’t get angry. There is no step two, because the world is full of slow Wi-Fi, hold music, and a military that answers...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. DC Universe Online with David Gallaher

    Oct 18, 202649 minAudio

    Read transcript Congratulations! You’ve been hired by the Justice League. Your title is “Hero,” your qualifications are “showed up,” and your first assignment is standing in Metropolis next to Superman while a stranger...

    Credit the people on this episode