On this episode, Walt chats with rail industry icon Tony Hatch, Senior Transportation Analyst, ABH Consulting. With over 30 years of experience as an independent transportation analyst, he wants to change the dynamics of railroads and the current public perception of the industry through the power of accurate information. Hatch pulls no punches as the duo discuss the latest news and events on everyone’s mind. From derailments and safety to changes in the C-Suite at Class 1s to the bright future ahead for rail, no topic is off limits on this fascinating and fast-paced episode.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00They need to be able to do really well without a butt. And I think they're aware of that. And I've been arguing for that. One of the things that means is a higher level of capex. And that will flow down to the people who are listening on this broadcast, right? The most important piece of a railroad, railroads have a couple of big advantages in transportation. They're very labor efficient, right? You know, you can think of a double stack train versus the trucks. They are very fuel efficient, four-to-one, the AAR says. And think about what that means also in emissions. But those two or three items are being attacked by people in Silicon Valley and Austin, Texas, and whatnot, who are developing electric vehicles, who are developing autonomous vehicles.
SPEAKER_00They're not necessarily looking at the rails in their sights. Maybe it's just a side effect. But the big advantages rails have in those arenas are, if not going to be eliminated, are being chipped away at.
SPEAKER_03You may know the American Railway Engineering and Maintenance of Way Association, or AREMA, as the quote, keepers of the manual. You may know them as the quote people behind the largest annual railroad conference in North America. This podcast is designed, no pun intended, to change your view of who AREMA is and how AREMA has changed the trajectory of many railway careers over its 100-plus year history. Welcome to Platform Chat with your host, Walk Fletcher, where he takes a moment to discuss the impact AREMA has had on the very people who are proud to be called members.
SPEAKER_03Are you ready to roll with AREMA?
SPEAKER_01ARE Corporation is a proud supporter of AREMA and Platform Chat. If you are looking to take your railway structure's career to the next level, or simply started down the right track, please visit us at ARE Corp.com. Please see our brand new job postings on our careers page or on our LinkedIn page.
SPEAKER_02Hey everybody and welcome back to another edition of AREMA's Platform Chats. I'm your host, Walk Fletcher. I apologize. Once again, we've had a bit of a issue with the cadence of our episodes this year. I don't know what's going on, but it seems like every time I go to record uh something has happened in my life less the past time uh my children gave me a nice little uh sickness that allowed me to not even be able to talk. So I had to reschedule with today's current guest for a couple weeks. But uh without further ado, I'm super excited. We've got uh Tony Hatch.
SPEAKER_02If you've ever been to any Arima conference uh for the last uh at least two since I've been going, which is about 2005 or 6, I I've remembered seeing him uh uh up on stage and he gives an excellent antimate animated uh speech on the on the market uh from a New York analyst perspective, and I always look forward to it year after year after year, and I'm stoked that I get him one-on-one here for a minute on the podcast. And I think if you do know him, many of you, I'd say almost all of you, probably should know him.
SPEAKER_02Um, you know that my talking in this episode is going to be limited because he has a lot to say.
SPEAKER_00And so, I'm a loud mouth.
SPEAKER_02So without further ado, there it is. Uh Tony, if you could just, yeah, give our listeners a brief background and then we're gonna jump right into it.
SPEAKER_00All right, well, thank you, and thanks for also. Well, I rescheduled one, so thanks for your uh your patience with me. Um, I've been an analyst covering the railroad and related industries with the class one, sort of the sun and others as moons around them of various sizes, uh, for about 30 plus years. Um I I went started uh going, I went into finance and I went to work for the I went to Solomon Brothers and went into their their second training program. Uh the first training program in Solomon Brothers was written about unfortunately for me, the book came out after I'd left the training program, but it was in Liar's Poker, which was Michael Lewis's first book.
SPEAKER_00Uh I highly recommend it. It's hilarious. Uh obviously I knew most of the people involved, but I didn't realize how uncool it was until I read the book to be an analyst as opposed to as opposed to being a hotshot trader. Uh but after going through the training program, I essentially apprenticed uh as a railroad analyst by chance. Given a choice of a couple of industries, I chose rail because I'd been a history major, and obviously that's important. And because I thought it was really important to know with rail with the commodity base, you had to be conversant on a wide variety of topics.
SPEAKER_00You weren't going to be bogged down, if you will, in a single commodity that might go up or down and you know be depressing, but you had to know about autos and grain and and you know manufacturing. And you know, it at the time I didn't think much of intermodal, but soon the consumer as well. Um I did that on the street for uh over a decade. I was ranked in the way we rank it's called the Institutional Investor All-Star team. I had left um one big bank where I worked under a former ICC commissioner, Jim Whitego, as the lead rail analyst at Pen Weber to go to Nat West to help privatize the European freight rail system, which never happened.
SPEAKER_00Uh one of the two great lies, I believe. One is we're fully committed to the capital markets, and the other is that we're going to privatize the European freight rail system. Neither turned out to be true. It was a great experience, but they closed at the turn of the century. And I decided rather than go back into Wall Street, uh, you know, and do some other kind of job or go on the buy side or the investor side, that I really had gotten the uh industry bug. I had developed an extensive Rolodex. I talked to somebody last night who literally did not know what I meant when I said I have a big Rolodex, but in other words, I had a lot of contacts, or they had no idea of the reference, even though I don't use one anymore.
SPEAKER_00It's still very visible in my mind. I really like the industry. So at the turn of the century, I started my own practice, ABH consulting. It's my initials, not very imaginative name, uh, but it was a great time to start. Railroads were down and out. Uh, people who followed the industry, as an analyst for what analysts do is they helped follow the industry for professional investors who care about the earnings projections and the finances and the strategy, et cetera, of the industry. All those people wanted to move to San Francisco and follow software companies because we weren't going to move any goods.
SPEAKER_00It was going to be moving electrons only. So while that proved to be both a you know a big thing out there, it also was untrue. Uh, from that point on, the railroads have you know crushed the stock market. The rail renaissance, as I called it, you know, happened right on my independent watch. I mean, it's purely coincidental. I'd like to say I have, you know, can take credit for it. Also, the rise of independent um needs for research, uh, hedge funds, activist funds, which is uh it's a kind of a dirty word, uh private equity infrastructure funds who are obsessed with short lines, lots of different stuff happening.
SPEAKER_00So I was able to create this business. One of the things, so I do three things. I follow publicly traded companies, much as the analyst for Bank of America does. I follow private companies like the shortline industry uh and other suppliers. You know, I follow rail car leasing companies and you know, and I don't follow them the same way. They don't publish the same kind of data. But I'm, you know, I try to stay, you know, cognizant. Uh, and with and that's the second leg, sort of private companies or due diligence on deals uh or bespoke, as we call it, research, something of a project on the Panama Canal, let's say, and what does East Coast versus West Coast intermodal mean for the industry?
SPEAKER_00The third leg of my three-legged stool is public speaking, and that's where you've seen me. Uh, because I don't have to go to Cleveland twice a year and spend three days talking to investors there, and I'm not on Cleveland, lovely town. I just been, you know, the the self-side analyst at a bank has obligations that as an independent I do not have, and that frees me to go to try to as many of the stakeholder conferences, a REMA being a major one, railway interchange in the fall. But I've just came from NARS, North American Association of Rail Shippers, uh, who gave me in 2019 their Person of the Year Award, probably my highest honor.
SPEAKER_00And as I as I like to say, 2020, we had a pandemic, so I'm the only two-year holder of that belt uh there. But um I I so I go and speak at all these conferences, and then I run my own conference called Rail Trends with my allies and partners at Progressive Railroading Magazine. So by getting out to AREMA, you know, I meet people, I learn about capital spending plans, I learn about you know new ways to do with uh uh you know maintenance, all sorts of things that that that I, you know, that same as when I go to shipper conferences, I learn about whether railroads' efforts to get you know better service are actually making it way down into the field to the people that matter.
SPEAKER_00I've addressed labor. You know, when I go and give my speech, and I'm not gonna do the hard one here, but later Arima will have a zoom of my speech, and you've seen me do it live. That's sort of my entry ticket to get there and then go to the coffee break and the bar after dinner and you know talk to people and figure out what's going on in the industry in ways that simply um listening to company presentations won't do. So that's what I do. I've been doing it now for 20 years. It's sort of a you know self-perpetuating machine, uh, if you will. I love the industry.
SPEAKER_00It's uh gone through some significant hard times of late, you know, all on a relative basis. They're all earning a fair amount of money, you know. Uh, but certainly from a uh a public and governmental and share and shipper and employee relations perspective, the rail industry has gone through some tough times. So uh I look forward to uh Renaissance 2 at some point, and I can talk to you later on about why I think that might actually happen.
SPEAKER_02Awesome. Uh well, yeah, I appreciate you taking the time to be with us. I understand that yeah, you technically are not an Arima member, but you are a as far as I'm concerned, uh, you're an associate member if you as far as I'm an ally. I I just can't you're an ally. There you go. Yeah, I just can't imagine a conference without seeing you up there. And so I guess you and I uh spoke earlier and we just had a couple different ideas of some of the things we should cover today. And I think the big one right now that's in a lot of people's mind, and I mean, uh for the first time in my rail career, so I've been around for about 20 years, um, I had neighbors and friends asking me about the derailments in Ohio and Norfolk Southern and safety.
SPEAKER_02And uh it got the attention of the general public that honestly, Tony, just most people don't really care what I do. But for some reason, when this happened, they had want to get my take on it. So I'm gonna flip that over to you.
SPEAKER_00So my mother actually called me in the fall and asked why railroad workers don't get paid sick leave, right? She'd never concerned herself whatsoever uh with what I did in the railroad, not to pick on my mom. But the railroads are had taken three body blows in the last roughly 18 months. Uh and each of these has progressively moved railroads from the business pages to the front pages and not in a positive way. Uh, not only because you don't want to be in the front pages for negative things, but also because the people who then write in the front pages don't know the industry. Uh the first was the supply chain crisis, uh, crew shortages.
SPEAKER_00You know, this was a universal problem. It was true at fast food, but in specifically the supply chain, it was true at warehouses. There were shortages of chassis, uh, it was true with the shippers themselves, at drayage truckers at the ports with chips lined up, you know, 100 deep. But railroads have their own regulatory body. So they had hearings on the hill in which the chairman, um, a good friend with whom I disagree about a lot, said, um, you know, basically called the railroads out for being inept. Uh, then came the labor contract, um, which came to a head in the in the fall.
SPEAKER_00And it's important, and I've really tried to stress this to the front page writers and to my mother and others, that this was a regularly scheduled round of negotiations delayed by the pandemic for a year, but taking more or less the usual amount of time. And like several times in my past, going all the way to a presidential emergency board and then the Congress, that's what the Railway Labor Act allows it to do. And because labor this time had basically all the face cards, they it paid off for them to delay this as long as possible.
SPEAKER_00And uh, and because they knew the Congress was going to be the ultimate arbiter of their paycheck, in effect, they they used social media, a new phenomenon, right? Out there to help talk about the the you know their conditions in order to condition the public, like my mother, uh, who were going to condition Congress. Um, once the PEB report was out, I knew there'd be no strike, but it really made the railroad seem overly greedy, right? They make all this money, they buy back all this stock. You know, why aren't they giving their workers more? Why don't they have paid sick leave? It's important to note that during the three and a half years of negotiations up to the fourth quarter of last year, labor had never asked for that.
SPEAKER_00But that being said, uh they won this round hands down. Um, all the things that that uh uh uh the investment community might have looked for out of the labor contract when it all began in 2019, very little of it came came to pass. And then we had going to your question, uh East Palestine in early February. Railroads are inept, they're greedy, and now they're unsafe. Um they you could argue about their how apt they are, if that's a phrase. Uh, and you know, we could have an argument about that. They're no more greedy than anybody else, uh, including labor and other industries, and they're clearly not safe.
SPEAKER_00But this was the really big blow that got people to talk to you uh, you know, about this, et cetera. And I really want to say um it's deeply unfortunate. It was highly unfortunate, and I'll get to this in a second, that it happened to Norfolk Southern for the reasons of the great experiment. We'll talk about that, but also because they have in the past tried to get out from the common carrier obligation. Um, you know, it's important to note that railroads are not allowed to carry these goods, they are compelled to. And the government, which compelled them to, even when Norfolk Southern tried to get out from these obligations, the government should have stepped up and said, you know what, we're in this together.
SPEAKER_00Railroads are safer, so we make them do this. Sometimes things happen. It appears that in this case, and we wait on the final NTSB report. But it appears that the railroads did all, you know, the right thing. Uh, and you know, accidents happen. I mean, they're very rare on railroads, that's why we do it. They didn't say any of that, right? Both parties, you know, are are are are I mean, my faith in government already been lowered by the last you know eight years, but but was crushed by the hearings when I heard the right say that railroads don't care about towns like East Palestine, despite the fact that Norfolk Southern had 13 employees from there, and that most of their employees look like the people of East Palestine.
SPEAKER_00And that the and the the left saying, you know, of which I'm more, you know, as a New Yorker, you can guess where I likely vote, right? But then saying profits over people, buyback stocks, ignoring the fact that the rail system, thanks to the good people in Arima and others, it's a B plus on the American Society of Civil Engineers report card, B for the industry, B plus for freight, uh, compared to a D on the highways, right? So ignoring that the railroads are spending money for safety, that that hotbox detectors are voluntary, let's get down to what's actually after a really awful period of time.
SPEAKER_00Um I think things in a PR front have somewhat stabilized. And, you know, they're I don't think the railroads are unsafe, and I don't nobody was injured, injured, much less killed. I think they'll be able to, at great expense, mitigate future issues. The the venting of the car on national TV was a bad issue, but you know, not an NS decision they participated in. Uh and they have pledged to do what's right, and I know Alan Shaw and I believe that they're going to. And I just saw him at NARS in Chicago, and it was a very moving speech with a video. It's a major issue for the industry.
SPEAKER_00So the industry, as Joe Henriks, the new CEO of CSX, said, the industry is now hated by all of its stakeholders except one, and that would be my group, uh the investment community. That's probably too strong. He was making a point. But let's get to directly with the uh safety issue and the acts in Congress. You know, everybody's coming out of the woodwork trying to get their own pound of flesh. There's even an effort to make larger trucks, truck size and weights, having nothing to do with this, to legislate two-man crews. There were three on the locomotive that had nothing to do with the accident.
SPEAKER_00They cut themselves loose from the train and moved a mile away. So you could have had 12 people in that locomotive. Uh, to uh, you know, there may be ECP brakes, probably not. Um, maybe it'd have more hotbox detectors. Remember, those are voluntary, not got, you know, the railroads put them in as a sign to me that they don't like to run off the tracks. It's expensive, it is the antithesis of reliable, consistent service, um, there's and that they're citizens. Uh, so the railroads have taken a blow. The biggest thing I'm worried about, and we can move on, uh, is you know, overreaction, and we're seeing that in the public statements, but also the the missed opportunity.
SPEAKER_00The railroads have technology that's important to a REMA people that we've seen work on the Canadian national that like automatic track inspection. And when they installed automatic track inspection at uh at CN in areas, they found a 90% increase in you know finding things to be shows you my technological skill. Um, they the same thing goes with car inspection, portals, where you can run through at speed. The FRA has fought this very heavily for basically as a jobs protection thing. Obviously, you you could use fewer people if machines work, but the real thing here is the capacity you save.
SPEAKER_00If you're running cars through at the at 50 miles an hour and they're being more better inspected than by the tired, cold human eye, you're also not taking hours out of freight revenue time. If you're inspecting the track with a car that looks like a boxcar, and we saw it at CN's investor day, I've seen it before, but in Chicago uh a couple weeks ago, um, you know, you're you're not taking up a five mile an hour, you know, high rail in a very expensive mainline. So these things are what one of the big first things that happened after the accident and all the reactions is several of the railroads having signed their national labor contracts, had talked individually to their individual conductors union and whatnot, and had worked out pilot programs to do a conductor on the ground, which would have one man in the cab.
SPEAKER_00And remember, the government is subsidizing autonomous vehicle, autonomous trucking, you know, research. But also that person who had a has a territory rather than riding the train has a schedule which allows him or her to go and see their children play sports. And you know, one of the big issues and it's quality of life. So it really had the potential, if it worked out right to be a win-win, all those have been abandoned for the present. Everybody has stepped back in this, you know, sort of safety witch hunt environment. And so what we're missing here is lost opportunity.
SPEAKER_02Interesting. And I'm gonna just there's a lot to unpack there, obviously. But I uh we we talked briefly about some of the leadership changes. You know, I I know in the past what two or three years we've seen BNSF their their CEO changed in 21 to Katie Farmer, CN had a change in CEO in 22, and Alan Shaw took over NS in in May of 22. So about a year ago. Does that sound right to you?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he's like I think he's yeah, he's about a year in now.
SPEAKER_02Which seems like that would be a tough time to step into that role.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Uh yeah, yeah. Uh you also have Union Pacific, and I know we'll talk about that, about the change. Um, you know, KCS, the CEO, resigned as part of the merger. So I guess I mentioned it already. I mean, every railroad out there has gone through a leadership change. One of the things where your audience and I might differ is I'm very pleased that so far, and I'm talking about more resume than specific people, that they have gone the route of hiring a marketing-based person. Now, Alan Shaw has operational and marketing skills, but he was a CMO.
SPEAKER_00Um, Haiti, all of them have some operational background, but they were coming from marketing, and I think railroads these days need to be more customer-centric, more uh, you know, stakeholder-friendly. Um, and that's a big issue that we'll talk about, uh, the so-called great experiment. Um, but we have seen uh leadership change almost across the board. I'm trying to think if anybody, you know, when we get Union Pacific, we'll have we'll have completed the deck. Um so yeah, we are. Alan did step in. He's you know he's a lot a lifelong uh NS employee, but at the top job, right, things were going really swimmingly for him.
SPEAKER_00In December, he had an investor conference that really was here's my team, my my new COO, Paul Duncan, and you know, here's the guys, and we're gonna, this is the team, here's what we're gonna do. And he really in a kind of back to the future, but also a radically different change, started what I call the great experiment, which is we are not gonna focus. Oh, PSR has been has taken us this far, but it often leads to an overfocus on the operating ratio. And if you are incentive financially and otherwise on the operating ratio, the easiest way to change that is cost cutting.
SPEAKER_00We're going to invest through a cycle. We are uh our experience with furloughing in this awful pandemic, we have to really keep remembering how traumatic that really was. But you know, historically, these are rough numbers. Railroads would furlough people when in a known downturn, right? When you like the Great Recession of 08, 9, right? So, you know, they could flex their cost down more than people gave them credit for, but when they wanted the people to come back, the vast majority came back, right? They took the time off to see their kids and go hunting, and then they all came back to work.
SPEAKER_00This time 30% or so did. And so there were labor shortages everywhere. They realized the cost of higher, you know, of reaching out to hire training and installing and getting experience for these crews, plus all the lost business, both normal business, i.e., losing share in things like paper, but also lost opportunity in intermodal and others, is way too big a cost to pair to try to manage short term costs. You know, nobody in any industry really predicts, you know, un can predict short term economic conditions.
SPEAKER_00You know, it's the longer term we can talk about e commerce is gonna grow, but but you know, nobody's been able to really say what's gonna happen next quarter, right? Or next year. And so running in a too fine a P PSR system. To find a just-in-time system, you know, that works when the sun is out and the sun is often not out, right? Weather, economy, pandemic. Um, and I think where the railroads have all learned from that to build a resilient case. The economists are calling it just in case as opposed to just in time, which is really having a resilient supply chain, multiple options.
SPEAKER_00You know, this really started going back to Fukushima in Japan when the auto industry was shut down because all of certain kinds of paint came from there, right? And they couldn't finish certain kinds of production. And nobody ever thought we can't have paint all from one place on an island, you know. Um, so that's you know, one of the big issues. And Joe and then Alan Shaw really spoke to a change in mindset. There, you know, the investors represent uh you know the whole lot of opinions, right? They're very short-term, you know, they're day traders to people who hold stock for a decade, right?
SPEAKER_00You'll hear more of the loudest of those who are going to talk about operatio and short-term uh changes. And so he had to fight back and say the ROI, the return on investment, is gonna be better if we win the trust of our stakeholders. You know, we don't have to keep hiring and attrition will decline. Uh, shippers will give us more business. You know, the entire 20th century is act doesn't look like it from this date, but it's been a really good one, the rail renaissance. But the railroads have always sort of taken two steps forward and a step back.
SPEAKER_00They're doing really well, but then growth overwhelms their capacity, right? Or they're doing really well, and there's some other, you know, the pandemic happens, you know, you know, or a flood or a hurricane. They need to be able to do really well without a butt. And and I think they're aware of that. And I've been arguing for that. One of the things that means is a higher level of capex. And that will flow down to the people who are listening on this broadcast, right? The the most important piece of a railroad, railroads have a couple of big advantages in transportation. They're very labor efficient, right? You know, you think of a double stack train versus the trucks.
SPEAKER_00They are very fuel efficient, four to one, the AAR says. And think about what that means also in emissions. But those two or three items are being attacked by um you know people in Silicon Valley and Austin, Texas, and whatnot, who are developing electric vehicles, who are developing autonomous vehicles. They're not necessarily looking at the rails in their sites. Maybe it's just a side effect. But the big advantages rails have in those arenas are, if not going to be eliminated, are being chipped away at. The other two big advantages railroads really have are the network with that high grade rating from the engineers, that that network pays taxes, right?
SPEAKER_00Which means it's politically palatable versus look, how long did it take to get an infrastructure bill passed? You know, we get one every decade, it seems, right? So also if they see something like the need to build a huge new intermodal terminal like Barstow or big Barstow Intermodal Gateway that BNSF is doing for$1.5 billion in California, they can just do it.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_00They have to have a good return. They have to make a good case to their CFO and to the board of directors and to their shareholders, the shareholders in BNSF, BNSF's case being just Warren Buffett. But you know, they they you know, they have to make a case for it, but they don't have to wait for a political compromise to do it. That's a real advantage. And then the last advantage railroads have is that they have a lot of money. They've done well this thing, you know, they generate a lot of cash. They can reward shareholders in a balanced plan. And I believe in buybacks and dividends, otherwise the stocks go down and then people try to come in and raid them, and they don't spend on capital.
SPEAKER_00What they've been spending, and the network capital spending has been very steady through all the PSR and economic ups and downs of the last decade. Um, so they are able to fund. If they need more technology, it's you know, it's just a matter of will, right? In previous crises the railroads had, they, you know, when they were deregulated, they were you know, 40% of the track bombs were in chapter 11. I mean, this, you know, a whole different world. So it's just up to them to um to spend it wisely and have good leadership.
SPEAKER_00And I'm greatly encouraged by this new generation of leadership that we have that you alluded to.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, because it looks like and and to pile onto that, Mr. Fritz is stepping down as well, correct?
SPEAKER_00Yes. Um Union Pacific tried to say this was a regular part of business. You know, Lance isn't very old, he's certainly very healthy, but he's been there a long time, you know, and you know, I was wondering what they were going to do. And they said, you know, they've been looking for a while, and then they put out a press release and uh, you know, winter Sunday. And I thought, hey, people don't put press releases out on Sunday. Uh one of their investors, not a large percentage, but a billion seven dollars, but$1.7 billion worth of stock, had basically been complaining. So we still have activists out there.
SPEAKER_00They really want a COO, Jim Venna, late of UP, you know, also of CN. Um I don't think they're gonna get him. He's been vetted several times. He's still actively campaigning for it. I have nothing against the man personally. Um, you know, I told you before it's the resume job. Uh, they've also said they're gonna look you know for a world-class person in the industry or adjacent industries. I think that's really boxed them in a corner. One of the things the problems that UP's had of late is they've keep boxing themselves in a corner. Uh they keep referring to their G55 or 55 OR target long after OR targets were really a fashionable thing politically.
SPEAKER_00And even now in the financial community to talk about, they kept saying they were going to spend 15% of their revenues or less on CapEx, which was an unnecessary line in the sand. Bailed out only because fuel surcharges inflated revenue. But here they said they need a world-class person. Now, in the rail industry, I would argue there's only one world-class person, and that's Keith Creel. I'm not saying there aren't other people who could be who I don't know that are, but think of the uh Union Pacific job as like the manager of the Yankees, right?
SPEAKER_00It's the prestige organization in the industry. When they say they're going to bring in a world-class person, they mean somebody they can introduce as world-class, as opposed to will develop and really be, you know, they've had great success. Um, Jack Koraleski and uh uh Jim Young, who became world class there. But they've really boxed themselves in and said, So what I think, and based on what Lance said at NARS just last week at Chicago, um, that they're gonna hire from outside of the industry a la CSX, where they brought in Joe Henriks, ex-president of Ford.
SPEAKER_00Um, Joe has been a smashing success so far. He's all about culture change and he speaks the truth. Uh, you know, um, I really think he's done a great job. He's only, you know, eight months in himself. So, you know, he's still feeling his oaths. We don't know what his final team will be because, you know, he didn't come with a team. He came from another industry. In fact, Joe is, as far as I know, the highest ranking incoming person. I mean, Union Pacific and CSX both in the past have brought in outside people into significant roles. Think of Oscar Munoz at CFO at CSX, for example, and often with a path to the top, but never at the top to start.
SPEAKER_00Um, that's a really unusual thing. I think Joe is going to do it, you know, is doing a tremendous job for the industry as well as for himself. And he's part of this great experiment of, you know, really looking to improve relations with labor, um, you know, to become a growth machine as opposed to just a cost-cutting machine. So that's all good. I have a feeling that that's what Union Pacific will now try to do as well. I have no idea who that person will be. Uh, I don't think they are in an operational problem at Union Pacific. Um, in fact, relative to BNSF, they seem to be really performing quite well.
SPEAKER_00But what they're, you know, they've done a couple things. They've drawn those lines in the sand, they've quite unnecessarily picked fights with the STB. Um, I think they could have avoided some of them. Um, and really they haven't lived up to their potential. That's the biggest thing. They have um the greatest franchise in the rail industry. That's a phrase I was told when I started back in the Solomon Brothers training program. I don't think that's been eroded. In fact, you know, their Mexico position, you know, uh it makes is even bigger than we ever thought it could be, et cetera, et cetera.
SPEAKER_00So um whoever comes in the Union Pacific is that step it in some big shoes, and you know, uh it'll be the front page of the Daily News and the New York Post. I mean, it won't really, but I'm making the Yankee manager, you know, statement. It's a big job. Uh frankly, my first thought is that Keith Creel wouldn't, I mean he's not, but you know, it is the big job. Uh Keith is making a heck of a, you know, Keith is running. Um, please, all you guys forgive me, but he's turning like the Tampa Rays into a you know perennial contender after he did it CP, and that's what he's doing in this combination.
SPEAKER_00Um, you know, they are they they're they're still the smallest, even in accommodation railroad out there. The Yankees are like, you mean the Union Pacific is like the Yankees. And so under a lot of circumstances, you would say anybody would take the Yankees job. Keith's not gonna go. He has so much on his plate and so much opportunity. Um, but the UP situation is like the biggest question mark after the legislative impact. My my sources tell me that the railroads can head off truck size and weight and head off legislative bad decisions based on the accident.
SPEAKER_00But you know, until they do, that's the big, you know, that's probably job one. And then job two is who's at Union Pacific?
SPEAKER_02So, yeah and you've been around this uh industry a long time, and as you started at the very beginning talking about how you've been analyzing the the class ones for for years, and I'm just sitting here looking and listening to you talk about the leadership changes, and uh, you know, there were seven class ones until not too long ago. Now there's there's six, and you listed literally five of them have changed CEOs in the last two and a half years. Is that normal? Or is that is that pressure to once one does it, the rest of them have to follow suit?
SPEAKER_02I I don't know how to ask the question.
SPEAKER_00Pressurized. Um CN had a a really unusual circumstance. I I mentioned Joe coming in and the first time, you know, maybe since the turn of the last century, when uh you know bankers were often CEOs, right? JP Morgan would install someone when they own Wall Street, ran banks, ran railroads, literally, they were headquartered in New York. You know, when I started my career, Union Civic was on Park Avenue, right? Where I'm where I'm talking to you from. Um so back then that that happened. Non-railroads had come in to represent their financial interests. Since then, these people have come out of railroading, uh, and then Joe comes along.
SPEAKER_00Um an investor, the Children's Investment Fund, um, forced a change at CN. Now let me backtrack about TCI as it's known in the business. TCI made a successful proxy attack on CSX in 2007, where they had five of their six, if I'm remembering correctly, proxy board members elected to the board. Um CSX later called it a victory because those people um had to leave because the Great Recession meant that uh the Children's Investment Fund, all the stocks went down, they had to sell CSX to pay redemptions.
SPEAKER_00They came out of nowhere. That that was the first proxy fight since I think 1954, New York Central, before my time, even before my time. Um, one interesting subset of that is um they were a client. I wasn't advising them on proxy fights, but on railroads and how they would do. And my contact was Rishi Sunak, who is the Prime Minister of Great Britain. So, you know, I have friends at high places now because of that. But TCI comes back around and is the largest shareholder of CP, passive, not activist. After all, what could you do with Keith?
SPEAKER_00You know, who are you gonna bring in to replace Keith? You know, God. Um when Keith spoke at Rail Trends, I said, I'm really sorry I didn't build a little pool for you in front of the podium because we all wanted to see if you truly could walk on water. Um, he got the joke, because I wasn't being serious for those of you uh released by it. I do not mean to offend. But TCI also was the second largest shareholder of CN. So they played an outsized role when those two carriers were bidding and fighting for Kansas City Southern in a battle that we now can look back on that said should never have happened because once the old rules and new rules issue with the SDB was resolved, that was game over, but it played out months longer.
SPEAKER_00But it's really interesting to have a single investor of both companies playing, you know, Puppet Master, uh, very reminds me of Jay Gould and whatnot. Well, they did make a run at a board proxy fight on CN and forced JJ Rue to retire. And one of the things they were talking about, you know, which I regret, uh, one of the things they were talking about was uh, or they allowed analysts to say this on their behalf without correcting them. This is going to be a return to margin from growth focus. We do not want to see that, right? Doesn't margin should come, as Keith Creel says, you know, the operating ratio is the outcome of a good process.
SPEAKER_00If your process is working, that'll be fine. Um, so JJ left, that was forced. You could argue that Lance was forced by, you know, I don't know what's happened in the boardroom there, but you know, one large shareholder, only 1.2%, but you know, almost$2 billion worth of shares. Um the uh uh came in and uh you know basically put this letter out, and that's happened. So the rest of them were natural heredity, you know, by which I mean heredity, so I'm turning longevity.
SPEAKER_00Uh Jim Foote was 67, um, you know, Carl Ice was, you know, the the you know, it was a weird that it all happened so quickly, you know. Um but but you know, most of it, well, actually, if we're talking about five, three of the five came as a natural process, right? Um and and we were given good signaling, even BNSF, which doesn't care about uh analysts, you know, clearly signaled that Katie Farmer was the chosen person, uh, and you know, uh as should be.
SPEAKER_00And uh, you know, so that all was normal. Um foot was a surprise only because we didn't know when he was gonna go. He was foot, he was Jim was my oldest friend in the business. I met him when he was in fester relations for the Chicago and Northwestern. Some of you in the podcast Google that that was an old railroad and a part of the Union Pacific. Um, so so Jim, you know, I I was sorry to see Jim go, but you know, he'd already tried to retire before. And I think he wanted to see CSX stabilized, you know, after the pandemic and the hiring issues, and he did get to see that, and then you know, it was ready for the next phase.
SPEAKER_00So it's a really interesting time because there's big changes, including maybe at this point, we're gonna have six, two of the six, one-third could well be outsiders, right? If Union Pacific does what I suspect, but don't know, but suspect they will.
SPEAKER_02Interesting. And and maybe that is an excellent transition to one of the final talking points we wanted to cover on this podcast, which was the CPKC merger. I mean, I I'd love to hear you talk about that a minute.
SPEAKER_00Oh, so okay, so the railroads, I told you the three big body blows, and and as Joe Henrich of CSX said, you know, every the stakeholders don't like us. We've, you know, all this anger, these dumb things that are being piled on in Congress are really a product of these guys hearing from their constituents for a long time all the problems with, you know, the overfocus on short term and and whatnot. You know, uh, some of that is is misunderstood. I don't believe it was as bad as they say, but the point is, chickens are coming home to roost. How do you change that situation? The public eye is important. Congress has a role, right?
SPEAKER_00What do you do? Well, you change the mindset. You do the great experiment led by the East. I would say that CN, they said that investor today, I could put them in the in the guys of like looking longer term. CN refused to talk about operating ratio. They've all the railroads have changed their compensation plans to look at safety, service, and return on investment, you know, which links the my stakeholder group, the financial community, with the employees, with the customers, and with the regulators, et cetera. Um, that's the first thing.
SPEAKER_00That's gonna take time. You have to build and earn trust. The other thing is really to focus on growth. Part of the great experiment is investing in growth, right? Not cutting back, providing reliable service. People will want more of it. It is cheaper, it is a better emission story. People like to brag about that. That's not yet a direct selling point, it's an indirect one, but it's moving up the food chain. The best example, the fastest example to show growth will be CPKC. They're having their investor day. I'm not sure when this will be broadcast, uh, but we're talking at the beginning of June.
SPEAKER_00At the end of this month, you're going to see uh a big investor in Kansas City where they lay out all their plans. This merger is unlike any of the others I've followed in my career because it's unlike most mergers in the past were 80% cost cutting, 20% growth opportunities. And we never know if they got that growth. I mean, if companies got big, they got blended in, and how could you tell what would have happened? This is 80% synergy or 80% revenue enhancement, 20% cost cutting. After all, they only meet at one place, Kansas City. You know, there is gonna reductions in um you know management, most by by luckily by by uh retirement, as the KCS management was getting closer to those ages.
SPEAKER_00But um the the uh uh this is a growth-focused merger. They're gonna talk about growth, growth, linking Mexico to Canada, linking the auto auto cycle all the way, linking oil sands to Texas and into Mexico with refined products, linking you know, uh Midwestern grain down in, you know, corn is the biggest U.S. export to Mexico, threatened a bit by Brazil, topic for another day. Uh, but you know, if they hit their targets, and I think their targets are very ambitious, they're gonna hit them, whether they could do it in the time frame.
SPEAKER_00I'm a little more skeptical. Nobody's really done any hard due diligence on this, and I'm joking a little bit here, because as I said, Keith walks on water and the belief sort of is he's always hit his targets. He's actually always outperformed his targets. So I'm just gonna assume, you know, 1.5% of his, you know, 150% of what he says. But all that said, this comp this story will change the the dynamic of um what how we think about railroads. The the the great experiment is the biggest story, uh, but that's gonna take time.
SPEAKER_00This one, they're gonna start growing next year. They're gonna be putting more track in next year, you know, or or later this year. You know, um, and that it's that's a good one to change the narrative. So it's really good if you're a shareholder of that company or a shipper on that company, but it's also good, you know, if you're Norfolk Southern or Union Pacific. Uh Union Pacific is fighting, it's gonna lose some market share. So they they might not think that all the time in Omaha, but you know, the change the narrative, um, you know, uh KC, CP, uh KCS and CP uh have always been really the favorites at the STB of the class ones.
SPEAKER_00Uh they didn't follow C CP only hit a little tiny piece in the U.S. But you know, if they do this, they do it safely, they have, you know, they don't get customer complaints, you know, we can start turning the page from these three blows we've hit and look to the a better and brighter future. I'm really looking forward to the month. Um also the Royals are in town.
SPEAKER_02And do you think that they will uh do I mean I guess do you think that will lead potentially to a second renaissance?
SPEAKER_00Yes. Um I think it has to, or we're all in trouble. Um, you know, that there's a little bit of faith in there, but there always is with this. You know, I think there's significant market share that has been lost that that will flow back with a little bit of reliability, that's sort of normal share. And I still think the opportunity, for example, in domestic intermodal. Um Katie Farmer said that as when discussing her big project, Barcel Intermodal Gateway, said that in the LA to Chicago lanes, there could be six to seven million loads that are available to rail, of which they're the largest player, that you know, that they think they're achievable.
SPEAKER_00That's the same size as their market now. And that's in the most mature, you know, the the most, you know, that lane has always been a big lane for BNSF um and for UP. So yeah, I think there's the opportunities out there. I've thought it for a while. I've seen strong hints for a period of time that they can do it. Um, I think the rail systems now have created both a north-south opportunity as well as the traditional east-west um growth opportunities in you know, uh Halifax and in the ports.
SPEAKER_00One of the things we didn't talk about is uh I think it's we're about to see a share shift from the east back to the west to LA Long Beach. That's very positive for railroads. Even Eastern railroads would rather get business out of Chicago because you know, all that business will be on their train versus the business they would pick up at uh let's say you know Charleston, most of it's gonna be trucked because it's close by. Um so I have hopes for that. Uh so I think there is, you know, the the opportunity that I saw a decade ago has not been achieved. Pete, you know, they've done it for two years and they fall back for whatever reason.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes, you know, calamity not of their doing, you know. Um if they could show consistency, I believe it's there. That they can grow faster than the economy, thereby gain share. I think if they do, you know, we're all in a better world. Not just Tony, not just Arima, but you know, North American citizens.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. I think we're gonna wrap this up. I just want to say, uh I think one of the coolest things about hosting this podcast is getting to talk to people that are extremely passionate about what they do, and you obviously fall into that category. And and I think we got a lot of listeners out there even even trying to define what they want to do with their careers. And I think, you know, just talking to an analyst of the industry that many of us participate in in intimately. Um do you have advice for for young people that are are looking at the railroad industry as a potential place to start a career?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think you have to be prepared for bumps. Uh you know, uh it's an outdoor sport, as they all like to say. But I really I believe in the future, I believe we could have a sec, you know, the the first Renaissance of 1400, 1500, but you know, that was you know before we had um you know Da Vinci. So uh, you know, there's room for more renaissance. And I think the it's gonna be an interesting industry. I think they are increasingly committed to diversity, uh, opportunity for young. I think they're changing the way they deal with young people. I think the old command and control military for you know attitude that you know kept them alive and thriving from the Civil War till now, you know.
SPEAKER_00But that's we're in a new era, and I think they are the new leadership is cognizant of that. So I think it's a pretty good time to be a young person in this industry. And you know, like me when I was struggling, you know, fumbling around in the turn of this century, um, only to find the industry sort of grew up around me, became really interesting to people. Luckily, I knew something about it. I think they'll find that right now this sort of this low point is the floor, and we're gonna move up from here.
SPEAKER_02That's there's no better way to uh end this podcast. So thank you so much for being here, Tony. Absolutely and uh I look forward to seeing you at the next uh major rail event.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely.
SPEAKER_03Thank you for rolling with Arima on today's episode of Platform Chat. For further information about Arima, please visit arcma.org or contact us at info at arema.org.
Host Walt Bleser picks up where AREMA's Emerging Technology panel at the Annual Conference left off, joined by panelists Laide Olambiwonnu, Head of Product at Parallel Systems, and Brett A. Story, PhD, Professor at...
In this annual Platform Chats tradition, host Walt Bleser welcomes AREMA President Jerry Specht, EIT, Assistant General Manager South S&C Operations, CPKC, and Senior Vice President David Clark, PE, Director...
Platform Chats host Walt Bleser sits down with Metro-North President Justin Vonashek, who turned a last-minute career fair resume into leading one of the nation's busiest commuter railroads. The conversation centers on...
The 50th episode of Platform Chats marks a milestone as host Walt Bleser sits down with Anamaria Bonilla, former Chief Engineer of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority Metro‑North Railroad, to reflect on a career...
In this episode, host Walt Bleser sits down with Jared Hopewell, AVP, Communications & Signals at Norfolk Southern, and Jason Schroeder, Assistant Chief Engineer at CSX, to introduce what attendees can expect at the...