Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Physics World Weekly Podcast

Physics World Weekly Podcast artwork

Near-oxymoronic requirements: the materials challenges of fusion energy

May 7, 202633 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Jacob John of the UK Atomic Energy Authority is our podcast guest

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello, and welcome to the Physics World weekly podcast. I'm Hamish Johnston. Nuclear fusion powers the sun, and scientists and engineers have long been trying to harness the process to generate clean energy. While much progress has been made, the commercially viable generation of fusion energy remains elusive. One important challenge is developing a range of specialized materials that can contain an extremely hot radiation

emitting plasma in close proximity to ultra cold superconducting magnets. Our guest this week is Jacob John of The UK's Atomic Energy Authority. He studies how radiation damages materials. And in conversation with Physics World's Mateen Durrani, he talks about the near oxymoronic materials requirements for fusion reactors and how they can be met.

Hello, Jacob. Welcome to the Physics World podcast. Pleasure to meet you, Matin. I am really happy to be speaking with you. Alright. So let's start with the basics. Do you want to for listeners, do you want to tell us a bit about yourself and where you are? You're in France at the moment, aren't you? Yes, sir. So I work for the United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority, and, we serve the British taxpayer. And I have the honor to represent the British taxpayer, in France currently. So in, in that's in CEA. That's in

France's, nuclear energy, research laboratory. And, so so you work in fusion. So before we get on to exactly what you do, let's have a quick reminder about fusion power and, you know, why it's so important for, you know, the future of our planet and our energy mix and so on. Yes. That'd be a pleasure. So fundamentally, what a fusion machine or a fusion power plant is doing is transforming mass into energy.

And, the energy density of the fuel that they're working with is so high that realistically, at our current energy consumption rate rates, running out is not a concern. They're they're beautiful machines, and and they're very comparable to particle accelerators actually in this the type of components they use with cryogenics, vacuum systems, the kind of materials. And that means in their core, they need a

very precise control. So what you're talking about is very precise control over transforming mass into energy, which if you can accomplish that, you know, the benefits don't need to be described, to your audience. I know they're very, scientifically, kind of aligned. So but, yeah, to be able to turn energy in a mass into energy is great. Yeah. I mean, it's one of the fundamental things of, you know, physics, isn't it? So,

a fusion machine, and, you've told me not to call it a reactor. It's a machine. And now these are I imagine I mean, you know, when we have one, they'll be and they are the ones we have at the moment are pretty extreme environments. So what sort of for those who don't know, what sort of conditions are typically found there and and sort of what sort of materials do we therefore need to survive in those kind of conditions? Yes. Lovely. So I would I would like to start with, where we talked about the, the machine,

idea. I heard I've heard one I've heard a I can't remember who is, the leader of a of a private, fusion company. He describes them as, fusion generators. And, because really at the end of the day, where we were talking about, this precise control over this reaction, it's quite quite quite different than than, the nuclear power plants that we use today. And it's important to draw a a a

designation between the two technologies. So you talked about the extreme environments, and they are very extreme. One of the difficulties or this deep irony of fusion machines is that you they perform better when you take very cold material, as cold as you can possibly make it. When you take very cold material, and bring it very close to very hot material. So so the hot material would be plasma. That's where the,

that's where the, the light atoms are combining and superheated very, very hot. But, of course, we use magnets to control these reactions as and, and these magnets have to be kept cold. So the closer these magnets are to this very hot plasma, the better con the better control of the reaction you get. It's a bit simplistic, but in their core, they're they're almost oxymoronic machines. So we have, we we need very high temperature resistance, but they're very different than our existing,

power plants because they're also very they're also very dynamic, very dynamic machines. So they're very hot, but they have rapid fluctuations. And these, the combination of the extreme temperature with the dynamics is, it it it presents conditions that we haven't tested. And kind of that's where you come in because you're working on, a plan for something called the Joule Horovitz Reactor Yes. Which is,

a plan for a machine being built in, it's, in Cadarache in Southern France. So do you wanna explain where is it, when will it open, and what's it gonna do to help us understand materials that are relevant to fusion power? Very yes. So, the Joules Horrors Reactor is a is a fission material test facility being built in France. And, there's a consortium. And in this consortium, different, countries,

have purchased in the past rights to the neutrons that come out of this machine. And, of course, with with approval from, from those that operate, they can use these neutrons to test various, degradation mechanisms or or develop fuels. So what what we're doing in the Fusero program, we're collaborating, with our French collaborators. It's very much an international collaboration. We have, we have, French contributors.

We have our British contributors. But we we really share what we're doing, internationally as often as possible in order to get feedback and make sure that, we're collaborating with the right people and that what we're doing is, going in the right direction. So what we're doing in this program, what we're focusing on are highly instrumented experiments that that are testing material degradation mechanisms that result

from dynamics. And this is during, neutron radiation. So these types of experiments, to operate in core, they're, they're, how do you say? Until we really started seriously, seeking to build commercially viable fusion power plants, it's hard to come up with the justification for this, for these kinds of experiments due to their expense and difficulty. But, with the promise of fusion power plants,

we can justify these experiments. And they they become necessary. And and the Fusero program, so that's got I think you told me it's got eight different countries involved. So what how what you know, how did you go about doing that and what sort of projects are being lined up? Yes. So, it's the Fusira program is a collaboration between Britain and France. But we, we we wrote a survey and we to update our strategy, the Fusero program

has been around for about ten years. Maybe maybe precisely, I think, eleven years. And, to update our strategy, we wrote a comprehensive, summary, of our existing strategy, and we asked the community to give us their insights, share us their insights with what they feel is important, for for, our, our program to explore. And, so yes. We sent it out to about 200, participants. Eight I think 13 participants from eight different

countries responded. We have, got feedback from, privates from private industry, from academia, and national laboratories. And, really, we strengthened our existing strategy, but also exposed, a little some areas of focus. And so in terms of sort of specific, material questions, you know, you mentioned things like, tritium and steel and superconducting magnets. What sort of, what sort of things are we talking about?

So we're interested in all of it, but we can't do all of it. But, and in in experiment that we're investing our energy into is one which describes thermal mechanical fatigue in a in in core. So that is we have a sample in the core of of this, wonderful Jules Horowitz, material test reactor. Incredible machine. Very, it's it's going to turn on to answer your previous question, it's gonna turn on

in about ten years. Very sophisticated machine, and it, will complement the, the deep the the closing or the plan closing of the B R 2 reactor, which might get an extension to not important. But, they're they're they're they're they're reactors that actually complement each other. So to not get derailed too much, we're look we're working on the, the thermal mechanical, fatigue in core measurements.

So we are planning to deliver an experiment of which precisely measures and changes or controls temperature and mechanical stress of a sample in core. So that is during very intense neutron irradiation. And this is a nontrivial thing to seek to accomplish. Some other experiments, of great interest are, are tritium production, which is essentially

essentially, essentially, fission fuel. This is this is a, complicated subject to, to really to plan around currently. It's because, yeah, there's concerns that must be addressed. But we're also working on some other, some other some other experiments. We we're building some some experimental setups in Marseille right now

where we examine subcritical crack growth of brittle materials. So this is interesting because windows are, infusion reactors or essential component, and they, they provide, isolation of the vacuum from from from air, from, pressurized volumes for diagnostic systems, but they're also subject to neutron loading and, and and due to their, changing temperature, fluctuating mechanical stress. So there there and, really, we don't we don't know that much about

how, precise, material about about how much certain material property degradation mechanisms such as, subcritical crack growth in the field of fracture mechanics really changes with neutron irradiation. It's accurate to say we don't know if that mechanism actually gets worse or better, under these conditions. I'm sorry. That was a bit of a detailed answer. But how do you, I'm trying to think.

You know, how do you plan these experiments, something that's not gonna open for ten years? You know, how do you, how do you know what's what's gonna work, or how do you even plan that far ahead? That's seems like an insanely long time scale for these sort of things. So we have to think we have to think on these time scales. We have to think about, what kind we have to choose an experiment of an appropriate amount of complexity for ten years of planning. That said, the United UKAEA, and I work in the materials division,

under, Amy Gandy, and our director is Amanda Quadling. And we have, and some of my other, colleagues, Slava Coccinto and, Chris Hardy, we work together, and we do perform radiations in in other reactors that are actually that are actually on today. And so we both build experiments to, prove, that to prove out, things that can be proven out of a reactor. But then we also have a radiation programs in operating reactors

today that, that answers some really fundamental questions. And and you kind of piece all of this together, in order to build robust strategies that, that inevitably must be answered at some point. So we're we're preparing, for the future. We're thinking ten, fifteen years out, but we're taking actions today that give us results today, to to really try to make, fusion power plants commercially viable.

I was gonna say, how will that information that you get from those experiments feed through to people building commercial power plants? If you talk to commercial fusion companies, they'll tell you, you know, we're on the cusp of doing something, but you're talking ten years ahead. How how do the time scales fit? So very interesting question. There's, at the end of the day, you're you're you're you're you're asking really the one of the hardest things to pull off in research, which is how do you do valuable research and turn it into outputs that make a difference? So we have to,

we have to be aware of what we intend to do with these results. Are we going to, patent our inventions that that that have, commercial viability? Are we going to publish our work to enable other researchers to progress the field? Are we going to maybe learn something specific that we then integrate into a commercially viable or a design of a of of Britain's, fusion fusion power plant?

There's there's there's we have to be we always have to be conscious about, translating our research into value. And and and we have to we have to know where we're going. So you asked, how do we make how do we ensure that what we're doing makes a difference? And and and I really do think it comes down to thinking ten years, fifteen years ahead and knowing where we're going and why we're doing it. And,

and, yeah, I guess we'll see we'll see in ten years if that's valid. And so you're in Kadesh in France. Obviously, everyone knows that for the ITER fusion experimental experiment there. Do you have do you work together with them? How would how does the information from what you're planning to do, how will that fit into what might go on there at ITER? Yeah. So, ITER, I've had the great honor to visit it three times in the last, I think, six months. And

each time, I was shocked how much progress they're making. There's very large components being as very large, very complex components being assembled and installed today. This place, looks like a place where lots of work is happening. So, I'm I'm very impressed with that project. We have the great and and and and through through doing these amazing things, they they really have, they've really exposed

crucial questions that need to be answered. So we we we've had the chance to, to, integrate with, people at various levels in the ITER program. And for specific specific, projects, we would discuss specifications of theirs, and how we and and and then how can we, change what we're doing to, support the the questions that they have deemed to be crucial.

So we do have the opportunity to, kind of collaborate with them, but they are in much later phases. So it's maybe less of a collaboration and more of us learning from them, from their from their decisions and and and understanding the things that they're concerned about and trying to keep us, on path on the right path. And the under other interesting thing you mentioned to me was that the role of, computer modeling and AI approaches can play in kind of complementing the experiments that you're gonna do with when you

come to test materials in a fusion reactor. So do you wanna tell us a bit about that? Yes. So a very, very, I'm excited about about, applying artificial intelligence. Of course, how you choose to do it, maybe considering to use local models if you're working with something either, of course, choosing not to use a model if it's, if it's something sensitive. Using a local model if, if, if if it's if it's if it's wise.

So we have to we have to apply it in intelligent ways and and and and be aware of security, security concerns that that they present. That said, the technology, seems to seems to offer an opportunity to accelerate research and development dramatically. Not only in in the in in in giving giving researchers access and then and access to information and what other people are doing much more easily, enabling them to be more creative. But just planning and just simple things like planning

and getting projects, justified and and and executing projects, will be so much easier. I'm very excited about the effect that this will have on fusion long term. I it seems that that this is that artificial intelligence is almost an enabling technology for fusion. So this is, very exciting, a very exciting time to be in fusion. The the the the the questions

that need answering, there's so many valuable things to do. And, with artificial intelligence, you really feel empowered to, accomplish as much as possible and really contribute as much as possible to our shared mission, that that humans share. It's very a human thing, to try to, control, the, the the the fusion, the fusion process. And on a short very short tangent, but but something very interesting about the fusion industry is

dating back to when, when tokamaks were being invented, during dating back quite some time ago, If fusion the fusion industry in its core is a very, a very collaborative, a very collaborative thing. And and, so it's it's it's very nice to have the feeling that, you're contributing to humanity's to humanity's benefit. And, it's it really is something that I

feel, you can derive hope from. So would the AI be a case of, drawing information from different sources together to give you a clearer picture of what's happened? Or would it be about suggesting new types of experiments or coming up with ideas for materials to test? How do you see it happening? So the funny thing is is I think it's just a it's just a fundamental everyone gets more productive. I think it's just everyone gets as simple as people get better at writing

emails to to people actually get better at, at learning things more quickly. And these these these small changes compounds. Even, like, people write script more quickly. And these these things are going to have, really compounding effects on, on on on on on our macro scale projects, on the macro scale effect, on on the effects will be really, really

interesting to watch over time. So, for me, my favorite thing is I've always enjoyed writing numerical solvers. So, I always enjoyed, kind of defining mathematical models and then using partial differential equations to, to describe the model. And then I would always write, numerical solvers. My preferred preferred language is MATLAB. And they were always writing numerical solvers to solve these equations. But then to do the plotting and just just, like, just to make the

scripts and make sure there's no bugs takes a lot of time. And and and I love doing it, but now you can do that so quickly. It's so empowering. It feels so good. Yeah. No. I can imagine that. I'm just saying that must be a great great feeling. Yeah. But coming back the Fusaro program that you've been being involved in, you know, so obviously the question is how, you know, how is that gonna help the results from the how will that help accelerate the timeline towards a working fusion reactor? I mean, realistically, how would it help?

So we are addressing some some pretty fundamental questions. Our our objective with with with Fusero c, which is characterizing thermal mechanical fatigue with, with plasma facing components. If we characterize this properly, engineers can make design decisions that enable the the the machine to operate for longer periods of time without shutting off. It enables us to design materials that can

operate at higher temperatures. Both of those things have a profound effect on the economics of the machine. So by addressing the fundamental the fundamental questions, in material degradation, we are we we enable ourselves to make machines that are more financially competitive. And what's interesting about this is when you increase the operating temperature or the outlet temperature of coolant from a,

fusion machine by like, let's just say you double it. This more than doubles the economic competitiveness of the machine that you're working with. So so small changes have a profound effect. And, and that's really what we need. We need a lot of these kind of, like, nonlinear increases in performance, and and I think we're going to see that. And what we really do need are these these kinds of experiments, these in situ,

heavily instrumented experiments in material test reactors that exist today. And look into the future then, Jacob. You know, what sort of technical milestones do you see, you're gonna hope to achieve with that Fusero program in the next few years? So this this is, like, this is very dependent on, on the funding that we get. But we have plans, we we have plans to deliver.

We have detailed plans that we're very confident we can stick to the time, to that we can deliver some some pretty important results inside of four years. And so this is this kind of inside of four years, that is possible, assuming we get the funding necessary. But these kinds of things, I mean, sometimes you have to spend time, you know, sometimes the experiment that you're working with has to be in the reactor for a year.

So it's like, there's nothing you can't make it be less than one year. And so four years is actually, quite quite, quite competitive when it comes to time and durations and delivery. So we we do want to see changes and and impacts as soon as possible, but we have to be honest with ourselves that, what we're trying to do isn't something that happens quickly. So that would be four years after the thing turns on in in ten years' time.

So as I said as I said earlier, so we are planning for the Jules Horrods reactor, and there's some experiments that we're developing that do actually need ten years of experiment, of development. But we have plans, plans we have plans, and there are only plans right now, to leverage other machines to do something, do something today. And we we do have actually have radiation programs going, today. But what's interesting is when you operate one one radiation program in one machine, maybe

prove out some experimental concepts, you can then use it again in a different machine assuming you have the right agreements in place with the laboratories that you're working with. Yeah. Given those long time scales, you know, if if I was a a, you know, young student going into, you know, thinking where to go with my research career, these are very long term questions. Some people might want a quicker fix than sort of things that happen quicker than that. What do you see as the, attractions of working in this area if you're a sort of up and coming scientist or

engineer? I would say the the best thing about working in the fusion industry is, the people that you get to spend your time with. The it's it's a pleasure to come in every day and work with people that love what they're doing, and and every person is excited to share what they're working on. So, if that's something that you like doing, then, then it's a good place. But but but I also appreciate what you say. Like like, my background is actually, I've

I've been interested in I've been my my first role in in the nuclear facility was almost ten years ago. But I have also had in, positions working in, other industries that have very high pressure, very high turnaround, and I do like that. So so you're asking a good question. And I think so there's first, there's some private private in private industries. Some private companies, depending on how much funding they have, they

do they do build a fair amount of experiments. But if you align yourself with with if you if you if you present yourself and you build the skill set of actually building things, like like, familiar with with manufacturing facilities and tolerances and materials and actually designing and putting things together, there will be roles for you. And something that I'm very excited about, with artificial intelligence is that it's it's

it accelerates things like things like, things that you would use computers for, but it doesn't accelerate, running a mill or running a CNC machine. And I think what we're gonna see is more, more, more value put onto the production and the assembly and the actual experiments experiments. So I would say, if you want to be in fusion, learn physics,

learn, many many fields in engineering. Don't specialize don't stick yourself into one like, I studied mechanical engineering, but I took extra courses in physics and, and math and electrical engineering, and and you can combine these subjects. But I also, took a job, working in a manufacturing facility where, I I I didn't necessarily get paid to directly use those skill sets. But but learning learning from people operating machines, how to build things,

is probably one of the most, complimentary and valuable, experiences that I've had. So I would really suggest for for students, to study physics, to do PhDs, but to not shy away from working in manufacturing facilities. So have you got any sense before we finish about, you know, time scales? So when will we see a commercial fusion reactor sorry, machine that's generating electricity into the grid? That's always the question that everyone wants to know. Which which country are you talking about? It

depends. Different countries are taking different approaches and and and taking different approaches, and they're kind of testing out different technology. So it really does depend who you're talking about. I wouldn't I wouldn't like, I like like, our project, The United Kingdom's project, our target is twenty forty. But, you know, our technology is different than than other than other, than other technologies in other countries. So,

you know, I wouldn't wanna give out a number, but, our target is twenty forty, and and and our and our project is quite comprehensive. Alright. Okay. So any final message before you go to people listening? No. I I, I wanna thank you for the time to speak. I'm I think we should all be very excited about the future for the fusion industry, and those that want to, enter the fusion industry

should learn about building things, about manufacturing. Yeah. Alright. That's a good note to end on. Alright. Thanks very much, Jacob. Great to talk to you, and good luck with your endeavors. And I know you're about there it's Friday afternoon we're recording this, though. You you've got a couple of hours before you have to leave. So, thanks for fitting us in. Oh, it's a pleasure to speak. A great pleasure. Thank you, thank you for making time, Martin.

That was Jacob John of The UK's Atomic Energy Authority in conversation with Physics World's Matin Durrani. Thanks to both of them for a fascinating conversation. I'm afraid that's all the time we have for this episode. I'm Hamish Johnston, and our producer is Fred Iles. The music for Physics World's podcast is called one three seven, and it was composed and performed by the physicist Philip Moriarty. We'll be back again next week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Taking an atomic approach to silicon quantum computing

    Nov 19, 2026Audio

    Michelle Simmons of Silicon Quantum Computing is our podcast guest

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Probing advanced materials with time-resolved photoluminescence microscopy

    Nov 12, 202635 minAudio

    PicoQuant’s Emilio Gutierrez-Partida is our podcast guest

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Building an international research institute from the ground up

    Nov 5, 202638 minAudio

    Our podcast guest is founding director of the IBS Center for Quantum Nanoscience in Seoul

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. From catalysts to quantum materials: exploring the future of platinum group metals

    Oct 29, 202639 minAudio

    Marge Ryan of Johnson Matthey is our podcast guest

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Theorists use cloud-based Bose–Einstein condensate to study tunnelling

    Oct 22, 202625 minAudio

    Quantum experiment is controlled from thousands of kilometres away

    Credit the people on this episode