
Motivation is key to the public’s trust in science, study reveals
Social scientists Shumaila Bhatti and Dara Wald are our podcast guests
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Social scientists Shumaila Bhatti and Dara Wald are our podcast guests
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
- Hello, and welcome to the Physics World weekly - podcast. - I'm Hamish Johnston. - Credibility is a cornerstone of modern science, - and concepts - such as reproducibility - and peer review have evolved - to ensure that the knowledge produced by scientists - is of high quality. - However, for science to thrive and benefit everyone, - scientists - must be seen to be credible - by the general public.
- Today, we're going to talk about a fascinating - new study that reveals that the motivation of - a scientist - plays an important role in how their credibility - is perceived - by the public. - The study involved - nearly 1,000 - subjects in The US, - and a key result was the identification - of five audience classes - that differ in terms of their perceptions - of scientific
- credibility. - My guests this week - are Shumila Batti and Dara Wold, who conducted - the study. - They're both social scientists - at Virginia - Tech in The US. - Hi, Shamila and Dara. Welcome to the podcast. - Morning. Welcome. Thank you. - Good morning. - So, Dara, my first question is for you.
- In your study, how do you define - scientific credibility? - Yeah. That's a great question. - There are, in brief, lots of ways to - define it. - One of the sort of key goals of - this project is to understand - how credibility was defined - in a bunch of different contexts. And in - this study, specifically, we're looking at controversial and - noncontroversial - contexts, - and how it's defined - for different individuals.
- I could actually spend a long time talking - about how credibility is defined, - but I think for me what's most important - is that - I want - people to understand that credibility is not just - the message that you send, - but it's also - you as the source, - and how you, - your characteristics - and your, - traits - and and your intentions - are interpreted.
- And so - the audience itself, right, they're gonna they're gonna - think about your message from their own lens, - from their own perspective and worldview, - but they're also gonna see you through their - own worldview. - And so one of the things that I - was motivated by by was the the idea - that I think credibility means different things to - different people. And so as social scientists, we - often try to define things and give you - specific measures for different ideas or or constructs. - Right? Things in the world that we, - that are really complicated.
- And and I think what I kept coming - across, - in my in my experiences - here was that source credibility was really complicated, - and it was a combination of multiple things. - And those things weren't always the same thing - for different people. - And so - what we tried to do in the article - is simplify that - and say, okay. - Credibility is this complex combination - of perceived character traits - and their perceived intentions.
- And we started with - early definition of credibility, - by, you know, Aristotle, right, which defined it - as expertise, - integrity, - and goodwill. - And in our study, we listed a whole - bunch of other things that people have used - to measure it in in different articles so - that we could capture the breadth of it. - And so I think if you had to - go to to something really simple, you would - say - credibility includes a scientist's - capability, right, their talent, their skills, their knowledge.
- It can include their results, right, what they've - done before. - It can include their signals of integrity. Right? - Are you saying and doing the same things? - Is there alignment between the things that you - are saying you'll do and your actions? - And finally, their intent, - and why they do something or who they - do it for. - And and, Dara, I just wanna make sure - that, - when you talk about an audience, you're you're - talking about - the general public, I assume. So it's not
- how, let's say, how one astrophysicist, - perceives the credibility of another - astrophysicist. - This is the - perception of a of a person who's a - non expert - or or or maybe not? Is it both, - expert and non expert or just about anybody? - Yeah. I mean, it's a great question. Right? - Experts are also people. Right? So so we - we all interpret other people's credibility, - credibility at all times. Right? It's it's it's - how the the world works. It's how we
- make decisions under uncertainty. - And so so yeah. And and and part - of what what motivated this research and part - of what I was fascinated by is that, - you know, as a scientist, someone who's trained - as a scientist, right, I am trained to - signal my credibility very much to other scientists. - Right? So if I go to a a - conference, whether it's a a it's a conference - for physicist or a conference for psychologists or - a conference for political scientists, right, I stand - up on the podium, I give my talk, - and what do I start to signal? I - start to signal my affiliations, right, the organizations - that I'm affiliated with,
- the the PhD behind my name, - right, the the peer reviewed journals, - articles that I've got. Right? And I might - do it subtly. Right? I'm not gonna be - huge hugely bragging about it, but I might - subtly put it there on my slides. Right? - The grants I've received. Right? That's how we - signal credibility - among and to other scientists. Right? - But part of the thing I would find - in my work, especially with - members of the public or in, many of - the environmental contexts in which I work, - those signals of credibility,
- they don't mean anything. - And so that's what I mean when I - say I think credibility means different things. - And so what are the goals behind this - this work? And, originally, my, - my original grant that I wrote for this - for this project - was to sort of say, okay. If if - credibility doesn't mean that, right, if it doesn't - mean PhD behind the name and grants and - and all this stuff that we do in - the scientific community, - what does it mean in these other places? - Right? And and how do we measure that? - How do we define that so that we - can then signal it? Right? Because if we're
- not signaling credibility in those spaces, - then our ability to take the science from - the labs that we work in into the - real world is limited. Right? Because our credibility - is in question, and then our recommendations are - not going to be followed. And that means - people could get sick because they're not adopting, - the health protective behaviors - or, you know, they could not they could - not evacuate when they need to evacuate because - they don't believe Noah's warnings. Right? And so - these are the things that that prompted me - to say credibility might be different things in - these in these other alternative
- contexts with people who aren't trained as scientists. - And and what does that what does that - mean? And how do we how do we - define it? Right? To get to your very, - very good question to start us off. Yeah. - And, Shumaila, can you describe - the survey that you did? How how did - you go about, - measuring - credibility in your study? - So, - well, - first, we can, - talk about - the - measures which were
- taken from previous samples, - and studies such as Wesley's work on reassessing, - perceptions of scientific credibility - and Colonial Mead's work. - We also looked at some very, - key - studies that have looked at different dimensions of - credibility. - Doctor Walls' work, - with, - doctor - Kathleen Hunt was also a key factor in - this one to understand the researcher's motivation and
- influence. - As doctor Wall previously has said as well, - what was important in this study was, like, - how people perceived or interpreted others' motivation and - intent. - By others, I mean, like, the scientist motivation - and death, not just, - the - the the work that the scientists were doing, - which was a big factor that played in - this. So we had, like, multiple items. There - were approximately 30 - or so items across three dimensions
- of, competence, - integrity, and openness, - and then, goodwill or benevolence. - Competence was basically whether they had expertise, they - were intelligent, they were skilled. Integrity and openness - was whether they were willing to share information, - whether they were willing to listen to public. - And goodwill was why they were doing the - things that they were doing, who they were - doing it for, - was was what was the motivation? Was it - an external - extrinsic motivation or external motivation for the sake - of their society good,
- public, - good, - human flourishing, or was it for their own - intrinsic - self interest - values? - So with regards to sampling, - we sampled a nationally representative US, - serve through a US survey acquired through Qualtrics, - in the winter of one twenty three between, - and, like, early twenty twenty four. And there - there were a total of 3,100, - participants approximately.
- They were all exposed to a short news - article that we had, drafted using AP News - sources, - and, - they were divided into two different, - types of news articles. - One was either on extreme heat. The other - one was on Samulana, and the reason for - dividing these two on these two topics was - because one is a little more politically controversial - and charged - than something like food poisoning. - Also, they were, - less likely there there's not a lot of, - what do you call it, vaccinations regarding food
- poisoning - in The United States or anywhere, - as we had, consulted with other, - health professionals as well in the field. - The other, thing we wanted to do was - for this specific analysis, we subsampled from those - 3,000 population, - the representative sample of 927 - people - who, focusing those who weren't shown certain experimental - cues, we had because the this was part - of a larger experimental study
- that had exposed, - participants to certain other cues such as uncertainty, - which was a cue view via, textual hedging, - which may it meant, like, model words such - as they maybe maybe there was a heat - wave. - Maybe a certain number of people died. Stuff - like that. And then we also had, - the - goodwill, - messages - in another ex in another factor factorial experiment - as well, which was, disclosure of biases
- and then also other oriented motivation, whether the, - scientists working in the heat table or the - similar conditions, - what was the motivation - regarding that to understand, - why exactly, - the scientists were doing the work that they - were doing in the news articles too so - that they can read it and and then - answer all those questions regarding their science beliefs, - their science perceptions of scientists, - also the perception of the institution of science - itself. - So, yeah, those were the big broad
- chunks or parts of the methodology - of how we, conducted the experiment, and then - we used the - statistical tool to categorize and identify the hidden - classes based on their credibility perceptions. - You know, it's it's interesting that when you - described the, you know, the article about salmonella - and and food poisoning, - you you said that it was sort of - less controversial - than, - than climate change.
- You know, sort of ten, fifteen, twenty years - ago, - I wouldn't have thought that food poisoning or - salmonella, - you know, would be - a controversial - topic. - You know, you would have thought that everybody - would be against - food poisoning. But it just seems today that - everything is - controversial - in some way or another. Did did you - really struggle to to find - something that - that you could consider - less controversial,
- rather than more controversial? - Yeah. - My personal expertise is in water resources management. - So - a part of me really wants to connect - with water resources and environmental issues regarding - water issues. - But also being an environmental photojournalist, - I had experience in, like, having to document - and tell stories regarding these issues from that - perspective. - So - being on the on the ground and having - that experience of
- communicating from that end of the journalist's perspective, - it it it was a difficult - decision to make, but we had consultations - across, - with doctor Wald and other postdocs as well - in the lab. - And, - coming to the decision of food poisoning in - 2023 - was - awesome. - In 2026, - I - will It feels a little different. - Yeah. I'll leave it to doctor Wall to
- answer that question. Yeah. No. I mean, it - feels a little different. I think it's a - great it's a great question. - Yeah. I think I I think one of - the things that's really so in in some - previous work I did, - public, - on public perceptions of both scientists, but scientists - who do research on genetically modified foods, - which is, as you may know, like, one - of the more polarized. Right? Like, when you - look at the perceptions of the public versus - perceptions of science on the safety of genetically - modified foods, it's highly different. I'm very, very - different. - A big gap there. And and and so - what that study found and sort of highlighted
- for me is that when we asked about - beliefs about genetically modified foods, it was the - environmental component of beliefs that was highly polarized. - It wasn't - perceptions of whether or not, genetically modified foods - provides a benefit to society from, making food - more plentiful or or more economic affordable. - Excuse me. - It it was the environmental part of that, - right, saying that genetically modified foods might have - an environmental, - harm. And that part was what was politically - polarized in particular in that particular study. And
- so it it it has always sort of - resonated for me, this, that study, because it - it really makes the point to me that - not all things are polarized, but environmental things - are highly polarized. - And particularly in The United States, I don't - think that's the case everywhere, but particularly in - The US. And so that's one of the - reasons why we specifically chose an alternative case - that was not - on it on its surface environmental. - Right? And that's why we went into the - sort of food safety type. Although, you know, - as we all probably know, food is connected - to our environment as well. But we chose
- that case intentionally to try to, - find something that was less polarized. And in - 2023, it did feel that way. - I absolutely agree with that. - Also, there's there's this policy, - politics, and information - aspect - of this that doctor Wall highlighted that I - wanted to specifically, like, emphasize as well. I - feel like when media communicates about certain policy - and politics, - certain people - have or use certain information channels - that they deeply rely on and trust
- and find credible. - Those those are also sources that people, - tend to, you know, fall back on. And - that also, in the end, like, leads to - certain, - I guess, political polarizations - on those - on those ideas or policy proposals or how - to manage certain issues, - regarding environment, health, - life in general. So - And, Shmila, your analysis identified
- five different classes of people - with respect to their perception - of the credibility of scientists. - And, - these are the enthusiasts, - the optimists, - the moderates, - the skeptics, - and the estranged. - So you can I suppose there's a clear - spectrum there? - Can you can you give us a definition - of each of these classes? What what what - sort - of views and beliefs do these people have?
- Yeah. This also falls in the line of - from the, like, the perspective of question that - you asked regarding, like, where do where where - would physicists fall? - I think physicists would fall in enthusiasts, - because they would be the most scientifically - engaged population. - According to our - survey, - they rated scientists as very highly competent, - very honest and caring - about the public, and they trusted, - scientific institutions.
- They didn't feel like they were isolated - from those institutions. - They had great confidence in them, and they - also strongly backed science based actions and policies. - So I think most - science pro science people would fall into the - enthusiast category. - Then we have the optimists who are closely - behind enthusiasts. - They're generally very positive, but the support shifts - depending on the topic. - And they are generally favorable and,
- but they're more sensitive to how the issue - is framed. - And - then we have the moderates, - which fall someone in the middle in both - salmonella and heat wave context. - They're more on the fence. - They draw both on personal experts and, - both on personal sources and expert sources, like - technical sources such as news, scientists, and political - sources. - But they also rely a lot more on
- family and friends when when it comes to, - like, getting information regarding certain health issues or, - like, even making decisions regarding environmental, - policies. - And their views - swing - a little bit depending on the issue - and the topic. - Again, that may also align with whether they - are, - leaning towards a specific political - ideology or not. Skeptics,
- vary. They give scientists, - generally lower marks across the board, and they - lean more on less on technical sources and - more on, personal sources, - and they are more doubtful of scientists' motives. - And the lastly is the estranged. They are - the most disconnected of all, - and they have the lowest trust in scientists - and institutions. - They feel there's a general lack of confidence - in the scientific, - in the science - institution, - and they are least likely to seek out
- scientific information. - And this is - this lack of information is - it may be less about, like, - the access to information - that they want to have because they do - seek information, - but more about a deeper resistance to science - itself. - So one thing that I would also highlight - is that - all of these groups, - they all rated scientists' - competence highly. They don't
- have a deep - questioning of whether scientists are skilled or intelligent - or they have expertise. - What really distinguished all of these people were - whether they believe whether scientists had integrity or - goodwill, - whether scientists were honest, - whether they were open, - whether they were willing to - have public's interest at heart. - Basically, why do we do the things that - we do is what really distinguished - all of these,
- categories apart. - And that is where I think - our work really, - lies in - highlighting - is - where does the the trust breakdown, - essentially. - I see. So so a skeptic - wouldn't necessarily - be - skeptical of the scientific method, - but rather - they would be skeptical of the motivation - Mhmm. Of the scientist?
- Yeah. Even even skeptics were, you know, confident - that scientists have - expertise, that they have knowledge, - right? And so really what she was saying - is that the the real difference there came - in came in the other measures, the non - competence measures, right, the measures of integrity and - the measures of goodwill. - So so the the the people - aspects of it, I suppose, is is - maybe a good way to think of it. - Yeah. - That that that is really interesting. Well, I'm - you know, I suppose it makes sense because
- after all, - we're all people, aren't we? - And we're we're subject to to prejudices and, - I suppose, questioning people's motives. - I mean, is is there a - did did you get a perception, - that - people - so non scientists. Do they do they see - scientists as - sort of fundamentally - different - to themselves,
- or - do they do they see - scientists as, - I suppose, normal people who just happen to - be - scientists? - Based on personal conversations or based on the - survey? - Well, I I mean, just in general, I - suppose. I I mean, maybe that's not something - that you investigated in the survey. - Yeah. This wasn't something that we investigated in - the survey whether they saw they saw a - scientist as - an outsider.
- But there are there are national studies, right, - that suggest - that scientists don't interact very often with nonscientists. - Right? That there's a big there's a big - social divide. Right? And and Mhmm. As we - sort ourselves more and more into different communities, - that interaction is even less likely to happen. - So, I think there are some studies that - suggest that as yeah. We did not measure - that specific question, but it's a it's a - really good one. - Yeah. - And they do look at how,
- different - those studies have looked at, like, how one - scientist have been communicated in the media and - how that plays a role in people's perception - or forming a people's perception of scientist. - But that's the thing. Like, science is to - science isn't just a natural phenomena. We as - human beings are also natural - beings, - part of the natural phenomena. - And when we separate the two, - like, social and natural - as being - different - and not part of the same - piece,
- it can become harder for us to connect - with each other. And that is why there's - a greater push towards, like, public facing, - education and processes and projects - for scientists to engage in as well - to have a greater connection with the communities - that they're actually - looking forward to serving and working with. - So, Dara, we talked a bit about what - could be behind - this wide spectrum of views. - Is it related to education,
- income, political outlook, or - something else? Yeah. - We don't have an easy answer to this - yet. Right? So, - I think that was one of the the - hopes, - one of the things we were hoping to - dig into a little bit more. I I - can say that there were no consistent differences - between these groups in education, - income, age, or gender. - We did find significant differences between the groups - in terms of their prior beliefs about science - and technology. - We found differences in their support for environmental
- and health protective behaviors. - And as, - Shwaila alluded to, their reliance on technical sources - of information was a big difference, - their levels of social trust, generally, - their confidence in scientific and other institutions, - and finally, their political affiliation and ideology, - as well as the region of The United - States they were located in in. So in - terms of the sociodemographic - variables - that that might, shed light on why these - differences exist, I would say political affiliation, ideology,
- and region, - were the two that that had the most - consistent, - patterns. - And I think that sort of aligns with - what other people have found is that, you - know, I think there's a tendency to say, - oh, well, you know, people just don't know, - right, or it's a lack of education. But - a lot of studies have found consistently time - and time again that it's not about education, - that people who are highly numerate, right, highly - educated can do a a really good, - solve, you know, solve logic puzzles, and all - this stuff, - are actually - better at finding information that,
- reinforces their beliefs, right, positively or negatively about - science or about data. - And so education or numeracy, - isn't isn't isn't always associated directly in the - way that we might think. - And that seems to to align with what - we found as well. - So so based on your research, Dara, how - would you advise - scientists - on how to best communicate to the public - about their research? Should they tailor messages - for
- specific groups when appropriate, or should they try - to come up with a a universal message - that will appeal to - everyone from an enthusiast - to an estranged person? What, - what would you recommend? - Oh, the great the the great unicorn message - question. Right? So - I I what years ago and I don't - remember his name off the top of my - head, - I heard a a really good scholar who - works on, - vaccine hesitancy and public perceptions vaccine say there - is no unicorn message. - Right? And and I that has really stuck
- with me. So I I think one thing - to remember is that communication is really hard. - And I think it's really important to think - deeply about how we do it, and who - our our target audience is before we're communicating. - And and, yes, I I strongly believe that - language and framing are very important. They have - effects, not always in the way we expect, - but but that understanding that is really important. - There are a lot of good there's a - lot of good, work out there, - very accessible work out there from social scientists
- and others about how to craft a really - short, compelling, public facing message, - on on a variety of topics. And while - I think this work is really, really important, - I think what our study is saying is - that in addition - to crafting a good message, - scientists also need to think about how to - reach audiences who might be skeptical - about them from the beginning. Right? And and - to do that, right, - I think we need to remember that skepticism - is shaped by concerns about
- what scientists - intend to do, what benefit they're bringing. Right? - Not their ability, not their expertise. - Right? - But really, - why do you do the work that you - do? Right? Who who benefits from it? - And so I would encourage scientists, in addition - to thinking about the messaging itself, - to to think about the signals we might - be sending about our credibility - unintentionally. - Right? And those are things like our character - intent. And and to be honest, I think - those are things that many of us as
- scientists - think, you know, oh, well, we shouldn't have - to talk about that. Right? Because of course - what we do matters. And of course of - course we're good people. Right? And and I - agree we are you know, there are so - many scientists out there who are working so - hard and and - doing such amazing work, and and just as - there are people in other places working hard - and doing amazing work. And I think - I think it's important to - remember that in situations where scientists - aren't sort of standing at a podium,
- they're they're out there communicating with the public - in in sort of more of a two - way model of communication. - They're working with a farmer to implement a - new on farm practice, so they're working with - a community group that wants to manage an - invasive species. - In those contexts, - both in this work and in the other - work that I've done, - integrity means are you showing up when you - said you would show up? Right? Do you - keep coming back and sharing information - as it's emerging? - Are you honest about what your study can - or cannot - say? Right? Are you,
- are you working to to continue doing this - work for in perpetuity for a really, really - long time, or does your project end a - year from now? And if it does, what's - left when you leave? Right? - Will this work or your research make things - better for your participants? - Is the outcome - information? - Is it beneficial? - Is it extractive? - Right? - So so I think that those are the - questions that I I think scientists, - really in those in those more place based
- context when you're going out and you're having - a a two way, - interaction - with, - an audience, whether it's someone who has expertise - or or not, - about what you're talking about. That's where I - think we really - haven't yet figured out how to how to - signal our credibility. - The the the the, again, the normal the - the forms that we use at conferences scientific - conferences are not enough. - And so - I think we need to think about whether - and how we're aligning our our words,
- with our actions when we share science in - public - and and how more broadly we are demonstrating, - whether you're a bench scientist or a scientist - who's out in the fields, - how are you demonstrating that our science is - benefiting society, - the public, or the places in which we - work? Right? And and and that's where I - think - we focus so much on these messages. Right? - But I also think it's about - these underlying deeper parts of communication - that sometimes - get forgotten or really that scientists, - to to their credit, like, we we study
- when we are trained, we there's so much - to learn. Right? And and this is stuff - that we don't really - focus on for a variety of reasons. Right? - And so - I think that but I think that they're - really important, and I and that's one of - the reasons why this this project was really - exciting for me, - to engage with is because I I I've - wanted for a long time just to be - able to articulate some of the patterns that - I was seeing in the work that I - do, which is much more two way communication - focused. - And so and and bring that to other - scientists who might be be struggling with that.
- Well, when the rubber meets the road and - I go to communicate my public my science, - it doesn't always work the way I want - it to, or I get skepticism, or I - feel frustrated - about, how my science is being interpreted. And - so, - yeah. So I think I think that that - deeper stuff is really important. - I mean, in terms of communicating - credibility, - I can see that, you know, the the - the there could be a bit of a - trap here because - if scientists spend a lot of time - talking about - their own credibility,
- that sort of implies that maybe - not all scientists - are credible. - Is there I mean, - how would you, - Shumaila, how would you, - sort of coach a scientist on on bridging - the the the concept of of credibility - without, - you know, sort of casting doubt on - on the profession. - You know, it's a bit like a banker, - you know, somebody who who,
- you know, I suppose works for a bank - saying, well, you know, we're - trustworthy. But, - implying that maybe other bankers aren't trustworthy, I - don't know. It's just it's just something that's - popped into my head when I was when - I was reading your paper. - That is, - that is a fair concern. - And - one of the reasons I think that concern - emerges is because of the misunderstanding of what - credibility is. And I think doctor Wald, - explained, - like,
- a lot of that by - describing that credibility isn't, like, the property of - the - of the source. It's of the receiver's - interpretation - of the source. - For example, - it's credibility isn't like something that - the the the scientist owns. It's not like - our - it's not it's not a diploma on the - wall. It's not - it's not my poster presentation. - It's not my manuscript publications.
- It's it's something that the public gives them - based on how they perceive their - different properties, and that includes their expertise, which - is their competence, - their character traits, which includes their integrity, their - openness, - and their goodwill, whether they have their best - interest at heart. - So - when scientists - are when we talk about, like, scientists working - to communicate the credibility, it doesn't mean that - they don't have it. - It just - or it also doesn't mean, like, you know,
- that they're admitting that there's a lack of - that said credibility. - It just means what aspect of that - of that part of yourself - as a scientist or that personhood as a - scientist are you planning on communicating - to highlight? - Because there are certain - people who are not perceived - as scientists. - Yeah. - I mean, I suppose, you know, a scientist - would look at credibility in terms of, you - know, their publication - list. You know, in physics, it would be,
- well, look, you know, I've got these papers - in - nature and science and physical review letters. And - so that makes me - more credible - than another physicist who maybe hasn't published in - such - prestigious journals. But, of course, yeah, that - Yeah. Those impact factors, those journals, they don't - mean anything to the public because to them, - it's like, what have you done for me? - What have you done - for the good of society
- in general if that is one of the - biggest concern of the public right now? And - that is what the study found was that - even the skeptics and estranged who are not - that connected to science and scientists, - their main concern was, like, why are you - doing this - work that you're doing? So tell me - don't show me just your diplomas, which is, - like, this is great, awesome work, but, like, - why are you doing what you're doing? - And - it's - so communicating credibility is about, like, closing that
- gap about, like, helping people see what science - actually is as a process. - In in terms of why, you know, why - does what why does a scientist - do something? - Would it be okay for a scientist to - say, well, you know, it it's my job. - I need a job. I like doing it. - I get paid a modest salary. - I like the people that I work with. - It's a job. - Yeah. I mean, is that enough? Or do - you know, do it it almost sounds like
- scientists - have to do - much more - to justify their existence - than, - I don't know, the, you know, a person - who who looks after elderly people or, - fixes - potholes in the road. - Do, you know, is is do do they - have to go the extra mile? - Or is just saying, - I want to do a good job and - I think in any any job interview, they - are going to ask why do you want - the job. And if somebody's like, I just
- want a job, I I don't think that - job interview is gonna go that well. I - I don't know, doctor Wall. What do you - think? Yeah. I mean, it's a great question, - and I I love it. I mean, I - like to think that my pilot flies a - plane because they, you know, they have it's - a job. Right? Reality. But I'd like to - think that that while they're up there, they - wanna make sure that they do the best - jobs that they can and that I feel - safe and that I'm gonna get home to - my family. - And I'd like to think that as a - scientist, you know and and maybe this is - just me, but I got into doing this - because I had real strong convictions about trying - to make the world a better place in
- a variety of ways. - And, - and and my motivation is is my family, - is is my - community. - And so - and and I don't yeah. It's a job. - Sure. And I'm glad I have a job. - I'm really grateful I have a job. It's - a job of privilege. There's no question. - But I also wanna do the best job - that I can, and I wanna make an - impact. And I think that more and more, - we're seeing that even among the students that - I teach. Right? When they talk about what - they wanna go do, they they talk about - that impact. Like, what kind of impact are - they gonna have?
- And and I think it it's rare for - me to hear that from other scientists. And - I think that's somewhat what this study is - saying. Yeah. It's a job, - but it's a job that's meaningful for many - of us. Right? We we we work really - hard to get to where we are. We - we study for a very long time. - Many of us who are fortunate enough to - go on to have, you know, careers where - we have to go through, you know, internships - and and apprenticeships - and - and tenure review and all these things. Right? - But we do that at the heart because - because of something. Right? We chose that path
- for some reason. - And - I I could I I can say that - a lot of us spend a lot of - time defending science. - Right? But but what you know, this study - and there's another study by Jan et al, - a couple years ago that that found that - most scientists spend more time defending science than - they do talking about why they do their - science, right, their intentions, right, to make the - world a better place or not. And - I guess we're we're saying what would happen - if we flip that switch? What would happen - if we spent more time talking about
- why we do what we do? And I - think people in in public health are are - are very good at this. They're becoming even - better at this. - And I've seen some really great examples of - this over the years. And so I I - wonder what would happen if we flip that - switch. And more of us started talking about - why we do what we do and who - benefits. - Yeah. So I think it's enough to have - a job, but I'd like to know you - wanna do that job well. - Yeah. Even if it's basically to understand - the world, you know, that is, like, considered, - like, meta empathy, which is part of, like, - a big way of, like, expressing competence. It's
- like, if I am taking time to understand - you, the world, and everything around me, that - itself is part of being - like, having a good intentioned, - motivational - interest in - in the world that I am existing in - and have a part and a role to - play in. And scientists play a big role - in creating new knowledge. - And that to me is a really, really - big job - because that means that they get to
- shape somewhat how we understand the material realities - of this world. - And if we have such a big job - in understanding - how we - how we make sense of that material reality, - that is that is a big - big duty - and responsibility - as a scientist, I think. - And I think that should be expressed - to the public as in how am I - doing that, and what is my intention behind - behind it, and what are the values that - I bring to the table?
- So what's next then for for your research? - Are are are you planning on looking at - perhaps how scientists can better - express, - you know, what we've just been - talking about, or are you looking at - at different issues, - with regards to credibility? - Yeah. - Yeah. We've got a lot of work to - do. So Shailila alluded to it. We included, - several, - experimental - components to this work as well, and we - haven't published those yet. So we're working on - getting those out.
- And, yeah, what we did do is we - tested different signals. Right? What happens when scientists - do signal these things, and is it effective - or not? - And then in addition to this, this work - was part of my, - career project funded by the National Science Foundation, - and that included an educational component as well. - And so for the last four years, I've - been working with, - a couple of different groups, - at other universities - to develop some extension, - materials that would actually - look at what happens when scientists in these - more two way communication
- kinds of contacts actually signal their credibility. And - so we've developed a curriculum, and we pilot - it pilot tested that curriculum, - and we, have some really interesting findings so - far as well. And so we're working on - continuing to, - format that curriculum and get it out so - that it'll be more accessible to extension agents - across the country. - And then the last part of the work - is that, I've been really - digging more into this political polarization, - and the idea of credibility as something that - is politically polarized and where that comes from - and what that means,
- in a variety of different cases and contexts. - And so, that work is is supported by - the Carnegie Foundation. And so I'm hoping to - continue, - in in sort of pulling at these threads - a little bit more, - as we go. And and - I just yeah. I think this topic has - really captured - our attention in the lab for a long - time, and it's exciting to see some of - this work starting to come out. - And when you say curriculum and teaching, is - that is that something that you've, you've developed - for scientists? - So a way for for scientists
- to better communicate. - Is that the idea? - Yeah. It's, I'm working with extension educators, - at a couple different universities in the Midwest, - which is where I started this work, right, - in the place based context of of, - land management, things like that. So, so, yeah, - so the curriculum right now is designed, - to work with, people who are land managers - and natural resource managers, - and help to - train them to understand what is credibility. Right? - A lot of the things that we've talked
- about this morning. Right? What is what is - credibility? What does it look like? How do - we signal it? Right? Scientists are used to - picking as credibility as our objectivity, but what - if it's these other things in this other - context? - And then what does it look like to - to signal it? And then, - in this curriculum also includes direct interactions with, - the target audience. - And so, scientists are trained to listen to - that target audience and to hear the messages - and the values that they're expressing, - and then come back and practice. Right? What - would it mean for me to signal that - or for me to meet them where they're - at in terms of their values and their
- concerns? - And how do I make sure that this - work is, - this work or these practices or the things - that we're talking about in terms of land - management, - also come along with messages about, you know, - how this might benefit them. Right? And so, - yeah, it would be a it'll be a - curriculum that'll be available, - at the start mostly to extension agents at - the universities that I'm currently working with, but - I'd like to make it, something even even - beyond that. And and this all started when - I did a review of the curriculum that - existed and realized that there was a lot - of educational material out there, for scientists about,
- you know, - crafting the compelling, right, the compelling message, that - we talked about at the beginning and, you - know, language and framing, which very much is - important. - But there wasn't a lot about what it - means to be a trustworthy source or a - credible source. - And, you know, there's also some curriculum out - there about telling your story, which I think - is really important too. - But this this part of, like, what are - your intentions? Why do you do the work - that you do, and and who benefits from - it? - Is not something that's currently being taught as - a curriculum, - and I'd love to see it,
- see it. - I'd love to start figuring out how do - we do that. Right? And does it matter? - Shwaila and Dara, thanks so much for coming - on the podcast and talking about, - what what is a fascinating study about credibility - in science. - Thank you so much for having us. It's - been great. Thank you for having us. This - was a great conversation. - That was Dara Wold and Shumila Bhatti of
- Virginia Tech. - Thanks to both of them for a fascinating - discussion. - Their work is described in a paper called - There Is Not - Divergent - Perceptions - of Scientists' - Source Credibility - in The United States, - and that appears in the journal - Humanities - and Social Sciences - Communications. - I'll put a link to the paper in - the notes for this podcast. - I'm afraid that's all the time we have
- for this week's episode. - I'm Hamish Johnston, and our producer is Fred - Iles. - The music that you hear in Physics World's - podcasts - is called one three seven, and it was - composed and performed - by the physicist - Philip Moriarty. - We'll be back again next week.
Nobody is credited on this episode yet.
Michelle Simmons of Silicon Quantum Computing is our podcast guest
PicoQuant’s Emilio Gutierrez-Partida is our podcast guest
Our podcast guest is founding director of the IBS Center for Quantum Nanoscience in Seoul
Marge Ryan of Johnson Matthey is our podcast guest
Quantum experiment is controlled from thousands of kilometres away