Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Physics World Weekly Podcast

Physics World Weekly Podcast artwork

Asteroid deflection: why we need to get it right the first time

Feb 12, 202622 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Aerospace engineer Rahil Makadia on the danger of asteroid “keyholes”

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello, and welcome to the Physics World weekly podcast. I'm Hamish Johnston. Our guest this week is Rahil Macadiah who has just completed a PhD in aerospace engineering at the University of Illinois Urbana Champaign. There, he explored how we could deflect asteroids away from Earth. We chat about the potential threats posed by near Earth asteroids

and how they could be sent on their way. Macadea also stresses the importance of getting a deflection right the first time. Here's that conversation. Hi, Rahil. Welcome to the podcast. Hey. Hey, Mish. Thanks for having me. So, Rahil, before we talk about deflecting asteroids, can you give our listeners an idea of

the threat? What sort of threat is posed to Earth from asteroids? Yeah. Sure. I wanna start off by saying that none of the asteroids that we know about are currently a significant threat of impacting the Earth. So for the next hundred years or so, none of the objects that we know about are gonna potentially hit the Earth, come close, enough to to pose a danger. So we should all be resting easy. The the threat really comes from the fact that we don't know about all of the

asteroids that are out there, so not all the asteroids in the solar system have been discovered yet. And if one were to hit the Earth, there'd be potentially dire consequences. So even a smaller object, say, I don't know, tens of meters in size can potentially cause massive infrastructure damage and cause injuries to to people. Like, there was an event in 2013 in Chelyabinsk, Russia, where a meteor exploded over the ground, and, the the shock wave from that explosion,

you know, shattered windows. And people naturally, when they see something like a meteor flying through the sky, they'll flock to the windows. And as a result of this shock wave, you know, exploding windows, there are a lot of cuts and bruises to to a lot of people. But if you go, larger up the the asteroid size scale, so if you have, say, an asteroid that is hundreds of meters in size, that one can cause, potentially massive damage. You know? It can wipe out cities, potentially do damage on continental scales. If you go even bigger, which there are asteroids that are kilometer sized and plus, then

we start getting into the realm of, you know, the the ones that that, made the dinosaurs extinct, and there'd be global consequences, if one that one that size were to hit the Earth. I see. And the the Russian asteroid, how how big was that? I think it was around 25 to 30 meters in diameter. Okay. So so fairly small, but, good given that the other asteroids, some of them are more than kilometers in size. But, you know, even a a small one can pack a bunch. And smaller asteroids routinely go through the atmosphere,

they usually end up not making it to the ground. So, you know, around five to 10 meters, there were, I think, around four small impactors just last year in 2024. But, those didn't cause any damage. Some of them make it to the ground in the form of small meteorites that teams can go out and recover, but it's the larger ones that we need to worry about potentially hitting the earth. I see. And and so let's say at some time in the future, unfortunately, we detect a relatively large object

that's bearing down on Earth. Could we deflect, such an object? Do we have the the technology at the moment? And and and how how would that work? Yeah. So the answer to that question depends on a a couple of factors. One of them is how big the asteroid is. For for asteroids that are extremely large, some of the deflection techniques we have, would take too long or so you need a large notice period before, the the potential impact date. But if we're

talking about the realm of, you know, these hundreds of meter sized objects, we have what's called the kinetic impact method where the basic idea is you just take a spacecraft and smash it into the asteroid, and that causes a small deflection because the size of the spacecraft relative to the size of the asteroid is pretty small. But if you give it enough time to accumulate, then the trajectory of the asteroid is altered enough that it would miss the Earth. And we successfully demonstrated this technique with, a mission called DART, the double asteroid redirection test, which was an asset mission that launched in

2021. And in 2022, it impacted, Dimorphos, which was the the smaller moonlet asteroid in the Didymos binary asteroid system. And it successfully altered the trajectory of the secondary around the primary, and it, you know, proved that we can do this kinetic impact method if we ever have the need to. And Dimorphos was around, a 150 meters, in diameter, so we've successfully proven that we can successfully hit asteroids that

are this small. Because the smaller the asteroid gets, the harder it becomes to target it because especially if you're coming in very fast because you have a small amount of time to to actually do the targeting when the spacecraft's on its way. There are other techniques, that have been studied. There are there are options that have studied the use of nuclear devices, what's called a standoff detonation, where they would detonate a device at a certain distance above the the surface of the asteroid and let the radiation melt away a

layer, a a top layer of the of the surface of the asteroid, and that would impart some momentum as the the material is getting vaporized and kicked off the asteroid. Those are the the sort of two shorter term deflection methods. There are a couple others that need a longer time scale between, discovery and potential impact. There's what's called the ion beam deflection method where you can redirect, an ion beam up up of a spacecraft towards the asteroid, and that slowly erodes, the surface of the asteroid to to part momentum

onto it. And there is the the gravity tractor method where you basically station keep, or hover around an asteroid, with a big enough spacecraft and just the gravitational interaction between the spacecraft and the asteroid over decades, maybe even, can cause, a big enough change to potentially deflect it away from the Earth. And you you mentioned that we we we think we're safe for for about a hundred years or so. Does that does that mean that, for example, tomorrow,

we could spot, a large asteroid that will reach us, let's say, within a hundred years, or I should say, in over a hundred years? And so we would have time to really think about how we would deflect it. And Yeah. I don't know. Maybe maybe get cracking in ten years from now when we've when we've developed some technology that's suitable for that particular object. Is that I mean, is that how it would play out, I suppose?

Yeah. I should say that for the larger objects, so let's say kilometer size plus, most of our population models indicate that we've discovered most, if not all of them, especially, you know, the 10 kilometer plus size. Those are the the sort of planet killers you might think of as. We we're pretty sure that we've we've discovered pretty much all of them, because the the bigger they are, the easier they are to detect, and telescopes keep getting better and better. So it would be pretty, difficult to detect a massive, asteroid at this point. But, yeah, like you

said, if we're, if we detect one that's massive enough, it it will likely be that it's far, far away, the the potential impact date. So I'll give you a specific example. There's this asteroid called nineteen fifty d a, which is larger than a kilometer, we think, and its potential impact date is the year 2880. So there are, you know, special cases like this one where we can predict that, you know, eight hundred years in advance. Obviously, we don't need to do anything about that one anytime soon. But,

a lot of these large asteroids, you know, we're able predict their trajectories for a pretty long term and, conclude whether or not they're a significant impact hazard. And I'd just like to talk about some recent work that you've done. You've you've looked at the possibility of an impact, putting an asteroid into a trajectory in which it could return to Earth, which is probably something that we'd like to avoid if possible. Yeah.

Can you explain how how this would happen? Is it is it simply a matter of of hitting the the asteroid, you know, with the wrong sort of impulse or in the wrong direction and setting it into a alternative orbit that eventually brings it back to Earth. Yeah. So it's, you know, the the the it's the opposite of being in the right place at the right time. So you're sort of deflecting the asteroid at the wrong place at the wrong time, and what you can do is potentially so

let's say in this hypothetical scenario, there's an asteroid headed towards the Earth, and we need to deflect it away. Right? And we send a deflection mission, let's say, a kinetic impact there because that's the one we know how to do. And we do this deflection, and we, you know, dismiss the immediate impact threat from the asteroid. But lo and behold, because we weren't that careful, we've put it now in a trajectory that will return to an to the Earth on an impacting trajectory forty years later. So in this scenario, what we've done is we've triggered what's called a gravitational keyhole.

And these keyholes are basically, you know, predictors of whether or not an asteroid might hit the earth in the future. So, if we blindly deflect an asteroid and push it through this gravitational keyhole, it's guaranteed to return to the earth on an impacting trajectory at a future date. But the the the nice thing about these keyholes is that we can compute them beforehand and map them, given an asteroid's orbit. And so if we're careful about it, we can directly map these keyholes when we're designing the initial deflection mission in the first place,

such as to avoid any keyholes while deflecting it clear of the the immediate impact threat. I see. And and are these these keyholes, are they are the I mean, do they tend to be large, or are there lots of them in the sense that, you know, if if we didn't think of this, we you know, what are the odds, I suppose, if we didn't think of this and just hit the the, the asteroid as hard as we could at a certain point in time? Would it be very likely that we could

go into one of these keyholes by mistake, or would we have to be really unlucky? So that sort of delves into specifics, because the sizes of the keyholes, they're usually pretty small. I think the largest ones I've seen so far are around a kilometer or a few kilometers in size. And given how vast space is a kilometer or a few kilometers is is minuscule, but, once again, we start delving into the problem of, you know, likelihood and consequence. So the likelihood might be low. And I think

the, I should mention, yeah, that the largest number of keyholes I've seen for an asteroid is is around a couple 100 or so, in a in a massive uncertainty region or the the region which you could find the asteroid at any given day. But once again, if we were to send an asteroid through one of these keyholes, because it's, you know, a a future predictor of an Earth impact, the same consequences apply as if that size asteroid were to hit the Earth. So it's a it's a trade off between do we wanna

just blindly deflect it, and, obviously, if there is no way of deflecting an asteroid without avoiding, a a keyhole, we need to dismiss the immediate impact threat. So that's the primary goal. But if we can be smart about designing the deflection mission and, you know, kill two birds with one stone, so to speak, and dismiss the impact threat, maybe permanently even from one asteroid. That gives us less to worry about in the future. And, I think that the you've found that,

that this the technique or or or, I suppose, avoiding gravitational keyholes involves, having an understanding of the topography of the asteroid. So I'm I'm guessing there that its shape, etcetera. Why why is that important? Yeah. So, yeah, like you mentioned, we need an understanding of both how the asteroid's local topography looks like, so what its shape is, as well as how it's spinning because most asteroids, are rotating.

So we need to know what orientation of the asteroid we're gonna be looking at when we're deflecting it and what the sort of local topography it at the is at the point, on which we're gonna deflect the asteroid because the local topography dictates where would where the ejecta will travel. So if you deflect an asteroid using a kinetic impact, what happens is that surface material around the impact site actually gets kicked up off of the surface, and gets released in the opposite direction that the impactor came from, and that acts as

an additional boost, on top of the momentum that's imparted by the spacecraft. So this additional boost can be significant. It can be, you know, similar to or larger than the the the contribution of the spacecraft itself. So we wanna be able to accurately model this deflection, and that involves accurately modeling the momentum that's imparted onto the asteroid, which involves knowing where this ejecta went, which dictates that we need to know what the local topography looks like because that's the local orientation is what dictates the direction of this ejecta.

But if we have a rough idea, you know, there are techniques even from the ground to, get the sit the shape of an asteroid. There's, what's called radar, astrometry. Radar imaging of an asteroid can tell us what an asteroid looks like. There's also light curve methods. So you you sort of measure the amount of light you're receiving from a given asteroid, and you can invert that to to get a preliminary shape of the asteroid. But the the best way to get an asteroid shape is obviously go visit it with a spacecraft beforehand. That'll give you as much

information as as my heart desires and and, you know, allow us to do this deflection the best way possible. And, I mean, I'm just thinking about, you know, this this idea of hitting an asteroid. And, you know, you mentioned that these asteroids, well, they're it's probably going to be rotating. It do you I mean, the the problem I I sort of I suppose a problem I can think of is that you really want, I assume that you want sort of maximum

momentum transfer from your spacecraft to the, to the object. And do you want to avoid having some of that energy converted into rotational energy in the sense that you you whack the the the the object, and instead of knocking it off course, you just spin it up or you reduce its, spin, and it sort of continues on in the same direct in its same trajectory. Is is that a problem as well?

Yeah. That is definitely something to think about is, yeah, if you hit it off center, you're imparting a moment onto the asteroid, and that will change its its spin. But, sometimes, you know, the the spin state change can be overruled by the amount of deflection an off center, deflection would give you. So even if you were hitting it off center, you might get enough deflection to to put it clear of the earth. And if, you know, the safe zone that avoids these keyholes, is sitting, let's say, 25 meters off of

the center of the asteroid, that's not that much, that you're losing. And with this technique, we actually put a band around the asteroid such as to avoid missing it. So if you're too far away from the center, you know, the the spacecraft can't perfectly target, the asteroid at the point you've told it to because there's, you know, algorithmic uncertainties and and just uncertainties in general in the world we live in. And that would mean that you might miss it, miss the the aim point, let's say. And we wanna make sure that in the

first place, we hit the asteroid because that's the the goal of the deflection. So we actually put a safety band around the the perimeter of the asteroid, the visible perimeter of the asteroid to make sure that we're in pursuit of doing a better deflection. We're not missing the deflection altogether because that would, you know, defeat the entire point of the existence. And and what's next for you in terms of your research? You you you've looked at these gravitational keyholes. Are you are you gonna do more studies, I suppose, on different types of asteroids, different shapes,

different distances from Earth, different orbits, or are are you go going to be looking at another aspect of, of asteroid impact? Yeah. Yeah. I think, so I do wanna continue looking into this this better deflection, you know, a more optimal deflection strategy, in terms of avoiding keyholes while deflecting asteroids. One thing I do want to look at is what happens if we if we use one of the other techniques I was talking about earlier to deflect an asteroid because kinetic impact is the one that we've demonstrated so

far. It's the one we already have in our arsenal. But, obviously, there are are other message, the longer term message that I was talking about, like, I NBM deflection and gravity tracker have been got getting a lot of attention in the in the research world after, you know, the kinetic impact, success. So I would like to see how it how avoiding keyholes while doing these other deflection techniques, what that looks like. Another thing that I wanna look into is potentially better ways of computing these keyholes in the first place. So it's a very nitpicky thing. Let's see. You know, improving every part

of this process as much as I can. But, well, yeah, we'll see where the this research takes me. Well, that's great. Thanks so much for coming on the podcast and talking about that. And and also reassuring our listeners that, you know, at the moment, at least, there's probably not much to worry about in terms of large asteroid impact. I mean, when when we say large, I mean, what what are the what are the sizes of asteroids at the moment that can sort of sneak through?

Is it the like, that that Russian asteroid, for example? Did did we see that coming, or is that just too small for us to detect? No. I think that with with Chelyabinsk specifically, and I I wasn't in the field in 2013, but, I think what happened with that one is that it came from the sunward direction. So none of the telescopes could point in that direction because, obviously, you can't point the telescope towards the sun. And so we're we're sort of looking to tackle this problem from a couple different avenues. There's a a new telescope in the Southern

Hemisphere called the Vera Rubin Observatory that's set to dramatically increase the rate of asteroid discoveries. There's also a mission called NEO surveyor, which will be a space based telescope that NASA's building right now and hoping to launch in the next few years, which will hopefully try to detect these sort of sunward geometries from the Earth from a different vantage point in space. So maybe we can discover these jelly bins like objects. And in terms of size in general, yeah, it's this sort of tens of meters to maybe a 150 meter size range that we

still haven't discovered, most of them. So that's where the the next discovery, effort is is headed. Well, that's great. Thanks, Rahil. Thanks for coming on the podcast, and I'll put a link to, Rahil's paper, in the notes for this podcast. Best of luck with your research. Thank you. Thank you so much. That was the aerospace engineer, Rahil Macadiah.

Thanks, Rahil, for a fascinating conversation. Physics World will be at the APS Global Physics Summit, which will take place in March in Denver, Colorado and online. At the largest physics meeting in the world, you can join thousands of physicists, students, and policy leaders for a week of connection and collaboration. Explore cutting edge science shaping our shared future,

and be part of the global physics community driving innovation forward. Explore the meeting at summit.aps.org. And when you're in Denver, look out for us at IOP Publishing's booth at the conference exhibition. I'm afraid that's all the time we have for this week's podcast. I'm Hamish Johnston, and our producer is Fred Isles. Our theme music is called one three seven,

and it was composed and performed by the physicist Philip Moriarty. We'll be back again next week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Taking an atomic approach to silicon quantum computing

    Nov 19, 2026Audio

    Michelle Simmons of Silicon Quantum Computing is our podcast guest

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Probing advanced materials with time-resolved photoluminescence microscopy

    Nov 12, 202635 minAudio

    PicoQuant’s Emilio Gutierrez-Partida is our podcast guest

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Building an international research institute from the ground up

    Nov 5, 202638 minAudio

    Our podcast guest is founding director of the IBS Center for Quantum Nanoscience in Seoul

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. From catalysts to quantum materials: exploring the future of platinum group metals

    Oct 29, 202639 minAudio

    Marge Ryan of Johnson Matthey is our podcast guest

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Theorists use cloud-based Bose–Einstein condensate to study tunnelling

    Oct 22, 202625 minAudio

    Quantum experiment is controlled from thousands of kilometres away

    Credit the people on this episode