The Art and Science of Negotiation in Medical Affairs
32 minAudio
In this episode of "Pharma Sessions," host Jonathan Kaskey delves into the crucial topic of why negotiation skills are essential in the field of medical affairs. Joining him, Megan Vignos, Head of Scientific and Value Communications for US Medical at Biogen. Together, they explore the importance of negotiation in medical affairs, and how a scientific mindset can aid in building effectiveness. Megan emphasizes the significance of maintaining a positive relationship with complian... Pharma Sessions is hosted by Jonathan Kaskey Follow along on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jonkaskey/ Or join the Pharma Sessions Substack: www.pharmasessions.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02The framework that I went through in business school came from a book that was called Getting to Yes. One of the things they talk about is separating the people from the problem. It's not me and Megan arguing, we're trying to solve this thing up. And the problem is there's a limited pool of resources, and commercial wants it, and I want it, and clinical wants it, or whatever, right? But it's that's not a that's not a personal problem, that's just a situational problem.
SPEAKER_01Hello, hello, and welcome to pharma sessions where medical affairs professionals can come to learn from each other. Today we're exploring negotiation, a subject near and dear to my heart. My guest is Megan Vignos, the head of scientific and value communications for U.S. Medical at Biogen. Now, many people think of negotiation as something between a company and an outside party, like a vendor, and this is true, but what Megan and I discuss are the much more frequent internal negotiations that are absolutely critical to the success of a medical affairs organization.
SPEAKER_01Of course, the views expressed here are Megan and my own and don't reflect those of our employers. So with that said, I think the episode gives some great tools for you to carry into your day-to-day. And let's dive right in.
SPEAKER_02Today we're going to talk about negotiation and what that means for collaboration in medical affairs. Is that correct? Yes, that's the plan. All right, excellent. So before we even get into that, why is this a subject that interests you?
SPEAKER_00With Metafairs, a lot of times we are not well skilled in negotiation. And it actually is quite a big portion of our job. We do a lot of negotiating on the day-to-day. And I don't think people typically within Metafairs feel very confident about it. I know when I started my career, I certainly wasn't confident in negotiating. And I always felt like some of the partners that I was working with, whether illegal or sales, they were very good at negotiating.
SPEAKER_00And so I felt like a lot of times I wasn't being successful because I wasn't well practiced at it. And, you know, over my career, I've learned to really identify ways in which to improve my negotiation skills, which has not only improved the outcomes that I'm looking for, but also allows me to be a better collaborator because I can more um clearly express what it is I need to do my job and how it's going to impact cross-functional partners.
SPEAKER_02And so most people in Metafairs, a lot of them, MDs, Farm Bs, these are very hard skill focused trainings. Going through that, have you ever been offered a formal training on negotiation? Or is this kind of something you came to the own realization that I need this as a skill set?
SPEAKER_00It was definitely something I discovered along the way as I grassed within my career. I started out as a medical science liaison and working in the field with the field sales colleagues, you know, they do it almost every day with the physicians or whoever they're interacting with. And so a lot of times they were coming in saying, Megan, we need help in this area. And I found myself having to be like, how do I appropriately push back on these um individuals?
SPEAKER_00And then as I moved to an in-house role as an associate medical director and then a medical director, I just discovered I had more partners that I was negotiating with. It was just a little bit of a different way to negotiate. And so as I reached each level, I discovered negotiation was becoming more of a key aspect of my job. And so it was something that I just felt like I needed to work on to be able to be more effective and efficient with my roles.
SPEAKER_02And if you are interested in progressing to the next role, right? It's critical for that.
SPEAKER_00And it's critical to make sure that And to your point, a lot of us, like I have a PhD. A lot of us are very much trained in all of these various techniques and the science. And one of the things that I had to do was shift my mindset about negotiation and realizing that like it's not necessarily this battle, the other person that you can still remain friends at the end of the negotiation. But I actually took my science perspective and put it on negotiation, right?
SPEAKER_00So I started to think about it as the scientific method. What are the factors that I am trying to negotiate for? And then it's okay, I'm gonna test this. Am I gonna get this? Right. So asking finance, like, could I get this money for this publication? Right. And then when they're like, oh, yes or no, then I'm gonna test, okay, said no. Why is it a no? And then getting curious and asking further questions to understand why the no.
SPEAKER_00So then when I ask for the next factor and tested for that, I have a better understanding of why the initial thing was a no from finance or whoever that partner is.
SPEAKER_02And what you're talking about is a collaborative negotiation where the goal isn't necessarily to win, right? You're not buying a house where you're never going to see this person again, right? You might be working with this person for 20 more years. And in theory, everybody has the company, like everybody's trying to go towards the same goal. You might just have different perspectives on what's going to get you there. So I love that idea of having it as a conversation and understanding are we even anniversarial on some points, or at some points we're we're totally aligned, are those important.
SPEAKER_00Perfect example, right, is compliance, right? Or like, what do you mean this isn't compliant? Where's the risk? And that's a partner that you're constantly going back to say, would we try this? Can we do that? And that's where using that scientific method can be valuable because it's more about the curiosity of help me understand that risk so I can better apply it to future situations, right? Future things that I want to ask compliance for the ability to do. And so that's where if you're thinking of it as a battle, that adversarial, it's going to make your relationship with that compliance officer very difficult to move forward for the next ask.
SPEAKER_00And so you want to keep it in a positive way. And that's where I find, you know, that using the experimental method allows me to do that because I can be like, okay, what do you think about this?
SPEAKER_02Hurry more.
SPEAKER_00And being more curious about what the response was, why they were giving you that yes or that no.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So the framework that I went through in business school came from a book that was called Getting Yes. And it's one of those courses that stuck with me because it's so useful in like your day-to-day and everything. But one of the things they talk about is separating the people from the problem. And I think that is it goes a lot, that's aligned with what you're talking about, where it's not me and Megan arguing, we're trying to solve this thing. And the problem is there's a limited pool of resources and commercial wants it, and I want it, and clinical wants it, or whatever, right?
SPEAKER_02But if that's not a that's not a personal problem, that's just a situational problem.
SPEAKER_00Definitely. And I think that brings up some of the skills that are needed when it comes to negotiation. You talked about problem solving. You have to be able to problem solve on your feet to be able to go into a negotiation and be affected, right? Because things change over the course of the negotiation. But I think in addition to that, emotional intelligence, reading the other person and understanding how you know they're feeling, because if they have just gotten yelled at by their boss and now you're trying to negotiate with them, they might not be in the best place.
SPEAKER_00So if you can identify that and say, you know what? Can we take a five-minute break? I really need to quick go do something, like giving that person that space can help your negotiation be in a better place, right? Because they have that time, like calm down from whatever, that task meeting that's happened. In addition to that, active listening, a lot of times we think about, I just got to tell them what my side is. But you actively have to understand what's going on from their perspective as well to be able to be a better negotiator.
SPEAKER_00Because if you understand, okay, they're looking for more data to be able to speak to, then I can say, well, listen, I want to publish this data set. It would be something that you could use in the future, allowing me to have that money to do it is going to benefit you now in the next couple of months.
SPEAKER_02And that so that's a part of the negotiation that I think is really can be very helpful to the actual doing of the job, is in some ways for you to make a coherent argument, you need to really understand the value that you're going to be providing. And sometimes I found it see going into it, I'm like, yeah, this is obvious. And then we start talking, and it's like, oh, wait a minute, I'm trying to do one thing and they're they care about something completely different. I'll give an example just because that's very that's very general. But at one point in my career, I was working for a software company, and what we did was provided virtual advisory board services.
SPEAKER_02It was a platform for that. And I remember going into a conversation where my goal was to basically get to do a license for this. We'd had a million conversations, like, okay, time to either do this or not do this. And so my argument was the savings that they get on the technology side of things. And as we started having the conversation and turnout, they didn't actually care about that all. What they cared about was consistency across their global organization.
SPEAKER_02So price is obviously a part of it, but they I hadn't fully explained how this is going to impact people in Vietnam who might not otherwise have budget to fly everybody in and have these advisory boards. So I thought it was a really interesting example. I came in all prepared and with my spreadsheets and everything to talk about one thing and they didn't really care. They cared about something completely different. And we were able to solve it and do something that really worked for everyone.
SPEAKER_00And I think that's where you can be the best communicator in the world, but if you're not communicating to what the other side wants, you're never going to have the positive outcomes that you want. And so through that active listening, you were able to show, oh, okay, great. The finance piece is obviously always part of it. This is where we're going to provide you the most value because you'll get consistency across all of your global teams to be able to have a great ad board that, you know, is not inhibited in any way by technology.
SPEAKER_02This episode is sponsored by Structured Meetings. It's a Teams app that turns your own Teams instance into the perfect advisory board platform. Save money, get insights faster, and keep your data secure. Check it out at www.structuredmeetings.com. So do you have just thinking of the conversation in your journey from MSL to journal medical? Do you have any examples of conversations you've had either in the fields or in corporate that you'd be willing to share where this has been helpful or useful?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I would say in in-house, working with our legal and regulatory teams. So they, of course, are reviewing the materials that we're putting together and wanting to show out to external physicians and other healthcare providers. And a lot of times they are evaluating risk, right? Similar to a compliance officer, but they're trying to see what the FDA is going to think, right?
SPEAKER_00Or what are other partners, our agencies going to think. And so again, these are people that I'm going back to weekly over this piece, over that piece. And so I need to be able to have a collaborative interaction with them in order to get other pieces, future pieces out. And so one of the ways was, you know, they were uncomfortable with how a PowerPoint slide came up, right?
SPEAKER_00Was being curious about is it the slide itself, or is it where it sits within the deck that these MSLs would be presenting? And so not just being like, no, I need this slide. You can't take it away. It will help me understand how it is that this is a risk. And it came up that no, it was actually just where it was placed, because it was placed after something else that some efficacy data that made it seem like, oh, you're potentially saying it's more efficacious than it is.
SPEAKER_00Right. And so by talking with them and saying, could I put it in front of it or could I put it further back in the deck so it's no longer linked? There could be no association with that piece of advocacy. Then they were like, oh, we're more than comfortable with you keeping that slide. Right. And so then it was a successful negotiation because I was able to identify what is the real problem. So then problem solving on the spot of like, right, now I know this deck top to bottom.
SPEAKER_00Where can I put it where it's not going to be linked to that efficacy?
SPEAKER_02That's a great story because then it's also a short-term solution to allow you to present what you would want to present. But also the next time you go and you talk to that person, they're gonna be like, oh good, it's Megan. We worked through this. They didn't light me up for telling me that we didn't.
SPEAKER_00We didn't get into shouting that. Yeah, for sure.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's very good. What if this is just me being curious in the knowing about knowing that we're the position, sometimes they can ask for a lot of stuff. And I'm assuming that if you're an MSL and you're in a position where they are controlling your access to them, right? So they're in a power dynamic there that's not necessarily in the MSL's favor. Are do you find how does that work?
SPEAKER_02How do you deal with kind of standing your ground and negotiating for what you need for doctors and even something as simple as, hey, you said you were gonna be here, not here, right? And we have to drive three hours to go see you again. Can you talk through some of your negotiation experience in the Yes?
SPEAKER_00Well, an MSL has to be skilled at negotiation because, as you said, there is a bit of a difference in the power dynamic. And so I think that's where you as an MSL have to demonstrate your value to a physician, right? If you go in and you're just gonna chit-chat and do small talk with them, though that is nice. And you need to kind of have that ability to have those conversations as well. If you can't demonstrate how you are going to provide them value for their patients who have no leverage in your negotiation.
SPEAKER_00So that's key, right? But I think one of the things where I experienced that was I had a physician that was always late, always 20 minutes late to our meetings, or was canceling last minute. And it always just wreaked havoc on my schedule. As much as I tried to be accommodating for them and I tried to like keep that in mind when I was planning it. Okay, I'm gonna tell them 10, expecting 10:30, they'll show up, but it did.
SPEAKER_00It just caused a lot of havoc in my schedule. Like, well, now I have to book it to my next meeting, and it was always a challenge. And so that's where I asked the physician with that curiosity in mind of what are the things that are causing you to be late to our meetings? Is it because of the location? Or do I need to come to your office versus meeting you outside of the office because I can do that?
SPEAKER_00Or is it something where your schedule just always patient schedules are always a challenge? Should I meet you before you start meeting with patients? Or could I meet you at the end of your day and then the end of my day, and more likely for us to be able to meet together online? And so I think it's understanding where they're coming from and that what's reading to them not showing up or showing up late. And if it's somebody who is habitually not showing up, I think that's where demonstrating sometimes your values that you have provided to other clinicians and how that can impact them is another way of negotiating, right?
SPEAKER_00Because sometimes physicians aren't always clear on what an MSL's value is. Right. Sometimes even internally, they're not always clear what the MSL's value is, right? Oh, which is why they're always trying to find a new metric to measure us by. But I think that's where you can use some of your experience with other physicians to demonstrate the value that you've brought to them and how that can also play a role in the you bring value to this individual.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that's huge. And just thinking back through the negotiating framework that I had mentioned earlier, the getting to yes, one of the things they talk a lot about is this term Batna, which stands for best alternative to a negotiated agreement. And so in that story, when the physician is always late or no showing or canceling, to them, there's a negotiated agreement that I'm gonna meet Megan at 9 a.m. My alternative to that is just not show up, and then she's still gonna want to meet with me next week, and that's fine, because then that's completely on my schedule.
SPEAKER_02But what you're creating implying is saying one, there's value to this so that if you miss out, you're actually missing out. But also, the alternative to hearing to our negotiated agreement is not I'm just gonna continue to just keep acquiescing and show up whenever you want at your back and call. The position is you're no longer gonna have access to me. And in a nice way, we're gonna try to work through it, we're gonna try this, that, and the other thing. But what's wide is like we need to find a way to maintain our appointments, and that only works if they understand that they're getting value out of seeing you.
SPEAKER_02And the more value you're giving them, the more leverage you you have to stand your own and probably have a better conversation when you're actually in the room because seeing you as a peer and not as a subsurf.
SPEAKER_00Right, exactly. Yeah, which I think really defines the difference between medical and sales, right? Because a lot of times physicians just see oh, they're a pharma representative. But if you've really instrated that you are a peer and that you can have these high scientific conversations and really help them understand how to utilize the drug in a way that is going to be most effective for the most number of their patients, then you know they're more likely to meet with you.
SPEAKER_00It allows those negotiations to be that much easier, right? Um, but it also helps them separate this is the value that I'm getting from medical versus that subservient sort of situation that you get with sales. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So can I maybe switching gears just a little bit? Can we talk about the other type of negotiation? It's probably important to everybody listening, which is jobs and job offers. And right? Because that to me that feels a little different because that a lot of what you're talking about are is can we expand the pie, right? So everybody gets their slice and everybody's happy. But when you're coming for a job offer, at some point the pie doesn't get any bigger, and you just most people want to be paid as much as possible for the work that they're doing.
SPEAKER_02So do you think about that either career progression or literally negotiating salaries and things like that differently? Or how do you think about that?
SPEAKER_00A little bit different, but some general teams are gonna carry across. So the first thing is we often think, oh, maybe it, maybe you're negotiating with a boss, or maybe you're negotiating with HR. Depend each company does it a little different. When it comes to negotiating with your boss on that, you're still gonna see them day to day. And so you still need to be careful about how you go around negotiating because this individual is going to then have an impact on your career moving forward.
SPEAKER_00And so when it's your boss, keep in mind negotiating isn't a bad thing, right? And some people are like so afraid of oh, if I try. to negotiate, are they going to think less of me? But actually, I think it's the opposite because as we've already mentioned, negotiation happens throughout your role, whether you're an MSL, a medical director, anybody in Metafairs, negotiation is part of your role. And so if you can negotiate well and effectively through that offer situation, that your boss is going to say, wow, I can already see the value because they're great at negotiating.
SPEAKER_00They're going to be able to do this with all of the cross-functional partners that we touch, whether it's sales, legal and reg, compliance, RD, whoever it is, right? And so I think it can actually show your value even more if you negotiate through your offer. Now if it's HR, you might be thinking, I'm never going to see this person again. Be careful. That's not always true, right? Because people change companies and you might be negotiating with that same HR representative in a future situation.
SPEAKER_00Be careful. It may not be a one and done situation there either. But again, in that situation, you want to be prepared. Go in with kind of a prioritized list of what are the things you're going to ask for. Right. Often we think, like you said, let's get the most money that I can up front. But that might not always be an option because you might, they might already have you at the top of the scale that they do for that role.
SPEAKER_00Right. And so then you need to be prepared. What are other things that you're willing to ask for? Is it I would like to work from home two days a week and I'll go into the office the other three days a week. Or is it that you want more vacation days? Are you going to ask for a different benefit? So I think it's being thoughtful ahead of that negotiation to be aware of what are the asks that you're willing to put in a particular order.
SPEAKER_00So when you get a no for something like an increase in the salary, again being curious to understand why, oh, I'm already given the top level amount, then you can proceed with other aspects of what are factors that I want to get if it's not money.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I think then I love that approach. And for me, usually when I'm talking to people about a job, let's say recruit calls, right? Talk about it if it sounds interesting, one of the questions is okay, what's a salary range? They tell you. So it's like you were going to graph when you're interested in salary, it's a lot at the beginning and I'm assuming that sounds acceptable, then it's a lot then that interest in salary stops being so important. Now it's all about the job am I going to like it is it's going to be interesting, challenging, whatever your priorities are. And then at the end you care about salary a lot too.
SPEAKER_02So I think that for me it's like I am a big believer in transparency as part of this because since you've at least done a little bit of initial vetting on let's say the finance part at the beginning do you know that it's going to be equal or better or whatever it is. It's appealing enough that you're having the conversation. When you get to the end or when I get to the end you're I'm I don't think I've ever taken a job without negotiating. And I try to be like honest.
SPEAKER_02Here's the situation this is where I am this is where I'd like to be these are the things that are important. I mean not quite everything right everybody's got the same list but you bold a little bit a little bit in reserve not in a bad way but it's like okay if I'm asking for X and they come in$10,000 less maybe that's acceptable I say and you say okay that's great but I want as you said the work model or the vacation and then you're moved forward and again you're separating the person from the problem and just building trust throughout the process I think can be a way to set yourself up for a really good start.
SPEAKER_00Yeah and I think it's also being prepared before you walk in. So you know understanding what is the market dynamics, right? So you can speak to that. Because if you think they're undervaluing you, you can then speak to why you're asking for that additional$10,000 right. Here's what I provide you and why you've clearly identified me as an excellent candidate if you're offering me this.
SPEAKER_00Now let me tell you why you know that I'm even worth more than what you've seen so far. Right. And so sometimes you have to do a little bit of research ahead of time to prepare for that kind of conversation in the negotiation as well.
SPEAKER_02Sure I understand yeah I'm sorry my iPhone started talking serious traveling yeah I'm let me ask you one and so you are you know managing people what is your earscope or responsibility so do you provide them you're not not not a audio audio audio media but do you provide them with any type of formal training or skills building around negotiation?
SPEAKER_00Yeah it's one of the things that I do when I have my one-on-one time with each of my direct reports is that when they're giving me a proposal of a project that they want to put forth I actually do a little bit of negotiation with them. They I'll start asking them tell me what is the value of this? How is this going to impact right our end result. And so I don't necessarily tell them we're going to negotiate now.
SPEAKER_00I just start negotiating with and then after we've had a little bit of back and forth, then I might respond and say it might have been more effective if you had led with this or if you had demonstrated this to me. And so then I give them feedback on how our negotiation went after the fact. So I let them go come into the negotiation unaware that maybe that's what we're doing, but then give them the feedback afterwards on where could they have better communicated a point or where they should have thought about look at how my body language was saying I'm frustrated and you're fucking me right now with and how if they had evaluated that and come to me at a different time, if it's not an urgent negotiation, that they may have been more successful.
SPEAKER_00And so that's how I approach it with my direct reports is that I don't like to tell them that's what we're going to practice. I like to just put them in the hot seats and then coach them through it afterwards.
SPEAKER_02Right. The coaching was the word that I had in mind as you were describing it where you're they're practicing coaching and you're doing it continuously and regularly.
SPEAKER_00So it becomes and if you don't practice you're not going to get good at it. It just makes perfect and or at least near perfect. And so yeah it's something that you have to do on a regular basis. And also if I'm watching them you know negotiate in a situation I may step in if needed or I may coach them after the fact right because sometimes I want them to take a lead on on a negotiation or sometimes I bring them in so they can observe me negotiating.
SPEAKER_00And I may kind of tell them ahead of time watch how this unfolds so they are clearly tuned in this is Megan wants me to observe this aspect because maybe I see it as a an area of opportunity for them. Right. And so then I might be more direct with them about watch how we handle this situation.
SPEAKER_02Let's leave it there. This episode is sponsored by Structured Meetings. For listeners who don't know my background I'm a huge fan of asynchronous adboards. I used to work for the leading provider of async adboards and not to brag but my clients did more events than anyone else's. I've literally led thousands from the vendor side so I can humbly claim some expertise. One of the questions I used to get all the time was can we just do this in Teams? And the answer back then was not really Teams out of the box is clunky and not fit for purpose.
SPEAKER_02Structured meetings change that by creating an MS Teams app that lets you have these discussions in a really smart way in your own Teams instance. It changes Teams just enough to check all the boxes for what's needed for great ad boards. And also it's super fast and it saves people a ton of money. Visit www dot structuredmeetings dot com for more info. All right, back to the show.
Dr. Paul Peter Tak, President and CEO of Candel Therapeutics, sits down with Jonathan to discuss the company's sprint from positive Phase III results to commercial launch. They explore how Candel is redefining the...
In this episode, Jonathan sits down with Annel Duckels, who leads worldwide commercialization learning at Bristol Myers Squibb, to talk about modernizing pharma training through data and AI. Annel's unconventional path...
Pharma Sessions - ACTO Client Summit: Hallway Interviews At ACTO's 2026 client summit in Boston, we pulled some incredible minds out of the hallway for quick, candid conversations about where field excellence, AI, and...
What happens when you put blockchain underneath AI in healthcare? According to Archita Samant, Head of Data Strategy & Analytics for Global Vaccines at Merck - you finally solve the interoperability problem that's been...
What separates a good pharma sales rep from a great one? According to Jennifer Muszik, it's the ability to understand the question behind the question - the real need behind what a customer is asking. In this episode,...