Fun playground or toddler emergency room invitation? Melbourne parents are fiercely divided over a controversial new playground featuring... checks notes... giant rocks. Is this brilliant independent play, or have we officially reached peak chaotic parenting? We have thoughts. Plus, Monz and Stacey ran to see Toy Story 5 and what they witnessed was a brutal gut punch. Pixar took our greatest screen-time guilt and put it on a 90-minute tear that has us questioning how imagination can possibly coexist with addictive tech. Also, as some Australians demand child-free flights and resorts, Amelia asks the question: Is this really so bad? Support independent women’s media and get our biggest offer of the year. Subscribe here for 30% off your annual Mamamia subscription. Code applied at the checkout. Offer ends June 30. Reccos: Stacey is loving America’s Sweethearts: Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders on Netflix. Amelia recommends the Finlay bedazzle kit, a incredibly soothing $40 craft pack featuring 24 sparkle colours that you can use to transform sunglasses and notebooks with your child. Monz recommends dump bags, the ultimate dietitian-approved meal-prepping hack where you freeze all your raw ingredients in one Ziploc bag so you can just dump it straight into the slow cooker midweek. What To Listen To Next: Don't miss an episode of Parenting Out Loud The Birthday Post That Sparked A Sharenting Debate The Royal School Run Is Just Like Yours & What Kids Think We Do All Day The One Word You Need To Stop Saying & Were 90s Mums 'All That'? 'Crying Cafes' & A Mother-In-Law Red Flag Signs You’re A Beta Mum & How To ‘Bounce Back’ The School Holiday Rule & The Big Bluey Stuff Up The Holiday Decision One Mum Regrets & Party Bags Are Officially Cancelled Connect your subscription to Apple Podcasts What to read: 'I thought Toy Story 5 would be an easy family watch. It's a gut punch.' 'I've finally cracked the code to screen time, and it only took this one thing.' Think of the parents: 3 reasons taking your kid to playgrounds is an adult's worst nightmare. CLARE STEPHENS: A rude stranger, a note from a neighbour and the age of utter intolerance. GET IN TOUCH: Share your feedback! Send us a voice message or email us at podcast@mamamia.com.au Join our Facebook group Mamamia Family to talk about the show. Follow us on Instagram @mamamia_family CREDITS: Hosts: Monique Bowley, Amelia Lester & Stacey Hicks Acting Group Executive Producer: Sasha Tannock Executive Producer: Grace Rouvray Video Editor: Julian Rosario Associate Producer: Tessa Kotowicz Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land on which we have recorded this podcast. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Welcome to Parenting out Loud, the podcast for parents who don't really listen to parenting podcasts. We look at the trends and the news and the culture and try to make sense of the world through that parenting lens. I'm Monic Bowley, I'm a merely a least, and I'm Stacy Hicks.
Speaker 2And guys, before we go in here further, I need to give another sea monkey update. The listeners are obviously very passionate about this. It's obviously not just me. Let me tell you.
Speaker 1Yeah, Stacy once recommended sea monkeys.
Speaker 3Yes, something we'd.
Speaker 1Never heard of, but we loosely described as bacteria. Yeah, and we think it's basically a crop of shit, don't.
Speaker 4But this is an update for that listener who's very passive.
Speaker 2Yeah, that one listener who was not my mum, who was very passionate about this subject that I brought up.
Speaker 5No.
Speaker 2Look, I was imagining this little whimsical journey where they were going to turn into these like big sea monkeys like I remember from a kid, and I've somehow after it. All I can see in the little tank is the food. There's there's no one.
Speaker 6They've escaped.
Speaker 2I think I've I think I've killed the bacteria.
Speaker 6Or they've escaped.
Speaker 3Well, they're actually krill.
Speaker 2For anyone who didn't hear our original episode on it, they're a little crill. Or yes, maybe they've escaped and crawled out. Who I think gives me the Well, I think I'm just going to start again. I think I'm not giving up yet. I'm going to start again. I'm determined to.
Speaker 1You know what, they're the Ikea of pets. Like you, you think the idea of them is really good, you think it's going to be amazing. You have these grand visions and then the execution just ends up disappointing everyone I know.
Speaker 3But once it's done, it's great. So if I get it right, and I feel just like my ike address.
Speaker 6You're also just describing parents, it's so true. Done, it's great.
Speaker 2Yeah, Yeah, once you get it right, awesome. But the journey like not great. So yeah, I'm working on it.
Speaker 1I'm working on a life lesson for all coming up on today's show, a.
Speaker 2Tiny neighborhood act that is being credited with changing a generation of.
Speaker 6Kids, And I'm going to make the parents' case for child free spaces.
Speaker 1If you're planning on going to see Toy Story five these school holidays, Grab the popcorn and get ready for an existential crisis, because we have a scathing and honest and beautiful and essential review for first in case you missed it. Before we get to all of that, a Melbourne playground has gone viral this week because parents are divided over whether it's a brilliant example of risky play or a toddler concussion waiting to happen. So there's this Melbourne influencer, a Melbourne mum's influencer called Zenya Coval and
Speaker 1she posted this playground, which is giant rocks on wheels, with the caption, sorry, but what the hell is this?
Speaker 3It looks like a junkyard? It really does?
Speaker 1Yeah, it does. It was designed by engineer and artist Mike Houston. He's known for creating really risky, very unique creative playgrounds. And the comments were really interesting. So Zenyakovil in her sort of reel of this, she said, what am I missing here? Have I got something wrong? The top comment was miss g Funk and she said, teacher here, this is risky play. It's so important for child development. Not many opportunities for this now in our world. So it's great to see this playground. And my favorite comment,
Speaker 1and something we don't often see on social media comments, was this very reasonable comment from Handy with Scissors, who said, if it doesn't feel right for you, that's okay. Not every playground needs to be the same, and not every playground needs to be for everyone. Did you guys see this?
Speaker 4I didn't, but now that you've bought it up, it reminds me that there's a playground in New South Wales on the south coast of New South Wales which was once dubbed after it's opening a couple of years ago, Australia's most Dangerus playground. Yes, it's in the town of Barry and we love going there whenever we're in that area.
Speaker 6There's an interesting sign on the playground there.
Speaker 4It features a lot of very high structures to climb, and there's a sign that says it sort of makes the point that kids know their own limits, so if you actively assist them in sort of climbing onto something, you're actually putting them in more danger than if you just let them go forth on their own. And I feel like there's some metaphor in that for life. But I love it all the same.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, this looked pretty crazy on first glance, but you're right, like, ugh, I mean, I guess some boy mums would probably disagree with me. They probably have crazy kids that will fling themselves off just about anything. But you know, kids do kind of know. Ah, this is scary to me. I don't want to go any further than this. So maybe it's cool to have a bit more imagination at your playgrounds.
Speaker 4Yeah, I got all zen about it, but then I did a little bit of research and it turns out that the most common A cents for children being hospitalized ages five to nine is playground injuries. And that surprised me a little bit because five to nine is an age group where you think they're kind of aging out of playgrounds, and also that they might know a little bit more about gravity and how it works. But apparently not.
Speaker 2I would have thought it was all the two year olds with those weird sheer drops to the fireman's polls where they have no idea what to do.
Speaker 3Those have always scared me.
Speaker 4I feel like, once you start, once you stop cutting your kids grapes in half, that's when you really have to start watching them at the.
Speaker 2Big Yeah, and the article I wanted to bring up this week. It was in The Guardian and it really tickled me. It's about Dutch kids and it was saying that they are abnormally happy and healthy, and they were attributing a lot of it to this one annual ritual that they do every year in the Netherlands. I am going to butcher the pronunciation. I'm so sorry to any.
Speaker 3Of our Dutch listeners.
Speaker 2I said it about ten times before the record and it's still going to come out wrong. It's called a von fisth Darcy. Nope, it doesn't sound anything like that, but you're just gonna have to trust me. But it literally translates to four day evening walk, which is a cent is exactly what it is. So every summer, for four nights, all the kids in the neighborhoods where these are organized rock up at about five pm on foot or on their bikes and they go on either these five or ten kilometer excursions. So they're all set up for them and they go and just walk and make
Speaker 2friends and go to neighborhoods that they've never been to in their area before. And there's no like, it's not a race. There's no prize for winning, but they all get an award if they complete all four nights of this event. And it's fully run by volunteers. And now there's like seven hundred different locations across the Netherlands that do this, and they say it's amazing for kids, like the resilience of getting through it, the socialization that they get from it. They do it rain, hail or shine, so if it's freezing, you're still out there, you just go and do it. I just love it and think
Speaker 2we should have them everywhere. It's the coolest idea. It's so simple.
Speaker 1Do you guys ever, just go not again with the Dutch, like seriously, just it's so perfect. Stop rubbing it in. Like I don't know, I just get a bit bored of the Dutch. Yeah.
Speaker 2There was a few people in the comments actually being like, I don't think we can just say it's this. It's more just their general quality of living and that kids get to be kids there, like kids are allowed to do whatever, they're not kind of rained in in restaurants. I learn a lot about the Dutch reading this.
Speaker 1But you know, I do see the I see why this works, and this is why I've turned the worm on Halloween. I used to be really anti, but then watching kids roam the neighborhood have to go and be social with their neighbors. It's like that, but just the more wholesome, less capitalist version.
Speaker 4Yeah, Londs, I thought I had won you over on Halloween. You're not attributing your turn around on Halloween to me and my rhetorical gifts a podcast.
Speaker 1It was all you, Amelia. It was all you.
Speaker 4So I like to hear I have an Australian twist on this, which is that my kids have their athletics kind of all this week. I was really interested to talk to there was there were a couple of Americans at the athletics carnival and they made their point to me which I didn't realize. There's nothing like an athletics carnival in American elementary school.
Speaker 3Nothing what Nope, no shot put, long job.
Speaker 4There's no day where everyone goes and like runs around the track and has fun with their friends.
Speaker 1Because Amelia, we watched this on Grease Lightning Sandy watches the Watches the People, Kinnicky not Kiniki, the other one Peep Danny. Sandy watches Danny in.
Speaker 4Grece Month People run. In America, they compete in running races. They do not have an athletics carnival. What I mean by athletics carnival is a day on the school calendar where everyone goes to the oval and has a go and runs around the field together.
Speaker 1I mean, I knew America, but this is new level.
Speaker 4Yeah. And what they loved about it was this sort of ethos of having a go. Like in the US, if you're a good runner, yes, by all means you're running around the oval all the time. But for the average kid who's not necessarily going to become like a serious athlete, there aren't those opportunities built in in the school day to do a one hundred meter dash.
Speaker 3So that we can feel we have about that version.
Speaker 6We have the athletics kind of one.
Speaker 3Yeah, at least we've got something, Okay.
Speaker 1I ran to see Toy Story five when it was released really recently, and within nine minutes I texted this here show and I said, clear the decks, we need to talk about this because what I have just witnessed is a slap in the face. Now. I want to say straight off the bat, this movie is brilliant. It is beautiful and funny and gorgeous and well written. It is all those things that we know Pixi is right. I loved it. I gave it. I give it a
Speaker 1ten out of ten. But it is brutal in its approach to what they call tech. Pixar just took parents' greatest guilt and put it on this ninety minute tear with the Taylor Swift song at the end, which.
Speaker 6We'll get to.
Speaker 1And look, don't worry. I think in this chat we won't sort of give away spoilers, but I do want to kind of take you through some.
Speaker 4Of the plot good because I haven't seen it yet, so I will be the standing for everyone who hasn't seen it and ask you questions about it.
Speaker 2And I can quote every movie from one to four and soon to be five. So I hear a polar opposite.
Speaker 4I have never seen the two of you write more notes in preparation for a segment than this one.
Speaker 2Yeah, I raised home and wrote an article for Mma Mia Like I I was determined for everyone to hear my thoughts immediately.
Speaker 3So okay, much was my reaction.
Speaker 1Okay, So the basic setup is this For anyone that's not familiar with toy story the toy It always kind of circles the same question what happens when your child grows up and doesn't need you anymore? And in the past, the toys have always been threatened by other toys coming along, sort of newer and shinier toys, but this time the common enemy is what they call tech. So the basic plot is we're back with Bonnie, who's now the child looking after the toys, and she's having trouble making friends right, and the toys are trying to help her and her
Speaker 1parents witness this and notice that none of the kids Bonnie's age, which is about eight, play with toys anymore. They're all on devices. And there is this extremely evocative scene really early on in the movie which foreshadows what's coming. So Jesse, she's the cowgirl Amelia, she's sort of the lead toy of Bonnie's toy room. Now she goes to the neighbor's house to investigate why the neighbors won't play with Bonnie, and when she gets there, she's met with
Speaker 1this foreboding music. It's dark and all of these toys like a tiny toy apocalypse in the backyard. There's like toys discarded, toys are broken, toys are lost, they're forgotten about, right, and these toys are traumatized Amelia. And they warn Jesse that once tech invades a house, playtime is over. One of them whales, the age of toys is over.
Speaker 6Oh my god, this is making me really upset.
Speaker 2It's somehow more upbeat than Mon's is describing it, but it is.
Speaker 3It is very confronted.
Speaker 1It's it's a lot of drama. One of them says, once tech invades your home, you're dead where you lie. And then the camera shows the neighborhood kids glued to screens, and then it pans out across the neighborhood to all of these glazed over, dead eyed children, just gripped by the blue light of a tablet. And Jesse says, no wonder she can't make friends, Bullseye. She's the only one out there playing with toys. So confronting, confronting. But Bonnie's parents,
Speaker 1who are well meaning, well meaning, worried parents, decide to help in the way that they think they can, and they buy her a device, and that is the inciting incident, and that's when things take a turn Stacy, when Bonnie receives her device lily pad. What did you notice?
Speaker 2It is that classic thing that you see And I could feel the energy shift in the cinema. I could feel parents on either side of me like wanting to melt into their chairs because Bonnie suddenly like zonked out, slack jawed, hiding under the sheet so that she can play for a few more minutes. The toys are literally to the wayside, looking at her as they kind of fade in the background, because she's just not paying attention to them anymore. She's obsessed with this what they call lily pad, which is essentially a tablet. And as you said,
Speaker 2that scene mons where it goes over the neighborhood and there's just all these kids on screens, it really did feel like a call to parents of we all need to stop this now, tell them to put the tablets down and let your kids be little.
Speaker 4That's how it fell. So for parents, this is kind of a gut punch, And I think that's what you said, Yeah, pease, yeah, what are the children in the audience, how are they receiving this, this lily pad, the entry of lily Pad? Are they feeling? Do you think like covetous, like, are they like, oh, finally a device.
Speaker 2Well, they've been seeing lots of videos pop up on TikTok of people when they got home from seeing the film with their kids, And there was one kid who hadn't and a tablet that looked like the tablet even with the green cover on it, and he ran and threw it in the copboard and closed the door like he was like ugh that things.
Speaker 6So kids are sort of understanding the message. I think. So this is making them jet in the eye. I think so.
Speaker 3But it's funny.
Speaker 2It is one of those classic what Toy Story does so well and has done in every single film that there's been, is that there is like a message running parallel for parents with the message running parallel for kids. So I think for a lot of kids on the surface, they're just watching Jesse and Bullseye go on these big adventures and you know, take off to this property in this place and seeing what's of there's like a hundred buzzers. It's like a subplot the story, and I think that's what they're seeing. But I think to justify a fifth film, they had to make a stand on something.
Speaker 1Oh it's brilliant, and it's like brilliant.
Speaker 3I love that they went rare.
Speaker 2I love that they did this when they could have just existed in magical toyland where time doesn't exist and tech doesn't exist.
Speaker 6But it might be brilliant, But how did you feel leaving?
Speaker 4Because to me this sounds not uplifting, like how did you feel when you left the cinema?
Speaker 1So I will say it's not all this, Amelia, No, we are focusy, we're honing in because this felt so prominent in my mind when I was watching it. But there are other themes of friendship and resilience, and there are other themes through the movie. I will say though, during the movie, I texted my husband who was at home, and I said, put the iPads in the shed and hide them. But what it did in my house is actually the opposite effect, where it reminded the kids how great playing with the device is, and now every day they're.
Speaker 3Like, mom, can I have the iPad?
Speaker 1So it's done the opposite thing in my house. But I think what is so interesting about this is what you were saying before. Stacy Pixar could have towed the line on this. They could have gone halfway and gone, oh, you know, Tech's not that bad. But they didn't. It feels to me like they went.
Speaker 3The whole hog.
Speaker 1I wrote notes furiously when I was in there, and here's one that I would just want to read to Amelia.
Speaker 2Oh god, Mon's was one of those people with their phone on the whole time.
Speaker 1Yep, I was. At one point, Jesse, the lead toy, calls Woody. You remember Woody. He's not in the house anymore. He's off rescuing other toys. And she says Tech has arrived. And these are the words that she uses to describe lily Pad. She looks like a frog, but really she's a leech, sucking up all of Bonnie's attention, making her stare at a screen all day. And I think what they did with the animation is really interesting too, Like
Speaker 1when that first moment that Bonnie, who's only ever played with toys, she's a pure eight year old that has never even looked at a screen, when she gets given the lily Pad by her mum, the mom says, okay, so you can take the day to get to understand how to use it, and then from there and it becomes all muffled and her eyes glazed overilling and it yes extremely evocative.
Speaker 2And when Bonnie is playing with the toys, everything's really pastal and fun and light like they actually use like a different variation of animation to differentiate between the two worlds, which was so clever as well, like that where it's existing in their mind.
Speaker 4One question I have for you is, I feel like there's already a lot of guilt out there in the culture directed at parents for sort of giving their kids tablets. Do you feel like the message here was perpetuating that guilt and shame or was it more about, hey, we've got to collectively get together.
Speaker 2Well, I feel like it stopped short of humanizing it all together like this. This isn't a spoiler of any major plot points, but in the end, it's kind of like when all of the toys bend together, they're able to save the day, you know. And we kind of see Bonnie towards the end using the tablet in a way that kind of works harmoniously alongside the toys, So she's getting to kind of still be young for a little bit longer. But it is their present, and I think that that is realistic for what we're all grappling
Speaker 2with Like the numbers are pretty huge. Like for the article I wrote, I was looking around because I was like, how many kids by that age have a tablet?
Speaker 6Really?
Speaker 4Age?
Speaker 3Yeah, age eight?
Speaker 2My daughter's five and doesn't have one yet, but I can very much feel that that's like coming down the pipeline. And it's eighty four percent of children in eight to twelve are using social media or messaging and eighty six percent have smartphones.
Speaker 3And that figures from twenty twenty four, so it's probably even US Australian.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's from the Safety Commissioner, So it's you know, it's very present in everyone's life, so it probably would have been hard for them to ignore it.
Speaker 1I think, what's Stacy, Do you think that the demonization of tablets in this in the first half is unfair? Because I think there are some value in this, right, it's play, but it's just a different kind of play. Is it anti tech? Like a kid's really losing something? Or are we just playing different now because it doesn't look like the way that we played in our childhood. Like a lot of these kind of devices have educational benefits.
Speaker 2Right, Yeah, And I think that's what they were trying to show like at one point in one of the scenes, Jesse says something to the tablet and she regurgitates it back in three different languages, like they're kind of playing with the fact that there is so much that tech does for our children now, and there is so much available to them that they're receiving. But it's I guess it's just posing that question. It's not giving us an answer. It's posing the question of how do we have these things alongside one another when tech is often so addictive.
Speaker 1I think the tension is between the real world of play yeah, as superior and the digital world as inferior. Because you're right in that scene when lily Pad first comes into the toy room, Jesse says, right, I'm going to go up there and tell her how things are run around here. Lily Pad completely in the first five seconds of Jesse saying, Hey, I want to talk to you, lily Pad starts scrolling her own page and Jess's like, hey, you're not even listening to me. She's like, yes, I am, I'm listening, parrots back to it what she says, turns
Speaker 1it into another language, turns it into rap song. And then when Jesse says, hey, listen, we're just trying to make Bonnie some friends. Lily Pad clicks three buttons and makes a friend in fifteen seconds, and all the toys are like, oh, we've been trying to make her a friend all summer and you just did it in like fifteen seconds. And then there's this tension of Jesse saying, yeah, but that's not a real friend. A real friend would be here in the room right now, playing with us, like this isn't friendship. Just connecting across the screen isn't friendship. So I thought that was really interesting too. They're trying
Speaker 1to show all sides of it, but they've really got their foot in the firmly in the camp of imaginative plays so important.
Speaker 4It's so interesting that we're at such a juncture of change and fear around an anxiety around technology. I'm thinking of The Devil was prior to to which felt like a gut punch to me. That's so much for someone who works in media. It was so much about how technology is disrupting media, and now we have a movie about how technology is disrupting childhood and zooming out even further, going to the movies used to be about escapism, but
Speaker 4this is where we're at. Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, look, I think it plays in two levels. I still found myself sobbing multiple times throughout this movie because it was so touching and laughing out loud. It's funny how it was able to do all of those things. And I do love that they did it because they could have just left this alone.
Speaker 6Can we talk about the tailor swift of it all ones?
Speaker 5Yes?
Speaker 1Yes, I was spent the whole time waiting with one year cock for Taillerswift's song. When's it going to come in? Stacy? Do you want to reveal when the Telesfift song enters?
Speaker 4Yeah, it's the closing credits and that's it. That's it, And does it work? Does it sort of fit in? Like in terms of the narrative.
Speaker 3I think we're going to have different opinions on this. I bloody loved it. I loved it being at the end.
Speaker 1Look it felt tacked on to me. I'm sure it was lovely, but look, I think I don't want to deter anyone from going to see this film.
Speaker 3No, absolutely not unbelievable. Yeah, I just.
Speaker 1Want you to know that you will be you may have an existential crisis in the seat and that's okay, that's what work grap with. It's just going to be up on the big screen for you this time.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2I think it was a I think it was a really good reminder for us all to be honest. As more Australians are embracing a child free life, some of them are also demanding child free spaces. I know this is controversial. I know as a parent I should hate this idea, but I happen to think that the child free advocates are making some good points. SBS Insights spoke to some child free Australians recently on this topic on an episode called No Kids.
Speaker 6No Problems.
Speaker 4I'm going to let two of them present their arguments here because they thought they were very well done. This first woman that you're going to hear from is a fifty four year old Brisbane business owner. Her name is Tanya Williams, and she loves travel and she knew from an early age that she didn't want children.
Speaker 7Absolutely every single time that I can.
Speaker 1For sure, Okay, why is that I like to go.
Speaker 7On holidays and relax by the pool and you drink champagne or cocktails or whatever it is. And when you've got screaming kids, kids jumping in pools or just causing havoc, and parents who often don't chastise them and let them do whatever they want, it's very annoying and inconsiderate to other people in the resort. And look, I remember being at a place in Kingscliff a few years ago and I was having a nice relaxing massage and I could hear these kids screaming and yelling and carry on by the pool and nothing was done. And it's the same on a plane. Look, it's very annoying. And I've actually
Speaker 7experienced this today traveling down here of a kid screaming its head off. Thank god it was a short flight, but it is hard. If I did the same thing, I'd be kicked out of somewhere. And I understand that they're children, you know, I understand that, But when you know we're on a.
Speaker 6Holiday, I call it going away.
Speaker 7With opk's other people's kids. I understand everyone wants to travel, but if I see family friendly, I'm like, I'm not booking there.
Speaker 4So that's Taniel Williams. And then this is a second different perspective. Still wanting child free spaces, but for different reasons from a Melbourne based content creator. Her name is Julia Datt. She is in her thirties.
Speaker 5I think it's quite problematic, especially as a neurodivergent woman. I have AUDHD. You know, a screaming child in a plane, we are going to experience it very differently in terms of panic attacks and our fight or flight is often triggered by sustained screaming yelling, and it's a very different experience to what a mother who's maybe a little bit desensitized to it. And this is something that sorely needs to be addressed.
Speaker 1Would you support adults only.
Speaker 5Flights unequivocally absolutely. I think it's very important for people to have a sense of comfort and a sense of safety while traveling, and now we need to not default too family friendly being the automatic right of way.
Speaker 4Mon's I heard an audible sigh from you there. Can you give us your immediate reaction?
Speaker 1Yeah, So, on one hand, I agree if you want a child free space, that's your right. Absolutely, go and pay for it and get it. They exist out there because there's obviously a market demand for it, and so that's your choice. And I think what's interesting about what the second speaker says there, Julia Datt, is that she centers herself in that and says, you know, I'm a eurodivergent woman and I can't handle this. But she doesn't consider that the children may also be eurodivergent or may
Speaker 1not be comfortable, you know. She says, we want a sense of safety and comfort when we travel, so to children, and they often act out or cry because they don't feel that. I just I really, I think it's a slippery slope.
Speaker 3I don't.
Speaker 1Yeah, on one hand, I agree with what they're saying, but on the other hand, I think it's such the thin end of the wedge of where is this going to go.
Speaker 4It's confronting to listen to those perspectives, and that's why I wanted us to hear them directly from women who would like this.
Speaker 6Yeah, what do you think I mean?
Speaker 2Tanya's was the one where I was going. Yes, Tanya, I would also love to be child. She wants the cocktails and the relaxing. I understand. I would also want to be there if I wasn't with my child as well. But I think there can be a difference between wanting them not to be children there and wanting permissive parenting around you. Like it's sounding like if someone's letting their kids jump in and splash all over her while she's at the bar, Well, that's a that's a parenting problem, and that's just being a considerate human.
Speaker 3It's not you know, anyone can be.
Speaker 1A splashing children are going to splash and squeal at a swimming pool.
Speaker 6Yeah yeah.
Speaker 4I worry a bit about distinguishing between those things because to me, Tanya's expectations around children were not necessarily aligned with what's developmentally even appropriate or realistic expect You're so right, like they are going to squeal, they are going to a time.
Speaker 3Yeah yeah, but.
Speaker 2I mean lots of people who aren't children do annoying things. People you know, sneeze.
Speaker 3Really loudly, on talk really loud.
Speaker 4They're like, it's about being commanded and notoriously good at drinking a lot and not being anti.
Speaker 3Social exactly exactly.
Speaker 2So it is a very it's a very tricky one because where does this end, Like what other types of people are we allowed to be Like, Oh, I don't want to be around them.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's so true. I thought if we flipped this to old people, and we said, I don't want a holiday with old people around. You know, they walkers get in the way, and I don't want to look at their wrinkly faces, and they're slow and they take a long time at the buffet. You can't say those things because that's agis, and yet we accept it about children. Seems crazy to me, But I think this also speaks to the fact that we're so used to curating everything now. We curate our playlists and our shopping lists and our personal spaces, and we get We're not used to inconvenience,
Speaker 1and we're not used to being irritated or being uncomfortable like we have been in the past. And I think that it speaks to that it's like now or can I curate the humans around me because they also kind of make me uncomfortable.
Speaker 4Okay, look, I agree with both of you, but I want to advance the case for these spaces just to sort of stress test it with you. And this is a parent's case. I heard Tanya and Julia's perspectives and I thought, I don't want to put my children in a space with you where it's going to lead to a hostile or at best, awkward situation, you might reprimand them in ways that I don't appreciate or want. There might be some tension that I'd prefer to live without,
Speaker 4and I sort of wanted to myself, maybe it wouldn't be such a bad thing if we siphoned off the people who truly are not tolerant of children into their own space.
Speaker 2That's so right, because a lot of the stress that comes with parenting in public spaces is that you're being conscious of the people around you. And if you knew that the people who were particularly bothered by it were able to kind of have their piecelswhere and that the people that were there were pretty okay with whatever your kids were doing, you're right, Like that takes so much pressure off the situation and makes it better for everyone, right.
Speaker 1Mind's no, Well, I think it solves a short term problem. And I think that, like, as we say it, if there's demand for it and the market provides, and what's the harm? But I think the harm is like more existential. If you like, zoom right out. If quiet and comfortable and child avoidant places like you know, you know what's quiet and comfortable and child avoidant first class on a plane, but that's also a premium product. And then so what it does is separate people into premium quiet luxurious You
Speaker 1have to be wealthy to be able to afford that kind of quiet, to be able to pay for that quiet, and then everyone else is kind of pushed down into the noisy, leftover spaces, and so like philosophically, families kind of get devalued in that sense.
Speaker 4That's a great point. Whenever I travel on a plane, I notice that the men in suits tend to turn left when we get on the plane, and the mothers and kids tend to turn right and go to the back of the plane. And so basically, like there's a gender element to what you're saying two months in that the quiet, luxurious spaces are spaces where there tends to be men. And then you know, actually privilege and well, yeah,
Speaker 4and that tends to be a male domain. Julia Datt actually even said in her answer mothers are more used to this, so they can put up with it. Meanwhile, the mothers are kind of confined to the smelly back of the plane near the toilets.
Speaker 2Yeah, like I don't want to be pushed in with all the other extra kids either, like, can't we just have like a cross section of society altogether.
Speaker 6It's just that's some crazy thing.
Speaker 2Yeah, I just think it's so important for kids to be around people that want them around, but also people we don't want them around.
Speaker 3Like, isn't that how we learn to function everyone?
Speaker 1It's true, it is.
Speaker 4I guess we have to also be less sort of finely tuned into the slight irritation or displeasure of the people around us who may or may not understand what is even.
Speaker 6Appropriate for a kid.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4Julia also mentioned in there that mothers are desensitized, or they tend to be desensitized to their kids cries. I don't think you ever really get used to your child crying. But what I will say is that there is no sweeter sound for me on a plane than hearing another child crying because it's not your responsibility.
Speaker 3I mean, that's the same anywhere.
Speaker 2Right, We're talking a lot about planes, but I feel like this is anywhere. This is at a park, this is everywhere that we go a restaurant, Like, when would it end this separation?
Speaker 1I think, like something you said before, Stacy, like children need public life to understand how to be in public it's understanding patients and manners and turn taking and these kinds of things. But adults also need public life to remind themselves how.
Speaker 6To be those things as well, Like.
Speaker 1We need to use public life to practice virtues like generosity, forgiveness patients, like how often do you see someone doing something that makes you uncomfortable? And the first thing we do is go off. You know, this is the worst day of my life because we've become so unattuned to discomfort. So it's both sides of the coin. Like kids need to step up and learn public life too, but I think adults do as well. All Right, philosophy a side. Existential crisis is aside. It's now time for the practical part of the show, where we bring you our great hacks,
Speaker 1our great recommendations, things we've watched or seen or done, and we want you to try as well. Stacy, what have you got this week?
Speaker 2I am currently watching the third season of America Sweethearts, Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders.
Speaker 3Okay, this is our.
Speaker 4Ven diagram, Yes, TV we love. I loved the first two seasons. I am scared to watch the third because Netflix shows often fall off a cliff in the third season.
Speaker 3I was worried too. It's great and it's quite different to the first two.
Speaker 1Yes, Monsie, are the two women the leaders of the Dallas Capalchilles. Are they still there? Like the evil twins to evil Ladies?
Speaker 3Yes?
Speaker 6And Australian I've heard rumor.
Speaker 2Yes, yeah, So faith Ward is Australian and she's the first Well she's actually technicality, she's actually born in New Zealand but lives in Australia.
Speaker 3So now I just claimed her.
Speaker 2It's like yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, we're taking her as ours. So she's the first to get through to the training camp at that level, any Australian to get through. But what's so different about this season is by the time the first season came out last time, they were already recruiting for what we see in the second season. So essentially those first two seasons existed in a bit of a pre Netflix before all of the hysterias around the.
Speaker 4Show me So has it become too matter? Because everyone knows how big it is, So.
Speaker 2Now a lot of it is about how big it is and how they're dealing with that, and how race everyone's favorite Reese from season one, how she's coping with that because they're like on the Jimmy Fallon Show at Times Square performing for the morning show like they are everywhere they do a live show. I mean, it's cooked to watch, but it's so fascinating. Okay, So mostly it's that it's that that they're now trying to decipher who is there because they want to be part of this, and who is there for fame because they want.
Speaker 1To be on a show, so hit the reality show to.
Speaker 2Be yes, So then they're trying to figure that out. At the same time as they're trying to figure out who's going to be in the team. There's also the most amount of veterans returning, so there's very few spots, so it's like who will get spots?
Speaker 4Why would any veteran leave now exactly watching exactly.
Speaker 2So they're clinging onto their spots for dear life. I think there's only six or eight spots, but they've got about twenty girls that they whittle it down to that they're putting through all of this. I mean, it's still just as cooked as the first season. I can't believe so much of what goes on and the reasons, like someone's five centimeters too short and that automatically cuts them out even though there's no actual height requirements for the role. But also the most interesting thing, I think the fame has gotten to Kelly Kelly Finlass, Who's she's the southern
Speaker 2woman that runs the team. Why what's suddenly we're getting Casey musk Graves is a guest judge and.
Speaker 3What's her name?
Speaker 6Is the weather Man still a judge?
Speaker 3No, sadly he wasn't fair. I know Casey's there.
Speaker 2And then Charlotte Tilbury, the Charlotte Tilbury and makeup artist, shows up on makeover day and there's like branded placement of her products. It's it's just so funny to watch. It feels like it's a different universe than it was in the.
Speaker 1First Are they still doing the Thunderstruck song? Oh yeah, oh yeah, they're still all having hip replacements because it's a split jump.
Speaker 6Yes, oh they.
Speaker 2Are, Like their injuries are brutal. They're twenty five and getting hip surgery. Like what they go through for this is crazy. But I just think it's so fascinating to watch.
Speaker 1I love Do you watch it with your daughter? No?
Speaker 3No, I would add.
Speaker 2And that's the thing I think that's also why it's fascinating. I was like, I would not let my daughter near this with a ten foot pole.
Speaker 2It's also does she look over the ponytail and is the uniform sitting right? And that will be the reason we cut her. I like it's it's a bizarre it's a bizarre diconomy, but I love it.
Speaker 3What's this week, Amelia?
Speaker 6Well, we're all.
Speaker 4Very on brand this this week with our recommendations because I.
Speaker 6Have a craft, you know, I love it.
Speaker 3I love your craft.
Speaker 4I'm not good at them, to be clear, but I enjoy them. This is the Finlay Dazzle Kit. It is twenty dollars from the Findlay website. I have never been dazzled before. I assumed it was beyond me. Frankly, like, it looks complicated, but the kit is great.
Speaker 6You get twenty four.
Speaker 4Different colors of sparkles. You get a pickup pencil, a super glue and a tray. Okay, and I and my six year old daughter figured it out.
Speaker 3So what are you be dazzling? Exactly like your phone case.
Speaker 4Yeah, we've done notebooks, We've done sunglasses and I want to do photo frames next.
Speaker 1I'm so jealous.
Speaker 4It is so soothing. She may have gone to bed. I may have popped on a podcast. I may have continued for dazzling. I love it's kind of like the new coloring. This feels like coloring coloring. It's new coloring soothing.
Speaker 3Okay, I'm going to get one on.
Speaker 1Oh well, I'm just going to bring the tone down and give you both a practical midweek dinner. Have you have you heard of a dump back? No, such an unfortunate name. My friend is a dietitian and she told me about this. What it is is you take you do like meal prepping. Stay with me, Stay with me. It's worth it, Okay. As someone who hates cooking, the dump bags has been really great for me. And you dump all the ingredients that you're going to need in one ziplock bag, You zip it up, you put it
Speaker 1in the freezer, and then the day before you're going to cook it. The idea is then on the day you're going to cook it, you just open it and dump it into the slow cooker and it all cooks it once.
Speaker 3Yeah, you all one pot stuff.
Speaker 1Did the French call it mess on place, oh, something like that, something that sounds more fancy than dump bag essential premise. So on Sunday, I dumped six meals in one go and now I have six, so I feel very smug. I now have six nights of meals ready to go in these dump bags in the freezer. So you can just google dump back best dump bag recipes and get on it. It's dietian approved.
Speaker 4Love it from the woman who brought us Fluffing your Christmas tree. Yes, now, dum dump your dinner.
Speaker 3Love it.
Speaker 1I didn't want to bring this up, guys because we're still in June, but the Christmas Mum's Australia Sace Stop group is lighting up.
Speaker 6It is not it is.
Speaker 1People have started. It has begun. Their little jingle bells are belling. All right, that is all we have time for today. Thank you for spending your weekend with us. If you're off to the movies, good luck, if you're dumping things in bags, if you're bedazzling, whatever it is. We hope that you've walked away today with something valuable, and thank you for listening and sharing this show. By the way, it's growing fast and we're astonished. So if you're not yet following it, probably a good time to do that. You just hit the little plus sign in your podcast app and that's like a thumbs up to us,
Speaker 1and it helps more people kind of discover the show.
Speaker 3We need it, we love it.
Speaker 4Can I give a quick shout out also to subscribers, We love them best of all. Look, if you give us a thumbs up, that's good. You subscribe even better. And I just want to mention that there's an end of financial year sale going on where you get thirty percent of an annual Muma mea subscription, which is our biggest discount yet.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's massive.
Speaker 4You unlock everything we make, Stacy, you know all the things.
Speaker 6Yes, we make here. How do we make it all? But like little elves inside?
Speaker 2Yes, And there's lots of like a lot of people just think it's the podcast. There are so many exclusive articles on the website too, Like our best articles get put behind that payball for subscriber Campbell is behind the paywall. There is so much good stuff that is kept just for this.
Speaker 4And also Move the exercise includes move walk.
Speaker 3Yeah, so you can listen to us while you're walking. What a delight.
Speaker 4I didn't even know this, but you get exclusive discounts at Brandsake, Nala andand Threads. I need new sheet plus automatic entry to subscribe it giveaways.
Speaker 6Yeah, it sounds great.
Speaker 2Yea.
Speaker 3So you don't do anything. You don't have to enter the competition. You're just in the competition already, so it's like a girl way to win.
Speaker 6Well you that's good.
Speaker 4So just to subscribe to you to click the link in the show notes and the code the discount code for the thirty percent off will be applied at checkout.
Speaker 3Nice.
Speaker 6I've got to add that the offer ends June thirty, which is the day after my birthday.
Speaker 4So if you've got if you want gift ideas, I'm already that doesn't work very.
Speaker 3Well, but get you home.
Speaker 4You know how the king celebrates his birthday. This is for my birthday, get a mom and maya subscription share.
Speaker 6That's all grandios?
Speaker 2Is that?
Speaker 6I don't think that's grandios? So it's fine. Yeah, And next week we get a day off. You will do a stamp and a day off.
Speaker 1All right, Well you've heard it. The gift of the year for Amelia Last's birthday is a Mummy subscription. Christmas Mum's Facebook group will be going off. I'll we loving it. Thank you again for spending time with us. That's all we have time foreign parenting out loud. We will talk to you again next Saturday. Mummy acknowledges the traditional owners of land on which we have recorded this podcast.
Eight mums went on a girls' trip and answered a simple question: who's watching your kids? Oh dear. The internet was not happy. Meanwhile, Amelia's noticed something in baby advertising: umm...the babies are missing....
Ever get petty revenge on your kids? Parents everywhere are confessing their own acts of petty parenting. Mean? Or just good resilience building? Stacey is questioning the friendship lie we were all sold by Friends and...
Noah Wyle just kicked the hornet’s nest by declaring that boys are tougher to parent than girls... at least at first. Stacey Hicks, Amelia Lester and special guest Grace Rouvray get into the conversation about whether...
A three-year-old soccer star, a viral video and cops called to the sidelines. What on earth has happened to parents at kids' sport? Amelia brings us the story that's divided the internet, while Monz makes a passionate...
Just when you thought the summer school holidays couldn't get any longer, one Australian school has announced it's finishing up next year in NOVEMBER. Yes, November. Cancel Christmas. You'll be too busy organising...