A 20-second clip of a mum carrying a baby, a backpack, and three trays of food had millions of strangers screaming “LEAVE HIM”. Is it the parenting equivalent of the Coldplay viral video? Also, we regret to inform you there is now a name for husbands disappearing into the toilet for suspiciously long periods: weaponised pooping. Also, if parenting feels impossibly hard right now, it's not your fault. We unpack the speech about Australian parenthood that had parents crying with relief, and the three changes that could actually make family life easier. Reccos: Stacey recommends the playlist; Chessy's denim shirt in The Parent Trap also her own; Girly pop songs that make you want to kick a door down Amelia recommends Group Chat by Zoë Foster Blake Monz's thanks you all for the vacuum help AND recommends a Digital Calendar to sort your family's life out. Plus, check out the Parenting Out Loud newsletter. What To Listen To Next: Don't miss an episode of Parenting Out Loud The World’s Worst Kid's Party & Is This The Gold Standard Divorce? Why You Should Cancel That Playdate & We Have Oreogate News Rent-A-Nana & Can Meghan Rebrand Motherhood? Where Have All The Rissoles Gone & “Who’s Your Least Favourite Relative?" What's Wrong With A Wine Playground & Is The Oreo Mum Even Real? Connect your subscription to Apple Podcasts What To Read Next: I’m the Mom in That Viral Giants Clip. Let Me Tell You About My Husband. 'With a 20-second clip, the internet turned on my husband. Here's what really happened.' Millie Bobby Brown just became a mum again. What she shared about motherhood is beautifully raw. Georgie Dent just said the quiet thing about being a working mum out loud. Get access to Very Peri, Mamamia's exclusive perimenopause series, for just $59. 25 world-leading experts, over 20 on-demand sessions, available now. We’ve sorted through the noise so you don't have to. Go to veryperi.com.au and join me today. You hot? Same. Buy today and save 40% GET IN TOUCH: Share your feedback! Send us a voice message or email us at podcast@mamamia.com.au Join our Facebook group Mamamia Family to talk about the show. Follow us on Instagram @parentingoutloud CREDITS: Hosts: Stacey Hicks, Amelia Lester & Monique Bowley Video Editor: Matt Perry Associate Producer: Tessa Kotowicz Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land on which we have recorded this podcast. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Welcome to Parenting Out Loud, the podcast for people who don't always listen to regular parenting podcasts. We're not like those ones. You're not going to hear about hair knits here. Instead, we like to take the news, trends and culture and kind of unpick it all and give you a little rundown on what parents are thinking about this week.
Speaker 2I'm Monique Bolley. I'm Amelia Lester. And I'm Stacey Hicks. And coming up on today's show, there's a viral clip that made millions of people urge a new mum to leave her husband, but we'll tell you what you didn't see.
Speaker 3And what's the perfect age to have a baby? One celebrity mum on the younger side is sparking lots of debate.
Speaker 1And why modern parenting feels impossible. The speech that was absolutely everywhere this week and why it had me just crying with relief.
Speaker 3But first, you've heard of the lion, the witch, and the wardrobe, and the way that a group of adventurous kids find a portal out of their everyday existence through the back of a cupboard.
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 3Well, men have a portal of their own out of domestic life, and it's called the toilet. Okay. The Substack of the Happenstance introduced me to the term weaponized pooping this week.
Speaker 2So good.
Speaker 3Now, the author, Olivia Howe, she is American. She does use the term pooping. I'm aware that poo versus pooping, there's a lot of strong feelings about that, but I'm going to go with the author's term, weaponized pooping.
Speaker 2We'll just have to deal with it. We'll just have to deal with it. Because that really gives me the ick.
Speaker 3Hal writes, the genius of the bathroom is as a domestic escape hatch. It comes with almost unlimited plausible deniability. She explains that if your husband is in the basement, he can theoretically be told to come upstairs. Yep. If he's in the garage, he can be interrupted. A workout can be postponed. A hobby can be negotiated around. But the bathroom is different because you cannot reasonably deny another human being access to a toilet.
Speaker 2So true.
Speaker 3I have to go to the bathroom is a very powerful sentence, she writes, because what are you going to say to a person who says that?
Speaker 2No, hold it, prove it. Now, Olivia argues.
Speaker 3That smartphones have made weaponized pooping even more powerful, I guess, as a weapon because now they have infinite bathroom reading matter and they're taking more time than they need on this basic bodily function because they've got the sum of the world's knowledge and writing on their phone and they're spending more time than they need to on this basic bodily function because it's peaceful in there.
Speaker 2Well, that's right. They're not reading the back of the shampoo bottle like we used to have to do.
Speaker 3Exactly. Now, Olivia's sub stack, let's just say it got a bit of an acrimonious response from men who said things to her like, no wonder you're divorced. Is this unfair to men, Stacey? Don't we all, and I get it, because don't we all just enjoy a moment of peace and quiet in the bathroom? Like, why are we coming for men in particular here?
Speaker 4Yes.
Speaker 2Look, I enjoy being a recluse in the toilet as well. I have been known to say, oh, go and just do a little bit of extra scrolling while I'm there. I don't think any of us can say that we haven't at one point or another, but if you're doing the sums, surely the men are in there For a much longer time. They are. And I think the reason it triggers women is because women, of course, mums, are the ones that get interrupted on the toilet. For us, toilet time is interrupted often. There's fingers under the door.
Speaker 2There's yelling for a snack from the other side. You shut the door?
Speaker 1I didn't even shut the door.
Speaker 2Well, that's the thing. Or there's someone in your lap.
Speaker 1I haven't shut a toilet door in seven years.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah. We're usually going with an audience. Whereas for them, it just seems like, no, I'm out. I'm off the showroom floor. I'm not available.
Speaker 1So she's saying... they do it on purpose by calling it weaponized.
Speaker 3No, she actually, no, to be fair to Olivia, she says that she doesn't think that this is necessarily conscious or intentional, but it is the way that households tend to be organized whereby men feel that they can take more time in the bathroom than women can. And therefore, by virtue of that, they get out of domestic tasks more often.
Speaker 2Yeah. And I love how she spoke about women often announce it when they're going or almost ask permission. That's so true. Like, well, are you okay? I'm just going to pot. I'm just going to go to the toilet. Whereas for men, it's more of an announcement. I'm off. Like I'm unavailable for, you know, who knows how long.
Speaker 3The foreseeable future. Have you ever read Roald Dahl's Boy? the memoir of his childhood at British boarding schools. And one detail that always stuck with me, even when I read it as a child, was that the prefects at his very posh British boarding school would have younger boys sit on the toilet for them ahead of time to warm the toilet seat up for them, which I don't think a woman would ever request. But look, let's just hasten to add here, it is not all men. Just this week, Mayor Zoran Mamdani in New York, who is
Speaker 3very popular and by all accounts doing a great job as mayor, has introduced these new public toilets in New York. And the way they work is they automatically lock when you close the door, but then they automatically unlock after a designated period of time. And he announced that the designated period of time, the official amount of time you should be taking on a poo is 10 minutes. Wow.
Speaker 2He said that's the maximum.
Speaker 3Oh, no.
Speaker 2The mayor has spoken.
Speaker 1And then does a child come up to the door and go, Dad?
Speaker 2Just to add some pressure. Yeah. Okay.
Speaker 1In the last week, everyone has been talking about the speech that stopped a nation. Georgie Dent, CEO of The Parenthood, gave this National Press Club address saying, called The Mother and Father of All Problems. And it got picked up everywhere, including a really great discussion on Mamma Mia Out Loud with you, Amelia, with all the key points. And you might have seen clips of it in your feed. You might have heard people mentioning it. And there was a lot made in there about how actually grim it is to be a parent right now. The birth rate is falling.
Speaker 1Parents are drowning. But what I want to pick apart today are two things from it. Firstly, what were her solutions? Because she had three answers. key pieces of policy that could do massive good here and that haven't been picked up in the media as well? And then secondly, what actually happens from a press club address? Can it affect some change? Because now I'm like, great, it's out there. The message is out there. It's gone bunta. What can we expect to happen next? So in case you missed it,
Speaker 1the speech in its entirety is on the ABC iView. And also the transcript is on the website at The Parenthood. And I listened to I played it on iview and I just listened while I was doing other stuff because I thought you don't really need to watch it. I just want to hear her words. So I used it as kind of like a little podcast. And here was the key message that I took in that, I think it was a 90 minute speech or something. It wasn't the data points, though they were excellent. And it wasn't the statistics also beautifully researched and excellent. It was the
Speaker 1feeling that I took away from it, that the way things are right now as a parent is not our fault. And parenting is really hard, yes, but there are all these invisible structural forces that are making it harder. And this was my aha moment in this speech where every mother I know has internalized, and I'm talking specifically about mothers. I know there'll be people listening going, what about the fathers? And we'll get to them. Every mother I know has internalized this message of I am drowning, but I chose this.
Speaker 2So you know what?
Speaker 1I just have to get on with it and make it work however I can. And this is also something we see in comment sections, right? People say, you chose to have children deal with it. You know, PS, you're shit at parenting.
Speaker 4There's a.
Speaker 1Is this generation of mothers who are suffering real consequences from having children, and that is in the data, the loss of income, the emotional, the economic, the professional strain, but who also think if family life isn't working, it's my fault. and we think, oh, if only I got up earlier, if only I had a digital calendar, if only I meal prepped, if only I signed my child up for daycare when they were in utero, if only I could ask my employer for flexibility or help or
Speaker 1quit my job or work part-time. And then Georgie Dent comes along like this angel in the white wide-legged pantsuit, and she just said it plain as day, and this was the moment that got me.
Speaker 5For the last 16 years, I have watched parents try to overcome failures of public policy with their own private ingenuity. Raising children will always require time, money, patience and compromise. But there is a difference between the inherent work of raising a child and the unnecessary difficulty created by systems designed for another era. To the parents listening today, I
Speaker 5know how it feels to appear capable while being completely overwhelmed, to love your children so fiercely and still struggle to make it all work. Struggling under these conditions does not mean you are failing. No parent can meditate their way out of a childcare desert or meal prep their way out of housing stress or time manage.
Speaker 2Their way into a 25th hour.
Speaker 5When millions of families face the same obstacles, it is not a personal failure. It's a policy failure with profound economic and social consequences.
Speaker 1I just felt so immensely seen and relieved when I heard it's you're not failing. It's not your fault. This is not on you. Stacey, have you ever thought something wasn't working in your family because you weren't managing it well enough or trying hard enough?
Speaker 2Oh, yeah, all the time, every day. And I think one example of that in my own life was dropping to four days of work. That was something that my family chose to do. We thought that that, well, I thought that that that would make things feel easier. But then you look around at the people doing five days and I'm like, why does this not feel easier? Why is this like they're somehow managing it? But what Georgie kind of put into words is that everyone's doing that to each other. Everyone's looking around and going, well, they're somehow managing. Why can't I? But the truth is that
Speaker 2no one really is managing. That is coming at a cost.
Speaker 1The other part of her speech that I loved, she said, we are asking parents to raise children, earn enough to support them, absorb some of the highest housing and care costs in the developed world, navigate workplaces and schools that still assumes somebody else is at home and somehow stay well while they do it. Is it any wonder that for too many Australian families, the margin has become impossibly thin? So this is a systemic problem to solve. That's what
Speaker 1she's saying. And what was so genius about it is that she didn't stand up there and say, hey, we're tired, help us. It wasn't an emotional argument. It was an economic argument. It was a sustainability, a productivity argument.
Speaker 3I was really glad that she took that more hard-headed approach because even in reaction to the Monday discussion on Out Loud about this topic, what I was struck by in the comments was everyone a certain impatience with parents saying that things are hard. So people who are child-free or maybe wanted to have children and didn't have them would say things like, well, when you made the decision to have children, you need to budget for that appropriately,
Speaker 3just like you would budget for a house or for a car or for a holiday. And the thing that I find frustrating in that rebuke is that a child is not the same as a house or a car or a holiday, primarily because houses, cars and holidays don't pay taxes, don't fund your retirement, don't help grow the economy. So I'm really glad that she drew the connection between policies around family and making sure that people can have
Speaker 3the families they want to have. And building and growing our society and economy.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1So I agree. I'm in full agreeance that it was a productivity argument. So smart. But her three asks are really very simple. And the other thing that is interesting is that the parenthood have mapped all of this out. Like they have done the research. They have gone, this is how we would do it. All they're waiting for is the knock on the door from probably Prime Minister Anthony Albanese. But before we get to that, because I want to ask you, Amelia, about press club speeches in the wider landscape, do you want to hear her like three asks?
Speaker 2Yes, because I feel like these got lost. I feel like what everyone saw last week was that number. And I do think it's important to say what that number was because everyone was talking about it, that 107 working days is how many days parents with school-age children have to cover. even if they took their annual leave separately. That number is massive.
Speaker 1Yeah, there are three solutions slated in this speech. The first one was a full year of paid parental leave that families can afford to take. So right now government paid parental leave is paid at minimum wage, which is less than half of the average earnings. And Australia, I found this fascinating, Australia is one of only a very small number of OECD countries that pays a flat rate for parental leave rather than a proportion of what you earn.
Speaker 3That's really interesting.
Speaker 1And she wants to move it towards replacement wages because sometimes people cannot pay the rent on a minimum wage. If you're a larger earner or you're the breadwinner for your family and then you have to take a sort of huge pay cut.
Speaker 3Well, I just want to draw out what she was saying there is she's saying by deduction that the average wage is twice the minimum wage. And so by giving parents only the minimum wage, a lot of people are taking a huge pay cut to have a child.
Speaker 1Yeah, they can't afford to do it. Because say you're a business owner as well, Amelia. Say you're a small business owner.
Speaker 3I can't imagine owning a business, but go on.
Speaker 1For you to then take parental leave under the government, but then you'd have to hire someone to replace you at your wage. The maths does not maths on that. So, yeah, she's asking and they've built out, they've modelled this pathway for you. They're currently at 26 weeks of leave. They've gone here. Well, we don't have to get to 52 next year. We can just incrementally do it piece by piece like they have done with superannuation. They go, hey, it used to be 9%. Now it's 10%.
Speaker 2I don't know, whatever it is.
Speaker 1Yeah, let's move it towards replacement wages and a full year.
Speaker 2Because that is what happens so much now when you have conversations with friends or child-free people talking about whether they might want to have children. it is often an economic reason that they will say, not I feel a strong yearning or I don't. It's I don't know where I'd put them because I'd need another room in my house. I don't know how I could afford that.
Speaker 1I can't take a year off work.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 1The second thing, the second piece, which I think is fascinating and I feel like Australia is screaming out for this solution is universal, affordable, high quality early childhood education and care. So they want, the parenthood want us to think about childcare like we think about public schools. They are just there to access as you need them.
Speaker 3Can we fund the public schools better while we're at it?
Speaker 1And that we need sort of a one national system and fund it like we fund public schools, not just subsidies for individual families and then like let the market work it out. It's not working.
Speaker 3The idea that we're just going to like farm it out to people to make the maximum profits on it, I don't think it's going so well.
Speaker 1It's not going well. And it would also solve a lot of the childcare desert problems that we see. And the third ask was about more family-friendly workplaces, which feels like a very unpopular. unpopular one? Like a lot of businesses and employers saying, well, we're already doing enough.
Speaker 3Well, Dish famously earlier this year put in place the ability for its employees, it's a fashion brand, put in place the ability for employees to take additional leave to look after their families after their children are babies. So throughout their child's life. And that got a very polarized response from people. Some people felt it was very unfair of DISH to extend that ability to take additional leave to parents and not then extend it to people who are child free.
Speaker 2So it is polarizing.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's really charged. But I think the childcare solution isn't. I think everyone would agree that that seems like a pretty great solution to an industry that's in crisis, I would say.
Speaker 3I love how she's broken down the action items into these three ideas. I think that's part of why this speech made such waves is because instead of just hand-wringing, Georgie gave us an idea of what we should do about it. And I think that's what these press club addresses do at their best. You asked about what they do earlier.
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 3And I think when I look back to really impactful press club addresses, it's because they changed a conversation. They may not have immediately led to a policy change, but they changed how we collectively thought about a problem in our society. I'm thinking, for instance, a very famous recent example, Grace Tame gave a press club address in 2022 with Brittany Higgins. And in that address, Grace Tame lambasted the coalition government and She said, you spent $ 90 billion on submarines and you spent just $ 1. 1 billion on violence against women. Now,
Speaker 3that was three months before a federal election. I don't need to remind you that the 2022 federal election was a very definitive rejection of the direction in which the coalition was taking things. And I'm not drawing a direct line between Grace Tame's press club address and Scott Morrison losing an election, but I think it created an atmosphere where people started to question the what he was doing and what his leadership was saying.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Which is why I wanted to talk about this today, because I think the more we talk about, the more we agitate, the more we go and sign their petitions to do this, people will take notice, right?
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Millie Bobby Brown has welcomed the arrival of a second baby with her husband, Jake Bon Jovi. And yes, he is the son of John Bon Jovi.
Speaker 1Who's Millie Bobby Brown?
Speaker 2She was in Stranger Things.
Speaker 1Is she a nepo baby?
Speaker 3No, not at all. She is an up-and-coming thespian in Hollywood. She's only 22.
Speaker 4But Bobbi Brown's the makeup person, so no relation. No relation, spelled differently. So her and her husband, Jake, he's only 24. They're very private. And so the news came out about this because eagle-eyed Instagrammers noticed that Jake and Millie were on a holiday in Italy that featured two young children. And they said, hang on, we knew about the first because they had adopted their first child together.
Speaker 2Who's the second?
Speaker 3And then Millie confirmed the arrival of the second with the caption, hi little guy, on a photo of her hand with the baby's. So that's all very sweet. But Stacey, you were a bit surprised by your reaction to this news. I was because I love her. and him together. I think they're great. And they're very open about adoption, which I also think is excellent. She gives all these beautiful quotes being like, there's two ways to have a baby and one is through your stomach and one is through your heart.
Speaker 2And my daughter was through my heart. Like she is obsessed with this little girl. She hasn't spoken about the little boy yet. And I also love.
Speaker 3That Jake Bon Jovi looks like a adorable, like miniature younger.
Speaker 2Version of his dad. He even has that fluffy hair. No wonder he's a model. Yeah. Gorgeous. But I have to admit, I had a bit of a funny reaction to it because she's 22. I felt myself clutching my pearls, being like, but they've only been married two years and now they've got two babies. Like, how are they going to do that? How do they know they're going to last? And then I was like... What are you thinking, Stacey? I don't know why this came up for me.
Speaker 1Oh, that is so middle-aged of you.
Speaker 4Isn't it?
Speaker 2Isn't it?
Speaker 4I know.
Speaker 2I really am. Because when you think about it, parenting really is a young person's game. Like all the research will say you're better off having children in your kind of mid-20s is kind of when you reach your peak. I don't think we need the research for that. My under eye circles are the research. Yes, and just general energy levels at that time were a lot better. But obviously the age of mothers now is getting older and older. It's about 29 now, but that's been on the creep for a decade now. But I couldn't help but feel like, oh,
Speaker 2does she know how much this is going to change her life? And how ridiculous of me to think that.
Speaker 3I think it's so culturally specific when you kind of regard as the ideal age to have a child. And I'm thinking of a friend of mine in New York who had her first baby at 29 and that was young in New York. And she told me that she felt like every time someone discovered she was pregnant, they would act like she was a teen mom. Like they'd be like, are you sure that you're ready to take this step? She's like, I'm a 29 year old with a full time job. I'm good.
Speaker 1I'm good.
Speaker 3But because in New York, it's so unusual to have a baby in your 20s. People were really expressing a lot of shock about it. Well, I am from the western suburbs as well. And they also talk about like, the city age for birthing children and the suburbs age for birthing children.
Speaker 4Oh, what is it?
Speaker 2Well, there's no specific age, but as in the western suburbs, me having a baby at 24 is not really looked at twice. But my city friends would be like, whoa, what do you mean? You're a child, kind of the same as New York.
Speaker 3But then you, not to get too personal, but you didn't have a baby at 24. No.
Speaker 2No, no. I was 32. I was ancient.
Speaker 3And did you feel like an outlier?
Speaker 4Yeah, I did.
Speaker 2I was the last one in my friend group from growing up to have a baby. So you do kind of, yeah, as you say, it's very different depending on where you're from. Why do you think I had this feeling? I don't know.
Speaker 1I don't know.
Speaker 2Do you just think I'm a judgy cow now?
Speaker 1No, it's just showing your age, that's all. I think 22 is a great age to have children, just like all that energy. You know who I can't stop looking at this week is actually 43-year-old Anne Hathaway. It took ages for the pregnancy to reach her face. Like for a long time she still had the Anne Hathaway like snatched jaw but with the huge belly and now it's all the fluids everywhere and she looks good.
Speaker 2She does.
Speaker 3She's in her prime. I saw her on a red carpet for what must be literally her fifth big movie of the year just this week. And the paps were a bit out of control taking pictures on the red carpet. So she single-handedly took matters into her own hands and started directing them. Okay, you're going to take a photo now. You're going to take a photo now. Big 43-year-old mom energy there.
Speaker 2But she's also so self-aware. There was a quote from her this week saying, let's not feel bad for the woman who got a manicure for her job this morning. Like, don't worry about me. I'm fine. Like, she's kind of saying, don't hold me up as a hero. I get it a lot better than a lot of pregnant mothers out there.
Speaker 5All right.
Speaker 2Another thing that caught my eye this week. Something for you to judge, if you will. Okay. Okay. I want to paint a picture for you. A mom named Erica has a baby strapped to her chest and she's at a baseball game. Doesn't matter which one.
Speaker 1Sport.
Speaker 2She was at sport. She's just changed her baby's nappy. She's gone and got trays and trays of food. She's precariously carrying them back down to where her husband's sitting. Sits down with him. It's only about 20 to 30 seconds of time, but little does she know, she's being filmed in the crowd and it's being beamed up onto the telecast. That was all it took. for people to say that Erica was the mum of the year and that her husband was a villain and a walking red flag. I saw this video everywhere this past weekend. It was everywhere.
Speaker 2I tried to figure out how many views this had. It's impossible because it has cropped up in so many different places. Like millions and millions of people saw this video and made a snap judgment. And the clip you're about to hear is from the commentators, Dwayne Kuyper and Mike Krakow, as Erica makes her way back to her husband. This is what they said and this is why it went so viral.
Speaker 3Look at this.
Speaker 5Well, if there's ever a true definition of a multitasking mother, that is the deal right there. Oh, my goodness. I think she's an Olympic champion.
Speaker 2Did I just hear that guy say, did you forget something?
Speaker 4Look at Dad.
Speaker 5Oh, yeah, did you bring the ketchup?
Speaker 2I don't know.
Speaker 5Last mom of the year right there.
Speaker 4Oh, my goodness. Are you kidding me?
Speaker 2She'll be the last one to eat, too.
Speaker 3This is the opposite of weaponized pooping. The exact opposite.
Speaker 2Yeah, exactly. And I mean, that's obviously just lighthearted banter, 20 seconds, and then they moved on to other people in the crowd. But the overarching reaction to this was, leave him. He is a jerk.
Speaker 3People got serious, right?
Speaker 2They did. People went out of their way to find their phone numbers and ring them. Okay, who are these people? People who need jobs, clearly, because, I mean, who has time to do that? But it was everywhere. Like, it got so wild from this snapshot of this couple. Yes, it didn't look great. Like she's carrying the baby and the backpack and the food and brings them back to him while he's presumably been having a lovely time watching the game.
Speaker 1He doesn't even get up off his feet. Like he doesn't even stand up.
Speaker 2No, he moves the jacket for her and she sits down.
Speaker 3Yes.
Speaker 2But now Erica has responded. She has entered the chat and not everything is as it seems. Stacey, you are.
Speaker 3The queen of debunking internet memes. And I was fully camp like maybe she should leave him. I didn't find their phone number, but that's what I thought to myself when I scrolled past it. But as usual, you found that the truth is considerably stranger than we thought.
Speaker 2Yeah, yes. So she has done a lengthy Substack post, which we can link to in the show notes.
Speaker 3Did she set that up to debunk this?
Speaker 2Maybe. What a genius.
Speaker 1It's her first and only Substack post.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And she said, you saw me carrying our baby in the food, but there was more happening in our family that night. Before you decide what our marriage looks like, I'd like you to hear from the woman you're defending, which I just loved. And she was saying that he is a very involved dad. She talked about the fact that it was freezing on that night and he offered to take the baby when she said she was going up to the bathroom and And she said, no, no, I want to keep her. She's like my little hot water bottle. Like she keeps me warm. So she changed her baby's nappy, was on the way back to her seat,
Speaker 2walked past the food stand. So she messaged him and said, do you want any food while I'm here? He just said, yep, sure. Whatever's got the shortest line, that's fine. And she went back down to the seat, kind of carrying these trays and the baby and the backpack. She says, then he offered to take the containers. And she says, no, no, you haven't had a full meal all day. You eat. So she's going through a line by line of how this unfolded, even includes the screenshot of the texts that they sent to each other. She did.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2She was like, I have the evidence for you. I'm going to prove that he is a lovely dad. The clincher for a lot of people is that she talked about the fact that he was grieving the loss of a friend of theirs who was a very good baseball player. but there was no memorial for that friend who passed. So this was kind of their way of going and honouring that friend. And she said, you know, people saw what I was shouldering, but they didn't see what he was. And this was my opportunity to look after him. People have seen 20 or 30 seconds of our relationship. That
Speaker 2is not indicative of what it is actually like. And I should be able to look after my husband in return. Her husband's name is Ramses, right? Ramses, yes. Yeah.
Speaker 1So what's so interesting is that even with this substat response, people did not back down from this discourse. And one of the most popular comments on the Substack was saying basically, well, you sound like you're over-explaining and you're massively being defensive here. Your explanation describes yourself as an over-functioning woman like so many of us are. While this description of your husband sounds like he's not as bad as the one-minute snapshot that it shows, he's doing minimum of what he should be doing and clearly shows that you're the default parent.
Speaker 1So please stop holding yourself responsible for so much. Like people were still like, girl, no.
Speaker 3My jaw is on the floor hearing that comment. People are not listening to Erica.
Speaker 2No. And I think a lot of that, and she acknowledged this in her post as well. She said, I'm sorry if this has triggered something for people who've seen that snapshot and remembered something they experienced. that wasn't pleasant. She doesn't need to apologize for that. She was at a baseball game. Exactly. But I think she was saying like, from that clip, sure, you might look at that and get an idea of a bad relationship because you had one that might have looked like that all the time. But that was mine for 20 seconds. That is not the full picture. And I think this is a really good example of what we do now in the culture generally.
Speaker 2Like we... Make snap judgments, especially when parenting is involved. I feel like the fuse is so short for anyone with parenting, right? Like I feel like unless you're kind of performing in the perfect parenting way, then you can just get sliced apart.
Speaker 3Stacey, when you debunked this for me, it made me immediately think of the Coldplay video where that turned out to be so much more complicated than we thought too because both the man and the woman in that video who we thought were having a quote-unquote affair were actually separated at the time.
Speaker 1What I think is subversive about it, what I liked about it, is that it would have been really easy for her to go, yeah, I am mum of the year. Like, yeah, men, huh? Like eye roll, like the commentators were doing, like so many online did. But to hear her defend... a man, a father, and say, hey, men have their own stuff going on as well. I thought that was really great. It's not something we hear heaps. Speaking of Substack, she's not the only one to have started a Substack.
Speaker 2That's true.
Speaker 1Stacey Hicks, you have started a Substack for Parenting Out Loud.
Speaker 2I have. There is a newsletter that you can get from us now too, not just Erica. Yeah, great. And I'll do it every week. So you'll get one from me every single Saturday.
Speaker 1How do we get it?
Speaker 3What do we do?
Speaker 2So just we'll put it in the show notes, a link to Substack. If you're on there all the time, just search Parenting Out Loud on there and you will find us. And I'll give you like a deep dive into one of the topics we talk about here, maybe some little behind the scenes moments. Can we go a bit rogue?
Speaker 1Can we say the things on the Substack that we might not say here because this goes on YouTube?
Speaker 2Oh, yes.
Speaker 3Okay, good.
Speaker 2Yeah, absolutely. So please subscribe. I'd love to have you with us.
Speaker 1Excellent.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Stacey's also a beautiful writer, so everyone should be signing up to get Stacey in their inbox on the weekend.
Speaker 1It's time for recommendations. These are all the great things that we've seen, loved, bought, worn.
Speaker 2Whatever it is.
Speaker 1Amelia, what have you got for us this week?
Speaker 2Look, there's a new book out this week. It's by Zoe Foster Blake. She needs no introduction.
Speaker 4She doesn't.
Speaker 3But I've been reading every single word Zoe Foster Blake has put out since at least 2011. I am not exaggerating. So 15 years in, it is saying something that her new book is my favorite thing that she's ever written.
Speaker 2Oh, that's a good rec. It's called Group Chat.
Speaker 3It came out on Tuesday and it is somehow Zoe's 18th book, which I just can't deal with. It's been described as a perimenopausal white lotus, the TV show.
Speaker 2That's good.
Speaker 1Did you describe it like that?
Speaker 2I did not, but I love it.
Speaker 3And it certainly gets the sort of holiday vibes of this book. Basically what it's about, it's five friends. They're in their 40s. We get to know every single one of them as they take this amazing trip together to Mykonos. Not everything goes perfectly, of course, but it's a celebration of their friendship through the hard times. The trip comes about because one of them is cheated on. That's not a spoiler. It happens in the first chapter. And it also has just a great dose of escapism because I would like to go to Mykonos with my friends for
Speaker 3a week. And now I feel like I kind of have. But it hits all the big themes of this era, just as you'd expect Zoe to. She's always got a finger on the pulse. It's about changing friendships and bodies and marriages. But most of all, like these are very busy women and they have very big and exciting lives, but they felt really real to me. Like I just felt like by the end of the book, you know, sometimes you read a book with five characters and you get a bit confused as to who's who.
Speaker 2Not going to happen in this one.
Speaker 3Nice.
Speaker 2Okay. I'm definitely getting that.
Speaker 1What about you, Stacey?
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 1Actually, tell the truth. You had a copy and I stole it off your desk.
Speaker 2Yeah, you did.
Speaker 3Sorry.
Speaker 4You did.
Speaker 2I regret that ever since, especially now I know how good it is. I know.
Speaker 1I'm sorry.
Speaker 2I'll bring it back. You can have it. No, that's fine. We'll pass it around. I'll get to it next. My reco this week is a Spotify playlist. You know I love a very specific playlist for every moment of my life.
Speaker 3Is it the Oreo Gate tunes strung together in a DJ mix?
Speaker 2Wow, that would be amazing. Why hasn't someone done that yet?
Speaker 1Is it an audio book of the Oreo Gate saga, chapter by chapter?
Speaker 2That would also be great. I'll take that. No, this playlist is called Chessie's Denim Shirt in the Parent Trap. Do you remember the movie The Parent Trap?
Speaker 4Yes.
Speaker 2Chessie is the beautiful nanny that they have at the house.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2And she always wears that denim shirt. She has very spunky energy. Someone has made a playlist that just is the attitude of her in that denim shirt in the movie. Oh, that's a great idea. It is. So good. It has songs on it like I'm Gonna Get You Good by Shania Twain. It has, you know, Sway. You know that song? Sway in the way. Yes. Yeah. And then it's got like There She Goes by Sixpence and I'm the Richer. There she goes. It's so good. And this playlist is four hours long. Like I'm never going to get to the end of it. It's amazing.
Speaker 3Wow.
Speaker 1Question, what do you do when you're listening to this playlist? Like, is it your cooking playlist? Is it your gym? What's its job?
Speaker 2You could just do a strut down the street. You could be vacuuming.
Speaker 1It's not very hot girl walk to listen to There She Goes.
Speaker 2No, it's not, but it's a little like country-ish. I don't know. I've used it when I'm writing, when I'm writing the newsletter.
Speaker 1I had it on.
Speaker 2Yeah, writing. Yeah, it's just got a bit of attitude about it and I love it. I've previously recommended my own playlist on this show before, which I should remind people to add. And actually, maybe they can drop in the Spotify comments what songs they want me to add to the list, because really it is a Parenting Out Loud playlist.
Speaker 3There is a party happening in those Spotify comments every week these days, and I'm loving it.
Speaker 2It's so good. So that one is called Girly Pop Songs That Make Me Want To Kick A Door Down. That's my playlist. There's a few hundred Parenting Out Louders following it. And now I get really self-conscious when I add stuff to it because I'm like, will they like this? So if you put your favorite song in the Spotify comments or like email them to us, then I will add them to the playlist.
Speaker 1Can you say the name of it again? That's so long. I lost focus halfway through.
Speaker 2Go. Girly pop songs that make you want to kick a door down.
Speaker 1We'll put it in the show notes.
Speaker 2We'll put it in the show notes and we'll put it in the newsletter so you can find it there.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1All right.
Speaker 2Speaking of Spotify comments.
Speaker 1Last week, I did something unprecedented on this show. I flipped it. I said, I don't have a recommendation. I need yours.
Speaker 2You did. Controversial.
Speaker 1Amelia mocked me relentlessly. She said, no one cares about you finding a good bagged vacuum, Monique. No one cares.
Speaker 2Did I say no one cares? I mean, not in those words.
Speaker 1You implied it. Many people care, Amelia. The Facebook group has been going off about people's vacuum recommendations. Guys, it's made me so happy. And thank you to all the people that put comments in Spotify recommending vacuum cleaners. People feel so passionately about theirs. But my favourite one, there's a vacuum that you can buy that has a face on it. It's pink and it has a face and the nose is the hose that comes out. It's so whimsical.
Speaker 1I love it. I was like, this is what we need in cleaning. We need more whimsy. We need less technology and more whimsy.
Speaker 2Yeah, we really do. We really do.
Speaker 4Thank you.
Speaker 2They came through. We knew they would deliver. Even though we don't care about vacuuming, famously, Amelia, the parenting allowed us to. I loved it.
Speaker 1So thank you. Now, my recommendation this week is another hot topic in Facebook groups world over. digital calendars. You may have heard of a skylight. Have you heard of the skylight? Now that I've said it out loud.
Speaker 3It's like super expensive and it can put all my stuff in it.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1We're not a skylight family.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 1My husband always says this is like, we're not a European car family. We're a Toyota family. We're not a Fenton and Fenton family. We're an Ikea or Kmart furniture family. This example, we are not a skylight family. But I wanted a digital calendar, so I went with the Kmart Slash Target option. It's called the Smart Family Calendar. It's basically one giant touchscreen calendar. It's next to our fridge.
Speaker 2Is it that big? Your hands are out very wide. It's probably that big. Okay, like an A4 piece of paper. Okay, yeah, yeah. And it's... it.
Speaker 1Syncs to all your calendars. So I put something in my calendar, boom, it goes up on the screen. No more missed appointments. Everyone gets to sport on time. Piano lessons, everyone knows when it's on. It's actually, it's changed the way our household runs.
Speaker 2Is it colour coded?
Speaker 1Yes, it can be.
Speaker 2I don't know.
Speaker 1I haven't worked out all the functionalities of it, but it was, the thing I liked about it was that It's the one-time payment because with the Skylight, you have to pay a subscription.
Speaker 2You have to keep paying. A subscription? Yes. What for?
Speaker 1I don't know.
Speaker 2I don't know.
Speaker 3Can I just stress test an idea? What about like a really big? calendar on a piece of paper.
Speaker 1Yeah so I um we tried that yeah and I get bored of it and also it's too many steps whereas if I put something in my phone right then and there yeah it will just go boom onto the screen so it was $ 249 so it's not cheap but the mental sanity it's bought me priceless and And I know I sound like contradictory because I was just saying how Georgie Dent's like, it shouldn't be on you personally to solve all these problems. But right now she hasn't got the solutions yet. So for now, I would recommend the family calendar.
Speaker 2Love it.
Speaker 4Yeah, cool.
Speaker 3All right.
Speaker 1That is all we have time for. Have a great week and we'll be back in this feed next Saturday morning.
Eight mums went on a girls' trip and answered a simple question: who's watching your kids? Oh dear. The internet was not happy. Meanwhile, Amelia's noticed something in baby advertising: umm...the babies are missing....
Ever get petty revenge on your kids? Parents everywhere are confessing their own acts of petty parenting. Mean? Or just good resilience building? Stacey is questioning the friendship lie we were all sold by Friends and...
Noah Wyle just kicked the hornet’s nest by declaring that boys are tougher to parent than girls... at least at first. Stacey Hicks, Amelia Lester and special guest Grace Rouvray get into the conversation about whether...
A three-year-old soccer star, a viral video and cops called to the sidelines. What on earth has happened to parents at kids' sport? Amelia brings us the story that's divided the internet, while Monz makes a passionate...
Just when you thought the summer school holidays couldn't get any longer, one Australian school has announced it's finishing up next year in NOVEMBER. Yes, November. Cancel Christmas. You'll be too busy organising...