Were Adam and Eve real historical people, and how should Christians evaluate scientific arguments about human origins? Host Luke Betzner welcomes Dr. Casey Luskin and Dr. Michael Keas to examine the biblical case for a historical Adam and Eve, the fossil and genetic evidence discussed in debates over human ancestry, and proposals for reconciling Christianity with evolutionary accounts of human origins. Drawing on The Comprehensive Guide to Science and Faith, the conversation explores Jesus’ and Paul’s references to Adam and Eve, four alternative models of human origins, questions surrounding biblical genealogies and the dating of humanity, and population-genetics modeling. Luskin and Keas explain their arguments for the traditional view and discuss how evidence and coherence shape their evaluation of competing models. Their interpretations and critiques are presented as the guests’ positions in an ongoing debate. In this episode The biblical case for a historical Adam and Eve Fossil evidence and human genetic diversity Evolutionary creationism, Homo divinus, genealogical Adam and Eve, and Homo heidelbergensis proposals Genesis genealogies and the question of when Adam and Eve lived Population-genetics models and the possibility of an original pair Recommended books and further reading Chapters 00:27 Introduction and guests 03:47 The biblical case for a historical Adam and Eve 12:16 Two scientific challenges: fossils and genetics 18:53 Four alternative models of human origins 27:53 Evaluating the models against Scripture 36:15 Do biblical genealogies establish a date? 40:18 Genetic diversity and a primordial pair 47:45 Final thoughts 50:50 Recommended reading 53:41 Support Paratus and closing Resources mentioned The Comprehensive Guide to Science and Faith, edited by Joseph M. Holden, William A. Dembski, and Casey Luskin C. John Collins, Did Adam and Eve Really Exist? and Reading Genesis Well Casey Luskin, “Comparing Contemporary Evangelical Models Regarding Human Origins,” Religions Discovery Institute: discovery.org About Paratus Paratus is the podcast of Veritas International University, helping Christians develop a biblical worldview and think scripturally and soundly about faith and culture. Learn more at ves.edu. Support Paratus and Veritas International University Help sustain this outreach at ves.edu/give.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
AnnouncerWelcome to Paratus, the broadcast ministry of Veritas International University. Paratus seeks to help Christians develop a biblical worldview, preparing believers to think scripturally and soundly about the Christian faith and our culture. To learn more about Veritas International University, visit our website at ves.edu. That's ves.edu.
Luke BetznerThanks for listening to Paratus, where we defend and discuss unchanging truth in changing times. I'm your host, Betzner. Joining me on the podcast today are doctors Casey Luskin and Michael Keyes. Welcome, gentlemen. Thanks.
Dr. Casey LuskinGreat to be with you.
Luke BetznerRight. We're really excited to have you today, and we're continuing our season on Paratus, turning our attention to science and the Christian faith. And we'll be using doctors Holden, Demski, and Luskin's book, the comprehensive guide to science and faith, as our text. Last episode, we explored, has science refuted miracles? Today, we're going to be exploring the historical Adam and Eve, something that's become a bit of a hot topic in the evangelical scientific community in particular. Before we begin our discussion, Casey, Mike, let me have you say a bit about yourself and your work for the benefit of our audience.
Dr. Michael KeasGo, Casey.
Dr. Casey LuskinOh, no. You go ahead, Mike. You go first.
Dr. Michael KeasAlright. Well, I have a PhD in the history of science, and I've published a lot on the role of Christianity and the rise of modern science, including an essay in the the textbook that you're using for this series. And, so my expertise is is in the history and philosophy of science in relation to theology. So you have to put all those four disciplines together, history, philosophy, science, theology. And I also taught introductory science courses for college students for about a quarter century with emphasis on origins.
So I I think I've got a kind of a good comprehensive look at this in ways that will help people to better understand these issues. Finally, I'm also an expert on the traits of a good theory or a likely true theory. Those traits are known as theoretical virtues such as evidence and coherence, and I'll refer to evidence and coherence later. But that I deploy my my expertise in history and philosophy of science to deal with how science and theology, can work together in harmony.
Luke BetznerThat is such an interesting composite of different fields. I can't wait to hear what our discussion looks like today. Thank you for that, Mike. Casey, I'm gonna come to you now. Tell us a little bit about what you do.
Dr. Casey LuskinYeah. My name is Casey Luskin. I work at Discovery Institute. I'm associate director there. And my background academically is I have a PhD in geology and also a law degree. Since our topic today is human, origins, I could mention that when I did my PhD, I actually lived in South Africa for about four and a half years. And although my PhD was not specifically, in the field of paleoanthropology and the study of hominid fossils, while I lived in South Africa, I did have a number of opportunities to go and visit some of the very famous hominid fossil sites, like at the Cradle Of Humankind or, other other places as well. And I was actually able to even do a sampling expedition one time at the Cradle Of Humankind. So this area of human origins and these kinds of questions is something I've been very interested in. Also collaborating on a very, very, very, very long term project with Mike right now.
We'll see if we ever get it done, but related to human origins. But, yeah, this is a topic that really fascinates me, and I think a very important one. Appreciate you guys covering it.
Luke BetznerWell, we're glad to have you gentlemen speaking to it. And I'm, again, very interested in seeing what the kind of composite these expertises produce for our audience. Now, Mike, I'm gonna come to you first. We start out with a biblical case for the traditional theological view of Adam and Eve. And so this is gonna be the positive case. In terms of what you would see, what is the biblical case for understanding Adam and Eve as real historical persons and the progenitors of humanity?
Dr. Michael KeasPaul and Jesus in the New Testament clearly refer to Adam and Eve in ways that that that, takes them to be real historical figures engaged in specific events in the past that have lingering consequences for today. For example, in first Corinthians 11, there is the statement that man was not made from woman but woman from man. There are some like, William Lane Craig who says, well, this is this was just, Paul didn't really intend us to think that that event happened. Adam and Eve were real were real, characters of history, but the stories about them were sort of, fabricated to teach or illustrate spiritual truths. And, so in in my interactions with with Bill Craig and he's he's great on almost all topics, but not on this topic, unfortunately.
But in my interactions with him, including a dialogue at the evangelical theological and philosophical society, I pointed out that leading first Corinthians, exegete, David Garland, leading commentator on the book, says Paul did intend us to believe that man was created at first and then woman was created out of man. And he Garland points out that Paul actually helps to interpret Genesis one for us through the creation account of Genesis two, where Genesis two gives him more detail what happened in Genesis one. And he makes his points based on the the the man was created first and the woman out of out of him, that that really happened in actual history. And a a a Cambridge theologian from the previous century once made the point that as woman is of the man by creation, so the man is of the woman by birth. That parallel between the original creation of the first woman and then every man since has come from a woman by birth, both the parallel makes sense if both are real events in that had real effects in history.
So so when you see in Genesis two this this narrative that ends with the conclusion, therefore, Mary. Right? Therefore, a man shall leave his father and become one flesh and so on. That's the conclusion of a historical narrative argument, and some things can only be explained well by a historical narrative argument. So so in Genesis two, you have this sequence, Adam made from dust. He he names the animals. He realizes lonely. God creates Eve, and it concludes, therefore, marriage. That event in history is the is the basis for biblical marriage. Furthermore, it's the basis for the correct kind of human sexuality, proper human sexuality.
We're not derived from animals. Animals have sex much more indiscriminately, typically with many mates and even what looks like same sex activity, at least what looks like that. So Jesus so that that's Paul in first Corinthians. Jesus in Matthew 19, he also refers to the Genesis two event sequence, and he said he says that he he who created them said, therefore, a man shall leave his father, mother, and so on. Marriage.
Therefore, marriage. And and that quotation of he who created them, he's he's quoting himself. Jesus was the took the the lead role in in deploying god's plan for creation to create the world, including humans in his image with distinctive human sexuality that's different than animal sexuality. So Jesus deployed this by saying, look. When he was facing the pharisees who were in favor of very easy divorce for the smallest reasons, he said, look.
From the beginning, it was not this way. And when he said from the beginning, it was not so. It's not the beginning of a fabricated story, as as Craig argues, but the beginning of of human history. And Jack Collins, I'll refer to in terms of recommended books, Jack Collins agrees with me here. He was also part of that event. He couldn't show up in person due to due to a a medical emergency, but he agrees with me that Craig is wrong on that point, that Jesus really did give us the understanding that these these events actually happened
Dr. Casey Luskinin real
Dr. Michael Keashistory. Last point I'll make about this is Craig will say, well, in Jesus, in the account of Jesus in Matthew 19, Jesus said, have you not read the the, you know, this Genesis two account? And he says, well, you know, have you not read? That is he's just referring to a story. He's referring to the story that could be fabricated and illustrates truths about how marriage should operate today. But Jesus used that same expression, have you not read, the exact same Greek word to refer to David in certain argument certain acts of history in David's life and and use those to legitimate his disciples doing certain things to in in Jesus' own lifetime. So in and several other instances, he uses that same expression, have you not read? And he was he's referring to have you not read what actually happened in history as recorded in scripture. And so, certainly, we don't Craig would agree that David's actions recorded in the Old Testament actually happened. So he's his theory is incoherent, lacking in the virtue of coherence by saying, on the one hand, you know, Jesus was referring to just a a somewhat made up story to to illustrate marriage, but David's actions in real history, which Jesus used to legitimate his disciples' actions, that was definitely from real history.
And so it's incoherent for Craig to have it both ways. And and there are others who have tried similar ways to make theistic evolution theologically permissible, but they fail.
Luke BetznerSo if I'm hearing you properly on this, Mike, we're saying what we find in the narratives of scripture is not just true historical events, but also serves as a template for the creation of man and man's sexual behavior and also creates a trajectory into the New Testament where we see the same kinds of behavior doubled down on by both Paul and Christ as marriage being the standard for sanctioned human activity in the marriage bed or in sexual activity. Am I hearing you correctly on those things?
Dr. Michael KeasExactly. So on the one hand, Bill Craig is motivated by the desire to include as many people as possible in the Christian faith. You know, let's remove any barriers. Now, hypothetically, sure, someone could believe that god used evolution to create humanity. But when you get to the details theologically, there's really big problems with that because then you're you're inviting them to a Christianity that then has fewer resources to answer LGBTQ ideology and other things that are really harmful for human flourishing.
So animals naturally do do things that are not okay for humans to do, and it's not perverse for animals to do that. God made them differently. I mean, plants, for example, are bisexual. They they have both male and female parts. They they literally are bisexual, and there's nothing perverse about that. But when humans try to emulate certain animal behaviors, that is morally wrong, and it and it actually harms humanity. It's good social science research that shows that that, you know, a man and a woman raising children is very important for their intellectual and, and social development.
Luke BetznerSome excellent points there, and that really brings us to the next question here. And, Casey, I'm gonna come to you on this because now that we've made this positive case, there's a there's more than two challenges, but we're gonna dwell on a couple major challenges that have been presented by mainstream science against the positive case that Mike has just articulated so beautifully for us. So what are two major challenges that that raises against the traditional view of Adam and Eve?
Dr. Casey LuskinSure. Yeah. Happy to talk about that, Luke. And by the way, just on the point that Mike just made about how there are many things that happen in nature that you would not want to take as prescriptive for human morality. My wife and I were just watching this, show on Disney plus called Lion about this this lion cub, and it traces him, like, growing up and then becoming, you know, taking his own females. Well, male lions, when they take over a pride, they typically will kill the offspring of the females that do not belong to them. Okay? They cut all this out of the Disney show, and I don't know if that really happened. It probably did because that would have been the norm. But, clearly, like, we would not recommend that let's say that, you know, you you marry a woman and maybe her maybe her husband died and she has three kids.
We would never recommend that you kill her kids. Right? Like, that's obviously clearly an evil, terrible thing. You should adopt those kids as your own, love them, become their dad. I have a friend who adopted four kids after after his sister died and basically took them on as his own. You know? So, like, a 100%, there are things in nature. Just because it happens in nature does not mean, therefore, it's the way humans are supposed to act. But, okay, back to your very good question, Luke. The two main scientific challenges to the traditional view of Adam and Eve.
So I I often will say that when you sort of look at these debates over theistic evolution, the idea that god used evolution and standard Darwinian evolutionary mechanisms to create life, when you try to merge that view with traditional Christianity, there's a lot of bumps in the road. But the area where I think you get the biggest friction is actually in the area of human origins. Okay? Because an evolutionary view directly claims that we evolved from a population a population of thousands of ape like hominid ancestors. Okay.
Now we're not descended from apes according to the standard evolutionary model, but we are descended from ape like ancestors and not an initial pair of two, but of thousands of them. Okay? And that is the standard evolutionary view. That is directly counter to the traditional view of Adam and Eve that they are not only our progenitors, but they are our sole progenitors. Okay? Like, when when Eve was created, what was the name she was given? She was given the name the mother of all the living. Okay? So, like, not the mother of some of the living, but she's basically being viewed as the mother of all humanity. So she is, like, the sole female progenitor.
We didn't have thousands of female ancestors. If you go back far enough, according to the traditional view, you should be able to trace this back to one single female and only one single female. Okay. So that's the basic view. And that's the basic problem. So the two major scientific challenges would be, number one, the fossil record. Folks will claim that there are fossils that supposedly document the evolution of ape like organisms into the human like body plan and showing this sort of evolutionary lineage or evolutionary transition from ape like to human like species in the fossil record. And then you will also find a challenge from genetics. And the main argument is that when you look at modern human genetic diversity, it is so great that you can never just reduce all human genetics back to just two individuals. So if you think about the way your chromosomes work, your DNA works, you have two copies of each chromosome.
You get one from your mom and one from your dad. Okay? That means that if you put two people together, Adam and Eve, they each have two, you know, versions of each chromosome. Between the two of them, that's potential for basically four versions of any given allele or any given gene. Okay? It's actually called a gene. Genes have different alleles. Those are versions of a gene. So you could have four different alleles for any given gene across two different people. And what the, sort of mainstream, view would be is that there was never a way to reduce all of human genetic diversity to an initial pair of two individuals where between the two of them, they had just basically four versions of a gene or four alleles.
There's way too many different versions out there in human genetic diversity in the population today to allow you to do that. And what's interesting is that the main folks that are making these arguments against Adam and Eve, it's not coming, by the way, from, like, Richard Dawkins and his buddies. It's coming from theistic evolutionists, our friends who are Christians in the primarily evangelical world who have come out really strongly. In fact, Dennis Vennema and Scott McKnight wrote this book called Adam and the Genome, where they literally argue I'm I'm gonna paraphrase here, you can go back. This is not a misrepresentation of what they said.
They basically said that the evidence for humans evolving from a population and basically against us coming from a traditional version of Adam and Eve where we came from just two people. They said the evidence is so strong against Adam and Eve, it's like stopping belief that the earth goes around the sun. Okay? If you believe in Adam and Eve, it's they would say you're like a geocentrist who believes that the sun goes around the earth. Okay? If you believe in Adam and Eve, that's essentially what they're saying. So that was a pretty strong claim.
Luke BetznerI'm I'm curious about how they try to apply that argument.
Dr. Casey LuskinWell, I mean, they would say that one generation gave rise to the next. And over time, slowly, that population of of, you know, ape like hominids evolved eventually into and, you know, obviously, it branched off and split various times. But some version of that population of thousands of individuals probably at a time eventually turned into us. They evolved. They changed over time. That would be the So they would say that, you know, maybe in some environments, some individuals with, I don't know, longer shorter arms and longer legs and shorter arms and bigger brains were being selected for, and we our our ancestors came out of the trees. This is a very slow, gradual process of Darwinian evolution, natural selection. Those those individuals which were able to leave more offspring tended to do so, and then the population would evolve in their direction, and, eventually, those ape like things became us. That's that's basically the story.
Luke BetznerFair enough. Well, I do wanna touch on something else that you had just mentioned, and that is that there's people in the theistic evolutionist community may largely be evangelicals that are in they're making some kind of attempt at synthesis to try to say, this is the most modern science. Here's what the Bible says. So in addition to having already looked at the major challenges that the scientific community may put forward against this view of a actual Adam and Eve. What are the principal alternative models that Christians have proposed?
And I'm using that word very loosely. You'll say Christendom in general, people that typically hold to biblical principles. What are those alternative models that they have proposed to reconcile the biblical account with evolutionary accounts of human origins?
Dr. Casey LuskinSure. So there's sort of, I would say, four main evolutionary models that have been put forth by the theistic evolution camp to or folks in the theistic evolution camp, or who I would describe as being in the theistic evolution camp to try to reconcile Christianity with faith. Not everybody likes that moniker. Some embrace it. There's kind of the classic theistic evolution, evolutionary creationism model. Sometimes they like to call themselves evolutionary creationists, and that model basically rejects a traditional agony. They really don't even try to do that. In fact, to quote some folks who used to be affiliated more with BioLogos, the leading theistic evolution group, they they put out a white paper on ADME, and that white paper said that the human population was, quote, definitely never as small as two. Our species diverged as a population. The data are absolutely clear on that.
Okay? And so when they're saying this, they're basically saying that Adam and Eve did not exist in the traditional sense. Now BioLogos' view itself has evolved over time. That was around 2011 that they held that view. I'm not I can't speak for them today, but I can say this has been the standard, theistic evolution view for a lot of folks in the very recent past. Okay. Where where exactly they stand today? You'd have to ask them. And this view, again, basically, it really just says, look. We're gonna take the science for what it is, and we're not gonna worry so much about the theology.
If the science says that Adam didn't existed, then we're gonna just, you know, reject whatever thousands of years of Christian theology there may be saying that Adam and Eve did exist, reject whatever teachings of Jesus and Paul alluding to Adam and Eve. We're just gonna say that, you know, whatever. I I don't know what they would say. I guess they would say they were they're wrong or we're not supposed to really take it very seriously. Okay. So, But then you get folks who might opt for other options. One is called the Homo DeVinis model. The Homo DeVinis model is promoted by a biologist, in The UK named Dennis Alexander. He's with the Faraday Institute. He's atheistic evolutionist.
And this you basically says that at some point in the past, there were two individuals. They might have been Neolithic farmers. Okay? A man and a woman. They had their little hut that they lived in. They were, you know, a population of in a large population of humans that maybe lived, I don't know, fifteen thousand years ago, ten thousand years ago, eight thousand years ago. You can take your pick. And God just kind of picked them out and said, you're the you're the two. You guys are going to be the sort of the wellspring from which, humanity comes. So maybe he puts, you know, the spark of the image of God in them.
He puts a soul in them, something along those lines. They become sort of like the federal heads of humanity. Now note that, their offspring probably then interbred with all the other hominids or, you know, humans, basically, that were around at that time. So they were not our sole progenitors, and they absolutely evolved from a population of hominids just like the standard evolutionary story says. They're not specially created. They're just normal human beings that got picked out of a population and said, you're Adam and Eve. You're gonna be the the heads of humanity. And, you know, maybe he did some special things in their lives. Maybe they rebelled against him, and, you know, there was a fall. We could talk about that.
But there's no special creation of Adam and Eve. They're not our sole progenitors. And, yes, they absolutely evolved from a an earlier population of hominids. So that's kind of the the, Homo Devinist view. Then there's the genealogical Adam and Eve model. This was put forth by, a computational biologist at the Washington University of St. Louis named Joshua Swaminas, a very smart guy. You know Joshua? And, he's had some very interesting ideas. His idea is basically this. If you read his book called the genealogical Adam and Eve, this is the model that is put forth in that book. Okay. Basically, have a population of hominids that evolved. Okay. Standard evolutionary story to a t.
No divergence whatsoever. But then God specially creates two individuals. Okay? So they're not just, you know, normal people that were born of a of a man and woman. They are especially created by God. He kind of plants them in that population, and this is Adam and Eve. Okay? And their offspring then interbreed with the offspring of these other humans, hominids that existed who were not specially created by God, and we are the result. Okay? So that then sort of gives you, over time, two different classes of humans.
You get the folks who were the descendants of Adam and Eve, who were specially created by God in the image of God and from which every human alive today is descended. And then you get the folks who were these biological humans who, yes, they looked like Adam and Eve. They maybe even talked and walked and ate and hung out and joked with Adam like Adam and Eve, but they were not made in the image of God. And it raises some really interesting theological questions. You know? Did those biological humans, did they rebel against God? Did they sin? Did they have a fall when Christ dies on the cross? Did he die for them too? What happened to them?
Did they have souls? We are descended from them. Okay. As well as Adam and Eve. And so what Swamy Das would say is that if you go back far enough, you know, basically today in the year 2026, all human beings that are alive today, he would say, are descended in a genealogical sense from Adam and Eve. You could we could all trace you know, if you did ancestry.com, every one of us would have Adam and Eve in that family tree. And he would even say that at the time of Christ, everybody who was alive was descended from Adam and Eve. So, therefore, at the time Christ died, Christ died for all humans at that time who were descended from Adam and Eve, who were basically inherited that fallen nature from Adam and Eve. But what about the other humans who may have existed over time who were not descended from Adam and Eve? That could be a problem.
And again, you get to verses like Act 17, which says from one man, God made all the nations or Eve being called the mother of all the living. Like a defining feature of the genealogical Adam and Eve model is that at the time that Eve is created, she is definitely not the mother of all the living. She is maybe the mother of some of the living over time. And over time, her her market share of the living gets bigger and bigger till today. Now she is the mother of all the living who are alive today. But for a lot of human history, there are a whole lot of humans, folks that, you know, hung out and, you know, played pool with Adam and Eve and their descendants, and they were not descended from Eve. She was not one she was not one of their mothers, so to speak. Okay? So there you go. Then finally, there's the Hummel Heidelbergensis model, and this is the model of, William Lane Craig that Mike, talked about very well.
And I would agree with Mike very much. I'm a big fan of, Bill Craig and a lot of his work. He's done a lot of great work in apologetics. When it comes to human origins, I do have to disagree with a lot of his views. His view is basically that that Homo Adam and Eve were Homo heidelbergensis. Now I actually think that's possible if Homo heidelbergensis was basically a human like organism that was specially created by God and that we're all descended from. Okay? And that's possible. Like, I'm not gonna rule that out, but but his book is very hard to interpret. But if you read him carefully, I think what he's saying is that Homo heidelbergensis was a very human like member of the genus Homo who descended from other hominids that evolved from ape like ancestors.
So again, we've we're down to the standard evolutionary story. And, under this model, there was like a bottleneck where the population of humans got very small that happened around the time of Homo Heidelbergensis such that that bottleneck maybe came down to just two individuals. And now those two, after that bottleneck, were all descended
Luke BetznerIn light of that, Mike, as we listen to what Casey was saying about these four alternative models, how well do those alternative models that have been proposed even by Christians hold up when they're tested against the biblical material.
Dr. Michael KeasRight. Yeah. They fail both scientifically and biblically. So emphasizing the biblical part of that argument, my my kind of introductory little mini speech about Jesus and Paul would apply to to the one the the the classical theistic evolution, the homo de vinis, and to Bill Craig's view. Now it doesn't quite apply to Andrew Locke and Joshua Swamidas who have coauthored or kind of worked on this genealogical view, but but their view has other theological problems.
So I've already covered why, three out of those four views just won't work theologically, given the biblical text. Let me just emphasize how the genealogical model, although it affirms a unique creation of Adam and Eve or at least the possibility of that, they they both say, well, Adam and Eve could have been specially created. Well, the thing is they they have this very implausible scenario of Adam and Eve's descendants interbreeding with the larger hominid population. That is these these human like animals that were around that were reproductively compatible with humans according to this, speculative theory. Well, I'll I'll specifically hone in on on Luke's version of, Andrew Luke's version of the genealogical model, because he's the one that I debated at at the last, EPS, ETS meeting.
But, he says that, all the offspring of these animal human mating scenarios were fully human, and that helped to spread the image of God. And he thought he thinks that Cain or someone later like Cain pioneered this human animal blended family as a way to spread God's image. And, he toys with two possibilities that was either against God's will or in in sync with God's will to have done this. And, I show how neither neither option works, but he he he kinda favors that it was against God's will, at least in the debate. And so running with that, he said, well, it was just a moral test.
God made them reproductively compatible, which is not the case of today with, bestiality. If if a human has sex with an animal, they can't produce, offspring. It's impossible biologically. But in this theory, in the past, that was possible, and that the offspring were all fully human. And this is very problematic biblically because, it would be like God creating Adam and Eve with strong natural homosexual desires and say, oh, it's just a moral test. Don't do it. So, I mean, look, God according to this theory, God deliberately gave them this the sexual inclination, made it so that they could actually have children with these, almost human animals, that lack the full image of God. And and then God said, don't do it. And yet, Luke himself says that that he thinks God designed this as a biologically more feasible way of spreading God's image because of more genetic diversity. And the the science of that is really not not well founded, but because there's there's there's way to get genetic diversity without this, human genetic diversity today.
But the but the biblically, it's a disaster, because then you would have to say that God God, deliberately made it so that we would interbreed with these creatures as a way to spread God's image even though it wasn't a part of his his perfect will, and and that that's just incoherent. Okay? So there's several traits of a theory that indicate likely truth. One is, does it fit the evidence? So I already showed that the New Testament evidence of Paul and Jesus shows that any pretty much any view of theistic evolution doesn't fit the evidence of scripture.
The other is coherence. How well does the theory and its parts fit together? Is it just kind of cobbled together? Well, Luke and Swamandas have a theory, this genealogical theory, that is scores very low in the virtue of coherence. And and so I I sort of described that, well, on the one hand, god's god made all this possible for this interbreeding with animals that were almost humans, and yet he said and yet he didn't want them to do it. So it's just really weird stuff. And they also toy with the possibility that it was god's will that they they did this, but that's very, very problematic because if you have one parent who's an animal and another that's human, those children are gonna be put at a disadvantage. That's a dysfunctional family. Now because of human sin, there are a lot of dysfunctional families. True.
But in this case, it would be deliberately designed by God to be a dysfunctional family where children would have language disabilities and all kinds of problems with having one, parent who wasn't fully human and didn't have the the spiritual and the linguistic capabilities of a full humanity to be able to relate to god through prayer and and other things like that. So, there's no way given god's love and justice that he would deliberately design for humans to have this animal human mixed family scenario. Is just totally out of sync, and it's really incoherent. It's a bad theory. So that's the briefest way I can put this.
Luke BetznerWell, those all raise some huge vulnerabilities, I think, on the fact that the theory, of course, as we discussed in other episodes, is supposed to provide a good explanatory vehicle across multiple areas of knowledge and understanding. And it does sound like this one really falls short of that. I'd say this also raises a lot of specters for me as someone who's studying history of nineteenth century anthropology and all of its unfortunate labels when it came to different classes of humans. It also reminded me of the other articles that I've read that even within the evolutionary community, there are certain constructs of ancient humanoids that were not supposed to be reproductively compatible with one another. And they had to sort of change that after the fact as to whether or not Cro Magnon or Neanderthal were actually reproductively compatible based on overlaps at certain times.
So this this really does I I can see how this could provide some incomprehensibility and also a lot of bad things that fall from this theologically.
Dr. Michael KeasYeah. In in in my debate with Luke at, EPS, I pointed out that Luke, personally, as a very nice guy, and he's definitely not a racist. But his theory about ancient communities is racist because you have to imagine imagine a group of children from, you know, and they're playing with each other and and and one points out, by the way, your mom's an animal. Your mom's not even human. And that that is that is racist for for to say that that for children to have to deal with, this scenario where one parent is a human, the other is not human or not fully human.
And and that's the nineteenth century racism came in this kind of form where they would say either certain ethnic groups are not human or not fully human. And there are some forms of racism today that that say something a little bit like that. And so it's really Christianity is completely incompatible with any form of racism, so that makes it also theologically a disaster.
Dr. Casey LuskinOh, just yeah. To your point that, you know, questions about whether Cro Magnon and Neanderthal were reproductively compatible, You get very different views on those questions depending on who you ask in the mainstream, paleoanthropology community. But what's interesting is a lot of folks would say that those groups were all fundamentally human. Like, they just look so much like us that they we would have been reproductively compatible then if they were alive today. And we
Luke BetznerI I appreciate that, and we've covered a lot of ground. Now that we've looked at four alternative views that are things that are have more proximity to the evangelical community in particular, does scripture actually give us an implication or an indication of a date for the creation of Adam and Eve?
Dr. Michael KeasThe scripture is compatible with both young earth creationism and old earth creationism. That is the idea that that, the earth and and humanity were created a long time ago or a short time ago. And when it one of the arguments that is that are that's used sometimes to argue for, the idea that only a recent creation is possible is the genealogies in the Old Testament and in the New Testament. But when you compare the genealogies, they're they're in various books. Sometimes when you compare one genealogy with another, one genealogy will actually skip generations that are mentioned in the other.
And that points out that the ancient Hebrew genealogical records were only giving highlights of major characters because it doesn't doesn't specify that one was literally the father of the next generation but was the ancestor of. And so you have oftentimes in the genealogies, you have internal biblical evidence that a certain a certain number of generations were skipped, at least a certain number. And and I think overall, we don't all we have is what the genealogies do is they say that, yes, these people actually existed, and they existed in this sequence of time, but it's just, giving highlights to to fast forward the story to say, look. These guys died. They died.
They died. So the theological point is these people died. And and, yes, they were real people that had certain names, and they lived in certain times and places, but but the actual date is never the Bible itself never adds up these genealogies and say, oh, and so the creation of Adam and Eve happened on this on this day or this year back in the past. The Bible itself never uses its own materials to add those up to come up with a a young date for Adam and Eve. So Adam and Eve could have been created at the time that Bill Craig thinks they were about seven hundred and fifty thousand years ago or so and or or even earlier than that.
The bible doesn't specify. So I think the bible leaves it open then to follow the evidence wherever it leads regarding the science as to when Adam and Eve were created. But I think the Bible does not leave open the option of theistic evolution. They were specially created. They didn't interbreed with animals or human like animals, and that we all are descended from Adam and Eve and only from Adam and Eve. Those are, I think, are biblical biblically well established, so theistic evolution is excluded, but there's still a good, healthy debate among Christians who take all this biblical data seriously to say, you know, the biblical data does not specify exactly when that happened.
Luke BetznerExcellent. So we look at general compatibility there. And speaking of compatibility, we've looked at how these synthesis methods really haven't gotten us anything that's compatible with either what the science claims or with what the Bible says. It doesn't really resonate well with either community, which is really interesting. But I do want to address one thing that's sort of been a constant theme as we've been talking, that both the theistic evolutionist community as well as the evolutionist community would take the standard evolutionary model, and they would say, there's just not any genetic genetic evidence that human beings could have been conceived in the manner in which we are currently being reproduced.
And so, Casey, I'm gonna come to you on this one. Is there more than one way to look at that, and does it actually rule out humanity beginning from a primordial pair?
Dr. Casey LuskinYeah. Great great question. And, you know, this really was the scientific argument that was being used against Adam and Eve, that modern human genetic diversity is too great for us to ever have been descended from just a pair of two individuals. And, two colleagues of mine at Discovery Institute, doctor Anne Gager and doctor Ola Hastur actually, Ola Hastur is a professor of mathematics at the University of Stockholm in Sweden, but they collaborated together to test this question. They actually looked at modern human genomes.
We sequenced now over a thousand human genomes. And so they looked at these human genomes and they said, let's compare the genetic diversity, and let's then do sort of standard population genetics modeling. What this basically means is that the human population is experiencing mutations at normal rates that evolutionists will claim, you know, that they happen at. So, basically, we are adopting sort of a just as for the sake of the argument, we're assuming a normal evolutionary modeling of the human species. Okay?
Whether that's actually true, we can set aside. But they're saying, look. Could we get modern human genetic diversity when we look at all the humans around the world whose genomes have been sequenced? Could we produce that through normal sort of human evolutionary population genetics, modeling and processes, could we actually trace everybody back to just two individuals and still get the modern human genetic diversity that we have today? And the answer they found was yes, you can do that.
Now it requires that Adam and Eve lived around 500,000 years ago. Okay. So whether or not you can push Adam to be back that far, you know, that's a question for Mike, who's the expert in the in the in the scripture and the dating of and the and the genealogies and all those questions. But then what they showed basically is if you define Adam and Eve as basically two individuals who could have been specially created that are the progenitors of all humanity and basically fulfilled everything in the scriptures. You know?
Like, God made them in a garden. They they fell. They didn't they didn't say this in their scientific papers, but, you know, basically, it could it that could all be true. If Adam and Eve lived far enough back. You could establish modern human genetic diversity. Now, in their papers where they did this modeling, they basically assumed that this initial pair of individuals was gifted with a design genome with great diversity that was built into the genome. And what they they made this point in their paper that says, look. If we're willing to question other sort of evolutionary aspects of the history of humanity, then the date of Adam and Eve they didn't say Adam and Eve, but the the date of this original pair could actually be much more recent than 500,000. And there's actually a younger creationist team that did some modeling. And they said that, look, what if Adam and Eve not only were created with that genetic diversity built into their initial genomes, but also into their gametes, into their sex cell producing organs?
If you think about it, every human female at the time that she's born already has all of her eggs established. They actually grow while she's in the womb. Obviously, she can't have children until much later in life, but those eggs and their DNA is already there. For men, for males, you know, we have these testes that produce sperm and those testes have special cells that are designed to produce sex cells in the form of sperm. And so what if when Adam was created, both Adam and Eve basically had genetic diversity built into their sex cells?
And then let's say that you take the standard biblical view that Adam and Eve lived for hundreds of years and could have had dozens of children and many of the early people could have had lots of children in that matter. They basically found that if you model genetic diversity being built into not just the genomes, but also into the sperm and the eggs of Adam and Eve, and if they had many offspring over a few hundred years, like you might assume in the standard traditional biblical view, then you could get modern human genetic diversity being produced in just, you know, a few thousand years, a few 100 generations, basically. So, you know, basically, the the upshot is this. Whether you're taking a a young Earth creationist view or an old earth creationist view of Adam and Eve, the modern human genetic diversity argument does not preclude, Adam and Eve, all of us coming from an initial pair of just two individuals. Okay.
And then as far as, by the way, the other main scientific challenge we mentioned was the fossil evidence. When you look at the fossil record, it really is not at all clear that we can trace our lineage back through these hominid fossils that are evolving from ape like creatures into human like creatures over time. What we really see in the fossil record is a distinct break between the ape like creatures like the Australopithecines and then the human like creatures, which are the main members of the genus Homo, like Homo erectus, Homo neanderthalensis, modern humans, etcetera, they all have a very human like body plan and are very different from these previous ape like creatures like the Australopithecines. So the bottom line is that I would say the fossil record does not even document the evolutionary origin of humans. So the point of all this would be then if the scientific evidence does not require you to adopt an evolutionary perspective, we didn't even talk about junk DNA.
There's a lot of problems with that view too. That's another argument that is made for human evolution, many, many problems, because it turns out the junk DNA is actually functional and we can't use it as an argument, you know, that it had to have been a result of an evolutionary blind evolutionary process. The point of all this is being If the evidence for the evolutionary view is really not all that strong fossils, genetics, etcetera, then why should we expending? Why should we be expending all this energy trying to reconcile a, some kind of some version of a biblical view or a wannabe biblical view with the evolutionary model. If the evolutionary model isn't even right, why should we waste time trying to reconcile it with Christian theology?
In my view, it's kind of an unnecessary, expenditure of energy. If the evolutionary model isn't even right, we don't need to try to figure out how to fit that with a Christian view.
Luke BetznerI think that's a great observation, and it does point to trying to synthesize things that just are fundamentally seemingly incompatible. There's also another thing that popped up as you were speaking, and that really gave me a thought about it seems like based on what someone wants to find, they could potentially carve out from amongst all the different evidence that's there a sufficient pile of materials that's good for a model that sort of confirms its own bias as it goes along. And both sides have been guilty of this, but you're talking about some groups that seem like they're actually looking beyond themselves, looking at pulling in more evidence, challenging more aspects of it, and trying to find better explanations for larger sects or swaths of data. And that's, that's a really positive development regardless of which side they're on in my opinion. But I do want to come to your final thoughts as we're wrapping this up.
And, Casey, I'm going to stick with you for your final thoughts on the historical Adam and Eve, and then, Mike, I'm gonna come to you to close that out, and we're gonna have you recommend some resources for our listeners.
Dr. Casey LuskinYeah. I mean, I would just say that I don't know of any evidence that is incompatible with belief in a traditional Adam and Eve, namely that there were two individuals specially created by God at some point in the past, and they are the sole progenitors of all humanity. I don't know of any scientific evidence that has actually held up, goes against that claim. Now, I can't I'm not saying that I can prove to you scientifically that avenue existed. Okay? In fact, in science, we never prove anything. But, you know, we are dealing with, you know, some very difficult questions to even get at scientifically. But what I would say is I don't know of any evidence that contradicts or counteracts or goes against belief in Adam and Eve. And that's kind of where I stand on the on the question. So I accept the biblical view that God especially created Adam and Eve as our sole progenitor.
That's more of my own Christian perspective that I that I'm not gonna say I can, you know, scientifically demonstrate all that, but at the same time, I don't know any scientific evidence that goes against it when when properly understood.
Luke BetznerExcellent. Thank you for those thoughts, Casey. Mike, let's come to you on what are your final thoughts on this historical claim about Adam and Eve?
Dr. Michael KeasRight. Well, given that I care about integrating history, philosophy, science, and theology and that all of them are rational disciplines, all of them require theories that fit the evidence and that are coherent and so on, which is my expertise in the in in, the philosophy of science, you know, the traits of a of a reliable theory, well, then I agree with Casey that there is no science that that that counteracts or undermines an Adam and Eve. But, of course, there are also other disciplines, history and theology, where we do have good evidence, you know, and and I know Casey agrees with me on this, from the larger world of apologetics, like in William Lane Craig's work on the resurrection. You know, we got great evidence that Jesus really rose from the dead, and and he he himself refers to Adam and Eve as real historical people who did certain things that became the basis for marriage and and our morality. And so which kind of which unfortunately undermines Craig's own views about the the the lack of historicity of those specific events.
So we we can all get along at various levels. We we need to encourage everyone to think carefully, about why they believe what they believe in all these fields, science, theology, and so on. And once you get the full picture, I think the the the traditional biblical view that that Casey so well described is very defensible and, if you include not just science, but also theology and history, and that we we need to live out our faith in light of this really strong these strong arguments for that because our our faith is a reasonable faith.
Luke BetznerThank you for that, Mike. As we move into the final part of this, I'd love to hear both of your recommendations, just a couple of books each, even though there's plenty, for encouraging our listeners to dip deeper into the topics that we've covered today. Mike, I'm gonna stay with you on that, and then, Casey, I'm gonna have you close out. Just a couple recommendations.
Dr. Michael KeasYeah. I referred to a guy named Jack Collins. His his actual name is c, like the letter, c in cat, John Collins, and he, he's our colleague at Discovery Institute with Casey and me. And he's a first rate, Old Testament, Hebrew expert, and he's written a number of books on science and theology, such as did Adam and Eve really exist? How about that title? Fits fits this talk today. Reading Genesis Well, a more recent book. And in any of his work is really good. And he k. One of the purposes of my debate with with Craig and Luke, which he was gonna be a part of kind of a moderating voice and so on because all of us try to appeal to Collins.
Craig, Luke, I all quote, c John Collins. But, my arguments against Luke and Craig's views, I think, are bolstered by Collins much more so than, any incidental ways where they may where Collins may appear to be, to be legitimating the possibility of these other alternative views. So Collins' work really does well support the traditional Adam and Eve, and so I'd recommend any of his books.
Luke BetznerThank you for those recommendations, Mike. Casey, what are your final recommendations?
Dr. Casey LuskinYeah. I appreciate you asking that. Certainly I would recommend, the book, The Comprehensive Guide to Science and Faith that, has formed a really big part of this series. There's some great chapters in that by Faisal Rana, also myself, and Mike Keys as well on questions related to science of faith and human origins. Also, the book A Scientific, Philosophical, and Theological Critique from Crossway has some great chapters on questions related to how evolution interacts with human origins and the Christian faith.
And then lastly, I'll just do some shameless self promotion here. I wrote an article for a mainstream academic journal called, religions, and the article was titled Comparing Contemporary Evangelical Models Regarding Human Origins. And then that article actually go through, eight different models, the four evolutionary models we discussed today, as well as four nonevolutionary models. Look at what the science says and shows that the science is really much more strongly on the side of the nonevolutionary models. And you can decide which model you like best, but, sort of just, you know, evaluating, comparing, contrasting these different models and showing how the science really does not support the evolutionary, synthesis of human origins and Christianity.
Luke BetznerI wish we had three hours to dig into this because I feel like we just scratched the surface. And, of course, you gentlemen know that we didn't properly even do that. But to our audience, if you're enjoying what you're hearing on Paratus, we wanna encourage you to help support our outreach endeavors. So simply go to ves.edu and click the donation button on the top right side of the page. All donations are tax deductible and will help you think deeply, stand firmly, and live purposefully. I want to also encourage you to go to discovery.org where you can look into the work that doctors Luskin and Keyes are doing there at the Discovery Institute, as well as their own website that deals with even more of the work that they're doing in addition to discovery. So join us next episode as we address Why Does Intelligent Design Matter? With Doctor. William Demski. Until then, may the Lord richly bless you.
AnnouncerYou've been listening to Paratus, the broadcast ministry of Veritas International University. To learn more about Veritas International University, visit our website at ves.edu. That's ves.edu. Or call (505) 407-4307. That's (505) 407-4307.
What does the fossil record actually show about human origins - and how much confidence should we place in claims of a clear evolutionary lineage from ape-like ancestors to modern humans? In this Season 8 finale of...
Can Darwinian evolution build the irreducibly complex molecular machines found inside living cells - or do these systems point beyond unguided processes to intelligent design? Host Luke Betzner welcomes back Casey...
Does the fine-tuning of the universe provide evidence of purpose and intelligent design? Luke Betzner welcomes physicist Brian Miller, Ph.D., and philosopher of physics Bruce L. Gordon, Ph.D., for a rigorous and...
Can intelligent design make a positive, testable scientific case - or is it merely a criticism of Darwinian evolution? Luke Betzner welcomes mathematician, philosopher, and intelligent-design theorist William A....
Does nature merely look designed, or does biology provide testable evidence of intelligent purpose? Host Luke Betzner welcomes biochemist Emily Reeves, Ph.D., and physicist Brian Miller, Ph.D., of Discovery Institute’s...