Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Page Fright

Page Fright artwork

The Worst Trend in Books: Over-Explaining EVERYTHING! | Page Fright Podcast

Nov 17, 202655 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Write to us Authors, you've heard it on this show before: Show, Don't Tell. But why are stories across many mediums becoming more and more comfortable with telling the audience exactly what to feel and leaving little-to-no ambiguity in tone and message? The answer isn't shocking: it's money. More specifically, it's riding the line between audience engagement and accessibility of the media to maximize audience reach. While accessibility of media is a beautiful thing, how do you find the balance between audience reach and the artistic integrity of your narrative? Buy our favorite books and support our guest authors here! https://bookshop.org/shop/PageFrightPodcast Follow us on Socials! https://linktr.ee/pagefrightpodcast

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Happy Wednesday.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, happy Wednesday. Yeah, so audience, we're recording on a Wednesday, just so you know.

SPEAKER_00Whoa, insider secrets. What?

SPEAKER_01Well, uh, God. We didn't even discuss how we're gonna start this episode. We just like

SPEAKER_00we're like feral cats. Just like, we just can't be tamed. I heard you had some good writing days. From you. You told me.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I did. Uh yeah. So I I definitely have like a bunch of, I don't know, emotional blocks uh when it comes to writing. It's not just that I'm a perfectionist. It's like I get super overwhelmed the second I open the document. Like if I don't write every day and I step away from the work and then I have to get back in, the getting back in. I don't know if anybody else agrees with me on this.

SPEAKER_01I do. It

SPEAKER_00does. I hate

SPEAKER_01it.

SPEAKER_00There's something about just writing the next sentence. That's why I forced myself before I got on here to write a sentence in my new work in progress, because I know if if the days keep passing, months will pass and it just becomes this huge thing hanging over your head that you just won't do.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. And it's crazy. You'll do every other thing in your life, but that one thing, it's such a nightmare. So I actually um I started doing something that feels so stupid uh when I do it, but it actually works kind of crazy.

SPEAKER_00And I

SPEAKER_01was telling you about this when we were texting. Um, my therapist has put me onto positive affirmations and they actually work. It's kind of weird. Um, but uh basically I've gotten into this routine uh where, you know, over the days where I didn't write, I just started to fill up with self-doubt all of these horrible, horrible, poisonous thoughts about, you know, can I do it? I can't do it, there's too much to be done, um, it's too much of a mess.

SPEAKER_01Um, you're secretly not good. Uh, all of these things that build up. And what I do is I just kind of do a little, I what are what is it called? Uh, a burn book on myself. I do a mean girls burn book, uh diary entry where I literally just write out all of those thoughts and it's like I'm purging it from my system, you know, like it's just like it's all leaving. And then the next part of my little diary entry is like the exact opposite.

SPEAKER_01I just, it's like rewiring my brain. I force myself to say ludicrously nice things about my abilities, about how the book's going, about how the book is. And like it's weird, but it works. And then I set a little goal for myself. I'm like, this is what I want to accomplish today. And I was able to actually do it over all my writing days this past week and was really happy about it. I was able just to stay on task and

SPEAKER_00that's awesome. It doesn't sound weird at all to me. I mean, it makes a lot of sense. Imagine if you were hanging out with somebody all day and all they said all day was like, you're pathetic, you're a terrible writer, you're lazy, you're this, you're that. You hang out with yourself 24-7. If you're talking bad to yourself all day long, that that can be a real downer.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but girl, I'm a realist.

SPEAKER_00Oh my God.

SPEAKER_01That's my excuse. Honestly.

SPEAKER_00No, if you were a realist, you would say, you know what? It's probably not the worst, probably not the best, but it's good enough to be published. That's what like a realist would say.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, actually, you're right. Um, there a lot of uh pessimists uh mistake themselves for realists. They're like, they're like, I'm not, I'm not a downer. I'm not saying that everything is bad. I just see the world as it is. Yeah, it's uh it's definitely a a mistake, I would say. It's been it's been holding me back. So I had two great writing days this week. Really happy about it. Um, and I yeah, I hope to just keep moving forward.

SPEAKER_01I'm just gonna try to like, I'm not gonna try to set any big overarching goals. Like, I'm done with that. I'm done with that life. You know, you ask me like, when are you gonna finish it? I'm like, six months. Yeah, I'm done. I'm done. I'm just like one goal at a time. Let's get it, baby.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that was so early 2026. You're you're you're like late 2026 now.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm ready for 2027. Thanks. Me

SPEAKER_00too. I'm ready for it.

SPEAKER_01Well, how about you? How's your writing been going?

SPEAKER_00Writing, I mean, I have about 500 words written in my new book. Um, mostly I've been focused on being on sub with my whore and getting events scheduled for my launch. And I actually just scheduled a launch event in Austin at Birdhouse Books. I'm gonna, I'm still working out the details on that, uh, but I'm gonna be in Austin on February 2nd. So if you're a listener in Austin, come and see me. I'm gonna be there.

SPEAKER_01I'll be there too, because I live in Austin. I'm gonna be trying to, I'm gonna, I'm gonna be trying to reel in people to come and and fill out the event. I I hope I hope I'm success successful. I

SPEAKER_00hope you are too. When when when they we were scheduling the event, she's uh she's like, Do you have a big community here? I'm like, no, I I live in Dallas. Um and I'm a debut. So

SPEAKER_01you should have said my podcast uh co-host lives in Austin and will be advertising it on our podcast and on our Instagram.

SPEAKER_00And I also have

SPEAKER_01another friend who lives in Austin and she's part of a big community too. So be optimistic.

SPEAKER_00Yes, yes, that would have been much better. I think I wasn't expecting her to say yes. I'm just so used to rejection in this industry that when I when I said, um, you know, I'm interested in doing a launch event, and then she said, Oh, that sounds amazing. I was like, What it does? It sounds amazing. Oh, okay. I wasn't expecting this. I didn't plan my next part. My next part was please, please consider.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I really, really want it. That's funny. Well, speaking of rejection, uh, I really want to get into our wait what segment for today, because it's all around something that I saw online a few weeks ago that is supposed to be, this is gonna be like industry news kind of stuff, people. So um, we're not talking about craft today. We are talking about the publishing industry.

SPEAKER_01Uh it's supposed to be an answer to publishing houses that are skittish about picking up new authors and uncertain about whether they should sign new untested voices. So I was just going to pull it up on my end and read uh this Instagram post, which I thought was incredibly informative. I'll I'll give a shout-out to the creator as well about this new publishing company.

SPEAKER_01It's kind of a it's a it's a weird hybrid. Um uh are you ready, Sydney?

SPEAKER_00I'm ready.

SPEAKER_01I think it's so interesting. And I kind of don't know what to make of it.

SPEAKER_00I have a lot to say.

SPEAKER_01So, shout out first to the Instagram account uh creator Alexa P. Drake. Uh, that's A-L-E-X-A-P-D-R-A-K-E. You should find her on Instagram. I find her posts very informative. I think she she finds really interesting news uh from the industry, and she has a lot of interesting questions uh that she poses to her audience. So uh here we go. This is what she wrote. Publishers want proven hits. What if investors could find them?

SPEAKER_01Two former Amazon publishing executives have a new business model for developing the next big fictional franchise. After years at Amazon Publishing, Jeff Bell has joined with fellow former Amazon exec Nicholas Dennison to create McGuffin Co. Its goal is to find and develop the next franchises across books, movies, games, and other merchandise. Bell saw the growing tendency of publishers to acquire safe titles with known demand rather than taking chances on new authors.

SPEAKER_01So now he's built a company to capitalize on that risk-averse mindset and to treat franchises like startup companies. Here's how it works. One, McGuffin identifies promising fictional concepts, including ideas developed internally and those submitted by creators. Two, it assembles creative teams to develop and test prototypes with a community. Three, promising concepts have investment offerings, allowing investors to fund further development.

SPEAKER_01Four, McGuffin develops the franchise and seeks licensing deals with publishers and other media companies. McGuffin has already got publisher interest. Its first agreement is with Andrews McMeal Universal for Arthur Trope's The Inscrutables, a franchise that spans comics, a digital greeting card catalog, a periodical, and novels, with apps, games, and animation currently in development. After allowing community members to grade the property, Andrews McMeal Universal will then decide whether or not to acquire it.

SPEAKER_01This option model allows publishers to back creators with very little risk. McGuffin's market testing period is supposed to give concrete insight into the sales potential of a project. Bell notes that the option fee is smaller than an advance and lets a publisher, quote unquote, place smaller bets on different projects. If a publisher decides to fully commit to a project, it quote, is getting a stake in all the franchises' IP.

SPEAKER_01To make each franchise financially viable, Bell anticipates each project will be, at minimum, a trilogy. McGuffin currently has 50 ideas in their pipeline. So I have questions. And this is Alexa P. Drake again, she's asking these questions. What's the revenue split between investors and creators? I assume creators get a much smaller piece of the pie than a traditionally negotiated publishing contract, because the creator, she put that in quotes, only pitched a concept.

SPEAKER_01McGuffin then brings other creators together to make it a reality once it's greenlit. Her next question, how much will AI be involved? Because once investors have committed money, they generally like as quick a turnaround as possible. And if these pitches are just concepts, then there's going to be quite the crunch to actualize them once they have cash. Another question, who will legally own the story? All of these questions are amazing for this venture, by the way, in my opinion.

SPEAKER_01With investors, the original creator who gave the pitch, and a whole mess of artists implementing the idea once it's greenlit. I wonder who owns the story. Another question, how much control will the original creator retain? I'd guess this will uh depend on each offering or concept, but I'm getting a headache just thinking about having to navigate this. Me too, Alexa. Me too. And then she summarizes this is a uh this is part of a bigger trend. I talked before about Simon and Schuster's Simon Streams, and she did.

SPEAKER_01It was a really interesting post. Again, want to promote her, go find her on Instagram and follow her, being particularly interested in indie authors. Now McGuffin wants to take that model to the next level with franchises and a startup financing approach to finding the next big thing. Publishers have always been risk averse because they want guaranteed profits. But this, combined with the rising importance across all genres for authors to demonstrate market reach, feels like a solidification. And then she asks, What do you think?

SPEAKER_01So I wanted to take the opportunity to discuss it with you, Sydney, and I don't know, talk about what we think about it.

SPEAKER_00I th I think it's really exciting. And if it's done right and ethically towards the author, uh, then it can be a really exciting company. And by the way, they're not the first people.

SPEAKER_01Is there even an author, though? Like that's the interesting thing because it's like there's a pitchmaker, you know, there's someone that gives them the idea, and then they hire a team.

SPEAKER_00So there is an author. The author writes the story, but then they have a team of people that make it into like video games or you know, apps or whatever. It's like a it's like a whole franchise, kind of like Harry Potter kind of turns into that. They have like Harry Potter World and stuff like that. You know, J.K. Rowling didn't create that that theme park, but I'm sure she's getting a huge amount of money from it. So that's a I think it's a huge money-making opportunity. And they're not the first people to do it. Alloy Entertainment did it with Gossip Girl and Vampire Diaries, and Skybound Entertainment did it with The Walking Dead.

SPEAKER_00So there is precedent, you know, for this. There is

SPEAKER_01hold hold on, hold on. Because this is specifically talking about like engineering a hit, right? Not chasing a hit with merchandise, with a theme park, with uh with video games. Like Harry Potter, all of that stuff came after the book.

SPEAKER_00True. That is true,

SPEAKER_01just knocked it out of the park, crazy profits. And then they were like, let's make movies, let's make toys, let's do everything. Same thing with Star Wars, same, like every hit that we know of right now is like it's it comes, it it's not engineered in this way. And that's what I find really interesting about this, because it's like they're trying to pro to predict something that's going to take off. And I mean, everybody's trying to predict that.

SPEAKER_01And I'm not sure if you can predict that with a focus group. I like this, because this feels really focus groupy to me. Well, I find it very interesting that they that they're Amazon executives because Amazon,

SPEAKER_00um, they're their Tradpub uh part of it, um, not the independent publishing part of it. They are notorious for making best sellers because they have nailed the algorithm. So it makes sense to me that they would be able to create big franchises because um they have an idea of what sells. They know how to market it, they know about ads, they know how to place it in the algorithm. And I think it I think that they could be very successful. And and and let's let's be real.

SPEAKER_00Publishers engineer bestsellers all the time with how much they're gonna put into ads.

SPEAKER_01That's true.

SPEAKER_00It's actually very smart of them to be like, let's dive all the way in, trilogy minimum, have all these different aspects, and let's let's like milk this cow for as much as we can get.

SPEAKER_01I mean, so there's another side of this because I could I can I can feel a lot of knee-jerk reactions to this type of venture being like, what about the little guy? And I'm like, it actually might help the little guy. Because from my point of view, and tell me if I'm wrong, the whole structure of publishing is surrounded around you get the whale,

SPEAKER_00you

SPEAKER_01know, you you get the unbelievable hit. It holds your entire enterprise together as a publishing company, and that allows you to pick up a bunch of other to take all the little risks that you you wouldn't otherwise take if you if you weren't making up making enough money to get by via the big hit project. So like if you can in a safer way guarantee profits via this company, you know, where you you get your whale, you know, you manufacture your whale,

SPEAKER_00like

SPEAKER_01really effectively. Um, and you and you know in the next year, because I don't know, it it actually worked, you know, all all of this all of this manufacturing uh of the amazing hit actually worked, and you're able to say, hey, we're gonna make this amount of money in the next fiscal, fiscal year. Does that mean that you can invest more into more editors, more marketing teams, more, more resources, more resources for the debut books that you sign up or the mid list authors that you have on your roster that weren't getting as much love before?

SPEAKER_01Like, do you think that that money is going to be dispersed in into those areas when they have more of a guaranteed hit on their hands? I don't know.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And and actually, as you were talking, I started thinking about ownership over the IP. So they offer an option, which is what uh film agents do too, and what um production companies do for um manuscripts is they'll uh buy an option for your book. And it's usually for a specific amount of time, and that tells that gives them that amount of time to do something with the book, like get a producer, get a team on board and actually start production. And so they pay an option fee, then they beta test it with a group of people, and then if they like it, they decide to invest and buy it.

SPEAKER_00But then the investors, everyone who's put money into it, gets a stake in the IP. And I think that's where it would get the most tricky because if there's gonna be a trilogy minimum and you have an idea where you want this book to go, but you don't own it 100% anymore, do they get to control your story? That's something that I would worry about. Like, do they get to control what happens to the characters? Or if you want one of the characters to die and they're invested in

SPEAKER_01it and

SPEAKER_00they say, No, you can't

SPEAKER_01do it.

SPEAKER_00I think they do. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I I like these these hits, essentially like on an artistic level, like that's like I get really squeamish because I'm just like, oh, who's deciding whether characters live or die or have have these problems? Like, I I don't know. And like, is it is it some sort of like non-artistic production team that understands the algorithm better than an artist? Like, fuck. Then like, okay, like, do I would I actually want to be part of a project like this?

SPEAKER_01I

SPEAKER_00know that scares me. Like, what if their artists that are making the animation make the characters look like something that you don't want them to look like at all? Or they make them do things that you don't want them to do, or you hate certain parts of it, and now you don't own it anymore. It's it's almost like they've reached into your brain and have stolen something that's yours and they're turning it into whatever they want. That's the that's the very pessimistic side of it. That's what I would be afraid of. That's my fears.

SPEAKER_01I feel like you're basically signing up to be a television writer at that point, you know? Like you're pitching a pilot script to a television studio, and it's it's ultimately going to get uh farmed out to big writing teams, you know. Your your ownership is always going to be in question over the product that gets made from season to season to season, you know. So I I don't know. I I don't know how book authors would be able to take that, but maybe it's just a new breed of creative who would sign up for something like this.

SPEAKER_00I also saw that another um potential issue, aside from losing rights and creative differences, is that uh it could really rule out slow burn stories. What we're gonna be seeing here is very big hooky ideas. And so you're gonna see things that are more in your face, and maybe some of these slower stories that aren't as popping out to you with big hooks aren't gonna get picked up as much. Which I mean, that may just be the nature of this company, that they don't want slow burn and they want, you know, big things like Star Wars or Hunger Games or Harry Potter, you know, they want things like that.

SPEAKER_00So, but that's just something, you know, to think about as well.

SPEAKER_01Well, so it's and and to my point earlier, like if I think that there's room for everything in the industry. And if if slow burn doesn't sell, you know, if they've cracked what sells and what sells can be supportive to structurally to the development of more avant-garde voices, more outsider voices, and that would be wonderful. I just don't know if that's actually gonna happen.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think uh, you know, this came out in 2024. So I haven't, I've never even heard of this. So I don't know. But I mean, that's not saying much. I don't hear about a lot of things unless someone tells me about it. But I would love to see like what it creates. It makes me kind of one of I think every artist also dreams of seeing their words on the big screen or seeing it in video games. I mean, I I imagine some of my stories being turned into a huge franchise. I mean, who wouldn't want that? And I think there's pros and cons to everything that you do. So that's really what's interesting about publishing too, is that you can take it at your own pace and figure out what works for you.

SPEAKER_00We have friends who don't want to do trad pub at all because they don't want to lose any amount of creative decisions.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And

SPEAKER_00then other people who don't feel that way. So I think this is another one like pick your pick your game and what do you want to do? Pick your level of risk.

SPEAKER_01You're dancing around it, pick your poison, people. Poison.

SPEAKER_00Let's go ahead and move into our main act where we are talking about another issue. In writing and publishing, and we've been seeing some readers complaining about this, which is why are authors overexplaining plot and overexplaining emotions?

SPEAKER_01So I found another, another Instagrammer who I thought, you know, she she just put her opinion out online of her experiencing reading books nowadays. This is um her opinion, and I mean Sydney just beautifully summarized it. Uh, but I thought that just the way that she explained her thinking around it was very interesting. And I wanted to do a react segment uh for today's podcast to this particular issue.

SPEAKER_00While you're pulling that up, I'm gonna get my coughs out. I've been recovering from a lung infection. Sick, bruh.

SPEAKER_01Sick.

SPEAKER_00You have two messages, by the way.

SPEAKER_01I know. Guys, I haven't read my messages. Are you ready?

SPEAKER_03Calling the opposite of an acquired taste in books, maybe uh an acquired pet peeve. And it has to do with this crisis of books over-explaining themselves to the reader. The thing that bothers me in particular is when an emotional experience is like beating you over the head with a frying pan, and the author is using three, four, five, six sentences when just one would have done fine. And sometimes a different sentence than any of the ones that they chose to bring in. I read a book earlier this year called The Emotional Craft of Fiction that I thought was excellent. And one of the main points really was that the second you tell, didactically tell the reader what to feel, they stop feeling it.

SPEAKER_03It becomes an intellectual exercise. I recently posted a video that was a list of books that I thought to be intelligent, and one of my criteria for a book that's intelligent is a book that trusts the reader to get there. It's not gonna do the banal work of connecting this particular physical reaction to an emotion word for you. It's been making me stray back towards classics to authors I already love, and it keeps threatening to put me into a reading slump, which is why I keep DNFing things where I see it. I don't know if you all are also seeing this pattern or if you know what I'm talking about here, but I would really like to see less.

SPEAKER_00Man, authors just cannot catch a break. You know, all we're trying to do is write a story, and then people

SPEAKER_01have so many

SPEAKER_00opinions about it.

SPEAKER_01I know. Well, I loved this because I feel like it encapsulates all of my worries when I write. Uh, because I feel like being an author writing a book is doing this dance of how much do I tell, how much do I show, how much do I trust my audience. And I think that it's it's really i it is a guessing game. You don't know, you know.

SPEAKER_01And apparently this woman is reading a lot of authors who guess wrong.

SPEAKER_00Yes. I I don't hate over-explaining. Sometimes I think if you want to drive a message home, it's okay. I I I think the best way to approach this is because I think we can all agree, yeah, okay, show, don't tell, but sometimes you should tell. And you know, don't always don't treat your readers like they're dumb, blah, blah, blah. But I think the way to approach this is to talk about why authors do this and understanding why this is happening.

SPEAKER_01Or their editors make them do it, just so you know.

SPEAKER_00I wasn't gonna

SPEAKER_01say it.

SPEAKER_00Number one, we have the second screen issue.

SPEAKER_01Second screen issue. What's that?

SPEAKER_00Where like you're not just focusing on it, you're looking at something else. So like Oh,

SPEAKER_01I've heard about this, this, that's no, no, no, I'm never gonna write for a second screen. Ever.

SPEAKER_00Well. I mean, that's what TV shows have to do now because most of the time people are looking at their phone while they're watching TV. So they're

SPEAKER_01not gonna be able to do that.

SPEAKER_00No, they don't

SPEAKER_01have to.

SPEAKER_00You're right, they don't. But they want their viewerships. They don't want people to go, I don't know what's going on. I'm gonna change it to something that's like less brain power, you know. So that's one thing I think that is influencing the way media is taken in.

SPEAKER_01You should make people want to know what's going on.

SPEAKER_00That's true. I mean, yeah.

SPEAKER_01That's that's my argument. I hate this where it's just like, oh, let's just give up and let's just assume that everybody's brain dead. And and like, it's just like, no, your show's not interesting.

SPEAKER_00Your

SPEAKER_01show's not making people put the phone down.

SPEAKER_00It's true.

SPEAKER_01You know?

SPEAKER_00I actually have my second screen shows where I put on a show that I know is really boring and dumb that will just soothe me at night so I can play a game on my phone that I don't need to pay attention to.

SPEAKER_01And that's that's a fine thing to make. I'm I I actually don't really have anything against doing this activity or making that kind of show. But like if like it's just such a sad state of things. If you're if you're a writer room, if you're a writer's room and the producer or or some some some somebody on the business side, it's just like, we want it to be this kind of show. So you are going to be boring and you are going to be super obvious.

SPEAKER_01It's just like, this is like, oh, kill me. You know, give me a paycheck, but also kill me.

SPEAKER_00I also think that there's a lower tolerance for ambiguity. And you see this too with like cliffhangers. People hate cliffhangers or endings that don't give the answer, or it's like a not clear answer, which those are my favorite. I love endings where I have to interpret it. Um what's that movie that was out? With with Hugh Grant, the heretic. Heretic.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00That one was so amazing in the end. There's a whole scene. I'm not going to give it away, but there's it's it's basically a movie about like religion and and being an atheist and this guy preying on these two girls. I saw

SPEAKER_01premiere, actually. Oh, so you've seen it.

SPEAKER_00And then the ending.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, the the directors introduced it. Oh, that is so cool.

SPEAKER_00Loved that movie. That to me was a genius, genius movie. And the ending mirrored the theme of the show, which was for you to interpret the ending based on your beliefs. Are you an atheist? Are you religious? And that's probably gonna that that's probably gonna be how you interpret the ending, which I thought was so amazing. And some people hated the ending that they didn't know what it was. And that's the whole point of it. It's like, it's okay for it to be ambiguous and for you not to know.

SPEAKER_01Well, and it's it's interesting because like listening to this woman, I I am a reader like her, where I will read things and I do get annoyed when I'm told. And I do feel like it's like, okay, now it's an intellectual exercise. Like, I really like that the way that the experience of being overtold uh is described in the book she mentioned, where it's like I I've stopped feeling it. And the feeling the feeling that you want me to feel because you're telling it to me.

SPEAKER_01And I think that part of that disconnection that happens when you tell is it's almost like when you're a reader, you have like there's like a mystery to be solved. If you're not told and you're going, I think this is happening, and you and you are generating all of that energy by going, I think so and so is the killer. I think such and such is gonna die. I think she feels sad in this moment, you know, and here are all these complex reasons why.

SPEAKER_01And the book is not telling you, like there is there's some sort of like you are pushing all of that energy along. And it's like the book is like kind of just dangling you, like like dangling something for like bait for you to just follow. And that is infinitely more fun than you just like oh, eating the bait and okay, I ate it. What next? Give me more book. Okay. She's sad.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01You know, she's scared.

SPEAKER_00I completely agree. I I also think that authors are afraid. They feel like they have to justify their their words or their character's actions because there's this cancel culture. And are you an author that um promotes violence? Are you an author that believes these things? So there's this overwriting to try and defend their actions. Um, we've talked about this before, but you see it in dark romance where if the girl, the guy that's the dark character that's kind of It's always the guy,

SPEAKER_01yes.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. The morally gray character does something very questionable, but then the main character still likes him. And I think the main the author, this is one thing I cannot stand, is when the author tries to overexplain why the main character still likes this morally gray character. I don't want that. I I want you just to make me uncomfortable. Don't make me feel like it's okay just to like this character. I want to feel uncomfortable in my feelings. Like, why am I still attracted to him, even though he's done these horrible things? I want you to challenge me to feel to feel that, not to placate me and make me be like, okay, here's why you can still like him.

SPEAKER_00Here's the other good things he did, here's why you're feeling this way. I don't want you to tell me that. But there's this fear. There's this fear that they're gonna be canceled or that people are gonna be mad at the characters.

SPEAKER_01Or they're gonna think that they're they're somehow bad. Like even if even if nothing, no repercussion comes for them, like in their career or real life, they're just like imagining readers going, Oh, she's sick. And I can't take it. So they try to make up for it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I would love for writers to think like, wow, Sydney is sick. Like she's got something going on in her brain. If somebody thinks that about while they're reading my book, then I'm like, yes. I

SPEAKER_01mean, plenty of great writers, like absolute classics, have been accused of being horrific people, you know, because of what they wrote and how they stood by it. Like they, they, the, their, their plots and the questions that they asked via their plots, like and the messed up characters that they wrote about, a lot of people misinterpret it as them condoning the behavior or them trying to indulge in the behavior of the character when in reality all they're doing is exploring the behavior.

SPEAKER_01Because honestly, all that behavior exists in the real world, and looking at it is not a sin. Like trying to go, why does this happen? Why do we have these different emotional reactions to these horrible events or these horrible uh characteristics of of different people in the population? Like, why do we like why do we want it sometimes? You know? Like, because honestly, like that that is a real question to ask about society. Like, we a lot of society says, all of this is bad, you know?

SPEAKER_01Like, you you don't you don't want to do any, any, anything that is gonna hurt another person. And yet a lot of people seek it out.

SPEAKER_00Well, and think about how often a day you're filtering thoughts. And I'm assuming most people are like this. You can't say everything that you think. You have to learn what's socially acceptable. And I think a lot of times writers

SPEAKER_01tell tell that to my grandma.

SPEAKER_00No, I'm not gonna say it to your grandma. She can she can say all the unfiltered words she wants. Don't worry, she she might actually appreciate it.

SPEAKER_01She's like, Oh, that's a real one. Okay. I'll tell her that she needs a nose job and she can tell me that I need to correct my character. Anyway, that's a real thing that happened, just so you guys know. Okay, go on.

SPEAKER_00That was making me lose my train of thought.

SPEAKER_01So sorry. Anyway, please go on. People filter their thoughts. And

SPEAKER_00so I'm authors like to find the thoughts that we filter, find the things that we're not allowed to say and say them and explore them. And that's what makes an author with a good voice someone interesting that we want to read. They could someone that taps into those thoughts and writes them down makes them interesting. And I don't want to hear the cookie cutter thing that you're allowed to say. I want to hear the thing that you're actually thinking. And yeah, it could get you canceled sometimes.

SPEAKER_00But

SPEAKER_01yeah, absolutely.

SPEAKER_00I mean, that's what makes it interesting.

SPEAKER_01Back back to the craft side of things. I think that there's there are other reasons why people why authors are overtelling. So you have the second screen thing um that you just talked about, but also I feel like, and it's not it's not a fear of being canceled, it's it's it's an honest underestimation of the ability to put two and two together. Like or empathy. Here's a particular thing that I don't like.

SPEAKER_01Uh in a lot of modern, and these are just basic romance books that I've been reading recently. And I'm not going after romance authors. These are these are the select few that I have read within the past few years. Okay. So it could be anybody. Um, but it's this habit that I'm seeing, and these are like hockey romances. These are very like office romances. There's nothing, it's not dark romance, it's not romantic. This is like the most basic kind of thing.

SPEAKER_01There's this habit that I'm seeing of almost psychoanalyzing each of the characters and having like them in their narration about themselves, like they psychoanalyze themselves. It's like I'm sitting there watching them on the couch with a psychologist going, Well, this is my history with my parents. And this is why I have this major character issue. And I think I need to get over it in this novel.

SPEAKER_01And you know who's not gonna help me? The person that I'm desperately attracted to. It's just like, it's so obvious, and it annoys the crap out of me. Because I'm like, people like, and this might be like a modern thing of like how people actually think about themselves. It might be like super reflective of how everyday people are going through life. Because a lot of people see therapists.

SPEAKER_00Yeah,

SPEAKER_01a lot of people psychoanalyze themselves. A lot of people talk about their life in relation to what was your trauma as a child? What did your parents do to you? You know, how how did you get over the divorce? Like,

SPEAKER_00as a psychologist, this makes me very proud. And I actually love this in books. I'm like, yes, the insight, girl, the insight is there. You're working on yourself, you're aware of your issues, you are ready for it. Every character's

SPEAKER_01working on themselves. Like, okay, the firefighter who doesn't see a therapist, who can barely put a sentence together, he does not need to think this way. Uncharacteristic.

SPEAKER_00Well, if he can't think that way, he doesn't need to be in a relationship. You gotta first heal yourself before you can be with someone else.

SPEAKER_01Oh no. No, everyone deserves love.

SPEAKER_00Not the ones that have not uh analyzed their life.

SPEAKER_01No, it's cause harm to others. Their drama. Anyway, that's that's like my personal overtelling, pet peeve, because I'm like, let your character mess up through action. And like, because honestly, like it isn't, it becomes in their the entire point of a romance is to have character flaws interact with each other in such a way that character growth happens, right?

SPEAKER_01And action is so much more representative and so much more fun of character flaws than an over over-explanatory internal uh, you know, talking session.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I understand. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Like have that happen.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. You want discovery, not you want them to grow and understand themselves through discovery. I understand what you're saying.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Yes. Or through lack thereof.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01You know, I like I absolutely love as a reader the friction from knowing what the character needs and watching them not know it. You know? Where like you just you are you get to analyze them. You do.

SPEAKER_00That annoys me so. When

SPEAKER_01they're not reflective, I think it's so interesting and fun and so tension-filled because you don't know whether they're gonna make the right choice.

SPEAKER_00I guess it would have to be, I don't know, if it's if it's an emotional thing, like a romance, and they're it's it's like the miscommunication trope. I really don't like that trope.

SPEAKER_02And

SPEAKER_00I feel like if they're like, why are you

SPEAKER_01so you don't like pride and prejudice? Sydney.

SPEAKER_00You are feisty today. You need to bring it down like three levels.

SPEAKER_01I'm lethal when I want to be.

SPEAKER_00You are, you could you got those claws out. That's true. Okay. I don't always hate the miscommunication trope. Actually, that's hilarious. Someone just left a review on my book that my book's a miscommunication trope, and I was like, no, it is not. I cannot stand the miscommunication. But everyone's laughing

SPEAKER_01together.

SPEAKER_00We're getting way sidetracked here. Um, what were we talking about?

SPEAKER_01You're saying that you don't like the miscommunication trope.

SPEAKER_00So is

SPEAKER_01it like you don't like when characters fight stuff about themselves? I feel

SPEAKER_00like if people uh if they're like, why are things not working out for me? Why are my relationships not going well? Why are we fighting? It's like, I don't know. Maybe if you realize that you're very defensive and you're not able to communicate properly or that you're very triggered by anger, like maybe if you could figure those things out, your issues would be resolved. That annoys the hell out of me when I have to be thinking that.

SPEAKER_01What I think what you are identifying is when an author has put their character in a non-growth stance and you feel like everything is stagnated for no good reason. Like what you're complaining about is lack of payoff in the plot and the character growth or the character arc. Because a character arc can also be a full-on descent breaking bad style. They just get worse and worse and worse. A lot of people enjoy that, you know?

SPEAKER_00That's fun.

SPEAKER_01If if someone is stagnated and you see them continually making the same mistakes, and there's no directionality to those mistakes, yeah, duh. I I would I would absolutely hate that. What I'm what I'm saying is there's clear directionality, there's clear plot, everything is going in a certain way, but you're telling me, you're hitting me over the freaking head that it's because they're getting over their mom's abuse or something. Like just let me wonder about it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I I hear what you're saying. It's that's like a more of a show-don't tell situation.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, I remember when you first wrote uh read my writing, we had a wonderful show-don't tell uh discussion. Cause like I remember you were like, Yeah, I just didn't get what was going on. And I was like, Yeah. And I didn't like I remember telling you, I was like, I'm pretty much trying to get away with as little tell as possible and then pepper in based off of what my beta readers tell me.

SPEAKER_01So like I think that that's my stance as a writer, where I'm like, my first draft is going to be as little tell as I can, as I think I can get away with. And I know that that's probably going to be more than is acceptable for readers. And then I feel like my read, my beta readers, my editors are gonna get me to the point where like I hit that sweet spot. Because that's what I'm aiming for.

SPEAKER_00Well, I think too, what the difference is there is the amount of effort it takes. When you're reading a book that's more in your face, it doesn't take a lot of mental effort to read. And with your books, and it does take mental effort. You have to be thinking about it, analyzing the actions, paying attention to facial expressions, which, you know, now, you know, I I love it. I just had never read anything like what you write, and and I love it. I love the challenge to read it and then be like interpreting my own feelings onto it. Uh, and it does bring up a lot of feelings for me when I read your writing.

SPEAKER_00And I love that. I love your writing. So I think you're totally right. I think there probably is a happy medium, you know, like probably if you're to go to the Trad publishing route, they're probably gonna force you to put some times he was angry, you know? Um, because this is another thing I actually was reading about this because I started reading about this issue. And that one of the reasons there's a lot more show is because of accessibility and wanting non-English speakers and to have like a a broader market for it to be sellable to a wider range of people, that non-English speakers uh may have a harder time recognizing subtext or symbolism and buried emotional cues.

SPEAKER_00So instead of saying, you know, his mouth pursed ever so slightly and his fingers wrapped the table, whereas we might say, okay, maybe he's getting impatient and angry, um, they might not catch catch on to that as much. And so you just say you could still say that line and say in anger. So that way they can understand the emotional cue. So it widens the market, and you know, uh publishing's a business and they want to sell more books. So

SPEAKER_01that was really painful for me to hear. Uh and painful because I can understand both sides of it. I can see the purpose of trying to be more inclusive, but I also go, you know, learn the language and the culture better of the book that you're trying to read and that language and culture. Cause and I know that that uh I'm not getting me canceled, but let me let me give you an example. So a lot. Lot of books written by authors who are not American, um, authors who are, you know, obviously living in their own country, a lot of great pieces of literature um across the globe are very, very entrenched in their culture, in their linguistic styles.

SPEAKER_01And when you read them in their linguistic styles, you are expected to, by the author, to know what the culture is.

SPEAKER_02And

SPEAKER_01sometimes they can be really um, I forget the word for it, but it's like they they're very referential to like local culture. So for example, I um in my book club, I was uh reading Heart of the Dog. Uh it's by Bolgakov, Russian literature, a great, wonderful 20th century writer. And one of the critiques from the group was just like there were so many references to early Soviet culture that were that went completely unexplained, that like true enjoyment of the book could only be found after doing a certain amount of research.

SPEAKER_01And you had to be committed to that. And like the book on its own, to a foreign reader, would be like, okay, this is a crazy plot. But like there were all these like little references to what it was like in 1929 in Soviet Russia in Moscow and what was happening here. All these little inside jokes. And I don't want to lose that. I don't want to lose the sense of travel and exploration and newness. Uh, and I don't want to take that away from pe from readers who are not America, uh, not American, not English speakers.

SPEAKER_01Like I want them to experience something that is specific and timely and rich with that specificity. So that's what I would argue on the other side. Like, just be true to yourself. You want to give people a clear individual voice.

SPEAKER_00I I tend to agree. I I want a book that is gonna immerse me. I want it to be totally true to their culture. I don't want to have it to where I can understand it better. You know, I want to be challenged to read something and understand the culture better. And I as you were talking, I was just thinking about how different, even different physical cues and emotional cues and facial expressions can be interpreted differently in different cultures. Um

SPEAKER_01100%.

SPEAKER_00Like in Japan specifically, you know, if if there's a scene where they're on a subway and the whole uh or on a train and the whole train is quiet except for one woman talking, you might be inclined to think that something's going on with all the passengers and this woman on the phone's not noticing. But in actuality, if you know the culture, you know that you're not supposed to be talking on the phone on the train, you're supposed to be quiet. That's respectful. And actually, she's being extremely rude. So, you know, so little things like that you might not catch on to, and maybe it's not important to the plot, but I want to be able to understand those little, those little details and pick up on it because that makes it more fun.

SPEAKER_01As a former anime fan, I'm talking about my teen self, teen Lisa. Uh like one of my favorite things, like I learned this from from watching anime, and I I wouldn't want them to take this out out of it. Just like characters would like hold up their pinky practice, and it was like a like talk like teasing someone talking about their their boyfriend or girlfriend. I can't quite remember exactly what the reference was, but like I would watch these animated characters being like this, and I was like, I don't even know what that means. And I had to look it up, and it was so fun.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's like it was

SPEAKER_01a cool inside cultural joke. I learned something.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And I thought that that was a beautiful thing.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I I yeah, I see both sides of it. I see wanting to make something more accessible, and then I also see wanting to keep it true to the writer and the writer's voice.

SPEAKER_01And just to cycle back, just like the things that I complain about in the romance books that I read and and all this kind of stuff, I do it as a reader, you know? And and I say that because I feel like there are tons of different reading groups, you know, reading markets. Like readers want a bunch of different things. And you're always when you're writing something, you're aiming for a specific set of readers, right? Um, and you have to, you have to recognize that other types of readers will also pick up your book and not like it.

SPEAKER_02Yes, you

SPEAKER_01know, and they'll have this girl's complaint. This girl is closer to me. I feel like she's she she is searching for a specific feeling that a lot of classic literature will give you and a lot of commercial literature from today will not give you. And she she's kind of expressing her upsetness about that, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And so that's I don't know, that that's kind of how I feel about listening to that kind of complaint as a writer where I'm like, okay, I just need to pick my audience and I'll be fine.

SPEAKER_00Let's move on to throwing a tomato.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Uh I did not look up one. I completely forgot. I'm so sorry. I knew it. Let me look one up. I was so good for the past few weeks. You have,

SPEAKER_00you were.

SPEAKER_04One hour later. So

SPEAKER_01let's throw a tomato.

SPEAKER_00All right. I chose to do a review, a bad review that would make me want to read a book.

SPEAKER_01Ooh,

SPEAKER_00okay.

SPEAKER_01Fun.

SPEAKER_00So I chose uh Victorian Psycho. Although I feel like your review of the movie made me not want to say.

SPEAKER_01No, no, no, I want you to see this movie. And I want to hear your thoughts on it. Um, and then you can hear mine. And

SPEAKER_00then we can argue.

SPEAKER_01I don't know. I don't know what will happen that conversation.

SPEAKER_00We're either still gonna be friends or we're not. I mean, it's love stakes, you know what I mean?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, love the lowest possible stakes. It's just a friend ender.

SPEAKER_00Um, okay, so this is two stars, Victorian Psycho. I'm actually so upset that I didn't like this. Maybe the writing style wasn't for me. Everyone else loved it, so it's probably me. It had some great, disgusting and depraved scenes, but overall, I just didn't enjoy it all that much. I don't know why. That review just made me really want to read it.

SPEAKER_01Hell yeah. Well, that actually made me want to read it because I'll say this the I want more disgusting and depraved scenes.

SPEAKER_00Oh

SPEAKER_01I wanted more of that. Okay. It made me wonder like, okay, did we get creative with the depravity? Because that would be enjoyable.

SPEAKER_00That's that was my issue with Verity the movie, is they left out the scariest scenes in the book. The book had scenes that literally made me put it down to recover for a minute before I would continue reading. And they completely left them out in the movie. Oh. So I don't know.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I know. It's always hard.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Well, I have a review for uh the book that just won the Booker Prize. And uh it has a lot of buzz because what people say is not coherent. And uh today we talked a lot about how much to tell, how much to show, like how do you trust your audience. Um, and so I haven't read this book, so I'm not gonna judge it.

SPEAKER_01But the things that I've seen online are people saying, uh either applauding the Booker Prize judges for picking something that feels so outsider and uh experimental. And also, you know, people saying, like, a lot of people are gonna try to read this book and they're not gonna like it. So it's kind of it's creating this little mini controversy. Uh anyway, so it's called The End of Everything. Oh, I've heard of it.

SPEAKER_00I've heard of it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Uh so I'm gonna read a one-star review for it. Not for me, semicolon, DNF. Uh, sixth book and second DNF from the Booker Longlist 2026. This was my first book by the author, and sadly I had to DNF after 100 pages. I tried my best to get through, but it became more and more incoherent with words, sentences, and description of events. I am fine with absurd, bizarre, and complicated, but this was incoherent.

SPEAKER_01I felt like a lot of information is kept away from the reader, which can provide a key to this puzzling story. I read a lot of five-star reviews in the hope that it may give me some clarity, but that too didn't help. I just thought it was really interesting, you know. This that

SPEAKER_00actually made me want to read it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, this big, prestigious award has been given to this specific book. And I mean, apparently it it it told very little. So and a lot of people have feelings about it. So I wonder if that'll make it um great literature for the ages.

SPEAKER_00Definitely.

SPEAKER_01Or

SPEAKER_00for sure.

SPEAKER_01Uh a big old flop mistake from the book or people.

SPEAKER_00No, I don't know. I have a feeling it's like yours, where you have to analyze it and pay attention really closely. And

SPEAKER_01I

SPEAKER_00have a feeling people just didn't have the patience for it.

SPEAKER_01Possibly. I'm I'm gonna try to read it, um, you know, like it's because what I've heard is it's it is very experimental. Like it because it's talking about the end of everything, it's talking about kind of an uh an apocalyptic situation. And, you know, if everything's falling apart, maybe the writing they're going for the prose also falling apart on some level.

SPEAKER_00That's cool.

SPEAKER_01Um, and that can be very difficult to follow along with and to get emotionally invested into. So um, I don't know, I'm gonna take a crack at it. It's gonna be interesting.

SPEAKER_00Well, I'm excited because next week we're gonna do the second half of our book club. Uh Gray After Dark. Oh

SPEAKER_01my god.

SPEAKER_00So I cannot wait. And so if you haven't read it, read the whole thing, okay? Because we are gonna do spoilers. Because how can you do a review of the end of the book without spoiling the end of the book? So read that book. It's great. And uh

SPEAKER_01we gotta redo this. We gotta say the name of the book, girl. I did. It's gray after dark. You didn't. No.

SPEAKER_00All right.

SPEAKER_01Did I just like have a brain fire?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I said it.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Well, I fucked it up, so you gotta say it again.

SPEAKER_00Girl. I am so excited because next week we're doing the second half of our first book club, and we are reading Gray After Dark. It is a very, very scary, exciting thriller about a girl who gets kidnapped in the mountains.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And everything that happens after that. There will be spoilers, so you better read the book. And uh thanks for listening. We'll see you back here next week on Page Fright.

SPEAKER_01Like and subscribe.

SPEAKER_00You just listened to Page Fright. Don't forget to like and subscribe and write to us at Pagefrightcontact at gmail.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Page Fright's FIRST Book Club: Gray After Dark!

    Nov 10, 202641 minAudio

    Write to us Can you believe it? We finally launched our book club! To quote Sydney: "What a gift to the world!" In this very special episode of Page Fright, authors Sydney Kain and Liza Petrov dig deep into their...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. SIMPLE Tips for Writing Your First Page-Turner Novel!

    Nov 3, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Write to us You know those books you shouldn't read before bed? No, not the horror novels (well, maybe sometimes the horror novels). We're talking about the ones which keep you up for hours, all while you make promises...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. What Makes an "Unlikeable Character" Interesting?

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Write to us Unlikeable characters: You love them, you hate them, you LOVE to hate them. Though, how do you take a character that is designed to be unlikeable, yet still make them interesting, entertaining, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What Is Simon Stream and Should You Use It to Self-Publish Your Book?

    Oct 13, 202652 minAudio

    Write to us Authors, there is some huge bookish news that Sydney and Liza are talking about today on the Page Fright Podcast! Simon & Schuster have launched a brand new digital-focused self-publishing imprint called...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Your Novel's Dialogue is Lacking and THIS is Why

    Oct 7, 202655 minAudio

    Write to us Welcome back to another episode of the Page Fright Podcast, and this time, we're talking ALLLLLL about...talking! Dialogue can make-or-break many novels, and writing it well is SO difficult. Too much small...

    Credit the people on this episode