Craig Elsten, Chris Reed, and Raphie Cantor gather on the Monday after the 2026 Padres postseason came to a close. The flamed burned bright, until they ran into a VERY good Brewers team. Where did it go wrong? What were the lessons going forward? And how do we even begin to look ahead into an uncertain offseason? Want to get this show and tons of others early and ad-free? Plus access to post game shows, our vaunted PHT Discord server and more? Become a patron at patreon.com/padreshottub
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Padres Hot Tub is a community-supported podcast, and that community has grown and grown over the course of the last month, six weeks, as the Padres made their playoff push and then made it through one round into the Division Series round of the playoffs. But the community doesn't slow down once the season comes to the end for the San Diego Padres. If anything, it might pick up because once you get into Rumorville, once you get into the ideas of who's going to opt out, Who's going to be traded?
Speaker 1Who's going to be signed? What's the payroll going to be? All the questions. And heading into a lockout? Hey, all the questions of labor and management and everything in between. It's all being discussed on our Discord on a daily basis. Plus, you get Banter the Show, which is our completely separate show that is exclusive to our patrons. They love it. They've demanded. They demanded back. They wanted it. And we give it to them each and every week, not only
Speaker 1giving our personal lives and just literally living up to the show's title of banter, but we also live up to the end of the show's title, the show, by volunteering ourselves to go through our patrons submitted ideas for crazy discussion topics, crazy things for us to do. And then we spin a wheel and whichever one it lands on, we do that. And that's a show you only get If you join us as a patron, which is still just $ 7 a month at the intro level for all the folks who are here, stick around. And for everyone
Speaker 1who hasn't, please give us a look at patrion.com slash. I grace hot tub. Yeah. Welcome to the Padres Hot Tub, everybody.
Speaker 1Craig Elston, Chris Reid, Rafey Cantor. It's Monday, October 12th. The NLCS is two games deep. The Padres are watching it. And so are we. It's tough, but true. Milwaukee Brewers ahead of the Dodgers two games to none. Holy cow.
Speaker 2Maybe.
Speaker 1Maybe the Brewers were really good after all, fellas. And the Padres taking them to four wasn't the worst result in history. How are you?
Speaker 2I'm good, Craig. That's basically the gist of what I said on the post-game show following the final game of the season. It was like 1 a.m. or something here when I finally got to it. But it's validating in a sense, yes. the next best thing to winning a championship is getting eliminated by the team that eventually does like, because then you get the, well, we only got beat by the best. And like, it's not a consolation prize
Speaker 2by any means, but it does feel good when it happens. And, um, it doesn't feel good, but it's like the smallest bit of solace and it would be the smallest bit of solace watching the Dodgers lose. Milwaukee has an insane pitching staff. We did their bullpen a little bit of an insult by not covering them as much as we did, I guess. I mean, I thought we did good on our pregame show talking about Ashby and McGill and Uribe and the
Speaker 2weapons they would have. But we got to see Pat Murphy utilize just about everybody against us. And they've been mostly perfect the entire playoffs.
Speaker 1So.
Speaker 2Looking at it, I got some thoughts on what stalled out the team in the round. We got a great couple games against the Cubs to hang our hats on a little bit. The Cubs had a much better Pythagorean record than the Padres, but we saw the Padres play great the last month, and I still can't help but feel that even though there were two better teams than them in the National League, I think fairly objectively, they could have beat either of them.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's interesting how in the Cubs series, the Padres faced one of the best lineups in the last decade in professional baseball, but the original sin of that Cubs team is that they did not have any pitching. They did not have any starting pitching, and their bullpen was pretty lackluster as well. And then when the Padres faced the Brewers, the Padres were then confronted with their original sin, which was that, yes, they had the bullpen, but they
Speaker 3didn't ever have enough starting pitching. And it's sort of funny how this long and bending arc of this season, which 2026 was a fascinating Padres season, you know, coming out of the gates really hot and then slumping in May in a way that the team really hadn't in a long time. And then at one point being the league worst offense at the halfway mark. and then completely turning it around for the second half of the season.
Speaker 3And in that first half, getting really unexpected performance from the starting rotation. And then that also taking a step back after making additions as well in the second half. And in the end, at the end of the season, it still kind of ended with exactly what we thought it was going to be when we were doing our preseason podcast in March, which is that You look at the Padres roster and you think, I don't know if these guys have enough starting pitching to make a serious run at it. And Craig, it turns out that they didn't.
Speaker 1No. And it turns out at the end that they didn't have enough bullpen to finish either. It's really hard in the modern day game When you start playing world series reindeer games in game one and game two of a wild card series to keep that up and win 13 games, I think it's.
Speaker 2Really, really hard.
Speaker 1And I know that in the very initial stages of the wild card era, the wild card, and especially the giants, you know, like they jumped in as a wild card and won the world series. And it became like, no, you'd rather be the wild card, uh, and, and be hot and get on a roll. But each year, Major League Baseball in the last decade has gotten, and especially in the last six years, has gotten more and more extreme about condensing their pitching staff, utilizing starters out of
Speaker 1the bullpen, utilizing rest days as bullpen days, you know, truncating and carrying a nine-man bullpen and using five of the guys. Uh, like those type of actions have accelerated where like you stop utilizing your pitching staff and instead it's just this group, you know, this tight group and we'll absolutely double up a guy, you know, we'll take
Speaker 1our starter and pitch him on game two and relieve him on game three. Uh, but those things are so unsustainable over the course of four weeks that And I think you see all the young pitchers in the playoffs right now to one extent or another.
Speaker 2I'm being general.
Speaker 1But the young starters who've carried the mail, and Mizorowski and Henderson, really both of their starts, only okay. Struggling a little bit here. It's hard to get through an entire season and then pitch another month and have that last month be the best month that you work.
Speaker 2So.
Speaker 1I'm really starting to feel in this playoff watching it that the way to build a World Series champion is to be able to build a team that can cruise, that doesn't have to do what the Padres did, which was to light the fuse and have the best 55-game record down the stretch in order to fight your way in as a wildcard team. No, you need to be
Speaker 1able to be up there in the high atmosphere like the whole season so that you don't have to deplete your staff, you don't have to wear them out at the end of the year, you can tailor their workload to the end, and you get to give them a week off before you start attacking, and it's two fewer games, and that means two fewer games. You know, like, if Morhone was healthy, he was going to pitch, like, every game. Right? You know, Brad Glay pitched every game. of the division series. And that's a young guy, right? You know, the last
Speaker 1time he pitched, he gave up some hits like shocker, you know? So that's what I think needs to be the puzzle, like for the Padres to solve going forward is how do we build a team that doesn't suck for the first 60 games and, and, you know, muddle their way through and all the stars are hitting two Oh eight. And you're like, okay, well, we're going to pick it up in the second half. Yeah, we are, but we're going to burn the rocket so hard. that we're going to run into these other teams that are better situated and better prepared, and we're going to run out of pitching. You know, and just like it happens
Speaker 1every year, it seems.
Speaker 2It's funny. You guys each, you know, Rafey points to the bullpen, you point at the starting pitching crag. And you're not wrong, like both of them did let down, but I don't assign them the blame for losing the series. I assign the most blame to the Padres' lack of depth and production from guys in the middle and the bottom of the order. Because... amongst Dustin Harris, Luis Camposano,
Speaker 2Samad Taylor, Austin Hayes, Ethan Salas, and Miguel Andujar, the Padres got 65 plate appearances. They walked six times cumulatively in that section, which is really bad, number one. So that brings it down to 59 plate appearances. In those 59 plate appearances, they got nine hits. So 15 times on base, out of 65 plate appearances they only knocked
Speaker 2in three runs and those guys only scored four runs and that's just not enough production i know the brewers are very good but it's not enough production in a modern playoff series so the brewers benefited a lot from key home runs i think they have hit about the same number as the padres yeah and i know this is a you know in um about the same amount of games now that they've played two against the Dodgers. But the Padres hit six home runs in their six
Speaker 2games in the playoffs, and the Brewers have hit five. So from a power standpoint, the offense was about the same. The difference is the same little chunk of the Brewers with Jake Bowers, Christian Yelich, Joey Ortiz, Sal Frelick, those four guys alone walked 11 times and got on base 11 times and were able to come in at way higher rate than the Padres did. And you couple that
Speaker 2with their really insane pitching, they're a better team.
Speaker 3Yeah, I mean, like, I think in miniature, you know, we can look at that final inning of Game 2 when. Mason Miller, you know, had trouble finding the strike zone. And, you know, I believe that that inning began with South Free, like I'm pulling it up right now, South Freelick grounding out. No, it was Garrett Mitchell.
Speaker 2No, he walked.
Speaker 3No, it was Garrett Mitchell ground out to start.
Speaker 2Yes, and then Freelick walked.
Speaker 3And then Yelich walked.
Speaker 1Walked. That was the key. Because then he stole second and started giving the signs.
Speaker 3Yep. And then Freelick walked.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3And then Andrew Vaughn flew out, and then Gary Sanchez, of course, walked before Chirio came up. But after Garrett Mitchell grounded out, in the Yelich, Freelick, Vaughn, and Gary Sanchez plate appearances, Andrew Vaughn's fly ball to center field was the only time that anyone swung a bat.
Speaker 1Yep.
Speaker 3In those four plate appearances. And I think that in miniature, that says so much about the series and who these teams are. The Brewers were the most patient team in baseball and incredibly well-disciplined, incredibly well-prepared, and managed.
Speaker 2Very, very well.
Speaker 3And the Padres... at the end of the day, you know, going against baseball's best team who are going to expose your weak spots, uh, were over leveraged in, in certain aspects of their roster. Um, and there are a myriad reasons for that. Many of which we will talk about on the show. Um, you know, obviously the more hone injury was, I think the defining thing for the Padres in this series, it, it, it literally affected every other
Speaker 3game after game one. Um, every game, um, as well as the fact that the, uh, Craig, I believe you, you coined the Craig Stammen trust circle of, uh, relievers, uh, effectively shrunk the Padres roster. Um, so that they were playing with 23 guys instead of 26. Uh, cause there were three pitchers who were never going to be thrown no matter what. Uh, it seemed like at least based on the fact that they weren't thrown, um, Um, and yeah, Craig, sorry,
Speaker 3go ahead. No.
Speaker 1So here's the thing about what this team had to do. And this is, you know, again, I'm kind of building my, my narrative argument here, but when you have a super pen with three guys that you rely on all year as your victory formula, right. But more homes got that extra edge. Cause he can go two innings for you and Miller, you know, he can go two innings for you, uh, did it twice during the regular season, he could get four or five outs if you really had to. And
Speaker 1when you're desperate from the 100 game mark on, which they were, to turn it up to that World Series notch, you know, playing at that 114 win pace level, well, you're leveraging those guys and they wind up pitching career highs. and Adrian Morohone pitched a career-high 86 innings, career-high 76 games. You get to the end of the year, you ask
Speaker 1him to pitch two innings in Game 1 and come back on Game 2, and he doesn't answer the bell. He can't. He can't answer the bell for Game 3 either. Meanwhile, Miller does, but he hasn't been the same pitcher for a while. And Acey actually had the breakdown game in his final newsletter of the year, but from August 25th to the end of the year, Miller had a 4-9-1 ERA in 16 games in 18 and a third innings.
Speaker 1FIP was 3-2-6. Average jumped almost 100 points from 134 to 225. On base percentage, jumped almost 100 points from 224 to 321. Walk percentage jumped to 12.3%. Strikeout rate dropped from 48 to 40. The second closer is a classic closer, you know, a little erratic, walking guys, striking out guys. The first closer is Mason Miller, the best in the world. And for one inning in game two,
Speaker 1you got that from Mason Miller. You got 12 pitches, one, two, three, two strikeouts, sit down. He was asked to get three more and. Somewhere in the middle of that second inning, he lost the zone completely and nobody want, I know, you know, nobody had to swing a bat to load the bases until Churio came to the plate. I'm not here like Mason Miller, you suck. I'm saying you run these guys so hard and then you ask him to run harder. And that was a great point you had
Speaker 1made on one of our postgame shows, right? If you write that everywhere else in the postseason, you're maximizing advantages to put your players in the best situation. And then for the relievers, you're saying we're going to ask you to work just double hard.
Speaker 2I really don't think Craig Salmon did a bad job of that. I think Mason Miller had two innings in him. If you look at it, I don't fault that decision at all. And the Brewers used the exact same amount of relievers as the Padres. They just did better. They just did better. You know, more homes, a home run away from. From being perfect, Mason Miller is a half inning away
Speaker 2from being the guy we needed him to be. And that's it. Like, I thought Fangraphs had a good article on Craig Stammen and his bullpen usage. You're welcome to go check it out. It was by, um, it wasn't by Ben Clemens. It was by, uh, oh, crap. You should know this guy better than I did. It's by John Becker.
Speaker 1John Becker.
Speaker 2Thank you, sir. the fault they had with Craig Stammen's managing was the lineup. Specifically that it took him all the way until the last game of the season to figure out Jackson Merrill should hit the two. Such an outside perspective. 100%. Padres hot tub fans have heard me argue for that and then give up midway through the season because we saw what he did. And, you know, my adage for the Padres two spot was whoever, man. Like,
Speaker 2whichever left-hander you feel best about that day. And for a long time, that was Dustin Harris, and he did really good, but then came the playoffs, and he put a 3-for-17 up with one walk against two strikeouts, 398 OPS. Like... If that's your two-guy for the bulk of the round, that's tough. And, you know, that's all... um john becker saw was dustin harrison going wait why is this well
Speaker 2we saw him we saw samad taylor we saw jay cronenworth we saw jackson merrill like padres fans had seen it the whole year we know exactly why jackson wasn't hitting two until the last game.
Speaker 1Yeah I'm not trying to. Be stuck on a point. But I do want to get back to that. Game two. Because I did agree with you. All the way until game four Chris. And this is where really. I get to the circle of trust issue. That I did have. Okay great. Fangraphs likes it. But Fangraphs is always going to like. The algorithm is always going to like. when the pitchers with the maximum effectiveness are given the maximum leverage. That's what it's built to detect. So if you're overusing
Speaker 1those guys, it's going to still like it because it's like, no, well, that's what you have to do. But I think to win four rounds in the postseason, you have to do it as a group. I think you can win the World Series like that. Absolutely. And have to pitch the World Series like that. But to get through four rounds, it's going to take a village. And the thing in game four that really stuck for me was when Joe Musgrove came in and shoved for two innings. He didn't wobble.
Speaker 2Yeah, when we said he probably wouldn't pitch. No, he had that stuff we saw.
Speaker 1Well, that's the thing. They put him on the first round roster. He pitched in game one. He was super shaky. He got out of it. You never saw him again.
Speaker 2I don't think he was shaky. He was wild. He was rusty. He was rusty.
Speaker 3He got Mason Miller up with an 8-0 lead.
Speaker 2He was shaky. He was shaky. That's true.
Speaker 1So then we're like, okay, well, he's not going to pitch again this postseason. Then they put him on the second round roster. Said, okay, that was a critique I had. I said, why is he here if he's not going to pitch? And then It very much appeared that he was never going to pitch. He was basically the last choice when they were trailing in the eighth and ninth innings of game four. And they brought him in, and he was freaking terrific. And I start to think to myself,
Speaker 1sliding doors, alternate universe, where Joe Musgrove pitches the eighth inning of game two.
Speaker 2We don't know. We don't know. He could have, we don't know where his elbow was. Like that's the whole thing about him coming back for the playoff run is we're not, we're not privy to that availability. Okay.
Speaker 1Then why is he on the roster? If he's not available, right? He was available. He, he pitched in game four. He was available.
Speaker 2And they need, they needed the innings from him. He was the next guy on the list. Like again, The Dodgers have pitched 13 guys. They've used everybody, and they've had dudes like Chris Bubich and Edgardo Enriquez blow up on them and explode. David Morgan is perfectly capable of that. We've seen it time and time again. Jason Adam was shaky. He was shaky the whole time. I really feel like it just comes to the ammunition that you have in
Speaker 2reserve and how it was deployed defensively. Didn't work out. Like, you look at the Mason Miller, you know, ninth inning, and he threw more innings than he ever has before. I think by something like 15 or 20%. Don't quote me on that. I don't have it up. Oh, here it is. 70 innings pitch in the regular season. His previous career high had been 65. So that's 10% more
Speaker 2right about right there, and that's before you get into the postseason. So that it makes sense. Uh, you know, it's just to keep Roberts. Whereas like what, what, what's the thing that can be done, you know? Okay. I don't think it's throwing Griffin canning.
Speaker 1I don't know. It's always, it's always important to throw more Griffin canning. We always need some more canning in our menu. Um, no, I, again, I'm not, I just don't want us to be so incredibly agreeable about it, and then we're done in 15 seconds. I'm not trying to be artificially argumentative, but I do think that was the inflection point of the entire series. We could talk about the cable, but no one's going to know in
Speaker 1the history of the universe if that ball was going to go foul, if it really was going to go fair. It's the best thing for the t-shirt, but not for analysis. I choose to believe contrarians. who said it was going to be gone and McGill, who said it was going to be gone and France, who said it was going to be gone. I just believe those three people, they were the most intimately involved in the experience. Um, but nonetheless, we don't know. And even if it went out, we don't know that they were going to win in the bottom of the ninth. We don't know for sure. We
Speaker 1think we don't know because Mason Miller proved the next day that you don't know. And even, in the end, if Morajon had a shoulder that he couldn't lift and Miller had lost the plate because they were out of gas, the Padres achieved their seed. They achieved their destiny. They got as far as they could go and they lost to one of the two best teams in the National League. They were probably the third best and they lost to one of the two best who are now playing one
Speaker 1another and chalk one out this year.
Speaker 2To your broader point, Craig, to your specific point where The Padres high leverage arms were worn out by the end of the year. More on shoulder was worn out. Mason Miller was worn out. You're on more home pitched almost 90 innings this year. Like that is nearly like an average, like four starters workload in major league baseball getting to 86. And, you know, with the post season, that's probably damn close to 90. Cause he had a two inning year in there.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Multiple.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, like an insane season from him, insane usage for a guy, you know, not, I wouldn't say in his Tommy John recovery, but aren't these guys kind of always in their Tommy John recovery once they've had it?
Speaker 3I think we should talk about who wasn't used in this postseason. You know, I think it's very notable that that David Morgan did not see any playing time. Craig, it's funny when you were talking about Joe Musgrove in the... in that game for, uh, being used for the last two innings and shoving. And he was like, it seemed like he was the last guy that wanted to be used. And I'm like, well, no, I think David Morgan was the last guy I wanted to be literally never used. Um, even,
Speaker 3even when they were out of it, uh.
Speaker 1Randy Vasquez, they never used Randy Vasquez.
Speaker 3Thank you. Uh, my, the point I was just going to make was that, uh, the, what I find interesting is that amongst starting pitchers, Randy Vasquez through the third most innings, uh, This year, 140 and two-thirds innings for the Padres in the regular season. Did not see any postseason usage. Something I found absolutely fascinating and never would have guessed is that after Adrian Morajone, the next highest used pitcher in the bullpen this year was Wandi Peralta. Wandi Peralta threw 77 and a third innings this year
Speaker 3and was not available.
Speaker 1Was not used.
Speaker 3Not used once.
Speaker 1Wasn't selected. Then he was on for the paternity. Was never used. Thank goodness Wandy Peralta wasn't used.
Speaker 2I'll stay.
Speaker 1I'll spam that button all day.
Speaker 3I would never have felt.
Speaker 2How many losses did they have? And how many of those innings were in losses is my question.
Speaker 3But here's what I'll say. They felt more comfortable using Robbie Ray twice than than they did using Wandy Peralta.
Speaker 1I would have trusted Wandy.
Speaker 3And I would have trusted Wandy more in both of those experiences.
Speaker 1Over Robbie Ray. Just over specifically Robbie Ray.
Speaker 2Robbie Ray, yeah, but he, like, I understand the dream. Like, it doesn't make sense to an extent, but I understand, like, you look at him like, man, when we traded for him, he was the best pitcher in.
Speaker 4The National League. He could find it. He could find it. Wandy's never going to find it. I, I, I don't think it's just that crucial in the loss, the usage. I think maybe not using Randy Vasquez when you knew his roster spot was, you know, like basically free because he was going to go away once Walker came. So those are like innings you get. But in how tight these games were, I wouldn't have felt calm about him
Speaker 4coming in, maybe on a clean inning facing two righties.
Speaker 3But the idea that this roster spot was free, I'm going to push back against because it was free. They were only in that position because they chose to carry Miguel Andujar and Austin Hayes.
Speaker 2Well, I meant it free in that Buehler was on paternity and he was going to be coming back.
Speaker 3No, I understand what you're saying, but they chose to carry 15 hitters and 11 pitchers in both series.
Speaker 2That's why I go like the main... The absolute failure point of this team is Austin Hayes and the guys who performed like him in the playoffs. Austin Hayes goes 0 for 9. with one walk.
Speaker 1I would have given every single one of his at-bats to Andahar.
Speaker 2Yeah, I agree.
Speaker 1And I would have given Andahar the pinch hit at-bats if you needed it, that second right-hand pinch hit at-bat. Hayes turned into D.F.
Speaker 2Hayes.
Speaker 1He... was useless, and in fact, his process was as bad as Jace Bowen's by the end of the year, where he was just hard swing. You weren't going to get anything worse. Yeah, hard swing first pitch, and the pitchers just threw him an off-speed pitch, and he'd swing over it by a foot and a half, and then he'd swing at the next one, and then he'd swing at the next one. Yeah, and it was just every single time. Austin Hayes was a big miss. That is one place I would absolutely criticize Stammen. I thought the lineup juggling was weird. I think it's panicky. Uh, I,
Speaker 1I get it when, again, the algorithm's going to agree because the algorithm is going to say that Jackson Merrill is going to be great in the number two spot, but Ethan Salas in the five spot. That's crazy. That's crazy in a must win game that you're going to put Ethan's. Oh, well, we're going to pinch it from then. Why is he going to be there? Like, you know, I don't get that at all. And the lineup got thin instead of deep. But again, you are panicky. Dustin Harris is three for 17 going into that game.
Speaker 3That's the thing. It's just as crazy to put Harris in the two hole. I'm sorry. You can criticize Merrill being there all you want, whatever. But Harris being there was fucking insane.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 1And to give our Padres their grace, I think it has to be said. Today was a deep aberration. I don't know what's happening in the American League game. But an 11-run game is a friggin' unicorn in the 2026 playoffs. Other than the White Sox pitching staff collapsing at the end, you know, like in games three and four. Like, this was,
Speaker 1at least as of the weekend Sheehan newsletter, because he had done the numbers, the worst-hitting postseason of the 21st century. Like, the lowest ever. average, you know, slash line, everything. So it's getting harder and harder and harder and harder and harder to score runs in the postseason. Again, everyone is ramping up to this. We got to pitch every game like Game 7 of the World Series and have the starters come out of the bullpen and, you know, double leverage.
Speaker 1Grant Taylor coming to start the sixth and pitch four innings for the same, you know, and then When they needed Taylor to close out a game and get them to the ALCS, he gave up six straight hits and got nuked out of the world. Well, why? Because we're doing it like a college baseball tournament now. That's what they do in college baseball tournaments. We're going to overuse our top pitchers. If they get hurt, sorry, you're a senior. See you later. It's wild to me.
Speaker 2I get it. I understand.
Speaker 1It's because the prevention environment is the toughest it's ever been. So to keep up, you've got to stay with that. If you let Randy go out there and all of a sudden it's double, single, double, you know, and you're like, oh my God, I just cost us the entire season. So I can't afford it. I can only throw my highest strikeout percentage guys the most often that I can. And man, that's a hard way to win. It just, it's hard. That's what I'm saying. Maybe the ultimate story is how can we build a machine good enough that
Speaker 1it's not 100 games, 50 and 50, barely hanging on, you know, 5% playoff odds or 15% playoff odds, push all in, make all the trades, do all the things, you know, and transitioning. For me, I'm not going to be very regretful. I'm not going to be regretful about Craig Stammen's performance. Craig Stammen, first year, good job. Good job. A couple of learning lessons, a couple of lineup shifts.
Speaker 1You'll make the changes. Good job. Really good job. I'm not upset at the players' performances. Obviously, we can talk about a couple of them that might be on the way out. But Manny showed up. Xander showed up. Merrill showed up. France showed up. Tatis died off, you know. But not for a lack of want to, and it's very hard to hit in baseball, and it's harder to hit than ever, as I just said, in this postseason than in any time in history. So, But I think
Speaker 1the regret that I'm going to, I'm just really afraid we're going to look back on three years from now is that we burned draft capital or, you know, franchise capital on two negative value pitchers at the deadline. Like literally last time I swear, I'll say his name. Canning could have put up those innings of that much bad baseball. I mean, Casey Mize. Oh, well, he gave us innings.
Speaker 1Twice he threw six innings. Like, that could have been in the bag for a guy who could have equally put up a seven ERA down the stretch and given up a homer every four innings like Casey Mize did. And Robbie Ray of the career, you know I brought this up before, 741 ERA in the playoffs pitched to a 736 ERA in the playoffs this year.
Speaker 2People can get better, and that's proof of it. Right.
Speaker 1Exactly. So good on you, Robbie. And the contract's coming. No, I mean, like, those guys were a complete waste. They were useless in the playoffs. And God forbid Cash Mayfield turns into someone good.
Speaker 2Before I, like, defend those trades, I'll say you're absolutely right because we also got nothing from Ramon Laureano in this offseason and this postseason. And we got next to nothing from Jason Adams. Both are guys that AJ targeted because they wouldn't cost much money and he would have years of control when making those deals at the deadline. A little bit of a different situation with the pure rentals of Ray and Mize. Sometimes they don't work. And that's 0 for 4 in really major deadline deals the
Speaker 2past couple of years. Yeah.
Speaker 3I mean, look, it's well known that you pay a premium at the deadline. It's well known that guys don't always pan out. I am not going to sit here and defend Preller's roster construction or trading at this point at the deadline. I think that there's a lot of track record that's done. One of the things I said after that deadline episode, though, was. Maize and Ray's performance is sort of irrelevant so long as that they stay on the field because they were
Speaker 3primarily there as human meat shields who might be great, but also as long as they stay healthy, will continue to eat innings. And what I think bears that out in looking backwards is that Casey Maize continued to pitch for the Padres long after it was clear he wasn't healthy. Like, he messed up his groin and they kept throwing him out there and they didn't IL him until the final appearance of the regular season because those guys went out
Speaker 3and got because they needed guys to come and eat innings because I hear you, Craig, on the Griffin Canning thing. Those guys could have, you know, Griffin Canning could have put up a 70 RA. Certainly, they didn't think that that's what was going to happen when they traded for those guys and they would turn into complete pumpkins. But, Okay, Griffin Cannon could throw 70RA. Who else? You know, like, are you going to be throwing JPCers? Like, maybe. He probably could have done what they did.
Speaker 1Would he have been better than Robbie Ray? Quite possibly. Probably, actually. Ray was not good. You know, that's the whole thing. Like, well, you can't possibly. Well, you could. You could throw Randy Vasquez more. They put Randy Vasquez in the bullpen for a while. I mean, yes, and.
Speaker 3What they also did not know at the deadline is that the Padres were going to have, like, the second or third best offense in baseball from that point on. You know, like, and so you can pitch guys to seven ERAs if you're going to score seven runs a game. Like, that helps. And the Padres were basically doing that during their, you know, pod-temper stretch.
Speaker 2They certainly were.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2You're scratching at something that really merits comment. conversation because deadline AJ is terrifying. That's why we go into the day after these days going like, man, that was exciting, but I'm nervous. He's not the only one who made a huge swing at the deadline that didn't work out for him. The playoffs, you know, the Brewers were right in the running for Tarek Scruble and stuck to their kind of organizational credo of not giving up the kids.
Speaker 2The Dodgers didn't have a hacked system, and they can give up their third highest-ranked prospect outfielder basically for Tarek Skubal and River Ryan, who's nothing to shake a stick at, but could have his shoulder explode tomorrow at any point, and everybody knows that. Sometimes they just don't friggin' work, but that being true doesn't mean the process shouldn't be scrutinized.
Speaker 1And again, if I'm building... a cruise ship of a team instead of one that's trying to turn into a wagon at the very end, then you've got to have that level of depth that you don't have to go spend the highest rate at the deadline in order to improve your team because your team's already good. And you did your spending in the offseason. And I would love to see Kwanzaa take a little bit from column A
Speaker 1and column B when it comes to the two teams right now that are above hers in the National League. The Dodgers focus on doing most of their spending in the offseason so that they don't have to make major moves at the deadline. Then they'll still go ahead and make a major move because they can. But it's fortifying the fortress right it's like taking the fortress and making it you know adding the extra big big arching uh crossbow you know boom now we added something more yeah
Speaker 1ramparts thank you that's good adding to the ramparts of of the fortress um whereas we're like building the fortress we're starting off with like this wooden wagon and then like trying to build it up and build it up uh over the course of the year and that's way more expensive and risky um so so Do we want to get to that spot there? Or is there more that we want to plumb from the postseason? Ideally, what I want to see this team do, what I'd like to see Kwanzaa and Jose E do, is commit to
Speaker 1some lavish spending in the short term. I'd like to see them put money into this team to be able to have a real starting rotation and not five guys out of the E group you know, on the pitching tier list that we're hoping that one of them, you know, a Herman Marquez, et cetera, you know, is going to kick into their 80th percentile outcome. But at the same time,
Speaker 1develop an organizational ethos where we're continuing to spend in the Dominican, we're continuing to spend in the foreign market, we're continuing to develop a minor league system that then because you've given him so much at the off season, AJ gets a big old handcuff at the deadline. And it's like, we're not trading our top prospects for a little while. We're going to, we're going to go two, three seasons and we're not going to trade our top prospects. Ethan is here. Merrill is here. Like Tati is here.
Speaker 1We just spent 325 million on this payroll and we're not going to, this time we're not going to trade the best guys. And get to that brewer's spot in three or four years where you've got that nice farm system. Now you can taper off the spending and start to have a robust academy system that is sending you top flight talent that you actually keep. That would be the dream come true for me. Is that just pie in the sky? That's too much?
Speaker 2Well, yes, because they've already said they are all in and this tournament has no rebuys. So they don't have any access to more chips. They're all in. That's what I've heard. No, yeah, they're done. It's done. Like, they went all in. And lost. Goodbye. Yeah.
Speaker 1So, like, they were all in. No, there's a rebuy every year. It's really good news. Oh, okay.
Speaker 2That's good.
Speaker 1You get a rebuy every single year.
Speaker 2Oh, I missed that in the analogy. That is rather huge. Okay. All right. Good, good, good. Yeah.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Uh, specifically Craig, I don't want them trading away, not even our best guys, but like our ground beef prospects, the ones who could get worked into a delicious meatloaf down the road, maybe not be the all around five tool guy, but you know, can contribute in a playoff run the way the brewers have their young guys doing and not trading them away to save four or $ 5 million on salary and that another team eats, like they did in the Arise trades, like they did in the
Speaker 2Matt Carpenter trade. We saw that not necessarily backfire. Ray Kerr was hurt for a really long time and is only now becoming a major league pitcher again. But we get to see what that journey looks like if you let it play out instead of trying to unload a few million bucks off your books. We saw them do it with Ramon Laureano. They did it this year with Robbie Ray, if I'm not mistaken. In trading, I can't remember our young international prospect's name.
Speaker 1Miguel Mendez, right, was the big hard thrower that we traded. And then a young shortstop.
Speaker 2The young shortstop's the one I'm talking about because they had signed him to their highest bonus for this past class. Like, he was their number one guy from the last class. And when AJ finds a Jarlin Susanna or a James Wood, like, everybody kind of takes notice of him focusing in on these guys because he's such a great scout. And those are the guys that I'm kind of done with them trading. Because if you keep them all in three or four years, one or two of those guys are going to be
Speaker 2problem solvers in the postseason.
Speaker 3I think what it's going to require, Craig, because I'm with you, I don't think it's crazy to think that the Padres and specifically Jose and Kwanzaa could institute some sort of, you know, we're going to spend in the off season and then we're going to handcuff AJ in the, in the regular season and say, you know, we've made your investments. It would basically require them being like the Medici, you know, family, uh, and being like benevolent, like patrons
Speaker 3of a team much in the way, by the way that Peter Seidler was at first, you know, like there is precedent for it in San Diego, uh, you know, could lightning strike twice potentially, um, you know, but you know, I, I look ahead to the Padres 2027 payroll, uh, you know, which will obviously be much discussed coming, um, you know, in, in our off season, but 2027 is the year that Manny Machado's contract goes full boat.
Speaker 239 million.
Speaker 3He is making $ 39 million a year. Um, Xander Bogarts, as he has every year, is making $ 25. 4 million. So between the two of them, you have $ 64. 5 million that is sunk already that you're spending on this team in the form of two aging superstars who, you know, it should be said, were both just in their age. 33 seasons are going to be playing their age 34 seasons
Speaker 3next year.
Speaker 1Plenty of good years left.
Speaker 2I need a good year's left.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Seven. That's why they're called the golden years, Rafey, because they're the most valuable.
Speaker 1You know, you need to have, I mean, when did Steve Young win his first Super Bowl, right? I mean, you need some of that veteran leadership. Exactly.
Speaker 3Additionally, Fernando Tatis Jr. has a pay upgrade to $ 25. 7 million. So, you know, Jake Cronenworth's making $ 12.
Speaker 12 million.
Speaker 3Joe Musgrove's in the last year of his contract at $ 20 million. Like, There's essentially... Sorry, Hugh Darvish, yes. We don't know what his deal is. One of the very little song things from this season is that Hugh Darvish did the bro-est of bro moves and went on the restricted list and only cost the team a million dollars this year. And I... There is a millstone around the neck of this team financially that will only be overcome
Speaker 3if they... Jose and Kwanzaa and whoever else in the ownership group is willing to contribute, uh, to spend on top of that. And, uh, you know, so there, Craig, I don't think it is, it is an impossible thing to ask, but it's basically saying, do what Peter did, but do it again with Peter's commitments, by the.
Speaker 2Way, without the meddling a little bit, right? Maybe a little like.
Speaker 1Yeah, do it, but do it a little less wildly. Do it a little less wildly. Let's let's do it with a five year plan. Do you know, do it with a five year plan. And if you can handle it in that fashion, that's what all in looks like in my mind is we're all in. That means we're going to put heavy commitment right at the top financially that we're going to commit to in a five year plan that includes signing and not trading the best international
Speaker 1pool guys. And, you know, who knows what the new system is, right? But going as far as we can go to get to the spot where we know we don't have the Dodgers fake money, but we've got clear like capital, the amount of money that can buy Chelsea. We've got all of this around us. Like all in doesn't mean we're about to fold, right?
Speaker 2Right. That's right.
Speaker 1If we're, if we're playing a disciplined game and the answer was, we're going to play the most, we're going to play the best. If that's what they said, we're going to be the best. We're going to, play the most disciplined game. We're going to try and do the sharpest things. I'd be like, uh-oh. Some things are about to change. When you say, I'm all in, that's okay.
Speaker 2Here we go.
Speaker 1And that, to me, is the all-in path. If you have the money to spend to pay $ 3. 9 billion to buy the San Diego Padres... And the San Diego Padres, not just a major league team, this team in this circumstance against this foe, this ever present foe. I mean, their team's going to keep getting older. The Dodgers, if they lose this year, there's going to be some real interesting questions about when do they phase out these veterans for the teaming farm system below. But they'll do it.
Speaker 1They're ruthless. They'll do it unless their ownership turns into, you know, orange jumpsuits and handcuffs, unless that happens, I'm incarcerated Lloyd. Um, unless that happens, uh, I don't see it. Uh, you know, then we've got to have a strategy to defeat them and spending early is a strategy that can be potentially viable. I mean, can we build back a really good rotation? I would love to see them take
Speaker 1on money that other teams don't want to spend. The Mets did it with Luis Robert this year.
Speaker 2It didn't work. I just say that because the free agent class is not the strongest. Like right now, your dream scenario is kind of going out there and getting Ian Happ, you know, who has not been good the past couple years. Like he's one of the best left-handed players. like if you're looking for somebody for the two spot, which the Padres would be crazy not to like, I, I, I put it, I, I burned some Palo Santo over my Padres hat that I was wearing the whole playoffs.
Speaker 2And I, I manifested Jackson Merrill becoming, um, a legitimate and consequential number two hitter. Because if, if that happens, it's huge for the team. You can't paint on it though. And like, Ian Happ is the only behind him, like Luis Arias. That's what I mean. The free agent market is rough. Pitching.
Speaker 1Pitching.
Speaker 2We need pitching. And it's not amazing there. You can get Shota Imanaga. Hey, can I sell you a Robbie Ray? But other teams are not going to want to spend money. And when the Padres got you, Darvish, when they got Blake Snell, it's because the Rays didn't want to pay Snell and the Cubs didn't want to pay Darvish. And if they can adopt that posture again, I would be really excited.
Speaker 1Here's a question. Okay, go ahead, Rafey.
Speaker 3No, no, no, please, please, please.
Speaker 1Well, if the best pitcher on the market is Tarek Skubal, Is Michael King the second best?
Speaker 2Yes. Who's the dude from Japan? He's got hype, but Michael King's the second best. Oh, right.
Speaker 1And then there's a dude from Japan that's got some real hype this year, but no one's going to be Yamamoto again, right? Like, I mean, Yamamoto's... And I know the Brewers grinded him today, but damn, he's good.
Speaker 2You know what I mean?
Speaker 1Like, he's been three years in, he's been worth his contract all three years.
Speaker 2Yeah. So.
Speaker 1Like, yeah, hey, you can find that guy? Great. But how about Tatsuya Imai this year? He was terrible. You know, Sasaki has been generally mediocre and was bad today. Came in and was bad and had to be pulled for LA. Our Korean picks have been decent. I mean, Song didn't really hit this year, but Matsui turned out. Well, if you count the Martinez in them, especially, he pitched, no, he pitched in Japan.
Speaker 2He was Japan.
Speaker 1But yeah, Kyle Hart was the Korean. Hey, you know, speaking of a guy that they left off the playoffs that gave them innings, you know, having four left-handers was this huge advantage they had all year. And then it turned into, we've got more at home.
Speaker 3And Robbie Ray is our second left-hander. You made an interesting point earlier in the pod, Craig, that I didn't get to follow back up on it. But, you know, Randy Vasquez and Wandy Peralta were guys who had sub-six strikeout per nines. you know, and we're left off the roster. And Kyle Hart was actually much higher, 8.3. But I understand in the playoffs being like, you know what, we got to go to our high percentage strikeout guys, which is, I suppose, the argument for Robbie Ray, even though he wasn't really such, you know, in a Padres uniform. What
Speaker 3I don't get then is, why go with Jason Adam, who was not striking out guys at any point this year?
Speaker 2Circle of trust, man. in the circle of trust.
Speaker 3That's when my wind horse fingers go up because i'm like why are why exactly is it jason adam and austin hayes in the circle of trust why would that be just things to think about wind horse fingers going down okay.
Speaker 2Oh man um.
Speaker 1Yeah, I think spending on King is a risky maneuver. You know, we'll have a future podcast to really break down the field, right? And to look at what options are out there.
Speaker 2Michael King... Emmanuel Classe is going to be a free agent.
Speaker 1Yeah, but... This is kind of like going back, circling back through what would have been a menu. But I do want to say this. Michael King, right now, today... is probably the best Padres postseason pitcher of all time. I mean, Kevin Brown had the one, he had an incredible start to that postseason. He did give up the ghost a little bit at the end. Couldn't finish in
Speaker 1game one. Of course, came out of the bullpen against Atlanta and got smoked by Michael Tucker. Michael King was an absolute boss in the Cubs series. came back, retired the first 14 batteries he faced against the Brewers before he started to fade and came back one day's rest later and threw 40 pitches to close out game three in innings eight and nine. I don't think the Padres, well,
Speaker 1the Padres lost game three of the wildcard series last year when he pitched a scoreless inning. Can't blame it on him. But otherwise, I think anytime that they've pitched him with intent, the Padres have won their playoff game. Like, This guy, if he never threw another pitch for the Padres, he should be celebrated as one of their greatest postseason performers of all time.
Speaker 3Here, here.
Speaker 2Way to give a guy some flowers that I always felt nervous about in a way. Kind of like I felt nervous about Dylan Cease last year. But none of that from Michael King. He was fantastic. He gave me probably my favorite moments from this pro season.
Speaker 3Well, you made me curious, Craig, so I wanted to pull up the comparison between Michael King and Kevin Brown in the postseason. So Kevin Brown obviously only had the one year with the Padres in 1998. Michael King, 2024 through 2026. Interestingly, they both played in six games. Kevin Brown started five of them. Michael King started four of them. Kevin Brown threw 39 and a third innings in those
Speaker 3six games, whereas Michael King only threw 27 innings. During that time.
Speaker 1Well, but he did have two relief appearances, but yeah.
Speaker 3But yes, and it's still a 12-inning difference. Five starts to four, right?
Speaker 1So yeah, yeah, it's a lot.
Speaker 3Kevin Brown had a. 252 ERA over that time. Michael King had a 2 flat, 2.00 ERA. Kevin Brown had a 2.66 FIP. Michael King, 2.43 FIP. Kevin Brown had a 1.04 WIP. And Michael King had a 0.815 WIP. So, I think you have a pretty solid argument there, Craig. I'm in the career numbers.
Speaker 2Um, and here's our, here's our top five, which really shouldn't surprise any of us considering, uh, PV didn't make the playoffs all that much. Our number one, uh, and this is going by innings pitch. You Darvis is number one with 39.2. Kevin Brown is 39.1. Michael King is 27. Joe Musgrove is 25.1. And Andy Ashby is 25. The only starting pitcher with an ERA above, uh, Three in
Speaker 2that group is Andy Ashby. Hugh Darvish has a sub three, 295. Kevin Brown is 252. Michael King is 2.00 on the dot. And Joe Musgrove is 249. By whip, Michael King is the best. By K through nine, Michael King is the best. By strikeouts to base defense, on balls, Michael King is the best.
Speaker 3And he's going to make a great New York Yankee next year, guys.
Speaker 2Stop it.
Speaker 1I mean, is Radon off the books? Who's off the books?
Speaker 3I was actually, if you listen to banter, you would know that I was at a wedding last night. And I spoke with my cousin at the wedding about this very thing. And he said he was doubtful that Michael King would go to the Yankees because he thinks that they're all set on starting pitching because they still have Freed, Radon, Schittler, Garrett Cole, Will Warren. Uh, I'm sure I'm forgetting guys.
Speaker 1Um, but they, they, they're like this big four.
Speaker 2That's a big four.
Speaker 1But why not the Cubs?
Speaker 2Like the Cubs, like we kept talking about the Cubs, like not having enough pitching, but they had a lot of guys hurt. They had Kate Horton hurt. They had Justin Steele hurt and they had to patch together the same way that we did.
Speaker 3Cubs make a lot of sense.
Speaker 1Yeah. Cubs.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1If you take out Gossman and put in King and then Steele comes back and then Maybe they resign him in Naga or Horton comes back. Horton was their best pitcher before he got hurt. Yeah. Or he could be one of those guys who had one good season, got hurt, came back, wasn't the same. And you never hear from him again after he's, you know, after he flames out the second time, you don't know. So King would be even more valuable at that point because he's somebody that
Speaker 1you can. Yeah. So yes, you're probably directly bidding with the Cubs. to get Michael King. Who knows what Buster Posey's going to do up there. Those guys are going to lose their mind in some way. They're going to throw money at somebody this winter too, but I don't know who. But, yeah.
Speaker 2So that's it.
Speaker 1I think that's the toughest decision of the winter. I think France is the easiest decision of the winter. I think they're going to figure it out. They're going to come to it. And it's got the highest floor in terms of it's not that much money and he's going to give you back a steady performance. Um, he's going to give you on base percentage and good defense at first base. Um, but more hone is a big question. How's your shoulder? You want to be here? Melanie wants
Speaker 1to be here. Everyone wants to be here. That has a price because everyone else is going to say, you can be my closer. Um, come on over, but how many teams are going to spend for a closer? this winter and King is the biggest one of all. He, he needs a real deal. And that's why I was thinking about lavish short-term spending. What if you gave him a, I won't say the name of the high price Dodger pitcher that was once signed, but like a short-term high value.
Speaker 2Dylan sees just got 210 over seven years. See, I'm wondering if you could give him a four or five year contract. It's going to cost you about 32 to 33 AAV because he's going to want more than Dylan because he's getting half the years, four years, 125.
Speaker 1He's never struck out to cease his level though. The strength ads get money.
Speaker 2Or the innings. Like that's the thing. That's why he's not going to get as much guaranteed. But I, like, I really think with pitching, it just comes down to total guarantee and the mechanics of how you get there. are, are the minutia of it. But I like, I think it makes sense for years, one 30, four years, one 40 for Michael King.
Speaker 1What do you think?
Speaker 3I think that this is going to be his one shot in his career to get a generational bag. Um, you know, he thought that it was going to be last year until he ended up not being healthy. Um, and he is 31 years old. Um, so he'll be 32 next year. Um, so I think if you're, uh, you know, rule of thumb for a team is that if you're paying five years for a pitcher, you are expecting them to throw three of them. Um, and so you're thinking, what would, if I can, if I'm thinking
Speaker 3three peak years of Michael King, if I think he's going to throw four, four war each of those years, if that's what I'm arguing, that's 12 war. It's probably a, that's, that's $ 120 million in value. Plus you're paying for the fact that that's all coming from one roster spot. It's probably a little.
Speaker 2Bit more than that.
Speaker 3Do you want to be the one holding that bag?
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3I mean, maybe it's worth it.
Speaker 1It's such a tough call. Because if it goes pop, then you can just be like, oh my God, I can hear Alex right now. Like another generational contract.
Speaker 2You know, blah, blah, blah.
Speaker 1Like, yeah, and great. Yeah, if you had a stream of first-round draft picks coming up from the minor leagues that were filling the major league rotation, then amazing. But, like, in real terms of what they've let go, was Robbie Snelling going to fill a playoff rotation this year? Of course not, and I believe he got hurt. Mackenzie Gore, you know, he was super mediocre this year.
Speaker 2Stephen Kolick, Ryan Berger.
Speaker 1Out, out. Both injured. You know, as the wheel happened to turn, that's where it landed. Like, it's not like they actually had a Garrett Cole in the system that they traded away to get two years of somebody else. Not yet. You know, but you have to pay for pitching. You have to pay for pitching. Ideally, you want to develop pitching. Logan Henderson is a find. Jacob Mizorowski is
Speaker 1a find, right? When you have those guys and then you trade your closer to get a Robert Gasser, you know, like that's how Milwaukee does it, is being very deliberate and systematic. The Dodgers do it by spending for big blocks, building a system below it, and then being able to use the system as they need it In like a torpedo fashion where there's like aim, bang, boom. We get what we want. As opposed to us, we use ours as a battery. We deplete it, we deplete it, we
Speaker 1deplete it. We have to charge it, we have to charge it. It's a system that doesn't let you, I think, get to 95 to 100 wins. I just don't think it does. I think we've seen the cap of it is best second half in 91 to 93. And that's how this part works. How can we get to that next level? I think that's the question that's got to confront this team.
Speaker 2Yeah, I'm looking forward to going through the butterfly and its beats of the wings with you.
Speaker 3Yeah, and just so folks have it on their radar, December 2nd is, you know, disclosure day. That's when it will be disclosed if we will be having a lockout or not. Um, because the, uh, the current CBA expires on December 1st.
Speaker 2There's going to be a lockout.
Speaker 1There's going to be a lockout.
Speaker 2What that means, like, is that scary or not is yet to be seen, but yes, the files are, but I just, I put that out there.
Speaker 3If there is a lockout, there will not be any free agent activity happening during that time. So could it be that we will see, uh, Like last time, last offseason, or excuse me, last offseason when there was a lockout where there was a flurry of activity right before the deadline and then a long silence. That's all coming up very soon. So be a part of us in our community if you want to be talking about it. Because let me tell you guys, it's really easy to talk about the Padres when it's October and everyone's in the
Speaker 3know and paying attention. If you're sickos like us and you want to talk about this, Dean, 365 days a year, come do it where the other sickos are on our Discord.
Speaker 1Absolutely. Patreon.com slash PadresHotTub. Thanks to everyone for being here. If you're watching on YouTube and you can hit the thumbs up button on the way out, make sure to click subscribe. All of that is going to be very helpful to us. And until next time, for Chris and Rafi, I'm Craig. Go Padres!
Craig Elsten, Chris Reed, and Raphie Cantor are joined by Abbott Elementary showrunner, novelist, and returning champion Justin Halpern to break down the start of free agency for the Padres, who enter the offseason...
A year after his last appearance, San Diego Union-Tribune Padres beat reporter Kevin Acee joins Craig Elsten and Raphie Cantor in the Hot Tub to look back at 2026 and offer a glimpse into the coming offseason. Want to...
Craig, Chris, and Raphie gather for the final post game of the 2026 season after the Padres dropped Game 4 of the NLDS 3-1 to the Brewers. Want to get this show and tons of others early and ad-free? Plus access to post...
Craig, Chris, and Raphie gather with hundreds of patrons after the Padres, led by Michael King, hang onto NLDS Game 3 by a score of 4-3 and force Game 4. Want to get this show and tons of others early and ad-free? Plus...
Craig, Chris, and Raphie pour some stiff drinks and try and breakdown what the hell happened as the Padres dropped Game 2 in Milwaukee after a disastrous 9th. Want to get this show and tons of others early and ad-free?...