Send us Fan Mail In this episode, our co-hosts explore how the smartest move for engaging in global alliances in child welfare, health, and economic development might be asking a better question, not funding a bigger fix. We talk with David Peter Strohl, internationally recognized systems thinking expert and author of *Systems Thinking for Social Change*, about why entrenched challenges in child welfare, global health, and international development can stay stuck even when everyone means well. David is a founding partner of Bridgeway Partners (www.bridgewaypartners.com), a consulting firm dedicated to helping mission-centered leaders reframe and resolve intractable social and environmental problems. He is also a founding director of the consulting group and informational website www.appliedsystemsthinking.com and a member of the systems thinking faculty for the Academy for Systems Change. David was previously one of the founders of Innovation Associates, the consulting firm whose pioneering work in organizational learning formed the basis for fellow co-founder Peter Senge’s management classic The Fifth Discipline. We start with the basics: what a system is, why it keeps producing the results it produces, and how interdependence and time delays can trick us into pushing harder or quitting too soon. From there, we get honest about unintended consequences, including “better before worse” dynamics where short-term wins can set up long-term losses. David breaks down the iceberg model so we can move beyond events and trends into system structure: policies, practices, relationships, power dynamics, perceptions, and purpose, which is where real leverage lives. Then we make it practical with vivid examples. We examine food aid through a systems lens and walk through a clean-water project in Togo where wells failed because the surrounding maintenance system never existed. We also map how a child welfare organization can align prevention, stabilization, development, reunification, evaluation, fundraising, and advocacy by seeing the whole rather than optimizing one part. Along the way, we confront the role of mental models and donor narratives, including the question that stings in the best way: do you want the credit or the results? If you care about sustainable social change, humanitarian response that builds resilience, and collaboration that strengthens families and communities, this conversation will give you language, frameworks, and questions you can use right away. Subscribe, share this with a friend who cares about impact, and leave a rating and review so more people can find the show. ___________________________ Maternal Health impacts child and family wellbeing, and is an indicator of societal wellbeing as well. Please listen to our podcast episodes on safe childbirth and maternal health to learn more about how health of a mother is basic survival for a child. If you want to support this work, please give to the HCW Maternal Health Mission ________ Travel on International Mission, meet local leadership and work alongside them. Exchange knowledge, learn from one another and be open to personal transformation. Step into a 25 year long story of change for children in some of the poorest regions on Earth. https://www.helpingchildrenworldwide.org/mission-trips.html ****** ____ Organize a Rooted in Reality mission experience for your service club, church group, worship team, young adult or adult study. No travel required. Step into the shoes of people in extreme poverty in Sierra Leone, West Africa, Helping Children Worldwide takes you into a world where families are facing impossible choices every day. Contact support@helpingchildrenworldwide.org to discuss how. _____ A bible study for groups and individuals, One Twenty-Seven: The Widow and the Orphan by Dr Andrea Siegel explores the themes of the first chapter of James, and in particular, 1:27. In James, we learn of our duty to the vulnerable in the historical context of the author. Order here or digital download Support the show Helpingchildrenworldwide.org
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Optimistic Voices, a podcast of helping children worldwide. We help children worldwide by strengthening and empowering families and communities. This podcast is for people interested in deep conversations with thought leaders in the fields of child welfare, global health, and international missions.
SPEAKER_01Today we're joined by David Peter Strohl, an internationally recognized system thinking expert, founding partner of Bridgeway Partners, and author of Systems Thinking for Social Change. For more than 40 years, David has helped leaders and organizations tackle some of our most persistent challenges, from poverty to end homelessness to education and public health. He also co-founded Innovation Associates, whose pioneering work in organizational learning helped shape Peter Singh's classic book, The Fifth Discipline.
SPEAKER_01David brings a practical approach to understanding why problems persist, how well-intentioned efforts can unintentionally reinforce them, and what it takes to create lasting change. His work asks us to look beyond individual programs and immediate results to the larger systems shaping people's lives, a perspective with powerful implications for how we support children, families, and communities. David, welcome to Optimistic Voices.
SPEAKER_03Thank you, Laura. It's a pleasure to be here.
SPEAKER_01I want to start with something very basic because I think some of the people listening to us may never have encountered systems thinking before. What is systems thinking and what does systems thinking allow us to see that our conventional way of looking at problems often misses?
SPEAKER_03Well, I would start with a definition of what a system is, which is a term that is getting you know thrown around a lot. Um, and I'm gonna use the definition of a very, very uh well-known, highly regarded systems thinker, sadly, who's no longer with us, Danella Meadows. And her definition is that it's an interdependent set of elements that is coherently organized in a way that achieves something.
SPEAKER_03Now, I just said world famous, highly regarded, and the best she can come up at the end of that sentence with is achieves something. That vagueness is very important because there is a principle in systems thinking that systems are perfectly designed to achieve what they are achieving right now.
SPEAKER_03So although we may be frustrated by what seems like the dysfunctional system that we're trying to change, be assured that that system is actually accomplishing something. There are always payoffs to the status quo, which then calls into question if we want the system to accomplish something else, then we first need to be aware of what it's designed to accomplish, because it will continue to do that until we understand how it is set up to achieve what it's achieving.
SPEAKER_03That being said, what I would call systems thinking, then, is the ability to think about these interdependencies in such a way as to help you achieve a desired purpose. So there's a purpose that is always being accomplished, multiple purposes, perhaps. What is the purpose we want the system to accomplish, and how do we understand and work with that discrepancy?
SPEAKER_03The other thing I would say is that systems thinking for many people sounds like a very esoteric kind of term, very abstract. I would w want to assure your listeners, particularly in the work that you do in the world, that systems thinking is child's play. And what I mean by that is we actually start off as natural systems thinkers.
SPEAKER_03When our son was, I don't know, maybe 10, 12, I was still picking up after him. It's like long past the time where he should have been able to do that for himself. And I remember walking into his bedroom, and there's a pile of clothes on the floor. He had his bathroom and laundry hamper like about five feet away. Not so hard. But they were on the floor, and I would say, Jim, Jim, pick up your clothes, just put them in the hamper.
SPEAKER_03No Jim. Jim, put them in the hamper, no Jim. Finally, I get so frustrated, I pick up the pile of clothes, I walk over the hamper, and I put at which point Jim walks in the room, looks down at the empty floor, and says, Oh, that worked. That is a systems thinker in action who understands the time delay, understands shifting the burden to the intervener.
SPEAKER_03In this case, me, and I teach the stuff. I should know better. What does systems thinking allow us to do? They help us appreciate interconnectedness. The world is becoming increasingly tightly connected, tightly interdependent, and yet we're not set up to understand the nature of those connections and certainly not address them effectively. Another characteristic of systems is that there are typically time delays between the actions that are taken and the results that show up.
SPEAKER_03So your listeners may be familiar with the idea of upstream versus downstream thinking. You know, we tend to kind of focus on where we are downstream when in fact the problems that are being caused and would need to be addressed lie upstream. There are delays all over social systems. There's a delay between when people become aware that a problem exists to being able to make a decision about what to do about it.
SPEAKER_03There's another delay between making the decision and taking action. And there's another delay between taking action and getting the results. Delay, delay, delay. And we, at least in the West, are not conditioned to appreciate time delay and work with it. We either tend to get very impatient and try to push harder, and you know that doesn't work. Uh if in fact uh it takes nine months to make a baby, it takes nine months to make a baby.
SPEAKER_03Um certain now, there are certain things where you can shorten the delay, and that's a good idea, but a lot of time you actually have to be practicing patience and persistence, which are, as I say, are not necessarily easy for us to do. The other tendency, if we don't overreact and try to do more and push things faster and harder, which tends to backfire and slow things down, is we give up. We give up prematurely.
SPEAKER_03So learning how to work, understand where the delays are in the system, and work with those delays is another thing that systems thinking helps us with. The third area where I think systems thinking is very helpful is in appreciating unintended consequences. Um we think something should happen, and in fact, something else happens. Now, there's actually uh related to that two principles.
SPEAKER_03One is called better before worse behavior. Very often, what we do to improve things in the short run actually make no difference or make matters worse in the long term. And that's very hard for us to appreciate. And it goes along with this idea of time delay, patience, and also wisdom, understanding that there are, in fact, longer-term consequences to the actions that we take that are often in the opposite direction from the actions, immediate results.
SPEAKER_01To pivot to the next question that I have for you, which is that um, especially in the work that we do, um, something that we are becoming increasingly mindful of is this idea that good intentions don't automatically yield good outcomes. And and to your point, sometimes they appear to yield good outcomes in the short term, and then the long-term outcomes are more serious and not good. And so and I think that's something that can be really uncomfortable for people in the nonprofit space, in the humanitarian space, um, is it to come to terms with the fact that just because we meant well doesn't mean the outcome is going to go well.
SPEAKER_01Um, and so I wondered if you could demonstrate some cases, cases where people's attempts to solve a problem could actually contribute to the problem persisting rather than solving it.
SPEAKER_03Well, I think one that may be uh understood by many of your listeners is food aid. Food aid in the short term reduces starvation. And what many countries have found out and regions have found out in the long term is it actually increases starvation. And it does through does so through a number of mechanisms. One is that people who are most impacted by food aid are the young children.
SPEAKER_03So mortality rates go up. And when mortality rates go up 10 or 15 years later and notice the time delay, those young children become of childbearing age and they start giving birth, and all of a sudden you've got population spikes that you hadn't taken into account when you sent the food in the first place. The second unintended consequence is that food aid tends to undermine the local agricultural system because farmers, local farmers, simply cannot compete with free food sent from abroad.
SPEAKER_03And so they disinvest in what really is the fundamental solution, which is to build up, not destroy, build up the local agricultural system.
SPEAKER_01As we talk about this issue of well-intentioned interventions, unintentionally creating long-term problems and making the system harder to change. I wonder how we can examine our own role without turning it into an exercise of shame and blame, which frankly turns people off.
SPEAKER_03Totally understand. And there is that tendency. Notice, though, the tendency, the way most people approach problems, is we are part of the solution. And if something isn't working, it's because other parts of the system are not doing what they're supposed to do. So there is plenty of blame in the system. It's just finger pointing outward. And you're absolutely right. You don't want to take that finger and then turn it back on yourself because that doesn't help either.
SPEAKER_03I there was a wonderful quote uh that I use in my book from a former colleague named uh Bill Torburn who said, if you want to be part of the solution, you must first become aware of how you are part of the problem. Everybody wants to be part of the solution. Nobody wants to think of themselves as part of the problem. The value of thinking of yourself as part of the problem is that actually you empower yourself.
SPEAKER_03It's sort of the opposite of what you think. It's not that you weaken yourself and make yourself worse or more of a bad person or less competitive or whatever. You actually discover where your control and influence in the system lie. And that is the value of asking yourselves the question: why often, despite our good intentions, despite our best efforts, are we unable to solve this problem or achieve this goal?
SPEAKER_03And the more you reflect on your own intentions, your own thinking and your own actions, the more power you have to do something different and get a different result. Now, I'm not saying that individuals by themselves are going to change anything, but it is the place where you can start and need to start.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. I really believe that. I often say that you cannot fix what you will not face. And I think understanding, you know, there is a there is a piece of reflection that needs to happen that's not about let's all put on sackcloth and ashes and beat ourselves with sticks because we we got something wrong or we played a part in the problem. But knowing where that problem is is where you can begin to address it. So I love the idea that that knowing your piece of the problem is where the empowerment starts.
SPEAKER_01And I wish more uh of the folks that we work with um could embrace it in that way. I think that's really that's very insightful. In your book, one of the frameworks you suggested we discuss is the iceberg. And so I wonder if you could walk us through the iceberg model and what we're looking at when we um dive below the surface.
SPEAKER_03Sure. The iceberg has actually become um sort of one of the most popular and um well-recognized images coming out of the systems thinking world. The idea being that we tend to see only the tip of the iceberg, and uh what's really going to get us is the part that's underneath, that's far underneath the surface. So uh a way to think about the iceberg is that it's helping us look at reality at multiple levels.
SPEAKER_0395% of what we read in the newspaper is what we might call events. What happened yesterday, what happened at a particular point in time, the headlines, etc. That's where our attention gets drawn to. So, you know, there's uh an event of starvation, and we feel compelled to address that particular event. If we step back from events and kind of start playing more around the waterline itself, we might come to be aware that the event that we're dealing with is not an isolated event, it's actually part of a trend, a sequence of events that has been unfolding over a period of time.
SPEAKER_03And if you understand those trends, then you can move from simply reacting or firefighting to trying to predict the future. But as any good investor knows, past results are not indicative necessarily of future results. And so on the one hand, it can help to kind of anticipate what might happen down the road. But one, often those predictions are not accurate.
SPEAKER_03And two, if the prediction is that things are going to get worse and worse, it's not particularly comforting to just be able to say that. You want to do something about it. And that's where this kind of lower part of the iceberg comes in. And we call it, for lack of a better term, systems structure. The forces and pressures at play in the system that impact the trends, which in turn impact the events.
SPEAKER_03System structure includes forces like policies and practices, relationships and power dynamics, perceptions, how people think about the system is actually a critical part of the system. And finally, this question of purpose. What is the system intended to accomplish? The idea being, it may sound like an academic set of distinctions, but in fact, your leverage, your ability to influence what happens in the future is primarily determined by your understanding of an ability to shift system structures.
SPEAKER_03Um, the last thing I will say about this is that to access these different levels, you ask different questions. So if people are saying, what happened? they're typically want to find out more about the event. If they ask what has been happening here over time, they're most likely looking at the trends level. And if they ask the question why, then you're starting to get at structure.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that's a really excellent way of putting it. Um, the kinds of questions we ask. We were talking about this before you got on. The kind of questions that we ask help drive our understanding of the situation. I want to go back a little bit to what you said about um being able to anticipate what will happen and the work that needs to be done to look towards the future by looking towards what's going on in the present and what has gone on in the past. So we can't always anticipate the future, but in your book, you present a lot of ways that we can understand and anticipate what is perpetuating the problems.
SPEAKER_02And you you put these as sort of systems archetypes. So I wonder if you could share a little bit about some of those archetypes that you described and uh examples of of how they function.
SPEAKER_03Sure. So um in literature, or not even just literature, in storytelling, globally, any culture, there tend to be a few plot lines. Uh some people say there's about a half a dozen, some people might say there's up to 20. The fight between good and evil, love. Um the the I don't know what else, but you can think of others.
SPEAKER_04The hero's journey.
SPEAKER_03I'm sorry, the right, the hero's journey. And then if you think about most Bollywood movies, they have this phenomenal capacity to integrate multiple plot lines and themes. Uh, and they're fascinating as a result. So you can think of a systems archetype as a frequently recurring structure or story. And I like to think of these systems maps as stories that reoccur in a wide variety of different circumstances.
SPEAKER_03And I mentioned the word, the term earlier when describing picking up after my son, shifting the burden to the intervener. That is a very common archetype, which has the following structure. There's a problem symptom, and there's a quick fix. There's also a more fundamental solution. Longer takes longer to implement, but you know if you address it, it's sort of like downstream, upstream. You can put a band-aid on what's downstream, but you can really address the issue by working upstream.
SPEAKER_03The tendency, though, because of our desire for immediate results, is to put the band-aid on, to focus downstream, to do implement the quick fix. And what we discover over time is that the more we implement the quick fix, the more we convince ourselves that we don't really need to make the investments required to implement the long term fundamental solution. And when we don't do that, the problem symptom just comes back.
SPEAKER_03And then we're faced with the same dilemma, and we tend to pick the quick fix. And then there's another final kicker to this, which is the more we depend on the quick fix, the more we actually undermine our ability. To implement the fundamental solution, even if we wanted to. So the more I uh, and you can think of my helping uh my son out with picking up the clothes, uh there's a common uh term I have seen in the the nonprofit and philanthropic world, toxic charity.
SPEAKER_03Um giving rather than empowering, giving people a fish rather than teaching them how to fish, for example. And um another term for this is addiction. We literally become addicted to our quick fixes. And these are policy fixes. You know, we don't think of ourselves as addicts. If anything, we're trying to help people with addictions, we aren't aware of our own addictions.
SPEAKER_03Um and another example, then, from the food aid example, when you send food in the face of a starvation event, and you don't think about the potential consequences of that on undermining the local food system, which is a more fundamental solution, you are shifting the burden over time to building a dependence on food aid.
SPEAKER_01And we see a lot of that in our field, obviously, a lot of um quick fixes that felt like the right solution that then built long-term dependencies and reinforced, I think, over time for those that were doing that quick fix, the idea that this is the answer. Obviously, this is the answer because the problem keeps happening. And so that just proves that we need to keep doing it. Um and it becomes this self-fulfilling prophecy.
SPEAKER_03It is so true. Uh, in fact, what people often say is we almost got it this time. If we just do more of it, right, then it'll eventually we'll we'll get rid of when in fact we are fanning the flames and not being aware that we're doing it.
SPEAKER_01And not again to go back to the original question, not seeing our piece of the problem, the piece of the problem that we that we bring to it.
SPEAKER_03Exactly. Exactly right.
SPEAKER_01I want to get concrete again.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um so for someone who's new to systems thinking, because I'm thinking we're hearing things like systems thinking and social structures and feedback loops, and that all sounds kind of jargony and you know, as a like you said, esoteric. And so I I think it can be easy to hear those words and think um about them conceptually without actually understanding what it looks like when you apply them. And the food aid um example really helped with this. So can you pick a problem within child welfare or global health?
SPEAKER_01Because that's what we do. I'm being a little selfish here, and and walk us through it as a systems thinker.
SPEAKER_03Well, I had two very different examples. Um, maybe I'll give you both and you can edit as you see fit, or not. That's great. The one we like the most. Okay. Uh so staying on the international front. Um in the late 1980s, um, the country of Togo was dealing with um polluted polluted water supplies. And women would walk miles from their village to you know carry back water from a source that they knew was polluted, but it was the only water around, and um carry it back, and that was the water supply that these villagers depended on.
SPEAKER_03Then uh US, I guess USAID um and other international, maybe WHO, other international organizations got involved, and they began a project of installing wells in the villages themselves. So the women didn't have to walk uh many miles a day and consume hours a day getting water. The water from underground was clean water, it did not create diseases, and the villagers were thrilled, the government engineers were thrilled, and over time they got so good at this that they were able to install um wells more quickly in more villages, and it looked like they had the problem nailed.
SPEAKER_03And then starting about two years later, the whales the wells failed, and the villagers didn't do anything. It's like, well, okay, that that was good while it worked, but it no longer works. I guess we're gonna have to go back and uh go to our uh pools of you know barely potable water miles away and carry it back to the villages. And the government engineers, of course, of course, were kind of very upset about this because of all the money they had invested and all the field good that had happened.
SPEAKER_03And um they went back to the villagers to find out what on earth was going on, and they discovered something very interesting. The villagers thought, and now we're into the metal models, the villagers thought, well, if the government installed the wells, then they should be maintaining the wells. And the government was thinking, well, we installed the wells in the villages, of course, the villagers should be maintaining the wells. And as a result, nobody maintained the wells.
SPEAKER_03And so um the government held engineers held interviews uh with the villagers and discovered there was no infrastructure and no ability and no skill to maintain the wells. And clearly the government wasn't going to do it. Um, it was best if the villagers took care of it. But in order to do that, they needed to uh the government needed to set up a training program so that there was a mechanic, a trained mechanic in the villages, uh in each of the villages who could identify a problem when a problem occurred and determine what needed to be done.
SPEAKER_03And the villagers needed to have a um reliable system for collecting money from the villagers to, let's say, play pay for the broken parts. And the government needed to be able to stock stores, hardware stores, in um towns uh that villagers could go to, where the mechanic could go and pick up the parts. So a lot of different things had to change.
SPEAKER_03An entirely new ecosystem needed to be developed so that, in fact, the villagers could maintain the system. And so the purpose of the new system was not to install wells, which the government had gotten really good at doing, but the purpose was to install wells that are well maintained. And the system evolved to do just that.
SPEAKER_03The villagers took more responsibility for the maintenance, and in the course of developing their own infrastructure to maintain the wells, they actually created infrastructure that allowed them to grow um cash crops, for example, which is not something they had ever done before. Um, and not the kind of monoculture type of stuff, but just additional crops that they could go to markets with and earn some additional money.
SPEAKER_03So a lot of, in this case, positive unintended consequences occurred. And it required a shift, of course, in the power dynamics between the villagers and the government engineers. It also, interestingly, uh required a shift in the power dynamics between the men and the women in the villages because um collecting the water had been women's work. And now they took on responsibility for collecting the money, which they were better at doing than the men.
SPEAKER_03And so the women now were had to become part of the decision-making structure in a way that they hadn't been before. So lots of different things shifted. Um, so that's the global example.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's brilliant. It brings to mind, I have a colleague um who taught he he likes he plays this game he calls, but what's the cause of that? Um, and he talks about how in child welfare specifically that often people will go in and say, Well, these children are living on the street. And so what we need to do is we need to put them in an orphanage, and that's the problem solved. And what he likes to do is say, okay, but why are they on the street? What's the cause of that? Well, because there's not enough food at home. Okay, but what's the cause of that? And that what he's trying to do is get down the iceberg levels to where can we uh affect systems change that will be longer lasting?
SPEAKER_01That isn't just gonna slap a band-aid on the tip, right? And then have it just keep reoccurring.
SPEAKER_04So exactly.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. Yeah. All right.
SPEAKER_03So the I'll just throw this other. Do you want me to throw another example and then you so the other one, in fact, is from a child welfare organization in the US. And um the context is that the the organization felt like it was spread too thin, um, too many programs, too few resources. Uh, and there were also conflicts between the program officers and the evaluation function, uh, not uncommon.
SPEAKER_03And there was this other thing, uh, other function in the organization called advocacy, uh, that seemed like a stepchild and nobody knew what to do with it. Um so they wanted a way of rationalizing how do we prioritize among these different investments that we're making. Uh they had 32 programs, they had the evaluation function that was conflicting with the programs, and then this advocacy function.
SPEAKER_03Um so what we first did is we categorized the programs and discovered there were sort of four major buckets. Uh, the first one, which alludes back to the story you just told, is prevention. Uh, what can we do from kids having to be uh taken out of their homes in the first place? The second category was if we can't uh let the kids stay in the home, then we need to take them out of the home at least temporarily, stabilize them.
SPEAKER_03So there were these programs of stabilization to um develop them. So the schools that they um you know to were part of the orphanages or whatever structure that they were, the kids were put in. And then finally, uh some kind of effort at reunification with the uh birth family or some kind of alternative permanent placement. So those were the different programs, they fed each other.
SPEAKER_03So um the the better you do at stabilization, the better you do at um development of the kids, and the better you do at development, the more likely that you'll be able to reunify or find a good alternative placement. And of course, all of that required resources. And this is where evaluation came in. It's like, oh, we get resources because we're good at raising funds, and we're good at raising funds because we can tell good success stories.
SPEAKER_03How do we get good success stories? Well, we have productive relationships between evaluation and the programs. And then the other way to uh increase fundraising effectiveness is by having an advocacy function that works all of this at the policy level, not just at the individual donor level. So all of a sudden, they were able to see how everything they were doing actually fit together in a way that made sense.
SPEAKER_03On top of it, when they did this exercise out of the 27 programs that they had, or 32 programs, they discovered that five of them didn't fit in the any of these buckets and didn't make any sense for the organization to continue. They had sort of been grandfathered in or legacied or whatever it was, but they actually didn't fit any of the work that this particular organization wanted to do and didn't well.
SPEAKER_03Um so they uh figured out ways to literally put those programs up for adoption uh by other organizations that were better suited for them. And interestingly, the programs that they ended up defunding and moving out were often the ones that argued the most intensely for getting more funds. And the reason they argued is because they actually were peripheral and didn't belong in the first place.
SPEAKER_03So a lot of different things got resolved as these interdependencies got clear.
SPEAKER_01It's really powerful. One of the things that really struck me reading the book, and when we talked earlier a few weeks ago, um, is something that's kind of connected to my own work, which is looking at paradigms and the way that people's worldviews impact the things that they do, the choices that they make, and the ways that they try to change the world, for lack of a better term. Um, and it strike it struck me that the book often um talks about how sustainable change eventually is going to require people to change the way they understand problems um to begin with.
SPEAKER_01And I wonder how mental models, which is I think what the the term you use in your book, I call them worldviews or paradigms. But uh I wonder if you could talk about how mental models keep social problems in place, because I think a lot of the work that needs to be done is in shifting the mental model.
SPEAKER_03I so agree with you. Um and I would say that the way you think about an issue is part of the issue. Um and we often take the assumptions that people have and literally put them as thought bubbles on the diagrams that we draw. And a very simple example I give is um when downsizing increases in an organization, what happens to morale?
SPEAKER_03And what would you say?
SPEAKER_01It goes down.
SPEAKER_03See, it goes down. And why does it go down? What are the assumptions that people are making?
SPEAKER_04That I'm next.
SPEAKER_03I'm next, exactly. Why put in the effort? I'm next. But in some situations, downsizing increases and morale goes up. How come that occurs? Wow, they think enough of me to keep me around. I must be really important. In fact, now with so-and-so no longer in the organization, my responsibilities go up.
SPEAKER_03Makes me even more valuable. So you can take the same cause-effect connection and come up with opposite conclusions, and those conclusions are totally determined by the assumptions that people make about what that change means to them. Um in the shifting the burden structure, the tendency to go for the quick fix, whether it be the food aid or just installing the wells or picking the clothes up, is I have to do something now.
SPEAKER_03People need help now, which is most likely true. But then there's another set of assumptions that people make, which is yeah, I know we should do A, B, and C instead, but it takes too long, it costs too much, et cetera, et cetera. So we convince ourselves, and again, these are assumptions, we convince ourselves out of the more fundamental solutions that we often recognize are there, but we're not willing to invest in.
SPEAKER_03And investment is actually a very good term for the long-term, putting effort into the long-term solution. We wouldn't we understand investment when it comes to building a business, we understand investment when it comes to building savings or insurance or whatever. But when it comes to helping people in need, uh, it's got to happen immediately.
SPEAKER_03And then we end up living with the consequences and not even aware that we contributed to those consequences.
SPEAKER_01We find too that a lot of times there's an emotional dimension to this, particularly um on the child welfare side where people got involved in helping children, and then that um becomes almost a piece of um my personal identity. I'm the person who rescued the the child, the child. Um, and so sometimes when we're approaching these systems thinking conversations, we're we're uncovering that we're asking someone to give up a very comforting story about themselves, about their their role in the in the project, about uh who is responsible for the problem, who's responsible for fixing the problem, and even how they see themselves.
SPEAKER_01Um, how do you help people sit with that complexity without becoming overwhelmed or or defensive, which we've seen?
SPEAKER_03Well, I think that we need to ask people one, certainly affirm what they're doing and why they're doing it. Uh secondly, ask them is this the result you really want? Is saving this particular child more important to you than potentially saving more children, for example?
SPEAKER_03Because if you want to save more children, you may need to think differently than uh about what's required than what it took to save this particular child. Um my long-term colleague Robert Fritz distinguished, he said you can always ask people whether their beliefs are true or not, and they're always gonna say yes, and they always have evidence to back it up.
SPEAKER_03So asking whether your beliefs are true or not is actually not a good question. The question is, do your beliefs serve you? Do they help you create the results you want to create now? I like to distinguish are they valid from whether or not they're useful? Um, it's certainly valid that you had this wonderful experience saving this particular child.
SPEAKER_03Is it useful to you if you want to save? More children. And only the donor can decide what is really important to them. But if it's important to them to save more children, then they're most likely going to have to think differently and invest differently.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, I think that that brings us to a really good question that we have been wrestling with a lot in our organization is the idea that people and it kind of goes to the larger conversation we're having about how we're naturally systems thinkers. But when it comes to a lot of things, we tend to shed that belief. Even though as I was listening to you talk, I was reflecting on all of the ways that systems thinking has uh created so many scientific breakthroughs.
SPEAKER_02So things like biological amplification, the DDT that you spray now is is leading to eagles dying somewhere down the road, or uh color epidemics, the idea that if the problem is is the water that you're just getting at the pump every single day is what's leading to this larger problem. Um and the or time uh these ideas of time delays, um, germ theory. Um, it's that thing that you touched that somebody else sneezed on a week later has you with 104 degree fever.
SPEAKER_02Um so I I think it's it's interesting that we shed those beliefs, as you said. Um and I'm I'm curious if we could talk a little bit more about how we can just tell those stories to our donor audience.
SPEAKER_02How do we make system thinking more emotionally compelling without oversimplifying it to the point that it misrepresents what change means? It's a lot easier to say your$50 provided this kid with food than it is to explain all of the different interdependent relationships that are required to make a more sustainable impact.
SPEAKER_03I think it's a great question. And um I think that I talk about character traits. The systems actually ask certain things of us. Uh years ago I had read a book called What Love Asks of Us. And um, you know, being in a long-term love relationship has requirements.
SPEAKER_03Uh requires certain qualities on our our behalf. Uh making systems change, leading systems change also requires certain qualities. Uh, some of those are uh start off with humility and curiosity. And for people who have been very successful and have a lot of money, um humility can be a tough one.
SPEAKER_03And yet another question to ask is do you want the results or do you want the credit? And sometimes in order to get the results, you may need to be willing to let go of the credit. You can't make them make that decision, but you can pose the question. You can continue to feel good about the one kid that you saved, and you know, the photos on the mantle and everything else.
SPEAKER_03Or you can try to change help change a more complex system. How your money actually got from A to B it's gonna be hard to tell. But you're gonna be part of a team, and you can feel good about being part of that team and just as proud of the outcomes if you choose to. If it doesn't have to be all about just you. And it really comes down to that.
SPEAKER_03And you know, our incentive systems are set up to optimize parts, not to optimize the whole thing. And yet if you're trying to optimize the whole thing, it can be very difficult to tease the parts apart. But that's okay if the whole is more important to you.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that totally makes sense. Uh things that are complicated are complicated. And it it's sometimes impossible to kind of parse out what causes what and and where uh impact is being made uh when the system is being is now achieving the goal that you're hoping it will achieve.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Speaking of you you talked about your role as conveners uh and recognizing that that's more and more an important role for you folks to play. And part of convening, I think, is building that team spirit, the feeling that we're all in this, we can all feel good at the end of the day about or the end of the year or whatever, about what we were able to change together, and just de-emphasize the individual contributor part.
SPEAKER_03Um you give what you can, and you all share in the satisfaction of what happens at the end. And that's that's a context that you can help create.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I I love that story. It it very much aligns with a lot of the work that we're doing. You know, as we said, we are we are conveners, connectors, collaborators, catalysts, capacity builders. And I'm thinking about a lot of the projects that we're working on now and maternal and child health and strengthening systems to care for children outside of institutions, and how much of that is uh systems and uh convening work. It's it's collaborative work. Yes, it could not be done individually, but it it's also hard to tell uh which part everyone is playing.
SPEAKER_04Yes.
SPEAKER_01It's a much complicated and complex story. And I I've been in this work a little bit longer than Yes. This is I've been in this work for 24 years at this point, and I can tell you from the very beginning, when we when we ran an orphanage and we ran it from this coast on on a on a different coast, um, we are much more in the sidelines, we are much more behind stage, we are much more in the audience um in this approach than we uh we were in those early days. And I think that's been really an interesting uh career trajectory for me and and much more rewarding.
SPEAKER_01We have all often said that the collaboration is where the magic happens.
SPEAKER_03That's lovely. It's great.
SPEAKER_02I want to throw a wrench in our conversation and talk a little bit about contexts where systems exist, but they may be particularly fragile or maybe disrupted. So humanitarian disasters, war, epidemics, displacement of people. So there are social systems that exist but and have met people's needs historically, but they're disrupted and they're no longer functioning in the way that they did before. What does it mean to respond in those situations in a in a genuine crisis?
SPEAKER_03It's uh a toughie, of course. Um I think one of the things to ask oneself, given this particular archetype, let's say, of shifting the burden, is that there are often many things you can do in the short term. And in emergency situations, you have to do something. And you feel compelled to do something, it's the humane thing to do, and so on.
SPEAKER_03Um the problem becomes when unwittingly the system builds up a dependence on fixing the emergencies. And we used to say um arsonists breed firefighters, uh, in the sense that if you keep lighting fires and then putting them out, now it's not that the initial fire in this case was your fault, but how you respond to those fires, how you put those fires out, are still choices that you get to make.
SPEAKER_03Are you just working the downstream issue, or are you trying to rebuild a system or build a new system entirely? When a system is so fragile in the first place, uh, you might say that rebuilding that fragile system is not a particularly smart thing to do. Uh, you actually want to build a more resilient system uh down the road.
SPEAKER_03So when the well breaks, uh you might call that an emergency, or you might call it a system failure. And if you call it a system failure, you're going to approach it very differently than uh coming in with the government engineer who takes a day to fix that particular well and then leaves. That's the best way to think about it. And then also that it's so important to engage the end ultimate beneficiaries in the problem-solving process.
SPEAKER_03They're the ones who have learned how to survive in the existing system. And they're also the ones who are most acutely aware of where that system is fragile and breaks down and could be strengthened. As part of humility, uh, it's not just humility around do we get credit for the results or not? But are we willing to also let go of credit for our remarkable um problem identification skills?
SPEAKER_03We may think we understand what the problem is, but the end users really understand what the problem is. At, you know, at the certainly at the end part of the system. And of course, one of the challenges in working any of this is everybody has different views of the world. Everybody has different assumptions. And one of the opportunities of systems thinking is to help people with very different perspectives integrate those perspectives into a more complete understanding of what everybody is dealing with.
SPEAKER_03So there's uh you know, story of the blind man and the elephant that many people are familiar with, different people touching different parts of the elephant and swearing that the part of the elephant that they touch is the, in fact, the elephant when it's not. So the more people uh touching different parts of the elephant can come together and develop some shared picture of what that elephant actually looks like that they're dealing with, and also some shared sense of aspiration or possibility, then you've really got the anchors for moving forward.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, absolutely. I love the story of the elephant and how that shows how we think that we see the whole picture when we don't always uh I also really like what you said about um looking at the example in Togo. Is this an emergency or is this a system failure? Because I think that gets to a lot of what we've been talking about today, which is we need to ask better questions. Um the the root issue is that we think that we're asking the right questions when we're not. So I'm wondering if you have other uh questions or things that you think people, not just organizations, but donors and volunteers and and church members who want to contribute to social change should be asking.
SPEAKER_03So I will come back to the one question I started with, which is why, despite our good intentions or despite our best efforts, are we not able to get the results we want? Or not comparable to the amount of resource we're putting into it. Uh another very powerful question is how are we, at least in part, unwittingly contributing to the very problem we're trying to solve?
SPEAKER_03And I put everyone on a level playing field with that. I ask people at the beginning, how many of you think you're part of the solution? Of course, everybody raised their hand. How many of you think you're part of the problem? Usually nobody raised their hand, or hardly anybody. To say, until you get to the point where you can understand how you're part of the problem, this is not gonna change. You can be as frustrated and and full of yourself as you want to be, but things aren't gonna change because you don't see yourself as part of the system.
SPEAKER_03And you are the part of the system that you actually have the greatest control over. So uh making that a question that everybody is fair game for everybody, uh, is really, really a helpful one. Um some of the other ones are what might be the unintended consequences of our proposed solutions.
SPEAKER_03So we do try to think ahead, and archetypes are useful in this because they uh show, you know, maybe a dozen different ways in which what seems to work in the short term uh actually makes matters worse in the long term. So we we can get a handle on some of these um tendencies to shoot ourselves in the foot. Um and another one uh which we've also alluded to is are we willing to optimize the whole instead of just our part?
SPEAKER_03Because the assumption when people say I'm part of the solution is if I had more resources, I could be even more influential in the solution. I could even help the solution along further. But if we understand that systems operate in such a way that improving a system comes from improving the relationships among the parts of the system, not each part independently, then we can start backing off from I just want my solution and more of it, to what do we need to do collectively?
SPEAKER_03How do we need to think differently? What can we do collectively that would move all of us forward?
SPEAKER_02So, David, thank you so much for joining us today and sharing with us this framework for systems thinking, uh opening our eyes to the systems that exist around us and the way that we interact with them and the ways that we choose not to interact with them and the problems that they cause. I wonder, we asked this question uh to all of our guests, if you could share what keeps you optimistic or hopeful about this topic.
SPEAKER_03I would say two things, one of which might sound a little odd. Um, the first one, I think, is that the world is becoming more interdependent and people are becoming more and more aware of it. And I don't know what to do with it, but it's kind of hard to escape the fact that those interdependencies are more salient and hard to avoid than ever before. So what keeps me optimistic is the ability to think in terms of holes and interdependencies, I think is going to become increasingly valuable to all of us.
SPEAKER_03The other sort of odd optimism is that we have fewer resources. And because we have fewer resources, we have to be much smarter about how to allocate them. And systems pivot around leverage points. It isn't how much you can do how quickly that makes the difference. It's what are the fewest things you can do strategically and sustained over time that are going to have the greatest impact and most sustainable impact.
SPEAKER_03And that means being much wiser about how we allocate our resources.
SPEAKER_01That's great. And I want to thank the audience for joining us on this episode of Optimistic Voices. You know, we always say it's a big, messy world out there and there is no shortage of need. But we here at Optimistic Voices believe that with radical courage and radical collaboration, together, we can change the world.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening. If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, share it with others, post about it on social media, or leave a rating and review. To catch all the latest from us, you can find us at Helping Children Worldwide on Instagram, LinkedIn, Twitter, and Facebook.
Send us Fan Mail We trace how PEPFAR went from a secret White House plan to one of the most effective global health programs in modern history, saving millions of lives across sub-Saharan Africa. We talk with journalist...
Send us Fan Mail A lot of people want to help vulnerable children, but few of us stop to ask the hardest question: what if we are the problem? Our support of children in adversity could be fueling family separation and...
Send us Fan Mail Home can disappear in a single night but the memory of it can keep you alive for years. We sit down with Emmanuel Mohammed Nabieu, known as Nabs, to begin a multi-part Child’s View journey that starts...
Send us Fan Mail Ninety percent of US Christians agree children thrive best in families. So why do so many of us still send money to orphanages and residential care? The latest Barna study puts real numbers on a problem...
Send us Fan Mail Trust isn’t a slogan when children’s safety is on the line - it’s a discipline. We sit down with Naomi Schalm, Executive Director of Trust for Africa in Lesotho, to unpack what radical trust really...