Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Olive Oil Drops

Olive Oil Drops artwork

92 Olive Oil Defects - So Many!

Jul 15, 202611 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Cucumber, dried mushroom, winey and earthy notes: sensory attributes or olive oil defects?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1In this episode, I would like to introduce what olive oil defects are, how they form, and above all, how to recognize them from a sensory point of view. Hi, and welcome back to Olive Oil Drops, the first podcast entirely dedicated to olive oil and olives. This podcast is created by Marco Antonucci. This is an English version. I'm Milena. So, in this first episode, I'll provide a general overview of defects, their names and and their origin. In the next episodes,

Speaker 1I'll explain in detail how they develop, how to prevent them, and how to recognize the most common ones that are easiest to encounter. Let me start with a simple statement. Over time, all oils age and deteriorate. All oils, and I repeat all of them, even the most award-winning and renowned in the world, gradually lose their positive qualities and develop defects until they eventually become unfit for consumption. Over time,

Speaker 1defects can only increase while positive attributes can only decrease. Defects can be classified into four main categories. Defects that develop before harvest, defects that develop between harvest and extraction process, defects that develop during extraction, and defects that develop during storage and preservation. Now, defects that occur in the first three categories, that is from a tree to the finished product, are already present in the oil and tend to increase

Speaker 1in intensity over time. It may happen that a mild defect is not immediately noticeable after extraction process because bitterness, pungency and fruity aromas are still very intense and tend to cover it. Over time, however, defect becomes more evident as the positive attributes fade. For example, a whiny note may be perceived a few months after bottling, even though it was not noticeable initially. In reality, the defect was

Speaker 1already present, but at a low intensity and covered by oil's positive characteristics. As bitterness and pungency decrease and aromas fade, defect becomes more pronounced. Defects that develop during storage are due not only to unsuitable or dirty containers, but also, above all, to the fact that olive oil is mechanically extracted fruit juice. So, unlike many other food products, it does not contain preservatives, as prohibited by law, and therefore

Speaker 1it naturally ages over time and tends towards rancidity. Let me make a second important clarification. When we say that all is defective, we must always name the defect. This may seem obvious, but it is not. If we perceive an unpleasant sensory characteristic, we can only define it as a defect if it corresponds to a recognized and defined attribute.

Speaker 1So it's not enough to say this all is defective. We must identify the defect or defects present. If we perceive rancid or whiny notes, the identification is relatively straightforward. But what if we detect an odor or a flavor that is neither a recognized defect nor a defined positive attribute? Well, in that case, it cannot be classified as a defect. So to address this issue, the International Olive Council has

Speaker 1developed a standardized vocabulary for sensory analysis, including an official and regularly updated list of positive and negative attributes of olive oil. This list includes all descriptors that can be used in sensory evaluation. There are many negative attributes, while the positive ones are limited to three, fruity, bitter and pungent. For oils with a designation of origin, additional positive descriptors may be used, We'll discuss this in a future episode. This approach reflects the fact that in olive oil tasting,

Speaker 1the primary objective is to identify defects. If no defects are present and the oil shows a perceptible fruitiness, it can be classified as extra virgin. For more on classification of olive oils, refer to podcast 2. This is also reflected in the official tasting sheet used by panel tasters, Seven lines are dedicated to defects and only three to positive attributes. So let's start with the defects that develop in the field before harvest. One of them is dry

Speaker 1hay woody. These defects share a common characteristic. A dry woody aroma, sometimes also with notes of dried mushrooms. They are typically associated with dehydrated olives, often due to over ripening or environmental stress. They may also occur in olives affected by frost or cold damage, especially in Italy's northern regions. Then there is earthy, a soil-like odor caused by olives contaminated with earth, dust or mud during harvesting. For more details,

Speaker 1you can refer to podcast 85. Then there is a defect called grubby. This defect is caused by olives damaged by the olive fruit flies Typically, when infestation exceeds a significant threshold, around 10-15%, it produces unpleasant, degraded sensory nodes. For detailed description, please refer to podcast 39. Then there is a group of defects that develop between harvest and

Speaker 1extraction process. One of them is FUSD. This defect is caused by the anaerobic fermentation of Olives stored in piles, sacks or poorly ventilated containers before milling. In podcast 74, I explained that olives must be harvested and placed delicately in thin layers in well-ventilated crates for transport to the mill. Now, if they are crammed into crates or sacks, fermentation is triggered.

Speaker 1Since it does not require air, it can develop and intensify. Then there is a defect called winy or vinegary, which is due to fermentation process that develops when olives are piled up, similar to the heated, fusty defect, but in the presence of air this time. This condition leads to the formation of acetic acid, ethyl acetate, and ethanol. Just to give you an idea, within 2 days, the ethanol

Speaker 1content can quadruple, reaching its maximum concentration, while the acetic acid content can triple after 4 days. These processes are further amplified by increased humidity and higher storage temperatures, or if the droops have even slight damage to the pulp or a simple bruising on the skin. And the last in this group is musty or humid defects. caused by the development of fungi and yeasts and olives stored in humid conditions or processed while wet. Then there is a

Speaker 1category of defects that develop during extraction process, like heated or burned. You try to take some oil and heat it in a pan for about 10 minutes. This can reproduce the organoleptic result of an oil that has undergone excessive or prolonged heating during processing especially during malaxation phase, even, of course, under incorrect temperature conditions. It can also be caused by damaged bearings or other mechanical components that, due

Speaker 1to malfunction, generate friction and lead to localized overheating. Then there is rough, a rare defect that produces a thick, pasty, and unpleasant mouthfeel. Then there's greasy, also rare, usually linked to mechanical or processing issues. Vegetable water defect occurs when separation is not properly carried out and vegetation water remains in the oil affecting its sensory profile. Then there is asparto,

Speaker 1a defect associated with traditional mats made of asparto grass, now almost obsolete as discontinuous cyclomels are almost extinct. And the last group are the defects that develop during storage and preservation so that's the metallic, due to prolonged contact with metal surfaces, cucumber, a defect caused by long-term hermetic storage, especially in thins linked to the formation of specific volatile compounds, brine.

Speaker 1Although this defect is technically attributed to the production of oil obtained from oils preserved in brine, it can also result from incorrect separation in the decanter, initial fermentation before processing, and, above all, improper storage after processing when these steps have not been carried out correctly. These conditions can produce this negative aroma. Rancid, this oxidative alteration of the oil is due to a phenomenon of auto-oxidation which can be delayed

Speaker 1with appropriate storage techniques, but cannot be completely avoided. During storage, the mere presence of air can lead to the formation of hyperoxides through mechanisms that involve the formation of free radicals. It is characterized by the smell and taste of rancid fat. Muddy sediment occurs when unfiltered oil remains in contact with sediment, which ferments and decomposes over time. So initially, the suspended

Speaker 1particles do not cause any problems, but after a few months, the sediment settles at the bottom and begins to decompose. If you wish to ask us questions or just share your olive oil experience, you can do so either by email oliveoildrops at gmail.com website www.oliveoildrops.com where you can also find text of this podcast, both in Italian and English, or comment space of the podcast platform you have been using and to which you can subscribe free of charge.

Speaker 1Thank you for tuning in today.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 96 Oil defects developed during harvest: winey, vinegary, fusty

    Nov 18, 202612 minAudio

    Why does oil turn into vinegar if it contains no alcohol? And what does drunkenness have to do with the olive harvest?

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 95 Stone Mills and Traditional Pressing Mats? No, thanks.

    Nov 4, 202613 minAudio

    What does a vintage car have to do with a traditional stone-mill olive press? Do the traditional pressing mats really cause the olive oil to heat up?

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 94 Oil Must Always Be Filtered! The Fusty Defect

    Oct 21, 202610 minAudio

    Why don’t we buy white wine with sediment, yet buy extra virgin olive oil with sediment - and risk the fusty defect?

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 93 Oil Defects: Rancidity Takes the Crown

    Oct 7, 202612 minAudio

    What exactly is rancidity? How can you recognize it, and why does it develop? How many types are there? Do all oils eventually become rancid? And can you actually create a sample of rancid oil at home?

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 91 What an oil mill looks like: the Destoner

    May 27, 202611 minAudio

    Do you remove the pit to make extra virgin olive oil? And what do train wheels have to do with destoning techniques? Does removing the pit really enhance aromas?

    Credit the people on this episode