Classification: [Real world Lore] A history of bleeding gums and medicine. Hear out guest Jack Sprat take us through a journey of trial and error to discover a cure for scurvy -Sponsored by- Our Patrons at http://www.patreon.com/ovpod https://www.ovpod.ca/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[Intro]: Warning, this podcast contains violence, sexuality, gore, and other horrible and [Intro]: disturbing things. [Intro]: Listener discretion is advised. [Intro]: Also, the hosts of this venture are ignorant dipshits, so please do not take [Intro]: anything they say as fact, and enjoy the show. [Intro]: Now, are you sitting comfortably? [Intro]: Good, then we'll begin. [Intro]: Today we had 15 homicides and 63 violent crimes, as if that's the way it's supposed
[Intro]: to be! [Intro]: It is our basic human right to [Intro]: be fucked up! [Intro]: A second plane now has crashed into the other tower of the World Trade Center. [Intro]: Putting chemicals in the water that turned the friggin' frogs gay! [Intro]: The defendant shall be incarcerated for the rest of her natural life with no [Intro]: possibility of parole. [Intro]: You are not machines! [Intro]: You are not cattle! [Intro]: You are men! [Intro]: We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began [Intro]: to take hold. [Intro]: Occulte Veritatis.
[Leon]: Hello occultists and welcome back to Occulte Veritatis podcast. [Leon]: My name is Leon Filger and recording remotely with us today. [Intro]: Jack Spratt. [Leon]: Evari. [Leon]: Ood Gallifrey. [Leon]: Richard Bigley. [Arthur]: Richard Bigley. [Arthur]: Richard Bigley? [Arthur]: Richard Bigley? [Intro]: Sounds like Richard Bigley. [Intro]: Misfit. [Intro]: So, as I just stated, I'm Zach Spratt, and my guest episode today is on a narrow [Intro]: period in the history of scurvy, which I will talk a little bit more in detail.
[Intro]: I do have an undergrad degree in history, and my big interest was early modern [Intro]: history, which is roughly, you know, the fall of Constantinople or the discovery of [Intro]: the New World through the French Revolution. [Intro]: So, what do folks think when you hear scurvy? [Arthur]: Like, what's your image of scurvy? [Arthur]: The first thing I think when I hear scurvy is, what's your poison?
[Zach]: Oh, yes, of course. [Zach]: So my poison does not contain vitamin C because I'm still drinking tea because I am [Zach]: very sleepy today. [Zach]: So I'm caffeinating myself. [Zach]: Again, Scottish breakfast tea purchased from Macquarie's in Saskatoon. [SPEAKER_07]: I am popping open a second angry orchard. [SPEAKER_07]: Oh, nice pap. [SPEAKER_07]: Good pap. [SPEAKER_07]: I'm drinking draft original 16 out of a mason jar. [Sage]: That's very hipster. Yeah.
[Bigly]: The thing even says wide mouth Mason on it. [Bigly]: So I'm assuming it's not like a band promo item. [Bigly]: I'm assuming it's like actually a Mason jar. [Bigly]: That's where their [Zach]: name came from. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: You didn't know that? [Zach]: No. [Zach]: I just clicked that. [Zach]: You lived in Saskatoon for how long? [Zach]: Yeah. [Zach]: 25 years. [Zach]: I just assumed he had a big mouth. [Zach]: I don't know. [Arthur]: They just knew some dude named Mason with a big mouth was around. [Arthur]: And fuck. [Zach]: 100%. [Ood]: You know, Mason, hell of a mouth.
[Zach]: That's a famous trait. [Zach]: So, Scurvy. [Zach]: I haven't done mine yet. [Zach]: I know, I'm so excited. [Zach]: Are you still drinking tap water? [Sage]: Well, I do have tap water, but I also went and got a tipsy hard apple cider from [Sage]: Minhouse because a Misfit Raider had cider and I was like, I fucking have cider [Sage]: upstairs in my fridge by the jug of milk that we have up there. [Sage]: I forgot about it. [Sage]: Yeah, it's from Minhaus.
[Bigly]: Okay. [Sage]: It's going to be an experience. [Bigly]: Did you ever have the Flatlanders cider? [Bigly]: Yes, Flatlanders is good. [Bigly]: That's a good cider. [Arthur]: Now, in the house that Ood and Leon live in, there is also a void. [Arthur]: And this void has dropped off small black satchels that are kind of cold. [Arthur]: They're made of paper and they are a little rubbery. [Arthur]: This is what our poison is. [Leon]: That's rubbery satchels.
[Leon]: That's the hugest one of those I've ever seen. [Zach]: Are you eating something or drinking something in the satchel or the satchel [Zach]: itself? [Arthur]: It is in the satchel. [Arthur]: Leon, can you tell us what it is? [Leon]: It's a massive green grape. [Arthur]: They're just green grapes the size of like almost a ping pong ball. [Leon]: That sounds amazing. [Leon]: That's the largest grape I've ever seen. [Bigly]: Oh, fuck yeah. [Bigly]: Seedless grapes. [Bigly]: Hell yeah. [Bigly]: Always better. [Bigly]: That's where it's at. [Bigly]: That's luxury right there. [Sage]: I just noticed that at the bottom of my can of cider, it says, warning, many apples
[Sage]: were hurt in the making of this product. [Zach]: That's amazing. [Zach]: That's why they're angry. [Zach]: They deserved it. [SPEAKER_09]: The Ore Tat had set sail from New Bedford for Hudson Bay in June 1872. [SPEAKER_09]: George A. Parker was the captain. [SPEAKER_09]: In September, Captain Parker steered for Dead Man's Island to spend the winter. [SPEAKER_09]: A stiff wind blew the ship toward the rocks, stern first. [SPEAKER_09]: The planking caved in, and the running tide flowed through the ragged hole and
[SPEAKER_09]: split seams. [SPEAKER_09]: The ship listed and sagged, but kept from sinking long enough for Captain Parker to [SPEAKER_09]: beach it upright so his crew could winter on it. [SPEAKER_09]: But worse than the cold during that cursed winter was the scurvy. [SPEAKER_09]: Our scurvy is on the increase. [SPEAKER_09]: A blacksmith is very low and can't stand it long. [SPEAKER_09]: He seems to be all gone inside. [SPEAKER_09]: Scurvy is the curse of sailors. [SPEAKER_09]: Scurvy is a deficiency of vitamin C, usually from a lack of fresh fruit and
[SPEAKER_09]: vegetables in the diet. [SPEAKER_09]: The body weakens, the body bleeds inside, slowly. [SPEAKER_09]: It bleeds into muscle and bone until there's no more blood to bleed. [SPEAKER_09]: It's a horrible death. [SPEAKER_09]: According to an old man at Rankin Inlet, it was the Inuit who eventually saved [SPEAKER_09]: these whalers from death by scurvy. [SPEAKER_09]: He tells how his grandfather crossed the ice bridge from the mainland with two deer [SPEAKER_09]: livers and two hindquarters of a polar bear. [SPEAKER_09]: The Inuit had saved these whalers from death by scurvy and starvation and from the
[SPEAKER_09]: heartlessness of their fellow whalers. [SPEAKER_09]: Perhaps what the Inuit said about these white whalers is true. [SPEAKER_09]: The white men came here to kill the great whale. [SPEAKER_11]: They killed each other to survive. [SPEAKER_21]: The way of the white men is not the way [SPEAKER_09]: of the people.
[Zach]: Now, what do you guys think of when you think scurvy? [Sage]: Pirate ship. [Sage]: Pirate ships and like limes. [Zach]: Lots of pirates. [Zach]: Right? [Zach]: That's exactly it. [Zach]: Sailors. [Zach]: Limes. [Zach]: Yeah, limeys, right? [Zach]: So the British soldiers called limeys in the 19th century. [Zach]: And, you know, as early as the 1600s, scurvy was like described as like the malady [Zach]: of the mariner. [Zach]: So it's kind of a sailor thing. [Zach]: And that's mainly what I'm talking about today. [Leon]: Guinea pigs require vitamin C because they cannot synthesize their own. [Leon]: They're like people. [Zach]: How dare you cut ahead three points in my script?
[Zach]: That is exactly where I was coming up to. [Zach]: So yeah, it's a vitamin C thing. [Zach]: And only a handful of animals actually don't make their own vitamin C. [Zach]: And it's basically fruit bats, guinea pigs, and primates. [Zach]: Some primates. [Zach]: And so yeah, vitamin C is a vitamin named C because it was discovered after A and [Zach]: B. [Zach]: And its chemical name is ascorbic acid, as in scorby, as in scurvy. [Zach]: So that's why it's called that. [Zach]: Discovered in 1928, right? [Zach]: Fun fact. [Zach]: And as I say, so basically anything that eats a lot of vitamin C in its diet is at
[Zach]: risk of developing scurvy. [Zach]: Or sorry, is at risk of losing that vitamin C manufacturing capability. [Zach]: Because if you eat it all the time and then you get a mutation that stops you from [Zach]: making it, evolution, it doesn't affect you being selected for or against. [Zach]: And that's why there's a handful of animals like guinea pigs, adorable, that do not [Zach]: produce it. [Zach]: And basically, it's used in creating all of your connective tissue, including [Zach]: bones, including teeth, gums, tendons, and ligaments.
[Zach]: But interestingly, it's actually also used in DNA formation and the production of [Zach]: dopamine. [Zach]: So it's used in a whole bunch of stuff. [Zach]: So not having enough and not being able to produce your own because we don't make [Zach]: our own sucks. [Zach]: It is water-soluble, which means that it's hard to overdose, which is fine because [Zach]: I love those vitamin C chews. [Zach]: They're so delicious. [Zach]: But you also can't store it because you just pee it out, which is part of the [Zach]: problem. [Zach]: And in the West, before the podcast, we were talking about kind of medical zebras,
[Zach]: quote unquote, which are [Zach]: Cool, but rare illnesses. [Zach]: And it comes from this first year med school expression that if you hear hoofbeats, [Zach]: think horses, not zebras. [Zach]: Think of the common stuff before you think of the rare stuff. [Ood]: House kept on saying it was lupus. [Ood]: I bet he was right one of those times. [Ood]: No, he said it was never lupus. [Zach]: Exactly that. [SPEAKER_07]: I was going to say for editing, you could always pop in the House theme song. [Zach]: Yes. [Zach]: However little we can get away with without needing to pay royalties.
[Zach]: Six for that. [Zach]: Perfect. [Ood]: Or longer if we talk over it. [Ood]: Or if Leon covers it, then we can do the whole damn thing. [Zach]: Yes. [Zach]: I want to hear it on Harmonica. [Zach]: Or Kazoo. [Leon]: Ocarina? [Leon]: I can do both. [Leon]: Yes. [Zach]: It's really hard to get in North America, in the West, quote unquote, in general, [Zach]: because basically every juice is supplemented because it's cheap to make. [Zach]: So you'll notice if you look like every juice is supplemented. [Zach]: We have good access to fresh produce, barring financial stress.
[Zach]: So the people who get it in the West are either extremely impoverished and so or [Zach]: foolish. [Zach]: So a classic person who gets scurvy is a college student who's been living on Robin [Zach]: for an entire semester. [Zach]: people who are neglected, especially the elderly, people who are on restrictive [Zach]: diets, and either that's through stupidity because they are on some fad diet, like [Zach]: a really intense keto diet, or they have to be on it. [Zach]: So keto diets are effective for preventing seizures in some pediatric illnesses.
[SPEAKER_14]: Are you surprised that it's reemerged? [SPEAKER_14]: It's sad and it is a big surprise. [SPEAKER_14]: In today's current society where you would expect we have so much choice to so many [SPEAKER_14]: healthy items and so many different types of healthy foods out there that we're [SPEAKER_14]: still lacking the essential nutrition in our diets to protect us from diseases such [SPEAKER_14]: as scurvy, which we did, let's face it, assume it was pretty much extinct, really. [SPEAKER_15]: So I mean with this case here we're hearing that a number of patients were not [SPEAKER_15]: eating fruits and vegetables because of concern of sugar levels.
[SPEAKER_14]: Now this is pretty concerning because there's been a lot of talk recently in the [SPEAKER_14]: media on obviously sugar intake and actually you've still got to be careful that [SPEAKER_14]: we're getting that balance in our diets. [SPEAKER_14]: I think the word balance is pretty crucial. [SPEAKER_14]: portion of fruit today lots of vegetables because the vegetables contain vitamin C [SPEAKER_14]: too so scurvy is prevented with enough vitamin C and vitamin C is linked to the [SPEAKER_14]: collagen production in our bodies all the connective tissues and if you don't have [SPEAKER_14]: enough vitamin C then you're obviously at risk of scurvy so I would always advise
[SPEAKER_14]: clients of mine personally to have at least two portions of fruit today and tons of [SPEAKER_14]: color I think in the diet [SPEAKER_15]: And so we're seeing a number of these cases in Australia, but are we seeing it [SPEAKER_15]: elsewhere? [SPEAKER_14]: It's the first I've heard, if I'm being honest, about this scurvy in particular. [SPEAKER_14]: It is pretty shocking, especially in Australia where they have such access to [SPEAKER_14]: beautiful fruit. [SPEAKER_14]: It is very surprising. [SPEAKER_14]: So hopefully we're not going to see more cases elsewhere now where awareness is [SPEAKER_14]: being raised again.
[Ood]: Is that what happened to Jordan Peterson? [Ood]: Because he was on that all-meat diet? [Zach]: Yep, exactly that. [Zach]: So vitamin C is not present in me. [Zach]: I thought that was the benzos. [Zach]: I mean, there was that too. [SPEAKER_20]: Are you still eating your all-beef diet? [SPEAKER_07]: Unfortunately, yes. [SPEAKER_20]: Really, just beef. [SPEAKER_20]: Can you have ketchup on it? [SPEAKER_20]: No, nothing. [SPEAKER_07]: I saw there was a thing on Twitter a while ago where JP was in touch with Skrillex. [SPEAKER_07]: And I was looking forward to their collab album, Scary Lobsters, Nice Sprites.
[Zach]: And the last population who get it are people who have malabsorption issues. [Zach]: People with short guts. [Zach]: So if you've needed surgery or you have had illnesses damaging your gut, [Zach]: Or people who are severe alcoholics can have more absorption issues. [Zach]: So it's much more common to see vitamin D deficiency, vitamin B deficiency, or [Zach]: other micronutrients like thiamine or folate. [Zach]: So vitamin C is rare. [Zach]: I've never seen a case of scurvy. [Zach]: I'm unlikely ever to see a case of scurvy because you almost have to work to get it
[Zach]: unless you have a complex medical condition. [Zach]: So do you guys have any idea what scurvy looks like symptomatically? [Arthur]: Bleeding from the gums. [Zach]: classic right exactly right like you look up pictures and it's always somebody [Zach]: holding up that lip and you can see the swollen gums and that kind of stuff shows [Zach]: up within a couple of months of stopping scurvy they're stopping vitamin c and what [Zach]: makes this fun for me as a medical historian no i'm not a historian but somebody's [Zach]: interested in medical history is that it's beautifully well-defined syndrome it has
[Zach]: a single cause and a single cure it is a very distinct set of symptoms [Zach]: where tons of illnesses are overlapping and vague. [Zach]: You know, people talk about fevers that could include almost every infectious [Zach]: disease and fluxes, which is basically any diarrheal illness. [Zach]: So it's really hard, but scurvy has like a super distinct syndrome. [Zach]: So when you're reading about it historically, you kind of know if somebody's [Zach]: talking about scurvy. [Zach]: And so a description of it from 1979, not 1979, 1679,
[Zach]: It is defined by, quote, putrefaction and stinking of the mouth and gums, [Zach]: toothache, spots on the leg, sometimes red, purple, black, or blue. [Zach]: It just, you fall apart, practically, because it is used to make connective tissue. [Zach]: So it starts, you just feel unwell, maybe you're a bit irritable, you lose your [Zach]: appetite. [SPEAKER_03]: You start bruising more easily and bleeding more easily, [Zach]: because blood vessels have collagen in them, like that pulls them together, or [Zach]: makes them work. [Zach]: You start getting what are called corkscrew hairs that grow out of what are called
[Zach]: hyperkeratinized. [Zach]: So your hair follicles kind of start developing bumps and the hairs are super [Zach]: coiled because your body can't make them right anymore. [Zach]: Then you start getting joint pain. [Zach]: You start bleeding into joints and eventually you develop psychotic symptoms and [Zach]: you die over the course of about six months. [Zach]: So don't get scurvy is the short version. [Zach]: It's actually not a very pleasant illness. [Zach]: So low priority. [Zach]: No kidding. [Zach]: Yeah. [Zach]: Except for the psychosis. [Zach]: That could be fun. [Zach]: I mean, it can be fun. [Zach]: People take drugs to induce psychosis all the time. [Ood]: So, like, just a couple clarifying points.
[Ood]: When I say putrefaction of the mouth, like, does it smell like the mouth is [Ood]: rotting? [Zach]: So it's, and we were talking again before the podcast about leprosy and open [Zach]: wounds. [Zach]: So open wounds in general, especially if they're falling apart, smell uniquely [Zach]: awful. [Zach]: It's the classic rotting meat smell. [Zach]: So if you've thrown out some raw chicken or something in your garbage and you leave [Zach]: it too long and you start, you open the garbage, you get that really vile smell. [Zach]: That is exactly what it smells like.
[Zach]: And that's because of a combination of things, but it's mainly... [Zach]: bacteria produce anaerobics, so bacteria that don't use oxygen, breaking it down [Zach]: into basically bacteria poop. [Zach]: And anything that's made without oxygen is going to smell really foul. [Zach]: And that's part of actually why poop smells bad as well. [Ood]: Oh, so it's just bacteria shitting in your mouth. [Zach]: Yep, exactly. [Zach]: Which they already do. [Zach]: That's why we get cavities. [Sage]: I tell my son that all the time. [Sage]: I'm like, bacteria will poop in your mouth if you don't brush your teeth, son. [Zach]: If you just blow air up your butt, then you will have non-stinky poop.
[Zach]: You know what? [Zach]: I will try that after this podcast, and I will report back. [Zach]: Report back. [Zach]: The more you know. [Ood]: The spots on the legs, are those like discoloration, or are those like bruises? [Zach]: You know on really old people where they just seem to have these big purple and [Zach]: blue patches on their arms and legs? [Zach]: It's basically the same thing because their connective tissue is poor just because [Zach]: of age. [Zach]: You know, everything starts aging just in the body. [Zach]: And it's very similar to that. [Zach]: So they get these big, dark patches that eventually open up, start weeping blood,
[Zach]: eventually get infected, turn into pus. [Zach]: And because we don't like we'll actually put antibiotics, powdered antibiotics on [Zach]: wounds like us in the modern era just to reduce the smell. [SPEAKER_22]: Yeah, this was a lady in her 60s who really had extensive bruising and fragility of [SPEAKER_22]: skin over the lower extremities. [SPEAKER_22]: Nothing on the upper body, but she was very thin, very stylish, very fashionable, [SPEAKER_22]: and I spent quite a few months trying to sort out what was going on with her.
[SPEAKER_22]: A lot of laser therapy, topical creams, and didn't really get much. [SPEAKER_22]: And then it suddenly occurred to me that maybe she had a form of skin fragility [SPEAKER_22]: that was related to her vitamin C levels. [SPEAKER_22]: We put her on a gram of vitamin C a day, and in four weeks her legs cleared up. [SPEAKER_22]: So I've since uncovered about five more cases like that in my practice. [SPEAKER_22]: I think they're all women who were... [SPEAKER_22]: nutritionally deprived, although no financial reason to be so. [SPEAKER_22]: They certainly don't fall into the homeless dependent category, but they've just
[SPEAKER_22]: cut out too much vitamin C in their diet. [SPEAKER_22]: It turns out if you have less than 10 milligrams a day for a month, you can begin [SPEAKER_22]: to develop clinical symptoms. [SPEAKER_22]: And these women had scurvy, basically. [SPEAKER_22]: In the modern age, in rich America, with enough food to go around for these people, [SPEAKER_22]: certainly. [SPEAKER_17]: What kinds of things did you try before you came to the realization that it might [SPEAKER_17]: be vitamin C? [SPEAKER_22]: Well, I initially thought there might have been some purper that would respond to
[SPEAKER_22]: long pulse dye laser. [SPEAKER_22]: I tried amlactin, ammonium lactate topically. [SPEAKER_22]: I tried retin-A topically. [SPEAKER_22]: I tried a number of things to see if I could slow down the fragility and the [SPEAKER_22]: bruising, but really to no avail. [SPEAKER_22]: And the response was so remarkable once they were on vitamin C. [SPEAKER_22]: I mean, it was in a matter of three or four weeks. [SPEAKER_22]: I just couldn't believe it. [SPEAKER_22]: Unfortunately, there's no good way to measure a vitamin C level unless you do it [SPEAKER_22]: experimentally in the tissue itself.
[SPEAKER_22]: A blood or plasma level doesn't give you any useful information. [SPEAKER_17]: Did you actually use the S-word with the patient and talk about scurvy? [SPEAKER_22]: No, I did not. [SPEAKER_22]: This was a group of women that would have been horrified if I had told them they [SPEAKER_22]: had scurvy because it sounds dirty. [SPEAKER_22]: It's not. [SPEAKER_22]: But I just told them, I said, I don't think you're absorbing enough vitamin C in [SPEAKER_22]: your diet, and I want you to supplement it by taking 1,000 milligrams a day, and [SPEAKER_22]: we're going to do it for a month and see what happens. [SPEAKER_22]: And the response was really pretty gratifying.
[SPEAKER_22]: So I wonder how many other cases of trace element malnutrition or other [SPEAKER_22]: deficiencies, dietary deficiencies may be out there in that population. [SPEAKER_22]: know that gets by with a green salad and no dressing and nothing else on it they [SPEAKER_22]: just don't get enough vitamin c in their diet [Zach]: the people who got this as you all correctly identified are sailors uh not just [Zach]: pirates but say actually in many ways less pirates because pirates could return to [Zach]: port a lot more often than like uh than naval like military naval ships and so my
[Zach]: focus is mainly on british sailors uh again [Zach]: because I read English, and the English really ruled the seas for much of the late, [Zach]: early modern period, and so they were most obsessed with this. [Zach]: Do you guys have any idea what sailors ate in, say, 1700? [Ood]: Hardtack? [Zach]: Look at that. [Zach]: That's the classic thing. [Zach]: Hardtack salted meat. [Zach]: So you can find videos of people eating Civil War hardtack, and it hasn't changed. [Zach]: So it was unleavened,
[Zach]: baked twice so it was rock hard, it wouldn't rot, and it was basically inedible [Zach]: until you soaked it in something else. [Zach]: In 1573, this is obviously translated, there was a description by a Spanish sailor [Zach]: of what they ate, which are biscuits as white as piles of dung, which is obviously [Zach]: being sarcastic, and stringy meat that was called saltmine because they needed to [Zach]: heavily salt this meat to have it survive for months. [Zach]: And then you jump 200 years in the future in 1789, a British description is almost
[Zach]: exactly the same thing. [Zach]: Unfermented hard biscuit, that's hard tack, boiled peas, and as long as it lasted, [Zach]: you get like butter and hard cheese. [Zach]: And then what you had to drink while you had it, you had fresh water, you would [Zach]: have diluted beer and diluted spirit. [Zach]: Again, because fermentation reduces the risk of bacterial contamination in your [Zach]: water. [Zach]: because you have to boil it, and because the development of alcohol, which is just [Zach]: yeast poop, kills off eventually the yeast as well, but also other bacteria. [SPEAKER_07]: I was going to say, there's always that thing about sailors having a ration of rum.
[Zach]: Yeah, and they'd mix it with water, and it'd be called grog, which I've tried. [Zach]: I've tried grog just to see what it's like, and it tastes exactly like you'd [Zach]: expect, but diluted rum is not fantastic. [Zach]: And they weren't stupid. [Zach]: They would bring fresh produce and stuff. [Zach]: It's just... [Zach]: I mean, even with a fridge, my fresh produce lasts like a couple of weeks. [Zach]: So it doesn't last that long. [Zach]: And so the only thing they would eat every single day were their drink rations and [Zach]: hard tack. [Zach]: And then across the week, they would get some meat, they would get some cheese, [Zach]: some dried fruit and stuff.
[Zach]: But really, most of the time, it was basically eating saltines and water, if you [Zach]: want to picture what a modern diet like that would look like. [Zach]: And so this was a big deal. [Zach]: You know, we always talk about, ah, you scurvy dog, but it really mattered. [Zach]: I have some stats. [Zach]: So in 1740, the English sent out a fleet to hunt the Spanish treasure galleon, [Zach]: which brought back all the gold and silver that they were pillaging from South and [Zach]: Central America. [Zach]: And by the time it returned, over half of its sailors were dead, and most of them
[Zach]: from Scurvy. [Ood]: Holy shit. [Zach]: Oh, man. [Zach]: In 1780, the English Channel fleet, and the channel isn't that wide, so these are [Zach]: people who were dead. [Zach]: pretty close to shore, had to return to port early, like against orders. [Zach]: And at that point, a sixth of its sailors were debilitated by scurvy. [Zach]: And that's like not in the middle of nowhere. [Zach]: Over half of the illnesses that affected sailors were scurvy. [Zach]: And that's including infectious disease. [Zach]: So that's just how wildly damaging this was.
[Zach]: And it is estimated that in the 18th century, the leading cause of death of sailors [Zach]: was scurvy, not infection or war. [Ood]: And Christ, you talk about half of them returning dead, but if you're on a voyage [Ood]: and you have duties to be done on the ship, your working capacity, your labor [Ood]: capacity of that ship is going to be diminished too. [Ood]: If half the people are dead, I bet the other half probably aren't in the best shape [Ood]: to work either. [Zach]: Oh, definitely not, because they'll also have scurvy. [Zach]: They just won't have died yet.
[Ood]: It sounds like they barely skidded into port. [Zach]: Yeah, and that's exactly where the worries are. [Zach]: And so this became a bigger and bigger issue, as you kind of see over the 18th [Zach]: century, because the empire grew and like the nature of naval blockades and [Zach]: increasing overseas territories. [Zach]: So this was a huge issue. [SPEAKER_12]: It is not easy to conceive a more dismal and diversified scene of misery than what [SPEAKER_12]: is beheld in the last stage of this calamity. [SPEAKER_12]: The blood, as it flowed out of the orifice of the wound, might be seen to run in
[SPEAKER_12]: different shades of light and dark streaks. [SPEAKER_12]: In dissected bodies, all the parts were so mixed and blended with each other that [SPEAKER_12]: they made up but one mass or lump, so confounded that one could scarce distinguish [SPEAKER_12]: one from another. [SPEAKER_12]: Their muscles were gangrened and upon handling them they fell to pieces. [SPEAKER_12]: The callous of broken bones, which had been completely formed for a long time, were [SPEAKER_12]: found dissolved, and the fracture seems as if it had never consolidated.
[SPEAKER_12]: What was very surprising, the brains of those poor creatures were always sound and [SPEAKER_12]: entire, and they preserved their appetite to the last. [Zach]: I'm going to use that ground to kind of explore the evolution of medical history [Zach]: from early modern period into what was sort of becoming a science by the start of [Zach]: the 90s. [Zach]: Because we have this idea of historical medicine as a bunch of idiots doing random [Zach]: shit.
[Zach]: Which to an extent they were. [Zach]: But they were still smart. [Zach]: Like these are still people whose goal was to help people. [Zach]: It's just their attitude was totally different. [Arthur]: And I think once you can understand that, everything they did made a lot more [Arthur]: sense. [Zach]: Because their goal was to understand the world and use that information to practice [Zach]: medicine. [Zach]: So at the time, medicine was very much like an academic or a theoretical pursuit as [Zach]: opposed to a practical pursuit. [Zach]: Quote unquote, practical medicine was mostly performed by barber surgeons and they
[Zach]: were kind of looked down on. [Zach]: And so that's what makes this to me really interesting. [Zach]: There are political elements to the scurvy story that I'll touch on, but that's [Zach]: boring to me. [Zach]: I don't love politics or at least historical politics. [Zach]: Basically, the big question I'm trying to answer is like, how do they go about [Zach]: thinking about and then finding a cure for scurvy? [Zach]: Or at least applying a cure for scurvy. [Zach]: Because basically by the 1600s, they knew that limes, as one of you mentioned, [Zach]: cured scurvy. [Zach]: It's just they didn't know why.
[Zach]: And so they continue trying to figure out just what made scurvy tick so that they [Zach]: could cure it. [Zach]: And they had a belief that is shared by a lot of, what's the nice word for it? [Zach]: alternative practitioners, people who do not practice scientific medicine, that, [Zach]: you know, it had to be individualized. [Zach]: There wasn't one cure for scurvy because everybody's scurvy was different. [Zach]: And when you kind of accept that, it makes sense why they didn't just go, oh, well,
[Zach]: limes work for people. [Zach]: Why aren't we just giving everybody lime? [Zach]: At least until the end of the 1700s. [Zach]: So basically, we're going to see medicine over this story evolve from like an [Zach]: academic thing. [Zach]: to an outcomes-based approach. [Zach]: So it transitions from a theoretical approach to an outcomes-based approach, and I [Zach]: think that's the cool part. [Zach]: So basically, what I'll be doing is wham-bam, through a bunch of different ideas [Zach]: about what it's going to be. [Zach]: And I'm going to start with one I know you'll all have heard of, and that's the [Zach]: four humors. [Zach]: Can anybody name them for me?
[Sage]: Bile? [Sage]: Like black bile and yellow bile. [Zach]: Mm-hmm. [Zach]: Flem and blood. [Zach]: Exactly. [Zach]: Exactly. [Zach]: So these were exactly what you'd think of. [Zach]: So there's blood, which is blood. [Zach]: There was yellow bile, which was a sign of gastric secretions. [Zach]: Like, you know, when you vomit and you get that bit of green stuff, that bit of [Zach]: yellow stomach fuses, that's what we today call bile. [Zach]: And that's what they called yellow bile. [Zach]: There was phlegm, which we all know. [Zach]: And then there was black bile. [Zach]: So it was just poop. [Zach]: And we always kind of think of this as a simple thing. [Zach]: But the humoral medicine was like the defining characteristic of Western medicines.
[Zach]: And in a different form, Chinese medicine for almost $3,000. [Zach]: And so it actually grew to be a very complex combination of how we understood [Zach]: personality and the body and the world. [Zach]: And like, the fact is, if you can't see inside yourself, people's understanding of [Zach]: how their body works is that, you know, we talked for instance, just to jump to an [Zach]: aside about like the quote unquote, wandering womb and hysteria, which I'm not [Zach]: going to touch on, but like people don't know what goes on inside their bodies. [Zach]: And even practicing medicine, like,
[Zach]: The questions people ask and the ways they try to contextualize their illness when [Zach]: they don't have a full understanding of their illness really helped me understand [Zach]: just where these historical ideas came from. [Zach]: Because it is easy if you can't see inside yourself to go, oh, maybe this is why I [Zach]: feel this particular way. [Zach]: And it's really interesting. [Ood]: I see so many people talk a lot about what goes on with their bodies. [Ood]: And I always wonder just... [Ood]: how accurate they're being because a lot of people suck at keeping track of cause
[Ood]: and effect and like and like keeping track of like all the factors that might [Ood]: contribute and might not contribute and what's a relevant variable versus an [Ood]: irrelevant variable and especially with people in their personal lives where you [Ood]: know people are kind of just assuming that their memory is correct like i can see [Ood]: so many errors happening [Zach]: Oh, yeah. [Zach]: Memory is terrible. [Zach]: Like eyewitness testimony is famously unreliable. [Zach]: And like in my own life, I know that. [Zach]: And I mean, the fact is, we don't fully understand a lot of stuff eventually around [Zach]: psychiatric medicine.
[Zach]: We were talking before the podcast about antidepressants. [Zach]: And there's this whole meme that like, oh, depression is a serotonin deficiency. [Zach]: That's kind of a back formation from the fact that we know that drugs like SSRIs [Zach]: that like increase the action of serotonin. [Zach]: make you less depressed like we don't actually have a direct mechanism we haven't [Zach]: observed that we just figured that's probably what's happening when there's [Zach]: probably a lot more complex stuff going on in the humoral worldview i suppose
[Zach]: basically scurvy was a build-up of melancholy or a build-up of black bile so [Zach]: basically this idea was that basically shit built up in your body and [Zach]: corrupted you it made you rot because in many ways if your connective tissue breaks [Zach]: down you're you're kind of falling apart [SPEAKER_07]: they thought you uh got scurvy because you were full of shit [Zach]: effectively and i'm actually going to read you a description so this is from 1587 [Zach]: it goes the scurvy is a stopping of the spleen because melancholy was felt to be
[Zach]: centered in the spleen [Zach]: Kind of talking about how these colorful spots develop. [Zach]: And so this is literally what they felt happen, that something in your diet or your [Zach]: lifestyle
[Zach]: made basically shit accumulate or at least something related to it and it made you [Zach]: rot. [Zach]: And kind of the idea was that melancholy is associated with sadness, with [Zach]: moroseness, with darkness, with [Zach]: with grayness. [Zach]: And so the logic basically was the sea is sad, gray, miserable. [Zach]: So that's obviously how they're getting it. [Zach]: That's why sailors get it. [Zach]: And that's why people who are in much more northern [Arthur]: climates that are very [Zach]: dark are at higher risk of getting it over the winter.
[Zach]: We now know because they don't have fresh produce, but this is their logic. [Ood]: Is this before the age of dissections and surgeries and stuff like that? [Zach]: This is not... [Ood]: So, like, how did they rationalize, because, like, they've dissected bodies at this [Ood]: point, so how did they tell themselves, like, well, yeah, the shit has to just spew [Ood]: out of the bowel somewhere and end up in the lips and all that? [Zach]: Yeah, because the idea was more metaphysical than that, I guess, would be it. [Zach]: Like, there was this idea of physically it happening, but also, like, just the
[Zach]: essence of melancholy leeching out. [Zach]: And the other fact is that often the bodies they were dissecting were not that [Zach]: fresh. [Zach]: Like the really fresh dissections started happening more in the 19th century. [Zach]: So often these bodies are a day or two old and especially the gut and stuff does [Zach]: not last long because it's full of bacteria. [Zach]: Like your gut is the very first thing to start rotting. [Zach]: So they didn't really have a great perception of this. [Zach]: And a lot of the people who are dying of scurvy are doing so on ships where they're [Zach]: not going to be immediately dissected.
[Zach]: Most of the people who are dissected are criminals. [Leon]: Is it true that your gut will start rotting before you're dead, depending on a [Leon]: diagnosis you might have? [Zach]: Yes and no. [Zach]: I mean, most of the people who have kind of rotting guts are usually ones who have [Zach]: something very wrong, like either their gut is obstructed or it's lost its blood [Zach]: supply. [Zach]: But it is very quick to fall apart. [Zach]: But that said, all of this was discussed even into the late 1700s. [Zach]: And they weren't 100% wrong because they ultimately... [Zach]: did say probably most of this has to do with whatever your diet is, it is affecting
[Zach]: the way melancholy is being processed or passed through your gut. [Zach]: The problem is that lemons and limes are viewed kind of as phlegmatic foods. [Zach]: They are cold, they are wet, and so it doesn't make sense that they would [Zach]: counteract melancholy. [Zach]: And so that's part of why they were like, wow, this doesn't quite fit. [Zach]: And so a lot of other foods were tried instead, especially things related to [Zach]: mustard, which are kind of viewed as hot food that would bring you up. [Zach]: And a relative of mustard called scurvy grass does have quite a bit of vitamin C.
[Zach]: And it was a classic thing that sailors would land because it grows on shores and [Zach]: eat it and get better because it has a moderate amount of it. [Ood]: Like they just chew on this grass or would they make it into the mustard? [Zach]: I mean, it's a relative of watercress, so it's leaves. [Zach]: But yeah, I had the name of it. [Zach]: Yeah, so it's still called scurvy grass, but it's cute. [Zach]: It's tiny little plants, but it does like growing near shores. [Zach]: So it got this reputation for curing scurvy because it did. [Zach]: It had a small amount of vitamin C. [SPEAKER_07]: It'd be a nice break from salt pork, hard tack, just a little light salad.
[Zach]: Oh, yeah, it'd be wonderful. [Zach]: And I never crave salads. [Zach]: There is one cure that I could not find the theoretical basis of. [Zach]: When I say cure, that's in big quotes. [Zach]: And that was dung that had been steeped in wine, which makes no sense. [Zach]: And I think I'd rather die scurvy. [Ood]: That sounds like a homeopathy thing. [Ood]: Like, you've got to give them more of what's illing them. [Zach]: Yeah. [Ood]: A dung of what animal, though? [Ood]: Like, what dung are you talking about? [Zach]: That's a good question. [Zach]: Literally the list of cures, because this is from a primary source from the 1600s.
[Zach]: just headed on a list. [Zach]: And so sadly, I could not find anything more about their logic. [Bigly]: Steeped in wine. [Bigly]: Would the wine have the vitamin C? [Zach]: No. [Zach]: So vitamin C is a very fragile thing. [Zach]: Even cooking fruits and vegetables often destroys the vitamin C. [Zach]: So that's why even though sailors were fed boiled peas, once you boil anything, it [Zach]: kills most of the vitamin C, which is why you need fresh stuff. [Zach]: Same with canning things. [Zach]: It doesn't provide a lot of vitamin C if you eat canned vegetables. [Zach]: Pickles don't have vitamin C. [SPEAKER_07]: If only they had access to like a shitload of rose hips.
[Zach]: Well, what's funny is that citrus fruit is fairly robust. [Zach]: Like it's got a big waxy rind. [Zach]: So it actually lasts a fairly long time, as we'll see. [Zach]: Now I could talk about the four humors all day because it is such a defining [Zach]: feature of medical history, literally up until the 19th century. [Zach]: But I do need to move on to the next one, which on the face of it makes total [Zach]: sense. [Zach]: And they said, maybe it has to do with an overload of salt because we're feeding [Zach]: them tons of salt and they're sailing on the ocean. [Zach]: But what makes this neat is that it's also shows this evolution.
[Zach]: So as you see natural science evolve, [Zach]: people would be like, oh, well, maybe this new thing I've discovered is why people [Zach]: get scurvy. [Zach]: And we'll see this over and over again. [Zach]: And so basically as geology, as people were figuring out solutions and things, [Zach]: they're like, I know it's salt. [Zach]: And so again, the idea was that somehow it stopped digestion and you got shit [Zach]: accumulating and you rotted. [Zach]: That's like the nutshell. [Zach]: There was also this weird idea that wetness, because most things you salt are dry.
[Zach]: So they're like, well, if you're in the ocean and you're around me, [Zach]: wet air all the time, maybe it like reverses how salt works. [Zach]: And so instead of preserving sailors, it makes them rot faster. [Zach]: And you see this trend, right? [Zach]: That scurvy is a disease that is just prematurely rotting. [Zach]: And a line from 1753 says that salt, quote, hastens the corruptions of our humors, [Zach]: they're not that far off, and corruption of the solid parts of our body, even of [Zach]: our bones. [Zach]: And so their cures, proposed cures,
[Zach]: explained, well, maybe lemons and limes somehow interact with this salt and just [Zach]: carry it out of your body. [Zach]: They neutralize it somehow, and that's why you get better. [Zach]: Or, speaking of homeopathy, the idea was that maybe we make them drink salt water [Zach]: because that will make you shit. [Zach]: It is a laxative. [Zach]: And they're like, maybe you just poop out more salt with it. [Zach]: We just carry it out. [Ood]: You know, I'm not a doctor, but that sounds like a good idea. [Zach]: Yeah. [Zach]: Oh, no, it sounds like a fantastic idea. [Zach]: That's what you need in a world where you are already dehydrated.
[Zach]: But this one was kind of disposed of pretty quickly through some pretty rational [Zach]: discussions. [Zach]: Number one, they're like, yeah, but people dying of scurvy, once they're dead, they [Zach]: don't like rot any faster. [Zach]: So it's not as if this is somehow accelerating decomposition. [Zach]: And the other part was that they're like, yeah, but people who work in salt mines [Zach]: never get scurvy. [Zach]: So obviously it can't be the salt. [Zach]: So this is pretty quickly dismissed. [Zach]: I just thought it was an interesting one. [Zach]: And the saltwater cure was actually used up until the mid-1700s.
[SPEAKER_18]: Today we're going to follow salt through the digestive system. [SPEAKER_18]: In the walls of the small intestine, salt is absorbed into the bloodstream, making [SPEAKER_18]: your blood, well, saltier. [SPEAKER_18]: As it goes through the body, it makes the fluid outside of the cells saltier than [SPEAKER_18]: the inside of the cells. [SPEAKER_18]: The cells notice the change right away. [SPEAKER_18]: That's because the extra salt outside acts like a magnet pulling the water out of [SPEAKER_18]: the cells. [SPEAKER_18]: When they try to hold in the water, they send chemical messages to the brain. [SPEAKER_18]: Meanwhile, in the brain, there are sensors that keep track of the saltiness of the
[SPEAKER_18]: blood. [SPEAKER_18]: When it's too much, it goes on alert to tell you, you're thirsty. [SPEAKER_18]: The kidneys also dilute the salt by slowing down the urine production and [SPEAKER_18]: conserving water. [SPEAKER_18]: Our blood pressure depends on the balance of salt and water in the body. [SPEAKER_18]: The kidneys use sodium and potassium to pull extra water out of the blood. [SPEAKER_18]: When you get too much sodium from salt, the kidneys can't put the excess water into [SPEAKER_18]: urine. [SPEAKER_18]: It stays in your blood and strains the blood vessels with high blood pressure. [Zach]: So you can see this is kind of fun. [Zach]: I mean, I think it's fun.
[Zach]: And so now this is a one that I had never heard of until I was in medical history, [Zach]: but it's called iatrochemistry. [Zach]: Has anybody heard of that? [Leon]: No. [Leon]: What is it? [Zach]: Well, that's exactly it. [Zach]: Or have you heard the term iatrogenic? [Leon]: Also no. [Leon]: What is it? [Zach]: Okay. [Zach]: Yeah. [Zach]: So iatro comes from the Greek for physician or medicine. [Zach]: They're kind of the same terms. [Zach]: And basically it means medical chemistry. [Zach]: And iatrogenic means things caused by the medical system or by doctors. [Zach]: And in the modern era, we use iatrogenic to mean like diseases that the medical
[Zach]: system causes or medical treatments cause. [Zach]: So, of course, there are lots of things. [Zach]: So, for instance, I had a patient not so long ago who had an iatrogenic bowel [Zach]: perforation because a tube that had been put into his stomach fell out and he had a [Zach]: hole in his bowel, in his stomach, actually. [Zach]: And so that's an iatrogenic illness. [Zach]: If we hadn't put that there, he wouldn't have had a hole. [Zach]: And medications can cause all kinds of iatrogenic. [Zach]: Chemotherapy. [Zach]: can create all kinds of iatrogenic illnesses, whether it's immunotherapy or [Zach]: immunosuppression or anemia, all of these things.
[SPEAKER_07]: So like if you were to go to a dermatologist to get like a wart removed or [SPEAKER_07]: something, and then you come down with MRSA, that'd be? [Zach]: Yeah. [Zach]: So that is an iatrogenic infection. [Zach]: You wouldn't have got it. [Zach]: Probably the most common lately have been people who are coming to hospital and [Zach]: getting infections in hospital. [Zach]: So there's a lot of iatrogenic [Zach]: infections or nosocomial is is a related term that means acquired in hospital so [Zach]: iatrochemistry and this is i think really neat so you see basically people [Zach]: discovering chemistry like the shift from alchemy to chemistry and then they're
[Zach]: like oh [Zach]: Maybe our bodies work like this chemicals we're discovering, which is of course [Zach]: false because the idea of like the human body, like life is defined by defying our [Zach]: external environment. [Zach]: Like that's actually one of the definitions of life, that it is able to maintain a [Zach]: separate system apart from our environment. [Zach]: I mean, that's why humans have a very strict body temperature, for instance. [Zach]: That is what we call homeostasis or keeping the same. [Arthur]: A bit of a side tangent here, but did you know that there are some very large
[Arthur]: viruses that can actually keep a different saline level within and without of their [Arthur]: own cell? [Arthur]: I don't know. [Arthur]: I can't remember if they're megaviruses or maybe viruses, but there's a couple of [Arthur]: viruses that have proton pumps that can pump shit out of their own cell, which [Arthur]: means that they have a bit of homeostasis, which means that maybe a little bit [Arthur]: alive. [Zach]: Oh, yeah. [Zach]: Well, Hank Green, the famous science communicator and brother of author John Green, [Zach]: he argues that viruses are alive and he will die on that hill. [Zach]: It's really interesting how our bodies, like basically life left the oceans, but we
[Zach]: still carry the ocean. [Zach]: It's like we, our blood is salty. [Zach]: All of the stuff inside and around ourselves is salty. [Zach]: Like we just are an ocean sack with organs. [Zach]: So if you want to think about it that way, but at the same time, [Zach]: It makes sense that somebody are like, we are part of the natural world. [Zach]: We have discovered something new about the natural world. [Zach]: In this case, acids and bases. [Zach]: Let's try to apply that to ourselves. [Zach]: It's actually in a world where our understanding, our as humans understanding was [Zach]: incomplete. [Zach]: And it still is incomplete, just less so.
[Zach]: It makes total sense to go, I have new knowledge. [Zach]: Let's apply it to this process. [Zach]: And what's interesting is that I think this is most where you see what is [Zach]: historical and incorrect medicine being applied in the modern era by kooks. [Zach]: And this is the idea that they're like, maybe it has to do with the acid-base [Zach]: balance in your body. [Zach]: Maybe it's out of whack and you just need to get that back incorrect. [Zach]: Or maybe your body is fermenting things wrong and we need to sort that out.
[Ood]: Ooh, autobrewer syndrome. [Zach]: What's hilarious is I was actually thinking of bringing that up and I deleted it [Zach]: out of my thing. [Zach]: But exactly that, that you are literally fermenting in your gut. [Zach]: And you know, if you look at all of this like new age dietary advice, it's all [Zach]: about acids and bases, which is ridiculous because the human body, if you screw its [Zach]: pH up by more than like 0.05, it is nearly fatal. [Zach]: Like our ideal pH is between 7.35 and 7.45. [Zach]: And like,
[Zach]: 7.2 is incompatible with life. [Zach]: So you can't make yourself more acidic. [Zach]: So they said this idea that this is kind of the first step where they're like, [Zach]: okay, humors, that doesn't make any sense. [Zach]: Let's try to apply modern science, so to speak, to this. [Zach]: And so their idea was that you would eat and digestion took place via fermentation. [Zach]: Because, of course, they had no way to know how digestion worked. [Zach]: And so they're like, well, this kind of makes sense because... [Zach]: Fermentation breaks stuff down. [Zach]: Yeast ferments stuff.
[Zach]: So maybe that's how this works. [Zach]: And their idea was basically that scurvy is an accumulation of alkali. [Zach]: Your body is too basic. [Zach]: And the fact is that most poisons are alkalis. [Zach]: And most things that smell terrible and rotting things are mostly basic. [Zach]: And so they're like, well, this makes sense. [Zach]: Plus, lemons and limes, like citrus fruit, are acid and they fix scurvy. [Zach]: So you can see on the face of it, this makes total sense. [Zach]: And so they extended this to say, well, then any acid should do it.
[Zach]: And so you would start seeing them feeding sailors stuff like vinegar or diluted [Zach]: sulfuric acid. [SPEAKER_07]: Oh, no. [Zach]: Yeah, right. [Zach]: And then they do the thing that modern, you know, creative practitioners of [Zach]: non-medicine pseudoscientists [Zach]: If it didn't work, they'd go, well, your scurvy must be acidic scurvy, and that's [Zach]: why my cure didn't work. [Zach]: So you can see them having a good idea and then refusing to reject it when provided [Zach]: with evidence that it's innocent.
[SPEAKER_03]: So meanwhile, in the South Pacific, Polynesian sailors were spending weeks and [SPEAKER_03]: weeks at sea and going tremendous distances. [SPEAKER_03]: But there were no written instances of scurvy. [SPEAKER_03]: Why is that? [SPEAKER_03]: Because their diet consisted of fruits, vegetables, tubers, fish, and instead of [SPEAKER_03]: beer, what did they have to drink? [SPEAKER_03]: Coconut water. [SPEAKER_03]: So just a couple of coconuts is plenty of vitamin C to keep scurvy at bay and to [SPEAKER_03]: heal you if you have problems. [SPEAKER_03]: But Cartier didn't know about that. [SPEAKER_03]: back in the uh in the doldrums of canada here um he was desperate to find a cure
[SPEAKER_03]: for his men so he talked to the iroquois who told him to use the branches of the [SPEAKER_03]: aneda tree and to boil them so cartier did that he boiled them gave the steed to [SPEAKER_03]: all of his men who would have guessed a week later the men who were still alive [SPEAKER_03]: were totally healed [SPEAKER_03]: So Cartier, of course, never acknowledged that either. [SPEAKER_03]: These guys were pretty stubborn. [SPEAKER_03]: By the mid-1700s, there were several dozen cures for scurvy that had been
[SPEAKER_03]: documented over the past 3,000 years. [SPEAKER_03]: But British, American, and Portuguese doctors either never got wind of them, which [SPEAKER_03]: seems improbable, or more likely, they refused to prescribe them because they were [SPEAKER_03]: considered barbaric, [SPEAKER_03]: unscientific, or even worse, French. [SPEAKER_03]: So instead, these doctors prescribed their own cures. [SPEAKER_03]: They forced patients to purge themselves with salt water. [SPEAKER_03]: They rubbed mercury paste onto open sores.
[SPEAKER_03]: They bled them, or check this out, they increased the sailors' workload and the [SPEAKER_03]: belief that the disease was caused by indolence and sloth. [Zach]: So they would move on to a new idea, again, based around growing knowledge of [Zach]: science. [Zach]: And they said, well, what if this, if this isn't about acid basis, what if it's [Zach]: about gases? [Zach]: Because in the mid and late 1700s, early and mid 1700s, different scientists,
[Zach]: especially Boyle, [Zach]: started, appropriately enough, started working with gases. [Zach]: They started isolating the components of air and finding out that different parts [Zach]: of air did different things. [Zach]: And they're like, maybe this is all about gas problems. [Zach]: Maybe our gas balances are wrong. [Zach]: Which is quiz time. [Zach]: Does anybody know what Phlogiston or Phlogiston is? [Zach]: Phlogiston! [Ood]: That's the fuel that fantasy ships use to fly in space, I believe.
[Zach]: So, yes, it is that. [Zach]: It actually is also historically a name for the greatest part of air, which makes [Zach]: up 70% of air. [Zach]: Does anybody know what that is? [Ood]: Nitrogen. [Zach]: Exactly. [Zach]: And then deflogisticated air would, of course, be mostly oxygen. [Zach]: That's the majority of the rest of air. [Zach]: And then the third component is called fixed air, and that is carbon dioxide. [Zach]: And it was called that because life produces carbon dioxide.
[Zach]: Now, we today know that that's a waste byproduct of anything that uses oxygen. [Zach]: But to them, they're like, oh, this is like something life does. [Zach]: This is something better, even though it kills life. [Zach]: Like you can put a mouse in carbon dioxide and kill it, which they did. [Zach]: That was this idea. [Zach]: And so they believed that, again, based on this idea that it's kind of like [Zach]: rotting, that... [Zach]: Maybe the problem is that you have too much carbon dioxide, too much fixed air from [Zach]: animals.
[Zach]: And since plants cure scurvy, maybe you need this byproduct of plants [Zach]: and of fermentation. [Zach]: And they thought, well, if plants cure scurvy, maybe we can distill the essence of [Zach]: plants, this byproduct, this fixed air from plants, and it will reverse that. [Zach]: So that's very interesting. [Zach]: And to quote one scientist from 1793, so this is super late in the era of the [Zach]: scurvy explorations.
[Zach]: One scientist said, well, the cure is certainly and solely to be obtained from the [Zach]: fresh food and drink because they contain the animal and vegetable principles, [Zach]: which is like their inherent essence, in the greatest quantity and perfection. [Zach]: And this led to this idea that they're like, well, how do we distill those essences [Zach]: out so we don't need to feed them fresh food and drink because we can't keep those [Zach]: on ships? [Zach]: And this led to the biggest cure that was used for almost 50 years, malt wort,
[Zach]: W-O-R-T. And so wort, malt, sorry, is partially for sprouted barley. [Zach]: It's what beer is ultimately made from. [Zach]: And wort is the liquid when you boil that stuff and then feed it to the yeast, [Zach]: basically. [Zach]: And so what they did is they would ferment the barley, dry it out, crush it up. [Zach]: And they're like, great, this is like plant essence. [Zach]: This is basically plant powder that we should be able to grind up and feed to [Zach]: sailors. [Zach]: And now we don't need lemons and limes. [Zach]: We don't need another cure.
[Zach]: And you might think, well, didn't they notice it didn't work? [Zach]: The thing was, there were a couple of shady experiments by a couple of scientists [Zach]: who said, no, no, no, ours works. [Zach]: They are, we have no idea why. [Zach]: whether they fraudulently created the data or whatever, but they did publish saying [Zach]: it worked. [Zach]: And so for, like I say, almost 50 years, this was literally the core part of scurvy [Zach]: treatment and prevention in the British Navy. [Zach]: And that's in part because it had a big political push.
[Zach]: There was the scientist who had [Zach]: championed it, was the head of the Navy hurt and sick board. [Zach]: So he was like the Navy scientist. [Zach]: So he was able to be like, nope, this is what we're doing. [Zach]: This is your cure. [Zach]: So that brings us to the end of theories. [Zach]: There were more theories, but these are the big ones. [Zach]: So just to go back, that's kind of the humors, this whole salt idea that was kind [Zach]: of tied to the humors, and then this gaseous theory and the chemical acid base [Zach]: theory. [Zach]: And eventually they said, you know what?
[Zach]: maybe we should just see what works, which sounds so obvious. [Zach]: But at the same time, this was an era where people, where it was felt that [Zach]: everybody's body was so different that you couldn't rely on a single cure. [Zach]: But eventually somebody just said, look, come on, let's just try. [Zach]: Let's try something. [Zach]: And the name in this, so if you ever look up scurvy, [Zach]: the name you will see is a guy named James Lind, because he was the push for [Zach]: improved hygiene on ships and ultimately improved diet.
[Zach]: And he ultimately championed citrus, specifically lemons and limes, as the cure for [Zach]: scurvy. [Zach]: And he performed what is considered the very first clinical trial, which is not [Zach]: true because there's one recorded in the book of Daniel in the Old Testament, but [Zach]: the first modern clinical trial, where basically he just put a bunch of cures on a [Zach]: ship and saw what worked. [Zach]: Basically, his quote, and I love it, was, it is not probable that a remedy for the [Zach]: scurvy will ever be discovered from a preconceived hypothesis or by speculative men
[Zach]: in the closet, which I think meant something different then than it does today. [Zach]: I mean, he's still right either way, but I assume it did not mean that. [Arthur]: Those damn speculating queers. [Zach]: Right? [Zach]: If only they'd come out. [Arthur]: Always thinking about scurvy. [Arthur]: If you just were out of the closet, you'd be good. [Zach]: Yeah, that's it. [Zach]: And so this point really begins the transition from medicine as basically an [Zach]: academic science to a practical science. [Zach]: And this came into the 19th century where kind of capital M medicine, as we think
[Zach]: about it today, began to develop. [Zach]: And so his trial started in 1741 on a ship called the Salisbury, the HMS Salisbury. [Zach]: And he fed different sailors either vinegar. [Zach]: It says sulfuric acid. [Zach]: I assume it was diluted sulfuric acid because that would be wild otherwise. [Zach]: Seawater, cider, or citrus fruit. [Zach]: And unsurprisingly, the only thing that worked were lemons. [Zach]: And there's this kind of popular narrative that, oh, this finally demonstrated that
[Zach]: lemons work. [Zach]: But no, they knew. [Zach]: They'd known for 150 years plus at that point that lemons worked. [Zach]: They were just trying to find something cheaper and simpler. [Sage]: Lemons were a pain in the ass. [Zach]: Exactly, right? [Zach]: But at the same time, it effectively completely disproved [Zach]: this salt idea, and this acid-base idea. [Zach]: And at the same time, despite what he said, James Lind didn't fully believe it was [Zach]: only diet-related, but diet was the easiest thing to test. [Zach]: What's funny is that this had the opposite effect, where this malt wort I was
[Zach]: talking about, that was the point where they were like, oh, great, well, nothing [Zach]: works. [Zach]: Let's start using this malt wort that I talked about. [Zach]: And that really cemented its place until the 1790s. [Zach]: So as I say, for 50 years. [Zach]: So another kind of experiment happened 20 years later where a guy was [Zach]: circumnavigating the world. [Zach]: He discovered that coconuts have a little bit of vitamin C. [Zach]: I mean, he didn't know that's what it was. [Zach]: And so he stocked up on coconuts, which is even less practical than lemons and [Zach]: limes, but it did prevent scurvy.
[Zach]: And so this kind of confirmed once and for all that you could just feed sailors a [Zach]: single thing, in this case, coconut. [Zach]: It's delicious. [Zach]: And it will prevent scurvy. [Zach]: So that is the point at which the Navy realized that, OK, what we are looking for [Zach]: is a dietary supplement only. [Zach]: A couple of years later, another circumnavigation of the globe was tried. [Zach]: And it proved that sauerkraut was ineffective. [Zach]: Now, cabbage has a little bit of vitamin C, but again, the fermentation process
[Zach]: kills it off. [Zach]: And it also demonstrated that limes were effective as well as lemons. [Zach]: But this malt wort wasn't tested because that was taken for granted to be [Zach]: effective, which is a bit silly, but that's the nature of the world. [Arthur]: It's very off topic, but there was a similar thing. [Arthur]: A... [Arthur]: A widow put out one time a 10,000 franc prize, which would have been a million [Arthur]: dollars or whatever, for people that could get in contact with the aliens that [Arthur]: lived on either Mercury or Venus or Jupiter or Saturn, but not Mars, because that
[Arthur]: would be too easy. [Arthur]: Just weird things people take for granted. [Arthur]: Like, the Martians are too easy to get in touch with. [Arthur]: We've got to talk to the other aliens. [Zach]: Yeah, isn't that bonkers? [Zach]: I mean, Deepak Chopra has offered a million dollars to say, if you can prove that [Zach]: consciousness originates in the brain, but you cannot use any neuroanatomy to prove [Zach]: it. [Sage]: That's when you fucking prove it. [Zach]: Yeah, right? [Zach]: Like, he knows he will be proven wrong, and that's why he's like, okay, you can [Zach]: prove it, but don't give me any evidence, and then I will reject whatever you
[Zach]: attempt to do. [SPEAKER_07]: Confirmation bias. [Zach]: Yes. [Zach]: That is a huge grape. [Zach]: Sorry, I just looked over in the chat. [Zach]: Oh, man, I feel like some grapes, which do have vitamin C, so they're on topic. [SPEAKER_07]: Yes. [Zach]: I didn't know the [SPEAKER_07]: thing about coconuts. [Zach]: Yeah, isn't that wild? [Zach]: I didn't know it either until I started researching this. [Zach]: And so then that wraps around to the very end of this story, which is James Cook, [Zach]: famous for being European and first seeing, you know, a bunch of Pacific Islands,
[Zach]: New Zealand and Australia. [Zach]: He obviously didn't discover them. [Zach]: He just Britishized them. [Zach]: And so he did three voyages. [Zach]: The first one demonstrated that fresh food would prevent scurvy. [Zach]: Not helpful at all. [Zach]: Like he kind of hopped from port to port, but that's not useful. [Zach]: His second two trips proved that maltwort was completely ineffective. [Zach]: The problem was the people who were championing it were still in power. [Zach]: And so it was only in the 1790s when Dr. McBride, who is the one who's championing
[Zach]: this, died and he was replaced. [Zach]: One of the sailors, the captain of the circumnavigation of the globe that [Zach]: demonstrated that limes were effective, got into power. [Zach]: And so what he did was ration lemon juice to every sailor, 20 milliliters, two [Zach]: thirds of an ounce, in the West Indies. [Zach]: Now, if you remember from earlier, the West Indies were losing more sailors to [Zach]: scurvy than anything else. [Zach]: Scurvy just disappeared in the West Indies. [Zach]: And that was the point that the Navy went, okay, fine.
[Zach]: we will start rationing lemon juice to everybody. [SPEAKER_02]: You know the old song? [SPEAKER_02]: Lemon tree, the flower is very nice, but the fruit of that tree is impossible to [SPEAKER_02]: eat. [SPEAKER_02]: Well, not impossible, but not great. [SPEAKER_02]: Malic acid and citric acid in the lemon, pretty tart. [SPEAKER_02]: And that takes us back to sailors. [SPEAKER_02]: One of the scourges of long ocean voyages was a disease called scurvy.
[SPEAKER_02]: And it turns out that the sailors who got lemons and oranges were the ones who were [SPEAKER_02]: eventually spared of scurvy. [SPEAKER_02]: Of course, Lynn didn't know what the active ingredient in there was. [SPEAKER_02]: That came much, much later. [SPEAKER_02]: Today we know what it is. [SPEAKER_02]: It is vitamin C. [SPEAKER_02]: Vitamin C was finally isolated in 1932 by the Hungarian scientist Albert St. [SPEAKER_02]: Gerdy and hid it from paprika because paprika has a very high concentration of [SPEAKER_02]: vitamin C. Anyway, Lind thought that perhaps the reason that lemons and oranges
[SPEAKER_02]: were protective against curvy was because they were acidic. [SPEAKER_02]: And it turned out that there were other fruits that were acidic that were much more [SPEAKER_02]: readily available to the British than lemons, limes. [SPEAKER_02]: Well, it turned out that lime did not work quite as well as the lemons in [SPEAKER_02]: preventing scurvy. [SPEAKER_02]: Because amazingly, that has only about half the vitamin C content that lemons have. [SPEAKER_02]: So they switched back to lemons, but in the meantime, British sailors started to be
[SPEAKER_02]: called limeys because they were eating lime. [SPEAKER_02]: Well anyway, finally in the 1930s, as I said, vitamin C was isolated from paprika [SPEAKER_02]: and it is now available in pill form. [SPEAKER_02]: Today, there are other allegations about vitamin C, what it can and cannot do. [SPEAKER_02]: For example, it's supposed to prevent the common cold. [SPEAKER_02]: The fact is that numerous studies have shown that that just doesn't happen, except [SPEAKER_02]: in some very rare situations where soldiers are exposed to very cold temperatures
[SPEAKER_02]: or marathon runners who are highly stressed. [SPEAKER_02]: When they take vitamin C anywhere from 200 to 1,000 milligrams a day, they have [SPEAKER_02]: somewhat fewer colds. [SPEAKER_02]: But the evidence is not there for taking vitamin C randomly in order to prevent the [SPEAKER_02]: cold. [SPEAKER_02]: And certainly the evidence is not there for lemons having any kind of medicinal [SPEAKER_02]: value in terms of preventing heart disease or any other medical condition. [SPEAKER_02]: But I can tell you that if you just take the lemon and you scrape the peel and you
[SPEAKER_02]: put it into a salad, it will add a lot of zest to the salad. [SPEAKER_02]: Although I don't think lemons will add much zest to your health. [Zach]: He described [Zach]: Every 50 oranges or lemons might be considered a hand to the fleet, insofar as a [Zach]: man would therefore be saved. [Zach]: And, I mean, the rest is history. [Zach]: So they'd often put it in their grog. [Zach]: So they'd mix lemon, rum, and water. [Zach]: Again, I've tried it. [Zach]: It tastes awful. [Zach]: But, I mean, I'd rather that than my teeth falling out and my legs falling off.
[Zach]: Your mouth rotting. [Zach]: Yeah, no, I'm just miserable. [Zach]: So that is the history of scurvy and a brief exploration of how medical science [Zach]: evolved across the early modern period. [Ood]: Yeah, even today looking up some recipes for what to order at the bar to get grog. [Ood]: A lot of them have lemon juice to this day. [Zach]: Yeah, it's wild, hey? [Zach]: I mean, some people put sugar in it now, which makes sense. [Zach]: But then it's just like putting lemonade in rum, which is a weird flavor. [SPEAKER_07]: Yeah, when you mentioned the stuff earlier about the bleeding gums and the
[SPEAKER_07]: toothaches, I was thinking back to myself because I have a ton of dental problems. [Zach]: So it's just awful. [Zach]: And dental health is so important. [Zach]: And there's a big push among physicians for Canada to cover dental care better [Zach]: because oral health is so impactful. [Zach]: Oh, sorry to back up. [Zach]: It was not James Jordan Peterson who got scurvy. [Zach]: It was James Blunt. [Sage]: You're a beautiful guy? [Sage]: You're beautiful. [Zach]: That is my story. [Zach]: That was wild. [Zach]: That was pretty cool.
[Zach]: I think it's neat. [Zach]: I love the evolution. [Zach]: One of my pet peeves is this idea that historical people were stupid. [Zach]: Because they were not. [Zach]: They were just working with humans. [Zach]: I mean, they were as stupid as humans always are. [Zach]: But that's not new. [Leon]: Okay. [Leon]: So, for our Colte Veritatis podcast, he's been... Zach Spratt. [Leon]: DeMerry. [Leon]: Oh, fuck. [Arthur]: Richard Bigley. [Arthur]: Misfit. [Arthur]: I'm the soundboard demon and dude's having fucking mic trouble.
[Sage]: Ood Gallifrey. [Sage]: Ood. [Sage]: Goodbye. [Ood]: Bye. [Ood]: Leon is taking over from this point. [Ood]: They are not only playing us out with their cover of Wagon Wheel, but they will [Ood]: also be doing the after show. [Ood]: Enjoy, and meet Leon in the after show.
[SPEAKER_11]: Heading down south to the land of the pines I'm plumbing my way into North Carolina [SPEAKER_11]: I'm staring up the road and pray to God I see headlights I made it down the coast [SPEAKER_11]: in 17 hours Picking me a bouquet of dogwood flowers And I'm hoping for Raleigh I [SPEAKER_11]: can see my baby tonight [SPEAKER_11]: So rock me, mama, like a wagon wheel Rock me, mama, any way you feel
[SPEAKER_11]: Hey, mama, rock me Rock me, mama, like the wind and the rain [SPEAKER_11]: Rock me, mama, like a southbound train Hey, mama, rock me
[SPEAKER_11]: Running from the cold up in New England I was born to be a fiddler in an old time [SPEAKER_11]: string band My baby plays guitar, I pick a banjo now [SPEAKER_11]: Oh, North Country winters keep a getting me down. [SPEAKER_11]: Lost my money playing poker, so I had to leave down. [SPEAKER_11]: But I ain't turning back to living that old life no more. [SPEAKER_11]: So rock me, Mama, like a wagon wheel. [SPEAKER_11]: Rock me, Mama, any way you feel.
[SPEAKER_11]: Hey, Mama, rock me. [SPEAKER_11]: Rock me, mama, like the wind and the rain Rock me, mama, like a southbound train [SPEAKER_11]: Hey, mama, rock me
[SPEAKER_11]: Walking to the south out of Broken Oak Caught a trucker out of Philly Had a nice [SPEAKER_11]: long toke But he's heading west from the Cumberland Gap To Johnson City, Tennessee [SPEAKER_11]: And I gotta get a move on before the sun I hear my baby calling my name And I know [SPEAKER_11]: that she's the only one And if I die in Raleigh At least I will die free So [SPEAKER_11]: rock me mama like a wagon wheel [SPEAKER_11]: Rock me, Mama, any way you feel.
[SPEAKER_11]: Hey, Mama, rock me. [SPEAKER_11]: Rock me, Mama, like the wind and the rain. [SPEAKER_11]: Rock me, Mama, like a southbound train. [SPEAKER_11]: Hey, Mama, rock me. [SPEAKER_11]: Rock me, Mama, like a wagon wheel. [SPEAKER_11]: Rock me, Mama, any way you feel. [SPEAKER_11]: Hey, Mama, rock me. [SPEAKER_11]: Rock me, Mama, like the wind and the rain.
[SPEAKER_11]: Rock me, Mama, like a southbound train. [SPEAKER_11]: Hey, Mama, rock me.
[Leon]: Hello cultists and welcome to the After Show. [Leon]: My name is Leon Filger and I just did something really stupid. [Leon]: I got high on cannabis marijuana. [Leon]: That wasn't the stupid bit, but I did that and that sort of precipitated what [Leon]: happened after it. [Leon]: And then I got distracted and decided I wanted to plant some flowers in the front [Leon]: yard. [Leon]: And I had some seeds that were in wet paper towel in the fridge downstairs. [Leon]: So I went downstairs to the fridge to get the seeds. [Leon]: But whilst I was in the fridge, I spied a bottle of hot sauce, the label of which I
[Leon]: wanted to read. [Leon]: And I picked up the bottle of hot sauce and it was 357 Magnum. [Leon]: That's the name of the sauce. [Leon]: It's pure capsaicin extract. [Leon]: It's like the hottest fucking sauce out there. [Leon]: And then after getting this hot sauce residue on my hand, I went out front to plant [Leon]: the seeds. [Leon]: My contacts were getting kind of dry though because I'm high and that's what [Leon]: happens to my contacts when I get high. [Leon]: So I tried to take my contacts out and the right one came out just fine. [Leon]: but the left one I took out with my left hand that had this pepper extract on it,
[Leon]: and immediately my eye was on fire, and I was completely blinded on the left side. [Leon]: So I staggered back into the house, got into the bathroom, showered my eye out with [Leon]: the hose, and I'm okay now. [Leon]: My eye still fucking hurts, but that's what I did, so don't do that. [Leon]: It's bad. [Leon]: Okay, Leon out.
Join Richard as he does a sequel to his "Real life Vampires" episode. Where we learn the terrifying truth that real people in history have been executed under suspicion from the powerful that they were wolves. Also,...
We needed a lighter episode. So lets talk about ten of the dumbest cryptids Ood and sage could research. Today, on Ovpod, get your Dong Wrangled,learn how to avoid mountain whales, meet the crying ballsack cryptid,...
An unavoidable follow-up to our poop episode, here, Arthur guides us through a river of PISS. What high end product is forged in piss? Can Aged urine cure insomnia? How do mice pee? Does a kidney stone gather moss? All...
Remember, if a loophole in a rule exists, it was put there to gain leads one second at a time. Formula One is a world wide, single seat, engineering arms race to build the highest performing racecars on earth. Hear a...
In Ages past, in the long long ago, humanity used to believe in cannibalistic demon men that preyed on the bodies of men. Too bad things haven't changed very much. Join Richard Bigly has he leads the ovpod crew through...