Case # 159: Logical Fallacies Classification: [Skepticism] "Logical Fallacy" is a fancy term for "bad argument". On this episode, Leon will take you through some basic logical fallacies, how to spot them, and just what makes those arguments illogical -Sponsored by- Our Patrons at http://www.patreon.com/ovpod https://www.ovpod.ca/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[Bigly]: And use my phallus logically. [Bigly]: Goodbye. [Arthur]: Logical phalluses. [Intro]: Warning, this podcast contains violence, sexuality, gore, and other horrible and [Intro]: disturbing things. [Intro]: Listener discretion is advised. [Intro]: Also, the hosts of this venture are ignorant dipshits, so please do not take [Intro]: anything they say as fact. [Intro]: And enjoy the show.
[Intro]: Now, are you sitting comfortably? [Intro]: Good. [Intro]: Then we'll begin. [Intro]: Today we had 15 homicides and 63 violent crimes, as if that's the way it's supposed [Intro]: to be. [Intro]: It is our basic human right to be fucked up! [Intro]: A second plane now has crashed into the other tower of the World Trade Center. [Intro]: Putting chemicals in the water, they turned the friggin' frogs! [Intro]: The defendant shall be incarcerated for the rest of her natural life with no [Intro]: possibility of parole. [Intro]: You are not machines! [Intro]: You are not cattle! [Intro]: You are men! [Intro]: We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began [Intro]: to take hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold.
[Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold [Leon]: Hello, occultists, and welcome back to Occulte Veritatis podcast. [Leon]: My name is Leon Filger, and joining me remotely, we have... [Sage]: Thanks, Murray! [Bigly]: Adam Fowler. [Leon]: Ooh, Gallifrey. [Bigly]: Richard Bigley. [Arthur]: And I'm the soundboard demon. [Arthur]: We don't do the guest as Adam Fowler anymore. [Arthur]: He's just apparently integrated well enough into the podcast.
[Intro]: Yeah, I'm just crashing this one. [Leon]: Logical fallacies are arguments containing logical gaps that are used in everything [Leon]: from political debates to marital disputes and are intended to invalidate sensible [Leon]: arguments. [Leon]: In today's episode, I'm going to cover some of my favorite logical fallacies and [Leon]: teach you how to spot them and call them out. [Leon]: But first, it's time for some poison. [Leon]: So, what's your poison?
Oh, my God. [Ood]: Just as a precursor to this episode and some upcoming episodes, if you listen to [Ood]: the track titled Alcoholic, you'll learn that Leon has stopped drinking. [Ood]: But we often shoot episodes out of order and release them out of order. [Ood]: So for the next few episodes, Leon will be participating in some alcoholic What's [Ood]: Your Poisons. [Ood]: Some of these were shot over four months ago. [Ood]: So just to clear up any confusion that might cause.
[Ood]: So the, the poison we [Leon]: have today is a Lindemann's bin 99, uh, 2018 Pinot Noir. [Leon]: The bottle reads Lindemann's bin 99 Pinot Noir has been brought to life through, [Leon]: uh, it's kind of boring. [Leon]: Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. [Leon]: I want to hear it. [Leon]: Pinot Noir. [Leon]: That's why you want, you want to hear it? [Sage]: Yeah. [Leon]: Okay. [Leon]: Fuck. [Leon]: Hold on. [Leon]: It's small writing. [Leon]: has been brought to life through artist David Bromley's eyes. [Leon]: His interpretation of a walk through the forest at dusk has been coupled with the [Leon]: elegant flavors of Pinot Noir to bring you this contemporary, approachable style of
[Leon]: wine which goes perfectly with food, family, and friends. [Bigly]: No one else goes perfectly with food, family, and friends. [Bigly]: What's that? [Bigly]: For just $6.66, you can join Team Richard on the Patreon and get some [Bigly]: pretty awesome shit for that each month. [Sage]: No one wants to join you. [Sage]: They want to join me. [Bigly]: It's $6.66. [Bigly]: Like, that's less than the piece of a plywood, you know, or a bag of gasoline. [Leon]: And if you join the Leon Filger Fan Club, also for $6.66 a month, you're going to
[Leon]: get a care package from me in a nice envelope that includes a condom. [Leon]: Because stay safe. [Bigly]: I don't think it's safe when it's already been used. [Bigly]: Ew. [Leon]: It's new. [Leon]: It's a new condom. [Leon]: It's got a clever saying on it. [Leon]: It's a new condom. [Leon]: What if they want a used one? [Leon]: No. [Leon]: Will you provide that? [Leon]: Go back to the cupcake episode and review that. [Ood]: And, you know, if you get it, post it on the social medias and shit. [Ood]: We'll share it. [Ood]: You can see what being part of Team Ood might be like, because I'm in the lead
[Ood]: right now. [Ood]: That fuck? [Ood]: I have the most cult members under my wings. [Ood]: You know, my faction may take over the whole cult eventually. [Ood]: I'm just saying we're grown quick and we're motivated. [Arthur]: Don't like that. [Arthur]: Do you guys want to hear the standings as they are now? [Arthur]: Yeah, I guess. [Arthur]: Ood is in top, followed by Sage and Leon, who are tied for second, and [Arthur]: then Richard. [Bigly]: That's right. [Bigly]: You can, for less than a sheet of plywood, you can join my team.
[Bigly]: We're accepting members. [Bigly]: Just saying. [Ood]: For less than a shopping bag full of gasoline, you can join our Patreon. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: Help support us, keep us editorially independent and just doing crazy shit, you [Bigly]: know? [Ood]: We just built a computer, and I think the next stage might be updating our mics or [Ood]: going for a road trip. [Ood]: Like, we got some plans. [Adam]: Wait, just going for a road trip or touring? Both. [Leon]: No, we're doing, like, on-location episodes in various exciting places.
[Leon]: Ah. [Leon]: Like a creepy old church in a graveyard. [Leon]: Yeah, it's going to be good. [Leon]: But we need Patreon dollars to make it happen. [Adam]: Of course. [Ood]: Yep, we po. [Ood]: Dream scenario, if we get the funds, we have plans to tour a bunch of Canada and do [Ood]: a bunch of on-location stuff. [Ood]: We want to do a Gold Rush episode in BC because there's a bunch of Gold Rush stuff [Ood]: over there. [Ood]: Who knows what we might find along the way. [Arthur]: Fun fact, the cost of gas in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan on the 15th of the 5th month
[Arthur]: for a shopping bag full of gas would actually be almost exactly $10, $1.25 today. [Arthur]: Wow. [Ood]: Oh man, I was right. [Ood]: Accidentally. [Ood]: I love when that happens. [Leon]: Okay, so I got to admit I'm a little bit disappointed by this particular Pinot [Leon]: Noir. [Leon]: I've got two Pinot Noirs on my desk. [Leon]: One is open that we're drinking and one I'm going to save for later. [Leon]: This is not as bright on the tongue as I expected a Pinot Noir to be. [Leon]: I mean, it's still an eminently drinkable wine, which is why I often turn to it. [Leon]: But this particular vintage isn't really what I was hoping for.
[Leon]: So I'm going to give it... [Leon]: The last person who used the toilet left a little bit of a shit streak, so you got [Leon]: to clean up the toilet before you take your own shit. [Bigly]: Yeah, it's not a very strong flavor. [Bigly]: It's, I don't know, kind of like that when you go get the Diet Coke from the [Bigly]: McDonald's and they've kind of like watered it down. [Bigly]: It tastes very kind of watery to me. [Sage]: It tastes pretty like juice with a little bit of that wininess. [Sage]: I don't usually go for a Pinot Noir first, but I do like a Pinot Noir, but this one
[Sage]: is just kind of like whatever. [Sage]: So I'd give it like a five and a half. [Ood]: I've had this problem every time I drink wine. [Ood]: Like, old wine tastes very similar to me, and like... [Ood]: I've talked about the damage to my tongue I got as a kid. [Ood]: I don't have much of my taste left. [Ood]: It tastes like a red wine to me. [Ood]: It has alcohol in it. [Ood]: I like that. [Ood]: So I'm going to give this a 5 out of 10. [Ood]: It's liquid and it has alcohol in it and I'm enjoying that. [Adam]: And I'm at a very far distance so I'm not drinking any wine.
[Adam]: Nor would you want me to podcast after drinking. That's what you think. [Sage]: Yeah, stick around until my episode and you'll see how fun it is. [Leon]: Yeah, I'm not too drunk yet. [Leon]: We're three episodes into the recordings today. [Leon]: And speaking of third episode, Ana, are we ready to go? [SPEAKER_13]: Well, first, we don't have house guests. [SPEAKER_13]: Our earthquake supplies. [SPEAKER_13]: We have a two-man, two-day kit. [SPEAKER_13]: So? [SPEAKER_13]: So if there is an earthquake and the three of us are trapped here, we could be out [SPEAKER_13]: of food by tomorrow afternoon.
[SPEAKER_13]: I'm sorry. [SPEAKER_13]: Are you suggesting that if we let Penny stay, we might succumb to cannibalism? [SPEAKER_13]: No one ever thinks it'll happen until it does. [SPEAKER_13]: Penny, if you promise not to chew the flesh [SPEAKER_32]: off our bones while we sleep, you can stay. [SPEAKER_32]: What? [SPEAKER_13]: He's engaging in reductio ad absurdum. [SPEAKER_13]: It's the logical fallacy of extending someone's argument to ridiculous proportions [SPEAKER_13]: and then criticizing the result, and I do not appreciate it. [Leon]: Leon's favorite logical fallacies episode.
[Leon]: I've been waiting to do this one for a long time, so I'm super excited that I [Leon]: finally got it done. [Leon]: So I was a member of the debate and elocution society back in high school and often [Leon]: came across logical fallacies during formal debates. [Leon]: Now, some logical fallacies like correlation versus causation and gaslighting are [Leon]: easy to spot, while other logical fallacies like straw man and red herring can be a [Leon]: bit trickier to call out. [Leon]: Now this is far from an exhaustive list, but these are the logical fallacies I [Leon]: encounter most frequently, particularly when arguing in the comments section on
[Leon]: Facebook. [Leon]: So let's begin with gaslighting. [Leon]: Now you won't find gaslighting on many lists of traditional logical fallacies, but [Leon]: I see it used in debate all the time, and it can be a powerful tool for tricking [Leon]: your opponent or domestic partner into using other logical fallacies that results [Leon]: in a really poor quality argument and problems in the relationship not getting [Leon]: solved. [Leon]: So the way gaslighting got its name is this. [Leon]: Back in the day when homes were heated with gaslights, there was this dude who [Leon]: lived with his wife and they had gaslights in their home. [Leon]: And one day he decided that he was using too much gas and it was too expensive, so
[Leon]: he turned down the lights a little bit. [Leon]: And his wife said, it got dimmer in here, what's up with that? [Leon]: And he was like, no it didn't, it's all in your head, the gas is still coming out [Leon]: at the same rate. [Leon]: And then the next day he turned down the gas a little bit more and she's like, no, [Leon]: really, I'm sure it's getting darker in here. [Leon]: And he's like, no, you're fucking crazy. [Leon]: The gas is still flowing at the same rate. [Leon]: And the next day he turned it down a little more and it was getting pretty fucking [Leon]: dim in their place. [Leon]: And she's like, okay, no, this is like some serious bullshit. [Leon]: The lights are getting dimmer. [Leon]: And he's like, no, you are actually crazy. [Leon]: The lights are not getting dimmer. [Leon]: The gas is still flowing.
[Leon]: And that's how gaslighting started. [Leon]: So gaslighting is when you try to get your opponent to believe something, even [Leon]: though you know it's not to be true. [Leon]: And it's a psychological bullshit technique that's used in a lot of abusive [Leon]: relationships. [Leon]: I've used it and had it used against me, as I'm sure a lot of us have. [Leon]: Don't gaslight is shitty. [Sage]: It's from a movie. [Adam]: Yeah, I think play originally. [Adam]: I've just I wanted to look that up. [Adam]: Yeah. [Adam]: 1938 was when the play came out called Gaslight. [Leon]: I'm so fucking glad you were on top of that. [Leon]: Thank you. [Adam]: well-reviewed, and it's interesting that something that far ago far distant has
[Adam]: given us a term that really I only became aware of ten years ago. [SPEAKER_29]: If I could only get inside that brain of yours and understand what makes you do [SPEAKER_29]: these crazy, twisted things. [SPEAKER_11]: Gregory, are you trying to tell me I'm insane? [SPEAKER_29]: It's what I'm trying not to tell myself. [SPEAKER_11]: But that's what you think, isn't it? [SPEAKER_11]: That's what you've been hinting and suggesting for months now, ever since [SPEAKER_29]: Since what? [SPEAKER_11]: Since the day I lost your brooch. [SPEAKER_11]: Yes, that's when it all began.
[SPEAKER_11]: No, no. [SPEAKER_11]: No, it began before that. [SPEAKER_11]: The first day when I found that letter. [SPEAKER_29]: What letter? [SPEAKER_11]: The one I found among the music. [SPEAKER_11]: From that man called Bowery. [SPEAKER_11]: Sergius Bowery, yes. [SPEAKER_11]: I remember. [SPEAKER_29]: Yes, you're right. [SPEAKER_29]: That's when it began. [SPEAKER_11]: Yes. [SPEAKER_29]: I can see you still standing there and saying, look, look at this letter and
[SPEAKER_29]: staring at nothing. [SPEAKER_11]: What? [SPEAKER_29]: You had nothing in your hand. [SPEAKER_11]: What? [SPEAKER_29]: I was staggered. [SPEAKER_29]: But I didn't know then how much reason I had to be. [SPEAKER_29]: I don't know. [SPEAKER_29]: What reason? [SPEAKER_29]: I didn't know then about your mother. [SPEAKER_11]: What about my mother? [SPEAKER_29]: Your mother was mad. [SPEAKER_29]: She died in an asylum when you were a year old. [SPEAKER_11]: That's not true. [SPEAKER_29]: I've been making inquiries about Alice Alquist's sister.
[SPEAKER_29]: I've talked to the doctor who attended her. [SPEAKER_29]: Would you like to see him? [SPEAKER_02]: No. [SPEAKER_29]: He described her symptoms to me. [SPEAKER_29]: Do you like to hear them? [SPEAKER_29]: It began with her imagining things, that she heard noises, footsteps, voices. [SPEAKER_29]: And then the voices began to speak to her. [SPEAKER_29]: And in the end, she died in an asylum with no brain at all. [SPEAKER_29]: No, please. [SPEAKER_18]: Oh, no, no. [SPEAKER_29]: Now perhaps you will understand a lot of things about yourself and me. [SPEAKER_29]: Now perhaps you will understand why I cannot let you meet people.
[Leon]: Next up, we have the straw man fallacy. [Leon]: So this fallacy occurs when your opponent oversimplifies your argument or [Leon]: misrepresents it altogether, often using hyperbole, and this is an important bit, [Leon]: which makes your argument easier to refute. [Leon]: Now, this is an elementary logical fallacy, and I faced it all the time during [Leon]: debate competitions in high school. [Leon]: Straw Man comes up in a lot of abortion debates, where the anti-abortion debater [Leon]: equates a pro-choice stance to murder. [Leon]: Now obviously no one on either side wants to kill babies, and the argument doesn't [Leon]: have anything to do with killing actual babies.
[Leon]: But in the context of abortion debates, Straw Man is rarely effective, but often [Leon]: used, likely because the anti-abortion crowd don't really have a leg to stand on. [Leon]: Another example comes from a business meeting I once attended while working at a [Leon]: funeral home more than a decade ago. [Leon]: It was suggested that the proceeds from the sales of winter wreaths be used to fund [Leon]: the staff Christmas party. [Leon]: Another employee piped up with, well, if we give up the commissions on all our [Leon]: sales, we'll go broke. [Leon]: But the person making the suggestion about winter wreaths wasn't suggesting we give
[Leon]: up commission on all our cemetery products, just the wreaths, which accounted for [Leon]: less than 8% of our total annual sales. [Leon]: Now, in the end, we voted to devote winter wreath proceeds to the Christmas party [Leon]: and the party was a jolly good time. [Leon]: The employee who freaked out about the commissions being lost was later fired for [Leon]: stealing toilet paper. [Leon]: Oops. [SPEAKER_39]: Products you could only imagine before. [SPEAKER_39]: The SS Microwave. [SPEAKER_39]: Ah, my crepes are done.
[SPEAKER_38]: The Doggy Doorman. [SPEAKER_18]: Good evening, Rex. [SPEAKER_18]: And Mobileeer, the chandelier for your car. [SPEAKER_18]: All on. [SPEAKER_38]: I can't believe they invented it. [SPEAKER_38]: Hello, everybody. [SPEAKER_38]: I'm Troy McClure, star of such films as P is for Psycho and The President's Neck is [SPEAKER_38]: Missing. [SPEAKER_38]: But now I'm here to tell you about a remarkable new invention.
[SPEAKER_38]: Until now, this was the only way to get juice from an orange. [SPEAKER_38]: You mean there's a better way? [SPEAKER_38]: But that's all changed, thanks to the juice loosener. [SPEAKER_38]: Let's meet the inventor, Dr. Nick Riviera. [SPEAKER_38]: Hello, toy. [SPEAKER_38]: Hi, everybody. [SPEAKER_18]: Hi, Dr. Nick. [SPEAKER_38]: Troy, would you like a glass of orange juice? [SPEAKER_38]: I sure would. [SPEAKER_38]: But won't we have to pay those outrageous grocery store prices for something the [SPEAKER_38]: farmer probably spit in? [SPEAKER_38]: Not anymore.
[SPEAKER_38]: All thanks to the new juice loosener. [SPEAKER_38]: Doctor, are you sure it's on? [SPEAKER_38]: I can't hear a thing. [SPEAKER_38]: It's whisper quiet. [SPEAKER_38]: You got all that from one bag of oranges? [SPEAKER_38]: That's right. [SPEAKER_38]: Order now and you'll also get Sun and Run, the suntan [SPEAKER_45]: lotion that's also a laxative. [Leon]: Next, we have the fallacies of composition and division. [Leon]: Now with the former, if it's true of the parts, then it's true of the whole.
[Leon]: For example, my favorite hockey team has three really good players, therefore my [Leon]: hockey team is really good. [Leon]: Now with the fallacy of division, if it's true of the whole, then it must be true [Leon]: of the parts. [Leon]: For example, my hockey team is top-rated, which must mean every one of its players [Leon]: are top-rated. [Leon]: Again, a fallacy. [Leon]: Next up is the bandwagon fallacy. [Leon]: Now, politicians love to use this argument to justify making horrible decisions. [Leon]: The bandwagon fallacy occurs when someone uses statistical or even anecdotal [Leon]: opinion data to validate an opinion or position, even if that position is
[Leon]: nonsensical. [Leon]: A good example of this is when a political leader cites a poll showing that the [Leon]: majority of people surveyed dislike COVID restrictions, and so the leader relaxes [Leon]: restrictions. [Leon]: Now, the majority poll do not constitute an expert opinion. [Leon]: Medical professionals all agree that restrictions should be tightened, but what the [Leon]: hell do they know? [Leon]: It's the will of the people that drives most political decisions, even if those [Leon]: decisions have disastrous consequences. [SPEAKER_02]: You know, if you were to follow a busy doctor as he makes his daily round of calls,
[SPEAKER_02]: you'd find yourself having a mighty busy time keeping up with him. [SPEAKER_02]: Time out for many men of medicine usually means just long enough to enjoy a [SPEAKER_02]: cigarette. [SPEAKER_02]: And because they know what a pleasure it is to smoke a mild, good-tasting [SPEAKER_02]: cigarette, they're particular about the brand they choose. [SPEAKER_02]: In a repeated national survey, doctors in all branches of medicine [SPEAKER_02]: Doctors in all parts of the country were asked, what cigarette do you smoke, [SPEAKER_02]: doctor? [SPEAKER_02]: Once again, the brand named most was camel.
[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, according to this repeated nationwide survey, more doctors smoke camels than [SPEAKER_02]: any other cigarette. [SPEAKER_02]: Why not change to camels for the next 30 days and see what a difference it makes in [SPEAKER_02]: your smoking enjoyment. [SPEAKER_02]: See how camels agree with your throat. [SPEAKER_02]: See how mild and good tasting a cigarette can be. [Leon]: Feel free, guys, to jump in with any examples you have of the bandwagon fallacy. [Adam]: I mean, I think democracy in general, I'm not an autocrat, but does run into the
[Adam]: risk of if you put everything to a vote, exactly as you say, you run into running [Adam]: the will of people who may not have an informed opinion. [Bigly]: Yeah, you take out the expertise, you know, you're removing expertise from the [Bigly]: equation. [Bigly]: And, you know, I guess that's one of the issues that we are currently seeing today [Bigly]: with all the discussion around COVID restrictions and 5G chips and vaccines and all [Bigly]: that other shit, you know, with the internet democratizing, I guess, in quotation
[Bigly]: marks, you know, people's ability to communicate, which is, you know, good in [Bigly]: some cases you end up with you know basically you know your your uncle joe having [Bigly]: the same um i guess level of opinion or consideration of opinion as uh you know as [Bigly]: a medical expert who's studied the you know entomology for like ever you know [Leon]: or local realtor cam bird who's a transphobe and an anti-masker and an anti-vaxxer
[Leon]: and a piece of shit uh throwing out his opinion there i think he's also a q anon [Leon]: guy too [Adam]: Here's an example, actually, that's been popping up on Reddit of a bandwagon [Adam]: fallacy that actually did some harm to multiple people. [Adam]: And it's in Poland. [Adam]: There was a series of towns that declared themselves, quote, LGBTQ free. [Adam]: So obviously big homophobes and transphobes. [Adam]: And they did so because of like, well, you know, the voters wanted it and are now [Adam]: reaping the whirlwind, so to speak, because they [Adam]: have been cut off from a lot of EU funding because the EU won't fund places that
[Adam]: are not fitting their human rights record. [Adam]: Oops. [Adam]: And it's a little satisfying. [Ood]: Oh, no, the consequences of their actions. [Adam]: Yeah, exactly. [Leon]: So this brings us neatly to the appeal to authority fallacy. [Leon]: Now, an appeal to authority isn't always fallacious, but can quickly become [Leon]: dangerous if the authority appealed to isn't actually an expert in the applicable [Leon]: field or wasn't actually consulted, which sometimes happens. [Leon]: Now, just because someone is in a position of power, believes something, doesn't [Leon]: necessarily make it so.
[Leon]: So an example of this is citing the opinion of Canada's chief medical health [Leon]: officer on medical assistance in dying. [Leon]: Now, yes, she's an accomplished medical doctor, but her area of specialty is public [Leon]: and population health, not end-of-life care. [Leon]: In this case, you'd be better off consulting a palliative care physician. [Leon]: This relates to the genetic fallacy, which is assuming an argument is wrong based [Leon]: solely on its source. [Ood]: It's like people saying that because an article comes from BuzzFeed, it can't be [Ood]: accurate or it can't be good reporting. [Ood]: Of course, BuzzFeed has done its fair share of tabloid articles and stuff like that
[Ood]: that really aren't concerned with accuracy, but they've done some great reporting [Ood]: in the last few years, and just because it comes from BuzzFeed doesn't mean that [Ood]: it's inherently inaccurate, you know? [Adam]: Yeah, it's the broken clock is right twice a day kind of thing. [Leon]: Exactly. [Leon]: And the genetic fallacy is sort of like the throwing baby out with the bathwater [Leon]: fallacy. [Leon]: I guess you could give it an alternate name, where it's just like assuming that [Leon]: because this person or this source has been wrong in the past, that they'll [Leon]: continue to be wrong in the future. [Leon]: And that, I think, gives them discredit because a lot of folks were wrong very
[Leon]: early on and then became right as they did more research. [Leon]: And so to say a study you did in 1982 was wrong. [Leon]: Well, fuck, you corrected it in 1992. [Leon]: So let's listen to your opinion. [Adam]: And I think this is used a lot by anti-science types to say, well, science is wrong [Adam]: because they changed their minds, which, of course, is the inherent quality of [Adam]: science. [Adam]: And so I know that early on in the pandemic, really early, like February and March, [Adam]: people were talking, oh, well, don't wear masks because there was a thought that [Adam]: this was transmitted a lot more from surfaces like other coronaviruses.
[Adam]: And then they changed their minds pretty abruptly. [Adam]: And people like, well, see that, you know, and it goes, well, no, it's that we [Adam]: started understanding the transmission better. [Leon]: The next logical fallacy is one of my favorites to call bullshit on, and it's the [Leon]: burden of proof fallacy. [SPEAKER_29]: We have a question now for Dr. Frank Turret. [SPEAKER_05]: Yes. [SPEAKER_05]: Your criticism of science is that there is no materialistic explanation of [SPEAKER_05]: morality, but theism makes the truth claim of knowing right from wrong. [SPEAKER_05]: Is it not then the theistic burden of proof to tell us which religion is true and
[SPEAKER_05]: which are false? [SPEAKER_05]: To be a theist is to be atheist to all gods but your own. [SPEAKER_09]: I don't know [SPEAKER_05]: if that's a question. [SPEAKER_05]: What's the question? [SPEAKER_05]: The question is, is it not your burden of proof to tell us which religions are true [SPEAKER_05]: and which are false? [SPEAKER_09]: Well, yeah, I think that's wise to try and figure out which worldview is true and [SPEAKER_09]: which isn't. [SPEAKER_09]: Michael thinks his materialistic worldview is true. [SPEAKER_09]: I don't think it is. [SPEAKER_09]: I think he can't even justify morality. [SPEAKER_09]: He can't justify reason. [SPEAKER_09]: He can't even justify the ability to do science.
[SPEAKER_09]: Again, because if we're molecules in motion, none of those things actually exist, [SPEAKER_09]: or we couldn't do science if we're just molecular machines. [SPEAKER_09]: I think, yes, you ought to give evidence for your worldview. [SPEAKER_09]: That's what I try and do through books. [SPEAKER_09]: And the Bible actually tells us to do that. [SPEAKER_09]: The Bible actually says, always be ready to give an answer. [SPEAKER_09]: Jesus says, love the Lord your God with all your heart, soul, strength, and mind. [SPEAKER_09]: The prophet Isaiah says, come let us reason together. [SPEAKER_09]: Paul says, I'm set in defense of the gospel. [SPEAKER_09]: Paul also says, let's destroy arguments and take every thought captive to Christ. [SPEAKER_09]: So,
[SPEAKER_09]: Contrary to what most people think, Christianity is a worldview built on reason. [SPEAKER_09]: You get evidence that it's true and then you trust in the object of that evidence. [SPEAKER_09]: Christianity is not blind faith. [SPEAKER_09]: Atheism is blind faith. [Leon]: This is the fallacy most often used by religious nutjobs when they argue with [Leon]: atheists. [Leon]: In arguments about unproven or unprovable facts, the burden of proof rests with the [Leon]: claimant, not with the refuter. [Leon]: If a person claims that argument X is true, it is their responsibility to provide
[Leon]: supporting evidence of that assertion. [Leon]: It is invalid to claim that X is true until someone else refutes it. [Leon]: It's also invalid to assert that X is true because it's impossible to prove that X [Leon]: is false. [Leon]: This is the common, I don't understand elementary evolution, so God must have done [Leon]: it argument. [Arthur]: This specifically doesn't apply to this podcast because, as we all know, I truly am [Arthur]: an incorporeal form stuck inside of a soundboard, and nobody can disprove that, [Arthur]: therefore it is true. [SPEAKER_32]: Exactly. [Arthur]: How does a soundboard demon cough with no throat?
[Arthur]: The answer is, shut up. [Adam]: I have no throat, but I must cough. [Leon]: So this leads us nicely into the anecdotal evidence fallacy. [Leon]: Now, in this fallacy, the claimant makes a statement based on personal or even [Leon]: secondhand experience and claims it to be fact. [Leon]: Unfortunately, this fallacy often rears its ugly head in clinical health care [Leon]: settings. [Leon]: An example of this fallacy from my own life is when someone claims that the drug [Leon]: dexedrine was effective at treating their narcolepsy, therefore it will be
[Leon]: effective at treating every case of narcolepsy. [Leon]: Now, in fact, dexedrine isn't even indicated for the treatment of narcolepsy and is [Leon]: rarely effective. [Leon]: In spite of this, the Internet is crawling with stories of people whose narcolepsy [Leon]: was successfully treated with dexedrine, which, by the way, is typically used to [Leon]: treat attention deficit hyperactivity disorder in children and adults. [Leon]: Narcolepsy is an off-label use not recommended by the manufacturer. [Ood]: So they assume because it's worked with a few that it must be some like secret cure [Ood]: for all kind of thing that like we could we could help all these people if they [Ood]: just would start taking this drug kind of thing.
[Bigly]: Well, I mean, in terms of anecdotes, I mean, I certainly would be skeptical of it. [Bigly]: However, if you take enough of those anecdotes, you may be able to establish a [Bigly]: pattern or enough anecdotes could eventually equate to some sort of data under the [Bigly]: right conditions. [Leon]: Yeah, it's definitely true that enough anecdotes become a statistic. [Adam]: Certainly. [Adam]: And I think it gets even weirder when people try to try to use a especially out [Adam]: there anecdote that counteracts the data that you really run into problems.
[Adam]: And I mean, I'm sure you all know the pyramid of data where class five evidence is [Adam]: expert opinion and then case studies and case series. [Adam]: And really, you get enough anecdotes. [Adam]: That's enough case studies. [Adam]: And it turns into a case series. [Adam]: which, of course, then can transfer into, you know, guiding studies, which is often [Adam]: how that works. [Arthur]: Honest question, because you said, I'm sure you all know, and then described a [Arthur]: thing I had never heard in my life. [Arthur]: Was that, I'm sure you all know, facetious, or was it supposed to be? [Adam]: Well, no, it was, you guys talk about case studies and things, or sorry, you talk
[Adam]: about logical fallacies, and I don't want to seem condescending by explaining stuff [Adam]: to people what they already know. [Adam]: But basically, it's increasingly, this is only, it works in the medical model, as [Adam]: my psychologist partner has reminded me. [Adam]: But basically, you have expert opinion at the very bottom, and that's the worst, [Adam]: quote unquote. [Adam]: Then you have case studies. [Adam]: Then you have what are called case control studies, where you have two branches, [Adam]: the control not getting a medically active treatment. [Adam]: And then you get increasingly more randomized stuff.
[Adam]: And classically, the RCT is at the top, the randomized control trial, which is [Adam]: exactly, you know, half the people get a placebo, half the people get an active [Adam]: treatment, they're randomized, nobody involved in the trial knows which is which. [Leon]: That would be the double blind study, right? [Adam]: The double blind, exactly. [Leon]: The circular reasoning fallacy is one in which the claimant defends the claim by [Leon]: using the conclusion as one of the premises to support the conclusion. [Leon]: So the best example of this is that God exists because it says so in the Bible, and [Leon]: the Bible is the word of God.
[Ood]: I mean, hell, this has been brought up again and again as a response to it, but [Ood]: that proves that Spider-Man comics are proof of Spider-Man existing because they're [Ood]: self-referential and stuff like that. [SPEAKER_16]: For the last time, I'm pretty sure what's killing the crops is this Brondo stuff. [SPEAKER_45]: Brondo's got what plants crave. [SPEAKER_45]: It's got electrolytes. [SPEAKER_00]: So wait a minute. [SPEAKER_00]: What you're saying is that you want us to put water on the crops? [SPEAKER_16]: Yes. [SPEAKER_00]: Water. [SPEAKER_16]: Like out the toilet? [SPEAKER_16]: Well, I mean, it doesn't have to be out of the toilet, but yeah, that's the idea.
[SPEAKER_45]: But Brondo's got what plants crave. [SPEAKER_00]: It's got electrolytes. [SPEAKER_16]: Okay, look. [SPEAKER_16]: The plants aren't growing, so I'm pretty sure that the Brondo's not working. [SPEAKER_16]: Now, I'm no botanist, but I do know that if you put water on plants, they grow. [SPEAKER_42]: Well, I've never seen no plants grow out of no toilet. [SPEAKER_42]: Hey, that's good. [SPEAKER_42]: You sure you ain't the smartest guy in the world? [SPEAKER_42]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_16]: Okay, look, you want to solve this problem. [SPEAKER_16]: I want to get my pardon, so why don't we just try it, okay? [SPEAKER_16]: And not worry about what plants crave. [SPEAKER_16]: Brondo's got what plants crave.
[SPEAKER_16]: God. [SPEAKER_16]: Yeah, it's got electrolytes. [SPEAKER_16]: What are electrolytes? [SPEAKER_16]: Do you even know? [SPEAKER_16]: It's what they use to make Brando. [SPEAKER_16]: Yeah, but why did they use them to make Brando? [SPEAKER_05]: Because Brando's got electrolytes. [SPEAKER_43]: After several hours, Joe finally gave up on logic and reason and simply told the [SPEAKER_43]: cabinet that he could talk to plants and that they wanted water. [Leon]: So another sin often committed by politicians when introducing debate on
[Leon]: legislation is the fallacy of false dilemma. [Leon]: And this annoys the fuck out of me, and the Sask Party does this all the goddamn [Leon]: time, and it's just frustrating as fuck. [Leon]: So in this fallacy, only two solutions or outcomes are given to a particular [Leon]: problem, when in fact multiple solutions or outcomes exist. [Leon]: So a recent example of this is when the updated medical assistance in dying [Leon]: legislation was being debated in the Canadian Parliament. [Leon]: Some special interest groups tried, unsuccessfully, to argue that the new [Leon]: legislation would result in disabled people being put to death against their will,
[Leon]: and that under the current legislation, MAID wasn't actually accessible to all who [Leon]: qualified for it. [Leon]: The truth, of course, was in the middle. [Leon]: The new legislation was passed, and it's fair and balanced. [Leon]: This is an example of a case of the slippery slope fallacy, an idea in which option [Leon]: A will ultimately lead to option C without any supporting evidence being provided. [Leon]: Now, in Canada, we now have fair, balanced, and compassionate maid policy, and [Leon]: seniors are not being executed by death panels, as the Catholic lobby warned us [Leon]: about. [Adam]: You know, the whole slippery slope argument is interesting because now I'm stepping
[Adam]: away from the MAID conversation to broader because what I find is that it can also [Adam]: be overused where people will say, if X, then I worry this will be the outcome. [Adam]: And everybody is then like, well, at slippery slope, we can't worry about potential [Adam]: outcomes, which, of course, isn't how it's supposed to be used. [Adam]: But it's definitely something I've run into on the opposite side of that. [Bigly]: Well, and speaking like I guess in a legal context, slippery slope fallacy is – I [Bigly]: mean it is a fallacy.
[Bigly]: But at the time, there are certain contexts such as in case law where you do need [Bigly]: to take that under consideration where if a judge rules one way on a particular [Bigly]: case – [Bigly]: And then it gets cited as case law in an argument on some other case and gets [Bigly]: accepted. [Bigly]: And then the merits on that case become case law, which is a future case down the [Bigly]: road. [Bigly]: And you end up with a complex system of law around specific ideas because of a
[Bigly]: judge ruling in one way versus another, like I said, as citing case law. [Bigly]: It is still something that does happen and should be considered, though. [Arthur]: that's exactly what adam was saying though it's like that's not slippery slope like [Arthur]: to say that oh like cases set precedent and from there you can like we have to be [Arthur]: careful setting precedent i think that is the exact not opposite of slippery slope [Arthur]: but slippery slope is saying well i think these two things are going to be [Arthur]: connected for no reason [Adam]: the classic gay marriage leading to marrying good dogs
[Sage]: Or giving women birth control will lead to no babies ever. [Adam]: Yeah. [Arthur]: But there's an obvious connection to, well, this is how the legal system works and [Arthur]: setting precedent is a thing. [Arthur]: It's like that isn't actually slippery slope, but people would call it that. [SPEAKER_37]: When your cable goes out, you get stressed. [SPEAKER_37]: When you get stressed, you need to get away. [SPEAKER_37]: When you need to get away, you go for something exotic. [SPEAKER_37]: When you go for something exotic, you get bitten by something exotic. [SPEAKER_37]: When you get bitten by something exotic, things swell up.
[SPEAKER_37]: When things swell up, you can't go home. [SPEAKER_37]: And when you can't go home, you become a local fisherman they call Big Fatty Face. [SPEAKER_37]: Don't become a local fisherman they call Big Fatty Face. [SPEAKER_37]: Get rid of cable and upgrade to DirecTV. [Leon]: Up next is another annoying one. [Leon]: Actually, these are all fucking annoying. [Leon]: I don't know why this is an annoying one. [Leon]: Logical fallacies annoy the shit out of me. [Leon]: Like, I've been debating semi-professionally since I was 16 years old, and fuck, do [Leon]: people ever piss me off when they argue on Facebook? [Leon]: So this one is the personal incredulity fallacy, and I face this one all the time
[Leon]: in dealing with anti-maskers, anti-vaxxers, and all manner of scientifically [Leon]: illiterate folks. [Leon]: With this fallacy, the claimant declares something untrue or impossible simply [Leon]: because they fail to understand it. [Leon]: A good example of this is folks who claim that the mRNA vaccines alter your DNA, [Leon]: which is factually fucking impossible, and this is probably the single most common [Leon]: logical fallacy and among the most annoying to refute. [SPEAKER_33]: How many of you have gotten a COVID vaccine? [SPEAKER_28]: These are four healthcare workers from different hospitals in North Carolina.
[SPEAKER_28]: Why not? [SPEAKER_20]: We don't know what the long-term side effects are. [SPEAKER_20]: It also hasn't been proven to be effective. [SPEAKER_28]: The CDC and many public health experts say that it's more than 90% effective. [SPEAKER_19]: They do say that. [SPEAKER_19]: That hasn't proven to me to be true. [SPEAKER_19]: I'm not going to just jump on a bandwagon with something that has not been tested. [SPEAKER_28]: When you say that it hasn't been tested, it has been tested, though. [SPEAKER_19]: If you look at the normal year span of how long something is tested, it's usually [SPEAKER_19]: 12 to 14 years before it comes to humans. [SPEAKER_28]: They say they're not anti-vax, more anti-mandate.
[SPEAKER_20]: and I'm not comfortable putting something into my body until I am ready. [SPEAKER_20]: If and when I'm ready to get the vaccine, I will get it on my own accord. [SPEAKER_20]: I won't be forced. [SPEAKER_13]: You just don't [SPEAKER_28]: trust the CDC. [SPEAKER_20]: I do not trust the CDC. [SPEAKER_03]: Absolutely not. [SPEAKER_28]: And that fuels their skepticism. [SPEAKER_03]: I have the right to question anybody in this country I want to question. [SPEAKER_28]: You're entitled to earn your opinion, but these are facts. [SPEAKER_03]: Are they, though? [SPEAKER_03]: Are they facts? [Adam]: Which is wild because there's increasing evidence that SARS infection, well, I mean
[Adam]: SARS-CoV-2, but like COVID infection can actually alter DNA. [Adam]: Like viruses insert themselves into our DNA all the time. [Adam]: So it's just wild to me. [Sage]: Don't you only get like a little tiny chunk of the virus anyway? [Sage]: So you can't even shed it either, which is another big, huge hullabaloo. [Adam]: With the vaccine, yes. [Adam]: The mRNA vaccine. [Adam]: And it's the magnets. [Adam]: How do they work? [Adam]: What are they called? [Adam]: The Juggalos. [Adam]: Who do that? [Adam]: The ICP.
[Adam]: ICP, yeah. [Arthur]: Have we done a Juggalo episode yet? [Bigly]: not we should do that one point one day [Ood]: we got it what's that soda they like to drink that's got to be the poison fago [Adam]: fago it can't be which now that i say it aloud makes me uncomfortable because like [Ood]: later on he recanted he kind of recanted that uh that magnet line and he like took [Ood]: some effort to like learn about like like uh magnets and polarization and stuff [Ood]: like that and [Ood]: Like, the weird thing about, like, ICP fans being labeled as terrorists by, like,
[Ood]: the American government. [Ood]: Like, something like that. [Ood]: Maybe, like, far-right extremists they were labeled as, like, falsely by the [Ood]: government. [Ood]: There's a whole bunch of stuff we could go into. [Ood]: Have you done ad hoc or ad hominem yet? [Leon]: It's coming, fucker. [Leon]: Just wait, dude. [Leon]: It's, like, literally at the bottom of the page I'm staring at right now. [Leon]: Okay, so next is the red herring fallacy. [Leon]: This is where the claimant introduces a bogus argument, a smelly red herring, if [Leon]: you will, to distract from their original shitty argument.
[Leon]: A red herring can follow or be associated with any other logical fallacy. [Leon]: Now, it's usually an act of desperation on the part of a claimant who realizes [Leon]: they've lost the argument, and calling it out can be as simple as saying, that's a [Leon]: red herring if ever I saw one. [Leon]: Now, your best defense against red herring is to doggedly pursue the original [Leon]: argument and don't allow the red herring to enter into debate. [Leon]: And fuck my God, did I ever experience this when I was debating in high school? [Leon]: Motherfuckers with their red herrings always getting up in my shit. [Leon]: And...
[Leon]: So useless adjudicators, which is another pet peeve of mine. [Leon]: Look, if you're going to sign up to be a judge of a debate competition, you need to [Leon]: understand the rules of debate. [Leon]: Just because you're a parent and your kid debates in like fucking Walter Murray [Leon]: Collegiate and is one of the good ones— [Leon]: doesn't make you an expert in fucking debate. [Leon]: Like you need to study the fucking rules and call people out when they use their [Leon]: fucking arguments because honest to God, nothing pissed me off more in debate than [Leon]: someone using a red herring and the moderator just sits there on their fucking
[Leon]: hands like they're just going to let it fly. [Leon]: It's bullshit. [Leon]: Stop it. [Leon]: Um, slippery slope fallacy is a red herring. [Leon]: Um, so if we allow abortions, all babies are going to be aborted. [Leon]: Well, it's a stinking red herring. [Leon]: That's not what the argument's about at all. [Leon]: It's just this fucking thing that you threw out there to distract from the fact [Leon]: that you don't have a leg to stand on. [Ood]: Is it also, is it also pivoting or is pivoting something different? [Leon]: Um, a red herring can be a pivot.
[Bigly]: Just any sort of misdirection. [Leon]: Yeah, like a smoke screen is a red herring. [Leon]: Like, yeah, any major misdirection when the opponent realizes they've lost their [Leon]: primary point. [Bigly]: You know, for example, you know, I haven't had a raise in five years. [Bigly]: And the boss says, yeah, but you work really hard to do a good job and you give [Bigly]: amazing customer service. [Bigly]: You know, like it's a complete, you know, sideways, unrelated thing to the original [Bigly]: premise of my comment that I haven't had a raise in five years.
[Bigly]: You know, that can [Leon]: definitely be hyperbole or non sequitur. [Adam]: Yeah, and red herrings can definitely be non sequiturs, but it might be something [Adam]: like, oh, I'm concerned about your alcohol use. [Adam]: Yeah, well, don't you use opioids for pain? [Adam]: And it goes, well, that's a red herring. [Adam]: Those aren't actually related issues. [Leon]: Exactly. [Leon]: That's a red herring. [Leon]: Perfect example. [SPEAKER_18]: Michael, I am so happy that we were able to have this little chat. [SPEAKER_24]: Wait. [SPEAKER_24]: You're forgetting something. [SPEAKER_24]: What? [SPEAKER_24]: This chat.
[SPEAKER_24]: Two men, one white, one Latina, a boss and a money cruncher. [SPEAKER_24]: I could fire you. [SPEAKER_24]: Fire him. [SPEAKER_24]: No, show mercy. [SPEAKER_24]: But here we are. [SPEAKER_24]: What's your point? [SPEAKER_24]: My point is that as long as people like you and me don't stop talking, [SPEAKER_24]: nobody can stop the USA. [SPEAKER_24]: I am talking about freedom, about choice. [SPEAKER_24]: America, I don't think you need to worry, because if you want to beat China, you
[SPEAKER_24]: will. [SPEAKER_24]: If you don't, that's fine. [SPEAKER_33]: That, my friend, is your victory. [SPEAKER_24]: You know, a lot of people say that if you dig long enough and hard enough, you will [SPEAKER_24]: get to China, and that may be true. [SPEAKER_24]: But what they don't tell you is that if you dig long enough and hard enough in a [SPEAKER_24]: conversation, you get to a friend. [SPEAKER_24]: So here is to conversation. [SPEAKER_24]: That's not... Raise your cups on high.
[SPEAKER_24]: Case closed. [SPEAKER_18]: That wasn't where we were. [SPEAKER_18]: That wasn't the [Leon]: whole... Up next is the appeal to tradition and appeal to novelty. [Leon]: Now, these fallacies assume in the first case that something is true or good [Leon]: because it's always been done that way, or conversely, that something is true or [Leon]: good because it's new and cutting edge. [Leon]: A lot of rip-off beauty products are sold using these arguments. [Adam]: Definitely, and it happens all the time in medicine.
[Adam]: the novelty rather. [Adam]: Well, I mean, both. [Adam]: I would say more often novelty, especially in the last little while. [Adam]: So it'll go, oh, for instance, to buy into my line of work, you know, oh, well, [Adam]: hydromorphone's newer than morphine, therefore it must be better. [Adam]: And it goes, well, actually, there's no evidence it's better. [Adam]: There's no evidence it's worse, but it's just being realistic about those kinds of [Adam]: things. [Adam]: Or treatments for cancer, where it goes, well, this is a new treatment. [Adam]: And I'm like, well, we've been using the same chemotherapy for 50 years because it [Adam]: works. [Arthur]: Isn't that the same thing as OxyContin when it came out in the 90s, 2000s?
[Adam]: Exactly. [Arthur]: They said, this is the new good opiate, and it's great because we say it's great. [Arthur]: And everyone's like, well, this is the new thing, so I guess I'll prescribe it, [Arthur]: plus I get a kickback. [Adam]: Well, definitely. [Adam]: And there's a cultural element as well, because this was right as there was a big [Adam]: push to acknowledge that pain needed to be more aggressively treated. [Adam]: And the makers of OxyContin took advantage of that. [Adam]: And OxyContin's a fine painkiller. [Adam]: The main reason I don't use it is that there's no injectable forms in Canada and [Adam]: all my patients lose their swallow.
[Leon]: That's fair. [Leon]: Richard Bigley, here you go. [Leon]: Up next is the ad hominem attack. [Leon]: In this case, the claimant makes a personal attack against their opponent rather [Leon]: than their opponent's argument. [Leon]: Politicians and angry spouses use this fallacy often, and it's frustrating as hell. [Leon]: In a formal structured debate, an attentive moderator will often cite a violator [Leon]: for using this attack, and an ad hominem attack is a sure sign that your opponent [Leon]: is losing their argument. [SPEAKER_20]: Harold Ford looks nice. [SPEAKER_20]: Isn't that enough? [SPEAKER_20]: Terrorists need their privacy.
[SPEAKER_33]: When I die, Harold Ford will let me pay taxes again. [SPEAKER_33]: Ford's right. [SPEAKER_33]: I do have too many guns. [SPEAKER_04]: I met Harold at the Playboy party. [SPEAKER_04]: I'd love to pay higher marriage taxes. [SPEAKER_33]: Canada can take care of North Korea. [SPEAKER_33]: They're not busy. [SPEAKER_33]: So we took money from porn movie producers. [SPEAKER_33]: I mean, who hasn't? [SPEAKER_01]: The Republican National Committee is responsible for the content of this [SPEAKER_01]: advertising. [Bigly]: I would like to stress that just because somebody insults you when they're arguing
[Bigly]: doesn't necessarily mean that the insult was the argument. [Ood]: Yeah, like saying like, hey, you're a shithead and this is why you're wrong. [Ood]: And then you explain why their argument was wrong does not make it like a ad [Ood]: hominem. [Bigly]: Yeah, your argument is not premised on them being a shithead. [Bigly]: You're just calling them a shithead and then dismantling whatever their argument [Bigly]: is. [Adam]: Yeah, or attacking their like credibility or say another expert's credibility is [Adam]: not an ad hominem.
[Adam]: So, you know, if it goes, well, Andrew Wakefield... [Adam]: was taking kickbacks when he did that MMR study, and he actually lost his medical [Adam]: license and he hasn't been able to get it back. [Adam]: That's not an ad hominem. [Adam]: That's explaining why his arguments are suspect. [Bigly]: Wasn't Wakefield also trying to develop an alternative MMR vaccine at the same time [Bigly]: and patent it while he was doing his study? [Adam]: Exactly. [Adam]: That's exactly it. [Leon]: Yeah, a good example of ad hominem is saying that Theresa Tam, Canada's chief
[Leon]: medical officer of health, is ill-equipped to be providing guidance on the [Leon]: coronavirus because she's a Chinese immigrant and that's where the virus came from. [Leon]: That's ad hominem. [Adam]: Or, you know, yeah, exactly. [Adam]: I can't think of a better example. [Adam]: I see this in the [Ood]: political debates all the time, too, especially when, like, things get really muddy [Ood]: and really, like, personal in political discourse. [Ood]: They'll say, like, you can't trust my opponent. [Ood]: You can't trust him to run the city. [Ood]: He's a philanderer. [Ood]: He cheated on his wife. [Ood]: How can somebody that cheated on their wife run a city?
[Ood]: You know, that whole thing. [Adam]: Yeah, Sleepy Joe. [Arthur]: Yeah, or another good example is all the people that say, well, they can't be good [Arthur]: at something because they're gay. [Arthur]: Yeah. [Arthur]: Exactly. [Leon]: Good discussion. [Leon]: Fuck, I'm really enjoying this episode.
[Leon]: I feel like I'm venting a lot of my frustrations from high school right now, and I [Leon]: appreciate the therapy you guys are giving me. [Bigly]: That's what these episodes are. [Leon]: So the gambler's fallacy implies that streaks of good and bad luck exist, and [Leon]: outcomes must not be random, particularly when they're coincidental or ironic [Leon]: outcomes. [Leon]: So that's pretty simple shit. [Leon]: It's just like it's happened three times like this, so the fourth time it's going [Leon]: to happen again. [Leon]: And that's clearly not true. [Bigly]: Makes me think of all the GameStop investors, you know, the day traders.
[Leon]: Oh, yeah, definitely. [Adam]: At the same time, there's almost the opposite where it'll go, oh, well, I have [Adam]: flipped heads three times in a row. [Adam]: So the next one has to be tails because randomness is naturally clumpy. [Adam]: Because the other part is, oh, it's not random because it doesn't go one, two, one, [Adam]: two, one, two. [Adam]: Well, that's not how randomness works. [SPEAKER_41]: What? [SPEAKER_41]: That's like the third time that lady's won on a machine I was playing.
[SPEAKER_21]: Oh, I'll bet she's one of those people. [SPEAKER_41]: Mall people? [SPEAKER_21]: What? [SPEAKER_21]: No, no, a lurker. [SPEAKER_21]: Oh, what's a lurker? [SPEAKER_21]: Okay, when you're playing a machine and it hasn't paid out, a lurker waits for you [SPEAKER_21]: to give up and then... [SPEAKER_21]: Kills you? [SPEAKER_21]: No, they swoop in and steal your jackpot. [SPEAKER_21]: Oh. [SPEAKER_41]: How do you know about this? [SPEAKER_21]: My nanny used to do it. [Leon]: Up next is the ad nauseum argument, and I fucking hate this one, too.
[Leon]: This is a truly maddening tactic in which the claimant repeats the claim so many [Leon]: times that no one cares to debate it anymore and concedes the point. [Leon]: And this is why legislative filibusters are often effective. [Leon]: Like... [Leon]: you get some debaters who just stick to their one single argument solidly, even [Leon]: after it's been refuted successfully using various tactics and like an adjudicator [Leon]: in a debate should call it out and ask them like, okay, you're, you're stalling, [Leon]: like proceed to your next argument. [Leon]: And a lot of adjudicators don't, which is why I don't like a lot of adjudicators,
[Leon]: but fucking like ad nauseum annoys the shit out of [Ood]: Is this like somebody using rhetorical tactics to convince instead of logical [Ood]: tactics? [Ood]: They're using very convincing language, even though the convincing language might [Ood]: be hollow of any real argumentation? [Leon]: Oh, yeah. [Leon]: Ad nauseum can partner with a lot of other logical fallacies if they're just used [Leon]: over and over and over and over again. [Leon]: And it's like, okay, what's the central argument? [Leon]: Can we get back to your argument? [Leon]: Stop using these distraction techniques.
[Bigly]: Think of it as like debating bedtime with a four-year-old, I guess, and the child [Bigly]: just keeps insisting on staying awake and yelling and screaming, and you as the [Bigly]: parent just get exhausted and you say, fuck, fine, you know, you'll tire yourself [Bigly]: out eventually kind of thing. [Bigly]: You know, you just kind of give in because you're just so bored and tired and just [Bigly]: sick of this and it's better. [Bigly]: You know, putting up with it is better than having to continue to debate it, I [Bigly]: guess. [Leon]: My two and a half year old son wins ad nauseum arguments with me on the fucking
[Leon]: daily. [Leon]: Like if his mom gets home from getting groceries and I'm watching him, she'll be [Leon]: like, why is he not wearing a shirt? [Leon]: And I'm like, because he just wouldn't fucking put it on. [Leon]: And I said... [Leon]: probably 50 times do you want to put on a shirt no and that's that's fucking ad [Leon]: nauseum like you cannot defeat a solid ad nauseum and there is no better ad nauseum [Leon]: argumenter than a fucking two and a half year old it's [Adam]: true yeah i was gonna say it's a comment on this because i have the same argument [Adam]: with my cat about when he gets fed
[SPEAKER_32]: I would say Mexico's going to pay for it. [SPEAKER_32]: I will build a great, great wall, and I will have Mexico pay for that wall. [SPEAKER_32]: Mark my words. [SPEAKER_37]: A lot of politicians have said, oh, they're not going to pay. [SPEAKER_37]: They never read the art of the deal. [SPEAKER_32]: We lose. [SPEAKER_32]: We have a trade imbalance. [SPEAKER_32]: But, Mr. Trump, hold on a second. [SPEAKER_32]: Of $50 billion. [SPEAKER_32]: And I said, you're not going to do it. [SPEAKER_32]: And everybody told me, everybody, [SPEAKER_32]: This is like the wall. [SPEAKER_32]: Believe me, we're going to build the wall. [SPEAKER_32]: Mexico's going to pay for it. [SPEAKER_32]: They don't get it, because I'm a business guy. [SPEAKER_32]: That's what I do.
[SPEAKER_32]: It's going to be built and it's going to be paid for by Canada, by the way. [SPEAKER_32]: It's going to be paid for. [SPEAKER_32]: Maybe I'll get Canada pay. [SPEAKER_32]: It's going to be paid for by Mexico. [SPEAKER_32]: The politicians are sharper and shrewder. [SPEAKER_32]: than our politicians. [SPEAKER_32]: You know, I went to an Ivy League school. [SPEAKER_32]: I was a good student. [Arthur]: Mexico, in some form, and there are many different forms, [SPEAKER_32]: will reimburse us, whether it's a tax or whether it's a payment. [SPEAKER_32]: Probably less likely that it's a payment. [Arthur]: There will be a payment. [Arthur]: It will be in a form, perhaps a complicated form.
[SPEAKER_32]: We're working on a tax reform bill that will reduce our trade deficits, increase [SPEAKER_32]: American exports, and will generate revenue from Mexico that will pay for the wall [SPEAKER_32]: if we decide to go that route. [SPEAKER_32]: We're thinking about building the wall as a solar wall so it creates energy. [SPEAKER_32]: and pays for itself. [SPEAKER_32]: What we save on that just with Mexico will pay for the wall many times over. [SPEAKER_32]: I view that as absolutely Mexico is paying for the wall.
[SPEAKER_33]: And when I said Mexico will pay for the wall in front of [Arthur]: thousands and thousands of people, [SPEAKER_33]: obviously they're not going to write a check. [SPEAKER_33]: They're not going to write us a check. [SPEAKER_32]: They'll pay. [SPEAKER_32]: They'll pay in one form or another. [SPEAKER_32]: They may even write us a check. [Leon]: Finally, we're wrapping this one up, is the fallacy fallacy. [Leon]: Now, this is the fallacy that invalidates an argument or position simply because [Leon]: the claimant has used a logical fallacy. [Leon]: Now, just because someone's argument fucking sucks doesn't necessarily mean they're
[Leon]: wrong. [Leon]: In evaluating other people's logical fallacies and flawed arguments, you should [Leon]: always entertain the possibility that they're actually right, but just have shitty [Leon]: arguments. [Ood]: Just a comment on the last one. [Ood]: What would be an example of that? [Ood]: The one I thought of would be like, yeah, we should take vaccines for COVID because [Ood]: they come in syringes, and I love things in syringes. [Leon]: Well, like an example with my son. [Leon]: He'll argue with me ad nauseum about not wearing a shirt, and at the end of the [Leon]: day, does he really need to wear a shirt if he's at home?
[Leon]: No, he doesn't, so why the fuck am I arguing with him? [Leon]: He's right. [Leon]: Shirts are not necessary. [Leon]: I just don't want to get in trouble with his mom because he's not wearing a shirt [Leon]: when she gets home. [Arthur]: I feel like a good example of this might be that scene from Trailer Park Boys where [Arthur]: I believe Ricky is in court and he tells the judge, I can't tell you the way [Arthur]: you want to be told. [Arthur]: I have to fucking swear. [Arthur]: So you have to fucking let me swear so that I can fucking tell you what the fuck [Arthur]: I'm talking about. [Arthur]: And they say, well, that's true.
[Arthur]: That's true, yeah. [Arthur]: The reality being that people that swear too much aren't intelligent. [Arthur]: And he has a perfectly intelligent response to the question and to the lawyers. [Arthur]: He just can't fucking say it without fucking saying fuck every fucking time. [Leon]: Yeah, his argument is that he can't have justice served unless he's permitted to [Leon]: swear in court. [Leon]: And it's a solid argument. [SPEAKER_18]: Mm-hmm. [SPEAKER_27]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_27]: Mr. Leahy, for your expert testimony and for providing this very illuminating tape. [SPEAKER_27]: Your Honor... [SPEAKER_27]: I think the video evidence clearly speaks for itself, and that any sane and
[SPEAKER_27]: rational person would have no choice but to convict these individuals of these [SPEAKER_27]: ridiculous crimes. [SPEAKER_27]: Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. [SPEAKER_27]: Oh, objection. [SPEAKER_27]: That's the 17th time that he has sworn so far. [SPEAKER_23]: Richard, please. [SPEAKER_27]: All right, I'm fucking... [SPEAKER_25]: I'm sorry about all the bulls... about all the stuff, but the prosecutor is a... [SPEAKER_25]: He's a... [SPEAKER_25]: He's an effing bad guy, and he's pissing me off. [SPEAKER_27]: He can't even speak without swearing.
[SPEAKER_27]: Your Honor, this is ludicrous. [SPEAKER_27]: It's a disgrace to these proceedings. [SPEAKER_27]: Thank you. [SPEAKER_23]: Richard, since you chose to defend yourself and fired the public defender, I guess [SPEAKER_23]: it's your turn to question the witness. [SPEAKER_25]: Thank you, Your Majesty. [SPEAKER_23]: And Richard, before you begin, I'd like to say that I think this is a bad idea. [SPEAKER_23]: However, you do have a right to defend yourself, so proceed. [SPEAKER_23]: But please remember to watch your language. [SPEAKER_25]: Look. [SPEAKER_25]: I can't speak without swearing, and I've only got my grade 10, and I haven't had a [SPEAKER_25]: cigarette since I've been arrested, and I'm ready to fucking snap. [SPEAKER_25]: So I'd like to make a request under the People's Freedom of Choices and Voices Act
[SPEAKER_25]: that I'd be able to smoke and swear in your courtroom. [SPEAKER_25]: Because if I can't smoke and swear, I'm fucked. [SPEAKER_25]: So are all these guys. [SPEAKER_25]: I won't be able to properly express myself at a court level, and that's bullshit. [SPEAKER_25]: It's not fair, and if you ask me, I think it's a fucking mistrial. [SPEAKER_27]: This man can't represent anyone, Your Honor. [SPEAKER_27]: He's a complete and total idiot. [SPEAKER_23]: Now, although I am opposed to that kind of language in my courtroom, [SPEAKER_23]: I'm going to allow it, as unfortunately it is part of your right to a fair trial. [SPEAKER_23]: So you may proceed, but please, I want to remind you that this is not a carnival. [SPEAKER_23]: Richard, you have permission to smoke and swear.
[SPEAKER_25]: Thank you. [Ood]: Another one that I want to mention just before we're finished here is post hoc ergo [Ood]: propter hoc. [Ood]: That's the false assumption that just because one event followed another that the [Ood]: first event caused the second. [SPEAKER_40]: Hey Joey, how you doing? [SPEAKER_08]: Great. [SPEAKER_08]: Roomie? [SPEAKER_40]: Yeah, I guess we are roommates now. [SPEAKER_08]: I know. [SPEAKER_08]: Well, now that you bring it up, our fridge is broken.
[SPEAKER_08]: We have to get a new one. [SPEAKER_08]: I checked around, and your half is $400. [SPEAKER_08]: Thanks a lot, Rich. [SPEAKER_40]: I'm not paying for half of that. [SPEAKER_40]: I'm only staying here until my apartment gets fixed. [SPEAKER_08]: Look, Rich, my parents bought this fridge just after I was born, okay? [SPEAKER_08]: Now, I have never had a problem with it. [SPEAKER_08]: Then you show up, and it breaks. [SPEAKER_08]: What does that tell you? [SPEAKER_40]: That refrigerators don't live as long as people?
[Ood]: A lot of people think of this Simpsons clip, the Tiger Simpsons clip, when they [Ood]: think of this fallacy. [SPEAKER_39]: Ah, not a bear in sight. [SPEAKER_39]: The bear patrol must be working like a charm. [SPEAKER_06]: That's specious reasoning, Dad. [SPEAKER_39]: Thank you, honey. [SPEAKER_06]: By your logic, I can claim that this rock keeps tigers away. [SPEAKER_39]: Oh, how does it work? [SPEAKER_06]: It doesn't work. [SPEAKER_06]: It's just a stupid rock. [SPEAKER_06]: But I don't see any tigers around here, do you?
[SPEAKER_39]: Lisa, I want to buy your rock. [Ood]: But I remember it as the Sesame Street example with a magic banana. [Ood]: Ernie. [SPEAKER_30]: Oh, hi, Bert. [SPEAKER_30]: You still have that banana in your ear. [SPEAKER_30]: What? [SPEAKER_30]: I said you still have that banana in your ear. [SPEAKER_30]: Yeah, Bert, I know. [SPEAKER_30]: You know? [SPEAKER_30]: Ernie, why is that banana still in your ear? [SPEAKER_30]: Listen, Bert. [SPEAKER_30]: I use this banana to keep the alligators away. [SPEAKER_30]: Alligators?
[SPEAKER_30]: Only there are no alligators on Sesame Street. [SPEAKER_30]: Right. [SPEAKER_30]: It's doing a good job, isn't it, Bert? [Ood]: Yeah, I think we did a good roundabout to some commonly used logical fallacies. [Ood]: Yeah, that's fine. [Leon]: Yeah, then for Cultivaritatis podcast, my name is Leon Filger, along with... [Leon]: Sagebury! [Leon]: Oodgallifrey. [Bigly]: Richard Bigley. [Adam]: And crasher Adam Fowler. [Arthur]: And the soundboard. [Bigly]: And use my phallus logically.
[Bigly]: Goodbye. [Arthur]: Logical phalluses. [Ood]: Playing us out this episode, a recording that I used... [Ood]: on one of my mysterious recording solo episodes. [Ood]: Recorded in 1902, this is The Last Castrati, a league of singers [Ood]: in Italy that were castrated in order to preserve the vocal cords of their youth.
[Ood]: And this is one of the last known recordings of these castrati. [Ood]: See you in the after show. [SPEAKER_18]: Oh
[SPEAKER_18]: oh oh oh
[SPEAKER_18]: ... ... ... ...
[SPEAKER_18]: ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
[Ood]: Hello, occultists, and welcome to the After Show. [Ood]: This is an update to our 2020 and Trump episodes. [Ood]: Really, there hasn't been a lot of movement here that we didn't cover last time. [Ood]: There's been more lawsuits brought upon by Trump. [Ood]: More and more legal teams have been hired, used up, and fired with no success.
[Ood]: And fewer and fewer judges, lawyers, [Ood]: and working politicians will publicly state that they think the 2020 election is [Ood]: stolen. [Ood]: In fact, since the January 6th insurrection that took place in America, or [Ood]: attempted insurrection, I should say, a lot have gone the opposite way to denounce [Ood]: the conspiracy. [Ood]: Even many mainline Republican politicians have denounced the conspiracy.
[Ood]: But as for the voters, two-thirds of Republican voters still believe the election [Ood]: was rigged somehow. [Ood]: And of those citizens, one I have to talk about in this update. [Ood]: Mike Lindell. [Ood]: One of the few, let's say, powerful people in Trump's corner to this day. [Ood]: You know, people have been abandoning Trump ever since. [Ood]: His conspiracies have been more and more ludicrous about how he lost the 2020 [Ood]: election. [Ood]: But Mike Lindell seems to stick by his side through thick and thin.
[Ood]: I often wonder what... [Ood]: magnetism or charisma like what does mike lindell see in trump that'll make him [Ood]: sacrifice his entire my pillow empire and spend every penny he has to support [Ood]: trump's conspiracy that the 2020 election was rigged [Ood]: He had a disastrous interview on CNN, and I think the interview speaks for itself. [Ood]: So if you're interested in seeing how this story has progressed, the sad middle to
[Ood]: it, here's a good example of that. [Ood]: Mike Lindell appearing on CNN and totally making an embarrassment of himself. [Ood]: I'll see you on the other side. [SPEAKER_44]: MyPillow CEO Mike Lindell continues to claim he has evidence that China hacked U.S. [SPEAKER_44]: voting systems and switched votes for the former president to Biden votes. [SPEAKER_44]: In a moment, you'll hear what two dozen election officials and cyber experts [SPEAKER_44]: contacted by CNN say about those claims. [SPEAKER_44]: Lindell is not backing down even as he faces a lawsuit from voting machine maker
[SPEAKER_44]: Dominion alleging he's defamed the company with his false accusations and Lindell's [SPEAKER_44]: company is countersuing. [SPEAKER_44]: CNN's Drew Griffin went to Minnesota to talk to Lindell about his claims that [SPEAKER_44]: threatened democracy. [SPEAKER_44]: Here's Drew's report. [SPEAKER_36]: The MyPillow guy. [SPEAKER_36]: Mike Lindell, yes, the MyPillow guy is convinced. [SPEAKER_36]: China hacked the election, Donald Trump really won, and Lindell has the absolute [SPEAKER_36]: proof. [SPEAKER_36]: They did it in all the [SPEAKER_33]: states, every single state. [SPEAKER_33]: And they changed the vote. [SPEAKER_33]: Every single state. [SPEAKER_33]: And you have the proof. [SPEAKER_33]: Yes. [SPEAKER_33]: That will show the actual exchange of votes.
[SPEAKER_33]: Yep, yep, 100%. [SPEAKER_33]: 100%. [SPEAKER_36]: It is, of course, complete nonsense. [SPEAKER_36]: Despite every piece of so-called evidence Lindell has presented so far, three [SPEAKER_36]: videos, a lawsuit, screenshots he sent to CNN, there's still no proof that the [SPEAKER_36]: election was hacked, and that's according to two dozen cyber experts and election [SPEAKER_36]: officials contacted by CNN. [SPEAKER_36]: 100% evidence. [SPEAKER_36]: When Lindell released his so-called evidence in videos like this, fact checkers
[SPEAKER_36]: quickly found out it was evidence of nothing. [SPEAKER_36]: These images are just publicly available voter data scrolling across the screen, [SPEAKER_36]: not proof of election hacking. [SPEAKER_36]: So Lindell changed his story, saying now the real evidence will be revealed at a [SPEAKER_36]: cyber symposium streamed live with MyPillow discounts available throughout. [SPEAKER_36]: And as further proof, [SPEAKER_36]: He sent CNN a preview, six different screenshots. [SPEAKER_36]: You sent us this on Friday. [SPEAKER_36]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_36]: What is this?
[SPEAKER_33]: That's just one piece of 1.2 billion lines of data from the election, okay? [SPEAKER_33]: Within that will be timestamps of when it happened. [SPEAKER_33]: There'll be flips in there. [SPEAKER_33]: So we sent [SPEAKER_35]: this to our own experts. [SPEAKER_35]: He said that it doesn't show any specific actions of any kind, election-related or [SPEAKER_35]: not. [SPEAKER_35]: and it's proof of of nothing [SPEAKER_33]: okay so he said that's nothing huh well he's wrong then you didn't hire a cyber [SPEAKER_33]: expert [SPEAKER_36]: we didn't consult just one cyber expert we consulted nine top election security
[SPEAKER_36]: experts who told us lindell's screenshots were extremely rudimentary metadata and [SPEAKER_36]: completely ridiculous we also reached all 15 officials from the 15 counties where [SPEAKER_36]: lindell says without any proof votes were hacked and switched [SPEAKER_36]: Rendell mentions some of the counties in his videos and lists them out in his [SPEAKER_36]: counter lawsuit against Dominion voting. [SPEAKER_36]: They are counties that use paper ballots counted by systems not connected to the [SPEAKER_36]: Internet. [SPEAKER_36]: Every one of them told CNN there is no evidence they were hacked by anyone.
[SPEAKER_35]: You identified 15 counties where the votes were switched. [SPEAKER_35]: We contacted all 15 counties, red and blue. [SPEAKER_35]: Red and blue. [SPEAKER_35]: That doesn't matter. [SPEAKER_35]: And we couldn't find a single person that said this is even possible. [SPEAKER_35]: They say, are you mistaken? [SPEAKER_35]: They think you're wrong. [SPEAKER_35]: The bottom line is they have paper ballot backups that [SPEAKER_33]: prove that they were not. [SPEAKER_33]: So you guys went and they let you audit there? [SPEAKER_33]: They let you do a full audit, CNN? [SPEAKER_33]: You guys did a full audit on 15 counties, huh? [SPEAKER_36]: We did what Lindell did not do. [SPEAKER_36]: We went to Delta County, Michigan to see how the election was carried out.
[SPEAKER_36]: Trump won here, [SPEAKER_33]: nearly two to one. [SPEAKER_33]: The state, Michigan, [SPEAKER_33]: Entry point order, Delta County. [SPEAKER_36]: In his videos and his lawsuit, Lindell claims someone in China hacked the election [SPEAKER_36]: system here and stole away precisely 3,215 Trump votes and turned them into Biden [SPEAKER_36]: votes. [SPEAKER_36]: The Republican County Clerk, Nancy Prisrocki, finds the allegation laughable for [SPEAKER_36]: one main reason. [SPEAKER_10]: It is never connected to the internet. [SPEAKER_36]: Never. [SPEAKER_10]: Never connected to the internet.
[SPEAKER_36]: at all whatsoever. [SPEAKER_36]: Not only are they not connected to the Internet, the votes are cast by hand on [SPEAKER_36]: paper. [SPEAKER_36]: Voters scan their ballots into this Dominion scanning machine where two digital [SPEAKER_36]: storage cards keep a tally. [SPEAKER_36]: The paper ballot goes right into this bin under lock and seal. [SPEAKER_36]: And that container is sealed. [SPEAKER_36]: And just to check that everything went OK, they conduct audits comparing the paper [SPEAKER_36]: ballots to the results on the computer. [SPEAKER_36]: And in 2020, it was an exact match. [SPEAKER_10]: We audited three different precincts and they matched exactly.
[SPEAKER_35]: So what would you say to somebody who made a documentary that among many counties [SPEAKER_35]: accused your county of being the victim of a Chinese hack that changed the vote [SPEAKER_35]: counts? [SPEAKER_10]: I would say that didn't happen in Delta County. [SPEAKER_36]: A Republican-led Michigan State Senate investigation found out it didn't happen [SPEAKER_36]: anywhere. [SPEAKER_36]: No evidence of widespread or systematic fraud. [SPEAKER_35]: I don't think you really understand how votes
[SPEAKER_35]: are cast, collected, and tabulated in this country. [SPEAKER_33]: Okay, you know what? [SPEAKER_33]: I do. [SPEAKER_33]: But what you don't understand is they can get, after they're tabulated, they can [SPEAKER_33]: get hacked after the fact, which they were, because Donald Trump was going to win [SPEAKER_33]: anyway. [SPEAKER_33]: Donald Trump was going to win anyway. [SPEAKER_35]: The paper ballots which were cast. [SPEAKER_35]: You didn't do an audit to match them up, though. [SPEAKER_35]: They were audited against the machine count. [SPEAKER_35]: No, they weren't. [SPEAKER_35]: No, they weren't. [SPEAKER_35]: In these counties, they were like... No, they weren't. [SPEAKER_35]: No, they weren't. [SPEAKER_35]: Who told you that? [SPEAKER_35]: The county officials who didn't. [SPEAKER_33]: Oh, did they tell you that? [SPEAKER_33]: Well, they're going to have some answering to do.
[SPEAKER_36]: No matter who says there was no widespread fraud in the election, whether it's [SPEAKER_36]: local election officials, secretaries of state, judges, or even Donald Trump's own [SPEAKER_36]: attorney general, Mike Lindell's conclusion is the same. [SPEAKER_36]: They are all wrong. [SPEAKER_33]: All these county officials are lying? [SPEAKER_33]: I don't know. [SPEAKER_33]: They might be misconstrued. [SPEAKER_33]: We'll say misconstrued because they don't realize what happened. [SPEAKER_36]: Lindell says his information comes from multiple sources, all of them super secret. [SPEAKER_36]: He claims he's spent millions on the project and also claims he will give $5
[SPEAKER_36]: million to anyone who proves him wrong. [SPEAKER_35]: Mike, you can make up anything. [SPEAKER_35]: No, you can't. [SPEAKER_35]: You are just going to have a demonstration in a room. [SPEAKER_35]: No, no, no. [SPEAKER_35]: This is where you're wrong. [SPEAKER_33]: We're giving it to the cyber people that show up. [SPEAKER_33]: We're going to give them each state. [SPEAKER_33]: Here's a state, Georgia. [SPEAKER_35]: They can take it apart. [SPEAKER_35]: You could possibly be the victim of a scam here. [SPEAKER_33]: Well, then why don't you come to the symposium and make $5 million? [SPEAKER_33]: Are you worried about me? [SPEAKER_33]: We should give a hug. [SPEAKER_33]: You're worried about, oh, Mike, oh, God bless you.
[SPEAKER_35]: Here's what we're worried about. [SPEAKER_35]: We're worried that what you are doing is mistakenly or deliberately destroying the [SPEAKER_35]: confidence in the legitimate elected president of the United States and fostering [SPEAKER_35]: what could be real damage to this country. [SPEAKER_35]: You know what? [SPEAKER_35]: I never said anything bad [SPEAKER_33]: about Biden or the Democrats, ever. [SPEAKER_35]: Never. [SPEAKER_35]: You have, through this investigation... No, I have not. [SPEAKER_35]: You pull it up. [SPEAKER_35]: You're lying now. [SPEAKER_35]: You're lying. [SPEAKER_35]: I said the Democrats warned us. [SPEAKER_33]: No, you're lying. [SPEAKER_33]: I said the Democrat Party warned us of this.
[SPEAKER_33]: You're saying that Joseph [SPEAKER_35]: Biden was illegitimately elected. [SPEAKER_33]: I'm saying that China did an attack on our country. [SPEAKER_33]: And that the wrong person won. [SPEAKER_35]: That's right. [SPEAKER_35]: The people who have watched your video believe what you say. [SPEAKER_35]: 100%. [SPEAKER_35]: If you're wrong, isn't that very dangerous? [SPEAKER_33]: Yes, but I'm not wrong. [SPEAKER_33]: I've checked it out. [SPEAKER_33]: I've spent millions. [SPEAKER_33]: You need to trust me and come there. [Ood]: Alrighty, that's it, that's all, dear occultists.
[Ood]: I hope you enjoyed Logical Fallacies, and we will see you next week for an [Ood]: adventure on the high seas and the world-famous book adapted from the real-life [Ood]: tale. [Ood]: Join in. [Ood]: Bye-bye.
Join Richard as he does a sequel to his "Real life Vampires" episode. Where we learn the terrifying truth that real people in history have been executed under suspicion from the powerful that they were wolves. Also,...
We needed a lighter episode. So lets talk about ten of the dumbest cryptids Ood and sage could research. Today, on Ovpod, get your Dong Wrangled,learn how to avoid mountain whales, meet the crying ballsack cryptid,...
An unavoidable follow-up to our poop episode, here, Arthur guides us through a river of PISS. What high end product is forged in piss? Can Aged urine cure insomnia? How do mice pee? Does a kidney stone gather moss? All...
Remember, if a loophole in a rule exists, it was put there to gain leads one second at a time. Formula One is a world wide, single seat, engineering arms race to build the highest performing racecars on earth. Hear a...
In Ages past, in the long long ago, humanity used to believe in cannibalistic demon men that preyed on the bodies of men. Too bad things haven't changed very much. Join Richard Bigly has he leads the ovpod crew through...