Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Occultae Veritatis Podcast - OVPOD

Occultae Veritatis Podcast - OVPOD artwork

Case #233: Pakistan International Airlines Flight 8303

Sep 16, 20261 hr 23 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

A flight where the pilots seemingly decided to make every wrong choice available to them, including literally forgetting to put down the landing gear. Hear every wrong choice made as told by Richard bigly to the OVPOD crew!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[Ood]: Before I tell this story, we have to go back long, long ago when I got into pilot [Ood]: school by the skin of my teeth. [Ood]: I shouldn't have. [Ood]: They shouldn't have let me in, but I did. [Intro]: Warning, this podcast contains violence, sexuality, gore, and other horrible and [Intro]: disturbing things. [Intro]: Listener discretion is advised. [Intro]: Also, the hosts of this venture are ignorant dipshits, so please do not take [Intro]: anything they say as fact, and enjoy the show.

[Intro]: Now, are you sitting comfortably? [Intro]: Good, then we'll begin. [Intro]: Today we had 15 homicides and 63 violent crimes, as if that's the way it's supposed [Intro]: to be! [Intro]: It is our basic human right to be fucked up! [Intro]: A second plane now has crashed into the other tower of the World Trade Center. [Intro]: Putting chemicals in the water that turned the friggin' frauds gay! [Intro]: The defendant shall be incarcerated for the rest of her natural life with no [Intro]: possibility of parole. [Intro]: You are not machines! [Intro]: You are not cattle! [Intro]: You are men! [Intro]: We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began

[Intro]: to take hold. [Bigly]: Hello, occultists. [Bigly]: I am Richard Bigley, and in studio with me today I have... [Bigly]: Sage Murray. [Bigly]: Ud Galfrey. [Demon]: And I'm the soundboard demon. [Bigly]: At 1.05 p.m. on May 20th, 2020, in Lahore, Pakistan, an Airbus A320 took [Bigly]: off from Alama Iqbal International Airport, headed towards Karachi, Pakistan, just

[Bigly]: over 1,200 kilometers away. [Bigly]: Eight crew members and 91 passengers embarked on their almost two-hour flight [Bigly]: towards the 12th largest city in the world. [Bigly]: Everything was going well for the most part, so it's time for some poison. [Bigly]: What's [Bigly]: your poison? [Ood]: Sure, nothing will go wrong.

[Bigly]: We are having Mango Lassi from Poutine's and Parathis in a small local restaurant [Bigly]: here in the city. [Bigly]: Yeah, so if you're a local listener, maybe check them out. [Bigly]: This is not paid advertising. [Bigly]: This is just me saying I like their food. [Sage]: Yes, we had it for lunch, and I had a paneer poutine, like a butter paneer poutine, [Sage]: and it was so good. [Sage]: It was amazing. [Sage]: It was very, very saucy and very delicious. [Ood]: This is really good. [Ood]: It's much better than the other Lassie I know, which is the dog that got shot for

[Ood]: having rabies. [Ood]: No, that was Yeller. [Ood]: Oh, shit, right. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: Lassie was the one that saves kids from wells. [Sage]: Oh, yeah. [Sage]: They can speak English. [Ood]: Timmy fell down the well. [Ood]: Oh, no. [Ood]: Dubai Southeast. [Ood]: Okay. [Demon]: What a slut. [Bigly]: Yeah, it's quite creamy, quite fruity. [Bigly]: This is delicious. [Bigly]: It's quite good. [Demon]: I'm a fan of mango lassie, and this is a very good mango lassie. [Ood]: This is like an elevated form of an orange Julius. [Ood]: Yes. [Ood]: It's way better than an orange Julius. [Bigly]: So if you're in Saskatoon, check them out. [Bigly]: It's Help Them Out, nice little local business, small hole-in-the-wall kind of

[Bigly]: restaurant. [Bigly]: The whole place has like three tables in it. [Bigly]: So the dine-in options are somewhat limited, but never had an issue having a place [Bigly]: to sit there. [Ood]: Yeah, and it's not some big corpo. [Ood]: Even McDonald's meal costs like 20 bucks these days. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: You know, support a local business instead. [Ood]: Get lunch there. [Demon]: Legitimately not sponsored by poutines and parathas, but 3310 Fairlight Drive in [Demon]: Saskatoon? [Bigly]: Yeah, they're kind of in the same strip mall as the Night Owl confectionery gas

[Bigly]: station place. [Demon]: Oh, yeah. [Bigly]: There you go. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Getting local with it. [Bigly]: Na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na. [Sage]: Na-na-na-na-na-na. [SPEAKER_13]: It was the aircraft's sixth flight since resuming operations after a coronavirus [SPEAKER_13]: lockdown. [SPEAKER_13]: A devastating blow. [SPEAKER_13]: The moment of disaster.

[SPEAKER_13]: The passenger jet crashed into this residential area in the port city of Karachi. [SPEAKER_13]: Terror for those who fell from the sky and for those who watched from the ground. [SPEAKER_13]: Houses crushed. [SPEAKER_13]: The frame of Pakistan International Airlines Flight 8303 halting in this alley. [SPEAKER_13]: Many of the 107 passengers and crew are feared dead.

[SPEAKER_13]: Casualties among residents as well. [SPEAKER_13]: But at least two on board survived, including the president of a Pakistani bank, [SPEAKER_13]: Zafar Masood, and this man named as Mohammed Zabair. [SPEAKER_13]: The Airbus ran into trouble on its approach to Karachi Airport after leaving [SPEAKER_13]: Lahore. [SPEAKER_13]: An investigation will seek to find out why.

[Bigly]: Pakistan International Airlines was founded in 1946 as Orient Airlines and started [Bigly]: commercial operations as Pakistan International Airlines in 1955 with flights to [Bigly]: London via Cairo and Rome. [Bigly]: And in 1964, it became the first non-communist airline to fly to China. [Bigly]: It was also highly regarded that in 1985, when the airline Emirates was founded in [Bigly]: the United Arab Emirates, they were involved in the establishment of this airline.

[Bigly]: So United Arab Emirates wanted an airline, so they went to Pakistan International [Bigly]: Airlines for help on how to get that set up. [Bigly]: In 2005, Pakistan International Airlines used the Boeing 777 and completed a [Bigly]: 22-hour, 22-minute nonstop flight from Hong Kong to London on the eastbound route. [Bigly]: So instead of taking the short way around the planet, they went the long way. [Ood]: Without any in-air refueling or anything like that?

[Bigly]: No, just non-stop flight. [Ood]: They were flying a big plane too, so like, you know, square cube law, the bigger [Ood]: the plane, the heavier it is, the more fuel they're going to need. [Ood]: And they still had a flight that long. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: That's incredible. [Bigly]: It was 21,600 kilometers. [Bigly]: This earned them the record of the world's longest nonstop flight by a commercial [Bigly]: airliner. [Bigly]: Despite all of this, the airline does have a bit of an issue with safety. [Bigly]: From the 1970s to 2020, it averaged a fatal accident every five years.

[Bigly]: They've lost 30 aircraft in this time, and between 1971 and 2017, there were at [Bigly]: least eight hijacking incidents. [Ood]: Oh, my God. [Ood]: Before we get feeling too big in our britches, let's remember over here in the West [Ood]: that Boeing's having its own little crisis with disappearing whistleblowers [Ood]: included. [Ood]: So let's not feel too superior. [Bigly]: So back to this particular flight was like one in the afternoon. [Bigly]: The flights are starting to resume since they were grounded when the pandemic

[Bigly]: happened. [Bigly]: So things are starting to kind of open up a little bit now. [Bigly]: This was one of the routine flights that were kind of coming back now that people [Bigly]: were able to travel again. [Bigly]: So the aircraft was in good working order. [Bigly]: The weather was fine. [Bigly]: No significant clouds. [Bigly]: Visibility was five kilometers. [Bigly]: Conditions were pretty much between this airport and the destination airport. [Bigly]: Everything was fine. [Sage]: It's good to go. [Bigly]: So Eid fell on May 24th, and many of the passengers were traveling to visit family

[Bigly]: for the occasion. [Bigly]: At 1.19pm, they were doing in-flight snacks. [Bigly]: The flight crew politely declined snacks. [Bigly]: Part of the reason for this is that this flight is taking place during Ramadan. [Bigly]: Oh. [Bigly]: So now Muslims abstain from food and drink every day, from sunrise until sunset [Bigly]: during Ramadan, and then they finally end their fast on Eid. [Bigly]: So this change in diet can have effects on the body and mind, disrupting sleep [Bigly]: patterns, hydration, blood sugars, etc.,

[Bigly]: We don't know for sure if they were fasting, but given that that is a thing that [Bigly]: was taking place and they did decline food and drink on the aircraft, it seems that [Bigly]: this is perhaps something that was taking place during this. [Bigly]: That seems logical. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So now at this time, the Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority left it to the flight [Bigly]: crew to decide about their medical fitness during this period of fasting.

[Bigly]: So basically the regulatory bodies were not really going to interfere with people [Bigly]: practicing this religious practice, even if they are flying commercial airliners. [Ood]: That's interesting because, like, you do want to give people freedom to practice a [Ood]: religion of their choosing, but logically low blood sugar and dehydration can lead [Ood]: to a loss somewhat of mental acuity. [Sage]: Right. [Ood]: So, like, what do you do in that case? [Bigly]: Well, think being hungry and tired and... And thirsty.

[Bigly]: And thirsty and then having to drive your car. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Like, this isn't a car they're driving. [Bigly]: This is a commercial airliner that they're flying. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So, like... [Bigly]: With a bunch of other people in it. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: So, I mean, it's certainly a questionable decision at that point. [Bigly]: However, as far as this goes, it's somewhat debatable as to what extent this [Bigly]: fasting would have affected the pilots. [Bigly]: You don't really know because no one was really there.

[Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So at 1.24 p.m., the airliner made contact with air traffic controller Karachi, and [Bigly]: they're flying around 34,000 feet at 268 knots or basically Mach 0.77. [Bigly]: Smooth sailing. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: The captain was 58-year-old Captain Sajjad Ghul. [Bigly]: He had over 17,000 hours of flying experience, including over 4,700 on the Airbus

[Bigly]: A320, which was this aircraft. [Bigly]: He started with Pakistan International Airlines in 1996. [Bigly]: He was issued a show cause notice for violating flight duty time limit and [Bigly]: exceeding stipulated limits of flying hours for 30 of 265. [Bigly]: days. [Ood]: That's like a trucker going over their allowable driving hours. [Bigly]: Yeah, that sort of thing. [Bigly]: Pakistan International Airlines was considering him for a supervisory role in 2014, [Bigly]: but was passed over due to lacking in technical knowledge and general awareness.

[Bigly]: Despite this, from 2017 to 2019, he flew 33% more than other A320 pilots working [Bigly]: for the same airline. [Bigly]: An aviation psychologist's analysis would describe him as being of bossy nature, [Bigly]: firm, dominant, and overbearing. [Bigly]: He had below average intelligence. [Bigly]: He tends to have little regard for the authority. [Bigly]: He has low mechanical comprehension with low comprehension of space relations. [Bigly]: His level of stress tolerance was also quite inadequate.

[Ood]: Oh no. [Bigly]: When he first applied for, yeah. [Bigly]: So, I mean, I believe that's actually a direct quote out of the psychologist's [Bigly]: notes there. [Ood]: Sounds like a weak asshole baby. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Not the kind of person you want in a high stress environment. [Ood]: No. [Bigly]: Especially when they're tired. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So anyway, when he first applied for Pakistan Airlines, their psychiatrist panel [Bigly]: did not recommend him. [Bigly]: He appealed this and was eventually accepted as fit to fly by a cadet pilot.

[Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Pakistan Airlines initially would allow applicants to get a second opinion. [Bigly]: So if there are people say no, you can go get your people and they can make a case [Bigly]: for you. [Bigly]: So he went to five different psychiatrists, three in the UK, two from Pakistan. [Bigly]: And during this time, while this was going on, the policy changed where the airline [Bigly]: decided to disallow second opinions. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So they changed the policy in the middle of his appeal. [Bigly]: So he went to the ombudsman saying that, well, I submitted my application before

[Bigly]: the rules changed, so you still need to allow my application. [Bigly]: And the ombudsman said, yeah, that makes sense. [Bigly]: And so anyway, after Pakistan Airlines had appealed the ombudsman decision, they [Bigly]: lost, and so he got to fly. [Ood]: By the skin of his teeth, he got into someplace he shouldn't have been. [Bigly]: Now, our first officer was Usman Azzam, who had been flying with Pakistan Airlines [Bigly]: for 10 years, and he had only about 2,100 total hours, but most of them were on the

[Bigly]: A320. [Bigly]: There were very few remarks on his record other than in 2014 on the ATR aircraft he [Bigly]: was endorsed with three satisfactory with briefings. [Bigly]: Basically, what this means is that he didn't do great. [Bigly]: He didn't really pass. [Bigly]: But after the instructor talked to him, the instructor felt that he knew enough to [Bigly]: get it. [Sage]: It was like, yeah, good enough. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Kind of, you know, sort of a bit of a mercy pass.

[Bigly]: Yeah. [Demon]: Which is definitely what you want for people flying airplanes is mercy passes. [Demon]: Yeah. [Demon]: No kidding. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So basically they cleared him and said, yeah, you're good to fly. [Bigly]: He was put under the observation of a Pakistan Aviation Authority inspector during [Bigly]: 2015 and [Bigly]: The airline also wouldn't promote him to first officer on the A320 until he was [Bigly]: cleared on that in 2016. [Bigly]: He lived with his parents, was not married. [Bigly]: And I only mention this because that's what the official accident report says.

[Bigly]: There's no judgment for him living with his parents and being unmarried. [Bigly]: It's part of the [Ood]: culture, isn't it? [Bigly]: Well, in a lot of... [Bigly]: higher populated places it's not uncommon for a house to be a generational house [Bigly]: where you know you have multiple generations living under the same roof and the [Bigly]: families lived there for years and years and years and years and years [Bigly]: First officer, Uzman Azzam, uh, was our flying pilot. [Bigly]: So he was the one behind the controls.

[Bigly]: Uh, Sajjad Gul was the monitoring pilot. [Bigly]: So he just, uh, kind of was there watching to make sure nothing goes, goes awry. [Bigly]: The cockpit chatter between them were about the COVID-19 pandemic, which was [Bigly]: certainly big news at the time. [Bigly]: Conversation was somewhat roken up by routine radio chatter. [Bigly]: Now there's this rule called the sterile cockpit rule, or the sterile, sterile? [Bigly]: How do you, how do you? [Bigly]: Clean. [Bigly]: Both are fine. [Bigly]: Both are acceptable. [Bigly]: Okay. [Ood]: I'm not laughing at that.

[Ood]: All right. [Bigly]: Sterile cockpit. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: That's what I was giggling at, too. [Sage]: No one wants a dirty cockpit. [Sage]: No. [Bigly]: So basically, if you are 10,000 feet or less, the only thing going on in the [Bigly]: cockpit is flying and communications related to flying. No fucking. [Sage]: No funny business. [Sage]: Actually, you might be. [Bigly]: So basically, you don't talk about anything else other than flying the airplane. [Ood]: Right. [Bigly]: And that's all you're doing is flying the airplane and talking about flying the

[Bigly]: airplane until you get to 10,000 feet. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: Of course, the flight crew did not follow this rule because they were busy talking [Bigly]: about COVID. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: So how was the honeymoon, Kevin? [Ood]: I don't want to talk about it, David. [Ood]: Sterile cockpit, David. [Demon]: You can't just keep the plane under 10,000 feet the whole time. [Demon]: Fucking watch me. [Bigly]: Don't want to talk about it. [Bigly]: So back to the flight. [Bigly]: They were supposed to fly to a waypoint called Nawabshah, which was a beacon 100

[Bigly]: nautical miles northeast of the airport. [Bigly]: And then they would then proceed to a waypoint called Mackley. [Bigly]: And then they would turn for an extended central line for runway 25L. [Bigly]: at the distance of 15.3 nautical miles. [Bigly]: Now between Mackley and the airport is a waypoint called Sabin, which is 11.4 [Bigly]: nautical miles from the airport where your final approach would start. [Bigly]: When you get to Sabin, you're supposed to be at 3,000 feet. [Bigly]: Now, if you reach Sabin and you're not at 3,000 feet, that's fine.

[Bigly]: There is a holding pattern there. [Bigly]: So basically, you can turn your airplane around and you basically fly between Sabin [Bigly]: and Mackley until you're at 3,000 feet. [Bigly]: And then he can check off that waypoint. [Bigly]: That's right. [Bigly]: And then you're at 3,000 feet, you go to Sabin, and then you just do the airplane [Bigly]: thing and you land and everyone's happy. [Bigly]: If something's not right, you just kind of go between them until you got it right. [SPEAKER_07]: Mm-hmm. [Bigly]: So air traffic control had told them to expect this pattern.

[Bigly]: And so they entered it into the flight management system. [Bigly]: And this included an instrument landing system approach. [Bigly]: Basically, once they get close enough to the runway, the technology takes over and [Bigly]: lands the aircraft form. [Bigly]: Now this being programmed into the airliner, [Bigly]: would basically mean that the aircraft would just manage itself and make all the [Bigly]: adjustments needed, combined with the good visibility, good weather, functional [Bigly]: aircraft, and no unusual situations. [Bigly]: There's really no reason for anything to go wrong with this. [Sage]: No. [Bigly]: But since this is a podcast episode, I'm sure you're expecting something to go

[Bigly]: wrong. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So at 2.15 p.m., the aircraft reaches and the crew requests clearance. [Bigly]: And so they're good to go down to 10,000 feet and approach Mackley. [Bigly]: The crew enters 10,000 feet on the aircraft autopilot and the aircraft enters into [Bigly]: descent mode. [Bigly]: So to understand what happens next, we need to understand how the A320 works. [Bigly]: So the aircraft is handled in 3D space.

[Bigly]: The systems handles the aircraft's lateral or heading, which is basically what [Bigly]: direction the nose is pointing on the compass. [Bigly]: So like your left and your right. [Demon]: Hmm. [Bigly]: You can adjust the speed, so it'll adjust the engines and the descent and the climb [Bigly]: and everything to get you to the required speed. [Bigly]: The altitude, so how high above the ground it is. [Bigly]: And then there's the vertical mode, which is basically what angle the aircraft is

[Bigly]: pitched to be at the specified altitude. [Bigly]: So that's your up and down with the airplane nose. [Ood]: Yeah, exactly. [Bigly]: Now these are all separate channels that can be configured independently of all the [Bigly]: others. [Bigly]: So you can set one to one thing, one to another and so on. [Bigly]: And so there are a couple of modes on each of these, which is selected and managed. [Bigly]: Now in selected mode, the aircraft will do what you want and then it just does it [Bigly]: until it's told to do something else. [Ood]: Yeah, like set yaw at whatever angle and it'll keep at that angle until you change

[Ood]: it. [Ood]: Exactly. [Demon]: It very much is like a little knob with a little light up display. [Demon]: And it's like heading 360 and then it goes to 360 and then altitude 100 for like [Demon]: 10,000 feet. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: And you push it in and it means one mode, you pull it out, it means the other mode. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: And so anyway, in selected mode, the aircraft just does what you want until it's [Bigly]: told to do something else. [Bigly]: So if I say fly due west, and it'll just keep going west until I tell it to stop.

[Bigly]: But then there's managed mode. [Bigly]: It reads the pre-programmed flight information and does that, keeping in mind the [Bigly]: value of what was entered into the channels. [Bigly]: Um, so like if you want the aircraft to go along some pre-programmed points, you'd [Bigly]: engage this mode and it'll change your heading and then it'll change your heading [Bigly]: again. [Bigly]: And as to get you to whatever way points you need to get to. [Ood]: It's like autopilot. [Ood]: It'll go from waypoint to waypoint on the way to a location. [Ood]: It's kind of like the, [Bigly]: you know, I don't know if anybody, you know, Tesla's autopilot mode versus Tesla's

[Bigly]: full self-driving kind of thing where it's like, you know, the full self-driving [Bigly]: will take you to where you tell it and versus autopilot where you just keeps you [Bigly]: driving on the road. Yeah. [Bigly]: I'm pretty sure. [Bigly]: That's probably a very niche explanation for like a really handful of people, but [Bigly]: yeah. [Demon]: There's some pilot out there that's like, you morons. [Demon]: But like, to my understanding, it's you file a flight plan, which is just like you [Demon]: say, it's, [Demon]: Waypoint to waypoint to waypoint, and I'll be at this waypoint at this time with [Demon]: this heading and this altitude.

[Demon]: And so the manage mode will look at that and say, oh, you want 12,000 feet. [Demon]: This says 14. [Demon]: We'll go 14 or whatever. [Bigly]: Mm-hmm. [Bigly]: So here's where things kind of go squirrely. [Bigly]: So they had engaged the aircraft into managed mode to change the heading to [Bigly]: approach the airport. [Bigly]: They then selected an altitude of 10,000 feet. [Bigly]: And so the aircraft did its thing until it got to Mackley slowly descending. [Bigly]: Now, the programming included that holding pattern between MACLI and Sabin, which

[Bigly]: the aircraft then descends with the expectation that it's going to be using this [Bigly]: holding pattern to get you down to 3,000 feet. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: So basically, this holding pattern, like I said, this takes you between Sabin and [Bigly]: MACLI until you're ready to carry on landing at 3,000 feet, your correct attitude. [Bigly]: This holding pattern adds an extra 23 miles to the descent path. [Bigly]: which gives the aircraft more time and more distance to descend. [Bigly]: Now, here's what happened was the pilots didn't need to use this holding pattern

[Bigly]: and didn't plan to use it because there was no air traffic in the area because it [Bigly]: was COVID. [Bigly]: You know, they're basically. [Bigly]: It's kind of [Sage]: alone up there and they're good to go. [Sage]: They don't need. [Sage]: Yeah, they don't [Bigly]: need to do all this extra stuff. [Bigly]: So they're like, yeah, just come in. [Bigly]: And so that was the plan. [Bigly]: And then they use the autopilot to do this, except the autopilot. [Bigly]: was expecting to have another 23 miles of flying to get themselves to the right [Bigly]: altitude. [Sage]: They just forgot to take that part out of the plan?

[Sage]: That's right. [Demon]: When they do it, they have to edit the plan individually by turning a little knob [Demon]: and pressing buttons to add in the new thing, and then it has to think and send it [Demon]: to air traffic control, and it comes back. [Demon]: It's not like a, oh, I'll just type it in my phone kind of thing. [Bigly]: Yeah, so they didn't need the holding pattern, but it was still in the aircraft [Bigly]: programming. [Bigly]: So the aircraft ended up reaching Sabin at 7,800 feet.

[Bigly]: And now had they deleted that holding pattern, which was present on their [Bigly]: instruments. [Bigly]: So like their instruments all told them there was a holding pattern. [Bigly]: Uh, if they would have just deleted it, that would have then adjusted how quickly [Bigly]: they descended, uh, so that they would descend into Sabin or at, uh, Mac Lee. [Demon]: So it was at a certain altitude and it was expecting this longer path. [Demon]: So it's going to descend at a much lower rate, a smaller angle, whereas they would [Demon]: have wanted to go much faster. [Demon]: So they're going from 10 to three or whatever.

[Ood]: Yeah, they were prepared to drop down a certain amount in like, I don't know, 10 [Ood]: miles, but the computer was set to descend at a smaller amount over 23 miles. [Ood]: So they were descending too slow. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: And so that would have put them at seven at the right altitude, but they didn't. [Bigly]: Um, so because they were distracted, talk about COVID-19, uh, basically everything [Bigly]: just kind of continued. [Bigly]: Uh, and so instead of figuring out what they needed to do to land the aircraft,

[Bigly]: this conversation about COVID just kind of carried on. [Bigly]: Had they conducted an approach briefing, that would have also included them [Bigly]: checking their flight program to make sure that everything was right. [Bigly]: And then they would have been like, oh, we have a holding pattern that we aren't [Bigly]: using. [Bigly]: And then they would have deleted it. [Bigly]: But they just were distracted by... [Bigly]: Talking about COVID, didn't bother to review anything, just figured that they would [Bigly]: approach. [Bigly]: So here's the first of issues. [Bigly]: It's 2.18 p.m.

[Bigly]: They accepted a clearance of 5,000 feet, and then they were told to tune their [Bigly]: radios to Karachi Approach traffic on a frequency of 125.5 megahertz. [Bigly]: Now, this was not acknowledged by the crew. [Bigly]: But the pilot turned their radio to 126.5 megahertz instead of 125.5. [Bigly]: Oh, no. [Bigly]: So the guy picks the wrong frequency. [Bigly]: So the air traffic controller keeps trying to reach them on 125.5, but no dice.

[Bigly]: Air traffic control tried to get another flight 8368 to give them a radio because [Bigly]: in case he's not getting through. [Bigly]: So he had another aircraft radio them. [Bigly]: And again, no response because they're tuned to the wrong frequency. [Ood]: Oh, boy. [Bigly]: Now, aircraft have a guard frequency, 121.5. [Bigly]: Now, this is for emergencies. [Bigly]: And meowing. [Bigly]: Yes, and meowing. [Bigly]: What? [Bigly]: Yeah, they'll use the guard radio frequency to just meow.

[Demon]: From what I hear, you're on guard and you just hear, meow, meow, meow. [Demon]: Guys, this is guard. [Demon]: Stop it. [Ood]: Meow. [Ood]: Oh, my goodness. [Ood]: Insert clip of pilots meowing. [Ood]: I'm sure I can find it. [SPEAKER_08]: This is the Chinese Navy. [SPEAKER_08]: This is the Chinese Navy. [SPEAKER_08]: This is the Chinese terrorist guy. [SPEAKER_08]: Please go away quickly in order to run documents. [SPEAKER_02]: I am a United States military aircraft conducting lawful military activities [SPEAKER_02]: outside national airspace.

[SPEAKER_02]: I am operating with due regard as required under international law. [Bigly]: And so, yeah, so aircraft are supposed to have this radio that's always tuned to [Bigly]: this frequency, you know, for emergencies. [Bigly]: And so air traffic control radioed them on this frequency, and then they got a [Bigly]: reply. [Sage]: Finally. [Bigly]: Finally. [Bigly]: Air traffic control tried radioing them three times on this guard frequency before [Bigly]: they got a response. [Sage]: Oh, my gosh. [Bigly]: Now, of course, this would have no effect on the outcome of this episode, but it

[Bigly]: does paint a picture of where things were at operationally in that cockpit. [Sage]: Well, these guys seem like fucking yahoos. [Bigly]: Yeah, so this whole radio communications fiasco took place over two and a half [Bigly]: minutes after losing contact with the aircraft. [Ood]: It's funny, like, there's a show called Nathan For You, hosted by Nathan Fielder. [Ood]: And in his new project, he actually takes on, like, why there's so many airline

[Ood]: crashes. [Ood]: And it's sort of half investigative reporting, half parody television. [Ood]: But in the investigative reporting half, it's revealed that, like, an arrogant, [Ood]: overbearing lead officer, lead pilot... [Ood]: often can overshadow or silence the dissent, criticisms, or second guesses of a [Ood]: more passive co-pilot. [Ood]: So it might not even be that they're both yahoos. [Ood]: It may be just this guy who got into flight by the skin of his teeth who was

[Ood]: evaluated to be arrogant and not great under pressure that may be overbearing. [Ood]: Maybe the co-pilot's clutching some of this shit, but he's just being, you know, [Ood]: overpowered by his overbearing lead pilot, you know? [Bigly]: So, with two-way communications re-established, Karachi approach cleared flight [Bigly]: 8303 down to 3,000 feet, the target altitude for Saban. [Bigly]: At that time, the aircraft was still at over 15,000 feet, approaching Mackley.

[Bigly]: And the crew had armed these modes to let the instrument landing system take over [Bigly]: as they approached MACLI. [Bigly]: So like when this happens, autopilot systems are basically dormant until they [Bigly]: receive signals from the ground-based instrument landing system to tell them what [Bigly]: to do. [Bigly]: So that's when you're... [Bigly]: You know, the pilot kind of gets close enough to the airport. [Bigly]: The airplane starts receiving information and telemetry from the ground. [Bigly]: And so the aircraft just knows, as a commercial aircraft, how to line up with the [Bigly]: runway and where it's supposed to be, what it's supposed to do.

[Demon]: Yeah, ILS is super cool. [Demon]: Quickly, it's an antenna that sits at the end of the runway and transmits two [Demon]: different frequencies that are split in the middle. [Demon]: And so the plane can kind of back and forth move and it can tell how far it is [Demon]: left, right, and up, down based off of the strength of these different signals is [Demon]: my understanding of how ILS works. [Ood]: And just for clarification, like, they're supposed to be at 3,000 feet, right?

[Ood]: But they're sitting at 15,000. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: That's way too high. [Bigly]: Way too high. [Bigly]: And so basically what typically happens is the ILS picks up the, like [Bigly]: the aircraft picks up the ILS, puts itself where it's supposed to be and lines up [Bigly]: with the runway. [Bigly]: And then it's supposed to do a descent profile, which is a gentle three degree [Bigly]: descent under normal circumstances. [Bigly]: So three degrees.

[Sage]: I bet it's not going to be more than three degrees. [Sage]: Oh, no. [Sage]: No, it won't be. [Ood]: Oh, wait. [Ood]: Oh, I know what's going to happen. [Ood]: Oh, no. [Bigly]: It's been trying. [Bigly]: Oh. [Bigly]: So as they armed this ILS approach mode when they got to MACLI, and MACLI was in [Bigly]: line with the runway, the aircraft actually ended up picking up the ILS landing [Bigly]: signals. [Bigly]: So in this case, it started receiving information about a runway heading, but it [Bigly]: did not receive anything to determine the aircraft's descent. [Bigly]: So the heading mode was turned off or whatever, but the descent mode was still

[Bigly]: doing the autopilot with the holding pattern on it. [Bigly]: Oh, God. [Bigly]: And so anyway, it didn't receive any information directing the aircraft, how to [Bigly]: descend. [Bigly]: So the descend just kept running the program. [Bigly]: So as a result, it disabled the lateral stuff, but everything else carried on in [Bigly]: the autopilot plan. [Bigly]: So until this point, the aircraft was descending with the idea that there was going [Bigly]: to be this holding pattern that would be used.

[Bigly]: but this shortened the descent of the aircraft by 23 nautical miles. [Bigly]: And then the flight crew had armed this mode before completing the holding pattern, [Bigly]: which proved that they really didn't intend to fly that holding pattern, which is [Bigly]: fine because they didn't need to, but they didn't remove it from the programming. [Bigly]: So the aircraft has to descend a lot quicker than that. [Sage]: Right. [Bigly]: So the lateral channel was being overridden and lining up for landing. [Bigly]: But the vertical channel was still doing the flight program.

[Bigly]: Vian thinks it's a holding pattern. [Bigly]: So the aircraft went into the Mackley Waypoint at 93, I guess 9,363 feet, with [Bigly]: only four nautical miles remaining to Sabin, where they were supposed to be at [Bigly]: 3,000 feet. [Bigly]: Oh. [Bigly]: So basically they are like over 6,000 feet higher than where they need to be. [Bigly]: And you can't descend that fast. [Bigly]: No. [Ood]: In order to compensate, they, oh, yeah, go ahead.

[Bigly]: No, no. [Bigly]: Keep in mind the aircraft is fully functional. [Bigly]: Everyone's alive. [Bigly]: The flight crew can take control of these systems at any time. [Bigly]: You know, some sloppy mistakes were made, but all of this was entirely correctable. [Bigly]: At this point, there was no big issue that couldn't be resolved. [Ood]: Right. [Ood]: It wasn't an ideal flight, but it could have been a smooth landing still. [Bigly]: Well, like I say, you decide, okay, well, now we're going to take this holding

[Bigly]: pattern. [Bigly]: We weren't going to, but now we're going to take it because we need to. [Demon]: I mean, you also have until you're, what, 200 feet above the runway to go around [Demon]: and cancel your... [Bigly]: So air traffic control saw what was going on. [Bigly]: Pakistan 8303 confirmed track mile comfortable for descent. [Bigly]: A pilot responds, affirm. [Bigly]: So the pilot seems to be completely unaware of what's going on.

[Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Now, then, of course, a few seconds later, he decides to look at his instruments [Bigly]: and the cockpit recorder says, what has happened? [Bigly]: Stop, stop. [Bigly]: Oh, no. [Bigly]: Take out the hold. [Bigly]: Take out the hold. [Bigly]: Take out the hold. [Bigly]: Take out the hold. [Sage]: Oh, my God. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So he realizes then that there was a holding pattern. [Bigly]: He's like, oh shit, oh fuck. [Bigly]: We need to take this hold out. [Bigly]: So the first officer deletes the holding pattern from the flight plan. [Bigly]: But this is meaningless to the aircraft because it's now following the ILS landing

[Bigly]: system. [Bigly]: So anyway, hold taken out. [Bigly]: The co-pilot or the first officer says, should we report this happening? [Bigly]: A captain, Mr. Gall, says, no, this could be due to the hold. [Bigly]: Tell Karachi Approach that we're established on localizer. [Bigly]: Now, if you recall from my Pinnacle Airlines flight, 3701 episode, it's the same [Bigly]: thing. [Bigly]: Pilots finding themselves in a situation but not communicating with air traffic

[Bigly]: control. [Bigly]: These pilots do not further discuss any plans to correct their excessive altitude. [Bigly]: Oh, my God. [Bigly]: nor did they discuss how high they were or what they needed to do to get back on [Bigly]: course. [Sage]: What? [Sage]: Just no plan. [Bigly]: Just no plan. [Sage]: They're just going to pull and pray. [Bigly]: So to fix, so like I said, the fix at this point would have been to disable the ILS [Bigly]: mode, enter that holding pattern and get set up for a proper landing. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Now, someone on the flight crew must have felt that they had a better idea.

[Bigly]: So at 2.30 and 44 seconds, one of the pilots changed the vertical mode on the [Bigly]: computer to open descent. [Bigly]: So what this does is it causes the aircraft to keep a certain speed, puts the [Bigly]: engines to idle, and it uses the pitch of the nose of the aircraft to control the [Bigly]: speed. [Bigly]: So it goes down, it speeds up while it descends... [Bigly]: and basically whatever that rate happens to be, so however many feet per second [Bigly]: you're falling, so be it. [Sage]: Oh, God.

[Bigly]: Now, open descent mode on final approach is prohibited. [Sage]: That makes sense. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: And several A320s crashed in the 1990s because of improper use of this mode. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Well, especially because the angle which you would have to go at to descend that [Ood]: much in that little space, it's pretty steep. [Ood]: It's not going to be great. [Bigly]: Yeah, the flight crew then extend the speed brakes. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Okay. [Bigly]: So now remember I said that the descent profile is three degrees?

[Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Well, this caused an average descent profile of about seven degrees. [Bigly]: In some cases, it was steeper, and they were basically falling from the sky at [Bigly]: about 3,000 feet a minute. [Bigly]: Oh, man. [Bigly]: So they then increase the speed controls to 255 knots, which is above the 250 knot [Bigly]: speed limit when you're flying below 10,000 feet. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: So like we're going to go faster than we're allowed to. [Bigly]: We're going to turn on open descent mode. [Bigly]: What's prohibited while we're trying to land this.

[Sage]: And not talk to the ground people about what they're doing. [Sage]: Or even each other. [Sage]: Or even each other. [Sage]: Just keep it a fun secret from everyone. [Ood]: Do you think, like, he didn't realize what he was doing, or do you think he was [Ood]: just like, oh, well, I'll get out of this pickle, I'm going to do some cowboy shit, [Ood]: whatever? [Sage]: That's what I would assume, the cowboy shit. [Demon]: Well, I mean, didn't you already establish that he sucks under... [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So meanwhile, the ground air traffic control sees this and the air traffic tower

[Bigly]: controller calls the approach controller and says, sir, it's too high. [Bigly]: And then the approach controller responds, yes, it's too high and I'm observing it [Bigly]: and we'll give orbit, which basically means give the, the ground air traffic [Bigly]: control talks to another, the approach air traffic controller. [Bigly]: So this is all taking place on the ground. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: And so he's like, yeah, I see they're too high and I'll give them an orbit, which [Bigly]: is basically tells them to take the holding pattern. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: Well, they should have done in the first place. [Bigly]: Yeah.

[Bigly]: The aircraft passes the Sabin waypoint at 7,800 feet, which is 4,800 feet above [Bigly]: where they should be. [Bigly]: Pakistan 8303 report level passing. [Bigly]: Captain responds to air traffic control out of 75 for 3000, meaning he was at 7,500 [Bigly]: feet. [Bigly]: Now this was maybe a bit off as they were actually at 7,700 feet. [Bigly]: So they were 200 feet higher than they were reporting.

[Bigly]: But I guess you can't blame them for being optimistic. [Demon]: Yeah, he knows how to set their altimeter when they're not able to get a glide [Demon]: slope. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So 75 for 3000. [Bigly]: The present position is 10 miles from touchdown. [Bigly]: The air traffic controller says, which is kind of trying to suggest that there's a [Bigly]: bit of an issue. [Bigly]: The captain responds. [Bigly]: No problem, sir. [Ood]: It's also like hard to be accurate. [Ood]: Like if they're descending 3000 feet a minute, a minute, that dial is fucking

[Ood]: going. [Ood]: Like it's hard to make the radio call before the number changes, you know? [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So they cross over to 7,400 feet and extend the landing gear. [Bigly]: This was not called out. [Bigly]: Typically when you're extending the gear, whoever does it yells it out so that [Bigly]: everybody else knows that the gear is down. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: Uh, but it was not called out in the cockpit. [Bigly]: It was just done. [Bigly]: Uh, they didn't do any cross check. [Bigly]: Um, and, uh, anyway, one of the ideas is that they probably descended or dropped

[Bigly]: the landing gear to cause more drag to slow them down while they were descending. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Um, so, uh, yeah, so that they could basically fall further without speeding up. [Bigly]: Um, so it's now two 31 and 41 seconds air traffic control, um, radios to the [Bigly]: airplane or to the aircraft. [Bigly]: Uh, sir, orbit is available if you want telling the pilot that there is a holding [Bigly]: pattern available if they want it.

[Sage]: Why would you not take that? [Bigly]: Now, I would suggest that this was a really strong hint from air traffic controller [Bigly]: that the first officer responds, say it's okay, which was a bit of a change since [Bigly]: the captain was basically handling radio until that point. [Bigly]: So it was just kind of odd that now suddenly the first officer is on radio. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Negative, sir. [Bigly]: We are comfortable, he said. [Bigly]: We can make it inshallah. [Demon]: Inshallah. [Demon]: Inshallah. [Demon]: God willing. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Okay. [Bigly]: We can make it inshallah.

[Ood]: Pilot skill willing. [Ood]: How about that? [Bigly]: So they're now at an altitude of 5,000 feet, descending at about 4,000 feet a [Bigly]: minute. [Bigly]: The captain remarks, hold was stuck. [Bigly]: This was automatically built in. [Bigly]: I forgot. [Bigly]: He, referring to the air traffic controller, will be surprised by what we have [Bigly]: done. [Sage]: What? [Sage]: Oh, no. [Sage]: So, you know, when you're like, oh, yeah, he's just doing [Bigly]: it to cowboy. [Bigly]: Yeah, yeah. [Bigly]: Well, that's it, eh? [Bigly]: Oh, fuck. [Bigly]: So, basically, there was an issue with this.

[Bigly]: Like, instead of thinking about the current moment, how he was going to fix it, he [Bigly]: was preoccupied thinking about how he ended up here. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: And furthermore, like I said, he seemed pretty interested in bragging about landing [Bigly]: the aircraft at this descent rate. [Sage]: Yep. [Bigly]: you know like this was some sort of accomplishment and and test of skill of of him [Bigly]: as a pilot even though [Sage]: it was him that fucked it up that had to do that in the first place [Ood]: well like jesus christ even the saying that some cowboy shit it's just one dude one [Ood]: horse at least he's just risking his own life he's got what 91 passengers yeah yeah

[Ood]: jesus christ [Bigly]: So then air traffic control radios, Pakistan 8303 disregard, turn left, heading [Bigly]: 180. [Bigly]: Now this was an order from the air traffic control ordering them to enter that [Bigly]: holding pattern. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So unlike the past communications where they're just kind of subtly hinting that [Bigly]: maybe they're too high, they're coming in too fast. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: This was him saying, take the holding pattern. [Bigly]: This is me ordering you to do this. [Sage]: Yeah.

[Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Now, however, there was the word disregard. [Bigly]: So some have suggested that maybe when he said disregard, that it added a bit of [Bigly]: confusion as to what the air was being directed. [Bigly]: But I mean, I think we kind of see where this is headed. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Um, so the flight crew radio back, sir, we are comfortable now and we are out of, [Bigly]: uh, 3,500 for 3000 established ILS 25 L. Now they weren't at 3,500 feet, uh,

[Bigly]: but they were actually at 3,900 feet, which is, you know, what, what's like 400 [Bigly]: feet between friends. [Demon]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Negative turn left heading 180. [Bigly]: Now air traffic control has basically had enough of this. [Sage]: Yeah. [Demon]: Yeah. [Bigly]: But ignoring their order... [Sage]: Oh, my God. [Bigly]: Sir, we are established on ILS-25L, and no change in course was made. [Bigly]: The crew reduced the target airspeed to 225 knots in an attempt to slow down the [Bigly]: aircraft so they can extend the flaps and slats.

[Bigly]: Now... [Bigly]: I have to drop at [Ood]: 4,000 feet a minute. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Ood]: And they have... What were they at? [Ood]: 4,500 feet? [Ood]: So they got 80 seconds? [Ood]: 80 seconds to do something about it? [SPEAKER_07]: Oh, boy. [Bigly]: Yeah, so they attempt to slow down the aircraft so that they can extend the flaps [Bigly]: and slats, but these can't or rather shouldn't be deployed at speeds faster or at [Bigly]: these faster speeds because it could cause damage to them. [Bigly]: Setting one for the flaps has a maximum speed of 230 knots.

[Bigly]: They deploy the flaps to setting one. [Bigly]: But they're traveling at 242 knots, 12 knots above the speed that they're supposed [Bigly]: to be deployed. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So the aircraft gives them an overspeed warning. [Bigly]: In the cockpit, none of this warning was not acknowledged. [Bigly]: They didn't say, oh, we have an overspeed warning, which is what you're supposed to [Bigly]: do so that people know there's an overspeed warning. [Ood]: Yeah. [Bigly]: They didn't acknowledge it at all. [Bigly]: And because the nose of the aircraft was pointing down at such a steep

[Bigly]: angle, the autopilot had disengaged because it's like... [Sage]: Something bad is happening and someone should take charge of this? [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Basically, at this point, the nose of the aircraft is pointing towards the ground [Bigly]: at 13.7 degrees. [Sage]: Oh, yeah. [Bigly]: Remember when I said three degrees? [Bigly]: Yeah, it was supposed to be three degrees. [Bigly]: Now we're at 13.7. [Bigly]: Wow. [Bigly]: Uh, so, uh, to keep the speed that was set, it just kept nose down, nose down, nose [Bigly]: down. [Bigly]: And with the landing gear, the speed brakes and the flaps extended and the engines

[Bigly]: on idle autopilot was really just pushing that nose down to keep that, uh, keep [Bigly]: that speed. [Bigly]: Uh, so now this would be considered an aircraft upset if your nose points down more [Bigly]: than 10 degrees. [Bigly]: So this is really a serious problem here. [Bigly]: This would never really be experienced in any normal flight. [Bigly]: And, you know, I'd like to remind folks that there are passengers on this aircraft [Bigly]: too. [Bigly]: Probably just losing their shit. [Bigly]: Well, losing their lunch too, I think.

[Demon]: Also, it's a couple seconds ago, but do you want to hear what an overspeed warning [Demon]: sounds like? [Demon]: Yeah, play that. [Demon]: Yeah, because it's not a subtle warning. [SPEAKER_07]: Ahhh. [SPEAKER_07]: Yeah. Yeah, so that, without acknowledging it, without turning it off. [Ood]: Wow. [Ood]: Well, them not saying anything, like that's one or both of them just like choosing

[Ood]: their pride over the safety of their passengers. [Sage]: Yeah, that's wild. [Sage]: Are they like passing notes back and forth? [Ood]: If I acknowledge it, it's going to look real embarrassing. [Ood]: So we're just going to [Sage]: deal with it. [Sage]: Like I'm going to get in trouble. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So, yeah, as I was saying, this kind of pitching would not happen. [Bigly]: The autopilot disconnect would then notify the pilots with like alarms and warning [Bigly]: lights, except not in this case, because the aircraft has to pick and choose what [Bigly]: alarms it plays. [Bigly]: And so over speed takes precedent over autopilot disconnect.

[Sage]: Okay. [Bigly]: But it would still register on the screen that autopilot disconnected, but that was [Bigly]: also not acknowledged. [Bigly]: Of course not. [Bigly]: So air traffic. [Bigly]: Sir, you are five miles from touchdown, still passing 3,500. [Bigly]: Flight response, Roger. [Sage]: Roger Dodger. [Bigly]: Moments later, they reach an altitude of 2,230 feet. [Bigly]: Their descent rate is 7,400 feet per minute. [Sage]: Wow, that's fast. [Bigly]: Now, a typical flight this far from the runway would be at about 1,000 feet, but

[Bigly]: they're 1,200 feet higher than they should be with a minute or [Bigly]: less to landing. [Ood]: Coming in like a rocket, too. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: And as for the descent rate of 74, or I guess, yeah, 7,400 feet per minute, the [Bigly]: only time you would ever experience that in a flight would be if this was like an [Bigly]: emergency descent because you've lost cabin pressure. [Sage]: Right. [Sage]: Right. [Bigly]: So like when the plug fell out of that one aircraft and they had to drop down, same

[Bigly]: sort of deal. [Bigly]: Like that's basically the only time you'd ever experience that kind of descent. [Demon]: Because when you descend, your wings get pushed up like this. [Demon]: I'm moving my non-existent arms. [Demon]: Your wings get pushed up as you are descending. [Demon]: And if you're pushed up too fast, they're going to snap off. [Bigly]: Oh, fun. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So, amongst all this, the ground proximity warning fired up. [Bigly]: Sink rate. [Bigly]: Pull up. [SPEAKER_09]: Sink rate. [SPEAKER_09]: Sink rate. [SPEAKER_09]: Pull up.

[SPEAKER_09]: Pull up. [Bigly]: And then the first officer pulled up, which caused the aircraft nose to come up. [Bigly]: And in seconds, the descent rates dropped to 2,000 feet per second. [Bigly]: So like it's kind of a, you're falling very fast. [Bigly]: Now suddenly you're not falling and then you're probably losing your lunch if [Bigly]: you're in the back of the aircraft. [Bigly]: Yeah, no kidding. [Bigly]: So the speed then increased to 261 knots. [Bigly]: The speed brakes and landing gear were retracted. [Bigly]: So they've had the landing gear down.

[Bigly]: And now they're putting them back up. [Sage]: You'd think they would want them to be down. [Bigly]: Given that they're going to land in the next minute or so. [Bigly]: So they didn't call this out or cross check it. [Bigly]: Nobody mentioned it in the cockpit. [Bigly]: And it's actually unknown who retracted the gear again. [Bigly]: But they'll never tell. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Or why they did that, nobody knows because it was never discussed. [Bigly]: However, speculation is that the first officer had raised the landing gear.

[Bigly]: So the speed dropped, the overspeed alarm stopped, and it is speculated that the [Bigly]: captain decided to extend the flaps further, setting two than setting three. [Bigly]: Now, flap setting three has a maximum speed of 189 knots, and they were going 232 [Bigly]: knots. [Bigly]: A little bit faster. [Bigly]: Way faster than what you're supposed to have for that setting. [Bigly]: So here we go again. [Bigly]: Overspeed alarm activates three seconds. [Sage]: Oh, my God. [Bigly]: And then it stops three seconds.

[Bigly]: Basically, they stop the overspeed alarm. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: And then they retract it, or then they sent the flaps out again. [Bigly]: And then three seconds later, the alarm is going again because they're going faster [Bigly]: than setting number three. [Ood]: Yeah, you can see the knock it under pressure coming out. [Ood]: Like, that was in his training. [Ood]: He should check the speed before he sets that other setting, and he should know you [Ood]: have to wait for it to drop. [Ood]: But he didn't. [Ood]: He just went down the list without checking because he was panicking. [Ood]: And then, whoo, overspeed alarm again. [Ood]: Yeah.

[Bigly]: Now, air traffic control gives clearance to land. [Bigly]: It appears this clearance was given by the approach air traffic controller instead [Bigly]: of the tower controller. [Bigly]: I'm not really sure why or how that happened because usually tower control gives [Bigly]: that clearance, but the approach controller gave them the clearance to do it [Bigly]: anyway. [Bigly]: Interesting. [Bigly]: So now they're at an altitude of 1,100 feet, landing gear up. [Bigly]: First officer asks, should we do the orbit? [Bigly]: Meaning, should they go into the holding pattern? [Sage]: A little too fucking late there, my friend.

[Bigly]: Well, and that's why people think that the first officer brought the gear up [Bigly]: because he was expecting to do the holding pattern. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: No, no, leave it, the captain replied. [Bigly]: Oh, my God. [Bigly]: The captain took over the controls, but for four seconds afterwards, the first [Bigly]: officer continued to provide inputs. [Bigly]: So both of them are trying to fly this aircraft at the same time. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Oh. [Bigly]: And so when the pilot flying changes hands, it's supposed to be called out.

[Bigly]: But I'll leave you one guess as to whether this was called out. [Ood]: I guess no. [Ood]: Do you have the plane? [Ood]: I have the plane. [Ood]: Yeah. [Bigly]: It wasn't called out in case you're still wondering. [Bigly]: So this is, like I said, this is why it was believed the first officer raised the [Bigly]: landing gear because the captain seemed really hell bent on landing. [Bigly]: And the first officer was asking about going into this holding pattern. [Bigly]: So it's unlikely that the captain would have raised the landing gear if he was [Bigly]: planning to land. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: So until this changeover, it seemed like the first officer was basically in control

[Bigly]: of the aircraft. [Bigly]: But it's not known for sure because the situation seemed to lack any sort of [Bigly]: communication. [Bigly]: Nobody really knew what the other person was intending to do, what they were [Bigly]: thinking or why nobody was following any sort of procedure. [Bigly]: Right. [Sage]: Oh, that's so nuts. [Ood]: It sounds like they're just like a bitter married couple having like a, let's give [Ood]: each other the silent treatment argument. [Ood]: Like a silent argument. [Ood]: While they're controlling like a plane full of 91 people. [Ood]: Yeah. [Bigly]: When you get through to 1,000 feet, this is known as the stabilization gate.

[Bigly]: What is defined as the stable approach varies from airline and jurisdiction. [Bigly]: But in this case, it would mean... [Bigly]: I don't know. [Bigly]: I got some stuff here. [Bigly]: Who wants to do some reading for me? [Ood]: Sure. [Bigly]: Okay. [Bigly]: Okay. [Bigly]: So this is what a stabilized approach looks like in this particular airline with [Bigly]: this particular jurisdiction. [Sage]: So we read these numbers like 0.16, 0.15, 0.5. [Sage]: Stabilized approach criteria by Pakistan Airlines.

[Sage]: A. [Sage]: Approach stabilization criteria and other relevant aspects are given in PIA. [Sage]: Operations Manual, Part A. [Sage]: The approach is stabilized when all of the following conditions are met. [Sage]: 1. [Sage]: The aeroplane is on the correct flight path. [Sage]: 2. [Sage]: Only small changes in heading slash pitch are required to maintain the correct [Sage]: flight path. [Sage]: 3. [Sage]: The aeroplane speed is not more than VREF plus 20 knots IAS and not less than

[Sage]: VREF or the adjusted GS techniques. [Ood]: I'm guessing they were over that. [Sage]: Four. [Sage]: The aeroplane is in the correct landing configuration. [Sage]: They're not. [Demon]: Sorry, V-speeds are your stall speeds. [Demon]: So, like, you have to be 20 knots over your stall speed to be... [Demon]: I think is what that's saying. [Ood]: Oh, so they are. [Ood]: They're way over. [Ood]: They're way over. [Ood]: Still no landing gear, though. [Sage]: No. [Sage]: Five. [Sage]: Rate of descent is no greater than 1,000 feet per minute below 2,000 feet AGL.

[Sage]: Oof. [Sage]: If an approach requires... [Sage]: Sorry. [Sage]: No, go ahead. [Sage]: Okay. [Sage]: If an approach requires a rate of descent greater than 1,000 feet per minute, a [Sage]: special briefing should be conducted. [Ood]: Nope. [Sage]: 6. [Sage]: Power setting is appropriate for the aeroplane configuration and is not below the [Sage]: minimum power for approach as defined by the Aeroplane Operating Manual. [Sage]: 7. [Sage]: All briefings and checklists have been completed. [Ood]: No.

[Sage]: B. I don't know why there's a B. [Sage]: Whatever. [Sage]: Oh, unique approach procedures or abnormal conditions requiring a deviation from [Sage]: the above elements of a stabilized approach require a special briefing. [Sage]: They fucking hate special briefings on this plane. [Sage]: C. PIA has a no fault go around policy when crew decides to execute a go around [Sage]: after having committed to land at any airfield due to factors deemed against safety [Sage]: of flight. [Sage]: However, for feedback and data compilation purposes only, Captain shall annotate

[Sage]: any go-around or diversion in debriefing. [Bigly]: So here's what happens is if you answer no to any of those above criteria, the [Bigly]: procedure is to do a go around, which you increase the engines to full power. [Bigly]: You increase your altitude. [Bigly]: You retract your flaps and landing gear. [Bigly]: You radio to the tower that you're going around. [Bigly]: And that's how you abort a landing of an aircraft that's on final approach. [Bigly]: Now, as for the criteria, flight 8308 basically answered no to all of the above.

[Bigly]: Yeah, it sure did. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So this is like absolutely a blatant disregard for standard procedures. [Sage]: Which is kind of a big deal when you're a commercial pilot. [Bigly]: So the captain directs the first officer to cancel the overspeed alarm. [Bigly]: Now, you shouldn't cancel an alarm without fixing the underlying problem. [Bigly]: Literally. [Bigly]: It's like when you clear the check engine light on your car, but you don't actually [Bigly]: fix what the problem is. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Same sort of deal. [Bigly]: Yeah, who does that? [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: I would never do that.

[Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: So you need to fix the problem for you cancel the alarm, but he just cancels the [Bigly]: alarm anyway. [Bigly]: Oh, my God. [Bigly]: So at 750 feet and 1.5 nautical miles from the runway, the aircraft alarmed that [Bigly]: the landing gear was not down. [Bigly]: In addition to the warning lights and such, it also lights up an arrow by the [Bigly]: landing gear switch. [Bigly]: It's like, hey, [Sage]: geniuses, press this button, you fuckfaces. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: But no communication on this took place. [Bigly]: Then it's believed that the pilot thought that it was triggered by the overspeed

[Bigly]: condition. [Bigly]: But basically, you'd have thought whoever would have raised the gear would have [Bigly]: caught that. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: But nobody did. [Ood]: Oh my God. [Ood]: They got to switch to a big red circle like in the YouTube thumbnail. [Bigly]: That's right. [Bigly]: So the aircraft chimes, sink rate, too low, terrain, pull up. [Bigly]: All of this ignored. [Bigly]: Oh my God. [Demon]: Terrain in this case is the ground. [Demon]: Yes, the ground. [Bigly]: You're 750 feet above ground and you're going down and you're gears not down.

[Bigly]: Under normal circumstances, the aircraft would have chimed too low gear, but due to [Bigly]: the message priority order, this wasn't heard. [Bigly]: Even if it were heard, they probably wouldn't have done anything about it either. [Bigly]: Judging by other actions. [Bigly]: And then there was that go-around procedure that I talked about earlier that was [Bigly]: still available, but it basically remained unused. [Demon]: One thing to note from what Sage said, too, is that no fault go around.

[Demon]: If you have to go around, just go around. [Demon]: The company's not going to be pissed off at you. [Sage]: You won't get in trouble. [Demon]: Yeah. [Demon]: So there's no reason not to go around. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: And like go arounds happen often. [Bigly]: Like it's, you know, the wind puts your aircraft at a wrong spot on the runway or [Bigly]: whatever. [Bigly]: You go around until you do it right. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: When I worked up north, we would spend like 20 minutes sometimes just circling [Sage]: until it was good to land because it's so dangerous. [Sage]: Better be safe than sorry. [Ood]: Like sometimes you get a weird wind gust and you have a wobble in the wing.

[Ood]: You're like, oh, I don't like the feel of this one. [Ood]: I'm going to go around, you know? [Ood]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Um, so the aircraft, uh, at 2 34 PM, uh, flies across the runway at 75 knots over [Bigly]: what they should have been doing. [Bigly]: Um, it won't touch down until about somewhere halfway towards the end. [Bigly]: Uh, landing gear is still not down. [Sage]: They're just going to go on their tummy, the plane tummy. [Bigly]: Yes, that's right. [Bigly]: A belly landing. [Bigly]: Oh my God. [Bigly]: Now at seven feet above ground, the captain engaged the thrust reversers.

[Bigly]: Oh God. [Bigly]: Good. [Bigly]: Now this is ridiculous because the aircraft won't deploy thrust reversers while [Bigly]: you're in the air. [Bigly]: You have to be on the ground. [Bigly]: So he applies the thrust reversers and the A320 does not respond. [Bigly]: Um, the reason for this is because the, but hand like the switches that tell the [Bigly]: aircraft that it's okay to use thrust reversers are tied to the landing gear. [Bigly]: But there's pressure on the gear because it's on the ground.

[Bigly]: It says, OK, we can deploy thrust reversers. [Bigly]: But because the gear is safely stowed in the underbelly of the aircraft instead of [Bigly]: being deployed, it does nothing. [Sage]: Oh, my God. [Bigly]: Basically, because of this, the thrust reversers are being called, but the thrust [Bigly]: reversers aren't doing anything. [Bigly]: That causes another warning or a series of warnings to come on in the cockpit. [Bigly]: And these were also ignored. [SPEAKER_15]: Oh, Jesus. [Bigly]: At 2.34 and 18 seconds, we now have touchdown somewhere between 4,500

[Bigly]: to 5,400 feet from the threshold of the runway. [Bigly]: So, you know, they're about 5,000 or so feet ahead of touching down than where they [Bigly]: should have touched down. [Sage]: Yikes. [Bigly]: So they hit the runway. [Bigly]: First part of the aircraft to touchdown are the underwing engines. [Bigly]: This throws sparks. [Bigly]: The aircraft bounces a couple of times and doesn't slow down. [Bigly]: The captain applies the wheel brakes to slow down the aircraft. [Bigly]: Again, the wheel brakes don't work because they're safely stowed in the belly of

[Bigly]: the aircraft instead of having been deployed. [Ood]: Oh, yeah. [Ood]: I'm sure the brakes are working on the landing gear that isn't even down. [Ood]: Yeah, no kidding. [Bigly]: And so it drags on the runway, chewing up the undersides of its engines. [Bigly]: Yep. [Bigly]: So now here's where you get that, like, record scratch freeze frame. [SPEAKER_15]: Yep, that's me. [SPEAKER_15]: You're probably wondering how I ended up in this situation. [Ood]: Before I tell this story, we have to go back long, long ago when I got into pilot

[Ood]: school by the skin of my teeth. [Ood]: I shouldn't have. [Ood]: They shouldn't have let me in, but I did. [Bigly]: Now this isn't a position you want to be in. [Bigly]: You've got less than half the runway to bring your shit under control. [Bigly]: You're moving too fast. [Bigly]: You've hit the runway without your landing gear down. [Bigly]: You've ignored direct orders from air traffic control. [Bigly]: Your engines are being destroyed by the runway under you. [Bigly]: Now, major airports such as this have emergency staff on site for just the [Bigly]: situation. [Bigly]: Ambulance, firefighters, you know, all sorts of staff ready to go at any moment

[Bigly]: because of this sort of thing. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: If you find yourself in this position as a pilot, the best bet is to stay put. [Bigly]: Yeah, you might have skid off the end of the runway. [Bigly]: You might have rode off $100 million aircraft. [Bigly]: But hey, you're on the ground. [Bigly]: You're at the airport you're supposed to be at. [Bigly]: Emergency crews are right there and ready to go. [Bigly]: You'll come to a stop at some time in the near future. [Bigly]: Everybody knows where you are. [Bigly]: And I'll give you one guess as to if they did this.

[Sage]: I bet they did not. [Bigly]: They didn't. [Sage]: Oh, good. [Sage]: Where the fuck could they possibly have gone? [Bigly]: Okay, so the first officer figured something wasn't right. [Sage]: No shit. [Sage]: You think? [Sage]: And he doesn't announce [Bigly]: that he's taking over control of the aircraft. [Bigly]: He just pulls back on his controls. [Sage]: Oh, my God. [Bigly]: So you've got the captain pushing in because he wants to keep the plane on the [Bigly]: ground, and you've got the first officer who wants to get airborne again. [Bigly]: The captain applies the thrust reversers again, and this time the engines slow down

[Bigly]: towards idle, but the reversers don't deploy. [Bigly]: Engine number two has a fire alarm and it goes off. [Sage]: Oh boy. [Bigly]: Nobody acknowledges this. [Bigly]: After about 10 seconds, the alarm stops. [Bigly]: Four seconds later, the first officer says, take off, sir, take off. [Bigly]: Two seconds later, the captain spools up the engines. [Bigly]: Engine one responds as it should, like a good little engine. [Bigly]: Engine two, the one with the fire, continues to lose power. [Sage]: because it's on fire the

[Bigly]: aircraft shifts to the right and then at a 234 and 46 seconds they are in the air [Bigly]: again after dragging the engines on their runway for 18 seconds and nearly a [Bigly]: kilometer jesus [Sage]: christ why why what's the what's the thought process behind that like why would you [Sage]: why would you do that when you just like commit to be like yeah i fucked up this [Sage]: plane is dead but at least i'm on the ground it's [Demon]: the same thing as two dudes in a canoe both like going the wrong way and spinning [Demon]: in a circle but it's a commercial aircraft [Ood]: uh seats were comfortable insight meal was adequate bit of a rough landing gonna

[Ood]: give that a four out of ten [Demon]: yeah still stood up and clapped [Bigly]: yeah over the radio it can be heard pakistan 8303 going around [Bigly]: So on the aircraft, it was a pretty shitty situation. [Bigly]: The left engine, number one, was putting the aircraft back into the sky. [Bigly]: The right engine, number two, was all fucked up and idling. [Bigly]: And the aircraft wouldn't transmit commands to this engine because the engine [Bigly]: control unit was damaged. [Bigly]: The generator, which powers the aircraft located in engine two, was damaged.

[Bigly]: So the aircraft shifted the systems to run off of the generator in engine one. [Bigly]: Now, this wouldn't be an issue. [Bigly]: However, engine one suffered similar damage to engine two, so its clock was [Bigly]: ticking. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: At 59 feet, the warning system comes to life. [Bigly]: Too low. [Bigly]: Gear. [Bigly]: Gear. [Bigly]: One of the pilots selected the gear switch to lower the gear. [Bigly]: Oh, good. [Bigly]: Nobody made any comments about this. [Bigly]: Oh my God, these guys. [Bigly]: At 442 feet, engine two, you know, when you are told to turn something like their

[Bigly]: computer off and turn it back on again, when things start getting kind of weird. [Bigly]: Well, same sort of deal with the engine. [Bigly]: Engine two was ready to go again and spooled up, responding to the command that [Bigly]: they had given it to spool up 25 seconds earlier. [Bigly]: So now you got engine two again. [Bigly]: But the clock was ticking on the engines. [Bigly]: The slide on the runway fucked up the oil lines. [Bigly]: And so about 30 seconds after taking off again, the engine oil for number one and [Bigly]: number two engines were 75% and 67% respectively.

[Bigly]: Yikes. [Bigly]: So without the oil, these engine components will seize up shortly. [SPEAKER_02]: Yep. [Bigly]: So number one engine, low oil pressure chimed. [Bigly]: They noticed this warning as someone canceled it within five seconds. [Bigly]: Immediately after that, number two engine, low oil pressure comes on. [Bigly]: The aircraft made it up to 2,160 feet. [Bigly]: The engine power was 40%. [Bigly]: Request heading for Pakistan 8303.

[Bigly]: We would like to come in again for ILS 25L. [Bigly]: Oh, my God. [Sage]: Oh. [Bigly]: Roger, turn left heading 110, climb 3000, controller replied. [Bigly]: Meanwhile, the tower and approach had spoke. [Bigly]: He had not put the landing gears down, said the tower. [Bigly]: I have declared full-scale emergency. [Bigly]: And then approach says, for the time being... [Bigly]: and then the tower continues he touched uh he touched and there was fire belly [Bigly]: landing type then went up the tower continued okay said approach i was telling him

[Bigly]: to discontinue ask him whether gears were down or not the tower said i saw those [Bigly]: were not down okay says the approach controller but he never did actually ask the [Bigly]: crew about the gear up landing [Demon]: So he said he would do it, but our approach controller didn't. [Bigly]: So the aircraft made it up to 2,670 feet while trying to climb up to 3,000 feet. [Bigly]: The left engine started, number one. [Bigly]: The left engine started to spool down.

[Bigly]: Thrust lever, number two, idle. [Bigly]: Move number two, idle, said the first officer. [Bigly]: Basically, so the left engine, engine one, had failed. [Bigly]: Most of these planes that have two engines, I'm pretty sure are supposed to be able [Bigly]: to fly with one engine. [Bigly]: They can't take off with one engine as far [Demon]: as I know, but they can fly with one fine. [Bigly]: But that was it. [Bigly]: Well, that was it. [Bigly]: Engine one failed.

[Bigly]: And so they set the second engine to idle for some reason. [Demon]: Unless they're trying to restart the first engine, which you would set it to idle [Demon]: and then pull it and then give it more gas. [Demon]: But that's just the wrong stick. [Demon]: And you're a pilot. [Demon]: What are you? [Demon]: Sorry. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So with engine one gone, the one that didn't have the fire, the one that was [Bigly]: generating electricity to power the aircraft was now done. [Bigly]: They lost electrical power. [Bigly]: The aircraft switched to battery and deployed the RAT.

[Bigly]: which is sort of like an emergency special power sort of turbine. [Bigly]: I talked about a similar system in my Pinnacle Airlines episode. [Bigly]: So the flight data recorder did not come back, but the cockpit voice recorder fired [Bigly]: up again as was designed. [Ood]: Yeah, I'm picturing a rat with the black box on its back and a little parachute. [Ood]: That's how they recover the black box. [Bigly]: What's a rat? [Bigly]: It's Ram Air Turbine. [Ood]: Ram Air Turbine. [Ood]: Yeah, it's live.

[Ood]: An electric generator, right? [Demon]: Well, it depends on what, like, what aircraft it is, but it'll either pop out the [Demon]: bottom, but it's just a little, think of a fan, basically, that catches the air and [Demon]: spins, because it's a turbine that [Demon]: It makes a [Bigly]: little bit of electricity to run the base systems. [Bigly]: Okay. [Bigly]: So, flight data recorder did not come back, but the cockpit voice recorder fired up [Bigly]: again as it was designed. [Bigly]: The aircraft was circling back to the airport with no engines.

[Bigly]: The aircraft had systems in place to stop the crew from providing inputs that would [Bigly]: cause damage. [Bigly]: However, without power, the systems were offline, so instead the aircraft would [Bigly]: just give you an alarm. [Bigly]: Okay. [Bigly]: Now, both pilots were basically fucking with the controls at this, and the aircraft [Bigly]: was giving a warning about dual inputs. [Bigly]: So they're fighting each other in the aircraft. [Bigly]: It's like that canoe where they're going around in circles. [Demon]: I just want to point out, as I'm looking up RAT on Wikipedia to make sure that it

[Demon]: is a Ram air turbine, one of the pictures is Pakistan International Flight 8303 [Demon]: with this Ram air turbine deployed. [Bigly]: Well, there you go. [Bigly]: After it's built. [Sage]: Oh, good. [Sage]: It's famous. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: The aircraft gives an alarm saying that it's receiving, you know, two sets of [Bigly]: directions. [Bigly]: And basically with no engine thrust, the angle of attack had started to increase [Bigly]: with the aircraft, putting it into a stall. [Bigly]: And so you hear a stall warning playing as well on the cockpit voice recorder.

[Sage]: They don't care, though. [Bigly]: Aircraft control radios to the aircraft. [Bigly]: Pakistan 8303, you are dropping altitude 2000. [Sage]: Pakistan Airlines 8303. [Sage]: What the fuck are you guys doing? [Sage]: What's your game plan? [Sage]: Yeah, what the fuck, bro? [Bigly]: Uh, just give me 2000. [Bigly]: The first officer replies, the voice recorder captured another alarm. [Bigly]: We don't know what it was because the flight info recorder wasn't working at the [Bigly]: time. [Bigly]: Cause there was no power, but there was some other alarm.

[Bigly]: Uh, the first officer noticed that engine number two was working, but at idle. [Bigly]: Uh, so it begins to spool up when they push a thrust. [Bigly]: Uh, [Bigly]: So the air traffic controller said that they were at 18, I guess, 1,800 feet. [Bigly]: The first officer responded that they're trying to maintain. [Bigly]: Captain said, you had selected number two to idle, whereas engine number one was [Bigly]: gone, realizing what the first officer had figured out moments earlier. [Sage]: Oh, my God.

[Bigly]: Yes, replied the first officer. [Bigly]: Then a series of banging sounds are heard. [Bigly]: This was the failure of engine number two. [Bigly]: Perfect. [Bigly]: And they reduced power. [Bigly]: The banging stopped, but 30 seconds later, the engine spooled down. [Bigly]: The aircraft started to descend and slow down. [Bigly]: Stall warnings would come in intermittently. [Bigly]: The first officer called on the captain to increase the speed. [Bigly]: The captain asked, how? [Bigly]: How? [Sage]: well like fair um [Bigly]: just push your nose down yeah yeah just push your nose down uh so basically the

[Bigly]: only way would have been to push the aircraft towards the ground to speed up the [Bigly]: aircraft [Sage]: oh my god [Bigly]: uh so they tried to line the aircraft up with the runway the controller asks you [Bigly]: appear to be turning left and they respond we will be proceeding direct sir we have [Bigly]: lost engines the first officer replied they're at 1500 feet [Demon]: Oh, that's getting close. [Bigly]: Confirm you're carrying out a belly landing, the controller asked. [Bigly]: Negative, sir, said the first officer. [Sage]: Not this time. [Sage]: That was just for fun.

[Bigly]: The captain asked about the landing gear, maybe a little bit later than he should [Bigly]: have. [Bigly]: The first officer said the gear was up, and then on the recording, the gear can be [Bigly]: heard dropping down. [Sage]: Oh, God. [Bigly]: This possibly contributed to the tragedy because without the engines to provide the [Bigly]: thrust, the gear only serves to provide drag and slow your aircraft down as it [Bigly]: glides towards the airport. [Bigly]: Cabin crew to be seated, the captain says. [Sage]: Oh, my God. [Sage]: You think they're not seated already?

[Bigly]: Now, remember, throughout all of this, there are passengers on this aircraft. [Bigly]: Oh. [Bigly]: And they say over the aircraft PA system, cabin crew to your station for landing. [Bigly]: Oh. [Bigly]: at 700 feet above ground. [Bigly]: They were over a densely populated suburb. [Bigly]: Warnings are blaring. [Bigly]: They couldn't pitch down or they would strike buildings. [Bigly]: The captain shouted, mayday, mayday, mayday. [Bigly]: And the first officer keyed his microphone and transmitted the same to air traffic [Bigly]: control.

[Bigly]: This was the final transmission. [Bigly]: The controller responded that both runways were available, but there was no [Bigly]: response from the aircraft. [Bigly]: The aircraft nose was pitched high into the air to try and gain altitude, but they [Bigly]: were falling. [Bigly]: Don't take flaps. [Bigly]: Don't take flaps. [Bigly]: The captain has heard saying they're almost got in line with the runway. [Bigly]: At 2.40 and 18 seconds, the aircraft strikes rooftops 1.4 kilometers short of the [Bigly]: runway, one block shy of open land.

[Bigly]: and the building tops are being sheared off by the aircraft wings. [Bigly]: The aircraft crashed on the ground, plowing into several vehicles. [Bigly]: The aircraft came to a stop against the wall of a school. [Bigly]: Witnesses rushed to the aircraft to find and help survivors. [Bigly]: Only two survived. [Sage]: I'll tell you this about that... [SPEAKER_01]: I was seated in first row. [SPEAKER_01]: To my right, across the aisle, there was a steward. [SPEAKER_01]: In front of me, two air hostesses. [SPEAKER_01]: When the flight crew, trained to maintain a stoic facade, begins to unravel, you

[SPEAKER_01]: know that something is wrong. [SPEAKER_01]: They were crying and reciting verses from the Holy Quran. [SPEAKER_01]: The plane circled back for another landing attempt. [SPEAKER_01]: This time, engines stopped working. [SPEAKER_01]: But no distress was announced. [SPEAKER_01]: I cannot explain how unnerving, complete silence in an aircraft that is still [SPEAKER_01]: suspended in the air and all its engines and auxiliary power units grind to a halt. [SPEAKER_01]: The cockpit's door flew open and I saw chaos beyond.

[SPEAKER_01]: It seemed like the plane was going to nosedive. [SPEAKER_01]: In those 30 seconds, I knew that we were going to crash. [SPEAKER_01]: I did take stock of my life very quickly in those 30 seconds. [SPEAKER_01]: And my conscious was there. [SPEAKER_01]: But the voice inside me told me that I was going to survive. [SPEAKER_01]: And then I fainted. [SPEAKER_01]: That is what has possibly spared me from crippling post-traumatic stress.

[SPEAKER_01]: because I lost consciousness during the most horrific part of the ordeal. [SPEAKER_01]: It was through others' accounts that I reconstructed what happened to me next. [SPEAKER_01]: And what happened reinforced my faith in miracles. [SPEAKER_01]: At the last minute, my seat was changed from a window side to an aisle. [SPEAKER_01]: I believe this location was crucial to my survival. [SPEAKER_01]: For some reason, when the plane broke apart, the seat was thrust out away from the [SPEAKER_01]: rest of the wreckage. [SPEAKER_01]: It fell straight onto the third floor rooftop instead of the road and the angle of

[SPEAKER_01]: the fall reduced the damage to my body. [SPEAKER_01]: It then slid off the rooftop and onto the bonnet of a car, further breaking my [SPEAKER_01]: fall. [SPEAKER_01]: Finally, locals in the area dragged me away from the car minutes before it burst [SPEAKER_01]: into flames. [Bigly]: 18 buildings were damaged in the crash, and out of sheer luck, none of them [Bigly]: collapsed, likely saving the lives of countless other people.

[Bigly]: Many other people living in the area were not home because they'd gathered at the [Bigly]: mosque for prayers. [Bigly]: It was found that the narrow streets and all the crowd of people gathering at the [Bigly]: scene to help had hindered the emergency response, which is why you would have been [Bigly]: better off to stay at the airport. [Bigly]: Yeah, no kidding. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Responding crews also did not have the proper equipment needed to adequately and [Bigly]: safely address the hazards they would face from an aircraft crash. [Bigly]: Evidence preservation was also found to be inadequate.

[Bigly]: This was an entirely avoidable catastrophe. [Sage]: One million percent. [Bigly]: It only came about from like raw unrestrained negligence. [Bigly]: They made almost no call-outs, no checklists. [Bigly]: They ignored standard procedures, intentionally disregarded instructions from air [Bigly]: traffic controller, triggered and then ignored most of every possible warning, [Bigly]: generally operated the airplane dangerously. [Bigly]: And as the situation became worse and worse, at each step there was an out, an exit

[Bigly]: to return to some sort of safe situation. [Bigly]: basically, until there wasn't. [Sage]: Yeah, they had so many opportunities to be less dangerous and less shitty. [Bigly]: Harm reduction. [Bigly]: I think harm reduction is the word you're looking for. [Bigly]: In unrelated news, following this crash, and while these pilots were not involved [Bigly]: with it, it would come out that around 40% of pilots in Pakistan had fake pilots [Bigly]: licenses. [Bigly]: This involved the airlines, Pakistan International Airlines, Serene Air and Air

[Bigly]: Blue. [Bigly]: Wow. [Bigly]: Wow. [Bigly]: The investigation into this incident asked if the aircraft could have landed the [Bigly]: first time had the gear been down. [Bigly]: And if it had full braking and full reverse thrust, they would have been possible

[Bigly]: to land without going over the end of the runway. [Bigly]: So had they put that gear down, they could have possibly done that. [Bigly]: There would have been a really high risk, however, of the tires bursting because [Bigly]: the speed they would have touched down at would have been just below the maximum [Bigly]: speed of these tires. [Bigly]: So like they would be really pushing these tires to the limit. [Bigly]: They had also asked about the possibility of completing the go around and felt it [Bigly]: was not something that they really could be determined by the go around. [Bigly]: I mean, like after they touched down and took off again, they were like, well, was

[Bigly]: it possible that they could have possibly made the airport, you know, had they not [Bigly]: put the landing gear down and it was just basically felt that there was no way to [Bigly]: determine this for sure. [Bigly]: Just because there's all sorts of variables, you know, if they, [Bigly]: If they hadn't idled the engine number two, could they have made it? [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Maybe, or maybe that would have made the engine fail sooner. [Bigly]: You don't know. [Bigly]: They couldn't determine that. [Demon]: Basically, we can't tell because they're not competent pilots. [Demon]: A competent pilot wouldn't have had this happen.

[Demon]: So could they have done it? [Demon]: Apparently fucking not. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: But if they touched down with gear, they could have applied brakes. [Bigly]: They could have thrust reversers and they could have landed properly-ish. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Sage]: So still it would have been scary, but at least there'd be more than two people [Sage]: alive from that plane. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: The report also points blame to air traffic controllers for not informing the [Bigly]: pilots that their gear were up after they touched down on the runway. [Bigly]: Though I personally think that that is unfair because given all the conduct of the

[Bigly]: pilot up to that point, I don't think anything air traffic control said would have [Bigly]: changed any of the pilot's actions. [Sage]: No, they had their heads up their asses for sure. [Bigly]: So out of this, some revisions. [Bigly]: Crew are now explicitly forbidden to fly if they're fasting for Ramadan. [Bigly]: If they are fasting, they need to apply for leave. [Bigly]: Airlines are supposed to have operations due quality assurance. [Bigly]: And basically that's a program to review the data from as many flights as possible

[Bigly]: to check for flight behavior that is risky, dangerous, and outside of normal [Bigly]: operations so that any corrections that need to be made can be made. [Bigly]: Pakistan Airlines had this program, but it really wasn't a program. [Bigly]: Not even 5% of flights were ever analyzed. [Bigly]: Basically, until now, Captain Gull had flown 289 flights and only six of them were [Bigly]: ever reviewed. [Sage]: That's bonkers. [Bigly]: So they went back to look at his record.

[Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: Oh, no. [Bigly]: At the available data after this crash. [Bigly]: And they found that Gull would often make high speed, really steep descents. [Bigly]: They would often trigger aircraft warning systems. [Bigly]: And, you know, had this quality assurance program been active and actually being [Bigly]: effective, you know, these behaviors likely would have been corrected, identified [Bigly]: and fixed. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: I nipped that in the bud a long time ago. [Bigly]: But, yeah, I guess after the fact.

[Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So since then, this program has been stepped up. [Bigly]: However, you know, we're going to see if it makes any difference. [Sage]: Right. [Sage]: That was wild. [Sage]: That was a wild story. Wow. [Ood]: You know what? [Ood]: Listen to the co-pilots in your lives. [Bigly]: And the ground control. [Bigly]: Yes. [Bigly]: Yes, yes. [Bigly]: They might have something valuable to contribute. [Bigly]: They likely do. [Demon]: Don't fly commercial aircraft unless you have a commercial pilot's license. [Demon]: Also that. [Demon]: A real one. [Demon]: Yeah, not a fake one. [Demon]: I don't know if this dude did, but [Bigly]: it seems not a fucking matter.

[Bigly]: These pilots had real licenses. [Bigly]: They weren't part of the scandal. [Demon]: I would legitimately be encouraged. [Demon]: interested to see which had better flight miles like this fucker or the dudes that [Demon]: didn't actually have their pilots like [Ood]: yeah well that floors me like the people that got other people take their exams you [Ood]: know you're gonna have to fly a plane at one point right yeah like why would you [Ood]: why would you fake that [Bigly]: that is a pretty big thing to fake [Sage]: god that's so wild [Bigly]: all right so with that i am richard bigley

[Ood]: Old Gallifrey. [Ood]: Sage Murray. [Sage]: Yeah, I've been [Demon]: the soundboard demon. [Ood]: All right, love you, bye. [Ood]: Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Case #238: Real Life Werewolves

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 13 minAudio

    Join Richard as he does a sequel to his "Real life Vampires" episode. Where we learn the terrifying truth that real people in history have been executed under suspicion from the powerful that they were wolves. Also,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Case #237: Ten Dumb Cryptids

    Nov 6, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    We needed a lighter episode. So lets talk about ten of the dumbest cryptids Ood and sage could research. Today, on Ovpod, get your Dong Wrangled,learn how to avoid mountain whales, meet the crying ballsack cryptid,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Case #236: PISS

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    An unavoidable follow-up to our poop episode, here, Arthur guides us through a river of PISS. What high end product is forged in piss? Can Aged urine cure insomnia? How do mice pee? Does a kidney stone gather moss? All...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Case #235: Formula One Racing

    Oct 16, 20261 hr 39 minAudio

    Remember, if a loophole in a rule exists, it was put there to gain leads one second at a time. Formula One is a world wide, single seat, engineering arms race to build the highest performing racecars on earth. Hear a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Case #234: Real Life Vampires

    Oct 13, 20261 hr 50 minAudio

    In Ages past, in the long long ago, humanity used to believe in cannibalistic demon men that preyed on the bodies of men. Too bad things haven't changed very much. Join Richard Bigly has he leads the ovpod crew through...

    Credit the people on this episode