Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Occultae Veritatis Podcast - OVPOD

Occultae Veritatis Podcast - OVPOD artwork

Case # 165a: Climate Change: Is it too late?

Nov 8, 20211 hr 13 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Case # 165b: Climate Change: Is it too late? The hosts have a existential crisis over the future of humanity. Join in as Ood guides everyone through the evidence of climate change happening on a mass and rapid scale. Let us look into the inevitable future that is paved before all of us. -Sponsored by- Our Patrons at http://www.patreon.com/ovpod https://www.ovpod.ca/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[Bigly]: You know, if we would have just extracted oil using nukes, that would probably save [Bigly]: the environment a whole lot, wouldn't it? [Bigly]: I think so. [Ood]: Or the environment would just be gone. [Bigly]: And there'd be way less greenhouse gases to have [Intro]: to contend with. [Intro]: If all the humans get radiation sickness, we die off, the Earth recovers. [Bigly]: The humans are dead. [Bigly]: The humans are dead. [Ood]: I think we should equip all vehicles with a couple of twin flamethrowers coming out [Ood]: the top just so we can burn that gasoline a little faster. [Ood]: Accelerationist. [Bigly]: I think so. [Bigly]: Good idea.

[Intro]: Warning, this podcast contains violence, sexuality, gore, and other horrible and [Intro]: disturbing things. [Intro]: Listener discretion is advised. [Intro]: Also, the hosts of this venture are ignorant dipshits, so please do not take [Intro]: anything they say as fact, and enjoy the show. [Intro]: Now, are you sitting comfortably? [Intro]: Good, then we'll begin. [Intro]: Today we had 15 homicides and 63 violent crimes, as if that's the way it's supposed

[Intro]: to be! [Intro]: It is our basic human right to be fucked up! [Intro]: A second plane now has crashed into the other tower of the World Trade Center. [Intro]: Putting chemicals in the water that turned the friggin' frogs gay! [Intro]: The defendant shall be incarcerated for the rest of her natural life with no [Intro]: possibility of parole. [Intro]: You are not machines! [Intro]: You are not cattle! [Intro]: You are men! [Intro]: We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began [Intro]: to take hold. [Intro]: Occulte Veritatis.

[Ood]: Hello and welcome back to Occulte Veritatis podcast. [Ood]: I am Ood Gallifrey and in live recording with me, Sage Murray, Richard Bigley, [Arthur]: the soundboard demon, Don Kessler, and Tori. [Ood]: So I'm going to be a stereotypical millennial here. [Ood]: I think researching this episode in abject horror over the future of humanity was [Ood]: captured best by modern-day philosopher Bo Burnham. [Ood]: You say the ocean's rising, like I give a shit. [Ood]: You say the horror world's ending, honey, it already did.

[Ood]: You're not gonna slow it, heaven knows you tried. [Ood]: Got it, good, now get inside. [Ood]: The reality is, is we don't respect our power and we aren't responsible with it. [SPEAKER_43]: Millions of years worth of energy from the [Ood]: sun has been captured in the form of fossil fuels. [Ood]: And in a few short hundred years, we of a species have decided to release it all in

[Ood]: one giant global warming fire. [Ood]: This is a trolley problem with all of humanity tied to the tracks. [Ood]: Things are looking bleak and even the best case scenario is heartbreaking. [Ood]: This is going to be a rough one. [Ood]: We need some poison. [SPEAKER_32]: Come now, pray for me, I'll say get your fucking hand up.

[Ood]: Today we have a splunt and a bliff. [Ood]: As you all know, a splunt is a cigar casing or something that looks like a cigar [Ood]: casing that's filled with weed. [Ood]: And a bliff is the same thing except mixed with some tobacco. [Ood]: So we're going to try one of each. [Arthur]: Specifically, this bliff is made with almost 100-year-old smoking tobacco. [Arthur]: I believe it is 95 as of this year. [Ood]: Wow. [SPEAKER_43]: Happy birthday. [SPEAKER_43]: Oh, wow. [Arthur]: This isn't the first time it's been smoked.

[Ood]: So I'm going to light the Bliff first, and then I'm going to pass it down the line. [Bigly]: That's a splunt, you say? [Ood]: It's a splunt? [Ood]: Yeah, mixed with tobacco. [Arthur]: No, the splunt is in a cigar casing. [Arthur]: You're currently lighting the Bliff, which is... [Ood]: Oh, I should be better prepared because these kick my ass. [Ood]: Sorry, the first one passed around is the splunt that is the cannabis in a cigar [Ood]: casing. [SPEAKER_43]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_43]: Which has a little bit of tobacco in it. [SPEAKER_43]: There's something timelessly classy about a good splunt. [Arthur]: Fuck. [Arthur]: Cliff, splunt. [SPEAKER_43]: Got that.

[Arthur]: Which one is it, though? [Arthur]: Because you have the splunt. [Bigly]: That's the splunt, yeah. [Bigly]: Splunt. [Bigly]: See, I'm going to have to say I'm partial to the Splunt, as it appears Oud is as [Bigly]: well. [Bigly]: It just feels fancy. [Sage]: It definitely feels fancy. [Sage]: I don't think I've ever felt so fancy in my life. [Bigly]: Were there any other enhancements provided? [Bigly]: Oils? [Bigly]: Extracts? [Ood]: Yeah, the hit's pretty hard and quick. [Ood]: Just like global warming. [SPEAKER_17]: Just like global warming. [Ood]: Believe me, a hundred years is going to seem like a blink of an eye when things get

[Ood]: bad. [Arthur]: Hard and quick is also how Richard Bigley's wife referred to him the other day. [Bigly]: Yeah, it's true. [Bigly]: In your episode about carbon release, here we are, burning carbon. [Ood]: Yep. [Ood]: You know. [Bigly]: But it's sustainable. [Bigly]: It's sustainable because we're just going to be using that carbon that we're [Bigly]: releasing now to help, you know, the crop... [Bigly]: The next crop to breathe, you know? [Bigly]: It's really just a carbon neutral process, I think, right now.

[Ood]: I think so. [Ood]: If we can reduce people's emissions a little bit by them listening to this episode, [Ood]: maybe we can cover the greenhouse gases that we're putting out right now. [Bigly]: Grow weed. [Bigly]: It'll help, you know, take in some of that greenhouse gas. [Ood]: Legit. [Ood]: Weed is a carbon hog, and it has a fuckload of flour, so bees love it. [Ood]: Double whammy. [SPEAKER_43]: Splunt, you mean, or the Bliff? [SPEAKER_43]: Yeah, Spliff. [SPEAKER_43]: Very fancy. [SPEAKER_43]: Splunt. [SPEAKER_43]: The big one. [Ood]: The Bliff. [SPEAKER_43]: The Bliff.

[SPEAKER_26]: I like the skinny one. [SPEAKER_26]: I liked them both. [SPEAKER_26]: They were both... [SPEAKER_26]: The Bliff. [Ood]: I like the other taste better. [Ood]: When you add tobacco, it really kicks my ass. [Ood]: So I think I prefer the classic... [Ood]: Splunt. [Bigly]: And I can assure our listeners that the cough is not COVID related. [Arthur]: Yes. [Arthur]: It's true. [Arthur]: If you were signed up to the Patreon, you might have remembered that at the [Arthur]: beginning of this episode or this series of episodes, recording night, we indeed [Arthur]: took COVID-19. [Arthur]: Tests.

[Bigly]: We took COVID-19. [Bigly]: Yeah, we just put it in little lines and just right up the nose, you know? [Arthur]: I'm getting that contact high from you guys. [Ood]: And if you're my neighbor and you've been hearing me cough for months and you're [Ood]: wondering why I'm not dead yet, it's because I just have a chronic dry cough. [Ood]: That's why that is. [Ood]: Chronic. [Bigly]: She treats with marijuana. [Arthur]: I do. [Arthur]: Chronic something velociraptors? [Ood]: Yeah, I have micro velociraptors attacking my avioli in my lungs. [Ood]: Carnifax infection syndrome or something?

[Ood]: I don't know. [Arthur]: Is Carnifax a 40K thing? [Arthur]: Carnifax is a 40K. [Arthur]: Son of a bitch. [Ood]: It's in my head. [Arthur]: You're mixing up [Sage]: your... Oh, goody. [Sage]: Mixing up your nerder. [SPEAKER_43]: You are patient zero of this gene stealer cult. [SPEAKER_43]: Enjoy. [Ood]: I mean, I look pretty human. [Ood]: I'm probably a pretty far-long generation of gene stealer. [Arthur]: Side note, a previous episode, someone had mentioned the militant order. [Arthur]: And I was like, oh, like the Adeptus Sororitus is the militant order of the [Arthur]: ecclesiarchy. [Arthur]: And then I realized that that would not make for good podcasts. [Ood]: Now that my lungs have been invaded with harmful gases, let's talk about us doing

[Ood]: the same thing to the Earth. [Sage]: Nice segue. [SPEAKER_54]: That's how the Earth feels, guys. [SPEAKER_43]: Nice. [SPEAKER_05]: All right. [SPEAKER_05]: Greta, your first climate strike was a lonely event a little over a year ago. [SPEAKER_05]: And in the intervening time, you have sparked the interest of millions, literally, [SPEAKER_05]: of children around the globe demanding action for climate change. [SPEAKER_05]: What's your message to world leaders today?

[SPEAKER_45]: My message is that we'll be watching you. [SPEAKER_45]: This is all wrong. [SPEAKER_45]: I shouldn't be up here. [SPEAKER_45]: I should be back in school on the other side of the ocean. [SPEAKER_45]: Yet you all come to us young people for hope. [SPEAKER_45]: How dare you? [SPEAKER_45]: You have stolen my dreams and my childhood with your empty words, and yet I'm one

[SPEAKER_45]: of the lucky ones. [SPEAKER_45]: People are suffering. [SPEAKER_45]: People are dying. [SPEAKER_45]: Entire ecosystems are collapsing. [SPEAKER_45]: We are in the beginning of a mass extinction, and all you can talk about is money [SPEAKER_45]: and fairy tales of eternal economic growth. [SPEAKER_45]: How dare you? [SPEAKER_45]: For more than 30 years, the science has been crystal clear.

[SPEAKER_45]: How dare you continue to look away and come here saying that you're doing enough [SPEAKER_45]: when the politics and solutions needed are still nowhere in sight. [SPEAKER_45]: You say you hear us and that you understand the urgency. [SPEAKER_45]: But no matter how sad and angry I am, I do not want to believe that. [SPEAKER_45]: Because if you really understood the situation and still kept on failing to act,

[SPEAKER_45]: then you would be evil and that I refuse to believe. [SPEAKER_45]: The popular idea of cutting our emissions in half in 10 years only gives us a 50% [SPEAKER_45]: chance of staying below 1.5 degrees and the risk of setting off irreversible chain [SPEAKER_45]: reactions beyond human control. [SPEAKER_45]: 50% may be acceptable to you. [SPEAKER_45]: But those numbers do not include tipping points, most feedback loops, additional

[SPEAKER_45]: warming hidden by toxic air pollution or the aspects of equity and climate justice. [SPEAKER_45]: They also rely on my generation sucking hundreds of billions of tons of your CO2 [SPEAKER_45]: out of the air with technologies that barely exist. [SPEAKER_45]: So a 50% risk is simply not acceptable to us, we who have to live with the [SPEAKER_45]: consequences. [SPEAKER_45]: To have a 67% chance of staying below a 1.5 degrees of global temperature rise, the

[SPEAKER_45]: best odds given by the IPCC, the world had 420 gigatons of CO2 left to emit back on [SPEAKER_45]: January 1st, 2018. [SPEAKER_45]: Today, that figure is already down to less than 350 gigatons. [SPEAKER_45]: How dare you pretend that this can be sold with just business as usual and some [SPEAKER_45]: technical solutions? [SPEAKER_45]: With today's emissions levels, that remaining CO2 budget will be entirely gone

[SPEAKER_45]: within less than eight and a half years. [SPEAKER_45]: There will not be any solutions or plans presented in line with these figures here [SPEAKER_45]: today because these numbers are too uncomfortable and you are still not mature [SPEAKER_45]: enough to tell it like it is. [SPEAKER_45]: You are failing us, but the young people are starting to understand your betrayal. [SPEAKER_45]: The eyes of all future generations are upon you.

[SPEAKER_45]: And if you choose to fail us, I say we will never forgive you. [SPEAKER_45]: We will not let you get away with this. [SPEAKER_45]: Right here, right now, is where we draw the line. [SPEAKER_45]: The world is waking up. [SPEAKER_45]: And change is coming whether you like it or not. [SPEAKER_45]: Thank you.

[Ood]: So, hundreds of millions of years ago, and today, but mostly hundreds of millions [Ood]: of years ago, plants turned sunlight into sugar and starch. [Ood]: Other animals ate that sugar and starch and stored that energy in their bodies. [Ood]: These plants and animals died in mass, their matter collected underground, and was [Ood]: trapped there. [Ood]: And over millions of years, their bodies were turned into oil, gas, coal, and other [Ood]: fossil fuels. [Ood]: And humans started to fuck with fossil fuels almost immediately.

[Ood]: Bitumen, a crude oil product, was used as a binding agent in ancient Greece. [Ood]: In 500 BC, when China was digging in old salt wells, they found that a few of them [Ood]: had oil at the bottom. [Ood]: And they extracted that oil to be used in lamps in 500 BC. [Ood]: But the widespread use of fossil fuels worldwide in all developed countries started [Ood]: mostly with the birth of the Industrial Revolution in the late 1800s. [SPEAKER_10]: Petroleum was thought to be good for rheumatism or for arthritis or as an eye

[SPEAKER_10]: salve, various kinds of medicinal uses. [SPEAKER_11]: As long as petroleum was limited to use as an ointment or toothache remedy, there [SPEAKER_11]: was little reason for men to spend much time searching for it. [SPEAKER_11]: A few hundred gallons skimmed off pools each year more than met the demand. [SPEAKER_11]: But the discovery of kerosene changed all that. [SPEAKER_11]: In 1852 a Canadian inventor named Abraham Gessner discovered how to make kerosene

[SPEAKER_11]: from crude petroleum. [SPEAKER_11]: In an age when candles and whale oil provided the only light after sundown, it was [SPEAKER_11]: a dramatic discovery. [SPEAKER_11]: Borrowing a page from alcohol distillers, Gessner used a primitive still type [SPEAKER_11]: system to distill and refine crude petroleum by heating it and separating its [SPEAKER_11]: various elements. [SPEAKER_11]: One of those elements was kerosene, which he found burned longer and cleaner than

[SPEAKER_11]: whale oil. [SPEAKER_02]: The superiority of kerosene was not only in the fact that it was a better [SPEAKER_02]: illuminant, but it was ever so much cheaper. [SPEAKER_02]: Whale oil was getting extremely costly. [SPEAKER_02]: Town gas, for example, about 1860, you could light your house with town gas for [SPEAKER_02]: about $10 a month. [SPEAKER_02]: You could light your house with kerosene for $10 a year. [SPEAKER_11]: Within a year of Gessner's discovery, his kerosene works was producing 5,000 [SPEAKER_11]: gallons a day, and the need for more crude petroleum became critical.

[SPEAKER_11]: By 1859, 34 start-up companies were producing $5 million worth of kerosene [SPEAKER_11]: annually. [SPEAKER_11]: The rush to find oil, and with it, huge fortunes, was on. [Ood]: Street lamps, hand lamps, heating in homes and businesses dominated major cities. [Ood]: And with a lot of humanity starting to industrialize, humanity started to consume [Ood]: millions of barrels of oil per day and burn tons and tons of coal every year.

[Ood]: Today, it's grown to a huge degree. [Ood]: We burn about 15 billion tons of fossil fuels every year. [Ood]: 54% of that is used in three countries. [Ood]: China, the United States, and India. [Ood]: The main culprits to blame for these emissions are corporations. [Ood]: Giant companies that put profit as a first priority and in doing so threaten the [Ood]: future of the planet. [Ood]: Just how badly are these corporations to blame?

[Ood]: You can take just 100 companies... [Ood]: that exist on Earth today, and those 100 companies are directly responsible for 70% [Ood]: of all greenhouse gas emissions in the atmosphere. [Ood]: 70% to just 100 companies. [Ood]: And of course, the leaders of the pack are big petroleum companies, ExxonMobil, BP, [Ood]: and Chevron. [SPEAKER_29]: Dr. Garvey and Dr. Hofford, is climate change real? [SPEAKER_48]: Climate change has been taking place over all geologic history.

[SPEAKER_48]: Climate change from fossil fuels is not only real, but it is happening at much [SPEAKER_48]: higher rates than we have recorded in the geologic record. [SPEAKER_48]: Thank you, Mr. Hufford. [SPEAKER_48]: So there is no doubt about that. [SPEAKER_29]: Thank you, Mr. Hufford. [SPEAKER_29]: I apologize. [SPEAKER_29]: I have to be expeditious with how I ask these questions. [SPEAKER_29]: Dr. Garvey, would you agree? [SPEAKER_01]: Yes, I would. [SPEAKER_29]: Are large corporations' use of fossil fuels one of the primary causes of climate [SPEAKER_29]: change that we're seeing today? [SPEAKER_48]: Yes, is the simple answer.

[SPEAKER_48]: Same here. [SPEAKER_48]: Yes. [SPEAKER_29]: And how long has there been roughly a scientific consensus surrounding those two [SPEAKER_29]: facts? [SPEAKER_48]: I would say roughly 20 years, and that consensus is of actively working scientists [SPEAKER_48]: who publish in peer-reviewed journals. [SPEAKER_29]: Thank you. [SPEAKER_29]: And we have documents going back decades showing specifically that ExxonMobil or [SPEAKER_29]: Exxon knew about climate change. [SPEAKER_29]: In 1977, Exxon scientist James Black told Exxon's top executives that, quote, the

[SPEAKER_29]: most likely manner in which mankind is influencing the global climate is through [SPEAKER_29]: carbon dioxide released from the burning of fossil fuels. [SPEAKER_29]: This was in 1977. [SPEAKER_29]: This was followed by an internal memo in 1979, which stated that, quote, the [SPEAKER_29]: present trend of fossil fuel consumption will cause dramatic environmental effects [SPEAKER_29]: before the year 2050. [SPEAKER_29]: Dr. Garvey, would you say that the folks you worked with at Exxon agreed with the [SPEAKER_29]: consensus on climate change?

[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, hardly. [SPEAKER_29]: Dr. Hoffert? [SPEAKER_48]: I can testify to after 1981 because I was working at Exxon with a group that was [SPEAKER_48]: doing the calculations. [SPEAKER_48]: And of course, we didn't know that. [SPEAKER_29]: Understood. [SPEAKER_29]: Dr. Hoffert, your work with Exxon was focused on the carbon cycle and climate [SPEAKER_29]: modeling. [SPEAKER_29]: I have a slide up here. [SPEAKER_29]: Are you familiar with this graph from 1982? [SPEAKER_29]: Yes. [SPEAKER_48]: I believe I am, but oh, I just saw the graph. [SPEAKER_48]: Yeah, that is a calculation.

[SPEAKER_48]: I'm not sure who specifically to attribute it to. [SPEAKER_48]: It could have been done by either of the researchers I was working with. [SPEAKER_29]: Can you briefly explain what it shows? [SPEAKER_29]: Sure. [SPEAKER_48]: What it shows is a projection into the future of carbon dioxide levels and [SPEAKER_48]: climate change associated with those carbon dioxide levels coming from fossil [SPEAKER_48]: fuels. [SPEAKER_48]: I don't have time for a detailed explanation, but that's it.

[SPEAKER_48]: And it's a very accurate representation of what today's climate change actually is. [SPEAKER_29]: So this was a model from 1982 with startlingly accurate projections into the [SPEAKER_29]: present. [SPEAKER_29]: That's correct. [SPEAKER_29]: The orange line shows the actual level of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere through [SPEAKER_29]: this year. [SPEAKER_29]: And the blue line shows the actual average temperature change. [SPEAKER_29]: So in 1982, Exxon accurately, 1982, seven years before I was even born,

[SPEAKER_29]: Exxon accurately predicted that by this year, 2019, the Earth would hit a carbon [SPEAKER_29]: dioxide concentration of 415 parts per million and a temperature increase of one [SPEAKER_29]: degree Celsius. [SPEAKER_29]: Dr. Hoffert, is that correct? [SPEAKER_48]: We were excellent scientists. [SPEAKER_29]: Yes, you were. [SPEAKER_29]: Yes, you were. [SPEAKER_29]: So they knew. [SPEAKER_29]: They knew. [SPEAKER_29]: And I presume they knew what some of the consequences of that one degree Celsius

[SPEAKER_29]: change would be. [SPEAKER_29]: Some of them, not all. [SPEAKER_48]: Absolutely. [SPEAKER_48]: I would like to have an opportunity to discuss that if someone asks me. [SPEAKER_29]: Dr. Hoffert, you have previously said that Exxon's historic denial was immoral and [SPEAKER_29]: greatly set back efforts to address climate change. [SPEAKER_29]: That's correct. [SPEAKER_29]: Yes? [SPEAKER_48]: It is correct that I said that. [SPEAKER_48]: I have good reason to say it. [SPEAKER_29]: And in 1998, API's Global Science Communications Team Action Plan, which involved [SPEAKER_29]: Exxon, Chevron, Southern Company, and more, laid out the industry's denial

[SPEAKER_29]: campaign. [SPEAKER_29]: They knew that they were going to dump unknown, at that time, amounts of money, but [SPEAKER_29]: a large investment in a climate denial and doubt campaign in the United States and [SPEAKER_29]: around the world, correct? Correct. [SPEAKER_48]: That's my, to the best of my knowledge, that's true. [SPEAKER_48]: But I didn't know of that personally. [SPEAKER_29]: They said victory would be achieved when, quote, average citizens, quote, unquote, [SPEAKER_29]: understand uncertainties in climate science. [SPEAKER_29]: Dr. Garvey, would you say these goals accurately represent the mission of Exxon in

[SPEAKER_29]: the past and today? [SPEAKER_01]: None in the past, certainly not when I was there. [SPEAKER_29]: Would you say that currently the current environment that is fostered around doubt [SPEAKER_29]: on scientific consensus could be a result of lobbying from the fossil fuel [SPEAKER_29]: industry? [SPEAKER_01]: I would say so, but I should let my cohort, you should answer that. [SPEAKER_29]: Sure. [SPEAKER_29]: Dr. Oreskes? [SPEAKER_29]: 350 pages on that in my book, Merchants of Doubt. [SPEAKER_29]: Thank you very much. [Ood]: All right. [Ood]: There's thousands of ships in the sea and planes in the air carrying commercial

[Ood]: goods that burn millions of gallons of fuel every year. [Ood]: There's 97 million vehicles worldwide that consume petroleum and expel greenhouse [Ood]: gases. [Ood]: Billions of gallons of cement are laid every year. [Ood]: Not a lot of people know this, but the curing process for cement releases a [Ood]: fuckload of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. [Ood]: Oh, man.

[SPEAKER_36]: Meat's footprint begins when grains are grown and transported to livestock to be [SPEAKER_36]: eaten. [SPEAKER_36]: Once the meat from the livestock is harvested, it must be distributed around the [SPEAKER_36]: country and even around the world. [SPEAKER_36]: One of the biggest impacts is water. [SPEAKER_42]: One hamburger, depending on who you ask, again, ranges anywhere from 440 gallons [SPEAKER_42]: per hamburger of water [SPEAKER_42]: to produce up to 800 gallons. [SPEAKER_42]: Well, these animals are born and they need to grow and they need to sustain [SPEAKER_42]: themselves. [SPEAKER_42]: We need to give them water. [SPEAKER_42]: We need to water the crops that they eat.

[SPEAKER_42]: We need to [SPEAKER_36]: hose down after slaughter. [SPEAKER_36]: Livestock produce methane as they digest their food. [SPEAKER_36]: Then their manure produces even more methane as it decomposes. [SPEAKER_36]: Methane is 30 times more potent than carbon dioxide as a heat-trapping gas for the [SPEAKER_36]: planet. [SPEAKER_36]: That means meat production contributes to climate change, which in turn contributes [SPEAKER_36]: to the world's ongoing water crisis. [SPEAKER_36]: Climate change causes an increasing number of droughts and prolonged dry seasons. [SPEAKER_36]: It also during rainy seasons creates precipitation to often come in more condensed

[SPEAKER_36]: bursts. [SPEAKER_36]: These bursts make it more difficult for the land to absorb water. [SPEAKER_36]: Water is also absorbed less by land that is deforested. [SPEAKER_42]: 40% of the world's land mass is occupied by livestock production. [SPEAKER_36]: When forests are cut down to make room for animals, it's a triple whammy. [SPEAKER_36]: Greenhouse gases are released into the atmosphere, there are less plants to take in [SPEAKER_36]: carbon dioxide, and now animal production will increase the carbon footprint. [Ood]: 2.2 billion tons of organic trash is thrown into landfills to rot and produce

[Ood]: methane. [Ood]: And many of our current agricultural processes also release greenhouse gases. [Ood]: We are collectively as a species liberating millions of years worth of collected [Ood]: carbon and energy into the atmosphere in only a few hundred years of our history. [Ood]: And just like a beaver can turn a stream into a swamp, [Ood]: the collective action of billions of humans or more accurately a few hundred [Ood]: corporations and powerful people is quickly and drastically changing the earth [Ood]: let's do a quick course on the greenhouse effect if earth had no atmosphere it

[Ood]: would be very cold we'd be getting the exact same amount of sunlight but the heat [Ood]: from that sudden light wouldn't be held on our planet [Ood]: The rocks don't hold heat very well. [Ood]: The trees don't hold heat very well. [Ood]: Even the water in the ocean doesn't really hold heat that well if it's just allowed [Ood]: to strike it. [Ood]: Most of the radiative heat that would come from the sun would just bounce off the [Ood]: Earth and go back into space. [Ood]: But we have a bit of an atmosphere, which means that when radiation from the sun [Ood]: comes in, some of it is trapped in our atmosphere and the heat is allowed to

[Ood]: dissipate throughout our atmosphere and warm up the planet. [Ood]: But we're starting to see the other side of that. [Ood]: We have essentially put a chemical blanket around the Earth that insulates the [Ood]: planet and traps thermal heat to a point where all the extra energy is having bad [Ood]: effects. [Ood]: There are many fragile systems working together to make the Earth a habitable place [Ood]: for humans. [Ood]: One of them is an appropriate level of greenhouse gases to keep things warm, but [Ood]: not too much as to plunge the world climate into chaos. [Ood]: And unfortunately, we're hurtling in the direction for chaos.

[Ood]: Something that adds to this is the fact that at the time of the Industrial [Ood]: Revolution, we weren't all that far away from that tipping point to begin with. [Ood]: We were at this whole time from the birth of the Industrial Revolution throughout [Ood]: the history of humanity about two degrees Celsius away from the tipping point. [Ood]: And we're already about a degree and a half of the ways there since the late 1800s. [SPEAKER_39]: Global warming or none like

[SPEAKER_39]: it hot. [SPEAKER_39]: Meet Mr. Sunbeam. [SPEAKER_39]: He comes all the way from the sun to visit Earth. [SPEAKER_54]: Hello, Earth. [SPEAKER_54]: Just popping in to brighten your day. [SPEAKER_54]: La, la, la, la, la, la, la. [SPEAKER_54]: And now I'll be on my way. [SPEAKER_38]: Not so fast, Sunbeam. [SPEAKER_38]: We're greenhouse gases. [SPEAKER_38]: You ain't going nowhere. [SPEAKER_39]: Pretty soon, Earth is chock full of sunbeams.

[SPEAKER_39]: They're rotting corpses heating our atmosphere. [SPEAKER_14]: How do we get rid of the greenhouse grasses? [SPEAKER_39]: Fortunately, our handsomest politicians came up with a cheap, last-minute way to [SPEAKER_39]: combat global warming. [SPEAKER_39]: Ever since 2063, we simply drop a giant ice cube into the ocean every now and then. [SPEAKER_14]: Just like Daddy puts in his drink every morning. [SPEAKER_14]: And then he gets mad. [SPEAKER_39]: Of course, since the greenhouse gases are still building up, it takes more and more

[SPEAKER_39]: ice each time. [SPEAKER_39]: Thus solving the problem once and for all. [SPEAKER_39]: But... Once and for all! [Ood]: So here is the evidence for global warming. [Ood]: Number one, global temperature rise. [Ood]: Since the year 1900, the global temperature of the Earth has increased by 1.18 [Ood]: degrees Celsius. [Ood]: About 70% of that warming has occurred in the last 40 years. [Ood]: The top 10 hottest years on record, going back all the way to 1880, have happened

[Ood]: after 2005. [Ood]: The source of this warming is the classic greenhouse effect. [SPEAKER_03]: Quick question to start off. [SPEAKER_03]: If 2020 is the hottest year on record, how does this change the way we should be [SPEAKER_03]: approaching climate change right now? [SPEAKER_13]: You know, it's an interesting question. [SPEAKER_13]: I think, if anything, it really brings home how immediate the problem of climate [SPEAKER_13]: change has to be. [SPEAKER_13]: You know, and it's happening right now. [SPEAKER_13]: It's no longer abstract. [SPEAKER_13]: It's very, very much a present tense issue. [SPEAKER_03]: You're right. [SPEAKER_03]: I think the reality of the situation has been one of the struggles to get across,

[SPEAKER_03]: at least from my view. [SPEAKER_03]: But we also had a record Atlantic storm season this year. [SPEAKER_03]: And bringing those two together, I read a meteorologist in our ESG Daily yesterday [SPEAKER_03]: said that we have entered a new climate. [SPEAKER_03]: Can you describe to us what this new climate looks like? [SPEAKER_13]: Well, I think that as we saw with the record-breaking hurricane season that you [SPEAKER_13]: just mentioned, as well as things like the California wildfires way back in [SPEAKER_13]: January, the bushfires in Australia,

[SPEAKER_13]: Also, less remarked upon, but we're in the middle still of a record-breaking fire [SPEAKER_13]: season in the Amazon again after last year's devastating fires. [SPEAKER_13]: So I think these are all examples of what we'll see from, I think, what this [SPEAKER_13]: meteorologist was referring to, which is just a lot more volatility. [SPEAKER_13]: We've said in pieces earlier this year that we're not headed for just a new [SPEAKER_13]: baseline. [SPEAKER_13]: There is no new normal. [SPEAKER_13]: The new normal is lack of normal. [SPEAKER_13]: sudden storms, more intense storms, more intense droughts, fatal levels of heat.

[SPEAKER_13]: And we're going to see these things not only more frequently around the world, but [SPEAKER_13]: in less predictable fashion. [SPEAKER_13]: Another thing that has broke records about this [SPEAKER_13]: hurricane season is that we saw storms intensifying really, really rapidly as they [SPEAKER_13]: approach the shore, which makes it much harder for people to prepare for them. [SPEAKER_13]: When you've got a storm that looks like it's going to be pretty slow moving one [SPEAKER_13]: day, and then less than 24 hours later, you find out that it's going to be a pretty [SPEAKER_13]: fatal hurricane, as happened with Hurricane Laura, there's not much you can do.

[SPEAKER_13]: People can't evacuate at that point. [SPEAKER_13]: It's too late to do a lot of the things that we would normally regard as sensible [SPEAKER_13]: preparations. [SPEAKER_13]: So yeah, so as the temperature continues to increase, as the amount of carbon [SPEAKER_13]: dioxide in the atmosphere continues to grow, we'll just see more of this [SPEAKER_13]: volatility. [Ood]: Number two, the warming of the oceans. [Ood]: The Earth ends up storing about 90% of its extra thermal energy in the oceans. [Ood]: So, of all the thermal energy that comes into the planet, about 90% of it is stored

[Ood]: in the oceans. [Ood]: This thermal energy guides global weather. [Ood]: It generates hurricanes and other mass weather events. [Ood]: This energy can help ocean life thrive in small doses... [Ood]: But in larger doses, oceans warming over centuries instead of hundreds of thousands [Ood]: of years will kill the ocean instead of feed it. [Ood]: So this little bit of energy we're putting into the ocean, it's beneficial. [Ood]: It gives a higher biodiversity of life.

[Ood]: but it's getting close to the point where it's becoming too hot to sustain life. [Ood]: Since 1969, the temperature of the ocean has risen by about 0.3 degrees Celsius. [Ood]: They may not sound like a lot, [Ood]: But heating the entire ocean by that amount is the equivalent of releasing 26 [Ood]: billion Hiroshima nuclear bombs into the ocean. [Ood]: So imagine lining up 26 billion of these things. [Ood]: That's the amount of energy you would take to warm the ocean up by that degree.

[Ood]: This is causing ocean acidification. [SPEAKER_24]: We knew that... [SPEAKER_24]: we were burning things to make energy and that carbon dioxide, some of it was [SPEAKER_24]: ending up in the oceans. [SPEAKER_24]: And for many people that was seen as a good thing. [SPEAKER_24]: What we're recognizing is that there are changes in the composition in the oceans [SPEAKER_37]: In the last 150 years, as CO2 has increased in the atmosphere, the pH of ocean [SPEAKER_37]: surface waters has dropped by around 0.1 pH unit.

[SPEAKER_37]: That's a 26% increase in ocean acidity. [SPEAKER_37]: And the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change predicts an additional drop of [SPEAKER_37]: 0.2 to 0.3 pH units by the end of the century. [SPEAKER_37]: That's a 100 to 150% increase in ocean acidity since before the Industrial [SPEAKER_37]: Revolution. [SPEAKER_37]: As the ocean becomes more acidic, it makes it harder for marine animals that build [SPEAKER_37]: their shells out of calcium carbonate, like corals and oysters.

[SPEAKER_37]: At the University of California, Santa Barbara, scientists are studying the effects [SPEAKER_37]: of higher CO2 on sea urchins. [SPEAKER_23]: We mix the carbon dioxide into our seawater tanks to mimic future high CO2 oceans, [SPEAKER_23]: levels that we thought we'd go to in 100 years or something. [SPEAKER_23]: And we do start to see effects at those high numbers in terms of slowing down their [SPEAKER_23]: growth. [SPEAKER_23]: They are a little bit smaller at any time in development. [SPEAKER_23]: And also there's some effects on fertilization, we think, when water gets really

[SPEAKER_23]: acidic. [SPEAKER_37]: Not far off the coast of UC Santa Barbara, ocean acidification could have a direct [SPEAKER_37]: impact on people who make their living harvesting sea urchins. [SPEAKER_19]: My name's Bruce Steele. [SPEAKER_19]: I'm a commercial sea urchin diver. [SPEAKER_19]: I work at the Channel Islands, which are right here off the coast. [SPEAKER_37]: The boom for sea urchin sushi started with the Japanese back in the 1980s. [SPEAKER_37]: Now the uni crop brings the state of California over $100 million a year and [SPEAKER_37]: provides essential jobs to hundreds of divers and processors.

[SPEAKER_37]: But the changes to ocean chemistry have them worried. [SPEAKER_19]: The problems that we're seeing with animals like sea urchins or oysters are kind of [SPEAKER_19]: a harbinger of problems that might be going on in the open ocean. [SPEAKER_37]: Two recent events clearly show that ocean acidification has already arrived on [SPEAKER_37]: western shores and could have a direct impact on the seafood we eat. [SPEAKER_37]: In 2007, Science Magazine reported that surface water in places along the [SPEAKER_37]: California coast was already more acidic than researchers predicted.

[SPEAKER_37]: Around the same time, news reports started trickling in from oyster hatcheries in [SPEAKER_37]: Oregon and Washington state. [SPEAKER_37]: Millions of larvae were dying. [SPEAKER_37]: The culprit? [SPEAKER_37]: Ocean acidification. [SPEAKER_24]: It seemed that it was actually the change in the chemistry of the seawater that was [SPEAKER_24]: killing the larvae. [Ood]: This is causing the reduction of oxygen in the ocean. [Ood]: As water gets warmer, its capacity to hold oxygen gets less and less. [Ood]: So that means that as the oceans warm up, fish are going to start to die because

[Ood]: they'll literally not be able to get oxygen from the water through their gills [Ood]: anymore. [Ood]: And evolution takes millions of years, not hundreds. [Ood]: So most fish species will not be able to adapt. [Ood]: And we're starting to see that. [Ood]: And also with the rising temperature of the water, it's changing the chemistry of [Ood]: the ocean. [Ood]: The ocean is becoming more acidic. [Ood]: And like I said before, evolution happens in millions of years, not hundreds. [Ood]: And coral reefs cannot keep up. [Bigly]: And it's – I mean we were seeing that this summer even locally here in Saskatchewan

[Bigly]: that – [Bigly]: A lot of dead fish were washing up on onto the lakes during that heat bubble that [Bigly]: crossed, you know, and that was the thing concerning the residents, understandably. [Bigly]: And they kind of explained that there was less less oxygen lower down. [Bigly]: So now they have to come up to the surface and it's too warm. [Bigly]: And that's what's causing causing these deaths. [Bigly]: So like we we can see this in real time in recent history. [Ood]: right now. [Ood]: Yeah, right in front of us. [Ood]: It isn't some hypothetical thing.

[Ood]: We're starting to see the bad parts of these events. [Ood]: And like I said before, that shows how fragile it is. [Ood]: A hot day can kill fish. [Ood]: Humanity started like 10 feet away from the finish line. [Ood]: We were almost at the tipping point at the start of our history, and a heat wave [Ood]: can kill fish. [Ood]: We're not all that far away from disaster, which is why this is scary. [SPEAKER_10]: Right now, it may be... [SPEAKER_16]: Colors bleach when the waters around them get too warm. [SPEAKER_16]: Something that's happening with increasing frequency and intensity as a consequence

[SPEAKER_16]: of global warming. [SPEAKER_35]: In big thermal extremes like we've been seeing during mass bleaching events in [SPEAKER_35]: recent decades, they can actually die very, very quickly. [SPEAKER_35]: They cook. [SPEAKER_35]: The footprint of a bleaching event is 10 times bigger than the most extreme [SPEAKER_35]: Category 5 tropical cyclone. [SPEAKER_35]: So they're off the scale in terms of the size of the impact and in terms of how [SPEAKER_35]: frequently they are occurring.

[SPEAKER_16]: Terry studies the Great Barrier Reef, the largest reef system in the world. [SPEAKER_16]: Bleaching events used to be localized and rare. [SPEAKER_16]: But over the past two decades, marine heat waves have caused widespread bleaching. [SPEAKER_16]: Three of the five biggest bleaching events have occurred in the past five years. [SPEAKER_35]: We're worried about that shrinking gap between one bleaching event and the next

[SPEAKER_35]: one. [SPEAKER_35]: We've already seen back-to-back bleaching events occur for the first time on the [SPEAKER_35]: Great Bear Reef in two consecutive summers in 2016 and 2017. [SPEAKER_16]: Those gaps are critically important if the corals are to recover. [SPEAKER_16]: Half the reef's corals have already died. [SPEAKER_16]: Terry's work involves conducting aerial surveys to record the extent of each [SPEAKER_16]: bleaching event.

[SPEAKER_35]: When we do our aerial surveys, we fly as slowly as we can, as low as we can, so we [SPEAKER_35]: can see individual corals and we can assess how many of them are bleached white or [SPEAKER_35]: not. [SPEAKER_40]: All the corals, please. [SPEAKER_40]: Yeah, look bad. [SPEAKER_35]: you can actually see a bleached reef from kilometers away because it virtually [SPEAKER_35]: glows. [SPEAKER_35]: There's so much white coral on it. [SPEAKER_51]: So it's got a very broad crest and just about everything's bleached.

[SPEAKER_35]: Those surveys have now been done five times and I have led three of those, the last [SPEAKER_35]: three in 2016, 2017, and 2020. [SPEAKER_35]: It's a job I'd hoped I'd never have to do. [SPEAKER_35]: because it's actually very confronting. [SPEAKER_16]: We're heading for the future in which the Great Ballet Reef is a coral graveyard. [SPEAKER_35]: The climate modelers are telling us, the biologists, that business as usual carbon

[SPEAKER_35]: emissions will result in back-to-back bleaching events every consecutive summer by [SPEAKER_35]: the end of this century. [SPEAKER_35]: We've gone past the tipping point for coral bleaching. [SPEAKER_35]: Scientists and ecologists like myself have been talking for decades now about [SPEAKER_35]: global warming. [SPEAKER_35]: And it has been frustrating that we haven't been listened to. [Ood]: Number three, the permafrost defrosting.

[Ood]: Permafrost covers 24% of the Earth's landmass, and it's permanently frozen Earth. [Ood]: Within this permafrost is millions of years' worth of trapped greenhouse gases. [Ood]: There is twice as much greenhouse gases trapped in the permafrost than currently [Ood]: exists in the atmosphere. [SPEAKER_26]: That's fucked. [Ood]: Uh-huh. [Ood]: And there is four times as much greenhouse gases trapped there as humanity has ever [Ood]: released. [Ood]: There's four times as much. [Ood]: So if the permafrost defrosts fully, it will release greenhouse gases that is four

[Ood]: times as much as humanity has put out thus far. [Bigly]: And that's like the big fucking thing now. [Bigly]: It's like that domino where now we put this thing in motion, this machine, this [Bigly]: carbon machine. [Bigly]: Now we put it in artificially, which tipped it. [Bigly]: And now nature itself is like... [Bigly]: fucking let's go and you know the permafrost melts and then you end up with like [Bigly]: massive massive forest fires of like old forest and that releases more carbon which [Bigly]: heats things more and like we've we've we've set this carbon machine in motion and

[Bigly]: like it's like [Bigly]: Fuck, you know? [Bigly]: I don't know. [Bigly]: It's hard for me to comprehend how fucked we are. [Ood]: Oh, yeah. [Ood]: And the number baffles me. [Ood]: You heard me at the start of the episode. [Ood]: We're burning billions of barrels of oil every year. [Ood]: And if the permafrost melts, we're getting four times the amount we've ever [Ood]: released. [Ood]: That's like taking a house fire and throwing a nuke on it. [Ood]: It's insane. [Ood]: If the global temperature... [Ood]: If the global rise in temperature hits three degrees Celsius or more, about 80% of

[Ood]: the permafrost will be on thawed. [Ood]: So that's the tipping point. [Ood]: Three degrees Celsius and billions of tons of greenhouse gases will push the [Ood]: warming of the earth into overdrive. [Arthur]: Thawed. [Arthur]: Thawed, yes. [Arthur]: Not unthawed. [Arthur]: Yeah, thawed. [Arthur]: Unthawed means frozen. [SPEAKER_47]: That's true. [SPEAKER_47]: My name's Ben Abbott. [SPEAKER_47]: I'm an ecosystem ecologist who studies the permafrost climate feedback. [SPEAKER_25]: Methane is a very potent greenhouse gas. [SPEAKER_25]: A molecule of methane is 25 times stronger than carbon dioxide.

[SPEAKER_25]: Methane is formed in millions of lakes around the Arctic where permafrost is [SPEAKER_25]: thawing. [SPEAKER_47]: The reason why we put things in the freezer is to keep them as they are. [SPEAKER_47]: We don't want them to rot and change. [SPEAKER_25]: And the soil contains the frozen remains of dead plants and animals, plants and [SPEAKER_25]: animals that lived tens of thousands of years ago. [SPEAKER_25]: And so when that ice melts and these lakes form, the soil thaws out and it becomes [SPEAKER_25]: food for microbes that generate greenhouse gases, carbon dioxide and methane.

[SPEAKER_47]: It's widely accepted that it's probably the largest terrestrial feedback to climate [SPEAKER_47]: change. [SPEAKER_47]: So all of the Earth systems on land, we think it has the largest potential to [SPEAKER_47]: accelerate human emissions or amplify human emissions. [SPEAKER_25]: We are standing at the threshold of unprecedented change since the last glacial [SPEAKER_25]: maximum. [SPEAKER_47]: The permafrost system has never seen, at least in recent history, change of this [SPEAKER_47]: magnitude this quickly.

[SPEAKER_25]: So if we had 1.6 degrees warming 10,000 years ago, the models suggest that in the [SPEAKER_25]: next 80 years, we could have 7 to 8 degrees warming in the Arctic. [SPEAKER_25]: So that's much faster warming, and we're expecting the response of permafrost also [SPEAKER_25]: to be much larger than what it was in the past. [SPEAKER_47]: I can say for sure that we're headed towards a really dangerous place. [SPEAKER_47]: There's a chance that some of these really big feedbacks, ecosystem feedbacks, will [SPEAKER_47]: take the fate of the climate out of our hands. [SPEAKER_33]: Methane hydrates in tundra and on the continental shelves could be melted and, in

[SPEAKER_33]: effect, the methane released to the atmosphere. [SPEAKER_33]: But we can avoid that. [SPEAKER_33]: if we phase down the fossil fuel use. [SPEAKER_47]: If we mitigate or reduce human emissions. [SPEAKER_47]: Looks like you can avoid 70 to 80 percent of the permafrost climate feedback. [SPEAKER_47]: That means that the size of this ecosystem feedback to climate depends almost [SPEAKER_47]: completely on what we do. [SPEAKER_33]: So it's not something you should be losing sleep over, but it's something that you

[SPEAKER_33]: should recognize, okay, we can avoid that, but in order to do it, we're going to [SPEAKER_33]: have to move off of fossil fuels over the next few decades. [SPEAKER_47]: I understand that we can sometimes feel despondent, feel like nothing, it's out of [SPEAKER_47]: our hands, there's nothing that we can do. [SPEAKER_47]: But that is not, as somebody who works with this system, over the past 10 years [SPEAKER_47]: I've been working in permafrost, that's not the impression that I have. [SPEAKER_47]: I think that this is a call to action, not a declaration of defeat.

[Ood]: The glacial retreat. [Ood]: So glaciers are giant slabs of ice many square miles in size. [Ood]: They have been steadily degreasing. [Ood]: I even have degreasing typed in. [Ood]: Have been steadily decreasing in size year by year. [Ood]: The Alps, the Himalayas, the Andes, the Rockies, Alaska and Africa. [Ood]: Glaciers around the world are shrinking year by year. [Ood]: Every year they're setting new records with how much they're shrinking. [Ood]: And scientists and climate scientists think of glaciers like canaries in the coal

[Ood]: mine. [Ood]: They show just how much extra thermal energy is being pumped into the system every [Ood]: year. [Ood]: Because it takes a fuckload of thermal energy to melt that much ice. [Ood]: And them setting records for them melting every year and not forming back as big in [Ood]: the winter. [Ood]: It's the canary falling over and dying in the coal mine. [Bigly]: It's kind of like a heartbeat, if you will, like a seasonal heartbeat, you know, [Bigly]: expand, contract, expand, contract. [Bigly]: You know, it's like beating year after year after year. [Bigly]: But with every beat, it's a little bit weaker, a little bit weaker, a little bit

[Bigly]: weaker. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Ood]: And like these ice masses were like they should last thousands of years. [Ood]: But like with our intervention, with us rapidly heating things up, they're lasting [Ood]: hundreds of years. [Ood]: Like in a couple hundred years, these things might be gone. [SPEAKER_53]: Kilimanjaro is a snow covered mountain. [SPEAKER_53]: Nineteen thousand seven hundred and ten feet high. [SPEAKER_37]: When people talk about the snows of Kilimanjaro, they're talking about its [SPEAKER_37]: glaciers, immense sheets of slowly moving ice formed from layer upon layer of

[SPEAKER_37]: compacted snow, accumulating for hundreds, even thousands of years. [SPEAKER_09]: To be a glacier, ice has to move, ice in motion. [SPEAKER_09]: To move, you have to have pressure from accumulating snow on top. [SPEAKER_37]: And like other glaciers on Earth, the ones on Kilimanjaro are in serious trouble. [SPEAKER_09]: we're losing glaciers around the planet. [SPEAKER_09]: It doesn't matter whether you're in the tropics of the Andes in South America or on [SPEAKER_09]: Kilimanjaro or any of the glaciers in Africa or over in Papua, Indonesia, the ice

[SPEAKER_09]: is disappearing. [SPEAKER_09]: One of our best records is what's recorded in the ice as far as getting us a [SPEAKER_09]: perspective on many of the variables that cause climate change. [SPEAKER_49]: And this is the second floor. [SPEAKER_50]: to bedrock on Kilimanjaro. [SPEAKER_09]: We can look at the composition of the world's atmosphere in the past, looking at [SPEAKER_09]: the air trapped in the bubbles. [SPEAKER_09]: So you have little capsules of the air of the past. [SPEAKER_09]: So you can measure CO2, methane, nitrous oxide, everything we're concerned about in [SPEAKER_09]: today's world, only you can get these long-term histories of how they varied in the

[SPEAKER_09]: past. [SPEAKER_09]: There's really no analog in this long archive of where we are today. [SPEAKER_09]: And of course, we're really concerned about where we're going to be in less than [SPEAKER_09]: 100 years if we continue on our current path. [SPEAKER_09]: And I think the fact that they're all telling us the same story, to me, is what's [SPEAKER_09]: really of concern. [SPEAKER_50]: Most glaciers around the world today are experiencing a negative mass balance of [SPEAKER_50]: the glacier as a whole. [SPEAKER_50]: We've got a tremendous amount of radiation coming from the sun, energy coming from

[SPEAKER_50]: the sun because we're at high altitude, we're above much of the atmosphere. [SPEAKER_37]: As the solar radiation penetrates the glaciers, it causes the ice to melt, turning [SPEAKER_37]: the solid ice into a liquid. [SPEAKER_37]: In some cases, the radiation is so intense that the ice is vaporized, a process [SPEAKER_37]: called sublimation. [SPEAKER_50]: Sublimation is nothing more than evaporation going, in the case where we go from a [SPEAKER_50]: solid to a vapor. [SPEAKER_37]: Precipitation is one of the keys to preventing these glaciers from melting and

[SPEAKER_37]: sublimating. [SPEAKER_37]: The more snow falls on the mountain, the more the glaciers are protected from solar [SPEAKER_37]: radiation, which reflects off the white surface of the snow. [SPEAKER_50]: Kilimanjaro precipitation is always in the form of snow, and every time it snows, [SPEAKER_50]: it brightens the surface of the glacier. [SPEAKER_37]: If there is less snow cover, the glaciers are more exposed to solar radiation and [SPEAKER_37]: thus more subject to melting and sublimation. [SPEAKER_37]: Tanzania has seen a lack of precipitation in the form of a drought, resulting in

[SPEAKER_37]: less snow cover on Kilimanjaro. [SPEAKER_37]: The drought some scientists believe could be the result of climate change over a [SPEAKER_37]: much larger area, the Indian Ocean. [SPEAKER_50]: We know that the heat content in the Indian Ocean has been increasing as a result [SPEAKER_50]: of warming of the atmosphere. [SPEAKER_50]: We know that the sea surface temperatures have been changing. [SPEAKER_50]: And we know that precipitation over much of Tanzania, East Africa has been [SPEAKER_50]: decreasing. [SPEAKER_09]: Climate is everything. [SPEAKER_09]: I mean, it's temperature, it's precipitation, it's radiation, it's cloudiness.

[SPEAKER_09]: I mean, all of those variables are out there. [Ood]: Yeah, so again, if we use our starting line, the Industrial Revolution, as a [Ood]: starting point, which is when we started burning the majority of petroleum products [Ood]: and releasing the majority of greenhouse gases caused by human activity into the [Ood]: atmosphere, the sea level has risen about 8 inches. [Ood]: And I know, 8 inches is enough to satisfy you, it's also enough to satisfy the [Ood]: flooding of coasts and the destroying of property and ecosystems. [Ood]: And again, with most aspects of climate change, the bigger changes in sea level

[Ood]: rise have been seen in the last 20 years or so. [Ood]: When I say it's risen about 8 inches from the start of the Industrial Revolution, [Ood]: it hasn't been an even rising through that time. [Ood]: It's been an exponential curve where it starts to rise a little bit, and in the [Ood]: last 30 years it spikes way up. [Ood]: Sea levels are rising, and every year they rise faster and faster. [Ood]: Best case scenario, in the next hundred years, the least amount of sea level rise [Ood]: we will see is 16 inches.

[Ood]: And suddenly, in the last hundred years, human settlements that have been stable [Ood]: since the Bronze Age are rapidly changing. [Ood]: Best case scenario, hundreds of millions of people will be driven out of their [Ood]: homes due to sea level rise in the next hundred years. [Ood]: And in our history, we've already seen eight inches of this rise. [SPEAKER_21]: I was going to save that house to the extent that I would probably... [SPEAKER_21]: Die trying.

Okay, Jerry, let's go. [SPEAKER_07]: Huss hired the same contractor who moved the Cape Hatteras lighthouse in 1999. [SPEAKER_21]: Tell me in one hour the house is going down the road. [SPEAKER_07]: He moved the house nearly 300 feet from the ocean. [SPEAKER_07]: But the ocean is following. [SPEAKER_21]: So now we're down to about 250 feet. [SPEAKER_21]: There is something to the global warming, and our environment with the hotter [SPEAKER_21]: temperatures is making the oceans rise. [SPEAKER_21]: That's a big enemy of any house that's on the coast.

[SPEAKER_07]: Sea level rise makes erosion worse. [SPEAKER_07]: Erosion has cost Nag's head several rows of houses over the years. [SPEAKER_15]: They seem to be the poster child and the picture of sea level rise, which we don't [SPEAKER_15]: want to be that. [SPEAKER_07]: From 1870 to 1924, global sea level rise has been less than a millimeter a year. [SPEAKER_40]: The process of sea level change on a global basis is really a slow, gradual

[SPEAKER_40]: process. [SPEAKER_40]: It's like filling your bathtub gently. [SPEAKER_07]: But Rick says global sea level rise is accelerating. [SPEAKER_07]: Since 1993, the rate has quadrupled to 3.2 millimeters a year. [SPEAKER_07]: He says sea level rise is accelerating because climate change is warming the [SPEAKER_07]: oceans. [SPEAKER_07]: Here in North Carolina, tidal gauges show the rate of sea level rise is less than [SPEAKER_07]: the global average. [SPEAKER_49]: On average, sea level has been rising annually about the thickness of a nickel

[SPEAKER_49]: every year for at least the last 80 years. [SPEAKER_07]: But Rogers expects that to change. [SPEAKER_49]: We think sea level is going to accelerate in the future, even though we haven't [SPEAKER_49]: seen it in the historical record of our gauges. [SPEAKER_49]: But it's almost certain to occur in the future. [SPEAKER_07]: Right now, scientific projections are for sea level along our coast to rise [SPEAKER_07]: anywhere from 15 to 55 inches between now and the end of the century, with a [SPEAKER_07]: 39-inch rise being the most likely scenario.

[SPEAKER_07]: The town of Nags Head has been dealing with the shoreline threat through beach [SPEAKER_07]: renourishment. [SPEAKER_15]: Our will is to continue to nourish the beach. [SPEAKER_15]: As long as we can afford to do so and as long as we have a sand resource that we [SPEAKER_15]: can replenish the beach with, we're going to continue to maintain the beach. [SPEAKER_07]: The town has also required new homes to be built further from the ocean and higher [SPEAKER_07]: in elevation. [SPEAKER_07]: The problem is there's little room left for new construction. [SPEAKER_07]: The town is nearly 90 percent developed.

[Ood]: Evidence of climate change, number six. [Ood]: There's been a drastic increase in the amount of extreme events in the past 20 [Ood]: years. [Ood]: When researchers and scientists look back at the amount of extreme events, storms, [Ood]: hurricanes, forest fires, extreme heat events, extreme cold events, [Ood]: They saw an 83% increase when they compared the 1980

[Ood]: numbers with the 1999 numbers. [Ood]: Current estimates of the 20 years that have happened since then have seen a similar [Ood]: increase. [Ood]: The amount of extreme weather events is starting to hit places where humans settle [Ood]: more often. [Ood]: hurricanes go farther inland and are stronger when they hit and occur more [Ood]: frequently forest fires burn hotter for longer destroying larger and larger areas

[Ood]: the season's extremes start to increase on both ends in some areas [Ood]: the winters are colder and the summers are hotter drastically affecting those [Ood]: ecosystems and the animals and processes within them major floods have more than [Ood]: doubled these days we're seeing about sixty-six hundred [Ood]: climate-related disasters happening every year. [Ood]: If this trend continues, if we continue as we have been, this number is due to rise

[Ood]: to over 30,000 climate-related disasters per year by the year 100. [Ood]: And each one of those disasters are going to be more severe individually. [Ood]: 7. [Ood]: Declining Arctic Sea Ice [Ood]: This is the one that most people know of. [Ood]: Everybody's seen the sad polar bear on a shrinking ice cap, and it's real.

[SPEAKER_00]: The ice is beginning to form in Hudson Bay, Canada and the polar bears are making [SPEAKER_00]: their way across the tundra out to the coast. [SPEAKER_00]: The bears have been out here on the tundra since the ice broke up in July. [SPEAKER_00]: Now typically this is the bears hungry season. [SPEAKER_00]: The problem is under climate change that season is getting longer and the bears are [SPEAKER_00]: finding it harder to survive. [SPEAKER_22]: Biggest threat to polar bears is clearly loss of their habitat due to man-caused

[SPEAKER_22]: climate change. [SPEAKER_22]: Polar bears get all of their food from the surface of the sea ice. [SPEAKER_22]: They're highly specialized to catch basically two species of seals, ringed and [SPEAKER_22]: bearded seals, and they can only catch them from the surface of the sea ice. [SPEAKER_22]: They can't catch them predictably in open water, and those seals don't come to land [SPEAKER_22]: very often. [SPEAKER_22]: So when the sea ice is gone, polar bears are food deprived. [SPEAKER_22]: The impacts of climate change have been best documented in two areas. [SPEAKER_22]: One here in Hudson Bay, where we know more about polar bears than we do anyplace

[SPEAKER_22]: else. [SPEAKER_22]: And one up in the Southern Beaufort Sea, where I spent 30 years studying them. [SPEAKER_22]: In both places, we're seeing declines in physical stature, declines in body [SPEAKER_22]: condition of some sex and age groups. [SPEAKER_22]: And the most important thing we're seeing is declining survival rates, especially [SPEAKER_22]: of young animals. [SPEAKER_22]: And when scientists say survival rates are declining, what that means is that more [SPEAKER_22]: polar bears are starving to death. [Ood]: Polar bears are starting to merge inland, and their old areas where they were able

[Ood]: to hunt and live are disappearing. [Ood]: But that's just one animal. [Ood]: That's the animal that has become popular on documentaries and in other places. [Ood]: It doesn't represent the actual hundreds of thousands of species that are going [Ood]: extinct across the line. [Ood]: And the Arctic sea ice may become a seasonal event. [Ood]: Where right up to the pole, it will be melted every summer and will return in less [Ood]: and less number per year every winter.

[Ood]: Perhaps within a generation or two, if we continue as we have been, the Arctic will [Ood]: be sea ice free year round. [Ood]: It's well within the realm of possibility if we keep on putting out emissions as we [Ood]: have been. [Ood]: Number eight, and the last one I'll talk about today, but if you continue [Ood]: researching this on your own, you'll find there's lots more venues of evidence for [Ood]: climate change. [Ood]: Shrinking land ice. [Ood]: Even bigger than glaciers, land ice is large swaths of ice that are often as big as

[Ood]: countries. [Ood]: If these melt and the water within them reaches the sea, not only will they dilute [Ood]: the seawater with their freshwater runoff and continue changing the chemistry of [Ood]: the ocean, they will raise the level of the oceans far past the current estimates. [Ood]: We only started measuring shrinking land ice in 1993, so a little more than 28 [Ood]: years ago. [Ood]: There are two major locations on Earth for these giant swaths of ice, Greenland and

[Ood]: Antarctica, and both of them have displayed staggering shrinkage. [Ood]: On average, Greenland ice has shrunk and released into the ocean an average of 279 [Ood]: billion tons of ice per year. [Ood]: Antarctica, on average, has lost an average of 151 billion tons of ice per year. [Ood]: If you count the land and the sea ice that's melting, as I previously mentioned, [Ood]: the ice in the Arctic and the floating icebergs and all those sources of ice, the

[Ood]: Earth is losing about 1.2 trillion tons of ice per year. [Ood]: And that number is increasing every year. [SPEAKER_04]: What you can see behind me here is a very good cross-section of a glacier in [SPEAKER_04]: Antarctica. [SPEAKER_04]: And what you can see with all of those different layers, that is hundreds and [SPEAKER_04]: thousands of years of snowfall and precipitation stacking up one on top of the [SPEAKER_04]: other and slowly exerting pressure downward on the on those layers of snow. [SPEAKER_04]: And that's basically how a glacier is formed.

[SPEAKER_04]: But Antarctica's ice is now increasingly being threatened. [SPEAKER_04]: And most researchers believe it's because of climate change. [SPEAKER_04]: According to one recent study, the continent's ice is slipping away six times [SPEAKER_04]: faster than it was 40 years ago. [SPEAKER_20]: And when you do the math, you wind up with the Antarctic ice sheet is out of [SPEAKER_20]: balance by more than three and a half swimming pools per second. [SPEAKER_04]: Every second, three Olympic-sized swimming pools worth of ice is disappearing from [SPEAKER_04]: Antarctica.

[SPEAKER_20]: Yes, when considered on average over the year. [SPEAKER_04]: Just to put that in perspective, in the amount of time it takes to watch this [SPEAKER_04]: story, Antarctica will shed more water than New York City uses every day. [SPEAKER_06]: It's becoming clearer that parts of Antarctica appear to be unstable and are losing [SPEAKER_06]: ice much faster than we expected. [SPEAKER_04]: Michael Oppenheimer is a climate scientist and professor of geoscience at Princeton [SPEAKER_04]: University. [SPEAKER_04]: He says this ice loss will only accelerate sea level rise, which happens for two

[SPEAKER_04]: reasons. [SPEAKER_04]: One, a warming atmosphere warms the oceans, and warmer water expands and rises. [SPEAKER_04]: Secondly, warming also melts ice and glaciers all over the world, sending new water [SPEAKER_04]: into the ocean. [SPEAKER_06]: So ultimately, if we lose all the ice that's vulnerable to a warming of only a few [SPEAKER_06]: degrees, we're talking about a very, very, very big sea level rise. [SPEAKER_17]: The continents warming from below and also from above. [SPEAKER_04]: Alexandra Isern oversees all Antarctic science for the National Science Foundation,

[SPEAKER_04]: who, for the record, is a NewsHour underwriter. [SPEAKER_04]: She says that in West Antarctica, two huge glaciers, Pine Island and Thwaites, are [SPEAKER_04]: considered at serious risk of collapse. [SPEAKER_17]: There's some researchers that study Pine Islands and the Thwaites Glacier that feel [SPEAKER_17]: that it's become sufficiently destabilized, that we won't be able to recover. [SPEAKER_04]: Michael Oppenheimer says if just one of those glaciers winds up in the ocean, sea [SPEAKER_04]: levels will rise five times higher than the UN predicted.

[SPEAKER_06]: The current estimates are if the Thwaites Glacier were to totally disintegrate into [SPEAKER_06]: the ocean. [SPEAKER_06]: that ultimately sea level would rise by something like five feet. [SPEAKER_06]: In areas around some of our biggest cities, New York, Boston, Miami, where you've [SPEAKER_06]: got a lot of development, homes, buildings, infrastructure like roads, very close [SPEAKER_06]: to sea level. [SPEAKER_06]: How do you defend those? [SPEAKER_04]: Many glaciers form what are known as ice shelves, huge platforms of ice, some as [SPEAKER_04]: wide as Texas and hundreds of stories tall, that grow out over the ocean and help

[SPEAKER_04]: hold their much larger glaciers up on land. [SPEAKER_04]: They hold it back and not let it slide into the sea. [SPEAKER_08]: Imagine a piece of ice the size of Texas, pretty thick. [SPEAKER_08]: It's going to slow the ice as it tries to flow into the ocean. [SPEAKER_04]: Robin Bell, of Columbia University's Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, has been [SPEAKER_04]: studying Antarctica's ice for over 20 years. [SPEAKER_04]: Robin Bell, Columbia [SPEAKER_08]: University's Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, has been studying Antarctica's ice [SPEAKER_08]: for over 20 years. [SPEAKER_08]: Ice shelves are very important. [SPEAKER_08]: They're essentially acting as bouncers in the bar, leaning up against the door and [SPEAKER_08]: keeping the ice from flowing into the ocean.

[SPEAKER_04]: But as the atmosphere keeps warming, major ice shelves in Antarctica have also been [SPEAKER_04]: collapsing. [SPEAKER_04]: In 2002, the Larson B ice shelf, the size of Rhode Island, completely [SPEAKER_04]: disintegrated. [SPEAKER_04]: As predicted, the glaciers that Larson B anchored up on land began accelerating [SPEAKER_04]: towards the ocean. [SPEAKER_04]: And then, two years ago, the even bigger Larson C shelf developed that miles-long [SPEAKER_04]: crack in it. [SPEAKER_04]: This shelf, which sits in front of the Thwaites Glacier, is also crumbling. [SPEAKER_04]: And part of the Brunt Ice Shelf is expected to break off any day now, releasing an

[SPEAKER_04]: iceberg that will be twice the size of Manhattan. [SPEAKER_06]: It doesn't mean we should all throw up our hands and run. [SPEAKER_06]: Let's start thinking straight, let's start thinking fast about how we're going to [SPEAKER_06]: help people, how we're going to help settlements, how we're going to help countries [SPEAKER_06]: deal with the outcome. [SPEAKER_06]: Because a lot of it is not going to be pretty, it's going to be expensive and it's [SPEAKER_06]: going to be disruptive if we don't get our act together now. [Ood]: Alrighty, that's part one. [Ood]: Join us in climate change part two, where we're going to talk about, quote-unquote,

[Ood]: the best case scenario and the worst case scenario. [Ood]: And we'll also have an interview with a researcher who has done some studies [Ood]: herself in her career in the area of climate change and how it's affecting animal [Ood]: species. [Ood]: And we're going to try and wrap a bow on this and, I don't know, maybe end with [Ood]: some hope with any luck. [Leon]: Hello, occultists. [Leon]: It's Leon Filger. [Leon]: Remembrance Day is coming up, so here is a Remembrance Day palate cleanser.

[Leon]: It's a song called A Pittance of Time by Canadian artist Terry Kelly. [SPEAKER_31]: They fought and some died for their homeland. [SPEAKER_31]: they fought and some died now it's our land look at his little child there's no [SPEAKER_31]: fear in her eyes could he not show respect for other dads who have died take two

[SPEAKER_31]: minutes [SPEAKER_31]: Would you mind? [SPEAKER_31]: It's a pittance of time for the boys and the girls who went over. [SPEAKER_31]: In peace may they rest. [SPEAKER_31]: May we never forget why they died. [SPEAKER_31]: It's a pittance of time. [SPEAKER_31]: God forgive me for wanting to strike him. [SPEAKER_31]: Give me strength so as not to be like him.

[SPEAKER_31]: My heart pounds in my chest. [SPEAKER_31]: Fingers pressed to my lips. [SPEAKER_31]: My throat wants to fall out. [SPEAKER_31]: My tongue barely resists. [SPEAKER_31]: So two minutes I will bide. [SPEAKER_31]: It's a pittance of time for the boys and the girls who went over. [SPEAKER_31]: In peace may they rest. [SPEAKER_31]: May we never forget why they died. [SPEAKER_31]: It's a pittance of time.

[SPEAKER_31]: Read the letters and poems of the heroes at home. [SPEAKER_31]: They have casualties, battles, and fears of their own. [SPEAKER_31]: There's a price to be paid if you go, if you stay. [SPEAKER_31]: Freedom's fought four and won in numerous ways. [SPEAKER_31]: Take two minutes. [SPEAKER_31]: Would you mind? [SPEAKER_31]: It's a pittance of time for the boys and the girls all over. [SPEAKER_31]: May we never forget as our young become pets at the end of the line.

[SPEAKER_31]: It's a pittance of time. [SPEAKER_31]: It takes courage to fight in your own war. [SPEAKER_31]: It takes courage to fight someone else's war Our peacekeepers tell of their [SPEAKER_31]: own living hell They bring hope to foreign lands that hate mongers can't kill Take [SPEAKER_31]: two minutes, would you mind? [SPEAKER_31]: It's a pittance of time for the boys and the girls who go over

[SPEAKER_31]: In peace time our best, still dawn battle dress and lay their lives on the line. [SPEAKER_31]: It's a pittance of time. [SPEAKER_31]: In peace may they rest, lest we [SPEAKER_31]: forget why they died. [SPEAKER_31]: Take a pittance of time.

[Leon]: Hello, occultists. [Leon]: Welcome to the After Show. [Leon]: My name is Leon Pilger. [Leon]: Coming up on the 11th of November in Canada and the rest of the Commonwealth is [Leon]: Remembrance Day, where we celebrate the end of the First World War, which was at [Leon]: the 11th hour of the 11th [SPEAKER_31]: minute, the 11th day [Leon]: of the 11th month, Bloody God. [Leon]: There are two poems that come to mind when I think about Remembrance Day, and I'll [Leon]: present them for you now. [Leon]: The first one is called High Flight. [Leon]: It's written by pilot officer John Giuseppe McGee, Jr., number 412 Squadron, Royal

[Leon]: Canadian Air Force, killed 11 December 1941. [Leon]: Oh, I have slipped the surly bonds of earth and danced the skies on [Leon]: laughter-silvered wings. [Leon]: Sunward I've climbed and joined the tumbling mirth of sun-split clouds and done a [Leon]: hundred things you have not dreamed of, wheeled and soared and swung high in the [Leon]: sunlit silence. [Leon]: Hovering there, I've chased the shouting wind along and flung my eager craft [Leon]: through footless halls of air. [Leon]: Up, up the long, delirious, burning blue, I've topped the windswept heights with

[Leon]: easy grace, where never lark or even eagle flew. [Leon]: And, while with silent, lifting mind I've trod, the high, untrespassed sanctity of [Leon]: space put out my hand and touched the face of God. [Leon]: And the second poem, which is probably the most famous thing to come out of the [Leon]: First World War, was written by another soldier, John McRae. [Leon]: It's called In Flanders Fields. [Leon]: In Flanders Fields, the poppies blow between the crosses row on row that mark our [Leon]: place.

[Leon]: And in the sky, the larks still bravely singing fly, scarce heard amid the guns [Leon]: below. [Leon]: We are the dead. [Leon]: Short days ago, we lived. [Leon]: Felt dawn, saw sunset glow. [Leon]: Loved and were loved. [Leon]: And now we lie in Flanders fields. [Leon]: Take up our quarrel with the foe. [Leon]: To you with failing hands we throw the torch. [Leon]: Be yours to hold it high. [Leon]: If ye break faith with us who die, we shall not sleep. [Leon]: Though poppies grow in Flanders fields.

[Leon]: So that's the end of my part of the after show. [Leon]: I'll turn it over to Ood. [Leon]: Next voice of here is our own Ood Gallifrey. [Leon]: Good night. [Ood]: Yeah, thank you, Leon. [Ood]: I think that it is both possible to criticize the decisions of the military as a [Ood]: whole and the country's decisions to enact power through their militaries. [Ood]: I think you can criticize that while still acknowledging the sacrifices of people [Ood]: that died thinking they were doing the right thing in defending their country.

[Ood]: So that's what Remembrance Day means to me anyway. [Ood]: I'll see you guys next week for part two of climate change where shit gets hopeless [Ood]: and then hopeful. [Ood]: Until then, make a habit of putting your drunk friends in the recovery position. [Ood]: Prevents accidental death. [Ood]: It's a good thing to start doing. [Ood]: Yeah, so we'll see you next week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Case #238: Real Life Werewolves

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 13 minAudio

    Join Richard as he does a sequel to his "Real life Vampires" episode. Where we learn the terrifying truth that real people in history have been executed under suspicion from the powerful that they were wolves. Also,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Case #237: Ten Dumb Cryptids

    Nov 6, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    We needed a lighter episode. So lets talk about ten of the dumbest cryptids Ood and sage could research. Today, on Ovpod, get your Dong Wrangled,learn how to avoid mountain whales, meet the crying ballsack cryptid,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Case #236: PISS

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    An unavoidable follow-up to our poop episode, here, Arthur guides us through a river of PISS. What high end product is forged in piss? Can Aged urine cure insomnia? How do mice pee? Does a kidney stone gather moss? All...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Case #235: Formula One Racing

    Oct 16, 20261 hr 39 minAudio

    Remember, if a loophole in a rule exists, it was put there to gain leads one second at a time. Formula One is a world wide, single seat, engineering arms race to build the highest performing racecars on earth. Hear a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Case #234: Real Life Vampires

    Oct 13, 20261 hr 50 minAudio

    In Ages past, in the long long ago, humanity used to believe in cannibalistic demon men that preyed on the bodies of men. Too bad things haven't changed very much. Join Richard Bigly has he leads the ovpod crew through...

    Credit the people on this episode