OVpod's original four episodes about The Murder of Neil Stonechild released as 4-hour episode. Hear us cover this murder at the hands of our local police department, and the lack of justice that has happened since
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[Ood]: These episodes were recorded late 2020. [Ood]: It consists of the hosts crushing a big case of 016 and talking about a local case [Ood]: that we've all become very interested in over the years, the death of Neil [Ood]: Stonechild at the hands of our own police force. [Ood]: It was released in four parts previously over a couple months, but I've stitched [Ood]: all four parts together. [Ood]: And we're releasing this on the night that he died, November 25th, 1990.
[Ood]: We're all Saskatoon locals. [Ood]: I don't think it's a question in our minds that our police force killed this man. [Ood]: So here's a story about a fairly small city's police force in the 1990s. [Ood]: Maybe hearing the tale of this in the past might help us make better choices in the [Ood]: future. [Intro]: Warning, this podcast contains violence, sexuality, gore, and other horrible and
[Intro]: disturbing things. [Intro]: Listener discretion is advised. [Intro]: Also, the hosts of this venture are ignorant dipshits, so please do not take [Intro]: anything they say as fact and enjoy the show. [Intro]: Now, are you sitting comfortably? [Intro]: Good, then we'll begin. [Intro]: Today we had 15 homicides and [Intro]: 63 violent crimes, as if that's the way it's supposed to be. [Intro]: It is our basic human right to be fucked up.
[Intro]: A second plane now has crashed into the other tower of the World Trade Center. [Intro]: Put chemicals in the water, they turn the friggin' [Intro]: The defendant shall be incarcerated for the rest of her natural life with no [Intro]: possibility of parole. [Intro]: You are not machines! [Intro]: You are not cattle! [Intro]: You are men! [Intro]: We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began [Intro]: to take hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. [Intro]: Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold. [SPEAKER_22]: Hold.
[Bigly]: Hello, occultists. [Bigly]: I am Richard Bigley, and we are in for a long-haul episode on this one. [Bigly]: Anyway, in studio with me today, I have... Sage Murray! [Bigly]: Leon Felger. [Bigly]: And... Ood Gallifrey. [Bigly]: All right, so yeah, this is... What about the radio demon? [Bigly]: Oh yeah, and the radio demon. [Arthur]: You don't have to introduce me. [Arthur]: Everyone knows me. [Arthur]: I'm the most famous member of OffPod. [Bigly]: Yes, very much. [Bigly]: That's what you should be. [Bigly]: So this is pretty heavy, and when I wrote it, I didn't really write any room for a
[Bigly]: poison in it, so let's just get to it right now. [Bigly]: So, what's your poison? [Sage]: So what's your poison? [Bigly]: All right. [Bigly]: So today we are falling back to our traditional comfort beer, the original 16 [Bigly]: Canadian Pale Ale by Great West Brewing. [Sage]: It's delicious.
[Bigly]: It is delicious. [Bigly]: And it sounds really crisp when you like open the can. [Ood]: And in 1784, the 16 Druid Kings of Saskatchewan defeated the ice giants and founded [Ood]: this beer company. [Ood]: They did. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: The 16 Druid Kings. [Sage]: Did I get that correctly on? [Bigly]: Yes. [Bigly]: Super duper. [Sage]: Fuck. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: named after the original 16 Druid kings. [Bigly]: Yep. [Bigly]: Of Saskatchewan. [Bigly]: Of Saskatchewan. [Sage]: I rate this beer 10 out of 10. [Sage]: 10 out of 10. [Bigly]: It's a comfort beer. [Bigly]: It's a comfort beer. [Bigly]: Yeah, it's nice. [Bigly]: It's cold. [Bigly]: It's beer. [Bigly]: It's not too hoppy. [Bigly]: I'm always happy to have one. [Bigly]: Yeah, I've never said no to an original 16.
[Ood]: No. [Ood]: It's very inoffensive, very crisp, and it's, you know, even in our household, which [Ood]: two of the three hosts, I don't know. [Ood]: Do they know you live here? [Ood]: Yeah, I live here. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Whenever we get money for empties or like extra cash or like pocket change that [Ood]: goes into the beer tip jar, 016 is most likely going to be bought with it. [Ood]: Okay. [Ood]: So let's get into it. [SPEAKER_32]: The city of Saskatoon is Saskatchewan's River City, developed around the shores of
[SPEAKER_32]: the South Saskatchewan River. [SPEAKER_32]: Currently the largest city in Saskatchewan, Saskatoon has become a cultural hub [SPEAKER_32]: with many theaters, restaurants, art galleries, music venues and historic buildings [SPEAKER_32]: calling it home. [SPEAKER_32]: Booming with opportunity, culture and beauty, now is a great time to come and pay a [SPEAKER_32]: visit to the city of Saskatoon.
[SPEAKER_08]: Saskatoon is a city connected by bridges and divided by race. [SPEAKER_08]: It has the largest urban population of Aboriginal people in a province with the [SPEAKER_08]: highest youth incarceration rate in North America. [SPEAKER_08]: In Saskatchewan, a young Aboriginal man is more likely to go to jail than finish [SPEAKER_08]: high school. [SPEAKER_08]: Few people understand the history behind the statistics, and many don't care.
[SPEAKER_24]: What are your conditions? [SPEAKER_24]: No drinking? [SPEAKER_24]: No weapons. [SPEAKER_24]: OK. What else? [SPEAKER_24]: Are you going to search me for a weapon? [SPEAKER_24]: I am, too. [SPEAKER_24]: Don't be nervous, man. [SPEAKER_24]: OK, you got a curfew on you? [SPEAKER_24]: Not that I know of. [SPEAKER_24]: OK, Mike, keep your hands in your pocket, buddy. [SPEAKER_24]: Hands in your pocket. [SPEAKER_24]: OK, what's going to happen here is that you're going to stay exactly put, all [SPEAKER_24]: right, until the other car gets here, and then you're just going to patch for [SPEAKER_24]: weapons, check and see if you've got a curfew, all right? [SPEAKER_24]: Nothing sudden or I'll put you on the ground.
[SPEAKER_24]: You understand that, eh? [SPEAKER_08]: Aboriginal people in the prairies have coped with assaults led by the church and [SPEAKER_08]: the Canadian government, residential school abuse, discriminations in the Indian [SPEAKER_08]: Act, racism and despair. [SPEAKER_08]: These are the people the Saskatoon police meet on a nightly basis. [Bigly]: So Dan Hatchin and Ken Munson of the Saskatoon Police Service, they're a bunch of [Bigly]: big old assholes. [Bigly]: In January 2000, Daryl Knight, an indigenous man, was dropped off on the outskirts
[Bigly]: of Saskatoon. [Bigly]: He had walked for a couple of miles and then was able to get to the nearby Queen [Bigly]: Elizabeth Power Station to call a taxi and had suffered no ill effects. [Bigly]: He later, a couple of days later, met up with Saskatoon police over another [Bigly]: incident and told them about his experience with Dan Hatchin and Ken Munson. [Bigly]: And anyway, this launched an investigation and the two officers involved basically
[Bigly]: claimed that they had simply given Daryl Knight a ride home and dropped him off at [Bigly]: his own request. [Bigly]: But, well, the reality was it was an unlawful confinement that occurred in [Bigly]: September 2001, and they were sentenced to eight months in prison. [Bigly]: Yeah, it was the subject, actually, of a National Film Board documentary called Two [Bigly]: Worlds Colliding by Tasha Hubbard. [SPEAKER_11]: As soon as I got outside, I seen two cops go.
[SPEAKER_11]: I mean, they must have thought I was the one causing the problems [SPEAKER_11]: or something. [SPEAKER_11]: They handcuffed me and took me to the car, and I'm thinking I didn't break no laws, [SPEAKER_11]: so I didn't do nothing wrong and took me away. [SPEAKER_11]: and they drove me out of [SPEAKER_11]: town.
[SPEAKER_11]: Scared the heck out of me. [SPEAKER_11]: I thought I was dead. [SPEAKER_11]: All those rumors I heard in the past, they were all coming true. [SPEAKER_11]: When they told me, Daryl, get the heck out, well, they swore out,
[SPEAKER_11]: you effin' Indian. [SPEAKER_11]: I told them, I'll freeze to death out there, you guys. And they stopped. [SPEAKER_11]: You can hear the tires crunching on the snow. [SPEAKER_11]: And I can hear the electric window go down.
And I remember that driver there said, that's your effing problem. [SPEAKER_11]: And they drove away. [Bigly]: Daryl Knight's experience, as well as the experience from a number of other [Bigly]: Indigenous people who were, I guess, found at the outskirts of the city in various [Bigly]: locations. [Bigly]: It was a thing that they wanted to look into to kind of get to the bottom of,
[Bigly]: because this was a recurring thing. [Bigly]: Now, for some context about how... [Bigly]: You know, a lot of Saskatoon and I guess Saskatchewan people view our, you know, [Bigly]: our indigenous populations. [Bigly]: You know, it's a very racist place. [Bigly]: Joni Mitchell, a lot of people in Saskatoon don't like her because she called us [Bigly]: out on the city's racism. [Bigly]: If you flashback to our Colton Boushey episode, after Colton was murdered, they...
[Bigly]: There were local politicians saying that the only problem was that the shooter had [Bigly]: left witnesses, and this was coming from, like, local politicians. [Bigly]: Yeah, it was super fucked up. [Bigly]: So, I mean, the general attitude towards Indigenous people here sucks, and we've [Bigly]: kind of got a clip here that we've got from the Two Worlds Colliding documentary, [Bigly]: which really highlights this fact. [SPEAKER_08]: Constables Ken Munson and Dan Hatchin admit to abandoning Daryl Knight in the cold
[SPEAKER_08]: at the edge of town. [SPEAKER_08]: As the case progresses, emotions run high in the city of Saskatoon. [SPEAKER_08]: Thoughts that usually remain unsaid are now in the open. [SPEAKER_05]: Why are these two taking the blame for everyone that's dead? [SPEAKER_05]: It's not their fault that everyone's dead. [SPEAKER_05]: They're just lucky that Daryl Knight found a phone to phone a cab. [SPEAKER_05]: Daryl Knight... [SPEAKER_05]: Please. [SPEAKER_05]: What about his arrest record? [SPEAKER_05]: What about the trouble that man's been in? [SPEAKER_14]: Does that mean he should die? [SPEAKER_05]: No, that doesn't mean he should die. [SPEAKER_05]: Nobody should die. [SPEAKER_05]: No one at all should have to die and pay the price.
[SPEAKER_05]: Your kind of racism is what I've been fighting all my life. [SPEAKER_05]: No, I'm not racist because my friends are Indian as well. [SPEAKER_05]: Anyone that says I'm not racist is Indian. [SPEAKER_05]: Some of my friends are Indian too. [SPEAKER_05]: Some of my friends are, and yeah, I have a certain amount of racism because I've [SPEAKER_05]: dealt with enough of Native that have caused me nothing but hell and havoc. [SPEAKER_05]: Broke into my homes. [SPEAKER_05]: Okay? [SPEAKER_05]: Well, fine. [SPEAKER_14]: How many beers do you drink and how much bingo do you do? [SPEAKER_05]: And how much welfare are you guys on?
[Bigly]: So yeah, how about that, eh? [Bigly]: She includes the, I'm not racist, I have Indian friends, and then follows it up [Bigly]: with a straight up, I have a little bit of racism. [Sage]: Maybe just a little bit of racism. [Sage]: A little bit of racism, maybe. [Bigly]: And yeah, so that's... How many beers do you drink [Ood]: and how much welfare are you on? [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: And like, speaking as a white guy in Saskatchewan, like... [Ood]: For some reason, other white guys seem to have a habit of like, when they get [Ood]: comfortable with me, they'll like confess their racist feelings to me.
[Ood]: Oh yeah, me too. [Ood]: It's happened over and over and over again, where I start to get to know somebody [Ood]: at a job or at a social event or something like that, and all of a sudden they'll [Ood]: start to speak about... [Ood]: Man, all these fucking natives are ruining the town, eh? [Ood]: Like, they confide in me their bigoted feelings. [Ood]: And, like, it gave me the impression that so many people out there just have racism [Ood]: just under the surface. [Sage]: I get that, too. [Sage]: Like, at work... [Sage]: Um, I work up, up North and there's, I work with quite a few white, older white [Sage]: men.
[Sage]: And, uh, after they hang out with me for a bit and I, if I, if I haven't like said [Sage]: anything about my beliefs, they just start being like, Oh, these fucking Indians, [Sage]: blah, blah. [Sage]: My sister owns a rental and they just cut up deer, these fucking Indians. [Sage]: No one should rent to them, blah, blah, blah, blah. [Sage]: And then I, uh, [Sage]: Depending on how drunk I am at the time of the encounter, I either yell at them or [Sage]: I pretend that I have to go wash my hair. [Sage]: Yucky. [Sage]: Super fucked up. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So that's, I mean, you don't have to scratch terribly hard beneath the surface of a
[Bigly]: lot of the people here to get their beliefs or I guess to have them expose their [Bigly]: racist beliefs. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: Yeah, Saskatoon police are certainly no exception to this. [Bigly]: They, I guess, seem to have a habit of, you know, taking indigenous people, [Bigly]: dropping them off on the outskirts of the city, often in freezing weather. [SPEAKER_04]: Right after the T-Pain and Nelly concert, we went for some drinks afterwards
[SPEAKER_04]: because... [SPEAKER_04]: you know, just because it was a date night. [SPEAKER_04]: And my significant other was waiting inside for me. [SPEAKER_04]: I mean, I'm not too big of a smoker, but I went outside for a cigarette, decided to [SPEAKER_04]: have a cigarette. [SPEAKER_04]: And I was approached by a black SUV with two police officers inside. [SPEAKER_04]: I don't really know the names. [SPEAKER_04]: I don't remember their faces. [SPEAKER_04]: I was quite inebriated, but that's nothing to do with it. [SPEAKER_04]: They had no right to do what they did. [SPEAKER_04]: I had cab money. [SPEAKER_04]: I wasn't being belligerent or rude in any way.
[SPEAKER_04]: I complied with them because, I mean, as a coach, you got to do a CPIC every six [SPEAKER_04]: months to attend the summer and winter games. [SPEAKER_04]: So I complied with their orders. [SPEAKER_04]: And they told me to get in a vehicle. [SPEAKER_04]: They told me to, you know, I was under the impression we were going downtown. [SPEAKER_04]: And next thing you know, we're on Circle Drive and heading to the outskirts of [SPEAKER_04]: town, which would be Preston and Highway 11. [SPEAKER_04]: Last thing I remember was, you know, them kind of, you know, belittling me and
[SPEAKER_04]: driving away. [SPEAKER_04]: I felt... [SPEAKER_04]: humiliated and betrayed. [SPEAKER_04]: I've never felt that before. [SPEAKER_04]: So it's all new to me. [SPEAKER_04]: I mean, yeah, it wasn't okay. [SPEAKER_04]: I mean, how long has this been going on? [SPEAKER_04]: How many people has this happened to? [SPEAKER_04]: You know, they haven't come forward. [SPEAKER_04]: It's not okay. [SPEAKER_04]: We need to address this situation. [Bigly]: There was a Mr. Nastus and Mr. Wagner.
[Bigly]: There was a Lloyd Dustyhorn in January 2000, a Darcy Dean Ironschild in February of [Bigly]: 2000, and the subject of this episode, Neil Stonechild in November of 1990. [Bigly]: The investigations into the deaths of Dustyhorn, Ironschild, and Nastus were [Bigly]: concluded, and it was determined that there basically wasn't enough evidence to [Bigly]: press any sort of charges. [Bigly]: Of course not. [Bigly]: Of course not. [Bigly]: The Minister of Justice had then, upon finding this out, had ordered a coroner's
[Bigly]: inquest into these three deaths. [Bigly]: These inquests had been completed by the time Stonechild's inquest had also been [Bigly]: done. [Bigly]: So, investigation into the death of Mr. Stonechild was concluded, and it was [Bigly]: initially determined that there was not sufficient evidence to lay charges against [Bigly]: the police officers who were last seen with him. [Bigly]: However, there was evidence that Mr. Stonechild had contact with members of the [Bigly]: Saskatoon Police Service the day he was last seen alive.
[Bigly]: So, there was the Neil Stonechild inquiry. [Bigly]: which was conducted to look into this matter, but they aren't able, the inquiry was [Bigly]: not given any authority to make a civil or criminal determination in liability. [Bigly]: So it's basically, they just go out there, interview people, look up whatever they [Bigly]: can find, get all the facts together and, you know, make a determination as to what [Bigly]: exactly happened. [Bigly]: But they had no capacity to, you know, discipline or direct.
[Bigly]: Or really do anything about it. [Bigly]: Or really do anything. [Bigly]: Just get all the information out there so we've got it compiled. [Sage]: Just say like, yeah, Nate. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: And yeah. [Bigly]: So like I said, no civil liability could be determined by this inquiry. [Bigly]: No criminal liability either. [Ood]: And, you know, that's just more of the thin blue line old boys club. [Ood]: Like the threshold to, quote unquote, suspect a citizen of wrongdoing is so much [Ood]: lower than to suspect an officer of wrongdoing. [Ood]: Because how could that happen? [Ood]: They're such good people, moral people.
[Ood]: They would never do that. [SPEAKER_06]: No, of course not. [SPEAKER_06]: Neil Stonechild and the Starlight Tours. [SPEAKER_06]: It's been 10 years since the anniversary of Justice David Wright's report into the [SPEAKER_06]: inquiry into the death of Neil Stonechild. [SPEAKER_06]: The Starlight Tours were allegations that police dumped troublesome and drunk [SPEAKER_06]: Aboriginal men on the outskirts of the city. [SPEAKER_06]: Neil Stonechild was 17 when he went missing on a stormy winter night in 1990.
[SPEAKER_06]: His body was found five days later in a field on the outskirts of the city. [SPEAKER_06]: Darrell Knight came forward 10 years later to say that he'd been dumped on the [SPEAKER_06]: outskirts of town on a freezing night. [SPEAKER_06]: It was the same weekend that two other Aboriginal men were found frozen to death in [SPEAKER_06]: the same area. [SPEAKER_06]: The matter resulted in an inquiry, a public inquiry into the death of Neil [SPEAKER_06]: Stonechild. [Bigly]: So about the inquiry itself, there was 43 days of hearings held throughout the
[Bigly]: province. [Bigly]: Evidence included testimony of 63 witnesses and there was 197 exhibits. [Bigly]: In all, if you take all the transcripts and evidence and everything that that [Bigly]: inquiry produced, [Bigly]: There was 8,506 pages of it for you. [Bigly]: Fuck. [Bigly]: So this is certainly a research-heavy episode because I wrote it. [Bigly]: The inquiry is what, 8,000 pages? [Ood]: 8,500. [Ood]: 8,500 pages. [Ood]: He went through that just to try and get a good definitive view of this case.
[Ood]: So like, you know, patreon.com slash ovpod. [Ood]: We're putting in hours for you guys. [Ood]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Yes. [Bigly]: It was a lot of research and, uh, yeah. [Sage]: We had a lot of like furious, like long paragraphs in our group chat at like three [Sage]: in the morning. [Bigly]: Being like, what the fuck? [Bigly]: Like, how did this happen? [Bigly]: Why didn't anyone do anything? [Bigly]: And I'm like, it, it, it should, [Bigly]: you know, make you enraged as well as educated, as well as maybe entertained.
[Bigly]: Oh, yeah. [Bigly]: You know, it's what we're here for. [Bigly]: So anyway, the inquiry had found that there'd be no evidence that the Saskatoon [Bigly]: Police Service had received any formal written complaint against any of its members [Bigly]: in relation to the Stone Child matter. [Bigly]: So nobody formally wrote the police service to complain about the handling of Neil [Bigly]: Stonechild's, I guess, case. [Bigly]: That said, the inquiry had found that there were a number of complaints received by [Bigly]: the police service, including information that was provided to members of the
[Bigly]: police service. [Bigly]: by Jason Roy, who was Neil Stonechild's friend, who gave that night that Stonechild [Bigly]: went missing, he gave the police the fake name of Tracy Lee Horace. [Bigly]: Complaints from the Stonechild family were actually literally published on the [Bigly]: front page of the Star Phoenix, which is like Saskatoon's daily city newspaper. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Basically complaining about the adequacy of the investigation to Neil Stonechild's [Bigly]: death.
[Bigly]: And even internal complaints by the members of the Saskatoon Police Service were [Bigly]: later to be found out. [Bigly]: However, because I guess nobody had formally written to the police service with a [Bigly]: formal complaint... [Bigly]: The complaint process that was mandated at the time under the Police Act in [Bigly]: Saskatchewan was never actually initiated by the Saskatoon Police Service in [Bigly]: response to any of these complaints, both internally from officers, from [Bigly]: Stonechild's friends and family. [Bigly]: or what was actually literally published in the newspaper.
[Sage]: So because they didn't write a proper letter with the proper words in it and sent [Sage]: through the proper channels, that all these mountains of evidence were basically [Sage]: just like, fuck it. [Bigly]: Well, it wasn't mountains of evidence. [Bigly]: It was mountains of complaints. [Bigly]: Yeah, mountains of complaints. [Bigly]: And they were just like... [Bigly]: Well, no one formally complained in writing as Amanda, so we're not going to look [Bigly]: into this. [Bigly]: No one sent in letters with stamps. [Ood]: It's excuse via bureaucracy. [Ood]: Like, was there injustice done or not?
[Ood]: Did they complain in the correct avenues, using the correct formats? [Sage]: Yeah, using the special form that they need to get. [Ood]: That's not how we should do justice. [Ood]: That's bullshit. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So, according to evidence provided at the inquiry about the night that Neil [Bigly]: Stonechild was last seen alive, Constable Larry Hartwig and Constable Bradley [Bigly]: Singer of the Saskatoon Police Service were dispatched to remove Stonechild from [Bigly]: the Snowberry Downs apartment complex, a few blocks away from my house, actually.
[SPEAKER_22]: Mm-hmm. [Bigly]: The complaint was called in by a Trent Ewert. [Bigly]: This fact was irrefutably established in the inquiry as police records and witness [Bigly]: testimony and the officer's own notebooks all acknowledge that this is what [Bigly]: happened. [Bigly]: So the police were dispatched. [Bigly]: Five minutes after they were dispatched, they were on scene based on the electronic [Bigly]: police records that they had kept at the time. [Bigly]: At 11.59, it's found that they run a search on Stonechild and find he has
[Bigly]: outstanding warrants. [Bigly]: At 12.17 a.m., they report back to the police station or whatever as being in [Bigly]: service and ready for the next call. [Bigly]: At 12.18 a.m., Constable Hartwig and Constable Singer are sent to investigate a [Bigly]: suspicious person on Oregon Crescent, a few blocks away from the Snowberry Downs [Bigly]: apartments. [Bigly]: They report to be on scene at 12.24 a.m., six minutes later.
[Bigly]: Now, here's the fun fact. [Bigly]: It does not take six minutes to go from Snowberry Down to Oregon Crescent. [Bigly]: Even if you catch the only red light on the way, you will still make it there [Bigly]: before six minutes. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: So at 12.27, they report to be in service again. [Bigly]: So from 12.24 to 12.27, they conducted their call on Oregon. [Bigly]: Then at 12.30, they run a search on the name of Trent Ewert, the person who had
[Bigly]: originally called in the complaint at Snowberry Downs. [Bigly]: Hartwig was the most senior of the officers. [Bigly]: In the inquiry, Hartwig had remembered responding to an assault complaint, which [Bigly]: had originated at a nightclub. [Bigly]: He also recalled attending a residence to notify a woman that her husband had [Bigly]: killed their two young sons and then himself. [Bigly]: And now one could understand why you would remember that second call. [Sage]: Right. [Sage]: That's a big fucking deal. [Sage]: Especially in Saskatoon.
[Ood]: That's not an every week occurrence. [Sage]: Well, it's also 1990s Saskatoon. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: It's like, hey, miss, your husband killed your kids and then himself. [Bigly]: That's a big thing. [Bigly]: That's a big fucking deal. [Bigly]: You can remember that. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: But, you know, it's kind of weird that he would remember the first call about the [Bigly]: assault at a nightclub because, I mean, that was a pretty unremarkable call. [Bigly]: It's, you know, probably some drunk guys getting into a fight or whatever. [Sage]: I've been assaulted at several nightclubs.
[Sage]: It's nice. [Sage]: Never called the police about it, but you know. [Sage]: I work as a bouncer. [Ood]: Me too. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So he remembered that assault call and he remembered the other call. [Bigly]: But further to that, Hartwig claimed that he had no recollection of the events of [Bigly]: 24th, except for those two calls noted above. [Bigly]: And he denied that Stone Child was in the car the night of November 24th slash 25th [Bigly]: of 1990. [Bigly]: Now, despite noting that Stone Child was in his notebook and reviewing his notes [Bigly]: from his notebooks from that night,
[Bigly]: It didn't help him recall that event when he was at the inquiry, so his mind didn't [Bigly]: remember the Stone Child thing at all. [Bigly]: It's like it never happened. [Bigly]: Even though he had time to go over his notebooks. [Bigly]: Yeah, even despite going over your notebooks. [SPEAKER_16]: Mr. Commissioner, the next witness is Constable Larry Hartwig. [SPEAKER_16]: Did you, sir, have Neil Stone Child in your custody on November 24th or 25th of [SPEAKER_16]: 1990? [SPEAKER_16]: No, I did not. [SPEAKER_16]: Is it possible, sir, that you mistakenly had him in your custody in the sense that
[SPEAKER_16]: perhaps he was in your custody, gave you a false name, and you didn't realize it [SPEAKER_16]: was Neil Stonechild? [SPEAKER_16]: Do you think that's possible? [SPEAKER_21]: No, I do not believe that's possible. [SPEAKER_16]: You were talking [SPEAKER_27]: to the RCM police about the death of people, right? [SPEAKER_27]: Human beings. [SPEAKER_27]: Correct. [SPEAKER_27]: Frozen to death. [SPEAKER_27]: Right? [SPEAKER_27]: Inexplicably. [SPEAKER_27]: Correct. [SPEAKER_27]: And there was some suggestion at that point in time, even in the media, that there [SPEAKER_27]: was some kind of involvement by the Saskatoon Police Service.
[SPEAKER_27]: Correct. [SPEAKER_27]: You were quite aware of that? [SPEAKER_27]: Yes, I was. [SPEAKER_27]: So you didn't try for a moment to downplay the seriousness of this. [SPEAKER_27]: You knew, going into your discussions with Staff Sergeant Lyons, that this is a [SPEAKER_27]: serious situation. [SPEAKER_21]: Absolutely. [SPEAKER_27]: And so... [SPEAKER_27]: You turn the conversation to the death of Neil Stonechild, right? [SPEAKER_21]: I turn the conversation to Neil Stonechild. [SPEAKER_21]: Sergeant Lyons turned the conversation to the death of Neil Stonechild.
[SPEAKER_27]: Now, am I missing something here? [SPEAKER_27]: Isn't that the same thing? [SPEAKER_27]: Apparently so. [SPEAKER_27]: Is that the same thing? [SPEAKER_27]: No, it's not. [SPEAKER_27]: All right. [SPEAKER_27]: Why would you even raise the name of Neil Stonechild? [SPEAKER_27]: Isn't that what you're asking, Mr. Warren? [SPEAKER_27]: I was trying to get to that. [SPEAKER_27]: What earthly reason would there be for you to mention the name Neil Stonechild in [SPEAKER_27]: this context? [SPEAKER_21]: Because I knew the RCMP were investigating the death of Neil Stonechild. [SPEAKER_21]: They asked me about people I did not know about. [SPEAKER_21]: The only person that I knew was Neil Stonechild.
[Bigly]: So when he was asked about reporting at scene that night, he indicated they must [Bigly]: have pressed it while they were in the area as opposed to actually being at the [Bigly]: scene. [Bigly]: So, you know, you're supposed to push it when you arrive. [Ood]: Yeah. [Bigly]: But they were kind of close enough, so they just pushed it as they were close, you [Bigly]: know. [Ood]: Just ish, yeah. [Ood]: I wonder if citizens are allowed to do that. [Ood]: Like if a prosecutor brings forward and say, hey, the cell tower pinged off your [Ood]: cell phone, you can just be like, oh, I just fudged it. [Ood]: I just drove by.
[Ood]: Like they're being given a level of scrutiny that's way lower than like if a [Ood]: citizen was in the same situation. [Sage]: Like even like reporting into work. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: Like I may have been half an hour late, but it was close enough to on time. [Sage]: So it's on time, right? [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: Also of note is that his notes didn't actually make any reference to the original [Bigly]: complainant, which was Trent Ewart, which is also kind of interesting that he [Bigly]: didn't note that despite him running a search against them.
[Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So, you know, it's like, well, I'm going to run a search on this guy and see if [Bigly]: he's got any warrants, but I'm [Bigly]: Not going to write anything down about him in my notebook. [Bigly]: Yes. [Bigly]: So anyway, the temperature that night was minus 28 Celsius. [Bigly]: For our American friends, that is minus 18 and a half degrees Fahrenheit. [Ood]: It's cold. [Ood]: It's cold. [Ood]: And like... [Ood]: For people that haven't lived in a cold environment like this, like Saskatchewan is [Ood]: also very flat. [Ood]: So that cold is often accompanied by very swift winds.
[Ood]: Like the chances of hypothermia skyrocket like in Saskatchewan because you're [Ood]: subject to both the cold temperatures and the winds to cool your body down just [Ood]: that much faster. [Sage]: Well, and also like you breathe in and your nose hairs freeze and you breathe out [Sage]: and they thaw. [Sage]: Like that's... [Bigly]: Yeah, and your glasses fog up, and you take your scarf off, and it's got, like, [Bigly]: caked ice on it because of the condensation of your breath. [Bigly]: That's right. [Bigly]: Freezing up against the fabric. [Bigly]: So, like, it gets fucking cold here.
[Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Anyway, Constable Hardwig had agreed that a warrant for the arrest of Stonechild [Bigly]: was on the system on November 24-25, 1990. [Bigly]: He testified that if he had encountered Stone Child, he would have arrested him and [Bigly]: taken him to detention. [Bigly]: Because, you know, you find a guy, he's got a warrant, he's in your custody. [Bigly]: Take him to jail. [Bigly]: Take him to jail. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: You know, he's got some administrative business that needs to be looked after at [Bigly]: the police station. [Ood]: Yeah, that's supposed to be part of the checks and balances so that abuse by, like,
[Ood]: corrupt cops can't be done. [Ood]: Because there's cameras and other accountability and shit at the station. [Ood]: Or at least that's the way it should be. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: The timing of them running the name of the original complainant, Trent Ewert, was [Bigly]: also curious given that they had cleared Stone Child or they had cleared the Stone [Bigly]: Child matter 13 minutes earlier. [Bigly]: So it's like this guy complained about Stone Child. [Bigly]: We got there. [Bigly]: Now we've just finished up with our business here. [Bigly]: We've cleared it. [Bigly]: We're back in station now or we're back in service now.
[Bigly]: And then... [Bigly]: we're going to run the name of the guy who originally called in the complaint. [Bigly]: Well, it seems like kind of weird because, you know, you think before you flip back [Bigly]: into service, you would do that work. [Bigly]: You would do all that work before. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So 13 minutes later, after clearing them, they ran a search on Trent's name. [Bigly]: Hartwig had no recollection of the event he responded to on Oregon either. [Bigly]: Furthermore, from 1230 a.m.,
[Bigly]: To 1.39 a.m., over an hour, there was no activity on the police record system from [Bigly]: Constable Hardweg and Constable Sanger. [Bigly]: Their notebooks, also silent. [Bigly]: No names were run. [Bigly]: No evidence of where they were, what they were doing. [Bigly]: Now, like, imagine being a cop and getting, like, no late-night calls on [Bigly]: Saskatoon's west side for over an hour. [Bigly]: That's not happening. [Bigly]: You're just driving around? [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: For those of you that aren't familiar, it's, like, petty crime is happening in
[Ood]: Saskatoon, like, a lot. [Ood]: Because there's a lot of poverty. [Ood]: There's a lot of, like, there's a lot of discrimination. [Ood]: There's a lot of... [Ood]: inequality creating crime, like within the city, there's not a proper support [Ood]: structure. [Ood]: So like on any given night, there should be a lot of crime happening around that [Ood]: time. [Sage]: Well, like I have the cop app and you can see when crime happens and where it [Sage]: happens. [Sage]: And there's no way that it would be an hour without, [Bigly]: without, without somebody calling on the West side, which is where they were [Bigly]: patrolling that night. [Bigly]: So for over an hour, there was absolutely no activity with these officers.
[SPEAKER_21]: Jason Roy was apparently right at this intersection here, so I would have talked to [SPEAKER_21]: Jason Roy, right, because I would have been driving the car that night. [SPEAKER_21]: I don't remember any of this. [SPEAKER_21]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_21]: I don't remember even taking the call, right? [SPEAKER_21]: There's no doubt we did. [SPEAKER_21]: I mean, it's written in my notebook, so we obviously took the call. [SPEAKER_21]: So, I mean, I wrote the alias that Jason Roy used in my notebook, Tracy Lee Horse.
[SPEAKER_21]: There's a reason why he was run twice on CPIC, and it's probably because nothing [SPEAKER_21]: came back up under the alias, right? [SPEAKER_21]: So I challenged him. [SPEAKER_21]: Again, I don't have any recollection, but this is my normal practice. [SPEAKER_21]: This is what we do, right? [SPEAKER_21]: We ran Neil's name because, I mean, it's normal to run the subject of the call on [SPEAKER_21]: CPIC while you're en route or when you arrive at scene. [SPEAKER_21]: At scene is not a literal designation all the time. [SPEAKER_21]: I might be at scene of a car accident and never see the accident.
[SPEAKER_21]: I might be at scene three blocks away directing traffic. [SPEAKER_21]: We arrived at scene here. [SPEAKER_21]: So... [SPEAKER_21]: The first question somebody would ask is, how could we already have Neil Stonechild [SPEAKER_21]: in custody when we were at scene? [SPEAKER_21]: The evidence all indicates that. [SPEAKER_21]: The fact that I was duped into believing the possibility that I might have [SPEAKER_21]: encountered Neil Stonechild was only as a result of my faith in the RCMP that they [SPEAKER_21]: were competent, honest, and fair.
[SPEAKER_21]: Second question. [SPEAKER_21]: But again, in the absence of information, a person can and will adopt or any [SPEAKER_21]: information as a fact. [SPEAKER_25]: This spot in particular, it's a very traumatizing spot for me. [SPEAKER_25]: I've never actually sat in this, stood here ever since that night. [SPEAKER_25]: And the cop was... [SPEAKER_25]: looking at me right here and asking me questions, and Neil's in the back, bloody
[SPEAKER_25]: face, asking for my help, and Neil was sitting there with his hands behind his [SPEAKER_25]: back, just yelling at me, man, help me, help me, help me. [SPEAKER_25]: These guys are going to kill me. [SPEAKER_25]: And I was just like, relax, man, relax. [SPEAKER_25]: Everything's all right, man. [SPEAKER_25]: You're going to go back to jail. [SPEAKER_25]: That's it. [SPEAKER_25]: That's all. [SPEAKER_25]: Just calm down. [SPEAKER_25]: And he was fucking terrified, man. [SPEAKER_25]: And I really didn't put it together until he was gone. [SPEAKER_25]: And I really didn't make that much sense to me.
[SPEAKER_25]: Like, I was so young at that time. [SPEAKER_25]: And I just didn't know how to put it together. [SPEAKER_25]: And it just... [SPEAKER_25]: It just bothered the shit out of me, I don't know. [Bigly]: Fast forward to March of 2000. [Bigly]: Hartwig is getting interviewed on the death of Neil Stonechild.
[Bigly]: The investigator who's looking into this is interviewing Hartwig. [Bigly]: Hartwig says they were going to a call of a suspicious person of a B&E in progress, [Bigly]: the break and enter. [Bigly]: They found Neil. [Bigly]: He was drunk at the time. [Bigly]: Now, Hartwig said that he gathered this information from newspaper reports that he [Bigly]: had reviewed prior to meeting with the investigator. [Bigly]: Now the investigator makes no reference to Hartwig getting the info from the [Bigly]: newspaper.
[Bigly]: Constable Hartwig also testified that he read the name. [Bigly]: Tracy Lee horse in the newspaper. [Bigly]: It was found in cross-examination that such information did not appear in newspaper [Bigly]: reports, nor did it appear in any media presented to the inquiry. [Ood]: Interesting. [Bigly]: So he learned all this stuff that he had forgotten. [SPEAKER_19]: Mm hmm. [Bigly]: And he learned it through reviewing media at the time, the newspaper. [Bigly]: That didn't actually exist. [Bigly]: That didn't actually mention, you know, the names of Tracy Lee Horace, despite
[Bigly]: using the name Tracy Lee Horace in the interview. [Ood]: Weird. [Ood]: It's almost like he knew only stuff that somebody involved would know. [Bigly]: That's very interesting, isn't it? [Bigly]: In the end, the inquiry found and quote, I cannot accept that Constable Hartwig [Bigly]: simply forgot about the search for Stonechild when he learned of the death or that [Bigly]: he failed to recognize the complaint might have some significance to the [Bigly]: investigation into Stonechild's death. [Bigly]: In all of the circumstances, his assertion that he did not recall what happened is
[Bigly]: simply not credible. [Bigly]: I conclude that he recalled what happened and his assertions are deliberate [Bigly]: deception designed to conceal his involvement. [Bigly]: So this inquiry, which cannot lay any criminal or civil liability, just found [Bigly]: Hartwig to, I guess, summarize it. [Bigly]: They're calling him a fucking liar. [Sage]: Yeah, they basically called him the fuck out. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So he's a fucking liar just saying shit to try to hide his involvement in this. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Ood]: I think what's lost in reading through this is Hartwig, was it?
[Ood]: Yes. [Ood]: From what I read from reading through this argument, like he was considered like a [Ood]: senior officer, like an officer to set the example for the juniors to like, you [Ood]: know, to teach and guide and shape the young officers. [Ood]: A mentor. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Yeah. [Bigly]: This is this is guy that's setting setting the example. [Bigly]: Well, and that's what I'm moving to now is Hartwig's partner that night, Bradley [Bigly]: Singer, was the newbie. [Bigly]: He joined the police service in January of that year. [Bigly]: So he was on there for less than a year. [Bigly]: Little baby cop. [Bigly]: Little baby cop.
[Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: Constable Singer had recorded the complaint involving Stonechild in his notebook. [Bigly]: So Hartwig didn't write it down, but Singer did in his notebook. [Bigly]: There were no other names recorded. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: constable singer had testified that he had no recollection of the events of uh [Bigly]: november 24th and 25th of 1990 other than his involvement of notifying the woman [Bigly]: about the death of her husband and two sons he denied transporting neil stone child [Bigly]: to the north industrial area of saskatoon he also denied that he had any knowledge
[Bigly]: as to who did take stone child there [Sage]: Also, the North Industrial Area is far the fuck away from any public transit. [Sage]: It's all just a bunch of, like, warehouse buildings. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Buses don't go there. [Bigly]: Even in 2020, buses still don't really go there. [Bigly]: No, buses don't go there. [Bigly]: It's dead. [Bigly]: There's no, you know, it's just industrial businesses that run, you know, like. [Ood]: Nine to five. [Ood]: Nine to five or [Bigly]: six to six or six to seven. [Bigly]: Anyone there is working in L.A. chapter. [Bigly]: We're doing drugs. [Bigly]: Or doing drugs. [Sage]: Like, there's really... Not even. [Sage]: There are better places to do drugs. [Sage]: Yeah, there's nothing there.
[Bigly]: You know, outside of regular operating hours. [Sage]: Well, like, they picked him up on the west side and brought him all the way the [Sage]: fuck over to the north end, [Bigly]: which is very far away from anything that he'd probably, you know, be familiar [Bigly]: with. [Bigly]: Yeah, it's way the fuck out in the middle of nowhere. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So Sanger was on the day shift of November 29th, 1990, when he received a call [Bigly]: advising that a body, which turned out to be that a body of a Neil Stonechild, had [Bigly]: been found. [Bigly]: Sanger stated that he did not recall many details.
[Bigly]: He didn't recall any of the press surrounding Stone Child's death. [Bigly]: Now, this may seem normal and inconsequential, but imagine you encounter someone [Bigly]: one night and then days later find out that their frozen body was found literally [Bigly]: on your next shift. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Like, you don't think that that kind of information would be etched in your brain. [Bigly]: Your experience with that person would... [Sage]: Yeah, no, that sounds like bullshit. [Sage]: I still remember shit that happened on shifts from jobs like three jobs ago.
[Bigly]: Fuck, I remember like a bunch of shifts from like working at, you know, Burger [Bigly]: King. [Sage]: Yeah, I remember shifts from working at Claire's when I was 16 years old. [Sage]: Like it's, that's bullshit. [Ood]: And especially like that can like amplify the experience in your mind. [Ood]: Like I remember in high school... [Ood]: sitting beside behind somebody that killed themselves and i remember like their [Ood]: name and face is etched in my memory just because like i learned about that later [Ood]: just for my small interaction with them so this cop should have like been like holy
[Ood]: shit especially since it was only a couple days before yeah [Bigly]: He and Hartwig were searching for Stone Child just days earlier, and when anybody [Bigly]: had last seen him, it was at Snowberry Downs. [Bigly]: After Neil Stone Child went missing and was later found frozen, they did not [Bigly]: approach the officer who was investigating the death. [Bigly]: Like, you think anyone investigating, you know, would have wanted to know about, [Bigly]: you know, your interaction with Stone Child those days earlier. [Bigly]: Mm-hmm. [Bigly]: Nope.
[Bigly]: not a, you know, like, you know, you're, you've got, you know, your coworkers were [Bigly]: last seen with this guy days earlier. [Bigly]: And then now you're investigating his death. [Bigly]: like you don't think you would have talked to your co-workers or the co-workers [Bigly]: would have been like hey man i like we had this guy in our custody like yeah [Sage]: i remember this guy you know [Bigly]: two days ago um you know would you you know can we help you out you know well [Ood]: and detectives are taught and police are taught that like any small information
[Ood]: could lead to a break in a case and they're they're taught to say the same thing to [Ood]: the public [Ood]: So like they already know, like they would have reason to come forward. [Ood]: Their training would dictate they come forward unless they had [Bigly]: something to hide. [Ood]: Right. [Bigly]: Aside from, you know, neither Sanger or Hartwig coming forward or the investigating [Bigly]: officer reaching out to Sanger or Hartwig. [Bigly]: That's fucked up. [Bigly]: Sanger was being interviewed in this matter on December 2001. [Bigly]: And they had basically asked him, you know, how good of a cop are you?
[Bigly]: Have you done anything wrong on the job? [Bigly]: And so anyway, Sanger admits to falsifying a breathalyzer reading to avoid having [Bigly]: to administer another breathalyzer test. [Bigly]: Mm hmm. [Bigly]: So while this wasn't relevant to Stone Child, it talks about the integrity of [Bigly]: Bradley Singer. [Sage]: Yes. [Sage]: He was lazy. [Sage]: He was a lazy fuck. [Bigly]: He was lazy, you know, just whatever, you know. [Ood]: So falsifying a breathalyzer report, that rings of a certain police attitude I keep
[Ood]: on running into when, you know, certain secret chats of police revealed the whole [Ood]: like, well, maybe they didn't commit this crime, but if they're a bad person, we [Ood]: convict them and get them off the streets. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: and we make some shit up to get them out of the city, then so be it. [Ood]: You know, that whole corrupt horse shit. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So I guess some other interesting stuff about Constable Hartwig. [Bigly]: On Saskatoon's 20th Street, there's an old gas station. [Bigly]: That was built in 1929. [Bigly]: The area is a low income area.
[Bigly]: Lots of indigenous people live there. [Bigly]: In 2003, the Saskatoon police took over this old gas station building, basically in [Bigly]: an effort to have like a sort of a satellite police station in the community where [Bigly]: the cops can like walk on the beat and that sort of thing. [Sage]: Is that called like Little Chief now? [Bigly]: The Little Chief Community Station. [Bigly]: It was the Little Chief Community Station, yep. [Bigly]: Wow. [Bigly]: It's in the area. [Bigly]: It was a police station basically from 2003 to 2011. [Bigly]: And one of the officers who was assigned to this station was Constable Hartwig.
[SPEAKER_08]: Sable got the chief's job because of his community policing style and creates 10 [SPEAKER_08]: new community liaison positions. [SPEAKER_23]: We want to make sure that whatever you guys do, we're communicating that because [SPEAKER_23]: you guys are fighting a battle. [SPEAKER_23]: You're fighting a battle, first of all, you know, the perception internally is, [SPEAKER_23]: well, take the 10 officers and throw them out in the street and we'll handle crime [SPEAKER_23]: better. [SPEAKER_23]: So... [SPEAKER_23]: You've got to fight that perception. [SPEAKER_23]: On the other side, you've got the people out in the community who are saying, well,
[SPEAKER_23]: we never see our officers. [SPEAKER_23]: So we want to make sure we have a nice balance in there. [SPEAKER_23]: But it's really important that you guys understand this is a huge hinge pin, I [SPEAKER_23]: suppose, for lack of a better term, for where we're going with this organization. [SPEAKER_23]: And you guys are the ones that can set the standard. [SPEAKER_08]: As part of his community-based strategy, Sabo opens the Little Chief Station in the [SPEAKER_08]: inner city. [SPEAKER_08]: Constable Larry Hartwig is one of the new community liaison officers assigned to
[SPEAKER_08]: Little Chief. [SPEAKER_21]: I've worked on three different reserves, and I've developed a healthy respect for [SPEAKER_21]: the Aboriginal community. [SPEAKER_21]: Hello, is Ed in? [SPEAKER_21]: We always have to be very, very careful as police officers because we have a [SPEAKER_21]: tremendous amount of authority. [SPEAKER_21]: And with that comes a tremendous amount of responsibility. [SPEAKER_21]: We must never, ever, ever abuse our authority as police officers. [SPEAKER_21]: We have the authority to literally destroy lives.
[SPEAKER_21]: We literally do have that authority. [SPEAKER_21]: And we must always be careful that that authority is never, ever abused. [SPEAKER_26]: SIP entries on CPIC. [SPEAKER_21]: Let me give you a little insight into what the police subculture is. [SPEAKER_21]: We do not identify ourselves as white, as Aboriginal, as African-American or [SPEAKER_21]: African-Canadian or Asian. [SPEAKER_21]: We choose not to because when we become police officers, we become blue.
[Ood]: Holy fuck. [Ood]: It's not like he misunderstands the nuance of his job. [Ood]: He understands and he fucking does it anyway. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: God damn it. [Ood]: Like he understands what damage he can do and he just doesn't fucking care. [Ood]: That's it. [Ood]: That was wild. [Bigly]: Well, and that's the thing is it's like, you know, this was done in like 2003, that [Bigly]: interview. [Bigly]: I believe it was around 2003, maybe 2002. [Bigly]: And, you know, given his actions in November of 1990.
[Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Like when you, you know. [Bigly]: You can't just oops my bad out of that. [Bigly]: Yeah, exactly. [Bigly]: Like what he said and how, you know, it's like, does this haunt you? [Bigly]: Does that haunt your mind? [Bigly]: Of course it didn't because he forgot all about it. [Sage]: Oh, my God. [Bigly]: Apparently. [Sage]: Yeah. How do... [Ood]: How do people like this, like, how do they convince themselves they're good people? [Ood]: How do they, like, hug their kids and think they're a good role model? [Ood]: Like, how do they do it? [Sage]: I don't know.
[Sage]: Just push it way deep down. [Sage]: That was wild. [Bigly]: Yeah, exactly. [Bigly]: So, like, finding that interview and given what the inquiry found, yeah, it's a [Bigly]: very uncomfortable, and I'm sure he's probably living with some interesting, like, [Bigly]: cognitive dissonance on that. [Bigly]: Yep. [Bigly]: When the RCMP began its investigation into the death of Neil Stonechild, the RCMP [Bigly]: had requested Saskatoon police records on the matter. [Bigly]: Anyway, the official copy of this file, which included the officer's reports who
[Bigly]: responded, had been destroyed. [Sage]: Of course it was. [Bigly]: All that remained of the official Saskatoon Police Service file in relation to the [Bigly]: investigation of Neil Stonechild's death was a very basic indexing information [Bigly]: about the file. [Bigly]: The paper copy, gone. [Bigly]: It was destroyed in 1998. [Bigly]: Now, here's the thing about the destruction of police files. [Bigly]: The police have a records retention policy of 10 years. [Bigly]: So eight years in, they destroy the file.
[Sage]: That's not 10 years. [Bigly]: Despite having a policy to destroy files after 10. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So when questioned as to why this file was destroyed after eight, despite a [Bigly]: retention policy of 10 years, the police said that they needed to destroy the file [Bigly]: to make room for renovations to the police station, their storage facilities. [Bigly]: So because they had classified Stone Child's file as a sudden death, not a [Bigly]: homicide, the [Bigly]: Boom.
[Bigly]: Gone. [Bigly]: Who cares? [Bigly]: He was there. [Bigly]: He died. [Sage]: Who gives a shit? [Bigly]: It's done. [Bigly]: On to the next case. [Bigly]: So anyway, this guy, Ernie Lutet, happened to be a cop back in the 90s. [Bigly]: Good old Indian Ernie. [Bigly]: And he also happened to make a paper photocopy of this file shortly after Stone [Bigly]: Child's body was found. [Bigly]: And all this information was coming forward. [Bigly]: So anyway, the inquiry kind of looked at his file and they felt based on all the
[Bigly]: be on the scene four minutes later. [Bigly]: People in the area had directed him to the body of Stone Child. [Bigly]: Rene confirmed the death and radioed back to dispatch. [Bigly]: He searched the scene for evidence of foul play and would relay anything found back [Bigly]: to dispatch. [Bigly]: He followed Stone Child's footsteps back to a gravel parking lot where they had [Bigly]: disappeared. [Bigly]: The disturbance in the snow suggested that Stone Child had fallen before walking [Bigly]: south to where his body was later found.
[Bigly]: They concluded that Stone Child had been intoxicated, but they later testified that [Bigly]: the steps were fairly straight, as opposed to a drunken stagger. [Bigly]: Stone Child was missing a shoe, and they sent the canine unit to go looking for the [Bigly]: missing shoe, but they were unsuccessful. [Sage]: Can you imagine being out in the snow in the freezing-ass cold? [Sage]: You're kind of tipsy. [Sage]: You're in a place where you have no idea where you are.
[Sage]: You're missing a shoe. [Sage]: Can you imagine how scared you would feel? [Sage]: Like, I can't imagine. [Arthur]: And you're 17 years old. [Sage]: Yes, and you're like a little baby. [Ood]: Exactly. [Ood]: And we're not going into super depth about other Saskatoon freezing cases, but [Ood]: there's a pattern of victims of this saying that the cops took away their shoes, [Ood]: took away their jacket, took away stuff before dropping them off. [Sage]: Pretty sure there's literally a Wikipedia page on Saskatoon freezing deaths. [Sage]: There it is, yeah. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So the constable Ladijamore...
[Bigly]: stated that there was no reason to call in an investigator as there was no sign of [Bigly]: foul play. [Bigly]: However, he agreed that it was an unusual situation and a body in an unusual [Bigly]: location. [Bigly]: How did Stonechild get there? [Bigly]: He noted the footprints in the snow appeared to be several days old. [Sage]: How did he get there? [Sage]: I don't know. [Sage]: I don't know. [Sage]: Just walked over from the west side with one shoe. [Sage]: Just sort of showed [Bigly]: up in this isolated north end industrial area in the middle of nowhere in freezing [Bigly]: winter. [Bigly]: Just poof. [Bigly]: I am. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Just happened. [Ood]: Lost his shoe.
[Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Just got in some shenanigans. [Ood]: Walked several miles in deadly cold. [Ood]: You know. [Bigly]: I don't know if we've walked several miles, but yeah. [Bigly]: That's what they want us to believe with the official report, right? [Bigly]: Later in an interview with the RCMP, he referred to Constable Hartwig as a very [Bigly]: aggressive individual who suffered from small man syndrome. [Sage]: He definitely looked like that. [Bigly]: Yes. [Bigly]: So officers found two scrapes across the bridge of Stonechild's nose and a cut into [Bigly]: Stonechild's lower lip.
[Bigly]: When they removed his clothing at the morgue, a stone was found in his left shoe, [Bigly]: the one that wasn't missing. [Bigly]: And it had left an impression suggesting that it had been in his shoe for some [Bigly]: time. [Bigly]: They did not send Stone Child's clothing to a crime lab for analysis, which would [Bigly]: have been commonplace in a homicide investigation. [Bigly]: But remember, they flagged it as a sudden death. [Sage]: Yeah, it was just like a real weird accident. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So January 12th, 1993, Stone Child's clothing was destroyed as they had not
[Bigly]: received a request for clothing from the family. [Bigly]: So, you know, your loved one passes and, you know, the police are involved and they [Bigly]: take the clothing and you can request it back when they're done their [Bigly]: investigation. [Bigly]: But who the [Sage]: fuck knows that? [Bigly]: Well, the family didn't request it back. [Bigly]: But it's also notable that the police practice with regards to exhibit destruction, [Bigly]: particularly with clothing, was that it would normally just automatically be [Bigly]: returned to the family. [Bigly]: So by default, they should have given the clothing back to the family, but they did
[Bigly]: not. [Bigly]: They destroyed it. [Bigly]: Weird. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Strange, eh? [Bigly]: I had to imagine why. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So, and it was always practiced to obtain clearance from the family before [Bigly]: destroying clothing. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So, you know, we got your family for it. [Bigly]: Well, we don't want it. [Bigly]: Okay, well, can we destroy it? [Bigly]: And the family says, yeah, go for it. [Bigly]: We don't want [Bigly]: you know, his, his shirt or whatever. [Ood]: Which makes sense. [Ood]: If you want to do the community based policing thing, you should make sure that, [Ood]: you know, a dead loved one's belongings, like get taken care of that. [Ood]: You make the, you do what you do to them with the family wants.
[Ood]: Right. [Bigly]: Staff Sergeant Jarvis worked for the police for several decades. [Bigly]: He was assigned to the investigation of Stone Child's death. [Bigly]: This assignment occurred after the body was in the morgue at around 8.10 p.m., [Bigly]: approximately seven hours after the first responder attended the scene of Stone [Bigly]: Child's body. [Bigly]: Jarvis had attended the morgue. [Bigly]: He did not examine Stone Child's body, but obtained a thumbprint for ID purposes. [Bigly]: Jarvis's explanation for not examining the body was that he had no medical
[Bigly]: training. [Bigly]: Now, Jarvis had been on the police for several decades. [Bigly]: Jesus. [Bigly]: So as a trained and experienced investigating officer, he was quite capable of [Bigly]: examining the body as it lay disrobed on the autopsy table. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: He ID'd the body of Neil Stonechild, and at 9.45 p.m., Sergeant Jarvis attended the [Bigly]: residence of Ms. Stonechild to notify her of the death of her son. [Bigly]: Okay. [Ood]: That's such a weird excuse. [Ood]: Like that's part of the investigation job is examining the body or at least like.
[Sage]: Well, cops have that in their training. [Sage]: Like cops can look at bodies and be like, oh, this speckle pattern meant that he [Sage]: was dragged across this kind of gravel kind of thing. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: Right. [Sage]: Like they should know or they should look at it. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: The family had told Jarvis that Neil was last seen on November 24th, 1990 at [Bigly]: approximately 9 p.m., [Bigly]: At the time, he was with Jason Roy. [Bigly]: Stonechild was staying with Pat Pickard, who later told Jarvis that they last saw [Bigly]: him approximately at 10 p.m. on the evening of November 24th and that he had
[Bigly]: indicated his intention to return home the next day. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: Midnight on November 29th, Sergeant Jarvis filed his report on Stone Child and his [Bigly]: actions that day. [Bigly]: Crime Stoppers tip was received November 30th at 4.42 p.m., suggesting that Neil [Bigly]: was taken to the area of 57th Street and beaten and left there by Danny and Gary [Bigly]: Pratt. [Bigly]: The tip suggested that the reason for the beating was that Neil was fooling with
[Bigly]: Gary Pratt's girlfriend, [Bigly]: The evidence with regards to injuries to Stonechild suggests that there was no [Bigly]: truth to that report. [Bigly]: He was not beaten severely. [Sage]: No, he had like a scrape and a cut on his lip. [Bigly]: That said, there was no indication that Jarvis actually followed up on this report. [Bigly]: So the tip came in. [Bigly]: And he just said, nah, like just didn't even look into it. [Bigly]: He's like, whatever. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Another constable raised concerns about issues between Pratt and Stonechild, but
[Bigly]: Jarvis never looked at that file either. [Bigly]: His explanation was this was something that had happened sometime before. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: People don't hold grudges. [Ood]: That's not a thing. [Bigly]: So Jarvis became aware of Hartwig and Sanger's involvement with Stonechild on the [Bigly]: 24th. [Bigly]: Checking the calls dispatched, I learned that Constable Hartwig had attended at [Bigly]: this residence at approximately 2356 hours and cleared at 01700 hours on November [Bigly]: 25th, 1990, being unable to locate the deceased.
[Bigly]: So why would he check the dispatcher's calls for November 24th and 25th when all he [Bigly]: really knew was that a dead body had been found? [Sage]: Right. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So in testimony about this fact... [Bigly]: and following up with Hartwig and Sanger, Jarvis suggested that there may have been [Bigly]: additional police reports made on the matter involving Stonechild, which had also [Bigly]: been destroyed. [Bigly]: However, there were no other reports, and the inquiry found multiple contradictory [Bigly]: statements being provided by Jarvis.
[Bigly]: Jason Roy had contacted Sergeant Jarvis and advised him that he was with Neil most [Bigly]: of the day and evening of November 24th. [Bigly]: Sergeant Jarvis had arranged to meet with Jason Roy, [Bigly]: The meet lasted for 55 minutes while Roy had completed a longhand written [Bigly]: statement. [Bigly]: Jarvis made no notes of their meeting. [Bigly]: He insisted all the conversation during this meeting was contained in this longhand [Bigly]: statement. [Bigly]: The statement written by Jason Roy was not even 400 words long.
[Bigly]: It was like 55 minutes for less than 400 words. [Bigly]: So it's like seven or eight words written per minute. [Sage]: Yeah, that doesn't happen. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So for the sake of comparison, Jarvis later met with Trent Ewert at 10 p.m. [Bigly]: that night, obtained a statement that was a page long and was only present with [Bigly]: Trent Ewert for 10 minutes to produce that statement. [Bigly]: So like, why did it take Jarvis so long to get a written statement, a 400 word [Bigly]: written statement? [Sage]: Plus than two pages. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: Yeah. [Ood]: And like my scripts for this podcast are frequently like eight to 12 pages long.
[Ood]: Like if some dumbass researching half-ass shit for a podcast has a longer statement [Ood]: than you, somebody who's involved in the investigation, something's wrong. [Ood]: That's right. [Ood]: That's right. [Bigly]: Jarvis filed his investigation report suggesting that Stonechild was going to turn [Bigly]: himself in and he was walking to the correctional center on 60th street, but was [Bigly]: intoxicated and fell asleep and froze. [Bigly]: Notable is that there was absolutely no basis for this conclusion. [Sage]: That's, that's insane. [Bigly]: Yeah.
[Bigly]: So like when he was questioned by the RCMP on the matter, Jarvis had agreed with [Bigly]: the RCMP that it would not make sense for a young offender to turn himself into the [Bigly]: correctional center. [Sage]: That's way the fuck in the middle of nowhere. [Sage]: How would you get there at night, right? [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: And said that the weather that night and being in that area of the city was very [Bigly]: feasible. [Bigly]: And basically the inquiry found this to be absolutely preposterous. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: That Stone Child would just go to turn himself in at a correctional center in the
[Bigly]: middle of fucking nowhere. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: In the middle of Warehouse City in the North End. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Ood]: Editing Ud here. [Ood]: I just wanted to emphasize just how out of the way Neil Stonechild would have had [Ood]: to have gone in order for his travel to meet... [Ood]: the police's theory of the story, that is, him going to the correctional center at [Ood]: the far north part of town to turn himself in, and he fell asleep on the way and
[Ood]: died in the cold, rather than the version of events that have the police forcefully [Ood]: confining and bringing Neil Stonechild there. [Ood]: It's walking across the entire city in the dead of winter, [Ood]: In the middle of the night, it's literally over 10 kilometers of walking. [Ood]: And this isn't an area where buses went to. [Ood]: As we emphasized in the beginning of the episode, there was no residential houses
[Ood]: here. [Ood]: There was no parks. [Ood]: There was no restaurants. [Ood]: There was no leisure centers. [Ood]: It was warehouses and industry in the North End. [Ood]: Just trucking yards and warehouses. [Ood]: There was nothing up there. [Ood]: And the police purport that he walked all the way there in the middle of the night, [Ood]: in the dead of winter, wearing only one shoe. [Ood]: That's the story they want you to buy.
[Ood]: Anyways, back to these guys. [Bigly]: Jarvis testified that Saskatoon's industrial north end was an area frequented by [Bigly]: people late at night who would likely be involved in crimes as well as late shift [Bigly]: workers, etc. [Bigly]: So it was often a very busy area for Saskatoon police. [Sage]: No, that sounds like bullshit. [Sage]: Sorry. [Bigly]: So December 5th, Jarvis spoke to people who had last interacted with Stone Child on [Bigly]: the evening of November 24th. [Bigly]: And he also spoke to a pathologist on the case who indicated that while they
[Bigly]: figured the body had been there for at least 48 hours, it was possible the deceased [Bigly]: died on November 25th. [Bigly]: And given that he spent the day talking to people about Stone Child who last saw [Bigly]: him on the 24th, you think he would have like connected these dots to say, hey, you [Bigly]: know, it was what was going on the 24th and 25th. [Bigly]: Yeah, like an investigator would. [Bigly]: Like an investigator would, yeah. [Bigly]: But he either basically ignored the statement from the pathologist about how long [Bigly]: Stonechild had been there, or just didn't make that connection.
[Sage]: I'm not willing to give him the benefit of that doubt. [Bigly]: So Jarvis concluded his file with the following note. [Bigly]: Several Crimestoppers tips have also been received. [Bigly]: However, it is the opinion of the investigator that these are unfounded and [Bigly]: directed more towards causing disharmony on the street against the Prats. [Bigly]: It is felt that unless something concrete by way of evidence to the contrary is [Bigly]: obtained, the deceased died from exposure and froze to death.
[Bigly]: There is nothing to indicate why he was in the area other than possibility that he [Bigly]: was going to turn himself into the correctional center or was attempting to follow [Bigly]: the tracks back to the Sutherland group home or simply wandered around drunk until [Bigly]: he passed out from the cold and alcohol and froze, concluded at this time. [Bigly]: That was the end of the file until the RCMP opened their investigation in 2000, [Bigly]: about 10 years later.
[Bigly]: Jarvis had interviewed eight witnesses, took written statements from two of them. [Bigly]: The inquiry found that following the closure of the file, two of his fellow [Bigly]: officers, one officer whose son was a friend of Stonechild, had contacted him about [Bigly]: this file, indicating additional investigation should be done. [Bigly]: Jarvis did not reopen the file. [Ood]: Jarvis says, fuck. [Ood]: Like, who opens up a police file when new information is found that could change [Ood]: the case? [Ood]: Sounds dumb. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: You should just stick with whatever you found first and don't let your mind be
[Ood]: changed by that liberal fax. [Ood]: You know, all that shit. [Bigly]: And boom, that's my section. [Ood]: I'm going to read you the first, second, and third of eight articles written about [Ood]: Neil Stonechild in Saskatoon's city newspaper, The Star Phoenix. [Ood]: Just as I read through these, just a reminder that there is a lot of bias in the
[Ood]: words the journalist chose to describe Neal and his actions. [Ood]: I think that's very evident of the opinions of indigenous people in Saskatoon and [Ood]: how Neal was described in these articles. [Ood]: So just a note on that, there's going to be some harsh framing for Printed in Saskatoon's newspaper, The Star of Phoenix, December 1st, 1990, three days after the body was found. [Ood]: Body found in Citi Field Identified
[Ood]: Saskatoon police have identified Neil Christopher Stonechild, 17, as the person [Ood]: whose body was found Thursday in a field in the city's north. [Ood]: An autopsy is expected to be conducted in the next few days to determine the cause [Ood]: of death. [Ood]: Printed, March 4th, in the Star Phoenix, over three months after Neil [Ood]: Stonechild's death.
[Ood]: Family suspects foul play. [Ood]: Police say every avenue investigated. [Ood]: When Neil Stonechild's frozen body was found in a vacant field in North Saskatoon [Ood]: last November, [Ood]: family members immediately suspected foul play. [Ood]: Three months later, they still subscribed to that theory, even though the police [Ood]: file on that case had been closed. [Ood]: The official cause of death was listed as hypothermia. [Ood]: Aside from some scratches on the nose, there were no marks of physical abuse.
[Ood]: His blood alcohol was .15, almost twice the legal limit for impaired [Ood]: driving. [Ood]: Stonechild's mother, Stella, and sister, Erica, are the first to admit Neil had a [Ood]: problem with alcohol, but they say in the months before his death, he was coming to [Ood]: terms with his problems. [Ood]: They also say that, had Stone Child been white, police would have been more [Ood]: thorough in the investigation of his death. [Ood]: It makes me wonder.
[Ood]: If Neil was the son of a mayor or commissioner, police would still be [Ood]: investigating, Stella said. [Ood]: A senior officer within the department guardedly agreed. [Ood]: But department spokesman Sergeant Dave Scott vehemently denies Stella's assessment [Ood]: of the investigation. [Ood]: Quote, [Ood]: I don't agree. [Ood]: A tremendous amount of work went into that case, he says. [Ood]: Pointing to a hefty file, Scott says investigators pursued every avenue.
[Ood]: The coroner's report said no evidence showed Stone Child, who was 17, was beaten [Ood]: before his death. [Ood]: The profile we have this time was death by hypothermia. [Ood]: It was an unfortunate incident, Scott reports. [Ood]: Nevertheless, the Stone Child family is convinced Neil was killed. [Ood]: He was found November 29th lying face down in a field behind 830 57th Street
[Ood]: West. [Ood]: According to the pathologist's report, Stone Child could have died as early as [Ood]: November 25th. [Ood]: It is where the body was found that puzzles his relatives. [Ood]: Why was he found way up in the North Industrial Area with only one shoe? [Ood]: Asks his mother. [Ood]: What kind of kid goes out with only one shoe? [Ood]: The temperatures in Saskatoon, the weak stone child disappeared and until the body [Ood]: was found ranged from a low of minus 28 on November 25th to a high of 5 on November
[Ood]: 29th. [Ood]: He was last seen alive November 24th. [Ood]: at a confectionery at 33rd Street and Confederation Drive. [Ood]: He was very drunk. [Ood]: Stella and her daughter don't believe the police theory Neil was walking to the [Ood]: Provincial Correctional Facility to give himself up. [Ood]: At the time of his death, Stone Child was a fugitive from a community home where he [Ood]: was serving time for a break and enter. [Ood]: Stella said, I know my son very well.
[Ood]: I know he wouldn't go out there by himself. [Ood]: Even though he was on the run, he always called home. [Ood]: It was a stormy night, November 24th. [Ood]: I told him please be careful. [Ood]: He said he was going to be alright. [Ood]: Even if he was so intoxicated at the 7-Eleven, how did he get to the North End? [Ood]: Erica asks. [Ood]: I don't know anyone. [Ood]: It was too late for buses to stop. [Ood]: There were no houses. [Ood]: Both women believe Stonechild was driven up to the area and abandoned. [Ood]: He was thrown out there, Stella said.
[Ood]: I know him. [Ood]: She feared for her son because in the weeks before his death, he had an altercation [Ood]: with a gang. [Ood]: He suffered a beating, the result of a deal gone sour over the sale of some [Ood]: handguns Stone Child acquired during a break and enter. [Ood]: He got a licking. [Ood]: He was beaten with guns and baseball bats, Stella said. [Ood]: Sure, he was drunk, but he had enough sense to run home. [Ood]: He was assaulted in a city location, but managed to stagger his way to his mother's [Ood]: home on Confederation Crescent. [Ood]: Stonechild was a familiar face to social services youth workers, who described him
[Ood]: as a likable, pleasant boy. [Ood]: His major downfall was alcohol. [Ood]: He enrolled in Alcoholics Anonymous program a few weeks before his death and had [Ood]: attended regularly. [Ood]: He was learning that a life with alcohol was bad, but he was dealing with the [Ood]: issues in his life. [Ood]: a social worker said. [Ood]: He was a smart kid with a lot of potential. [Ood]: He had a terrific personality. [Ood]: He could have been anything. [Ood]: His death was a terrible waste. [Ood]: Estella ponders the tragedy.
[Ood]: She declares, Not a day goes by when I don't shed a tear for my boy. [Ood]: It's heartbreaking to know my son is gone. [Ood]: I can't let him rest in peace knowing he didn't die naturally. [Ood]: Whoever did it is still out there. [Ood]: Written in the Star of Phoenix, August 17th, 2000. [Ood]: Two officers confronted in Stone Child freezing death. [Ood]: An RCMP task force has identified and approached the two Saskatoon police officers
[Ood]: who supposedly last saw 17-year-old Neil Stone Child alive, say sources close to [Ood]: the investigation. [Ood]: The two officers were confronted by the RCMP, and they said, talk to the Saskatoon [Ood]: Police Association, the source said. [Ood]: Association Vice President Sergeant Dick Melinchuk confirmed the RCMP investigators [Ood]: spoke with several members on the Stone Child matter, but he did not know whether [Ood]: any of those approached or the two officers identified as allegedly having last
[Ood]: contact with Stone Child. [Ood]: Stonechild went missing on a frigid night in November 1990, after creating a [Ood]: disturbance at a Saskatoon apartment building. [Ood]: Five days later, on November 29, 1990, his frozen body was identified in a field in [Ood]: Saskatoon's North Industrial area. [Ood]: near the 800 block of 57th Street. [Ood]: A friend partying with Stone Child that night has said that he watched Stone Child [Ood]: get driven away in a Saskatoon police patrol car.
[Ood]: The friend who asked not to be named says Stone Child was screaming, they're gonna [Ood]: kill me. [Ood]: Police, however, say that a drunken Stone Child was seen just after midnight at a [Ood]: convenience store at 33rd Street and Confederation Drive, contrary to the account [Ood]: of the friend. [Ood]: An autopsy determined that Stone Child died of hypothermia. [Ood]: Although his frozen body showed no signs of a struggle, police at the time said [Ood]: there were several scratches across his nose.
[Ood]: Editor's note, stay tuned to see how truthful the statement, no signs of a [Ood]: struggle, and just some scratches are. [Ood]: Back to reading. [Ood]: Stonechild's sister, Erica, says she examined her brother's body before burial and [Ood]: showed signs of a beating. [Ood]: He had numerous bumps all over his head and tiny little cuts. [Ood]: He had a gash right across his nose, diagonally from his forehead to his cheekbone,
[Ood]: and bruises on his face, she said Wednesday. [Ood]: The RCMP task force is examining seven separate cases, five of which involve the [Ood]: deaths of Native men. [Ood]: The task force will forward the results of its investigation to provincial justice [Ood]: officials, who will then recommend whether criminal charges are warranted. [Sage]: Now the question arises, did Sergeant Jarvis learn that Neil Stonechild had been in [Sage]: police custody in November 20th or 25th?
[Sage]: So when Jarvis was questioned by the RCMP, he suggested that he had a recollection [Sage]: of Jason Roy telling him that he was stopped by the police and provided a fake [Sage]: name. [Sage]: So now I would note that this was not mentioned in Jason Roy's 55 minute, 400 word [Sage]: or less statement. [Sage]: Jarvis told the RCMP that Jason Roy was quite proud of deceiving the police with a [Sage]: fake name. [Sage]: when they met and he obtained the statement. [Sage]: He also said that Jason would talk about seeing Stonechild in the back of a police [Sage]: car.
[Sage]: Jarvis would later testify that these statements were based on, quote, false [Sage]: memories, saying he learned of these things during discussions with the RCMP. [Sage]: Kind of crazy. [Sage]: When the inquiry listened to the tapes of the interview with RCMP and Jarvis, they [Sage]: found nothing leading, inappropriate or unfair in their interview with Jarvis. [Sage]: So nevertheless, the inquiry contacted memory experts, who I will summarize, [Sage]: indicated Jarvis was full of shit. [Sage]: Jarvis was an experienced officer, conducted a shitload of interviews in his
[Sage]: career, was trained in interview and interrogation techniques, was aware of witness [Sage]: contamination, etc. [Sage]: When Jarvis was interviewed, he knew the RCMP was investigating a possible police [Sage]: involvement in the death of Neil Stonechild. [Sage]: He had known that Neil Stonechild was in police custody on November 24th, 1990, and [Sage]: he knew that that would be extremely significant to the investigation. [Sage]: So how did Jarvis learn he had a false memory? [Sage]: The information he gave the RCMP was not recorded in his notebook or his report.
[Sage]: Also notable, Jarvis had also provided independently to the RCMP several [Sage]: recollections of matters of his investigation, which were not in his notebook or [Sage]: report. [Sage]: So he's just all over the fucking place. [Sage]: Basically, in cross-examination, Jarvis metaphorically shit the bed as far as [Sage]: credible testimony goes. [Sage]: He didn't remember one thing, then remembered something else, then later forgetting [Sage]: about it. [Sage]: So he just like waffled and flip-flopped all over the place. [Sage]: Basically, he left out critical information from his notes and report about
[Sage]: Stonechild having been in police custody. [Sage]: What would have appeared to be incompetence now appeared to be something much more [Sage]: serious. [Sage]: So now it's kind of seeming like maybe he's got something to hide and he's just not [Sage]: a dumbass. [Ood]: It's not that he's an incompetent cop. [Ood]: It seems like he may be a corrupt one at this point. [Ood]: It seems like it's more cover-up than forgetfulness. [Sage]: That's right. [Sage]: So an investigation of other officers at the inquiry also was concerning.
[Sage]: A constable Brand met with an informant in detention on November 30th around 7 p.m. [Sage]: And according to his notebook, the informant indicated Stonechild had concerns [Sage]: approximately a week before his death about his safety and that he had received [Sage]: threats. [Sage]: He then indicated he passed this information on through an internal memo, which he [Sage]: believes was given to Saskatoon Police Service Sergeant Neil Wiley. [Sage]: Sergeant Wiley denied in the inquiry that he had received any information from [Sage]: Constable Brand.
[Sage]: But that said, Sergeant Jarvis records receiving information from Wiley on November [Sage]: 30th, 1990 in his notebook. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: So even more puzzling, the note in Jarvis's book appears between 4.42 p.m. [Sage]: and 6.52 p.m. [Sage]: This was before Constable Brand met with his informant at 7 p.m. [Sage]: So understandably, the inquiry felt Brand's testimony to be unreliable. [Sage]: Like no shit. [Sage]: That was a fucking mess.
[Sage]: Glenn Clayton Winslow was a patrol sergeant assigned to Area C, which is the north [Sage]: end of Saskatoon. [Sage]: Police records indicate he was dispatched at 525 a.m. [Sage]: on November 25th. [Sage]: Hartwig and Sanger were also dispatched to advise next of kin about a [Sage]: murder-suicide involving a father and two sons, like we talked about before. [Ood]: Yeah, significant event. [Sage]: Yeah, like a real big thing. [Sage]: Winslow did not recall this or any contact with Sanger and Hartwig. [Sage]: He was also not aware of any dispatch regarding Stonechild.
[Sage]: He testified that he spent a great deal of time as probably the only policeman in [Sage]: this industrial area. [Sage]: He said that he rarely encountered young people in the area at night, which [Sage]: directly contradicted Jarvis's earlier testimony about it being a busy place for [Sage]: police. [Sage]: Like, no shit, I could have fucking told you that. [Ood]: When you don't live here, you don't realize how far out of place this area is. [Ood]: It's away from any building areas. [Ood]: It's away from any residential areas. [Ood]: It's like a work city all on its own.
[Sage]: Yeah, it's far away from everything. [Sage]: There's nothing out there except for trucking companies and window places. [Bigly]: And truck car washes. [Sage]: There's nothing out there. [Bigly]: There's nothing. [Bigly]: It's like field and warehouse. [Bigly]: It's a ghost [Ood]: town at midnight. [Sage]: Well, like having been a... [Sage]: teenager on the north end we just went and drank in parks we just put our rum in [Sage]: our slurpee cups and went to the local playground you know like you didn't [Bigly]: hang out in the industrial section [Ood]: no there was no you want to go hang out by the barbed wire fence outside of the
[Ood]: giant like semi car wash place [Sage]: no or you or you'd go down to the shack by uh mewassen park or you'd go to [Sage]: someone's house like those you you wouldn't never go out to a the fucking [Sage]: industrial area like what [Sage]: What do you do if you got to pee? [Sage]: Especially in the winter. [Sage]: That'd be cold as shit. [Sage]: Yeah. [Ood]: Yeah. [Sage]: That's fucking stupid. [Sage]: So Constable Luteet knew Stonechild's younger brother, Jake. [Sage]: He recalled that on December 4th, he ran into Jake, who wanted to talk to him about [Sage]: the death of his brother.
[Sage]: Luteet learned that Jake had heard that Neil was at a party and got beaten up and [Sage]: then dropped off by the Prats. [Sage]: This was also noted in his notebook and took place at 4.50 p.m. [Sage]: Luteet pulled the file from police records and photocopies it. [Sage]: This was the photocopy provided to the RCMP after the Saskatoon Police Service [Sage]: destroyed the original to make room for the Renos that you'll recall [SPEAKER_02]: from last episode. [Sage]: He then passes along the info he received from Jake at major crimes. [Sage]: The Stone Child file lived in the morality unit and there was some discussion about
[Sage]: it and if it had should have been transferred to major crimes. [Sage]: He had concerns about the file and met with Stone Child's mother but did not [Sage]: document the meetings as he was afraid he would be subject to discipline. [Bigly]: Oh boy. [Sage]: Which is sketchy. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Well, I mean, you're like a cop and you're doing this like sort of side [Bigly]: investigation on your own. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: You know, of not, you know, certainly not sanctioned by the department or the [Bigly]: actual officer who's supposed to be investigating this.
[Sage]: So he's just kind of doing this on the side and like, because his kid knew the [Sage]: brother of the Neil Stone child. [Ood]: And likely this guy already has a full workload. [Sage]: Yeah. [Ood]: He's doing this in addition to that. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: Ah, so Lutit felt the investigation was poorly done. [Sage]: No shit. [Sage]: He actually said that if Neil was a different person and a different social [Sage]: surrounding, the investigation would be much more thorough. [Sage]: He made a list of concerns and met with his staff sergeant. [Sage]: These concerns were found in his notebook on December 30th, 25 days after Jarvis
[Sage]: closed his file. [Sage]: So Lutit's concerns were as follows. [Sage]: Why would a young offender go to the correctional center? [Sage]: Like we said, it's like in the middle of fucking nowhere. [Sage]: No public transit. [Sage]: It was cold as balls. [Bigly]: Well, you're a young offender. [Bigly]: You're not going to go to an adult fucking prison. [Bigly]: No. [Bigly]: To turn yourself in. [Bigly]: No. [Bigly]: That makes no sense, especially in the middle of fucking nowhere. [Sage]: Yeah, that's stupid. [Ood]: You would call 911 to turn yourself in, especially like if you're inner city youth [Ood]: that doesn't like may not have access to like transportation in the middle of
[Ood]: winter in the middle of night, you know? [Bigly]: Or a cop shop, take a bus downtown, and just walk to the police station. [Bigly]: It's right downtown. [Sage]: It makes no fucking sense. [Sage]: He would go all the way to the North End. [Sage]: No, that's stupid. [Sage]: There was no effort to find Stone Child's missing shoe, nor find his baseball cap, [Sage]: which he was known for wearing. [Sage]: That was another concern. [Sage]: What efforts were made to establish Stone Child's activities the night he was last [Sage]: seen? [Sage]: So that was another concern. [Ood]: Yeah, retracing steps to see where he was at what time. [Ood]: Mm-hmm.
[Sage]: So Luteet met with Staff Sergeant Bolton from Major Crimes on January 7th, 1991, [Sage]: which was 33 days after Jarvis had already closed the file. [Sage]: Bolton and Luteet met for several minutes and Bolton told him to go speak to [Sage]: Jarvis. [Sage]: Luteet met with Jarvis for 40 minutes and found Jarvis to be dismissive. [Sage]: And he told Luteet the matter, quote, was in hand and that Luteet should leave the [Sage]: matter alone, which doesn't raise any alarm bells or red flags at all.
[Bigly]: Oh, no, definitely. [Bigly]: It's standard police operating procedure, right? [Sage]: Exactly. [Sage]: Like, keep your nose out of my fucking business. [Sage]: Definitely doesn't sound sketchy. [Sage]: No. [Sage]: No. [Sage]: So in 92 or 93, two or three years after Stonechild was found, Luteet followed up [Sage]: with police records to see if anything had been done on the file. [Sage]: There was nothing from major crimes or anything about his meetings with Bolton or [Sage]: Jarvis. [Sage]: At the inquiry, Luteet testified that he never received any information or heard [Sage]: any rumors that Saskatoon police were involved in the death of Stonechild and that
[Sage]: if there were such going on, he would have followed up with the officers. [Sage]: At the inquiry, Major Crimes Staff Sergeant Bolton testified that the Staff [Sage]: Sergeant in charge of the morality unit would have to contact him to have the file [Sage]: transferred and that it was possible that the Staff Sergeant in morality did not [Sage]: reassign the file. [Sage]: He also testified there was no time in his memory where the Major Crimes Unit [Sage]: declined a file transfer from another unit. [Sage]: He said that he did not have any recollection of the Stone Child file, nor of the
[Sage]: conversation with Luteet, but said that it was possible that he spoke with Luteet [Sage]: as per Luteet's version of events. [Sage]: So also of interest, a little meaty tidbit. [Sage]: Bolton had been disciplined by the police services in 1969 for picking up an [Sage]: individual and dropping them off outside of town. [Sage]: The individual filed a complaint, which led to Bolton's discipline. [Ood]: Shrug. [Ood]: That's something that's going on in the background of all this. [Ood]: Like this isn't an isolated event, like an indigenous person or somebody of a
[Ood]: visible minority being dropped on the outskirts of town. [Bigly]: It's just what they were doing. [Bigly]: That's how they handled it. [Bigly]: It was standard procedure. [Bigly]: It was a thing that maybe wasn't talked about, but everyone knew about. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: And sometimes they died. [Bigly]: Sometimes they didn't. [Bigly]: And if they didn't die... [Bigly]: How many of percentage wise, how many would have the capacity to lodge like a [Bigly]: formal complaint? [Bigly]: As you can see, there can be a formal complaint on the fucking page of the Star
[Bigly]: Phoenix, as we mentioned, you know, last episode. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: And the police didn't follow up with it because, you know, proper channels and you [Bigly]: got to do this and this. [Bigly]: It wasn't on the right form. [Bigly]: You know, and yeah. [Bigly]: So, I mean, this was... [Bigly]: This is baked for decades into their operating procedure. [Bigly]: This was baked into, you know, into the whole conduct of the force. [Sage]: And people that probably did make complaints and then didn't have them ever [Sage]: followed up on was just like, don't even fucking bother.
[Sage]: They're not going to do, they're going to do shit all for you. [Sage]: Don't even try. [Bigly]: Don't even push back. [Bigly]: Don't even. [Bigly]: It's a waste of time. [Bigly]: Don't rock the boat. [Bigly]: You know, you'll be disciplined or they'll find something to discipline you on. [Bigly]: And yeah. [Ood]: And make no mistake about it, some of the people that were involved in the [Ood]: cover-ups, some of the people that helped the case not get along properly, some of [Ood]: the people that are directly involved, some of the people that actually drove other [Ood]: people out, some of the people that agree with that as a course of action to deal [Ood]: with, quote-unquote, the Indigenous folks, some of those people are still working
[Ood]: and training people in the Saskatchewan police force today. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Some of them are still there. [Ood]: Yep. [Ood]: Right in Saskatoon. [Ood]: Yep. [SPEAKER_19]: Why is there such a neglect? [SPEAKER_19]: Why is there such disinterest on the part of those who are in power to hear what we [SPEAKER_19]: are telling them about our daily lives? [SPEAKER_19]: This is what it's a matter of. [SPEAKER_19]: I would imagine in a democracy, people speak to those in power and say, this is [SPEAKER_19]: what's happening with me. [SPEAKER_19]: And those in power say, oh, well, let's look at it. [SPEAKER_19]: Let's determine whether or not it's true.
[SPEAKER_19]: Maybe if you don't even believe it, you look into it nonetheless. [SPEAKER_19]: Many chiefs of police in the United States who say they don't believe in racial [SPEAKER_19]: profiling believe in democracy and have brought into place systems to begin looking [SPEAKER_19]: at the issues of whether or not racial profiling does in fact exist, only to point [SPEAKER_19]: out that in Canada, [SPEAKER_19]: Outside of Kingston, we have not got a police force that is willing to engage in [SPEAKER_19]: the matter. [SPEAKER_19]: And we have laws, particularly through the anti-terrorism laws, where many legal
[SPEAKER_19]: scholars have said to the federal government, you should be banning racial [SPEAKER_19]: profiling in the law. [SPEAKER_19]: How brown-skinned people tend to be stopped all the time. [SPEAKER_19]: And this continues on. [SPEAKER_19]: And despite the evidence we provide to the government, nothing seems to change. [SPEAKER_19]: Why? [SPEAKER_19]: There's some interesting issues around the way police look at us. [SPEAKER_19]: And so years ago, when I used to work in the metropolitan government in Toronto, we [SPEAKER_19]: actually did an audit. [SPEAKER_19]: An audit was done of policing and so on. [SPEAKER_19]: And the person who conducted the study, a white man by the name of Alan Andrews, he
[SPEAKER_19]: kind of started out on the side of the chief of police. [SPEAKER_19]: But after he went through the study, here's one of the things he said. [SPEAKER_19]: There was significant evidence that many police officers who are constantly in [SPEAKER_19]: contact with the public develop strong feelings and beliefs as to the attributes of [SPEAKER_19]: individuals based on factors such as appearance and racial background. [SPEAKER_19]: These officers would no doubt be offended if their attitudes were described as [SPEAKER_19]: potentially racist. [SPEAKER_19]: Nevertheless, the same attitudes can and do produce a bias in behavior which
[SPEAKER_19]: results in unequal treatment of individuals of different cultural or racial [SPEAKER_19]: backgrounds. [Sage]: So in November and December of 1990, when this was all happening, it was reported [Sage]: that Eli was a patrol sergeant for Saskatoon's east side. [Sage]: His adopted son was a friend of Neil Stonechild, who knew the Stonechild family [Sage]: before Neil's death. [Sage]: So Tarasov was was reading the paper and he saw Stonechild's obituary. [Sage]: That is how he learned of Neil's death.
[Sage]: He was contacted by Stonechild's mom afterward, asking him to look into the [Sage]: investigation. [Sage]: At the inquiry, he didn't know if he looked in the records after being contacted by [Sage]: Stonechild's mother or if it was after reading the obituary. [Sage]: He didn't recall seeing the autopsy report or the toxicology report on the file [Sage]: when he accessed it. [Sage]: So he doesn't really remember much. [Sage]: No. [Sage]: Tarasov spoke to Jarvis about the matter sometime after the file was concluded. [Sage]: When interviewed by the RCMP, Tarasoff said Jarvis was, quote, an Englishman with a
[Sage]: colonial attitude. [Sage]: And that, quote, when natives were involved, he did not take it serious. [Sage]: That's interesting. [Sage]: Yeah, which is a lot of, again... [Bigly]: That's your own co-worker. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: So he said that shit about his own co-worker, that he was... [Ood]: colonial attitude sounds like a bit of a softer term for like white supremacist [Sage]: yeah like am [Ood]: i am i wrong in making that leap no i don't think so yeah [Sage]: uh so he asked sergeant jarvis what he thought about the file and sergeant jarvis
[Sage]: had responded the kid went out got drunk went for a walk and froze to death how [Sage]: fucking callous is that yeah [Sage]: So Tarasov advised Stonechild's mother to contact a lawyer who might have success [Sage]: in getting additional investigation done. [Sage]: He testified to the inquiry that he did not hear anything about the police being [Sage]: involved in Stonechild's disappearance. [Sage]: So he was obviously on the outs with those like main click of officers who clearly [Sage]: knew everything that was going on.
[Bigly]: As it is often the case, you know, if you're going to rock the boat, well, we're [Bigly]: just not going to include you. [Sage]: Well, exactly. [Sage]: He seemed like he was maybe a quote-unquote good apple in the bunch of cops. [Bigly]: ACAB except for Tarasov and Looted. [Sage]: Yeah, ACAB except for those guys. [Ood]: Yeah, like good cops are fired or in the process of being fired. [Sage]: Yeah, they get pushed out. [Sage]: Or quitting. [Sage]: Yeah, or quitting. [Sage]: And yeah. [Sage]: So David Scott was the Saskatoon police's media person from 1988 to October of
[Sage]: 1991, encompassing the period of time that the Stone Child investigation was [Sage]: occurring. [Sage]: He would later become Saskatoon's chief of police in June 1996, and he left in June [Sage]: of 2001. [Sage]: A Star Phoenix article was going to hit March 4th, 1991 about the case. [Sage]: Allegations in the article suggested a poor investigation was done. [Sage]: No shit. [Sage]: And suggesting that racism was a contributing factor to the lack of investigation. [Sage]: Again, no shit. [Sage]: So at the time of the article, Scott denied this.
[Sage]: In quotes, I don't agree. [Sage]: A tremendous amount of work went into this case. [Sage]: And then the newspaper article indicated that he pointed to a, quote, hefty file. [Sage]: It turns out the file that he referred to by the reporter may have been one of two [Sage]: files that he routinely carried with him. [Sage]: One contained the current Crimestopper flyers that had been inside to [Sage]: investigators, and the other one was a file of occurrences of the next 24 hours. [Sage]: It's real fucking misleading when you're pointing to a hefty file and it literally
[Sage]: has nothing to do with what you're fucking talking about. [Ood]: That's something that Trump has done recently is put a bunch of blank papers in a [Ood]: file and say, look at all the... Look at all the work we've done. [Ood]: So much work. [Ood]: Binders of women. [Ood]: Who was that one? [Ood]: That was Mormon. [Sage]: What's his name? [Sage]: Radio Demon. [Sage]: Who came up with the binders of women? [Arthur]: I forgot about binders of women. [Arthur]: Give me a second. [Sage]: Why am I drawing a blank on this man? [Arthur]: Binders...
[Ood]: I guess those magic underwear didn't protect him from bad press. [Arthur]: Just to add, it was in response to a question about pay equity, referring to ring [Arthur]: binders with resumes of job applications. [SPEAKER_01]: We took a concerted effort to go out and find women who had backgrounds that could [SPEAKER_01]: be qualified to become members of our cabinet. [SPEAKER_01]: I went to a number of women's groups and said, can you help us find folks? [SPEAKER_01]: And they brought us whole binders full of women. [SPEAKER_01]: Just binders of women. [Sage]: So anyway, the article goes on to say that the police pursued every avenue.
[Sage]: So in February of 2000, David Scott, now chief of police, is quoted again in an [Sage]: article. [Sage]: At the inquiry, he indicated that more work could have been done. [Sage]: So I need someone to read this. [Sage]: You. [Leon]: Question. [Leon]: Okay, now, Mr. Scott, is that the extent of the investigation conducted by the [Leon]: Saskatoon Police Service? [Leon]: Do you today believe it's correct to say that a tremendous amount of work went into [Leon]: that case? [Leon]: Answer. [Leon]: Well, it depends. [Leon]: This case, when I read it after receiving it from you, was completed on the
[Leon]: assumption that the death was from hypothermia from the autopsy, and I believe that [Leon]: the pathologist who took part in it... [Leon]: I realized in reading through it that there could have been more work done on the [Leon]: investigation. [Leon]: Yes. [Leon]: End quote. [Sage]: So this, uh, buddy didn't even know, didn't seem to know that if he, uh, did not [Sage]: review the reports or if he had read some or all the reports. [Sage]: So he just like basically was like, I don't fucking know what I read. [Sage]: I don't know. [Sage]: The inquiry found David Scott had misled the public in a 1991 interview and
[Sage]: And had David Scott carefully reviewed the file, the matter may have been [Sage]: investigated further in the same year. [Sage]: Once again, chief of police. [Sage]: Yeah, chief of police. [Sage]: So he basically like shit the bed on that. [Sage]: That said, he ultimately started the process to have the RCMP investigate the death [Sage]: of Stonechild. [Sage]: Also, another similar issue about Daryl Knight had arisen, leading to the [Sage]: suspension of Hatchin and Munson. [SPEAKER_12]: Good evening. [SPEAKER_12]: Harsh allegations against two Saskatoon police officers.
[SPEAKER_12]: They're accused of mistreating a native man. [SPEAKER_12]: And at the same time, an investigation is being launched into the mysterious deaths [SPEAKER_12]: of two other Aboriginal men. [SPEAKER_12]: Pia Chattopadhyay reports. [SPEAKER_12]: A brave face [SPEAKER_03]: from a police chief fearing the worst. [SPEAKER_36]: And we have nothing that would indicate that they are related, the person being [SPEAKER_36]: dropped off or the two people that were found. [SPEAKER_03]: This morning, the chief said what happened during the past few weeks would be at [SPEAKER_03]: the center of two separate but internal police investigations.
[SPEAKER_03]: He was firm. [SPEAKER_03]: The police could and would investigate two of their own officers. [SPEAKER_08]: But the Saskatoon police are under pressure. [SPEAKER_08]: Hours later, Chief Dave Scott reverses his decision and turns the investigation [SPEAKER_08]: over to the RCMP. [Ood]: But by the way, for our non-Canadian listeners, RCMP and city cops are kind of the [Ood]: same distinction as like city cops and state cops. [Bigly]: I think the RCMP are probably more akin to the FBI in the US.
[Arthur]: Yeah, so the RCMP are a federal policing force, which the state doesn't really [Arthur]: have. [Arthur]: But it's closer, like you said, to a state's police who would do investigations [Arthur]: over the whole state as opposed to a city's police that would just work on a single [Arthur]: city. [Ood]: RCMP have jurisdiction over all of Canada, right? [Ood]: Yeah. [Sage]: Yeah, but there are specific chunks of Saskatchewan RCMP that are in charge of [Sage]: Saskatchewan RCMP. [Bigly]: Division F, I believe. [Sage]: Oh, there you go. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: All right. [Sage]: He also wrote the Ministry of Justice asking for investigation into two other
[Sage]: deaths. [Sage]: The RCMP actually created a task force called Project Ferrick to look into this [Sage]: eventually leading to discipline of the deputy police chief, Dan Wicks. [Sage]: So that's enough of David Scott. [Sage]: And here we are on to David Wilton. [Leon]: David Wilton. [Leon]: At the time, he was the duty officer. [Leon]: So basically, he deals with major incidents that arose on or staffing issues during [Leon]: the shift that he was assigned.
[Leon]: He reports to the superintendent of operations. [Leon]: Now, he didn't recall Stone Child, but finding the freezing body should have been [Leon]: brought to his attention. [Leon]: He said he should have no issue calling in an investigator if they were off duty if [Leon]: one wasn't available. [Leon]: So in an interview with the RCMP, he indicated, quote, he can't even remember [Leon]: Stonechild coming in or going out of cells, what officers might have arrested him, [Leon]: end quote, but also recalled that, quote, a fair bit of news and talk about it, end
[Leon]: quote, but that, quote, that's one case that I had little or next to nothing to do [Leon]: with, end quote. [Ood]: Yeah, so he's separating himself from the case. [Ood]: Yeah, it's like, [Bigly]: not my business. [Ood]: I don't know my problem. [Ood]: It's not my problem. [Ood]: Yeah, not my monkey, not my circus. [Bigly]: You know, it's like that whole ACAB thing where it's like, well, I have an uncle [Bigly]: who's a good guy and a good cop. [Bigly]: And it's like, well, okay, if he's a good person, he's still being complicit in all [Bigly]: the other shitty work. [Bigly]: In this shitty system, yeah. [Bigly]: You know, this guy totally fucking complicit in it.
[Bigly]: You know, I'm not involved, but I'm certainly not stopping it either. [Ood]: There's some chatter. [Ood]: I think I heard about [Leon]: it on the news, but I can't be sure. [Leon]: And that's exactly what his testimony says. [Leon]: He went on to say he was asked about a feeling he had that Stone Child had been [Leon]: arrested. [Leon]: Quote, it's the feeling I had. [Leon]: Back in 1990, I got the feeling a couple of officers brought him into the cells and [Leon]: then took him out. [Leon]: End quote. [Leon]: And during the time he spent in the detention center and communication center, [Leon]: quote, I don't recall Stone Child either seeing him or hearing of him, end quote.
[Leon]: He referred to the papers when he became aware of Stone Child. [Leon]: He said that he had a feeling that, quote, in the back of my mind, he, Stone Child, [Leon]: was brought in and taken out because there was no charge or he wasn't drunk enough [Leon]: to hold, end quote. [Leon]: Whoa. [Leon]: That said, at the inquiry, he said all he knew of Stone Child was from what he had [Leon]: read in the media. [Leon]: So, like, despite his testimony that he would be advised in the event of a frozen [Leon]: body, he had no memory of it. [Sage]: Yeah. [Leon]: Shrug emoji. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: It was a definite shrug emoji. [Sage]: Yeah. [Leon]: So basically the dude who was supposed to be supervising really wasn't supervising
[Leon]: shit. [Ood]: Well, we're not like... Sassoon isn't processing like 50 murders a weekend or [Ood]: something. [Ood]: No. [Ood]: Like New York City. [Ood]: Like finding the dead body of somebody and doing like a partial... [Ood]: We don't get a lot of those. [Ood]: Yeah. [Leon]: You would remember that shit. [Leon]: It seems to me there were a whole lot of people that forgot a whole lot of shit [Leon]: that they shouldn't have forgotten. [Leon]: Like, I've undergone 30 ECT treatments, and I remember this shit better than some [Leon]: of these cops. [Leon]: That's right. [Leon]: Okay, so Frank Simpson, in charge of plainclothes investigations, Murray Montague,
[Leon]: the deputy police chief, and Joe Pencallum, the chief of police, had no [Leon]: recollection of the Stone Child matter at the time. [Sage]: Sorry, plainclothes investigations is a name that I've danced under. [Ood]: Okay. [Ood]: You start just like civilian clothes. [Ood]: No fancy outfits. [Ood]: Just like, you know what? [Ood]: These are my mama jeans. [Ood]: Plain clothes, investigations. [Leon]: Sorry. [Leon]: However, the chief did instruct subordinates to advise of anything major that had [Leon]: happened day or night, duty or off duty.
[Leon]: And nothing was mentioned. [Leon]: He recalled nothing. [Leon]: Yep. [Leon]: He indicated that if there were concerns about investigations brought up in the [Leon]: media, he would expect to be advised. [Leon]: Nope, nada, nothing. [Leon]: Nothing. [Leon]: He was asked to review the Stonechild file and felt more investigation could have [Leon]: been done and even went so far as to say there was negligence in the investigation. [Leon]: Now, James Madden, Jim Madden, who was Saskatoon's mayor from 2000, 2003, and then [Leon]: lost badly, fucking got his ass handed to him, finished a distant third behind Don
[Leon]: Atchison. [Leon]: It was a bad election. [Leon]: I know because I actually volunteered for Jim Madden. [Leon]: I knocked on doors for the guy, so he's on my team. [Leon]: Sort of, I guess. [Leon]: Sort of, I guess. [Bigly]: I mean, Jim is really on Jim's team. [Leon]: Jim is on Jim's team. [Leon]: He's now the mayor of Purdue? [Leon]: I don't know. [Leon]: He's the mayor of a small town in Saskatchewan. [Leon]: He still does the mayor thing. [Arthur]: I'm going to say it's Asquith. [Arthur]: Asquith, yes. [Leon]: Asquith? [Leon]: Asquith. [Leon]: Okay, so anyway, Jim Madden, who was Saskatoon's mayor from 2000 to 2003, during
[Leon]: the inquiry and an NDP candidate in the 2006 federal election, which is when I [Leon]: worked for him, he axed Dave Scott, who was the chief, and weren't clear as to why, [Leon]: but told the media that it wasn't due to the inquiry. [Leon]: Of course not. [Leon]: Not at all. [Leon]: Nope. [Leon]: Had nothing to do with it. [Leon]: So a cop from 1972 to 1997, retiring a superintendent, nothing to do with the [Leon]: investigation, did recall hearing of a frozen body found, heard about Hart [Leon]: Wigginsanger in connection with the story, not sure when he heard about it, but
[Leon]: that it was prior to 1997 when he retired. [Leon]: Madden was interviewed by the CBC and stated that there were, quote, groups of [Leon]: people working within the police service that were successful in keeping [Leon]: information contained, end quote. [Leon]: When he testified for the inquiry, he indicated that he did not receive or rather [Leon]: did not believe that there were, quote, contained information with respect to Neil [Leon]: Stonechild that had been withheld from superiors or the public. [Leon]: Yeah. [Sage]: Okay, that was like wiffle, wishy-washy, waffling? [Sage]: Kind of.
[Leon]: Yeah, it is. [Leon]: He testified that the rumors on the matter ought to have been known by the [Leon]: superiors and senior members of the police. [Leon]: That said, he said that there was a divide in information flow between lower ranks [Leon]: and higher ranks. [Leon]: Said during an interview with the RCMP, quote, I know that it was known that these [Leon]: guys were being looked at, referring to Hartwig and Sanger. [Leon]: When cross-examined, he said that he did not hear stories about Hartwig and Sanger [Leon]: being improper towards Stonechild. [Leon]: Did he just say that? [Bigly]: Did he know or did he know?
[Bigly]: Do you know who knows if anyone knows what's going on? [Ood]: They say there's a block in the up current, but like we just went through like some [Ood]: statements from the chief of police and he seemed to be playing ball with the boys [Ood]: pretty, pretty smoothly. [Ood]: You know, he was holding that thin blue line up high. [Bigly]: Well, and he turfed Dave Scott, but it had nothing to do with the inquiry. [Bigly]: No, definitely not. [Leon]: My personal opinion is Leon Felger is that the termination had everything to do [Leon]: with the inquiry. [Leon]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: His personal opinion, allegedly.
[Bigly]: Leon Filker's alleged personal opinion. [Bigly]: My alleged personal opinion. [Bigly]: Allegedly. [Bigly]: Allegedly. [SPEAKER_29]: When you talk to police officers, they don't admit to this blue wall. [SPEAKER_29]: It exists. [SPEAKER_29]: There's no question about it. [SPEAKER_29]: I mean, I was part of that profession, and I know that it exists. [SPEAKER_29]: And I think you see it time and time again when an officer that was there is [SPEAKER_29]: interviewed with regard to what he saw. [SPEAKER_29]: You know, they didn't see anything. [SPEAKER_29]: They were busy doing this or busy doing that, and that's a bunch of crap. [SPEAKER_29]: In a lot of cases, they know exactly what happened, but they just don't say
[SPEAKER_29]: anything. [Leon]: And this is like as a kid growing up with this inquiry, like this happened in 2000. [Leon]: I was in my early 20s and I remember following this very carefully and thinking all [Leon]: of it was 100% bullshit. [Leon]: And now a decade later coming into this podcast and doing this, I still feel that [Leon]: most of this testimony was bullshit. [Bigly]: It happens. [Leon]: It happens. [Bigly]: It happens. [Leon]: So the hearing felt Madden's testimony was important as he was able to recall the [Leon]: death of Stonechild. [Leon]: Many people involved in the investigation did not remember this.
[Leon]: Surprise. [Leon]: He was also the only police witness to attribute the matter to Hartwig and Sanger [Leon]: before the RCMP investigation started. [Leon]: Dun, dun, dun. [Ood]: So he started pointing figures at people inside the police department and then he [Ood]: got canned? [Ood]: Yes. [Ood]: Weird. [Ood]: Weird. [Ood]: That's not like a trend that happens over and over [Bigly]: again in police departments, is it? [Bigly]: Madden wasn't canned. [Bigly]: Madden retired as a superintendent. [Leon]: But but when he retired and I mean, and this is me throwing this in, this is not [Leon]: from the script that Richard Bigley wrote for me.
[Leon]: Madden was retired under quotation marks, under quotation marks. [Leon]: OK, like he was [Bigly]: suspicious air quotes. [Bigly]: There were suspicious air quotes retired. [Leon]: OK, he get a great going away party. [Leon]: Encouraged to end his career. [Leon]: Okay, so back to Constable Mackey. [Leon]: Not related to Stone Child, but rather Jason Roy. [Leon]: He testified to the inquiry that he responded to a robbery at a Humpy's restaurant. [Leon]: Jason Roy and Elton Dustyhorn were suspects.
[Leon]: He said he would try to contact the suspects, but if not able to, he would place a [Leon]: warrant for their arrest. [Leon]: Now, there's no evidence that a warrant was, in fact, issued for the arrest of [Leon]: Jason Roy. [Leon]: Mackie acknowledged that from time to time, detente-en-tente, he would arrest a [Leon]: person who was causing a disturbance and drop him off at a safe place several [Leon]: blocks away. [Leon]: He described this as, quote, unarresting the person. [Sage]: That's fine. [Sage]: Like, drop him off at the... [Sage]: at the Sev or whatever.
[Bigly]: You know, I'm being a disturbance. [Bigly]: The people I'm with don't want to see me. [Bigly]: Cops get called. [Bigly]: He puts me in the back of the car, drives me to a pay phone, gives me a quarter. [Bigly]: I don't know. [Bigly]: I'm just making up giving him a quarter. [Bigly]: But, you know, and says, get out of the car, call somebody to get your ass out of [Bigly]: here. [Bigly]: Don't fuck with those people anymore. [Bigly]: Don't go back to the hunties. [Bigly]: Don't go back there. [Bigly]: No. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Leon]: So why is Mackey important? [Leon]: Well, it gives reason for Jason Roy to believe that he was wanted by police at the [Leon]: time of the Stone Child disappearance. [Leon]: So anyway, the RCMP took charge of the Stone Child investigation in 2000.
[Leon]: So Police Chief Dave Scott advised Deputy Chief Wicks to basically give the RCMP [Leon]: any and all information about [Leon]: Ooh. [Leon]: Ooh. [Leon]: August of 2002, Wicks was advised that the Justice Department had reviewed the file [Leon]: and were not recommending charges be laid.
[Leon]: At meetings with the RCMP, Wicks was shown photographs and documents, but would not [Leon]: be given copies. [Leon]: He also testified to a number of changes that the Saskatoon police had made in [Leon]: policies and procedures since 1990, including the creation of a suspicious death [Leon]: review committee. [Leon]: Wicks told the inquiry that he felt the officers involved had done their jobs. [Leon]: However, on the matter of Jarvis, he felt that it wasn't Jarvis's fault that he [Leon]: wasn't called to the scene. [Leon]: He also noted that Jarvis should have been asked to be switched to a day shift
[Leon]: instead of the night shift so that he could follow up on the investigation. [Leon]: Wicks did also testify that it was not clear how Jarvis came to the conclusion that [Leon]: Gary Pratt was not involved and that statements should have been taken from more [Leon]: people, including the people who found the body. [Leon]: Yes. [Leon]: Imagine finding a body and the cops don't ask you any questions about it. [Leon]: That's fucking insane. [Leon]: It's fucking insane. [Bigly]: We just missed that. [Bigly]: We were going down the checklist. [Bigly]: We just missed that line. [Bigly]: We kept checking through. [Bigly]: We thought it was done. [Leon]: Also, in the May 2003 newspaper article titled, quote, officers stayed on job
[Leon]: during Stonechild probe, end quote, Wicks told the paper that police did not know [Leon]: that constables Hartwig and Sanger were considered suspects. [Leon]: But at the inquiry, Wicks acknowledged that, at the time, he knew they were [Leon]: suspects. [Leon]: So why did he lie to the media? [Leon]: Why leave them on the job? [Leon]: There wasn't really any explanation. [Leon]: No. [Leon]: Or was there? [Leon]: The Saskatoon police created a, quote, issues team intended to deal with security [Leon]: issues around the inquiry, provide info... [Leon]: that the inquiry needed and attended communications matters.
[Leon]: The inquiry reviewed the minutes of the meetings held by the team and found that [Leon]: the issues team took on another role. [Leon]: As the inquiry unfolded, they started to seek out experts to comment on the [Leon]: injuries Stone Child had to his nose and wrist. [Leon]: The team contacted the FBI attache in Ottawa, found a pathologist in Minneapolis, [Leon]: which they went to go visit. [Leon]: who indicated that Stone Child's injuries were consistent with a fall on ice or [Leon]: snow, definitely not a blow. [Leon]: The cuts on Stone Child were too clean and straight to be from something in nature,
[Leon]: like twigs or what have you. [Leon]: The inquiry found that, quote, purpose was to obtain an opinion that the marks on [Leon]: Stone Child's nose and right wrist were not caused by handcuffs. [Leon]: The team were focused on discrediting medical reports. [Leon]: The inquiry found that the police service was acting as an advocate for its members [Leon]: and [Leon]: instead of carrying out its job of law enforcement and ensuring that discipline of [Leon]: its members. [Ood]: And be reminded of my forensic pseudoscience episode. [Ood]: Like a lot of these comparisons of marks is just a human eye comparing marks made
[Ood]: in the lab to marks on the body. [Ood]: Like it isn't an exact science. [Ood]: And when they're going against medical experts with what may be like a [Ood]: pseudoscientific forensic technique or even just an unreliable, unaccurate forensic [Ood]: pseudoscience technique, they're trying to discredit medical science with that. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Well, and that's exactly it. [Bigly]: They know what conclusion they want. [Bigly]: They know how they want this person to testify. [Bigly]: So you just go out there and find the person who's going to testify that for you as
[Bigly]: an expert. [Bigly]: You know, unlike actual science where you do experiments and then you get your [Bigly]: conclusions, conclusions created. [Bigly]: You just try to produce enough facts to back it up. [Leon]: I just spilled beer all over my pants. [Sage]: It was kind of fun. [Sage]: I tried to mop it up. [Bigly]: What the fuck, man? [Bigly]: Get it together. [Sage]: I tried to mop it up with sheets of paper and I'm dangerously close to his penis. [Bigly]: Chicken or go? [Sage]: Chicken or go? [Sage]: I'll always go, bud. [Ood]: He dressed to the left today. [Arthur]: We're not cutting this.
[Sage]: It got a little bit. [Sage]: It looked like you peed. [Sage]: But now that I know that your penis is on the left and not the right, it does not [Sage]: look like you peed. [Bigly]: Well, how do you explain the wetness on his left side, though? [Arthur]: We need a forensic pseudoscientist. [Bigly]: We'll get ourselves a forensic pseudoscientist. [Bigly]: Okay, shut the fuck up. [Sage]: There's no wetness on the left side. [Sage]: It's only on the right. [Leon]: Do I have to wash these pants now? [Leon]: Okay, so... [Arthur]: I hear all, I record all. [Leon]: The inquiry found that the purpose was to obtain an opinion that the Markson stone
[Leon]: child's nose and right wrist were not caused by handcuffs. [Leon]: The team were focused on discrediting medical reports. [Leon]: The inquiry found that the police service was acting as an advocate for its members [Leon]: instead of carrying out its job of law enforcement and ensuring the discipline of [Leon]: its members. [Leon]: The inquiry went so far as to state the police department's position is [Leon]: indistinguishable from the police association. [Leon]: That is the union who is tasked to defend its members rant about police unions. [Leon]: So fucking police unions. [Leon]: Fuck them. [Bigly]: They're not real unions. [Bigly]: They're fake bullshit unions designed to oppress workers and ensure that bad cops
[Bigly]: get to keep their fucking jobs. [Sage]: Or just get moved to a different location. [Leon]: One staff sergeant spoke to the inquiry about how the cops need to defend their [Leon]: own. [Bigly]: Should I? [Bigly]: I could read that. [Bigly]: No, I want to read it. [Sage]: You want to read it? [Sage]: Okay, you read it. [Sage]: Do you want to be the A? [Sage]: I'll be the Q and you be the A. [Bigly]: You are Q and I am a real big A, so yeah. [Sage]: Now, I guess the problem or the potential concern, though, is when and how do you [Sage]: come to the conclusion that one is unjustly accused? [Bigly]: Oh, no doubt about it.
[Bigly]: You're right. [Sage]: And if you come to that conclusion too soon, you're rallying around and defending [Sage]: your own when perhaps you shouldn't be? [Bigly]: You're right. [Sage]: You testified that you thought it was a positive thing when the RCMP were called in [Sage]: in response to certain now well-known situations of bodies being discovered on the [Sage]: outskirts of town and the Daryl Knight situation. [Bigly]: Yes. [Sage]: I suggest to you that part of the reason that's positive is to have an outside [Sage]: force brought in is the potential problem for you.
[Sage]: And by you, I mean the force, the investigative arm of the force to be objective in [Sage]: looking at their own people. [Bigly]: No doubt about it. [Sage]: That is a concern? [Sage]: Always. [Sage]: That you could lose your objectivity? [Bigly]: Definitely. [Leon]: So basically, this speaks to the issue of cops. [Leon]: Why did Lutit fear he would be reprimanded for bringing up concerns of an [Leon]: insufficient investigation? [Leon]: Why was Tarasov told to stay out of the matter? [Leon]: Why would they say the issue was investigated when it obviously was not? [Leon]: Why would they lie to the media in 2003?
[Leon]: Like, what the fuck transparency? [Leon]: And Leon's getting high. [Leon]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_02]: Stone Child's frozen body was found on the outskirts of Saskatoon in November of [SPEAKER_02]: 1990. [SPEAKER_02]: He died of hypothermia and his death was labeled accidental. [SPEAKER_02]: But an inquiry is set for this fall to examine how the police investigation was [SPEAKER_02]: handled. [SPEAKER_27]: Much of that evidence is coming from this man, Jason Roy. [SPEAKER_25]: He was a friend of Neil's and says he was with them the day he disappeared. [SPEAKER_26]: The next time I saw him he was in the back of a police car.
[SPEAKER_37]: According to the inquiry report, that was the last time Neil Stonechild was seen [SPEAKER_37]: alive. [SPEAKER_37]: It took until 2003 and an inquiry into his death for them to get answers and to [SPEAKER_37]: share their story. [SPEAKER_37]: The inquiry established through Jason Roy's testimony that Neil Stonechild was with [SPEAKER_37]: two police officers the night he disappeared. [SPEAKER_37]: The two officers named in the report, Constables Larry Hartwig and Bradley Singer, [SPEAKER_37]: they have never been found criminally responsible for Stonechild's death. [SPEAKER_09]: On November 24th, 1990, did you
[SPEAKER_21]: have Neil Stonechild in the back of your card? [SPEAKER_21]: Absolutely not. [SPEAKER_21]: Absolutely not. [SPEAKER_21]: The evidence, the evidence, the evidence all indicates that. [SPEAKER_21]: The first I heard about stuff like this happening was prior to the inquiry or at [SPEAKER_21]: the inquiry, Brett Mackie was a police officer who testified in the public inquiry [SPEAKER_21]: that said police officers unarrest people all the time, you know? [SPEAKER_21]: Like I said before, what ass would do that, right? [SPEAKER_21]: What person would take a guy from a drunk, obnoxious guy involved in a disturbance
[SPEAKER_21]: from one location, drive him to another location, drop him off. [SPEAKER_21]: You only move the problem. [SPEAKER_21]: You don't solve the problem. [SPEAKER_21]: You only move the problem. [SPEAKER_21]: I mean, my badge was the symbol of my commitment, right? [SPEAKER_21]: If you interview the members of the Saskatoon Police Service, they'd tell you in a [SPEAKER_21]: heartbeat that if, you know, Larry and Brad could come back as police officers, [SPEAKER_21]: you'd welcome them with open arms. [SPEAKER_21]: Of course, now the Saskatoon Police Service will demand these back.
[SPEAKER_21]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_21]: Screw them. [SPEAKER_21]: Being able to lie is a trait that is necessary as a police officer. [SPEAKER_21]: I know that's tough for people to listen to or people to hear, but you have to be [SPEAKER_21]: able to, and it's not a matter of being a liar, you've got to be able to work your [SPEAKER_21]: way around other people's lies. [SPEAKER_21]: So how do you do that? [SPEAKER_21]: You have to be a good liar yourself.
[Ood]: Last time we looked at how the city cops of Saskatoon dealt with Neil Stonechild, [Ood]: which is mostly... [Ood]: They didn't. [SPEAKER_22]: They didn't. [Ood]: There was a lot of cover-ups. [Ood]: There was a lot of indifference. [Ood]: There was a lot of them doing things that wasn't the way they usually do them, such [Ood]: as giving clothes to the family. [Ood]: There was a bunch of sneaky shit. [Ood]: Listen to the past two episodes if you want to find out just how little they seem [Ood]: to care about the death of this young man. [Sage]: I can sum it up in yikes and sneaky shit.
[Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: But today we're going to look into what the other class of cops in Canada, what [Ood]: they did about it. [Ood]: This is the RCMP, the Federal Police. [Ood]: Equivalent sort of to the FBI, state cops. [Ood]: Basically, the RCMP coming in is a sign that bigger guns are being brought in. [SPEAKER_22]: That would be [SPEAKER_11]: nice if that happened. [Ood]: But yeah, they became involved at some point. [Ood]: So Officer McFadden. [Ood]: McFadden? [Ood]: McFadden? [Ood]: McFadden. [Ood]: McFadden.
[Ood]: One of those. [Ood]: Officer doesn't really cover it. [Ood]: The RCMP is built much like a military corps where there's certain ranks and the [Ood]: ranks that go up. [Ood]: As they go up in authority, they're in charge of more people. [Ood]: They have more power. [Ood]: They have more sway within the organization. [Ood]: He was a 2IC for the F Division. [Bigly]: Second in command for the F Division. [Bigly]: That's what 2IC means. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Second in command. [Bigly]: He's not the guy in charge of F's division, which is the entire province of [Bigly]: Saskatchewan, but rather the second in command of the province of Saskatchewan,
[Bigly]: which is still pretty high in the RCMP ranks. [Sage]: Yeah, it's a pretty big fucking deal. [Sage]: It's a fucking deal. [Ood]: He was brought in by the Ministry of Justice to investigate what happened to Daryl [Ood]: Knight. [Ood]: He was also to investigate Rodney Nastis and Lawrence Wegner, two other freezing [Ood]: deaths in Saskatoon. [Ood]: This started Project Ferrick. [Ood]: Project Ferrick cost around three quarters of a million dollars in addition to the [Ood]: usual salaries of the officers and RCMP staff involved. [Ood]: It was an expensive investigation.
[Ood]: They took on the Stone Child case in February of 2000. [Ood]: The RCMP interviewed about 200 witnesses in relation to this case. [Ood]: They measured the marks on Stone Child's nose in post-mortem photographs taken of [Ood]: him and to compare them to measurement of the Saskatoon police handcuffs in use at [Ood]: the time. [Ood]: This job is called a photogrammarist. [Ood]: Cool. [Leon]: I'm that. [Ood]: And again, this is kind of something I touched on on the forensic pseudoscience [Ood]: episode. [Ood]: So this is a person that I'm sure is practiced.
[Ood]: Like this is a job that they've done before. [Ood]: But they're still a human with human flaws and just using their human eyes to go [Ood]: over one picture and another and comparing marks. [Sage]: As opposed to elf eyes. [Ood]: Yeah. [Sage]: Legolas, tell me what your elf eyes see. [Ood]: They do not get advantage on spot rules. [Sage]: No, no. [Ood]: So the job is called a photogrammarist, and the guy that RCMP called in was named [Ood]: Gary Robertson. [Ood]: The RCMP had Stone Child's body exhumed, so dug back up, and a second autopsy was [Ood]: done by Dr. Graham Dowling.
[Ood]: The RCMP were continuously in contact with the Saskatoon police, and they found the [Ood]: Saskatoon police to be professional and cooperative with the investigation. [Ood]: The RCMP say that. [Ood]: The RCMP provided their findings to the Department of Justice in June of 2002. [Ood]: In August of 2002, the department wrote back and was not recommending charges. [Ood]: They were not recommending any charges be placed upon the officers involved or [Ood]: anybody else involved. [Ood]: In July 2003... You say July?
[Ood]: July. [Ood]: In July 2003, Deputy Chief Wicks contacted the RCMP about his objections to Gary [Ood]: Robertson's assessment. [Ood]: He wanted a new one done. [Ood]: Apparently that's just something you can do if you aren't happy with the report. [Ood]: You can just request, hey, you didn't do it right. [Ood]: I don't like the conclusion. [Ood]: Redo it. [Bigly]: Well, you always can get a second opinion on pretty much anything. [Bigly]: Oh, yeah. [Bigly]: You know, I don't like this. [Bigly]: Well, okay, well, second opinion. [Bigly]: You get someone else in and presumably they're, you know. Yeah.
[Bigly]: They'll side with you and then whatever. [Ood]: In general, I'm very in favor of second opinions. [Ood]: I just wish they were offered more often to citizens rather than just when cops are [Ood]: trying to get out of trouble. [Ood]: Hot take. [Ood]: It seems like, like I said, more tools, less scrutiny is offered to police when [Ood]: they get in quote-unquote trouble than do citizens. [Ood]: Like if second opinions were allowed in citizen cases more often, then I'd be more [Ood]: happy. [Bigly]: Well, I mean, I think second opinions are permitted. [Bigly]: It's just the issue is that if you are a citizen, instead of having like billion
[Bigly]: dollar budgets out of taxpayer money, you get your whatever your income is and [Bigly]: you've got to pay for that in addition to your lawyer. [Sage]: Yes, which is not feasible for lots of people. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Which is why I think a lot of citizens don't actually have second opinions is just [Bigly]: on that basis that can I afford the guy from Minneapolis to fly to Saskatoon to [Bigly]: review this sample or review this case and provide an opinion that counters what
[Bigly]: the state has come up with. [Bigly]: It's one of those failures of the justice system, I think. [Sage]: As a comfortably, like, middle-class family between me and Mr. [Sage]: Sage Murray, like, we couldn't afford that. [Sage]: And that's not, like, we're, like, comfortably middle-class, not... [Bigly]: Like, one of y'all would have to be in some serious fucking shit for you to want to [Bigly]: expel that kind of [Sage]: cash to get off of something. [Sage]: Like, it would be a lot. [Sage]: Yeah. [Ood]: I mean, and looking at expert testimony, knowing how much these people are paid, [Ood]: like... [Ood]: Getting an expert for $100 an hour for 40 hours a week for the months it may take
[Ood]: for a court case. [Ood]: Like, $100 an hour for an expert testimony is a fucking bargain. [Ood]: Like, usually most of these guys charge three, four, five, $800 an hour for their [Ood]: opinion. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Like, class justice, all that good shit. [Ood]: So, the RCMP wanted a new one done. [Ood]: They wanted a second opinion. [Ood]: So, Frodo, photogrammar... [SPEAKER_22]: Frodo. [Ood]: Frodo at the Shire. [Ood]: Photogrammetry is described as the science and engineering of taking measurements [Ood]: from imaging. [Ood]: For example, photos, but electronic records also count.
[Ood]: So taking measurements of, like, waveforms of radar sheets, stuff like that. [Ood]: So Gary is super into this. [Ood]: Gary Robertson. [Ood]: He got a diploma in 1973. [Ood]: He was employed by the government of Canada from 1976 to 1980, doing close-range [Ood]: photogrammetry at historic buildings. [Ood]: He wrote articles on the topic. [Ood]: He taught police courses on the subject. [Ood]: He seemed to be practiced in this realm. [Ood]: Mm-hmm. [Ood]: Whether the realm of study is valid or not on a scientific basis, either or he had
[Ood]: a lot of experience doing this. [Ood]: Commissioner Council tried to discredit him. [Ood]: They dug up past cases where he was challenged in his ability. [Ood]: They questioned his curriculum vitae. [Ood]: What's curriculum vitae? [Sage]: Like a resume. [Ood]: It's like an extended resume. [Ood]: Okay. [Ood]: As it appeared to bolster his qualifications to suggest more than what he had [Ood]: obtained in training. [Sage]: Okay. [Ood]: however what mattered was his measurements taken this is where it mattered he asked
[Ood]: he was asked to provide measurements based on photo he was not told in advance [Ood]: about the marks being suspected from the handcuffs when he did his original [Ood]: measurements he knew nothing of the handcuffs after this he was provided handcuffs [Ood]: and asked to measure them [Ood]: He testified that the marks on Stone Child's nose would be consistent with forceful [Ood]: application of the handcuffs. [Bigly]: Can I pause you there? [Bigly]: I just want to interject what that means. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Like, you're familiar with the concept of brass knuckles, right?
[Bigly]: Oh, yes. [Bigly]: Okay, well, as a cop, you don't generally carry brass knuckles, but you do carry [Bigly]: handcuffs. [Bigly]: And if one were so inclined as a cop who has handcuffs, you could, you know, use [Bigly]: them as like brass knuckle substitutes. [Bigly]: And so that is where the concern over the marks on Stone Child knows comes about, [Bigly]: is that it was perhaps, you know, suggested that Stone Child was, you know, that
[Bigly]: the police had used their handcuffs as brass knuckles prior to [Bigly]: abandoning Stone Child in the north end of the city. [Ood]: Right. [Ood]: And that's something that cops are taught. [Ood]: There's a lot of erectile nerve-filled tissue in the nose, and it hurts when it [Ood]: gets bopped. [Ood]: And that's something that the police are taught in the academy. [Ood]: If you need to do pain compliance, if you need somebody to do something, you make [Ood]: them feel pain. [Ood]: And one of the ways you can make them feel pain is go for the bridge of the nose. [Sage]: Yeah, fuck. [Sage]: I've had my son just sitting on my lap and put his head back, and it hurts like a
[Sage]: motherfucker. [Sage]: Mm-hmm. [Arthur]: how to make people get tortured [Sage]: yeah like it's like it hurts when it's coming from like a like a baby sounds like [Sage]: you [Arthur]: get down here [Ood]: so so the gary prepared photos with the handcuffs superimposed over the marks the [Ood]: inquiry accepted gary's testimony as the likely cause of the marks when constable [Ood]: jarvis the the original investigator was shown photos in 2000 of the marks he also [Ood]: said it was consistent with handcuff marks here is a listing of the medical
[Ood]: evidence [Ood]: From Dr. Brian Fern. [Ood]: Fern, I like that. [Ood]: A coroner appointed to the Stone Child Investigation. [Ood]: That's Dr. Fern. [Ood]: He started his practice in 1961 and he moved to Saskatoon in 1970. [Ood]: And he's been here ever since. [Sage]: Is he still alive? [Ood]: I don't know, probably. [Ood]: His testimony indicated that a coroner would be called in if a death was suspected [Ood]: to not be entirely due to natural causes. [Ood]: He indicated that when he was called to the scene of Neil Stonechild, his primary
[Ood]: role was to ID the body. [Ood]: Police were generally responsible for further investigation. [Ood]: So all he was given to do was to identify the body. [Ood]: He wasn't asked to do any type of homicide inspection of the body as a medical [Ood]: expert. [Ood]: He told the inquiry that when he was called out, the police told him that the [Ood]: deceased person was a young offender and that the officers knew the deceased's [Ood]: identity. [Ood]: However, when compared to his notes of the call, he noted that the police told him [Ood]: the person was about 30 years old.
[Sage]: Oh. [Ood]: He was 17 at the time. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Just throwing that out there. [Sage]: Yeah, he was a little baby. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: And Dr. Fern is alive. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Ood]: It sort of holds parallels to some of what black people go through in the States [Ood]: where as soon as they start to look sort of like a man in their late teens, they're [Ood]: considered to be like an adult offender. [Ood]: That's sort of treated by the police. [Sage]: Whereas if it was a white guy, he would be a juvenile. [Ood]: Yeah, he'd be just a kid. [Ood]: Mm-hmm.
[Ood]: He requested the body be moved to St. Paul's Hospital for an autopsy, where Dr. [Ood]: Jack Adolph would conduct it. [Ood]: I was born [Bigly]: at St. Paul's Hospital. [Sage]: Really? [Bigly]: I was. [Sage]: I think I was born at RUH. [Bigly]: I was born in City. [Bigly]: Well, nobody's perfect. [Bigly]: I was born in North Battleford. [Sage]: My son was born at RUH. [Arthur]: I was born in the pits of hell. [Ood]: In the pits of... [Arthur]: But Arthur was born in RUH. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Dr. Brian Fern received a phone call from Stone Child's uncle. [Ood]: Stone Child's uncle was asking about the cause of death, and he indicated that Neil
[Ood]: Stone Child died from exposure to Stone Child's uncle. [Ood]: Fern's notes indicate that at some point he was informed Stone Child was a young [Ood]: offender who was unlawfully at large from his community home. [Ood]: His notes also log a call from St. Jarvis. [Ood]: Fuck. [Ood]: Fucking balls. [Ood]: Lay off the weed, buddy. [Ood]: I think so. [Ood]: I think it's more the beer. [Ood]: I'm very lightweight when it comes to beer. [Sage]: He's real good when it comes to weed. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: His notes also log a call from Sergeant Jarvis on December 6th.
[Ood]: The note says, definitely seen alive, 930, Saturday, 24th of November. [Ood]: Had been to party. [Ood]: Drank about 26 ounces. [Ood]: Tried to get into an apartment shortly after midnight. [Ood]: Snowberry downs. [Ood]: All confirmed by friends who were with him. [Ood]: Body was well frozen. [Ood]: Temperature was very cold. [Ood]: Probably died Sunday, the 25th of November. [SPEAKER_10]: You're getting cold now, aren't you?
[SPEAKER_10]: Remember, it's blowing a gale, and the wind chill is about minus 27 degrees [SPEAKER_10]: Celsius. [SPEAKER_09]: The body tries very hard to conserve the energy towards the core, to the important [SPEAKER_09]: bits of you, the heart and the brain. [SPEAKER_09]: That's why you can't feel your fingers anymore. [SPEAKER_09]: This must be distinctly uncomfortable now. [SPEAKER_09]: Actually, no, I'm starting to get quite chilly now. [SPEAKER_10]: My head is seriously cold now. [SPEAKER_10]: 36.5 at the moment, Peter.
[SPEAKER_10]: 36.5. [SPEAKER_10]: OK. [SPEAKER_09]: If it happens quickly like this, you're very aware of getting cold. [SPEAKER_09]: If it happens more slowly, more insidiously, then you don't tend to have as much of [SPEAKER_09]: an awareness. [SPEAKER_09]: And you don't tend to feel all that uncomfortable. [SPEAKER_09]: Sometimes you'll paradoxically just start undressing. [SPEAKER_09]: taking your clothes off once you get really cold. [SPEAKER_09]: And that, of course, just as part of a downward spiral, there's no way out of. [SPEAKER_10]: My way out of this is to get dressed and get out of this wind.
[SPEAKER_09]: Yeah, you're starting to shiver. [SPEAKER_09]: I think it's time we maybe stopped this and got you warmed up now, eh? [SPEAKER_09]: Not a bad idea. [SPEAKER_09]: Yeah, OK. [SPEAKER_38]: But wind and snow aren't the most dangerous part of a blizzard. [SPEAKER_38]: The biggest killer is the cold. [SPEAKER_38]: A drop of just four degrees in core temperature and the human body becomes [SPEAKER_38]: hypothermic.
[SPEAKER_38]: It's a condition that Dr. Colin Grissom is an expert at treating. [SPEAKER_34]: A person experiencing mild hypothermia typically feels cold and they start [SPEAKER_34]: shivering. [SPEAKER_34]: The shivering progresses to an uncontrollable shivering. [SPEAKER_38]: Shivering is the body's way of generating critical heat to keep you alive. [SPEAKER_38]: But if body temperature continues to fall, hypothermia deepens.
[SPEAKER_38]: Then the shivering stops, and that's the beginning of the end. [SPEAKER_34]: When you stop shivering, the body is losing its ability to rewarm itself, so it is [SPEAKER_34]: failing. [SPEAKER_34]: Everything slows down, metabolism slows down, so the heartbeat slows down, the [SPEAKER_34]: breathing slows down, and all the cells slow down, including the brain. [SPEAKER_38]: Left unchecked, severe hypothermia like this will lead to death.
[Ood]: In the declaration of coroner, he indicated that the cause of death was as [Ood]: exposure. [Ood]: He wrote, natural, and crossed it out and wrote, accidental. [Ood]: He noted police were still investigating the matter. [Ood]: Dr. Fern had also received a toxicology report in April 1991 on this matter. [Ood]: Unusual practice for the report was to be received by the coroner before police [Ood]: having a copy. [Ood]: It was very unusual for the police to receive the report before the coroner.
[Ood]: This time the police received the report first and gave it to the coroner. [Ood]: There was no explanation as to why the police received the report first this time. [Ood]: Fern suggested that the police had some interest in this matter, and so the report [Ood]: was sent to them first. [Sage]: Some interest. [Sage]: Dun, dun, dun. [Ood]: What does that mean? [Ood]: 0.15. [Ood]: That's a lie. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Yeah.
[Bigly]: But I mean, it's very easy to get there. [Sage]: Like, I'm probably there right now. [Bigly]: Well, Filger and I, we got like a cheapo breathalyzer. [Bigly]: And he and I would often in our younger years conduct races to see who could max [Bigly]: out the breathalyzer first. [Ood]: Do we still have access to that? [Leon]: Yeah, I know where mine is. [Sage]: Go get it. [Leon]: Oh, it's not here. [Ood]: I think that would be some good Patreon content. [Ood]: See who biologically, like by the numbers, can hold their booze better. [Sage]: Yeah, because I probably feel the best, but I'm probably the most drunk.
[Sage]: We got moonshine. [Bigly]: But yeah, we would sit down at the bar and the bartender would laugh at us because [Bigly]: we'd just order drink after drink after drink and then like breathalyze ourselves. [Bigly]: I'm so ashamed. [Bigly]: To see who could get up to like point, [Leon]: I think the breathalyzer capped [Bigly]: out a 0.16. [Leon]: Capped out a 0.16, we'd see who could hit 0.04 first and it was always you and 0.08 [Leon]: and it was always you and 0.16 was always me. [Bigly]: I am all that is man. [Leon]: No, but I finally maxed out the breathalyzer more frequently than you did.
[Leon]: I caught up. [Sage]: I would literally really like to do this all the time. [Sage]: Why are we not doing this right now? [Ood]: You guys doing this comes from a place of curiosity and loving alcohol, and I can't [Ood]: disagree with either one of those. [Ood]: No, just reckless ambition, I think. [Sage]: All of a reckless ambition. [Sage]: I've danced under that name. [Bigly]: I mean, of course, the note on the breathalyzer is not to be used for criminal [Bigly]: blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. [Bigly]: You know, because, you know, no breathalyzer company wants to get like fucking
[Bigly]: tagged unless you're like, you know, got the like $4,000 roadside test that the [Bigly]: police actually do and calibrate like every... [Bigly]: You know, every week I think those things go through a calibration just to make [Bigly]: sure that they're still given proper results. [Bigly]: But I digress. [Bigly]: Stone Child had a blood alcohol content, according to the toxicology report of [Bigly]: 0.15. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Ood]: And so we've seen so far that this Dr. Fern guy, like he seems to be a little bit [Ood]: wishy-washy. [Ood]: He seems to be giving some mixed messages, and that's about to amplify.
[Ood]: In a 1990 newspaper article, he was quoted as saying, we have excluded obvious foul [Ood]: play as he did not have an injury of any kind. [Ood]: We've already learned that he has cuts on his nose. [Sage]: He could be, yeah, like, but he did. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: He told the inquiry that Stone Child had injuries but would not have contributed to [Ood]: his death. [Ood]: However, in a June 2003 CBC interview, he stated that Stone Child's injuries were [Ood]: consistent with being beaten and dragged. [Sage]: That's a large departure from what he originally said.
[Ood]: He defended this inconsistency by saying that these words were suggested by the [Ood]: reporter. [Ood]: Also, the dude totally pulled a Bill Clinton. [Ood]: Depending on what you mean by the word is, is, like, this is a statement. [Ood]: The statement was true depending on how one defines the term beaten. [Sage]: Oh, my God. [Sage]: How do you, how do you, like, okay, beaten is like you have been beaten. [Ood]: You have been beat? [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: And remember, one of the theories that the police were trying to put forward as
[Ood]: like, this is a plausible explanation, so don't blame us, is, [Ood]: He got in some interpersonal disagreement with some people and they beat his ass [Ood]: and dragged him out there. [Ood]: So this sounds like he's he's trying to play both sides a little bit. [Sage]: OK, well, first, no one would take a kid all the way out to the north industrial [Sage]: area from the west side. [Sage]: Like no one would do that. [Arthur]: Dictionary definition of beaten is having been being having been beaten or struck. [Sage]: Yeah, like pummeled with fists or like struck with something.
[Sage]: Like a handcuff? [Bigly]: Or being handcuffed. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Or handcuffs to the nose as brass knuckles. [Sage]: Yes, have had bodily harm inflicted upon you. [Leon]: Okay, quick survey. [Leon]: Raise your hand if you've been in handcuffs, like police handcuffs. [Leon]: Fuck yeah. [Leon]: Like by being arrested? [Bigly]: Stage actual arrest, like police have applied handcuffs to you. [Bigly]: And they said you're under arrest. [Bigly]: Just security guard training. [Sage]: What did you do? [Sage]: I ran from cops when I was in high school. [Sage]: Okay. [Bigly]: Bad boys, bad boys. [Bigly]: Really? [Bigly]: What you gonna do? [Bigly]: That's intense. [Bigly]: What you gonna do when they come?
[Sage]: They never booked me. [Sage]: Stay tuned. [Sage]: They put me in handcuffs, yeah. [Bigly]: The cops. [Sage]: I was kind of a badass, but I was also getting 100% in everything in high school. [Sage]: Yeah, that's cool. [Arthur]: If you join that Patreon for just a dollar a month, just maybe, just maybe, you [Arthur]: might even hear the story. [Arthur]: You might. [Sage]: I'm the only one. [Sage]: Oh, me and Richard. [Sage]: Sorry. [Sage]: Richard and I, we have a story. [Sage]: We have a Leon story. [Sage]: I haven't done my story, and Richard hasn't done his story. [Bigly]: Nobody needs to know my fucking story, I tell you. [Bigly]: You have a very interesting story. [Bigly]: I have all sorts of stories.
[Bigly]: Your story is tragic. [SPEAKER_22]: Oh. [Ood]: So a bit more about Dr. Furr. [Ood]: He hadn't attended a formal coroner's meeting since he started work in 1967. [Sage]: That was a while ago. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So like this is like 1990 when he's being like the coroner over Neil Stonechild. [Bigly]: And he hasn't like attended a coroner's meeting since like 1967. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Sage]: That was a minute ago. [Sage]: Yeah. [Ood]: And you know, they don't teach anything important at coroner's meetings, just stuff [Ood]: like, here's how to better evaluate bodies.
[Ood]: Nothing ever changes. [Ood]: Maybe he could have learned how to survey a frozen body a little better if he [Ood]: attended one meeting. [Ood]: Maybe. [Ood]: So the inquiry found that he had not executed his responsibility in the Stone Child [Ood]: matter appropriately. [Ood]: So he didn't go back for further training. [Ood]: He didn't attend a conference. [Ood]: He wasn't qualified to be executing his responsibility on Stone Child. [Ood]: He didn't take the responsibility to continue his education. [Ood]: He didn't question why a 17-year-old was found in the middle of nowhere, away from
[Ood]: his home, intoxicated, away from any bars and restaurants, missing a shoe, with a [Ood]: worn-out sock from walking some distance without a shoe. [Ood]: He did not examine Stone Child's clothing. [Ood]: Again, Stone Child's clothing was destroyed before it could be properly examined. [Ood]: And he didn't examine it for blood or other bodily fluids, like what may be present [Ood]: if he got hit in the nose. [Ood]: Maybe he had... [Sage]: Nobody knows. [Sage]: Oh, no, Dr. Fern. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: That was bad. [Ood]: Dr. Jack Adolph performed the initial autopsy from 1975 to 1997 when he retired.
[Ood]: He worked at St. Paul's Hospital as a pathologist. [Ood]: That's a guy who studies bacteria and viruses, like how pathogens spread and grow, [Ood]: I believe. [Sage]: No. [Sage]: Not at all. [Leon]: That's someone who studies dead people. [Sage]: Okay, well, let's Google pathology. [Sage]: I'm on it. [Arthur]: Pathology is a branch of medical science that involves a study and diagnosis of [Arthur]: disease through examination of surgically removed organs, tissues, bodily fluids, [Arthur]: and in some cases, the whole body. [Ood]: Disease or injury, yeah. [Ood]: There we go. [Ood]: So, yeah, it's almost like a guy that diagnoses cause of death kind of stuff, eh?
[Ood]: Yes, that's exactly what it is. [Ood]: That's exactly what they are, yes. [Ood]: Fuck yeah. [Ood]: He also did not examine Stone Child's clothing, so the coroner didn't look at it, [Ood]: the autopsy guy didn't look at it, and the police didn't look at it. [Ood]: So nobody would, like, there's so much stuff that wasn't done. [Bigly]: Can't imagine why. [Sage]: Yeah. Hmm. [Bigly]: Coincidence, eh? [Bigly]: Yep. [Bigly]: All these coincidences. [Bigly]: Now, I'm not one to say there's a conspiracy. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Because that would not be me. [Bigly]: But I'm thinking that there's a lot of coincidences here. [Bigly]: Yes. [Ood]: Allegedly. [Ood]: Just over and over again, the ball is dropped and it seems to be an indigenous
[Ood]: person every time. [Ood]: Weird. [Ood]: Weird. [Ood]: Weird. [Ood]: Go figure. [Ood]: He told the inquiry, this is Dr. Adolph. [Ood]: He told the inquiry that he determined the cause of death to be exposure to cold. [Ood]: He reached this conclusion by ruling out other causes of death. [Ood]: Basically, you are found frozen in the snow, and there's nothing else to suggest a [Ood]: cause of death. [Ood]: Boom, died by exposure. [Ood]: He figured Stonechild would have died in two or three hours given the situation, [Ood]: like given the weather and the temperature and all that.
[Ood]: But there are factors that could have prolonged or shortened this. [Ood]: The autopsy report states that the time of death was 2200 hours, 10 p.m., November [Ood]: 27th, 1990. [Ood]: He was unable to explain how he arrived at this. [Ood]: He said a pathologist's time of death is often not reliable and that it was [Ood]: possible he had been dead since November 25th. [Ood]: What? [Ood]: You know. [Sage]: You'd be like, well, like, I give this time of death, but like, fuck me, I'm not [Sage]: accurate. [Sage]: Don't even fucking listen to me.
[Bigly]: I mean, in his defense, though, I mean, you're looking at something that's a lot of [Bigly]: unknowns after the fact. [Sage]: Okay. [Bigly]: And you're being told to come up with an expert opinion based on the evidence face [Bigly]: that you, you know, and you're like, well, I can tell you at least this much. [Bigly]: And you put that in like, like think of, you know, say you washed your car. [Bigly]: Yes. [Bigly]: And you notice the big fucking gash on your bumper. [Bigly]: Yes. [Bigly]: And you don't remember hitting anything. [Bigly]: You're the only one driving your car. [Bigly]: How did you get this information?
[Bigly]: How did you... And you're looking at this gash now that you've washed your car. [Bigly]: Sorry, Mr. Sagemire. [Bigly]: And now someone's going to say... You file a claim with your insurance company. [Bigly]: And they're going to say, well, when did this happen? [Bigly]: Well, you don't know when the actual gash happened. [Bigly]: But you knew last Saturday you were washing your car and then you noticed it. [Bigly]: So you would say... [Bigly]: Well, I noticed, I noticed that last Saturday. [Bigly]: So whoever's taking your claim will put in last Saturday as the date of the loss, [Bigly]: even though this could have happened days prior, months prior, weeks prior.
[Bigly]: Who knows? [Bigly]: Probably. [Bigly]: You know, and so like in his defense, I I'm going to say that maybe, you know, [Bigly]: looking at the facts, he knows at least this much. [Bigly]: And so he probably put down the most reliable information he had at the time. [Bigly]: You sound like a fucking union rep for the doctor. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Arthur]: As a gross closer analogy, imagine taking a steak out of the freezer and someone [Arthur]: saying, when did you put that in there? [Arthur]: And you'll say, well, it's frozen solid. [Arthur]: So it had to have been within, it couldn't have been five minutes ago. [Arthur]: It had to have been at least a day ago.
[Arthur]: But other than that, how do you tell? [Arthur]: if it was a month ago [Ood]: and stuff that doesn't freeze solid that could be used to measure degration like [Ood]: fabric and like materials will degrade in exposure over a couple days you'd be able [Ood]: to measure that but those things were immediately destroyed and by the time this [Ood]: guy got to it it's like [Sage]: I guess the best he could do is like an ish time yeah well like okay [Ood]: okay like it's [Ood]: I'm sure this guy, like, I'm sure this guy isn't, like, a chief, like, fighter for [Ood]: indigenous rights. [Ood]: Like, and all that. [Ood]: Like, he's part of that same system.
[Ood]: But I'm saying that, like, the initial investigation was not done correctly. [Ood]: So this guy really couldn't do his job correctly. [Sage]: All right. [Sage]: I take back my initial derision. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: to me i i think that he said that it's possible being november 25th like to me it's [Bigly]: like you know like he knew by 2200 hours november 27th yeah 1990 right he was dead [Bigly]: yeah but you know when they say well well it could be possible it was the 25th yeah [Bigly]: i mean it very well could have been he's you know based on what you have you gotta
[Bigly]: make a decision right that's what he put down so [Leon]: You got a frozen corpse that's been out for a few days. [Leon]: Who knows? [Leon]: Yeah. [Sage]: Okay. [Sage]: Could have been yesterday. [Bigly]: Could have been two days ago. [Sage]: Could have been. [Ood]: It could have been. [Ood]: His autopsy report noted the marks on Stone Child's nose. [Ood]: So this is Dr. Adolph again. [Ood]: Saying that they were abrasions. [Ood]: Abrasions only take off the surface layer of skin. [Sage]: Road rash. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: In comparison, like a laceration cuts through multiple layers of skin. [Ood]: It cuts deeper. [Ood]: He testified that abrasions aren't unusual when someone dies by exposure.
[Ood]: I learned this in first aid too. [Ood]: As the skin starts lowering temperature and starts stiffing up and freeze, it [Ood]: becomes way less pliable. [Ood]: So if you rub it against something, it can slough right off. [Bigly]: Because of more damage, yeah. [Ood]: But usually that's only the first layer of skin. [Ood]: So falls, stumbles, bumping against things could lead to abrasion. [Ood]: He indicated that the injury looked recent, but it would not be possible to [Ood]: determine an exact time frame of when the injury happened. [Ood]: He also stated that Jarvis' report that there were no signs of trauma to the body
[Ood]: was incorrect. [Ood]: He said that he told Jarvis that there was no sign of traumatic death, which is a [Ood]: different matter. [Ood]: The doctor also noted in his autopsy report that there was a stone in the shoe worn [Ood]: by Stone Child, which was unexpected given where the body was found. [Ood]: He testified to the inquiry about Stone Child's blood alcohol level, indicating it [Ood]: may have contributed, but at a .15 was not linked to any sort of incapacity or [Ood]: coma, so it wouldn't have been the reason that he passed out unconscious died.
[Ood]: It wasn't blood alcohol poisoning. [Bigly]: Well, I mean, like I said, Phil Guerrero and I, we would do it. [Bigly]: We'd reach like 0.16, which is twice the legal limit. [Bigly]: And I mean, we were still like, you know, laughing it up and having a good time. [Bigly]: It was just what you do. [Bigly]: You know, like, you know, it's not enough to cause someone to be blackout drunk to [Bigly]: be twice the limit. [Sage]: No. [SPEAKER_35]: and I wanna show everyone really quickly how blood alcohol concentrations affect [SPEAKER_35]: your judgment.
[SPEAKER_35]: You may start off, have a drink, and you're starting to feel relaxed. [SPEAKER_35]: your intensification of mood. [SPEAKER_35]: Then you're getting a little sedation. [SPEAKER_35]: This is where you start to wonder, you know, driving may not be such a smart idea. [SPEAKER_35]: Maybe after two or three drinks, you're starting to get impaired motor skills. [SPEAKER_35]: 0.08 in many places is an illegal level of blood alcohol concentration as far as [SPEAKER_35]: DUI. [SPEAKER_35]: So things are beginning to be impaired. [SPEAKER_35]: Not really dangerous yet. [SPEAKER_35]: This is where things get kind of
[SPEAKER_35]: Scary. [SPEAKER_35]: Between point three and point four, for most people who are naive to alcohol, you [SPEAKER_35]: can start to lose consciousness. [SPEAKER_35]: And then beyond point four, again, if you're alcohol naive, you can go unconscious. [SPEAKER_35]: That's how you die. [Ood]: So why does the blood alcohol level matter? [Ood]: Because there was a lot of suggestion that Zone Child had consumed a lot of alcohol [Ood]: that night and that he was intoxicated and that he drunkenly wandered out there on [Ood]: his own. [Sage]: No, that's insane.
[Sage]: How would you drunkenly wander all the way the fuck out there? [Ood]: Yeah. [Bigly]: That's because he wanted to confess at the correctional. [Bigly]: He turned himself in at the correctional. [Bigly]: That's why he got drunk and walked all the way out to the correctional from, you [Bigly]: know, those apartments. [Sage]: That would take so long. [Ood]: Well, look at the clip that we played, like, in episode one of the series. [Ood]: Like, that's a very common attitude. [Ood]: Like, you know, just another one of these natives, like, drinking. [Ood]: He probably got drunk and just wandered out there. [Ood]: Now they're trying to bring down these good old cops and, like... [Sage]: Okay, but like, hey, let's bring up the map.
[Sage]: Okay. [Sage]: Okay, where was it? [Sage]: Yeah, you do that. [Sage]: I just want to know how long it would take to walk. [Bigly]: Looks like you got a whole bunch of the evidence packages that I've found too, eh? [Bigly]: That's... Oh, it's amazing. [Sage]: Well, it says an hour and 52 minutes. [Bigly]: To walk all the way out that way where he was. [Bigly]: So if he were walking... [Sage]: Or two hours and two minutes, depending on which way you go. [Sage]: But it's a really fucking- It's two [Bigly]: hours to get there by foot. [Sage]: Yeah, it's a really fucking long walk that I don't know if you-
[Bigly]: Assuming he walked directly there. [Sage]: Yes, and like, I don't know if you've ever been drunk, but when I'm drunk, I do not [Sage]: want to walk for two hours. [Bigly]: Remember that time, Leon, when we got really, really fucking drunk at the Hosen [Bigly]: Hydrant and then we walked all the way to your place in Lakeview? [Bigly]: Yeah, I do remember that. [Bigly]: Yeah, fuck. [Sage]: That's a long way. [Bigly]: That was a long [Ood]: walk from Broadway to Lakeview. [Ood]: Be reminded that the medical expert had said that somebody in this condition [Ood]: probably wouldn't have lasted more than a couple hours in this condition.
[Ood]: So he probably wouldn't have even made it there. [Sage]: No. [Ood]: So in comes another doctor, Dr. Graham Dowling. [Ood]: So this is different from Dr. Adolph and stuff like that. [Ood]: He does a second autopsy on Stone Child. [Ood]: He was certified in anatomical and forensic pathology. [Ood]: He was also a clinical professor at the University of Alberta. [Ood]: Due to the passage of time, he was limited in what he could do with the autopsy. [Ood]: The abrasions noted in the original autopsy were no longer visible due to [Ood]: post-mortem decay of the body.
[Ood]: Remember, at this point, Neil had been in the ground for years, and he had to be [Ood]: exhumed for this to happen. [Ood]: There was a darkening of the skin and a loss of soft tissues. [Ood]: X-rays showed no evidence of cartilage or bone fracture. [Ood]: No injuries were found that were not already on the initial report, and they did [Ood]: not find any indication of disease. [Ood]: There was no evidence to refute the original autopsy report. [Ood]: The RCMP requested five answers to five questions about Neil Stonechild's death
[Ood]: from Dr. Dowling. [Bigly]: number one are they more likely to be from like like the marks are they more likely [Bigly]: to be from being assaulted or are they more likely to be from falling uh [Sage]: stumbling around yeah [Bigly]: from like yeah yeah you fucking trip over your feet you fall on the ground you [Bigly]: smack your face on some some grass [Ood]: or or did he get like a like you said or did someone a handcuff [Bigly]: handcuffs and fucking punch you in the face [Arthur]: did a cop punch [Bigly]: Yeah.
[Ood]: Yes. [Ood]: Number two, are the wounds on the nose more consistent with a blow or an incised [Ood]: wound? [Ood]: Incised wounds are wounds that are usually longer than they are deep. [Ood]: So like longer cuts. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: You just kind of like scrape yourself, you know, you get like a paper cut where [Bigly]: it's like longer on your finger than it is going inside your skin, you know? [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Number three, are the marks on the face more consistent with a blow or a cutting [Ood]: force?
[Ood]: So like the difference between bludgeoning and slashing damage. [Sage]: Yeah, so like a punch or like a slash. [Ood]: Number four, can you, Dr. Dowling, offer any suggestion as to the origin of the [Ood]: mark on Stone Child's right wrist shown in photo 42? [Ood]: So there was an abrasion on his wrist? [Ood]: Let's see if we can pull it up. [Ood]: Are you able to find that? [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: And number five, is the blackening of the lips due to injury or to freezing? [Ood]: Probably both.
[Ood]: Dowling's report indicated the wounds were caused by blunt trauma and not a sharp [Ood]: object. [Ood]: He indicated that he was unable to determine if it was from a fall or if it was [Ood]: from a blow, but in either case, the injuries were minor. [Ood]: The snow around Snow Child was crusty and hard, so it could have come from a fall, [Ood]: but he would not rule out the injuries were due to an assault. [Ood]: At the inquiry, he was questioned on his report by the Council of Police [Ood]: Association as well as the Council for the Stone Child family.
[Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: He did, however, when questioned, venture that looking at a bigger picture, a man [Ood]: last seen in police custody with possible cuff marks on his wrist and possible cuff [Ood]: marks on his face that would help him assign probabilities to what may have
[Ood]: happened. [Ood]: Enter Dr. Emma Liu, a forensic pathologist in Miami, Florida, but was trained in [Ood]: Canada. [Ood]: The assistant clinical professor of pathology at the University of Miami. [Ood]: She was called at the request of the Saskatoon Police Service. [Ood]: Her experience with dead bodies was mostly in Miami, so not much. [Ood]: Well, like hotter, [Bigly]: hotter, hotter bodies. [Bigly]: Yeah, not much experience dealing with frozen bodies in Miami. [Ood]: Yeah, not too many frozen bodies in Miami, but because of her experience, she was
[Ood]: brought forward to give an opinion on the case. [Ood]: She looked at the photos of Stone Child's injuries for a few minutes and drew her [Ood]: conclusions. [Bigly]: I just want to note that this was the doctor called in by the police service to [Bigly]: testify. [Bigly]: So, like, you know, earlier we were talking about how the fucking police service [Bigly]: and the police association slash union... [Bigly]: were more or less there to try to defend their people. [Bigly]: Yes. [Bigly]: And so Emma Liu was basically there at the request of the police service to
[Bigly]: defend... [Sage]: Defend their people. [Bigly]: Their people. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: And so what this person's saying is, you know, they're not necessarily the neutral [Bigly]: party. [Bigly]: They're another party called in by, you know, the police service. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Ood]: Let's just say that when the police hire experts, they're often not looking for [Ood]: objectivity. [Ood]: We've all seen the staircase. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: They're looking for somebody who's going to help defend the officer because that's [Ood]: the number one priority in a lot of books.
[Bigly]: Well, that's that whole forensic science thing where it's like, well, you've got [Bigly]: your conclusion and now you've got to try to make the facts line up to your [Bigly]: conclusion. [Bigly]: And that's basically what she does. [Ood]: Yeah, and because of how the legal system works, like, subject matter experts are [Ood]: some of the only people who can offer facts in a courtroom, so their opinions can [Ood]: become facts, and that's very dangerous when you have forensic science that may or [Ood]: may not be reliable and, you know, flawed people that, yeah, all that good stuff. [Ood]: Mm-hmm.
[Ood]: Her opinion, so she looked at Stone Child's injuries for a few minutes and drew her [Ood]: conclusions. [Ood]: The police were also kind enough to have the photos enhanced to see if she could [Ood]: provide a better opinion of the marks. [Bigly]: Enhanced is in like those suspicious air quotes, just saying. [Bigly]: Good old suspicious air quotes. [Ood]: Her opinion was that the photos from the scene were better to evaluate the injuries [Ood]: versus the autopsy photos as the cold slowed the post-mortem process. [Ood]: She stated that a handcuff could have caused the injuries if you scraped it hard
[Ood]: across the skin. [Ood]: It wouldn't break the cartilage or bone. [Ood]: The answer that she came up with was that it was caused by stems and grass on the [Ood]: ground. [Ood]: As Stonechild's face fell down on the ground, she dismissed the handcuff [Ood]: hypothesis, as she felt there would be a bruise from the handcuff strike. [Ood]: The talk to the vegetation causing injuries to Stone Child was discussed at length. [Ood]: She seemed to dismiss the marks on Stone Child being parallel of having any real [Ood]: meaning. [Ood]: Talks of stems, twigs, when the area didn't really have any trees.
[Ood]: She dismissed the marks on Stone Child's wrist as being from clothing, not [Ood]: handcuffs. [Sage]: No. [Sage]: Yeah. [Ood]: Photos shown at the inquiry show Stone Child's body with his hands tucked inside of [Ood]: his sleeves. [Ood]: Like, you know, you would do if you were cold and didn't have any gloves. [Sage]: Yeah, like I do all the time. [Sage]: Or like my six-year-old son does also. [Ood]: Yeah, you pull your sleeves off your hands and get them out of the cold, out of the [Ood]: wind. [Ood]: Yep. [Ood]: So how does that make any sense? [Ood]: The cuff of his clothing was not in contact with his wrist. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: And his hands were in the sleeve.
[Ood]: If your clothing is loose enough to pull your hands into the sleeve, it's not going [Ood]: to be tight enough to cause injury on your wrist. [Sage]: Yeah, like when you fall on it. [Ood]: She said it could have been found from the shirt he was wearing. [Ood]: It was suggested Stone Child was wearing a t-shirt at the time of loss. [Ood]: She did say upon cross-examination that a handcuff could have caused the mark if [Ood]: Stonechild was resisting, which makes sense when you consider that he was about to [Ood]: be thrown out into the cold in the middle of nowhere by the Saskatoon police. [Ood]: Yes.
[Ood]: She then stated that the wrist marks could have happened after death. [Ood]: However, then agreed with Dr. Dowling that it's difficult to place an age on these [Ood]: sorts of wounds. [Arthur]: It took a while, but I found the picture. [Arthur]: Also, there's another picture to show you afterwards. [Arthur]: This is Neil Stonechild's hands post-mortem. [Sage]: Well, you can definitely see, like... Like [Bigly]: you see the indentation of the handcuffs. [Sage]: Yeah, you can see a mark. [Bigly]: Those are exactly the same indentations that existed for literally hours after I [Bigly]: was released by the police.
[Bigly]: Yeah, it happened. [Bigly]: I literally, like... [Bigly]: got released from the police. [Bigly]: Then I went to the bar to meet Fielger's mom and dad. [Bigly]: And we like talked all about the marks on my wrists from the police handcuffs. [Bigly]: So those look exactly like that. [Bigly]: Those are police handcuffs on his wrists. [Sage]: And I like anecdotally, that's what, that's what my marks looked like too. [Ood]: Anecdotally, that's what [Leon]: my handcuff marks look like. [Ood]: And indentations like that are only filled back in through capillary action. [Ood]: You know what needs capillary action?
[Ood]: Heat. [Ood]: A heartbeat. [Ood]: A heartbeat. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: So that's why those marks are so prominent. [Ood]: But you can see the very clear marks of a handcuff around his wrist. [Ood]: The fact that she thinks it was made by a tight sleeve. [Ood]: No. [Ood]: Bullshit. [Ood]: Bullshit. [Ood]: Yeah, when it was cold and he was probably tucking his whole hand into his sleeve. [Arthur]: Now, the next photo I'll show you is actually a little bit... [Arthur]: It is a photo of a face of a dead person. [Arthur]: So here is Neil Stonechild's face at post-mortem. [Bigly]: Yeah, and you see across his nose, two cuts on his nose.
[Bigly]: They are parallel. [Bigly]: Like very fucking parallel. [SPEAKER_06]: Yes. [Bigly]: And now I don't know, like if you've ever sat down in a field on grass, on twigs, [Bigly]: on leaves, and you sit down for a while and then you like stand up and you know how [Bigly]: you got like the imprints of the grass on your skin? [Sage]: Your hands, yeah, wherever you've been laying on there, yeah. [Bigly]: Yeah, none of that shit's parallel. [Bigly]: No, because it's nature. [Bigly]: Like you've crushed grass and it's imprinted itself on your skin. [Bigly]: These marks are parallel.
[Sage]: They're from where the handcuffs do the swoopity thing inside the two prongers. [Bigly]: You know, and like using them as brass knuckles to like punch his face in, I guess. [Arthur]: I would consider those gashes. [Arthur]: Gashes? [Arthur]: If I had one of those on me, I would say I had a gash. [Sage]: Yeah, and they're definitely... [Arthur]: Data point of one. [Sage]: They're also far too, uh, [Arthur]: parallel and made by something like that. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: Straight and parallel to be from something in nature. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Like that, that was very much the, the argument, uh, you know, that was being
[Bigly]: proposed. [Bigly]: And this, this Emma, Dr. Emma was saying, well, no, that that's from like nature [Bigly]: and twigs, even though there's like no trees in the area. [Bigly]: No. [Bigly]: No. [Bigly]: putting a smiling face back up because they can't watch that. [Bigly]: Twins just show up. [Sage]: They just sprout out of nowhere. [Sage]: And they spring up very, very uniformly. [Ood]: Very parallel, you know? [Ood]: Yeah, it's not like those ditches are manicured by, like, the city and the [Ood]: companies and there wouldn't be little trees growing inside. [Ood]: Like... [Ood]: There wasn't any found at the scene.
[Ood]: So we're getting to about that time where we're going to be closing out this [Ood]: episode. [Ood]: So bottom line, we talked about the RCMP coming in. [Ood]: We talked about them hiring some experts, some pathologists, some doctors to [Ood]: review. [Ood]: But a lot of times, by the time they got access to the evidence, Neil had been dead [Ood]: for years. [Ood]: And a lot of the original evidence had been tossed away. [Ood]: The inquiry found her testimony to be unconvincing. [Ood]: This is going back to Dr. Emma. [Ood]: Injury caused by twigs and grass, which happened to be exactly parallel, would be
[Ood]: very unlikely. [Ood]: If you sit in the grass for a long time and stand up, there's marks on your skin [Ood]: from the grass, but not a lot of parallel marks. [Ood]: It's not consistent. [Ood]: And, like, there wouldn't be parallel injuries along the nose. [Sage]: No. [Sage]: That's like a very specific location to have such like harsh parallel lines. [Sage]: Like even if you were lying face down on the grass, you wouldn't get marks like [Sage]: that. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: So that's the end of my section of the RCMP pulling in their experts. [Ood]: Yeah.
[Ood]: Not a lot of conclusions were drawn because a lot of the evidence had been degraded [Ood]: and a lot of kind of play ball with the police opinion seemed to have been floated. [Ood]: Forensic pseudoscience and that whole thing, you know. [Ood]: This is part three. [Ood]: We've gone through a lot of stuff, but we're going to bring it together in part [Ood]: four of the conclusion to the Neil Stonechild freezing death. [Ood]: So, uh, this is the Occulted Veritatis podcast. [Ood]: I'm Ood Gallifrey, uh, standing in a field in northern Saskatoon with...
[Ood]: Leon Filgert. [Ood]: Sage Murray. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Richard Bigley. [Ood]: With us. [SPEAKER_14]: Geo. [Ood]: And, of course, the radio demon. [SPEAKER_14]: I'm gonna talk into Leon's mic. [Ood]: As you probably already know, because we probably already got a couple episodes of [Ood]: it out already, we did a long episode about Neil Stonechild, and a long warranted [Ood]: episode... [Ood]: And we thought that it wouldn't really be complete unless we visited the spot where [Ood]: the police left him. [Ood]: We really want to absorb the gravity of what happened here, absorb the consequences
[Ood]: of government agents doing terrible things to indigenous people. [Ood]: And this is just one of the results of their actions. [Ood]: So we're here. [Ood]: We're on 57th Street in Saskatoon. [Leon]: So you can imagine back when Neil Stonechild was left here to freeze, none of these [Leon]: buildings existed. [Leon]: Yeah, none of these buildings existed. [Leon]: This was the middle of fucking nowhere. [Bigly]: There's aerial photos available that compared what it looked like then to what it [Bigly]: looks like now. [SPEAKER_36]: Right. [Bigly]: And I mean, again, even today...
[Bigly]: There's absolutely no reason why, despite what the officers at the time may have [Bigly]: suggested, there's absolutely no reason why he would even be here. [Ood]: And for those of you that don't live in Saskatoon, I think we mentioned this in the [Ood]: episode, but I just want to reiterate now, there are no restaurants. [Ood]: Even in today's, there are no coffee shops nearby. [Ood]: There's no residential areas. [Ood]: This is all industrial zone. [Ood]: If you leave someone here in the middle of winter, you're doing it to harm them. [Sage]: Yeah.
[Ood]: I believe our radio demon has the GPS coordinates. [Sage]: There's also a cop plane that's been circling us. [Ood]: Yes. [Ood]: Our wonderful city of Saskatoon and its police service has decided to dedicate a [Ood]: bunch of its funds towards having a police plane flying overhead with a camera [Ood]: pointed below, and it appears that that camera's pointed at us tonight. [Leon]: It's called the EGLE Unit, Enhanced Air Guided Law Enforcement.
[Ood]: Yeah, so we're walking down a field just in between a couple of warehouses. [Ood]: You know, during the work week, these would be populated, but they're very empty [Ood]: now. [Ood]: And back when Neil Stonechild was left here, even these buildings weren't around. [Ood]: It was literally just a field. [Ood]: Mm-hmm. [Bigly]: So it's basically just chain link fence and barbed wire in front of us. Yeah. [Leon]: It's a sad place to die. [Bigly]: Yeah.
Yeah. [Sage]: So it was right here. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Sage]: There's just like power lines, chain link fence with razor wire on it. [Bigly]: Industrial stuff. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: You know, agriculture, implements and stuff like that. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Um... [Sage]: Yeah, there's literally no reason to ever drop anyone here for any reason. [Sage]: Yeah. [Ood]: I just, you know, in a free and fair society, nobody should have to be brutalized
[Ood]: or die alone or be put through torture just because they were born a certain [Ood]: culture or a certain race. [Ood]: But that's exactly what happened to Neil. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Unfortunately, this is the end result of a very brutal and unfair system. [Ood]: Yes. [Ood]: It doesn't seem very motivated to change. [Ood]: It's very cold. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: Yeah, it's not even... Like, I'm wearing a sweater, a couple T-shirts, and...
[Ood]: Do you remember what Neil had on that night? [Ood]: It wasn't much. [Bigly]: It was, like, a T-shirt and a jacket. [Bigly]: They found a missing shoe. [Bigly]: Ah. [Bigly]: They are very interested in us. [Bigly]: They are. [Leon]: If we stay here long enough, police will show up. [Bigly]: Well, they're probably on their way, and they're probably going to track our cars
[Bigly]: when we head out, so it wouldn't surprise me. [Leon]: What are you doing in this field, naloxone training? [Leon]: We're certified. [Sage]: I've got my kit in my purse. [Ood]: You know, we get to return to our vehicles after being just briefly chilly.
[Ood]: I can't help but be struck by the contrast how he died cold, alone, and in pain [Ood]: because of the decisions of the Saskatoon Police Department. [Sage]: Yes. [Sage]: It's very sobering. Yeah. [Ood]: And, like, I was even thinking, like, we were talking about maybe the police might [Ood]: pull up here, but we'd probably turn out okay. [Sage]: Well, white, we'd be fine to be like, oh, hey, sorry. [Bigly]: Hey, would you like to talk about this on our podcast? [Bigly]: You know, would be, like, the response. [SPEAKER_26]: Yeah. [Bigly]: You know, and, of course, by that point, they'd probably say get off the property
[Bigly]: or whatever, but we'd probably turn out okay. [Sage]: Yep. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Sage]: Okay. [Ood]: Yeah, so on location for Occulte Veritatis, I'm Oud Gallifrey. [Ood]: David Murray. [Ood]: Leon Filgar. [Ood]: Gio. [Bigly]: Richard Wigley. [Ood]: And the soundboard demon.
[SPEAKER_39]: I can tell you how fast that officer drove the car every inch of the way that he [SPEAKER_39]: drove that day or she drove, where the car stopped, where it started, completely [SPEAKER_39]: archived. [SPEAKER_39]: So if anybody does make an allegation, we can check on it right away. [SPEAKER_39]: We also have forward-facing video and audio in our marked cars and our traffic [SPEAKER_39]: cars. [SPEAKER_39]: So if we pull somebody over, we have a full documentation of the whole event as it [SPEAKER_39]: unfolded. [SPEAKER_39]: And also we archive that. [SPEAKER_39]: As a really good safeguard, I think, we also have rear-facing cameras in our patrol
[SPEAKER_39]: cars. [SPEAKER_39]: So if we're going to place a prisoner in the back of our car, as soon as one of the [SPEAKER_39]: officers opens the back door, the rear-facing camera is automatically put into [SPEAKER_39]: place. [SPEAKER_07]: Fifteen years after the release of the Stonechild Inquiry report, the Federation of [SPEAKER_07]: Indigenous Sovereign Nations acknowledges that, yes, the relationship between [SPEAKER_07]: Indigenous people and the Saskatoon Police Service has improved, but more needs to [SPEAKER_07]: be done. [SPEAKER_07]: Neil Stonechild was found frozen to death on the outskirts of Saskatoon, November [SPEAKER_07]: 25, 1990.
[SPEAKER_07]: shortly after he was last seen taken into police custody. [SPEAKER_07]: Chief Bobby Cameron of the FSIN says he looks forward to working with the Saskatoon [SPEAKER_07]: Police Service and the province to keep improving the relationship and dialogue. [SPEAKER_31]: We're here to say that we continue to strive for that communication piece that we [SPEAKER_31]: at the FSIN have advocated for in terms of Saskatoon Police Service, the RCMP of [SPEAKER_31]: Saskatchewan, [SPEAKER_31]: It's a critical component to have that constant communication about First Nation
[SPEAKER_31]: input. [SPEAKER_07]: Saskatoon Police Service held a community engagement session recently, and Chief [SPEAKER_07]: Cameron says it's a good start and key component to getting input from First [SPEAKER_07]: Nations. [SPEAKER_07]: But former chief of the FSIN, Lawrence Joseph, who was in office when Neil [SPEAKER_07]: Stonechild died, says the police need to be policed. [SPEAKER_33]: Saskatchewan is the only province, apparently, that does not have a [SPEAKER_33]: of civilian or impartial oversight and we'd like to have that.
[SPEAKER_33]: There's no reason why we cannot have that because there's still some filth and crud [SPEAKER_33]: out there from certain members of [SPEAKER_33]: Police agencies, under treaty, we're promised that the red coats will protect us. [SPEAKER_07]: Vice Chief Dutch LaRaw says yes, they have come a long way, but there's a long way [SPEAKER_07]: to go. [SPEAKER_30]: I think it's more important to have a civilian oversight and how that's arrived at. [SPEAKER_30]: Because, as the chief said, it's the perception of the blue veil of police covering
[SPEAKER_30]: for police. [SPEAKER_30]: And, you know, that perception is not only within the Indian country, but when in [SPEAKER_30]: outside of Indian country as well. [SPEAKER_30]: Case in point, we've had two deaths, one in North Battleford, another one out by [SPEAKER_30]: Wadena. [SPEAKER_26]: Definitely, yes, I'm happy that I was a part of this process that helped a lot of [SPEAKER_26]: people and opened up a lot of eyes to a situation that was out there.
[SPEAKER_26]: I feel that there's been a lot of changes. [SPEAKER_26]: For the most part, they've been good. [SPEAKER_26]: Chief Clive Weahill has done a really good job coming into a job where he didn't [SPEAKER_26]: really... [SPEAKER_26]: that he came into a battle zone really when he got elected as chief, so he did a [SPEAKER_26]: pretty good job at that. [SPEAKER_26]: I think that there's still issues when it comes to Aboriginal people and policing. [SPEAKER_26]: There's still going to be issues, and there probably will be for a long time, but I
[SPEAKER_26]: think it was a great start in the process. [SPEAKER_26]: Personally, I've dealt with it in a lot of different ways, and it was traumatic for [SPEAKER_26]: me going through the experience of Neil dying, and the moment he died, that he had [SPEAKER_26]: died, was a life-changing thing for myself personally. [SPEAKER_26]: And then I think also when the inquiry... [SPEAKER_26]: started, went through its process and ended, you know, the city of Saskatoon had a [SPEAKER_26]: lot of big changes in it. [SPEAKER_26]: Because of it, I think, I just hope it will kind of shed some light on some other
[SPEAKER_26]: big issues and mainly one that I find very important is murdered and missing women [SPEAKER_26]: in Canada. [SPEAKER_26]: And I hope that this exposure kind of gives some enlightenment on that as well. [Bigly]: So the conclusion drawn from the inquiry was that the only people who knew for sure [Bigly]: what exactly happened would be Neil Stonechild and Hartwig and Singer. [Bigly]: There was like 8,000 pages, I guess 8,500 pages of evidence and transcripts.
[Bigly]: They put it all together and basically they recreated kind of the events of what [Bigly]: happened. [Bigly]: So how it... [Bigly]: played out was that Stone Child met up with Jason Roy. [Bigly]: They were taking the bus, and while on the bus, they met with an old girlfriend of [Bigly]: Neil Stone Child's. [Bigly]: They learned that she was babysitting for her sister and her boyfriend, who was [Bigly]: Trent Ewert. [Bigly]: They went to Stone Child's place where Neil promised his mother to return to the
[Bigly]: group home after the weekend. [Bigly]: And he even actually phoned the manager of the community home and promised to [Bigly]: return. [Bigly]: So, you know, he's like, I'm leaving, but here's where I'm going to be. [Bigly]: I'll come back at this point. [Sage]: Seems pretty responsible. [Bigly]: You know, it's a responsible thing that you would do if you resided in a group [Bigly]: home. [Sage]: Which I have worked in several. [Bigly]: Yeah, where people would be concerned if you weren't back. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: So anyway, Jason and Stone Child went out, grabbed some booze, and Stone Child had [Bigly]: a white T-shirt on and a lumberjack jacket.
[Bigly]: so the t-shirt of course as we discussed last episode uh they had said well if it [Bigly]: wasn't from his jacket it was probably from a shirt he was wearing and it's like [Bigly]: well he's wearing a t-shirt so a t-shirt isn't going to leave a cuff mark on your [Bigly]: wrist so anyway uh jason and stone child they drank a bottle of vodka likely a 40 [Bigly]: ounce at a friend's place uh stone child wanted to go to snowberry down so they [Bigly]: went uh they stopped [Bigly]: at the 7-Eleven across the street first on 33rd and Confederation Drive in
[Bigly]: Saskatoon. [Sage]: Is that still a 7-Eleven or is it a 7-Eleven? [Sage]: No, it's a 7-Eleven now. [Bigly]: It's still a Sev. [Bigly]: It's been a Sev forever. [Bigly]: Then they crossed the street and went to Snowberry Downs, which is a collection of [Bigly]: apartments. [Bigly]: So they went looking, basically going from apartment to apartment, looking for [Bigly]: Stone Child's old girlfriend. [Bigly]: Uh, Jason kind of got fed up with this, you know, cause you got a buddy who's like [Bigly]: looking for an old girlfriend and just kind of harassing a bunch of strangers, you [Bigly]: know, trying to find her going, you know, building to building, buzzing all the [Bigly]: different things, trying to find her, you know?
[Bigly]: So Jason was like, no, this is, I'm, I'm done with this. [Bigly]: So I'm just going to leave. [Sage]: Bye. [Sage]: Like bye, bro. [Bigly]: Yeah, bye, bro. [Bigly]: And so Stone Child then became angry. [Bigly]: Jason left and went to the 7-Eleven to warm up because it was, what did I say? [Bigly]: Minus 28. [Sage]: Which is probably like minus 33 [Bigly]: with the wind chill. [Bigly]: With wind chill. [Bigly]: It gets fucking cold here. [Bigly]: Stone Child, you know, managed to get into an apartment and basically went door to [Bigly]: door looking for his old girlfriend and
[Bigly]: eventually running into Trent Ewert and you know Trent Ewert wasn't having none of [Bigly]: this so Stone Child was kind of causing a bit of a disturbance and he threatened to [Bigly]: call the police so Trent eventually did and then Stone Child apologized and was [Bigly]: like you know I'm [Bigly]: sorry man i mean i don't know if that's what he said because nobody knows what he [Bigly]: said but he basically just you know was like no i'm sorry he went this far and he [Bigly]: left so stone child would never be seen again by anyone in that apartment
[Sage]: just a quick pause i want the last bite of that cookie [Bigly]: i want the second last bite of that cookie i [Sage]: have oh my god sorry i'm so excited no problem continue [Bigly]: So what we do know is that a police cruiser with Hartwig and Sanger was dispatched [Bigly]: to Snowberry Downs. [Bigly]: They indicated they were en route at 11.51 p.m. [Bigly]: The next hour, the inquiry found based on evidence that the officers came upon [Bigly]: Stone Child shortly after 11.51. [Bigly]: Stone Child was drunk.
[Bigly]: It was likely uncooperative. [Bigly]: They took him into custody shortly after they drove down Confederation drive, [Bigly]: finding Jason Roy, who denied knowing stone child. [Bigly]: Now stone child was calling to Jason for help in the back of the police cruiser. [Bigly]: Roy gave the officers a fake name and a fake birth date. [Bigly]: Uh, the name and the date matched up with, uh, his cousin, actually Tracy Lee [Bigly]: horse. [Bigly]: So Jason Roy gave his cousins information, uh, to the police because, you know, he
[Bigly]: figured he was had a warrant for his arrest as we had heard earlier in, in previous [Bigly]: episodes. [Bigly]: So at 11.56 p.m., Roy was released by the police, and at 12.17 a.m., the officers [Bigly]: logged a call as gone on arrival. [Bigly]: Basically, what that means, a stone child was gone by the time the police arrived. [Sage]: Gone like dead? [Bigly]: No, like as in, you know, hey, there's a guy outside. [Bigly]: He's being annoying.
[Bigly]: Please come deal with him. [Bigly]: And so the police get there. [Bigly]: But by the time the police attend, he's already gone. [Bigly]: Right. [Bigly]: Okay. [Bigly]: And that's the end of that. [Bigly]: So Stone Child was recorded as gone on arrival. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: And, um, yeah, so basically the status and name searches by the officers were very [Bigly]: suspicious. [Bigly]: For example, uh, the call to Oregon Crescent, a block away that took like six [Bigly]: minutes to arrive at, uh, and then was cleared again. [Bigly]: And then again, as gone on arrival.
[Bigly]: So whoever was breaking in at Oregon Crescent was gone by the time the police [Bigly]: arrived. [Bigly]: Then at 1230, they searched Ewert's name long after saying that they've handled the [Bigly]: Stone Child complaint. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: So according to them, it was a nothing burger. [Ood]: They went to a call. [Ood]: By the time they got there, they say that Stone Child wasn't even there. [Ood]: They didn't even make contact. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Sage]: Troublemaker was already gone. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So between running Tracy Lee horse's name and clearing Eward's complaint, 21
[Bigly]: minutes had passed. [Bigly]: There was six minutes to get to Oregon to the Oregon complaint. [Bigly]: So like 27, 27 minutes, I guess, was unaccounted for. [Bigly]: And then between Snowberry Downs, the dispatch and the Oregon dispatch, then there [Bigly]: was enough time in that unaccounted for minutes to drive Stone Child off or drive [Bigly]: to where they drop Stone Child off. [Bigly]: However, there was not enough evidence to pursue that matter further, according to
[Bigly]: the inquiry. [Bigly]: The inquiry had found that there was sufficient evidence that Stone Child had died [Bigly]: in the early morning hours of November 25, 1990 as a result of cold exposure. [Bigly]: Nobody had heard from Stone Child since the event with the police. [Bigly]: So, yeah. [Bigly]: The inquiry found testimony from Jason Roy. [Bigly]: There were some contradictions, but it was corroborated with other evidence [Bigly]: otherwise.
[Bigly]: They explained the contradictions were a result of the lifestyle that Roy was [Bigly]: living at the time. [Bigly]: According to his testimony, it was that he was stopped by police and [Bigly]: And what he saw was Stone Child in the back of the police car. [Bigly]: And they felt that, you know, that was that was credible. [Bigly]: Sure. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Hartwig and Singer maintained that they had no memory of stopping Joyce and Roy. [Bigly]: They insisted that they would not have had time to arrive at Snowberry Downs, meet [Bigly]: with Ewert, arrest Stone Child and put him in the car.
[Bigly]: and then have an encounter with Jason Roy at the time indicated after they had [Bigly]: apprehended Stone Child. [Bigly]: Of course, the evidence suggests that Stone Child had left the apartments after the [Bigly]: police were called already, so this defense does not really actually stand up to [Bigly]: scrutiny because he had already left the apartments. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: I like it. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So the officers didn't remember nor make any notes with regards to any contact with [Bigly]: Ewart that night, despite having been [Bigly]: The guy who phoned in the initial complaint.
[Bigly]: Evidence shows that A, Neil Stoneschild was last seen in their custody at [Bigly]: approximately 11.56 p.m. November 24th, 1990. [Bigly]: B, that he died of cold exposure in a remote industrial area in the early hours of [Bigly]: November 25th, 1990. [Bigly]: And C, that there were injuries and marks on his body that were consistent with [Bigly]: handcuffs. [Bigly]: Mm-hmm. [Bigly]: With regards to the discovery of Stone Child's body, it was found that the officers [Bigly]: who attended the scene did their jobs. [Bigly]: However, an investigator did not attend the scene and the morality unit was put on
[Bigly]: the file and not major crimes. [Bigly]: So this oversight was, I guess, essentially going to be very minimal compared to [Bigly]: the inadequate investigation that would have followed. [Ood]: Yeah. [Ood]: And you can see the level, like as we went through before, you can see the level of [Ood]: attention given that [Ood]: for just victims of accidental death versus victims of a homicidal crime. [Ood]: His clothes weren't even inspected, they were thrown away because [Ood]: He was considered a quote-unquote an accidental death.
[Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Which like went against police procedure to actually just give the clothes back to [Bigly]: the family. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: They were just straight up destroyed. [Bigly]: So a quick and superficial investigation was conducted by Jarvis with the file [Bigly]: being closed merely days after being opened. [Bigly]: Six people were interviewed, mostly by telephone. [Bigly]: Two written statements obtained. [Bigly]: Jarvis did not attend the scene of the death. [Bigly]: He did not look at photos. [Bigly]: He didn't examine the body or look at autopsy photos.
[Bigly]: He didn't read the autopsy report or the toxicology report. [Bigly]: Why would you even have photos taken if you're not even going to look at them? [Sage]: No, he like literally just like tootled around. [Bigly]: Well, exactly. [Bigly]: And that's always my thing is it's like, why would you do something if you're not [Bigly]: even going to use that information or use, you know, [Sage]: If you're just going to fuck around, like, around the edges of the information. [Bigly]: Why put somebody through the effort of having to actually, like, do their job when [Bigly]: you're not even going to take the results seriously and use them in your
[Bigly]: investigation? [Ood]: Yeah, you're an investigator, not an assumingator. [Ood]: Like, investigate. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So it's like, why even do these reports if you aren't even going to look at them? [Bigly]: Like, that just seems, you know. [Sage]: Sketch. [Sage]: It's mad sus. [Bigly]: Jarvis had received a tip that rival Gary Pratt may have been involved in [Bigly]: Stonechild's death, but there was minimal follow-up. [Bigly]: There was poor records of correspondence, no records of contact he claimed to have [Bigly]: had with Sanger and Hartwig. [Bigly]: He was completely disinterested in the investigation and protocols were not
[Bigly]: followed. [Bigly]: These deficiencies were apparently okay with Jarvis's supervisor as the file was [Bigly]: approved for closure. [Bigly]: Okay. [Bigly]: Internal complaints about the investigation after the file was closed would have [Bigly]: allowed the police another chance to investigate, but no, the complaints were [Bigly]: disregarded internally. [Bigly]: namely because complaining officers were referred to the officer who they were [Bigly]: lodging the complaint against. [Bigly]: It's like, I think Jarvis needs to do a better investigation.
[Bigly]: Oh, well, go see Jarvis and let him know of your concerns. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: Even though he's your superior and has a direct impact on your career. [Sage]: Precisely. [Sage]: That's like a really good plan. [Sage]: Like, hey, Jarvis, I... [Bigly]: Great mechanism. [Sage]: Yeah, like I'm aware that you're my supervisor, but I think you're kind of doing a [Sage]: shit job. [Sage]: It's essentially saying, [Ood]: hey, little chicken, put your head on the chopping block. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Yeah, so that's how the Saskatoon police does things. [Bigly]: Or at least did things. [Bigly]: I don't know if that's changed. [Bigly]: Maybe. [Bigly]: uh public complaints about the investigation via media offered another chance to
[Bigly]: look at the police or at the case did the police do this upon like media you know [Bigly]: these complaints being brought forward to the media no despite an article [Bigly]: suggesting that racism played a role in this lack of investigation so it's like [Bigly]: you know, you're the cops, you do the shitty investigation, and boom, you're in the [Bigly]: newspaper, and they're saying, well, it's because you're racist, and they still did [Bigly]: not feel compelled to do anything better. [Ood]: Like, even if they gave, like, 5% of a shit, they might, like, do a crappy
[Ood]: reinvestigation just to gain, like, public favor, but they didn't even care enough [Ood]: to do that. [Sage]: No, they didn't even give, like, half a shit. [Sage]: Yeah, no. [Bigly]: Sigh. [Bigly]: So the only time Stone Child was revisited was in 2000 when the RCMP opened a case [Bigly]: and launched Project Ferrick. [Bigly]: The media started reporting on the conduct of the Saskatoon police. [Bigly]: Minutes of Saskatoon police meetings showed vile feelings towards the media. [Bigly]: For example, stating, and now this is in police minutes, like your official formal
[Bigly]: documentation of the meetings you have held. [Ood]: And they know that they're being recorded. [Ood]: So this is them on their best behavior. [Bigly]: Yeah, this is their best behavior. [Bigly]: And anyway, I quote for the minutes, it's their job to cause alarm. [Bigly]: And a lot of what is stated, the general public are able to see through this. [Bigly]: The media's job is to sell newspapers. [Bigly]: What? [Bigly]: That is literally what was in the minutes of the Saskatoon police on this matter
[Bigly]: when it was, like, brought up about, you know, now the media is reporting on Neil [Bigly]: Stonechild in the year 2000. [Sage]: They were like, well, oh, shit. [Bigly]: Well, the media just wants to cause alarm and sell newspapers. [Ood]: It's a total non sequitur. [Ood]: It's just like, you know, newspapers, they survive on money. [Ood]: Okay, but respond to the criticisms, maybe? [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Well, and it gets even more fucky because like when you add this kind of attitude [Bigly]: that they're willing to put down on fucking paper in their meeting minutes.
[Bigly]: What are they saying in the locker room? [Bigly]: Well, exactly. [Bigly]: These, you know, you couple that with the misleading statements that were made to [Bigly]: the media on the investigation. [Bigly]: You know, one person's like, oh, yeah, an extensive investigation. [Bigly]: And he points to a file folder with a bunch of non-unrelated material. [Bigly]: Completely unrelated material. [Bigly]: Leading the reporter to think that, you know, this file is the investigation. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: You know, like one can only imagine how the Saskatoon police felt about the media.
[SPEAKER_19]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_19]: You know. [Bigly]: That's fucked up, man. [Bigly]: Yeah, it's really kind of fucky. [SPEAKER_00]: I covered the Stonechild inquiry start to finish. [SPEAKER_00]: And my prevailing memory from that event is how ashamed I was of the city and of [SPEAKER_00]: the police department. [SPEAKER_00]: But there were moments during that inquiry where I was proud as well. [SPEAKER_00]: I was proud of the Star Phoenix, for example, of the work that we did in covering [SPEAKER_00]: that story. [SPEAKER_00]: Not long after Neil Stonechild went missing, Terry Craig, my former colleague, went
[SPEAKER_00]: and interviewed Stella Bignol. [SPEAKER_00]: She was unhappy with the state of the investigation. [SPEAKER_00]: The police brushed her off. [SPEAKER_00]: No justice authorities wanted to hear from her. [SPEAKER_00]: But Terry Craig of the Star Phoenix went and met with her and talked to her about [SPEAKER_00]: how concerned she was over the sloppy investigation done into the death of her son. [SPEAKER_00]: And that story became an important piece of evidence later on in the inquiry. [SPEAKER_00]: And so there was some good work done in that too by a lot of people. [Bigly]: Given the power of the state that police are entrusted with, you think they should
[Bigly]: be, like, open to scrutiny and be, like, transparent to people. [Bigly]: Yeah, the inquiry exposed a lot of problems with the Saskatoon police. [Bigly]: The police association union is basically not immune to these issues either. [Bigly]: Basically, the association and the Saskatoon police went buddy-buddy on this to try [Bigly]: to cover their fucking asses. [Bigly]: Yep. [Bigly]: Yep. [Bigly]: In the 90s, the police had abolished several specialized investigation areas.
[Bigly]: So, like, you can't take a cop from one area of specialization, say, like traffic [Bigly]: investigation, and expect them to be a major crimes investigator. [Sage]: No, those are completely different things. [Sage]: Oh, exactly. [Sage]: And completely different skill sets. [Bigly]: But that's what they did in the 90s was they were like, well, you're a traffic [Bigly]: investigator, but we're going to put you on major crimes. [Bigly]: So now a guy who's used to like accident reconstruction, measuring, you know, tread [Bigly]: marks and skid marks and analyzing that kind of data is now expected to deal
[Bigly]: with murders, you know, and like they're completely different. [Bigly]: They're not the same thing. [Ood]: They just leave so much room open for bullshit politics and nepotism and, like, [Ood]: don't forget, the piddly little they learn at the academy is just like the basics. [Ood]: When they get assigned different jobs on the beat, there's a lot of mentorship and [Ood]: on-the-job training, which depends on, like, higher-ups, which we've determined may [Ood]: or may not be corrupt fuckers, you know? [Bigly]: Mm-hmm. [Bigly]: Since then, the Saskatoon had actually returned back to the idea of a specialized
[Bigly]: units for special, you know, people who are specifically trained to know. [Sage]: About specific things. [Sage]: About shit that [Bigly]: they need to know. [Sage]: Right. [Bigly]: Imagine that. [Bigly]: So you won't have like the traffic guy trying to solve a murder. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: Or like the brand new cop trying to solve a giant pedophile ring. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: So they've since returned to the specialization thing. [Bigly]: Officers would do 12 hour shifts, basically four days on and four days off.
[Bigly]: This means that a file would sit dormant for four days while the officer handling [Bigly]: the file was off. [Bigly]: Supervisors would not. [Bigly]: like reassign the files, they would just, you know. [Sage]: Just let them hang out. [Sage]: Just let them hang out for [Bigly]: four days until the actual officer gets in, you know. [Bigly]: So, I mean, at that point, you know, as time progresses, the likelihood of [Bigly]: evidence, you know, is reduced. [Bigly]: People's recollection diminishes. [Bigly]: A lot of [Sage]: shit happens in four days. [Bigly]: Yeah, so in four days... [Bigly]: you know, they just let the file hang out until the guy came back and memories
[Bigly]: fade, evidence degrades. [Bigly]: Yep. [Bigly]: Um, so they had also exposed in this inquiry, a number of training issues, um, you [Bigly]: know, with, with the police officers of Saskatoon, um, [Bigly]: The chain of command basically broke down. [Bigly]: Top officers were not being informed of, you know, the stone child of stone child's [Bigly]: body, which we had discussed in previous episodes. [Bigly]: Top officers were very unaware of what was being reported to the media. [Bigly]: and which is weird because it's like it's on it's on the fucking paper like you
[Bigly]: think one of these top officers would pick up a paper and [Sage]: be like oh [Bigly]: shit oh shit that's our guys yeah no like no it didn't happen [Sage]: like back in the day everyone got their everyone got the paper [Bigly]: I believe it was Jim Madden who had said that there was a big disconnect between, [Bigly]: you know, the lower officer ranks and the higher officer ranks. [Bigly]: And, you know, and basically that disconnect, you know, was quite apparent there [Bigly]: when top officers didn't know anything about Stone Child or allegedly didn't know
[Bigly]: anything about Stone Child. [Bigly]: Okay. [Bigly]: Okay. [Bigly]: Probably most importantly, it exposed the need for racial and cultural diversity [Bigly]: training in the police force. [Bigly]: Aboriginal people were underrepresented in the police force. [Bigly]: Saskatoon police leadership tried to spin this to suggest that Aboriginals were not [Bigly]: interested in policing, despite the RCMP. [Bigly]: having many, many, many Aboriginal officers compared to the Saskatoon police at the [Bigly]: time. [Ood]: That rings of what they used to say about women in STEM, too.
[Ood]: Like, women just don't seem to like math. [Ood]: They don't have a mind for science, so you can't... [Sage]: But they're simple women minds. [Sage]: They're good at feelings and caring. [Sage]: Oh, Christ. [Sage]: Just a bunch of stereotypes again. [Bigly]: Well, and like many Aboriginal people, even in the 90s, they were lawyers, they [Bigly]: were social workers, corrections officers. [Bigly]: So it's like, why the fuck wouldn't they be police officers too? [Bigly]: Like, it's not that they weren't interested, you know? [Bigly]: It's that they were denied. [Bigly]: It's almost like there's a systematic system keeping them out.
[Bigly]: I don't know. [Sage]: Oh, yeah. [Sage]: I don't know. [Sage]: Like, I don't know. [Bigly]: You obviously didn't hear it here first. [Bigly]: Yes. [Bigly]: The inquiry would eventually hold Constable Lutet up as an example of the kind of [Bigly]: Aboriginal officer that Saskatoon police need to hire. [Bigly]: You know, he was questioning things. [Bigly]: He was concerned. [Bigly]: He brought his concerns forward. [Bigly]: He copied the file to make sure that, you know, he could document it. [Bigly]: But he just got rebuffed. [Bigly]: And people didn't give a shit what he had to say.
[Bigly]: Well, and he was concerned that if he pushed the issue, he would be disciplined for [Bigly]: it. [Ood]: It's funny that somebody who actively rebelled against guidelines and rules that he [Ood]: was given... [Ood]: Like he's what's touted as what should be the example of a cop should be hired. [Ood]: Kind of a commentary with [Leon]: the rest of the cop shops. [Leon]: Upon his retirement, there was a letter to the editor published in the Star Phoenix [Leon]: that I remember reading in which an indigenous member of the community slammed him
[Leon]: for abusing his indigenousness to actively oppress indigenous people while he was [Leon]: police officer. [Sage]: Is he still a cop? [Sage]: No, he's retired. [Sage]: And when did he retire? [Leon]: A number of years ago, but he's written a couple of books. [Leon]: Okay. [Leon]: I'm just curious. [Sage]: I don't know anything about this guy. [Ood]: I mean, it's a complicated issue. [Ood]: It's just like members of visual minorities becoming like police in the states. [Ood]: If they're trained in the same corrupt system, then even if they're representative,
[Ood]: they're still causing harm. [Ood]: They may try to fight against it, and they may do some great work, but that effect [Ood]: is still existing. [Bigly]: You're still complacent in the system. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: But yeah, the inquiry found him to be what you would expect out of an officer. [Bigly]: A good apple. [Bigly]: Yeah, one of the good apples, I guess, in the police force. [Bigly]: So the police service became more interested in defending its employees than [Bigly]: serving the public interest of law and justice.
[Bigly]: Oof. [Bigly]: In response, the police have tried making filing complaints more accessible to the [Bigly]: public. [Bigly]: That said, if the police are left to investigate themselves, you know, you can't [Bigly]: help but be skeptical. [Ood]: There are different cultural perspectives on the police, surprisingly. [Ood]: Like, I grew up white. [Ood]: I didn't get harassed by the police a whole bunch. [Ood]: Like, I grew up, most of the time, the police giving me the benefit of the doubt. [Ood]: But... [Ood]: We have to be reminded the justice system is colonial. [Ood]: Yes. [Ood]: It's put there by oppressive colonialist people and it was instituted by
[Ood]: colonialists and, you know, the descendants of those colonialists are keeping those [Ood]: traditions alive. [Sage]: Well, exactly. [Sage]: Like when I mentioned that I had been cuffed by cops, like I'm super white. [Sage]: All of my friends were super white. [Sage]: Mm-hmm. [Sage]: We were busted in a super white neighborhood and they were just like, oh, we'll [Sage]: just give you another chance. [Sage]: Like, this is a warning. [Sage]: Basically, even though if I had been literally any other shade other than what I [Sage]: am. [Sage]: probably would have been taken to jail [Ood]: and i've seen it actively working as a bouncer sometimes we had to call the cops
[Ood]: because like you know a bunch of people got in a brawl and we we weren't able to [Ood]: handle it anymore and i saw actively how they treated people differently you know [Ood]: you know you know some some white college kid versus some like some indigenous guy [Ood]: like they treated them very very differently [Sage]: even if it wasn't like an indigenous college kid versus a white college kid just [Ood]: an example like [Ood]: The justice system is colonial and foreign. [Ood]: Indigenous justice is not. [Ood]: And this causes problems. [Ood]: As Neil Stonechild's sister told the inquiry, quote, In general terms, there was no
[Ood]: trust established there. [Ood]: At all. [Ood]: Period. [Ood]: My mother tried to teach us children that under every circumstance, you need to [Ood]: help, you need to call the police. [Ood]: That's their job. [Ood]: That's what they're there for. [Ood]: When you have conflict with that, what you've been taught your whole life, [Ood]: but you're experiencing a whole lot of other things that's just otherwise, then I'm [Ood]: sorry. [Ood]: There was a few incidences in my personal life and our entire family's. [Ood]: And I'm talking, when I say my entire family, I'm talking my mothers, my brothers,
[Ood]: my uncle, my cousin, whoever happened to be in our home at the time. [Ood]: They were never reported simply because there is no trust. [Ood]: And it didn't. [Ood]: That's not going to say that I'm slashing up the Saskatoon police force because, [Ood]: please, there is a lot of good people out there. [Ood]: I know there is. [Ood]: We can't ignore the fact that they're human. [Ood]: Everybody's a human being. [Ood]: We don't have no trust for the city police. [Ood]: If we had more trust for the city police, my mother would have been reporting them [Ood]: left and right center every time they went AWOL from somewhere, every time they
[Ood]: went... [Ood]: unlawfully at large, from somewhere. [Ood]: Or they run away from their community home where she was trying so hard to help [Ood]: them. [Ood]: She was trying so hard to help them, to understand their cycle, or whatever you [Ood]: want to call it, their way of being and holding themselves. [Ood]: You can kind of see through what his sister is saying, like kind of the breakdown [Ood]: of [Ood]: the role of what the police should be. [Ood]: When we talk about the ideal form of justice, what the police should be, they [Ood]: should help. [Ood]: They should improve community relations.
[Ood]: When you see a police officer, there shouldn't be fear. [Ood]: There shouldn't be a need to hide. [Ood]: They should be people that are helping you along in your community. [Sage]: Yeah, not someone to be scared of. [Sage]: Like, I am a white, white, white, white, white woman. [Sage]: And when I see the cops, I'm like, fuck, fuck, oh shit. [Sage]: And I know that I've passed that along to my, rightfully or wrongfully, I've been [Sage]: passing my opinions about the cops along to my kid. [SPEAKER_37]: Yeah. [Sage]: But if police was as it should be, they should be seen as helpers in our community,
[Sage]: not someone that's going to punish us. [Sage]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Yeah, when you see a cop car, it shouldn't be, oh, shit. [Bigly]: Like, it should be safety. [Bigly]: You should be feeling safety. [Sage]: Yeah. [Sage]: But no, like... No, no one feels safe. [Bigly]: Think about it when you're driving and you see a cop following you. [Bigly]: What are your thoughts? [Bigly]: Oh, fuck, what am I doing wrong? [Bigly]: You're thinking, I'm safe. [Bigly]: I'm safe. [Bigly]: He's protecting me. [Bigly]: No, you don't fucking think that. [Bigly]: You think, shit, he's going to fuck with me one way or the other. [Sage]: And this is coming from super white people. [Bigly]: Like, I'm fucking neon white. [Bigly]: Yeah, you are. [Bigly]: Like, you put me in the dark and I glow.
[Bigly]: Like... [Sage]: Like, I can't imagine how it is for people who are of a darker shade than we are. [Ood]: Look at directly what Neil Stonechild's sister says. [Ood]: She said that, like, my mom, like, when people wandered off, when their lives could [Ood]: have been in danger, I didn't call the police. [Ood]: We don't trust them. [Ood]: It wasn't worth it. [Ood]: Nope. [Ood]: Exactly. [Sage]: So the following recommendations were made. [Sage]: One, the province reviewed the Coroner's Act based on recommendations from people [Sage]: who testified at the inquiry. [Sage]: Two, province established an intro to policing program to get more Indigenous
[Sage]: officers in law enforcement. [Sage]: Three, the Minister of Justice established an advisory board from police, [Sage]: Indigenous and non-Indigenous communities to focus on recruitment of Indigenous [Sage]: officers. [Sage]: Four, the province improved procedures around police complaints. [Sage]: and that materials be made public and widely dispersed with regards to this, like [Sage]: in the lobby of the police station, in interview rooms, etc. [Sage]: Five, police forces will have a member who is Indigenous with the rank of sergeant
[Sage]: to liaise and be an informal ombudsman. [Sage]: Okay, five. [Sage]: Five. [Sage]: Five. [Sage]: Police forces will have a member who is Indigenous with the rank of Sergeant to [Sage]: liaise and be an informal ombuds... Oh my God, I can't say ombuds... [Sage]: Ombudsman. [Sage]: Ombudsman. [Sage]: Ombudsman.
[Sage]: Okay, five. [Sage]: Police forces will have a member who is indigenous with the rank of sergeant to [Sage]: liaise and be an informal ombudsman. [Sage]: to deal with people of Indigenous heritage. [Sage]: Six, police forces need to provide an annual report to the Ministry of Justice [Sage]: about complaints and nature of complaints against officers and the disposition of [Sage]: these complaints. [Sage]: Seven, officers receive race relations training.
[Sage]: Eight, review of officers' training in anger management and dispute resolution. [Sage]: Cops need to be professional and react appropriately. [Sage]: So I've taken nonviolent crisis intervention training as part of working with [Sage]: the John Howard Society in like a halfway house setting. [Sage]: And we had to do that all the time. [Sage]: So it's probably good that cops do that. [Ood]: And remember back to my police training episode, like a lot of police departments
[Ood]: make a habit of hiring aggressive cops because they believe that they will act in [Ood]: dire situations. [Ood]: And because of that, a lot of cops with anger problems have been put on the beat [Ood]: because they are aggressive and they will act in dire situations. [Ood]: But it has the result of them brutalizing citizens because you hired somebody with [Ood]: an anger problem and gave them authority and weapons. [Sage]: Whereas you hire someone like me who does not have anger issues but is fucking [Sage]: great in a crisis. [Sage]: Like, I don't know. [Sage]: You need to kind of be able to sort through those people.
[Ood]: And I just wanted to reiterate, because we touched on it earlier. [Ood]: When I say that hiring members of visible minorities to be police doesn't solve the [Ood]: problem, I'm not saying that it isn't a step. [Ood]: Having relevant people in there would be a step. [Ood]: I'm annoyed when liberals and centrists and even fucking conservatives say, well, [Ood]: we hired more indigenous cops, so problem solved, right? [Ood]: Yeah. [Bigly]: It's not problem solved. [Bigly]: It's like step one. [Bigly]: Step one of like 20. [Bigly]: Yeah.
[Bigly]: You know, to reform the police. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: Like that's what it is. [Bigly]: It's like step one of 20. [Sage]: Yep. [Sage]: In 2005, Propaganda released the album Patentment City Lights. [Sage]: The song The Bringer of Greater Things was dedicated to Rondi Nastas, Neil [Sage]: Stonechild, and Lawrence Wagner, murdered by members of the Saskatoon Police [Sage]: Department in the album notes. [Ood]: Leon, would you like to read your sheet? [Sage]: Are you on 30? [Sage]: Nope, that's my sheet. [Sage]: Where the fuck [Ood]: is my sheet? [Sage]: Would you like me to read your sheet?
[Sage]: Where is your sheet? [Ood]: I don't know where it is. [Bigly]: He doesn't even fucking know. [Bigly]: Dude's so stoned. [Ood]: It's the one with the 30 on it. [Ood]: I've done the science. [Sage]: Are you sure you don't want me to read it? [Leon]: I got this. [Sage]: As long as it doesn't say ombudsman, I'm good to go. [Leon]: Ombudsman. [Leon]: Leon? [Leon]: No, I read this to someone two days ago. [Leon]: Oh, fuck yeah. [Leon]: Canadian musician Chris Demeanor wrote the song One Shoe, which refers to a stone [Leon]: child who is found missing a shoe.
[Leon]: In 2015, author Candace McLean, and fuck her, I went, I protested at her book [Leon]: launch with a sign that said Indigenous Lives Matter. [Leon]: I don't know who that is. [Leon]: APTN interviewed me. [Leon]: Cool. [Leon]: Yeah, I was pretty tight. [Leon]: I was the only white guy there. [Leon]: I was proud of myself. [Leon]: Good for you, white guy. [Leon]: Thanks. [Leon]: Yeah. [Leon]: So in 2015, horrible author Candace McLean, who's horrible, wrote the shitty, [Leon]: horrible book, When Police Become Prey, The Cold Hearts Facts of Neil Stonechild's
[Leon]: Freezing Death, which was a bullshit book full of lies. [Ood]: When police become prey. [Ood]: Oh, can you cry victim any harder? [Ood]: People who murdered indigenous people. [Ood]: Yeah, you're definitely the victim. [Ood]: People who organized the murder of indigenous people, you're the victim. [Ood]: In the book, she [Leon]: tried to exonerate Hartwig and hang... Fuck me sideways and a half. [Leon]: Later. [Leon]: In the fuck... Fuck me. [Leon]: How high are you?
[Leon]: He's like, no, it's high. [Leon]: How are you? [Leon]: In the book, they tried to exonerate Hartwig and Sanger. [Leon]: Apparently, there was a book signing that would have coincided with the 25th [Leon]: anniversary of Stone Child's death, which was canceled. [Leon]: I know because I was there. [Sage]: Yuck. [Leon]: Yuck. [Sage]: Well, good for counseling it. [Sage]: That's fucking yucky. [Leon]: Yeah, she's just terrible. [Leon]: And it was at the Anivets Club, the Army, Navy, and Air Force Veterans [Leon]: Association's club downtown, and there were a bunch of white racists there, and it
[Leon]: was just super racist, and it was terrible. [Ood]: Yeah, I imagine that video we played on episode one would have seemed familiar. [Leon]: Yes, yes, it was that sort of interaction. [Leon]: Because protesters went down into the Annabeth's Club and, like, busted in during [Leon]: the book launch. [Leon]: Oh, it was intense. [Leon]: I thought my sign was going to get broken by a white person. [Leon]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_14]: I just want everybody to know that my name is Songgirl.
[SPEAKER_14]: And I am a member of the Stonetrall family. [SPEAKER_14]: I'm a descendant of Neil Stonetrall. [SPEAKER_14]: And with this book, I have read bits and pieces of it in the past. [SPEAKER_14]: And with this book, you have been re-victimizing the family. [SPEAKER_14]: You have humiliated them. [SPEAKER_14]: You have discriminated them. [SPEAKER_14]: This needs to stop. [SPEAKER_14]: Everybody that is here is pretty much in support of this family.
[SPEAKER_14]: I'm not insulting my stonetown family. [SPEAKER_14]: I am trying to get to the truth about how I got here. [SPEAKER_14]: There is no truth to this. [SPEAKER_14]: It has been... No, no, no, no. [SPEAKER_14]: Don't touch her. [SPEAKER_14]: Do not touch me. [SPEAKER_14]: Do not touch me. [SPEAKER_14]: I'm not talking to you. [SPEAKER_14]: I'm talking to Candace. [SPEAKER_14]: I'm asking you to let Candace finish. [SPEAKER_14]: That is my right to speak. [SPEAKER_14]: And I will speak on behalf of my family.
[SPEAKER_14]: She has spoken enough. [SPEAKER_14]: We have heard enough already. [SPEAKER_14]: You are hurting my family. [SPEAKER_14]: You are hurting this thought of the community. [SPEAKER_22]: They don't want to know what happened to us. [SPEAKER_22]: They know what happened to us. [SPEAKER_22]: This is all you're opening up for. [SPEAKER_22]: We still don't even know the shame. [SPEAKER_22]: I'm trying to make a [SPEAKER_14]: presentation here, and you're interrupting, and you're being damn rude.
[SPEAKER_14]: Yes, we are. [SPEAKER_22]: You are being rude and offensive to that young man. [SPEAKER_14]: He died. [SPEAKER_14]: You cannot let that man sit down. [SPEAKER_14]: And they got caught. [SPEAKER_22]: That's what happened. [SPEAKER_22]: That man was no more racist than that. [SPEAKER_22]: We are not lying to him for this [SPEAKER_07]: day, and listen to any more of this. [SPEAKER_07]: That's fine. [SPEAKER_22]: Then please leave. [SPEAKER_14]: Trying to get this reinvestigated. [SPEAKER_14]: The investigation was done. [SPEAKER_14]: It was closed and there was no need and no reason
[SPEAKER_14]: for you to reopen it. [SPEAKER_14]: There was a reason. [SPEAKER_14]: There is no reason. [SPEAKER_14]: No, it's not. [SPEAKER_14]: The injustice is to the family. [SPEAKER_14]: That's who the injustice is doing. [SPEAKER_14]: It's to the family. [SPEAKER_14]: It's to Stella. [SPEAKER_14]: It's to Dean. [SPEAKER_14]: It's to all of them. [SPEAKER_14]: It's to Neal. [SPEAKER_14]: You cannot even allow Neal to rest in peace after 27 years. [SPEAKER_22]: Alright, let's go. [SPEAKER_14]: Jamie.
[Sage]: In March of 2016, it came to light that Saskatoon police removed Starlight Tours [Sage]: section from their Wikipedia article. [Sage]: The IP address that made the change was made from a Saskatoon police IP address. [Sage]: Police said they wipe server logs after 30 days. [Sage]: And in quotes, we will never know for sure what computer who signed into that. [Sage]: It's my understanding that at any time up to 200 people would be utilizing the same [Sage]: server. [Sage]: Yeah.
[Sage]: That's some fucking bullshit right there. [Sage]: I want to throw that out [Bigly]: because these are the people who are like investigating online, like child [Bigly]: pornography and shit. [SPEAKER_22]: And they can fucking [Bigly]: nail, you know, some guy in India for some child [Bigly]: pornography through like this coordinated international fucking police force. [Bigly]: How the fuck don't they know who signed in on the fucking server and made that [Bigly]: goddamn change?
[Bigly]: Like, honest to fucking God. [Sage]: That's fucking yucky. [Bigly]: And bullshit. [Sage]: So much bullshit. [Ood]: If they're like any other government agency that owns and operates, uses the [Ood]: internet and uses proprietary emails... [Ood]: they have to log in under a username and password, which they're probably required [Ood]: to change every three months. [Ood]: And like when they request information, all that, all that shit's logged. [Ood]: Yes. [Ood]: And like, oh, the servers are wiped after 30 days. [Ood]: Very convenient. [Bigly]: When I started working at my job,
[Bigly]: I was a low level employee or I guess low, I mean, not low as in like degrading [Bigly]: low, but I mean like introductory level employee. [Bigly]: Yeah, like an entry level job. [Bigly]: You're an entry level employee. [Bigly]: And I had requested internet access because at the time they didn't give you [Bigly]: internet access by default. [Bigly]: I had requested internet access. [Bigly]: They gave it to me. [Bigly]: I was conducting my job or whatever, doing my thing. [Bigly]: And then I'd surf the internet on my lunch breaks and coffee breaks, which is what
[Bigly]: you did back in, you know, the early two thousands. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: And the boss came up to me one day and was like, please explain this to me. [Bigly]: And on this list, like, like he gave me like, like a ream of paper, which basically [Bigly]: listed every website I was on, [Bigly]: every you know how long on every website i was and basically broke out all my time [Bigly]: and i was like well i served on my lunch break and coffee break because like if you
[Bigly]: look at the times that's when they line up i'm not fucking around doing nothing [Sage]: like were you on cracked.com yeah [Bigly]: no i was generally just on flicker because that was a thing in the early 2000s [Bigly]: right okay and he was like well what's with it i'm like well if you look at the [Bigly]: times they line up with my coffee break and lunch break so i'm like not [Bigly]: I'm not fucking around on work time. [Bigly]: Okay. [Bigly]: I just, I just, I got the report. [Bigly]: I figured I'd ask you some questions about it. [Bigly]: Cause you know, why would an entry level employee spend so much time on the [Bigly]: internet? [Bigly]: And so much time.
[Bigly]: Well, I mean, it was the early two thousands. [Bigly]: And it was like, [Sage]: forever ago okay right i keep forgetting [Ood]: if i had to guess this is some order to cover up bad press that was covered up by [Ood]: like oh well there's so many people that have access to the computer who can really [Ood]: know [Bigly]: well exactly and it's like if my if my employer can produce this report outlining [Bigly]: every website i was on how the fuck do the saskatoon police not have that yes [Sage]: No, that seems like a budget. [Sage]: This is a bullshit reason. [Sage]: In 2016. [Sage]: Exactly. [Sage]: That wasn't that long ago.
[Bigly]: Exactly. [Bigly]: It was four years ago. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: They did this to me in like the year, I don't know, like 15 years ago. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Bigly]: So no, seriously, fuck, like bullshit on that. [Bigly]: Yeah. [Sage]: No, that's bullshit. [Sage]: All right. [Sage]: And then lastly, in 2017, Micmac artist Kathy Elliott completed a five-week [Sage]: workshop with students from Sheridan College for her musical Starlight Tour. [Bigly]: And that's our episode. [Ood]: Yeah, I mean, as far as I can tell, like, I don't think any other podcast out there
[Ood]: has gone through, like, the work of going through the entire inquiry. [Sage]: We can't say we. [Sage]: It was all Richard. [Sage]: It was. [Sage]: I'm sorry. [Bigly]: If you liked this episode, it was all me. [Bigly]: If you didn't like this episode, it was we. [Bigly]: Can I just say that? [Bigly]: We went through it if you don't like the episode. [Bigly]: But if you did like the episode, it was me. [Sage]: It was an excellent amount of research done by our very own Richard Bigley. [Bigly]: This is like an OV pod deep dive. [Bigly]: Yes.
[Bigly]: But I digress. [Bigly]: For Occulte Veritatis, I am Richard Bigley. [Bigly]: Sage Murray. [Bigly]: Leon Pilger. [Bigly]: Ood Galliprey. [Arthur]: And the soundboard demon. [Leon]: Goodbye. [Leon]: Love you. [Leon]: Bye. [Leon]: See you next week. [Ood]: Playing us out the song mentioned and featured in the episode. [Ood]: This is Bringer of Great Things by Propagandhi. [Ood]: Enjoy and see you in the after show.
[SPEAKER_22]: Drive you to your skin and bone And when we finally reach the end Fall into our [SPEAKER_22]: open arms Except our tears of sympathy [SPEAKER_22]: You should know by now that we never come in peace.
[SPEAKER_22]: Endure this tragedy, wrap yourselves in our fantasies. [SPEAKER_22]: When you think of all you've lost, weigh it with what you've gained in trade. [SPEAKER_22]: We've given the greatest gift, this savior that will never run. [SPEAKER_22]: creator of greater things creator of brighter days the city comes to sub-09 a [SPEAKER_22]: midnight ride out of town the
[SPEAKER_22]: passenger was found [SPEAKER_22]: frozen to the snow [SPEAKER_22]: Our handshake crushing bone.
[SPEAKER_22]: The blankets that keep you warm. [SPEAKER_22]: Soiled with disease. [SPEAKER_22]: The bringer of greater things. [SPEAKER_22]: Creator of brighter days. [SPEAKER_22]: The hollow soldiers sang at the ending.
[Ood]: And there is the end of our first deep dive. [Ood]: This is a topic we wanted to cover and we wanted to put the effort in. [Ood]: And once again, big thank you to Richard for pouring through 8,500 fucking pages. [Ood]: What a hero that dude is. [Ood]: But yeah, we got some comments along the course of the series that were along the [Ood]: lines of, [Ood]: This was over 30 years ago. [Ood]: In November 25th, 2020, it was 30 years since Neil Stonechild's death.
[Ood]: And we got some comments along the lines of, why are you guys talking about this [Ood]: old case? [Ood]: The Neil Stonechild tragedy, the way that he was handled and killed by the [Ood]: Saskatoon police, isn't an isolated incident. [Ood]: And it isn't an isolated incident in time, either. [Ood]: His tragedy is one of many, and he is a symbol of the injustice and discrimination [Ood]: that... [Ood]: resides in saskatoon resides in saskatchewan resides in canada we get some
[Ood]: flack for all the complaining we do about americans and american society but when [Ood]: you point with one finger three are pointing back at you canada has a deep darkness [Ood]: of discrimination and racism we can't ignore it we can't turn away we can't pretend [Ood]: that the problems are in the past [Ood]: That was our motivation for talking about this and, you know, discrimination [Ood]: continues up until today. [Ood]: It's an ongoing battle and we have to keep on fighting for it in whatever way we
[Ood]: can. [Ood]: That's it for me. [Ood]: I've been Ud Gallifrey. [Ood]: See you next week where we talk about some other interesting bullshit. [Ood]: Have a wonderful night.
Join Richard as he does a sequel to his "Real life Vampires" episode. Where we learn the terrifying truth that real people in history have been executed under suspicion from the powerful that they were wolves. Also,...
We needed a lighter episode. So lets talk about ten of the dumbest cryptids Ood and sage could research. Today, on Ovpod, get your Dong Wrangled,learn how to avoid mountain whales, meet the crying ballsack cryptid,...
An unavoidable follow-up to our poop episode, here, Arthur guides us through a river of PISS. What high end product is forged in piss? Can Aged urine cure insomnia? How do mice pee? Does a kidney stone gather moss? All...
Remember, if a loophole in a rule exists, it was put there to gain leads one second at a time. Formula One is a world wide, single seat, engineering arms race to build the highest performing racecars on earth. Hear a...
In Ages past, in the long long ago, humanity used to believe in cannibalistic demon men that preyed on the bodies of men. Too bad things haven't changed very much. Join Richard Bigly has he leads the ovpod crew through...