Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

NVus Alien

NVus Alien artwork

Chris Carter: The Case for the Afterlife

May 26, 202554 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode of the NVUS Alien Podcast, Heather Woodward speaks with Chris Carter, author of The Case for the Afterlife, about decades of scientific research into survival of consciousness, near-death experiences, mediumship, apparitions, and psychical phenomena. After a series of personal experiences challenged his skeptical worldview, Carter began studying historical and modern research on life after death, including investigations conducted by the Society for Psychical Research and other organizations dedicated to exploring consciousness beyond the material world. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/nvus-alien--4798594/support. 🛸 Love what you heard? Keep following the weird. Get full show notes, exclusive content, and the occasional paranormal rant at NVusAlien.com. 🔮 Want the universe to spill its secrets? Book a tarot reading with Heather and pull the receipts straight from the void: Tarot Readings 📢 Tell your weird friends Seriously. This podcast grows by word-of-mouth. Share it with your favorite conspiracy theorist, ghost hunter, or lowkey witchy cousin.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1You are listening to the NVS Alien Podcast with your host, Heather Woodward, an award winning psygig, supernatural author and lover of all things true crime. On this show, we're going to deep dive into topics so don't usually see the light of day, the spooky, the weird, the macabre, the paranormal, and of course aliens. Sit back, grab a cup of tea, and let's get on with the show.

Speaker 2Hey, everybody, welcome to the Envious Alien Podcast. Today we have Chris Carter and we're going to be talking about the book The Case for the Afterlife. Hey Chris, how are you.

Speaker 3I'm fine, Heather, how are you?

Speaker 2I'm doing really good. So first tell us a little bit about who you are and how you got into this field.

Speaker 3Okay, I guess it all started when I was a student to overseas and it was in my first year over there, and it was in England, and one evening, a friend of mine who lived in the same graduate dormitory, he is trying to convince me to spend our second year living in a farmhouse which is owned by our college, which lay on farmland just oside of town. And I wasn't sure if I wanted to leave the dormitory was much closer to town and college, but he was adamant, and at one point he simply said to me the

Speaker 3place has a ghost. And I was taken aback by his words, but I said, has anybody seen anything? And he said no, but there's been a lot of strange sounds reported. So I hiked over this farmhouse and decided to see the place for myself, and it turned out to be a two story stone house built in medieval times. I stopped in to speak with the college carpenter. He had his workshop on the property, and after a brief chat, I just came straight out with it and I said, they tell me the place is haunted, and he said I don't know myself, but the carpenter before me, he

Speaker 3swore the place was haunted. So I decided to move in spend the next year living in this allegedly haunted farmhouse. To make a long story short, I did see and hear some things which I could not readily explain, which were contrary to the materialist opinions of some of the philosophers I'd studied with. But I was open minded enough to admit that perhaps these strange experiences were of just what they seemed to be, that is, the lingering, disembodied presence of someone who had lived in the house in days long past. Nothing I saw was terribly dramatic or

Speaker 3terribly convincing, but it did spark my interest. When I got back to my own country, I started reflecting on my strange experiences in the old farmhouse. So I went down to the local library and I was wondering if I could find anything, any serious research that had been done on the subject of hauntings and communication with the departed other similar topics. I was surprised by the amount of material that I found, and particularly impressive was the other research conducted by the British and American Societies for

Speaker 3Psychical Research. These societies were both founded in the eighteen eighties. The British Society was founded in eighteen eighty two, with Henry Sidgwick, a philosopher at Cambridge, as his first president. The American Society was founded two years later in eighteen eighty four, with William James, a philosopher at Harvard University, as its first president, and its membership included some of the most influential scientists, philosophers, lawyers, physicians, politicians, clergymen on

Speaker 3both sides of the Atlantic. And despite the often repeated lie that the British and American societies never found anything, the truth of the matter is that they found an awful lot and it was enough to convince almost all of the members of the reality of the afterlife. By the term in the twentieth century, another words, one hundred and twenty five years ago, and this also included several members who started off as diehard skeptics. Their stated intention,

Speaker 3they stated openly their desire was to discredit mediums and expose them as frauds. After encounters with several mediums, their in depth investigation of different mediums, they came to the exact opposite conclusion. And you also have to remember that the mediums that they studied, most of them were not professional mediums. They were women of high social standing. One of them was missus Verell. She was a professor at Cambridge University. There was another one, Missus Coombe Tenant. She was a Justice of the Peace and she was the

Speaker 3first woman appointed to represent Britain at the League of Nations, which was the forerunner of the United Nations. Of several of the other women were wives of politicians, wives of physicians, and they did their mediumship. When their mediumship was recorded in the various journals of the American British societies research, it was under pseudonyms, in other words, anonymously. They did not want their interest in mediumship revealed, did not receive any sort of payment for their services. Was all done voluntarily.

Speaker 3So to somewhat all up, there's an enormous volume of evidence for survival and to argue on the basis of this evidence that the case has been proven beyond all reasonable doubt.

Speaker 2So we were talking a little bit before the interview, and you said that your body of work is mostly about skeptics and what the difference is between what skeptists believe and what is actually out there. And you have four.

Speaker 3Books, correct, that's right, this is the fourth. Yeah.

Speaker 2I was looking at your body of work. You have an interesting take on things, and I just want to know a little bit about how you got to be. I don't know what the right word is, but you really you're very granular with your information and your very much. I went down this rabbit hole and this is what I found, and it's without a doubt and I just want to know.

Speaker 3How to without without without reasonable doubt, not without conceivable doubt. It's a huge distinction.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, But I want to know what got you to that place. I know you said that you were in this hunted place, but what in your mind made you go, this is what I'm going to study, and this is what I'm going to do.

Speaker 3That was just the spark to set the fire. It was. I was amazed by the amount of research, but I was also aware of the famous saying by the physicist Richard Feyman, you must not fool yourself, and you are the easiest person to fool. In other words, his warning was to try to avoid the confirmation bias, and that is to seek out information that confirms what we already believe or what we want to believe. And so I was aware of this, and I decided to seek out any dissenting opinions I could possibly find. And it wasn't

Speaker 3hard to find them. A little bit of searching, I found a website devoted to debunking the belief Afterlife. I was shocked by the sheer ignorance and the vehemence of the author's opinions, and equally unimpressive were the quotes that he supplied from other skeptics Susan Blackmore and Richard Wiseman and others James Randy. They were completely I couldn't believe it. I was shocked, and so I wrote to the author

Speaker 3of this website expressing my disagreements. He replied, and over the next few weeks we engaged in online debate. That was really the second spark, or the added fuel to the fire, I should say, at that two three week period I gained great insight into the skeptical way of thinking, and I realized it was based upon several misconceptions, fundamental misconceptions about things such as the relationship between the mind and the body. It was also based upon sheer ignorance of the best evidence, and in many cases it was

Speaker 3based upon little more than misrepresentation, slander, things that quite frankly, I was just shocked by the whole mess. Decided that a book was needed, and so my first book was written. It was called It was originally titled Parapsychology and the Skeptics, and it was essentially a history and a critique of the skeptical movement and in particular their publication the Skeptical Inquirer, the magazine of Reason and science they call it. It's

Speaker 3nothing of this sort. It's the magazine of prejudice and ignorance. And I've taken these people on many times, both in person and in print. There's also a book out there titled Debating Psychic Experience, and I contributed two articles to it. And in this book, essentially it's a debate between the leading so called skeptics and myself and the parapsychologist Dean Rayden. So I've got extensive experience dealing with these people. I understand them.

Speaker 2So what do you think At the core of it is why do people want so veheminently to debunk sigh your death experiences, mediumship?

Speaker 3What's the driving force? Is the motivation? You have to remember that most of these skeptics are militant atheists, and one of the fundamental pillars of the atheist worldview is the ancient doctrine of materialism. Now, this is the idea that all events ultimately have a physical cause, and it follows from this that the mind is produced by the brain and cannot exist or operate in the absence of a functioning brain. Now, any evidence to the contrary discredits

Speaker 3materialism and thus threatens the collapse of this entire worldview. And I believe this more than anything else, explains their opposition to the evidence that proves materialism false. Essentially, they don't want to be held accountable for their lives. They they hate religion, they hate the whole idea of an afterlife. They don't want to be told how to live, so they engage in this sort of scorched earth policy of denying and dismissing and ignoring evidence proves their worldview is ultimately false.

Speaker 2It's so interesting that there's always a dogma behind it, though, because as you're talking and I'm like, what if there is an afterlife, it doesn't have to be a religious afterlife, It doesn't even have to coincide with Christianity or any religion. It always seems very a myopic to me that somebody, even if they're an atheist, would think that if there is no Christian afterlife, then there is no afterlife, because isn't that kind of pigeonholing people into one way of thinking.

Speaker 3The belief in the afterlife goes back, at least to the Neanderthals who bird they're dead with the tools, utensils, jewelry and whatnot, presumably for use in the afterlife. So it long predates Christianity or any organized religion for that matter. So you're right, two ideas are logically independent, but the ideas are tied together in their minds. Again, these people, they simply do not want to open the door at all for any sort of spiritual or religious beliefs, and to do so they quite falsely invoke the name of

Speaker 3science and reason and rationality. They're nothing of the sort. There's one person. She was a Elizabeth Meyer, and she started off as skeptics. It was a professors psychology. She had an unusual experience, and she began reading the literature, the favorable literature, and then she thought she'd read the Skeptical Inquirer. She thought that would provide useful balance. It did nothing of the sort. She described it as and I quote these are her words, like reading a fundamental religious tract. She said it was full of sarcasm and self congratulation and insults people who disagreed with their opinions.

Speaker 3There's a very strong emotional undercurrent to the motivation of these skeptics. They're not all the same they're mixed and motley crew, but they tend to have that in calmon, especially the most militant ones. Others are simply ignorant. They're simply not aware of the evidence. But there's a difference between genuine skepticism and what these people are doing, because true skepticism is the practice of doubt. It's the suspension of belief, it's not the refusal of belief. So these people are not actually skeptics, they're actually deniers.

Speaker 2I like how you put it that way from just my own experience, as anybody who I have come across who has been a skeptic, just a little bit of in my background. I've been a permenal investigator for twenty plus years. I work as a psychic for a living, and I have studied sigh relentlessly because I've wanted to know what's the scientific basis for what I can do, because it doesn't make sense to me. And I found that people who are skeptical, like you said, there is

Speaker 2no reasoning. It's that it has to be this way and there's no other way. And it's usually very dystopian kind of negative connotation as to what it is to be alive. And I always wonder if this is more about you and your trauma than it actually is about being skeptical and usually I found that most of the people have had experiences in their life that they have chosen to deny, and I'm wondering if you have that same experience.

Speaker 3These people are, as I said, they're mixed and Motley crew, but the Milton Ones. It's astonishing how often the same arguments has come up again and again. One thing I've heard before more than once is the ridiculous accusation. So you just want to believe these things are true, I simply reply, and I guess you don't want to believe they're true. Perhaps you don't want to be held accountable for your life. Anyway, instead of criticizing me as a person, why don't you try criticizing my arguments? Or is that just too hard? The fact that I do or do

Speaker 3not want to believe something is irrelevant. Just because a man wants to believe his wife is faithful, it doesn't mean is unfaithful. Ultimately, these are two separate issues, but they don't see it that way.

Speaker 2Makes sense, That makes a lot of sense. So I was jumping around in your book because understanding my consciousness. And one of the things that was really interesting to me when I was reading it, and it's something that has always fascinated me, is you were talking about how most people and a lot of skeptics think, and they've had to try they've tried to proven this that our consciousness is in our brain or it's somehow in our body, and the more that they study it, the more that they have found that it's non local. And I wanted to touch upon that, and what kinds of evidence have

Speaker 2you shown or have you researched about that particular subject.

Speaker 3That's a great question that goes back to the mind, the relationship between the mind and the body. Does the brain produce the mind or is the brain the instrument of our minds? I think that the evidence indicates the second, that the brain is an instrument of the mind. I think that the evidence indicates the brain works as a two way receiver transmitter, sometimes from body to mind as in sense perception, other times from mind to body as in willed action. Now it's not even necessary to discuss

Speaker 3the paranormal evidence or offer paranormal evidence in support of this. Mainstream medical evidence supports this idea. Sir John Eccles he won the Nobel Prize and in Physiology, I believe for his discovery of how the brain works. It communicates. Neurons communicate by exchanging chemicals at the synaptic sites, the connection between two different neurons by exchanging chemicals, which he called neurotransmitters. He believed that the brain was the instrument of the mind. He came to that conclusion as did Wilder Penfield, the

Speaker 3great Canadian brain surgeon who won the Nobel Prize in Medicine for his work with epileptic patients. He also thought that that was a relationship between the brain and mind. Even though he started off as a materialist, he thought that the brain was a sort of biological computer, that the relationship between the mind and the brain was that of programmer to computer. In other words, the mind programs the brain which to do mundane routine tasks in order to free itself up to do other things. We all

Speaker 3know this, We all have experienced this. Think about learning to play a musical instrument, or learning how to drive a car, or speak another language, or play a new sport. At the beginning, it requires a lot of conscious effort, just to do the basics. But once we've programmed our brain to handle routine, mundane tasks, then it freeze ourselves up, freeze our minds up to think about other things. So we're playing a piece in the piano, we're not thinking about which keys were pressing and which pedals were pressing.

Speaker 3We're raither thinking about how we would like the music to sound, how fast do we want to play it, what mood do we want to convey. Same thing with driving a car, we've all had the experience going somewhere. We normally don't go, perhaps to somebody wherever, and we're thinking about something else, or we're engaged in conversation. We find ourselves driving to work, or driving to school, or driving to the grocery store. Why because we programmed our brain to follow these at these paths. And I said, we don't have to even bring in paranormal evidence. Mainstream

Speaker 3medical evidence I believe supports this. I discuss in my book The Case for the Afterlife a well known medical phenomenon called terminal lucidity. Now this is familiar to people who work with dying patients and hospices, the physicians and the nurses and so forth, and It refers to the phenomenon which is remarkably common that patients who are suffering from some sort of brain damage, whether it's Alzheimer's, dementia,

Speaker 3injury due to accident, or disease, during the last few days, hours, minutes of their lives, suddenly regained their lucidity. There's one case I discuss which a woman who's suffering from severe Alzheimer's that had destroyed parts of her brain. She'd been a little more than a babbling, demented person for several years, and yet one day her nurse came into the room and the woman was awake and lucid, and she wanted

Speaker 3to see her daughter. The nurse realized what was going on, called her daughter and said, your mother wants to speak with you. Intrigued, the daughter went down and found her mother perfectly lucid for the first time in about ten years, and the woman asked about relatives and current affairs and what have you, and the daughter said it was like talking to somebody who'd been asleep for ten years. Shortly after she died. In cases like this have been reported, the ancients talked about them. Hippocrates, the father of medicine, Cicero,

Speaker 3Galen and others. They wrote about these experiences, and they all took the opinion that this was evidence that during the last few moments of life, the soul or the mind was disengaging from the restrictions of material brain. So it's not even necessary to bring in a near death experience or other interesting lines of evidence that I discuss in my book. Even mainstream medical evidence suggests that the brain is the instrument of the mind, not the producer.

Speaker 2I always find that to be so fascinating, just because I always wonder in slit experiments and the shrew Dinger's cat and all that kind of goes into that which is like, as the observer, how much of our reality do we create and doesn't exist if we don't interpret it as existing, or if we don't witness it or observe it. And these lucid moments that you're talking about. My stepmom was a nurse forever like thirty years, and

Speaker 2she said that she always knew someone was going to die because there would be these moments of loosidness. And she said that people nurses especially would tell their loved ones, hey, just because they seem like they're getting better that's not actually a sign of them getting better, that's actually just under them going the opposite way. So prepare your stuff because it's time. And it's such a fascinating phenomenon to

Speaker 2me that, like you said, we disconnect. It's like our brain is letting go of our consciousness and it's like pulling apart.

Speaker 3You're right that people who work with the dying have noticed for thousands of years that if they're suffering from some sort of brain injury and they become lucid, it's a sign that the end is approaching. There was let's see here Michael Naum. He's a biologist in Germany. He surveyed the European literature and found the following case reported in nineteen twenty one. So fellow Nim Surya, his friend's brother had been confers fine to what those days was called a lunatic asylum for many years because of a

Speaker 3serious mental derangement. I'm just reading his serious quote here. He says, one day, Suria's friend received a telegram from the director of the asylum saying that his brother wont to speak to him. Now, this is Suria writing he at first himself in the third person, serious friend received a telegram from the director of assiment saying his brother want to speak with him. He immediately visited his brother and was astonished to find him in a perfectly normal mental state. On leaving again, the director of the asylum decently informed in the visitor that his brother's mental clarity

Speaker 3is an almost certain sign of his approaching death. Indeed, the patient died within a short time. Subsequently, an autopsy of the brain was performed, to which Suria's friend was allowed to attend. It revealed that the brain was entirely superadd meaning filled with pus, and that this condition must have been present for a long time. Suria asks, with what then, did this brainsick person think intelligibly again during the last days of his life. Yeah, and as I

Speaker 3mentioned before, Hippocrates, Plutarch, Cicero, Galen, and other scholars of classical times noted the symptoms of mental disorder decrease as death approaches. I'm reading the work of Michael Namir. He says all of them held a view that the soul remains basically intact when the brain is affected by physical conditions and disturbance of the mind. Therefore, they believe that during and after death, the soul was freed from material constraints, regaining its full potential.

Speaker 2It's astounding to me because it's like, where are we then? If we're non local, where are we? And it seems like we're in the spiritual context. You would say you're part of universal consciousness? But then what is universal consciousness? It's an abstract idea that we've.

Speaker 3Come up with aspects to reality, though it's been noted for thousands of years by just what anyone has thought about it. The two aspects of reality, of course, the physical in the psychical, and we have to remember that the two are related. Of course they interact with each other, and believe they interact. The intersection occurs within our physical brains. But to ask where we are, I think that's asking the wrong question because location is a physical concept, not a psychical one. I don't think it really makes a

Speaker 3lot of sense to ask where our minds are located. If there is any sort of space, it's certainly not in a physical space.

Speaker 2No, it would it be a physical space. Universal consciousness. People think of it as like a river or a matrix. It's just a river of ideas that we moved in and out.

Speaker 3I have to make them skeptical in the true sense of being skeptical of the idea of universal consciousness. I don't think that we're all part of one great mind, or we all merge into one great mind, or anything like that. It's not what I think the evidence indicates. I do think that our minds are connected, So in that sense, I believe there's a universal consciousness in the sense that we're connected, but not in the sense that we're all part of one whole. You mentioned something interesting and caught my attention. I just wrote down a brief note for myself. You briefly mentioned physics. Modern physics does

Speaker 3not imply or indicate or prove or anything like that, that we survive the deaths of our bodies. It's compatible with both. But you get philosophers such as Daniel Dennett and so forth who will argue that. Oh. Dannett wrote a book titled Consciousness Explained, and in this book he simply denies consciousness even exists, presumably because of his inability to explain it. But he thinks that dualism, the idea that our minds are separate from our brain, is contradicted by physics. He argues that any sort of physical action

Speaker 3requires an exchange of energy, that therefore a non physical mind cannot influence a physical brain. This is ridiculous, This has been it's contrary to quantum mechanics because there's something called the collapse the state vector, which I don't want to get into here, the collapse of the wave function rather, which in which conscious decisions can influence reality at the atomic and subatomic levels. So several physicists, including Henry Stapp at Berkeley University and other people Fred Kutner, they've argued that modern physics allows an escape fromism, from the supposed

Speaker 3flaw of dualism, and the dualism cannot be ruled out in the basis of physics. But it's not even the base. We don't even have to invoke quantum mechanics. So there was a philosopher, he's both a physicist and a philosopher, named C. D. Broad. He was a member of the British Society Psychical Research, and in the early nineteen twenties, I believe he argued that dualism cannot even be ruled out on the basis of classical physics, that is, the physics of Isaac Newton, and others James Clark Maxwell. He

Speaker 3argued that as a philosopher, just because all physical to physical causation may require an exchange of energy, it doesn't fall from this that physical to mental or mental to physical causation also requires an exchange of energy. Dennett's argument that dualism should be ruled out from the start on the grounds that somehow conflicts with physics. It's simply ridiculous. It's based upon nothing but ignorance and dogmatism.

Speaker 2Yeah, I would say it's because you don't understand, it doesn't mean it doesn't exist.

Speaker 3The history of science is filled with examples of scientists behaving in this manner. Reports that rocks fell from the sky were dismissed and ridiculed by the natural philosophers, which is what scientists recalled in those days for decades. How can rocks fall from the sky? They around their rocks in the sky to fall, and so these reports were ridiculed and dismissed. The idea of a continental drift it was first proposed by a geologist named Wagner back in the nineteen thirties. I think on the basis of geological evidence,

Speaker 3similarities in fossils and similarities in rocks and oil deposits in the Arctic and so far, and he argued for the reality of continental drift. His arguments were ridiculed by geologists. Continents don't move around, They're not floating on the oceans. How can they possibly move? And the idea that surgeons had washed their hands before performing surgery or assisting in childbirth was also mocked and ridiculed. There's an Austrial Austrian physician named Hungarian physician named Semmelvis. Way back in the

Speaker 3eighteen hundreds. He was presenting statistics that he had gathered that showed that in hospitals where physicians washed their hands before surgery or helped assisting in childbirth had much lower rates of death by infection. And he was trying to get the physicians of his time to wash their hands before surgery. Most of them laughed at him. They ridiculed his beliefs. They said, my hands aren't dirty. I just wiped them that rag ten minutes ago. There's no dirt on them. And they refused to wash their hands because

Speaker 3it made no sense to them. This is before the role of microbes and bacteria, the existence of microbes and bacteria was even known. Because some of these couldn't explain why couldn't explain why washing hands before surgery resulting in meaningful reduction in deaths, they rejected that it was true. But there's a distinction between knowing that something happens and being able to explain how it happens, and the fallacy

Speaker 3of combining the two has led to tragic results. Thousands of people died needlessly in hospitals before physicians began to wash their hands. It was only after the existence of microbes and bacteria and their role and disease was first noted. Then it made sense, and then they started doing it. So today meteorites, continental drifts, the importance of washing hands before eating, or what have you. School children around the world take these things for granted. Yet these things were dismissed,

Speaker 3ridiculed for decades by scientists and physicians.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's funny how one man's conspiracy is another man's scientific breakthrough. As time goes on. I want to talk a lot about something that is dear and dear to my heart, which is messages from the dead. And you go a lot into this, and then you go into characteristics of the dead and what has your research shown about that.

Speaker 3In this book, The Case with the Afterlife, I present evidence from five independent lines of evidence. Deathbed visions, the near death experience, reports of apparitions, children who claim to remember a previous life, and yes, apparent messages from the departed. These lines of evidence, all very different from each other, all pointed in this direction, so they reinforce each other. But I argue that the single most impressive and convincing

Speaker 3line of evidence would be messages that give every indication in the best cases of being received from those who have passed over. That was one of the primary research goals of the British and American Society's psychical research. They first started studying two types of mediums, physical mediums and mental mediums. Now, physical mediums are the ones that claim at least to produce physical phenomenon phenomena tables that float, musical instruments that play without anyone playing them, appearances, things

Speaker 3like such as that. After a short period of time, they exposed several physical mediums as fraudulent, and they abandoned their study of physical mediums on the grounds that there were too many fraudsters out there, and on the grounds that it was too easy to explain it away as being due to fraud or misperception, or exaggeration or mal observation, and so they concentrated their studies on as mental mediums. These are mediums who produce messages either through voice or

Speaker 3through writing on a piece of paper. They'll typically go into a trance. Sometimes they'll convey the messages verbally, seemingly from other times they'll write rapidly on the piece of paper, and in the most dramatic cases, possession mediumship. The medium's vocal cords and hands and so forth seems to be taken over by the departed and they speak directly through the medium. As I said earlier, most of the mediums studied by the British and American societies were not professional mediums.

Speaker 3They were women of high social standing. I mentioned a few of them. One was a lecture at Cambridge University, another one was a justice of the piece. And they did not want their activities publicized, and so they operated under pseudonyms. The reports are written under sudonyms. So yeah, I argue, that's single most impressive line of evidence.

Speaker 2This is something they want to talk about little bit when I do medium ship readings. I know I'm picking up on something because I can feel the shift, right, there's an energy shift that happens, and I've read a lot of Dean Raiding stuff and the Ion stuff to try to figure it out. I know I'm going somewhere with it. I know I'm not reading the person per se, but I'm not sure if I'm picking up on their consciousness somewhere. I know i'm not picking up on the person. No,

Speaker 2I'm not reading the person, but I don't know if I'm not reading their experiences outside of their body. Does that make sense?

Speaker 3Not sure what you mean.

Speaker 2When I do like a tarot reading or do a psychic reading, I'm reading off of the person. I'm reading their energy. I'm just pulling from them so I can access their experiences through that. When I'm doing medium ship readings, I'm going somewhere else and I don't know where I'm going. And that's something that's always confuse me. Am I reading their consciousness somewhere else? Or am I actually reading the person? Because even though I do mediumship readings, I'm not sure

Speaker 2about spirit communication. And even though I've done I don't know thousands of investigations and allegedly haunted locations and have had all these experiences. I'm not sure that there actually is an afterlife, or that there are that actually people come back. And I've never experienced anything that would give me the indication that there isn't afterlife. And that's probably why I read your book, because I'm still trying to find the evidence that can definitively give me that strong

Speaker 2case for it. I know there's cases for it, I've read them, but it's I guess my situation here is I don't know what I'm tapping into something. I just don't know.

Speaker 3What it is. That's why the systematic and careful research of the British and American society psychical research is so important. I want to mention a case her out describing my book in the chapter titled Evidence of Design and let's see here, Let's see here, Okay, I'm just reading from it if i'm me. On March seventh, nineteen hundred and six, missus Verel's script contained an original poem which which started with the words Tintagel and the sea that moaned in pain. When Miss Johnson, She's General Secretary of the Side of

Speaker 3Psychical Research see gathered all these different messages from the cross correspondences which her messages received from different mediums in different parts of the world, in England, the United States, and India, and said when miss Johnson read this, she was struck by this its similarity to a poem by Rodin Knowle titled Tintagel to the best of her recollection. Missus Verel, she was electure at Cambridge, had never read this poem. On March eleven, nineteen hundred and six. Missus Holland's script contained these words. Now, Miss Holland was a pseudonym for miss Woman I discussed earlier. These are the

Speaker 3word messrs came through. This is for a W. Ask him what the date May twenty six, eighteen ninety four meant to him, to me and to F W h M. Frederick Myers, a deceased person allegedly communicating. I do not think they will find it hard to recall, but if so, let them ask Nora. Now the date given in the above, which meant nothing to missus Holland, is the death of Roden Knowle. The initials A W referred to Professor A. W. Verrel and F W h M referred to of course to F. W. H. Myers, both of whom knew Knowle,

Speaker 3but not very well. Nora means missus Sidgwick, which seems appropriate, as Knowle's an intimate friend. Now here's where it really gets interesting. On March fourteenth, before any of the above facts were known to Missus Holland, she wrote in a trance state eighteen fifteen four five fourteen fourteen fifteen five twelve, not to be taken as they stand. C Revelations, Chapter thirteen,

Speaker 3verse eighteen, but only the central eight words, not the whole passage. Now this whole thing was meaningless to Missus Holland. Then she did not look up the passage, but miss Johnson, the General Secretary of the spr who's receiving these dispatches, did and found the central eight words were for it is the number of a man. Taking this to be a hint, she translated the numbers given in the script into the letters of the alphabet, with D being the fourth letter, E being the fifth, and so forth, and when finished the letter spelled rodin No, so that's only

Speaker 3what's one small part of one of the cross corresponds's case. This add message, by the way, was allegedly related or re transmitted by the late Frederick Myers. He was one of the founding fathers of the British Society's psychical research. He had died in Italy in nineteen hundred and one. That message came through in nineteen hundred and six. He was one of the prime authors, along with a few others, of the cross correspondences and which messages are received through different mediums, but they're given in a very enigmatic and

Speaker 3enigmag manner. Their meaning is not obvious. They have to be deciphered. So this one example of a puzzle which took some work to decipher, which in the common theme of the messages received through two different mediums two different parts of England, was the name Rodent Knowle, the late poet.

Speaker 2I can tell you just from experience, it never comes. It always comes in symbols. It's me having to figure out what is a symbol and what is a symbol for the other person. If I see flowers, is it actual flowers or is it for me to say, hey, you never got your flowers, So here's the love and respect that this person wants to give to you. It's never literal, it's always an experiential thing where you have to know yourself enough to know what to say and what to keep to yourself and interpret. You've done a

Speaker 2massive amount of research from that. Where do you think the information actually comes from? Do you really think it comes from the deceased person or do you think that it comes from the experiences of the living person both? Oh, that's interesting, Okay, explain.

Speaker 3The human medium is just that a medium, a method of communication similar to a cell phone or what have you. It's just not an electronic medium. It's a physical medium. I arguement my fourth book that the case with the afterlife has been proven beyond all reasonable doubt. Not beyond all conceivable doubt, but beyond all reasonable doubt. And it's confusion between the two standards of proof that allows skeptics to claim that the case has not been proven. It hasn't been proven beyond all conceivable doubt. That I grat

Speaker 3But that's a standard that is simply impossible to attain. We're dealing with factual matters. I'll give you an example what I mean by proof by proof beyond all conceivable doubt. We've all seen this before. If A is greater than B and B is greater than C, then A must be greater than C. Now it is simply inconceivable to us that C is greater than A, given that A is greater than B and B is greater than C. That's what we mean by proof beyond all conceivable doubt. But the only reason we can attain this sort of

Speaker 3mathematical certainty is because A, B, and C are purely abstract entities in a purely abstract argument. When we leave the realm of pure logic and mathematics, we enter the world of facts and evidence. We can never prove anything beyond all conceivable doubt, only beyond all reasonable doubt. Now what do I mean by that? I argue in my book that a statement is proven beyond all reasonable doubt when we have good reasons to believe it is true and no good reason to believe that it may be false.

Speaker 3And when we're dealing with factual amount, all good reasons are reasons based upon evidence, not upon speculation, not upon could be this or maybe this, maybe that, Maybe the police detective framed my client, who knows it could have happened. No, unless there's evidence to believe that the police detectives framed someone accused of murder, then there's no reason to take it seriously anymore than we should take seriously the existence of unicorns or what have you. So I argue in my book that the case of the Affli has been proven beyond all reasonable doubt, not beyond all conceivable doubt.

Speaker 3But you mentioned mediumship. Some of these cases are extremely impressive. I wanted the most impressive cases. I mentioned a case where there was a chess game played between a living and a deceased grand master, and I give this case began in the nineteen eighties when doctor Vulfgei and Eisenbeiss wanted to initiate a chess match between living and deceased grand masters. Now he contacted an amateur medium named Robert Rowlands, who've always offered his services free of charge, and he asked them to find a departed chess master who was

Speaker 3willing to play. And he came across and he found someone named Victor Korchnoi came through. He was ranked third in the world round the turn around nineteen hundred, and he agreed to play. Robert Rowlins seemed to find a deceased Hungarian chess master named Geza Maroxi who agreed to play. He was ranked third in the world in nineteen hundred, so about eighty five years previously who and he was known for his remarkably strong endgame, And so the game was played over several years with Robert Rowlands acting as in intermediary. Now Roles did not know how to play chess,

Speaker 3yet to be taught that various pieces and so forth, And at the twenty seventh move Korchnoi, the living chess master ranked third in the world at that time, he commented on the quality of his opponent's play, and this is what he wrote. He wrote, during the opening phase, Moroxy showed weakness. His play is old fashioned, but I must confess on my last moves have not been too convincing. I'm not sure I will win. He has compensated the faults of the opening by a strong end game. In the end game, the ability the player shows up, and

Speaker 3my opponent plays very well. Now, when he said that the play was old fashioned, he was referring to the opening, apparently coming from the deceased that departed the grand master Gaze and Waddox. Moroxy used a very old fashioned opening that was not taught anymore. Chess theory had made enormous strides since nineteen hundred and so Moroxy opened with a very old fashioned opening, but after that he played what seemed to be perfect chess. That the game went on to fifty two moves, in which the departed Moroxy conceded.

Speaker 3And let's see here, Bobby Fisher, he's considered one of the greatest, of not the greatest chess player of all time. He was shown the moves, a record of the moves which I included in my book on page one thirty two, and his brother in law, the physicist Russell Targ, sent Bobby Fischer these the chess moves and asked him his opinion, and Targ wrote, I sent the reported final chess score to Bobby Fisher. Bobby wrote to me saying wrote back to me saying, these are the words of Fisher. Anyone

Speaker 3can go fifty two moves with Victor Korchnoi's playing at a grand master level. And after that. Remember, a large part of my book focuses on critically examining the skeptical objections. I go through every one of them. There's no reason to believe that computer was used by Rollins to fake the moves. In those days. It's back in the nineteen eighties. Computer hardware and software were simply not advance enough to give a grand master a challenging game, and it certainly wouldn't be programmed to use an old fashioned opening, which wasn't even taught in those days, taught anymore. And not

Speaker 3only that, but anyone who knows chess can look at a chess score and tell whether the player was human or computer. Computer. Chess is detectively inhuman. It does not resemble the way human being played, and Moroxy, every indication was he played very human type moves from the other side, so it wasn't faked with a computer. There's another fellow who claims claimed that it's all fraudulent, that Robert Rowlands somehow was conspiring with a living chess grand master and

Speaker 3they worked together very closely in order to fake the scores. Now, this was put forward by a fellow named Edwin may As a physicist, and he said he basically raised the logical possibility that maybe, perhaps for all we knew, for all we know, Roland's secretly conspired with a living chess master. It's absolutely utterly ridiculous. He didn't offer any shred of evidence. He merely raised the logical possibility. In other words, he raised conceivable doubt, not reasonable doubt. Here's my final conclusion,

Speaker 3after several pages of analyzing mays speculation, I wrote the supposition that an elderly frequently ill man, that's the medium Robert Rowlands, an elderly frequently ill man with an impeccable reputation for honest, he secretly conspired with a living chess master over seven years and eight months in order to mimic the chess ability and style of a deceased grand master and secretly travel to Hungary to carry out an in depth investigation of Moroxy's life, all for no apparent

Speaker 3purpose or gain. And somehow did all of this without arousing the slightest suspicion of any of the five other persons directly involved. Can be safely rejected by all but the most dogmatic skeptics.

Speaker 2That's a lot of commitment for what That requires so much planning, and I think that's part of the skeptical brain doesn't realize that is the commitment to that for seven years is that's ridiculous. Most people don't have that kind of commitment to anything.

Speaker 3These skeptical objections are they're ridiculous. The fact that they have to resort to such far fetch ridiculous counter arguments his testimony to the desperation of their position. Basically, they follow the time on a tradition of defense attorneys, and that's throw anything and everything you possibly can think of against the wall and the desperate hope that something might just stick.

Speaker 2In your opinion, based on what you read and what you've researched, where do you think he got the information from? He was obviously channelling this person, but where was this person?

Speaker 3I argue that the evidence is exactly what it seems to be. Communication via Rolands from the departed chess master gaves a moroxy.

Speaker 2Right, and it wasn't just where his consciousness.

Speaker 3Again, I don't think conscious is necessarily anywhere. I think consciousness location is a physical term, not a second goal term. So I don't I think the question is a little inappropriate. It's like ask you how much does your mind weigh this way anything, or how big is it? It doesn't have physical dimensions. It's not a physical entity. It shouldn't be described in physical terms. But much more than remarkable chess playing skills were shown. Eisenbiss questioned Moroxy through Rolands about the life of gaysa Moroxy, and Moroxy provided detail after detail about his personal life, and these details were

Speaker 3so hard to verify that Eisenbis had to hire a professional historian to travel to Hungary research Life gaysa Moroxy, going through libraries and old chess journals and just speaking to his living children. Rolands not only would have had to conspire to living chess master, he also would have had to travel to Hungary secretly on his own expense to research life Moroxy to provide all this detailed information. And the only remaining skeptical counter explanation is that of

Speaker 3super esp the idea that the mediums these mediums produce or possess rather virtually omniscient powers of telepathy and clairvoyance, that they can read the minds of living people, and they can instantly scan documents in the world regardless of what these people are thinking of out the time, regardless of where these documents may be located, or it's absolutely ridiculous. But when this doctrine of living agent ESP or super esp as I refer to, it is put to the test,

Speaker 3which Eisenbeiss did. It's proven false. So living agent ESP is an explanation in medianship has been proven false by the data. And I'll give you an example. I mentioned this in my book. I has to do with something called the Vera Mentchik Club. The August fourth, nineteen eighty eight edition of the Swiss Chess magazine. I don't know how to say this. Shash Wash held a reader's competition asking them who was the Austrian founder of the Vera Menschik Club. Menshik was the first female world champion, and

Speaker 3the club's members were those whom she had beaten. In other words, it was a joke. So Eisenbeiss asked Moroxy through Robert Rowlands, the same question on August eighth, nineteen eighty eight. This was four days after the readers of the Swiss Chess magazine were asked that question. Yesked Moroxy the same question on August eighth, nineteen eighty eight. Moroxy confessed he was uncertain and speculated on various names. He described the club as a silly joke to which he paid no attention. On August eleventh, Moroxy considers Albert Becker

Speaker 3as a plausibility but the end rejects Becker. Note that the super esp hypothesis would predict that the medium posing as Moroxy would give the correct name, because by August fourth, the entire editing team at the Swiss Chess magazine knew the correct name. The solution was published in the same magazine in August eighteenth eight, nineteen eighty eight. Albert Becker on August twenty first, nineteen eighty eight, Moroxy's again asked for the founder's name. Now this is three days after

Speaker 3was published in the magazine. However, this is what Eisenbeiss wrote. He still does not name Becker as the founder of the club, as might be expected under the super esp hypothesis. Once the solution was published, it should be possible for the medium to access the information either clairvoyantly or telepathically from the minds of the magazine's readers. But instead of correcting his wrong answer, Moroxy, quite unprompted, comes up with a different story which evidently demanded his attention much more

Speaker 3than the silly joke. And this is what Eisenbeiss and Hassler, his a colleague, concluded. They wrote, in our example, Moroxy's Rachdale for forgetting the name of a man whom he would have considered to be merely indulging in a pointless joke, but then relating an unprompted story about a woman whose beauty had impressed him as plausible. Whereas for Roland's the medium is difficult to understand if using super esp, why he should be unable to retrieve the name requested, given his ability to convey detailed, precise information on other occasions,

Speaker 3even less why he should digress to an unprompted narrative thread. Now think about that, if super esp were actually operating, if the medium Robert Rowlands were using super esp to telepathy and clairvoyantly access all this information, he should have given the correct name of the very founder of the Vera Men Check Club, Albert Becker, who was a contemporary of Gays and Moroxy, should have been child's play because he can He gave correct answers to much more difficult questions than that, questions which were in which they again

Speaker 3they had to hire hungarian a historian to find the answer. Never made a mistake. There's a couple of times where the historian could not track down the answer to the question. It was too difficult. But in there were two occasions I believe where the correct answer made unknown, But every other answer occasion, the answer given by apparently seemingly by Moroxy through Rollins was correct. And yet when he asked asks them this simple question about who was the founder the Vera Men Check Club, which was a silly joke

Speaker 3which was made when when Moroxy was on this planet, he can't get it. He just simply cannot retrieve it. Instead he comes up with a different story. So, insofar as living agent ESP, that's what it's called, it's testable, it's been proven false, and I argue that it hasn't been abandoned. It's just been turned into the ideology of super ESP, which is ultimately untestable and offers nothing but rais is nothing but conceivable doubt, not reasonable doubt.

Speaker 2We're coming up on the hour mark. Is there anything that you wanted to conclude with?

Speaker 3I guess I'd just like to say that it's not necessary for those of us who accept the reality of the afterlife to hesitate or to take refuge in the mysteries of faith, arguing modern revelation fully supports and it supplements the words of the ancients, including scripture, now, the evidence itself is vast. It's very and it's ancient, and it fully supports the reality of the afterlife.

Speaker 2Very cool. If people want to get a hold of you, or they want to find you, or they want to get a copy of your book, where do we go.

Speaker 3The best place to start would be the website of my publisher, Llewellyn. On that website, they'll find a description of my book, they'll find endorsements from leading scholars in the field, and they'll also find an essay, a short essay that I wrote titled can We Prove the existence of an Afterlife? And they can read that and see what they think of my writing and the way I think. There's also the book is available on Amazon, on good Reads, and also in fine brick and mortar bookstores such as

Speaker 3Barnes and Noble, where I like to shop.

Speaker 2I love Barnes and Noble too. Very cool. Thank you so much for this interview. This has been a great interview with The book is called The Case for the Afterlife by Chris Carter. Thank you so much for this interview.

Speaker 3My pleasure.

Speaker 2Heather

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. David Wilcock Deep Dive Part 2: Corey Goode, Cosmic Disclosure, Secret Space Programs & the Legal Fallout

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 30 minAudio

    Beginning with a July 21, 2015 episode of Cosmic Disclosure on Gaia, David Wilcock helped introduce Corey Goode's extraordinary claims about secret space programs, extraterrestrial civilizations, and a hidden history of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. David Wilcock’s Death Part 1: Official Timeline, Corey Goode, Edgar Cayce & the Four Phases of His Career

    Nov 7, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    The reported death of UFO researcher, author, and former Cosmic Disclosure host David Wilcock on April 20, 2026, at age 53 sent shockwaves through the UFO and alternative research communities. Almost immediately,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Capturing Bigfoot Review: The Patterson-Gimlin Film, Alleged Rehearsal Footage & the Bigfoot Hoax Controversy

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Nearly sixty years after Roger Patterson and Bob Gimlin filmed what would become the most famous piece of Bigfoot footage in history, a new documentary claims to have uncovered evidence that could finally settle the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Kenneth Arnold’s 1947 UFO Sighting, UFO Flaps & the Cottingley Fairies

    Oct 12, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    In this episode of the NVUS Alien Podcast, Heather Woodward and her guests revisit Kenneth Arnold's historic sighting and explore the UFO flaps that followed. They examine possible explanations for what Arnold...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Black Dahlia Part 3: Seven Years Later, I Read the Black Dahlia Case Again

    Oct 4, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    In Part 3 of the Black Dahlia deep dive, Heather finishes the forensic analysis of her original 2019 psychic reading and follows several unexpected threads that emerged during the research. This episode digs into...

    Credit the people on this episode