Daisy Edgar-Jones and Esme Creed-Miles are bringing Jane Austen’s Sense & Sensibility to a new generation - and one creative choice has already sparked a very passionate debate. While in Australia promoting the new adaptation, Daisy and Esme sat down with The Spill’s Laura Brodnik to talk about becoming the Dashwood sisters, the friendship they first formed years before making this film, and why they felt so safe and supported by one another on set. They also address the conversation surrounding the film’s historically unconventional hair and styling choices, why Esme believes some of the criticism misses the point, and why Daisy says a new adaptation should offer audiences something distinctive rather than simply recreate what has come before. Plus, they talk falling in love with Jane Austen, sisterhood, romance, and the unexpected Love Island memories that connect them to the very first time they worked together. Find more celebrity interviews and entertainment conversations on The Spill, wherever you get your podcasts. What To Listen To Next: Listen: Everyone Knows Rodger Corser. Almost Nobody Knows The Real Him Listen: "I Didn't Know How to Deal With It": Jason Donovan on the Years That Almost Broke Him Listen: Cassandra Thorburn: "I Have My Own Platform To Say My Truth" Listen: Jennifer Robinson On Amber Heard, Brittany Higgins & The Price Women Pay For Speaking Out Listen: Everyone Thinks Ally Langdon Has It Together. She’s Here To Tell You She Doesn't Listen: "I Went to a Really Dark Place": Jessie Stephens on the Six Months Nobody Saw You can now watch our show in full length video on the Apple Podcast app - make sure your phone is up to date and we can't wait for you to see. CLICK HERE. SUBSCRIPTION GIVEAWAY: The You Beauty hosts have bundled together their all-time favourite beauty products and two Mamamia subscribers are winning the lot. Subscribe to Mamamia to be automatically entered to win. Current subscriber? You're already in the draw. T&Cs apply. Discover more Mamamia Podcasts here. Watch No Filter on YouTube. Follow us on Instagram here. Follow us on TikTok here. Feedback: podcast@mamamia.com.au Share your story, feedback, or dilemma! Send us a voice message, and one of our Podcast Producers will get back to you ASAP. Rate or review us on Apple by clicking on the three dots in the top right-hand corner, click Go To Show then scroll down to the bottom of the page, click on the stars at the bottom and write a review. CREDITS: Guest: Daisy Edgar-Jones & Esmé Creed-Miles Host and Executive Producer (No Filter): Bree Player Executive Producer (The Spill): Monisha Iswaran Video, Content and Social Producer: Jess Chan Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land on which we have recorded this podcast. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hi, it's Brie Player here, executive producer of No Filter, and today I am.
Speaker 2Joined by host of The Spill, Laura Brodnick, who is a fellow co-host with me when I appear on it sometimes. Recently, you would have heard my interview with Benson Boone that ran on The Spill here in the No Filter feed, and we told you at that time that we had a few more coming up, and this one we are so excited to give to you, which was Laura Brodnick's interview with with the girls from Sense and Sensibility. Yes, while they were in Australia promoting Sense and Sensibility, stars of the film, Daisy Edgar-Jones, who plays Eleanor, and Esme Creed-Miles,
Speaker 2who plays Marianne, came in here to the Spills studio to talk about the movie, which was obviously so excited because Australian audiences were very, there was a lot of anticipation for this new adaptation of one of Jane Austen's most famous books, So they came into the Spill studio and it was so lovely because they had this moment of talking about the moment that they first met, which they remembered in the studio. And they talked about bringing the movie to life and the characters and what it was like to be in Australia. And it was just a very girly, lovely chat about Jane Austen, love, yearning, friendship, sisterhood.
Speaker 1All the things we want to talk about.
Speaker 2And you are a big Sense and Sensibility Jane Austen fan.
Speaker 1Yes. So this was a big one for you. Yes, because again, I was very excited. I know a lot of people love the 1995 Emma Thompson adaptation, which is a perfect movie, but this was kind of a new spin on it. It's also the screenplay was written and adapted by an Australian author, Diana Reads. We're kind of claiming this movie as our own. So yes, I was excited to sort of hear the behind the scenes stories and how they brought it to life. And there was actually one kind of quite big controversy about the movie that was just starting to hit as they came into
Speaker 1the studio. So I think we were really the first people who got to ask them about it and kind of get their take on it. That's absolutely true.
Speaker 2And what's really interesting is we don't normally have As much as we'd love to. Big Hollywood stars rolling into the Mamma Mia office on a daily basis. So it was quite the operation for us to bring them up here, have them here live in the studio with you. And then of course, help them out of the building as well without them being mobbed. I was the one that took them back down to the car park, to their sprinter vans to head off to their next engagement. And I don't know if I've told you this, but in the lift the whole way down, That particular question you asked them about the controversy, they talked about the whole
Speaker 2way down and said.
Speaker 1How glad they were. Oh, they did? That they were asked about it. That makes me feel better because you just never know. As lovely as Daisy Edgar-Jones and Esme Creed-Miles are, you just never know how those things are going to go. The controversy in question was about hair, which is very important in Jane Austen land because in this new adaptation, both the characters, Eleanor and Marianne, but particularly Marianne, wear their hair down through a lot of the movie, which is very removed from how we usually see women in that time period and how we see them in Jane Austen movies where their hair is up
Speaker 1and perfectly styled in like a very kind of beautiful way. And so in this movie, it was a very conscious decision to to have the hair down free-flowing, sometimes not even like in a beautiful blowout, of course, because that's not the time period, but like tangled and messy and very... A bit like mine is right now. And how mine sometimes looks too, like very wild. And there was a lot of controversy because when people saw the trailer for the movie in the film stills, they were very upset. Why is the hair down? Will we still see the movie? Like it all kind of blew up. And so when
Speaker 1I asked them about it, Esme in particular, I mean, they both really gave strong answers, but they had seen the criticism and they were ready to talk about it. And they gave some very intense, compelling replies to why they had made those particular decisions and why they stood by it, which when our interview went out, then sort of sparked a whole big debate. Like historians were making videos, Jane Austen fans were. So it's become a big talking point. So If you've seen the movie, this kind of adds more context. And if it hasn't, it'll kind of give you, again, this behind the scenes story about how this whole thing
Speaker 1kind of blew up, how Hairgate blew up.
Speaker 2So we've got here in the feed for you for No Filter listeners, because we know you love a great quality interview. And that is what we've got here. We've got Laura's chat with the stars of Sense and Sensibility, Daisy Edgar-Jones and Esme Creed-Miles. And if you keep your eye out, we will bring you more of these from time to time when we have great guests on The Spill.
Speaker 3Thanks.
Speaker 1Daisy and Esme, thank you so much for joining us on The Spill today. And it's so exciting to have you in Australia to promote sense and sensibility. You were just saying this is both your first time here.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 4Yes.
Speaker 1How are we finding it? How's the rating so far?
Speaker 3Oh my gosh, very high.
Speaker 1Very, very high.
Speaker 3We went to Bondi Beach on, we landed and immediately went and had brunch and went for a swim and it was so magic.
Speaker 2Oh, lovely.
Speaker 1That's a very nice introduction. Bondi is like a beautiful part of Sydney. And I'm so excited to talk to you both about this movie. As May, this is the first time I've interviewed you. So I'm excited that our first chat is about this. Daisy, I would not expect you to remember this, but you're one of my most memorable celebrity interviews from the past because it was 2020, like the world had just shut down. And I think it was like maybe your first Zoom interview, definitely my first Zoom interview. And I remember you were in a share house maybe and you were like downstairs in a little room she's like I'm trying not to wake my
Speaker 1housemates oh my gosh.
Speaker 3Of course because it was a Australian time yes yes it was.
Speaker 1Very late at night for you and I just remember it was this crazy time we were locked at home but then we had this beautiful conversation about normal people and like not getting our hair cut and all these things and I always remember that as like one like a beautiful moment in that crazy time well.
Speaker 3We both have a fringe and obviously COVID COVID and fringes yeah it wasn't a.
Speaker 1Great time it wasn't a good time no for that but it's so lovely to chat to you in person now yeah so I wanted to start off by asking you both when did you both sort of fall in love with Sense and Sensibility was it as young girls was it as adults what's the sort of genesis of you coming to that story.
Speaker 5Um I I think I'm more of a Austin late bloomer because when I was a little younger I was I think I lent more towards the gothic in the books that I enjoyed and um the stories that I gravitated towards and And then I think almost like Marianne, I've kind of like grown up and learned to really appreciate, I think, the wit and the subtlety of her storytelling and how these are really artfully, you know, they're really artful character-driven plots. And I think that's why they're so
Speaker 5adaptable and such a joy for us as actors to kind of investigate. And now, having done the movie and read the book a couple of times and read some other Austen, I have developed a real... like, love an intimate relationship with the source material and I love Marianne a lot. But it was like, yeah, it was a new thing. It was a newer experience for me than maybe some other. And I think that's really cool as well because it speaks to how this film, I think,
Speaker 5can hopefully reach audiences that maybe aren't familiar with Austen or maybe bring Austen to a new generation or, you know, I think reading is maybe not as prized at the moment with technology. So it's really wonderful to be a part of something that's bringing that to young people.
Speaker 1Bringing that to people, yeah, that's beautiful. And what are your relationships like?
Speaker 3Well, I think I've always been a bit of a romantic and tended to explore that in what I read and listened to in movies that I watched. And so, yeah, my mum is a huge Austen fan and an avid reader. And when I was very young, she handed them to me and was like, this is going to be your next few books. You're going to have to read them all.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 3And I was so glad she did because they were really formative. And I think I've always been drawn to work that really explores the stakes of a human life and interpersonal dynamics. And I find the way that Austen, you know, writes about the female experience and the characters that she draws are so specific and so clear. And yeah, her witticisms. Yeah, I've always been a huge Austen fan.
Speaker 1Yeah, isn't it beautiful? No matter what time you come to it, it finds you in the moment you are. Because I remember reading Sense and Sensibility and watching movie versions as a child. But when I was watching your new version and watching it through the eyes of an adult, oh my goodness, it hits differently. And the nuances you pick up on and even how much you sort of, you feel for even Mrs. Dashwood in a way I didn't as a kid because I couldn't kind of comprehend what she was going through. So I think that's the beautiful thing about always getting a new version is you find a new part of the story. And I also very much loved your sisterly bond on screen. This is
Speaker 1the second time you've worked together, isn't it?
Speaker 5Yes.
Speaker 1Was it back in, was it 2018 you did a smaller movie together?
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2It was 2017.
Speaker 4Oh, okay.
Speaker 1And it came out in 2018. What was your first impressions of each other? Can you remember the moment you first met on that movie?
Speaker 4I do.
Speaker 3That job felt really significant for me. It was my first ever feature film and it was so exciting. And we were shooting in Doncaster and this, and it was very sort of low budget indie movie making. So we were all staying in the same hotel. And I really remember- meeting Esme and we had like, well, we bonded a lot watching Love Island at the time because that was all the rage and we sort of spent a lot of our summer watching that together.
Speaker 1Love Island, beautiful.
Speaker 3Yeah, but I really remember, I have like such an image of seeing you, like we, because we, I feel like we had like a bonding day when we went and played tennis or something like that.
Speaker 4Do you remember that?
Speaker 2Do you know what?
Speaker 4I was thinking about that this morning.
Speaker 5That like image of mine.
Speaker 4I was going to say.
Speaker 3And we were sat by the tennis court.
Speaker 5You were writing poems.
Speaker 1I was writing poems. Oh, Daisy, that's so beautiful.
Speaker 4Sorry, no, she was writing poems and they were really good. I'm sure they were.
Speaker 3And I remember Andy turned to me and she was like, that's really beautiful. And I was like, Oh, like, thank you.
Speaker 1That's so funny.
Speaker 3That is my memory too.
Speaker 4How funny is that?
Speaker 1How funny is that?
Speaker 3But yeah, I definitely felt like there was magic in the air on that job. And like, sometimes I feel like I have little premonitions and I definitely had one on that one with Esme. And so it was really magic meeting again, like however many years later and sort of having an image of her 17 year old face and seeing her all grown up. Yeah. So special.
Speaker 1I love that. It's like you were destined to play the Dashwood sisters in the future at some point.
Speaker 5Can you imagine coming up telling us then that that was going to happen?
Speaker 4Crazy.
Speaker 1Crazy.
Speaker 4Crazy.
Speaker 1I love that. And I understand that you're working a lot on different locations and filming in those beautiful, the sets and the scenery, everything about that. Was there a moment where you sort of went from, I guess, like you were already colleagues, you were friends, were there moments on those long days of filming where you really felt like sisters? Because that's a particular bond, I think. I've got two sisters and a brother, but he doesn't fit into the story very much of like how you can sort of like be very honest with them then you can have a laugh you have in jokes that people don't understand did you feel that sort of bond making this movie.
Speaker 5I did definitely yeah I really did I have a sister and I do feel like Daisy's another sister like one of my sisters like it was just I think yeah you know it's such a rewarding thing what we do I mean it really is and it's also vulnerable and um having someone there who can hold space for all of that emotion and like it's really magical you know and um that was I think a really yeah I felt.
Speaker 3Yeah I think it's like a feeling of safety I've always felt so safe with Esme and I felt that on the set it's like a wordless knowledge that that person is there to support you and be there for you and that Because it can be really vulnerable and hard, you know, and the pressure of it is a lot. And so days where even if it wasn't with words that we would just have, you know, a sense of knowing that we were safe with one another is such a special thing.
Speaker 1Oh, I love that. And that really shone through just like those scenes in the cottage. It's what so lived in. Like I could tell that the characters like are sharing clothes and there's like a pile of ribbons and the way like the way sisters touch each other as they go past and all those beautiful moments. It really felt like you were living in that family. I also want to ask you a little bit about the creation of the characters, particularly you as maybe, because when I was reading through the production notes, I saw director Georgia Oakley said that when she saw your audition and like that process of casting you, that it was an interpretation of Marianne, like she'd never seen before. And she said, it feels
Speaker 1like you were born 200 years ago. So I guess the first thing is, can you confirm or deny if you were born 200 years ago? And how did you, did you, and what was your sort of idea of creating this character when you went into the role?
Speaker 5I'm not really cerebral like that as an actor. I try to work with instinct. You have an instinct or an impulse with something and then you just kind of have to trust it and follow it through. And my instinct with Marianne was that she was a little camp and a little. She was fun and outgoing and there was some parts
Speaker 5of her that were like kind of transformative for me. And then there was some parts of her that were quite close to home. And, um, I, I, I, I didn't try and get to, I really loved the book.
Speaker 1I read it twice.
Speaker 5I read it once in before casting and then I would come back to it at times during the shoot. But I also wasn't like, obsessed with it in the way you know I tried to like really lean in on on Diana's script and um and and Georgia as a director you know just like and then also the thing really to remember with act with that sorry I'm rambling but it's like when you're in a scene with someone like Daisy and you and who's such a brilliant actress and you you're both acting together and you can't
Speaker 5really predict like how a character is going to come out. Like my choices are informed by her choices. Like she'll do something and then that will create a safety to feel like, oh, I can try this thing out. And you don't really know, you know, it wasn't like, oh, I'm going to do this version of Marianne. I'm going to do a modern Marianne. It was just like an instinct. And I think we created that together, like all of us, I would say.
Speaker 1Oh, I love that. And speaking of that sort of modern twist on it, I know that you from the production notes, you're both very involved in sort of how your characters would look in the style. And so I wanted to ask you about the hair down sort of conversation that's around because I saw Nadia Stacey put up who did the hair and makeup and put up an explanation of how that she wanted it to have a bit of a modern lived in feel. and not sort of show that these characters always spent all their time doing their hair. And audiences have kind of had a lot of conversation about that. I saw you post about it this morning on your Instagram story of like hair down,
Speaker 1that's what we're doing. I loved it because I feel like it just makes the movie look so unique. Like I think the point of remaking a story is to keep the heart of the story, but have each story look its own sort of way. Was that something you're involved in? Like how the characters were going to look?
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 5So I've got a few things to say about this. Yes. First and foremost, historically, if we want to talk history. So women and girls, young girls did have their hair down before they came of age. That was very normal. Marianne is stuck in this kind of transition period before coming of age. And I think there was this idea, this very intentional idea idea to have her and Margaret feel at times like they were almost closer in age than, like they have a kind of synergy. There's a youthfulness
Speaker 5to Marianne. There's an energy that she's not really letting go of her youth yet. She's not kind of growing up, so to speak. She's very, and Eleanor on the other side of that coin is more responsible and is kind of like taking the burdens of the family on her own shoulders. So I also think there's that I saw some Instagram a tik-tok girl doing some video and she's comparing portraiture of the era to the film and I think what the problem with that is that we don't actually know What the interior lives of these women look
Speaker 5like because we don't have depictions of them. Of course, there was social etiquette and beauty standards and there were beauty codes that women were expected to adhere to but just as there are rebellious women today there would have been rebellious women then and I think in the comfort of your own home amongst people that you have an incredibly intimate interior experience with you know, there may have been rules being broken. And I think that, you know,
Speaker 5having the freedom to express character through different choices like that is really important. And I think it's what's so beautiful about how we interpret history in film. And this idea that we would need to make everyone look like a painting, I think is really distancing because those, I think it's an error of film actually in general that we are obsessed with making things look perfect. especially in period dramas. And life is not perfect. And if we're always looking at women and they've got the exact perfect curls, you know, that was a choice for some characters who
Speaker 5were more kind of immaculate.
Speaker 4And then, of course, when the girls are at balls and at dinners, they do conform and they do what's appropriate because it's not like, you know, no one's there with a smoky eye.
Speaker 1Or a laminated brow.
Speaker 4Or a laminated brow, but like, sorry, that was really too long.
Speaker 1No, that was important. I wanted to get that.
Speaker 5Out because it's become a talking point and I think it's distracting and I think it's silly and I think it's reductive of the actual craftsmanship that went into this film.
Speaker 3And the care and thought. The care and thought that went into the creation. And also I think that's the beauty of adaptation. It's an artistic interpretation of this material, you know, and it's, it's, it's, I hear this conversation about remakes, but actually it's a readaptation of a shared source material. And so it should be distinctive and different. And I think that George's vision was one that wanted to make Austen's world feel intimate and raw and kind of earthy. And I feel like the Dashwoods, what I
Speaker 3love about them, they're quite bohemian. They lose their fortune at the beginning of the film. And so they are a group of women who are kind of looking out for each other and occupying a space that would have traditionally been the man's space. You know, Eleanor is out there in the earth digging and growing vegetables. And these women, you know, even on our costume, we have our dresses recut to be for a more modern style, the sense that these women are having to be economical with their clothes. And yeah, I think George's vision was so earthy and
Speaker 3exciting to me because I don't think I've ever seen the Dasha's in this way and I've never seen an Austin in this way. And that's kind of the joy. That's why we remake Shakespeare. We, you know, because there's so much to dig and interpret and find and explore. And it's the same with Austin. She's, she, she's a prolific and brilliant writer. And if we don't continue to readapt and re and rediscover different sides to her, then, you know, then she'll become obsolete and only available to those who study her in school or, you know, who, who happened to be gifted her novels. But I think, yeah,
Speaker 3film can open up a whole new generation to her work. And I'm so excited and proud to be a part of that.
Speaker 1Oh, yes. And you've both explained that so beautifully. And as I said, I loved, as a diehard Austen fan who's read every book, seen every adaptation, I loved being able to live in this world you created and have the story of sisterhood be just as strong as the story of romance. So unfortunately, we're out of time. I could talk to you about this for hours. Thank you so much for coming in.
ABBA is one of the most successful bands of all time, but according to founding member Björn Ulvaeus, their story could have been very different without Australia. In an exclusive interview with The Spill’s Bree Player,...
When Mia Freedman turned 50, she realised she’d accidentally become grout: the stuff between the tiles that nobody notices, holding everyone else together… while quietly falling apart. Grout is a living audio memoir...
Want to listen before everyone else? Mamamia subscribers get exclusive early access to No Filter from 6am every Saturday, a full two days before regular listeners. Click here to subscribe now. Kath Koschel was a girl...
Want to listen before everyone else? Mamamia subscribers get exclusive early access to No Filter from 6am every Saturday, a full two days before regular listeners. Click here to subscribe now. Waleed Aly spent more than...
Want to listen before everyone else? Mamamia subscribers get exclusive early access to No Filter from 6am every Saturday, a full two days before regular listeners. Click here to subscribe now. In 2005, Nic Russell’s...