Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

.NET Rocks!

.NET Rocks! artwork

The Future We Were Promised Geek Out

Nov 5, 20261 hr 13 minAudio

Whatever happened to the future we were promised? Time for a Geek Out! To celebrate the end of the opening history bits, Richard pulls together all the most popular topics of "things we were supposed to get in the future." From flying and self-driving cars to fusion power, personal jetpacks, Star Trek replicators, space tourism, and more! While some things are coming true, in a form different from what was expected, other things continue to be very difficult - and there is no sign of when that future will come. The future is here, just not exactly the one we thought it would be!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1How'd you like to listen to. NET Rocks with no ads? Easy. Become a patron. For just $ 5 a month, you get access to a private RSS feed where all the shows have no ads. $ 20 a month will get you that and a special. NET Rocks patron mug. Sign up now at patreon.dotnetrocks.com. Hey, and welcome back to. NET Rocks. I'm

Speaker 1Carl Franklin.

Speaker 2And I'm Richard Campbell.

Speaker 1And it's just you and me today, Richard.

Speaker 2Well, it's show 2027. Right.

Speaker 1So we're going to start with what happened in the year 2027. Wait a minute.

Speaker 2Okay, you ready?

Speaker 1Hang on.

Speaker 2I don't know.

Speaker 1Hasn't happened yet.

Speaker 2Hasn't happened yet.

Speaker 1But it turns out that we wanted to, we had this idea of sort of thinking about things that we thought would happen by now that haven't happened and sort of our wishes for the future and maybe even a little bit of a prediction.

Speaker 2It's also, it's very nostalgic engine too, right? Like that wish of, you know, the future we were promised happened over and over again.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2But I got to tell you, I don't know how much the history bit annoyed people or they liked it or any of those sorts of things, but, But it affected me writing them.

Speaker 1Yeah, well, and me relearning everything as well.

Speaker 2So part of this was just coming out of all of these things. And seeing the evolution of SpaceX or the evolution of driverless cars, the evolution of fusion power. Do you know how long we've been talking about fusion power on this show?

Speaker 1I know. It's crazy.

Speaker 2It's been a long time.

Speaker 1Yeah, how about the evolution of. NET? I mean, our whole show tracks that.

Speaker 2Our whole reason-de-attra.

Speaker 1Yeah, it tracks that. And we always said that this wasn't a show about. NET all the time. It was a show for. NET developers. many of which we personally know. And so we kind of know what the interests are outside of. NET.

Speaker 4Sure.

Speaker 2And on all the feedback we get. Yeah.

Speaker 1And simply take JavaScript for an example. That's not. NET.

Speaker 4Sure.

Speaker 1But we talk about it extensively because it's part of the ecosystem of development.

Speaker 2For sure.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2Well, how do we start this without doing the history bit? Is the first thing a comment?

Speaker 1Let's start with Better Know Framework.

Speaker 2That's a good idea.

Speaker 1All right. All right, man.

Speaker 2What do you got?

Speaker 1So, I went looking for trending repos that weren't. NET, and I found SQL Fluff.

Speaker 2What is SQL Fluff? That's a hilarious name.

Speaker 1Yeah. The SQL Linter for humans.

Speaker 2Ah, interesting.

Speaker 1SQL SQL Fluff. SQL Fluff is a dialect, flexible, and configurable SQL linter designed with ELT applications in mind. And ELT stands for extract, load, transform.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 1SQL Fluff also works with Jinja templating and DBT. SQL Fluff will auto-fix most linting errors, allowing you to focus your time on what matters. And I got this in the, you know, when I search for languages. It was Python that I searched for that. Oh, interesting. This is trending really heavily in Python right now.

Speaker 2Yeah. That's cool.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1Okay.

Speaker 2Good one.

Speaker 4Okay.

Speaker 2Fine.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2So sequel fluff. Yeah.

Speaker 1Sequel fluff. Apparently it's popular right now. So check it out. All right, Richard, who's talking to us today?

Speaker 2Grabbed a comment off a show 2019. That's the one we did with Jeffrey Sachs about numerics.net, which I really enjoyed. That was, you know, It's nice talking to a serious math guy and just real work that we do with tech all the time. And this comment comes from Alex Morrison. It's not really to do with numerics.net whatsoever, but he says, one of these days, whenever the opportunity happens to present itself, I think that's today, I think it would be kind of interesting if you two would spend a little time talking about the show logo, more specifically the microphones that

Speaker 2each of them seem to be using in the photo. I think that might be worth discussing. So I think you, because there's two microphones that are in the top, the banner shot on the. NET Rock site.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2The one on the right is the original logo microphone. What's the story on that one? Because that was there before I was there. Yeah.

Speaker 1I mean, I found that, or I purchased it actually from, you know, an online place that sold art.

Speaker 2Oh, yeah.

Speaker 1And photographs. And this was a transparent photograph of a mic that said on air.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 1And I purchased a license for it. And, you know, I've always just been fascinated with radio and it was a very radio thing. Sure.

Speaker 2That microphone is an RCA 77, which is one of the classic radio mics. And they actually had those little things on top of it. You'll usually see them with like the call letters of the radio station.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2I don't know if they're on the air. It looks like it's faked in there, but it's that concept. That was really a thing for those microphones back in the day.

Speaker 1I think of albums like Donald Fagan's The Night Fly, which is all about fantasies that they had in the 50s and 60s about the future.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 1And The Shot is about a radio guy, like a DJ, on the air at the foot of Mount Belzoni, jazz and conversation.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1I got plenty of Java and Chesterfield Kings, but I feel like crying. I wish I had a heart of ice. That kind of stuff. That's great.

Speaker 2Okay, so the other thing about that banner picture, I mean, the on the air mic, the RCA mic is clearly edited. And I used to think that that picture was a composite and you showed me the original because we did that photo together at the studio years ago. And I was holding that other mic. And that other mic, that's a Shure Unidyne, which is another classic microphone. But I don't think it was ever working. I think it was just a prop. It was just a prop. I borrowed it from my friend, Ben. And he's a local musician

Speaker 2and he let me borrow it for the shot. And we had it shot at a local photographer's who was literally in an office space right below the studio at the time.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2Serenol.

Speaker 1And what a great photographer he is.

Speaker 2And so, it's a powerful picture that, you know, how often do you get both of us looking pretty good? Yeah, that's right.

Speaker 1We look old now.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2We were younger then. That picture's a while ago.

Speaker 1Well, two things about that picture. First of all, the guitar I was holding got stolen.

Speaker 4Ah.

Speaker 1Yeah. It was when I had moved into the guard theater and I had left it there and somebody took it. That sucks. And I was pretty stupid about leaving it there because they were.

Speaker 2You were used to your own studio where you could leave your stuff anywhere, right?

Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. But there were people who had codes and keys and stuff and people coming in and out all the time. So- And also the microphone got left at Cyrano's place and then he disappeared. He went to the hospital for a long time and shut up his business and moved and stuff. And he told me it was in storage and I haven't been able to get it. Since I probably could, if I, if I pushed it and I told Ben about it, he's like, nah, it's all right. It wasn't even working anyway.

Speaker 2So no, it was a, it's a, it's a prop bike, but it'd be nice to have it there. Art Deco. They're gorgeous.

Speaker 1Beautiful. And you also would see like early talkies of like Frank Sinatra singing into one of those microphones.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1In a radio station or in a recording studio or something.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 1Well, should we talk about the mics we're using now?

Speaker 2Oh, yeah. Because we're both using the same microphone. We're both using the Heil PR40s. And that's a funny story, too.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2So when I got hooked into Windows Weekly, Mary Jo Foley had moved on and was doing other things. And Paul and I are old friends. And he asked me, of course, you and I had done a few Windows Weeklys over the years. We were the Bourbon Brothers, right, when we did that?

Speaker 1That's right. I think we got Leo in trouble one night with some scotch.

Speaker 2We got Leo in a little trouble. They still talk about that. Because we're good guests. If we're coming in, we're going to bring a gift. So of course we brought whiskey. I didn't expect them to open it.

Speaker 1And I gave him a theme song too, didn't I? Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2That's right. You did.

Speaker 1Does he still use it? I don't know.

Speaker 2Probably not for Windows Weekly, but there's a few of them floating around.

Speaker 5Anyway.

Speaker 2Anyway, yeah. That was a funny bit. So when Paul asked me to sit on a few shows and we had some fun with that, And the first time, I think I was still using my AT4040.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2The first time I sat down to shoot with them as a co-host. And Leo, who really has a sharp ear, like he knows which mic is which and what's going on. But, you know, goodness, that guy's made more shows than we have, which is saying something.

Speaker 1That is true.

Speaker 2We were in a pretty rare league. He's in a rare league. And he's like, I don't like that mic. I'm like, what do you want to do about it? It's like, I'm sending you a Heil.

Speaker 1I'm like, okay.

Speaker 2I didn't know he was actually going to do it, but he sent me the Heil. It showed up. So I got the spider for it. I rigged it up. I plugged it in. And the very first time you and I recorded together. You're like, what's that microphone?

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1It's like, that sounds so good.

Speaker 2And it was so, it was that, it was like the first thing you said to me, it's like, you didn't say hi. You said, what's that microphone? That's the Heil PR40. It's like, I'm ordering one. I'm like, okay.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1And I've been using it ever since.

Speaker 2And then, and the next thing after that was after we both had one, you're like, Hey, uh, we got to reshoot the ads.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2Cause they, they need to be in the same voice. Right. So yeah. uh it's hard to argue with these hiles they're they're pricey and they're worth it they're so good that's yeah they're so so we learned a.

Speaker 1Long time ago not to chintz out on microphones the microphones that we used for doing dot net rocks live yeah the first ones And I don't even remember what they were, but they cost like $ 300 a piece.

Speaker 2We went through three versions of microphones on the road until you finally landed on those D-Finds, on the DPAs.

Speaker 1Yeah, the DPAs are twice the money. And hey, testament to Sweetwater, because my guy- They took them back every time? My guy was like, you know what? These things, the first time, they all broke, right? The first ones.

Speaker 2Have you priced them today, the DPAs? No. They're like $ 1, 200 now.

Speaker 1They're twice as what we paid for them? Oh, my goodness.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2I think we could probably sell them used for a profit.

Speaker 1Now you're talking like a Ferengi.

Speaker 2So, Alex, there's your story about microphones. And I'm sorry, we are truly microphone geeks. We love them. We work with them. We put a lot of hours into them. It's important to us. but there's your story. Thank you so much for your comment. And a copy of music to go by is on its way to you. And if you'd like a copy of music to go by, write a comment on the website at.net rocks.com or on the Facebook. So we publish every show there. And if you comment there and read it on the show, we'll send you a copy of music to go.

Speaker 1And if you don't want to do that and you just want to get music to go by, go to music to code by.net and you can download the collection in flack MP3 and wave formats. And, uh, What else did I want to say? Oh, I got a little geeky story before we start.

Speaker 2Go.

Speaker 1My bass player is taking his first vacation since he retired, and he's going to visit his wife, who's visiting her mother, who's elderly, in South Korea.

Speaker 2Oh, wow.

Speaker 1And it's the first time he's been to Korea, but he's not at band practice.

Speaker 4Right. Right.

Speaker 1So for two weeks. And we wanted to learn this new song. And it's not a new song, but it's new to us. Right. We don't learn new songs. So I found a MIDI file of it. And I got the bass part soloed. And I used a really good bass instrument, virtual instrument, instead of the crappy MIDI things that are built into Windows. And I put a click track on it. And we played to it last night several times. And I'm just thinking to myself, you know,

Speaker 1it's just like no big deal to do that kind of stuff today. It was just like, foop, foop, foop, and done. And we have a bass player for rehearsal. Crazy, man. It's crazy.

Speaker 2It's a different world, without a doubt.

Speaker 1Just so cool.

Speaker 2And that is not a future we were promised. It's just a future we've discovered.

Speaker 1Well, yeah. It was a future that was amazing 20, 30 years ago. And now it's just like, oh, yeah, you did that. It's trivial. It's trivial.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's easy to do.

Speaker 1I got to say, the MIDI file did cost me $ 8, though. So, there is... Commerce is alive and well on the internet.

Speaker 2There you go. There's still some money to be made.

Speaker 4All right.

Speaker 2So I put out on the social medias this idea of the future we were promised and like what were the things you think about when you think about the future you expected. And I more or less ordered it in the list that people asked the most. And let me, I'll call out some of the folks. So what do you think was the number one?

Speaker 1Well, I think from a baby boomers perspective, most of them are dying without ever having a jet pack.

Speaker 2Yeah. Jet packs. A good one. It's on the list, but number one, that was a fifties. Yeah. By a mile was flying.

Speaker 1Car, flying cars. That's how we met my friend.

Speaker 2That's how we met was me talking about the molar car, which of course is obviously disappeared. Right?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2So a call out to Devin Goble and little John and Corey Robinson and Wad fan all said flying cars. And to be clear, You don't really want a flying car. What you want is no traffic. You want no waits. Because we've built flying cars that exist today. Terra Fugia is a roadable airplane. It didn't quite finish its qualifications as a road car. But what it was was a two-seater car that you could drive on the road whose wings folded up. And then you could take it to

Speaker 2the airport, unfold, and fly away. It got light sport certification from the FAA in 2011. And so it was a real product. Now, a Chinese company called Geely bought it up, and it's basically disappeared at that point. But it never took off because it's got problems, right? There's another version, a version called the PAL-V, which, again, also– exists. And this is more of a rotable gyrocopter, so unpowered

Speaker 2rotary aircraft. It's certified, but it got certification both by the FAA and by the National Transport. So it's truly a car and a flying machine. But same thing, you go to the airport, you accelerate down the runway, your gyrocopter spins up and off you go.

Speaker 1The things that I've seen that look promising anyway, and who knows if they are, obviously not because we don't have one yet, Are things based on drone technology? Yeah.

Speaker 2Let's get there because I want to wrap up this, the original flying car idea before we get into what we call eVTOL. All right, cool. Because the reality is nobody actually wants to fly. It's freaking hard.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2Right? It is, right? You need to have two licenses, a driver's license and a pilot's license. Like, none of that's easy. And all flying machines are noisy.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2If you are a helicopter pilot flying in urban areas, you're required to stick over, stay over– noise zones, so down rivers and industrial areas and things like that, people don't like them around.

Speaker 1And people get very suspicious when there's helicopters in.

Speaker 2The air that are hovering around. Black helicopters.

Speaker 1Yeah, this just happened recently. The Amtrak inspections, track inspections were going on over the last month and big helicopters were hovering over you know, railroad tracks and they go through cities and stuff. So people naturally get nervous. Hey, what is that?

Speaker 2What is that?

Speaker 1And the mayor actually of new London actually had to put a Facebook post. I was like, look, this is nothing crazy. This is just doing track inspection. We expected this. It's the Amtrak inspectors, you know, go back to your homes.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2Take a breath. You're going to be fine.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2I would also argue that GPS, Google Maps, especially with traffic data, has changed driving fundamentally. I know where I'm going. I plug it in to really know is the road closed or what's the rest route, that kind of thing. Exactly. We've done a lot of optimization that way. And then you have the Ubers and the Lyfts of the world. If you really don't want to pay attention, let somebody else drive for you. We can talk about the problems of gig economy and stuff. But, you know, that product uses too.

Speaker 1Speaking of trains, they also have trains where you can drive your car into a train car.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1And park it there and then go take the train. And when you get out, you got your car.

Speaker 2You got your car. That's the channel experience.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2So let's talk about eVTOLs, which in general, these are not personally owned vehicles. They are air taxis. And so, yeah, taking drone technology, you know, because the personal version is going to be $ 100, 000 plus.

Speaker 1Sure.

Speaker 2You know, maybe there's some market for it, but you're likely to need some kind of pilot's license. The most advanced of these or the most real of these is in China. It's called the Ehang EH216. So, it's a two-seat autonomous flying taxi. And they've made about 300 of them over the past few years. But they're not … commercial product per se like they're not flying between key destinations you can get a ride on one but it's mostly like novelty flights so at at the harbin ice

Speaker 2and snow world show you can do a 10 minute ride in one of these taxis for 500 rimby which is about 70 or so But, you know, it's just a 10-minute fly around and back again. Like actually going point to point, even though there's several hundred of them, they really have not got any schedule of flying.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2In the U.S., there are two products that are in fairly far advanced certification with the FAA. One by Joby Aviation and one by Archer Aviation. Both of them are four-pasture vehicles plus a pilot, so not autonomous.

Speaker 5Right.

Speaker 2And they use variations on the tilt rotor ducted fan approaches. So they're electric vehicles. fan based. So they're quieter than helicopters cause they have multiple fans, but they're still pretty noisy and they do need a pilot. When the closest thing to an autonomous fly taxi in the U S is a thing called whisk, which is backed by Boeing. I don't know if that's an advantage or a disadvantage. It's in much earlier stages, but to carry that droney concept of multi road or fixed wing and so forth. Right. Many of the other, uh, products out there, the Lillian's

Speaker 2and so forth. It got funding, spent too long building, ran out of money. There's lots of failed projects like that. But for the most part, they're all too noisy, flight restrictions and so forth. It's going to be very tough to make these into products. But the air taxi model point to point is pretty close. We might get that future.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1And I imagine... Because of the popularity of those things, the prices will be less than, you know, chartering a private jet or that kind of thing.

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, very much so. I mean, say an air taxi sort of sets the price for it, right? Right. It should be cheaper than a point-to-point helicopter.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2You know, so the $ 100 range, like that's very feasible.

Speaker 1Sure.

Speaker 2To make that happen. If you can get rid of the pilot and literally be autonomous, you know, that's a big cost factor. Pilots get well paid as well as should be. They're qualified specialists. All right. Next topic. Self-driving cars.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Our friend Dominic Beyer mentioned this one, but lots of people think about self-driving cars. There is a rating system for self-driving. Level zero is considered no automation, although that might still be blind spot alerts, collision and lane departure warnings, that kind of thing. Your level ones are your adaptive cruise control, you know, distance maintaining cruise control.

Speaker 1You and I both have that.

Speaker 2Keeping you in a lane, that kind of thing. Level two is what they call partial automation. So now you're steering, accelerating, braking, but the driver must be available at any time to take control.

Speaker 1Like Teslas.

Speaker 2That's the official level of a Tesla is a level two. Although entirely too many people use it in level three, which would be conditional automation where you don't really need to pay attention until the system asks for it. But let's be clear, by the time a Tesla is beeping at you, you're in danger. You might die. And people have. Level four, high automation, no driver, no supervision, but limited domains.

Speaker 1That's Waymo.

Speaker 2Right. And then level five, the thing nobody's ever achieved, drive anywhere, anytime, any weather, on any road with no restrictions. And we've never pulled that off.

Speaker 1So, first of all, a couple of stories here. Yeah. My sound guy slash roadie has a Tesla and he brags about outsmarting the thing that lets you know that you're in tries to keep it safe. Yeah, that lets you know you're not paying attention.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1So, apparently, if you avert your eyes down, you know, to your phone, let's say.

Speaker 2Yeah, the camera sees that.

Speaker 1Camera sees it and says, ah, stop, you got to look ahead. So, what he does is he wears sunglasses.

Speaker 2So, he can't see his eyes.

Speaker 1I swear to God, he's telling this story and I'm like, and you're proud of that? Yeah.

Speaker 2Endangering your life. I know folks who've hung a picture in front of that camera of their face.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2It doesn't trigger it.

Speaker 1No.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1Stupid yeah it's like remind me never to drive with you.

Speaker 2Yeah no kidding but if if you're in the right city and that city list right now is what phoenix san fran la austin atlanta miami dallas houston san antonio orlando you can get a waymo right no driver fully automated uh there is a ability for a moat operator to take control of the vehicle although they don't really drive it so much as they tell the vehicle what to do it doesn't sound driving You'll notice something in common with all those cities. Weather's very mild there because there are challenges with weather, of course. Although all those

Speaker 2places have rain, and these machines drive more carefully in the rain, but they do drive. So they are level four, just regional. And I've seen some accidents happen with Waymos. Yeah, and stuff does go wrong, but it's rare enough that it makes the news. They are supposedly going to expand into Denver, and that means actually managing snow. So we'll see how that actually goes.

Speaker 1Can I ask you, this might be in your notes already, but I understand that China has a very developed automatic taxi and car system.

Speaker 2They're going down that path as well, very much based on Waymo. But it's the same thing. These systems, because they use LIDAR, need very detailed maps of their operating areas.

Speaker 5Right.

Speaker 2And so it just takes time to build up the map set. Yeah. And so that's been the only thing that's worked so far. So limited areas, but fairly effective for most cases, especially from a taxi role. This is good enough. Okay. And so, understand, this is just a long tail problem. There's so many edge cases. It's going to be very tough for us to ever get to level five. Goodness knows when that's going to happen.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2That being said, I would be remiss to not mention Aurora. So, this is on the semi-trailer truck side, the heavy truck side.

Speaker 1All right.

Speaker 2And Aurora builds the electronics for several cars. Truck manufacturers, and they're actually operating point-to-point routes. So between logistic hubs doing automated highway driving without a person on board.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2So between Dallas and Houston, between Fort Worth and El Paso, like these kinds of deserty areas with good weather conditions. And they just go from one logistics hub at the edge of the city to another logistics hub at the edge of the city.

Speaker 1You know, I don't remember– what show number it was or what year it was but the first time we talked about this we talked about uber and self-driving cars in the same show and it was at a live what maybe a code mash or something like that.

Speaker 2Possibly or it might have been that conference.

Speaker 1Yeah it might have been that conference yeah i think it was actually that conference yeah but uh at the time you know we speculated that That tractor-trailer trucks would be the first, you know, casualty.

Speaker 2Because they have the most economic advantage, right?

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2Because a tractor-trailer driver, which, by the way, is one of the best-paying jobs for someone with only a high school education and employs a huge number of people in the U.S. So, it's a big deal if this gets disrupted and it's likely to be. By law, they only drive eight hours a day.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2So, that pretty much means that truck is parked. 16 hours a day and if you could automate that without a driver so that it was fully utilized literally three times the utilization like that drives down the cost of goods like you think about a refrigerated truck moving produce yeah the idea that it can get that produce fresher to the to the locations that it needs to be it's a big deal it adds up it's a huge deal yeah it will change economies while also creating a huge disruption employment and it's one of those things where the If you can make it work at that 24-hour cadence,

Speaker 2the non-automated trucks will just not be able to make money. The change will happen very rapidly.

Speaker 1The other thing that you could foresee happening before that is you have the driver driving eight hours and then sleeping eight hours and then you know, being in the car for awake for the 16 hour for the other eight hours.

Speaker 2Well, and arguably if you can only drive eight hours a day, just drive in the city where the machine can't handle it. All the long range stuff done by automation. Right. So you get better utilization.

Speaker 1So you get the best.

Speaker 2Like you're exactly right. A hybrid. A hybrid.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2Is a great answer.

Speaker 1Okay.

Speaker 2Let's keep moving. We've got lots of topics to cover next on the list. Then Corey Robertson called this one specifically fusion power. Oh, fusion.

Speaker 1Fusion power.

Speaker 2Been 20 years away for the past 70 years. And the last time we did a Geek Out of Fusion was 2017. Yeah. When I did an update after doing the triple set of shows.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2We did the update. And back then, I talked about the joint European Taurus, which was actually from 1997. They had their biggest run. They got 16 megawatts of power out for 24 megawatts of heating. That's not good. Far more energy went in than came out. ITER, which is the huge project in France that all these countries are contributing to, was under construction and was going to have first plasma in 2025. It didn't make it. Really? All the fusion was pretty much just government-funded. Although that was

Speaker 2around the time, and I mentioned at the time, that Commonwealth Fusion was partnering with MIT to make what would become SPARC, and that was using high-powered– superconductive magnets and we hear we talk about we hear about spark again in 2021 when they actually build their first revco magnet now a little fusion recapper for those remember we're trying to make a sun and the way stars work is with gravity right that you have enough gravity to press hydrogen atoms together so they fuse in the helium atoms

Speaker 2and emit a lot of energy and that fusion continues up the chain from helium over to lithium and so forth We don't have that much gravity, so we have to contain it with magnetic fields. There's a few different ways to go about this with inertial confinement and so forth, but let's talk about the magnetic field one. The strength of the field matters. In the case of the joint European Taurus jet, they were just using copper coils cooled with water. Magnet can only be up to maybe a Tesla from that. The ITER project, which by the way still isn't functioning, is using niobium-10 superconductors. And they can

Speaker 2put out about three Teslas of field. The Spark demonstrator, which may actually get done before ITER, you can actually get niobium tin up to nine or 10 Teslas, but it can do 20 Teslas. And in fact, that's what they demonstrated in 2021, is that they built a REBCO coil. And that's challenging because REBCO superconductors are not a metal. Niobium tin, they're both metals. You can make them into wire. REBCOs are actually ceramics. So how do you make this into a coil? Well, you have to spread this stuff

Speaker 2on a tape and then use the tape to wind it. It took a long time to get that right. But making more powerful coils, more powerful magnetic fields means you can make a smaller, more efficient fusion reaction. Next big milestone in 2022 was the National Ignition Foundation. This is Lawrence Livermore Laboratories. Their real business is understanding how nuclear explosions work. This was a side project for them. But they did what we call fusion ignition, which is you have enough fusion that more energy comes out of the

Speaker 2reaction than went into it. So this is in 2022, where two megajoules of laser energy being fired at a halorum creates three megajoules of fusion energy. That's a big deal. No one had ever done that before. That's a Q of 1.54. Anything above a Q of 1 means you got out more energy you put in. Now, that being said, lasers are not that efficient. So, well, yeah, they made

Speaker 2a 2 megajoule laser. We are using megajoules here because it's the total energy over time as opposed to instantaneous energy. It took 300 megajoules of energy to make that 2 megajoule laser beam. So, this is still way behind in the energy equation. But, it is we can make a fusion reaction that emits more energy than we put into it. And they have repeated and improved that project since then.

Speaker 1Well, that's encouraging. What are your thoughts on it?

Speaker 2It is very much so. I don't think inertial confinement is the way forward. And believe me, we're going to talk about more problems in fusion before we get to the end of this. But I think the talk of Mac approaches are more sustainable. And, and so, but it's good to get that experiment done to actually demonstrate that they've been working on that experiment for many, many years. Uh, the laser system is very old. It could be improved, but that's huge amounts of money. Uh, so goodness knows when that, what that'll actually look like. Uh, I'm going to switch over. China has a reactor called the East reactor, uh,

Speaker 2And their real experiment is sustainable plasma. So this is a Takamak style, like the donut style. Same as JET, same as ITER. There's a bunch that work this way. Their first plasma was back in 2006. But their goal was, can you do really long runs? Because that high energy run, the JET run in 1997, that was the record for many years, is literally several seconds. You know, five, six, seven seconds. That's all it did. What China's East reactor was trying to do is, could you actually run this for long enough that it would be a meaningful amount of energy? And so in 2025, they hit their record

Speaker 2where they've sustained 120 million degree plasma, so that's real fusion temperatures, for 18 minutes. So dramatically longer than anything else go on. The reality here is we're at a point with these superconducting tachymax now where it's about the control systems. And while the Chinese project didn't actually do this, there is a lot of work today on using machine learning models to adjust the magnetic fields to keep the plasma combined. for longer and longer times. Today, if we're talking about fusion, we need to talk about ITER, who

Speaker 2was supposed to go first plasma in 2025. Current date now is 2034.

Speaker 1We've been talking about ITER ever since we've been talking about fusion.

Speaker 2Because it's been a story ever since. They are building the thing. They've poured enough money into it, but their goal is to get to a Q of 10. The current record is 1.5 So that would be I put in 50 megawatts of heating, I get out 500 megawatts of thing. That's impressive. It still won't be enough to be really productive. They would want to build another reactor after that, but this is the large-scale project. And the funny thing is they're so far behind schedule, I wouldn't be surprised if Commonwealth Fusion and Spark actually deliver before them.

Speaker 2It's really going to be a question on the read. But there have been some great experiments, including famous AI-related experiments like DeepMind worked with the Swiss Tachymac to actually use reinforcement looming to improve plasma. So we're at the point now where we can make the plasma. We're starting to get real run times. But now we get into the next set of problems. And one of the largest problems that you can face with now is what they call the fuel problem. So 100 million degree plasmas that you can do fusion with are hydrogen-based, right? Specifically, heavy

Speaker 2isotopes of hydrogen, deuterium and tritium. Deuterium is a hydrogen atom with one neutron. Deutridium is a hydrogen atom with two neutrons. Deuterium is common. You can get it out of seawater. It's that stuff we call heavy water. It's easy to find. But tritium... It has a short half-life. It decays constantly. And so you have to make it in reactors. Today, it's primarily made in fission reactors where neutrons from the reactor bombard a lithium blanket, which is a catalytic reaction. It doesn't destroy the lithium, but it

Speaker 2does produce tritium as a byproduct. But the worldwide production of tritium today is in the kilograms because the main thing it's used for is nuclear weapons. Ah.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2So we don't need very much of it. And if you are actually going to run a power plant with DT fusion, because it's the lowest temperature fusion, only 100 to 200 million degrees, you need tons of tritium. Now, the current theory has been because the byproduct of DT fusion is a lot of neutrons that will use the fusion reactor. To breed its own tritium. The challenge here is can you breed more tritium in that process than

Speaker 2you're consuming to operate it, which nobody's been able to demonstrate. Because it's kind of counterintuitive. Like, how would that even be possible that as the fusion reaction of a tritium breakdown for fusion spits out enough neutrons to actually make more tritium that you're in a positive breeding cycle?

Speaker 4Mm-hmm.

Speaker 2Mm-hmm. There's another solution to this, which is to stop using DT, deuterium tritium, because the neutrons are also a problem. One of the things that JET showed was that DT fusion destroys the inside of the reactor. You can't contain neutrons in a magnetic field. They're not magnetically reactive. So they go right into the walls. Now, normally, that's how you'd actually make power, is you'd collect those neutrons in water. and that would create heat, and you'd boil that water,

Speaker 2pressurize it, spin a steam turbine. So once again, fanciest reactor in the world, boiling water like a kettle.

Speaker 1That's what they all do, mostly.

Speaker 2It's unfortunate, but it's true.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2But another approach is the one we talked about in a past show, which was tri-alpha energy, or TAE. These guys want to do proton-boron fusion. Yeah. Boron is element four rather than element one. It's a bit heavier. You collide it with a proton, which is essentially an ironized hydrogen atom. It does not emit a lot of neutrons. It emits alpha particles, and you can collect those. Those are charged, so they can be neutralized by the field. And part of what TAE's approach was that you pulse

Speaker 2these reactions. You build up two groups of plasma at either end of a tube and then you fire them at each other and they fuse when they impact. And that burst of magnetic energy actually turns into the way you collect that energy off of the field. It's complicated. It's very cool. So it would be a modern way to collect electricity in a pulsed form with no neutrons, so non-destructive as well. Here's the problem with proton-boron fusion. If you're trying to get to between 100 and 200

Speaker 2million degrees for DT fusion, you need to get between 1 and 2 billion degrees to do proton-boron fusion. That's a lot more heat. Do we have magnetic fields strong enough? Good question. Not the primary problem. The other thing that happens when you start to get to those kinds of temperatures and pressures is that sometimes the way the electrons break down emit X-rays. Now, that's hazardous, but you can absorb it with heavy metals. But it's also a waste

Speaker 2of energy, right? You're trying to collect all that energy and actually use it to make electricity. And so we might lose more energy to the x-rays than we're getting from the higher energy fusion. So I just get the scope that there are so many problems to solve in this space. It's not simple. We're further away than you think.

Speaker 1And that's why it hasn't happened yet. All those reasons.

Speaker 2And with that, why don't we take a break and then we'll do the back half.

Speaker 1Sounds good. We'll be right back after these very important messages.

Speaker 2And we're back. It's done at rocks. It's a geek out the future. We were promised. I'm Richard Campbell. That's Carl Franklin. Hey, we did all of the, you know, cars and, and of course fusion, like the most popular ones right off the bat. Why don't we get into some travel-related stuff, starting with supersonic travel. Okay. So we had Concorde. It was announced in 62. It first flew in 69. They only ever built 20 of them, of which only 14 went into service. They had about 100 seats in them, all quote-unquote business class, but this was

Speaker 21970s business class, which is pretty basic. So commercial service started in 76, just in time for the oil crisis, which jacked up the prices because it burns a lot more fuel to flew at supersonic speeds than to fly subsonically. And then, of course, there was that terrible crash of Air France in Paris in 2000, which they did a bunch of repairs and improvements to the vehicle to make it safer. It returned to flight November of 2001, just after 9-11. Yeah. And that finally ended it in 2003.

Speaker 1Cursed by bad timing.

Speaker 2And to that degree. But also, it was just expensive. And I think the bigger thing was air travel had changed, right? Yeah. With business, if you're going to spend that price on Concorde just to cut the time in half, so instead of a seven-hour trip from New York to London, you now have a three-and-a-half-hour trip to New York to London, it's still long enough that you want to be comfortable. And they never really improved the interiors that much. There wasn't a lot of room in that vehicle. It was quite narrow. It's a supersonic aircraft. It was all about the speed.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Where for the same amount of money, you could fly a 777 first class with a live flat seat and nice meals and– You didn't want to get out of that seat. It was so nice.

Speaker 5Right.

Speaker 1And that's the thing. It not only happened with air travel, but with train travel too. It's like, you know, instead of.

Speaker 2Yeah. Just make it more luxurious.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1Make it more luxurious. Give everybody free Wi-Fi, give them some free drinks, you know, and then nobody wants to, nobody cares that it's taking a longer time.

Speaker 2No. And that sort of, you know, we gave up a supercharged travel just wasn't worth it. Now, that being said, you've got companies like Boom Supersonic trying to build a new vehicle that's a supersonic aircraft, 60 to 80 seats or so. They've flown a demonstrator. But they haven't really addressed any of the real issues. It's still going to have just modern materials. Maybe it'll be more efficient. I wonder if they won't get past the biz jet version of it. It won't really be an airliner. And then there's NASA's X-59 where they're trying to change the shape of sonic booms because one of the things that happened to Concorde when it became popular was we didn't allow

Speaker 2overland flights. The sonic booms were too disruptive. They rattle windows and wake people up and people don't like that. Right. But the X 59 is demonstrating that we can make sonic booms that are more like a car door closing than an earth window shaking explosion. And that's actually got the FAA talking about changing regulation where we're not saying no supersonic flights, just your boom can't be louder than X.

Speaker 1You know, I knew if they put Chief O'Brien in charge of that, that he could figure out a way to lower the sonic boom impact.

Speaker 2Yeah, he can. So is it going to be enough? I don't know. Because still, the same old thing. Cut the flight in half, but more money. But what if you cut the flight by like 10 times? So SpaceX Starship. One of the proposals that Elon's made with Starship, because it's a fully reusable spacecraft, is under an hour to any point on the Earth.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 1Because full- Because it goes up so fast and comes down so fast.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1It's just a parabola.

Speaker 2A full low-Earth orbit is only 90 minutes. You only have to go halfway. Now, you'd have to have these launch pads away from city, so you'd be going out to probably a floating platform. You and maybe 100 of your friends load up into this rocket and 45 minutes later, you're landing on your tail on the other side of the world. So, take a flight like the one I do regularly, Vancouver-Auckland, 15 hours on the 787. It's a long way. You knock that down to 45 minutes.

Speaker 1That's pretty crazy.

Speaker 2That's crazy. Now, admittedly, you still have a couple of three hours at the airport getting out there and so forth, and you're going to have some time on the other end. So, maybe it's four or five hours.

Speaker 1You're going to have to pull some Gs.

Speaker 2Well, that's the other part of this, right? Like, Typical crew spacecraft is 3Gs. That's fine when you got a bunch of astronauts, but a bunch of fat old business people with stents and hard blood pressure, you might kill somebody with that stuff. Plus, I mean, Starship has only gone into orbit exactly once at the time of this recording. It's going to do some more. It's a cargo ship. It wasn't until the 86th flight of Falcon 9 that they flew a crew. So it's going to take some

Speaker 2time to mature Starship enough to say, is this safe for crews? And we've gone back to capsule style flying because it's safe, right? You can pull away from an exploding rocket and so forth. The way Starship's designed, it might be more like shuttle, which is to say there's no way to get out of the vehicle. So if the vehicle fails, everybody dies. So- But when you, you know, I'm only talking about long haul flights that we can do today. Let's talk about long haul flights you couldn't do right now. Like they're now, Qantas is doing a

Speaker 2specialized version of an A350 to fly from Sydney to London direct. Wow. That's over 24 hours on a flight.

Speaker 5Wow.

Speaker 2It's the other side of the world. The fact that you could knock that down to less than an hour.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2Like that might be worth it.

Speaker 5Wow.

Speaker 4So.

Speaker 2There's possibilities there, but it's only if we get down to those kinds of times. So, it's enough savings. So, you don't care. Like, you're not going to have a bathroom. You're not going to get out of your seat. You're on a starship. You're going to be packed into a memory phone seat, strapped in a six-point harness, and you're there. You might have your phone and you might have a barf bag, but that's all you're going to have.

Speaker 1There's another hidden problem there, which is extreme jet lag. Extreme, you know?

Speaker 2Yeah, it's a great question. Is it more jet lag or less jet lag if you travel that fast? Is it the speed and distance that matters, or is it the time in the airplane that matters?

Speaker 1Yeah, I think it's the time change. I think it's the time change, right? I mean, if you take off at 6 p.m., right, where you are, and you wake up at, At 45, you don't even go to sleep. 45 minutes later, it's 6 a.m. You're screwed. I mean, you have to acclimate over a day at least.

Speaker 2I think you do your acclimation at home, you know, a day or two before you start sleeping to your destination schedule.

Speaker 1Yeah, that's a good, I mean, you know.

Speaker 2All right. Let's keep moving. You mentioned his personal jet pack, so let's talk about him. Okay. So, we've seen him, 1961, the Bell Rocket Belt Pack. This is a hydrogen peroxide rocket engine. You saw it in the James Bond film, Thunderball, 1964 or 1965. They only had like 30 seconds of flight time. Yeah.

Speaker 1And it was tethered too, right?

Speaker 2So, very dangerous.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 2Today, there's a couple of companies making jetpacks, but now they're using jet turbines. So jetpack aviation is one of them. Gravity industry is another. Jetpack aviation is very much that backpack concept. They've got several turbines on the back, up to 10 minutes of flight time. That's pretty legit. You're not going to go that far, but it's kind of an indulgence running on kerosene. But gravity industries are the guys making the Iron Man-like jetpack. So you actually have two turbines on each hand. as well as ones on

Speaker 2your back. So you are the flying machine. How you move your hands is how you do your maneuvering. It takes a lot of practice, but these are actually being used for search and rescue and military applications today.

Speaker 1That makes sense.

Speaker 2So I've seen the demonstration of a guy who's a search and rescue guy with an emergency kit for an injured hiker way up on a hill. And the fact that this guy could take off and fly up that hill rather than have to climb it in a minute and get to the person who's injured and be able to apply first aid right away while waiting for an extraction crew.

Speaker 3It's powerful.

Speaker 1That's really good.

Speaker 2And there's, been demonstration of military applications for shipboarding very dangerous process yeah for coast guard or our navy to try and get on another ship by helicopter where you have to hover very risky the idea that individuals could come up on all sides of a ship in these little packs and land and you know.

Speaker 1You're you're at such a disadvantage when you're trying to board a ship because they have the home turf and.

Speaker 2They have the home turf they're already in place yeah but To go down to human size, multiple targets moving simultaneously, actually probably the best way to board a ship. So military product, without a doubt.

Speaker 1Yeah, okay.

Speaker 2So that sort of come true. Again, we get back to the personal flight travel, which is you just want to travel that was quick. And these are not long-range devices. These are quick point-to-point devices for a particular app. Okay. Here's a random one. This is from Christian Wadengard. I did not put this on my list. He put it on the list. He asked about pneumatic tube travel.

Speaker 1Oh, God.

Speaker 2So, this comes from the.

Speaker 1Pneumatic tubes are only cost-effective at the bank, right?

Speaker 2You're exactly right, right? It goes all the way back to the Victorian era, mid-1800s. For mail, right? And memos and things, little tubes you could fire around. But in 1864, in the Crystal Palace, there was the pneumatic railway. So literally human-sized, get in this vehicle, pneumatic pressure moves the tube from point to point. Very cool. Very exciting. And then science fiction grabbed on with the evacuated tube concept, continent flying, like you can do supersonic speeds when you have no air in the way. And this then turns

Speaker 2into Hyperloop, right? Back in 2013.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2Elon, the old Elon, you know, the guy who flew his sports car into space, not the guy who.

Speaker 1Yeah, the Elon we like.

Speaker 2Yeah, the one that was easier to like. Clearly annoyed about the problems with the LA to San Francisco train, said, why don't we just do this thing, right? Where you just revive that whole idea of being able to fly airline speeds on the ground by doing an evacuated tube maglev train at very high speeds.

Speaker 1I haven't heard too much in the news about Hyperloop lately. Yeah.

Speaker 3Why?

Speaker 2There's a reason. It's– well, starters, the same way we– same problem with monorails. Changing tracks, very difficult. Maintaining that evacuated tube over hundreds of miles, extremely difficult. But the main stopper when you're talking about people is the failure modes are not survivable. You're moving at 700, 800 miles an hour and the tube depressurizes, the deceleration is going to turn everybody into strawberry jam. The tube actually breaks

Speaker 2or anything goes wrong in any respect, everybody dies. Like there's all the failure modes involved, everybody died. You just can't move that fast and not have safe failure modes. Virgin Hyperloop went the farthest with this. And one of the last proposals was actually cargo transport between Vegas and L.A. Interesting idea. Cargo doesn't care about acceleration near as much and so forth. But you know what else cargo doesn't care about?

Speaker 1Speed. Yeah.

Speaker 2Not that important, right? Trucks are cheaper. Hybrid was never going to be cheap. So the idea is largely done. Okay. Uh, from a listener, Hassan Savarin asked, what about the next internet? Is there a next internet? I think, I don't think there's a next internet. I think the next internet is the internet.

Speaker 1Well, the next internet is, it's what it's today versus what it was yesterday.

Speaker 2I mean.

Speaker 4Sure.

Speaker 2And I think it's already gone through a couple of transformations.

Speaker 1And that trend is going to continue, I think.

Speaker 2I totally agree. Uh, especially when you start thinking about moving away from browsers and agents are what communicates over the internet. You don't, You didn't actually want to surf the web per se. You just wanted answers. The fact that we're starting to have new tools that can do that for us is kind of interesting.

Speaker 1And comes with a whole bunch of new security concerns.

Speaker 2Oh, by far. And data quality concerns. Like we've dealt with all of this and we'd have to deal with it again. And then when you start thinking about post-smartphone, like virtual reality stuff or augmented reality, goggles, glasses, that kind of thing, same thing. The real thing that changed the internet is the interface changes. Yeah. It's been the browser for a long time. It wasn't always the browser. Once upon a time, it was gopher, you know, then it was, it's been the browser for the long time,

Speaker 2but it could be changed again.

Speaker 1If you're Joe Finney, it's back to windows apps.

Speaker 2So I love it. That was such a great conversation. Another one from a listener, quantum computing. Are we ever going to have ubiquitous quantum computing?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 5Okay.

Speaker 1From what I understand, and it's very little, from what I understand, you wouldn't do the same kinds of things with quantum computing that you do now with conventional computing.

Speaker 2They are not general purpose computers. They are specialized computers for very specific tasks. They are a kind of supercomputer. And for their specific tasks, so things like molecular simulation and physics problems and prime number cryptography, which is the scary one, they are extraordinary at those things. We don't have enough algorithms for them. We certainly haven't built big enough ones yet, but we've done a post-quantum show for a reason. The threat to cryptography is real, and there are solutions that make us immune. So they're going to

Speaker 2move away from that. But that just means that You're not going to have a smartphone with a quantum computer into it. It's probably just going to be a cloud device. The question is, when would you use a quantum computer? And I suspect it's when you're not going to decide that. You can envision with the new tools that are emerging today around large language models and agents and things, you describing a problem that you want to work on. Say you want to make a new material or a new device or something. And then that tool decomposes that problem into a set of steps. And one of those steps

Speaker 2could be best served by a quantum computing calculation. And then it helps prepare that calculation, sends it off to a service to compute it, along with all the other computing workloads it is doing around that to assemble your solution. Quantum computing is going to be another platform in the cloud at some point. Okay. Sam Sipp asked about robotic maids.

Speaker 1Oh, well, okay.

Speaker 2All right. Your personal home device, right?

Speaker 1Yeah, the Rosie Jetson kind of thing.

Speaker 2Yeah, that's it. The Rosie the robot kind of thing. And let's face it, there's some interesting progress being made in here. But mostly– China. China's done a bunch. Of course, when we think about North America, it's like the Tesla Optimus and the figure robot. And you've seen very carefully curated demos of their robots picking things up and putting them away.

Speaker 1And, I mean– Some funnier things that I've seen with robots are them doing sports challenges.

Speaker 4Oh, yeah.

Speaker 1And totally failing. Like running into a wall.

Speaker 2Well, or running so fast they cannot stop.

Speaker 1Yeah, they can't stop.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Getting beamed.

Speaker 2There's a reason we run as fast as we can run. That limit is not our muscles so much as our ability to stop. And now that they've made robots that can run faster, they're finding out they cannot stop.

Speaker 1That's how that works. It's kind of funny.

Speaker 2But the real linchpin when we talk about a household robot is the hand. Yeah. Hands are incredible. Our human hands are extraordinary. to be able to pick up a sock, something soft, pick up a wine glass, something brittle, pick up a banana. Like those are not small problems.

Speaker 1I still have a hard time believing at 58 years old that a human such as myself can play guitar. And after practicing for so many years, it just, it's like drinking water, you know? And, and I just marvel at the mechanics in the memory and the muscle memory and stuff. Cause you know, it, You tend to think when you see people doing something ridiculously cool with their hands that they're thinking about it, like they're concentrating on it.

Speaker 2No, they couldn't.

Speaker 1They couldn't.

Speaker 2Well, you're my proof point, Carl, about what practice actually means, right? I've seen you do it. I've traveled with you for days and days and days and you practice every day and it's practice. Yeah, it is. It's pressing against the edges of your ability. It's not playing a song.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2It's practice and it's you are– modifying the neurons in your spine yes to have those.

Speaker 1Reflex have the memory i'm you can see in the in the video but we can see each other but you guys can't see us but i have my guitar on the stand and that's because every single day after the last gig that i did where i completely screwed up the solo to peg by steely dan oh god it.

Speaker 2Was horrible did you really oh man you ate it.

Speaker 1I totally ate it. And it was because I hadn't practiced because I had a finger injury, right?

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2Your hands weren't.

Speaker 1And so, I hadn't practiced and I hadn't practiced. But now, every single day, I pick that thing up and I play that solo and all the other hard solos and things. And it's just for the point of muscle memory. The next gig, I just want it to flow.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1And it will. But it's still amazing to me.

Speaker 2It has to be there.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah. So, you know, the other thing you think when you think about one of these robots, there's a few other concerns around these robots. One is, okay, I get having a hand articulate enough to handle all the different materials. There's another question for it to assess and go, ah, that's a pile of dog poop.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Don't pick it up.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2Right. You know, this is the curated demo you've never seen is, you know, Baby barf.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2Now it's got to go get a mop or get a towel or how to clean that up. You know, a little kid can do that, but our software is not that good. Figuring that stuff out is really hard.

Speaker 1Well, if you think about it, the LLMs are smart enough to tell a human how to do it.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1But it's the interface between interpreting... English language and turning that into mechanical movement, that's the difficult thing for robots. It's easy for them to say or to be presented with.

Speaker 2They've never done a carefully curated demo of wiping something up. Right. You talk about the thing a hand can do, a human hand can do that's unreproducible, wiping up a spill. It's just not that simple.

Speaker 1They pretty much have walking down... now yeah fairly well fairly well.

Speaker 2Yeah but yeah you're right so and it's and i mean why would we have a legged robot because a lot of our houses can only move to be removed around in the legs right i also think that the companies have sabotaged themselves by these constant cases of oh these robots being taken over by a person seeing through the robot so you know when i talk to a civilian normal human about why would you have one of these in there it's like they're spying on me it's like they probably are that's fair Heck, we've got enough problems with robotic vacuums sending ultra-tremendous telemetry out.

Speaker 1Do you remember we did a show where I think it was Steve Smith had an iPod, an iPad on a stick on a robot wheelie that he could operate around and move around and talk to people with a FaceTime, right?

Speaker 2Hanselman did that for Microsoft.

Speaker 1It was Hanselman too, yeah. But I remember Steve Smith doing it as well.

Speaker 2That's a product.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1It's pretty cool, actually.

Speaker 2It's pretty cool. All right. So Yeah, I asked the spouse, you know, what would it take for you to have a robot in the house? And she said, toilets. I'm like, you know, legit. If you had a machine that could reliably clean the toilet, and it doesn't have to be a humanoid, really.

Speaker 5Right, right.

Speaker 2As long as you can get around and you can get over a toilet and actually clean it, you probably could.

Speaker 1If you could have a self-cleaning toilet or a toilet cleaner that sits next to the toilet or rolls in. Something. For Kelly, my wife, it's coffee maker.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1She said, I want you to invent a robot. She's telling me, I got to invent a robot.

Speaker 2Yeah, you got to do this.

Speaker 1You got to invent a robot that brings me a hot, fresh cup of coffee in the morning in bed. I said, well, you know, get a Keurig, plug it in, put it on a timer, and that'll be your alarm clock.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1No, it's not good enough.

Speaker 2Not good enough. That's not what you really want. All right. Let's get through a couple more. I have a Star Trek set.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2So Universal Translator, I think this is solved. I think we got Universal Translation now. I mean, it's through our smartphones, and it's not perfect by any stretch of the imagination, but we both have text and speech translation. I now think it's not unusual to flip over my phone and look at a foreign language menu and can figure out what I want to order.

Speaker 1I've had conversations with people that don't speak English using Google Translate and just put the phone right in the middle. You speak, it speaks English. the other person speak it speaks to you it's.

Speaker 2Really novel enough and let's face it the communicators of star trek are nothing on the modern smartphone we've vastly exceeded those communicators yeah um what about the tricorder ash asked about what about medical scanners we're getting pretty close You know, everybody's got a wearable now that'll do heart rate, blood ox saturation, ECG, sleep monitoring, activity level.

Speaker 1Still, it's nothing you could just go in front of somebody.

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah. I mean, we do have handheld ultrasonic scanners now.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2So, you have to press against the person to do that. But you can look inside them. So, we have some of that capability. And we certainly have.

Speaker 1I have a continuous glucose monitor.

Speaker 2Yep. continuous glucose monitoring. That's a little robot. And we now have machine learning models that are analyzing that data and giving us pretty useful feedback these days. Certainly more like that. And then there's all the experiments happening with lab on a chip. So we're getting closer to the idea of, you know, a little bit of spit or a little bit of snot. It's like, this is what you're infected with. Here's the best treat.

Speaker 1Yeah. I can't wait for that. I just remember the day that I had a cold and I went to the doctor and doctor's like, well, I can't really do anything for you. I said, can you like put it under a microscope and send it to a lab and have them tell me what the bacteria or the virus is? And it turns out viruses are very, very hard to detect under a microscope. In fact, impossible.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2Because they're so small. Bacteria can be detected, but, and that's what you want.

Speaker 1Bacteria can be detected.

Speaker 2I mean, you just want to knock a few obvious ones out. So I'd be interesting.

Speaker 1Well, you know, if it's not a bad bacteria, you can tell it's a virus and then they can just send you home with chicken soup. What more can you do?

Speaker 2I mean, one way or the other, they can give you medicines, you know, flu or cold medicines and, And you can either take those and get over in about a week or do nothing and it'll pass in like seven days.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 1Unless it's particularly virile like COVID or something.

Speaker 2Unless it's something serious, right? And that's the real thing is you want to be able to test for something serious. One more Star Trek technology. Replicators. George Armstrong asked about replicators, right? And to be clear, the replicator, like the transporter, these were just workarounds for limited budget in Star Trek.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2They're wildly more advanced than everything else that was in Star Trek. Like, Star Trek makes no sense in this disproportionality of technology. Sure. I mean, that being said, what is DoorDash but basically a food replicator? You pull out your phone, you tell it what you want, and an hour later it appears. That's pretty close, man.

Speaker 1That's pretty cool.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, no kidding.

Speaker 1Do you think of 3D printers as replicators of some kind?

Speaker 2I think so, yeah. Especially when you get into more of the ecosystem of them. So your little 3D printer may be only working in various kinds of plastic. But that file can be sent to a service and have it made out of titanium. Yeah. Right? Or any other combination of metals. Even we're starting to see versions of laser sintering where they're doing dynamic alloys and coatings.

Speaker 1Isn't it ironic that tea, Earl Grey hot, is probably one of the hardest things to just pull out of thin air? I mean, seriously.

Speaker 2Well, yeah. Although you could easily make a machine that had Earl Grey tea bags or Earl Grey Keurig and just run it.

Speaker 1Yeah, that's true.

Speaker 2There is some 3D printing for food.

Speaker 1I've heard it.

Speaker 2You see these 3D printed like chocolate dust on top of your latte and things like that. Yeah. But yeah, these things are pretty convenient. I would take this another level, too, which is, and I've done this a bunch of time on the coast here now, where I have a broken part. I pull out my phone to take a picture of the part with the recognizer. It tells me what the part is. I select that part on Amazon. Part appears the next day.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's pretty amazing.

Speaker 2It's astonishing, right? You're getting 3D printing or getting replication just done with Amazon.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2Okay, last set. Space stuff.

Speaker 1OK.

Speaker 2And it's mostly just tourism, right? So Keith Hill asked about hotels in orbit. Let's be clear, space tourism exists today. You just need to be a billionaire.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2A Crew Dragon's about $ 100 million to save up for you and three of your friends. Axiom Space will get you to the space station if you want to go. It's just expensive. We're seeing a new generation of space stations starting to come along. So vast aerospace, I think, is the most interesting one, flown on a Falcon Heavy. These could be the first generation of space hotels. Here's the real problem with all of this, and we have empirical data around this for the inspiration for our flight. You are going to be space sick.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2You are going– everybody is space sick. In fact, if you're not space sick, there's something wrong with you. There's a couple astronauts with a genetic defect that make them not space sick. But the difference between an astronaut space sick and a regular person space sick is the astronauts being paid to be there and doesn't care that it takes a couple of days in a six-month flight to recover. If you've just dropped a lifetime price of a house for one week in space and three of those weeks you're vomiting the whole time, this sucks. Now, your answer is going to be rotating space station, right? 2001 A

Speaker 2Space Odyssey, Space Hilton. Now, we've never built one. We will. It's time to start doing experiments with rotating space stations. But here's the sad part. Why do you want to go to space?

Speaker 1To get away from Earth.

Speaker 2You want to look at the Earth. You want to look at the Earth, right? You want to look out. You can't really see anything else but the Earth. You know what you don't want to see? The Earth wildly spinning around because you're in a space station.

Speaker 5Right.

Speaker 2Everybody who talks about the International Space Station talks about going to the Coppola.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2And they may be floating, but they're staring at the Earth and it's beautiful. If you're in a rotating structure, it's going to make you nauseous to be whipping around like that.

Speaker 1It's not only beautiful, that picture of Earth from space, but it's life-changing.

Speaker 2Yes. No borders.

Speaker 1Because you see no borders, no countries, no– Yeah. different people it's it's one people on one place yeah it's amazing.

Speaker 2Oh no it should be a requirement for any world leader yeah go up and see the world as a whole yeah we we want you to to think that way yeah we'll all be better off for it so it's gonna they this whole laura thurbert thing it's gonna be tough it'll be very interesting to see how they figure this out uh bases on the moon We seem to be on our way. There's a lot of energy around this specifically.

Speaker 1Oh, by the way, we own that now.

Speaker 2Based on the moon.

Speaker 1I didn't know if they told you in Canada, but yeah, the US owns the moon.

Speaker 2Pretty sure there was an agreement, the Space Act 1967.

Speaker 1Anyway.

Speaker 2We're going to have science labs up there with the tourism part. Goodness knows when. I mean, the tourism of the moon is more feasible in low Earth orbit because at least you'd have some gravity. You're only a few days away. You'd spend three days getting there. That would be your space-sick part. Then you'd have some amount of time on the moon, and then you'd have three days coming back. It could be a 10-day trip. Obviously, a lot of technology needs to be advanced. The main thing is in-situ resource utilization, starting to use water on the moon, starting to make stuff with moon materials. That's the current lab experiments we want to get to, the developments that

Speaker 2are going on. So this is still decades away, but genuine progress is being made on that. And then last topic, of course, people ask about Mars colonies. There is no time horizon on this whatsoever. Elon seems to have largely abandoned the subject. It was a daft one anyway. Yeah. Science experiments on the moon totally makes sense. We should have scientists up there learning, understanding that you go from a 10 or two week trip to the moon to a three year trip to Mars. It's going to take you six months to get there. Then you're going to

Speaker 2have to wait for orbital conjunction to be able to get back.

Speaker 1If you survive.

Speaker 2So if you survive. There's no rescue modes. There's a bunch of rescue modes for the moon. There's no rescue modes for Mars. You either make it or you don't. There's no reason to want to be on Mars. It's not any more habitable than the moon, really. We're better off if we want to build habitats, building O'Neill cylinders and things like that.

Speaker 1Yeah, I agree.

Speaker 2Research is a good thing. It's still decades away. So it's not the future as we thought it, you know, mostly it was marketed to us, but it's a pretty cool future, you know, and I'm not going to say we don't have problems. We do. There's a bunch of things that people asked about, like universal healthcare that I didn't necessarily fit into that. I don't know that anybody was necessarily promised universal healthcare. I would say as a living in a country that has it would recommend, but you know, it's outside of the spectrum that the Star Trek,

Speaker 2utopian life, the post-scarcity. We can see it from here. We just have to choose to work towards that. And that's a whole other set of battles. And one would argue that the current stupidity that's going on right now is the fight against what post-scarcity looks like, which is how that mindset dies.

Speaker 1Hey, before we leave, can we put on our future-looking... caps for a bit and give our opinions about, let's just say, the next year as the economy and AI converge. Do you have any predictions? I do.

Speaker 2Well, it's funny that you mention that because we happen to be recording on the day that the South Korean stock market took a big dump, like 10% down. And one of the questions was, is this the contagion? Is this the beginning of the decline? It turns out so far it hasn't been, but the day's not over. But often that's the way these things start is with the stock prices of a bunch of the RAM makers, Samsung, Heinex,

Speaker 2and so forth, took a hit. We know that AI is over-leveraging our markets. The products are unstable. that the build-out for data centers is kind of outrageous and unnecessarily expensive and not sustainable from the point of view of the costs. So far, the big hyperscalers, the Amazon, Microsoft, Googles, have been financially stable over this. But you look at companies like Meta and Oracle who are selling bonds and

Speaker 2things to try and leverage their builds. That's really getting risky. So we're seeing all the ingredients that reminds me of the dot-com boom ending.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Um, 2027 is going to be tricky for that. You know, we, we, we're hitting the limits. We, these companies have made promises of their investors that they cannot deliver on. When do the investors decide enough's enough?

Speaker 1I read an article, uh, in the wall street journal by Andy Kiesler Kessler, uh, October 11th called how the AI boom ends. And, you know, he's talking about, um, prices, the demand isn't about to let up. And this is the tagline. Demand isn't about to let up, but prices will start plunging by factors of 10.

Speaker 2All right.

Speaker 1So you're already starting to see LLMs on smartphones.

Speaker 2Yep.

Speaker 1Like Quen.

Speaker 2And they're good enough.

Speaker 1Quen has got their, yeah, 80% of the way of what the big ones do. And Quen is good enough. They got it down to like six megabytes or something like that. unbelievable, this model. And so basically, there's a couple of things that come out of this. So if the prices start plunging and it's a race to the bottom, all these big companies that are currently propping up the world economy are going to tank, right? And so that's

Speaker 1a big problem for the economy. Now, for people who Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah. Maybe bringing in $ 50 billion a quarter, but they're spending $ 100. And they're raising their rates to try and get those numbers to make sense. And it's driving customers over to the free models. And so you get into a situation where the debate we've always had is, are they Netscape or are they Google? Both existed during the dot-com boom. Netscape had vanished, having created the dot-com boom.

Speaker 2And Google went on to be relevant. And at this point, with these numbers, they are all Netscape. The companies that are going to survive are the hyperscalers, the ones building all the data centers, Microsoft, Google, Amazon. They appear to be fine.

Speaker 1But the cost of new data centers, or the building of new data centers is practically going to be non-existent it'll probably stall it's the ones that are all right yeah the ones that are existing and owned.

Speaker 2Mel, and I've done this talk where I said, what we're really seeing by those big three is the same thing that the telcos did in 2000. Buy up all of the locations where you can put cell towers so there'll never be a cell tower competitor again. Yeah.

Speaker 1Right?

Speaker 2You couldn't start a cell company today. There's nowhere to put the towers.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2Well, you're watching the big three buy up every location you could reasonably put a data center. So they'll never be a competitor again. They're locking up their lead. And it doesn't matter what they put in them. It's just a big box. They can put anything they want in them.

Speaker 1So the options for running your own local LLM become probably a lot cheaper because the prices are going to fall. That's going to affect the chips and the NVIDIA's chips and the hardware that you would run it on. So that's going to become more and more attractive to companies, especially where privacy concerns are. And I've talked about that.

Speaker 4Sure.

Speaker 2All along. Which since we failed the privacy so badly.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2You know, the people are just going to want to keep it to themselves. It's the simplest solution. Right. Exactly.

Speaker 1So there is that. But I also don't want to gloss over, you know, what could happen to the economy. Yeah. Like a major, major correction crash.

Speaker 2Yeah. Correction.

Speaker 1Depression?

Speaker 2We'll see.

Speaker 1Who knows?

Speaker 2Yeah, we'll see. We've been through this before. It ends in a couple of years. Those will not be fun years.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 1Well, I've been out of the stock market since March, I think. And I had all my cash just sitting there. And today, I purchased some more silver.

Speaker 3Wow.

Speaker 1Even though silver was up at $ 127 or $ 128, it's back down to less than half that. But it's still up, what, $ 150? 20, 150% from where I bought it first, but it's still, I think that it's at a low where it's a good investment, especially if you're going to see a major correction. No, that's what I got.

Speaker 2We'll see.

Speaker 1We'll see. Hang in there. I know what, we're going to be here every Thursday with the new. NET Rocks, no matter what happens.

Speaker 2Yeah. Don't forget the end of the year, there will be the space and energy geek outs. I'm already working on them.

Speaker 1Yep.

Speaker 2All right.

Speaker 1Thanks, Richard.

Speaker 2You bet.

Speaker 1All right, and thanks for listening, and we'll talk to you next time on.

Speaker 3NET Rocks.

Speaker 5NET Rocks is brought to you by Franklin's Net and produced by Plop Studios. a full-service audio, video, and post-production facility located physically in New London, Connecticut, and, of course, in the cloud, online at pwop.com.

Speaker 4Visit our website at dotnetrocks.com for RSS feeds, downloads, mobile apps, comments, and access to the full archives going back to show number one, recorded in September 2002.

Speaker 1And make sure you check out our sponsors. They keep us in business. Now go write some code. See you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. OWASP Top Ten and ASP.NET Core with Anders Abel

    Nov 19, 202649 minAudio

    How does ASP.NET Core help you make secure web apps? Carl and Richard talk to Anders Abel about the OWASP Top Ten and how ASP.NET Core addresses many of the vulnerability elements - at least where it can. Anders talks...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Modern Mentorship with Ethan Winer

    Nov 12, 202651 minAudio

    What is mentorship like today? Carl and Richard talk to Ethan Winer about his experiences helping people grow in their careers. Ethan talks about growing Crescent Software back in the QuickBasic and Visual Basic days -...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Building System Tray Windows Apps with Joe Finney

    Oct 29, 202657 minAudio

    It's Tray-Tober! Carl and Richard talk to Joe Finney about his latest project - building small, useful Windows apps that live in the system tray. Joe talks about his original project inspiration, Radio Tray - a way to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. XAML.io with Giovanni Albani

    Oct 22, 202657 minAudio

    OpenSilver evolves! Carl and Richard talk to Giovanni Albani about how OpenSilver continues to help folks migrate Silverlight apps into a sustainable model not dependent on the plug-in - but now the focus is on WPF!...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. AI in Live Broadcast with Tim Huckaby

    Oct 15, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Can AI tech work in live television broadcasts? Carl and Richard talk to Tim Huckaby about his work building Duff Foreman, an AI-powered avatar for live golf programs. Tim talks about using AI to build AI, using M365...

    Credit the people on this episode