This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.imperialistrealism.com Yesterday, Mark and I got on the livestream to talk about some of the big issues that have cropped up in the last week. Multiple systems outages gave us a little taste of post-technological dystopia, Anthropic’s IPO created a new crop of millionaires and billionaires just as one of the company’s employees said that AI would likely eliminate all jobs in the near future, and the much-anticipated new edition of Grand Theft Auto turned out to be a boyfriend training module. Have LLMs rendered moot one of literary theory’s most infamous debates? Has the world’s ever-increasing complexity condemned humanity to wander a jobless wasteland forever? How will Ethan Klein manage his divorced dad era? Read our latest post, “Intimations of End Times at Costco”
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Well, it's just social science is so obviously fake. I think that, to me, this is my ultimate criticism of it. It's that social science is not a real thing. It is a tool in the toolbox, but it's kind of achieved an epistemological superiority. But it's just not real. Intelligence studies aren't effective ways to measure... a category like intelligence, which is itself super ill -defined.
SPEAKER_01Super contingent. It presumes... The worst arguments in favor of it beg the question. They presume that the test is a measurement or is a good indicator of merit. But merit itself is a category that has been shaped and fashioned in certain ways.
SPEAKER_00So it's intelligence?
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah. I mean, Intelligence itself, whatever, I'm sure you've read Stephen Jay Gould on this, but Gould points out that the initial IQ test was designed as a way to try to ensure that people were getting the kind of education that would be the most helpful to them. Right. To say like, well, okay, so if you're not able to perform up to this level on a test, then we need to find a way to get you the kind of education that's going to be useful to you because there's no point, like, you know, honestly, in putting you in an advanced calculus class because you're not going
SPEAKER_01to get anything out of it. Like, what's the thing that we can do for you that's going to help? It had a kind of socially praiseworthy goal initially. It was when it was taken to indicate something that Inherent and empirical and then most damagingly heritable that it became something else entirely and took on a life of its own.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, the other thing with these intelligence tests is... They're just non-reproducible by any stretch of the imagination. They presume so much about what one's role in society should be. Not only that, I think with AI, a lot of fields that are now considered high IQ are not going
SPEAKER_00to be considered high IQ because AI is going to be able to do it so much better. It does genuinely seem That AI is going to be able to outperform the best mathematician and buy a lot.
SPEAKER_01Well, it already has in a certain sense. And then the debates in the mathematics community are some of the most interesting that are happening right now. Because these AIs, agents that have solved all of these problems, you know, the mathematicians, like the handful of mathematicians on Earth that actually understand this stuff, are looking at it. And some of them are just like, well, it all works, but we don't know why.
SPEAKER_00And they're inelegant oftentimes, is my understanding. It's not like you do it in six steps, they do it in like 400 or whatever, but they're doing it.
SPEAKER_01And then most interestingly to me, this guy, Tao, who is a Fields Medal winner, and I think one of the kind of representatives of the field broadly.
SPEAKER_00Fields Medal is under 40 math, right, I believe.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. He has said that... And people who work with him and many mathematicians are just pointing out something that's quite obvious that isn't something that I'd never thought about, which is they're like, we don't do math because we need to do math. We do math because we like doing math. That's what we do. It has an aesthetic dimension to it. Oh, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Especially, well, pure math really does. Right, and that's what is a bit of a different... I think in universities, there's two divisions in math departments. And surprise, surprise, my understanding is that pure math is far smaller than applied math given the actual political economy in which Americans live. But like, I mean, I do think, I'm in Seattle, man. I think all these software engineer jobs are going to be seriously reduced.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, they already are. It's going to be way worse, I think. Right now, the talent pipeline has been completely disrupted because we've written about this at Imperialist Realism. The entry-level positions for all of these tech jobs are just going away. They're just not hiring people. And if you are sort of severing the talent pipeline from the very early stages, kids just coming out of college who are trying to get their first job, You're not gonna have people who have careers in this field and it's gonna shrink
SPEAKER_01the talent pool and it's sending signals to students and we already see CS degrees.
SPEAKER_00Serious decline, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Serious decline because they're just like, well, it's not gonna guarantee me the kind of job it was going to 10 years ago. And so there just aren't going to be the people who are going into the field. Now, maybe that's like the market correcting itself, but you better hope that this is a permanent development. Otherwise, 15, 20 years down the road, we're like, oh shit, actually, we can't use this technology. Because I don't know, it's an existential threat to human life on Earth or whatever. You're not going to have the people who can actually do the useful jobs that need
SPEAKER_01to be done in terms of like keeping and maintaining infrastructure and making sure it doesn't break in all kinds of unexpected ways that really freak people out like in or like as it has in the last week. So, you know, there's just a tremendous amount of uncertainty that's happening. And the fear, or my fear, is that we're setting ourselves up for a situation that's going to have repercussion decades down the road. Again, asterisk, assuming we're all still alive.
SPEAKER_00Well, fuck that shit. At least all the housing crisis in Seattle are going to come down. And all the snobby engineers. No, I'm just kidding. But I think there is going to be a lot of existential crisis stuff. Because I do think people who go from making $500,000 to $200,000, even though that sounds good, or not being able to find a job, that's going to be a big deal for a lot of the super-educated workforce in this country. And I think, as you know, AI ultimately is a de-industrialism play fundamentally. I think that's where it's going to be really good at math.
SPEAKER_00I think it's going to be good at medical stuff. That does seem like a field where it will do really well at. And I do think that it's going to be good in closed systems generally, and it'll not be great at writing the proverbial poetry, writing the proverbial proverb. That's where it won't be as good. I don't think it'll ever have that human hand feel. Even though a lot of work is shit, it'll be able to do shitty, mediocre work, or above average work even. But I don't think it'll ever be,
SPEAKER_00I don't think anyone will ever ontologically produce a Shakespeare. I don't think that's really possible.
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.imperialistrealism.com Last weekend, Mark and I talked with Eleanor Janega, author of The Once and Future Sex: Going Medieval on Women’s Roles in Society...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.imperialistrealism.com On this episode of Mutual Ruin, we sat down with journalist Ken Klippenstein to talk national security, Trump’s NSPM-7, what...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.imperialistrealism.com On this, the latest episode of Mutual Ruin, I talk with historian David Sessions, co-host of the Off Christopher Street podcast,...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.imperialistrealism.com This afternoon I had Freddie deBoer back on Mutual Ruin. Freddie shared his own experience with bipolar disorder, which informs...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.imperialistrealism.com On this week’s episode of Mutual Ruin, I talk with Oliver Batemen about the bygone era of doing little and earning plenty, our...