Ep. 181: This is the second episode in a two-part series about the evolution of CMOs - recorded as collective management organisations undergo their most significant transformation in decades. In this episode, Sacem’s Director of International, Caroline Champarnaud chats with Julien Dumon, its Director of Digital. They explain how the global infrastructure only works if it ultimately serves creators -whose needs are evolving just as fast as the systems built to support them. They go on to explain how Sacem is redefining its services, tools and philosophy to support modern creators - from digital-native artists to global collaborators - while maintaining fairness, transparency and trust. SACEM: Society of Authors, Composers and Publishers of Music ========= Series recap: In the first episode in the series, David El Sayegh, Deputy CEO of Sacem, discussed how the organisation is defining the future of copyright. In the second episode, we were joined by Julien Lefebvre, the Head of Innovation and Sacem Lab, to talk about its startup partnerships, and the strategic decision to open up certain proprietary technologies to all creators. In the third episode, we spoke to Caroline and Julien about how CMOs are evolving into interconnected, global infrastructure players: the challenges of global metadata, why international partnerships with organisations like ASCAP and GEMA are more vital than ever, and how Sacem is scaling its systems to match the explosive growth of music streaming in emerging markets. ======= This is a Music Ally Co-Labs podcast: musically.com/music-ally-co-labs. Co-Labs content is created by publishing partners in liaison with the Music Ally Editorial Team. We work closely with partners to ensure that it adheres to Music Ally's high expectations of quality, thoughtfulness, and usefulness.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hi there. Welcome to Musical Focus. I'm Musicalize Managing Editor Joe Sparrow. And a quick reminder that you're listening to the Musical Focus Sasam Collabs podcast. Series. So we're concluding today our two-part discussion with Carolyn Champagne and Julian DuMont from SASSEM. And we're shifting the focus away from global systems to the individual artist digital native. Creators today work across borders and. Across genres in ways that traditional models weren't always built to handle. So we're going to look at creators needs today and we'll. Discuss how Sassem is adapting
it's services and philosophy to support. These new creative modes. Hello to the two of you again. Great to have you. And as I said, the first conversation we had was about the global infrastructure and the challenges and the work you're doing. But obviously, as I said at the end of last episode, that only really counts for anything if it serves the creators who are making music and, and, and writing songs and putting things into the system as well as the consumers and the people in between. And the needs of creators are
changing just as rapidly as everything else. And so I wanted to talk to you about how Sasim is redefining your services, the tools and your maybe even your philosophy in terms of supporting modern creators. And I think that word creator is perhaps really key to this as well, because the the what it is to be, let's say in the past, we may have used the words words like songwriters and artists. It's it's everything has has become very multifaceted.
Very everybody is a number of things now, and that's a great thing. But I want to talk to you about from the perspective of digital first, the artists to global collaborations in, in that sort of context. So, and at the same time, of course, you have to maintain all these, all the stuff we talked about before, fairness, transparency, trust, and delivering all the services you do. So let's first of all talk about this shifting creative landscape.
We have creators now. Who are digital natives? They've never known anything else, unlike I think all of us. And they work across borders, across genres. And they also sort of create with a, maybe a often with a platform first approach as well. They're designing work with platforms in mind. So from the very top level then, how is SASM thinking or rethinking its role and in terms of keeping pace with these creative changes?
For all those digital natives and and for the others, the relationship with Sasam can be fully digital. You can become a member using our portal. You register your works online. You can use Music Start and maybe Julie, I'm gonna describe a little bit better Music Start and how you can protect your songs. You have access to your digital portal of course, so you can retrieve your distribution information, you can upload your
bank account number, etcetera, etcetera. But what we have realised is that our members, they like speaking to real human people as well. And we often hear some of them say, well, I was a member of whatever CMO and nobody would pick the phone to answer my questions. So it's a mix of both. Of course you can do everything digitally if you wish, but when you have a question there are people on the line that can
answer them. You can come and meet us and each time we are travelling the world, if we are have members in a given territory that we are visiting, then we organise, you know a miss and greet a coffee break so that we can meet in person. If I if I can add, I think that's on the really high level perspective Sassem had to obviously follow the trend of this music industry switch.
We are seeing now more and more DIY artists and creators, thanks to the tool available to them for simplifying their creation, their performance, thanks to the digital distributor or aggregator fastly allowing the upload of their work or track on some streaming platform and so on. So we have a double role. First is to be really be supportive and flexible as possible, as Caroline said,
allowing online quick registration of work, providing flexibility with multiple creators involved in a work. But also we have a, a strong role of educational, bringing them knowledge because they are not necessarily accompanied with legal experts, lawyers or things like that or people like that. So being the one who could explain how work this tricky
industry between recording rights, publishing rights, CMO infrastructures and road is something we have to do on their behalf. And we organise webinars for all the new members, you know that they can attend and ask questions. You know, we have a, a standard set of information to share with them how to navigate this industry. But if they have specific questions, then they can take this opportunity to ask them as well. And it's interesting. That what you've both mentioned there for this, this a digital
native group of creators is, is the human element essentially, which is they, they, they want education, they want connection, they want clarity. They, you know, it's, it's, it's almost the, the flip side to having much less friction on the creation side. And I'll talk to you about that in a moment. But the flip side is they still need support and help, right? And that's something which I guess CMOS have always done, but you're, you may be having to lean into a bit more now. What what are the other big shifts you've seen? You know, we, we it's you know,
at Music Hall, I'm constantly reporting on new platforms, new ways of sharing, new cross-border genre collaborations, all these things. What's what's this? What are the biggest notable other shifts that you're seeing in how creators are making, sharing, and monetizing on? The direct to fan relationship. Right. Through streaming platforms, you know, they do not need to have a label or they can go through a digital distributor, but then they handle, you know, their
relationship with their fans through social media, etcetera. We may also sometimes have to protect them from the fans because when you're so direct, you know, you may have bashing campaigns or whatever. So we we had to to have some of our members in the past that had to face those types of issues. But yeah, we'd say direct to fun is is one of the main trend for the new generation. This DIY element which is, you
know, from a consumer perspective, right, it's fantastic that that we're getting people who couldn't be creative. Perhaps in the past there were limitations. They now can write, record, distribute all from their bedroom or wherever. And we the consumer are reaping that reward in the in, in sort of an extra number of high quality musical works, right? We, we, it's the best time to be a music fan For these reasons.
But as you just mentioned there, there are many many. Alternatives now to. In terms of routes to market, routes for monetization, routes to recovering of royalties and etcetera. And it's, it's again that flip side of the, the benefits of DIY, the DIY approach, right? It's, it's liberating and yet you're on your own. Essentially you can feel like you are one person against the world and the DIY distribution area platform specific monetization, it could be very appealing.
I understand that to creators, but it can also result in fragmented or absent revenue streams, right. And that's a big problem, particularly when we look at a global scale. So what are the challenges that you're seeing with with that particularly in in relationship to how SASM is adapting to help? I would start first saying that education is the most biggest challenge because DIY today mainly concern the the recording, the master side, the
ability to provide in the easiest way possible your track onto many different platform thanks to a lot of facilities and things like that. But this is not necessarily focusing on the author right side or copyright side. And this is where we need to bring really a lot of education to those early bedroom producer creators and so on. Because it's great for them to have this channels of distribution for the recording. But that should not prevent them
to sign and to register or become a member of ACMO in order for the CMO to defend and protect their interest on their work, their really creative work. But this is where we are operating as much as possible by doing webinar, by exchanging and making your education. And you know, the more creators, the more works. The volume of original works is increasing significantly. This is why, and we spoke about this in the previous episode,
This is why we need to have a consistent database. We need to be scalable. We need to have reliable data. And it's also part of the education we can provide to the new members or the new creators. Please register your works. Don't forget your friends. Don't forget to agree on the splits so that we can more quickly identify your works, more quickly collect and then distribute.
Please send us all types of IDs you may have. You know the video ID of your YouTube video, music video, Give it to us. Do you know your ISRC that has been given by the digital distributor? Maybe give it to us so that we can be of a better help for you guys. And here's a slightly provocative question. But are CM OS adapting quickly enough to this new reality? And are creators perhaps
building parallel systems outside of the CMO system? As you would say in English, I guess not all CM OS are created equal. OK. We do not operate in the same territory. We don't have the same financial surface, I would I would say. So not all of them will adapt the same way. And I guess as a big CMO, our role is also, and we talked about that in the previous episode, we need to encourage
partnerships, neutralisation of costs, you know, so that in the end the creative community benefits of all of our joint efforts. So at a average scale all CM OS are adapting. You know, either it's part of their strategic road map or they are building new things in reaction of what's happening in the market. But yes, CR OS are adapting and we are seen sometimes as old
administrations which we are not. I can tell you meet with our IT team and you'll see, I think it's, it's not a one-size-fits-all answer obviously. But talking about SSM and obviously we will need to get feedback from all the other, but I'm pretty sure that we're trying to do our best to adapt as fast as their or creators and member needs. And this is basically part of our DNA for a really long time.
Well, you, you spoke about technological innovation there and that leads us on nicely to what I wanted to talk to you next about. We spoke in a previous episode to Julian Nephaev, your colleague about music start. We we touched on it. I was hoping that you could expand on that a little bit and sort of explain, you know, when you talk about delivering, delivering education and capturing information and collaborating with these, this new crop of creators, why tools like this are important.
So just for the audience, I'm going to just explain exactly what Music Start is. Music Start is actually a time stamping solution which is based on blockchain and which offer it's you there with ability to obtain a data for an anteriority for their creation. And we believe started thinking about building such kind of tool or service that it will must have solution, especially in the era today where creative
collaboration is growing and collaborative is really multi multiple, multiple creators. So every single user of Music starts can at least in a certain way protect his creation. But what is also actually really interesting with this, with this service, this is because it address early documentation registration and accordingly it reduce friction later in matching, in claiming, in payout and so on.
So that's why and how the Music Stock Service has been built thanks to Giulian Lefevre and all the SASSEM lab for which we've discussed in the previous episode and up to date would say that it's a pretty good success for a company Sasam, which is a non profit company. So we don't have a lot of money to spend in marketing and so on. But we have reached so far more than 3370 three 175,000 protection on the service and we
have more than 45,000 user actively using the service both between or direct member for which the service is offered free of charge because they are member but as well from or let's say B to C offering where we can offer the opportunity to access the service thanks to a monthly subscription. I speak to a lot of emerging artists and they, it's one, this is one of their key concerns, which is, you know, I collaborate with all these people.
It's just natural to them. They, they, they, they message people online, they, they send stems back and forth, they collaborate. And then, and then they, they have that moment where they go, well, how do I, how do I prove that I did that and, and that we did this. And, and, and when they start thinking about money, which of course is a good thing because they're thinking in a sensible way. So, and this is a solution that is aiming to capture all that information at the source. So, you know, what is the feedback you're getting from these users? Because it's I'm, I'm, you know,
you're making it as easy as possible. You're combining this with education. But what are they saying that that they like about it? Well they are. They are super happy the feedback we are getting that it's a simple way for them to protect. It's honestly take two minutes maximum to protect your creation. But it's also really interesting and we discovered that few months after the launch of the service, it's for us a final of acquisition of new member. We've seen many creators which
were not members of SASSEM using that service and afterwards becoming members. And actually as you, as you see, it's open to non members and to our members when they want to say that, you know, draft works, let me say, so they can use it. They only have the lyrics. They can put the lyrics in music start. They have the, the, the beat, They can put the beat in, in music start and then figure out after how they register the entire song.
So this system is open to everyone, non members members and if you are in conversations with artists, tell them they can use music starts from wherever they are in the world. Actually there's an English version available. What else are your members? And I'm, I'm saying this is members, but also people perhaps we're using services like this who are not perhaps quite yet full members, you know, the, the people who are engaging with your services. What are the kind of you've mentioned?
You've mentioned capturing data, you've mentioned education and assistance. What else? What? Are there any other sort of needs that perhaps have emerged from this new group of creators? They are and one of them, one obvious one actually it's merchandising. We we are really and due to this highly competitive landscape, we need to be service oriented. And so by being service oriented, we always try to
address our members needs. But those member are not necessarily at the same level. You have really big members, mid range ones, small one. We have more than 275,000 members, right Caroline something like that 150,000 yes. So, so merchandising actually has been an interesting topic because we understood and we've seen thanks to data since to data analyse analysis on the on on, on our different member that
we have a wide range of creators, mid range creators who are always making most of their distribution thanks to live and tour just locally in France from a city to another. And they were in need of getting a proper size merchandising solution. When I'm talking about proper size solution, I'm talking about volume. Those people don't need huge volume of merchandising content.
But when you are not dealing with huge volume, the price points is an important matter. And So what we've done and that we have been able to partner with a French company named Mercy Le Merch and this company has actually created a dedicated platform in which each of our member could easily access choose volume, make them own personalised merchandising item for a reasonable, a reasonable price. So this is typically the type of services we are offering to to
our member among a lot of other as a webinar to understand how the the Tiktok platform is working, how to improve your fan based on YouTube. All of our initiative are really focused on the service to our members and it is part of our Sassem Plus portal. If you look, for example, for a venue to play with your band, you can be connected with our clients. You know, cafes or shops
organising, organising concerts sometimes, etcetera. If you're looking for a big maker, you can just post, you know, a description of what you're looking for. If you want to sell your guitar, you know, it's, it's a community, it's our own Facebook in a way. And then you can exchange, you know, experience and and services. We've talked about technology in terms of serving your members and the, the one thing we've sort of blissfully not really discussed very much so far is
AI. But it's we, we do have to talk about AI and we can't ignore that it's becoming obviously it's a, it's a major thing everywhere in every facet of life now. But from a music creation perspective, or perhaps a composition perspective, if you like, it's, it is a major tool now. And the, the, the, how we might feel about that runs from every end of each end of feelings of positivity and negativity.
But on on a basic level, then what? What opportunities does AI as a as a music creation tool present and what are the risks from your perspective? So on opportunities, there are obviously 2 main opportunities. First, AI could be a phenomenal tool to support creativity. And this is where actually we need to encourage and educate member to embrace this kind of new technology for those who
want to to play with it. Second opportunity, but this is also linked to risk. We should have some window to get new partner, new licence partner because at some point there is no doubt that there will be licencing agreements with AI generative solution in order to allow the the training of those AIAIAI solution. So there might be a positive
economical aspect by getting a new range of customer using, using our work. But that bring bring me obviously to the other parts the the the flip coin of it risk. We are struggling right now with a lot of uncertainty about how AI, Gen AI I would say will or or will not be properly regulated. Should we have the ability all together at the industry level to properly value and get a fair
compensation about how training on pre-existing cooperated work will apply. And that bring us also with a lot of other risk which is obviously dilution of our revenues through streaming platform. If AI which is currently uploaded more and more on those platform will be actually diluting our work. And there will be some specific activity which might be in risk.
Music library on audio, visual contents, all these there, there will be specific area where there there are more risk than opportunity. Overall we do believe it's a well balanced situation and we hope and the same way then we did address 25 years ago the peer-to-peer and piracy issue. We are confident that we will solve this situation. And Caroline, this is one of the interesting things Julian said. There is from that global perspective is, and this is from
a creative standpoint that it's that potential risk of dilution of, of, of royalty distribution is a really important thing for, for human artists. And it's, it seems silly to put the word human in front of the word artist, right? But for, for the human beings who are making the music, they, they must be concerned about this, right? Is that what you're hearing? Yes, they are. And This is why again, I'll go back to the the need for
cooperation among the CM OS and within CSAC. You can imagine that this topic is at the forefront of what we're doing. We need to make sure that nobody is trying to steal any work using AI, you know, when replicating a copy of your work and trying to register that work, etcetera. So we, we've already built some safeguards and and we're still trying to improve how works are registered, how we exchange works, because once ACMO have
accepted a work, then it's, you know, distributed in all international databases. So we need to this is a joint effort we should make. And this is on on C Zac agenda of course and and the strategic road map and yeah, the registration of the works and and the dilution and maybe Julian can explain what we are doing with some of the DSPS to avoid more dilution. Yeah, I was going to say it's,
it's clearly a industry wide collaborative process. On that, just just to rebound dilution is one of the most important issue we're we are facing right now until we will get more clearer view about how we will deal with AI and so on. But one of the solution which could be interesting to consider and for which we've already made some initiative is switching from the current market centric model distribution to something
different such as the artist centric model or user centric model. So I'm not going to go to compare because that's not necessarily the question the the pros and cons of each model. But entering into something when the redistribution of the value is based on real creation and not white nose or AI generative content. When the model of redistribution is much more give much more value to the active stream compared to the passive stream address, the duration of the track.
These are things we need all together to consider to avoid being in risk with the emergence of all this AI generative content coming onto the streaming cloud. It, it, it does feel like it is from speaking to lots of people a time to at least sit down and agree what all these things are and where the value of all these things sits in, in a priority order and how that then results in money, doesn't it? And of course, that's a huge conversation, but it, it feels
all the way down from the bottom DIY creators all the way to the top. It feels like something that everyone wants. Which does then lead us once again into sort of the, the final part of this episode, which is what I'd like to look ahead sort of over the next 10 years. You've had you've both spoken about this, the enormous change that we've seen over the last 10 years. And so let's look ahead to if you can, if you can bear to think of it sort of 2036 when you know so much change has already happened.
Global infrastructure, for instance, is shifting to serve individuals even more and revenue streams are coming in from so many different platforms and there's going to be probably more platforms in the future. So this sort of sits in with the the question we just had, but what are you planning to do to make sure that there's fair conversation, there's more transparency as the the technological space and the
infrastructure space develops? Well, I, I would start if I may and that would be a perfect segue to the end of the the last question, innovation. Innovation is not necessary something based on technology. But you mentioned it too. We should not consider that what has been said 10 or 20 years ago as what we believe at that time to be the most perfect or accurate rule cannot be changed. We need to be open minded and follow the trend of the industry and and that's the thing where I
wanted to make about especially potentially considering a new model of redistribution instead of sitting on the market centric which were which were efficient and solid at the beginning, but not necessarily now after that. With respect to fair compensation and and transparent right management, while fair compensation clearly this will be thanks to the good deal which were negotiated between the right holder and the and the GSP and transparent right management.
I do believe that this is thanks to data-driven processing, reality of usage, distribution and detailed information provided to to our member. We we see more and more individualism that's for sure. But in CMOS, TC stands for collective. So it's, it's the challenge, you know, serving each individual creator thanks to collective
means. And this is what we've been doing for 175 years, by the way. But what we are also very aware of is that gathering, you know, in public places, in venues, you know, is also very important. And I guess we, we all know that feeling, you know, when attending your favourite artist concert or discovering a new band, etcetera. Only music can provide that kind of feeling.
And in the world we live in, we believe it's also our mission to favour, you know, the gathering. And, and This is why we are engaged so much locally in France and elsewhere because you know, we have a lot of, a lot of, we have some affiliated companies in, in the world and, and we believe that it's our mission as well. Of course we will keep on investing in technology, in services, etcetera, but well, we
are lucky enough to work for musicians actually. You've addressed the needs of creators. What future needs do you think that they may have beyond the ones we've discussed that are sort of the need to be met in a different way in the future? You know, everything is almost instantaneous nowadays, so they expect to see on a day-to-day basis how much they've earned or they will be paid for, you know,
so this is a major challenge on our end. But maybe Julian can elaborate on this. Well, that's perfectly that's we need to get some kind of real time dashboard highlighting real time consumption, providing an end to end solution on where is my money or when I will get that. After that on a pure processing matter, we need to consider and thanks to AI probably we need to consider some predictive claiming solution where it could
help to go faster to claim and then accordingly to collect and distribute. You know today SSM, we are one of the most faster CMO to distribute revenues on digital. We are distributing 3 months after exploitation. But in an ideal world, looking at 2O22O30 or two O 35, we should be in a position ideally to distribute monthly, weekly or even daily. That could be a.
For now it's just a dream the objective, but that's what the the creators will need. So that's what they want. And that all ties in with everything we've discussed, really, which is tied to collaboration with data sharing, with technology and with serving the needs of, of, of everyone in that value chain. It's been great having you on these two shows. And, and we've, we've really sort of worked all the way from the, I don't know, the top of the pyramid to the bottom or the bottom to the top. I'm not sure we, which way around we did it, But we've,
we've managed to look at the infrastructure all the way through to the creators. And if you haven't heard the first part of the podcast, I would, I would urge you to go and listen to that to join the dots and make it all make extra sense. But look, look, it's been great. Caroline and Julian been great on the podcast, and thanks for spending the time to shed some light on what you're doing. OK, that's it. You will find links to
everything we discussed below and around this podcast and as well. Don't forget that this is one of four in the series and you should be able to hop around your podcast player and find the other. Episodes. We'll put links to that. Too beneath the podcast, if you've enjoyed that, please do share it on with someone else who you think will get something out of it. And as ever, if you'd like to get in touch with me, please do. I'd love to hear from you. It's Joe. Joe at musically.com. OK, so that's it for this week. I've been me. You have been you. Thanks for joining us and see
Ep. 190: At a time when streaming dominates and independent labels are supposedly fighting to survive, Frontiers Music has marked its 30th anniversary by taking Megadeth to No.1 on the Billboard 200. It’s the first US...
Ep. 189: Earlier this year, German rights society GEMA took generative music platform Suno to court in Munich, and won - demonstrating legally that AI models memorise human compositions and then reproduce them. But...
Ep. 188: If you own an indie label, publishing company, or back-catalogue, there is a very high chance your IP is leaking revenue right now. Between messy global metadata, unclaimed rights, and passive distribution,...
Ep. 187: Back-office admin - from distribution and DSP analytics to neighbouring rights and D2C sales - remains a massive operational drain for indie labels, publishers, and self-releasing artists. In this episode, in...
Ep 186: Forget AI music for a moment: more humans are making music than ever before - and they're using powerful, accessible tools to do it. One of those tools is the digital audio workstation FL Studio - and we spoke...