Send us Fan Mail Can exercise cause pain, or can it be part of the solution? In this episode of the Move & Thrive Podcast, Dr Linda Steyn-Bodington (physiotherapist) and I explore the science behind musculoskeletal pain and how movement and exercise can help manage chronic conditions such as low back pain and fibromyalgia. We discuss the risks of inactivity, the benefits of small amounts of daily movement, preventing exercise-related injuries, and the role of fear of movement in pain management. Discover practical, evidence-based strategies to move safely, manage pain, and improve your quality of life. Remember: Movement is medicine, but the right movement and dosage matter! Please like, share and subscribe to Move & Thrive with Dr Siya_K, where science meets practical health. #MoveAndThrive #MusculoskeletalPain #ExerciseIsMedicine #Physiotherapy #PainManagement
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01What I like about exercise is a polypill that caters for various systems in your body, including musculoskeletal system. It is a medicine. Movement gives you life, movement heals, movement makes you mobile and functional. So today we're going to unpack that science and talk about what is it that we should be doing so that we can improve our musculoskeletal system because there's many musculoskeletal pains and disorders that we experience, back pains, neck pains.
SPEAKER_01How can exercise assist in that? I'm so fortunate today to be joined by a well-experienced physiotherapist, Dr. Linda Stein, who is also a leader. She has led the physiotherapy society, and she's doing a wonderful work in the musculoskeletal field. Welcome, Dr. Linda Stein. How are you doing?
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for having me, Dr. Kinene.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00No, I'm doing well. I'm doing well. I'm looking forward to our conversation. Yes. Sharing some insights and knowledge to your listeners out there. Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_01No, thank you so much. We we acknowledge the work that you do in leadership, leading the physiotherapy society. You've been a leader. Which period were you a leader of the physiotherapy society?
SPEAKER_00It was a while ago. So from about 2010 to 2014. Before that, I was also involved. After that, more just in actually helping lecture at the postgrade courses that the physio society run.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so you do a lot. You do teaching, you do leadership, you do clinical work and research. And you did your PhD when?
SPEAKER_00Oh, that was a long time ago. That was 2005.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I looked at the biomechanics of schoolboy rugby players for their necks. Okay. And then sort of had a program to prevent injury and to restore the biomechanical dysfunction. Okay. Okay.
SPEAKER_01And you're currently practicing as a physiotherapist? You run a business? Yeah. Tell us about your business.
SPEAKER_00So I'm in private practice with an associate. We're based at a school. So we see a lot of the sports injuries at the school. Okay. And then I'm also involved with the pain clinic. So right at the other end, people suffering with chronic pain. I work with a specialist anetist. Okay. Yeah. To help people with chronic pain. Dr.
SPEAKER_01Linda Stain is my physio. She checks my neck and all my problems that I experience as a runner, as a cyclist. Thank you so much for joining me. Today we're going to talk about exercises and musculoskeletal system, exercise and musculoskeletal pain disorders. What is musculoskeletal pain? What are we referring to? And what are the common musculoskeletal disorders that you see in your practice?
SPEAKER_00So I think the first interesting bit about the definition of pain is that it's a subjective experience of actual or potential tissue damage. In other words, we cannot assume that if there is damage, there is pain. And then we can also not assume that if there's pain, it means that there's damage. It doesn't correlate. So there's a lot of research that actually show that. I think that as a physiotherapist, understanding and listening to a patient when you have your interview with them and when you take the history, you have to try and establish their journey.
SPEAKER_00So whether they somebody that has never trained before, or if it's somebody that has trained their entire life and now all of a sudden they've developed pain. So why did they now feel pain? If they've been running or cycling or crossfitting forever, why would one day in a normal program they'll now have pain? So we also know that even in traumatic pain, you don't necessarily have pain. Or traumatic injury, you don't have pain.
SPEAKER_00So we see a lot of people that have had bad car accidents or something like that, and then they say they're fine. They don't need to go see a doctor because they maybe they will leave their muscles their their bodies and their muscles will heal.
SPEAKER_01So you're saying uh pain is a subjective thing.
SPEAKER_00Yes. It's your life experiences. So um we actually, it's the people around us when we're little. So if the first time you fall and you see blood, blood, but now if everybody around you then that starts to develop. Like, okay, so if there's blood, there must be pain type thing. I don't know. Sometimes you'll see a bruise on your body which equates to tissue damage, and you won't even remember where you picked it up.
SPEAKER_01Sure. What are the types of musculoskeletal problems or disorders or pain that we experience?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, by far the most uh is the low back pain.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00So that has become a worldwide problem. So some research say that it might even be up to a hundred percent of people out there in the world that might experience at least one episode of low back pain in their life. So the prevalence is very high. And unfortunately, what's happened is that the prevalence of that acute pain becoming a chronic problem is about one in five of people that develop low back pain where it will then become chronic.
SPEAKER_01Sure. So we're saying it's a common problem. Is it something that relates to activity or inactivity? What is the cause of back pain?
SPEAKER_00That's an interesting one because you the it's it actually is not just a sedentary person that would have low back pain. Okay, they are also prone. Um, most people, if you take a history, then they don't know where their back got hurt. I think I might have picked up something wrong, or um, I think I might have overtrained, but they can't actually pinpoint the exact incident like you would maybe sometimes get with uh uh a sports person that have sprained an ankle and they heard a pop or they felt the sharp pain, um, which is like they can pinpoint it to a specific episode.
SPEAKER_01Could be because of posture or something or inactivity.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that is a very interesting one. So there was a big study done to see if bad posture would predispose you developing low back pain, there's no link.
SPEAKER_01Sure.
SPEAKER_00No link.
SPEAKER_01So the way I sit will not necessarily mean I will have back pain.
SPEAKER_00No. So what we do know is that in some low back pain patients, sustained posture can be a contributing factor. So even if they sit perfectly, but they sit for two, three hours, and then they the pain starts coming on, maybe like after an hour or so, and then they don't move. I see. So their body's already warning them. That alarm system is is is telling them move, and they ignore that alarm, and they continue to sit, and they sit then to pain tolerance, not to onset of pain, then move.
SPEAKER_00Then then the posture might be an issue. So what we then can do is we we actually want them to move more. We don't necessarily want them to sit better.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so yeah, inactivity can be a contributor to pain, musculoskeletal pain. So, Doc, we talked about back pain as the common problem, musculoskeletal problem. What are the other musculoskeletal pain or disorders that we see commonly see in your practice?
SPEAKER_00So I'm in a very privileged position that the school that I work at they have lots of sports. So you tend to find specific injuries in specific sports. So with your maybe your long distance running, it'll be more overuse injuries, tendons, that sort of thing. In your sprinters, it will be muscle tears. In your netball players, it'll be ankle and knee ligament injuries. Rugby players, because it's a contact sport, and there's lots of injuries.
SPEAKER_01So in sports we see a lot of musculoskeletal problems that involves muscle, bones, cartilage, ligaments, and all of that. What about neck pains? Because I know myself I do sometimes struggle with neck pains. Uh, I always associate it with the work that I do, sitting on the laptop or sometimes with the running. What how common is neck pain?
SPEAKER_00It is very common, specific more so in sedentary um people or people that work at a desk a lot. So even if you're training um quite vigorously, um, I've got uh a New York Times article that I always tell my patients about, where it is the title of the um article is Sitting is the New Smoking.
SPEAKER_01Ooh, yeah, I've heard of this.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So if you sit for more than an hour without getting up, it equates to smoking six cigarettes.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And it negates half an hour of training. So that's the important bit. So if I sit for eight hours, even if I train an hour a day, the effect on the circulation is actually quite traumatic. And we know that so many lifestyle diseases are linked to just bad physical activity habits, long sitting habits, all of those kind of things.
SPEAKER_01Sure, sure. And you emphasize a lot about inactivity as the contributor to these problems. Yes. Um what about osteoarthritis or rheumatoid arthritis? Because it's one of the skeletal conditions where there's issues with joints. Can you just explain what type of condition is that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so osteoarthritis is actually a very, very interesting one now. So historically, we used to believe that it's a wear and tear model.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00So the more wear and tear you put on a specific joint, the more degenerative changes you'll see in that joint in terms of cartilage or if it's a lumbar or disc segment in the whole segment. We now know that there's a huge biochemical component as well.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00So in other words, if somebody's overweight, for example, they are five times more likely to develop OA in the knee. Women, men six times more often. Okay. Then they started looking, okay, but why? Why does it happen? And then they found that if you have symptoms of metabolic syndrome, in other words, you're not active, you're already a type 2 diabetic, you've already got high blood pressure, um, those kinds of things would then markedly increase your likelihood of developing osteoarthritis in your joints.
SPEAKER_01So it becomes a systemic problem.
SPEAKER_00It's a systemic problem.
SPEAKER_01Is it linked to um is it an issue of inflammation that is there?
SPEAKER_00So it's like a low grade inflammation. So it's not active inflammation like we see when you've sprained a joint and it's red and swollen. It's not that, but it's a constant low grade inflammation in the tissue of the joint.
SPEAKER_01Would you link it to lifestyle?
SPEAKER_00For sure. Yeah, in terms of the food we eat, does it the food, the sleep, the physical activity, those are the big ones.
SPEAKER_01I see, I see.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Because I've re I read somewhere that if your body is acidic, I mean there are foods that are causing acid in our bodies, and that can lead to inflammation and inflammation of joints as well. So so osteoarthritis is a lifestyle issue. It's a lifestyle condition.
SPEAKER_00You do get the I think for me the biggest um example would be Bruce Fordyce.
SPEAKER_01I see.
SPEAKER_00So he doesn't have a lifestyle issue, he has a probably an 80% wear and tear issue of all the years and years of I I'm assuming just the number of kilometers run on his knees and maybe not having the strength and doing enough strength training, like we know we need to do. Um but but definitely that would be an example of somebody that has more wear and tear than metabolic issues.
SPEAKER_01So you're saying also wear and tear is an issue. So we attended a Congress, a physio congress, uh, some years ago, and there were presentations to say it is not true that when you run, you destroy your joints. Yes, there is acute you know effects of running, but there's no long-term unless if you are really overdoing it. This wear and tear we talk of and always associating arthritis with running or with loading the joints too much, somehow the research says that's not true.
SPEAKER_01What is your take on that?
SPEAKER_00If you um if you load any joint within its limits and you recover properly before you load it again, you shouldn't pick up a problem. I see. The problem comes that if you overload, you don't wait until your tissues have recovered, and then you overload again and you don't wait and you overload again. So then you're getting um like almost a constant inflammation in a in a joint. Okay, but the the opposite side of that is if you are strong enough to manage the load that you put on your joints, it should also not be overload.
SPEAKER_03I see.
SPEAKER_00So in the short term, you reduce the load so that your body can heal. But in the long term, you need to make sure that your body can manage the load.
SPEAKER_01I see, I see. So osteoarthritis, so what about rheumatoid arthritis? What's the difference between the two?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so that's very different. So your rheumatoid arthritis is an autoimmune disease. In other words, it's like your body's attacking itself. We actually, there is a small genetic component, but an autoimmune disease, I think, from personal experience, is on the rise in our society. We don't quite know why.
SPEAKER_01Do you think it's linked to lifestyle as well?
SPEAKER_00They haven't made an official link yet. Um, because you also get it very often in people that are active and healthy. I see. It's something that happens or triggers. We don't know yet exactly what.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Talk about fibromyalgia. What what is that?
SPEAKER_00So fibromyalgia is like um they used to think it was only a muscle issue. In other words, they defined 20 spots in the body, and if you pushed on every single one of them and your patient was sore, that was the diagnosis. We know now it's a little bit more complicated, and there's a very real gut component as well.
SPEAKER_03Oh.
SPEAKER_00And we see that a lot of irritable bowel syndrome, IBS patients um also have fibromyalgia or chronic pain.
SPEAKER_01So is that is that uh the pain that you feel all over your body? How does how does somebody with that present?
SPEAKER_00So very often it's a it's a it's a vicious cycle. So when they first start hurting, it's very painful to move. So they move less.
SPEAKER_01Painful what?
SPEAKER_00Muscle.
SPEAKER_01Muscles okay.
SPEAKER_00So fibromyalgia is more muscle.
SPEAKER_01Muscle, okay.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Then they move less. Then they become weaker, so they can manage less load on their muscle system. So now it becomes they move less and less and less and less until eventually they pretty much disabled. I see, I see. A lot of them.
SPEAKER_01You know, I want us to go a little bit backwards to look at chronic pain. There's a concept called catastrophizing. Oh, yeah. A lot of patients have that. What is that?
SPEAKER_00It also very uh we as healthcare professionals are sometimes at fault because our patient is trying to tell us about their pain. And if they get even like an inkling that we're not believing them, they start using language like it feels like the muscle is tearing off the bone. Or I can hear my joint is cracking, the bones are are moving apart, or they're moving, yes.
SPEAKER_00Um, because they want to to convince you of how serious their pain is, and the more you ignore them and don't like want to acknowledge their what the narrative that they're giving you, the more they up the wording. Just so that you believe, so that you believe and take them seriously.
SPEAKER_01So, what does that do to them? Does it make the pain worse in a way if they believe it's that you know big of a problem? Because I've come across a patient who came complaining of back pain, not moving, afraid of moving, but once you explain what is happening, that there's no damage, it's just maybe an issue of posture, muscles are weak, this and that, they start to move and they start to believe that there's not much of a problem, then pain reduces. I think it goes back to what you were saying that pain is subjective.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and if your environment is encouraging pain, and if you tell yourself stories about or convince yourself of what is happening in your body, you tend to feel pain more if you believe that your spine is broken.
SPEAKER_00Belief system is very important. So you have to understand where the patient is coming from, yeah, but your own belief system is just as important.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00So, in other words, if somebody comes, our first job is to reassure someone.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00If they're in chronic pain, the message we need to convey is that there is hope.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00There's always hope for your condition to improve. If it's an acute pain, you need to explain to them how the body heals. In other words, if they've had a scan or an ultrasound or anything like that, and the doctor drew like this big red circle around the problem, and then they tell you, look how bad this is. The doctor said it's the worst one he's ever seen. That the message they're getting is that same doctor doesn't tell them that it's going to heal.
SPEAKER_00So you, as a healthcare professional, need to put it into perspective. So even if something's broken, you put it in a cost, and after six weeks it's healed. If it's a bit more severe, you give them a timeline to explain how long it takes the tissue to heal. If now the pain then continues past where you won't expect for physiological healing, that is then classified as chronic pain. And now you need to understand what is driving that pain.
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_00Is it overload? Is it fear? Is it catastrophizing? Is it a belief system? It might be something as as simple as changing a pillow.
SPEAKER_01Which is something I need to do, I realize with my neck issues.
SPEAKER_00So because if you're not sleeping properly and you're waking up often during the night in pain, then your body doesn't recover.
SPEAKER_01I see. I see. Yeah. I see. You know, it reminds me of a story I had. Someone was uh narrating a story of a man walking in the bush, and he was he felt something by his ankle, and then he didn't take it seriously. Then he went and then we got home, the ankle was big, swollen, and then they realized no, it's a snake that beat you. Then after that, some days later, he got recovered, and then later he walked again. Then he felt something scratchy, he was screaming of pain. He was, and then the doctor said, No, nothing wrong.
SPEAKER_01Chances are it's just some wood that scratched you. The question is, why did you feel so much pain the second time? Does that explain how pain is subjective?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so that that would be an example of his life experience telling him something. Okay, so there was a very high stress level when they start they realized that there was a snake bite. So that upped the sensitization of the system.
SPEAKER_03I see.
SPEAKER_00Dramatically, life-threatening, if it was a poisonous snake. Okay, so in other words, the link of your body is if you think of the pain as a protective mechanism, it's an alarm telling your body, check this, might be something wrong. Last time I ignored what my body was telling me, and it was very serious. This time it feels like the same sensation. So my body goes into that same stress response that maybe there's something serious going on now.
SPEAKER_01Sure. Let's talk solutions now. We're talking exercise is medicine. How can exercise be a solution to these all these problems?
SPEAKER_00There isn't one musculoskeletal issue that is not fixable with exercise. Not one. Even the worst of the pathologies.
SPEAKER_01Including injury.
SPEAKER_00Including injury. It's about the dosing.
SPEAKER_01I see.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So if it's an acute injury and there's maybe an instability or a reason not to load that area, you you will still do what we call active rest or active recovery.
SPEAKER_01What does it mean?
SPEAKER_00So that area that is injured might have to be supported in a brace or unloaded for the physiological healing to happen. But the rest of your body should.
SPEAKER_01Must must move, yeah.
SPEAKER_00The rest of your body must move.
SPEAKER_01I see.
SPEAKER_00If it's an ankle, you can go to gym and you can train knee, hip, core, shoulders. You can use a a cardio piece of cardio equipment where you're only using your arms like the ski erg. I see. Or you can use maybe one of those assault bikes where you can still use your arms and you just put that one foot just to keep the body moving.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Okay.
SPEAKER_00Because you want to get oxygen to wherever there's a there's a problem.
SPEAKER_01Talking acute injury, maybe due to inju an incident that happened, you talk of immobilization of the area for some time. Will that be the time where you allow inflammation to subside? At what point do you do you start exercising?
SPEAKER_00Weak at the very most that you think of a post-operative patient.
SPEAKER_03Yes.
SPEAKER_00We get them out of bed and they've got to move that limb very quickly after the surgery. There's so much research to say early mobilization is is better. It's better.
SPEAKER_01The sooner you exercise, the sooner you move, the better.
SPEAKER_00The only difference is if something is unstable. So if there's a severe ligament tear where fracture where the joint is rendered immobile. But even that, so think of ten years ago, one would say that every single complete ACL rupture needed surgery. Now we know that if you brace them, even in a complete tear, that ligament can attach onto the bone again in as little as six weeks.
SPEAKER_01I see. I see.
SPEAKER_00So there's so few injuries that actually require surgery as being better than conservative treatment. What we do get, however, is that with surgery you buy time.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00It's it so most of the research shows that in the first year, say for instance we we talk meniscus or uh shoulder rotator cuff or something like that. In the first year, the outcomes look a bit better in the surgical group, but in five years down the line, they are patients are generally better off not having had surgery. So I know the surgeons might not agree, but that is what the research showed.
SPEAKER_01Tell me about your recent injury. You just told me about your bike uh related injury. What were you doing?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, um I I had uh uh bob wire wrapped around my my leg. While you are riding. While I'm riding, I didn't see it. It was um in the grass. So that it essentially wrapped around my boot plus hooked onto um the foot peg of my bike.
SPEAKER_03Sure.
SPEAKER_00And the bike stopped and I continued. And then so that was like a a torsion type injury.
SPEAKER_01Sure, sure, sure. Yeah. Where did you injure yourself?
SPEAKER_00My knee meniscus, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And then how bad is that?
SPEAKER_00So um I said to the sports physician that I saw, I'm not considering surgery.
SPEAKER_01Was he suggesting surgery?
SPEAKER_00No, no. Uh even before he could suggest it. Yeah. So then he sort of He mustn't even think about it. Yeah. What else can we do?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Um, so I went for PRP injections, the platelet injections. I see. I had a series of those, and then I started rehab.
SPEAKER_01What do they help with those platelet injections?
SPEAKER_00Um, so they do help with the recovery process. So that actually is like if you think of the platelets as being the glue in your blood. So it facilitates exiting a little bit of extra glue to help heal the injury.
SPEAKER_01So you got that and what else?
SPEAKER_00Then the rehab.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00Just that and rehab.
SPEAKER_01Rehab mean would include exercise. What type of rehab were you talking about?
SPEAKER_00So slowly starting to load the knee again in available range. Okay. And so my general rule for rehab is what you do today you don't pay for tomorrow. So we don't want that inflammatory reaction every time after you've exercised. And then so if you load your your any injured area today, you should be able to recover that load during the night when you sleep. So because that's when the tissue healing happens. I see.
SPEAKER_00And the recovery happens. The next morning you should be better than the day before.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00So, um, and then you always slowly progress. So it's about progressive overload.
SPEAKER_03I see.
SPEAKER_00So as soon as you can do something, you have to then make it a little bit harder. So you can't stick to the exercises that you did in week one and think it's going to make your knees strong.
SPEAKER_01I see.
SPEAKER_00As soon as it's easy, you've got to keep on progressing.
SPEAKER_01So the the the exercises include that mobility.
SPEAKER_00Yes, and then loading with an external weight eventually when walking wasn't sore anymore. I see. Squats, lunges. Okay.
SPEAKER_01Do they just strengthen the muscles or all the soft tissue and the joint itself?
SPEAKER_00The the actual soft tissue as well. So what we do know is that if you never put strain on soft tissue, it will be weak.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So principles of training means overload. Yes, you're challenging the soft tissues with load, either with stretch or with strengthening.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so with your um with your non-contractile, so like your ligament and your tendon that can't contract, you can physically improve the sense tensile strength of that structure by progressing um load on it. So if you never load it, it stays weak. Okay. So say for instance you did hurt a ligament and you put it, you decide to wear a brace because it feels so much better in the brace. And you never train without the brace, the ligament will stay weak.
SPEAKER_01Sure.
SPEAKER_00Because it's it's never under load or strain. Okay.
SPEAKER_01So early mobilization, early exercise is is is now proven to be effective. How are you feeling with the re much better?
SPEAKER_00I can run now.
SPEAKER_01I saw you climbing stairs just.
SPEAKER_00Yes, and there's actually climbing downstairs was the most difficult for me.
SPEAKER_01Do you think you would have done all of this moving around, climbing stairs without exercise rehab?
SPEAKER_00No way.
SPEAKER_01If you stayed immobile, because I know the people who believe if you are injured, you must just keep it immobile.
SPEAKER_00I had a very good example only this morning of somebody that had a lumbar fusion.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00And the doctor said to them they're not allowed to bend. They didn't give a time frame of when they can start bending again.
SPEAKER_01I just said don't don't Don't bend.
SPEAKER_00Don't pick up anything, don't bend, then you'll be fine. Okay. He's still not bending. He is still not bending. So like how do you pick up anything off the floor? No, he's got all these fancy grab um assist handles and that. Which one's only supposed to use for the first six weeks? Because yes, in the first six weeks, while the bone is still being fused, you don't bend. Yes. Depending on what kind of surgery you had.
SPEAKER_00But after that, it's that progressive, gradually getting the the movement and the mobility and the strength back.
SPEAKER_01I'm sure if in you during the period of immobility you still do your isometric exercises, you still move your muscles without really moving joints.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so that's an example of where there's an instability where you don't want the unstable area to move, but definitely everything around that must and should move. So yeah.
SPEAKER_01Now I see how exercise is medicine in the rehabilitation after an injury, and I see you are leading by example as a physio. How else can exercise be a solution? Um, just talk maybe chronic pain now. We're talking lower back pain, neck pain, due to behavior, how we sit. We talked about the causes of all of that. How is exercise? Give an example of how exercise is helpful for back pain, for example.
SPEAKER_00I quite like an article that was published in 2023. They call it the fit-for-purpose model.
SPEAKER_01I see. Okay.
SPEAKER_00So, in other words, with each patient, you need to set a goal for them. How strong do they need to be? Or what would they like to do? And say for instance, it's a 65-year-old lady who has grandkids and she wants to play with her grandkids. Now she's every time she has to babysit the grandkids, she's in agony because her back just cannot manage the load.
SPEAKER_00So then I would say to her, okay, so how heavy are your grandkids? How much do they weigh? And they say maybe 15 kilos. Then I say, We need to get your spine strong enough to manage 15 kilograms.
SPEAKER_01I see.
SPEAKER_00So that is a goal then. Then it then we start low. And it might mean so they might ask them, can you pick up a water bottle? Like a 500mm water bottle. Of course I can do that. I said, Well, that's picking up. So that's where we start. Something that the the patient is comfortable doing doing that aggravating activity that they are scared of, so that we can then teach them gradually we can get you stronger without flaring up your back.
SPEAKER_01Getting stronger to the point of ending up lifting your kids one day. I like that. The goal is specific to what the patient is wanting to do with it.
SPEAKER_00Which would be very different to somebody that's a power lifter that have hurt their back. They also have chronic pain because maybe they've constantly overloaded their spines and they're in a chronic pain state. But they want to compete.
SPEAKER_01I see.
SPEAKER_00So for them, you have to how heavy do they want to load? How how you know, so you adapt it and adjust it to them and you start them low. You ask them, would it be so if you um did your weightlifting with 10 kilos? No, 10 kilos is fine. Then you start there and you build up. So you find a baseline that is non-threatening and you still you slowly build that up.
SPEAKER_01So is that the framework fit for purpose you're referring to?
SPEAKER_00So fit for purpose also has a they say that low back pain, chronic low back pain, they explained it as an information problem.
SPEAKER_01Information.
SPEAKER_00Information problem. Okay. So I hurt my back first time round. The doctor said I have to bed rest for three days. So if I lie down and I don't move, I'm not sore. When I move, I'm sore. So in other words, the message then becomes do less.
SPEAKER_01Because don't move. Because it's movement causes pain.
SPEAKER_00So now we need to teach them, but that's their belief system now. Movement equals pain.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_00The back gets hurt quite easily. The the spine is fragile. So we're teaching with our information, maybe we're teaching people that the spine doesn't have resilience. And now we need to change the information. If they then Google their symptoms, they will find injections, medication, machines, nothing about being able to move safely.
SPEAKER_01I see.
SPEAKER_00So now you will be the healthcare professional to explain to them. Allow the tissues to heal, maybe we brace you for a week or two.
SPEAKER_03I see.
SPEAKER_00If moving hurts you that badly. Or strap or do something to support until the physiological healing takes place and then we move. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So movement is is is is the solution to these to these challenges. Give me some basic exercises for somebody. I know you said lower back pain is a common problem. What type of exercises should I be doing right now? A listener wants to just start something. What can you give as an example?
SPEAKER_00Are they already in pain?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so what um provokes pain is very important. Okay. So if you've you know muscle memory.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00So if I've learned how to ride my bike and I've not I don't ride for 10 years, I'll still be able to get like pedaling bike, I'll still be able to get on a bike and pedal. I might not be as good as I was 10 years ago, but I I know how to muscle better, better than somebody that's never done it before. Okay, unfortunately, you also get pain memory. So if with the same movement you keep provoking the symptoms, like for instance, my belief system might be, and I've read somewhere I need to do sit-ups to strengthen my core.
SPEAKER_00But every time when I do sit-ups, it hurts. But I'm just working through it. I'm then saying to my body, sit-ups equals pain. So now I have to teach my body sit-ups do not equal pain. So maybe if I make the range smaller, I make the less reps, or um, I use a ball instead of lying on the floor, and then the pain is less. So, in other words, I'm modifying the symptoms, still getting that same exercise, but doing it in such a way that it doesn't provoke the pain.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so that's whatever triggers the pain, one has to you can't just not do that exercise. You've got to get used to doing the exercise and starting low and going slow. So that's the first important thing. Then the next is I like loading a spine.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_00So for me, it's very important. For women, even more so, because we know that by loading the spine, um you actually even get better bone density.
SPEAKER_01I see. Loading how?
SPEAKER_00So the one big study that they did with women for bone mineral density was deadlifts and squats.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So proper load.
SPEAKER_01That will help to load this brain.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And then they followed through for a year, and the bone density actually improved more than with medication.
SPEAKER_03Wow, wow.
SPEAKER_00So twice a week, the actual work sessions were 10 minutes, so there's a warm-up and a cool down before and after. And every six weeks they did a new one rep max for the squat and the deadlift and adjusted the load accordingly. Sure, sure. Yeah. You have to also understand what the patient enjoys. Because if they're not somebody that enjoys to go to the gym, you will not convince them. You might have to start something like Tai Chi or Yoga or Pilates or something else that they might enjoy more.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Would running be considered as a loading exercise?
SPEAKER_00So let's use and ask the question to the patient: is it sore to run? Does your back hurt when you run? If it doesn't hurt when you run, you you must run.
SPEAKER_03Okay. Yeah. Okay, okay, okay.
SPEAKER_00If it causes pain, you must find out why. Then you look at the different um maybe contributing factors like a leg possible leg length discrepancy or the shoes or the stabilizers, and then you address that in a rehab program or you adjust that and then you test again.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Oh, wonderful.
SPEAKER_01Now I've read somewhere that exercise does relieve pain. Yes. And there's through a pain gauge theory. Is that true that exercise when you as much as it will be painful as you start moving, but that movement will actually take away pain in a way? How does that concept work? Because it yes, it's hurting when I'm moving, but that same movement will make me better, will reduce my level of pain. How does it work?
SPEAKER_00So there's two big principles. The first one, there must never be a threat value to the pain.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00So it mustn't be a pain that your patient is worried about. So say for example, you know DOMS, delayed muscle on soreness.
SPEAKER_01Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01The one you get when you've just exercised, you feel your muscles are sore after it.
SPEAKER_00And even the next day and the day after, if you've had a good workout. Yes. Okay. So we know that if it's somebody that's used to training, for them it's not a fearful, they know if they work hard, they're going to be sore. Okay, so the experience tells them not to be worried about this pain. If it is a pain that you are worried about, then you need to address it and speak to a healthcare professional about it. Don't just then keep on moving.
SPEAKER_00It might feel better while you're exercising, but the next day it's even worse. Okay. So that's that's different. What we do know is if it's non-threatening pain, then it releases endorphins. So your brain doesn't release endorphins if it doesn't train into pain. So that I often say to my my patients, is if you just walk casually, then the motion is lotion applies.
SPEAKER_00But you won't get that endorphin release. I see that a lot of athletes are hooked to exercise. So they want that feel-good hormones released. Okay. So then you've got to drain into a bit of pain.
SPEAKER_01So, in a way, with that release of those hormones, then pain in a way reduces.
SPEAKER_00Yes, directly. So you get um from the tissue, you get the local response from for the pain gaze. So there's some mechanical forces working in it, and then you get um on a spinal level, you inhibit the pain. I see. And then you get from the brain down the endorphins the pain.
SPEAKER_01Wonderful. This is amazing to know that exercise can be a solution to the pain you are experiencing, whether lower back pain or neck pain or even arthritis, movement is the solution. What would you say to somebody sitting at home listening to this and is going through pain? What would be your advice?
SPEAKER_00I think the most important is to find a healthcare professional that understands chronic pain. Okay. Because it is not something that is necessarily taught to like a level of excellence undergrad. So that is like if you have to do some courses, postgraduate courses to really get to understand how to treat someone in chronic pain. The term that we use it very often is that you need to understand how to do psychologically informed rehabilitation or cognitive functional therapy.
SPEAKER_00Those are the kind of terms that you might then ask, does your physiotherapist have they done courses in to be able to help you?
SPEAKER_01I see.
SPEAKER_00Um, I also think it's very important that the idea must be that the healthcare professional becomes a coach.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_00It's not about I have this silver bullet magic technique that I'm going to do for you, um, I'm gonna put a needle in, or I'm gonna do this manipulation, or I'm gonna do that, and then you're gonna be pain free. It's not that. We know that touching someone helps them. We do know that. But then you have to coach them. In other words, you need to teach them how to take care of themselves. So maybe you you will see them once a week to start, but then you've got to make it every second week and see if they cope.
SPEAKER_00And they've got to give you feedback and they've got to journal so that they understand what triggers the pain. Then you speak about how to do things differently and how to modify and how to gradually increase the load. Then every three weeks until such time that they actually don't need you.
SPEAKER_01I see. Yeah, I see. And I know you do a lot of education around the pain. Yes. How much of education do we do as physiosists, or do you say education is part of the management of pain?
SPEAKER_00A very big part. Okay. Because if we think of the the fit for purpose article where it's an information problem.
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_00So we need to build a trust relationship with our patients so that we can trust convince them to try the techniques that we coach, I see. Which is different to what they Google. The solution is different to what they Google. And then The more they improve, the more they will trust you. And then you can give them proper education and proper information. Because eventually, what we want to do essentially, the person that's in chronic pain will not reach the required exercise dosage to stay healthy.
SPEAKER_00They just it's too sore. Because that's the ultimate goal. The goal is to get them to be able to do enough exercise so that they can reverse the lifestyle problems.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, good. Lastly, as we come to the end, we talked about exercise as something that must be given in a dose because it's all about how much of it. If you do too much of it, you might hurt yourself. If you do too little, you might not gain the benefit. How much is prescription important? Maybe somebody's listening and think, oh, exercise is good, and then I must just do, but you must be careful how you do it. How much is dosage important?
SPEAKER_00The dosage is super important and initially the rate of recovery is what's going to dictate how quickly you can progress.
SPEAKER_02I see.
SPEAKER_00So you can't progress quicker than what your body can recover between sessions. So that is very different to somebody in their twenties versus somebody in their 60s.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So the effect has to be considered here.
SPEAKER_00Yes, there's other factors one has to take in consideration. Is it somebody that have maybe trained for a long time and then took a break and wants to come back? Or is it somebody I often see school kids that have never exercised? They're 18 years old, they haven't ever participated in they've you have to start them very low and dose very small and make sure that you don't overload. Because if you if they get hurt, they're gonna stop.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00So if I get the comrades athlete that have they consistently overtrained, my dosage is going to be to calm them down, not up.
SPEAKER_01Up with the exercise prescription, yeah. Yeah, no, that's good. So what I hear is it's important to know the type of exercise, important to know the intensity, the frequency, the duration of all of these are uh are variables, uh components of exercise prescription. Who is who is who is fit to give that prescription? Can I just decide on my own this is how I want to do it, or I need like like medication, you need a doctor, if you're not so and you're healthy.
SPEAKER_01Whether whether you are so or not, but as a way to do it correctly and know how to prescribe it correctly, who is fit to advise on that?
SPEAKER_00I still think that you need to find somebody that really understands exercise and training. And um, so in other words, if it's a healthcare professional, it needs to be somebody that is um there for me, there's scope of profession. So if as a physiotherapist, by profession, I should be able to do that.
SPEAKER_02I see.
SPEAKER_00But say for instance, I only work in a hospital in the ICU, and I never do exercise prescription for someone, then I might not be the best person because it's not my scope of practice, it's not what I do every day. But if I work with a sports team, I'm a physiotherapist for a sports team, um, then I'll I'll be the perfect person to help you.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So among physiotherapists, you'll have to still check which one is relevant for your condition. Because I know there's musculoskeletal physiotherapists like yourself, there's sports physiotherapists, there's neurophysiotherapists, pits, there's different uh fields within physiotherapy. So it's important to go to the relevant therapist that can give you the relevant uh treatment or rehabilitation for your problem.
SPEAKER_00So, say for instance, somebody is trained as a strength and conditioning coach and you don't have any pain, that person will also be perfect. You don't have to see uh a physiotherapist. You can also see a biokinetist as well. Yes. Yeah, so there's definitely many professions out there that can help you, but you need to set your goal.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00That I I think that's important. Decide what you enjoy, set a goal, and then go with somebody that can help achieve that goal.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much, Dr. Linda Stein, for your time. And thank you for confirming that um exercise is medicine. We've been talking exercise medicine, how it's medicine for cancer, for high blood pressure. It's a poly pill, it's something that caters for all the problems that we experience. Unfortunately, many of us do not use it enough. Professionals do not prescribe it enough. But I think it's time now to consider it because there are gonna be many problems that would be solved through exercise.
SPEAKER_00For sure.
SPEAKER_01Any last word?
SPEAKER_00Maybe I'll speak to the physios out there. Okay, okay, especially musculoskeletal physios.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00In the words of um Professor Jeremy Lewis, who has recently published an article to say that you have to understand the context of your patient and their lifestyle. And if we think as physiotherapists, if you prescribe um a couple of rehab exercises and you do a couple of manual therapy techniques, but you do not address the lifestyle issues of the patient, that you will be successful, you are fooling yourself.
SPEAKER_00You have good got to look at the patient as a whole, and we are responsible to help people be healthy, not just be pain free.
SPEAKER_01Wow, wow, yeah. Thank you so much. Thank you so much for that. Thank you for tuning in to Move and Thrive, where science meets practical health. Thank you so very much. And please remember to subscribe, share the links so that many people can benefit from these discussions.
Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we talk about change - and how to move from struggling with healthy habits to sustaining a healthy lifestyle. We acknowledge that changing our habits is not always easy. There is often...
Send us Fan Mail Can exercise help prevent cancer? Can it reduce cancer-related fatigue and support recovery during and after treatment? Join me (Dr Siyabonga Kunene) and renowned oncology rehabilitation expert Prof...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode of Move & Thrive, I’m joined by Michael Alves, a physiotherapist and academic, for an important conversation about the science of physical inactivity and the consequences of living a...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode, I sit down with Professor Georgia Torres, an exercise physiologist, to explore the science behind exercise and why movement truly is medicine. We unpack what it means to say "exercise...
Send us Fan Mail What really happens to your body when you don't exercise? In this evidence-based episode we explore how physical inactivity affects your muscles, heart, brain, metabolism, immune system, and overall...