In this crime recap, Heather (solo) discusses some of the latest headlines. A shocking South Carolina rescue, celebrity crime, and two trials... Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/mountain-murders--3281847/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey y'all, welcome back to Mountain Murderers. I'm Heather, and today I've got a round of crime headlines, and I have to tell you, some of these stories are absolutely unbelievable. As you know, if you listened to last episode, The Murderer of Ferlin Bryant, Dylan has started a new job, and we're hoping to kind of level out our recording time and episodes, but until then, I thought I would drop a midweek on ya. Yup, that's right, you got me just soloed. Flying solo today.
Speaker 2Oh gosh, I know. Poor you guys. I'm definitely going to miss Dylan after this one.
Speaker 1So today we're going to talk about a baby found alive after being buried underground in South Carolina, a deadly incident aboard a luxury cruise ship, and some major developments in criminal cases that are making national headlines. So grab your coffee, settle in, prepare yourself. We've got a lot to unpack. Now, we're starting with a story right here in South Carolina, and this one is absolutely horrifying. An 11-month-old baby named Koa Sharp was found alive after authorities say he spent approximately 24 hours buried underground inside a
Speaker 1dog crate. According to the Lexington County Sheriff's Department, Koa disappeared Monday after being left in the care of his father, 25-year-old Michael Comer. Deputies eventually located Comer, but the baby was nowhere to be found. Nearly 100 first responders participated in the search, and on Tuesday afternoon, searchers noticed freshly disturbed dirt in a wooded area near the home of the baby's paternal grandfather. And then something extraordinary happened. So as they began digging, they heard a baby crying, and
Speaker 1little Koa was inside a dog crate wrapped in a towel and buried beneath the dirt. Somehow, it's a miracle, he was still alive. Sheriff Jay Kuhn said investigators believe that the towel may have created an air pocket that helped the baby survive. Koa was rushed to the hospital for medical treatment. Comer had initially been arrested on burglary and resisting arrest charges, and investigators were working with prosecutors to determine some additional charges. So as of the initial reports,
Speaker 1the full circumstances surrounding this terrible fucking incident are still under investigation. Now, this is the kind of story that makes me physically sick to my stomach. An 11-month-old baby is completely helpless, right? I mean, he can't defend himself, escape, or even explain what is happening. And the fact that rescuers heard him crying underground, I mean, that's something those first responders will probably never forget. Of course, I will keep you posted as more information comes out about this case,
Speaker 1but I'm really interested in this timeline. Like what did investigators learn after finding Michael Comer and what led them to search that particular wooded area? As a society, I think we need to be having a bigger discussion about child protection and also, you know, how quickly a missing child investigation can become a race against time. This is a perfect example of that. What would have happened if investigators hadn't noticed that disturbed dirt? And I have another question,
Speaker 1and maybe some of you out there are first responders and you can fill me in on this, but how do you first responders process a rescue this traumatic? Our next story involves a former Massachusetts police detective, a young pregnant woman, and a death that was originally investigated.
Speaker 2As a suicide.
Speaker 1So former Staunton police detective Matthew Farwell has been convicted of murdering 23-year-old Sandra Birchmore and her unborn child. Birchmore was found dead inside her apartment in February of 2021. Investigators initially concluded that she had taken her own life, but federal prosecutors eventually presented a very different account. According to prosecutors, Farwell began sexually abusing Birchmore when.
Speaker 2She was just 15 years old.
Speaker 1And that was after meeting her through a police like youth program. Now at the time, this dude was 27. This relationship continued for years and prosecutors argued that Farwell killed Birchmore because he feared she would expose this sexual abuse. And gosh, what a creep this guy is. So the FBI reopened the investigation and they uncovered thousands of text messages and evidence that that ended up challenging that original suicide determination. So on November 10th, a federal jury found
Speaker 1Farwell guilty of killing a witness or victim and killing an unborn child. So he faces a mandatory life sentence. There are so many disturbing layers to this case, but one of the biggest is that imbalance of power. Sandra met this man through a program that was supposed to introduce young people to law enforcement. And instead, prosecutors demonstrated that he exploited that access. And then there's the original investigation. How does a death get classified as a suicide when the person responsible is a police officer with a documented
Speaker 1relationship to the victim? I think it's worth asking whether investigators would have handled the scene differently if the suspect hadn't been one of their own. This is a powerful example of why families sometimes refuse to accept an official determination when the evidence doesn't add up.
Speaker 2So what do you guys think?
Speaker 1Should deaths involving police officers or their intimate partners automatically receive independent investigative review? And also, when it comes to these police departments, what safeguards could have protected Sandra as a teenager?
Speaker 2I mean, it just seems to me if.
Speaker 1You are in law enforcement and you have some kind of program like this for young people to come in and get this introduction to law enforcement, That there.
Speaker 2Should be more oversight.
Speaker 1I mean, how does a police officer get access to this young girl and have the ability to abuse her for so many years? And not only Farwell, but like other officers, including his brother, sexually abused this poor young girl. It's one of those cases that's really captured my attention. And Sandra Birchmore and her unborn child deserve justice. And I'm glad that Farwell has been found guilty. I mean, this guy's a creep, and there are so many other people,
Speaker 1it seems, involved in this. She was abused by multiple people, and they all need to be arrested, too.
Speaker 2That's disgusting.
Speaker 1You know, they all took advantage of a 15-year-old girl. Y'all know how we feel about that.
Speaker 2Here at Mountain Murders. Now, moving along to our next headline. Imagine boarding a cruise ship. You know, you're.
Speaker 1Expecting like a week of sunshine, cocktails, Caribbean beaches. And then the voyage becomes the scene of a homicide investigation. And just last year, you know, we had headlines about a young woman who was murdered aboard a cruise ship. A Texas man named Jason Leon Watford has been charged in connection with the death of a woman aboard MSC Seascape. Now, according to an FBI affidavit described in news reports, crew members discovered the woman dead on the floor of a
Speaker 1cabin on Sunday, which was the first day.
Speaker 2Of the cruise.
Speaker 1Watford was reportedly found sitting outside the cabin looking at his phone. And investigators say he acknowledged that he had snapped following some kind of verbal argument with the woman. The ship returned to Galveston where Watford was arrested and charged with felony homicide. So this case is now being handled through the federal criminal justice system. And I don't know about you, but the detail about him just sitting outside the cabin scrolling through his phone is unsettling. Cruise ship crimes present some unusual investigative challenges. And we've seen
Speaker 1this with like the Amy Bradley case and the Anna Kepner case because it did seem like the investigation took a very long time. It seemed like forever before charges were finally brought against her stepbrother. But, you know, you've got this moving vessel, potentially multiple jurisdictions. You've got thousands of passengers and a crime scene that investigators may not be able to access immediately.
Speaker 2But what stands out to me is.
Speaker 1How quickly this ordinary vacation turned into something tragic. When someone says they simply snapped during an argument, that deserves scrutiny, don't you think? An argument doesn't explain why you would kill somebody immediately. And it seems at this point investigators still have not established exactly what happened. From what I understand, Jason Watford, he's a 48-year-old Tyler, Texas man. He was
Speaker 1previously arrested in 2024 after a woman reported abuse and a history of violence inside the home. So once again, we have a man with a reported history of domestic violence admitting to killing a woman. I'm not sure what state it was, but someone was like proposing a domestic violence registry. Like if you're convicted of domestic violence, there should be a registry like a sex offender registry.
Speaker 2And you know what? I agree with that. I think there should be.
Speaker 1I do have some questions. I would like to know how are crime scenes preserved aboard cruise ships? And also, how much responsibility do cruise lines have for passenger safety? Just in light of these recent crimes, I mean, it just, you know, kind of comes to mind. Now, let's get into our next story. British comedian, actor, and media personality Russell Brand has been sentenced to 10 years and 6 months in prison following his conviction for rape and sexual assault. 51-year-old Brand was convicted of one count of rape and
Speaker 1three counts of sexual assault involving four women. And these offenses took place between... 2004 and 2009. Now the women did not know one another and prosecutors emphasize the emotional toll of coming forward and testifying about events that happened nearly two decades ago. The crown prosecution service said that brand used his growing celebrity status to and influence to create opportunities to exploit women. It's a tale as old as time, it seems. Famous men doing creepy things to
Speaker 1women because they're famous and they think they can get away with it. Now, one of the things that stands out here for me is the passage of time. I mean, we're talking about crimes that were committed, what, nearly 20 years ago? You know, in these cases, evidence becomes harder to locate, your memories can change, and victims may have spent years wondering whether anyone would believe them. But I think it also raises the issue of celebrity culture.
Speaker 2I mean, when someone is famous, rich, and surrounded by.
Speaker 1People whose livelihoods depend on their success, accountability can become complicated. And I think it's important to remember that a person's public persona doesn't tell us what happens behind closed doors. A question I see a lot is, why do survivors sometimes wait years to report sexual assault? And I think there's this persistent misconception that someone who's been sexually assaulted will immediately contact police, because in reality, delayed reporting is common, and there are many reasons someone might wait years or
Speaker 1just never report at all. You know, survivors may fear being judged, blamed, or accused of lying, which almost always seems to happen in these celebrity cases. Some worry that, you know, their personal lives, their sexual histories are going to become subjects of public scrutiny. You know, their reputations will be soiled or ruined. And we have to remember, you know, sexual assault can produce shock, avoidance, like fragmented recollections.
Speaker 1I mean, these are all trauma responses and some survivors need time before they feel emotionally prepared to talk about what happened to them. When the alleged perpetrator is like a celebrity or an authority figure, you know, like in the Sandra Birchmore case or your employer, survivors often feel like retaliation could happen.
Speaker 2They fear it.
Speaker 1And sometimes I believe nobody is going to take their accusation seriously. And as we know, in many sexual assault cases, they involve somebody the survivor knows. So reporting, you know, your friend's A colleague, a romantic partner, your family member. I mean, that can have enormous personal consequences.
Speaker 2And I think we often forget about that.
Speaker 1Survivors may worry about aggressive questioning, the disbelief, you know, the possibility that the investigation isn't going to lead to charges. A lot of victims have a distrust of the criminal justice system, and honestly, for good reason. Let's be so for real. You know, the criminal justice system is often not kind to victims. Something I always find interesting is how can prosecutors build cases involving these decades-old allegations? I mean, prosecuting a sexual assault case from 10, 20, 30 years
Speaker 1ago is challenging. But as we've seen, it isn't necessarily impossible. People always assume there's.
Speaker 2No evidence left.
Speaker 1And, you know, in some of these cases, I guess I naively kind of thought that as well. But, you know, we have to keep in mind that evidence isn't always DNA or fingerprints. Maybe a woman told a roommate what happened back in 2005, or, you know, maybe she wrote about it in a journal, or there could be an email from the accused that suddenly, like, takes on this whole new meaning. I mean, I think we've seen that in the Weinstein case. Investigators can start kind of putting those pieces together, and sometimes the result is like a clearer picture of what happened. But I think we also
Speaker 1have to understand the other side of this. You Documents can disappear. And defendants have a constitutional right to challenge the evidence against them, right? So the passage of time creates like real obstacles for everybody involved. And that's what makes these prosecutions so complicated because you have to take these allegations seriously while still maintaining the burden of proof required in a criminal courtroom. And here's something that bothers me about these celebrity sexual assault cases. You know, we
Speaker 1see people defending someone they've never actually met because they love their.
Speaker 2Movies or their music or their comedy.
Speaker 1And I understand being disappointed when someone you admire is accused of something terrible. James Franco comes to mind. I was madly in love with James Franco for many years. I mean, I still think he's quite a gorgeous man. But when these accusations came out about him, the way he was treating students at his acting school, I mean, all of that was really troubling. But we need to remind ourselves that being talented doesn't make somebody incapable of committing a crime. And at the same time, An accusation
Speaker 1isn't a conviction. I mean, we have to be willing to examine evidence rather than deciding someone's guilt or innocence based on whether we like them.
Speaker 2And then there's the money.
Speaker 1I mean, you're talking about an ordinary person making an allegation against somebody who can afford like a team of lawyers and public relations professionals. I mean, that's a pretty intimidating situation. And what really gets me is how differently we sometimes treat accusations, like depending on who the accused happens to be. Like if it's somebody we dislike, we're ready to believe the worst. And if it's somebody we've admired for 20 years, suddenly we're looking for every possible reason that this accusation just simply could not be true.
Speaker 1And I think that says something uncomfortable about how celebrity culture shapes our understanding of justice. And ultimately, I think these cases force us to confront something bigger than one celebrity or one criminal prosecution or We have a society where people who experience sexual violence spend years wondering sometimes whether it's safe to tell anybody. And then the justice system has to balance the rights of the accused with the need to investigate these serious allegations, like even when
Speaker 1these decades have passed. And we have a celebrity culture that sometimes confuses admiration with actual knowledge of a person's character. And I think the question worth asking is this, you know, are we equally interested in justice when the accused is somebody we admire? I mean, because accountability shouldn't depend on wealth or fame or popularity. You know, how many people bought your last album? I think it always needs to depend on facts and evidence and the law.
Speaker 2And lastly, you know, time.
Speaker 1Goes by so quickly when we don't have Dylan here to offer up his insightful commentary. Dylan, we miss you. We're going to revisit a murder that made headlines back in 2023. Nima Momini, and I know I just butchered that, so excuse me, guys. The tech consultant convicted of killing Cash App founder Bob Lee has been sentenced to 16 years to life in prison. Lee was stabbed to death in San Francisco back in April of 2023, and initially
Speaker 1his death sparked widespread speculation about just like random street violence in the city. But investigators discovered that, you know, Bob Lee actually knew his attacker. Prosecutors argued that the killing followed a personal dispute involving Momini's sister. Momini claimed that he acted in self-defense, but the jury rejected that argument and convicted him of second-degree murder in December of 2024. On November 10th of 2026, the judge denied Momini's request
Speaker 1for a new trial and imposed the prison sentence. So, His attorneys have indicated that they plan to appeal. I think what makes this case particularly interesting is the difference between the initial public narrative and the facts investigators eventually established. Before police had identified a suspect, a lot of people were using Bob Lee's death to make sweeping statements about crime in San Francisco. And we see that a lot, you know, deaths being exploited for political reasons or whatever.
Speaker 1But then we found out the actual case turned out to involve two people who knew each other and there was some personal conflict, right? So I think it's just a reminder that these early assumptions can become embedded in public discussion long before investigators have a complete picture. And that's not to say that San Francisco hasn't struggled with like highly visible crime. I mean, there's a lot of property crime, car break-ins. I mean, we've seen retail theft. These open air drug markets and just public disorder. They
Speaker 1keep telling us that across the board, crime is down. And I don't know if we can believe that. I mean, who knows what we can believe? It just seems like they're always telling us, I mean, honestly, just a bunch of bullshit, right? And we see through that bullshit quite a bit. So overall, crime might be down in places like San Francisco, but homicides increased. I mean, there is actual proof that during the first six months of 2026, homicides increased to 16 from 12 during that same period
Speaker 1from 2025, even though overall reported crime continues to fall, as they say. San Francisco has become something of a political punching bag when it comes to crime, and there's a reason the city developed that reputation. I mean, for years we've seen footage of people smashing car windows, walking out of stores with stolen merchandise, and then just openly dealing drugs on city streets. Those are real problems and the people living and working in those neighborhoods, they deserve to feel safe.
Speaker 2In 2025, San.
Speaker 1Francisco had 28 homicides and that was the lowest annual total since 1954, according to the police department. And car break-ins, which had practically kind of become like synonymous with the city, dropped by 43%. But you know, two things can be true at once. I mean, San Francisco can have serious problems with drug trafficking and theft and All of that stuff while experiencing, you know, low homicide numbers. And we can say, oh, well, there were just 28 homicides in 2025.
Speaker 1But if you ask me, that's still 28 too many. Well, that wraps up another round of crime headlines here on Mountain Murders. And there's one thing we can take away from today's stories, and I think that's that the headline rarely tells us everything we need to know. There's always more to the story. And it's always good to remember that behind every sensational headline, there are real people whose lives have been changed forever. And on a lighter note, if there's one thing this week's news has taught us, it's that humanity continues to to be an endless source
Speaker 1of questionable decision-making. I mean, seriously, you couldn't make up some of this shit if you tried. But before we go, we want to hear from you. Drop us a comment, send us a message, or, you know, join conversation over on social media. You can find Mountain Murders on Instagram. And if you enjoyed today's episode, you know, you can always do us a favor and subscribe. You can leave us a five-star review and share Mountain Murders with your favorite true crime loving friend. He really does help us reach new listeners and keep the show going. So until
Speaker 1next time, folks, don't forget the world is full of strange people making terrible decisions. So lock your doors, you know, trust your gut. And for the love of everything holy, do not become a subject of our next episode.
Speaker 2Dylan, we love you. We missed you. We can't wait.
Speaker 1For your return to the mic. Thank you guys for hanging out with me.
Speaker 2I appreciate it.
Speaker 1And yeah, I know. I know I'm not Dylan. I understand that. But thank you for your patience anyway and for sticking around. Bye, y'all.
Welcome to Sleaze & Slashers, where the blood runs thick, the body counts are high, and good taste is strictly optional. We’re diving headfirst into the wonderfully wicked world of horror, exploitation, grindhouse...
Atlanta millionaire Lance Herndon had it all-wealth, success, and a reputation for being one of the city's most eligible bachelors. But in 1996, he was found brutally murdered inside his upscale home, setting off a...
In the summer of 2005, the quiet mountain community of Spencer, Tennessee, was rocked by a gruesome discovery. The remains of recently retired Furlan Bryant were found in a burn pile. Investigators uncovered a bitter...