Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

MonsterTalk

MonsterTalk artwork

S04E11 - The Saucer Life with Aaron Gulyas

Dec 16, 202447 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

An interview with writer, researcher and podcaster Aaron Gulyas - host of the UFO themed history podcast The Saucer Life. Gulyas is also the author of many books (affiliate link) including some likely to be of particular interest to MT listeners: Extraterrestrials and the American Zeitgeist: Alien Contact Tales Since the 1950s Conspiracy Theories: The Roots, Themes and Propagation of Paranoid Political and Cultural Narratives ----- If you like the 1970s In Search Of... why not check out our sister show In reSearch Of... Blake (and his wife Kathleen) will be participating in the 2025 "Skeptoid Bermuda Triangle Adventure" - details here if you want to come along and explore Robert the Doll, the Bimini Wall, or to look for the missing planes of Flight 19... Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Monster House Presents.

Speaker 2If you've been listening to Munster Talk for a while, you've heard a few things here and there about how I served in the Navy, and my web handle is usually doctor Atlantis, although I have to add that I'm not a doctor and I don't believe that there was a literal Atlantis. And maybe you thought to yourself, what if there was a way that this guy could combine his experience with being on a ship, his fascination in the mysteries of Atlantis, and the Bermuda Triangle, oh, and his twenty fifth wedding anniversary all into one big cruise ship themed experience that you could come along with. Well,

Speaker 2then you're in luck, because Monster Talk is combining forces with the popular skeptical podcast Skeptoid as we brave the Bermuda Triangle in twenty twenty five. I'll be one of the skeptics celebrities participating in this adventure in the warm waters off the coast of Florida. Will we find the Missing Flight nineteen? Will we find proof of Atlantis? Will Sea Musters pilot us through these mystery filled waters? No, but I promise you there will be science and history field discussions and plenty of punds if I have anything

Speaker 2to do with it. Early bird pricing is still available, so come get some sun, visit beautiful places, roll your eyes at my terrible puns, and raise money to fund Skeptoid and Monster Talk shared mission of promoting skepticism and science while still enjoying a good mystery. Plus you'll get to meet my wife as we celebrate twenty five years of marriage together. So maybe there's not going to be any UFOs or time bor disease, but you know a thing like that. At least since that, miracles can happen, So sign up soon before the early bird prices go away.

Speaker 2Check the show notes for a link, or go to skeptoid dot com and click events to find your way onto Braving the Bermuda Triangle, a Skeptoid adventure.

Speaker 3Flying saucers have invaded our planet.

Speaker 4Washington, London, Paris, Moscow are key targets.

Speaker 3The whole world is under attack.

Speaker 2Can it survived? It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before.

Speaker 3A giant hairy creature.

Speaker 2Park eight Park Mass in Luckness, a twenty four mile long bottomless lake in the Highlands of Scotland.

Speaker 3It's a creature known as the Luckness Monster.

Speaker 2Moormstertall, Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner. This week we're going to be having a chat with author and podcaster Aaron Gillias, host of The Saucer Live. Check out the show notes for links to Aaron's books and his show. I've been enjoying Aaron's historic romps through some of the weird and unusual narratives of American saucer culture, and we'll be chatting about how he got into this research topic and why modern UFO culture isn't quite as fun as the good old days.

Speaker 3All right, here we go, Moormstertall.

Speaker 2Aaron Gilias is a historian, an educator, and an author, and he is, in fact the author of more than a dozen books, according to my very extensive Amazon search, including Extraterrestrials and the American Zeitgeist and Alien Contact Tales since nineteen fifties. But I have to say you've got several intriguing titles that concern conspiratorial thinking in American pop culture. I am of only having listened to your podcast and not reading your books, but I am very I didn't realize you'd written so much. I'm very interested in hopping

Speaker 2in those. I'll linked all that in the show notes. But you're also the host of the podcast The Saucer Life, which just celebrated at seventh anniversary, so congrats on that.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2Anyway, welcome to the show. Thank you for joining.

Speaker 3Us now, great to be here.

Speaker 2I have been following you for a long time, and there's a lot of alien and UFO themed podcasts out there. In fact, I believe nine more launched since I started reading your bio, But yours is very distinctive. It takes a historical framework and you have a very deep knowledge of the topic, but especially like when you cover sort of the classic early days of saucer Mania. But how did you get immersed into this topic so deeply?

Speaker 4Well, like most Generation acts dorks, I discovered Omni mag Oh Wow at some point, yeah, Bob Guccioni's less successful magazine. And before that, I read some UFO books when I was in elementary school that I got at the library.

Speaker 3Dan Cohen.

Speaker 2Oh, we wrote love things about.

Speaker 4Ghosts and aliens and things like that, The Time Life, Mysteries of the Unknown series and I do remember when I was very young catching a lot of episodes of In Search of Syndications.

Speaker 2So quick insert. I would be remiss if I didn't drop in a little note here to plug another Monster House podcast. If you're curious about the old nineteen seventies TV show In Search of hosted by Leonardy moy and wish someone would take two or three hours to dissect every one of the twenty two minutes of those original shows. Oh We're in luck. Check out another fine Monster House podcast with In Research of hosted by myself and doctor Jeb card To. The show does but you can find us and most podcast apps are by visiting in Research

Speaker 2of dot com. Now back to Monster Dog.

Speaker 4So those things sort of sort of got me into it, and then I think my senior year in high school, the X Files started, so that was fascinating. And then I went off to college and discovered the Internet and Usenet groups where people are talking about these guys named.

Speaker 3Bill Cooper and Bill Moore and.

Speaker 4All these documents that they've that they've you know, you know, recreated from their memory of seeing top secret stuff.

Speaker 3When they were in the Navy.

Speaker 4And I was just I was just all in on it, and after a while, a couple of years, I was like, Okay, this this stuff's mostly just made up, but it's fun. It's fun, and I'd buy books and magazines. And this was back when to learn about this stuff you had to read a lot of books and or listen to to talk radio. But where I lived, I couldn't pick up any good talk radio stations, so I was mostly

Speaker 4reading books and magazines and interviews and things like that and just sort of piecing it, piecing it together.

Speaker 2Well, you know, you mentioned magazines, but on your show you've also covered zines, which are a little different. And I never ran into zines in real life until I saw them sort of archived on the internet. How did you find them and how did that play out? Because that's really interesting to me.

Speaker 4YEA, Honestly, it's something that I've mostly found on the internet as well. I do remember back when I lived in Indianapolis for a few years, there were some big like like like not bookstores, but like news stands, like magazine stores, which I miss. I missed those things, but and there would be magazines where and they might not a little more professional than zines, but nothing mainstream and and you'd find one issue one time and then never

Speaker 4see another issue of that magazine again, and you know, you can't find anything about it out there, and it's it's just weird. But then you go to, oh, you go to like UFO conventions and people are selling stuff and they've got like a pile of these stapled together that they've that they've done. Or you go to used bookstores and you might find some things laying around there, so bits.

Speaker 3And pieces here and there.

Speaker 4But the Internet has been a godsend for building up a I call it an archive. It's it's really just you know, digital hoarding of all these things. And thank goodness for searchable PDFs, because otherwise I would never get anything done.

Speaker 3You're here, Aaron.

Speaker 1Sources and UFOs used to be more fun, but things seem darker in Grima these days. And maybe we'll dig into that in a bit. But what part of the history of this stuff do you find the most fun to research and talk about.

Speaker 4I really like contact ease from the nineteen fifties, the people who claim to have had encounters with usually human type people from other planets that are usually but not always in our solar system. Sometimes their physical contacts. Sometimes they're psychic contacts or channeling or other sort of esoteric things, and there's usually some kind of political or social message going along with these, and it usually tended to be

Speaker 4a bit the messages tended to be have elements that would have been considered subversive in the nineteen fifties and early nineteen sixties. And I've always been interested, well, not always really. Beginning in graduate school, I got interested in that angle and ended up writing my master's thesis on UFO belief during the Cold War and how it was a sort of reaction and response to politics and things

Speaker 4like that with contact these sort of finding ways to camouflage political messages in their flying saucer stories. And also you've got elements of earlier spiritualism and the theosophical movement sort of informing contact e beliefs. So as somebody who was scrambling around for a thesis topic, it was it was pretty a pretty rich field.

Speaker 2Oh yeah, yeah, we always talk about theosophy is you know, one of the most influential religions nobody knows is secretly behind everything. It's just amazing. Now do you teach about this stuff in your professional life? Because given your writing about conspiratory stuff and your interest in pop culture, we're really interested in how this might come up in coursework.

Speaker 3Yeah, it's interesting.

Speaker 4I have before occasionally if I'm doing especially like a like a US history class and we get to the post war stuff, I will sort of use the contact these as one of several examples of counterculture and subculture in the nineteen fifties, so sort of of a piece with the beats and things like that. It's it's gotten, it's gotten more difficult to talk about it that, Karen,

Speaker 4that darkening you mentioned of the UFO scene sort of makes UFOs a topic that is much more, much more political than it used to be. And I don't really feel like talking to my students about anything modern in my history class. It feels like, you know, current turn events. Yeah, so's it's it's difficult. And the conspiracy stuff as as well.

Speaker 4I mostly I mostly just sort of try to debunk the conspiracy theories they bring to the classroom from their own media experiences, which it isn't as bad as I as I always think it will be. Every semester I go into it thinking, you know, is this is this the semester where I get the hardcore flat earther, you know, and waste twenty minutes trying to prove the world is round,

Speaker 4you know, just like didn't tole me do this already, you know, back in ancient Greece. But it's it's it's becoming more prevalent. I have a lot of sympathy for my colleagues who teach political science and sociology because they seem to be getting a lot more of the conspiratorial stuff than I am. Of course, I've been mostly teaching world history the last few years, mostly to avoid current day American politics.

Speaker 3I don't really want to get into it. So it's like, you know, what nobody is.

Speaker 4Going to get on my case about when I talk about, you know, the Assyrians or something. So seriously it's you know, well, how do you know, I don't know, I'm making it all up.

Speaker 2Well, it's funny you mentioned that, because you know, given what you said, you found us net groups and that sort of thing. The conspiracies on used net could go pretty deep. But a lot of it seems like today young people are getting a lot of their stuff from TikTok, and I just maybe it's out there, but I haven't seen that much dark, deep, you know, threaded conspiracies coming out of TikTok. It seems more I don't know, still conspiracy stuff, but it seems more upbeat, sometimes literally with

Speaker 2a beat.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 4I think that the sort of short, snappy nature, the sort of you know, attention short attention span theater of TikTok sort of makes it not a not the ideal medium for conspiracy stuff because you hardly are able to get into it before you know it's It just doesn't work as well as like on YouTube, which I think I think YouTube's the worst thing to happen to mankind. Ever, you used to have to, like I said, read books

Speaker 4to become a conspiracy theorist or.

Speaker 2And you used to be able to find things on the Internet and text and not have to watch a nine minute video to get thirty seconds of content that you're looking for.

Speaker 3Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 4And so now you know you can read fifteen books on the JFK assassination or watch a nine minute video and declare yourself just as big of an expert as people.

Speaker 3Do your own research, do your own research. None of you are capable of doing your own research. You don't know how.

Speaker 4But it's the Internet has has changed how we how we absorb information, and I find myself, you know, not having the patients for reading long, you know, convoluted conspiracy books anymore.

Speaker 3I just I just don't have the attention span.

Speaker 4But I hate watching videos because they go so slowly and I can read much faster. So I yeah, it's it's different and can.

Speaker 2Get an amen. Brother.

Speaker 1Well, Aaron, given how much you've written about pop culture, what are your thoughts on the interplay between pop culture and how people experience this stuff that is allegedly in real life.

Speaker 3I think I think.

Speaker 4It's interesting because we see these shows on television, for example, going back to The Invaders and Project UFO all the way up through the X Files and Wow Dark Skies and shows like that, and there's there's almost a conversation between some of these shows and the like the UFO conspiracy culture, to the point where when I was working on a project about conspiratorial and paranormal science fiction TV

Speaker 4with The X Files, it was very difficult sometimes for me to track down exactly where some aspects of stories came from. Was this something that was invented wholly by the X Files creators? Or were they drawing from some Internet post that they saw, but I have it and don't know where to find it, and so trying to find sort of the sort of a chicken in the egg thing, you know, where do these stories really begin?

Speaker 4And I know with the X Files, there was a lot of a lot of talk back when it started that you know this is you know, these are these are real government cases that have been dramatized.

Speaker 3It's like, no, no, they're not.

Speaker 4Despite what the little title slide on the pilot episode, which is kind of it's kind of vague, but says something like based on stories that have been found.

Speaker 3In FBI records or something like that.

Speaker 4It's like it's like that this is not a specific case, this is based on but but people see things that reflect they're the UFO narratives they've heard, and thus they think, well, it's sort of like this isn't just an example of the story.

Speaker 3This is corroboration of the story. Right, We've got like.

Speaker 4Not just one person saying this, it's one person saying it, and now it's on TV and you point out that it's that it's fiction, and they're like, is it though? Is it isn't the best place to hide the truth inside fiction.

Speaker 3I'm like, no, why are you trying to hide the truth.

Speaker 4If this is an effort to disclose something, why not just disclose it? But or it's like movies like e T are designed or were designed rather to prepare and acclimate the American people for the possibility or the reality of alien beings coming to visit us, and close encounters of the fourth kind being the same sort of thing. I noticed that they usually don't say that about movies like Alien because those aliens are scary and jump out

Speaker 4of your chest, right, But we got to get ready for the peaceful, cuddly aliens to come visit us. And some people claim that that popular media and movies and television are part of that agenda.

Speaker 2They're preparing us for disclosure, which I swear to Lord is gonna happen any minute now.

Speaker 4They're gonna at some point between now and the Sun's heat death.

Speaker 1It's a singularity and all that. Yeah, So when do you think things in this sourcal world started to become more conspiratorial and darker?

Speaker 3It goes, It goes in waves.

Speaker 4The Men in Black in the nineteen fifties, that emerges from Albert Bender's experiences in Gray Barker sort of gins up the whole men in Black mythos and that this idea that silencers are out there targeting UFO researchers goes way back to the fifties and sixties and then kind of goes into that idea, goes into into decline, becomes less popular, and then in the nineteen eighties we start

Speaker 4getting more and more of the abduction stories and the hypnosis and the bodily viole relations that come out of these experimentation memories. And then you sort of in eighty eight eighty nine you get Bill Cooper and Bill Moore and Majestic twelve and the idea that the government is in league with these aliens, and then you've got the underground bases and you know they're going to replace us all with hybrids, and that sort of thing was really

Speaker 4sort of prominent in the eighties and nineties, and then, honestly, I think that sort of comes to an end with September eleventh. I think the September eleventh attacks kind of resets some things, and I don't know if there's what kind of connection there is there, but after that things sort of shift to the disclosure stuff and sort of the ufology as a lobbying effort rather than a scientific exploration,

Speaker 4because we've already decided that the aliens are real and are visiting us, so now we've got to jump ahead to disclosure. And that's disclosure is sort of a fundamentally optimistic sort of sort of movement. They're going to reveal the truth about the aliens, and we're going to start using that technology, and we'll have free energy, and we'll fix the environment, and we won't need money anymore, and everything will be perfect. We're going to cure every disease,

Speaker 4but we just have to wait for the disclosure. Since twenty seventeen, with the New York Times story and all the acronyms and lou Elizondo's stuff and all that to the Stars crew and everything, it's sort of stayed in that disclosure mood. But also there's some of the sort of conspiratorial aspect of it is very much sort of

Speaker 4an anti gum vernment.

Speaker 3What are they hiding?

Speaker 4Why are the lifelong bureaucrats and the deep state continuing to cover this up? And it's sort of gone down the same sort of anti bureaucratic, anti anti government track that some other politics have.

Speaker 3So it goes, it goes.

Speaker 4The darkness and the conspiracism really does sort of wax and wane over the decades.

Speaker 2I think that makes it Yeah, yeah, and how the nature of the conspiracies themselves as well seem to kind of shift. So I mean, yeah, there's always some conspiracy going on, but like some of them are darker than others. But I know, on the show here, we've talked a lot about what we've tried to sort of expose what I think is an influenced campaign by Robert Bigelow and his crew, And certainly the New York Times story was

Speaker 2definitely written by people all plugged into that. You get the Bigelow needs nap killer her, et cetera. But it seems like that stuff's more effective than what they used to do, which was always rent the Washington, DC Press Club and make it make it seem like that was a government reveal. But what's your take on this whole thing?

Speaker 4Like, Yeah, I think it's I think it's a way to make money, and I think it's a way to make a lot of money off the government by setting yourself up as the private corporation that gets contracted to look at reports, right, so you you sort of put yourself into the sort of list of people who who get money when appropriations time comes around. And I think that that Bigelow and that whole crew, I think what

Speaker 4they did that was really smart. I don't like it necessarily, but it's really smart. Was it seems like they have been spending a lot of effort cultivating some members of Congress into a point where they are willing to use their position to spread this message and and spread the testimony and and we saw, you know, the testimony and the committee hearings the last few years and uh and

Speaker 4even more recently. And it's it seems like there's some some credulous people out there who don't know enough about the history of euphological culture. Uh, and they they think that all of this is new and this is not necessarily new, even the the new sightings and things, and this is there's nothing newer groundbreaking here. And there's a

Speaker 4lot of things that sound sensational and get sensational headlines that really aren't sensational, Like what was his name, Groosh.

Speaker 3David Groosh?

Speaker 4Yes, his his you know soundbreaking testimony was that somebody told him they saw something, and you know that's you know, this is I mean, this is.

Speaker 3Like literally hearsay, it's yeah, it's.

Speaker 2Not by the way, presented to a room full of people, many of whom are lawyers, none of whom call him on that.

Speaker 4That's yes, yeah, yes, there's there's an agenda. The money trail is probably fascinating. I'm I'm not completely up to date with with all the players sometimes with this because my eyes just glaze over with all the acronyms and everything. I did start reading Elizondo's book. I have not finished it.

Speaker 2H we had that in common.

Speaker 4But yeah, I like, hey, I should, probably I should probably, you know, read this.

Speaker 3I'm like, life is short. Well, you know it's.

Speaker 2Lou l liz.

Speaker 3Oh. Yeah, yeah, he's he's a character.

Speaker 4Yeah, he's actually actually, if you if you sort of put him in the view him as as one of the many people who have found a way to make more money than I have at UFOs, you know, he sort of facts the pattern.

Speaker 3He's not anything really new. He's he's you know, the the.

Speaker 4The phil Corso of the twenty first century, the guy who wrote Day After Roswell. Right, It's like, oh, I know, yeah, they're gonna I'm gonna tell you, tell you what it is, tell you what the truth is, because I was I was there, and was he there.

Speaker 2Well, I know, of course I believe he's passed, but he is. He's a very deep en of me of mine. I mean, like, my god, I'm literally writing a book in his ideas about UH and and they're not even very good ideas that that maybe we got computer ships from UH from crash Roswell craft. I'm like, no, we have an absolutely clear trail of how the technology progressed from vacuum tubes to transistors to microchips. It is not anything to do with craft saucers. It is everything to

Speaker 2do with the hard work of people being very clever and trying things.

Speaker 4I remember reading in that book about how fiberglass was one of the things that fiber hence hence fiber optics. And I'm like, I remember, like in junior high, in a family vacation going to the Corning Glass Museum in New York. You can sort of see the whole history of how this happened. It's you know, it's it's not I mean I'm pretty sure I could make fiberglass in my garage if I really needed. Probably not, but it's it's it's just cotton candy made out.

Speaker 3Of light bulbs.

Speaker 2Yes, yeah, yeah, basically, but.

Speaker 3Then you insulate your house with it. Yeah.

Speaker 4The Corso stuff is just so you know, easily dis rupable that it's ridiculous.

Speaker 3I know.

Speaker 2I don't Karen has a follow up, but I just want to say I just I think Bigelow to me, it feels like he's a true believer. But there's there's so intent on what doing what I call credibility anchoring, like they're trying to just get if the government does anything. It's as though now the government, the government, this giant monolith, you know, is now endorsing the idea. And people don't understand that the government is not a monolith. It's like any community or any bureaucracy. It's it's lots and lots of people with lots of different ideas. But yeah, boy,

Speaker 2their credibility leeches.

Speaker 3Yes, yes, well, So.

Speaker 1I didn't have a follow up so much as I wanted to ask another question. Recently, my family we traveled down to we're traveling around Colorado and we went through Hooper, Colorado, which is the home of the UFO Watchtower, or believed with that, but it was my first time to go there, and it was really interesting. It was actually closed the kind of information center, but they had this large yard and it is just full of what's almost like a

Speaker 1shrine to aliens. And there are these little altars everywhere and statues, and people have left jewelry behind and coins and I had to stop my nine year old from collecting coins everywhere. So it was just this whole kind of spiritual element. And so there was this sign that I took a photograph of and it talks about the garden, and I'll just read a little bit to you. It says, as you walk through the garden, pay attention to your body as you can feel the energy from the vor texes. We encourage visitors to leave something in the garden to

Speaker 1get their energy there as well. Please do not move or remove anything in the garden. Bad bad karma if you do. The last thing that psychics told us is that there are two large beings who protect the entrances to the vor texes, but are also here to help. There's been there have been phenomenal results for those who needed help in their lives, just to ask. So I thought this was a I mean, I've heard of this kind of religious spiritual aliens before, kind of law of attraction style thing. But I'm just wondering where did that

Speaker 1come from?

Speaker 3Dear.

Speaker 4It's one thing I really I desperately want to go to the UFO watch Tower.

Speaker 3It just looks, oh, you have to.

Speaker 4I haven't been there, and I just I usually do like a UFO road trip every year. I might it's a long I might have to fly to Colorado. That's a long drive from Michigan.

Speaker 1But make sure you do something else because it is a little bit kind of cheap and chintzy.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 4I think the religious aspects of it come from those those sort of the contact e era sort of spiritual roots of it, the channeling, channeling the aliens, people like Fred Fred George van Tassel, who was the originator of communications with Ashtar command which supposedly one of my favorites craft in orbit of the Earth to protect us from from cataclysms that are coming. And then then Ashtar has

Speaker 4sort of spun off with other people channeling him and it sort of it's connected to to new thought, new religious thought traditions. I'm working on some episodes right now about a UFO religion that started up as a commune in very countercultural, hippie San Francisco back in the late sixties. And it's they've got, you know, their own Bible and it's all been channeled to their leader by aliens. And

Speaker 4it's and it's it's it's they call it christ Communism, and it's been delivered by the aliens. Jesus is a communist, and this is how we save America by everybody owning everything together. And those those religious beliefs, those religious you UFO trends, really do kind of collide against the nuts and bolt stuff. The people like these are alien flying saucers and the air forces covering them up. And that's the only story we need to talk about. Anything else

Speaker 4is just sensationalist nonsense. Well maybe, but it's it's more interesting, I think. And these these sort of new American religious traditions that emerge around flying saucers, not that it's just the United States, but that those are the ones I'm most familiar with. It's so many similarities too. Like we talked about theosophy and these ashtar, the ashtar figures, the aliens who are sending these messages. They're basically the same as the ascended masters of theosophy. It's just and in

Speaker 4some cases they're claimed to actually be the same ascended masters. It's just that Helena Blovatski and her friends didn't understand the the outer space nature of them, didn't understand that they were aliens. And so now we have, we have more information. So it comes it comes a lot from from that. I remember.

Speaker 3I remember when I was when I was in high.

Speaker 4School, I'd go to the mall and the one place where I was guaranteed to at least find one or two UFO books was in the New Age bookstore. So I'm I'm there, you know, really confused by why the UFO books are in with all the crystal dolphins and things like that. And because I didn't really get I didn't really understand that connection. Yet it was later before I before I really understood that. So I think it

Speaker 4comes out of that that long spiritualist tradition, and it's and this is this is a very cynical thing that I'm going to say. I think some people realize that their religious beliefs are probably more attractive if you can latch onto something that has a lot of pop culture cachet, so UFOs aliens, you know sort of.

Speaker 2Yeah, absolutely, Well it's funny to me because Pasilka wrote that book American Cosmic, and I don't think she's wrong about an emerging religion. But also there's always been religion with this stuff, like from the very early days. It's always been very, very tied into religious concepts, maybe not mainstream Christianity, but to some extent even that. But yeah, I mean it, I mean, thinking about the Nine and

Speaker 2those that sort of stuff. I mean, like, it's just ridiculous to the idea that now it's religion. But I get. I mean I read the book and I don't Again, she's right, there does seem to be some new emerging religious sort of narrative, but it also has never not been religious, you know, Yeah.

Speaker 3I agree totally.

Speaker 4I think one of the things that irritates me is when people talk about Pasulka's book as something like the first time academics, yeah really delved into UFOs, like you know, I can. Robert Elwood was a religious studies professor back in the sixties who wrote about this stuff. George Everhard compiled a massive bibliography of every contact ee writing ever and he was a religious studies guy. You know, this is it's not even scholars have done it. Scholars in her field have been doing it. So when I always

Speaker 4goes back further, yeah, exactly. And to be fair, I've never heard her say that she's the first to do this.

Speaker 2But boy, that's the way other people talk about it.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, maybe they need to read more, but yeah, yeah.

Speaker 4Everybody, everybody needs to read more. Absolutely.

Speaker 3No.

Speaker 2Well, Aaron, when you started your show, you started out saying you were going to avoid snark, but it.

Speaker 3Seems like I couldn't do it.

Speaker 2It seems like a little snart stream in So what do you do to try to keep positive with this? Because, I mean, the saucer culture, and I'm especially thinking about UFO Twitter has become such a soul sucking, toxic swamp and it's it's just it's painful to me because I've read about this stuff for my whole life. I mean, I remember reading gold Key comics about UFOs and aliens. It's like, so I it when I say it used to be more fun, I mean literally it was more fun,

Speaker 2and it's just become so dark and depressing lately. So how do you stay positive?

Speaker 4I stay positive bye bye by reminding myself that that I have a history podcast that happens to focus on UFOs, not a UFO podcast.

Speaker 2Ah ah.

Speaker 4I try to I try to stay focused on Honestly, I try to stay focused on the things that make me happy about ufology. And usually that's stuff from the fifties and sixties and even even into the nineties, but the really the twenty first century and onward, it's it's just been either stuff that's been rehashed or people who are ignorant of the entire history who just insist on screaming at each other. And yeah, like you said, it's

Speaker 4it's it's horrible. So I focus on those stories and topics that I find the most interesting, rather than sort of pledging to cover every aspect of the phenomenon. I don't think I could. I could do it if I couldn't really pick and choose things that things that I talk about.

Speaker 1Yeah, I think that's the approach that we take with this show too. We have to focus on science and folklore and just talking about cryptids and monsters and everything else is just part of them.

Speaker 2Say we are lucky though that I mean, well, I'm sure within any community there can be some toxicity, but it's been my experience that monsters in general are a lot more upbeat in aliens and UFOs. And I don't know why, but I'm happy it is. It is saying something.

Speaker 4But yeah, I think you know, I'm I'm not saying this absolutely, but I think in the cryptid world you don't have as much of the conspiratorial laalady, that's not a word. Conspiracism, not against the government. I know there is quite a bit against the scientific establishment. You know that, you know, the zoologists are are covering this up because they don't want to be proven wrong.

Speaker 2It's a minority, for sure. There's a few people who are in these sort of missing for when one crowd who think the government's hiding Bigfoot in the deaths, that it's incurring that sort of thing.

Speaker 1It's still there, just not as not.

Speaker 2As profoundly popular.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 4Yeah, you know, when I watch you know, hunting Bigfoot or something like that, all episodes.

Speaker 3Of that, it's it's just goofy fun.

Speaker 4You know, it's and and you know, you only have to watch one episode because they're all the same. But uh, it's it's you know as well, Yes, you have the town hall meeting where everybody comes in and we need to hear your bigfoot stories and that's like this is this is great. And I spoke this, uh this summer at the UFO Days Festival in Elmwood, Wisconsin, which had some really interesting sightings back in the seventies. And it's like their town, their annual town festival, and it just happens to be UFO themed and it's only been UFO

Speaker 4themed since the eighties.

Speaker 3It was switched to that.

Speaker 4It used to be like a flag Day celebration, but that wasn't drawing enough people, so they decided to emphasize these UFO sightings from a few years previous. And it's it's amazing. They had this parade and uh and they bring in speakers and there's bands and they got they're selling souvenirs and it's it's just people having fun. Yeah, And if this stuff isn't fun, then why do it.

Speaker 3I Mean, there's enough.

Speaker 4Serious stuff out there that's actually important, and I don't think UFOs are super important in the grand scheme of things. I think it's a window into certain belief systems, and it's a lens through which we can we can look at the changing American history and culture and in other places as well. But No, I just I can't get on board with this. Is this is the greatest thing that humanity will ever encounter, is our understanding of the

Speaker 4space people.

Speaker 2No, I've been kind of toying with this idea and it's kind of a joke and kind of not a joke, which is that.

Speaker 3For people who.

Speaker 2Don't use evidence based thinking, that a lot of their certitude comes out of how they feel. And I call it, they're pisstmology instead of epistemology, right, because what makes them angry is what they believe. And maybe that conspiratorial stuff is giving fuel to that, Like that that strong emotional belief that not only does this tied into a cosmology, but that people are trying to deny it and it pisses them off. Maybe that really is something. Maybe there's more than just a joke and wordplay there. Maybe there's something to that.

Speaker 4I think there's some people who are desperate to be right about something. Yeah, this is the thing that some people have chosen and they have they have made it their identity. Of all people who have made their personalities or their their hobby their entire personality. Right, and unless you're making money off it, it's a hobby. And there's how many professional upologists are there?

Speaker 3Maybe six? It's not you know, it's like full time.

Speaker 1Unfortunately they have to start to but to wrap things up. Yeah, but we've got time for a final question. It's a signature closing question for first time guess. So, Aaron, what's your favorite monster?

Speaker 3Flat Woods Monster?

Speaker 2Wow?

Speaker 4I I I've got to say the flat Woods Monster. I. I love the story. I love that it's the thing that got Gray Barker into the UFO field. I just read an advanced copy of a new biography of Barker that's.

Speaker 3Coming out UH next year, and it.

Speaker 4Goes into the a lot more depth on on the the Flatwoods thing than I had seen before. I think the design of the monster, or the sort of appearance or presentation of the monster is amazing. The red, glowing head and sort of green I I love that it's it's sort of in the middle of nowhere. I've been to Braxton County, West Virginia where it happened and it's it's a long way from anywhere, and it's it's a

Speaker 4it's an interesting environment to be in with the woods and the hills. I just I love the monster, I love the story, I love the environment. I've probably been to that part of West Virginia more than I've been to any other paranormal themed place.

Speaker 2And yeah, you might be the first guest to pick that one. That's really cool.

Speaker 3Really yeah, I think so. Yeah. I mean it's a fake.

Speaker 2We've talked about it many times. Yes, yeah, but I was.

Speaker 3I was worried. I wasn't obscure enough.

Speaker 2No, no, no, but it is. It's one of those monsters that's kind of a shibble if if you show people that image, they either know what it is or they don't, and it's like it quickly tells you how deep they're in, right.

Speaker 4Yes, yeah, absolutely, Well, Aaron, it has been so fun to talk with you.

Speaker 2Finally, this has been great.

Speaker 3So yeah, really enjoyed it.

Speaker 1Thank you so much for your time.

Speaker 2If if listeners have not heard his show, you got I'm gonna put a link in the show notes and check out his mini books, which I will also be checking out, probably some of them literally from the library, but I because the prices are high, but a lot of these look right up my alley. So I look forward to seeing what you've done. And so thank thank you so much.

Speaker 3Thank you.

Speaker 4And I will also tell people go to your local library and inner library loan those books because you know, just that's fine.

Speaker 2And it's a fun way. It's like using the system, and that's the old ways, is how we used to do things. I've done so many research projects where I had to do that and you're waiting for him to show up. It is so exciting when they call. It's really cool. It's really cool.

Speaker 3Really, it's fun. I still do it.

Speaker 4Yeah, it's like, oh, I could buy this book, but I want to get the email saying it's in and I want to go pick it up.

Speaker 3It's fun.

Speaker 2It is delightful, love it. This has been such a treat. Thank you so much for joining us too.

Speaker 3I have a great night, you too.

Speaker 2Monster You've been listening to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolzner. You just heard an interview with author and researcher Aaron Gully as host of the Saucer Life Links to Aaron's books and podcasts are in the show notes.

Speaker 3Check them out.

Speaker 2A lot of modern UFOs shows ignore the strange history of the early days of upology, but Aaron never flinches from a glitter glued antenna or a space pancake. Check his workout. Around the world, people report monsters, but are they real? Join the Detective of the Impossible Joe Nickel as he walks you through investigations to reveal often surprising natural explanations behind some of the most famous cryptids and legendary animals ever reported. Using scientific skepticism, meticulous field work in historical deep dives, Joe Nichols seeks out hidden clues

Speaker 2and real world candidates that sometimes reveal that even the most unlikely monster stories may have a basis in reality. The Science of Monsters is the first book from Monster House LLC, the publisher of science shows, Monster Talk, and in research of The revised edition is now on sale and includes corrections and suggestions from you, our listeners and now readers. Sales of the Science of Monsters directly benefits Monster House and its podcasts thanks to the generosity of its author. Pick up The Revised Science of Monsters today

Speaker 2at Amazon dot com. Available in paperback and kindle editions. Monster Talk theme music expect Pete stealing monkeys. Stay tuned next week when we'll be having a ghost story for Christmas.

Speaker 2This has been a Monster House presentation.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S06E07 Elizabeth Taylor and the Burton of Truth

    Nov 16, 202655 minAudio

    Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S06E06 🐈⬛Evil Cats and Revelatory Revenants👻

    Nov 9, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S06E05🎃 Live 2026 Halloween Show

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S06E04 🍿Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈 Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S06E03 🎥 Capturing Bigfoot 🫈with Marq Evans

    Oct 19, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...

    Credit the people on this episode