Flashback to January 2018: In this episode of MonsterTalk, we return to discussion of the Ultraterrestrial Hypothesis (UTH) and what seems to be its growing influence in paranormal circles. It’s been used to explain UFOs, mothman, bigfoot, fairies, dogman, ghosts and many other phenomena which defy scientific demonstrability. Now it crops up again in a new film event titled Alien Intrusion which turned out to be a stealth evangelical creationist film which suggests that aliens and UFOs are actually demonic. We are joined by MonsterTalk alum Joe Laycock, Natasha Mikles and Jeb Card to discuss the UTH and Jeb’s Paranormal Unified Field Theory (PUFT) as it relates to this film and the work of John Keel and others. In Research Of… MonsterTalk Joe Laycock Natasha Mikles Jeb Card Music Monstertalk Theme: Monster by Peach Stealing Monkeys Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Monster House Presents. This episode is part of our Monster Talk flashback series. I'm cross posting it to our sister show in Research of the show where Jeb Cart and I watch and comment on episodes of the Vintage Leonard nine Boy host a TV series in search of if you somehow ended up listening to one of our shows and weren't aware of the other. Links to both were in the show notes for in research of I'm currently editing the Bimini Wall episode, but ironically I'm running behind because of many unavoidable issues, one of which is that I'm going to be in Bimini in person with my
Speaker 1wife to celebrate twenty five years of marriage on a skeptics cruise hosted by the long running podcast Skeptoy.
Speaker 2If we don't.
Speaker 1Disappear to the Permuter Triangle, I'll be able to finish up this Bimini episode soon after returning home. The episode is a flashback from January twenty eighteen, and I'm cross posting it because Jeb and I just posted a five hour look back at the film The Mothmet Prophecies, and Jeb was suggesting that revisiting our discussion of the utch in this roundtable would make a good supplementary episode for that topic. So links in the shows to all this cross pollination stuff, and I hope.
Speaker 2You enjoy the monstrutle.
Speaker 1Last week I went to see a film called Alien Intrusion. Here's a little sample from the trailer.
Speaker 3Now, I'm a science fiction fan, and I can tell you the truth is out there, but it's a lot stranger than any science fiction.
Speaker 2It's claimed that over twenty million Americans have seen in UFO.
Speaker 3The Ropapole concluded that up to four men in Americans had been abducted by aliens.
Speaker 4I've been involved in the development of space vehicles for expiration for over sixty years. You know, there are massive problems with the idea that advanced aliens can simply work themselves around the galaxy. The starship Enterprise travels at multiple luck pusion.
Speaker 5It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before.
Speaker 1A giant, hairy creature, part ape, part Matt in Luckness, a twenty four a mile long bottomless lake in the Highlands of Scotland.
Speaker 2It's a creature known as the Luckness Monster. Monstert.
Speaker 1Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith. And this week we're going to be talking about a film that I saw last week called Alien Intrusion and how it relates to something called the ultraterrestrial hypothesis. In the interview that follows, you're going to hear a discussion with Joe Laycock, Natasha Michaels, Jeb Card, all of whom have been on Monster Talk before joined the Tasha teach religious studies. We've had them on to discuss Tulpa's in relationship to the slender Man, and we had on Joe to talk about Satanism and the Satanic Panic and
Speaker 1dungeons and dragons, and we've had Jebond to talk about fairies with our archaeological fantasies crossover. Anyway, you'll recognize their voices, I believe if you're a regular listener, And their discussion we're about to have is about ultraterrestrials, John Keel, the paranormal Unified Field theory, and this film Alien Intrusion and how it ties in UFOs and demons. It's really quite interesting and I hope you'll give it a listen. And I want to give a quick thank you to Peter Ahler, my friend who joined me to watch this film in preparation for this episode Morensterutle. All right, so welcome to
Speaker 1Monster Talk again, all of you.
Speaker 2Thank you very much, Oh, thank you.
Speaker 1So we're here tonight to talk about some things. This is going to be kind of a roundtable discussion, and I, along with Sharon Hill, have been working on researching something that we're calling well, actually, Jeb, why don't you explain what the PUFT is.
Speaker 2The puff to the paranormal unified field theory. Yeah, I think we're.
Speaker 6Going to come back to it again and again, but basically wrestling with the idea that all sorts of things that people put into what academics might call the Celtic amelia, which include conspiracy theory as well as words like occult, paranormal, etcetera. I'm probably not the person to talk about this in this conversation, but that people would talk about as being paranormal are all increasingly in the community that's very interested in such topics interlinked.
Speaker 2Yeah, and it's a thing that I'm interested in. And when we went to.
Speaker 6Cryptocon we saw very firsthand, and it's a thing I've been talking about a lot. And then I think I finally all convinced you all that it really was a thing after seeing it there with dogmen and whatnot.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1So, yeah, the Michigan dog Man and other aspects of the paranormal, they don't fit into the flesh and blood, meat and bones sort of aspect of things. And this is not new because even really early on in the UFO world, there was a split. And I say UFOs first because that sort of predates Bigfoot. Doesn't really predate the yety, but it does predate Bigfoot. There was a split between the UFOs are real physical craft and UFOs
Speaker 1are some sort of ultradimensional or transdimensional phenomena. And I guess the guy who really focused on the ultraterrestrial hypothesis, in fact, who gave it that name, is John Keel.
Speaker 6He doesn't invent he doesn't invent the concept. And honestly, I think we're probably going to backwork into the roots of this in all right, So, if you listen to the show that I'm usually on archaeological fantasies, we generally have two drinking game words. One is victorian in and the other is theosophy. And I'm about to say both. So I just did what's that that.
Speaker 7We have drinks and hands.
Speaker 6All right, So why don't we introduce why don't we talk about let's bring in the other people on this, because I guarantee, because I'm just going to say this straight out one y'all's discussion of Tulpa's, which are very tied into this on Monster Talk was astonishing and also it appears to have made it on the X Files, which is pretty amazing.
Speaker 1That is awesome.
Speaker 2Locks Yeah, yeah, no, very much.
Speaker 1Well, let me let me explain why I invited joined Natasha on. It's because, in conjunction with his research I've been doing to help Jeb on an article that he's working on, I synchronistically had a friend point me to this theater event that was happening called Alien Intrusion, and I looked into it and within about five minutes realized that this was not a UFO documentary. This was a religious documentary.
Speaker 6Well it is a UFO doctors, Well it is, I'd say, it's just kind of the point, right, it is.
Speaker 1It is a Well, in fact, we'll get to that. But because of the fact that it looked to me like they were basically saying that UFOs were a demonological phenomena, I thought that there was a good chance it might tie in with this ultraterrestrial hypothesis stuff, and so I went to watch the film. And after and even before I went to watch the film, I reached out to Joe because this is a film in theaters, right, It was a special event Fathom Events hosted, So this is
Speaker 1like a one night simulcast across many theaters.
Speaker 6And so you saw in the theater, and Joe and Natasha, I believe you saw it in the theater.
Speaker 7It was one night only. How could we resist?
Speaker 2That's right? Yeah, So I.
Speaker 6Am going to be the This is a horrifying position for everybody involved. I guess I'm going to be the audience proxy because I have not seen this. I've looked into it. I've seen the guest list or the speaker's list, but I have not seen this.
Speaker 2So I will probably be.
Speaker 1Asking questions about us. I'm the I'm the far end of that spectrum. I've lived this. So when I was growing up, my mother told me not to be afraid of UFOs or aliens, because Lucifer is the lord of the heir and could make all things appear to be something that they're not. Basically, that it's much more likely that it's demons than physical aliens from another planet, and that was really seriously the hypothesis of this film.
Speaker 2Yeah, so it did go straight up demons.
Speaker 1Oh absolutely, And I want to get into it quite Yeah, I'm just no. But but Joe or Natasha both being religious studies people, both being very familiar with the field and having a much deeper knowledge of religious studies than I have. I mean, I've only got sort of the evangelical Christian view and the lightest understanding of other religions. So I thought it would be helpful to have them to give us some context. So I really appreciate you guys joining us and for attending the film, because it gives you absolutely the best position to talk about it.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 7Well, the way that they did this is you were saying, Fathom looks like they were set up if you know, there's a Broadway show and you want to watch it at a movie theater live, and so using that as a distributor whatever audience there would be. It seems that it just got split up across because multiple movie theaters in Austin were showing it. When we went, there were less than a dozen people in the audience, A good portion of them seemed to be ufo buffs who walked out in anger really about halfway through it. And I looked today on the IMDb page for this film, and
Speaker 7in the trivia it actually says lots of people walked out of this film because they didn't know it was religious. And Natasha also got pretty restless and got up during the film and actually saw an audience member berating the poor guy taking tickets.
Speaker 2Oh God, Asha, what can you remember.
Speaker 7From that conversation?
Speaker 8So he was out talking to the young young guy taking tickets and was just saying that, well, I guess I should have researched this film better, but shame on you guys for showing this.
Speaker 5And this poor kid is you know, he doesn't make these decisions. He take some tickets, and then he kept saying, you know, I want to go out and get a breath of fresh air, but I don't have my ticket to return. You know, He's like, I think I need to go take a walk, And he seemed very very agitated. And I was actually in the search of trying to get myself a water or something, because by this point the movie had been going on for about two hours, and at this point I was just beating us over the head with New Testament versus and different things from
Speaker 5Paul's letters.
Speaker 7So it's so.
Speaker 1It would have been a great one hour sort of presentation I think. I mean, you could have made the case in an hour, but they stretched it out to two and then had like a Q and a afterwards.
Speaker 2A Q and a.
Speaker 6Yeah, like there were people from the film sort of the company or whatever.
Speaker 1Right, Oh it was. It was definitely a bait and switch, I think.
Speaker 6Which the first IMDb review that shows up the title is I feel lied to, with lied to being all.
Speaker 2Caps, which is why I put a little more volume behind that.
Speaker 1Yeah, I do know the bait and switch evangelical approach has been around for a long time. I mean I remember many times when I was a kid going to the fair and then have like free puppet show and then you know it's a puppet show, but it is definitely an evangelical, you know, conversion puppet show.
Speaker 2I've also done that to get anthropology majors.
Speaker 5But yeah, I remember in college there was a free comedy night and it was an evangelical bait and switch.
Speaker 1Yeah, I don't think that's kind of like it's almost like a pious fraud, you know, it's not like quite faking a miracle, but it is it is a little bit deceptive.
Speaker 6And which is by the way, literally the subtitle of the movie, it is Alien Intrusion Unmasking a Deception.
Speaker 1Well, surprise, I got one of the deceptions for here.
Speaker 6Narrated by John Schneider, one of the two dudes from the Dukes of Hazzard.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 7Yeah, that was also interesting because John Schneider now does something called Faith Works Productions and so important. Again, but he did not introduce himself as Bo Duke from Dukes of Hazzard. He introduced himself as Clark Kent's dad from the show Smallville.
Speaker 2Interesting, that's right, yeah.
Speaker 7After the sci fi craft.
Speaker 6Yeah, and also just people who are, you know, younger than a lot.
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 1Let me tell you a different view of the audience. My theater sold out two auditoriums, and it real almost entirely church groups where everybody knew everybody. Everybody was like, hey, brother so and so, and hey sister so and so. There was there was a real sense that I had walked into a church service. And before the movie started, there were a lot of advertisements about Creation Ministries. It was really and the narrator or not the narrative. The
Speaker 1director of the show is from Australia, so he wasn't ken Ham, but there is a strong I'm just just kind.
Speaker 2Of immediately go where my mind went.
Speaker 1Thank you, Yeah, no exactly. It wasn't kN Ham, but it was yet another strong Australia anti evolutionary thing, and I wish Karen was here to defish your country.
Speaker 7Christian Ministries had a nasty breakup with ken Ham in two thousand and six, and the reasons for this are not entirely clear, but there's a lot online if you want to dig into that breakup.
Speaker 1It was a secret anti chin Beard sort of movement.
Speaker 2Wow wow, that's harsh but fair. By the way, he does not have.
Speaker 6Like they sell a little pamphlet about UFOs at the so pretty much if you go to the Creation Museum, all the stuff they sell text wise is theirs, which surprised me when I went there.
Speaker 2I've not been to the ark and Karra, but.
Speaker 6In the Creation Museum and they do have a tiny little pamphlet on UFOs and they don't do the demonology thing. They actually have a largely skeptical perspective that basically says sightings are probably blah blah blah mistakes, and the idea of aliens reifies evolution.
Speaker 1Let me just say that a good seventy percent of the first half of this movie. I know that's a little bit of too much math, probably, but the predominant content of the first half of the film was about what the UFO phenomena is and why modern day science rejects the idea that physical extraterrestrial craft are traveling from other planets. It could have been put on by psycop It was absolutely you know. Bullet pointed the same arguments
Speaker 1that most physicists have against the idea that just as a visiting Earth, but they moved, which does open the way for demons, which makes that they move on to the argument, well, people are seeing something, so what are they seeing. If it's not physical craft, it must be demons. So I mean that there's a lot of other things that I would have liked them to include it, but the idea that maybe it's misidentified or misunderstood, or sleep paralysis, none of those ideas came up.
Speaker 2So how much of it was abduction?
Speaker 6Like looking at the IMDb thing, abduction seems to come up a lot, was a lot of it, which if they're talking about sort of demonological you know, nocturnal attacks, abduction seems like it would be a big part of Is that a big focus in the film Big?
Speaker 1The second half is all about abduction, Yeah, because.
Speaker 7The narrator says, abductees are the most testable evidence that we have of this phenomenon.
Speaker 2Wow, which I guess wow in.
Speaker 7The sense that you can bring an abductee to a.
Speaker 2Lab and like yeah on them.
Speaker 7But a lot of upologists, including you know, Jacques Ballet, have said the contact these are the worst evidence, right, The best evidence are is ideally a video or something like that, and not somebody who is remembering something under hypnosis.
Speaker 6But on the other hand, of course Ballet is also mister aliens or fairies, which if you want to be away with the fairies and missing time under the hills and uh.
Speaker 1They brought up fairies. You have been so proud of them.
Speaker 2Oh, I've made all the made all the mistakes in my life.
Speaker 5Especially when they use the abductees, because it's like they were they were trying to show in the first half or the first two thirds, like this is all illogical. You know, fast than light travel is illogical, and you know all this other stuff.
Speaker 7And then when we got to the abductees.
Speaker 9There was just so much crying and with like really sad piano keys in the background. Music was horrible, and it was just it was just this like kind of blatant appeal to emotion as it.
Speaker 2Was telling stories over sat piano. Interesting.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, that's very popular.
Speaker 6Sorry, it's a little in joke there, but so so it was very very like like sort of therapy culture kind of sort of with the app which is not a new.
Speaker 2Criticism of abduction stuff.
Speaker 1Not so much. They treated the abductees like they'd had legitimate experiences. They they very politely discussed the common feature of the rectal probes, and then they basically came down to correct me if I'm over simplifying this, Natasha Joe. But I think it came down to invoking the name of Jesus Christ repeatedly is the best defense against alien abduction.
Speaker 7That's right, and and and two of the people in the film are involved in this ministry called alien resistance.
Speaker 6I think the websites they were in there, that's a amazing I've been.
Speaker 1In their church yep, right across right.
Speaker 6Well they're not anymore, but they used to be literally across the street from the UFO Museum in Roswell.
Speaker 7Yeah, and there's a resistance is fertile?
Speaker 1Nice?
Speaker 2Nice?
Speaker 6Do they still have as their symbol the sort of no smoking aka Ghostbusters like the red circle with oh my god, what the alien had? The gray head in the middle. My favorite picture period of all is I went to the two thousand and two UFO Festival in Roswell and the Rallians, the group that is basically a contact ee flying saucer religious new religious movement primarily based out of Quebec.
Speaker 2All those a ton of them in Korea.
Speaker 6They were going to speak, not it wasn't gonna be rey Ale, but it was disciples of His who made their hair and beard look like his, who were going to speak at the International UFO Museum and Research Center aka the big museum with a almost as big gift shop attached to it. Then at the last minute their speaking got revoked because they were too weird for the UFO Museum, which is a merit badge. But they were allowed in to the Alien Resistance storefront church, which at
Speaker 6that time existed across the street. And the story behind that is I know his name is Guy. I don't remember his last name, but he was from I want to say, Tennessee in the nineteen nineties, and.
Speaker 2If you all know the story, better please interrupt me.
Speaker 6In the nineteen nineties, he started having in essence what would be sort of alien abduction or what a skeptic would say would be sleep paralysis events, but he interpreted them from a born again perspective as demonic attacks, and so he decided, well, where am I going to go into the belly of the beast. He went to Roswell, right at the sort of the height of all of this, and opened up a storefront church of a ministry again aliens because he believes their demons. But they allowed the aliens,
Speaker 6who say they don't worship aliens, they say they're atheists, but they kind of worship aliens, allowed them to come in and speak. And there is a picture that a dude who was sort of reliving the film Six Days in Roswell, which is a very interesting film. God of me listening to all of this, and I now have it in every who am I? Because I don't want to do this lecture at the beginning of semesters. The guy I'm Alone, I want to say it was Guy Alone that seems very like Batman, villain from the thirties.
Speaker 2I wasn't certain, but that sounds right. Yeah.
Speaker 7Yeah, He and Joe Jordan, who they said was the moufon director for South Korea. Interesting players in the film.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah, and then Jim Subtle from Roswell as well.
Speaker 2Wow. Yeah.
Speaker 6I don't know if they're still in Roswell. I know they are no longer in right in front of the museum, but I don't know if they've left Roswell.
Speaker 2I get the feeling they're still there.
Speaker 6I saw some YouTube videos a few years ago of them having sort of an alternate conference at the same time as the Big festival, and one of the people in the film spoke there, who I don't believe has the same ideology one Nick Redford.
Speaker 1I don't know what Nick believes exactly, but I know that he makes his living off of the same sort of topics that I'm interested in and doesn't have the sort of skeptical framework that I do. But he was in the movie quite a bit, and every time Nick Redford appears. It's moments later we see John Keel over and over and over again. So it's like Nick Redford, Nick Nick Redford serves as John Keel's proxy for this film.
Speaker 2Well, do we want to briefly talk about that a little? Like?
Speaker 1Like, not briefly, I think we should talk about a whole lot.
Speaker 6Okay, all right, I mean I just didn't know if if there was anything else we need to get out of the way.
Speaker 1Yeah, no, I think. I mean, I think the main thing is that, you know, my position as a skeptic. You know, we're a podcast that works with Skeptic Magazine. But I've always felt that I think it's absolutely fine that people have religion. I you know, I grew up in a religious family. I'm not an anti god person. I'm not an anti religious person. I am a very pro evidence person, and I don't think I think that the usefulness of using skeptical methodology to figure out whether
Speaker 1things are really demonstrably true or testably true or not is important, and critical thinking is important, and I find it unfortunate that this whole thing is also wrapped up in a big anti evolution nutshell, because the I think there's very few scientific theories that have turned out to be so demonstrably reliable as natural selection as an explanation for evolution, and as a quick reminder for audience members who may not know it, the evolution itself was never
Speaker 1really debatable. I think prior to Darwin, Darwin was looking for a mechanism to explain it. He wasn't inventing evolution. Evolution already existed. His grandfather had talked about evolution. But what he did was came up with natural selection as a methodology to explain how, over time, selective pressures can cause change that looks like design. And it's interesting to me that that a group that's primarily focused on pro creation as not pro creation but promoting.
Speaker 2Yea, is that they're parly clear of that up.
Speaker 1I think that that's their primary sort of focus. That they would hop into the alien hot tub and want to have a swim with us is fascinating. So and I'm not sure where that metaphor just went, but uh.
Speaker 6Well, well, let's what's I think. As an archaeologist, I like to sort of look at things from it. Let's let's go to an origins. If you watch any random documentary about although maybe these days maybe not so much, but in the past, and I think sleep in today about UFOs, what would the origin be like?
Speaker 2What? What what would be the.
Speaker 6UFOs were first blah blah blah blah blah, Well, what would it prop what would the sort of bill.
Speaker 1Popular Keith Arnold as the first and then the.
Speaker 1Yeah, and then they go back and say, oh, but there were also airships and go back to the Bible and Ezekiel, right.
Speaker 6But the thing, so, the typical kind of kind of perspective on this is you have this sudden emergence of this phenomenon of strange things seen in the sky that may have something to do without her space, although it takes a few years for it to sort of go there in the summer of nineteen forty seven, specifically starting, as Keiland has pointed out, on Saint John's Day, John about this day on June twenty fourth, bye, And I would love to turn this over to people who probably know a hell a lot more about this than I do. The actual origins of all of this can of what
Speaker 6we call flying saucers and UFOs and many of the ideas that we see emerge after nineteen forty seven, can all be found? Can I'll put your glasses in your hand. In the late Victorian period and in sort of the movement known as Theosophy, which is sort of a reaction to modernity in some ways and in other ways it's not. It gets really complicated, and I'd love you all to talk about more than me. That then kind of tracks through places like Maurice Doriol and Richard Shaver and gets
Speaker 6up there. So the reason I say this is the idea that you'd have psychical interests or what we'd call parapsychological or psychic mixed in with strange things in the sky, mixed in with weird places, mixed in with strange creatures is actually not new.
Speaker 2And if anybody wants to jump in, feel free.
Speaker 7Yeah, a couple of things. You know, the Christian attitude that these are just demons goes back to probably the seventies and is you know, fairly mainstream and serving the movements. How Lindsay wrote a lot about this, that the UFOs are the false miracles that's going to usher in the end times. What was different about this was I have never seen a Christian take on UFOs. That gets into Jacques deval At and John Keel and what you call the puffed yeah, unified field theory. And there's some consequences
Speaker 7to that. One of them is people like haw lindsay assumed UFOs have never happened before, and if they're happening now, it's because these are the end days. Interesting in this film they have to say, well, this is actually always gone on, right, because there's always been demons you mentioned I think Blake mentioned Ezekiel, which is interesting Ezekiel did not show up in this film, yeah, because that would have kind of throw a monkey ranch into they're claim that all anything that looks like an alien is demonic, right, because they can't say the wheels that's seen by the prophet Ezekiel were demonic.
Speaker 6They have because they're they're angelic, right, They're angelic, right, So that's interesting.
Speaker 7That that was sort of a left interesting the.
Speaker 5Angel Gabriel and Mohammad showed up, as did the as did Joseph Smith.
Speaker 1That right, what yeah, yeah, because these are it goes. I think that tied into the nobody should add anything to the Bible approach, right, like the original prophecies of the Bible are the Bible incomplete and anything that happens after that is entirely suspect.
Speaker 6Right, So this this thing basically argue that Gabriel and Mohammad is demonic and Joseph Smith is demonic. Not them, but the revelations thereof.
Speaker 7Yes, wonderful at scientology. And so really the film was putting all three of these religions in the same category. Who propaganda When.
Speaker 6They talk about scientolic, tell me about the scientology that may actually get into some of what I would love to talk about. Tell me more what they talked about in the film.
Speaker 7Well, so they're approaching euthology from what I would call a haresiological perspective, basically saying this is a false religion. Right, they say it's a scientific theory. It's not it's a false religion. And I mean they actually make some good points on that front. Some religion scholars might agree with them, not that it's a false religion, but that it serves a kind of religious function in people's lives. And then they say, and we know that there are religions that have been started by contact with these entities such as scientology, and there's a slide very quickly of a scientology temple.
Speaker 7I don't really think it's an accurate assessment of the history of scientology. I think they were banking on the fact that people will have heard of this religion and they'll have a negative attitude about it, and this will sort of score points with the audience down.
Speaker 6So they didn't get into like say Jack Parsons now because given that they got redfern there. So we will probably come back to this, but probably Nick Redferns, who's written a lot on UFOs and his big thing and he talks about like his ide you know, he likes the idea that like things like NeSSI and Bigfoot may actually be psychic thought forms or spirit not spirits, but more parapsychological than biological. But he wrote a book in twenty ten, I believe, called Final Events where he argues
Speaker 6that there has been this group inside the United States government. He calls the Collins elite that have become eventually born again or evangelical Christians that pretty much buy into this worldview that UFOs in fact are demonological and that they intend to do something about it. And I actually there's an episode of Sharon Hill's fifteen credibility straight. We talked about this at some length because that's what I do. How the recent revelation of and things related to it. I don't want to really get into this too heard unless it becomes an issue because there will be a
Speaker 6rabbit hole of the Department of Defense. Recent UFO project actually lends some interesting credibility to the idea that such a group or groups like it, or one could see how such groups might be in essence bouncing off of a longer term sort of parapsychological, youthhological sort of I like to use the word rolodex, but sort of contact list of people you call people in the remote viewing thing.
Speaker 6And again, this is getting into a rabbit hole. So let's leave it alone for the moment. But that's why we keep bringing up in addition to him being the one who is not a primary religious apologist.
Speaker 2In the film Nick Redford.
Speaker 7And Final Events is discussed explicitly.
Speaker 2Yeah it is. Oh, so let's just let's let's talk about that then.
Speaker 1Yeah, so tell us. I mean I still have not read Final Events, although after seeing this, I.
Speaker 2Well, what do they say in the film, what do they say in the film.
Speaker 1I wrote down Final Events. Look this up. This is a super helpful, right. It was one of the I know they made quotes from Redfern he explicitly talked about he said, I talked about this in Final Events. I believes what he said. I can go back and get the exact quotes.
Speaker 7Later, Redford names his source, who he said was a priest.
Speaker 1And I've got that written down.
Speaker 2I didn't.
Speaker 1I didn't want to say it, but it's his Final Events.
Speaker 2He's been in Moufon.
Speaker 6He's been a long term UFO investigator, but he's also a priest.
Speaker 7He was the head of Nebraska move On, I believe.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, he was like a state director. Yeah yeah, but he's not.
Speaker 1I've got a contact in mouf On. I don't want to talk much about this, but he said that it's an interesting mix of people and there are people who you know, who believe in the extra tristial hypothesis, and there's people who explicitly believe there's angels and demons involved.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's correct.
Speaker 1I find that fascinating. But you know, it's so. Moufon has been around the mutual ufone network exactly.
Speaker 2Yeah, since the seventies.
Speaker 6It basically arose out of the ashes of APRO. I think was the Aerial Phenomenon Research Organization, which sort of arose out of the ashes of NICAPAP, which was sort of for a long time the big UFO Civilian Bureau since the fifties and so since the seventies and especially since the eighties, Muffon has been the sort of last man standing of UFO groups and the recent Department of Defense stuff. It has not been proven that government funding was directed towards them, but pretty much everybody's looked at
Speaker 6the situation, looks at timelines and says Robert Bigelow was funding them at points, and here's when he got money from the government, and it's the same time.
Speaker 2Therefore, therefore therefore.
Speaker 1Yeah, so there's a lot of interesting ties. You can draw lines all over the place.
Speaker 6Yeah, so final events is brought up in the film interesting. So again this book that Redford, and you can find a lot of podcasts and interviews and things he's done. He pretty much tells you a lot about the book out there, so you can just look this up everywhere. But basically he makes the argument that so in this guy Ray b O'Shea, who is in movifile comes in and says, look, there's this group called the Collins Elite that has come to me and has told me that there are groups inside the United States government that are
Speaker 6very involved in UFOs, but they have come to the conclusion that it is demonic, and some of them want to fight it, and some of them want to weapon exploit it.
Speaker 2And then this all gets very stranger things.
Speaker 1And then I just inject here that the drinking game now switches to Tom Collins Elite, which is a regular Tom Collins. That the ad who that's your call, that's your abbadouri makes it green? Go for it, all right?
Speaker 2So oh there you go, all right, nice, Okay, that's fair.
Speaker 6But he basically spins this tale, which I used the word spins a tale simply in the sense he produces a narrative. I'm not actually putting a judgment on that. That Jack Parsons, who is one of the co founders of the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, he was in the same social circles until things went sour with al Ron Hubbard, which is why I brought him up at that point. And he was a follower of Alistair Crowley and the Ordy templar is it ordo templary orientalis the which again
Speaker 6I'm not the expert on this panel on but basically Alister Crowley's kind of spin off from the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn and blah blah blah. So the one of the co founders of JPL in the forties is also a hardcore interested in the esoteric occult scene in California, and Redfern argues that near the end of his life, because he blows himself up, he's he's he's a major pioneer of rocketry in the United States. But near the end of his life he starts wanting to
Speaker 6offer his services to the newly founded nation.
Speaker 2Of Israel, and he gives them a little too.
Speaker 6Much when he's making sort of his job proposal, too much in terms of potentially classified information. So there is an investigation, and Redford in the book basically says the group FBI and whoever then investigate him, go, wait, he's hanging out with demon worshippers, and wait, he's doing all these things and wait, and then they link this into alleged UFO stuff, and this begins this sort of Delta greenish kind of group in the government, and I have
Speaker 6thoughts about some of this history that I think is not relevant to really get into. But that's basically what Redford is suggesting. And then around the time of Ronald Reagan becoming president, this group changes its perspective in Redford's telling, decides that things like abduction are demonic attacks, that in essence, we are a farmed for demons eating our souls. Again, this is Redford and telling the story. He was adamantly said we multiple times. He doesn't believe this. He just says that he believes there's a group that says this, and that this group was at one point sort of
Speaker 6plotting various things to try to defend the United States with spiritual warfare.
Speaker 1It's fascinating to me because I think when you look at all these well, think of it this way. When you look at government, I think most people think of sort of a monolithic, long term thing, this organization, But it's made up of people, and each one of these individuals has their own belief systems, and it's really easy when you're thinking about these kind of stories to sort of put your own spin on it. I mean, the fact that you've got Ronald Reagan he represents to some
Speaker 1people this sort of ultimate, you know, macho American tough guy, and then to other people we see him as a sort of a befuddled old man who you know, relied on astrologers to get his information. And there's so many nuances to the individuals involved in these stories, but there's such a rich, rich well of material to form your own opinions on, it's it's really hard to kind of pin down what's really going on. It reminds me of
Speaker 1some of the better episodes of The X Files, where you know, you think you know what's going on, and then there's a twist, but what if it really means this? And what if it really means that? And I don't really know what it all means, but I'm more inclined to think that, using sort of the same natural selection thing, that what's really going on is we just get by. Like the sort of bozos who sort of make these decisions that sort of form our government, we just managed to get by. Like the fact that we're still around is kind of a remarkable because a lot of really strange people with weird beliefs are really making things work well.
Speaker 6Given the events of this weekend. Yes, yeah, but that we are all still alive is impressive. So Joe and Natasha, you both mentioned that in the film this was the first time you had really seen as you mentioned like John Keel and Jacques Vallet, and I think for what we're talking about, that's I think that's actually really important. Could you talk about that a little more like not that's personally I ever seen them the first I ever seen them in relation to these ideas.
Speaker 7Yeah. So, I mean usually when I see Christians talking about UFOs, they they say that they're demons, kind of just to get it out of the way. Yeah, So it's just kind of just like, don't pay attention to UFOs. Those are just demons, And this was different. These were two people guy I'm Alone and Joe Jordan who were really part of the UFO culture and then it appears that they became kind of born again afterwards.
Speaker 2And so interesting. Interesting.
Speaker 7It was kind of what in religious Sudy was something to called hybridity, right, where two differentations begin to resemble each other.
Speaker 6I have literally edited volume and ran a conference on hybridity. So it's a thing that I've up to the gills on.
Speaker 2Yes, but I.
Speaker 7See this a little bit as a as a case study in hybridity, because the one of the narrators begins saying, you know how annoyed he is when people like their aliens say, oh, well, Jesus was really just an advanced alien, right who came to give us wisdom. And so I see this kind of turning it around where the kind of christianized youuthology weirdly mirrors groups that have been doing this youthologized Christianity, yes for a while, and it's a kind of you got chocolate in my peanut butter, right, Well, yeah,
Speaker 7that's blending of ideas.
Speaker 1Heaven's State, Heaven's Gate was like that. They I mean, they had their whole the luciferian actions of these aliens versus the good level above human approach, right, So exactly. But before before we go further, I would like to mention that when you're talking about hybridity and you're talking about aliens, I want to be clear we're not talking about alien hybrids, which is a different thing.
Speaker 2Well together, I mean, i'd be very curious here.
Speaker 6From my perspective, hybridity is basically it's as an archaeologist, as a student of social this.
Speaker 2That and the other. It's a very valuable concept.
Speaker 6All it's a contested concept that people have issues with it, but basically a recognition, a recognizing.
Speaker 2Recognition, that's what I'm looking for that Uh.
Speaker 6So much of culture is actually made in the interstitial spaces in between things. Uh and that you know, the idea that, oh, there's a cultural norm over here. It's like, well, in reality, a lot of things are mixed up. And actually you understand the structures of society and the structures of global society by looking at that mixing up. Is that is that sort of what y'all are talking about.
Speaker 7Yeah, we used to use this term syncretism, yes, religious traditions, and I decided, well, hybridy is better because that implies a kind of agency that this doesn't just happen by accidents. And you can really see that agency when you see these Christians kind of reading John Keel and sort of and often.
Speaker 6A subversive agency, often a subversion of existing concepts.
Speaker 7Right, So this kind of polemical reading of people like Valet and Keel and sort of seeing what here is useful to us and what are we going to have to kind of sweep under the rug to make our arguments.
Speaker 6Well, the thing I find particular interesting. So you all mentioned you know that they didn't mention Ezekiel, but you all were like, but they should because they're pulling this from ancient aliens or ancient astronauts or the term I use in my book ancient extraterrestrials because no one's trademarked it.
Speaker 2But Ezekiel is always brought up there.
Speaker 6But as you all pointed out, you can't call that demonic if you're wanting to say this is all demonic, blah blah blah. And I think what you're finding there and this is one of the beauties when you, for example, I look at material culture that's hybrid is when you can find trace markers, when.
Speaker 2You can find uh.
Speaker 6There's a term that we use that is on the tip of my tongue, and I'll come back to it when it when it pops in my head.
Speaker 1A brief interjection. The term Jeb was trying to remember is skew morphism. He wrote me after the interview to say that when elements transfer from a design and when medium to a design and another, even though they aren't purely functionally needed, that's skew morphism, things like attempts at preserving elements of a desktop are books or newspapers, et cetera in a computer interface. There are tons of examples in archaeology, including rivets on ceramics that were modeled after midtal buckets. And we now return to the conversation.
Speaker 6When something survives in one material into another kind of medium. And it's really bugging me. I can't think of it right now, but you're seeing this here where you all expect, Ezekiel, it should be there if you're looking at things that are reinterpreted from a UFO perspective, But you can't do it over over here for the reasons that you brought up. And I think that's what's happening with.
Speaker 10Keel So John keel He he's often depicted as a respectable reporter, like a journalist in the nineteen fifties and sixties that then gets wrapped up in UFOs and weird.
Speaker 2Strology and so on.
Speaker 6Around his most famous book, The Mothman Prophecies, involving the incidents around nineteen sixty seven in Point Pleasant, West Virginia that he writes the book, And I want to say it's seventy five, where he was not the first person to sort of para to pioneer this idea of a sort of unified theeld theory that these things. He called himself a demonologist, and he didn't mean that in a theological sense, but he sort of did.
Speaker 7That was clouded extensively in the film Oh really from Operation Trojan Horse Ye, Yeah, which I am.
Speaker 6Literally reading right now. I had not read it before and I'm reading it right now. I'd read some of his other works in reality, keel if you read his first book, Jadoo, which has not been easily found until recently, Like it's not lost, but it was not as you could find Operation chijan On as you could find the mauthor prophecies. Good luck finding Jadu until we've now gotten into the era of easy self publishing. He started looking for magic. I mean you could pretty much just put
Speaker 6Max Weber in the index and index most pages. I mean, he literally talks about the lost magic of the landscape that is about to be swept away by industrial civilizations. So he goes to the Middle East and Egypt and India to find it, and that's how he starts. So the fact that he then pretty much in every one of his works brings in this concept of finding magic in the landscape, finding spirits in the landscape, finding a sort of not anti science but extra science in the landscape.
Speaker 6Well it is anti science in places, is not surprising. He then becomes the darling of sort of UFO intelligentsia, him and Jacques Vala. And since Vala was brought in, do you all want to talk about, like who Jack Vale is or.
Speaker 2Was he is? He's still alive unlike John Keel.
Speaker 1Yeah, I know him as a UFU researcher, but he was also a it guy.
Speaker 2He was.
Speaker 6He started as an early like he's now a venture capital. He started doing early statistics, early computer stuff. But I want to say around sixty five, nineteen sixty five, he decided to start applying his statistic statistical background to UFO sightings.
Speaker 2He came up with a few interesting things.
Speaker 6And then two years later it was like, actually they're fairies.
Speaker 1Wow. Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 6He writes the book called Passport to Magonia, which is I think literally written one year after mothmant It's not involved with Mothmam, but it's all in the same era and it's four years or five years before Mothmann prophecies where he goes back and he reads tons of the first Occupant UFO reports that are not obviously contact e Angelic. So when he used the word contact d we're talking about basically since around nineteen fifty to fifty one, people, many of whom who had a background in theosophical lodges
Speaker 6other esoteric pursuits. They meet, often very white, Nordic tall These are names they give, and some of them were actually Nazi sympathizers.
Speaker 2Others were not.
Speaker 6In the desert and say, oh, here's a new revelation. But you start having in the middle of the nineteen fifties reports in France and then in South America, and then in the United States and elsewhere people seeing little people collecting flowers and doing weird things outside of flying saucers and then running away. Valet, in his book in nineteen sixty eight Passworamagonia catalogs these, analyze these and says these are almost the same, if not the same as and then he pulls out a huge amount of early modern,
Speaker 6late medieval to early modern stories from Europe of fairies involving people who are taken away by the fairies. This is when inbduction is beginning to become a thing in uthology. People that have missing weird time, have strange events and so on. And Valet basically makes the argument, and this is the sort of bedrock of what I call the puff the parami unified field theory these things, and Keel makes the same argument, these things are normal to this planet. They are not from outer space in nineteen forty five
Speaker 6because we blew up nuclear bombs. They've been here forever. They're older than us, and they're strange and we don't understand them. Yeah, which then kind of fits demons, if you want to go that way.
Speaker 1Yeah, it does. And also I think most people would know weirdly, they would know Valet through his proxy, which was as Claude Lenc Lacomb And uh.
Speaker 6Yeah, there's some dispute whether that's really based on them or not. But Valet was one of the people that Spielberg was reading. Yeah, he created close encounters of the third kind, right, and they used to get a Heinech well and jail and Heinech, by the end of his life had basically come over to a parapsychological slash sort of quasi cultish perspective on UFOs as well.
Speaker 2To be honest, So, I.
Speaker 1Know we're going to keep talking about sort of is you followg your religion. That's one of the is the ultratreustural hypothesis of religion. Your religious studies people, what's a religion?
Speaker 2Wow?
Speaker 7So when I teach so, when.
Speaker 5I teach World Religions at Texas State, one of the assignments I have my students do is to create a definition of religion. They have to do it three times throughout the semester. And this is really be to kind of demonstrate that there is no inherent definition to religion, that we create working definitions based upon the data that we have. And so, and that's how I would answer it.
Speaker 1Well, the reason I ask is because I think over the course of Monster Talk, I've talked to a lot of different people about religion, because religion crosses into monsters in a lot of interesting ways. And one of the things that seems, I guess in modern in modern times, especially within Christianity, religion is about a faith that's what you believe. But that didn't seem like it was always the case. Religion was sometimes what you do. It was the actions you take and the sort of practices that you have, and maybe it's a hybrid of that.
Speaker 5But well, there's a one theoretical model thinking about religion that says that there are religions that are more based on orthodoxy, so what you believe, and religion is more based on orthopraxy what you do, and this is how.
Speaker 7You determine who is in or not in the religion.
Speaker 5And I think that's a really interesting divide, a very interesting kind of theoretical tool that can be used to think about religions. Another one that I was thinking about you guys are talking about this puffed theory, is the idea of a sacred canopy. And this was made by sociologist Peter Berger.
Speaker 6That's a cannop pay, that's a canno pey, very different.
Speaker 5So the sacred canopy, and Joe can jump in if you can explain this a little bit better than I can. But the sacred canopy is the idea that religion is a way to organize the world, that we are bombarded by information all times, and that religion is a way to kind of make categories and to put things in their place, and that you kind of exist under this large sacred canopy, and that to be in a religion is to say say, oh, I know where to put this new phenomenon. I just saw it goes into this category.
Speaker 5And so in many ways, the idea of puffed, I think, is in some ways making a sacred canopy out of this saying that all of this data is actually interconnected and interwoven.
Speaker 7I don't know, I.
Speaker 2Could definitely tell that disagree with me.
Speaker 7So maybe no, that was I thought that was That was great, Natasha. So in religius studies, we know that religion as what we call a second order category, meaning it's not something that exists out in the world. It's something that we make up, and we decide what goes in the category and what doesn't. And there's not a perfect definition of what gets lumped in the category and what isn't. But one of the things I try to impress on my undergraduates is it's important that we are fair about what the rules are when we talk about what is or is not a religion, because there's something at stake. So in San Marcos, where Natasha and I teach,
Speaker 7there was someone on the city council who, in retweets was saying that Harry Potter is a religion, and so it is unconstitutional to have Harry Potter books in public schools. But Islam is not a religion, and so Muslims do not have any constitutional rights. And so that's the kind of gaming the system that goes on, which is why theories of religion are important. And to the credit of these filmmakers that Gary Bates is the filmmaker he actually says, I define religion as having the following three characteristics, and
Speaker 7he defines it in terms of answering questions, right, where do we come from, what are we're doing? What happens when we die? So he is at least fair right that he says, these are the rules of the game, and by these rules, ethology is a religion.
Speaker 1The reason I am because they treated within that film, they treated religious eupology upology as though it were religion, or it seemed to me that they did, and it tied in so nicely with the Keel ultraterrestrial hypothesis. So Keel, even though he viewed himself as a demonologist, I didn't get the feeling in any of the things I've read. Of course, I still haven't read this Operation Trojan Horse yet. But I didn't get the feeling that he was necessarily prescribing any sort of protection from these things. Oh god, no, yeah,
Speaker 1he was just saying, here or whatever this is, it's not of this world.
Speaker 6So John Keel basically suggests we all are living in a horror novel.
Speaker 2Nice.
Speaker 6Yeah, I mean he doesn't literally say that, but his is a dark world of at best tricksters and at worst things that eat us spiritually or otherwise.
Speaker 1Oh that fits in nicely with the fairies, doesn't it. Yeah, the fair folk.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, No, that's his world. Yeah, yeah, he is.
Speaker 6He has no where he the the in his world, Like if you read his Mothman prophecies, there's all these contact ees, but the aliens or whatever the hell they are, that they're he's they're talking to lie and lie in not good way. So, I mean, the the the famous beginning to end. Everybody forgets at the very beginning of the movie. Not the movie the they did make a movie, which is interesting, but the beginning of the book of the Mothman Prophecies. He tells you, by the way, this is all about this bridge collapse which killed forty six
Speaker 6people and then he writes this amazing book. I'm not saying it's true, but as a book it's really good. As the reason it's famous, it's creepy and at the end you've forgotten this. And then there's this bridge collapse, and all throughout he's having all of these people in his sort of network seuse he's going on the long John Neble Show, which is sort of the predecessor to Art bel which is the preecessor to George Norris, is the predecessor to the entire History Channel, and and contact teaser saying this is gonna happen, This is gonna happen.
Speaker 6He's freaking out about there's gonna be some horrible disaster and he's thinking it's a nuclear war or a giant power outage.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 6And then this bridge collapses in this town that he's been visiting for thirteen months. As he writes it, I have seen letters, like original letters in point pleasant of John Keel. I don't know what he believed, but I mean there's literally scrawled in the sides of these type written letters to people, I think something's bad is going to happen. Like he's not entirely bullshitting people those letters.
Speaker 7Too, and I believe Linda Scarborough.
Speaker 2Yes, Yeahsoel, you would have.
Speaker 6Yes, I wrote a fantastic article on the whole point pleasant Mothman stuff.
Speaker 7Yeah, but he he did tell her I think the men in Black, which kind of emerged partly out of the Mockman story or After your Baby kind of changeling lore there, and he actually, I think if you hang a go old cross up, this will help keep the men in Black away.
Speaker 6So he did occasionally make those sorts of suggestions, but not as supplications.
Speaker 7This was a letter to a friend basically.
Speaker 6Right, Yeah, yeah, so yeah, but he is very in this and I'd love to hear if you'd agree that. I would see that Keel sees a sort of a demon haunted world. I mean, and when he says a demonologist, he doesn't mean that he's he's not suggesting that he's he's the Warrens, He's not Earl of the Rain. He's not saying he's an actual demonologist. He's just basically saying this is a demon haunted world. And that's what I've been studying for the last forty years. But he does mean it with that sort of.
Speaker 2Menace.
Speaker 7Yeah, I will say, and the thing about this film, I think groups like creation ministries and answers in Genesis are very good at cherry picking right and finding people who have authority on a particular topic and homing in on the one quote that really makes their point and sort of sweeping other things under the rug. Keel and the Mackmann prophecies basically suggests that the ancient Israelites were being tricked by the entities. Yeah, and that the Arc of the Covenant has these electrical powers because it's basically a machine the entities told them to build. Of course,
Speaker 7none of that is going to show up in the Alien Intrusion movie. Keel's ideas are kind of held up as being sort of good research that leads us closer to the truth of what these entities are.
Speaker 6Well, and that's the thing in reading and reading Nick Redfern's Final Events like I again, because of the recent revelations about the DoD and more sort of thinking about and seeing who's involved, I'm like, you know, maybe he's describing an actual group of some kind and in sort of their interaction with more parapsychological uri Gellar led how puts off John Alexander groups inside the government. But the thing is, at one point, the sort of leap that he suggests this Colins elite made only kind of makes sense,
Speaker 6like that, the fact that they would have seen Crowley and his contact with this spirit called Lamb, which is only in recent times been allegedly tied into gray aliens and blah blah.
Speaker 2Basically, the point is.
Speaker 6Parts of it only makes sense if you actually know your ufology stuff, and they have to sort of sand parts off to put it in here. But that's been done, or allegedly been done. I have the page by the way for the alien intrusion thing up, and it is guy. I'm alone, and I'm looking at the credits. I see Nick Redfern, I see person in Johnny Hunt. I don't know who that is. The next one is Norio Hayakawa. So did he showed up in the film?
Speaker 1Yes?
Speaker 2Yes, what was his role in the film. I'm curious. I have a reason for asking.
Speaker 1He was if I remember correctly, and I could verify this later, but I believe he was along the same lines talking about the I remember if he explicit in many religious comments, but he seemed to be paralleling the comments from the guy from from Korea that that the whatever the physical explanation of aliens is that it's not thisly extraterstrial craft. Therefore it fits in with the demon hypothesis.
Speaker 5I remember thinking during the film that he was like the more reasonable gentleman. Yeah, he was a more reasonable reflection of the gentleman from South Korea.
Speaker 6So Nori Ohayakawa's primary calling card within ufology, and I think he's sort of backed off this a little, has been. He was for a long time the primary purpose person interested in studying the Dulcet, the Dulcet legend.
Speaker 2Do you all know the Dulcet legend, that's.
Speaker 1The secret military base beneath the Dulcei.
Speaker 6Yeah, the Archleda, the arschilda mountain mountain ridge in northwestern New Mexico that is tied into Paul Benowitz, all these other things. But basically, there's this legend that appears to have been at least partly seated, potentially by a member of the Air Force in the nineteen eighties Richard Dodi into the euthological and that gets really complicated, but of a horrifying underground and I'm just going to say, we've been talking about religion and demons. Just listen to everything
Speaker 6I'm about to say. A horrifying underground base where there are humans and aliens that have made a pact and they kidnap people and they.
Speaker 5Do horrible, horrible.
Speaker 6Experiments on large numbers of people. And this emerges in the late seventies early eighties, and that literally Level six is referred to as the Hell Level because of all the terrible things that are done to people there. And in reality, while the government made this pact, according to the legend, everything went horribly wrong. The aliens double crossed them, and they've been there for far longer, and there's deeper, deeper levels that the human zone have access to, and
Speaker 6eventually they killed all the humans, or they were a bunch of them killed in a firefight. And now it's this, it's pretty much hell under New Mexico. And so Dulcie has become this very sort of infamous thing that most ufologists don't think. There's necessarily a lot too, but it's a kind of beacon on what I believe Jerome Kart called the dark Side, sort of theoretical approach to UFO conspiracy theory.
Speaker 2The fact that they're talking to him is fascinating.
Speaker 7And Christopher Partridge, who's a religion scholar, has us basically looking at how when this phenomenon begins in the fifties, the aliens are very angelic. There are space brothers. I think Carl Jung called them technological angels, and then by the period that you're talking about, it's the opposite, right, They're demons, live underground, they torture people, and part I think kind of suggests that, you know, Christianity has just permeated our culture so thoroughly that this is just sort of naturally the way that these legends are going to
Speaker 7take shape.
Speaker 2And I think he's not wrong.
Speaker 6I also, though, as we've sort of all been I think kind of nosing around, I think that it's going both ways. And I'm one of my favorite authors is Michael Barkoon and his discussion of sort of forbidden knowledge and the idea that once you have some ideas and kind of conspiracy culture and in the cultic milieu, they all start to well, they start to hybridize, like we've been talking about, and these ideas coming from people like Keel and coming from people like Valet and Frankly, I'll just drop this here because we know I was going
Speaker 6to go there, coming from their ancestors, people like Charles Fok and people like the fiction writer HP Lovecraft of a demon haunted ancient aliens world are influencing the other side. And I would say that the two are are sort of influencing each other, which is how you end up with Norio Hayakawa and Nick Redfern in a Christian apologetic UFO demon documentary.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 7I mean, one thing that you know some theologians have said about the kind of fundamentalists movement and its claims that the Earth is five thousand years old and biblical and errancy, which are both positions of creation ministries international, is that this has kind of changed what Christianity is about. Right. It's taken a text that has many meanings and it's kind of actually said, well, really, this is about history and cosmology and geology, and that's kind of the most important thing to it. So while these movements present themselves
Speaker 7as being very conservative, they're actually it's something very new, right, that's a very new way of reading the Bible and interpreting ms to say, And I think we're seeing something similar. So just as the fundamental really begins in the beginning of the twentieth century in response to Darwin, Yeah, and so called Hierchrism of the Bible, and it sort of makes this new form of Christianity that's very concerned with kind of the discourse of science and the authority of science. It didn't exist before, and we may be seeing a similar move now right, Well, we're seeing this kind of new brand of Christianity that is about theories of the paranormal,
Speaker 7and it sort of begins to look increasingly like the people that it is in dialogue with.
Speaker 6Yeah, and if you throw in into this conspiracy theory, which is never far behind these topics, all of this starts to get very political.
Speaker 1Also, well, yeah, that's there. I guess one of the things that I am curious about is you've got this is an easy way for sort of an evangelical foothold, or at least an incursion into the ufology world. You know, it's a big production. I mean, I don't know what it costs exactly, but this was not a small thing, and I don't know if it's going to have an effect because they didn't have people there. You know, I
Speaker 1didn't see John three to sixteen come up on screen, you know, some of the classic sort of things. I would have expected an evangelical conversion sort of approach I didn't see. But what I did see was a straight up hey, you know, if you're a Christian, you should be concerned about ufology. You should care because this is the work of demons, right. So I don't know how it works as outreach, but I am curious as to how it works as far as latching itself into this mix, because there's no orthodoxy here as far as that goes. This is another example of I guess, using your term hybridism,
Speaker 1where you're taking something they're gloming into something that's not really a religion and trying to pick out the pieces they like well.
Speaker 6And Barkoon's term for that is improvisational apocalypticism.
Speaker 2Ooh, I like that.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah, So it didn't feel apocalyptic, but it definitely felt like so it felt like a war, like I don't know what the right word is for that, but it felt like this was a pitting us versus them, whatever they are.
Speaker 7But it actually was unusual to me how not apocalyptic it was. I assumed Christian's talking about UFOs is going to be this is a sign of the end times, right, you know, maybe left and I didn't see that. So that does suggest this is something new.
Speaker 6And this could be again maybe Keel and people like Keeld this is a permanent part of our reality kind of effect.
Speaker 2Possibly.
Speaker 7I think you're right. Yeah, I think if they've accepted Keel and Ballet enough to think that this is more or less normal. This isn't some new dispensation that began in nineteen forty seven signaling the end times. It's more or less okay and normal.
Speaker 1So going back to my personal feelings on this is I don't personally mind people trying to deal with what I would suspect is sleep paralysis in a variety of ways. If you have sleep paralysis problems in praying helps you with it, great, you know, But I don't you know, my personal experience was it wasn't effective. So I'd like to see some clinical trials on that or something. I just don't know. I mean, it's the kind of it's kind of the the I think the harm here is that if you tell people that, if they say, you know,
Speaker 1the name of Jesus Christ and it will drive away, uh, these alien invaders that are actually demons, and then it doesn't work, then it becomes they They even threw in the you know, real Christians versus the just wow walk the walk versus talk the talk kind of people.
Speaker 6Well, the one thing I do want to add here is that's been a that is not a new idea like that has there has There has been for I would say at least twenty years, this sort of dialogue within the kind of abductee community that oh the author so they'll point at you know, there was at one point the sort of the trifecta of abductee rights. There were others, but there was there was John Mack, the Harvard psychologist.
Speaker 2Oh god, I'm forgetting to say Bud.
Speaker 6Hopkins, but how because yep, they were both in there, and David Jacobs. Now, David Jacobs is one of those three that's still alive and he's talked about hybrid invasions. Bud Hopkins was sort of your X files like medical experimentation aliens, and John Mack was more they're here to warn us about ecological disaster. But there was always this undercurrent within the abduction community that if you said the Lord's prayer or if you invoke Jesus.
Speaker 2It would end this.
Speaker 6And this is not new, and there was always the idea that the abduction people are not talking about this, So this was the dirty secret.
Speaker 1I never could get it to work, but I you know, that was just my experience.
Speaker 7Well, we do know that Bud Hopkins would hypnotize people and sometimes they would recall details that he thought just didn't fit and so just delete them.
Speaker 2Yeah, exactly, exactly.
Speaker 6Apparently this element was one that all three of them, allegedly and again this is something I've heard were.
Speaker 2Like, let's not talk about that. Let's not talk about that at all. Yeah. And if you go back to.
Speaker 6Was it Betty Andreasen who's often considered the second or third kind of on the record alien that ductee in American culture, her visions or whatever you want to call them were fairly explicitly religious in nature, unlike say Betty and Barney Hill, but hers were, and that goes back to the early seventies, late sixties, I think, late sixties of the Betty andreas in case.
Speaker 7Joe Jordan's talking about the talk, the Talk versus walk the Walk Christians was also interesting. There was this great book called Paranormal America by the sociologists who at Baylor, who crunts these numbers from the Baylor Religion Survey that asked about paranormal topics, including aliens, and one thing they found was that religious people are more likely to believe in paranormal topics, but that regular church attendance correlates negatively. Right, So the ideal person to report a paranormal experience would
Speaker 7be someone who's religion but doesn't attend church regularly. In other words, a talk to talk, but not a walk the walk Christian.
Speaker 2Yeah, and that makes a lot of sense.
Speaker 7Yeah, So I thought that was interesting that he was finding that pattern as well.
Speaker 1Well.
Speaker 6I guess that makes me ask, then, So you've been talking about like sort of hooks in and outreach. What is the ultimate purpose from what you can tell of this film.
Speaker 2Is it to.
Speaker 6Get people who are interested in UFOs? Is it to explain to people why UFOs are demonic? What's this sort of the purpose of this particular film familiar again from what you can tell.
Speaker 7Honestly, I think part of it is CMI had this painful split with answers in Genesis. Answers in Genesis has the Creation Museum, they have the Noah's Arc thing. I think partly they just thought, we want market share, we want something to compete, so.
Speaker 6They want to get into pop So they're seeing this as sort of a pop culture outreach.
Speaker 7I think, yeah, more than anything, this was sort of just this is a way to get on the map and answers and and as can't do it, only we can do it. We've got this, this book that people are reading. Let's let's take a chance on this. I also think this was an attempt to sort of be the apostle to the sci fi geeks, particularly by having the narrator emphasize as credentials as you know, being on the show Smallville. So I think and they sort of thought, this is another angle we can take towards discrediting the Big Bang theory and evolution. Right, if we can get
Speaker 7you to think UFOs or demons, maybe we can get you to think that these are false scientific theories as well.
Speaker 2Well.
Speaker 5I think, and going back to this idea of the sacred canopy that we talked about before, I mean, this is a way of like for CMIA, very demonstrably showing, look, Christianity can explain this, and these people are now part of our sacred canpy.
Speaker 7Aliens don't challenge us.
Speaker 5We had engulfed them into our idea, in our worldview.
Speaker 6And that very much fits with what I saw in person with the alien resistance thing, like they were not afraid to let these people in and talk. You know, there's like, go ahead, We've got this copboard.
Speaker 7And I think at the end of the film, Gary Bates says, and I think he was being very honest about this. He says, it grieves me that people have these these problems with aliens and they don't think to come to the church, right, we are the ones who should be equipped to help you if you're having this kind of problem, and we need to sort of let people know that we are the place you should go to. Not I don't know what else he was thinking, the History Channel, paranormal websites, right, something something like that.
Speaker 6Again, that is an excellent insight, I think, because you see a lot of the so we haven't mentioned, but if you're interested in all the ancient alien stuff at all, obviously go check out Jason Colovito's blog. But he is documented really well that there is that often in many times the Great Enemy sort of in the kind of populist response to ancient alien stuff is not mainstream science. I mean, they all kind of poo poo that, but it's it's literally what we're talking about, sort of a
Speaker 6demonic or a religious conspiratorial mindset versus the same shann alien's mindset. And I think the thing that really pointed this out there was there was this film that many of my students are actually very familiar with, the YouTube focused film called Ancient Aliens Debunked, and it's gotten millions upon millions of views. But it was coming from a religious perspective, but it was not advertised as such until you watch it and you realize it's invoking the deluge and giants. But I think that actually really pointed out that in
Speaker 6many senses, the potential audience for both of those cells, if you want to put it that way, are the same people or potentially the same people.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1That's and I think many many great arguments were made in that video, But you're right, they most of it's.
Speaker 6Fine, yeah, until they're like, also, by the way, the flood's real.
Speaker 1Yeah, right, So I'm I'm not envious, but I do understand that the ultraterrestrial hypothesis is a perfectly rational way to deal with the fact that there's no physical evidence for the things that many people are experiencing, and it can sort of explain away why we have no evidence because these things are coming from another dimension and the reality is that the skeptical alternative, which I've been calling
Speaker 1the nul terrestrial hypothesis, is there's nothing there. Everything that we're having is people misunderstanding phenomena, misunderstanding things that they're seeing. You know, it's problems of human perception, not problems of things that we just don't understand right.
Speaker 6Or not even problems I would say features feature.
Speaker 1It's not as exciting, but it fits into a world where you can actually test things and it comes out you know.
Speaker 6On bound you I mean, if you believe you live in a magical spirit in demon and trickster haunted world, Yeah, there's a certain aspect of like again re enchantment.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1No, it's very exciting and magical. I just don't think it's real. So, but but I am concerned about its market share in the in the in the psyche of pop culture and what's I think maybe one of the most ironic things is that if natural selection is real, which I think it is, that the idea of sort of Dawkins's mimetics means that what will end up coming out of this will be the parts that people like will stick and the parts that people don't want, and you'll end up with a hybridization that will, in at
Speaker 1least somewhere become a new view of the role of religion as ties into eupology. Maybe not new, but at least it'll have evolved.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1So what could be more bizarre and fitting than that that the that the anti evolution people themselves are actually demonstrably showing how ideas can evolve over time.
Speaker 2I don't know, I'm pretty sure.
Speaker 6I'm just gonna answer with I'm not sure it was demons, but it was demons.
Speaker 2It's pretty much where I'm going there.
Speaker 1I notice we've been talking for like an hour and fifteen minutes, and I do have to edit a little bit out, but I do like to keep the episodes around sixty minutes. Is there anything you guys would like to add that we haven't sort of naturally segued into.
Speaker 7I can't think of much.
Speaker 5I mean, this has been actually very informative for me. I was mostly a bystander to this, and Joe tends to drag me to all sorts of crazy things, and so promised me there'd be a you know, pint of beer afterwards.
Speaker 1I with him, that's the way to do it. I did mine up front. I should have done it afterwards. That would have been very smart.
Speaker 7Don't take your significant other to this film?
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, no, I was so glad I took a friend instead of a wife. Yeah no, but you know good on YouTube.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 6If we had a movie theater in town, I might have seen it, but I'd have to get in a car in the snow, so I did not see it. The only thing I would I would add to this is I will try to watch this when it comes to a place that I can actually see it, because I am actually very very curious.
Speaker 1Yeah, I think you'll agree.
Speaker 2Though.
Speaker 1It should have been about thirty minutes shorter.
Speaker 6So I think everything should be shorter when it comes to media.
Speaker 1So it shorter.
Speaker 5It just kept going, Oh.
Speaker 7Is so bored.
Speaker 1Oh, I'm so sorry I've shart you going.
Speaker 6Though I'm highly selling it, I'm just saying and that's probably fair.
Speaker 1Well, I'm one of those people who went to see Expelled with Ben Stein, and so.
Speaker 2I've still never seen that. I do have something.
Speaker 1Positive to say about this movie. It didn't go full Hitler, so good for them. Ben Stein's little film ended with a giant Poe argument. I was like, oh, come on, is that Poe or is that the O was Gudwins right?
Speaker 2Sorry? Guy, yeah, Godwin Godwin argument. So there was no Nazi bell, there was no.
Speaker 1Relatively Nazi free so good for them.
Speaker 6Well then I don't know if they'll make it on the History Well these days, I'll make it on History Channel.
Speaker 2Yeah, awesome.
Speaker 1Anyway, I want to thank you all for coming and spending some time on Sunday evening, and I really appreciate you guys coming back to talk to me.
Speaker 2Thank you, Thank you.
Speaker 1Now Monster, you've been listening to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith, and you just heard a roundtable discussion with religious studies experts Joe Laycock and Natasha Michaels and archaeologist Jeb card As. We talked about the connection between John Kill's ultraterrestrial hypothesis are the ut H and the new film Alien Intrusion. A creationist film tying evangelical Christianity into ufology. I do not know if the UTCH is really gaining market share or if my
Speaker 1increasing recognition of it in paranormal literature is merely confirmation bias. But it seems to be pop up more and more, and perhaps someone with the time in academic training can see if a literature survey supports my suspicion. What concerns me is that the UTCH is unfalsifiable. We've talked about this before, using Carl Popper's idea that in order for an idea to be considered scientific, it needs to be testable and falsifiable. The UTCH, by its very nature, is untestable. It is the invisible magic dragon that Carl Sagan talked about in his book The Demon Haunted World. As such,
Speaker 1I hope that serious enthusiasts of the paranormal and cryptozoological will continue to reject it as the research that end it truly is. I hope you enjoyed this episode. Monster Talk theme music is by Peach Stealing Monkeys. Thank you so much for listening. This has been a Monster House presentation.
Speaker 6I'm not responding to anything that's happening right now.
Speaker 2That's fantastic. Yeah, we're editing also all of what we just talked.
Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...
Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...
Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...
🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...
Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...