Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

MonsterTalk

MonsterTalk artwork

S04E17 The Ghost of Ticonderoga with Joseph Gagne

Jan 27, 202542 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This week we're welcoming back historian Dr Joseph Gagne to tell us about a ghost story that straddles North America and Scotland. He was last with us to tell us about the legend of La Corriveau in episode 181. Appearances of the Dead: A Cultural History of Ghosts by Ronald C. Finucane - mentioned by Joseph as his introduction to this story. This is an affiliate link and the book is out of print, so be advised it's PRICEY. But wait! You can read it for free at Archive.org. Joseph asked me to be sure and share links to: Bibliothèque et Archives Nationales Du Québec Also to his blog: Curieuse Nouvelle France And of course the official site of Fort Ticonderoga Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Monster House Presents.

Speaker 2Monster Talk is combining forces with the popular skeptical podcast Skeptoid as we Brave the Bermuda Triangle in twenty twenty five. I'll be one of the skeptic celebrities participating in this adventure in the warm waters off the coast of Florida. Will we find the Missing Flight nineteen? Will we find proof of Atlantis? Will sea monsters pilot us through these mystery filled waters?

Speaker 3No?

Speaker 2But I promise you there will be science and history filled discussions and plenty of punds if.

Speaker 3I have anything to do with it.

Speaker 2Early bird pricing is still available, so come get some sun, visit beautiful places, or roll your eyes at my terrible puns, and raise money to fund Skeptoid and monster talk shared mission of promoting skepticism and science.

Speaker 3While still enjoying a good mystery.

Speaker 2Early bird pricing ends January thirty first, so hurry up and sign up. Check the show notes for a link, or go to Skeptoid dot com and click events to find your way onto Braving the Bermuda Triangle a Skeptoid adventure.

Speaker 4It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before.

Speaker 5A giant, hairy creature Partype Part Matt in Luckness, a twenty four mile long bottomless lake in the highlands of Scotland, get the creature known as the Luckness Monster.

Speaker 2Monstertle, Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters.

Speaker 3I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner.

Speaker 2Hey there, Monster Talkers. This week we welcome back doctor Joseph Ganie, who is going to share his research into a famous ghost story that straddles the shores of Scotland and North America. Joseph was last with us back in episode one, where we discussed the legend of the Quebec figure La core of You, a tale of witches, ghosts and gibbets. I'll link to that in the show notes. Monstertle, Well, you're here tonight, you're gonna tell us a ghost story?

Speaker 4Yes, yes, indeed, and I think.

Speaker 3Kiaren was instrumental setting this up. I'm gonna try to stop talking over here.

Speaker 1Sorry, Karen, No, no worries. I was kind of hoping that you would try to pronounce taekwonder rogo oh, I have.

Speaker 3No yeah, yeah, tae kwonder roga.

Speaker 2Yeah, that's good old fashioned American history.

Speaker 1So wanted to bring you back on the show to talk about a case that you've been researching, I believe for quite some time, So the story of the Duncan Campbell's ghost. And I wonder if you could we could start with you telling us a bit about Duncan Campbell. Who is this fellow.

Speaker 4Well, Duncan Campbell is a Scottish officer who served under the British Army during the Seven Years War, or at least the portion we know of in the US known as the French and Indian War and known in French Canada as the Conquest. And Duncan Campbell is a fascinating character because he actually existed first of all. So this is what's actually quite interesting with those ghost stories, that there is a grain of truth behind the story.

Speaker 2There really was a Duncan Campbell, and I really was a Duncan Cambll and.

Speaker 3A tykonder Roga and.

Speaker 4I take although what one has to know is that taekonder Roga was not always known as such. Now it is the indigenous or deformation of the indigenous name for the city of ticonder Roga that is an upstate New York on Lake Champlain. But the French had originally built a fort there in seventeen fifty five against the encroaching British that we're getting closer and closer to what will

Speaker 4become the border between Canada and the US. But you have to remember that the entirety of Lake Champlain was claimed by the French, and in fact that the name of the Lake Champlain comes from the French explorer Samuel de Champlain. Now, Duncan Campbell, what's interesting with the story? Just like I wrote a paper on it, and just as I introduced, you know, I feel like one good story deserves another in essence. A few years ago, I was gifted this wonderful, this wonderful book on the history

Speaker 4of ghosts by A Finucane. I hope I'm pronouncing that name correctly, Fi n uc A Finucane, I guess. So, a book on the appearances of the dead and cultural transformation. And I was reading through it, all of a sudden there was a I stumbled on the story, this short story about the ghost of Ticondaruga. Now, I consider myself an aficionado of ghostly stories having to do with the French and Indian War. Whether we're talking about James Wolfe.

Speaker 4Apparently predicting his own death on the eve of September thirteenth, seventeen fifty nine, on the morning of the taking of Quebec City, which essentially redrew the North American map by kicking the French out eventually and then leading way to the American Revolution a decade later. Two ghostly stories of soldiers being still seen to this day on the plains of Abraham, just haunting the area where they were killed. But I had never heard of the ghost of ticonder Roga. Now.

Speaker 4The gist of the story is that there is this man named Duncan Campbell who lived in Inveraw which is in the old County of Argyle in Scotland. And one stormy night, as any good story begins, he hears pounding on his door and he calmly opens and there's a desperate man saying that there's a posse running after him, and he pleads with him to please hide him from

Speaker 4the posse and to swear swear by God that he will protect him and not reveal his whereabouts. And so Campbell agrees hides him in the basement and then has nothing better to do, so goes back to bed until he is awoken once again, just a few minutes later, in fact, by the posse and question knocking on the door, and they demand to know if he saw a man go by who apparently had just killed his cousin. Now,

Speaker 4poor Campbell is is torn between his promise of hiding the man or delivering him to the posse for having killed his cousin, but he decides that his that his his word was more important and so fulfills his promise by basically denying that he saw anyone. And then the posse leaves, and so distraught, he goes back to bed trying to sleep, but he is woken by his brother

Speaker 4that appears in his room in a ghostly figure. And depending on the version, there's some versions of the story where he's very gnarly with guts hanging out and so on, but clearly the man is dead and but surprisingly, not only is he appearing in front of his cousin, but the ghost speaks to him and says, how dare you hide my murderer? How dare you? And Campbell tries to beg forgiveness and explains why I gave my word. I

Speaker 4can't go back on my honor and rescind my promise, and the ghost disappears and he goes back to bed, and he's awoken again once or for a second and even a third time, depending on the story, where the brother keeps saying, how dare you protect my murderer, until finally the ghost says, I will see you again at Taykonda Roga and disappears, and Campbell is scratching his head, going, Tykonda Roga, I've never heard of such a place, and

Speaker 4immediately goes in the basement to see if the murderer is still there, and unfortunately a man fled, and so for the next few years Campbell kind of delicately asks people, oh, by the way, have you ever heard of this place called Taekwondo Roga? No one has ever heard of this place. Well, after a while, he kind of forgets about the incident leaves it behind him until war breaks out between France and Great Britain and he is amongst the Scots that

Speaker 4are sent to North America, to the American colonies to help fight against Canada or New France back in the day, and as they're approaching this fort that the French called Carrion Fort Carrion, he starts discussing with other officers, and one officer turns and says, oh, yeah, apparently the local name for this fort by the indigenous people call this fort Taekwonda Roga. Duncan's eyes go wide and realizes, Oh,

Speaker 4my god, this is exactly the spot that my brother, that my cousin said I would meet him. And depending on the version, sure enough he sees his brother up on the by the fort and knows that he will die, and and indeed he gets shot and killed and dies at Taekwonderoga. That is the story of a ghostly warning from beyond the grave, of a prophetic death.

Speaker 1I immediately wonder how long after Campbell's death was this legend told. Do you have any idea?

Speaker 4That's the issue now. When I read the story, I didn't really have any leads as to where it came from, except that Finny Kaine had had mentioned it. But a few years later, as I was working on my postgrad ironically, I was working on something totally different. I was working on the role of women as camp followers in the French Army. I stumbled on a French version of the

Speaker 4story published by H. R. Cos Gain, who was an abbot and also an early Proto historian who contributed a lot to our knowledge of the French and Indian War. And in fact, he was great friends with Parkman, who was one of the early American historians who was also absolutely obsessed with New France. He wrote a lot about the French and Indian War, the Jesuits and so on,

Speaker 4and cos Gaay talked about the story and then mentioned he had heard of the story through another man named Arthur Penryn Stanley, who was the Dean of Westminster, who he had heard it from a parson in another in a in another parish, and and so on. And so I started seeing that through these retellings, these published retellings, you can kind of go uh from publication to publication trying to retrace the literary genealogy of this story. And

Speaker 4in the end I ended up with four distinct lines which seemed to be unrelated on the surface, but clearly are basing themselves on the same story. And in fact, probably the most famous telling was by Robert Louis Stevenson, who you'll remember as the author of Treasure Island.

Speaker 3I do, that's exactly how I remember him.

Speaker 4What except, what's fascinating is that Robert Lewis Stevenson took a lot of liberty. First of all, it's no longer Campbell, it's a Cameron uh. And he has his character traveling around the world, even all the way to China, trying to figure out what is tykonder Roga, just obsessed with the name until finally arriving on the shores of Lake Champlain in front of fall Carrion known as Taekwonderoga.

Speaker 5Wow.

Speaker 2So he's the opposite of the When I was thinking about this episode, I went and the first thing that popped in my mind after reading The Ghostty was this reminds me of Arthur Dent in the Hitchhiker's Guide series, because he meets a guy named Agrajag who I don't want to spoil anything about that character, but at some point he basically is told like they're supposed to meet at a place called Stavromulos Beta, and so he thinks, well, as long as I don't go there, I can't be killed.

Speaker 3I can't die, Like.

Speaker 2He's basically immortal until that happens, right, And so.

Speaker 3Things hilariously turn.

Speaker 2Out to that's not as easy as he thinks to avoid this thing but anyway, in TV Tropes the website, they list it under the tree prophecy armor, which I just love because there's several other examples I have which we can talk about, or we could skip, but I could put it this intro or whatever. But lots of cases throughout history that are kind of similar to this idea that you get a prophecy and you want to avoid it, or maybe in the Robert Louis you.

Speaker 3Don't yeah, yeah, or you're just curious about it or whatever, right, yeah.

Speaker 4And that's the thing that's fascinating is that it's a trope or as in literal circles they call it a motif you can recognize it. So the story in itself is as as remarkable as the story is, it's actually unremarkable in another way because it is a trope, as you've mentioned. In fact, if you read Shakespeare Julius Caesar, well, the ghost of Caesar appears to Brutus and tells him that, oh, we will meet again at Philippi, and Bruce has no

Speaker 4way where that is and ends up dying there. And it it's the kind of story that comes back again and again and again. So then in approaching this story, the question becomes, well, what is real in this story? And it's it's hard to get a hold of the correct information from the retellings. For example, one thing that really frustrated me as a specialist of the history of New France was the fact that barely a single story

Speaker 4had the right name for Carielle. They kept inventing names like Fort George, Fort Louis, just anything that vaguely sounded French for the purpose of the story. But so I was curious to find out, well, okay, we have various names. Is it is it Duncan Campbell, is it Donald Campbell? Is it a Cameron? Who is this guy? And so the first thing I did was actually search through newspaper records using various databases, whether newspapers found on our website

Speaker 4at Bibi a tech Yeshiv Nasbek, which, by the way, since since my last interview, I'm now officially an archivist for the Province of Quebec. And so, as I was saying congratulations, thank you, I get to play with wonderful documents every day. I feel like a kid in a candy store, where literally, on an idle day, I could be like, oh, I feel like touching a document signed by Washington just because I feel like it. I'm not that petty, but I do find excuses to turn these

Speaker 4these documents to good use with such papers as this ghost story. And so, as I was saying, I turned to many databases of old newspapers, mostly from the eighteenth century and nineteenth century. And that's how, on one hand, I got to track down how many versions? Did I say? I think I had ten or twelve versions of the story that I tracked down, and that I that I enumerate in my paper. But which And by the way, I keep talking about my paper, It's a paper that

Speaker 4was published in the bulletin of the Fort Ticonderoga Museum, I believe in the twenty twenty three in October of all months. Now, if you want to have a copy, just look up for Ticonderoga's website and you can order a copy of the journal there. Though a again, I'm jumping from one thing to another. I was just about to say that an earlier draft of this paper is found on my blog Curious New France. You just have

Speaker 4to google Curious New France Taekwonderoga and you'll you'll stumble on it. So as I was saying through this long meandering is that I got to find certain newspaper clippings having to do with Duncan Campbell confirming not only that he existed, but he was at Takonda Roga. But what's interesting that he did not die at Taekwondo Roga. He actually died a few days later. Specifically, he died four

Speaker 4days after getting his arm amputated. So he had been wounded in his arm, had to get it amputated, and unfortunately it kind of got gnarly and killed him. But what's fascinating, and this is kind of what's maddening with all these versions, is that every once in a while you have versions of the story that will skew so many facts, but then every once in a while have a new fact that is actually authentic. So you will

Speaker 4have there's at least one or two versions of the story where the storyteller mentions that Duncan had a son, Alexander, who also dies following his wounds. And indeed I stumbled on Acottish newspaper mentioning an Alexander Campbell who had suffered wounds at Taekwonder Roga the same day as his father only he dies two years later, two years later back

Speaker 4in Scotland, and one can only imagine how like suffering from your wounds for two years before finally dying. And the kicker. I even found the announcement of the death of Duncan's wife, who died one year after her son. And so thanks to these newspaper clip is, you can you can actually go and double verify the events, and you can also you could you can also determine what

Speaker 4events are not true to the story and in fact kind of certain anachronisms. For example, when it comes to the victim, all the stories have a different version of who is the victim of the crime, whether it's a cousin, a brother, a stranger met in a cave. Some people will try to tie it as the murderer and the victim are Jacobites and loyalists from the Scottish Uprising of

Speaker 4seventeen forty five. And so you see these motifs coming out depending on the history we're trying to put forth. And one case in particular that came back a few times was the murder of appened in seventeen fifty two where a certain James Stewart of the Glens was accused of murdering Colin Roy Campbell. But what happens is that this is a murder that happened in seventeen fifty two, and so this is a few years before the Battle

Speaker 4of taekwonder Roga. But our are the two stories tied together? Or did people just conveniently see Oh, these are two events that happened roughly at the same time. Let's slap them together.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2Well, actually, I wanted to ask you about this because you get these You've listened to the show enough to know how obsessed I am with the transmission of stories and ideas across culture.

Speaker 3What are your thoughts about these different versions?

Speaker 2Are the writers trying to make the stories more entertaining, or are they trying to root them in some kind of cultural thing happening at the time, or is it all over the place?

Speaker 3What were your findings there?

Speaker 4What I'm gathering from this? Because here's the thing, I am a French colonial historian who specializes in the history of French Canada. I don't know anything about Scotland, and so this was actually fascinating. As much as I've always wanted to be more better introduced to Scottish history and everything. This was a wonderful little excursion into the literary world

Speaker 4of Scottish folklore and from what I gather from from what I read, well, one has to remember that after the the the Jacobite rebellions of the seventeen forties, Scottish culture was really frowned down upon for having been disloyal and so on. There's a whole the common story that Killts and tartans. For example, we're outlawed except for scotsmen

Speaker 4who would that would agree to join the British army. That was the only way to be permitted to wear your clan tartans, and so on, and so by the by the end of the nineteenth century, so we're over one hundred years later, well, political tensions have have have calmed down a lot, and so there's a kind of like a new recognition of Skish culture. And so there's a new obsession in writing down Scottish stories and myths

Speaker 4and legends and superstition and so on, which also coincides or is fed by a more global interest in popular folklore. One just has to think of the Grim's fairy tales. Even in French Canada, we have that movement with various people like the the ex Mayor of Montreal and other French Canadian authors that are putting on paper stories of French Canadian werewolves and flying canoes and so on. So

Speaker 4it's it's basically in the Western world you have this movement to to write down oral history and popular culture. And so the legend of Taekwondo Roga becomes very interesting because not only does it spark interest in Scotland, but it is also of interest in the US because of Lake Champlain being an upstate New York and being part

Speaker 4of the story, being part of American history through the French and Indian War, but also of interest for French Canadians because of the central battle in the story. And this begs to be repeated, is that the Battle of Carrion is not just any battle for the French. During the French and Indian War, the French had been I don't want to say winning the war necessarily, but they were successfully defending themselves against a vastly superior army. And

Speaker 4the case in point, the last successful major battle in New France was at taekwondo Uga or Fort Carrion, where you you have for about a little less than four thousand French troops against sixteen thousand British troops, so four times more British troops and yet the French win. They pull this off, and so it was a dramatic battle.

Speaker 2I just want to say, as a tabletop gamer, I'm like, oh, I'd like to see that battle, you know.

Speaker 4And just to help you nerd out a little bit. The short version is that when the British arrived, they try to take the fort, initially on the fifth of July seventeen fifty eight, and what happens is that the commander, the second in command, Lord Howe, gets shot and dies, and so the army kind of folds back. They're trying to get their bearings back together and reorganize. This gives the French two days to hurry up and organize. And the leader of the French, General Molcott, who is famous

Speaker 4for having died on the planes of Abraham depending defending Quebec City. He's a veteran of the previous war where he was on the losing end in what is now Italy, and he was in the same situation in Italy in another battle, but in a reverse position where Italians were on this. So imagine Fort Taeiconderoga is on a promontory overlooking Lake Champlain and is surrounded by the lake on one side, a river on another, and then these kinds

Speaker 4of planes behind it. And Mont cam had been the same situation, except as the attacker in Italy at a fort that was almost identical to Fort te Conderoga. And so he has the bright idea of doing the same as the Italian defenders by abandoning the fort, ironically going out for two or three miles away from the fort and building new defenses out of tree trunks call so

Speaker 4basically creating a new wall and putting as much junk as possible in front. So basically left over trees, pointed logs and so on, what the French called an abbet sea. And in a nutshell, the British had sent a spy on the overlooking mountain. I believe it's a is it mountain Independence or fort mount? I forget the name of the mountain. That any who, It's overlooking the fort, and the spy sees the French defense and says, oh, it's only four feet high. We can easily take that. He's

Speaker 4seeing it from the inside the spy is not seeing it from the outside, and so when the British arrived two days later with sixteen thousand men, the men in front immediately realized that's a nine foot tall wall. They can't breach that. But the problem is they can't get the word across to the back, and so they're being wedged and pushed against this wall where the French are basically just sniping them at their leisure. And what's also remarkable is that the only members of the British army

Speaker 4that made it over the wall before then getting shot once inside the fort were the Scots the Black Watch, and so you see that the Scots are present throughout this war. They're always an important component. And so this really solidifies the place of this story because it also talks of the central point of honor, not only in Duncan Campbell's promise to the murder of not ritting him out, but also of basically giving his life for king and

Speaker 4country after a rebellion, because a lot of people saw the French and Indian War as basically these Scott soldiers final chance to prove that they were loyal and could be counted on and not seen as potential traders as during the rebellion.

Speaker 1I have to ask there are the ghost stories that are associated with this battle, because this was so bloody well.

Speaker 4This one as such, I would not doubt that there are, but none that comes to mind. But there are many ghost stories I have to do with the French and Indian War though in the US. Another one that comes to mind is at Faldschat also known as Fort Charters, as they mispronounced it in Illinois. I'm sorry, Illinois, just a poke fun at you for mispronouncing it. Was considered the largest French fort west of Fort Niagara. And there's

Speaker 4a legend that every few years, I forget the frequency, but every so often. Was it like every seventy five years or something like that, Do not quote me on the time. You can see a ghostly army, basically the French trying to march back into the fort that they were forced to surrender to the British after the Peace Treaty of seventeen sixty three.

Speaker 5Wow.

Speaker 2Well you've done a beautiful job of explaining this, and we'll definitely link out to the web version and to the journal version. A couple we got a couple of little questions before we go, though, the when was while you were doing the research? Because Karen and I love research, and I always love it when we find something we didn't expect or something exciting. Was there any point during your research where we found some big surprises or you know, like what kind of kept you.

Speaker 3Going while you were on the hunt?

Speaker 4I ever get those moments in your life where you realize after the fact, oh my god, what I just saw was a big deal and I had no idea. Yes, absolutely, So this was back in twenty sixteen ish something like that. I was traveling with my then girlfriend to Fort Edward, which is just south of Fort ticonder Roga in upstate New York, and we went to see Union Cemetery. Now, on one hand, I was being I was being told of the famous UH tombstone of Jane McCrae, who was

Speaker 4famous because basically she had been killed by indigenous people and Ben Franklin had used her as propaganda to say to tell American c see, these are British allies and look how they mistreat her women. Please go to war and will become independent. So so she's a big figure in UH in the American Revolution propaganda. But right next to or near her tombstone. There was this beautiful modern tombstone.

Speaker 4It was a recreation of this fellow I had never heard of, Duncan Campbell, and I remember being told apparently that guy's a big deal, and I was like, oh, well, I guess he is. And I just took a picture of it and didn't think twice about it until I read this The Ghost Story, and it hit me, Oh my god, I saw his tombstone. Yeah, not his actual tombstone. As I said, it's a recreation because his the original tombstone was well, it was started to needed a little

Speaker 4bit of love, and now it's been it's now held. If you want to see the actual original tombstone, you can see it in the cronkite pavilion of the Old Fort Old Fort House Museum in Fort Edward. And so that was, Yeah, that was my moment. And it's kind of interesting because earlier, when I was mentioning the fact that one of the major components for the spreading of the story was Arthur Penrin Stanley, uh, he had he

Speaker 4had actually traveled in to the US and Canada hoping to get information on the story, and ironically no one had heard of of Duncan Campbell's story, and so he spread it around. But he found out he found out about the tombstone after he was out of the area, and so he never got to see the original tombstone. And I get to say that I got to see, well, I have yet to see the original tombstone because the museum was closed last time I went the summer. So

Speaker 4always always check museum when you visit. Always check. The second time in my life that happened, we didn't.

Speaker 3I got to.

Speaker 4See where Duncan Campbell is buried today, which Stanley didn't get to even though uh he is the only author of all out of all these the authors of these different versions, he's the only one who had who obsessively went on site to see all the areas having to do with the story.

Speaker 5Nice.

Speaker 1Well, you know, hearing this story, it does seem to have parallels Blake got and if you picked up on this to the Lord Dufferin story a little bit, Oh yeah, there's a place that you you're going to die at that and you should never be at that place. So I'm wondering, Joseph, if you ever came across the evidence that Duncan Campbell told anyone about this dream, not at all, And in fact.

Speaker 4What's strange is that there's In certain versions they even add that members of Campbell's family had either seen his ghost in their dreams after he died, or that some female members of the family were walking down this dirt road and looked at the sky and they saw the battle in the sky, and they knew that he died. But again this is all hearsay from different versions, and in fact, the earliest version I could find, the earliest printed version was eighteen forty one, signed by Thomas Dick Lauder,

Speaker 4and the next story only comes comes along almost forty years later. So I have no idea why the dormancy between these versions. But unfortunately I have not been able to track down the source of the original stories, even though I have four potential ways to follow. I'm curious to know if one day I'll find out that these basically these four routes all finally join in with the same source, and the question will be also well, if

Speaker 4there is an older source to be found, how close is it to the original story? Is it something I was printed in the in the seventeen hundreds. I doubt we'll find that, but it is tantalizing to think about it.

Speaker 1Yes, story is not over then, yes, not at all.

Speaker 3Well, golly, this was really neat.

Speaker 2I'm really glad you've done this work and we'll be able to share it with listeners. Yes, it's a good job. I'm kind of envious that you've run it all to ground.

Speaker 3It's neat. I love doing this kind of work and I love.

Speaker 2Hearing about other people doing it, So it's pretty cool.

Speaker 4And if you will permit me, I do also want to give a shout out if for anyone listening interested in the French and Indian War to not forget to visit the website of the archives where I work. So I work at BIBI a tech ANABK. That is the official name, which in English is roughly translated National Library and Archives of Quebec. You can visit the website at triple W b A n Q dot QC dot C

Speaker 4A and.

Speaker 2I'll put a link in the show notes too. Yeah, and of course I mean right after this we have to do this whole thing over again in French because of Quebec law. But that's okay.

Speaker 5Let's try well.

Speaker 3Going forward, what are you working on now? What's next right now?

Speaker 4It's kind of ironic that you you just came out with an episode on Griffins and currently I'm actually working on the Shipwreck of the Griffin. The guideafone, the first ship, the first European ship to sail beyond Niagara Falls. It sank during its maiden voyage, kind of like the Titanic in sixteen seventy nine. And it's associated with a lot of the American Midwest because it was the ship of

Speaker 4Kevilida Lasal LaSalle. If you live in the Midwest, you definitely have a LaSalle Street somewhere in your towners city.

Speaker 2Well, I've served in the Middle East and the LaSalle was the flagship the great White Ghost of the Arabian Coast they called her, which a big white ship for the command.

Speaker 3Yeah, oh, that is lovely.

Speaker 4He would love knowing that he had a ship named after him, because he had a ginormous ego. But it's interesting because it's one of those ships. Again, it's like the like I said, it's like the Titanic of the Great Lakes or the Mary Celesta of the Great Lakes. They called the Flying Dutchman or the Flying Frenchman. In fact of the Great Lakes, no one's found it. Many people claim to have found it, and I'm not so much interested in where it is. And if we're going going to find it, then the circus surrounding that every

Speaker 4time people declare they found the ship and what happens from there.

Speaker 3Oh kind of like a million air hard.

Speaker 4Yeah yeah yeah, basically yeah.

Speaker 3Yeah, She's like Atlantis. She's like, you know, her crashes everywhere. Atlantis is everywhere.

Speaker 4At least at least twenty shipwrecks that had been tied to the Griffin, there's only three that were kind of good candidates. And I hate to say that the final good candidate on Manitoulin Island in Ontario, I will spill the beans and say I can conclude it is definitely not the Griffin.

Speaker 1Alas well, Well, you're always working on something interesting, so you have to keep in touch with this.

Speaker 3Absolutely. Absolutely, we really are.

Speaker 2Thank you so much for joining us again for a fascinating look into histories and ghosts and all this guy. That was great.

Speaker 1It's one of those nights where I'm sitting by the fire, roaring fire and it's cold, and that was very fun.

Speaker 4Perfect yeah, and thank you for inviting me again.

Speaker 3You are more than one anytime monster.

Speaker 2You've been listening to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters.

Speaker 3I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stoltner.

Speaker 2You just heard from doctor Joseph Ganie sharing his research into the legend of the Ghost of Taekwonderoca and Duncan Campbell. As we mentioned in the episode, this legend hints at the trope of prophecy armor, and we talked about how that shows up in stories from Shakespeare to Douglas Adams, and it also reminded me a little bit of an old Middle Eastern legend of the Appointment in Samara, wherein a man sees death wandering the streets of Baghdad and fearing the figure is there for him, he decides to flee to the remote city of some Zara. Death seeing

Speaker 2him flee, is surprised to see the man in Bagdad at all. In comments to his current appointment, that's funny. I didn't think he'd be in Bagdad. I was supposed to meet him tomorrow and samaraw. We hope you enjoyed this episode of Monster Talk. Our goal here is to bring you the best in monster related content with a focus on scientific skepticism and critical thinking. If you enjoy our show and want to support our mission, start out by visiting monster talk dot org forward slash support. That's monster talk dot org forward slash Support. There you'll find

Speaker 2links to our Patreon page, as well as a donate button if you'd like to just make a one time contribution. A great way to support the show is to buy books from our Amazon wish list.

Speaker 3These are books that directly help with our monster research.

Speaker 2We love used books very much, so don't feel compelled to buy new ones, and we're also very fond of kindle editions because of their easily searched content and without spending any money at all. You can support and raise the profile of the show by leaving a positive review at iTunes or wherever you get your podcasts. Positive reviews help keep us visible in iTunes, which is a great way to help us find you listeners. Finally, remember to share episodes you really like with your friends and family. You can help make Monster Talk the nightlight that keeps

Speaker 2monsters away from someone you love. Monster Talk theme music is by Peach Stealing Monkeys. When torn between honor of oath, and loyalty to family. We hope things work out better for you than they did for old Dunk and Gamble.

Speaker 2This has been a Monster House presentation.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S06E07 Elizabeth Taylor and the Burton of Truth

    Nov 16, 202655 minAudio

    Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S06E06 🐈⬛Evil Cats and Revelatory Revenants👻

    Nov 9, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S06E05🎃 Live 2026 Halloween Show

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S06E04 🍿Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈 Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S06E03 🎥 Capturing Bigfoot 🫈with Marq Evans

    Oct 19, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...

    Credit the people on this episode