We discuss the sketchy "science by press release" of Colossal Biosciences and the controversies lurking in the history of its lead scientist. Have they resurrected dire wolves? No. Definitely not. If only overblown celebrity endorsed hype was the only problem… Did they make a Dire Wolf? (Spoiler: NOT EVEN REMOTELY CLOSE) George Church's explanation of Epstein ties James Arthur Ray - Guru of Death? Tony Robbins (more from Quora and Reddit) Peter Jackson and the Moa George R. R. Martin and the Dire Wolf For a more… salacious take on this, check out the 2-part "Behind the Bastards" coverage of this topic. Part 1 and Part 2. --- on a more positive note --- What is CRISPR? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Monster House Presents.
Speaker 2This is the ad supported version of Monster Talk. We're dependent upon the revenue from these ads and from the support of our patrons at Patreon dot com forward slash monster Talk to continue making this show. As a disclaimer, your hosts are unable to control what ads you will hear, and while we have done what we can to avoid ads that are divisive, the system that injects them sometimes ignores our preferences and always seems to ignore our efforts to not interrupt the conversational flow. While we understand this can be disruptive, we're trying our best. Patreon remains the best way to enjoy commercial free listening to our content,
Speaker 2plus you generally get extending coverage of the subject. We're working on other ways to consume our content as well, so please stay tuned.
Speaker 3At Colossal Biosciences in Dallash, the mission is clear payer cutting edge science with high tech tools to reach a goal of preist store proportions.
Speaker 2We are less than five years away from seeing mamos back on the planet. Not if it's going to happen, when it's going to happen. It's simply a function of time.
Speaker 3So two brilliantteresting, which is why co founder and CEO Ben Lamb says now's the time to embrace the term de extinction, the process of creating an extinct species, or at least an animal that resembles one. In Colossal's case, the wooly mammoth, which died off roughly four thousand years ago.
Speaker 2We turned out of that remarkable scientific breakthrough thirteen thousand years after the last dire wolf walk the earth.
Speaker 1Scientists say they've now brought them back.
Speaker 3Tonight.
Speaker 4How thirteen thousand years in the making. In a first for science, biotech company, Colossal Biosciences says it brought the extinct dire wolf back to life.
Speaker 2It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before. A giant, hairy creature, part ape part in Luckness, a twenty four a mile long bottomless lake in the Highlands of Scotland, get a creature known as the Luckness Monster. Monster Talk.
Speaker 2Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith.
Speaker 1And I'm Karen Stolsner.
Speaker 2Hey there, folks. This episode's been on the back burner for a while, but the news releases that keep generating topic requests just keep coming. So we finally decided to tackle it. As you heard in the news clips at the top of the show, there are stories everywhere right now claiming that the extinction of lost species is taking place. Has science brought back the dire wolf, our mamm that's soon going to be roaming the tundra again. Well, Karen and I sat down this week to discuss these controversial stories,
Speaker 2and I don't know what you think, but I found this all to be pretty shocking, more obstrutal. So Kiaren, I have to say the topic this week, I think is going to be a little controversial. And I say that because we've had emails and messages on social media from listeners on the grounds of, hey, please cover this whole dire wolf thing because people are saying it's not real science. And then we've had people saying, hey, please
Speaker 2cover this direwolf thing because it's obviously BS. And I'm going to probably end up having to edit myself because I think the idea of BS is going to come up a lot in this conversation.
Speaker 1Well, yeah, I think this is an interesting topic, And be honest, I didn't really see those messages myself, and I hadn't really heard much about this, and I mentioned it to Matt and he was like, Oh, yes, I've been hearing about this debate, and I think d extinction is such an interesting term, and I'm thinking, Jurassic Park.
Speaker 2You should, I mean you should, because it's pretty clear that the company we're going to be talking about, which is called Colossal Biosciences, is absolutely leaning into that Jurassic Park. What is that, I like to say culturally available template, Like, they're absolutely without saying they're doing Jurassic Park, they're absolutely cosplaying Jurassic Park. And I think what I'd like to talk surmize is why are they doing that, you know, and how much of it's real and how much of
Speaker 2it is not real? And if it's not real, what is it they're doing so.
Speaker 1Yeah, and how they're doing it exactly. There's a lot to unpack here. I guess we should start with the definition. What is d extinction?
Speaker 2Yeah, it's a interesting question. I think in the in the strictest in the strictest sense, the extinction is about the idea of resurrecting the DNA through actually building type specimens of species that have gone extinct by either cloning good samples or reconstructing samples of their DNA. That's what the classic definition is. You'll see the extinction coming up
Speaker 2a lot in talks about the colossal bioscience. But I don't think what they're doing qualifies. They're doing something a little different. Now, I guess there's I guess I was maybe going to say this. Let's just talk about the topics. There's sort of three models. There's the the extinction through resurrection of literal DNA, and then there is what Jack Corner talked about with the dino chicken, the idea of
Speaker 2undoing gene sequences and seeing if you can reverse engineer previous sort of versions of an animal from its genome. So, in other words, if if modern birds used to be therapied dinosaurs, what can we do during their development to trigger the genes to get access to those atavistic traits, you know, So chicken getting birds with hands like get in claws would be you know, like one interesting step.
Speaker 1So this is a little bit and not particularly that in particular that style, but just this whole concept. Is it a bit like what we've been hearing about with the Tasmanian tiger as well? The same.
Speaker 2Yeah. Well, now you may recall we actually talked to the team that was trying to bring back the Tesmanian tiger, and they're doing what I would call or they're trying to do like general de extinction through replication and reconstruction of ancient DNA or or whatever. The samples they're not that ancient.
Speaker 1But you know which, Yeah, I mean we're talking about a creature that was around less than one hundred years ago, as opposed to these dire wolves or when when did they When were they in existence?
Speaker 2Oh, wild back. I don't remember the dates, but it's been a long time ago. There's samples in the Librea tar pits, but I don't know if they were co contemporaneous with humans at all.
Speaker 1Yeah, so we took me about ten thousand years ago or something like that.
Speaker 2Thousands of years, yeah, exactly, Yeah, not millions. Right. The whole thing with Jurassic Park is DNA doesn't last that long. I mean, some really interesting discoveries have happened in fossils where they've been able to extract proteins from these stones. I mean it's not DNA, but like you know, seeing blood vessels and proteins that was super controversial, but I don't think it's controversial anymore. It seems like they're actually able to sort of dissolve the stone and actually find there's still protein around from sixty five million years ago,
Speaker 2which is just not DNA though the DNA breaks down, so you can't you can't really do the Jurassic Park trick. But what Colossal Bioscience is doing is something yet a third option, which is to take existing species and then to insert DNA either from those other species are similar species, to get the kinds of traits that we would expect with the lost species. Now, okay, that's interesting, and that's
Speaker 2a real genetic modification, but it's not the extinction. And yet if you look at the news stories, all the headlines are about the return of the dire Wolf and the return of the thila scene and the return of the moa and.
Speaker 1Exactly like that.
Speaker 2Yeah, so let's see if we can sort of unpack what's going on and why.
Speaker 1Well, yeah, so who is involved in this project?
Speaker 2Then? Good question. So it comes down to a guy named Joe words Church, who is the scientist and I mean he's legitimate DNA expert, who's really done interesting biological work with DNA manipulation absolutely real. He was one of the pioneers of Crisper and crisper. I'm sure our science fans here are going to know what chrisper is, but it just is remind you. It's a gene editing tool.
Speaker 2People describe it as being like scissors for DNA. It comes from a natural process that your cells use to fight incoming infections. They can like snip out bad sequences. And what scientists have figured out is how to use those tools to snip out sequences and then replace them with sequences they want to use and create new self replicating cells that now have a different DNA makeup than the original cell, which is really amazing.
Speaker 1It seems a bit more important to me than bringing back a Dodo bird. I don't know, There're all different things right now.
Speaker 2I mean, the technique has been absolutely revolutionary. It has completely changed the possibilities within genetic manipulation.
Speaker 1So amazing. And well, what I'm wondering is, I can't go to the zoo and watch a chimp without getting that passed by an ethics committee. So how are these kinds of things being done and being acceptable and.
Speaker 2Really great questions. So Colossal Biosciences is a commercial venture, not an educational one, right, so they have different restrictions you'll notice, you know. I guess we should get into as funding mechanisms and how they're doing their fundraising a little bit. Let me finish talking about church for just a moment. His background. He's absolutely a real scientist. He's absolutely done really important work with crisper and genetic manipulation.
Speaker 2But he has controversies surrounding him, and I.
Speaker 5Guess, well, he's he seems like the kind of guy who's super interested in what's possible and maybe less interested in what's ethically sound.
Speaker 2That's one way of looking at it.
Speaker 1I've seen that before.
Speaker 2Yeah, but your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they couldn't they didn't think they should things he gets into, like he got into supporting a DNA dating app that was all about uh, I mean, maybe matching people with good genes. What would you call that? Like good genes? Surely there's another phrase for that. If I can't think, Oh, I remember now, eugenics. Yeah, yeah, this is ethically a hot potato. Maybe it's a hot potato
Speaker 2with tentacles and extra eyes. But it's a hot potato. And but Church has not avoided that kind of controversy. In fact, that's not the only baggage he carries, because he also had a lot of interaction and meetings with famous science supporter Jeffrey Epstein.
Speaker 1That's a different epithet for him, famous science supporter. I've heard other descriptions on her.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, maybe that's not his most famous trade. Now as you mentioned it, I mean, unfortunately Epstein when he was doing his bad things with teens, and that's absolutely real, folks, that's not a conspiracy. When he was doing his bad things with teens, he was also doing some very weird stuff that involved funding lots of scientists and taking them to his private island.
Speaker 1Like Lawrence Krause and others.
Speaker 2Yes, like Lawrence Krause. I mean people that were I guess mainstays of the sort of science cheerleader crowd in the you know, amid ten twenty thirteen, in that zone that long ago, not that long ago, how they have fallen. Yeah, being affiliated with Jeffrey Epstein has generally been, if not a career ender, it's certainly the kind of contamination you just don't want on your resume, but it has not
Speaker 2well again, you know, some people just ignore it, you know, I mean, you know, people just pretend it's not happening. But this guy, dude, yeah.
Speaker 1Defend himself. I know, Lawrence Krause came out and said some kind of troublesome things at the time to defend what it is.
Speaker 2I mean, Unfortunately, Lawrence Krause, Stephen Piker, these guys were really close and when it came out the Epstein, these legal accusations were made against them and eventually convictions. Some of them continue to support him. George Churtz took the tack that well, I'm just a nerd, like I don't know about those things, like that's not a thing that I was just interested in talking science, you know.
Speaker 1And that's sounds a bit like some of the yeah Nazi arguments during.
Speaker 2There following orders, but I was definitely following funding, right, So yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, I guess we could really get bogged down into this aspect. So that's interesting to know, and it certainly does affect a lot of aspects of this research.
Speaker 2Would be conversation ever bogged down by a mention of Epstein, so that would be new.
Speaker 1Well, that's unfortunate. Is he the only person who's involved.
Speaker 2No, No, there's another billionaire tech bro named Ben Lamb who's one of the principal funders. But I'll say this about most of your billionaire or multimillionaire funding people. They get addicted to opim you know, not the drug, the letters, OPM other people's money. So they're always looking for.
Speaker 1Funding maybe opium too.
Speaker 2Yeah, it is, it is. It is very addictive.
Speaker 1So and I empathize to an extent. I mean, how otherwise do you do your research. I'm not talking specifically about the nature of the research, but ye, it's a tough game. Academia is.
Speaker 2In fact that that's one of those things that's got to be covered in my TechBook because the reality is innovation doesn't happen just through enthusiasm. It takes money, and I you know, I again, I don't want to spoil it because I really need to be writing about it. But one of my hypotheses is that innovation behaves a little bit like life in that it has sort of a biome, it has an ecosystem, and the energy it doesn't come from calories, it comes from dollars or money. And that's what keeps innovation moving and growing and mutating.
Speaker 1Interesting idea.
Speaker 2If you don't have money, you just don't get innovation. You might get inventions, but they don't go anywhere without money. It takes money to make these things happen.
Speaker 1I think nothing comes from nothing. So who is behind this?
Speaker 2Then?
Speaker 1The in terms of investment.
Speaker 2Well, that's the thing. It's bin Lamba. George Church have it set up and they have done this meticulous social media and pr master work of bringing in people who are closely associated with high profile projects. So, for example, I guess the one in the news all right all the time now is George R. R. Martin being involved. He's a funder and they're trying to bring back the dire Wolves us. He's a beautiful giant, snow white dire
Speaker 2wolf puppies they're calling them here, okay, monster talking listeners. I know we're always putting the pin in our big balloon monsters, but I have to say this one breaks my heart because I would love this to be real. But what they're making is not a dire wolf. Also, the things in George R. Martin's books are not dire wolves. Dire wolves are not these pony sized wolves I mean they're just a little bigger than the modern timber wolf,
Speaker 2like they're extinct. They were big and impressive, but not big like in Game of Thrones. That's just not a thing. So but every one of these things they hook up with a person who's well known. So they've got Peter Jackson trying to resurrect the mo right. Yeah, So they keep getting these high profile people who are affiliated with ideas of properties and they bring them in. They've got Peter Teel involved, one of my sort of intellectual arch enemies.
Speaker 2They got social media people on n they've got the Winklevoss twins from the early days of Facebook. They've got influencer and self help guru Tony Robbins. They've got yeah, no, it's not it's not good. So it's got a lot of high profile people who like to have their names in the news as well, you know, and egos egos and the profiles themselves, the projects they're doing. Uh, they're
Speaker 2like they claim they want to bring back the dire wolf. Why why do we need a dire wolf?
Speaker 3No?
Speaker 2Is it? Is it some important part of the ecosystem we're missing right now? No? Were we responsible for it? Going extinct. I don't think there's any proof of that.
Speaker 1That's a good point. Which animals do we bring back and why exactly?
Speaker 2The other one obviously huge? Uh the wooly mammoth. Uh would be when that they're trying to bring back allegedly, except you know, how are they proving they can do this because they're making wooly mice? Karen and I think we all know that mice are the next step before you get to full sized elephants. It's a well known fact.
Speaker 1Yeah, I guess there's always mice and rats and worms they work with first. But that's exactly something out of AI.
Speaker 2Yeah, it does. I mean, I mean they're legitimately modifying these creatures, but to what end?
Speaker 1I mean, and are they the same thing?
Speaker 2No, they are absolutely not the same thing. It would be interesting to see the moa come back. It is a big scary bird. Again, if you see the bones, they're huge. So I mean, is are bad enough?
Speaker 4So?
Speaker 2Yeah, they are?
Speaker 1That's right. Yeah. The castle here, we remember our episode?
Speaker 2I do.
Speaker 1Yeah, so I'm not too sure about this. I think interesting in theory.
Speaker 2The castle worries are great, but we needn't be better if they were nine feet tall. You know, I think we all know it would right.
Speaker 1My Nightmass, I.
Speaker 2Mean, where are they put these things right? And they're making this just claims like that if they could bring back the wooly mammoth, it would help stop global warming because you know they would keep the tundras safe.
Speaker 1Well, you know, that just makes me think about our episode on cane toads and the introduction of the cane toads into Queensland and how that disrupted the ecosystem. So you can you imagine if we're talking about dinosaurs and other creatures, what would we be unleashing and what would be the result?
Speaker 2Right? I mean, I know, I know Peter Jackson is not Australian, he's a New Zealander, but only the news just traveled to New Zealand that maybe introducing species is maybe not the best idea, maybe maybe not, you know, so.
Speaker 1He should know better.
Speaker 2So I think the reality is that I think you have to sort of if you look past all that, like, if they look past the hype, what they're really trying to do is raise lots and lots of money, So that means you have to ask, is this a grift? And now skeptics. Okay, let me be clear, these guys are big, rich business people, and I don't want to get sued.
Speaker 1But oh yeah, last thing we need. Huh.
Speaker 2But this is not my first rodeo with nonsense claims in the media around science and health, and this has all the earmarks of a scam slash grift. Now it may have true components, but what they're doing, the real things they're doing, are so far away from the things they're claiming that it just comes across to me as well. The only word that makes any sense is bullshit.
Speaker 1Karen mm hmm, yep, yep. No fair enough call a spade a spade. But yeah, I mean, do they well I was going to ask if they know that, but obviously they have some inkling that it's not going to turn out exactly the way that they're pays you.
Speaker 2I mean, if you're talking about Church, I mean, he's got to know. But I don't think Tony Robbins, I don't think Peter Jackson, I don't I don't think George R. And Martin. They're not trained scientists. They're certainly you know, they're not trained in you know, spotting hoaxes and tricks. You know.
Speaker 1I mean, yeah, you got me thinking about Tony Robinson firewalking now, so absolutely not.
Speaker 2Yes, Tony Robbins in particular. You know, he takes and collects lots of ideas from different writers and puts them together into his own narratives, right, and that they all so there can be good info in there and it's helped people. But there's also the subscription fees and the high priced seminars and the idea that you got to keep investing, and then the cost fallacy. There's a lot of traps there.
Speaker 1Well, you're making me think of people like James Arthur Bray and what happened with him and that criminal case and people dying during his camps.
Speaker 2It's a lot of people that the self help industry is full of grifters and charlatan's. It doesn't mean they all wealthy ones. Yeah, very wealthy ones. Who how do they sleep on a big pile of money at night? Yeah? Exactly, that's you know, because who are the most frequent victims of self help gurus? Desperate people who don't have to give like they Maybe if I'll just keep pouring my money into this, it'll turn things around.
Speaker 1For me, you know, yeah, multi level marketing in a sense.
Speaker 2Really you're going through this and I am too of this job loss situation that you're within your household. And I don't know how Matt's been dealing with it, but my LinkedIn feed has just been a waterfall of scammers trying to say, I've got a deal for you. Here's a job, you work from home, You'll make three thousand dollars a week. I know you won't.
Speaker 1You know, tons of recruiters too, who are asking for money so that you can just search for work and of you pay us and we'll find you a job.
Speaker 2And exactly it's crazy anyway. So it's a terrible ecosystem that victimizes the desperate.
Speaker 1So and absolutely all the time.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, I know, I skepticism is a big umbrella or as I like to say, reality based activism. It's there's lots of ways that critical thinking can help protect you in this story. I think we need to use those tools to separate the science fiction and the possible economic drifting from what's actually interesting science.
Speaker 1So, okay, how do we do that?
Speaker 2You know, it's kind of like I am very immersed in this large language model AI stuff, right, now there are real useful things that can do, but the hype around it is so explosively large that I can only say it's a bubble and when it blows up, it's going to be devastating. Does it do good things?
Speaker 5Yeah?
Speaker 2It can. But are most people who are using it actually going to be able to get a return on investment from that stuff? No? They aren't.
Speaker 1You know, it's not level marketing again.
Speaker 2Yes, you know, it's the tulip thing again. I mean, you know, it's all these It's just we as humans. We are constantly repeating that that looping you know, getting something for nothing, you know, and investors in Wall Street just want quick return, they want, you know, exponential growth.
Speaker 1Right, everything old is new again.
Speaker 2If you don't have a model for actually producing something that is not sustainable, eventually it collapses because it's a bubble. Eventually reality comes calling.
Speaker 1Sure, absolutely, that that's what we're all about. So I guess at this point in the conversation, can we talk a little bit about the die wolves then, and the claims and the reality?
Speaker 2Yeah, so they these beautiful pups.
Speaker 1There's three some pictures.
Speaker 2Yeah, so I think what's called Khalisi and the other promul remis mixing your metaphors as like, well, I just want our characters something cool from our game, you know, Okay, whatever, this is some dungeons and dragon stuff here. I mean they are editing gray wolves. Then they too gray wolf genomes, and they made modifications. So what will that turn out to be? You know, I don't know, I mean, and will they be able to not a dire wolf for sure?
Speaker 1It's just you know, I've heard the term mosaic.
Speaker 2It's a nice term. It's good.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, is that what's going on. It's a kind of.
Speaker 2We also talked about chimerical, right, I mean, I guess it's probably a mosaic if it's you know, relatively a cane in to canid. But if they were to say put you know, they do a lot of things where they put like bio luminescent markers or fluorescent markers into life forms so that they can see if genes are activating by putting a fluorescent light on them. That's really cool, you know, But that's I think if you're bringing something from another species, it's chimerical. In this case, they're calling
Speaker 2it what we just said, the terms mosaic yea mosaic. Yeah sorry, yeah.
Speaker 1So yeah, just a kind of variation on a thing.
Speaker 2I need to do a little insert here. The animals currently being developed by Colossal Biosciences are probably best described as engineered hybrids. This term more accurately reflects their nature than the word mosaics are the word kimera, which have actually very specific scientific meaning. A camara in an organism is made from the fused cells of two separate embryos. While a mosaic has different DNA within its sales due to mutation, colossals process is quite different. It involves editing
Speaker 2the genome of an existing species to introduce traits from an extinct one. For example, they are supposed to be modifying elephant DNA to express wooly mammoth characteristics. Well they've done it with a mouse anyway, not quite an elephant. Their stated ultimate goal is the extinction, and the company's current work, and if I'm being very generous here in regarding their sincerity or their motives, is more of a proof of concept. They're creating smaller, incremental projects like the
Speaker 2mice with traits from extinct rodents and wolfly canines to demonstrate and refine the genetic engineering techniques. These animals are not yet the fully resurrected megafauna that the media portrays, and I wonder why they portray it that way. Could it be they're reading the press releases. Instead, they are stepping stones, living laboratories for the complex process of genetic modification that might one day make the extinction a reality.
Speaker 2I guess we'll find out. And again it is it has been said not by me, but by someone clever that this is an act is clearly for spectacle, and I think that is exactly exactly what it is. It's what we used to call science through pr or science through press release. Right, instead of like doing incremental changes and having those published in a journal and being peer reviewed,
Speaker 2you just released the story of Wired magazine or the Time or whatever, you know, the New York Post whatever, like whoever published the story.
Speaker 1Big difference.
Speaker 2Being in stars and well known people is a great way to bypass that whole you know, the questions of peer review and.
Speaker 1So make you can get more money, more funding.
Speaker 2Yeah, and again real scientists doing this, But that doesn't mean what he's doing is following the scientific method.
Speaker 1Oh absolutely not know.
Speaker 2So I mean maybe worth mentioning again, what is science? So, and know there's lots of definitions, but I lean into the idea of the what do they call it the paparion the science philosopher who says that you, Carl Popper, you've got to have a falsifiable hypothesis and then test it because what science is best at is finding out what's not true. Right, So if you can't eliminate it, as you know, maybe there's something there, but you keep
Speaker 2testing it to see if it's not true, and then what remains is tentatively true, right, but you keep questioning. You're always looking for it to change. Now, other philosophers of science have pointed out that we don't usually see paradigm changes in science without the death of an entire age. So it takes a long time to get scientists to come in to accept a new idea when there's an existing paradigm. But but science is not stagnant. It's constantly
Speaker 2looking to overturn those ideas, those existing paradigms, because that's how you make your name for yourself. Or you do some stunt and get into a bunch of news stories. I mean, you know, so you jump a couple of Yeah, so I'm not saying they're not doing anything. I'm just saying that they're not doing what they're claiming. So and I think that's pretty clear.
Speaker 4Hmm.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's just such an interesting contrast to the other research.
Speaker 2But it is and again, there's real good science being done with Crisper. It is changing the world, you know. And again I don't avoid the politics, but scientific funding is under attack right now because I think a lot of people would serve and kinds of ideas don't want to see changes. You don't want to see certain kinds of research being done if they see it as having a political agenda. And it's a human process, so it
Speaker 2is political. I mean, you basically can't escape personally political. You certainly can't escape ethics. So the fact that they are trying to sort of circumvent those things by you know, getting stars to come in and support it is kind of disturbing. It's kind of disturbing. Yeah.
Speaker 1It does speak volumes too, though, I think, just are you mapping it out like this, laying it out? It's really interesting. It's certainly instar contrast to what I'd originally heard about these creatures. It sounded more along the lines of the whole dolly thing. Obviously sheep.
Speaker 2Well, I mean google headlines about dire wolves, right, and I'm just reading this off. It's like Time Magazine the Return of the dire Wolf CNN. Scientists say they've resurrected the dire wolf. So Nature, this company claims to have de extincted dire wolves. New York Times scientists vive the dire wolf for something close.
Speaker 1Okay, no, well, Nature is hedging a little bit, but maybe less the other outlets.
Speaker 2There is scientific skepticism out there, it's just not in the mainstream publications. Serious science outlets recognize this for what it is, science through pr and that's not how you do things in fact in our lifetime, I guess the most notorious case of this was the cold fusion fiasco. Was it Fleischmann and Ponds, I think about it. They claimed that they had done cold fusion in the lab, and instead of doing a journal and peer review and
Speaker 2all that sort of thing, they just went and did a giant press conference and then within I don't it was like probably forty eight hours it had been demonstrated to be nonsense. But for just a few glorious moments people thought maybe we had a giant energy breakthrough. So and meanwhile, I'm gonna say, real or apparently real efforts for things like actual fusion have you know, thirty years later, you know, we're just now getting the breakthrough, starting to get you know, chain reactions that produce more energy than
Speaker 2goes into them. So I feel like that's exciting. I hope something comes of that.
Speaker 1But you know, well, you're making me think too. You and I have both been to Coral Castle, and I'm just thinking about all the pamphlets that you can buy there in which this lead Skeleman was claiming he'd invented a perpetual motion machine.
Speaker 2I literally have a stack of them on my shelf over here. Yeah, what an interesting little man he was. You know, my mother in law fled from Latvia during World War Two with her mom. He was Latvian, so she ended up in Miami. They came to Rochester, but work took my wife's father down to Miami and they were right there, they were right there by Coral Castle. And so it was like pride that this little Latvian man had done. And he did cool stuff. I mean,
Speaker 2he did really impressive, cool stuff. But he did he did with magic, you know.
Speaker 1So simple machines.
Speaker 2Yes, And it's so funny because I just went again to visit and they've really even more than last time I went. They've stepped back from some of the supernatural claims, which I applaud, right, but they always need that. But maybe it was something else. But maybe it was something else, you know.
Speaker 1Oh yeah, yeah, But I remember when I was there, that was quite some time ago. They were really leaning into that, and they had that very interesting book there that made lots of associations between him and what he was doing and all different other kinds of paranormal phenomena. Even Nazism was very very strange, some of the claims that they were making. But yeah, I guess we're deviating. We are a little bit, but you know, uh, that's what we do.
Speaker 2Whenever we get a chance to talk about girl Castle, we have well you're gonna have to do make the Castle the old news host from wait, wait.
Speaker 1Don't tell me, but well, maybe to be confused.
Speaker 2Every time I heard cral Castle's name, I was like, cral Castle, no.
Speaker 1A little different. Yeah, well this is really interesting and it certainly makes me think about other uh creatures that we've looked at, like the thiless scene and the the Moa, and these probably deserve their own episodes too, of the wooly mammoth uh these other colossal projects, as.
Speaker 2You, they deserve moa skepticism. I thought she talks southernly. So yeah, I hope that we've answered both kinds of queries we've been receiving and I don't. So, by the way, I'm sorry if you haven't received these. I need to make I need to do some out of metion better about making sure that I forward stuff to you that
Speaker 2I get. But if you send the emails a blanketcolate or Karen must or we do get it.
Speaker 1So yeah, Well, I think in terms of the Internet, you and I see different things, but together usually we managed to see just about everything, all most of it.
Speaker 2Anyway, It's like me and my wife. I mean, between the two is we almost make a perfectly functional person.
Speaker 1So well, it just sounds like this just raises a lot of interesting questions. I guess more questions than providing answers at this point. And it's to be continued this yeah kind of science.
Speaker 2If you were if you're interested in this, and you think, are they doing real science? They're doing something If you think, wow, they're changing the future and they're going to bring back these animals. Should I give them money? You know, No, don't. In fact I do. I think one of the ethical concerns people have which I would not have thought this. I read this, it was like, oh, yeah, that's a good point. To some small extent, These kind of high profile we can fix it with DNA resurrection processes do detract from more serious efforts to save species that are
Speaker 2still alive today, in the same way that we got to get to Mars and terra form Mars. Okay, it is a lot cheaper to fix Earth than it is to fly to another planet.
Speaker 1It just is in priorities.
Speaker 2Huh. Yeah, I mean, would it be cool to have basis on Mars. Yes, I'm a sci fi fan. It would be great. But does it make any kind of sense to do that as our primary plan? No, it just doesn't. So yeah, yeah, that is.
Speaker 1A really good point that you raise, and what's important what should be our priorities? And that really does I think position this as being more about I guess, as you said, spectacle.
Speaker 2Yeah, and also Georgia r MICUs, just stop holding dire wolves and get back to right now, next book.
Speaker 1Well again, priorities, right.
Speaker 2That's right. Well, I love him, take as long as he needs to. But I think this is I think the old man's been duped on this one. Yeah, they are beautiful puppies.
Speaker 1Though I can understand the allure. I mean, you and I have really been immersed in skepticism and immersed in a lot of aspects of science from different perspectives obviously, but I think for the average person and someone who's got a little bit of money and they think, well, I can be attached to this, I can be a part of something big. I can really understand the allure of that, but the reality is quite different.
Speaker 2I mean, this is a little fringy, but totally plausible. One of the things George Church has done is encode a book in DNA, just to show that it could be done. His book, you know, so you know, I mean they could do something wacky like, you know, help us bring back the dire Wolf and will inclode that will enclode in code, well, in code the funders' names in the DNA sequence. They could totally do that. That's crazy but real.
Speaker 1You know, that's a big Kiss fan, and he's told me a few times about the it was a Kiss comic or something that had some of their blood, Yeah, the members blood put into it.
Speaker 2Yeah. I think they did that with The Squadron Supreme too, one of my favorite comics when the when the author died, I think they did an issue where they included some of his blood in the ink. Yeah. So it's a way to be immortalized, I guess, you know.
Speaker 1Timothy, Yeah, Leary sending himself out into space.
Speaker 2Yeah. I think a lot of people from Star Trek have gone up there. I know James Dewan has, so, you know. I mean that's ashes. It's not actually the best preservation, but it's symbolically beautiful.
Speaker 1So yeah, yeah, yeah, Well, well, lots of things going on. But it's an interesting topic, and I think we should stay tuned because it doesn't sound like this is the end of it.
Speaker 2Oh it's not for sure, but you know, again, uh, just be skeptical of these kind of claims. If it sounds too good to be true, probably is it probably is, you know, I don't Again, I'm not trying to be a downer at all. I love experimentation. I want there to be frank and beet. Of course I do food, you know. Yeah, yeah, the old The Attiger's Guide dinner creature that wants to be devoured and tells you, oh
Speaker 2you should try this, you.
Speaker 1Know, like, oh god it Davidson.
Speaker 2By the way, did you know that from the the BBC TV version is Peter Davison and he ends up becoming one of the doctors and doctor who So oh, you're.
Speaker 1Making me think of those trucks where you like a butcher and you see a pig that's being chopped up and it's got a big smile on its face.
Speaker 2Yes, Or the weirdest one all over the South is the go to a barbecue place and the cook is a pig cooking the other pig eggs. It's like, this is delicious, Come on in and have some of me, you know.
Speaker 1It's like, well, you are reminding me that we're going to be talking about cannibalism again soon. Brian Sharpless in a couple of weeks.
Speaker 2That is. I love talking to Brian, so oh yeah, I mean that book is a treasure trove of cool stuff.
Speaker 1So yeah, yeah, absolutely, and yeah, we I think since there are those other documentaries where we did the cover the documentary recently, the ghost Hunters, and we're going to have to follow up with the other two documentaries of the one on Lockedness and the one on UFOs too because we have just had such interest in that particular episode.
Speaker 2We also, I'll tell you one more we need. I'll probably cope this out and just leave it in for the patrons because I don't know how much speculation about future episodes we need to leave in for the regular show. But yeah, yeah, I've been looking for It's probably been three or four years now. I've been collecting articles about what I like to think of is the Milwaukeean hypothesis, the idea that there is this god Moloch that people sacrifice children to and it exists as an idea. Demonizing
Speaker 2your enemies by claiming that they sacrifice their children to demons is an ancient idea which is still going on today, Like even right now, it's happening in American politics, people saying that on their they sacrifice their kids to demons, or you know, are there's baby farms or all these great but this ancient idea, it won't go away. And it came up in the Gulf War, and I have
Speaker 2an interesting story about that.
Speaker 1So uh yeah, okay, well yeah, well high patrons, yeah, and uh yeah, definitely we'll go to get around to these things.
Speaker 2Yeah. So just again, I know we said all the time, but just be skeptical, you know, hold on to your money to you're sure, you know so exactly when it comes to supporting Monster Talk, which is absolutely worth your investment.
Speaker 1Indeed, we make no promises.
Speaker 2All right, I think that went very well.
Speaker 1All right, I think that sounded great and you don't have to worry you You sounded absolutely fine.
Speaker 2So do I actually feel pretty good. I'm gonna stop recording.
Speaker 1That is great, and good luck tomorrow.
Speaker 2You've been listening to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stoltner. You just heard a discussion about Colossal Biosciences claims that they're de extincting species. I've put links in the show notes for further reading and listening. And I'm sorry that some of the stuff here got so dark. The technology and ethics questions around this stuff is really challenging enough without having to bring in sketchy celebrity endorsements, and you know Jeffrey Epstein affiliations.
Speaker 2So will the few true eventually see mankind restoring extinct species to nature. The problem is I can't see the future, and I refuse to not see the past. We hope you've enjoyed this episode of Monster Talk. Each episode we strive to bring you the very best in monster related content, with a focus on bringing scientific skepticism into the conversation. If you enjoy Monster Talk, we now have a variety of ways to support the show, all with convenient links
Speaker 2at monster talk dot org forwarde slash support. That's monster talk dot org forwarde slash support. We have links there to our Patreon page, as well as a donation button. Another great way to support the show is to buy books from our Amazon Monster Talk wish list, which directly helps us with our research. We love used books very much, so don't feel compelled to buy new ones, and we love kindles so we can share our digital libraries with each other. And finally, without spending any money at all, you can support us by leaving a positive review and
Speaker 2iTunes or wherever you get your podcasts. Positive reviews help keep us visible in iTunes, which is a great way to help us find you listeners, and please share our show on your favorite social media platforms. Monster Talks theme music is by Peach Stealing Monkeys. As always, thank you for making Monster Talk a part of your listening life.
Speaker 2This has been a Monster House presentation. It's a free It's a dire Wolf.
Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...
Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...
Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...
🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...
Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...