Cemeteries Cleaning and Grave Rubbing - Karen and Blake are joined by Matt Baxter to discuss the ethics and best practices around maintaining and preserving graveyards. Links for Grave Rubbers from CyberSpace: The article that inspired this conversation (via The Conversation) Ken Feder (friend of the show and emeritus professor of archaeology) sent along this helpful article about grave preservation. The woman with the pink foam (Kaeli Mae McEwen - aka "Clean Girl") has a site where she sells the stuff. In Atlanta - at historic Oakland Cemetery - they have community cleaning projects. They list this under an article titled "Pro Team Field Notes on Scrubbing the Surface" Thoughts on Grave Rubbing from a blogger. Additional Links: Since we mentioned The Conversation, by coincidence Jeb Card got interviewed about his paranormal course at University of Ohio - check it! Karen's book Bitch: The Journey of a Word is out now - grab a copy! (affiliate link) Don't forget to grab a copy of Joe Nickell's The Science of Monsters: Tracking the Real-Life Creatures - every sale helps MonsterTalk! (affiliate link) And if you want to meet me at sea in the Bermuda Triangle, sign up for the Skeptoid Adventure - there's still a few cabins left! (as of 2/1/2025) Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Monster House Presents.
Speaker 2Let's clean a random grave.
Speaker 3Who do you think is buried here? Let's clean it and find out.
Speaker 4I have so many questions.
Speaker 2How old is this grave? It looks like it's been here for five hundred years? How this gravee gets so dirty? We there's a tree growing out of it.
Speaker 5I love plants.
Speaker 2This transformation is extremely hard for me, but I believe everyone deserves a beautiful grave.
Speaker 4It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before.
Speaker 3A giant, hairy creature.
Speaker 4Part eighte part mass in Luckness, a twenty four mile long, bottomless lake in the Highlands of Scotland.
Speaker 5It's a creature known as the Luckness Monster.
Speaker 3Monster Talk. Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner.
Speaker 4This episode deals with death and cemeteries. The audio at the top of this episode was from a YouTube video, one in a series and of an entire class of cleaning videos that we'll be discussing in today's chat. The title of the episodes a play on the original title of Edwoods film Plan nine from Outer Space. The original title was Grave Robbers from Outer Space. And since we'll be discussing grave rubbing and the Internet, I decided to.
Speaker 3Call it grave rubbers from cyberspace.
Speaker 4Now, you may find the term cyberspace sounds a bit dated, and before we started calling it the Internet or the net or that digital hell that I can't escape, it was also called the Information super Highway, and of course cyberspace and the term cyberspace was coined by William Gibson around nineteen eighty two. But that word itself is derived from cybernetics, which was coined by the mathematician Norbert Wiener in the nineteen forties to describe a field of study of communication and systems control, and that got a lot
Speaker 4of content overlap with Claude Shannon's information theory. Now, Wiener was naming the idea after the Greek word kibernetes, which means a ship's helm or governor, which is also where we get the word gubernatorial. And if you're in it, you'll know there's a popular software package called Kubernetes which is used to manage our govern server instances of what we call containerized applications. You don't need to know any of that for the episode, but I always find it interesting to see a word rise and fall in usage, and to note how the meaning changes over time. For instance,
Speaker 4right now everyone in the media is calling large language models by the letters A and I, but AI researchers would not.
Speaker 3Classify them this way.
Speaker 4It's sloppy and misleading, and there is nothing we can do to fix it, because that's how language works. Language does not bow before leaders. It does not stay in tidy containers. It describes the ebb and flow of ideas an effort to constrain it, or like ordnance against storm or earthquake. But I love dusting off a formerly popular word and taking it around the block, or maybe scrubbing it down with pink foam and then creating it around TikTok hmm, maybe not mobstrtal.
Speaker 3Thanks for joining us all tonight. Hey Matt, welcome back. Thank you, Karen.
Speaker 4As always, you know this is this is your topic. I'm excited and I've sort of put I put peanut butter in the chocolate, or I put chocolate and the peanut butter.
Speaker 3Because as soon as you said that you wanted to.
Speaker 4Talk about this online culture around grave cleaning.
Speaker 3I immediately went to and what about grave rubbing?
Speaker 4Because I did that in the eighties and that's really relevant.
Speaker 1Oh you did. I didn't know you ever did it. I know it was.
Speaker 5It's been a thing on and off, and there could be some confusion here. So yeah, we're going to talk about a couple of different things. So grave cleaning and grave rubbing, but not robbing.
Speaker 1That's another day, exactly. No grave robbing.
Speaker 3I'm planning grave rubbers from cyberspace. That's my plan. Nine tie.
Speaker 2Oh yeah, that's good.
Speaker 1T lovely lovely.
Speaker 5Well, yeah, this is a kind of complicated topic. But I came across an article in The Conversation and it was about people who clean the Conversations. Okay, so it is a kind of an online magazine, I guess, and they say something about their journalistic flair and academic rigor. So it is that there are articles written by scholars academics, but they are written for a general audience.
Speaker 1So I do tend.
Speaker 5I've written for them before, not about this topic, and so this article came up for me and I thought this sounds interesting. And we've treated a lot of cemetery law and topics surrounding cemeteries in the past.
Speaker 2So I'm sorry, Can I interrupt for one second? Karen, I'm so sorry. I just need to ask Blake. When a statement such as academic rigor is said in a topic about cemeteries, do you have any puns that come to mind?
Speaker 1Because, oh, don't encourage him.
Speaker 4Well, yeah, I was sitting here waiting to do something with rigor mortis, if that's what you're asking.
Speaker 2Yes, I just couldn't find it. I couldn't find a clean way to do it.
Speaker 4Yeah. No, no, rigor mortis was I was just sitting here waiting. It was loaded up, ready to go. No, you're absolutely on point there.
Speaker 6Okay, I'm so sorry with this stupid.
Speaker 3She's stiff delivery.
Speaker 5There it has begun. So yeah, this article, i'd encourage people to go and read it. Grave cleaning videos are going viral on TikTok. Are they honoring the dead or exploiting them? So, yeah, this is a trend and there are a number of people who are doing this, but they're doing this in different ways. So the article cites a woman named Alicia Williams of Virginia, and so her angle is more as a kind of historian. She restores
Speaker 5headstones and she cleans them.
Speaker 1So we're going to get into that shortly.
Speaker 5But the other side of the coin is a woman by the name of Kaylee Mae McEwan. So her style it's a little bit more click bait.
Speaker 1I guess we can say yeah yeah.
Speaker 5Now she's known as the clean Girl. And it's so funny because I read this article and I said, hey, Matt, we're going to watch the Clean Girl on YouTube, and so we've got off one of her videos and then blade nine year old walks past is like the clean Girl.
Speaker 1So this is such a thing.
Speaker 5That even nine year olds know who'she she is. And she has four point two million followers on TikTok and her video that she puts out she gets millions of views. I mean upwards of seventy million views per video. So this is a real thing. So her technique, it is a little bit questionable. So again, this Alicia Williams, she does consult with the families, I believe, and she works
Speaker 5in with them, gets their permission, works in with the caretakers at the cemeteries as well. But this Kaylee McEwan, the Clean Girl. She has a kind of pink spiky ball. Now did you watch any of these videos?
Speaker 3Like I can never get that time back, Yes I did.
Speaker 1Yes, I'm going with it.
Speaker 2But yeah, did you notice that she had no disclaimers about I talked to the cemetery, I told, oh, yeah, yeah, no, no, no, there was no disclaimers at all.
Speaker 4And I mean to be to be fair to her. She is the clean girl, not just the graveyard clean girl. So she also cleans bathrooms and other stuff, you know, a really nasty job, which is fine, but when you get into cemeteries and people's remains, there's a lot of cultural norms, you.
Speaker 3Know, that that can be violated here.
Speaker 4And I think something about her tight fitting exercise gear and bright pink soap and the rolling the ball to find Whi's grave is going to be grace with her, you know, cleaning uh yeah.
Speaker 1Magic foam. Yeah.
Speaker 4I just fine, it just I I can't explain why I've been thinking about this for days now, why I find this so cringe worthy.
Speaker 3But I totally find it cringeworthy.
Speaker 4And part of it is I think I don't know what's in her soap, and like the preservationist to me is concerned that she's not using you know, cemetery safe materials, you know, But well that's just me.
Speaker 5I don't know, well you are, You are right that she does clean things other than gravestones. And I saw a video that came up and it was her cleaning a public restaurant, a restroom in KFC for free. So she's really out there.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's another thing she says, though it's for free, and this video only got forty million views.
Speaker 4Yeah, for free, except for you know free, She's okay, just not by the venue right now.
Speaker 2So there was a lot of clickbait going on. But whatever it is, her business is working. You know, she's doing well with her business. But we do have to be a question.
Speaker 5Well, she does have her outfit and everything, and we don't want to shame her or anything like that.
Speaker 1That's not what we're talking about.
Speaker 5But I think it's more a matter of that she doesn't seek permission from the cemetery. She doesn't seek permission from the families. Now, she has been accused of over zealously editing some of her work as well, so I guess we should go back to what she does. So, as you said, she's got the pink spiky ball and she goes to a cemetery and she just rolls the ball and it hits a particular grave, and so it's meant to be a random thing.
Speaker 1So I don't know if that's reality or not.
Speaker 5I don't know if she chooses a grave that she wants to work with, or chooses maybe a person or a family that have a story that she wants to treat. But she throws this ball lands there, and then she cleans the grave, and sometimes that can take her five six hours. Sometimes she's doing it in scorching hot sun. Other times she's cleaning at night at.
Speaker 3Night, which is super weird to me.
Speaker 4I mean, not because it's scary, but just because the implication is she's sneaking in there doing well.
Speaker 2And we don't know how that's going to affect her soul.
Speaker 3Oh well, I don't know that.
Speaker 5You're right, Yeah, could get an attachment and leave and take a ghost home.
Speaker 4I'm pretty sure that therapy that pink foam will take care of that.
Speaker 3I'm sure. I'm sure.
Speaker 1Yeah, it looks a little nuclear. Yeah.
Speaker 2Now, Karen, you said something there that I was wondering if do we know this for sure? Do we know that she's not asking permission or is she just not promoting that she does?
Speaker 3Yeah?
Speaker 5I do not know that, and again she's accused of a lot of different things like questionable editing and people saying that there are lots of privacy issues surrounding this.
Speaker 1So honestly, I don't know.
Speaker 5Watching these, you would assume anyway that she's just doing this randomly because she talks about cleaning the graves of strangers. So I just don't think she's getting permissioned. And when she goes in and does this at night, she's jumping at every noise that she hears, so it just doesn't seem like she's got permission.
Speaker 1I just heard something weird? Is that a ghost?
Speaker 3It was not a ghost. I accidentally clicked the link.
Speaker 2They would tell her. They would say, you could, you could clean these ones, but do not touch these ones. You can do this, but you can't do that, And they would be giving her, you know, a lot of rules and guidance that she probably doesn't even want to say that she you know, follows, you know, I we know how it is to be accused of things online. I know that my coworker accuses me of stealing his stapler every day, and it does not matter that my stuff is impeccably stapled.
Speaker 7They've moved my desk four times already this year. And I used to be over by the window and I could see the squirrels and they were married. But then they switched from the swing line to the buston Stafler. But I kept my swing line stapler because it didn't bind up as much, and I kept the staples for the swing line stapler.
Speaker 2The thing is is it doesn't always just because she's being accused of it doesn't necessarily mean that she's guilty.
Speaker 5I think there are kind of indicators that she's not seeking permission. And again, because she talks about cleaning the graves of strangers, she's doing this at night, and I just don't think that she'd get permissioned from any cemetery or any council to go.
Speaker 1And do that.
Speaker 5I know in Australia there are some cemeteries that are just open all the time, but it seems to be more of a trend here that you have locks and gates and hours usually from I guess sunrise to sunset that cemeteries are open. So I just really can't talk to that, but it is I think the assumption in this article is that Alicia Williams is doing this, she does get permission. She tells the stories and the history of these people and their families and their life experiences
Speaker 5and what happened to them. And we're not getting that with the clean Well. Instead, she's kind of cracking jokes and making assumptions about people, and I mean, I'm just really not getting respect from.
Speaker 2Maybe we ought to keep an eye on this because of the fact that for someone who has four point two million followers, she's got a ton millions and millions of views on each video. That makes her a huge target. So if somebody wanted to come after her with any kind of lawsuit or anything like that, she is a prime target for that. And if she is doing things she shouldn't be, we will see that. So I would rise open too.
Speaker 5I would add too that from the examples I've seen, we're talking about people who died quite some time ago to so we're not talking.
Speaker 1About recent interments. We're talking about people.
Speaker 2We're still talking about the cemetery.
Speaker 3Well, the cemetery.
Speaker 4Yeah, the fact that the graves she claims tend to be the most unkept, which implies there's no next of kin, there's no next to kin, nobody's taking a look at it, so you know, they don't care.
Speaker 3It's interesting.
Speaker 4I mean she her brand is perky and bubbly, I guess, and like quite literally bubbly with that pink stuff.
Speaker 1She's very pink.
Speaker 4Yeah, but I mean she's got that girl next door in a you know, tracksuit, you know, or type fitting exercise gear kind of vibe. So I mean, I I don't think a cemetery in a cemetery, I don't think it's hyper sexualized or anything like that.
Speaker 3But I mean she's definitely going for the cute thing. Yeah, yeah, she is.
Speaker 5And I would venture to say that's why she has so many followers and so many of her videos are watched as.
Speaker 1Much as they are.
Speaker 5But that's a good point anyway. Talking about the magic foam, Now, it's funny. I always hear late he does something, he says, oh, that's so satisfying, and she does that too. She has this magic foam. She calls it pink foamy cleanser, and she has marketed this. So this stuff maybe it's twenty nine nine five, I think a pop and she is making a mozza from selling this and from all of her social media accounts.
Speaker 1But it is this bubblegum pink.
Speaker 3It really is.
Speaker 4It's impressive that it doesn't stain the stone. Honestly, I'm surprised. So that's that's good.
Speaker 1I don't know what the hell's in it.
Speaker 5What I guess was outlawed by the government in this country a red dive sometimes. But the funny thing is she has been accused too of editing and that the foam is a different color blue or something like that. I've seen it using different colored lenses as well, and I don't know if that's I mean, she is doing layer upon layer of this, and that is another complaint. This conversation piece talked about how that could cause damage to the graves.
Speaker 3Well, and I've.
Speaker 4Seen her use pressure washer and scrub brushes and other brushes.
Speaker 3Yeah, and it's like, here's the thing, toilet cleaners.
Speaker 4The stones themselves at cemetery areas are made out of different materials, and some of them are hard and sealed, and some of them are porous and soft, like limestone. Yeah, limestone marble, you know those are pretty and then granite is really hard. But you know that's they really needed to improve tools to make granite monuments, you know, pretty inexpensive so they had to have like really powerful sand blasters and other tools and stuff. So I guess my
Speaker 4point is the older the tombstone is, the more likely that they are going to be damaged by a rough cleaning.
Speaker 5And yeah, and they are filthy, as you say. I mean, they're covered in mold. They're covered in fungus and algae and lichen and things like that. And so one of her claims too, is that she is I'm just trying to find the quote that she says to do. She says that she's giving them their name back. So she because a lot of these you can't even read any longer because they're just so covered in endured and felt and they're that old.
Speaker 4Ah.
Speaker 5But you know, you do have a lot of culture around cleaning as well. So there is a lot of history of people talking about washing as a kind of ritual or a purification process or preparation for the afterlife and things like that. And there are a lot of people who are doing things that are similar to this too.
Speaker 2There are even baptism, Yes, that baptism is a washing way of sins.
Speaker 5Feats, that kind of thing. References to Jesus before he was crucified, but there are other creators who are doing similar things, and I guess they're less hands on. For example, there are a number of people who are very successful at making recipes found on headstones. I think that's such an interesting thing. I mean, I've been to a lot of cemeteries over the years in the course of the things I've done in skepticism, and I've come across a lot of headstones that have a recipe maybe for cookies
Speaker 5or a cake that a particular person loved to bake and.
Speaker 3Wanted to just the last thing, I ate, what could plus bigger wrong?
Speaker 1Yeah, the salmon.
Speaker 2Darling.
Speaker 3You didn't use canned salmon, did you.
Speaker 5I didn't even eat the salmon moves. So I think that kind of thing is really charming. And I've watched some of these videos and there was a lady who baked a recipe for cookies that was on a headstone. I thought that was really sweet and recorded the process was really honoring that the person who died so but again, that's not physically touching these headstones. I'm assuming this person too did have mission from the families. But again, it's
Speaker 5this is a really tricky one because I'm sure that there would be that a lot of these people who are buried there would have living family members, and maybe others wouldn't have been the family line would have died out with that person or with subsequent generations, and so you know, who do you seek permission from?
Speaker 2From what I've seen? Uh, you know, there there's a lot of issues around this when it comes to like I said that the Lichens and the fun guy and things like that that get on these weaken what.
Speaker 3Do you think about werewolfs? A lot of Lichens are fun guys.
Speaker 1A yeah, I was waiting for that.
Speaker 6Yeah, wow, all right, it's it's it is one of those things that that that you know, you've got the it's a balance because you've got these these.
Speaker 2Funguses and everything that all fun guy already causing damage. Uh, but when you clean all them off, you are clean taking off a bunch of that damage with it, and it looks like even more damage as being because I mean the stone is weakened and everything else. Now when it comes to you know, the cemetery, they if they see that there's these kind of problems going on, they'll reach out and try to locate the surviving family members. You know, from the records and try to let them know if they can't get a hold of them. Different
Speaker 2cemeteries have different policies, but they might attempt to repair it themselves. If it's beyond repair, they'll probably just remove it and store it somewhere. So it's kind of one of those things that if it's in a situation where you know, the only other alternative is that they're going to remove it and store it, well, then maybe they might allow her. But if she's not even asking, then she is absolutely violating a lot of these cemeteries policies.
Speaker 2But yeah, a lot of times that the cemeteries will replace headstones and stuff like that they can't reach anybody, And it just really depends on the situation and how involved the cemetery is, because you know, we've all been to cemeteries that have no one.
Speaker 4Oh yeah, well I've been to abandon you know, cemeteries lost in the woods, and that's where too. Now several of her videos she says I found a grave in the woods, and it's like, clearly she's at a.
Speaker 3Cemetery that's like grown up, it's like it's.
Speaker 4Got it literally has the sort of Stelli marking out areas of the cemetery. This is not in the middle of a forest that this is in a cemetery that's overgrown.
Speaker 1Well, that's a.
Speaker 5Good point too. She never states where she is. She doesn't say what town or city states, what the name of the cemetery is. It's really but she is promoting, you know, her work via on the back of these people and exposing their names, talking about references to when they died and whatever information is on the headstones too, So it is really exposing these people.
Speaker 4It's it's such a conundrum for someone like me, who I don't think anything happens when we die except we stop living.
Speaker 1Oh us too, And I just but I still have.
Speaker 4A tremendous respect for cemeteries and as a representation of lives gone. I mean, I just because their dad doesn't mean they need to be forgotten.
Speaker 3And so I mean it's history. Yeah, it's histortory right there. And if your work to.
Speaker 4Preserve history also destroys it, that's really bad. So the vibe is one thing, but is she doing real damage as another? Now I don't know on this case, but I will tell you this. I did some research and I have a couple of pieces of advice if anybody in the audience wants to get involved in symmetry cleaning, because when you watch these videos, it will make you want to clean.
Speaker 3It really does.
Speaker 4And that video that you watch, yeah, I mean it looked extraordinarily satisfying. And I actually have family members in rural cemeteries who.
Speaker 3Do need upkeep.
Speaker 2Now we're just trying to sound young and hip.
Speaker 3Gotcha, gotcha.
Speaker 4But well, I'll tell you the in your county, are your state, there are historical societies, and there are parks, governance organizations. You can just go to your state or local government and find organizations that deal with cemetery rules and you'll find there there are groups who already want to go help restore cemeteries or keep them maintain cemeteries. Now we're not talking about big modern cemeteries where people
Speaker 4pay thousands of dollars and they have regular upkeep.
Speaker 3These are small parcels.
Speaker 4These are you know, we're again it's lost memories, lost history where these things are being overgrown.
Speaker 3Right, They're all over.
Speaker 4The place in every state as far as I know. But if you want to do this work, seek out the organizations that already have control of that because they are going to give you good guidance and help you avoid an ilegal.
Speaker 3Problems, right, for that's one thing.
Speaker 4Second of all, make sure that whatever you do is not going to harm what's still remaining. For example, in Atlanta, we have this huge symmetry called Oakland.
Speaker 3It's really beautiful.
Speaker 4It comes from that classic age of massive monuments, beautiful Gilded Age.
Speaker 3It's amazing.
Speaker 4Well, they have groups that preserve and protect the cemetery, but they don't let you just run around and start scrubbing stuff. So they have very careful, organized efforts along those lines. But one of the things they talked about is using a specific kind of cleaner. There's a substance it's literally called a graveyard cleaner. It's called d SLASH two biological solution, and it's designed to be ecologically safe for the monuments and the surrounding landscape. But it will break down and remove layers of moss like in dirt
Speaker 4and other environmental pollutants from the air and the rain. You put it on there and then it takes a week to two weeks or sometimes even a month, but it will dissolve all that goo and leave a clean stone. And then they also recommend once you get it started and cleaned, you just come back and retreat it once a year. And I'll put a link to that in the show notes because Oakland, not to the cleaning solush, but to the story I took that from.
Speaker 1It's easy.
Speaker 2You have to find these slash too, But that sounds satisfying. Yeah, to have something clean like that without having to really do anything.
Speaker 8Yeah, to be ecologically safe, ethically safe to preserving the stone, and relatively easy to just keep it going by coming back once a year. The stuff is fifty dollars a gallon, but you water it down so it's not pink.
Speaker 3Sorry, yeah, never mind, never mind, Yeah, I forget, forget everything.
Speaker 5Yeah, speaking about colors, I was going to say something, Matt, you want to I'm sorry.
Speaker 2I was just going to say, Blake, you said that you had done grave rubbing.
Speaker 3Yes, yeah, yeah, well it was a thing. I mean it was a thing. Yeah. I talked to my wife and she goes, oh, yeah, we did that.
Speaker 4We went to Savannah and like you know, had to like rub old tombstones in one of the Savannah cemeteries. There's some beautiful ones in Savannah too.
Speaker 1But bon a Venture we've talked about that.
Speaker 4Yes, absolutely and unfortunately, well or maybe fortunately, depending how you look at it. Savannah has now banned that you have to get special permission to take a grave rubbing legally right. They basically just banned it completely. And the reason this led me down a rabbit hole and I never could find what I considered to be a satisfactorily definitive answer, because the question was is grave rubbing detrimental to the tombstone? And the answer it varies all over
Speaker 4the country. There's different people who have different opinions. The general idea that you could take a piece of paper, put it on a stone and rub it with a crayon and that would somehow damage the stone sounds crazy to me, but I'm used. I'm used to newer stones that are not fragile, and where they've been banned pretty widespread is in New England, where the stones are often made out of much softer and much older stones like slate, you know, which is fading fast and you know old marble, these things, and they are thin upright stones, and if
Speaker 4you're pressing on them, you could easily make them tip over and then break, which would absolutely be that you know, if you're dealing with slate in particular, that's oh my gosh, it's so fragile.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 4But so if you're in Massachusetts, I would say don't try this because it does appear to be illegal there. Same in Savannah, and there's take your local ordinances, is what I'm getting at.
Speaker 5Yeah, yeah, yeah, I think it's pretty safe to say that you would want to chick in with local authorities about it because it's going to really be a state driven thing. And I looked into it in Australia to where a lot of those headstones for white people in terms of burial grounds, they're going to be no when you're as old as some of the ones that you'll have here in some parts of the country, so they're going to be going back a couple of hundred years. So it doesn't seem like there are any specific laws in Australia that's implicitly prohibit brave rubbing, but at the
Speaker 5same time it seems to be considered to be disrespectful and it's really discouraged by a lot of cemetery authorities. So they want you to seek out prior mission and to document and photograph headstones and to do that instead of actually rubbing them.
Speaker 2Yeah, and that's been the alternative that I've personally gone for. It's been photography, and it's I think it's fantastic because you get a much better representation of it. Yeah, it's not as satisfying though.
Speaker 4I even saw sites recommending you get a higher end iPhone and do a light our scan. I'm like, Okay, yeah, that's not happening. But I mean it does sound very cool though, yeah it does.
Speaker 5No.
Speaker 3Yeah, I still I have mixed feelings about this because again.
Speaker 4I did grave rubbing, and I know a lot of people who are into genealogy like to, and I used to be.
Speaker 3You used to see it on people's walls.
Speaker 4You'd come into their houses and they'd have framed, you know, stones from their own family or whatever, you know, these rubbings.
Speaker 3And I haven't seen that in years.
Speaker 4And I'm just wondering when it kind of died out, because it does not seem to be nearly.
Speaker 3As popular as it used to be.
Speaker 5But I'm wondering, well, this is still a popular thing to some extent. And what I find interesting is are the people who have websites about this, and they do this because.
Speaker 1They're historians or folklorists or.
Speaker 5Something like that, and when they do tell you the story of the person that is buried beneath. And some of these sites that I've looked at have been very touching too. And I remember reading about one little boy who was six years old and died on Christmas Day back in nineteen thirty five, died of meningitis. So we should probably put some kind of content warning in this episode too, some of the nature some of the things we're talking about. I do think it's really important. This is one thing that the clean Girl does not do,
Speaker 5and that is she doesn't talk about the family. She doesn't talk about the history or to present these peoples as people any longer or who once lived lives. It's really just a kind of an object.
Speaker 1She's kind of defined them and what.
Speaker 2She's doing she does, but only if she can do it in acutey way.
Speaker 3Right, I would just.
Speaker 4Say this, I would be dead, so it wouldn't matter. But if she came in to change my bedpan or like help me in a nursing home and was that perky, I would lose my mind.
Speaker 2Just go away, leave me to my misery.
Speaker 3Yeah, I'm old. I can't take your level of happiness stop it.
Speaker 5I do think that the point with this should be, you know, no matter what you're doing, whether it's grave cleaning or rubbing, that you should be honoring these people.
Speaker 1And Matt and I have had a lot of.
Speaker 5Experiences dealing with various ghost hunting groups and going on cemetery tours that where they really do show some terrible disrespect.
Speaker 3You helped me.
Speaker 4Let me do your story just a second, give me just you gave me the perfect words. I've been trying to wrap my words around my feelings and I couldn't get there. It's performative and disingenuous. That's the vibe she gives me. Nicely said, yeah, you just helped me get those words wrapped around my feelings. So now I have that, you can go back. So I do want to hear your story.
Speaker 5I think that really reflects our feelings too from watching some of her videos. But yeah, some of these dodgy cemetery practices that Matt and I have seen. We went on a ghost tour of a cemetery in Manitou Springs.
Speaker 1It's kind of what near Colorado Springs.
Speaker 4But Yes, and managecent Rings did a dwarf pop out of a lady's back and attack Tony Curtis with lasers.
Speaker 5And again that's another episode, I think. But Matt, do you want to tell the story of how we came across this group?
Speaker 2I really want to do a dotes on nine two. Anyway we should. Yeah. So, yes, we heard that this group was going to be doing these tours and we decided, well, let's sign up and go.
Speaker 5Well, you were actually contacted by some of the members of the board, yes, of.
Speaker 2The board, the cemetery board, yes, and they were concerned about what was going on, you know, while this group was doing this, because nobody from the cemetery was there at the time to really monitor them, and they were a little concerned. So they did let us know about it. So we went down there, and you know, we're allowed to come along. Of course, the people given the tour did not know who we were, which is always fun to be under cover. So we had to pay yes,
Speaker 2well actually actually we didn't. We had tickets, but we didn't have to pay because they the Cemetery Board, took care of that. But we uh got down there. Karen's wearing flip flops and everything, and The first thing they let us know is about all the rattlesnakes that we could come across in the cemetery. So she is like, why the f am I here?
Speaker 5Yeah, and we had to sign disclaimers to to say if we got bitten that we wouldn't.
Speaker 1Sue them anything or die going downhill from here.
Speaker 3I thought you would just fill at home, not with rattlesnakes.
Speaker 4In Australia, we keep the rattlesnakes and check with our spiders.
Speaker 2It was a brown snake or something to be fine'd.
Speaker 1Be best friends. But rattlesnakes.
Speaker 3They're so noisy.
Speaker 1But we we were warned about that.
Speaker 5And I mean there was absolutely no history on this tour whatsoever. It was just all ghost stories and the people people were recordings.
Speaker 2Yes, yes, there was a lot of the typical ghost hunting shenanigans going on. But they would come up to a headstone that had a name that sounded maybe the least bit ethnic, and they would say, oh, she was a witch.
Speaker 1You know, and yes I forgot that.
Speaker 2Yeah, get some kind of crappy thing there. And then you know, in between all this is there's there's no restrooms on the tours, so we just asked that you don't urinate on the graves.
Speaker 7Mmmm.
Speaker 2Okay, well yeah, that's pretty cool.
Speaker 5But yeah, we heard about people who were stealing as souvenirs trinkets that were left on graves, so things like little toys or flags or just moments too's other things and turning them around selling them on eBay e'ss that kind of thing.
Speaker 1There's been quite a big market for that sort of thing for haunted supposed haunted objects. A lot of TV.
Speaker 5Shows that we've discussed in the past where they do that kind of thing. So, yeah, there was they were allowing a lot of things to go on there that were doesn't matter what your religious beliefs are, we're extremely disrespectful and criminal.
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 4Well we talked about that on the stole Kansas grave where or the cemetery where they think there's the folklore has it there's a gateway to Hell there and people will go there there is no gate and they get disappointed.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's Kansas. Are saying that there's some truth to it.
Speaker 4What Kansas is No, No, kan It was a lovely town. It did leave me feeling a little flat, but I mean it was a lovely town.
Speaker 3But no, they had it. They they were because of the folklore, really have trouble speaking. Because of the folklore.
Speaker 4People were going there expecting Satan to appear on Halloween night. He never appeared, but they would get mad and they would break tombstones and steal tombstones and all this stuff. It was like it was a real It was an absolute nightmare because the town still had people who that was their relatives and these vandals.
Speaker 3Were you know, it's heartbreaking.
Speaker 4It's also economically challenging because those are very expensive. Uh and you know you don't put it in your budget. Don't forget to replace Grandpa's headstone when the looters come every Halloween.
Speaker 5So yeah, but with this group anyway, there was a happy ending in that we had them banned wow from doing further to us. Sir, Yes, there we go at.
Speaker 3That was cool.
Speaker 2But you know, I have to say that, you know, just visiting cemeteries is you know, in all of the trips we take, we always liked to visit the local cemetery and just you know, cemeteries are just incredibly beautiful and it's such a connection with history that it gives you, it.
Speaker 4Gives it gives you that interesting sort of snapshot. I mean it's not perfect, but it gives you a nice snapshot of how long have these people been here?
Speaker 5You know, absolutely, and you might have some recipes as well.
Speaker 4Well, do you have a recipe in mind, Karen, because I want to put that in the show notes if you do.
Speaker 1Yeah, the cookies one.
Speaker 5Yeah, I'll find that and send it.
Speaker 4Well, this has been I mean, it has been an interesting topic. I mean, I normally we come down on this is real, this fate, but this is more of a question of taste, I guess, ethics, and I'd be interested to get some you know, thoughts from the listeners because we don't usually have these sort of thought provoking episodes where.
Speaker 3What do you think? But here we are what do you think? I'm really curious, you know.
Speaker 2Most of the episodes are just cracked.
Speaker 3No, this one is great.
Speaker 4I was on it.
Speaker 3So a lot of.
Speaker 4Times we're just trying to save people time, you know. You know, if you want to know the defendive answer, we may not know, but we'll sure do a good job of trying to dig it up.
Speaker 1Yeah I got that one.
Speaker 5But yeah, I think we've talked a lot in the past about visiting cemeteries and how they used to be more like parks and people would go to have picnics and that was the norm. So I think people still do things like that, and like Matt and myself, we like to visit these places. And it doesn't matter again, what your religious persuasion is or not. I think that you do need to respect the living and their memories of these people.
Speaker 4All Right, I guess that's probably enough on this topic, don't you think I think we got I think we got this one covered pretty well.
Speaker 1Yeah, I think so. Yeah, let's bury it.
Speaker 4Yeah, all right, Well we've left our mark and we'll move on.
Speaker 3Okay, Monster, you've been listening to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner.
Speaker 4You just heard a discussion with Blake and Karen and Matt Baxter about the ethics and best practices around cemetery maintenance and grave rubbing. I found it to be an interesting topic, an interesting discussion, interesting chat.
Speaker 3But maybe you'd like to chime in yourself. We'd love to hear your thoughts.
Speaker 4I'm sure there will be discussions on Patreon and Facebook as well as on our Discord server, and I look forward to hearing what our Monster talkers think about this. You're listening to the commercial supported version of this show, so I'm going to quickly plug some of the stuff that Karen and I have been working on. Don't forget Karen's latest book titled Bitch The Journey of a Word. It's out in bookstores right now. It's more than an etymology. And Joe nichols book The Science of Monsters, which was the first book produced by Monster House Publishing, that's out in bookstores or on Amazon. And the early bird sale
Speaker 4for the Skeptoid Cruise the Bermuter Triangle, which I will be a guest talker on. That sale is over, but there are still a few cabine remainings, so check the show notes if you want to join us on that.
Speaker 3That'll be fun.
Speaker 4Monster talk theme music is by Peach Stealing Monkeys.
Speaker 3Oh, good grief. Another update to my editing software?
Speaker 4Well what if I don't want to update us?
Speaker 5M hmm.
Speaker 1This has been a Monster House presentation
Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...
Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...
Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...
🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...
Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...