Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

MonsterTalk

MonsterTalk artwork

S03E43 - Ancient Werewolves

Jul 22, 202452 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Werewolves are an ancient idea, but the meaning and beliefs around the concept have changed over time. How were they viewed in the classical world and even earlier? Find out in this week's episode as we interview Dr. Tanika Koosmen. Dr. Koosmen's thesis at Newcastle online archive The werewolf story in Satyricon Some movies mentioned: Van Helsing (2004) Deep Rising (1998) Interesting terms: Versipellis - In Roman mythology and literature, a "versipellis" is literally a "skin changer" and referred to someone who could change their skin or shape, similar to a shapeshifter. The term is derived from "versus" (changed) and "pellis" (skin). Episode art by Team Smith (my kids worked together on this one) Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1You're listening to an airwave media podcast. Monster House Presents.

Speaker 2Monster Talk is proud to be a part of the airwave media family, home of such shows as Fork in the Road, Small Things Often, and Therapist Uncensored. If you'd like to advertise on the show, contact sales at advertisedcast dot com. I'm going to read a little excerpt from The Satiricon by Petronius. Now, this story dates from the end of the first century, but I think you'll find

Speaker 2it pretty familiar to the modern ear a man named Trimalchio, who was a freed slave who'd made a big success of himself. He's hosting a party and most of the guests are other freed slaves. Tremalchio complains that Necros, who's normally quite entertaining, as being too quiet, and so Necros tells a strange story.

Speaker 3Now he thinks the other guests.

Speaker 2That the party are going to laugh, but he swears the story's true and that it took place years ago when he was still in a state of servitude. It seems that he had fallen in love with the wife of an innkeeper, and her name was Melissa of Tarentum. Fortune had it that her husband died, and Necroes decides that he needs to rush to her aside while he has the best chance to beat out any other suitors. But then things turned quite odd. I seized my opportunity and persuaded a guest in our house to come with me as far as the fifth Milestone. He was a

Speaker 2soldier and as brave as hell, so we tried it off about cock Crow. The moon shone like high noon. We got amongst the tombstones, and my man went aside to look at the epitaphs, and I sat down with my heart full of song, and began to count the graves. Then when I looked around at my friend, he had stripped himself and put all his clothes by the roadside. My heart was in my mouth, but I stood like a dead man. He made a ring of water around his clothes and suddenly turned into a wolf. But please

Speaker 2do not think I'm joking. I would not lie about this for any fortune in the world. But as I was saying, after he had turned into a wolf, he began to howl, and he ran off into the woods. At first I hardly knew where I was, and then I went to take up his clothes, but they had all turned to stone.

Speaker 3No one could be nearer dead with the terror than I was.

Speaker 2But I drew my sword and went slaying shadows all the way until I came to my love's house. I went in like a corpse and nearly gave up the ghost. The sweat ran down my legs, My eyes were dull. I could hardly be revived. My dear Melissa was surprised at my being out so late, and said, if you had come earlier, you might have at least helped us. A wolf got into the house and worried all our sheep and let their blood like a butcher.

Speaker 3But he did not make fools of us.

Speaker 2Even though he got off or our slave made a hole in his neck with a spear. When I heard this, I could not keep my eyes shut any longer. But at breakup day I rushed back to my master Gaius's house like a defrauded publican. And when I came to the place where the clothes had been turned to stone, I found nothing but a pool of blood. But when I reached home, my soldier was lying in bed like an ox, with a doctor looking after his neck. I realized that he was a werewolf. And I could never sit down to a meal with him afterwards, not if

Speaker 2you had killed me first. Other people may think what they like about this, but may all your guardian angels punish me if I am lying.

Speaker 1It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before.

Speaker 4A giant, hairy creature part apes part mass in Luckness, a twenty four a mile long bottomless lake in the Highlands of Scotland. It's a creature known as the luck Ness Monster.

Speaker 1Monster tal.

Speaker 2Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner. This week we're talking with doctor Tanika Kuzman about ancient werewolves. I try to spread my monster love across the entire monster spectrum, but werewolves definitely rank among my most favored monster topics. So I was excited to dig in on a bit of deep history of stories about people being transformed into wolves. Ancient history is fragmentary because we don't have a contiguous body of texts going back into deep antiquity. For most

Speaker 2of human history, oral transmission was how stories were kept alive, and while spoken stories are very entertaining, they are as ephemerals.

Speaker 3Moths fart.

Speaker 2So studying the scattered fragments of human history and finding stories about werewolves and then trying to figure out not just what they say, but where they existed in the cultural framework of their historical context is a challenge, but it's the sort of challenge that can really turn on the mind of.

Speaker 3An obsessed researcher.

Speaker 2Says an obsessed researcher. I'll put links to Tanika's work in the show notes, so be sure and check those out. And at one point we do talk briefly about the idea of wild or feral children, and it turns out that this topic will be coming up on another Monster House podcast, the in research of show that I do with Jeb Kard. As we alluded to in this episode, the romantic idea of children raised by animals seems to hide a much darker story that's less about altruistic wildlife and more about parents unable to deal with kids with

Speaker 2challenges and impairments. We may dig into that further, but I can attest that the folklore is far more fun than the reality. But this is an episode about werewolves, and it is packed full of fun information. So let's dive in monstrutal.

Speaker 3Okay.

Speaker 2This week on Monster Talk, we're welcoming doctor Tanika Kuzman is all right. Doctor Kusman's academic research specializes in the development of the man to wolf metamorphic tradition in the Greco Roman corpus and its impact on modern werewolf fiction. Her research delves into the symbolic meanings behind transformation, examining how evolving concepts of human and nonhuman influenced the depiction of werewolves and folklore fiction and history. Her research interests span folklore studies, posthumanism, and changing perspectives on the body

Speaker 2in the modern world, and she's currently a casual academic at the University of Newcastle in Australia.

Speaker 3So welcome to Monster Talk.

Speaker 1Welcome, Thank you so much for having me on. This is going to be fantastic.

Speaker 5So, Tanika, we should probably start with how you got interested in werewolves? And I have to say I'm very jealous of your PhD topic. What a fantastic subject to to devote a PhD too. So how did you get interested in were wolves enough to tackle them academically?

Speaker 1Oh goodness, Well, I took a fantastic course as an undergraduate student at the same institution that I'm currently working at even and it we sort of talked a little bit through some of these sort of changing myths and myths of transformation and how the body adapts and adjusts in all of these like ancient Greek and a few Latin mythological structures as well. So I ended up getting very obsessed with this ancient text called of its Metamorphoses,

Speaker 1which is so many different episodes of transformation. And I was writing my honors thesis after my undergraduate degree was finished on of its Metamorphoses and the amount of sort of different ways that women in particular were being utilized as all of these different sort of warning stories and all of these stories about power. But I got so invested in this one episode, the tyrant king la Chaeon,

Speaker 1who is the very first transformation of a human being in the entire minimal foces, right after all the cosmological stuff about the creation of the universe, and I wanted to know so badly why why it was a werewolf transformation that was the very first human being being transformed in this entire book about all of this historical and mythological material, and I just got so obsessed with this one story. It really expanded from there. I wanted to see how this specific type of transformation was being used

Speaker 1in all these different kind of genres of writing, and that was where the obsession truly started.

Speaker 5I can imagine that happening. There's just so much material there. But I've always had a question. Maybe I'm jumping the gun too much with this, but was the king transformed into a where wolf obviously transformed into a wolf?

Speaker 1Oh, this is my favorite question. The difference is all down to this idea of So in theory and in sort of philosophical inquiry, we talk about something called the human animal binary and the difference between humans and animals and how those boundaries are really drawn. And a lot of the time in the ancient material you find that this binary is being developed, so it doesn't have a lot of strict boundaries just yet. So the way we approach a lot of transformation material, especially coming from a

Speaker 1contemporary error where we have all of these really cool werewolf stories that have a tendency to show the werewolf in much the same as that sort of there's a human being and then there's a monster. It's two parts of the same whole, but a lot of the time, it's kind of dichotomy sort of thing. It's a binary there's two pieces, but when you get to the ancient material, when you travel all the way back, there not a lot of that binary thinking. So for like Chaon in particular, in a couple of his different literary appearances, they talk

Speaker 1about the fact that like Chaon's transformation came because he was already a wolf, if not in form, then in function and in action. So of its in particular, it's such a beautiful, such a beautiful myth to put together, but it talks a little bit right at the end afterwards that he's still got his sort of human mind within him, because that was always the monstrous part of him,

Speaker 1that was always the animalistic part of him, was that he was the wolf. Because they never really have creatures or people or gods or any sort of beings in these ancient mythological structures that have different forms as opposed to their mind sort of thing. So while he might have transformed into a wolf, it is like a big, hulking, proper monstrous kind of wolf that they describe. It is a where wolf in the sense I think that we take from the contemporary from the modern era where he

Speaker 1really is that sort of figure.

Speaker 5Okay, I see, So now that I've leapt forward, could we possibly backtrack and could I ask you to summarize the myth because some of our listeners might not be familiar with it.

Speaker 1Yeah, absolutely so, also to Ovid's version of events, because they can be just a little bit varied in between ancient sources. Especially. So the king like Chon is one of the first human beings, one of the really early Arcadian human settlements in this sort of mythological structure, and he is a king who has many, many sons and this big old family. And when Jupiter or Zeus comes

Speaker 1down from the heavens and wants to test human kind and see if they're kind of beings that can inherit this sort of this kind of worship of the gods, if they're good people and if they deserve to sort of inherit the earth this way, he comes down and he sends signs to the people, these sort of omens and little like divine sightings and stuff like that. And he's in his disguise as an old man, and he

Speaker 1wanders into this kingdom and all the people start to pray and worship for Jupiter to be walking among them, and like Chaeon, gets maybe a little too big for his breeches and tells everybody, no, there can't possibly be a god walking among us. I know best, I am your king. And he decides that instead of providing offerings and being pious in the way that the gods expect of their kings, He's going to test the God in disguise.

Speaker 1And so what he does is he violates quite a few of the the laws of Xenia, so the laws of hospitality that Jupiter is in charge of, and instead of offering the God in disguise at a feast, he slaughters a hostage, a protected person's and cooks the corpse and offers that for the feast for this God in disguise, and very very unhappy about this, he decides this is the trigger point for Ovid's version of events, especially this

Speaker 1is the point in which he decides that humanity cannot be saved and they must be rebuilt and recreated. So Avid raises the kingdom to the ground, he kills all of like Chayon's suns, and he transforms, like Chaon, into this huge, hulking monstrous is punishment for not knowing and for not following the rules that he should have followed.

Speaker 3Does he get redemption later?

Speaker 1It would have been nice, I think, to bring him back in the story. But like Yon's story especially is one of those really special things that weaves in and out of a lot of different ancient texts, so's he comes up quite often. There's a few constellation myths that concern him because one of his children was supposedly the nymph Callisto, who is transformed in there later on, so she has a whole different mythic cycle, but she she has links back to like Chaon as the daughter of like Chaon sort of thing, and Plato in particular, So

Speaker 1he writes political philosophical texts, all this fun sort of stuff, and Plato is one of the earliest references to literary references, at least to the like Chaon myth cycle. And he actually mentions like Chaon in this teeny tiny little paragraph on tyrants and tyrant leaders, and he doesn't even mention him by name. He just says the tyrant will they will consume their people, like the mythical the King of Arcadia did to his people. So there's all these tiny

Speaker 1little references and to that for that, to a classic scholar or someone who's familiar with ancient history, means that there was this huge oral tradition where people knew exactly what Plato was talking about just by that one little line, and we might not have it recorded in its sort of ancient form the way that they knew the story, and we have to piece it together from all these little bits and pieces from the literature later on.

Speaker 3Gotcha.

Speaker 2So there's no official canon of the classics, I guess. So the reason I found your work was because I'm I'm obviously obsessed with were wolves, as listeners will know.

Speaker 3But we talk about all kinds of monsters.

Speaker 2But I really have spent a lot of time really doing a lot of research on this topic. And I came across an article that you had published on The Conversation about the ancient history of werewolves, and I thought, Oh, here's someone working from the oldest stories forward and I'm working for modern stuff backwards. This is really great. We can kind of meet and somehow still exclude the middle. But I thought maybe we could walk through some of the history of werewolves. So I would like to ask you about what is the oldest werewolf story we've got

Speaker 2preserved in text or imagery that you've you've come across so far.

Speaker 1So it can be a little difficult for us as classicist and knowing full well that there's material that didn't necessarily survive all the way to the modern day. There's a really cool reference all the way back in the Epic of Gilgamesh, the little story of that Gilgamesh tells in response to the goddess Ishtar and her apparent proposition to Gilgamesh. One of my favorite parts of that text is the fact that the things that Ishta offers to

Speaker 1Gilgamesh are actually a sort of reflection of their funerary rites. So Gilgamesh's re rejection of the goddess is on the basis of the fact that she's told him all these lovely things will happen to you, and he said, oh, wait a second, that's what we do when people die. So are you going to You're going to kill me? And he goes, okay, how am I going to get out of this? And he starts listing all of the things that she's done to her lovers in the past, and one of those is that poor shepherd who worshiped the goddess so well, and she still transformed him into a wolf to be chased around by his hunting dogs.

Speaker 1Such a delightful little little reference, and it's definitely the earliest one that we have for wolf specific transformation.

Speaker 2I'd say it's the for Gamma Thrones list readers, it's the Ramsey Bolton Finish, right.

Speaker 1They do adapt it quite well.

Speaker 5And do we see versions of this story in other cultures at all? Or is this a completely unique tale?

Speaker 1This one in particular seems to me to be fairly unique, part because it's such a small like a small reference to it does sort of almost have echoes and a couple of later stories that talk about the There's one specific narrative written by I believe it is Petronius in the first century AD, in the satiricin which is actually it's a book on satire. It's quite literally a satirical story. But he has this great little folkloric story about a

Speaker 1man who walks through a cemetery with a soldier and is terrified when the soldier starts tearing his clothes off and transforms a wolf under And this might be one of the first instances where we see the connection to the full moon is because as the moon is as it is on high noon. So this little tiny one, this little tiny story that doesn't get repeated anywhere else. It's this sort of folkloric, more personal or domestic kind

Speaker 1of story. And that were wolf in particular is discovered because he hunts after a pack of sheep and the locals stab him in the neck as the wolf, and that wound is transferred to him when he transforms back into a human, and they discover that man is the were wolf because he has a wound on his neck, just as to the right it is.

Speaker 2That is such a classic motif of all the werewolf floor and a lot of the witchlore that comes up in medieval times. Yeah yeah, yep, no, absolutely. Now we lost gilgrimesh for thousands of years, but the idea of a werewolf didn't die out. So where does it pop up next?

Speaker 3Is is it Greek? I guess next? And then rollman or how does that flow?

Speaker 1So definitely Greek first and foremost. The really interesting part about were wolves I think in Greek culture, ancient Greek culture specifically, is that that edge of animality, that animal sort of in heritance that the were wolf has means that it's so often associated with monstrous races that exist outside of the Greek borders. So in particular in the Greek literary history. One of the next ones we have is from Herodotus in the histories, and this is Herodotus

Speaker 1is sometimes called the father of history. He sits down and he says, I'm going to write about historical events, and then manages to include a whole bunch of mythical material as well. But he's the first one to do it, so it's a little practice involved in taking it all out. But Herodotus's story concerns tribe of people called the Nurians who exist in the sort of Black Sea region that they're absolutely really convinced has got a whole host of monstrous races that exist beyond these borders. And the Nurians

Speaker 1in particular are men who transform into a wolf for a couple of days out of the year. And this teeny tiny little refference to these sort of nomadic people that exist to the north is couched in all of these really cool descriptions of all of these monstrous races that occur, these people that might have human flesh included in all of their feasts or who have like strange customs and weird rituals and stuff like that, and it does it might signify to us as sort of further

Speaker 1connection into Baltic mythology and like sort of that huge Siberian region that had wolves to contend with as actual predators. So the likelihood of folding that into their folkloric beliefs and sort of religious structures is so much higher when they have that interaction in person with the wolves.

Speaker 5So we get where wolves in both Roman and Greek mythology. But did both cultures look at where wolves the same way or did they have different beliefs or was there a lot of crossover between the the two mythologies.

Speaker 1There is a bit of crossover. I think fundamentally. The Roman mythological structure does inherit quite a bit from the Greeks, and a lot of those attitudes tend to get sort of mixed in together. It's interesting to see when we do have the instances where these sort of little stories that might be more concerning to say Greek culture that had more interaction with people and those monstrous races like the Scythians. And then when that specific myth might be

Speaker 1adapted into a Roman text. It's interesting to see the way that that interaction might change or might stay the same for us, and a lot of the times it does stay the same, which is an interesting thing. Given Rome's own association with wolves. It's a whole different angle on it. Like they're founding narratives, they're founding.

Speaker 3Volved what was the founding myth?

Speaker 1So Rome's founding myth is centered around the brothers Romulus and Remus and their birth story specifically, so is so held under prophecies. The prophecy is that these these children will will not be not be kind to the line of inheritance specific to their I believe it's their grandfather. So the birth of the children who are apparently they are born to Rhea Sylvia, I might be mispronouncing that

Speaker 1it's been a while since I've gone back.

Speaker 3Over my room and founding there she won't mine.

Speaker 1Let's cross our fingers. Yes, So she is put into a cult for protection, effectively, so the vessel virgins. She is introduced to this specific worship practice in order to keep her away from men, so she can't have children ever, and they can't usurp their grandfather and prophecy solved, but as as it goes, that never really solves anything in the ancient stories and mars or areas, if we're going

Speaker 1with the Greek name comes down from the heavens and still manages to impregnate Ria Silvia with the children that inevitably fulfill the prophecy, but they are sort of they are still in danger for it, so they're abandoned by a river and rescued by a she wolf who feeds them and nourishes them and make sure that they still survive to adulthood in order to fulfill the promises. And there's lots of nonsense that happens in between. And the founding of Rome is so inherently there's such a big

Speaker 1mythic cycle, so much information involved in it. But when Romulus murders's brother Remus and establishes establishes Rome, they still carry that wolf, that wolf imagery. It's so inherent in their image going forward. So it's surprising for especially academics that look through these sort of history of images and the way that the this iconography is adopted. It's so interesting to see the Romans repeating folklore that might insist

Speaker 1that the wolf, the were wolf is this sort of like monstrous creature or their animal law. Sometimes it's an inherently like foreign connection these people who are not Roman or who are not Greek and sort of see that involved in a culture that is so obsessed with the wolf imagery beyond the specific transformation context.

Speaker 2So narratively, I mean, I think it's pretty easy to hop into the idea of these are stories about people turning into wolves, but why or how they turn into wolves, whether it's on purpose, which seems to be really common by the Middle Ages, or whether it's as a curse, which was in the source material that seems to get changed. So like ultimately you come out in the twentieth century with the were wolf is a is the primary narrative,

Speaker 2but they also i guess in the twentieth century and also a lot of people want to turn it to being a superhero because they look at all the advantages where wolves have over humans and they're like, oh, this is awesome. But it's also kind of like Jacqueline Hide or The Hulk, where most of the stories you become a ravenous beast and don't have control. I'm curious in the ancient world were their story. Did you run into any stories where the.

Speaker 3People intentionally became wolves?

Speaker 2I mean, obviously the metamorphosis when sounds like it might be that's the case, but it's a little unclear it is.

Speaker 1There's a really cool tradition that sort of almost spans from the like Hayon story. So the region that he was a king in in Arcadia is sort of treated in a lot of mythological sources and historical ones as the original place in which the Greeks were this sort of almost like indigenous area of Greece, the oldest sort of kingdoms come from. And I think because of that, and because of that link, there was this really cool cult dedicated to Zeus, like Chaos so Wolf Zeus effectively

Speaker 1in this region where they believed Zeus was birthed in these caves and sort of grown up in these caves, and there there was a really extensive cult that had all these really cool practices, the Arcadian Cult, and they in particular developed these sort of rituals and stories about where wolf transformation for the members of this group. It's spoken about in a couple of different sources, and a few have some different details to provide and sometimes conflicting details, which is the way, but a lot of the sources

Speaker 1tell us that the ritual as it proceeded, was a young boy, usually an adolescent boy, was chosen by lot from all of the families that were involved in this this worship in this cult, and he would be taken to a lake where he would shed his clothes and swim across the lake and then transform into a wolf that he would have to live as a wolf for anywhere between I think it's seven and ten years. They don't give us specific numbers or corresponding numbers at least,

Speaker 1and he would so go and live his life as this wolf, and then when he was done with his initiation, right, he would come back to the lake and he would swim back across the lake, and he would pick up the clothes that he had hung on a tree and they would still be there, and he would transform back into a human being, but with the age that he's spent as a wolf. The years he spent added to his age and to his appearance, and that was the big initiation right for this specific passage passage cult. Rather, so this was I think one of the only instances

Speaker 1that we can sort of point to in antiquity in which this is an active choice to be made by the person who was transforming ah Neat.

Speaker 5It seems to me, I don't know how much you know about medieval history and mythology, but it seems like that story is played out a lot by the Middle Ages are in kind of French stories and English stories about were wolves. That seems to be a similar kind of story.

Speaker 2It does feel like those elements get carried forward absolutely.

Speaker 5But I wanted to ask you, I don't know if you'd know this, but from all of your research, do you get a feel for how the average person felt about were wolves in these times? In ancient Greece, in ancient Rome, how did they feel about were wolves?

Speaker 1Actually? Yeah, it's there's a couple of different threads that come together, and I think it really speaks to how many different genres of writing are included. These are including these sorts of myths and folk tales and stuff like that. Is that we almost want to see a sort of like more domestic narrative coming through. In a lot of the later texts, especially, they talk about this specific term and it's used as an invective, and I'm probably going to mispronounce this. I think it is syphilis. It's certainly

Speaker 1how I was how I have been pronouncing it. Goodness knows. The Australia.

Speaker 3What does it mean?

Speaker 1It means skin changer. And the fantastic thing about this is it's associated with a couple of different werewolf figures and talked about in in reference to or in relation to werewolf transformations. But a lot of what of the time, A lot of a lot of the time it's being used as an invective to sort of mean like two faced or someone to not be trusted because they change their skin. And it's so connected to this mythology that it would make us think that this implication that someone is a werewolf or someone transforms into a were wolf

Speaker 1means that they're not to be trusted. And that's something we did get from. So Pomponius Mela's rather Petronius is Satirican that did that was a part of the story. Right at the end, he has a little line that says, I knew now that this soldier was a werewolf, and I could never sit down to a meal with him again ever, because he was evil and he's it's this intrinsic belief that these people are terrible people because the transformation indicates that's what they are.

Speaker 5Have the god Janis who Janus is just thinking that, Yeah, but.

Speaker 2It's funny because Janis is like he's two face, but he's also the god of entrances and like, so I don't think he's universally negative, but the whole Janus two face, yeah, two face, now for sure he's So did you did your research take you into any sort of post Roman Empire era?

Speaker 1Yeah? Absolutely so I I did, Uh, for some reason, I thought it would be a very interesting thing to go through a whole bunch of French philosophy, because everybody knows how easy French philosophy.

Speaker 3Dozens of people have followed that path.

Speaker 4So.

Speaker 6At least, yeah, sure, absolutely, And I sort of found my way to a bunch of contemporary where wolf stories and adaptations and sort of stuff like that.

Speaker 1And what I was finding in part, I think because I skipped over a lot of this medieval era material on were wolves because I knew how connected it ended up being to that witchcraft and like witch trials and all of that sort of stuff, and it ended up sort of not necessarily corrupting, but maybe changing the narrative quite a bit, and it's not what I really wanted to focus on. So I jumped all the way into the modern era, and I was finding all of these examples of were wolf stories that almost mimicked the context

Speaker 1or the themes of the stuff I was reading in the ancient world, and it was the coolest thing to be able to go through and just I mean, I was a huge fan of This might be a bit embarrassing, but I love it so much, the Hugh Jackman Van Helsing movie.

Speaker 3It is a fun ride.

Speaker 2But you're the first person I think I've talked to who's also liked it so yeah.

Speaker 1So much. It's so awful and it's so beautiful, and I think I can appreciate it so much.

Speaker 3I love their patchwork man too.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, absolutely, they're sort of Frankenstein character too.

Speaker 3A lot of fun.

Speaker 1You just throw so many different creatures and monsters right in there, with no concern about the fact that those are completely different historical Ay ye exactly.

Speaker 3It's just that put it in the blender and see what it tastes like.

Speaker 1Here's Dracula just for fun, and it's so good. But the web of transformation in that film. It's actually one of the things that convinced me to go on this big right because in that in that specific narrative, the we wolf tears the skin of the human often reveals the wolf underneath. Yes, really, it's a really cool I mean, for its time, it's such a fantastic cgi example. Yes, Yes, it was such a cool thing for me to see

Speaker 1growing up, especially like all of this sort of monster obsession that I had as a child and to see it sort of depicted that way, and it started me on this really interesting journey through some contemporary examples to try and see all the ways that we've shown the werewolf transforming in a really physical sense. And Van Helsing did it so well, that tearing of the skin off and they're crawling up the walls, and all I could think was, is there, does that mean that they have

Speaker 1a limited life cycle? Is there a certain number of moments that they get to tear that skin off and eventually it'll run out and they don't transform anymore. And I wanted to know more about the structure around something like that, because that sort of like infinite movement, the back and forth and the implication that there's no two sides to the creature. There's no two sides to the werewolf. It is one whole thing that is like full and complete within itself was something that I just I really

Speaker 1wanted to delve into because it felt so so much more true to the ancient material than anything I'd sort of seen before, and that led me right through. So I talked about the MTV adaptation of teen Wolf, the TV series Wow, which is fantastic, fantastic example of how morality gets folded into the werewolf narrative so often.

Speaker 3I never watched that because I got old, but.

Speaker 1It is delightful. It's such a cool, almost close bracket to the ancient stories of like chaon the way that they sort of manipulate morality and authority and their idea of the true alpha, which is the alpha that can that can take power without needing to kill for it. It was such a cool, almost like superhero version of events that still referenced all the way back to the like Hay mythology that they sort of used as their

Speaker 1inaritance in the TV series. They talked about it.

Speaker 2See you mentioned the Van Helsing movie. I would like to mention for our listeners as a fan. Steven Sommers was the director, and you would probably know him from The Mummy, the n eighty nine Mummy with Brendan Fraser, but he also did a movie called Deep Rising, and if you like creature features, that one's really good.

Speaker 3I'd say it's a treat.

Speaker 2But since the hero is treat William's rest in Peace, that's too much of a puny even for me.

Speaker 5Well, and also talking about that movie, talking about the tearing off of the skin is kind of making me think of the Inquisition and the werewolf Trials. So, Tanika have you has your research taken you into the were wolf Trials? I know that's a leap away from ancient Rome and Sumerians.

Speaker 1But so in a very sort of tangential way. I did so. As I mean, as a part of a PhD. One of the big things you do is a big literature review and you go through in your mind all of the little places where your sort of background information may lie. And I did a little bit of work in and around medieval uses of ancient texts to provide a sort of sense of authority to the sort of

Speaker 1developing narratives, especially around the literature that was being published as a part of witch trials and this huge sort of call to identify creatures and identify witches especially, so there isn't a huge reference, but there is one small one in the big main witch hunting manual, the Malleus Malafakaram, which is white texts, those big ones that sort of kick off quite a lot of the events that do occur,

Speaker 1and there is one small one, but it's sort of filtered through a couple of different religious like early religious Christian texts, so it doesn't necessarily follow. But there are a whole lot of especially sixteenth century demonological texts. There's a couple written by There's one Reginald Scott writes one the Discovery of Witchcraft. I think it is the title for that one. And I want to say there's a king that writes a specific demonological texts as well.

Speaker 3Yeah, it's King James, right.

Speaker 1I think that's the one. So when I was going through and doing my literature review, I think it's in Reginald Scott's text where there's this really cool line that sort of draws back to the epic poets, to the Homeric texts, all the way back some of the earliest sort of literary examples that we have, and one in particular was that people could turn into were wolves or could be transformed into were wolves because the witch Circe who trapped Odysseus on his island, on her island rather

Speaker 1had all of these animals around her and could transform pil into animals, and that was there, that was their sort of authority of transformation and how that sort of functions. So the ancient texts really did have a lot of influence on the way that people would believe, people would sort of create these medieval texts and these understanding of how it happened. The witch trials themselves, I know, are very very focused, I think, on the connection between witchcraft

Speaker 1and Satanism, which is a whole different area of inquiry, and how sort of like how witchcraft practices and some of them inherited from the ancient Greek and Roman cultures, tended to interact with sort of introducing and sort of really strong Christian and Catholic developing sort of doctrines, and the were wolves that get caught up in that have a tendency to either be demonized by way of their connection to magic, which is something that happens quite often,

Speaker 1or even potentially on the other side of that, saved by the fact that a lot of this was really really very invested in women and femininity, so the fact that they were masculine figures can sometimes sort of shift that identification or accusation of witchcraft from them. So there are occasions in which there's a couple of accusations of where wolves in particular, that did end in those sort of trials. It didn't happen very often, and it is

Speaker 1sort of once it does happen, it's only a very short period of time in which the trials are occurring and then they completely stop. And it does have quite a few interactions with the area of inquiry concerned with feral children as well, So the kids that sort of get caught up in or running away I guess from parents from growing up in these wilderness contexts and stuff like that and trying to be reintegrated into society.

Speaker 2Yeah, raised by wolves Malgli kind of storyline, right, Yeah, absolutely.

Speaker 1So there's a surprising amount of cross there for the witchcraft trials and the were wolf trials.

Speaker 3That's really it.

Speaker 2I will probably dive deeper into that topic soon, because it's anytime I run into it something where I have a role hole in my knowledge, my first impulse is to find fill it with lots of information.

Speaker 5So children, feral children, well, oh.

Speaker 2I met the Werewolf trials versus the Witch Trials, but also well, yeah, yeah, yeah, the feral children thing I'm very interested in, largely because it seems like much like we did some work on change links in fairy lore, and it turns out that there's a pretty strong case to be made that a lot of the changeling stories are about autistic children or people going through dementia, so it's like a sort of a supernatural way to deal with real world problems or to explain them. And I'm

Speaker 2curious about the Werewolf Trials versus the Witch Trials because in my head, I see those as a masculine versus feminine thing, and I'm not sure that's really true. So I need to find out, you know, I need to.

Speaker 3Actually go back to the source material. But we have one more serious.

Speaker 2Question before we get to our fun closer, and that is this is kind of a broad survey question, but in your research, it seems like some of these stories have a really strong moral component, but some of them seem more like accidents of fate. So did you find a lot of moral content in the mythology in the ancient world around these these cases or these these examples.

Speaker 1There was definitely a good amount of connection there between the were wolf stories that I was studying and that sort of moral, ethical kind of edge I ended up for my dissertation specifically, I sort of separated the ancient material into four different streams of sort of thematic inheritance that we like inevitably find and it made it a lot easier to connect to the ancient to the contemporary as well. So I talked about the developing humanist traditions

Speaker 1race and species, and then morality, and also individualism and multiplicity, and then magic and technology, and so those were my four sort of areas of inquiry in the way that I sort of drove the research and could discuss the ancient texts specifically. And the moral one especially was absolutely such an embedded part of the ancient material that it was sort of drawn into those other examples. But it

Speaker 1really did come through with Ovid in particular that like Hayon story, is so inherently connected to this sort of moral obligation and the moral responsibility of a leader to their people. That that was the contexts that we were seeing like Hayon come up in again and again. And the best part about that in particular was that I got to connect it all the way down to Stephen King and the where Wolf, the way wolves he has in his particular brand of fiction, which is so often

Speaker 1a really moral journey. There's this this implication that by way of I don't want to quote Spider Man, but it's almost Spider Man. It's the with great power comes great responsibility, and it seems to be that's the that's the inheritance of the moral story from the werewolf stories of of ancient recent Rome. It's this real, this really insistence that with that sort of power and with that sort of like physical end and in a sort of

Speaker 1metaphorical sense as a leader, that there needs to be more responsibility or it turns you into this like monstrous creature.

Speaker 3Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 2The story of like Ian reminds me a little bit of King Saul and David, you know, where he sort of he turns into a beast, but it describes him as being more of a herbivore, so it's not quite the same, but yeah, that's that's really interesting.

Speaker 1There's an interesting comparison made in a couple of ancient texts, king like Chaon to the first king of Athens, and I do not know how to pronounce his name. I'm not going to try, I butcher it properly. But this, this this Athenian king was the one that helped his people and fed his people and stuff like that. And the comparison that's made is while while this Athenian king was taking that responsibility, like Chaon brought the body, the body of a child to the altar for worship and sacrificed the child sort of thing. So it's a really

Speaker 1common theme, this idea that you're not protecting the people who are under your protection. It's really really deep ebedded well.

Speaker 2In so many ancient stories. The rules of hospitality being violated just bring down the God's wrath upon those who do it. And it's it's really interesting because you know, if it was it was a really tough.

Speaker 3Time to survive.

Speaker 2You know, there wasn't a safety that and it's like if you didn't give people hospitality or support them, yeah, moral condemnation from your peers is one thing, but it's like, it's so satisfying to know that the gods will smite you if you don't.

Speaker 3That's way better, right.

Speaker 5Well, Tanika, it's just been fantastic to chat with you, and yeah, I've really really enjoyed this conversation. But we've got one final question that we like to ask our first time guests, and that is what's your favorite monster?

Speaker 1My favorite monster? Oh, it would be so easy for me to say were wolves in this instance, very very easy for me to say it, but I have to be honest. A lot of the work that I've done around monstrosity and humanity and the connection between those two means that there's one person, one figure in particular that sort of is my absolute all time favorite creature. And her name is a Rick though she's actually a Roman witch, a fictional Roman witch that comes up in an epic

Speaker 1called Fossalia written by Lucan and it's sort of this fictional retelling of the historical era of civil war in Rome between Caesar and Pompey. And she is this absolutely horrifying creature, this witch figure who prowls battlefields and collects pieces of corpses to perform her magic so she can see the future. And she's so incredibly terrifying that when she speaks, the gods give her whatever she wants because

Speaker 1they're so scared of her. Wow, And she's delightfully powerful and so horrifying that she's my absolute all time favorite. She's just so cool.

Speaker 3That's neat. We've a new one for me, exactly, definitely.

Speaker 2But I love that because you know, that's the sort of dichotomy and we've talked about so many times on the show. There's there's the Witch as a human who does magic, which is I guess more of the modern conception. There's the Witch who's clearly some kind of a creature slash monster, you know, the Baba yagas, you know, these sort of creatures, and that that.

Speaker 3Is so blurred throughout folklore and history.

Speaker 2And I just it's fascinating. I can't stop thinking about it. And you know that's why.

Speaker 3We do this show. So there you go.

Speaker 2Absolutely, thank you so much for taking the time to talk with us today.

Speaker 5Thank you. It was really cool.

Speaker 1I'm here. This has been fantastic. I love a good chance to ramble about my area of expertise, and it's so exciting that I get to it gets to be my area of experctise.

Speaker 3Yes, it is.

Speaker 2Anybody absolutely if you managed to get a degree in doing doing so with monsters is the basis, you're definitely winning in my mind. So if if people want to read your work, what's the best way to find it?

Speaker 1Oh so, a good old Google search is usually the best way. I have a couple of publications coming out, but good I'm not too good at timelines in terms of stuff like that. But my work, in particular my thesis can be found on just on the web. The University of Newcastle, Australia has a good online repository that has my digital copy of my thesis there too, for anybody willing to breathe the madness.

Speaker 5And will be people.

Speaker 2Well, I'll see if I can get a link straight to it or real close to it, and I'll put a link to your article at the conversation as well. Those were great monster You've been listening to Monster Doc, the science show about monsters.

Speaker 1I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner.

Speaker 2You just heard an interview with doctor Tanika Kusman discussing her research into the history of ancient werewolves. You can find links to her research and to the books and movies that we mentioned by checking the show notes that accompany this episode. And remember you can always search up past episodes easily over at MonsterTalk dot org, where there's a full archive of all our content. We hope you've enjoyed this episode of Monster Talk. Each episode we strive to bring you the very best in monster related content, with a focus on bringing scientific skepticism into the conversation.

Speaker 2If you enjoy Monster Talk, we now have a variety of ways to support the show, all with convenient links at MonsterTalk dot org forwarge slash support. That's monster talk dot org forwarge Slash support. We have links there to our Patreon page as well as a donation button. Another great way to support the show is to buy books from our Amazon Monster Talk wish List, which directly helps us with our research. We love used books very much, so don't feel compelled to buy new ones, and we love kindles so we can share our digital libraries with

Speaker 2each other. And finally, without spending any money at all, you can support us by leaving a positive review at iTunes or wherever you get your podcasts. Positive reviews help keep us visible in iTunes, which is a great way to help. Let's find you listeners, and please share our show on your favorite social media platforms. Monster Talks theme music is by Pete Stealing Monkeys and you can trust us to be your companion when you have to walk past the cemetery to get to your lover's house. We

Speaker 2may not shut up the whole time, but we definitely will not turn into wolves.

Speaker 1This has been a Monster House presentation

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S06E07 Elizabeth Taylor and the Burton of Truth

    Nov 16, 202655 minAudio

    Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S06E06 🐈⬛Evil Cats and Revelatory Revenants👻

    Nov 9, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S06E05🎃 Live 2026 Halloween Show

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S06E04 🍿Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈 Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S06E03 🎥 Capturing Bigfoot 🫈with Marq Evans

    Oct 19, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...

    Credit the people on this episode