It's Hollow Earth, UFOs, the birth of Sci-Fi, and more wierdshit than you can believe as we present a super-cut of our 2-part interview with Jerry Drake and Jeb Card about one of the foundational stories of "weirdshitology" in a new ginormous single episode. And there's a little bit of reading if you want to follow us down the rabbit hole... EXTENSIVE show notes freely viewable at Patreon. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey, they're Monster Talkers.
Speaker 2Before I get into anything, I just wanted to say thank you for all of the outporting and supportive emails and Patreon signups that we've been having.
Speaker 1I haven't found a new job yet, and I don't want to.
Speaker 2Turn these intros into the Blake Job Update podcast, but I do want to say we saw a twenty one percent growth in our support on Patreon and that is so helpful, and on behalf of Karen and myself, we really really appreciate the new backers immensely. Please, if you want to support the show's Patreon dot org forward slash monster talk and we would love to have you can even join at the free level and it gets you access to the discussions on these episodes and lots of bonus material.
Speaker 1And then I mentioned that while Karen and Matt were in England, Matt got laid off too. Hey, wow, twenty twenty five is so hard on us.
Speaker 2I kind of see it being used as an insult or a threat in the future. Hey, Jeric, I hope you get twenty twenty five. Oh man, I'm sorry, mister. I don't know what got into me no, but he deserves that.
Speaker 3Like that.
Speaker 2You know what, I'm still able to find tremendous satisfaction in doing.
Speaker 1Historical research on monsters, and I'm.
Speaker 2Enjoying Lucy, the library kitten, who's the newest addition to the Munschtalk family.
Speaker 1We adopted her just a few.
Speaker 2Days before I got laid off, but you know what, She's been an absolute delight and so feeling that cat shaped hole in my heart that the other two cats we have have failed to feel for more than a decade. And I'm not going to brag, but the people who've been defending those two jerks for a decade have all had to admit that Lucy is a lot more interactive and affectionate or you know, she's like an actual pet instead of whatever those bozos are. Anyway, next week I will share my research on the van Meter monster with you. I'm really getting into the research zone on that one,
Speaker 2and I love sharing my process, so I hope you'll tune in for that. I was gonna do that for this week, but I could not stop researching long enough to write my script, which is a fun place to be for research, but not.
Speaker 1Conducive to getting an episode about the door.
Speaker 2So it's another flashback this week, but this one has a bit of a value add I've combined our two part coverage on the Shaver Mysteries, which is all about the Hollow Earth and the rise of flying saucer culture in the mid twentieth century, and it's also about the birth of science fiction. It's about Nazis, and it's about all sorts of weirdness that never disappeared from our culture so much as metastasized. This is a wild ride and it's all here in one giant episode for you. I've even combined all the show notes into one big brain drop.
Speaker 1So have fun.
Speaker 2Enjoy me and Jerry Drake and Jebcard as we dive into one of the most influential yet largely unknown narratives from the annals of weird Shitology Monstertal. Monster Talk is supported by listeners like you. Find out how you can contribute via Patreon or with reviews at monster talk dot org, forge slash support. Your contributions, large or small, make a huge difference.
Speaker 1Thanks.
Speaker 2In the twenty eleven book Idiot America, author Charles Pearce opens his story of the dumbification of American culture with the classic exemplar of wingnut ideas ignacious Donnelly, author of the eighteen eighty two book Atlantis The Antediluvian World. While it was Plato who gave us the legend of Atlantis, it was Donnelly who turned out the template for all modern variants of the Lost Continent. It was a strange idea, and apparently as enticing as it was wrong. Piers uses
Speaker 2a very specific word to describe Donnelly and his ideas.
Speaker 1He refers to both as crackpot.
Speaker 2Crackpot is said to come from the word cracked, which means faulty, and pot being used as a slang for a person's head.
Speaker 1But whether that's right or wrongheaded.
Speaker 2The more obvious metaphorical references to that of a ceramic pot with a crack in it. On first glance, it looks like a sound vessel, but it simply won't hold water. A crackpot idea won't hold water either, But that doesn't matter, because it turns out that even the most cracked crackpot idea can hold infinite quantities of belief. This is part one of a two part series on the Shaver mysteries. We're going to be talking about the Hollow Earth, ancient astronauts, Nazis, UFOs, comic books, science fiction, and much much more. Get ready
Speaker 2for a strange trip.
Speaker 3It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before. A giant, hairy creature.
Speaker 4Part ape, part mats in Luckness, a twenty four mile long bottomless lake in the highlands of Scotland. Get the creature known as the Luckness Monster.
Speaker 3Monster tal.
Speaker 1Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith.
Speaker 2You know I read our reviews on iTunes and I'm really happy that so many of you have enjoyed the show enough to take a moment to give us a very positive review. But I also take the criticisms to heart as well. One that we get occasionally and then I'm going to try to address in this two part episode is that when we deep dive into topics that I and my guests know well, we sometimes forget to contextualize all the name dropping during the interview. I try to augment the show notes with links that will fill in those gaps. But if you find that there's something we mentioned in this show that you don't recognize or we don't have a reference to, please shoot me an
Speaker 2email and I'll add it to the show notes. You can always contact me at Blake at MonsterTalk dot org. So in point, the topic of these next two episodes is the Shaver Mystery. What is the Shaver Mystery? Well, it's a complicated story, which is why this is such a long coverage. But the nutshell version is that in the nineteen forties, a man named Richard Shaver wrote about mysterious experiences he had in which he was receiving information from telepathic evil robots inside the earth. That's right, Shaver
Speaker 2believed that evil monsters lurked inside a hollow Earth and could influence the lives of us mere mortal surface dwellers. Now that may sound like science fiction, but I want to save the really fascinating twist and turns for our guests, which we'll come up during these discussions. As we've got two returning fan favorites, archaeologist and author of the book Spooky Archaeology, doctor Jeb Card and researcher doctor Jerry Drake, who previously joined us to discuss grimoires and the amazing Jack Parsons. You can find fascinating episodes featuring their wit
Speaker 2and wisdom in our archives MonsterTalk dot org. But before we dive into a story that deals so heavily with the topic of a hollow earth, I think it would be useful to do a really brief overview of the history of the theories around that topic. Now, we could start in a lot of places, For example, the writing of Athanasius Kircher, who's sixteen sixty five compendium Munda Subterraneus or The Subterranean World, had been inspired by his own trips inside Mount Vesuvius to see the roiling and boiling
Speaker 2gas emitted from the hellscape of a volcano. He wrote about giants and dragons and other legendary dwellers of caves, and many things that make me desperately want to read this huge and prodigious work. Even if the factual accuracy of his speculations are wildly wrong, the illustrations are amazing. To do a comprehensive history of the hollow Earth for this show would be impossible. There's far too many legends involving giant caverns, lost civilizations, holes in the polar regions, suns,
Speaker 2and a scis eye of an inverted globe.
Speaker 1It just goes on and on and that's just the nonfiction.
Speaker 2But let's skip quite a bit forward from ancient stories of holes that lead down into hades and other sorts of myths and legends, and instead we'll arbitrarily start our modern conceptions of the hollow Earth with someone we usually think of as a scientist, Sir Edmund Halley of Comet fame. Now it might seem odd for a person so firmly associated with the birth of science to postulate a hollow earth, but how he was trying to account for a recently discovered anomaly. The Earth appeared to have four magnetic poles
Speaker 2and they wandered around wildly, so how could this be.
Speaker 3To explain it, he.
Speaker 2Postulated that the multiple poles were from multiple spheres which were inside the Earth that moved in ways that accounted for the wandering, and also accounted for the Earth having four, when no magnets on the surface ever have but two. We now know that he he had left to a complicated conclusion to explain a phenomena was actually based on incomplete data. The poles do move, but we only have two of them. As wild as his idea was, there are actually layers within the Earth, just not the strange
Speaker 2sort of bull's eye of concentric circles you would see if his model of the world were correct. Now, I'm not a geologist, but thanks to some very clever science experiments, we now know the Earth's solid crust moves around on a sea of molten rock, and deep within that rock is a denser metallic core. The spinning of all this material generates to the magnetic field, which in turn protects us from harmful cosmic radiation and gives us the marvelous polar lights. Thanks to seismic readings during earthwake activity and an understanding of density, distance, speed, and many other basic physics,
Speaker 2researchers have used seismic data, almost like a sonogram, to infer much about the Earth. Among those discoveries, none of them confirmed a hollow Earth. It was just a notable starting point with his paper in sixteen ninety two. And these things don't just die once they've been published. They live on, they mutate. Even when the scientific world rejected or ignored much of Holly's writing about this, others republished it, including the Reverend Cotton Mather, who included it in the volume he composed on Christian Philosophy and others would come
Speaker 2up with their own ideas as speculations. In seventeen twenty one, a French adventure novel titled an Account of a Voyage from the North Pole to the South Pole via the Center of the Earth was published. I think the title is a fair summary for our purposes. A whirlpool carries a ship through the Earth from the North Pole to the South Pole, and many adventures are had. In seventeen forty one, The Journey of Neil's Clym to the World Underground was published by Ludwig Holberg, whose work appears to
Speaker 2have been heavily influenced by Halley's conceptions of spheres separated by empty spaces. In eighteen eighteen, five hundred copies of an Amazing Letter was sent out to papers, politicians, schools, and basically anybody the author thought might be influenced. And that author was John Cleves Sims, and he was not shy and stating, I declare the Earth is hollow and habitable within, containing a number of solid concentric circles, one within the other, and that it is open at the poles.
Speaker 2He went on to say in side it would be tropical and stocked with plants and animals and perhaps even a people. And all he asked was for one hundred brave companions, well equipped to venture from Siberia to the North Pole to have a look. We'll hear more about Sims in our interview, but spoiler alert, he did not make it to the Hollow Earth.
Speaker 1Are the polls?
Speaker 2Weirdly, nobody wanted to fund his speculative investigation, but he spent the rest of his life lecturing and lobbying for such a trip, and at least one of his sons took up the.
Speaker 1Cause after his father.
Speaker 2Sims claimed to have come up with his Hollow Earth concepts by himself, but it did have remarkable parallels to Halley's version. In eighteen twenty a novel came out called Simsonia Voyage of Discovery, about a trip to the southern opening of the Hollow Earth. The author, a man called Adam Seaborne, is speculated to have been Sims, using a pseudonym. Simms also petitioned Congress to organize an expedition.
Speaker 1But that went nowhere.
Speaker 2Still, it would not be the only time Congress was lobbied to fund such a trip. In eighteen twenty six, James McBride published a book called Sims Theory of Concentric Spheres, which argued in support of Sims theories. A man named Jeremiah Reynolds joined Sims in a touring lecture series, but the two men eventually went their separate ways, splitting into two Hollow Earth factions. Reynolds was a persuasive lecturer, and his work may have contributed to the support of the Great United States Exploring expedition of eighteen thirty eight to
Speaker 2map Antarctica's coast. In eighteen thirty three, Edgar Allan poe O published manuscript Found in a Bottle, which featured elements quite similar to Sims and Reynolds theories, as well as travel to Antarctica. In eighteen sixty four we get Jules Verne's beloved Journey to the Center of the Earth. A popular book, it describes a scientific expedition into a hollow Earth filled.
Speaker 1With strange life and adventure.
Speaker 2Eighteen sixty four is also the same year that a zoologist named Philip Sclater came up with a theory about a lost continent between India and Madagascar to explain why the animal life in both places are so similar. He concluded that there must have been a continent between them, which he called Limoria, after the famous Lemurs of Madagascar. We'll get back to Lemoria shortly. In eighteen sixty nine, a patent medicine and electrical and magnetism doctor I'm using scare quotes around doctor named cyrus Ted says that he
Speaker 2had an experience where he discovered the alchemist's Philosopher's Stone, and then he was visit by the goddess creator of the universe, who told him he should save the human race. He rebranded himself as Korreesh and founded a new religion called Korshianity, one of the beliefs of which is the earth is hollow and that we live inside the sphere of it. He would not be the last religious latter to change his name to Koresh and start a cult, nor the most famous. In eighteen eighty eight, Madame Helena
Speaker 2Bolovotsky published The Secret Doctrine, one of the foundational texts of Theosophy, a mystical thought movement whose influence we discussed frequently. She included Lemuria as a lost home of ancient masters with all sorts of strange and mystical powers. In nineteen o five, a book was posthumously published by an American named Frederick Oliver. The book was titled A Dweller on Two Planets. It told the story of an Atlantean who was reborn as a Civil War veteran and is later led into a secret world by a mystic master, a
Speaker 2subterranean world ridden under California's Mount Shasta and full of ancient fantastic technology from Atlantis. In the introduction, Oliver explains that he didn't write the book himself, rather, the content was channeled through him that will become important later in our timeline. In nineteen oh six, William Reid argued in his book Phantom of the Poles that at both polls there's actually a huge hole thousands of miles wide, instead of land or ice. He also thought that there are
Speaker 2no meteor rocks, but they're just rocks from inside the earth thrown out by volcanoes from these holes. In nineteen oh nine, two teams raced for the North Pole. One was led by Frederick Cook, the other by Robert Perry. It's hard to say if either team really made it precisely to the pole, or if they did, which one got there first, but neither observed one thousand mile wide hole, which would have been hard to miss. In nineteen thirteen, Marshall Gardner questioned whether Cook or Perry really got close
Speaker 2to the polls in his book A Journey to the Earth's Interior, or have the polls really been discovered. Gardner did encourage aerial exploration of the polls to investigate these large holes that he postulated. In nineteen fourteen, Edgar Rice Burroughs published At the Earth's Core, which became a series known as the Pellucidar books. His Hollow Earth has dinosaurs and adventure and ape men and Strange Peoples. In nineteen thirty one, Limoria, the Lost Continent of the Pacific was
Speaker 2published by Harvey Spencer Lewis using the anagrammic pseudonym Wishar Spinley Survey. He melded elements from Theosophy and the book A Dweller onto Planets and created an even more elaborate tale of an advanced Limorian technology under Mount Shasta. These ideas perhaps inevitably led to splinters of religious belief forming around them. One of the most famous was and still is, the the I Am movement, whose name recalls Ascended Masters,
Speaker 2as well as the Old Testament Bible tale of Moses and the Burning Bush. The Iam movement was started by Guy and Edna Ballard and dealt with many of the same ideas as presented in A Dweller Onto Planets and adds in the character of Saint Germain as the ascended Master who guides this tour into the Limorian subterranean wonderland under Mount Shasta. The nineteen thirty four book Unveiled Mysteries describes this tale. The similarities between the two books led
Speaker 2to a fascinating court case where the family of the late Oliver sued the Ballards for plagiarism, but ultimately they lost because Oliver had claimed he didn't write the book himself. Remember he claimed to have channeled it and to not be the author.
Speaker 1Whoops.
Speaker 2The Ballard's I Am movement still exists, though the movement had a good bit of drama themselves in the nineteen forties when the government revoked their tax free religious statf German World War I Air Force veteran Peter Bender picked up the Kureshian ideas of the Hollow Earth, and in the nineteen forties he worked with the Nazis to try to use this secret knowledge of their advantage.
Speaker 1Remember that Koresh thought we were.
Speaker 2Inside the spherical Earth, and all the evidence to the contrary is because of optical illusions. I wasn't able to find primary sources about the experiment that Bender and his team conducted, but a couple of versions seemed to agree that he traveled to the Black Sea with a team to build a device that would either look into the sky to detect enemy ships or to project something into the sky to confuse enemy radar. But whatever the actual plan was, it didn't work, and Hitler was apparently furious with the waste of resources, so Bender and much of
Speaker 2his team ended up in a concentration camp, where Bender apparently died in nineteen forty five.
Speaker 1We get to the.
Speaker 2Subject of our episodes, our two part discussion the collaborative writing of Richard Shaver, a mentally troubled artist in Welder, and Raymond A. Palmer, a science fiction magazine editor and science fiction writer. Together there are stories of a hollow Earth filled with evil robots and lost civilizations. Drove a massive social discussion. Now, if that sounds like a bunch of wacky history with no relevance to modern times, you'd be wrong.
Speaker 1Like I said at the.
Speaker 2Top, a crackpot idea may not hold water, but it can hold infinite amounts of belief, and the influence of Shaver's and Palmer's collaboration is still being felt today and will likely continue to be felt for decades.
Speaker 1A lot of links, including two issues.
Speaker 2Of Junior Skeptic around the topic of hollow Earth by Daniel Loxton that do a great job of a more detailed primer on this topic. We'll be linked in the show notes, plus many of the articles and books that we just discussed. So buckle up, We're going on a deep dive into the hollow Earth with our speed linking guides, doctors Jerry Drake and Jeb Carr. This is more obstrutal, so I'm going to try to put a little bit
Speaker 2of order to this, and we'll just get started by saying welcome to Jeb Card and Jerry Drake. Thank you very much for coming back to talk to us again on Monster Talk. Absolutely the reason I've asked you to come here tonight is to talk about a topic which is a little bit obscure. I think most people will not have heard of these people and this whole idea of the Shaver Mysteries. But I think as we start to dig in on it, you'll see that it is
Speaker 2a topic which is absolutely critical, foundational, even for a lot of what we think of is weirdology today.
Speaker 3I'll just study you straight out. As I found out on Twitter this weekend, apparently more people know the DC Comics character Ray Palmer than I was aware of.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah, that's so just I guess we should probably introduce these characters and talk about who we're talking about. So I wanted to talk about Richard Shaver, Richard Sharp Shaver, who is at least at least the co author, if not the author, of something that was known as the Shaver Mysteries, and we'll talk about what that is. But it kind of comes out of the hollow Earth, and it kind of comes out of possibly mental illness. But
Speaker 2it was brought to the public by a guy named Ray Palmer who was running a magazine called Amazing Stories and Amazing Stories. You may know from the Steven Spielberg inspired TV series. I guess he produced it, but it was a magazine back in I guess the late thirties up into well, it's actually still around now, but it's changed.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, yeah, but for the most part, really the thirties to the fifties. In any real recognizable, exactly important way.
Speaker 2It sort of parallels a lot of the sort of I guess weird tales as well, sort of the same kind of idea where it's still around, but is it really you know so well.
Speaker 3I we'll get into this, but I think they're actually there's an important distinction between you know, there's there's several big ones, but weird Weird Tales will get into why that's important, and then you have astounding and and then you get amazing stories. And those latter two are pioneers of what's now called science fiction, but they at the time the word was sort of scientifiction or or you know, various terms when fandom and science fiction were beginning to
Speaker 3emerge after the era of sort of the weird tale and weird tales, And we'll we'll talk more about that, because that's actually integral to understand.
Speaker 2Palmer, I think, so, I think this is absolutely true.
Speaker 5Yeah, it's an interesting time.
Speaker 6I mean, it's this post World War One era when sort of the world of science fiction that we knew it under guys like H. G. Wells and Jules Verne was morphing kind of merging in with the lovecrafty and weird tale and it was getting voice in these publications. And they were cheap reads. I mean they sold for ten cents quarter at that time period, and you know, people could sit down around the you know, put their feet up and read something that was more lurid than
Speaker 6what they were getting on the on the radio. I mean, don't forget most of this stuff as post Hayes code. So movies are not as interesting as and lurid as magazines like Amazing or True Detective or what people were able.
Speaker 5To buy, you know, down at the news rack.
Speaker 3Yeah, you can basically see this progression of them them starting as adventuring fantasy, romances and westerns and all that, then being sort of increasingly the dregs where all kinds of lurid stuff goes. Some of it's sexually lurids, some of it's just other lurid. And as we're going to see this bifurcates into one could argue, more proper science fiction and fantasy, which then becomes the world of the paperback and then these that basically go into the sweats
Speaker 3of the fifties and early sixties. Listeners probably know them best for the Frank Zeppa Weasels ripped my flesh comes from one of these stories of burly men fighting Nazi dominatrixes and wild animals or both or all the above, and then these end up just basically being the origins of like mass porn magazines.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 6I mean it's funny to watch because you know, my nineteen thirties issues of these magazines are very readable and you could give them the kids.
Speaker 5By the fifties it's pornography.
Speaker 6Yeah, and writers like you know, more serious writers Block and people like that who got started in these pulps move on to paperbacks and novels and then later television of course.
Speaker 3So the thing for kids is that comic books also emerge. Yeah, they also take a chunk.
Speaker 6Of those comic books become less dirty, which is what's funny, Like post the comic books become less dirty and lurid.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, well there's a whole nother story there with the seduction of the innocent and right easy comics and yeah, so yeah.
Speaker 3Well I think they're getting that from these roots, though.
Speaker 2I mean absolutely, yeah, yeah, I.
Speaker 6Guess to set the stage, we're at a time when when Lovecraft has died, and you know, the these magazines are being dominated by a weird, kind of transitionary kind of writer that will turn into the modern science fiction writer of the fifties, sixties, and seventies. And so Richard Sharp Shaver comes on the stage at a time when people are looking for content.
Speaker 5I mean, to borrow.
Speaker 6A phrase from the Internet, they're looking for stuff to publish that will sell magazines.
Speaker 3And there's one more piece. Many of these people are not so much Shaver, but many of these people are very young. Many of the people that are not only so the thing that becomes fandom, the thing that becomes comics, it becomes the fandom that supports all of this in the nineteen thirties, a lot of it coming from people like the Lovecraft circle, like Robert Block, for example, are teenagers, and there are some that are older, but a lot
Speaker 3of them, not only fans, are teenagers. They get jobs out of it. And we're going to see that with Ray Palmer, where these basically these kids. So the fact that this sounds a hell of a lot like the Internet and creepypasta. There's multiple reasons. One, it's where everything that's not allowed in polite society goes and it's run by basically man children.
Speaker 6Well, don't forget when Shaver shows up. It's nineteen forty three. The US has been in World War two for a couple of minds, so it's a time for escapism. People who are too young to go to the war are reading these things, versus people who are too old to go to the wars are kind of publishing and trying to monetize them. So it's a really weird time in American literature where people just want to think about something that's not the Second World War.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's true, but it's probably worth mentioning that this whole field of scientif fiction comes from a guy named Hugo Gernsback, and we get the Hugo Award from him. But he to me, when I was reading about this and the birth of fandom, it felt almost like he was sort of a Fagan character because he was relying so much on these young kids to kind of pull the stories together, and he was doing a lot of reprints of HG. Wells that sort of thing.
Speaker 3Well, if that sounds a lot like early comics too, all the exploitation of the creators of all these characters that are now billion dollar industries.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think that's true, and I think Gernsmack wanted to professionalize it, and he wanted it to be a new kind of thing. He wanted this science fiction to inspire mostly boys, I guess, to be science people, to promote science and technology.
Speaker 3But well, I want to name drop something that I think we've all pulled from here. An excellent book by Fred Natis the man from Mars Ray Palmer's Amazing Pulp Journey, which is a biography of Palmer, but a lot of it's also about Shaver. And the reason I want to name drop that right now is I think this also might help as a sort of a statement. Is where we're going, he argues, and he pulls us from someone else. I'm not going to pull up the flipnote that you have three basic characters, each of which is sort of
Speaker 3striving in a different direction. You have Hugo Gernsback, who helps create scientifiction and literally wants to teach physics with it. Like he literally wants to teach science and astronomy and have like the core of the story be a science thing, and let's have some characters to sort of sell it to the youth. Like that is how he sees it. And it's the it's the bright future. You've got your John Campbell, who we will probably talk about more, who
Speaker 3is kind of in the mold of the self made man and adventure and daring do but still science. And I want to bring in kind of literature, and he wants to make it legitimate literature. And then the third strain is Palmer, and as we're going to see, he basically wants to mix this world with an already existing world of occultism, theosophy, weird ideas, weird tales, all of that.
Speaker 3And these are the three kind of forces straining here.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think that's well said.
Speaker 1Uh.
Speaker 2And I think that although Campbell doesn't come up a lot in The Man from Mars, uh, his role in establishing science fiction yeah, to be what it is. It is kind of hard to overstate. Isaac Asimov basically divides the world of science fiction into before and after Campbell, Like the coming of Campbell was like the single event. So though he.
Speaker 3Has his own weird aspects that we might get too, and indeed we might we might clear that up.
Speaker 2And I feel like, well, I want to talk about Shaver. I mean, this is an episode about Shaver. It does matter, I think to talk a little bit about Palmer. Uh.
Speaker 3And I don't think you can divorce them.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, I think no.
Speaker 3I mean there are a lot of ways.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 6So they're in terms of the product that is the Shaver mysteries, they're they're one person. I mean, you have Janitor Shaver who was probably mentally quite mentally ill, not probably was, versus a guy who had quite an imagination. But one thing that I want to do to set the stage a little further is that if these stories had not hit the mark, we wouldn't remember them, they wouldn't have been successful.
Speaker 5What we're really talking about are sort.
Speaker 6Of these what becomes a kind of hollow Earth conspiracy. And in nineteen forty three, when this shows up, the concept of the hollow Earth is super relevant and valid.
Speaker 5At that time. You know, the Nazis have built a.
Speaker 6Lot of their sort of social religion around the concept of rill and the idea of these earth energies. Hitler had this idea that there could well Hitler and his people, that you that the Earth might be on the inside, that us the people might be on the inside of the earth. And so he sent expeditions across the Atlantic to try to see if he could see the British positions by looking out across the sky and all this weird stuff.
Speaker 3Do we want to do a very very very like one sentence each short trajectory of the hollow Earth, because because you just dropped rill, so I think you should ideas ideas of the hollow worth that you can find them, or ideas of a world inside the world. You can go back at least to the late Middle Ages. You can hear this idea in various places, but it usually gets associated, at least from the tellings I've heard, with the sort of the Enlightenment period, and particularly Edmund Halley.
Speaker 5Yeah, ally is the first querson to scientificize it.
Speaker 3If you want to see it, to argue that there's there's weird magnetic fields and other things that can be explained by there being multiple shells of earth inside, and there's various versions and then a sort of local here around here. John Clive Symes or John Cleeve Simes, a hero of the War of eighteen twelve in southwest Ohio here not the war part where he settled, where his father settled, also from the Revolutionary War. He was obsessed with this idea of Halley's and tried to convince in
Speaker 3the early in eighteen eighteen the American government to fund an expedition through a hole in the poll to what he called in a novel Simsonia to get inside and basically, hey, we're already conquering a continent. We're in the continent conquering business. Let's go do this. And he sent out circular one to everyone in Congress, everyone he could think of, which included a statement that he wasn't crazy. It was always a good start. And while this didn't really catch on, it did actually help inspire the first major scientific expedition
Speaker 3of the United States federal government into the South Atlantic, which actually helped create the Smithsonian in terms of part of its collections. And there is a monument in Hamilton, Ohio, about twenty miles from here, where he is buried, and on top of it is a concrete will. It was concrete, but stone hollow earth the next big one. And Jerry, I suspect you probably know this better than I do would be Edward Bulwer Lytton.
Speaker 6And he writes a book called The Coming of the Future Race, which is interesting in its parallels to the as we'll talk about to the the original title of Shaver's uh first manuscript, which was called a Letter of Future Man. Yeah, I'm actually I'm actually holding a copy of Sims's circular.
Speaker 5Here in my hand.
Speaker 2Oh, if you could scan it, we could put it in the show notes.
Speaker 6Yeah, I'll do a scan of some of the stuff.
Speaker 2It does have. I mean that that is one of my favorite bits of American marketing, uh, with the you know, if if you'll pay, but I will happily go to the poll and explore.
Speaker 6It's out for not a It's just like that's how David ply This makes all his money. I'm not really looking for Bigfoot, but if you pay me, yeah, I'll go on for Bigfoot. Yeah. Buller Lytton writes a work of fiction which deals with this idea of earth energies called Vrill, which is that's another whole mythology that we don't want to get into, but the sort of wielded by frog descended humanoids from the Earth.
Speaker 3By the way, you all know Bulger lit the employs.
Speaker 5By the way, in mythology, they.
Speaker 3Kind of do, they kind of dot into it.
Speaker 5They become the reptoids later on.
Speaker 2They yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 3He's the it was a dark and stormy night guy.
Speaker 5He is.
Speaker 6He's the guy who wrote the novel with the But the thing to remember about about Buler Litton is this is a work of fiction, and it is a work of fiction that hits home so strongly with a subset of Vulcan ranch Germans, people who kind of believed in land and blood and all that great late eighteen eighties stuff.
Speaker 3And also theostists, I mean, Blevati praises.
Speaker 6It, and they decided just to believe it. They just take it it's true.
Speaker 3And either like it's supposedly fiction, but it clearly isn't because he's so tuned into everything we already know. So we're going to see this happen again in the twentieth century where he writes a novel and you have a major part and you know, theospice are not obscure. They're a major part of the Western occult tradition, and they're like, yes, this is all actually a thing.
Speaker 6Yeah, that's and that's kind of scary. In itself. But that's also sort of what happens with the Shaver mysteries, is that people start to believe it even though it was never actually meant to be true, because it fits so well into this tradition of the hollow Earth, underground societies and all that stuff. One thing I did want to bring up before we get too deep into it, you know, I think I've got to copy this thing lean here too.
Speaker 5Remember the Mound that HP Lovecraft.
Speaker 6Miz Elliot Bishop the Ghost wrote for Zelia Bishop. I think it's like twenty nine to thirty, but a version of it comes out in nineteen forty and Weird Tales, which of course is White Ray Palmer's.
Speaker 3Yeah, oh no, I strongly suspect. So we'll get to what Shaver talks about. I think I think one other just we should mention for completeness. So there's not I think a huge amount of relevance. Abraham Merritt's The moon Pool, which was a big influence on Lovecraft and I think sort of helped bridge the gap between the Coming Race and the Mound and Shaver. But no, it is hard to read the Mound and not imagine that it's an influence on Shaver as far as.
Speaker 6I can tell, the earliest American version of these sort of underground kingdoms being real.
Speaker 5Comes from a guy named G.
Speaker 6Warren Schulfeldt who was arguing that he had found a This is in nineteen thirty four.
Speaker 5It shows up in the Los Angeles Times.
Speaker 6He argues, Oh, yeah, underground city, you know, outside of LA right, inhabited by a bunch of lizard people.
Speaker 3Well, people that worship the lizard totem, that's correct, like Native Americans.
Speaker 6And it gets sort of they were, and there actually was some sights there, and allegedly the Smithsonian conspiracy came in and they took all the bones, et et cetera, just the.
Speaker 5Way they take.
Speaker 6I do as they do, as they do.
Speaker 3So before we go further into Shaver, I would I would argue that we need to. So we mentioned the mound basically for the listeners. Zelia Bishop is living out in Oklahoma, wants to have a story about a ghost indigenous woman and a headless dude ghosts okay, yeah, and a mound. And Lovecraft runs with this and writes this huge story about uh super underground in human quasi human
Speaker 3civilizations and here's the point. They are super scientists. They can basically control anything, including biology. They can phase through things, they can create like limbless zombies and all of that. And they derive their only pleasure because their society has gotten to the end of where societies go from sadistic entertainments.
Speaker 6Thedistic torture and entertainment. Yeah, the city is called Kenyon, and the mound is a real place. It's in a place called Binger, Oklahoma. I've actually been there. I grew up near Dallas, and of course, as soon as I got a car, i had to go see the only piece of Lovecraft country in my part of the country. And it's a weird place. I think it's a woodbine outleer. For the geologists in the audience, there's those. Those are pretty common in the area of Oklahoma and North Texas that were not fully scourged by the by the glaciation, and it is weird looking. So it does look a
Speaker 6lot of people thought for a long time that it was man made and some kind of a pyramid. So Zelia had something to work with. I think it's called Dead Woman Mound, and the story that she came up with is basically local local folklore. But what Lovecraft rights, I'm sure is not what she no.
Speaker 3I think literally he gets she gave him like one sentence.
Speaker 6It's like one sentence if I remember the day Book, right, it's like one sentence.
Speaker 2Yeah, he expanded quite a bit then, Yeah, it's I think.
Speaker 3I think it's the longest of his ghost writings. And while it's really important, it is also really friggin hard to read. Though I'll say this, I'd still rather read it than I remember Lemuria.
Speaker 2So just I want to make sure we mentioned it. I we went through a litany of Hollow Earth and this sort of thing. Did we mention Egar, Rice Burros and Pollucidar?
Speaker 3No, we did not.
Speaker 2I think we should because go ahead. In addition to Merit, Shaver was a big fan of Eggarrice Bro's Pollucidar stories, which are yet another hollow war story, as is a Journey to the Center of the Earth by HG.
Speaker 3Wells, which also has evil reptile people. So with I think psychic powers, hypnotic.
Speaker 2Yeah, animal hit says I remember correctly, it's it's like glamouring.
Speaker 5Yeah, and correct me.
Speaker 6If I'm wrong.
Speaker 3They get there with a drill, but the evil lizard people on under the ground. They control like I think ape men that are called sagoths, which is awful interesting. Yeah, they use hypnotic powers to create a slave. Yeah, I've never heard of it.
Speaker 6Well, I think if you want to talk about Wells and Vern's influence on Shaver, we'll drop one more, and that's the time machine, which has the Morlocks and the Eloi, and that breaks down. I mean, we're gonna mention it later pretty pretty cleanly into the concept of the Tarots and the Darrow's are Tarot and Darrow. So I mean, I guess the question is you know somebody was reading. I guess the way to set the stage is to say that in nineteen forty three, when Richard Shaver writes this letter a Note the Future Man to Ray Palmer,
Speaker 6the idea of a hollow earth full of alien races is not only in the pop culture, it's actually taken quite seriously by people.
Speaker 5So it arrives.
Speaker 6Shaver arrives at the right time for for what he has to offer to be accepted by the populace.
Speaker 3He does.
Speaker 2Although his initial writing would be what would you call that? The slush pile are the kook Puppet, the crank file, it's.
Speaker 3It's the Green Letter Brigade.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's it's.
Speaker 6Uh.
Speaker 2His initial submission is not a narrative. It's not a story.
Speaker 3Okay, so let's we want to talk about where he gets it from.
Speaker 2Well, let's talk about Yeah, let's mention what it is, and then we can talk about where you can get him.
Speaker 3Yeah, all right, well, I mean, yeah, he sends in, according to Palmer, sends to amazing stories, which at this point while Palmer, when he takes it over, starts to lean it less from and now you will learn astronomy to basically pulp daring do basically what we would know today as space opera like Star Wars. Basically he turns it more or to Star Wars if you want to use that as a as a shorthand. It's science fiction, it's fantasy, it's it's the movies, it's comic books, like,
Speaker 3that's what it is. This guy Shaver's like, by the way, here's ten thousand words. I have deciphered a ancient language that's part of evil robot monsters under the ground. And also all of this is real, So you.
Speaker 6Know who is Shaver? He's born in nineteen oh seven in Burrowick, Pen, which is actually not far from where I'm at right now.
Speaker 5It's right outside Wilkes Barre. In fact, we rove through there.
Speaker 3Okay, that's where the area I grew up just above, just north of the border.
Speaker 6Gotcha. Yeah, I'm sitting here in York, PA tonight, so it's not to NPA's high Strangeness area anyway. But what's interesting about the guy is he does a lot of wacky stuff, like he's in the John Reid Club and he kind of bums around for a long time. He later tells people that he was living as a hobo at a time when he was actually in I believe the Ipsilanti State Mental hospitals. Yeah, he's got a serious history of mental illness, but he does manage to get married. He's clearly a voracious reader, and that the gist of
Speaker 6this letter that he writes to Palmer is about his deciphering. Decipherment of this letter that he calls mantong, which sounds suspiciously to me like mantong. Basically, what he's decided is that every letter of the alphabet, and by this he means the English alphabet, not some er.
Speaker 5You know, proto Indo European alphabet has.
Speaker 6A symbolic meaning of like.
Speaker 5A.
Speaker 6I don't want to say. But what he's actually saying is that like the letter A represents a concept, the letter B represents a concept.
Speaker 3Well, the natis gives one. He gives the example of ape. Apes have animal power energy.
Speaker 6Yes, animal power energy. And in the case of the darrow, which are the evil robots, that's detrimental energy robot. Yeah, and the good guys are integrated robots, because in his language, the word integration is the best thing you can be. And for some reason to me this sounds completely idiotic. But for some reason, this is what god Ray Palmer going. Was this linguistic concept that he thought was definite proof that the legend of Atlantis was true.
Speaker 3I'm not so surprised by that. So the thing this immediately reminds me of is the work of Brassier di Borborg.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 3It is an important is an important Mayanist, an important student of Maya anthropology history. He is works in archives, he writes fiction. In the middle of the nineteenth century, he finds parts of an actual Maya book, a Maya codex. He also finds more finds a elements of the Popol Vu, which is this incredibly important piece of literature. All the others had also found it. But the thing that he's most known for, and that is the most important, is
Speaker 3that he finds in the middle of the nineteenth century a copy of Verlas Angeles closest to Yucatan. Basically, colonial Spanish culture was incredibly litigious. It was assumed that people in office would be corrupt, so when you left office, you had to provide a defense of yourself, and the Archbishop of Yucatan, Diego de Landa, had done this in the late sixteen hundreds. As to what did he do, he described the place he worked, Yukaton and the Maya people, and this is where we get a lot of information
Speaker 3about early information about Maya kalndricks and numerals. The most important page is he gets this Maya noble to help him translate Maya writing Maya hieroglyphs uh, and he asks the guy please write ade please, because he's like, write a sentence in your language. And he writes matingati, I don't want to. I don't want to and he then writes letras and it's a and B and C and dysh.
Speaker 3It's a and bay and say and day and a et cetera in Spanish, and that's important. Landa writes this, Delando writes this down. It is basically lost. Rosser Diborborg finds it in the middle of the nineteenth century, and unfortunately, in addition to being a good archivist, Brassard Borborg was obsessed with Atlantis conspiracy theories and other ideas of weird shitology. So he finds this thing and he doesn't interpret it the way it eventually is interpreted. We eventually realize the
Speaker 3work of your e Canora is off in the nineteen fifties that when Diego DeLanda says, damn Mace, give me the letter for h the guy writes ah and chay. He writes out two syllables, and canaras offf eventually figures it out, and that way goes the Miyad acidpherment, and that's a whole other story. DeLanda or excuse mean not Dalanda. Bros Barborg takes this at face value oh eight, initially backwards. Then he starts making translations, but he they're completely insane.
Speaker 3Right on top of that, he believes that each one of these letters has a super secret meaning in symbolism that ties it back to the destruction of Atlantis, because of course it does.
Speaker 4Uh.
Speaker 3And on top of that, he thinks he finds the name of Atlantis moo. Right, He basically create establishes the word moo being associated with lost sunken continence. He inspires his stuff is found in the work of ignatious Donnelly, who basically creates the modern content of Atlantis, with Atlantis the anti Liluvian world. It inspires the Lon Jean's and Yucatan and many others.
Speaker 6Well, Jeb was talking. I brought up that chapter and he's dead right, Like, there's a whole chapter here where Donnelly lays out how the Mayan alphabet is basically a history of it is a subtext history of Atlantis.
Speaker 5I'll scan you some of those pages because it is sweet and we.
Speaker 3Don't want to go too far down this road. You've actually talked about it before, but not so much that. But that word move continues to get associated with ideas of sunken continents, including symbolic writing in the nineteen twenties found on the Moostones dug up by William Nivin. I happen to have four of them in the lab and interpreted by Colonel I'm doing a lot of air quoting. You can't see James Church word. All of this is
Speaker 3part of the sort of theosophy and Theosophy adjacent occult world, which also produces the Ohaspi Bible, which Ray Palmer was a huge promoter of.
Speaker 6Right, So, I guess the question is who's who's the person who out of the maybe hundreds of.
Speaker 5Thousands, if not millions.
Speaker 6Of words that got written about the Shaver mysteries, who's the person that knew all that stuff?
Speaker 5Was it Shaver or was it Palmer? Or was it some of each?
Speaker 3I think some of each, but a lot of it's Palmer, I think, Yeah, I think so, I think Palmer.
Speaker 6Well.
Speaker 2I think the original manuscript is what ten thousand words, and yeah, Palmer bumped it up to yeah, thirty thousand. So but while we're talking about linguistic scholars, this this whole thing about extending the meaning by looking at each letter and applying symbolism to that. And another famous, uh sort of linguistic scholar who has done that very successfully is Gary Busey.
Speaker 3Right, Okay, So I'm I'm pretty proud about knowing not knowing what the you're talking about. Really, I mean, I know there's a motorcycle accident at some point.
Speaker 2Gary before before the motorcycle accident was a very intimidating actor, h and he played a lot of heavies. Uh. And after the accident he had I mean apparently, uh, some some brain damage. Where your helmets? People? Is the I think the message you where your helmets?
Speaker 3Uh?
Speaker 2But yeah, he he constantly does this thing where he will take a word and then he will take each letter of the word.
Speaker 3I had successfully forgotten that.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah, So it's the same kind of thing.
Speaker 4I have a hobby that's really wonderful because it helps me understand the meaning of one word with the sentence that reflects the words meaning and definition. These are called beer seisms. The word now in ow no other way, the word team, team together, everyone to change more.
Speaker 6Well. One of the things we should mention then, is where Shaver does get it from. So he's he's working a welding job one day. Man, this is a little vague, and we don't quite know what happens before that.
Speaker 3Before that, there's the whole thing with the demon.
Speaker 5Oh, go ahead, I'm not clear on that.
Speaker 3So yeah, So before that, his brother dies and he becomes obsessed with the idea that a demon is stalking him and his family. And I believe the demon's name is Max. I don't think it's the brother's name. I think it's the demon's name. I could be wrong about that. Like, so that's.
Speaker 6Already happened before about what you're about to say. So he's already got that going on and paranoid, yes, and his welding machine malfunctions, and he believes that it gives him the ability to hear the voices from his coworkers.
Speaker 3Yeah, you can hear what you're thinking exactly.
Speaker 6And then later on this power develops into his ability when he's laying in bed at night, to hear the voices of these darrows first and then these tarots later, and they essentially start to tell him this story about the Mantong language. And if we are shooting influencing rays into his brain, which is not an uncommon symptom of unchecked schizophrenia what they used to call paranoid schizophrenia. This
Speaker 6is something that actually is in my field a little bit, so I don't feel bad about being a doctor of cognitive behavioral studies. The influencing machine is a concept where people believe that they are being told something or given information from outside their body. And it was first documented in the late seventeen hundreds, but there have been a couple of famous people since then who have actually had the influencing machine talking to them in their lives. Famously,
Speaker 6who is the killer up in New York City?
Speaker 5His dog told.
Speaker 3Yeah, David.
Speaker 6So that's a classic example of the influence machinefluence.
Speaker 3The phrase you're using on the origin of the influencing machine and schizophrenia written by Victor tosk in nice dreaded nineteen and that that you.
Speaker 6Know, I mean, it's still a concept that we use in cognitive studies. The idea of the influence machine is a way of externalizing the internal voice and concrete to concretizing it, if you want to use that phrase. The question that we ask ourselves is, you know, was you know obviously if somebody were walking down the street today and said their welding gun was telling them, you know about these ancient races of people, we wouldn't think twice about wanting to have them medicated. But in the old days, you have to wonder is Padre Pio was he somebody
Speaker 6that was influenced by that Saint Francis. I always kind of wonder how much of our mythology is simply the result of really compelling voices in people's head. And I think Shaver is a great example of how people can get carried away. I mean, the guy, in a way was actually a victim more than a perpetrator of any kind of oh hoax.
Speaker 3I would absolutely agree with that. I don't know if you can say that Shaver was exploited, especially since once he starts working with Palmer he seems to at least get better in terms of his everyday life. Although we'll talk about the Rock books thing. But yeah, no, he's not. I don't know if exploits to write work, because maybe there's actually some kind of art therapy or something going on here. Palmer, on the other hand, I'm sure we
Speaker 3will talk about where this all goes. Yeah he yeah, he's not a victim of anything. Well, he's a victim of a truck. That's a different discussion.
Speaker 6So the book they eventually come up with, but it's novella length. It's over thirty thousand words. I mean, it's a chunky story. I reread it the other day and it about it about gave me a headache because I was trying to read it in the original format, which was not real smart.
Speaker 5It's it's called I remember Lemuria.
Speaker 6And you know, Lamuria is the fictional continent that was supposed to hypothesize to exist between Madagascar and India.
Speaker 3Initially starts as a scientific hypothesis but versapically gets picked up by Theosophists, specifically Blavatski in the eighteen sixties.
Speaker 6And this is another piece of concretization of something that's totally fictional or hypothetical. It has the name Lemuria because the guy who postulated the original idea didn't understand why the creatures of Madagascar were more similar to the creatures that were found living We're in the fossil record in India.
Speaker 3It's literally lemur Ea, lemur Ea, and it comes from Murs and the theosophists actually, and of course Palmer himself decided that that was the actual name of the place. Why not, Yeah, I mean, why not?
Speaker 6It was a good name. You could have called it Moo. You could have called it Atlantis or I believe that Tamil have in their mythology a sunken continent that the Theospis ofventually in the modern era sort of connected Lemurria with. But nope, they went straight with the basic name.
Speaker 3And it's kind of hard to separate Moo and Lemuria. Like Moo is clearly supposed to Churchwards, Moo feels a lot like Levatski's Lamurria, and most people, I think, actually combined the two. I'm not sure it matters except in very specific historical contexts, right, But you know.
Speaker 6If you're trying to explain Easter Island or Stoneworks in Polynesia and stuff Tulu, it's a very convenient uh rhetorical device to have stuck out there in the Pacific.
Speaker 2And I'm drinking a Moscow mew right now, So that's that's awesome.
Speaker 5So a Moscow I'm wandrincken.
Speaker 2Well, a Moscow move move, it's got the I've got my Crystal Skull vodka, uh and fresh lives.
Speaker 3Yeah. Well, as always, I'm concerned about the malaria, so I'm having some quinine.
Speaker 2Yeah. So, so I have read the biography of Ray Palmer and I've read some of the biography of Richard Shaver, but what I failed to read, or I found it very difficult to read, was the actual I remember Lemoria. I just had a hard time. But it's such an influential thing, Jerry, were you able to get into it.
Speaker 6I've read it a couple of times now, I read it magnificently.
Speaker 3Yeah, I h this is my first time through it specific for this podcast, and I'm not sure I'm ever going to forgive you Blake.
Speaker 2Yeah, I I couldn't. I will because now I have to solid air.
Speaker 6I'm not.
Speaker 3I'm not really sure you do. Actually, I like, what's it like? Well, okay, let I there's a fawn girl. It starts right there. I don't know it's it was nearly incomprehensible.
Speaker 6Imagine, I don't know the John Carter of Mars written by four chan, and.
Speaker 3But more than a touch of tumbler with which the furry elephant.
Speaker 6Yeah, I mean, apparently a lot of riders work on it, and I don't get that sense at all. It feels like somebody wrote it out in a in a day. Yeah, you know, progressively getting a little bit drunker.
Speaker 3Yeah, just when they go on, just constant trash jargon like stem rays and knees and that, and like seventy foot tall snake women who you know, the the elders get bigger and bigger and constant, the constant allure of giant women. And yeah it the Internet has existed for far longer than you realize. Wow, it just happened to be on paper.
Speaker 6So it's got I mean the first ti I'm looking at it here the first paragraph says, this will give you a flavor. I was working in the studio of Artan Grow when I heard a great laugh behind me. If ever there was a derision in a laugh, there was a derision in this one. I flung down my gaudy brushes and my palate, and turned about in rage to find the master himself, his red cave, red cave of a mouth wide open in his black beard. I cooled my temper with an effort for great Indeed is
Speaker 6artan Grow, master artist of subatline. The whole damn thing goes on like that one big run on paragraph. It's Lord Dunsany to the fiftieth degree. Oh funky phrases, you know, weird hoogety boogey kind of made up place names.
Speaker 5It's just very difficult to reach.
Speaker 3Well, I would go even farther than that. I would absolutely agree that what you just read with the run on sentences is quite representative. But there's there's two there's there's several other elements. So one there's footnotes. Oh yeah, there's footnotes to try to make this be more real. So for example, at one point we're looking at where's his footnote? Oh yes, uh, soon I was striding between the pillaring fangs of the great Beast's mouth. That was
Speaker 3the door of the Hall of Symbols, where the school's school ways converged. About was the bustle attendant to any roll at way station bearers rushing traveling, gazing about, lost in wonder at the vaulting glitter of sculptured pillars and painted walls done by men of a caliber whose work row like myself, cannot grasp entirely. Roe having a footnote here again are we had to appeal to mister Shaver for application amplification. We certainly got it, and along with some amazing thoughts. Roe, he says, is a thing of simple,
Speaker 3repetitive life pattern, easy to understand and control. To row you is to make you do things against your will. A large generator of thought impulse can be set up to row a whole group of people. Row the boat with w the other row doesn't have is modern and the meaning has become physical force and not mental force. Row the people was an ancient method of government. Romantic was the name of such a government. Row Man Tick science of man life patterning by control. And it continues. It's like that for the whole thing, except for when
Speaker 3he's admiring the tale of his fawn girlfriend.
Speaker 2Wow.
Speaker 3And by fawn I mean half dear.
Speaker 2Yeah yeah, yeah, yeah, I just came back from an anime convince, So yeah yeah.
Speaker 3The whole book is like that and gets worse as it goes, because once it mentions and rais and it's like, now I'm going to have forty of them.
Speaker 2Wow.
Speaker 3Like I said, the Mound is considered one of Lovecraft's worst stories, and it is a thousand times more readable than this.
Speaker 6My assumption is that from the footnotes is basically that's the meat and potatoes of shape.
Speaker 3That actually came from Shaver.
Speaker 5Yeah yeah, I think.
Speaker 3I think the vast majority of the ancient society stuff came from Palmer, who again was deep. So we mentioned the Ohaspi Bible. Now that's the thing I have not read. I have sampled it. It is fifteen hundred pages, but it's basically a theosophy adjacent early kind of ancient Aliens book, like one hundred and thirty years ago, and he shape Palmer eventually became such an at a hero and advocate of it. He republished it and was putting it out there.
Speaker 3I get the feeling that almost all of the La Murious is coming from is coming from Palmer. Yeah.
Speaker 2Interesting, Yeah, well, you know, Palmer is obviously also well read in the classics of sci fi, and his first pro sale was to Gernsback and it was a story called the tim Ray of Jandra, and in that there's an ancient city in a lost jungle and the people in there are trying to drill to the center of what a hollow earth, which is full of riches. So he had already gotten that hollow earth sort of mentality.
Speaker 3But then there's horrible disaster, which is also every turn in I remember Lemuria.
Speaker 2So we got the hollow earth, but we also have this whole thing about the Darrow and the taro. Can you explain that that's uh, because because she ever believed people were influencing him these these it was it wasn't just that there's a hollow earth, it was that the people.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, the hollow earth is like literally the least part of this.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 5Yeah, Well, let's let's call the Atlanteans. They're the people that lived on Atlin And apparently in the far distant past we can call it. Can we skype in Robert Shock to confirm or deny this? Apparently in the far distant past, the sun had a solid like a like an M and M shell around it, and as it began to fail, the people that lived on this continent could not survive. So there was a plan to.
Speaker 6Vacate the earth to go elsewhere and survive, but a large group, a contingent of the society, didn't want to do it, so they were sort of sabotaged in their attempt and YadA YadA, YadA, giant sexy women and daring do Later, a bunch of folks decided to stay behind and Morlock style, they sort of devolved into these pot bellied you know, disease they've got all kind of heart diseases and weird stuff wrong with them. Bad guys who
Speaker 6are very similar to the residence of Kenyon in Lovecrafts. They're sadistic exactly. They're totally decadent, totally animals.
Speaker 5Yeah, and I will.
Speaker 3Say the original Morlocks. I kind of like them. I'm not a big fan of the evoy but continue.
Speaker 6The society has has declined, and these these detrimental energy robots that Darrow's are still around, and they're sort of the influencing machine that is that is pestering poor Shaver.
Speaker 3And they're harmed by the sun's rays because the sun's rays are toxic to everything. And at one point Shaver and Palmer, once they've become partners and actually end up living near each other, try to improve their diets by only, according to Shaver's teachings, eating very young things like young plants and young animals because they haven't been exposed to the sun long. Yeah.
Speaker 2Gross, It's like I'm not a vegetarian. I'm a vialetarian.
Speaker 6Yeah, a vegetarian, but still gross. I like I like my cheese to be old though.
Speaker 5Not sun exposed.
Speaker 6So the tarots, on the other hand, are the are the integrated robots, and they are analogous kind.
Speaker 3Of the angels.
Speaker 6Yeah, they're like angels and probably linked to angelic beings, and they're the ones trying to help the human race resist the the negative influence of the darrow And And the story is really a lot about that first battle. The first story I remember Lemuria is all about that. Then the return to Snathas is the second one, and that's sort of what happened back on on Moo later on down the road related to this conflict. And I
Speaker 6get I don't One thing that I've not been able to understand is what the Darro's motivation is is like, are they're not really trying to conquer the earth.
Speaker 3I think that they're just broken. I think that they're just diseased and so they just do evil things because their minds are warped.
Speaker 5That seems to be the case.
Speaker 6I mean, I don't know if they're a metaphor for you know, Nazis and Japanese imperialists at the time, or I'm always trying to find uh, you know what.
Speaker 3I By the time it gets to Palmer, I think they may be atamor metaphor for something else, because no theorists you know where I'm going with that.
Speaker 6Yeah, here we go.
Speaker 5If no Jews, no news, right.
Speaker 3I mean no, the Palmer later gets into some real trouble with with anti Semitism. Yeah, and this is this would not be the only example of various secular conspiracy theories basically replicating the medieval blood libel, which then goes through which trials and ghost are also stuff and has never gone away, which we see in stuff like Pizzagate and QAnon today. And there's more than a hint of that. And frankly, I would argue some of the artwork used
Speaker 3to illustrate the DROs looks a lot like stereotypes of anti Semitic stereotypes of the twentieth century.
Speaker 6So if you ever, if you ever take a look at that All Shaver Mystery edition that's got the Darrow's on it, it is a virtual you know who's who gallery of anti Semitic execs.
Speaker 3I mean, I don't show that imagery in class when I talk about this, and I talk about the origins of flying saucers in case you were anywhere we're going and all of that, I don't show that stuff because I'm like, yeah, no, it's it's Yeah, no, I think that's kind of where this is going.
Speaker 2We probably need to take a break. When we come back, let's talk about how this stuff does lead into the world where Ray Palmer becomes the father of flying saucers. It's really interesting. More obstrut you've been listening to months the Science Show about Monsters. I'm Blake Smith, and you just heard a discussion with Jerry Drake and Jebcard about the strange history of theories around the Hollow Earth and the collaboration between Richard Shaver and Raymond Palmer that became known.
Speaker 1As the Shaver Mysteries.
Speaker 2Tune into the next episode for the conclusion, in which we learn how Ray Palmer becomes known as the father of UFOs and what happens to Shaver Palmer and the narrative of the Darros and the Tarots. Morenstert, Welcome to Monster Talk, the Science Show about Monsters. I'm Blake Smith. In this episode, we're going to continue our look into the curious narrative created by Richard Shaver and Ray Palmer and its impact on culture. I'm tempted to say American culture, but honestly, this got bigger than that. As you'll hear
Speaker 2in the interview. Palmer was an early and prominent member of science fiction's fandom. His interests even predates the use of the phrase science fiction. He'd been involved when Hugo Gernsback was a encouraging everyone to call it scientifiction and abbreviating that as STF instead of the more widely known term sci fi, which is abbreviated as SF. Fans have been arguing about which term to use for the field since the nineteen thirties. In two thousand and nine, when
Speaker 2the television network the Sci Fi Channel, which was spelled SciFi, changed it to sci Fi spelled Syfy, it rekindled this argument yet again about what the name should be for this field of literature. That the selection of what name to call a group with common interests would be the kind of wedge that could split people into factions should not be surprising to listeners in a world where people routinely split into factions around what TV shows they like to watch within this genre, or split into groups around
Speaker 2fictional characters such as Team Cap or Team Stark, or a Team Edward versus Team Jacob, or a Team jar Jar versus Team Annie. Anyway, the point is, people who have lots of reasons to join together can find plenty of reasons to split apart. Whatever you want to call it, fantom at this time was in its infancy. The word fan is a diminutized version of fanatic. When you're a fan of something, you may find yourself quite passionate about stuff that you're really not in a position to have
Speaker 2control over. Your joys and disappointments become rallying points for you and others like you. Fans of science fiction quickly connected via mailing lists, home brewed newsletters, local clubs, and of course, through the letters pages of their favorite magazines. Insider terminology was developed which could be used to identify other fans. For example, a collection of fans could be called a Finn, similar to how the plural version of man is men.
Speaker 1This linguistic development is still ongoing.
Speaker 2Terms like fanfic a fan written fiction that occurs within the setting of some popular intellectual property or shipping when someone fervently wishes that particular characters would form strong romantic relationships. Are slashfic, which describes non canonical fanfic involving characters having sexual, often homosexual liaisons. Despite the many reasons fans might be united by their common interests, these early fans almost immediately factionalized around politics, ideas, around the direction of the field,
Speaker 2over capitalism versus socialism, and even over a variety of made up religions. Sorry, Flying Spaghetti Monster and Reverend Bob Dobbs, your biding satirical take on religion is not new. I'll put a link in the show notes to a site called encyclopedia dot org, which is just full of deep esoteric history around science fiction fandom. It's a fascinating resource if you want to see how we got to now. And as Jerry and Jeb describe, the Internet culture on these fan topics is merely the electronic version of a much longer pin and paper tradition. We talked a little
Speaker 2bit in Part one about how Richard Shaver had been struggling with mental illness, and how Ray Palmer took his story of detrimental robots and integrated robots the Darrow and Terot, and expanded on it and then framed it as both real and reminiscent of a pre existing body of lore with which many readers would have already been familiar. He was blurring the lines between fact and fiction and did not give a fig about it. This delighted some readers and infuriated others, and have included a brief clip from
Speaker 2the Long John nebl Show which includes audio of Ray Palmer, Richard Shaver, and of course Long John talking about this topic. When you hear the show turn into a sort of old timey recording, that's me playing the clip, which I forgot to introduce. A link to the full episode of Long John Nebel's party Line will be in the show notes. A couple of words come up in this interview that are not very common, so I'm going to go ahead and define them here just in case you aren't familiar with them. The first one is shibbaleth, a word or saying used by adherents of a party or sect or
Speaker 2belief and usually regarded by others.
Speaker 1As empty of real meaning. These are different from.
Speaker 2Jargon, which are specialized terms with precise meaning for a technical profession. I like the word because of the story behind it. It was a term used in the Bible, where there was this common word shibolith, and it became a password to distinguish between members of one tribe from possible impostures from another tribe who couldn't pronounce the sh sound because it wasn't part of their native tongue.
Speaker 1The other word I wanted to fine.
Speaker 2Is reification, to consider or represent something that's abstract as material or concrete, to give definite or concrete form to a concept or idea. This term reification is about making something like an idea into a more concrete form, but the word also has multiple meanings.
Speaker 1In various fields.
Speaker 2For example, there's a logical fallacy where you would argue against an idea as though or a real thing, and that's considered to be a reification fallacy. And in information technology, reifications when you fully define a data model so that you've got a complete, functional, virtual model.
Speaker 1Of a real thing.
Speaker 2Amusingly to me, I had to look this up myself, despite the fact that I do that very kind of work all the time without ever using that term. So I'm not sure who in the IT world uses the word reification, but I know that everybody in software development is doing it during the process of making software. We also briefly discussed in this interview the contact ee UFO movement. Early UFO history includes a variety of people who came for to say they'd been contacted by intelligent humanoids from outer space. Now, this is quite different from the abductees
Speaker 2who occur later. The abductees are taken against their will. The contactes are mostly happily contacted by these intelligences. These include people like George van Tassel, who also started a large UFO convention in the desert at Giant Rock. There's Georgia Damski, who was another contactee who was also previously involved in theosophy.
Speaker 1And ran a Hamburger stand. And I'm not being tried.
Speaker 2He really did run the Hamburger stand and would tell customers all about his UFO experiences in addition to writing books about his work with the aliens and being interviewed. We've also talked about Woody Dedrenberger before, who's probably most well known for his meeting with Indrid Cold, as depicted in the movie The Mothmon Prophecies. I've said it before, but if your only knowledge of Indrid Colds from the movie, you should take the time to either read The Mothmaon Prophecies or read Woody's own book about his meeting, or you know what, you can listen to an interview with Darren Berger himself talking about meeting Indrid.
Speaker 1I'll put a link to that in the show notes.
Speaker 2If you've ever been frightened by the movie version or had trouble sleeping because of it, I think hearing Woody's own story will probably allay your worries. And if you do find yourself spooked by the movie version, you can think rich HadAM, who has appeared on Monster Talk and who kindly bought me some very nice cocktails in real life.
Speaker 1I thank you a lot, Richard. I owe you a couple of rounds. Man. I need to get to la and have some kind of Monster Talk meetup sometime. Okay.
Speaker 2Finally, while the core material of the Shaver Mystery comes to Richard Shaver, as we discussed in part one of the show, Ray Palmer expanded the text considerably and was probably respond possible for much of the theosophical, Atlantean, Lemurian and other referential material that ties the Shaver stories to other works around the Hollow Earth, lost civilizations, and ultimately to ancient alien lore that already existed prior to the nineteen forties.
Speaker 1We read a lot.
Speaker 2Of material to prepare for the show, with the biography of Palmer called The Man from Mars. Ray Palmer's Amazing Pulp Journey by Fred Natus was particularly helpful.
Speaker 1A few points that.
Speaker 2We may not have made in this interview but are worth mentioning because they give some insight into Palmer's views. First, Raymond A. Palmer used his initials as a nickname. People called him Rap. When he had a son, he named him Raymond B. Palmer. It's difficult to get a feel for how seriously Rap approached all this stuff. He definitely played with reality far more than just in the Shaver mysteries. After a childhood injury, he had spent years in forced traction and reduced mobility around curing his spinal damage. Reading
Speaker 2was his escape, and he was a voracious reader and highly imaginative. He never had a college education, and it seems he resented the kind of language common to scientif fiction, later sci fi, and the technical jargon. Comment to his competitor magazine, Astounding, which was edited by John W. Campbell, Palmer had a mischievous, prankish nature. He frequently used pseudonyms to pin his columns and stories, and then would proceed to berate in the editorial page this fictional author.
Speaker 1Who was himself.
Speaker 2His work with Shaver led to a blurring of the lines between fantasy and the cult. Madame Blavatsky had done something similar when she claimed that Bulwer Lytton's The Coming Race book was actually based on real history, but Shaver really mainstreamed it to the American pulp magazine public. When Palmer promoted Kenneth Arnold in nineteen forty seven, he had set himself on a clear course to weirdology. We talked about this a bit in the interview, but later in life Palmer promoted some writers who were clearly antisemitic, while he vigorously denied that he himself held such views. Promoting
Speaker 2the writing of Nazi sympathizers this is a poor way to desistance himself from such accusations. We've already covered the Nazis' obsessive interest in the occult in a previous episode, but what I find troubling is the way that it's become twisted by a variety of parties, including Nazi sympathizers, that the Nazis actually had real occult powers. These allegedly included magical powers, connections to the hollow earth flying saucers and other occult energy sources. This glorification of Nazi power often is threaded together with Holocaust denial, and I find
Speaker 2that abhorrent. There's a very thin line between using fictional versions of Nazi occult fascination to that of celebrating Nazis as misunderstood victims. I still find it hard to believe we have to see modern neo Nazis being celebrated and publicly defended by anybody. I don't like mentioning politics on the show, and I know some listeners have been annoyed that we've talked about politics at all, and I get that. But if people are confused about whether the Nazis or the bad guys, something has gone horribly wrong. Not sees
Speaker 2are bad. If you feel a need to defend the Nazis, please go read some real history books or talk with actual Holocaust survivors. As much as I hate politics, I hate more the normalization of.
Speaker 1Racism based on junk science.
Speaker 2I think Jerry and Jeb do a good job of contextualizing the role of the Shaver mystery has had in putting us in the world we're in now.
Speaker 1It's a frequently ignored.
Speaker 2Foundational text that builds to a time when ancient aliens and hollow Earth theories are threaded through the foundations of modern pop culture as deeply as the tunnels of the Darros are in Shaver's conception of the Earth. Don't believe me. See how you feel after this part two of the interview. Oh, one more thing. I know, the flat Earth gets lots of press and is shockingly accepted by a lot of the misinformed, Gulbible and anti establishment types of in our population. But the hollow Earth is all over the place. It even shows up in the latest Godzilla movie. It's in manga,
Speaker 2it's in anime, it's in comics, it's in horror films, it's in fantasy films. I mean, where would the D and D world be without the underdark and those extensive caverns and dungeons? And where do you think those ideas came from. Also, we talk a little bit about a famous science fiction writer and fan who was angered by the Shaver mystery.
Speaker 1But what we didn't mention.
Speaker 2In the interview is another writer who read the Shaver stories and was also suffering from the same kind of psychological effects of an influencing machine.
Speaker 1And that's Philip K. Dick.
Speaker 2If the things we create are influenced by the things we consume, Shaver's influence is going to last a long long time, even if people.
Speaker 1Don't know his name or work directly.
Speaker 2Now, if that's not enough background the info for part two of this discussion, you can check the show notes, where there's even more reading. I don't think the world is hollow, but this Shaver stuff does seem to go on forever. Let's find out why this stuff matters and get on with the Morgell. So we're back.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 2So these stories came out and it created some nineteen Yeah, let's talk about how they were received by the science fiction fandom.
Speaker 5They hit like crazy.
Speaker 6I think the magazine's letters returned letters to the editor went from something like fifty to like twenty five hundred. I mean, it basically became like the no Sleep Reddit thread, where everybody else suddenly had a share in these experiences, and they immediately began to build the exact same kind of mythology you would find on Reddit or four chan.
Speaker 5Now, so one of the.
Speaker 3Things the listener needs to understand here is that this was not just an amazing stories thing. This had existed with weird tales, where people would write letters in and they would communicate, and at some point they I already printing the address of the letter writer so that they would start writing each other. This became the network that becomes fandom. I mean, when we talk about the Internet existing on paper, this is the equivalent of Oh, I could I could send a direct message to this person, I could send them an email or something. I could
Speaker 3comment on their comment and take it out. And so fanzines would emerge and communities would emerge. Now, but as as you all were.
Speaker 6Saying, the numbers here exploded, and I think, and I suspect this was what Palmer was at least somewhat trying to do.
Speaker 3I don't think it was like all of a sudden, There were a ton of sci fi fans who are like I like ray guns, but also the DROs, the fact that it was the Muria. I don't think that that name was chosen by any accident, the fact that it's basically warmed over theosophy. I think, all of a sudden, you know, it's like, you know, you make a mistake in the in the keyword you use of the hashtag using Twitter, and all of a sud you're like, wait, why am I surrounded by hollow Earth people? What the hell has happened? Yeah? I think that's kind of what he was doing, was basically using this network but trying
Speaker 3to tie it into another community that then glommed onto it.
Speaker 2But he also received pushback from some sci fi people who thought that this was disingenuous, that it was exploitative, and that it was contrary to the science focus that had been the hallmark of science fiction before before.
Speaker 3And science fiction is beginning to emerge as something quasi legitimate. It's not just ray guns and you know, big eyed monsters. You're starting to get what becomes the golden era of science fiction. It's about to hit. And he's like, also, by the way, Victorian occultist Tripe.
Speaker 2I think that that sort of fan pushback.
Speaker 1Was legit.
Speaker 2I mean, I think, I mean it was an interesting and legitimate argument, right when I think about these sort of discussions. This came known as the Shaver Mystery.
Speaker 6Palmer calls it the Shaver Mysteries. That's the name, and he sort of brands it under.
Speaker 2He's being coy. Uh.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's an understatement.
Speaker 2Yeah, he's he's basically trying to have his cake and eat it too. He's saying, you know, we're not commenting on whether this is true, but it's claimed to be true by Shaver.
Speaker 3That's a and it clearly resonates with everything we know, like stuff like that.
Speaker 2Yes, yes, yeah, he can't just leave it alone. He's got to say that it seems to like be based on the underpinnings of you know a lot of lore, right, yeah.
Speaker 3And and so these people start writing in and they're like, you know, I went into the caverns and my friend was vaporized, and I have a hole the size of.
Speaker 5A coin in my arm my arm.
Speaker 3Yeah yeah, and you know, because they ran into the DeRos too. And and so these people start writing in, as Jerry was saying, like like no sleep like creepy pasta, Like what's what's that one with the institute like sc something? Oh yeah, yeah, where it's just like these stories. And I don't think everyone writing in was trying to tell a real story. I think some of them were like this is fun, this is fun. I'm gonna tell a creepy story.
Speaker 5I have a confession to make.
Speaker 6If you go back and listen to the Mel's Whole episodes of the Art Mel Show. Oh boy, go ahead, I am a trucker in one of those episodes who tells a ripping yarn about a hole into the center of the earth. Total book. I was a college kid board at work and had not, you know, had the level of adult adulting that I have.
Speaker 5Now.
Speaker 6People lie, People lie a lot, you know.
Speaker 3I mean, you're not the guy who you know, told them the story of Half Life, which is you know, famous. But yeah, no, exactly, and I would expect a lot of that. But then, so I think one of the things that's interesting here, we're going to get into the idea that Palmer invents the flying saucers. We'll get to that, but skip forward even a couple of years, and certainly by nineteen fifty you have a number of people, many of them tied into the Shaver network, who had deep,
Speaker 3long histories in this occult lodge, this theosophical group, this ancient teaching that as soon as you get rockets, and then especially when you get flying saucers, they're like, oh, I used to get stuff from the ascended masters. I mean, I mean they're from Venus actually, I mean they're from Venus. And this becomes the Contact Team movement, one of whom Maurice doriol Is directly plagiarizes people from the Lovecraft circle,
Speaker 3like Lovecraft himself and Roberty Howard and Frank Bell Knap Long and is involved in the Shaver community of letter writers and whatnot. That emerges, and the the idea of like the Reptilians basically comes in right through there.
Speaker 6Yes, I can't remember off the top of my head who introduces Lovecraft to theosophy, but he writes one of his letters, He's like, gimme, He literally says, give me more of that stuff.
Speaker 3So he from what I think, there's two introductions. One he gets the ideas from stuff he reads, so he reads is always I always forget the name of Scott Elliott.
Speaker 2But the Atlantis, the book that Jeb's trying to remember is the Story of Atlantis by William Scott Elliott, which was later expanded to the Story of Atlantis and the Lost Limoria. I put a link to that in the show notes.
Speaker 3But right before he writes Cthulhu, he reads a book on the idea of Atlantis and Lost Continence. And again I'm blanking on the name. Later in New Orleans, E. Hoffman Price introduces him to theosophy like for real. And but that's well after he's written most of his stories.
Speaker 6Right, So it's a reification machine really at that point where the Lovecraft didn't believe any of this stuff. But it's authors who are sort of going, oh, I love this mythology and I'm going to adopt it. Believers read a story by someone by Lovecraft like Lovecraft and goes, oh God, there's my mythology. They must also be channeling the ancient mask.
Speaker 2Yes, well, and Damski was straight up trained in theosophy, wasn't he? Yeah, yeah, yes, And.
Speaker 3And doriall the guy who introduces reptilians to UFO or through Shaver. He ran a lodge in Colorado, he ran he ran a magical lodge. Now we mentioned love We just mentioned Lovecraft right now. I want to make a huge distinction here, And I did this on the Twitter thing last night. During his lifetime, Lovecraft, mind you, had a lot of faults. We've talked about him before, h But he mined the theosophical stuff, he mined all this stuff, turned it into fiction and did have ramifications later, but
Speaker 3when he started to get letters of like, tell me more about the reality of Cthulhu. Tell me where I can find a copy of the Ecronomicon. Where are you getting this? Where you get He's like, it's fiction, it's fake, it's not real about it. Yeah, stuff that he really believed, like for example, Margaret Murray and the Witch cult he would go on and on about. But if he didn't believe it, he's like, look, and not only that, I don't want He literally said, I don't want people like looking for this stuff. I'm happy to tell them that ecronomicons not real. It's fun to write about, but it's
Speaker 3not real. Palmer is literally the opposite.
Speaker 6Yeah, he's taking stuff that's not real and wholesale re regurgitating it as as this true.
Speaker 2Story that's really good. I mean, that's a really good comparison. Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah, and he has a much faster impact. And I think that's important to note. Lovecraft stuff does eventually inspire a lot of ancient aliens. I think ancient aliens would have happened without him, But he's a huge influence on it. Palmer immediately, so these stories, the Shaver stories, they blow up. But yeah, sci fi fans aren't happy. He quickly gets kicked out of Amazing Stories, but he had already kind of started to build a escape plan and found several
Speaker 3new magazines, including Fate Magazine, which becomes a major standard of the paranormal world. In nineteen forty seven, when Flying Saucers emerge hed, they get instantly locked into the Shaver mystery because he'd been talking about, you know, flying from the caverns of Mountain Shaft and all that, and he hires Kenneth Arnold, the guy from the first Flying Saucers sighting, to go investigate the Moury Island UFO hoax.
Speaker 6Yes, indeed, Moury Island is one of those oh my god, it shows up in everything. I don't know, if you guys read the background literature for the latest Twin Peaks, Moury Island is like one of the major subplots in there. And then in the podcast Tannis, they use Marie Islands as a plot point. So it's one of these things that is alive and well. And I expect, you know, a Hellier type documentary about Mario any minute. Did Josh Gates just deal?
Speaker 5No, he's he's trying to go legit one of the big shows that.
Speaker 3They did it on, well, they did it on UFO Hunters years ago.
Speaker 6Es they did, but there was one that just ran like a couple of weeks ago where they were looking at some of the metal from Morio at I it might have.
Speaker 5Been Josh Gates, I can't remember. They all read it's all just one.
Speaker 3So I have heard, I'm hesitant to say this this way, I have heard responsible UFOE people that I kind of do actually like as historians if you fology, et cetera, et cetera, who are really fascinated by moriy Island. And I'm not like, it's pretty obviously a hoax.
Speaker 2It was a hoax. While uh Keith Arnold was still on the ground, he knew it was. Yeah, I mean, it was a host. But the fact that it's being regurgitated and uh and heated up and swallowed as a are presented as a scrumptious meal is disturbing to me because it's a although like Groswell, it's grown a little bit, not even close to as much as Roswell's grown, but it's grown.
Speaker 3It's comparable to like Aztech, the az Tech UFO story.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, it.
Speaker 6Has.
Speaker 2Yeah, let's let's talk about it. I mean, I don't want to go off into a huge tangent about Marie Island, but basically, people claim that they saw UFO and it dropped slag or metal parts on their metal.
Speaker 5Burning burning silver metal slags, and.
Speaker 2It killed killed their dog. And uh, Palmer got very excited because he wanted to cover it for his new magazine.
Speaker 3So he hires Kenneth Arnold, the pilot right and and and fire extinguisheder salesman, to to go out and investigate it. Yeah. Now, Paul literally like a movie.
Speaker 2I mean, Kedith Arnold is not a UFO investigator, he's not in any investigator, and he it's he realizes he's kind of in over his head really quickly.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2The people there are, the people who are making the claims are cagey, to say the least, they're inconsistent. And ultimately, yeah, the slag turns out to be from a nearby foundry if I remember correctly.
Speaker 3Well, that's that gets a little conflict. And then they put it on a plane to take it away because the air Force is actually investigating, and the plane crashes kills two air Force officers, and I think the two reasons this is continuing to reverberate through wu Landia uh is one, the plane crash adds this element and I'm like, wow, that's not awful back to Salem. But two, because Fred Christman shows up in the friggin Jim Garrison JFK investigation.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, one of the guys involved in this.
Speaker 6Well there's two. There's two additional legacies. It shows up in Gray Barker's book. I think it came out in fifty six All Men in Black Business, much about the Flying Sauces and Diestic twelve documents reference it after that.
Speaker 5So it's it's got a story that keeps rolling.
Speaker 2Yeah, it becomes an anchor point that you can hand, you can hang stuff on it, basically, but it's itself. There's not much there there.
Speaker 3Well, let me let me ask you all. So Arnold when he goes out there, says, oh my god, somebody like phoned ahead and got me a hotel room. And I don't know who did it. I want to like, I want to ask you, is it a Arnold is just making that shit up? Or b is it Ray Palmer?
Speaker 2I assumed Palmer.
Speaker 5It's Ray Palmer.
Speaker 3It's got it. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I just yeah.
Speaker 6I mean, Palmer was trying to build this UFO mythology once he got to Fate, and Fate is the place where it all happens, right, and.
Speaker 2Fate is because so he goes to found Fate. He's partnered with is a Jern Clark, Well, Jermee Clark's one of the editors. Later, yes, later it's pick.
Speaker 3Well, while you're trying to think of that, it was just the Fullers, yeah.
Speaker 2Well the family. Yeah, but he was to get away from Ziff Davis because they're ever so slightly limiting his editorial control.
Speaker 3Right, So let's let's do a very quick chronology here. Nineteen forty five forty six Shaver mysteries explode, but they're causing controversy, and Palmer's like, I need to do something else, and he wants to go paranormal. It's very very clear. Forty seven flying Saucers. He hires Arnold to go investigate More Island. Now here's the thing. Nineteen forty seven Flying Saucers June twenty fourth, and then a whole bunch of
Speaker 3sightings over about three weeks, and it basically ends with the flying disc at Roswell on July eighth, nineteen forty seven, and after that there aren't really a lot of Flying Saucer things. Now in the halls of power inside the Pentagon, there is actual interest with Project Sign and then later Project Grudge, Project Saucer all that, but out in the public. While it's a fun, weird thing, they don't generally associated
Speaker 3with aliens or martians. It's they're probably weapons, and it kind of goes away, and it only sort of re emerges in nineteen fifty and fifty one when it begins to be what we think of as UFOs today, that they're aliens, that they're you know, all the stuff that we now think of those three years is when Palmer is building it.
Speaker 6I mean, don't forget. Do not forget that. The first episode, issue volume one, number one, and I've got it right over here of Fate Magazine was headlined with Kenneth Arnold's The Truth about the Flying Saucer. They used that story of him flying in his Sessna seeing the discs out across the sky as the foundation for this new business opportunity.
Speaker 3And it is a business, yes, When so that we didn't call Palmer the man who invents flying saucers that actually comes from John Keel. Yes, yep, and I think he's largely right.
Speaker 2I don't disagree at all. The more I read around this, the more I became convinced that we wouldn't have flying saucers and that whole lore the way we do today. If it hadn't been for Palmer, it would be very different. It'd be very differ. Indeed, it'd be very different, and Fate I became like a really safe place to talk about any kind of weird.
Speaker 3Well not just any kind of weird shit. I'd like to point out when he creates his basic thesis for what Fate is, it is like, yeah, we're going to investigate like I don't know, ancient mysteries, and I'm like mother, It's just like, can I get away from it? You know, spooky archaeology is always at the base. It is always at the base because it's it's the myth that props all the rest of it up. But I digress.
Speaker 6I want to point out one thing about UFOs. You know, the people in the government aren't dumb, and people in the government read Trashy pull Up Magazine two yep, and Roswell is buy ranches in Utah. They buy ranches in Utah, they collect twenty plus thousand occult books and sit in Victorian libraries doing podcasts in the middle of the night too. The thing to realize is that when Oswell happened, it was the government that said it was a UFO, and
Speaker 6that becomes a kind of a kind of beat throughout the Cold War. And I would offer up the hypothesis that if a government counterintelligence person would much rather have Joe Public looking up at the sky and seeing something weird and saying, well, what's a man from Mars, then that's an exotic spacecraft or an exotic piece of aeronautics. So there's there's a there's there's a lot of reification
Speaker 6that goes on in the fifties, sixties, and seventies, where where the UFO movement suits a.
Speaker 5Lot of diverse interests in a very convenient way.
Speaker 3I I don't know how much it does earlier earlier, my own personal take. Earlier, I think a lot of it is accidental. It's I think I think Roswell's entirely accidental. But by the eighties it's not. By the eighties, they are clearly doing.
Speaker 6But Roswell just it works so well.
Speaker 2So yeah, oh, we should probably take a moment here and say rest in peace Stanton Freeman. Yeah, yeah, yeah, all right.
Speaker 3Just that curiosity. Did either of you meet him ever? I've met him, Yeah, yeah. I only met him once. I saw him give a talk once, and then I met him in an Applebee's because he was the only place near the hotel out near the airport in Albuquerque, and he sat down next to me. When I went to the UFO festival in Roswell, he sat down next to me when I was trying to understand this whole thing. I'm like, well, guys built this myths. Just sat down and we had this conversation. And that was when I realized. Prior to that conversation I thought he was not just
Speaker 3full of like Charlatan. I thought he was making this stuff up. That conversation made it clear to me that he wasn't. He actually did believe this stuff. It's just that he had given the talks that he gives.
Speaker 2So many times. Yeah, yeah, that it.
Speaker 3Comes across as canned and insincere. Yeah, but no, I met him once and it was it was actually quite interesting. I don't believe he's right about pretty much anything involving Roswell. But I digress.
Speaker 2I don't know Matt Moneymaker, but the times I've interacted with him, I believe that Matt Moneymaker believes the things he says. I mean, yes, he's figured out a way to make money on it.
Speaker 3Yeah, he has a very unfortunate last name. Yeah.
Speaker 1Well, you know his.
Speaker 5Dad's name is Rich Moneymaker, which.
Speaker 7Is oh, oh my, oh my god, you know my pick.
Speaker 6I run into this guy in the government all the time. You know, it's an interesting character who who was highly educated, often Ivy league educated, you know, xtremely privileged and smart person who will plant the flag on something and let it destroy their career. And it's such a I don't know if because we don't have to do we have to be.
Speaker 5Right enough to keep getting paid.
Speaker 6I think there's a there's not a lot of self checking as you as you age. And Friedman always struck me as one of these guys who had just he had planted a flag on this thing.
Speaker 5It was paying his bill.
Speaker 6It mean, into enough of a celebrity for him to you know, get the ego ego boost out of it that he was sort of satisfied with the idea he was right about what was happening. But it's a it's a trait among academics that I mean, it just happens, like everybody knows that kooky guy who believes in well, I mean there's some Jeff mir there's some characters out there who have just planted a flag on this thing. Broke anyone in conversation, anyone in this conversation.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, I would say with Friedman, I personally think, uh, we should get back to Shaver in a second. But I personally think that my own belief is that he kind of got stuck with MJ twelve. Like I absolutely think he thought it was an amazing Watergate at the beginning, and I think at some point I think cognitive dissonance is a hell of a drug.
Speaker 6Yeah, it is. And those documents are not authentic, like I have analyzed them myself. If I know anything, it's government documents and the history of how they were produced, and those are not authentic government documents. There there are too many obvious flaws in them. Yeah, I mean, it's a very good hoax by somebody who did not know if I hoaxed the government document from that time period, you would not be able to to tell that.
Speaker 5It was a hoax.
Speaker 6So this was not someone who was don't don't about that stuff, man, don't about that stuff, I.
Speaker 3Mike, all right, So so Shaver, So Shaver and Palmer. They continue to the Shaver mysteries for like a couple of years, and then it basically becomes flying Saucers.
Speaker 6Yeah, it morphs into the flying flying souther religion almost, yeah, Saucerianism.
Speaker 3Yeah. Yeah, And the first wave of contactees sort of start to appear basically doing what I would argue Palmer was doing, taking decades of the Western occulture tradition or a century or more of the Western culture tradition and Sci fiing it. Yep. Yeah, So like like Adamski, like like all the others.
Speaker 2That's a really interesting distinction though, the the religious approach, the spiritual approach, the New Age approach, versus the nuts and bolts approach, or like what I would say, the sincere inquiry into what are these things and where do they come from? Uh, there's there's a pretty big divibe between the people who have been given wisdom from these craft and from the inhabitants of these craft uh. And the people who just see lights in the sky and have strange experiences. Uh. And and that that early schism,
Speaker 2as far as I can tell, it's still out there.
Speaker 3I don't. I don't. I don't know if it is anymore. I well, I mean, I'm a champion for the puff do you know that? But it's not like it, you know, it's it's not like it is when there's a keyho around or nycap or anything like that.
Speaker 2Well, what about what did Tom DeLong stuff? What do you think their goal is?
Speaker 3Tom DeLong is working with the dude with the ranch, with Space poultergeists.
Speaker 6It's Space Poulter guys and and techno wizardry.
Speaker 3And the higher wolves and synchronicity. No, there's no barrier there.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, And you know, I say, you're saying the barrier is just broken down completely, gotcha. It's not not that one side one or the other they just merged. Oh no, I think one side one, Well, who won the.
Speaker 3I personally think that the putting theology on the end of weird shitology, cryptozoology, uthology, parapsychology is largely a structure of the social status of the sciences. In the middle of the twentieth century, and as that social status declines, so do they. We live in a world. Here's anology for you. We live in a world of a new demonology. But this idea that I'm going to looking for a gigantopithecus or a plesiosaur, or I'm trying to understand recurrent spontaneous psychokinesis, or I'm looking for people from Zeta reticuli
Speaker 3makes a lot of sense from basically the end of World War Two and maybe a little earlier and about the nineteen seventies. And that's when it begins to break down. Is in that period, and I think at this point it's gone.
Speaker 6Well. I will admit that I have two things in common with Kenny Fetter, well three things if you count the profanity. A degree in archaeology. And I first learned about Eric von Danakin in a barber shop. I was Carl's barber shop in Louisville, Texas, as a high school junior senior. And in the pile of books you could read that smelled like nicotine and you know barber oil was a copy of von Dannakin's first book, and I started reading it and to my sixteen or seventeen year
Speaker 6old mind, you know, steeped in the religion of Indiana Jones, it made a five sense, But after I finished about my second or third class as an undergraduate in formal archaeology, it didn't make a lick of sense. But I can totally understand how people who are exposed to that stuff, well crafted and well written, could totally turn Jesus into first and ascended Master and then second into an alien. Like it makes perfect it's logistically logically convenient.
Speaker 3To preserve your beliefs, like I think, it's actually harder to keep it as nuts and bolts or pelts and paws. Yes, like I have. I have very hard times with a gigantopnthists Bigfoot. I actually have less problems with demon portal Bigfoot because I don't know how Demon's great work, but I know how Gigantopithecus would probably work.
Speaker 6Actually, I wrote a I wrote a blog about that for a friend of mine's paranormal cy called Quantum Bigfoot, where I made that same case where I was like, look, guys, a dimension time hopping Bigfoot is more believable than Bigfoot, Like, yeah, there's nothing in the fossil record. There's no way this like, if you want.
Speaker 5To believe in Bigfoot, believe in Bigfoot.
Speaker 6As a time hopping alien, not as any kind of a North American primate, because there's nothing about Bigfoot that makes any food sense.
Speaker 2So what you're saying is that the Bionic Bigfoot was a documentary.
Speaker 6Yeah, I mean that's a lot closer now. And so here's I think.
Speaker 3Where this ties into the into the the Shaver stuff is that you have sort of flying saucers get taken over and it explodes in an era of big science. Initially there's contact ease and they kind of, you know, die on the vine for a bit. The Shaver stuff, the fact that the sort of the initial seed is straight out of theosophy, it's straight out of Lovecraft, it's straight out of all those things. I think that that
Speaker 3is I think there's an element of the fruit for the fruit of a poison tree. I think the fact that it's since it's there at the beginning, Yes, you can have people talk about radar traces and government conspiracies for a while, but eventually it was going to go back there and it absolutely has u And I think that that's one of the integral parts of Shaver is Shaver gets downplayed and made to be this weird, little quaint thing by historians of sort of eufology, not necessarily historians of contact eaism or flying saucersm but historians of euthology.
Speaker 3But you fast for the early twenty first century, and it looks, frankly, a lot more like the Muria than it looks like Zada Reticuli.
Speaker 6Well I drew down from the shelf.
Speaker 5Here the book that changed all of that.
Speaker 6It is The Interrupted Journey The Lost Hours of Border Flying Saucer by John G. Fuller, And my copy is autographed by Benjamin Sein and the doctor who wrote the introduction. So this is of course the Barney and Betty Hill case took uphology out of the hands of people like Palmer and legitimize. That's nineteen sixty five, so that's roughly twenty years after the Shaver mysteries first show up, and about eighteen seventeen years after Roswell, and it completely changed.
Speaker 6It opened the door for the spiritual version of ufology that we see in the seventies.
Speaker 3I would say two books in quick succession do that one and Passport to Magonia. Yeah, absolutely, and Passport to Magonia. I only only learned this back and I read it years ago, and I had forgotten this. I was preparing for a paper I was given earlier this year at a conference on like the Deep Past and fairies and all this stuff. It opens with pacall sarcophagus, Right, what the fuck.
Speaker 2Is which straight out of cheers to the gods.
Speaker 6That's the Yeah, the magicians.
Speaker 3Yeah, the these two. Well, yeah, there's that, There's that whole element. But yeah, the basically Shaver anticipates and well Shaver doesn't Palmer anticipates all. Well, I guess Shaver does. I mean Shaver and Essence is anticipating the sexually charged narratives of abductions.
Speaker 6Yeah, absolutely absolutely, And that's that's that runs right.
Speaker 5Through all the Shaver stories, right up until the very last ones.
Speaker 3Yeah, I mean his like we were talking about how the pulps were slowly becoming basically erotica and porn. His stuff had to be massively tamped down to make it into the pages.
Speaker 6Well, he has in the story, he has a wife that lives with him in the cave, who's very like the woman that people in the real movement see from time to time, like like hot blonde women you know, giving you the good news is a pretty common trope at this time, and contact.
Speaker 3Ease with the same thing, with our rains and all of that. And then there's all this weird like sort of sado masochism and these other kind of like ageah, this weird stuff.
Speaker 6Is it, Jeb You may know, because I don't. Is it Palmer that introduces the whole concept of the Nordics and the tall whites and that whole.
Speaker 3No, uh, not really because because honestly, in Lameria and Shaver stuff, it's all they're all weird and giant sixty foot snake women elder things.
Speaker 6So all that comes from the contacts.
Speaker 3Well yeah, the early fifties. But it's just like the stuff before.
Speaker 2I was gonna say, but isn't it basically repurposing the stuff from Blovatsky with the race core types in some sense?
Speaker 3Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah yeah. Well and also quite a few of the contact ees, I mean, so you know, I've gotten this far without mentioning Michael Barkum, but you know, quite quite a few of the contactees are have other kinds of rejected knowledge, like like Nazism. Yeah, and so one of the one of the contacts, George Hunt Williams Williamson that Shaver or Palmer published, was basically a Nazi sympathizer. So, yeah, the tall Whites and the Nordics and all of that. You know, the the idea that the Nazis had a base in Antarctica and they had super secret technology that
Speaker 3was coming from Nazi sympathizers within years of the war.
Speaker 2Yes, let's let's let's actually hop back to this timeline thing for just to make because we're gonna I want to get to that, but I wanted to come in context to the timeline. So we have this controversy in Palmer and the fandom. He breaks off and forms Fate magazine.
Speaker 3They're forty eight, there are.
Speaker 2We've talked about a monster talk before.
Speaker 4Uh.
Speaker 2The other big media at the time around this kind of stuff was long John nebyllh Nebll Yeah, and so Long John was already having on contact Ease and psychics and all sorts of things. Uh, and he started to include some of the Shaver mystery stuff on his show. So that was coming out of New York and they actually had the shows the party line, the party line. Yeah, it was. It was a precursor to Coast to Coast. If you haven't listened to our episode about it, I
Speaker 2recommend that you do. So there's some there's some audio out on YouTube. We can put links to that in the show notes. It's it's really amazing. I think it holds up very well. It's very engaging.
Speaker 6Uh, listen to it because this was at a time when everyone, every American white male sounded angry.
Speaker 3Uh, that's that's not happened since.
Speaker 6But it's like, sir, it's it's the opposite of the Rogan experience where it's like, sir, do you mean, sir? Sir, sir. It's it's hilarious to listen to.
Speaker 2They're very polite, but but like you say, the anger certitude. People people are eloquent. Yeah, yeah, yeah, there's a lot of eloquence.
Speaker 6And but then there's some great Brooklyn accents in there too.
Speaker 2There are there are you can be eloquent and be from Brooklyn.
Speaker 3I mean, what we're hearing Palmer talk on the radio does not help your attitude towards his credibility.
Speaker 2No, but you know, you know, we've talked about Palmer all this time, we haven't mentioned something really important about Ray.
Speaker 1Ray.
Speaker 2Ray had a physical injury when he was about seven years old, and as a consequence of that, his back was broken and he spent a huge amount of time locked into traction. They thought he was gonna die. Basically, he was sent off to a centatearium to die. There's various versions of this story, but Ray was apparently about four feet tall because of his back injury. Yeah, he has a hunchback. I think Jerry mentioned that, and that's how he self described.
Speaker 6And this is of course why he does not go to World War Two if we're wondering he was. He was not a countard or a draft on it.
Speaker 3He had never been drafted yet.
Speaker 2Right, right, So he did other things, you know, he entertained people, I suppose. But this this is actually tied to this interesting thing that you mentioned before, Jeb, where people are contacting you and they're thinking you're talking about Ray Palmer the Adam. Yes, and this is I find this fascinating. So what happened is the Adam was one of those characters that d C had picked up and was going to revitalize, and so they decided to turn
Speaker 2the atom into a science hero. And this is Julias Schwartz who was doing this work, and he's a friend of Ray Palmer's, and he calls up Ray and says, hey, I want to turn the atom into a hero again. We're gonna do it DC, and I want to name him after you. And of course the joke being that the Adam's power is he's very small, but he's also a science guy, which is I think, uh, I think not that accurate. I mean, Ray is known for his
Speaker 2science fiction work, but when you actually read what Ray wrote, it's not that science Yuh well, yeah.
Speaker 6Let me let me cavea out. That just a little bit blake if you read the old fake magazines. We're kind of being a little hard on him. Fate did a lot of hard science, and they did, and in later years in the seventies, they did a lot of good debunking on once Palmer had kind of left the scene. But Fate is brought low by the worst of it. But there's actually some damn good stuff in there. There are whole issues that read more like like Popular Mechanics than then a UFO zine.
Speaker 3So you're saying it's more Discovery Channel than History Channel.
Speaker 6It's more Discovery Channel than History Channel in that occasionally there is a little nugget of goodness in a sea of just stuff I watch while I'm.
Speaker 5Folding my laundry.
Speaker 2Well I have I don't have some of the really oldest fates, but I do have some. Uh the the Watertown ghosts mystery I tried.
Speaker 6Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, was that boy that was.
Speaker 5Born out of Fate magazine, wasn't it?
Speaker 2To an extent? I mean, the the photo existed long before that, But the first serious investigation, well even that's not true. Harowood Carrington investigated it, but I don't know if he published his work, But the later on it got researched in most of the details we have, and one of the better photos we have of the original is from Fate as well. So yeah, yeah, So anyway, I didn't mean to sidetrack on that, but the uh yeah, Palmer has broken off from this, and so I was
Speaker 2gonna say, the science fiction community is mad at him because he keeps keeping this coy attitude around whether or not these things are true. Does he really believe in the Shaver mysteries? Is that stuff's really supposed to be happening or is it all fiction or what is going on? And one of the famous stories around that is that at one of these science fiction conventions, which were still in their early days back then, Palmer gets cornered in a elevator by a fan who's also a writer, a guy named Harlan Ellison, and Ellison insists that Ray tell
Speaker 2the truth about what's going on with the Shaver mysteries.
Speaker 3And I'm just gonna put this out there, Harlan Ellison would make if I was in an elevator with him, he would make me pee my pants because he's a terrified individual.
Speaker 2He was a very terrifying individual. He was also not very tall. I was just these both of these guys are basically titans within science fiction, yet tiny and life so uh, I just imagining the two of them having that encounter in elevator. I would have loved to have been a fly on the wall. But Ray basically said, look, I was cornered, I was an elevator. It was obvious. Harlan wasn't going to let me go until I confess. So I gave him what he wanted, so he let me out of the elevator.
Speaker 8Right, let's a shame him. Let me talk with Ray Palmer again for a couple of minutes, if you will, please Hello, hell right, ask it lay sometime. Ad All. We had a young man on the program just about a year ago, a young man who writes science fiction. Yes, and he made the statement that he met you at a convention of science fiction writers convention a few years back. That is correct. And you know who I'm referring to
Speaker 8the thank you, Harlem Ellison at that he made the statement on the program here the two gold him. That's the uh, that's the shame in tree all things that you published them just to create good circulation for amazing history. Well, I think now that that's demands an explanation, which I think I can give you when you try.
Speaker 6Please.
Speaker 8When I went to that convention, I was very sick. I was invited to the convention and made the trip inspite of being ill. Now, when I got there, I expected to receive what D say, courteous reception, and instead I met with a group which I which I believe was mostly linked with mister Ellison. It would have me decided that they were going to bagine me. I see now.
Speaker 8They kept asking questions which actually you can't answer without it's a sort of a question to do you well beat your wife in the fact ration. Finally, when he to in front of me in the cellarator, I said, well, what do you want me to answer to the question? He said the truth. I said, well, I've told you the truth and you haven't existed. This is my only alternative is to tell you what you want to hear.
Speaker 8And this is entirely fiction, and that it was donal their purpos's raising circulation. Now this was done in what you might say, with anger. It was done off but said hadn't, and it was done to rid myself of these this group which intended to follow me the home the whole of convention and apparently we're having to take you the fun out of measuring me. They had no intentions of of giving me a chat to get out.
Speaker 8Sary say, I'm saying that is the actual conditions in my statements semester Ellison. I've had several runn with mister Allison sis and one of them came about as a result of his oppearance on your program. And I did at that time tell him that I at my statement, Sam and I elevator work were in the in the vein that we got to just describe to you. I see, I think it's cold, easily understand that.
Speaker 6Uh.
Speaker 8I don't believe that it is necessary to give an honest fanswers or personal UH. Does give me the courtesy I see of the chance to give you an honor STANSWERU. Actually, I don't think that anybody with the against an editor trying to increase the circulation of a magazine. Well, I want to clarify that too. If I wasn't hired by this Day's too to get a lot of returns. I
Speaker 8was hired to sell magazine. And I realized from the very beginning that the fam Mystery was the thing that was so magazine. He had certainly from around fifty thouds when I took this thing over, and it was and thirty five thous when I got hold of the gabor mestery. Over night we raised in fifty and eighty five thousands, which is a finger for a fiction magazine of that type.
Speaker 3That's possibly the most honest thing I've ever heard him say.
Speaker 5Yeah, it truly is. But it's impossible to underscore how small that community was at that time.
Speaker 2And he's not talk about how tall they were. He's talking about how tiny the community in number.
Speaker 6I regret that I'm just slightly too young to have gotten out of the early sort of sci fi stuff that I went to in the eighties and early nineties, because that community even then was very small.
Speaker 5You could show a bit of sci fi.
Speaker 6Convention and meet legends, yeah know, and not only meet him, you could eat lunch with him.
Speaker 5Yes, like that anymore.
Speaker 3This is when it was still actually like freaks and geeks and weirdos and not the only thing that is the part of our economy, right.
Speaker 6Exactly, So have Harlan Ellison and Ray Palmer in the same elevator is not fantastical. It also underscores the extent of which the Shaver mysteries at the time were influential, and we've just sort of decided to forget about them.
Speaker 3Yeah yeah, yeah, yeah, Well, because upologists absolutely wanted to you know, the you know, Keyho and nihap and and traditionally euthology. They didn't want to do with the contact ees, they didn't want to do with occupant cases, they didn't want to do with crashes. All these things were being reported and said, and they're like no, just radar, just photos. Okay, maybe because there's a hypnosis involved this couple in New Hampshire, maybe with the with the hills. Yeah, but this was
Speaker 3a large chunk of it. I don't I don't know. I would say the bulk of it. But there's been a long history of pelts and pause or nuts and bolts, people ignoring demonological or religious imagery, and abduction cases or strange you know, portals and UFOs and whatnot in cryptozoology cases and all these things being weird in your mixed and I would argue that it is when people are
Speaker 3able to tell these stories themselves, not unlike the letter columns with the Internet, that all of a sudden.
Speaker 6This comes back.
Speaker 3Yeah, you know that the gatekeepers aren't gatekeeping.
Speaker 6So the point is is that Ray Palmer created, in his own way what we might call modern Saucerianism, with the idea that in his mind, the Saucerians, the creatures from another planet, didn't come from another planet, they came from inside the Earth, right Like. That was what he was pushing, is that these these critters that we see as aliens were actually the precursors to modern humanity.
Speaker 3And in a way.
Speaker 6That's a lot neater and cleaner than the idea that somebody could develop faster than light travel and get here to planet Earth.
Speaker 5And that's like using them and then look like us exactly.
Speaker 3Yeah. No, And in fact, you see that idea that things were here and then they go out. I mean the X Files eventually went there, for example, in fiction, all the time afterwards you know it's it. And of course there's elements of the previous writers have been talking about as well. No, it's super influential and no one wants to mention it. And I kind of get why. Like I have been trepidacious about this episode, because the more I read of I remember Lemuria, the more I read this, I'm like, I don't like this guy. Like this guy is using a man with clear mental problems
Speaker 3with mental illness, taking his stuff and capitalizing and searching for others like he's for other shavers. She just didn't find them. Yeah, and then coyly, which is probably the most polite way one can tricks to really say it spins it into a small industry all for the benefit, and he pretty much just smirks about it through the rest of his life. And I'm like.
Speaker 1The one.
Speaker 3The sort of the takeaway from me, I have been interested in this stuff sense of very early age, you know, like every other gen xer. At some point I could say, well, I watched in search of you know, but like since a very early age, I've been interested, and I have been interested in this academically for a very long time. And the thing I had always been told by folks is, oh, don't there's no interest in that. It's just cooks and Charlatans. You know, it's just people in Arkansas. You know. It's just now I think they're wrong in terms of the
Speaker 3big social First of all, you look into the history of redology, it's actually tied very much to elites and all other kinds of people all across the spectrum. Everyone has elements of this. It doesn't work that way. And secondly, it's clearly had a massive impact on our society. It's been a lot easier to talk about conspiracy theory since oh, I don't know, November eight, twenty sixteen, but literally getting to the bottom of flying sauces in UFOs and seeing a guy hearing stuff from an arc welder and a guy who's basically a Charlatan selling. It is not really
Speaker 3making me feel good right now about studying people who believe in UFOL. What happens next?
Speaker 2What happens next?
Speaker 3What does he do?
Speaker 2He goes, he makes Fate magazine. What happens to the Shaver mysteries?
Speaker 6I mean he keeps running them up until the fifties. I think the last Shaver mystery story is nineteen fifty six. Yeah, and they are heavily built on by other people. I think it's actually a woman that writes in and proposes the mythology.
Speaker 3That's that.
Speaker 6And this goes to the whole Dulce story. This idea that, uh, there are elevators that can take you in all world's major capitals down into.
Speaker 5The place where the darros and tares exist, push.
Speaker 3The buttons a certain amount of time or something like that.
Speaker 6And so there's these people that run around looking for elevators to try to take them down into.
Speaker 3The basements under a pizza place.
Speaker 5Yeah, well can you give it?
Speaker 6Hit that pizza place and there's no basement there.
Speaker 2Well, there's no Bob. That's the common problem. Can you quickly talk about Dulce?
Speaker 3I don't.
Speaker 2Some of our listeners have probably never heard of it.
Speaker 6Oh you have not. You have never done an episode on Dulce head close as we can't.
Speaker 2We briefly talked about it when we talked about skim Walker.
Speaker 6So Dulce Bass was one that was sort of born out of the Art Bell Show. Really a lot like John Long. I assume you're if listeners don't know Art Bell, they need to log out right now.
Speaker 3And do some different Well comes out of it's a fair to some degree.
Speaker 5Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 6And it's this idea that under Dulcain, New Mexico is a giant alien base. I'll tell this story since we're since we're talking, I got a call a couple of years back. My first job with the agency I worked for was treaty archivist in the United States. So I get a call from a guy who a soccer fan from the UK, who has an English accent and probably likes Cyan colored shirts, who asked me for a copy
Speaker 6of the greata Treaty between the United States Government, President Eisenhower and the Gray Aliens. And I informed him without even walking into the vault, that we did not have such a treaty. Of course I knew what it was. This was supposed to be in nineteen fifty four, and we got into a huge road that lasted about two hours in discussing this this is not something that you're supposed to do in your capacity as a government employee. And whenever he found out my last name was Drake,
Speaker 6that made it. That's a that's a very that's a very icky situation to be in. Yeah, if your name is Drake and you work for a certain government agencies, that's not great.
Speaker 2You were on the phone for two hours, were able two hours to get like a snack, like a like a some ike and mic or hours.
Speaker 6And there was a point blake where I literally had my feet up on the wall and I was like stomping the wall trying to get off the phone with this guy. The greata treaty does not exist, but it was a treaty that it was supposed to be between the Gray aliens, who some people are villainous, who are in others are good guys. And basically what President Eisenhower supposedly agreed to was that we would allow the Grays to take a certain quota of human beings from the Earth in exchange for access to their advanced technology.
Speaker 5And I cannot remember the guy's name in God I wish I could.
Speaker 6Supposedly, on the Art Bell Show, it was disclosed that the base where the Grays, the Draco's, the Tall Whites, all these characters interact and live together is under a mountain in Dulce, New Mexico, and it goes down into the part of the world that is inhabited by the Darrow Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's like they were they were they were building a base, they were already trying to build a base, and they break into and already existing cavern and they're.
Speaker 6Like, oh, exactly people.
Speaker 3Yeah, no, this this comes out of even I think even before the Art Bell thing. So there's the Paul Benowitz stuff in the eighties, and I am blanking on the name of the abductee that allegedly she has been down to level six, the hell level the hell where they are like like mutating people, and that there's people down there that are screaming for help, but the guards are said, don't talk to them because they're clearly crazy. And so if you've ever heard any story stories like man talk like Pizzagate, like all these things of oh,
Speaker 3by the tens of thousands people are being kidnapped and used for horrible experiments and sacrificed and cannibalized. This story in the in the in the eighties, that becomes dulce. It's very Shaverian, It's extremely shaving.
Speaker 6It totally is, and it requires shaver for that piece of the mythology.
Speaker 5It really was.
Speaker 6But the idea that you can get on these magical elevators and go down into the world really adds to the sort of the mythology of it. I've even I even saw somebody the other day who suggested that Alyssa Lamb was trying to get to the the Darro's world in that elevator in that damn hotel where she ended up in the Oh God, like these stories.
Speaker 2That's that's the wrong way she was going up. I know, I know.
Speaker 6But the point is is that these stories are so fluid and so universal in these tropes that anything, it's perfect.
Speaker 3For the puffed Oh yeah, well, I mean bark Barker's apocalyptic Uh what does he call it? Improvisational apocalypticism?
Speaker 5I mean exactly.
Speaker 6Any Any of your convenient mythologies related to the paranormal can be folded into this. From QAnon, Pizzagate, Alyssa Lamb. It all works. You just keep adding, you just keep adding. You know, lego expansion kits to the original mythology, and you can go on for it.
Speaker 3And I think the fact that it starts with Palmer doing that in fact, gives it part of that cast, like you know it. I think that I think that is important to the fact that UFOs have always been the one like this, you know, you know, we're talking about the parentlym unified field theory. One could argue it's a takeover of all the rest by parapsychology. But if you look at those those things, you look at crypto, you know, the normal thing that monsters talks about, you look at parapsychology. For most of the twentieth century, they if I had to stay within their alleged academic whatever
Speaker 3you want to call it, we're looking for plesiosaurs, we're looking for psychic abilities. Whatever. UFOs started there, but it was always the one that bled farther, you know, that would produce a Kiel, that would produce a Valet, that would produce abductees and Level six and all of that. And I think the fact that it started with a mishmash of Ojaspi and pulps is part of that.
Speaker 6Well, it's the people's literature in the same way that four chan and read it and eight chan and all that is the people's literature. It's a place where those folks can get affirmation in a way that they can't get from traditional academia. I mean, they're trying to build a sidebar to legitimate intellectual pursuit that satisfies their ends.
Speaker 3And I'm trying to remember the exact quote from Ray Palmer, but Ray Palmer at some point basically said something like the purpose of the parent is to make.
Speaker 5You think, yeah, but it kind of doesn't.
Speaker 3No, it just makes you regurgitate these ideas, but call them new and shining.
Speaker 2He also said, I mean, he also kind of tied into my pet peeve about the way that fiction and fantasy sort of overlap and in folklore.
Speaker 1He said that.
Speaker 2Fiction often shapes our perception of reality, particularly of the extraordinary, and he was specifically talking there about how that people's perception of the unusual is affected by the things they've read or experienced in the world of fiction. So you're like, yes, yes, yes, Ray, Ray, Yes, the things you are writing, is affecting how people perceive the stuff that they're experiencing. Yes, exactly so. And also one more thing that I think is of interest. There's
Speaker 2a sort of stereotype of the skeptic who just dismisses these weird claims as that person's got a mental illness. That person and you know in the non piece way that that person's crazy.
Speaker 3Like all the people telling me why you're looking into.
Speaker 2This, right, exactly so. The thing is, though, there are people with mental illness, and I think in this particular case, multiple people with mental illness have been taken advantage of, manipulated and lost a lot because of others who were trying to control the narrative. Not just Benwitz, not just Shaver. I'm thinking here of like Phil Schneider, who was another
Speaker 2dulce person who.
Speaker 3Well, well here's one for you. I mean, so Shaver. But to be fair, as I sort of alluded to earlier, Shaver's life actually sort of settles down. He I mentioned the rocks. We should probably have mentioned this. He eventually starts finding like pictures in rocks everywhere, which is a whole other fascinating thing. But paranoid, yeah, which I mean, as an archaeologist, people are constantly bringing to our office like, yes, I found this, I found this, and like that's a rock,
Speaker 3and they're like, oh, but it's got this, like it's a rock. And then at some point I just have to I'm like, look, I'm sorry, I can't tell you anymore. But here's a here's an excellent example. So Shaver and Palmer, Shaver's life settled down and he kind of found a purpose, and one could argue again sort of a certain therapy. But here's one for you. The mon Talk project, where you have these guys that clearly have stuff going on with them, which gets which gets rationalized into well, they have problems because of all the awful things that were
Speaker 3done to them in the caverns underground for a Shaverian, which then not only develops a whole bunch of paranormal war becomes the clear basis given that the show was initially going to have the title mon Talk, Yeah of Stranger Things Thanks, which becomes this gigantic thing and inspires a whole bunch more based off of people that are basically based off of like modern day Richard Shavers.
Speaker 2And causes revitalization of Dungeons Dragons. Well, that's true.
Speaker 5Yeah, the the Stranger Things Dungeons and Dragons set is pretty sweet.
Speaker 3Yeah, I have seen one and it is pretty nifty. But yeah, no, this is this is a recurring theme, Like I have I have long thought someone not me needs to write an article about this kind of diad of an a exploiter or whatever word you want to use, and someone who has like clearly getting things that there's there's some sort of mental health element and it's being
Speaker 3rewritten and repurposed. Benewitz is an example. Mon Talk's an example. Uh, the Philadelphia Experiment falls in here. Oh yeah, and there are there are others.
Speaker 6Carlos Ayende, the Philadelphia Experience, Montak. I don't want to talk about Montac. I think there will be a time in the future when people will talk about Montak, but now it's not the time to talk about it. But with Carlos Sayende and in the Philadelphia Experiment, that was just literally a very sick person who who had found a hobby that people just decided to believe in. Like he's a guy that just wrote crazy stuff in books and people decided to adopt it as a and man
Speaker 6Philadelphia experiment.
Speaker 5That is one of the ones I really want to believe. I really want to believe it.
Speaker 6I loved that movie as a kid. It was so perfect and the mythology is so rich. I just want that one to be true so badly.
Speaker 3It's a it's a great iya. I mean Burlitz, you know, he batted a thousand on that bring me the Triangle Roswell Incident, Philadelphi experiment, you know, publishing that stuff in the seventies. He had a very Palmrian like I for inspired talent, if you want to put it that way.
Speaker 6Yeah, I mean the Eldridge story. I mean the Eldridge is now the last time I looked into it, it was a Greek shipping vessel. But I mean, none of the story is true, and and Carl Allen was not in any of the places he said he was in. But it just it's just great and it and it was so compelling that even the Office of Navy Intelligence slipped into it like they got that thing and was like, look, man, we need to take a look at this.
Speaker 2Wow.
Speaker 3Well, that that's a topic for a whole other discussion. The the the reification or the not the ratification. The ratification of of claims. When the government's like, oh, we'll look into it, and it's like oh no, no, no, no, no, no no, no, higher hire a freaking folklors higher anthropology use.
Speaker 2As soon as they look into it, it gives it just it gives it a.
Speaker 3Yeah, well, governments look into it. There's gotta be something there.
Speaker 6So I have to say this, like the volume of crazy mail we get is you couldn't even conceive.
Speaker 5But I don't even want to talk about how much crazy mail we get at work.
Speaker 6And but yet we still have to read it and go mm hmm, there's nothing here, there's nothing here, there's nothing here.
Speaker 5Wait a minute, wait a minute, we better look into this one.
Speaker 6And as soon as you have to look do some due diligence on something, it gives it a lot of legitimacy. And then the whole world is suddenly on you, you know, like flies on what flies go on, you know, and that you know, the government is cognizant of that, Like we tend to be fairly careful about our level of exposure because again, we read this stuff, we understand this stuff, and we know that as soon as we put our eye on something that the world's eyes on it. So,
Speaker 6but people stumble onto stuff all the time that they interpret incorrectly and and then write letters about I mean, that's just reality. Yep, it's true.
Speaker 2It's true. But uh uh, well, the thing is And I realized we've kind of rambled all over the place because but there's first of all, I knew we would, and and second of all, it's because this story has threads that go all over American weird culture. I mean all over the place.
Speaker 5And so I want to I want to ask you.
Speaker 6A question, doctor Atlantis. Who is the monster in the Shaver Mysteries story? Is it UFOs? Is it the Darrows? Is it mental illness?
Speaker 3Who?
Speaker 5Who is the monster in this story?
Speaker 3Well?
Speaker 2I mean capitalism, the Americans, the American failed mental health system. Yeah, how about that?
Speaker 5How about that?
Speaker 2Yeah? Uh the the if if America had a better mill health care system, then instead of being imprisoned and locked up and maltreated, then maybe Shaver would have gotten some help that he desperately needed. Now, in a sense, he got help and was able to make a living because of Palmer. So in one sense, Palmer as a person who really values testable reality, Palmer could be seen
Speaker 2as sort of a villain to me, exploitative, But everything in my reading suggests that Shaver and Palmer did not have a exploitative relationship. They had a friendship that just was one that also led to them both relying on each other to the point.
Speaker 6That they seem to have moved very close to each other at a point later, and they died in the same year.
Speaker 2Yeah, so I think, you know, a lot of friendships come and go, and there's was no exception. It had its ups and downs. But I think Shaver really cared about Palmer, and I think Palmer really cared about Shaver, and I think it seemed like by the end of his life, Richard was getting some pretty decent therapy through his rock art. Even though it appeared to be nothing more than paradolia, he was also able to take that
Speaker 2and make fairly impressive looking artwork.
Speaker 3Out of it and to contextualize it. Yeah, you know, there's a difference between I'm writing howling manuscripts about like people being shredded under the earth by cannibals, and hey, look, I know the mysteries of the universe through my rock art, Like that's one is a lot healthier. So I mean, I guess the conversation here, I still don't like Palmer. I don't know if i'd call him the monster if I had to actually sort of find a monster. I mean,
Speaker 3I said capitalism somewhat jokingly, but I think I would elaborate and instead say this, this sort of attitude of like, it's it's kind of fun, it's kind of true. Does it really matter that that? Does it really matter? Attitude, which absolutely Ray Palmer clearly had, yes, and so many people after him have had. You know, when your smug friend is like, oh, well, age and aliens, that's fun. No one really believes that, And I'm like, yeah, actually they do. They do. They absolutely do. That's the monster
Speaker 3whatever that is.
Speaker 2No, I agree, I agree. So I want to say though that Palmer, towards the end of his life we started to talk about this before, and I cut you off because I wanted to kind of hit it chronologically. But he got involved in, first of all, some very right wing politics. He got involved with supporting some people who were let's say, Palmer himself tried to distance himself from the anti semitism, but the people he was publishing did not.
Speaker 3And then he became a big fan of George Wallace.
Speaker 2Yeah wow, Yeah, so making some really I would say, poor political choices.
Speaker 3It turns out if you write about hollow Earth ancient civilizations, he turned into a hell of a racist aka also a Lovecraft who knew.
Speaker 2Yeah, except that you can see this today everywhere. But Palmer also got in with this Giannini guy talking about the hollow Earth again, this time talking about Admiral Byrd and the Poles.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Some really weird I would say weird science. It's not even science fantasy. But it's built on a sort of a hoax around the idea that bird had actually gone inside the hollow Earth and knew about it and there was a governcover up. That was a fairly interesting story because, as you were.
Speaker 3Saying, this actually came.
Speaker 2Out of uh sort of pro Nazis story. But I do find that that that narrative around the Earth being hollow is still out there. And oh yeah, it's not going away. I mean it's it's I it's not as prevalent as the flat earth.
Speaker 3Okay, remember when the flat earth was a joke and yeah, no one really believes that.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, oh.
Speaker 3Yeah, there is this.
Speaker 6There is this concept in politics right now, and I'm not going to make fun of anybody's politics, despite the temptations that I have to do so that if you are anti establishment, then you're right by default. I mean, I'm as establishment as you can come. I believe in the establishment. I believe in the idea that you work your way into the establishment and then you you you advance your agenda based on having earned a place.
Speaker 5At the table.
Speaker 6But a lot of people believe that, you know, the whole idea of righteousness in politics comes from the fact that you're the ultimate outsider. So anybody's who's anti establishment by default as a hero. Maybe that's Julian Assange, maybe that's Brad Manning, Chelsea Manning.
Speaker 4I don't know.
Speaker 6But the reality is is that there is this weird contingent in American and European politics that if your anti establishment, you're automatically valid. And I think you see a lot of that emerging, especially in the fifties and sixties in this kind of eufology in so Serrianism, where they the fact that these people have an anti establishment voice automatically grants them legitimacy. And what I'm seeing is a lot of people adopting some super effing racist beliefs simply because
Speaker 6they're not part of the establishment right now.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, no, I mean that I would absolutely agree. And that's the turn we've taken, is oh, if it's if you know. And again I mentioned Michael Barker. He wrote Possible, in my opinion, the best book on this back in two thousand and three or two thousand and two, culture Conspiracy, whereas like it all gets thrown into the gutter of rejected knowledge and once it's in there, you're you're going to pick it up.
Speaker 6Like there's a little more anti establishment belief than the idea that the world is not freaking round.
Speaker 2I mean, yeah, I don't know. I can't stop laughing at but it the people who believe it. While they may be basing that on the way that it drives other people crazy, some of them are basing it on the fact that they have bought into this conspiracy.
Speaker 3That that No, I don't I there was a time when it was there was there was an ironic component. I don't think there's much of that left. And I just want to say, and maybe this is why again with the Shaver and well Palmer's really the issue why this kind of really hit some bad buttons with me. I haven't laughed about any of these topics in a long No.
Speaker 5They're not funny. Yeah funny, man.
Speaker 6I mean this is like we are literally looking at the birth of everything that created the decadent anti intellectual culture that we're struggling with right now. Yes, and this stuff's not funny.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's important. But and this is sometimes where I have a hard time with some people that do follow this, where it's like, oh, well, you know, I'll follow this because it's a music and laugh at the people's like, Okay, here's your fiddle. There's a city of Rome. It's on fire. If you haven't noticed it's on fire.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, no, I.
Speaker 5Think you've been struggling.
Speaker 6I can tell Jeb from the your comments with the idea that studying this stuff is not important. I think that this is the exact reason why it's important. If we ignore the fact that people would rather believe some convenient bullshit as opposed to reality, then our mission is teachers and educators and scientists is just completely thrown out the window.
Speaker 3I know it's important, it's just I struggled for so long to be like this is an important part of our culture. Is like, oh, it's just nuts and cranks and seeing.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's missing the point and an.
Speaker 3Origin point that sounds like that, I guess is just more that. But no, it's it's far bigger and it's far and it's far more important. And I think that's why we have done a very long episode about this, because it's like, wasn't that just a piece of history. It's like, no, you don't get where we are today without this. Yeah, Like this is super integral, and it's super integral for the way it turned out, Like this is one of those moments. I'm not saying to send a terminator back to do something to Ray Palmer, but this is one of those cases where like, if you
Speaker 3had paid Ray Palmer to go just write space opera, the future would have turned out quite different.
Speaker 6Yeah, And the fact that nobody even knows who the guy is is to me especially compelling, Like we all know, you know, l Ron Hubbard, but at the end of.
Speaker 3The day, he's had far less, far less influence on western.
Speaker 6Far in because he was such an obvious crank. Apologies to the five scientologists that listen to this part.
Speaker 2Yeah, I doubt we have five, but but if you are listening, I hope you're Thetan free good luck.
Speaker 5Yes, theytan free since ninety three.
Speaker 2Oh my gosh, Well, guys, is there anything else we want to add? Because I feel like we've done a really good job of covering what's a pretty difficult topic. I know, I'm going to edit this a little bit.
Speaker 6Blake.
Speaker 5This is a very difficult topic because a part of me wants.
Speaker 6To just put on my party hat and you know, drink a gallon of booze and ride through it as a romp. But then, you know, I'm glad that Jeb is here to anchor us in the reality that this stuff is really like, this is the this is the zeitgeist we're dealing with, and it was born out of a poor man's inability to understand.
Speaker 5What was going on inside his head.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah, And I will say to balance that, twenty years ago, when I really started to look into this more significantly, I would have talked about Shaver. I remember this because I talked about it in classes and things of like, oh, well, it was this weird thinging. Yeah, it's a little questionable because this guy probably had problems, but this other guy sort of and now I'm like, oh, fuck this. And and it's because I because of what has happened and also seeing it's it's it's tendrils everywhere everything. So I get I get that tendency because you're like, he's got
Speaker 3a dear girlfriend, not one he finds his deer. One that's a frickin already adactyl that he's got mind control raised under the earth. And there's an immediate like, oh ha ha ha, that's funny. Look at that. You know, Oh look it rained on the create on the Noah's Ark and it got broke. Isn't that funny? You know that that sort of thing.
Speaker 6But yeah, I mean there's a we kind of talked about it privately, but there's a documentary out right now that's Reinventing the paranormal and it's straight out of the Shaver or mysteries.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, And I mean we've we've talked about it. I was just say that the hell your thing, it's it's come up and and and you mentioned it earlier, and it's it's out of a lot of things. I don't think it's out of juth, actually I do. But we'll leave that there.
Speaker 6Yeah, death is not a planet, by the way, it's a it's a dwarf planet. It's the dwarf planet.
Speaker 2Yeah, I guess I think we covered everything. The only thing I'll see was we didn't talk about Martin Gardner and.
Speaker 3His uh sort of oh his his his his dissing on on on Palmer from seeing him in the seventies. Yeah.
Speaker 6Yeah, you know what, Palmer.
Speaker 3Palmer does not need anyone to physically observe him to tell you what he's about. He makes it amply obvious what he is about.
Speaker 6Like that.
Speaker 3That's you know, I don't I saw that part and I'm like, eh, whatever.
Speaker 5I mean, I have a question to I know we've been going a while, but I hope you guys don't have to work tomorrow. But why.
Speaker 6Why does it go to the Jews? I mean, you don't have to put this in the episode, but Jeb, how does it get there every fun time?
Speaker 3Well, I'm okay with actually discussing this. I at one point I would not have been able to answer that question. I really do think as an archaeologist, there are not everyone would agree with this, but especially an archaeologists that works with certain I'm not gonna get into that. I am a believer in the concept of deep tradition that while there are huge changes, while there are transformations, that you can look at certain traditions and see deep echoes
Speaker 3like the area where I am trained and I have done most of my archaeology, meso America. Does it go through huge changes over thousands of years? Yes? Can you see core concepts at all mech sites in eleven hundred BCE that you see in the Mashika Empire in the in the fifteenth century? Is it the same? No? Are there some connections, Yeah, there are. I would argue that there is a deep myth, a deep tradition that emerges.
Speaker 3I don't know exactly when this is outside my abilities of a it's clearly tied to I mean, and there's other versions of this, but there's a specific one, a specific one that's clearly tied to medieval Christianity. That is that there are two enemies, that there are a decadent urban anti christ enemy that starts off being identified with
Speaker 3Jews in Europe in league with a barbarian outside which is pretty obviously the Turks and you know, and all of that, and it starts with the pilgrims against Jews in Europe in the medieval period. Then it transfers over to the templars where they get the exact same, are very similar accusations thrown at them that are thrown at Jews before that, when they are thrown out of countries.
Speaker 3Then about a century and a half later, which panics which had not happened before, but they're the exact saying, oh, they don't meet in the Sabbah, they meet in the Sabbath. It's very very different. And then that gets thrown onto Illuminati and Masons and Catholics, and then it gets thrown on onto Illuminati again. Uh, and then we get into the Satanic panic, and then we get to Pizzagate and QAnon right exactly. So I think it's I don't think
Speaker 3it's it's not one of these reinvent things. I think there's an element of that. I used to like when I started looking at witch trials, I'm like, oh, it's what I call the crucible model. Well, when you get in a certain kind of circumstance, these ideas like reinvent, it's like the circumstances make them more palatable to more people, make them more possible to be in the mainstream. The idea is centuries old, so I think I think that's why I think. I think these ideas are much older and they get transformed. But the reason they're successful is
Speaker 3that they're digging into a thing that's already there.
Speaker 5The enemy has a certain set of characteristics that.
Speaker 6Translate over to the person who seeks to persecute the enemy, and the hedgemon has to make itself into a victim. I believe that's the case. The hedgemon in this case, the white American male, has to be a victim in order to engage in persecution. And that's a pattern that has existed as long as humanity has been around.
Speaker 3Yeah, I don't know. I don't know if it's as long as humanity. I don't know about that. It might be. I would say, however, the fact that you have a persecution narrative that goes back to the Roman Empire. Sure, of course for the Abrahamic tradition, I think does actually play into that. I think it's actually quite important there. Whereas I can look at you know, say, Phuronic Egypt, they don't feel that way. They're like, no, everything's yeah, there's awful chaos monsters out there, but society is pretty solid.
Speaker 6Well the Hicksaws or Aqunans, sure, yeah, but.
Speaker 3Those are but those are weird periods. But but that, but that's the thing whereas you get to everything that comes after the Romans and the encounter with the Abrahamic religions, I agree with that, and that is a very wrong narrative in that tradition. And so I'm a believer in deep traditions that yeah, they're because you're like, why on earth are the protocols of the Elder of Zion showing up in friggin Behold a Pale Horse? But the fact that these are all basically just the same myth being
Speaker 3retold and retold and retold.
Speaker 6I actually I want to highlight that. I don't know, Jeff if Blake sent a petition to show, but Behold a Pale Horse is the ultimate puffed Bible.
Speaker 5Everything is in there. Oh yeah, all in there.
Speaker 6It's one hundred percent the entirety of the paranormal linked with conspiracy theory into one single document, and it has.
Speaker 3Never been out of print, and it has never done poorly.
Speaker 6It's not a bad book. It's not a bad read.
Speaker 3Yeah, you know, Bill, Bill Cooper long Beyond the Grave has has can you know he's he's one of those prophets. I would argue that he's not quite keel, but he's one of those profits that well he's not.
Speaker 5Only a profit, he's a martyr.
Speaker 1Yeah, well, there you go.
Speaker 2Uh yeah, if you're not going to pay your taxes and you're going to get shot by the government, what better way to prove your point.
Speaker 3Make sure you do it right around two thousand and one too.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, Bill Cooper annoys me. Although I think you've you've fairly well convinced me that my first UFO documentation that I saw in the wild outside of a UFO book was probably Horse Well, it was probably the Cooper documents around that with the alien types and stuff. Yeah so yeah, uh yeah, it's very peculiar.
Speaker 6Said.
Speaker 3This actually turned out more coherent than I was expecting.
Speaker 2I think, good, good.
Speaker 3I like this.
Speaker 2I mean, uh, I was going to add one more thing about the anti Semitism stuff. I mean, Palmer was working for years with Shaver doing stories where their secret influence their secret controllers, and then in his life for years he's working for Ziff Davis.
Speaker 3Oh, yeah, so he's.
Speaker 2Not able to do all the things he wants to do because the people who were in charge are Jewish, right and not letting him do what he wants to do. And whether he consciously resented that or not, it would be an easy step.
Speaker 6Well exactly. Yeah, I'm glad you brought that up. In the West, secret masters are always jewsed like, that's just part of the tradition, and I think in this case it was very concretized. I mean, you know, God like, that's just the way we interpret it. And it's regardless of politics. The left and the right in America in twenty nineteen have the same problem with Jews as they ever had it.
Speaker 3Well, and the beauty of it is is that because it's it's this very specific like urban elite idea. It's like, oh yeah, most of them are, but well that one's not. But he's like them, you know, you know this this this the coast you know, the coastal elite. The uh you know. No, and and I don't even think that's a code at this point. I think it's more just being generous with numbers, if if if that makes if, that makes sense, But no, I think it's a historical myth. I I really think that I wrestled that for a
Speaker 3long time, like why does it always go back there? And I think it's ultimately these ideas are a lot more powerful on this than we think.
Speaker 6It is integrated into the DNA of Western politics. Yeah, it's at it's at the fundamental level.
Speaker 3Yeah, I mean it literally goes back to the medieval period at least.
Speaker 5Yeah, so the real monster was man all along?
Speaker 2Yeah, monster, you've been listening to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith, and you just heard part two of our coverage of the Shaver Mysteries with doctors Jerry Drag and Jeb Cart. There are a lot of links in the show notes if you want to dive deeper into the Hollow Earth and the Shaver mysteries. I've received a lot of interesting links to a variety of fictional properties that directly or indirectly build them this mythology. I didn't try to include them all in the show notes, but there are plenty of them, and the numbers growing. When the Hollow Earth material showed up in the Godzilla
Speaker 2King of the Monsters movie, I was the only one in the theater cackling madly. I may have spent too much time on this topic for my own good health, but I hope that you all enjoyed the fruits of this effort. Monster Talk theme music is by Peach Stealing Monkeys. No Darrows or Tarots were harmed in the making of this episode. This has been a Monster House presentation that
Speaker 2could split these folks into fashion people into factions. Should not surpell that would split folks into factions in a world where people non canonical fan fiction fiction?
Speaker 1Uh, because I really should.
Speaker 2Not even be saying this, you know, Honestly, I'm just having trouble here and probably was responsible for much of the theist to the tech jargon that was that was into his competitive ah well basket.
Speaker 1We already recovered, not that in fantasy it's
Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...
Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...
Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...
🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...
Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...