Blake and Karen are joined by Matt Baxter to discuss the 2023 film Nandor Fodor and the Talking Mongoose, based on the story of Gef, the talking mongoose at the heart of the story. Visit our original coverage of Gef in episode #67 Watch the film (Amazon affiliate link) A list of the clever things a mongoose might say... The Haunting of Alma Fielding - a recent book about Nandor Fodor's investigation of an alleged psychic (Affiliate Link) Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Monster house presents.
Speaker 2I am doctor Namdorfold or the world's foremost parapsychologist.
Speaker 3I am not a skeptic.
Speaker 4This is the strangest case I have ever earned out.
Speaker 1A family living in farmhouse claim a talking mongoose lives in that barn. Creature's name is Jeff.
Speaker 3What do you think about attacking mongoose? Serving family are peculiar?
Speaker 5Did you observe this creature? No?
Speaker 3No, I did hear him. We are going to the Isle of Man. I have almost twenty years of research in this field.
Speaker 5You're ready to say, Jeff, it's the creature here.
Speaker 1Well, because we can't see him doesn't mean he ain't here.
Speaker 2And I see automatous.
Speaker 5Doctor Photo has a tremendous skepticism.
Speaker 3Indeed, this is an inexplicable force.
Speaker 5I'd say the way Russell is probably watching us right now.
Speaker 3Everybody on this island has their Jet story.
Speaker 3Ever seen before. A giant, very creature.
Speaker 5Part eight. Part of that.
Speaker 3In Luckness, a twenty four mile long bottomless lake in the Highlands of Scotland.
Speaker 1It's a creature known as the Luckness Monster.
Speaker 5Monstertle. Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner. What you heard there at the beginning was a bit of the trailer for Nandor Fodor and the Talking Mongoose, a twenty twenty three film directed by Adam Siegel, featuring Simon Pegg, Minnie Driver, a brief appearance by Christopher Lloyd, and lots of other faces that you'll likely recognize from shows like Game of Thrones, Toast of London, Supernatural, Dead Boy, Detectives, and lots of
Speaker 5other places. The strange story of Jeff to Talking Mongoose is one that Karen and I bonded over our shared fondness for when we first met back in two thousand and eight, and we were quite excited when we heard about this film. So, as you can imagine, a lot of listeners asked our thoughts on this, and we sat down in July to discuss it, and then I lost the recording, but then I found it again and with apologies for the delay, were joined by Karen's husband, Matt Baxter to talk about our thoughts on Nandor Fodor and
Speaker 5the Talking Mongoose.
Speaker 3On Monster.
Speaker 5It's another Monster Talking. This week, we're gonna be doing a fan request show. We had several listeners contact us and asking us, Hey, we've covered Jeff the Talking Mongoose. We've talked about Jeff the Talking mangos being an important part of our individual monster histories.
Speaker 1And before he was cool as well, Yeah, before anyone really knew.
Speaker 5About exactly before he was Yeah, like you had to be British or an American with an usborn book to really know.
Speaker 1But today I'm obsessed with this kind of thing.
Speaker 5Yeah, exactly. But we've got We've got Matt Baxter joining us today. It's we're gonna be talking about the twenty twenty three movie Nandor Fodor and the Talking Mongoose. So yeah, as I said, multiple listeners wrote in asking us when we're going to cover it, how we wash it, what did we think? And I guess we're about to express those thoughts.
Speaker 1Really something we should have been more proactive about. But here we are. We finally watched it, and I mean lots to say about this. I'm not really sure where to begin, because I mean this is a bit like a debased on a true story episode a little bit.
Speaker 5Yeah. Yeah. So so let's assume that you have not been following Monster Talk since our inception in two thousand and nine, and that somehow you missed our episode in I think twenty thirteen when we talked with Christopher Joseph, who was at the time working on a book about Jeffah Talkingmongers and later finished that book, and we can put a link to that in the show notes.
Speaker 1Yeah, about twenty seventeen, I think is when that came out.
Speaker 5Yeah, so it takes a little gap, takes some time. Books apparently take some time. I've heard. Yeah, I can be counting.
Speaker 3I can be counted in those ranks. I don't follow the show.
Speaker 5Yeah, Like my wife says, you have a podcast that's her favorite joke.
Speaker 3Well, you know, to me, this whole thing was interesting because I thought, what a mash up, you know, a vampire and a talking mongoose. And then I realized that it's not an and or the Relentless from what we do in the Shadows, that it's someone completely different. So I was very disappointed in the movie.
Speaker 5Yeah, more of a poultry geist, although I didn't see a lot of chickens right.
Speaker 3Well, another good movie.
Speaker 5So we're going to be going back in time, and I think was the year explicitly stated in the film, but the real investigation was around nineteen thirty one, and that's right.
Speaker 1Yeah, I don't think it is in the movie. I think you get a kind of general sense. It's the early nineteen twenties, thirties.
Speaker 5Yeah, exactly. Clothing, Yeah, and it's set on the Isle of Man. And this is the story of the Irving family, who although in our movie it's really the story of nandor Fodor, but we'll get into that. But this is the Irving family are the ones who reported. Again, it starts sort of poultrygeist, see, with things moving, noises, weird things in the walls, and ultimately is quite different from a Poultrugeist case in the sense that the entity at
Speaker 5the heart of it claims to be a mongoose from India who is also the eighth Wonder of the World and does quite a lot of stuff, yeah, quite a lot of Yeah.
Speaker 1But I do think that there are similarities though with a poltergeist case, because everything's surrounding the twelve or thirteen year old daughter, So Ray is how they pronounced it in the movie. I've heard Voyy. It's basically Manx for Mary. That's what the name is it.
Speaker 5Manx is the native language of the Isle of man Yep.
Speaker 1Yeah, and I mean there are just some similarities to poltageist activity, with things being stolen or disappearing and then appearing somewhere else, things being damaged, to people getting attacked or scratched or bitten. But the difference is that this poltergeist.
Speaker 5Speaks it most certainly does tells people.
Speaker 1To go and put ointment on their wounds.
Speaker 5Yeah, in the real world story. Again, I'm not saying Jeff is real, but in the story that happens in our real world, Jeff does a lot of peculiar things, like he spreads gossip and tells people sort of secrets about them, and he seems to be widely known throughout the island, like he somehow making his way around outside of Yeah, quite a bit.
Speaker 1Yeah, and that does come to nice. But yeah, I do want to get talking about psychic Jeff a little bit later on. But I don't know, Matt, do you want to kind of give us a rundown of the plot.
Speaker 3Well, it's it's interesting because you know this, Uh, they don't come out in the beginning, say hey, based on a true story. It's it's maybe sort of implied, but it really doesn't say you know anything about that. This is a fictional account, like you said last night, Careen's a fictional account of a fictional account. And and Uh it's it's basically, you've got nandorfhod Or Uh being seemingly fed up with a lot of paranormal claims and he's
Speaker 3taken quite a step view on things and he's getting, you know, just bored with all the kind of same stories. And then across his desk sort of comes this story of the talking mongoose, and but it was it was from a letter sent to him by Harry Price, and we all know him from you know, the Price is right. So he basically decides I'm going to go investigate this after he has a little meeting with Harry Price, and wackiness ensues. And the fun part about this it's basically
Speaker 3a story about psychic phenomena, poltergeist activity and talking animals, and it's a comedy rather than a horror movie.
Speaker 1And kind of a pseudo romance. It feels to me because when Nandor Phodor Gosh that's a mouthful. When he went to Cashion's Gap, originally he went there with Lambert. He didn't go there. What was his name was it? Rs? Lambert?
Speaker 5Is that her last name? She's a character? Oh sorry, sorry, sorry, I'm.
Speaker 1Saying in real I'm saying in real life he went there with the Lambert. He didn't go there with an assistant. So in the movie he has this assistant, And I think they're kind of setting it felt to me like they were setting it up to become a romance or something.
Speaker 5Or a recurring like a recurring series of ventures with the two of them being the Watson Holmes or something.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's it's interesting you bring that up, because I wasn't all that. I mean, a lot of people seem to be very disturbed about the fact that this is so far removed from the actual story with all this stuff going on. But it reminds me a little bit of that series of Hoodini and Doyle.
Speaker 1Yeah, and I really see the similarities too with Fodor and Houdini, And I think they are kind of setting him up as a bit of a that that he's gone from being a believer to becoming a skeptic and following in the Shoes and the Footsteps of Houdini, I really get a sense of that.
Speaker 3Yeah. Yeah, but like that Houdinian Doyle Show was a fictionalized account of their friendship and the wackiness that would ensue when they would get together and solve crimes. So, you know, I kind of looked at this movie as a little bit like that, it's not claiming to be anything other than that.
Speaker 5I just sort of recent book about Nandora Fodor and it's about one of his investigations into the case of a psychic, and it was really interesting. It was a popular book, but boy, it was frustrating because in the case that they're investigating, it's obvious throughout parts of it that the person who's supposed to be the psychic is faking things. And now, for us, since skeptical investigators, I think we tend to think that once we've even there
Speaker 5has been some hoaxing, it's poisoned the well, if you will, and it's like the whole case becomes suspicious or suspect and foot or like would just sort of compartmentalize well, faking that, but what about the rest of it? You know, Like, so maybe it's not all fake and uh right, quite an interesting tale, and I think it gave me some insights for how he actually did investigations. And within the film it was a little peculiar because you don't see him doing a lot of experiments or you know, he's just quietly, politely saying, show me what.
Speaker 1You got, you know, until the end of the movie where things turn a little bit violent and he becomes inebriated, and I thought that was really out of character, and that of course didn't actually happen. Yeah, I thought that was a really strange twist that they took, and I think it just and then for them to imply that if he was to write about write an account of what had happened to expose them, that he would be sued for slander. And so there was a lawsuit that
Speaker 1was associated with the case, but it didn't have anything to do with photo at all.
Speaker 5Yeah, And this is the other thing is I think it starts to sort of it's sandwiched with appearances by Harry Price, and this is Harry Price as played by Christopher Lloyd, which is pretty a very strange casting, yes, because Christopher Lloyd is like eighty five. There's a thirty one year gap between Simon Peg and Christopher.
Speaker 1Lloyd Passions gap.
Speaker 5Yeah, that's right, and then between the actual Harry Price and the actual Nandor Photo there was only like a fifteen year gap. But to see, yeah, yeah, it's a weird case. Both Nndor Photo and Harry Price investigate. They both write about it. It's in the newspapers, it's in the it's in the radio news.
Speaker 1Delby spook. Yeah, because it was known at.
Speaker 5The time, and they both I mean, they do a lot of what I guess you could consider serious investigations, but they take this one so lightheartedly. Yet at the same time people really took this quite seriously. It became a point of contention, it led to fist fights in parliament. There's a lot going on.
Speaker 1Well, I think we should get back to the case a little bit. And I think that in reality, the way that the story was treated was like it was a kind of local interest story. So this part of the Isle of Man was known as Dolby, so the phenomenon was known as the Dowby Spook. But there was a lot of focus on voy Ray being the center of all of this activity. And I just think it's notable too. In the movie, they really played up the fact that Jeff would catch rabbits for the family, either
Speaker 1to eat or to sell, and that's something that voy Ray was actually known for doing. That was kind of her. She just wandered the moors and go hunting for rabbits heirs. So it's kind of, you know, a no brainer that that's what Jeff was doing. But a lot of the phenomenon when it originally started occurring, was attributed to Jim So the father, and originally he was called he called Jeff Jack and was attempting to communicate it, to communicate
Speaker 1with the character. And I just think it's interesting because in the movie there was a lot more focus on the father, I think, and the less on voy Ray.
Speaker 5Yeah, she gets real light treatment, although they're quick to say, I mean, like from the very beginning they say in the movie that she is a skilled ventriloquist. And then you know from an again, as a writer, I think about this in terms of structure. If you're going to a movie about a talking mongoose, you're gonna see a talking mongoose, Like there's no chance that it's going to turn out to be entirely made up, like, I don't think it would be very hard to sell that, and
Speaker 5I don't think this.
Speaker 1Would be But.
Speaker 5I think they're doing a bait and switch whether they try to make you think, of course, here's the explanation, is this, it's the ventriloquist daughter. But then they quickly make it clear that nobody could be that good of a ventriloquist, right, that's the thing.
Speaker 1Yeah, I think they kind of straddle that line because you can't quite tell whether they're implying that that she is a skill of ventriloquist and that she is doing this, or whether that's separate to the fact that Jeff exists and he's a separate entity. So I think that was a little bit confusing, and you certainly had the assistant walking away thinking or believing that Jeff existed. We never actually see Jeff. We see like a bit of fur in the what is it like a barn or something,
Speaker 1where Jeff decides he's finally going to reveal himself to not only Fodor and the assistant but also other members of the community, and that he's phoning them up. He's making phone calls to members of the community and basically dishing secrets on them all. And as you say, Blake, that was that aspect was true that someone was going around gossiping, someone knew all of the town gossip and was spreading that through Jeff. So again, it kind of
Speaker 1reminds me of Marie Leva, who had all of these contacts and basically knew everyone in the community and had was dishing out of the gossip on everyone and kind of blackmailing people, and that was her real power, not psychic or voodoo abilities. And I think that that was what was going on. I don't know if that Jim was the source of this, Jim Irving, or if it was Voi Rey or the mother, because certainly in this h this movie, the mother is played up to be a gossip.
Speaker 6And it's slash astrologer or forts intelligence, you know.
Speaker 5Very interesting, right yeah. Oh, by the way, I remember, it's The Haunting of Alma Fielding Colon, a true ghost story by Kate Kate. That's the It's really a story about nandor Fodor's investigation of this famous British psychic case. And uh, it's it's a right. I found it. It was extremely well reviewed, but I found it extraordinarily frustrating. Because by the last third it's just constantly nandor photo
Speaker 5finding clear evidence of hoaxing and yet being ambiguous or uncommitted about whether or not it's a real case or not.
Speaker 1Yeah, and that's definitely the impression that I get as well about him that because his conclusions ultimately about Jeff were that mister Irving was behind everything and that he was suffering from some kind of you know, Freudian split personality. Yes, And you know, I have to say that psychology in those days and sometimes today, can be very pseudo scientific, so I think it's no surprise that he was kind of to use the term again straddling that line of
Speaker 1being scientific and at the same time being pseudo scientific. But I mean, you really get an impression from the movie too that everyone's kind of in on this joke or everyone in the family, including the farm hand, and that he doesn't believe in Jeff, but they're just you know, wanting to have fun. And again, I think this really brings in other cases of poltergeist activity like Enfield, the guy Ry Ghost. You know, we're not so much with Enfield.
Speaker 1We're not talking about like a an isolated town, but we're talking about I think bored young girls who are maybe going through some psychological issues, and so there's a lot of reason and cause there, I think for imagination to come to the fore and for people to come up with these stories, and then once they start getting attention from the media to really play into that, lean into that. And you know, with voy Ray, she for
Speaker 1her entire life maintained that Jeff existed. But if you have a look at the we can put this into the show notes. But it was an oral history. I came across from a woman named Kathleen Green who's now passed, but she was a friend of boy Rays and she'd gone over there with some friends to see the delby Spook and the experiences that she has. I mean, this is really interesting stuff. She talks for about five minutes about going over there, and it kind of reminded me
Speaker 1a little bit of this when she goes back to the house to go to the restroom and she overhears voy Ray supposedly talking to Jeff. And so it was a situation like that with this Kathleen who went over there with some friends and overheard the mother and voy Ray talking about what they were doing and kind of revealing that it was a prank, and then they stayed for a couple of hours and didn't witness any phenomena, but at the same time did see the mother kind
Speaker 1of pulling some pranks and things like that. So it just does seem like people on the island didn't actually believe that anything paranormal was taking place. And it is interesting that this garnished so much attention, I think worldwide, because I think this was really debunked very early on.
Speaker 3Well, it's such an absurd idea. I mean, it's just an absurd idea from the gag going no matter which way your slave. So whether you think it's a porter geist from India that's taken over a mongoose, or whether this mongoose is an earth spirit or whatever, or it's just a talking mongoose. Either way, it's just over the top. And how many people are you going to convince with this story? Well, and so it's remarkable that it has legs.
Speaker 5Yeah, it's the thing about the if you're gonna do a bit and you commit to it fully, like the honey out in Swamp Monster, pretty clearly a hoax. But Harlan, the guy who comes up with it, never breaks character, never stops acting like it's real, and that's enough for some people. Why would he lie or why would she lie? Why would anybody lie? You know, But at the same time, there is a tremendous amount of joy to be had
Speaker 5at pulling one over on somebody, and you get these you know, intellectual investigators coming over to have a look around, and you just keep pretending that there's a talking mongoose, very.
Speaker 1Similar to with the guyra ghost that the young girl was caught several times throwing rocks. Now, it might have been a pious fraud kind of situation too, where she was trying to prove to the investigators that this kind of thing was going on, and the humpty dew, which we need to definitely talk about at some point, Yes you have to do yep, but we certainly do see that kind of pious fraud, and I think that that
Speaker 1was taking place with this story, where you know, there might have been times where they faked the phenomena just to prove to whoever was there that this was going on, but then got caught doing that.
Speaker 5We've talked before on the show about you know, how powerful spiritualism was and theosophy was at this time period. It was huge in the United Kingdom and Great Britain in particular, and there were multiple psychic newspapers available, and we've talked about on the Harry Hans case. How you know a lot of that was Theosophus injecting stories into the newspapers and they were just like it was just a common thing that you would run into. It was extraordinarily common. And so it's a very rich ecosystem for
Speaker 5this kind of content and for a family that was formerly living in London and now lived in this rural island, you know, switching from sales to farming. It reminds me so much of the British series. I was trying to remember the name The Good Life, which was the British name for the BBC's sitcom starring Felicity Kendall and Richard Briers. In America, it was known as Good Neighbors when it ran on PBS, and I used to watch this with
Speaker 5my sister and we enjoyed it so much. But my memory failed me and I mangled the name into something unrecognizable. So I'm fixing it here. Sorry, Felicity, Well.
Speaker 2You can just shut up at the end you can just about and well shut up, because if you've got anything poet to say about Felicity Kendall, just about ante me fast.
Speaker 5Anyway, It's it's a couple that was a city.
Speaker 3Yeah, it was a city.
Speaker 5A city couple that moves out into the They want to become you know, farmers and live on the land, a very hippy sort of thing, and that that sort of in the green acres. You might think about that. It's it's a family of the city moving in a really remote rural environment.
Speaker 4Uh.
Speaker 5It's a place where you know, interacting with the locals and your family is the entertainment, you know, reading and that sort of thing. Yeah, it's a different time and and keeping yourself busy and you know, finding things to you know, to fill your life with a little bit of wonder Uh. You know, I can see lots of reasons why this would have been a fun thing to generate. I'm extraordinarily skeptical that there was actually a talking mongoose for a variety of scientific reasons. But it's still a
Speaker 5fascinating story, an interesting story. So I have to ask why was this movie so abominably dull?
Speaker 3Well, I want to want to ask you to explain. Explain this if you don't believe. What about the mongoos standing like a meerkat at the end of the movie, Explain.
Speaker 5That standing a lot like a mere cat. Yeah, that it's the it's the old turns out there was no ghost after all. You cut back to the hunted house and it ghost floats through the room and goes, whoa who me.
Speaker 3I really hate to you know this. This wasn't a great movie. It wasn't as bad as an episode of Ancient Aliens, but yeah, it wasn't a great movie in any sense, and I hate to compare it to two much better movies. But I I think you know, they were taking from some tropes in this, like the pious fraud aspect of her being caught doing such great ventriloquism reminded me a bit of ghost Watch when they were
Speaker 3caught when the girl was doing pious fraud really as a ghost. But since you guys are skeptic, I'm going to help this along. Ghost Watch was far superior, but there is that relationship there. And also at the same time, this this this uh uh sort of what would you call it. This was like a slam dunk of oh this is fake. When we're seeing her do this ventriloquism, you're like, okay, you're really questioning. Well, you're not even questioning, you know, Okay, this is this is all just fraud.
Speaker 3Reminds me of The Exorcist when basically he throws holy water on her and she reacts very violently and he's like, that was tap water.
Speaker 5This is fraud, gotcha.
Speaker 3Yeah, So you're kind of feeling, like early on on like oh, yeah, okay, she's not really possessed, and oh she really is. So it was kind of like, you know, why are they showing this so early that she's such a great ventriloquist. It's like they busted her right off the bat. And it just reminded me of those two movies of that kind of whoa, No, they didn't, they're just throwing you a curveball.
Speaker 1Yeah, they were trying to keep as gussing.
Speaker 3But just it wasn't done with the skill of the other two movies.
Speaker 5Let me say this, I am a huge fan of independent productions, and I know it's hard to make a movie, and so when you see somebody come together and they pull together the funding. This was a crowdfunded movie and they managed to get big stars. I mean, it's impressive. So I'm rooting for the film from the beginning. I love Jeff the talking mongoose, I want. I love the actors in this film. I love it's great names, it's
Speaker 5incredibly well shot, it's beautiful, like it's really nice color. It's like it's a very cozy film. Yet somehow, and I think this has to come down to the mak the writing it It doesn't engage, it never grabs me. It's I'm struggling to keep my attention on a movie about something I love in a field that I love, about characters that I love. And I just and I'm not mad. It's not it's not like it's so wildly inaccurate historically or anything.
Speaker 1It's just it just it was disappointing.
Speaker 5Yeah, I'm just disappointed that it wasn't more better. As my wife, we.
Speaker 1Feel, let me film it's the same way, and you know, because we love all the same things that you just expressed, and yet we were still a little disappointed. And I mean, part of me thinks it's because they tried to take that romance route, and because they took that comedy route, and at times that worked. When we're introduced to that fellow, the drunk in the pub, and we find it well, thanks you, then we find out he's the mayor. I thought that was really comical, and some of the things he did and said were comical. But perhaps there was
Speaker 1just too too much comedy in it for us to to really take this seriously as a paranormal thing of wonder. It was just too too silly and right.
Speaker 5And you call it an indoor photo and the talking mangos, you assume it's a comedy that like, because it's a very strange name. And I love Simon Pegg's acting, but his accent was quite peculiar.
Speaker 1It was all over the place. And the man servant as well, his his accent was all over the place.
Speaker 5Maurice or no, no, not Maurice, Errol, the neighbor the.
Speaker 1Yea, yeah, he was the farm hand, Yeah yeah.
Speaker 5I couldn't figure out what his role was it was he a farm hand? Was he a neighbor who was also a farmer. I didn't know, but he He and and the mini driver character are both they're created from nothing to be, you know, and I think the it is diversity, you know, adding ethnicity and gender more. You know, they could have used.
Speaker 1It wouldn't have been like that. They wouldn't have had him no, you know, in the house and having raspberry taunts with them and all of that stuff.
Speaker 5It was quite peculiar. It's very peculiar, you know. I And in a sense, I think the script is relying on sort of archetypes because they're not really doing a lot of character development. Yet. We don't have archetypes for a lot of these characters, so there's nothing to like, you're trying to draw this out real thin and let it, you know, let people's understanding of what kind of characters is fill in the blanks, and that these aren't they're not written that well. They're not written well enough to fall into that archetypal bucket so that we could just
Speaker 5take the ride. So yeah, if there's a dramatic arc, I guess it's supposed to be about nandor Fodor, you know, being confronted with something that he thinks is pure hokum and realizing no, no, no, there's something to this. Yet at the end they undermined that by having him still questioning despite the fact that he was literally, you know, clawed by this creature, right.
Speaker 1Yeah, But at the same time, was he still inebriated when that happened. And then you have the whole incident too with Jeff relaying the message from his father. Now that harkened back too to the Houdini case, and they implied that Best had once received the message from Houdini that he'd given to her before he passed, and that of course didn't happen either, but they kind of had parallels of that in this movie, that he was receiving a message from his father. What was it, I'll never
Speaker 1see you again?
Speaker 5Yes, yeah, yep.
Speaker 1And then that Jeff was somehow psychic and picking up all of these messages from other members of the community. And I think they really lent into that too hard because I just don't think that nandor Fodor had that experience, and you know that, because that certainly would have impacted him or a lot of people had they had something like that happen.
Speaker 5Yeah, I think this is sort of a case of Chekhov's trauma. Like if they were going to rely on the traumatic message from the father being a key dramatic turning point. Then they needed to give us a flashback or something so that we could know.
Speaker 1They didn't. They didn't.
Speaker 5They didn't really make that just like, oh my god, that's the thing that my father said, Well, that's not really that's not the same as we know that going in that he's still sort of dealing with the grief around the death of his father. Did you make the right you know?
Speaker 3So yeah, conversation with Harry Price, with him saying, I think you still just mister father.
Speaker 5It's just not enough.
Speaker 1I feel that was enough of a sinup for sure.
Speaker 5So I think not to be a jerk about Adam Siegel, I don't really know him that well. And but but it is extraordinarily funny because I was mad at the end of the film that I was I was mad that I was disappointed because I really wanted Jeff to get more of a really richer, deeper story that you know. I mean, I think there is there is a story here that I love and that's not what I saw. And there's a story potential here that would have been could have gone in a lot of ways that I
Speaker 5would have also have loved, and it wasn't that so I think I'm just generally disappointed by the whole thing. But Adam Siegel at the end, it's because it's a crowdfunded film. They do this extraordinary if I found it, very very funny thing where they're thinking everybody who contributed to the making the film, and they're like except for one person, and like it goes on to you finally realize they're talking about the director being just a terrible person. And I know it's a joke, but it's like, since I was kind of mad at the end of the film, I was like, yeah, okay, yeah, that's fair.
Speaker 1Yeah, but it was. I think it was great to see the story come to life that it was. There's something at a point now where the story's so popular. It was good to see it in a movie format. But yeah, I think it could have been executed better.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 3Well, I would get behind a crowd funded movie about Nandor the Relentless and Jeff the Mangos. I would get behind.
Speaker 1That that I would believe in.
Speaker 5I would also, I would, I would I would welcome an entire series about Nandor Fodo and investigations if they could do that.
Speaker 1But you know that, yes, yeah, I think that would be something worthy, Lauren.
Speaker 5That whole time period is just rich with interesting stories that sort of between the Wars period, just some fascinating characters and it. As a skeptical person, I'm not mad about that sort of vacillation between scientific rigor and you know, the wishing it was real kind of hope. I get it. I understand that that that pressure, and that's the kind of thing that makes for really good storytelling. Is that
Speaker 5is it real? Is it not? You know, do I believe? Do I not? These are really big questions, and they they they are very human questions.
Speaker 3Well we're you know, imagine nandor photo or in today's with today's technology, with the you know, super information Highway and everything, having access to so many different kinds of science at your fingertips. He didn't have any of that. So, you know, I think that you know, him trying to be skeptical. I think that he was on the right path in a time when spiritualism was really at its cheek. I think that I think he did. He did an outstanding job, and I think he would be a force
Speaker 3to be reckoned with in the skeptical community were he alive today.
Speaker 5He doesn't be really old. But yeah, but you know, we're not alone. This is not just a skeptic take. If you look at the reviews for the film, they're pretty brutal. And I recently listening to Ian Simmons being interviewed. He's the news editor at forty Times, and he was interviewed on chin Whack, which is hosted by Paul Giamadi, the actor, and Steven Asthma, who was a guest. We've had multiple times on Monster Talk talking about sort of
Speaker 5like monster studies, and they're talking to Ian Simmons and they mentioned this film and he was like, oh, yeah, that film was terrible. And so it's not just the skeptics who are mad about this. There's something fundamentally flawed with the film. I'm having a hard time putting my finger on what I think. It's just I think it's the not interesting enough, like it's just narratively not keeping my engagement. And I well, for me, it was that struggling.
Speaker 1For me, it was a crossing over the genre. You know, genre is the comedy romance. You know, what is it is this, you know, a historical portrayal of the case, or is this fictionalized account. So I think it was really all over the place that darted back and forth. There was some truth to it to parts of the story, and other things were fictionalized. So I think it was just that confusion for anyone who knows the story, I think, Yeah.
Speaker 3I think the filmmakers themselves didn't.
Speaker 5Yeah, that's also a that's really challenging as an indie developer, filmmaker, writer, director, you know. So Adam Siegel had a lot of a lot of hats and a lot of pressure to get this story out, and he worked on a long time. And so again I always commend people who managed to get something to the screen because it's hard, and I'm extraordinarily forgiving. But one thing I have a real hard time forgiving is being boring. And I just feel like there was so much material here that could have been better. But oh yeah, look at the photography, the lighting, the sets,
Speaker 5the costumes. All that was gorgeous. It's not a special effect. I think it feels like it wanted to be kind of a quirky Wes Anderson film. And this morning I couldn't help the stop. I kept thinking, oh, how about Les Anderson? Because it's not quite there. You know, I don't mean to be mean. I bet if I met Adam we'd have a fun time talking about this stuff, because he clearly cares about the material. But I think this one's a swing and a whiff. You know.
Speaker 3Well, for any listeners that want to watch the movie, go and watch a few episodes of Ancient Aliens first, and this will be such a relief.
Speaker 5Oh my god.
Speaker 4Yeah, absolutely, this background to what But that's the pickle ginger of this sushi meal, right, yeah, if you want to clear your palette.
Speaker 1First, Yeah, we can talk more about that.
Speaker 5Yeah, But.
Speaker 1Yeah, I I think it's good that it's keeping the story alive, and it's just another take on the tail.
Speaker 5And fluffy fluffy tail, yeah.
Speaker 1The fluffy dog for tail or whatever it was discovered to be from their sheep dog, which they do introduce to. I guess I'm going going back to the beginning of the film where they introduced the pets as well, But I think that that's kind of a nod to the the debunking of the story too. But again, it's a confusing thing.
Speaker 5Is a confusing film, but it's a confusing story. So I mean, you know, he pulled it together. He made it a cohesive narrative. I just I just am sort of I'm struggling to understand why I couldn't love it, because, like, boy, you put all the right ingredients, but maybe the wrong proportions, or maybe you don't bake it enough. Something's wrong with this movie.
Speaker 3Well here's one thing that's I know, there's a lot of things. Here's one thing that I know got under your skin because it got undermine and Karen's. And that's Phudini's widow. The first psychic she spoke to gave her the code.
Speaker 1Oh, I said that earlier. I don't know if you heard that.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, but that's that's you know, to me, one of the really huge faults in it is they took this, this real life character and so blatantly lied about a very important thing, you know, because that was the whole thing, is that nobody could give the code, and they made it the first person gave the code, and that that just like kind of ruined everything.
Speaker 5Well just from you don't remember the details, But I have a recollection. I probably should I should probably do an answer here where I actually fact checked myself. But my recollection is that later in life, Bess got involved with someone who like sort of coaxed out the answer and then pretended to be contacting, you know, as Houdini. And then ultimately that didn't really like it wasn't really proof because it was clearly compromised. But I might be
Speaker 5misremembering that, So I'll edit that out or replace it with it.
Speaker 1Yeah, I don't. I don't think that that's it completely rip, but let's do a show on that. I think we should do a show.
Speaker 5Yeah, you know, you know Joe Nichol used to do an annual Houdini seance. I don't know. I don't think he still does those, but they used to know he's still doing that.
Speaker 1But yeah, it was something about Rosa bell I had I.
Speaker 3Had done a joint Houdini seance with was it with the j REF? I believe years ago. I think it was twenty eleven. Uh, and we didn't get the code either.
Speaker 1So yeah, we should wrap this up, I guess in the end.
Speaker 5I love the story of Jeff's talking Mungo's, but if you want my opinion, this movie can be safely skipped.
Speaker 1I think it's worth watching, you know, having a bowl of popcorner drink with something and just if you've left the story.
Speaker 3I stopped drinking.
Speaker 1It was still still worth watching to me, but it just missed the mark for me.
Speaker 3Matt your thoughts, Yeah, yeah, no.
Speaker 1Very Australian.
Speaker 5They have it, they have it all right. Well, we'll see you again in seven days. Thanks for listening to mons. You've been listening to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stoltner. You just heard a discussion of the twenty twenty three film Nandor Fodor and the Talking Mangos. A link to the film will be in the show notes, along with links to our previous episode on the allegedly true story upon which the film is based, plus other stuff relevant to this topic.
Speaker 5We hope you enjoyed this episode of Monster Talk. Our goal here is to bring you the best in monster related content with the focus on scientific skepticism and critical thinking. If you enjoy our show and want to support our mission, start out by visiting monster talk dot.
Speaker 6Org forward slash support. That's monster talk dot org forward slash Support. There you'll find links to our Patreon page, as well as a donate button if you'd like to just make a one time contribution. A great way to support the show is to buy books from our Amazon wish list.
Speaker 5These are books that directly help with our monster research. We love used books very much, so don't feel compelled to buy new ones, and we're also very fond of kindle editions because of their easily searched content and without spending any money at all. You can support and raise the profile of the show by leaving a positive review at iTunes or wherever you get your podcasts. Positive reviews help keep us visible in iTunes, which is a great way to help us find new listeners. Finally, remember to share episodes you really like with your friends and family.
Speaker 5You can help make Monster Talk the nightlight that keeps monsters away from someone you love. Monster Talks theme music is by Pete Stealing Monkeys.
Speaker 1I have not seen it at Extra Extra Clever Mungus.
Speaker 1This has been a Monster House presentation.
Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...
Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...
Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...
🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...
Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...