Today we're discussing the strange story of The Houdini Seance and Arthur Ford the Spiritualist. The last Houdini Seance (1936) - Audio + Story Bess Houdini Arthur Ford - Spiritualist Arthur Ford - Obituary The Houdini Code The Bishop James Pike Was Pike Seance Hoax? The Skeptics Dictionary: Arthur Ford Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Monster House presents.
Speaker 2Around the world. People report monsters, but are they real? Join the detective of the impossible, Joe Nickel as he walks you through investigations to reveal often surprising natural explanations behind some of the most famous cryptids and legendary animals ever reported. Using scientific skepticism, meticulous field work in historical deep dives, Joe Nichols seeks out hidden clues and real world candidates that sometimes reveal that even the most unlikely monster stories may have a basis in reality. The Science
Speaker 2of Monsters is the first book from Monster House LLC, the publisher of science shows, Monster Talk and in research of The revised edition is now on sale and includes corrections and suggestions from you, our listeners and now readers. Sales of The Science of Monsters directly benefits Monster House and its podcasts thanks to the generosity of its author. Pick up The Revised Science of Monsters today at Amazon dot com, available in paperback and kindle editions.
Speaker 1It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before.
Speaker 3A giant, very creature Part eight, Part mat in Luckness, a twenty four mile long bottomless lake in the Highlands of Scotland, it's a creature known as the Luckness Monster
Speaker 3Monster Talk.
Speaker 2Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner. Hey, they're Monster Talkers. I'm running a little bit late this week because the episode ended up having several inserts and edits that I forgot that I would have to do, so my time to write a lengthy intro ran off without me. Anyway, I think this episode will speak for itself and then some, so let's just hit the monster. Okay, Welcome to Monster Talk.
Speaker 1We're joined by Matt Baxter again.
Speaker 2Hey Matt, how's it going. Happy New Year? You too.
Speaker 1You sound like you're in the bathroom.
Speaker 2I might be, Oh yeah, Matt's got some audio issues, but he sounds He's clear. It's just the echoey sound is well.
Speaker 1Blake, what are we talking about today? Because this is a kind of convoluted, complicated topic, but one that we've touched upon before.
Speaker 2Yeah, we've kind of talked about this a little bit, but there's there's always been this. This a dindom at the end. So we're gonna be talking a little bit about the history of what they call the Whudi. Any seance, and uh, we're going to lightly remind everybody who who Deni was, although he seems to be one of those dead people who remained famous. I mean like he really has been such a big figure historically that somehow I think the kids still know Whodini, right, they still know who it.
Speaker 1Was, especially among a group of people.
Speaker 2Oh yeah, but we're hardly the kids anymore.
Speaker 4Speaking for myself, well, I just want to start by saying that I was amused when you raised this topic and you set up a Google doc or maybe a month or two ago, and then I said to you, look, we really do need to revisit this topic of Whodini and Ford.
Speaker 1When do you want to talk about this? And you were absolutely perplexed. And then I realized you thought I was talking about Henry.
Speaker 2I sure did. Exactly. I was like, what does who Deni have to Did he escape from a Ford car? Yeah?
Speaker 1Exactly, Probably some connection there. There's probably something going on.
Speaker 2There inhabiting history at the same time.
Speaker 1Yeah, they might have crossed parts. But no, you were referring to another gentleman by the name of Arthur Ford.
Speaker 2Right, exactly. He was a psychic or spiritualist. I guess is what he really should be called.
Speaker 1Yeah, and medium clavoyant.
Speaker 2He kept popping up in my research for different reasons, and I really it always goes like this. Okay, Houdini dies, and then before he dies, he and his wife had made this arrangement that if it was possible to do so, he would send a message from the other side, because you know, much of his career he had spent debunking fake mediums and spiritualists.
Speaker 1And in general.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, and so you know, if it was possible to reach across the other side having a coded message, you know, not entirely scientific, but a really cool.
Speaker 1Idea, the great idea. Yeah, and lots of potential flaws, which leads us to, yeah, we talk about this today exactly.
Speaker 2So you actually said what inspired this episode? And I guess it was because in addition to his normally showing up during our ghosts and seance investigations and like historically looking at these cases, and he was very prominent in Scientific America and other magazines trying to get to the bottom of whether this stuff was real or not. This Ford character also shows up in relationship to a guy,
Speaker 2the Bishop Pike, who is a prominent religious figure in the nineteen sixties.
Speaker 1So he is a bishop. His name wasn't just bishop right right?
Speaker 5Right?
Speaker 2No, no, exactly, Yeah, James Pike. And James Pike's son die. I guess we'll get into the details of that, but he his son dies. So James Pike was this famous, very progressive religious figure, and when his son died to suicide, sadly, Pike was really despondent, and Arthur Ford reached out to him and said that he could help him make a connection, and they did a seance on television. It was like
Speaker 2a big deal. It was very controversial, and Pike got into trouble with his church, and which was not unusual. He was very much an outspoken figure and so ultimately though that became one of the well known things about Bishop Pike. But the other thing about Bishop Pike was Philip K. Dick was absolutely obsessed with him, the writer who gave us Blade Runner and all these other great stories do Androy Stream of Electric Sheep. I'm a big
Speaker 2fan of Philip K. Dick's writing. As much as I do enjoy the movies based on his work. His writing to be extraordinary, and I actually have to dole it out in doses because it's like, if I read it too much, it kind of puts me in an altered mental state and it feels like I'm tripping. I don't know. It's very weird stuff.
Speaker 1So well, and he was he was obsessed with this Bishop Punt.
Speaker 2Yeah, he really mean, Philip K. Dick was a weird guy himself. You know what, we probably do another episode on that because just a quick answer here, I had just finished reading High Weirdness by Eric Davis, which is about Terrence mckinna, Philip K. Dick, and Robert Anton Wilson and psychedelics in California in the nineteen seventies. So I've actually reached out to Eric to see if you'll come on our show and talk about that book. But I wanted to clear that up because I's sort of rambled about that for a bit here. Anyway, we'll get well, we'll just put that on the back burner that will
Speaker 2be coming around because of this sounds interesting. Yeah, it's really good. It's a good read. But this whole thing with Udini, you know, we're skeptical people. I mean how many times I mean, I know, Joe Nicol carried on the seances. They were always done on Halloween night because.
Speaker 1Kind of tradition. Yeah yeah, yeah, and for fun as well entertainment purpose.
Speaker 2It's a nice spooky thing. But you know, Houdini did die on October thirty first, so there's some sort of it. Slady puts the sort of bow on this spook chronicitys right.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 5I just wanted to say that the knight that Karen and I met face to face, we embarked on a who sands, oh wow, it is kind of this is all coming full circle for me.
Speaker 1It's all coming together. So yeah, it's it's just quite as a sort of complicated story. So Matt and I were doing a little bit of research into Arthur Fordham. We were kind of confused by some of the things that we read that implied that he had formerly been a magician and then become a psychic, which says he's one of these kind of of eyes open psychics who kind of manipulate, manipulative and knows what he's doing. But we just wonder if maybe that isn't the land that
Speaker 1has been presented on Wikipedia.
Speaker 5Yeah, yeah, see, and that's where we were seeing this was Wikipedia was kind of implying that he became a professional hot and cold reader, is what it said, and they referenced his biography, which says nothing about that.
Speaker 2Okay, I'm making another quick editorial injection here. We got into a little bit of a spicy discussion about editing on Wikipedia. It's a very important topic to me and what I'm pretty feisty about. But I decided to edit this bit out for now because I want to address it more formally and hopefully more productively in a future conversation. I'll just say that while I do appreciate the intent of skeptical people who try to keep Wikipedia from becoming another place, there's still massive room for improvement and how those editors engage with people who disagree with them. Please
Speaker 2don't try to read into this about any particular group or person. My ideas in this are still nebulous, but I know that there's room for improvement. The reason we were having discussion was because the entry implied that Arthur Ford was a stage magician who then gave that up to become a spiritualist, which is a very strong accusation. But the article didn't properly cite the source for it, and the way that it's written, it would be very easy for someone to think that the source was supposed to be Forg's biography, which was not the case. The
Speaker 2actual source of that information is a stage magic publication called The Sphinx, and in nineteen twenty four, the following entry comes under a section called Massachusetts News. At at Whole Massachusetts, mister Arthur A. Ford, the Chautauqua Superintendent, delivered one of the finest talks on magic that I have ever heard, mister Forest talk was given dear and the intermission in mister Henry's program. Now the Spiritualist. Arthur Ford's full name was Arthur Augustus Ford, and he was born
Speaker 2in eighteen ninety six and died in nineteen seventy one. And it's possible that this article really is talking about the future Spiritualist, but I don't think there's enough there to prove the case at any rate. I didn't change the text on the Wiki article, but I did track down a copy of the journal and bought it for five bucks to verify whether the wording in that nineteen twenty four publication really said what was cited. So satisfied that this much is true, I added a link to the source in the wiki article, so that at least that step will be easier for future researchers. Can anyone
Speaker 2validate that Arthur A. Ford the Magician went on to become Arthur A. Ford, the noted spiritualist. I don't know, but it's not a case that I have time to pursue myself right now, So let's just get back to our discussion.
Speaker 5Yeah, go ahead, turn.
Speaker 1Oh, it just really does seem as though he ordered to be a psychic, although he did indeed use hot reading, so hot reading read read cheating. So it was really interesting that he had all of these bound poetry books, and within those he had clippings of obituaries and just newspaper clippings, and so he was collecting information, which is what psychics used to do in the day. Sometimes they even used to share information that.
Speaker 2They Yeah, the Psychic Mafia book talks about that quite a bit.
Speaker 1Yeah, absolutely, Yes, it seems like he was a part of that shtick and gathering information on people, and so he did it. It appears use cold reading, but wouldn't have labeled it thus, and did use hot reading, but wouldn't have labeled it thus either. So he truly claimed to be.
Speaker 5Yeah, the biography is very pro board.
Speaker 2There was an article on from Skeptical Inquiry that talked about Ford and said that even in the biography they admitted there had been hoaxing, but ultimately came down that he was legit.
Speaker 1Which as fraud. Then he had to hoax to prove.
Speaker 2That is such a it's it's such a different way to approach this stuff to be able to well, they're usually real, but occasionally they would cheat, you know, uh, you know that that's yeah, that that kind of we talk about that showing up in poultry guyst cases as well, where like well there's a lot of pressure perform, you know, and then like sometimes that you know, they'll just try to keep things.
Speaker 1Moving, but the rest of it is real. Yeah, And being found with throwing rocks at the house.
Speaker 5Yeah yeah, Poulter guyst case for the pious fraud there is usually done by children.
Speaker 2Yes, yeah, which yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1And then people like Padre as well.
Speaker 5Right, so yeah, not a far stretch, but we'll just leave that there.
Speaker 2Well, it bucks me because I mean it's a different epistemology. It's a different way to understand what's real and what's not real because for us, I think it's speaking only for myself, you know, as when if I see someone cheating, I lose my ability to trust the things I can't confirm, you know, like I just I no longer trust credibility. Yeah, it literally poisones the well for me. It's it's it doesn't mean that everything they do for the rest of
Speaker 2their life is hoax, but it means that anytime they're making extraordinary claims, I have to think, well, we know, at least sometimes when they needed to perform something miraculous, they didn't pull it from the ether. They pulled it from their butt. And that's not.
Speaker 1Can you trust them now right?
Speaker 2It's like it really makes it difficult for me to trust them. But what I find extraordinary about this is I had never really dug in to actually go back to the source material and see, you know what happened and I guess so. Houdini dies in nineteen twenty six. Ford is a spiritualist pastor. He has a Spiritualist church, and he starts sending messages to Udini's widow, Bess No No through through connections like he sends them via friends.
Speaker 2But that is a funny joke. Sorry for not laughing, is funny.
Speaker 5Why why wasn't it telepathically that's the big question.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, because later on it was right.
Speaker 2Yeah, well I'll take that that actually because well I don't want to spoil it, but like it really is funny to me. So what happens is on February eighth, nineteen twenty eight, apparently he sends a message that he claims this is kind of convoluted, but apparently it was a message that Houdini's mother was supposed to give to Houdini from the other side, a sort of similar arrangement, and that was the word forgive. Now, whether that was a real message or not, it just shows up a newspaper article saying that he had previously contacted her. But by January the ninth, they do this big seance and
Speaker 2they have a story. It's like a press release and everything. It's a big deal. It's on the front page of newspapers all around the country saying that Arthur Ford had provided best Hardini this message that was coded and from the other side. And I mean it's a big story. It's a multi page story, and it goes all over the place. Immediately people who knew Houdini say, well, that's ridiculous. You know that, No, this is a hoax of some sort. You know, they didn't do this under any kind of
Speaker 2scientific controls. It's just best suddenly saying this happened. Now, she had been injured a few weeks before, or maybe a month before. She had hurt her back, and so some people argue that she was, you know, on paid medication, or that she might have started drinking. She was definitely grieving the loss of her husband. She may have had financial trouble. There's lots of things alleged. A couple of days after, just very quickly, another Taboli newspaper comes out
Speaker 2and says that Ford hoax the whole thing, that he confessed this hoax to this reporter, and that there were ear witnesses. She basically had two people in the apartment hidden listening to the whole conversation, and that what they were actually going to do is a press tour with him and Bess going out and saying that you know, this is confirming spiritualism, confirming contact from the other side. Now,
Speaker 2Ford then denies that that's the case. There's a whole lot of huha back and forth about whether it's real or not. Best continues to say it's real well into the summer. And now I don't know exactly when she starts to retract it, but I do know that by the next year, by January the next year, she has said publicly that you know, that's not the case. She admits that the silence of death is impenetrable. And you know, she continues to host annual seances all the way up
Speaker 2to nineteen thirty six, and for that final one when she decides she's no longer going to continue this. They made a big radio to do about it, and there's recordings of it. So I'll try to stick some audio in here so you can hear kind of what that was like if you're a radio listener back in nineteen thirty six.
Speaker 6Ladies and gentlemen, in this cathedral like atmosphere, tonight, I wish to remind you that this is a most solid occasion for the close friends that have gathered here, that the zero hour of an anniversary of our departed friend is fast nearing the end, and that the results of tonight are primarily of a personal and private nature. Know
Speaker 6what tempt is being made to sway the world or to convince the skeptics one way or the other.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean so many questions that are unanswerable. I guess at this point, do we know if the Houdini's had anything to do with Ford when Harry Houdini was still alive.
Speaker 2Yeah, I don't think so, not that I was able to find. That's a really good question for me. I'll follow up if I find anything else, I'll put that in as an insert or put it in the show notes.
Speaker 1Yeah. And it just seems to me like there are so many possible reasons why she gave credence to this story. I mean, it does sound like she did change sides temporarily. Yeah, but we don't know that the reasons for this and what was driving that.
Speaker 2We'll have some cool links in the show notes if you're interested in learning more about this. Because the code that they used he and best Ues was one that they used during their mind reading act when they were sharing the stage together, and the ultimate message it was very personalizes. But here's the thing. Apparently, and I don't know why she would have done this, but apparently she had published information about the code in a book, and
Speaker 2the skeptical response back.
Speaker 1Then was it was a bound poetry book.
Speaker 2Well, I don't think it was about poetry book, but it was a book about Houdini, and there was another there was a bio about it as well, and I just I don't know why she would have published that at all. So I haven't found a copy of that online anywhere. I'm going to just see if I could track down what that was about exactly. But so their point being that Ford had ways of getting the information and basically may have actually been working for effect an entire year to sort of get this uh solved, so
Speaker 2that when he actually met with her, he already knew the answer.
Speaker 1That's some lead up time, isn't it. And since we know you for.
Speaker 2Reading, yes, yeah, no, that to me, that's the it's absolutely the most plausible explanation was And there here's the other thing. She was having financial difficulty. More than one person has alleged that she had by this point developed a drinking problem. He had a drinking problem. He had had a car crash and had, if I understand correctly, a morphine addiction and some alcohol issues. I mean, so these things happened, and this is not a moral problem, But I mean, it can affect your judgment severely if
Speaker 2you're under the influence or you know, if you are desperate for money or all these things can Like if this was going to be like the bo it does, doesn't it. And the other thing was in the reading about this was that, you know, his colleagues were like, well, you know, best was never that much into the spiritual debunking the way you know his other friends were in colleagues like, you know, she was his wife and you know, she was his partner and confidant and all those things. But maybe she was more open to this possibly, I don't know.
Speaker 1You know, yeah, well I think even just the kind of parallel that they both had issues with drinking. Yeah, I wonder if they weren't closer. I mean that the suggestions that they had a relationship.
Speaker 2Yeah, yes, exactly, that's exactly a relationship.
Speaker 1That was a genuine clearing of my throat. But you could certainly construe it that way too, if you like, it's a little little suss that.
Speaker 2Yeah, it is, but I mean, absolutely that is. It's so funny you say that because I again, I've heard so many people say this. I've heard people say it on stage. I've heard people say it in conversations, but I really couldn't find anything substantive to support that idea. Now now it's been a minute, right, so it's not like we can go to her Facebook page to see her relationship status change.
Speaker 1It's complicated.
Speaker 2It is very complicated.
Speaker 1Well, was there an age difference between them? I mean it must have been.
Speaker 2Oh, he would have been yeah, she had been a little older. I mean, Houdini died at age fifty two. This was Arthur's Ford. He was young ish, he was a young guy. I mean, I don't have the date. I'll do an insert here and put their exact ages. So here's the insert. Ford was born January eighth, eighteen ninety six. This event took place January ninth, nineteen twenty nine, so he turned thirty four just the day before this event.
Speaker 2And Bess Houdini, she was born in eighteen seventy six. At the time that this takes place, she's just fourteen days before turning fifty four, so there's about a twenty year gap. But also you can see that he was a Capricorn and she was an Aquarius. So you know, I had to actually go to pretty ridiculous research to make that joke accurate. Back to the show, But my understanding was he was a young, handsome man, young, you know, and charismatic pastor. I mean, you know, so who knows,
Speaker 2But he continued to be a preacher and to lead his spiritual flock for a long time. He didn't die until seventy one and.
Speaker 1So recent to me.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, for real, And for him to have spent a career doing this sort of thing, I don't know. I again, having read The Psychic Mafia, I find all that and so many takedowns on spiritualism, you know, and I understand that it's some people's faith, right, but it's all also rife with historically fraudulent behavior. So this yeah, yeah, well, and you know billet reading and you know it's hot reading,
Speaker 2like so many things go on. It's just it's really i'd say farcical. But you know, when people lose a loved one, I mean you look at Conan Doyle. I mean, his faith and spiritualism never wavered towards the end of his life. I mean, you know, just it's just when he gets you, that's what you believe, you know, And.
Speaker 5You know, if you've got if you have the loss of the loved one, you really needed to be true because you're so feeling so desperate.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 5So on the flip side of whether she was an alcoholic that was wanting a younger guy, on the flip side, she was still in pain, yeah, exactly, so, you know, and she needed this to be true.
Speaker 2So I don't know that certainly makes sense to me. But if it was in her financial best interest, I mean a few weeks before this happened, I guess we should mention the cash prize. There was a cash prize.
Speaker 1Oh okay, there's the incentive.
Speaker 2Well yeah, maybe, but it never really happens. So there was a twenty one thousand dollars prize from a magazine, and there was a ten thousand dollars prize from the Hoodiny estate. And so if someone were able to prove this was real effectively, they had a potential you know, thirty one thousand dollars prize in nineteen twenty nine. That's a lot of money.
Speaker 1Right from his estate. So that wasn't hers, Well it's hers, but she ends up state.
Speaker 2She withdraws the reward weeks before Ford shows up with this message. So I don't know why, like there's no explanation for why. But it turns out that she's pulled the prize. So at least ten thousand dollars is not eligible. And that's front. I guess to me, Lynn's some credence that maybe she was having financial issues at that point, like maybe she didn't want that money.
Speaker 1It's a lot of money for that time.
Speaker 2It really is. In October of twenty nine, it'll become a lot of money. You get that little stock market crash and suddenly the world changes significantly. Holy cow. So purchasing power of ten thousand in nineteen twenty nine is about one hundred and eighty thousand dollars today. Wow, So thirty one thousand dollars is substantial? Is substantial? Yeah, that is a that's a lot of money. That money has
Speaker 2not been claimed. So if you do contact from Houdini and can prove it, some of that money still out.
Speaker 1I don't think we mentioned the code word, did we. I think we know let conversation.
Speaker 2No, do you want to talk about that?
Speaker 1Yeah, wasn't it?
Speaker 5It was a Rosea Bille Rosebud was a sled.
Speaker 2That's exactly right, Roosevelt answered, tell prey. The message was believe Roosevelt Believe.
Speaker 1That's it.
Speaker 2That's it. It was a code. It was a really strange code where it's like answer tell, pray, answer look tell answer answer Tell. And then her wedding ring had the word roose bel And then she has this song. In fact, she used to sing the song in their act and at the seance. This is really sick if it's a hoax. At the seance forwards asking her what is the meaning of this phrase, like after he explains it to her, it gives her the message. She just starts singing the song with tears in her eyes, which is really heartwarming and sad.
Speaker 1Uh you know that is well, yeah, it just seems to me, like you know that it would be a pretty easy password to guess. Yeah, And I don't know exactly what information would have needed to be given, but if he is this expert hot breader and cold reader, I think just with the combined bits and pieces.
Speaker 2And I saw something implying that the article had been written ahead of time before the seance happened, which is pretty crazy, like if that's true. Yeah, So again, there is a lot of weird claims within just a few days in the newspapers about this. So it's very much a controversial incident right up at the moment that it happens, and continues to be and then again by January the following year, Bess has said that she didn't hear from her husband, but I have yet to find any written
Speaker 2statement from her explaining what's going on. It's more like she just went quiet and let Houdini's friends and colleagues run defense for her, is what.
Speaker 1It feels like, right, Yeah, it just seems like the mold than meets the eye with his story is Yeah, it makes we know.
Speaker 2Like a lot of the explanations that would make sense to me would not look good for best. And I don't think anybody wants to know detegrate her.
Speaker 1I'm thinking that too. Yeah, I'm just.
Speaker 2Wondering how the grieving widow crushing the hopes of the grieving widow not a good look.
Speaker 1Yeah. Well, but you know, I think this has to the life has to be shown on board in that case. You know, if that is true, then really she was vulnerable and he's he's to blame exactly.
Speaker 2And again I think what happened with later on with Arthur Ford and Bishop Pike certainly comes across his crass as exploitative and just taking what is the common skeptical think grief vampires, you know, like the idea that these are people who basically they extract cash from people who were sad and that is.
Speaker 1No conscience.
Speaker 2Yeah, and I don't want that to be the case, but I know too many times it is. You know, I know there are some people out here who are you know, they self you know, I what's the word? They see themselves as psychic and they're trying to help, right, And then there's other people who it is a business and they are heartless and you know, trying to figure out of the Yeah, they sure do. They sure do, Boy don't they. A lot of them get TV shows, and it's just sickening because on TV what do they do.
Speaker 2They play you know, sad music, and they you know, they really you know, ham it up to make.
Speaker 5It like at it.
Speaker 2Exactly. So, I mean it's just a lot of editing. It's just it's very disingenuous. And I know the people who do TVs it was just entertainment.
Speaker 3What is it?
Speaker 2What's the harm? Well, I'll tell you the harm is stripping the cash for people who no longer have income. I mean, like it's just not good. It's really bad, you know, like whether you're taking their insurance money or their fixed income or maybe they're rich, it doesn't matter, taking people's money and offering them hope when there's nothing there.
Speaker 1Well, oh, just lying to people, destroying their memories.
Speaker 2You on so many levels, and again we're just talking about psychic's here. Definitely, definitely never talking about religions, you know.
Speaker 5Blake, I see that you you found a tremendous number of newspaper articles about this, and they almost are universally skeptical, and I think that's really interesting. Did you see much in the way of hey, it's it's true, it's you know, psychic phenomena has been proven.
Speaker 2No, did you see I mean, I'll tell you two things that really struck me as funny. One was there was a woman who said in this really really literally made me laugh out loud. She was saying, well, we're not really sure that Ford spoke to the other side because he might have been using telepathy to read best his mind. I was like, you're right, right, of course, because we.
Speaker 1Don't actually yeah, yeah, I mean, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2It's very it's a very sci fi take, right, So telepathy that's science, right, but spiritualism that's nonsense. But the other one was the Catholic Church was not like the Pope or anything, but like there was a Catholic magazine that posted an article talking about it was definitely a hope, which just amused the hell out of me. Yeah.
Speaker 5So yeah, Well it's interesting because I was looking at some of these articles that you had sent over. In one of them the I think it was the Minnesota Star.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, that.
Speaker 5One was interesting on a several different several different levels. One the typos gorgeous. I mean, it's like the very first quote, no professional psychologist or psychiatrist of standing believes in the existence of spirits revealing themselves through mediums until every possible explanation based on the functioning of the nervous system has been exploded. Wow, instead of explored.
Speaker 2That's so weird. You know the spell check would have turned that red.
Speaker 5Yeah, yes, or at least, you know, squiggily underneath it.
Speaker 2There were so many things I love looking at a newspapers and again, I we do this show out of love, but people do support us on Patreon, which I'm extraordinarily thankful for which allows me to have a newspaper's subscription to newspapers dot.
Speaker 1Com to ask you what you used to.
Speaker 2So I go to all these old newspapers all the time, and I was absolutely delighted and shocked that while looking at one of these stories, the adjacent story was about the Pennsylvania heckxing murders, which we talked about before, where the guy, one of the Pennsylvania Dutch people, thought that his neighbor was hexting him and we talked with Jerry Drake about this and ended up murdering the suspected, which
Speaker 2this has to do with like the Long Lost Friend, and it became this big national news story because suddenly people realized people were still practicing folk magic in Pennsylvania, and so some of it was kind of like laughing at the Rubes, but it's also it sort of made The Long Lost Friend kind of a notorious book for a bit, and it's it's hardly notorious, but that was how it was kind of played up in the in the papers.
Speaker 1Wow, well we've covered a little ground.
Speaker 2It's a crazy, nebulous story. Houdini he debunked a lot of people. Yet he became the sort of center of this big question. And the cool thing about it is, as much as possible, he and scientists and even a lot of the you know, purported psychics participated in what they tried to make as scientific as possible inquiries into the survival of consciousness or spirit or life or intelligence after death. And I appreciate the efforts and I appreciate
Speaker 2the continued efforts as people try to seriously look into this, but it's a tough slog. It's hard to falsify or prove one way or the other. And it's also rife with fraud and cashing out and people people make a lot of money taking and I think take advantage of this. And so we live in times when there's probably bigger issues going on. But somebody's got to look out about this stuff. I mean, somebody really needs to be out there, because when you're in the middle, when it's you who are grieving, if someone comes to you making claims that
Speaker 2they're talking to your dead relative, if you're not already fortify with information about this, it's really easy to succumb to hoaxing and trickery. And it's just it's sad true.
Speaker 1Well, I was just going to say, I think the fact that these beliefs are still around today, that there are mediums and channelers and psychics and clairvoyance, et cetera, who purport to be able to communicate with the dead, that they, as we said, they've got TV shows that we're about to go into more uncertainty and uncertain times. I think that society is going to continue to be right with this kind of thing. So I think it's very on point.
Speaker 2Yes, absolutely, thank you. Yeah.
Speaker 5I wanted to mention really quickly that Ford had an opportunity to debate magician Howard Thurston. Now, in the biography Forward's biography it says that he just basically hummeled Howard Thurston in this debate, and just you know, there was just no doubt about it. But Time magazine, however, had
Speaker 5it in a slightly different light, and the quote from Thirst and I think is kind of important right now. See, the quote was that that brought first into this debate was that he had been quoted as saying that he could do anything with a watch size instrument that mediums say they have done with supernatural power. So Ford contested this and wanted him to come a debate and thirst and said I was quoted incorrectly. All spiritualistic phenomena cannot
Speaker 5be reproduced with a small watch. It says there is an intelligent psychic force which can manifest itself, but everything done at a stated time and for money is likely to be trickery. Now, if you pull that apart a little bit, he's basically saying, it's not that that I'm saying psychic force doesn't exist, because I don't know, you know, it's you can't say whether or not psychic force exists. But if someone is saying that they can do it
Speaker 5at a specific time and for money, you're being fooled. Yeah, and I think that that's just still true today.
Speaker 2I mean, it's all there's certain things we could say every time we cover some of these topics. If you're going to a fortune teller, for example, and they tell you you've been cursed and that the way you can get rid of it is to like burn a thousand dollars, guess what you're about to see a very funny magic trick where they take the ten thousand and burn nothing.
Speaker 5But was that what that was?
Speaker 1Yeah?
Speaker 2I mean, there's just so many examples of this where it just being forewarned is helpful, right, But again, when you're sad, when you're in the grief situation, or maybe when you're in a financially desperate situation. I don't know, I I mean, yeah, it's just it's just it's I think there's so many other explanations besides that Houdini, you know, uh did this communication. But it is, it is it has complicated his legacy for sure, because this cloudy, muddy
Speaker 2question of what exactly happened there. Uh, it sits out. There is a sort of a stain on you know, on the whole record, on the whole story.
Speaker 6You know.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's it's very complicated and very messy and very disappointing. And uh you know the fact that the next nine years after this best continues to say that it didn't happen. Uh, it doesn't remove this weird blip where she said it did. So. But I think this has been interesting to look.
Speaker 1Into, and it certainly has, and if more comes to life, we can revisit it.
Speaker 2Yeah, there's a lot. It's a very I don't know what the right word is. It's as muddy and cloudy of a case as I've ever looked at yet to have such prominent people involved with it, like nobody has done a definitive look timeline. Here's exactly what happened and when and why? You know? That's just.
Speaker 1I think it'd be an interesting.
Speaker 2Not it would definitely be. The pieces are out there, spread across many newspapers and probably several books, but I don't think I've come across anything that just breaks it down and here's exactly what happened, or is there. I got to thinking, while I was editing the show, how would I have researched this before search engines stopped working for anything other than retail. So I checked my books on my bookshelf for primary sources or solid secondary sources.
Speaker 2No luck. But that made me think of a site that I hadn't looked at in ages, but it's thankfully still out there doing its good work. I remembered the late Robert Todd Carroll site, The Skeptic's Dictionary. So I went there and I searched, and sure enough I found a bunch of info. Now I'm not going to read the whole article to you, but I think mister Carroll's site gets the meat of the matter, summarized in a cogent and more comprehensive way than I was managing to so listen now, as a living skeptic channels the voice
Speaker 2of a dead skeptic, or at least where a living one reads the words of a dead one to you from beyond the grave. Thank you, mister Carroll. Houdini died on Halloween in nineteen twenty six. His wife Beatrice or Bess, offered ten thousand dollars to anyone who could produce an authentic message from the spirit of her husband. Every Halloween for the next ten years, she held a seance, hoping in Vain for Houdini's spirit to turn up. Fletcher, the Reverend Ford's spirits guide, claimed to get the message forgift,
Speaker 2not from Houdini, but from Houdini's mother. On February eighth, nineteen twenty eight, Bess wrote Ford that her husband had awaited in Vain all his life for that word from his mother. However, Ford's message need not have come from the spirit world, since Bess had told a reporter for The Brooklyn Eagle in nineteen twenty seven that Houdini had longed to hear from his mother and that any authentic communication would include the word forgive. In January nineteen twenty nine, Ford crony friends his fast, claimed that he had brought
Speaker 2word to Missus Houdini that Ford was ready to crack the secret code. She was not in the best of health, however, she had fallen down a flight of stairs a week earlier and was also battling influenza. A reporter, Ria Jarret of the New York Evening Graphic described Missus Houdini as in a semi delirium from her illness and medications. Even so, she allowed a seance with Ford in her home on January eighth. At that sitting, Fletcher claimed to have a message from Houdini Rose answer Tell, pray answer Look Tell, Answer,
Speaker 2Answer Tell. Fletcher explained that the decoded message was believe best verified the decoding before witnesses Ford. Fletcher, still claiming to be speaking for Houdini, went on to repudiate Houdini's crusade to expose fraudulent mediums. Houdina's work Apparently now done, he disappeared into the mist, never to be fletcherized again. Ford would not use Houdini again, but other mediums would invoke his spirit when it suited their needs. Bess Houdini
Speaker 2publicly avowed that only she and Houdini knew the code, yet the code had been published the previous year by Harold Kellock in his Houdini, His Life Story from Harcourt Bracing Company in nineteen twenty eight. In any case, Ford and his cronies got Missus Houdini to sign a document not in her own hand, stating that Ford got the message right. Her lawyer B. M. L Ernst wrote as to the alleged Ford message when Missus Houdini signed the paper, to the effect that the message was genuine. She was
Speaker 2confined to a bed after a fall, had been taking drugs, and was not in a position to know what she was doing. On January ninth, the day after the seance, Missus Houdini was quoted in the New York World as saying, I had no idea what combination of words Harry would use, and when he said believe, it was a surprise. She said she expected to get a ten word message from Houdini, but that she didn't know what the message would be. On January tenth, Edward Churchill of The New York Evening Graphic declared that the Ford seance a monumental hoax and
Speaker 2wrote that Ford had admitted that he got the secret code from Missus Houdini. Reya Jarret, who wrote the original article about the seance, invited Ford to her apartment the next evening, where she confronted him with the claim that she had a copy of a letter forged Crony's had brought to Missus Houdini two days before the city and that it listed the ten words he had claimed the spirit gave. Fletcher, Jare church Hill, and William Plummer signed Swarren statements that Ford offered her money to play ball and admitted that he couldn't get the code from spirits.
Speaker 2Churchill and Plumber, the managing editor of the graphic, were in another room of Jarret's apartment where they could overhear the conversation. We'll be back next week. Thanks for listening to another Monster Talk. Happy to here, and thanks Matt for joining us today. Monster You've been listening to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner. You just heard a discussion of the Houdini Seance and the strange story of how a spiritualist got involved in May of hoaxed Houdini's wife. Check the show
Speaker 2notes for more reading. Monster Talk is combining forces with the popular skeptical podcast Skeptoid as we Brave the Bermuda Triangle in twenty twenty five. I'll be one of the skeptic celebrities participating in this adventure in the warm waters off the coast of Florida. Will we find the Missing Flight nineteen? Will we find proof of Atlantis? Will Sea Musters pilot us through these mystery filled waters? No, but
Speaker 2I promise you there will be science and history filled discussions and plenty of puns if I have anything to do with it. Early bird pricing is still available, so come get some sun, visit beautiful places, roll your eyes at my terrible puns, and raise money to fund Skeptoid and muster talk shared mission of promoting skepticism and science while still enjoying a good mystery. Early bird pricing ends January thirty first, so hurry up and sign up. Check the show notes for a link, or go to skeptoid dot com and click events to find your way onto
Speaker 2Braving the Bermuda Triangle, a Skeptoid adventure muster Talk. The music is by Peach Stealing Monkeys. As always, thank you for listening. This has been a Monster House presentation.
Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...
Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...
Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...
🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...
Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...