Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

MonsterTalk

MonsterTalk artwork

Flashback: The Warren Omission

Jun 23, 20251 hr 20 minAudio

We will be playing some episodes from our archives for a few weeks this Summer - let's kick it off with this classic from October 2013! THE WARREN OMISSION.WAS THE STORY OF The Conjuring the true story of how Ed and Lorraine Warren fought demonic forces in Rhode Island? In this special episode of MonsterTalk, we hear a different side to the story of America’s first family of ghost hunting. Features interviews with investigators Joe Nickell and Steven Novella. Full Notes Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Monster House Presents.

Speaker 2Welcome to Monster Talk Flashback. I'm recording this on June twenty second, twenty twenty five. I think I've mentioned plenty of times in the past few weeks that this year's kind of kicking Team Smith pretty hard. We're dealing with some complicated issues right now. I got a family member on hospice care, and we have one that's going to move in with us, and somehow I'm supposed to be going on a cruise during all this, and I got job stress and blah blah blah.

Speaker 3You know life. Anyway, in an effort to save some of my sanity, I'm going to be pulling from our archives for the next few weeks until things hopefully settle down. We plan to keep on recording new stuff even while this is going on, but for the next four or five weeks, I will be dusting off some oldies from way back, and I know a lot of you will not have heard these before. I'm also trying to level off the audio. It seems like what wasn't really great at that when we started out, or I wasn't, as my wife would correct me. And finally, I'm working on

Speaker 3a project to load the back catalog without any ads into the Patreon fe but that's going to be later this year and probably done in batches. I've got to teach my kids the family business so that they can help with the load and learn some useful skills. So tikkok off this summer series. Let's return to the thrilling days of yesteryear, when my friend Joe Nichol was still alive and I had just celebrated my forty fourth birthday. This little ditty comes to us from October of twenty thirteen and features Joe Nichol and Steve Novella from the

Speaker 3Skeptics Guide to the Universe podcast. I know a lot of people have written me in about this episode, so if it's new to you, I hope you learn a lot and enjoy it. If it's old to you, I hope you don't mind hearing it again. It has been a minute monstrutle.

Speaker 4On December eighteenth, nineteen seventy five, George and Kathy Lutz and their three children moved into a house in empty bill Long Island. Nineteen days later, they were running for their lives. What Happened to Them.

Speaker 3Became one of the best selling books in years.

Speaker 5And is now a fascinating motion picture.

Speaker 4An experience in terror to make you believe in the unbelievable, the Amityville.

Speaker 3Or something in this house since the evil you are in Connecticut. This here November one, nineteen seventy one. I'm sitting here with Carolyn Perrin, who with her family has been experiencing supernatural currencies. You're picking up anything in here, Hunt.

Speaker 6Something awful happened here? Ed, what is it?

Speaker 3What are you guys?

Speaker 7Well, we've been called ghost Honors paranormal researchers.

Speaker 8We prefer to be known simply as Ed and Lorraine Warren.

Speaker 3It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before.

Speaker 4A giant, hairy creature, part Ape, part Matt in Larkness at twenty four a mile bottomless Lake and the Highlands of Scotland get a creature known as the Luckness Monsters

Speaker 4Monster Talk.

Speaker 3Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm your host, Blake Smith. This episode's a little different from anything I've put together before. I'm a big fan of horror films and thrillers, and like a lot of folks, I used to be terrified to hear those chilling words based on a true story when a supernatural horror film was being advertised, and even though the so called true stories often turned out to be less convincing than the case behind them, like for example, The Exorcist, or a complete fabrication like the events in the film The Changeling, I still like those movies. I recently went to see

Speaker 3the The Conjuring, which is based on a haunting case investigated by the famous or perhaps infamous couple Adam Lorraine Warren. I wanted to do an episode about that case, but it decided instead to look at the Warrens themselves. While I really enjoyed the first third of The Conjuring, the depiction of d and Lorraine was as unbelievable to me as the levitating chairs and the flying bed sheets. Now Ed died in two thousand and six, but Lorraine's still alive and actively promoting her work and her brand of investigation. For years, I've been hearing Lorraine talk about the Amityville case,

Speaker 3which I found perplexing because really, the Warrens seem to have nothing to do with that case. Also, I knew that I'd heard some first dance stories from paranormal investigator Joe Nickel, and also from Steve Novella about their encounters with the Warrants. I thought it might be fun to pull together multiple interviews to give a kind of counterbalance to the way the Warrens are usually depicted, especially to counterbalance the ridiculous, almost saint like depiction they were given in the Conjuring. In this episode, you'll hear from Joe Nickel, a longtime investigator of the paranormal through scientific methodology. He's written numerous books since the chief investigator at CSI, the

Speaker 3Committee for Skeptical Inquiry. You'll also hear from Steve Novella. Steve is a neurologist, a proponent of science based medicine, and the host of the popular Skeptics Guide to the Universe podcast. And we'll hear from Ray Garton, who did an entire episode with us on his experience with the Warrens during the making of In a Dark Place, which later became the film A Haunting in Connecticut, and I interviewed WPIX New York's senior reporter, Marvin Scott. Unfortunately, I was not able to get audio from that interview, but I did find a clip in which Marvin gives a neat summary of his experiences with the Warrens at Amityville.

Speaker 3So let's start there. For years, I've heard d and Lorraine talking about the trauma of their experience at Amityville. But I knew for my own reading and research that they weren't part of the original haunting investigation or are in the book by Jay Ansen. So how did they get involved? In this clip, you'll hear Ed and Lorraine explain exactly how they got involved with the Amityville case warms Trutle.

Speaker 9Now, Ed, can you tell me how you and Lorraine got involved in the Ambityville.

Speaker 10Horror Well, it was Marvin Scott from Channel five News team. He was the anchorman at the time, and he had been involved with a haunting that we had investigated in Bloomfield, New Jersey.

Speaker 11And he was impressed by this.

Speaker 10So he gave us a ring and he said, we'd like us to come down and see what's going on in Amityville, Long Island. Now, this was not the Ambityville horror.

Speaker 11Case at that time.

Speaker 10You understand, this was just another haunted house and we didn't even realize that six people had been murdered in that house of a failed family Okay, Iraen.

Speaker 9I know you went in the house and you experienced things, but can you just go over how you first were called into the house, Like, who was the gentleman of people who called you? And was it the lux as they called you in?

Speaker 8No, it was not Tony. It was Marvin Scott who called us in.

Speaker 5He told us there had been a tragedy in that home.

Speaker 8He didn't go into detail regarding he told us that it was a prominent family. He also told us during that very first conversation that the family that were living there at the present time had fled and left all of their possessions behind, and their viewers were very interested of the history of that house and what exactly might be wrong with the home. That's how we first became involved.

Speaker 3A few years ago, I had seen a documentary about Amneyville with Marvin Scott discussing the Amityville Halloween special that he had done. I contacted him and he explained, just as he had in the show, that there was little to tell. He had taken a film crew and some paranormal investigators into the Ambyville home to do a seance near Halloween, and it was a big flop. Nothing happened of interest, but Lorraine Warren did ask to go to a separate seance upstairs, and while Marvin and his crew left disappointed, Lorraine and d left with a legend that

Speaker 3would stay with them for the rest of their lives.

Speaker 6Whatever it was the Lutz's believe was in that house, it did not manifest itself the night I spent in the house twenty three years ago with a group of parapsychologists who conducted a seance. The demonic force was supposedly the strongest in the sewing room, where Lorraine Warren conducted another seance by candlelight. Other than a brief chill at rule it was February, I felt nothing unusual, but it give.

Speaker 8To me Marvin, because I said to you, Marvin, I hope this is as close to hell as I'll ever get.

Speaker 6But I the only persistent voice I heard that night was that it like crew wanting to know when we were going to have the sandwiches we had brought along.

Speaker 3Now let's get to Joe nicol. He just finished up a very thorough investigation into the case behind the contrary and the right up of that will be in an upcoming Skeptical Inquirer magazine. I talked to you about his involvement with this case and with the Warrens, and it goes back a while, but I'll let him tell you all about it.

Speaker 4Warms Trut.

Speaker 3When did you first become aware of the war in their work?

Speaker 5Well, I really got him first hand back in the days of the haunting in Connecticut, the first version of that with the Sneteckers.

Speaker 3Yeah, the.

Speaker 5Case that made Sally Jesse Raphael just in time for Halloween. And I was on with the Snetteckers and with Ed and Lorraine, and I left a very bad taste in my mouth. Ed Warren was a bullying type and a backstage a loud mouth, swearing sailor and not, in my opinion, a nice guy. He made veiled threats to me on

Speaker 5the Sally shows or under his breath, and I turned to him at one point and I said, are you threatening me? And of course they cut all that out of the tape.

Speaker 8Joe, you say the investigation, the warrants conducted as Bologney, Why.

Speaker 12Well, I've investigated haunted houses for some twenty years and a professional psychologist. Pardon is there such a thing I've not met a house that I thought was haunted. I think the Warrens have never met a house that they didn't think was haunted. I think that you're the turn I've heard that you were allowed mouth, you shouted people down. Just give me my chance.

Speaker 7You did a bunch of lies, Joe.

Speaker 12I'll give you your chance, your allowed mouth, Warren and we all we all know it. But if you'll just let me finish.

Speaker 3When you're concerned, I'm allowed.

Speaker 10Try to show, Try to show a little.

Speaker 7I don't have a lot of time class.

Speaker 12If somebody is sitting here, ed, let Joe just explain about.

Speaker 7Guys. Joe put by point.

Speaker 12Yes, one thing that the houses that sincere people report that they think or haunted usually follow certain patterns. This is a hodgepodge of the sort of ghost tale, poltergeist, part demon part this part that we saw a similar pattern with the Amityville horror, a case that the Warrens thought was genuine. It turned out it turned out to be a blatant hook concocted over several bottles of wine. The evidence, yes, I can prove it, Yes I can. It's been proven. The evidence is very clear. In the

Speaker 12case to Amityville, horror. The whole packaging of this story the book says it's for Halloween release. The book was written by a professional fiction writer who writes horror stories. This whole packaging is a frock.

Speaker 3Joe.

Speaker 7Does the church admit to exorcists?

Speaker 12According to according to a newspaper article that I have, the Bridgeport Newspaper, that diocese refuses to confirm that they had any exorcism there. If there was, If there was an excism, I don't understand why there is any any reason why they can't come out and say so on the show.

Speaker 7That there wasn't.

Speaker 5Actually, after the show, I went outside and Ed Warren was sitting in the limo to go back to the airport, and he had the car door opened, and I walked right up to him and I said, you were going to do what to me? And he looked, you know, frightened, and and I leaned in and I said, you know, Ed, you're a tough guy, You're tough around the mouth, and walked off.

Speaker 3The whole episode is available on YouTube right now, so I'll put a link to that in the show notes. Okay, and so the Haunting a Connecticut case we'd actually talked about In a previous episode, we got Ray Gartin, the author who wrote the novel about that on, and I had actually run into him on a message board where he had spoken very disparagingly about the whole experience of writing that book and that he hated the fact that it had been written in the based on a true

Speaker 3story motif. And so I didn't know if that was really him or not. And I tracked him down and got him to come on and talk about it, and so I'm gonna put a little bit of that in this episode as well.

Speaker 5Yeah, I understand he had trouble because he thought the Sneteckers kept changing their story for one thing.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 5And I'm not sure if he was saying that the Warrens were encouraging, but one of the one of the ghost writers, was saying that they would encourage him to sort of make up stuff or you know, ed scary improvised with scary elements.

Speaker 3I'm gonna clip a little bit of that audio.

Speaker 13I went to Connecticut and I met with Ed Lorraine Warren and Alan Carmen Snedeker, the couple who had lived in the former funeral parlor, the house that used to be a funeral parlor, and I recorded our conversations. I had quite a few tapes, and I couldn't get the Snedekers their stories. The details of their stories weren't meshing, they weren't adding up. And so I went to Ed Warren and I explained to him that this was happening,

Speaker 13you know, and I said, I'm not sure how to go about this. I had never done any nonfiction before, so this was a new experience for me, and I was trying to I wanted to have all the information laid out in chronological order in front of me, and it just wasn't adding up. So I told Ed and he said, well, they're crazy. He said, all the people who come to us are crazy. He said, you just use what you can and make the rest up. He said, that's why we hired you. You you're a horror writer.

Speaker 13You write scary books. We want this to be a good story, and we wanted to be scary.

Speaker 5Because I think that's really uh. I think that's really important to understand that about about what the Warrens were up to. You know. It's one thing to be very very misguided, which of course they were, but but that alone does not make someone odious perhaps, but but when you're misguided and not honest, then you're well, it's hard to find for me to find redeeming quality.

Speaker 3Did did you have a chance to see this Conjuring?

Speaker 5Yes, I've not only seen the Conjuring, but I've I've read both of the available too books of a trilogy by Andrea Proon, so I deserve some kind of metal. There were there were several things. The Warrens did come there, and and uh and the the father Roger didn't didn't know that they were coming. They didn't invite them. The

Speaker 5Warrens just showed up one day. So that's really quite different from the way the movie has them being sought out as this famous duo and so forth, that they begged him to come and help them. No, they just showed up sometime before I think it was again before Halloween, and it shows a whole lot I think about what they're up to. Most of their work was done around Halloween, looks like, and they they tried to ingratiate themselves. And then then Carol and Perron, the mother did kind of

Speaker 5buy into the Warrens while her husband kept saying, you know, these people are Charlatan's and this whole approach is just nothing better than a kind of fraud and a bunch of silliness. And he wanted no part of it. But she, she was very intent, and so she invited them for the famous sort of exorcism, which was originally built as just a cleansing of the house or a seance. And

Speaker 5they showed up. So Roger was not happy. He was, you know, pretty much had outs with the whole operation. So he was not sitting in the circle of the seans. And so at some point she scoots back in her chair and falls over. This, of course is in the movie is made that the chair levitates and turns completely upside down. Yeah, so just to kind of compare well,

Speaker 5he so her husband rushes over to help her, and Ed Warren tries to restrain him. We're upon in one of the great moments of skepticism. He Decked Larren, hit him right in the nose and blooded his nose.

Speaker 3Wow.

Speaker 5And I thought back to Sally Jesse Rafiel when I read that, and I thought that could have been me. But you know, you just realize these things that you might might have done, and someone else did it, so seriously seriously, that's what happened.

Speaker 3And in the books since I have not had the opportunity to read that are Is that the right word? Anyway? I haven't read those books.

Speaker 5Right right, I mean a thousand, a thousand pages of about fifty dollars worth of books the things I do for the cause of skepticism.

Speaker 3And it's appreciated, I assure you.

Speaker 5Do you know somebody had to read them.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, And now these are self published and I think one of the things that really made me not want to read them, besides the Amazon reviews, was the fact that.

Speaker 5Well, the trouble. The trouble is, though in not wanting to is is that they nevertheless are the most the most authoritative, is not the right one the closest to a primary source, closest to a primary source, that's right. And even at that, it's pretty pathetic because she's writing thirty some years after the fact, right it is not recorded or you know. Now there were allegedly some notes

Speaker 5her mother made and some sketches and so forth, but she gave those to Lorraine Warren with the understanding that you know, there were a couple of understandings. One was that they were sort of talking to them confidentially, and secondly that they you know, she was lending these notes, at least that's the way it's presented in the books. And of course she didn't understand the Warrens. So of course he's never to this day has anyone gotten them back,

Speaker 5if the Warren's even you know, if if Lorraine Hids did, but if if Loraine even knows where where they are. And as to the confidentiality, of course, the first thing they know is that people are coming to their house sort of sort of like happened at Amityville. People were coming to their house sort of wanting to see the ghosts, you know, and Carolyn Perrin was wondering, where are these

Speaker 5people coming from, you know, and how do they know about our rural, isolated farmhouse. Well, the Warrens were giving public lectures and telling people right where they were, and so they were they were.

Speaker 3And I shouldn't interject here that that if anyone listening to the show is interested in looking at the house, please don't, because the current owners are already suffering from a tremendous amount of harassment because of the public from this film.

Speaker 5I am I'm not surprised you know, the to mention another house that the Warrens were connected with, and there were several, uh, the Smurl's House in West Pittston, and uh and Amityville and and and others. They the Amityville house. I knew Barbara Cromarty who lived in the house with her husband after after the famous uh brew haha created

Speaker 5by the Letzes and the and the book and and movie and uh, you know, eventually the Cromarties sued on the grounds that they there, you know, they bought the house in good faith. And it turned out that it was all these false stories, as it turned out, matter really of judicial record in the in the trials that were held, the lawsuits that were heard, and the there

Speaker 5was no truth to the Amityville story. It was all made up. As the attorney for the attorney William Weber, who was the attorney for Ronald of Fayo, who's known as Butch. Butch had had Weber as his defense attorney, and Weber was trying to think of some angle to get him a new trial, you know, because he had he had murdered his entire family, siblings and parents in

Speaker 5that house. And so Weber thought that if people believed he was driven to this by demon possession or something he might get some you know, a new look at the case. And Weber has you know, publicly confessed that that story was made up with him and George and Kathy Lutz in his law office over as he put in several bottles of wine that George was drinking. So

Speaker 5that's that's another case. And the the point there is that you know, people would would be knocking on the Cromarty's door wanting to come in and look around and see the ghost people milling about in the yard. And as I say, I got to know her and we had had some interesting conversations, and a TV show wanted

Speaker 5to get in there and film, and she explained to me, you know, very very nice to me. She said, look, Joe, I can't. I can't let anybody in because if I do, then, you know, will undermine our lawsuit. You can't. You can't complain that people are bothering you coming to the door and wanting to come in, and at the same time let let a TV crew in, right, That's sort of contradictory.

Speaker 3And and I understood that after the book, there were a lot of uh, the Amityville book. I mean, there were a lot of really important inconsistencies that were just i mean physically obvious things that we could not have been true.

Speaker 5Well, that's exactly right, And and I went over some of those with with Barbara Cromerty. For example, they mentioned in the book that there were devil's tracks in the snow at a certain point, and pretty simple research showed that there was no snow on the ground.

Speaker 6At that time.

Speaker 3It was a demon snow.

Speaker 5Well you know, uh there, you know, you could do a book, there's a chapter right there and and explain these these otherwise perpexed, perplexing paranormal mysteries. But that was one example. And but where Barbara was concerned the the the book claimed that, you know, a door was ripped off its hinges, and windows were ripped open and so forth.

Speaker 5And in fact, as she assured me, and then later a TV after after the dust had settled and everything, she was willing to let a TV crew in. And I didn't get to go, but they picked my brains and I put him in touch with her, and and she took them around the house and showed them a number of the inconsistencies. How things were exaggerated, and one of them was that the the doors, the doors and

Speaker 5windows all had the original old hardware and the old Varney shawl evidence and they got you know, close up shots of that and everything that nothing had been replaced, no locksmith had ever been called to the house. In fact, the police hadn't been called to the house. So really it was just a you know, a travesty the Amityville case, which which is really the Amityville hoax.

Speaker 3And it seems to be a pattern with the Warrens that that their most popular or well known cases are sort of plagued with these what would you call them, reality based inconsistencies.

Speaker 5Yes, yes, the Warrens didn't have as much really to do with Amiteville as they might have liked to, because you know, they didn't do one of their famous books that went to somebody else and they were kind of kind of not not famous enough at the time or something. But they did they had been involved in Amityville, and they went on, as I mentioned, some these other houses. And there's a pattern I've written about this, the the Warrens modus operandis i'd call it, is this they and

Speaker 5you have to understand that the Warrens are this sort of were this couple of me I think of as medieval minded Catholics, unlike modern and often very enlightened Catholics. They believe literally in demons. And Ed Vancied himself had a business card and said Ed Warren demonologist. And Lorraine was you know, acclaimed clairvoyant, but wasn't It wasn't claiirvoyant

Speaker 5at all, as as far as I can tell. And they they had this medieval notion of demons, and they had gotten into ghost hunting. Ed was was an artist, amateur artist, and he would make paintings of haunted houses and then used those to kind of get in, get in in with the people in the house and and begin his sort of career. And what they what they did was to eventually the cases that ended up his books.

Speaker 5They would show up and try to convince the people that they were They were experts. They knew all about everything, and they had some you know, ghost tunding equipment, like cameras and an ultraviolet light and and some holy water and a crucifix just what you need, you know, if you're going to investigate ghosts. And they they would go in and take take a case that, for all intents and purposes, had thus far been in the news as

Speaker 5pretty much a ghost case or maybe a poultergeist case, something like that, not not too much about demonic forces. And the next thing you know, the warrants have convinced everybody that there are demons involved. Lorraine would go into one of her light trances, which just would mean she would just close her eyes and haul off and say something, and she would sense some demonic presence, and the two

Speaker 5of them would talk a good talk about this, and and you see these poor unsuspecting people who, first of all though don't know anything about the paranormal and not aware that you know, there are no haunted places, only haunted people, as Robert Baker used to say. And so when you have someone who's an expert explaining to them, you know that they're, well, there are these different kinds of spirits and this and that and the other. They don't know any better. They think maybe these people know what they're talking about, and so they It's interesting that

Speaker 5in every case of this, these were Catholic families, and Ed and Lorraine would show up and convince them that it was really demonic and that they really needed to use their you know, Catholic powers of exorcism and holy water and so forth, and they would convert it into a demonic book, and then they would get a ghost writer and all of all of the shenanigans would be

Speaker 5sort of restyled and and exaggerated and spooky elements thrown in.

Speaker 3They would punch it up, as we say, would.

Speaker 5Punch it up. That's right, they would punch it up. And this is this is for the books. And then of course by the time Hollywood got it. I mean we're talking really punched up.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 5When a chair scooted backwards ends up, you know, turning upside down and hanging in the air upside down, it's pretty pretty punched up.

Speaker 3As a skeptical paranormal investigator, how excited would you be to see a levitation or something like that happens in the thing?

Speaker 5I mean, well, I just would love to know. I mean it just there's nothing that that would thrill me more. I remember once talking to a young lady many many years ago who had been you know, taken in by the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi group, you know, the transcendental the TMS, the transcendental meditation people. And sadly, my good friend Doug Henning, the magician, the very talented young magician who who's who

Speaker 5died young, and he was taken into this and and you know, Doug would Doug was well known as a TM or and he would go on TV and levitate people, and uh, James Randy chastised him because obviously Doug was doing using the magic trick version of this on stage, and he wasn't deliberately trying to be deceptive, but it just, you know, a lot of people didn't understand here's a guy believes in TM and they teach levitation, and well here he is on TV levitating someone. You know, if you don't really make clear that yes, but this is

Speaker 5a trick and so on. But I remember telling this young lady that I doubted that anyone could levitate, that there was this thing called the you know, the law of gravity. And she began to berate me about how close minded I was and and how pitiful science was, and science didn't know everything, and you know, the usual, the usual clap trap, all very emotionally presented, and I said, well, no,

Speaker 5wait a minute, stop, I said let me tell you how really open minded I am. I am willing because she was telling me she knew this, this guy, this guru that could levitate, and I said, have you seen him? No, but he wouldn't lie to me.

Speaker 3She said wow.

Speaker 5And I said, well, but okay, so let me tell you how really open minded I am. I will go any place and need any reasonable conditions for him to show me this. And of course, immediately the you know, the barriers went up. Well, nobody has to prove anything to you and I and you know, and I said, well, but but wait, I'm not. I'm not at this point just anybody. I'm I'm somebody who's written on this and

Speaker 5made a lot of TV shows, and I'm someone that I can tell you a lot of people would pay attention to if I said, okay, I've really seen this. Andre appearon thinks that her mother's share lifted up or something. But as best I can tell, if you subtract thirty some years of exaggeration and and brew haha and power suggestions, so for it. Basically, her chair slid back and snagged on something or whatever certain physical laws come to mind here,

Speaker 5and tipped backward. Basically, you know how when you go to a Pentecostal service or one of the televangelists services where they demonstrate going under power, and the evangelist is there and the people are, you know, getting ready to go into the power, and you can watch some of them, you know, sort of getting into the into the role, and then they're they're pointed at or touched or something and they fall back. There's usually a catcher.

Speaker 3Yeah. I would actually encourage listeners to seek out the documentary Marjoe m A R.

Speaker 5Joe And yes, Marjoe, you know which one is standing Ovation at Cannes way back in the seventies. He has an excellent, excellent movie and he shows that and he shows how to give him a push if you need to. And which happened to me. I was in at one service, curiously enough, at a Catholic church, which doesn't usually do that, but they had a visiting charismatic Catholic who did who did that? And and I had talked to the guy

Speaker 5and he invited me to the service. I had no idea who I was, of course, and I decided to just stand there, you know, pretty rigid, and it was kind of funny. He was so determined I was going to go he was. He gave me a real push on the forehead and at some point, you know, it's hard not to go down or step back, and the catcher caught me. Wow. Yeah, my wife caught it on it's a blurred it's a blurred picture, but it's priceless.

Speaker 3Wow.

Speaker 5But I think that's same, the same psychology of that, which is very much like station. And those people you find will be compliant and if you ask him to do something and tell them they then they can't do this or whatever, they will probably go along with you, and that you may lead them into a kind of dissociative state. Eight. But they're basically, you know, doing what's expected of them. And certainly these people who fall into the power, they know they're supposed to fall down. No

Speaker 5two do it the same way, because there's no set way you have to do it. Some will stiffen and fall straight back, some will slump, some will fall down and twitch and so on. Kind of like when you were a kid and someone said bang, bang, you're dead. Yeah, there were several ways to act.

Speaker 12Right.

Speaker 3Certainly you just become quite dramatic based on your own information.

Speaker 5Yeah, we had each had our own style. You know, we could pitch forward or fall backward, or you know, twitch, or our eyes would fall with their eyes open or whatnot.

Speaker 3And I don't want to sound like a cynic, but I suspect the same thing is going on with Bob Larson's demonology courses. Its well exactly.

Speaker 5I think that's what That's where I'm getting to is that's the root of that's the root of all of this stuff. And I think that's what happened with missus paren and in the books that her daughter has written, and anyway one can read my analysis, but I go into you know, pretty much all of the phenomena. Yeah, and it's a little my assessment is a little less supernatural thing.

Speaker 3Right, And I would suspect that most listeners would probably think that that kind of let's call it stage possession is relatively harmless. But I think what I've seen is maybe not. Because a lot of people, and I say a lot enough that is troubling h throughout the world, are conducting exorcisms against unwilling victims. And that's where it

Speaker 3really seems to be quite dangerous, and people get hurt or die from the experience of the exorcism.

Speaker 5Exactly, and and and even even the most you know, when you when you tell people that they're possessed or you put them through some some supernatural business, you're really you know, you're changing their lives in all kinds of ways. You're, for example, you're you're telling them that there's this invisible, supernatural realm that is controlling things, and and science can't

Speaker 5find this realm. And you know, those of us who I mean, I've done this work, paranormal investigative work now for over forty years, and I increasingly am convinced that we live in a real natural world. I found no evidence at all for anything supernatural, and so but if but if I did, I would obviously be life changing, life transforming. And that's what happens to people. They get caught up in in cults and and fringe groups and

Speaker 5so forth, in which they become increasingly seduced by you know, invisible forces, demons and so forth. And it's it's not healthy, it's not harmless. It's not harmless. The people who think, oh, well, but if the person's the person's you know, chronic drinker, and you convince him that it's devils that are making him do it, and you exercise the devils and maybe

Speaker 5you could trick him into quitting drinking. Well, I just don't think that's okay. I mean, I think that's that takes paternalism to a kind of fascistic degree. And and I don't I don't like that idea that it's okay to fool the little people. I don't know. I personally don't know any little people. U being in a qualitarian I think people are people and they don't need to be treated like well, we'll humor them and convince some

Speaker 5that some demon did this and their guardian angel is going to do that and so forth. No, I don't think that's helpful or health or healthy to do.

Speaker 3Yeah, And I would say that if you're in a position where you feel like you're experiencing a supernatural event, it would be really helpful to go to someone who's not in I guess to someone who's in an out group, you know, someone who's not experiencing these things, because I think you can get into a reinforcement loop where if you're like if ghost hunters, I think you have this problem if you go ghost hunting and you only talk to ghost hunters. You never talk to anybody who might be have a different opinion, then you're only going to

Speaker 3get reinforcing feedback.

Speaker 5Right, And there are ghost owners who would not even talk to a guy like me.

Speaker 3I've had that problem too. I find it really disappointing because I'm very interested. I mean, what could be more exciting than evidence of life after death or continued existence after death. I think it would be wonderful.

Speaker 5Oh absolutely, if we're you know, this is the thing. We've talked about this before, but the paranormal offers all these great promises that you know, if ghosts are real, then we don't really die, and if if flying saucers are real and we are not alone in the universe, and so on, if psychics are real, we might get a glimpse of something in our future that we could avoid. So,

Speaker 5of course, if we were voting, we probably all vote for these things. But we know in science we are not voting, and that's not how we decide. But I understand people. A lot of people think that that skeptics somehow just don't want to believe in all kinds of things, and know that they're most skeptics as well, would vote it's just that they've wised up and they've learned a

Speaker 5thing or two. For example, that professional wrestling is faced. Well, I hate to bring that up, you know, in front of your audience, who I'm sure is you know, a bunch of nidies.

Speaker 7You're supposed to.

Speaker 3Say spoiler alert, Joe, you say spoiler.

Speaker 5Alert, Yeah, But pretty soon you realize that geea would wouldn't it be nice? As Carl Sagan? I remember once, I remember Carl Sagan saying this. I was there when he said it, that he wished he wished he could talk to his dead parents, even as he put it, just once a year to tell him how the grandkids are that kind of you know, that kind of feeling and and those feelings are powerfull. I've felt them in myself,

Speaker 5you know, wishing. I remember when my grandmother died now much I did not want that to be the case. And I think most of us have some feelings and experiences like that, where no, we wouldn't be against communicating with our dead loved ones, not an idea we're innately hostile to. In fact, we've had to protect ourselves from the tendency to be seduced by Charlatan's on these fronts.

Speaker 3Yes, I think going back to the conjuring case the parent family, when you read the book or the books, did you see anything in the books that led you to believe there might be something that could be investigated at this point or is the whole case primarily just anecdotal at this point.

Speaker 5Well, I treated it the account as here's an account that one can respond to, and I have done that. I don't want to say too much about my approach, but can one can look at it. It's pretty much what you can do with a cold case. People are at this stage, you know, dead some of them. The principles are if you could have gotten to them thirty years ago, you might have been able to do something. But now the positions they take are entrenched, and they've

Speaker 5got maybe exaggerated views of things that happened so on. But I think it's still possible to suggest based on things they say. Some things that can you can't explain pretty much on their own terms.

Speaker 3But well, I would say that in the film they did a lot of the kind of things that I really i'll say disdain about a lot of ghost investigations, which is they felt like paranormal things were going on, so they apparently went and looked to see who had died there.

Speaker 5Well, yeah, just straight out of the formula of the idea that I mean, you're almost expecting him to try to prove that there was the house was built on an Indian burials. You know, there are certain sort of stock motifs and and and you know what they are, and so you go looking for them. It's a kind of you're engaging in confirmation bias big time.

Speaker 3That was exactly.

Speaker 5You You get some paranormal things going and then you you jump to try to confirm it. Well, you know people died here, right, They die everywhere?

Speaker 3Do I've noticed up.

Speaker 5And down every street, and then you know suburban homes and so forth.

Speaker 3Most Steve Novella and his group, the New England Skeptic Society also met and investated the Warrens. Their interaction wasn't as hostile as Joe Nichols, but it's just as interesting. How did you hear about the Warrants for the first time? Do you remember when you first heard about them and their their their work.

Speaker 7No, I don't remember when I first heard about them, because they're just there. They were already locally famous before we started the Then the Connecticut Skeptical Society was soon very quickly transformed into the New England Skeptical Society. Uh, they were, They were locally famous people.

Speaker 5You know.

Speaker 7I just so I always knew about the Warrens, you know what I mean, it was I don't remember the moment when I became aware of them.

Speaker 3Wow. So they had already been operating for.

Speaker 7A while forty years before we got involved in Wow. And right Connecticut, right, and like, you know, literally down the road from us, you know, a couple of towns over. So yeah, we absolutely knew who they were.

Speaker 3So was it let's well, let's talk about the nest. So, like you had a group of friends who formed the Connecticut Skeptic Society, said.

Speaker 7Yeah, that at first, and then we realized there were no other ones in New England, so we might as well just be the New England Skeptical Society.

Speaker 3Could you talk about that, because I think you mentioned that a long time ago in your podcast where you talked about looking in the back of the magazines.

Speaker 7Yeah, it was actually Perry. You know, Perry, you always liked to take credit for that. We we became friends and then both realized that we were both skeptics, and we both read The Skeptical Inquirer. And you know, Perry was over my house one day. He shows me the back of the Skeptical Inquirer where all the local groups are. He's like, you noticed anything, it's no group in Connecticut said we should do that. You and I should form the Connecticut Skeptical Society. And as soon as they said that, I knew it was a perfect idea. You know, of course, of course we should do that. So we did it.

Speaker 7You know, we got my brother Bob involved, our friend, mutual friend Evan, you know now of course around the podcast with us. Jay wasn't involved in those early days. He got involved little bit later, and we, you know, we just started doing the things that local skeptical groups do, doing local investigation, writing a newsletter, holding local lectures, trying to get plugged into the big national group, which at that time basically was psychop that was really the only game in town. Yeah, it was a lot of fun. We really cut our teeth in a lot of a

Speaker 7lot of really interesting local investigations.

Speaker 3So I'm trying to picture this, how old were you in this? Like is this college.

Speaker 7No, No, was this So this was nineteen ninety six, So I was like just finishing my residency.

Speaker 3Oh wow, that's actually wow. Okay, I didn't realize that was this recent. Okay, So how did you decide that? How did you pick your investigations there? Locally?

Speaker 7Whatever came our way. You know, we weren't that discriminating, and once we got a little bit of credibility and got our name out, then some started coming to us, which is always nice, but you know, the Warrens, you know, it was interesting because for us, they were the big fish, right, they were the most famous paranormal promote proponents in our region, and they were a little intimidating to us. You know, we really thought, oh, we really got to make sure we're prepared and really, you know, haven't get some experience

Speaker 7and know what we're talking about before we take them on, because they're going to be you know, they know what they're doing. They're going to be you know, uh, difficult to really do a good job, and we were. We totally overestimated them.

Speaker 3Well before before you tell them forget what were they famous for? What did they do? I mean what what? Yeah?

Speaker 7They you know, they spawned many many ghost investigating groups. Uh, they're probably their Their biggest claim to fame was the Amityville horror case. They had already by that time been the subject of movies, so you know, uh, any local ghost story had their name attached to it. Wow.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 7They investigated thousands of cases, so they pretty much had their hands in any local ghost hunting ghost story situation.

Speaker 3So you decide to investigate the warrants. How did you reach out to them and make arrangements to do that.

Speaker 7I don't remember the details. I think we just called them up. You know, Perry used to do stuff like that a lot. So I just called them up, said hey, you know, this is who we are. We want to see what you got, you know. So I remember the first meeting very well. I don't know if you want to just dive r into that.

Speaker 3Yeah, let's talk.

Speaker 7Yeah, so first meeting. What We went over to their house, which apparently they often had people over. They had a museum in their basement, and so they would frequently invite people into their house, bring them down into their basements, show them all the artifacts that they had collected over the years.

Speaker 3I just saw a documentary about that called the conjuring. It was very scary down there.

Speaker 7Yeah, right, we had We had a blast doing this because there we are so get this. You know, just imagine this old couple, you know, Ed and Lorraine Warrant. By this time, they were already in their seventies, and you know, they were or maybe they were at that time, they were in their sixties, and they were clueless. I mean, we had built them up in our heads because we you know, you watched a movie about the Warrants, and they're presented as like serious researchers who actually know what they're doing, and then you meet them, you're like, oh my god, Ed is just a govone. I mean, the

Speaker 7guy he had no idea what he was doing, didn't know the first thing about really anything relevant to paranormal investigation or ghost phenomenon, or had just totally unprepared for any question that we had to ask him. And he desperately desperately wanted the validation of scientific investigation. He wanted us to validate his claims and his evidence, which was interesting. We quickly picked up on that. It's like, Wow, this guy's actually desperate for our validation. Lorraine, you know, who's

Speaker 7still around is a self proclaimed clairvoyant, and so she was much more you know, what's what's the word. I mean, she was just way out there. Both of them extremely extremely religious, and of course all of us are are atheists. And like right away, it's do you guys believe in God? That's like they they want to know that right off the bat, and we was so many inside jokes came from that that.

Speaker 3Yeah, I was gonna say, Lorraine, I mean even now, if I've listened to interviews, she always starts off, if you don't believe in God, you know, you really are in a hopeless situation in the paranoi.

Speaker 7Yeah, oh yeah, yeah, yeah yeah. So at one point she asked us, so what was it? Why are you atheists?

Speaker 3Well?

Speaker 7What went wrong? Was it the science thing? But yeah, Lorraine, it was the science thing. That's that's what drove us from God. But you know, they were just otherwise. They were just like you're like your grandparents. You know, they were just a regular old couple. This is what this is their living. This is what they did for a living. They went around giving lectures at colleges and you know, they had classes where they told ghost stories.

Speaker 3You know, that was it it doesn't seem like a very steady income. No, they did.

Speaker 7They did it good for themselves. You know, they were on the college circuit. You know, they got thousands of dollars. Oh yeah, they talked probably at every college or university in New England and the Indian area, and they yeah, they at being absolutely made a steady income doing that, no problem. So our, of course, our approach was, you know, we did not confront them on their belief system. That wasn't our purpose there. Our purpose was to investigate their evidence, and that's what we told ed. We just want to

Speaker 7know what. You know, you've been doing this for forty years. You must have accumulated some evidence after at that time he claimed eight had to have investigated eight thousand cases. So we're like, hit us, give us your best evidence, show us, convince us. We're open minded. We will believe it. You just show us some whatever. The most compelling evidence you have is he was very, you know, very squirrely about the whole thing, and I think he was he was afraid that we weren't going to validate his evidence.

Speaker 7So he showed us a lot of ghost photos, which if you've ever just gone on the web, and look up ghost photos. You've seen them. You know, it's all the same things. It's basically the three four most common photographic artifacts. And you get some flashbacks, some camera cord effect, occasional double exposure, all very unimpressive, just blobs of light on film. And you know, you know, when we wrote about our experience with them, we had a section on the photographic artifacts, because that's that is their ninety nine

Speaker 7percent of their evidence. It's just ghost photos. And they made absolutely no attempt to rule out artifacts to understand the nature of the evidence. Here and here's an example of the level of sophistication that we were dealing with. On their website, they had a section where they described how to take a ghost photograph. Now, they claim that the ghostly images get on the film psychically, the ghosts like psychically project the images onto the film. But they were surprised to find that that happened more often when

Speaker 7you used a flash, and the brighter the flash, the better. And yet it didn't occur to them that the flash was producing the effect that was producing the light on the film. They still thought it was a psychic effect from the ghosts, or at least that's what they professed to believe. So that's what we were dealing with. We pointed that out to them, and they just sort of quietly took that off their website without ever acknowledging our correction. But that's basically what we were dealing with.

Speaker 3Wow. So other than that, they seemed like nice people.

Speaker 7They did. It was fun hanging out with them. They were nice people, you know, at least at that stage. You know, once we wrote our article and like Ed no longer had any you know, delusion of convincing us about anything. Uh, he did get a little nasty in a couple occasions. So we Perry and I were on a local TV show with Ed Warren and somebody who's working with them at the time, and yeah, he was kind of a jerk on that show. He did a

Speaker 7typical thing where he sort of dropped new evidence on us that we had never seen before. Explain that skeptics. It's like, uh, you know, Ed, we've been asking you for evidence now, it had been a couple of years. We've been asking you for evidence for a couple of years. We've never seen that before. We'd be happy to take a look at it if you're willing to give us the evidence now to evaluate, because he would never put evidence in our hands to investigate. He would only show it to us. And we wrote about the two big pieces of evidence. So Ed Ed claimed that his best

Speaker 7single piece of evidence was a video of the white lady at Union Cemetery, And as we described it, it was at that perfect distance and resolution that it was suggestive of a ghostly figure, but you couldn't really see it well enough to know that it wasn't Lorraine in a bedsheet, you know what I mean?

Speaker 6Right?

Speaker 7So right, it wasn't close up, it wasn't focus enough, just the quality was not there. So it was like if you were trying to fake a ghost video, that's exactly what it would have looked like. The other piece of evidence, which actually was Ed did not own. It was actually owned by somebody who was investigating with him, and that's how we got our hands on it. So again, Ed never gave us a single piece of evidence to actually investigate, but somebody who went on an investigation with

Speaker 7him did and this was now the infamous video of the kid that did disappeared. You mean yeah, well teleport he de materialized was the term that right? Okay, yeah, so yeah, but they're they're investigating a haunted house. There's a lot of students with them, and you know, when they were they didn't notice anything unusual during the investigation, but the next day when they're looking at them, now, it's like a VHS tape, right that we're talking about. At one point, one of the students was standing in

Speaker 7a doorway, like puts his hand on his head and looks up. Something had dripped on top of his head, and then he disappears and and he's gone from the tape. Now, a three year old looking at this would say the tape stopped and then was restarted later when the kid wasn't there. That's the obvious sort of hypothesis.

Speaker 3Yeah, I would pause it that it might take a six year old. But yeah, I'm with you. O, No, I think my three year old, well your three ye olds exceptional. My six year olds are still kind of amazed by that.

Speaker 7So so that in persistence thing, Uh when do kids figure that out?

Speaker 3But I'm just kidding, Yeah.

Speaker 5I know.

Speaker 7But so, okay, so is a fine?

Speaker 5All right?

Speaker 7You know, I said, I know, are you sure that the camera wasn't stopped? I mean, because that's the first thing that occurs to me when you look at that and you know, we are absolutely sure nobody was anywhere near that camera. It didn't stop, that kid disappeared. That was Ed's famous line, Okay, can we look at the tape? Yes, you give us a tape we had. We didn't touch it. We handed it directly over to a technician, somebody from HB Group, which you know they do. They have video equipment and do this sort of thing. They had an editing deck. Now with the old VHS tapes, once you

Speaker 7know the technology, then you can make sense of the investigation. So first of all, the editing deck that you can view information around the edge of the picture that you wouldn't see on your TV. And when you look at the tape on an editing deck, you could see that there was someone standing right next to the camera, despite the fact that they insisted there was nobody anywhere near it. So that was just flat out proven factually wrong. Next, you can, you know, pretty much prove that the tape was stopped and restarted. And that's because the way these

Speaker 7tapes worked is the images were scanned line by line across each frame from top to bottom right. So because you have the spinning head and it's just scanning the line very very quickly. However, many you know, lines that were per second. So if someone disappeared, actually disappeared, what would they would that would have happened in the middle of that scanning process. It wouldn't have happened at the

Speaker 7end of the last swipe on one frame and prior to the first swipe on the next frame. Does that make sense?

Speaker 3I think so.

Speaker 7Yeah, the chances of that happening would be a minuscule that it happened at that perfect moment that it was right, you know, it almost certainly would have occurred while one frame was being swiped, and it didn't. The kid was completely there on one image and completely gone on the next. Really, the only way to make that happen is to stop the tape and restart it. But then further, I mean, this is like total overkill. There were multiple discontinuities right at the same moment, audio and video discontinuities like footfalls

Speaker 7with echoes that abruptly stop right at that frame, and also a flickering candle that shifts right at that frame. So you could, you know, multiple independent lines of evidence showed that there was a discontinuity right when the kid vanished from the film, and it was completely in between two images, not while when image was being rendered. So there we go. The analysis pretty conclusively proves that the tape was stopped or restarted.

Speaker 3Did they ever find that child's stave?

Speaker 7The guy knew nothing. The thing that's the interesting thing. The guy the kid said, nothing unusual happened, He didn't disappear, and he remembers nothing unusual from that whole evening. Again, nobody did. It was only noticed when they viewed the tape, which is a red flag for a photographic artifact. You know, nothing happened, Nothing happened, It was just something that appeared on the video. So it's something it has to do something with the video. So anyway, so like total overkill

Speaker 7proved that that's what happened. But the most simple thing is in fact, what all the evidence points to. They never accepted it. They never accepted that conclusion. They insisted that that kid de materialized, just immune to evidence and reason. They knew what they were looking for.

Speaker 3Yeah, I think that's one of the big challenges that most people don't know the details of the real investigations they're only familiar with the fictionalized versions. Yeah, and so I had a lot of issues with this after I became more well just openly a skeptic when I was younger. Is that story true? Is that story true? I would investigate, you know, let's see what I can find out, and

Speaker 3a lot of things converge to get me where I'm at right now. But the Amityville Horror in particular was one that used to scare me a lot, and now I don't find it frightening at all, and I wonder I understand that the Conjuring is doing quite well, but I don't think there's been any really great takedowns of the backstory, or not that there necessarily need to be a takedown per se. But it's heavily fictionalized, I mean,

Speaker 3even compared to what the actual people reported at least. Yeah, and so did you see the film?

Speaker 7Not yet. I will go out to see it. We're gonna probably review it on our show too, but we haven't had a chance to see.

Speaker 3Ye.

Speaker 7We just got through filming our web series, so that that's kept us busy. But yeah, you know, like the Amityville Horror, you know that you have an absolutely fictionalized version of events. And although in this case, you know, with the Amityville Horror, there was an admission that it was all made up, in this case, the family claims that, yeah, that's pretty much what happened. You know, we were haunted. Although it was over in the movie, it's over a very short period of time. In real life, they were in that house for nine years or something like that.

Speaker 3That's a long time.

Speaker 7That's a long time. Yeah, you know. And when asked, for example, why did you stay in the house if they were apparitions of rotting flesh walking around and the answer was very unsatisfying, the daughter, who was the youngest person at the time, said, I guess it's just our destiny to tell this story to the world. That doesn't really answer the question, does it, And she ends She ends like I've read some interviews with her which says, I know what we experience, And of course, nope, you don't. You really don't know what you experienced. You have a

Speaker 7constructed perception leading to a constructed memory and reconstructed memory over and over again. Whatever's going on in your head right now of events that happened thirty plus years ago, forty years ago is a complete confabulation in fiction without necessarily any relationship to reality. But in her mind that story really happened, you know.

Speaker 3I know. But to really enjoy the film, I have to suspend my materialist dogma and have some popcorn Minnesota.

Speaker 7Oh yeah, yeah, listen. I love a good ghost story. I'm sure I'll enjoy the movie as a good horror film. I love being creed out.

Speaker 3Yeah, I'll tell you this. The first third of it is the most effective horror film I've seen in a long time. If you know anything about the warres, which you do having actually met them, you'll find that the on screen portrayal of them is I want to say, too goody two shoes, Like they're too good at what they do. Yeah, any question at all, Like yeah, yeah and so, and you know they're going to succeed in what they do.

Speaker 7Yeah, So it'll probably be hard not to vomit watching their trail.

Speaker 3But the first yard is rocking good. It's really good.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 7Yeah, yeah, that's the thing. I think. Same thing with other movies, at least one other movies I saw where the warrants were depicted and the stark contrast to reality is jarring. They had like a scene where like that someone is telling them about their experiences. Oh, you know, they're not quite sure what's going on yet. The person who's being haunted, like these strange things are happening in my house, and like Ed and Lorraine give each other a knowing look like oh yeah, we are familiar with this phenomenon, you know, oh please, I mean, it really

Speaker 7is nothing like them at all. They really were very unsophisticated, uh individuals. And you know, we I have lots of secondhand stories about Ed because once you started investigating the warrants, we that investigation took us to a lot of people who used to work with the warrants and then broke off again. The warrants over the previous decades must have spun off dozens and dozens of independent ghost hunting groups,

Speaker 7because this is the this is the cycle. You know, you see Ed and Lorraine talking to college, you know, give a college lecture and go up afterwards, and they would tell you, oh, you should come to our classes, you know, we give They used to give classes at the Carousel restaurant, you know, down the road, and you'd go to the class, you know, so you catch you they would go through a process of of serial selection until you get the people who are like really into it, and and then you would they would take people on investigations,

Speaker 7and then they would figure out a couple of things. One you know, Ed wasn't the most honest person in the world, and two that what he did took absolutely no special skill or knowledge. And so they figured, hey, we could do this, and we'll do it right, and we'll do it better, and we'll do it honestly. And so they would just break off and do it on their own. And then so there was this never ending cycle of new people coming in and then just very quickly leaving and going off to form their own groups. And so when we talked to them, so we talked to many people disillusioned former colleagues, you know, former students

Speaker 7of Ed Lorraine, and they had a lot of nasty stories to tell about them, which I feel a little uncomfortable talking about because it's all secondhand, you know, so it's essentially hearsay. But I'll just say, you know, if we were told, you know, firsthand stories from the people who were investigating with Ed Lorraine involving you know, pretty nasty Shenanigans.

Speaker 3So many people mentioned like having worked with Ed Lorraine and like even the Paranormal State show worked with her for a while. It just it astonishes me she still has that much cachet at her age with her alleged levels of competency. I don't know, though. On the other hand, she seems like she's probably a really a nice lady. I think the thing is, there's there's two parts of that. I tend to like people in general, yeah, but at

Speaker 3the same time, I think there is they have an undue influence in the paranormal world based on fiction, right.

Speaker 7Yeah. So we we tried desperately to have Ed Lorraine take us on one of their actual investigations, but at the last minute Ed was talked out of it by his some of the people who was working with him, and then he made the excuse that well, because we were atheists, he couldn't protect us from the entities. And we're like, hey, listen, we'll take our chances. We know what we're getting into. It's not your responsibility. We'll be fine.

Speaker 7Don't don't worry about us. But you know, I remember if I had that final phone conversation with Ed, like before we were going to write our article, and he was like really worried that because he was bailing on us, that we were going to again do a hit job on that we were going to write a very critical article about him. And what he said was, you know what he find us with this, I just we can't do it. You know, the other guys won't won't let you guys come on investigation with us because you're atheists. And I said, yeah, Ed, yeah, it's very disappointing. We're

Speaker 7going to have to go with our article without that, and we have to explain that you didn't do that. And I could just hear how crustfallen ed was, because again he still was desperate for our approval at that point, and he said, you're going to make me look like a chump, aren't you. Well, well, I'm going to tell the truth that I'm going to write it as I see it. But he was, yeah, so he did. That's being a part of that. You know, him was afraid that we were going to be critical of him and really wanted to please us. But but still, you know, hey,

Speaker 7he made the decision. You know, but of course, if we had gone on an investigation with him, we just would have had more material. It really wouldn't have changed the tone of our article, or you.

Speaker 3Had disappeared and never been seen again.

Speaker 7Yeah right. We did go on investigations with people who worked with the Warrens, though just not with with Ed Lorraine Warren themselves, and again they were, you know, and same thing. Lots of ghosts. It's all just people with ghost stories at the end of the day. That's it's just like watching the ghost hunting shows today. It's just people scaring each other with ghost stories without a shred of credible evidence, and without the slightest idea how to do an actual scientific investigation, the difference between a hypothesis

Speaker 7and a theory about it not only hunting hypothesis testing. They had no clue. They really are, you know, pseudoscientists. They just simply have no idea about how to do an actual scientific investigation. In fact, I gave a lecture for a ghost hunting class where I explained to them what a scientific investigation is and what the kind of evidence it would take to convince us that ghost surreal,

Speaker 7and they just didn't get it, you know, just they just just didn't They didn't want to get it. It just was they were just having fun. You know, most people, it's just this was their fantasy. It really wasn't about And you know what I often say, it's like, that's fine if this is what you know, we all need to do stuff for fun, you know, if this is your fantasy, if this is for fun, you have a good time. Just stop saying you're doing science. Okay, just stop that. Stop it, because you're not. You're not doing science.

Speaker 7That's really the only beef that we have with them that they claim that they were doing that they were gathering scientific evidence when they were making a mockery of the scientific method.

Speaker 3So you think it was a form of LARPing.

Speaker 7Yeah, absolutely, And we often would say that, We say, these people need to play tabletop or need to go LARPing. They need to have some kind of fantasy based escape that they know is fantasy. The problem is this was their escape, but they were confusing over reality. We used to say that all the time, these people just went LARPing, you know, they wouldn't have to do this funny.

Speaker 3Well, I don't want to spoil the findings of your investigation. We will put a link to that in the show notes. Sure, but I did notice that the list of incredibly dangerous arcane tomes and Ed's library included well unearthed arcana.

Speaker 7Yeah. Oh, that museum was hilarious. It was you know, it was I don't know where they got all that stuff.

Speaker 3Here's a good example of the kind of research Ed did for his occult museum. In this clip, he's walking an interviewer through his museum of cursed and demonic artifacts. As an FYI. This interviewer here is his son in law, Tony Spira, who continues to help out Lorraine to this day, and it was also the fellow conducting the interview. At the start of this episode, Tony points out a copy of a dark covered book with a post it note on it which says Book of Shadows, and above that printed on the cover are the dread words the necrydomicon.

Speaker 9We had it read this way, but while we're heading this way, right here, I see this book here, this book, he says, a Book of Shadows.

Speaker 3Niramonkaki, tell me what that.

Speaker 11Yes, that's one of the original books of Shadows, which were written in the Midi of old days, and this one here was translated into English. Just the reading of that book has a terrible results for many people. This is not a book that anyone should ever buy, a book of shadows that goes into the incantations of devils and demons and rituals.

Speaker 3Just a modicum of research and Ed would have learned that the Book of Shadows he's holding is first of all, not a book of shadows, and second of all not the Necronomicon. This is a copy of the hoax Necronomicon, released by the writer known as Simon. It's a famous literary hoax. It's full of incantations and spells that are supposed to be from a Sumaria, which are in fact not Also, it's not a book of shadows. Book of shadows are spell books for modern paganism, not ancient medieval scrolls or spells or rituals. His museum of demonic possessed

Speaker 3items was full of off the shelf halloween junk dolls and toys books you could buy any bookstore, and in this case, one which wasn't even close to being what he was representing it to be.

Speaker 7But it's like stuff that they thought was demonic or scary or whatever, you know. Again, to put a lot of this into into context, Ed Lorraine were very devout Catholics, and that was their mythology, and so anything firmly for you. I'd called himself a demonologist, you know that. That was his approach to These weren't just ghosts, these were demons. His most haunted artifact, according to Ed, was a raggedy

Speaker 7and doll, which he kept in a glass case. And before and again, we were still not sure why he did this. But when he led us down to the basement, then he disappeared for like ten minutes and then came back. I have no idea what he was doing. I think it was just spying on us. But he warned us, don't go anywhere near the raggedy and doll, don't touch it, try not to brush up against anything, because then you might get possessed, because these things are all so evil. So of course we're standing around there touching everything, you know, having a good time, and you know, mocking the raggedy

Speaker 7and doll. He told us like a story about the last person who mocked that raggedy and doll got died an hour later in a motorcycle accident. Okay, yeah, we're all still around, no problems. But he said, if you if you do touch anything, let me know, because I'll cleanse your aura by visualizing you in a christ light, and He'll be able to cleanse us in that way. So well, we never fest up to having touched.

Speaker 3Anything, and the curse is still with you, you're saying.

Speaker 7I guess we're all still cursed.

Speaker 3So okay. So what cracks me up about this, to know, I mean, just to no end, is the I had heard you tell that story about the doll, and you always called it a raggedy ann doll. And I always assumed you were saying that like it was a xeroxor it was you know what I mean, Like that was a generic term. And when I went to see the movie, they have this doll Annabelle as part of the story in the beginning. It's part of the intro. Yeah, and

Speaker 3oh it's super creepy. It's awesome. And then I thought, well, what does the real annabel look like, because I'd heard Steve talk about seeing it, and I went and looked. It was like, oh my god, no, seriously, it's a raggedy an.

Speaker 7It is a literal raggedy hand doll.

Speaker 3And we were talking. I was talking to my friends about why they changed it. And you know, obviously the copyright issues or obviously a raggedy and doll is not as scary as this creepy thing they use. I'm like, no, guys, don't you see the doll had to be able to pick up stuff and raggedy ann doesn't have fingers, right? That was that was great. So I'm gonna put a picture of that in the show notes too. About the real Annabelle and the winner from the film, warns Trutle, Well,

Speaker 3that's a lot of information about the Warrens. In my research. I also found some interesting articles and videos, and links to those are in the show notes. Be on the lookout for Joe nichols research on the Parent Family haunting is depicted in the Conjuring It'll be an upcoming issue of Skeptical Enquirer magazine. Also in the show notes is a write up of the New England Skeptic Society's investigation of the Warrens by Steve Navella and the late Period DeAngelis. It's a great read. Be sure to check it out. Monster Talk is an official podcast the Skeptic Magazine. I'm Blake Smith and you've just been listening to our special episode The Warren Omission. You heard interviews with Joe Nichol,

Speaker 3Steve Novella, Marvin Scott, and Ray Garden. An additional audio from Edwin Lorraine Warren and their son in law, Tony Spira. If you want to help out Muster Talk, please share this episode with your friends and enemies alike. Our frenemies are inemens.

Speaker 1Yeah, this has been a Monster House presentation.

Speaker 11No, no,

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S06E07 Elizabeth Taylor and the Burton of Truth

    Nov 16, 202655 minAudio

    Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S06E06 🐈⬛Evil Cats and Revelatory Revenants👻

    Nov 9, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S06E05🎃 Live 2026 Halloween Show

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S06E04 🍿Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈 Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S06E03 🎥 Capturing Bigfoot 🫈with Marq Evans

    Oct 19, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...

    Credit the people on this episode