Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

MonsterTalk

MonsterTalk artwork

S04E26 - A Natural History of Sea Serpents with Adrian Shine

Mar 31, 202555 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

We're delighted to get to talk with Adrian Shine, who has worked for decades to raise awareness about Loch Ness and investigated the legendary creature said to inhabit the dark waters of that deep Scottish lake. He's written a new book about Sea Monsters and their connection to the Loch Ness Mystery which releases April 1st, 2025. A Natural History of Sea Monsters (affiliate link) The Loch Ness Centre In the intro you hear a clip of IN SEARCH OF from S01E20 - which features a young Adrian. Check out In Research Of's coverage with guest Daniel Loxton here. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Monster House Presents.

Speaker 2Adrian Shine is another veteran of the hunt, but he has chosen to track his quarry at lock Moraar, just above Lockness. Monsters have been seen here too, and the relative clarity of the water in Morale may give Shine an advantage.

Speaker 3We are laying out this year cameras television cameras beneath the surface in order to carry out a constant surveillance over some three months. We can lay the cameras down to sixty feet beneath the water and hope to get a silhouette of creature passing over the top. We can get ranges underwater of nearly one hundred feet. We have some conventional cameras as well, conventional thirty.

Speaker 4Five milimeter cameras, but the video.

Speaker 3Technique, in my opinion, is better because we have an immediate and immediate rickold, we don't have prosis film, and because we're going to move.

Speaker 5It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before.

Speaker 6A giant hairy creature park Ape part Mat in Luckness, a twenty four a mile long bottomless lake in the Highlands of Scotland, get a creature known as the Luckness Monster.

Speaker 4Monstertal.

Speaker 5Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and.

Speaker 4I'm Karen Stolsner.

Speaker 7Putting together Monster Talk has allowed me to talk with an astonishing collection of intelligent and accomplished people from a huge and very diversity of backgrounds. We've talked to physicists, biologists, naturalists, psychologists, folkloris.

Speaker 8It's been an.

Speaker 7Honor and a pleasure to be able to ask questions and get answers across so many domains of expertise. But I didn't come to monsters as an academic, and I didn't come to them as an adult.

Speaker 4Nope.

Speaker 7I was a monster kid, and even way back in my scholastic book days, I also scoured the TV for any shows and what we often called specials back then, they had it to do with cryptids or weirdness of any kind. Adrian Shine has been in my world since I was a kid. His kind face and magnificent beard have made him the Gandolf of Lockness in my mind. His Lockness Center exists both as a museum and as the website Lockness dot com, and it's one of those places where you can come for the mystery of NeSSI

Speaker 7and leave with a richer understanding of the ecosystem of the Locke and it's placed in geography, biology, and history. From submarines to massive sonar surveys. Shine has been a part of investigating every aspect of the deep, dark body of water and it's alleged denizens. Now he's written a book that connects sea monsters and lake monsters with their common biome, which might not be dark deep water, but rather the human mind.

Speaker 1Read it and decide for yourself.

Speaker 7The book will be released April first, twenty twenty five, and links to it or in the show notes. But let me say right now that talking to Adrian was absolutely one of my bucket list items achieved the thing I really wanted to do.

Speaker 1Before I kicked the bucket.

Speaker 7He was a delight to chat with and Karen and I enjoyed this immensely and we hope you do too.

Speaker 1Morenster, Well, thank you so much for taking the time to talk to us today. I again, this is a lifelong dream for me. You know, I've always wanted to get to the lock and I've never managed to make it. But maybe it's on the list.

Speaker 7It's definitely on the bucket list, but it's always talking with you. This is just remarkable. So I will read a brief bio for you in the show's opening, which i'll record offline. But in the unlikely event that someone has joined this episode here and doesn't know who Adrian Shine is, would you like to give a brief introduction the way you'd like to be introduced.

Speaker 8Well, I'm a naturalist.

Speaker 4I have been interested in the deeper Scottish locks for a long time.

Speaker 8They drew me.

Speaker 4First because of the controversy that we all know about, but my interest diversified not just in terms of the whole biology and geology and what not of Lockness, but into the realm of sea serpents, which are the true ancestors of the Lochness Monster.

Speaker 9Just to begin with, Adrian, did you start out as a scientist and being skeptical about this creature or did you have a belief in it or hope that it might exist? And if you did, how did you transition to that the skepticism.

Speaker 4Well, it was an interesting transition because I start my interest was piqued as an eight year old on the on the east coast of England, where I saw a sea serpent, my first sea serpent, and my parents. I found the responses of my parents extremely unsatisfactory. They wanted, they wanted me to believe in a lot of things that could not be seen. But they had to tell me that those sea serpents were seen, they were not

Speaker 4believed in. And that was a very unsatisfactory answer to me. But later at school I became aware that one of our foremost naturalists, Sir Peter Scott, was seriously in in trying to find out what people were seeing in Lockness. This was in the nineteen sixties, and if it was good enough for him, it was certainly interesting for me. And I'd read the two books by Bernard Hervelman's what

Speaker 4would be called now Cryptozoology, and it took my fancy. So, no, I wasn't a skeptical scientist at all. I wasn't a scientist then. I'm not a scientist now. But the scientific method is available, and you see cameras and sonar. There are ways of looking. Science is a way of thinking, and that is the stage that we have got to now at Lockness and relating it to the much bigger question,

Speaker 4the original question of the sea serpents. Because the original investigators of Lockness all assumed and had to assume, that a sea serpent in inverted commons that includes sea monsters had entered after the last ice age. We were one big ice cube until ten thousand years ago, and so the two subjects are intimately interwoven.

Speaker 1So I think maybe some readers might be surprised that you're writing about sea serpents when NeSSI is more if you're pardon the pun, land locked, but wit misconceptions or what key ideas about sea serpents and lake masters did you want to clarify with your fascinating new book, A Natural History of Sea Serpents.

Speaker 4I wanted to show the true connection between the two, and also to show that locke Ness provided the answer to at least the classic sea serpent form, which is a there as of multi humps or loops on the cartoon postcards. They're always actually seen as humps, humps, and maybe a relatively short head and neck sticking out of

Speaker 4the water. And that was the Originally it was called the Norwegian sea serpent because that's where it was first drawn and recorded in the eighteenth century, and then it became very popular in eighteen seventeen on the coast of New England where hundreds of people saw this multi hunt short necked creature swimming about. And that is the classic

Speaker 4sea serpent. And it was what the original investigators of loch Ness thought must have entered Lockness, and in fact it did and it was amenable to investigation as Rupert Gould hoped it would be, not perhaps in the way he had expected, but we found that the multi humps were caused by ships. Lockness is part of the Caledonian

Speaker 4Canal and quite large vessels moved through it. They leave displacement wakes which cause a series of very inky, black, solid looking humps behind them, sometimes a very long way behind them, such that the vessel causing them has disappeared. Right, That is the main cause of the sea serpent. So it was found in Lockness, and that's what my little

Speaker 4book demonstrates.

Speaker 7That's very Yeah, we've talked a bit about that on the show. Very compelling illusion I if that's the right word. It really does look like something is moving through the water.

Speaker 8Is it an illusion?

Speaker 4Perhaps that is the Lochness monster, It is the Lake Tahoe monster. It is the Lake Okanagan monster. That is it in a nutshell. It is the sea serpent form, and the sea serpent form with the multi humps are wakes.

Speaker 8Now, it's no Perhaps it's a bit of.

Speaker 4A coincidence that the first steamship to enter Gloucester Harbor was just before the sightings began of the New England Sea Serpent. So the steamships had a lot to do with it because they left wakes, these multi humps. The illusion you speak of on calm water, sailing ships don't sailing ships. Sailing ships if there's no wind blowing, they

Speaker 4go nowhere. They are becomed. Once the wind is blowing, they begin to move, but the wind is raising waves on the surface of the water which obscure their wakes. And so the wakes of these steamships, the first steamships were novel, that's the thing you've got to remember. And they're not the only thing that can cause wakes. The leatherback turtle is an animal of substantial size which swims

Speaker 4for quite long periods on the surface, and that's got a lot to do with it too.

Speaker 2Well.

Speaker 1It is interesting that you speak of oroboros in your introduction, and in a sense it could be said that that the explanation of wakes in turn provides a reason to have a wake for NeSSI. In that NeSSI might itself be awake.

Speaker 7Which there's a symmetry there. But I'm not quite prepared to put her to bed.

Speaker 1You know, she's even if she's fully explained as a as a result of perception issues I she holds such a special place in my heart folklorically and culturally. I'm not ready to let go of NeSSI.

Speaker 8You know you don't have to.

Speaker 4If you now perceive any wake you see as NeSSI.

Speaker 1She's around the world to live.

Speaker 4Anywhere anywhere, see or NeSSI one and the same thing as Rupert Gould always thought they were.

Speaker 1That's so funny. You mentioned in the intro you talk about and tune Cornelius Udeman's and Bernard Hogelman's as being influential on you. You talked about Udeman's if I'm saying that correctly talking about an undiscovered pinniped and Hubelman's talking about cryptozoological taxonomy. Where do you find yourself in relationship to their theories?

Speaker 7And I should also quickly point out you also talk about Charles Paxton, who we've had on the show before, and we have a running bet on whether or not a kraken of a particular size will be proven to exist within a ten year period, at which time either I will buy him or he will buy me a bottle of krack and rum.

Speaker 8So that's a good arrangement.

Speaker 1Yeah, quite, And I don't.

Speaker 4Have money on either side of that argument.

Speaker 8Yeah at the moment. No, I'm sorry.

Speaker 4So your question, your initial question before we digress.

Speaker 8Was Hervelman's Damans.

Speaker 4Well, I think I'm closer to Hervelman's in Thatans took.

Speaker 8The whole.

Speaker 4Catalog of citing reports and compressed them into one explanation, his long necked seal, whereas Hervelman's exploded them into no less than nine categories of sea serpent, the long neck, the multi hump, the superata visual impressions. Well, I'm closer to that in that idea. Though I reject some of

Speaker 4his classifications, they are useful targets for investigation, and so his multi humper we have already addressed. And it's the same in my book as his super otter, one of them appearing on one side of the Atlantic, on the other on the other side. And that is also interesting in that he sees them both ceasing becoming extinct in his terms, in ecological terms. In my terms, it's more

Speaker 4cultural in that multi humped serpentine monsters began to lose favor in the nineteenth century in terms of the discoveries of fossils fossil plesiosaurs on the south coast of England, and from about I like to think of eighteen forty eight, you tend to hear more sea monsters being seen, which are more long necked, single bodied, not multi hump and

Speaker 4with long necks. So I see that as a sort of a cultural reaction. We try to make our myths, if you like, more rational as we go along, because we don't want to relinquish them. Ghosts might once have been thought of as the souls of the departed, maybe coming back in some form. Now people might think of relict energy. We try and modernize things. So the sea

Speaker 4serpent became less rational than plesiosaurs, which at least had existed in fossil form. We knew there had been some. Wouldn't it be nice if there were still some? And that was one way of us making our myths, if you like, more rational. Of late, things have gone on stage further. People we haven't really sought reptiles or mammals

Speaker 4in Lockness since the nineteen seventies. The best we can come up with in lateral terms is a basket of fish. You know, my favorite surgeon, Dick Rainers catfish, and the giant eel, the eunuch eel, which likes it so much in Lockness that it doesn't go to Sargasso to breed and gets bigger and bigger.

Speaker 8We try and make.

Speaker 4Things more rational because we found lots of eel DNA in Lockness. Of course it's the same DNA as for all the little eels, right, So actually it doesn't provide a refutation or a confirmation of the giant in your theory.

Speaker 9And when you mentioned the stir, I first thought about the surgeon's photograph, and I think it's very difficult for a lot of people do not think of the surgeon's photograph, that iconic picture when they think of the Lockness monster and claims about the creature. So is this a myth that you're constantly having to dispel or do you find that nowadays people are dismissive of that story.

Speaker 4I think people accept the hoax story, the revelation of it being a little model on a toy submarine, because there's a lot of confirmation for it. But one of the fundamental issues with the surgeon's picture is that it is seen as the epitome of the Lockness monster. I'll never deny that. Everybody knows that picture and it's a beautiful picture, very enigmatic, but it is also seen as

Speaker 4the epitome of a plesiosaul. Recent paleontology has made it clear that this upraised posture for the head and neck is the one thing that a pleisi saw could not do because of the spiness processes in.

Speaker 8Its servical vertebrae.

Speaker 4Its neck vertebrae have got sticky up bits that would lock together if the pleas you saw tried to raise its neck very.

Speaker 8Far at all.

Speaker 4And so the one, the one thing about the surgeon's picture which suggested pleasosaurs is the one thing that pleasosaurs could not do.

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 1Yeah, We did an episode with the Adam Stewart Smith. It was like our fifth episode in basically just take in the approach if if NeSSI were a please us or what would it look like based on current paleontology, And that's been become our elevator pitch for the show, you know, just talking about what does real science tell us about monsters? And you know, we've been doing this in two thousand and nine, and it's obvious monsters will not be killed by science. But then we have to ask, well,

Speaker 1then what are they what?

Speaker 7You know, if they're not going to go away just because they're impossible, what do they represent?

Speaker 1What do they mean? That sort of thing.

Speaker 10So it's interesting to the monsters have got to the point where we're not talking about probabilities anymore.

Speaker 4And there was a probability if there was a big lake and hundreds of people saw a big animal in it, I would say it was probable that there was a big animal in it. But I'm afraid we've now got to the point since we've explained very search what people are seeing, and we do know what people are seeing. They're seeing they're seeing boat wakes or multi hun sea serpents, and they're seeing waterbirds for the long necked plisorian ones.

Speaker 4This we've known for a very long time. Once you have calm water. Calm water is the common factor, by the way, you need calm water to sea serpents or lockness monsters. And I've explained why, in the case of the water birds, you lose your sense of distance. If you lose your sense of distance, you lose your sense of scale. And the behavior of these long necked lockness

Speaker 4monsters is extremely birdlike, shaking their heads, floating on the surface, and dipping their heads into the water as if feeding. Now, that does not imply an aquatic creature, does it. It implies a terrestrial one to dip its head into the lock to feed. So that's where we are with it. I think you asked a question just before that to

Speaker 4do with to do with the lock itself, and I probably digressed.

Speaker 1No, no, no, I'm not quite sure I had a question at that point I was. I think I was just commenting because I find it it's fascinating to me that, even as a person who has, you know, started out as very much wanting these things to be real. I've never lost my love for them, even though my personal skepticism has made me come down into thinking that they're more of a product of human perception. But it's interesting because you describe your own approach is one of sympathetic skepticism,

Speaker 1which reminds me very much of our own stance here. We've called it a presumption of sincerity when someone brings us a monster story or we see a claim and we approach it that way. So how do you balance sort of validating these experiences of the witnesses with that skepticism, Yet you know that sort of sympathy that we know that human perception can lead us down monstrous paths.

Speaker 4Yes, I think this does draw us back to what you were saying, and I think, just to remind myself, I'll say the word now it's confirmation by us. In other words, although this might now be a societal construct, it nevertheless influences what we expect to see and maybe even in retrospect, how we just crime the things that

Speaker 4we see because we're trying to rationalize them. By definition, a lockiness monster or a sea serpent is something we don't recognize, and so we grasp for a cogent narrative in explaining with what we've seen to somebody else. And that is how I think societal constructs actually influence the way we place our experience on record. Now, my sympathetic

Speaker 4skepticism is broadly because I accept the integrity for the most part of the witnesses. Less so the photographers. That's just fun that all the good pictures are fakes and all the bad pictures are useless. But witnesses often have very compelling experiences, and I believe that the vast, vast

Speaker 4majority are entirely sincere, and the work that I have done I believe vindicates them in so far as their observations go. When somebody reports seeing a multi humped phenomenon on the lock, they are it's a displacement wake, It's a Kelvin wake. We can define it precisely in physical terms.

Speaker 4They have exactly, They have exactly described what they have seen. Interpretation is something else. It impugnes nobody for me to say that their interpretation is but an opinion. I can say that I have seen a bus. It's acceptable for me to say that because I have perceived a bus. But I cannot say that what I have seen is

Speaker 4a bus. That is an interpretation and an opinion. And that is the difference. That is where the skepticism actually applies. The sympathy is to accept the witness and their statement and their observation. The skepticism is the matter of interpretation.

Speaker 9Do you think you could share a particular case where your approach of this sympathetic skepticism perhaps led to a surprising or revealing conclusion.

Speaker 4Yes, yes, and I can think of one example. There was a young man growing about a boat on Lockmore. It was his first visit to a Scottish lock He had expectations. Yeah, I believe he had a book with him my previous expedition. And he was rowing the boat nine miles from habitation towards the head of the loch in the dusk, and he was rowing along and then suddenly,

Speaker 4from behind him he's looking backwards obviously a great, big black hump cruised from behind a promontory out into the loch. And he stopped rowing, and the hump stopped moving, and he began to close in, pushing on the oars to close the rain. She took a picture and he got his city camera ready, and then ripples broke away from

Speaker 4what no longer looked like a big hump. That was a huge head in the water. So it's always sinister That young man was me in nineteen seventy three. It was a rock with about two inches high and about six feet long. If I couldn't trust my own eyes, I could hardly trust anybody else's either. And my sea

Speaker 4serpent when I was eight years old, a set of humps going rapidly across the horizon. A local man told us the next day what we had seen. It was a line of birds, water birds, which I think is causing some issues in San Francisco Bay just now. So

Speaker 4perhaps that's whereby skepticism started. But it didn't well my interest. You've made the point that you've not lost your interest.

Speaker 8Well neither have I.

Speaker 9Yeah, remarkable.

Speaker 1You mention eighteen forty eight as a potential watershed year for cryptids, which I imagine alert readers will recognize as being contemporaneous with the sighting of HMS Daedalus. So exactly how did this sighting shape perceptions of sea serpents? And do you see it as a sort of definitive turning point and how sea monsters are imagined?

Speaker 4Well, I doative narrative terms. Dr Paxton might disagree with me in purely mathematical terms, but in terms of the narratives that witnesses have produced. You've got to remember Dadalus. Though long, it was a long creature in inverted commas. It didn't have any humps, did it? No humps? It was long and straight, and the captain called it a

Speaker 4sea serpent, as he would as you might expect him to say. But ten years later one of his officers wrote an anonymously in support of the skepticism that had been expressed, particularly by Professor Owen, and he said he would not call it a serpent, but more of a lizard. And so I take that as the watershed moment. And then you have Captain Kringle on the umfully seeing what

Speaker 4I would regard as the classic plesiosaur, the sea serpent. So I see it as the smoothing away of the humps.

Speaker 9So we've spoken a little bit about some of the creatures that would cause this phenomenons, and eels and sturgeons. Could you provide some further insight into the different types of natural phenomena or marine animals that you frequently found to be responsible for these reports, and what kinds of behaviors or misinterpretations might lead to these classic sea serpent descriptions.

Speaker 4Yes, we've dealt with lockness in terms of the plesiosaur types and the sea setpent types, and there are a few more types.

Speaker 8But going to the sea again, we have.

Speaker 4The wakes most aquatic creatures do not leave wakes for very long because they just take a breath of air and they're down again. The leather bag is an exception to that, and that's why I believe it was behind a lot of the Gloucester, New England Sea serpent reports of eighteen seventeen and afterwards.

Speaker 8But if we go back.

Speaker 4Into the eighteenth century, we have the Norwegian missionary Egada, who reported a very dreadful monster which erupted close to his ship and reared up as far as the yard arm before falling back. It had a serpentine head, it had big flippers as well, and its tail broke surface

Speaker 4a whole ship's length away. Well, I and doctor Paxton think in terms of the humpback whale. Nowadays we are much more familiar with the humpback. A generation or two ago, the only whale that we would have really thought about would be the sperm whale, where it's great, big square head. And if I ask, as I have dozens of people

Speaker 4to draw a whale, it is still a sperm whalehead that they draw. But in terms of the now popular commercial whale watching enterprises, the absolute mainstay is actually the humpback whale, and everybody is hoping for a breaching to happen when they have ropped from the water and fall down backwards. It is an awesome sight, probably the most

Speaker 4awesome sight in nature. And I believe it fits all the criteria. This thing blue like a whalefish, well, humpbacks, all whales blow. It had the big flappers, that is, the flippers. It felt out, it went down backwards, It had a rough skin. Its tail came up. When a whale breaches, almost always one lobe of its tail comes up,

Speaker 4just momentarily. And I also think the humpback is behind the stories of sea serpents battling whales. The humpback has a behavior called pectoral slapping. The pectoral fin of a humpback is about a third of its own length. It's the longest fin, and when the humpback turns on its back,

Speaker 4waves these flippers in the air and slaps them down onto the water surface. And it exactly describes the motion that in a couple of cases has been interpreted as sea serpents wrapping themselves around a whale and killing it. So I regard the humpback as very much behind that in terms of long necks. I see the male orcus

Speaker 4fin as an example of interpretation there, particularly if it is approaching you or going away from you, when it appears thinner, and when the male is not in the pod. Unusually, male orcas stay with the maternal pod, but they breed elsewhere, and they make excursions. You would never think of a

Speaker 4sea serpent if you saw a male orcer's fin surrounded by the females, But if you see it by himself sinister rising moment movement, you could well be thinking it was something else. And also, in latter years, the tip of the male orchid fin can begin to collapse turn over,

Speaker 4giving the impression perhaps of a head.

Speaker 8So there's another example.

Speaker 7The collapsing of my physical structures with age is sadly very familiar.

Speaker 8Yes, yes, do you see this.

Speaker 7Shift from sea monsters to hidden species is part of a broader pattern in how humans explain the unknown.

Speaker 1I guess I'm wondering here.

Speaker 7Has kryptosology inherited these same structures of belief that that fueled sea serpents in earlier centuries.

Speaker 4There was plenty that was unknown in previous centuries, and so so I think I think it was a move towards rationality. I think, I think now it's not. What we're trying to do is to find mystery in a shrinking world where we know a lot more about it. I think we do, and we don't want to know all about it. We still want those hidden areas the

Speaker 4cryptozoologist would say, the hidden animals. So yes, I think it's different. It's different now, and we want something manageable scientific questions now can.

Speaker 8Scarce Well, we're scarce.

Speaker 4The man in the street scarcely understands the questions now, let alonely answers. So the sea serpent or the lake monster, at least is an easy, accessible idea. They are there or they are not. It's simple, it's finite. One can understand it. So one can be a believer or a skeptic. I suspect that you and I are neither. We are interested,

Speaker 4which is enough.

Speaker 9We've talked about the surgeon's photograph a little bit already, and lockness has generated some of the world's some of the most famous monster photographs, and many of which have been debunked over the years. How do these visual proofs compared to see serpent photographs? And how do you see similar patterns in how they've been received by believers and skeptics alike.

Speaker 4Well, there aren't really that many Lockness pictures that would be considered classic. There are lots of lots of bad ones and mistaken ones and ones that frankly aren't worth talking about. But I imagine you're talking about the surgeon's picture, the huge gray picture, and I don't know what that is, and I don't think anybody else does either. I think it's double exposed and a bit of a mess. But it gives scope for the imagination, doesn't it. And then

Speaker 4Stuart picture, which is completely different. These angular well i'd call I suppose you call them humps. We know that was a fake straw bales with Paul and in very shallow water. We found the water was very shallow at that point. The McNab picture is huge. You've got a creature there which is impossibly big regarding the food resources

Speaker 4of the loch.

Speaker 1Yes, I was just thinking that's the one where you can see the castle. It is quite quite large.

Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, yes.

Speaker 1It's guyed you as the kids would say, it's quite it's God's level.

Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, it's probably it's probably if it were an animal. It would probably weigh twice the entire fish population of the loch. It's just outrageously big, and it looks just like a retouched boat wake, which is.

Speaker 8What I think.

Speaker 4It is.

Speaker 9Interesting.

Speaker 4So no, I don't give any credence to the classic pictures. And of course, in terms of sea serpents, there are a very very very few sea serpent photographs. It was won by a Professor Sharp, who was an ornithologist. I think it might have been a beaked whale. That's in my little book as well. It's because, of course, a lot of these were in the nineteenth century, when cameras were a lot more cumbersome.

Speaker 1True, and took longer to make an ex Yes, it's a love.

Speaker 4Just how many You've get a lot of pictures now, some of them try On's, and others, of course, because they're moving, very often resolve themselves into something explicable.

Speaker 7It is interesting, I think when I think about, say, Bigfoot, you know, the Patterson Gimlin film sort of created a template for exactly what Bigfoot's supposed to look like, and there were a lot more interesting variations in the alleged photos in the seventies than now.

Speaker 6Now.

Speaker 1Everything favors Bigfoot in the Patterson line. It's like everything sort of melted down to that one shape. And I'm wondering when you think about the rise in sonar, drones, AI analysis, like all these new technologies for looking at physical or photographic evidence or any kind of instrumental evidence. I guess, but how do you think these are going to help or will they help resolve these mysteries or

Speaker 1will they always remain just another nudge at plausibility But without ever answering anything, I'm very curious where you think things are headed.

Speaker 4Well, the more sophisticated your machine and the more likely it is to produce some noise that you can't explain. And that is, after all, what a monster is. Something you want to believe in and you can't explain all your expert cannot explain it. We've got our answer to what people are seeing, thank you very much. We did that back in the seventies and eighties.

Speaker 8You know, yes, you did.

Speaker 4Hope springs eternal, and I don't want to spoil it. Good is day. You can keep on thinking about it, but think laterally. Now you have to think about an animal in lockness which evades environmental DNA detection.

Speaker 8Now, how is it going to do that?

Speaker 4If it's a reptile, how would it cope with the cold? There's no reptile DNA in lockness. There is no amphibian DNA except a bit of toad DNA, which of course is from the sides.

Speaker 8There is no mammal in.

Speaker 4Quantity in lockness apart from human DNA. There's a lot of that all the way through.

Speaker 8So what are you left.

Speaker 4You're left with the basket of fish. And my favorite sturgeon doesn't leave any DNA because it isn't there, because it's migratory.

Speaker 8Might pop in.

Speaker 4Every now and again, might cause a bit of interest, and then it would go away again. The catfish, the European catfish, one or two survivors, possibly from human introduced stocks in Victorian times, meant to live one hundred years. Perhaps one or two might not have left enough DNA. And then you have the giant eunuch eel. Well, as

Speaker 4I explained, its DNA would be exactly the same as all the little eels.

Speaker 8There's no different eel DNA. So those are lateral solutions which allow a putative animal to evade confirmation or refutation by the most elegant method we have for looking at species diversity environmental DNA. So that's the point, think literally

Speaker 8into the realm of possibility. Probabilities are long gone. You are left with your possibilities, but you'll have to think hard now.

Speaker 4To get around the environmental DNA.

Speaker 9In the epilogue of your book, you touch upon the enduring human fascination with monsters and the shift towards seeking lost worlds in inaccessible locations. So how does the ongoing interest in sea serpents, despite the lack of definitive physical evidence, fit into a broader psychological and cultural context.

Speaker 8The sea is a very big place.

Speaker 4It is a very big place, and I believe there are monsters still to find in it. I have simply sought explanations for some of the historical and classical sea serpent stereotypes, I suppose, But I think until we have explored that the real ocean depths, the worst thing out there is still us.

Speaker 8We've got a lot to learn. Yet.

Speaker 4The point about lockness was that it provided a finite area, an accessible idea. And this is where I come back to Karen and the cultural element of this. It's got to do with understanding the question and the matter of is there or isn't there a monster. The way these stereotypes have developed came directly from the sea serpent controversy

Speaker 4of the nineteenth century. People started off seeing serpents, ended up seeing monsters. Please you saw monsters. So that's the way the cultural change happened at Lockness as well. Well. The two stereotypes actually coexist, even though they contradict each other. I suppose it is the accessibility of the idea in Lockness combined with the geographical accessibility of that environment. Do

Speaker 4you see to have to have hidden animals, you really need lost worlds inaccessible places. Well, Lockness just about qualifiers. It's deep, and it's dark and it's hostile, but it is accessible geographically, only fourteen miles south of the Highland capital and you can drive down the AET two road,

Speaker 4you can stop in a lay by, and you are.

Speaker 8On the brink of discovery.

Speaker 4It'll be a lot, a lot more complicated than that nowadays, photograph well you know what with AI and photoshop. Yeah, it wouldn't be as easy as all that, but you get the point. You'd be on the brink of discovery.

Speaker 1Absolutely, So I want to commend your book to our readers.

Speaker 7It is a natural history of sea serpents. It will drop in bookstores everywhere on April first. It's available for pre order now.

Speaker 1Adrian, thank you so much for taking the time to talk with us now as a first time as a first time guessed. We have a signature question we like to ask everyone, and that is, and I'm really curious, that's what you'll say here, what is your favorite monster?

Speaker 8My favorite?

Speaker 7Yeah, and it could be anything with whatever you define as a monster, so.

Speaker 4Well, my leather back would be my favorite, all right?

Speaker 6And why is that?

Speaker 4Because I believe that is what caused the issue in the first place, off the Norwegian coast back in the eighteenth century, and then sustained that that idea off the coast of New England in eighteen seventeen, and in fact long afterwards as well. I think it is probably of all the animals, it probably has had the greatest influence

Speaker 4with its wake.

Speaker 1It is amazing. It is interesting to me. I mean, I grew up around farmers. My grandfather was a farmer and rancher, and you sort of assume that people who live in nature know nature deeply and that's just not true, not at all. T it's shocking true.

Speaker 4They've got a job to do, that's right. Granted they're not they're not looking. The local people aren't looking at lockness. They've got better things to do.

Speaker 8Exactly, it's living to earn. I know what lockness looks like.

Speaker 4Thank you.

Speaker 8They've been here a long time.

Speaker 7It's Renchers are concerned with keeping animals alive, not with studying their decay, so you know, cattle mutilation become these weird mysteries.

Speaker 4Uh.

Speaker 7People who frequently walk in the woods aren't aware that bears frequently walk on their hind legs, so they see a two legged, hairy animal and assume it's a bigfoot and it's just time and time again. Are our own limited understanding of the natural world provides a landscape for monsters, which.

Speaker 9Is different contexts?

Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, the true landscape is of course our own mind, our own imagination, but the background is nature and knit we find confirmation.

Speaker 1Thank you so much for talking to us today. Thank you to Marilyn who not only helped us coordinate this interview but also did illustrations for your book. And I really hope I get to meet you in real life at some point. But I thank you so much for a lifetime of work on this.

Speaker 9Yeah that much.

Speaker 1I really really want to. My niece now lives in Scotland, so I'm really hoping to use her house as as a waypoint to go have adventures north of the Wall.

Speaker 4So we don't live far from Lockness.

Speaker 1Well, there you go. I really hope to make it. I really do.

Speaker 7Anyway, Again, listeners, check out A Natural History of Sea Serpents. A link will be in the show notes. Adrian Shine, thank you so much for talking with us.

Speaker 9That's wonderful.

Speaker 5More you've been listening to Monster Talk, the science show about my mind. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stoltner.

Speaker 7You just heard an interview with Adrian Shine, whose new book, A Natural History of Sea Serpents will be released on April first, twenty twenty five. Be sure and grab a copy by clicking the affiliate link in the show notes. We hope you enjoyed this episode of Monster Talk. Our goal here is to bring you the best in monster related content with a focus on scientific skepticism and critical thinking.

Speaker 5If you enjoy our show and.

Speaker 1Want to support our mission, start out by visiting monster talk dot.

Speaker 11Org forward slash Support. That's monster talk dot org forward slash Support. There you'll find links to our Patreon page, as well as a donate button if you'd like to just make a one time contribution. A great way to support the show is to buy books from our Amazon wish list. These are books that directly help with our monster research. We love used books very much, so don't feel compelled to buy new ones, and we're also very fond of kindle editions because of their easily searched con.

Speaker 5And without spending any money at all.

Speaker 1You can support and raise.

Speaker 12The profile of the show by leaving a positive review at iTunes or wherever you get your podcasts. Positive reviews help keep us visible in iTunes, which is a great way to help us find you listeners. Finally, remember to share episodes you really like with your friends and family. You can help make Monster Talk the nightlight that keeps monsters away from someone you love.

Speaker 7Monster Talks theme music is by Pete Stealing Monkeys. I know a lot of you have written me and Karen to thank us for being here, but we feel the same way about you. Thank you for being there for us.

Speaker 12This has been a monster House presentation,

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S06E07 Elizabeth Taylor and the Burton of Truth

    Nov 16, 202655 minAudio

    Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S06E06 🐈⬛Evil Cats and Revelatory Revenants👻

    Nov 9, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S06E05🎃 Live 2026 Halloween Show

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S06E04 🍿Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈 Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S06E03 🎥 Capturing Bigfoot 🫈with Marq Evans

    Oct 19, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...

    Credit the people on this episode