A fascinating chat about Australian Magpies (Gymnorhina tibicen) with Dr. Grainne Cleary in which we talk about the role of stories in creating monsters, the role of citizen science, and lots of cool biology facts about these birds. Not everything about Magpies is black and white, it turns out. Why do birds do that? (affiliate link) Your Backyard Birds (booktopia - Australian bookshop) And remember: Why do Birds Sing? will be dropping into stores September 2nd, 2025! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Monster House Presents.
Speaker 2Hey, they're Monster Talkers. It's been a rough week here at Munster talk manner. In twenty twenty, like many of you, I had my life turned upside down by the pandemic and the economic hit of that disaster, and for the second time in my career, I had to burn down through my life savings to survive. But thanks to a listener to this very show, I got introduced to a manager at Stanford University and just in the nick of time, landed the most amazing job that I never even dreamed of doing. I was a robotic process automation specialist for
Speaker 2Stanford University. In the past five years have been incredible. My fascination with innovation, especially in the computing space, had put Stanford in an elevated place in my heart because, along with my Tea, it's one of those key birthplaces of much of the tech that makes this modern world work. I was working remotely, but times I got to go visit campus, and my first visit I stayed on campus at the hotel next to the Stanford Linear Accelerator or SLACK, and I made a pilgrimage to so many Silicon Valley
Speaker 2sites and when I went to go get coffee and pull Ya Hall. It was next to Vince Serf's old office where he helped create TCPIP And when I visited my clients in Pinehall, it's where Cisco's Systems was born. And my first units experience had been on SUN named for Stanford University Networks. This was a dream job, and for the first time in my life, I thought I had found a place where I could actually work until I retired. Well, I don't like to talk about politics, but this current administration is run by very wealthy people,
Speaker 2and a couple of them and I'm looking at you, Peter Thiel and Mark and Dreesen really hate Stanford and universities in general. The administration is attacking many universities, and they're cutting federal funding for science research, and they're attacking the universities themselves with punitive tax hikes. It's almost like this administration doesn't want people to have higher education at all, or perhaps any education, to be blunt. Anyway, they hit Stanford with one hundred and fifty million dollars budget shortage
Speaker 2because of these tax hikes, and sadly, I am a casualty of that carnage. I really don't have the right words to describe how sad this makes me. But I don't even have time to mourn because with my wife also newly unemployed, we are scrambling to get our resumes out there as fast as we can. Now. My specialty for the past decade has been process automation and process improvement using what's called robotic process automation or RPA. But the truth is I just like making people's jobs easier with automation and computing. This show's not going to become
Speaker 2about my employment challenges, but it would be irresponsible to my family to not at least say that I'm looking for work now, and if you have any leads of that sort, I would be happy to send you my resume. Normally I would say send them to me my Monster Talk email address, but let's just skip that because that email is a forwarder and sometimes it loses messages. So if you have an opening or think you need someone like Blake Smith at your work, send an email to you doctor Atlantis at gmail dot com. That's fully spelled out doc t O r at L E. N Tis at gmail dot com. That's my personal email address. And
Speaker 2I know this is a long shot. Anyway, the kind of work I do is not well known to most people, but I'm really good at it and I enjoy it immensely, and I like fixing stuff and making people's lives easier. So I hope that I can continue to work in that space. In the meantime, I've got a few weeks before the panic really hits, and I'm going to put some of my decade long research.
Speaker 3Into innovation into something tangible.
Speaker 2I don't know how this will work out exactly, but I've started a new feed on Patreon where I'm going to release some of my writing and thoughts on my innovation work.
Speaker 3It's not live yet, but it will be this week.
Speaker 2That's going to be located at patreon dot com Forward Slash the Invention Fallacy. That's not going to be a podcast, although I may post some interviews there in the future. It's a good old fashioned blog of chapter material, and I think it'll be a useful step into turning my work into a complete book and not just a bunch of notes and thoughts. So one more thing here, I'm not trying to make anybody sad. My family's challenges are far from unique. We're just having a lot of them all at once, and even my pathological optimism is being stretched a little thin. But if you like this show
Speaker 2and would like to see it continue, I cannot think of a better time to support us on Patreon. If you're listening to the free feed right now and are a longtime listener, I would really urge you to consider even the lowest tier of support. Ditch your commercials, enjoy unbleeped conversations, extra content, and often there's really fun conversation and discussion on the episodes on Patreon. That'spatreon dot com forward slash Monster Talk all one word. Okay, that's enough begging for a miracle. Let's get to some good old fashioned monstrutal. It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before.
Speaker 2A giant, hairy creature part ap.
Speaker 1In Luckness, a twenty four mile long bottomless lake in the highlands of Scotland, get a creature known as the Luckness Monster. Monster Talk.
Speaker 3Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith.
Speaker 4And I'm Karen Stolsner.
Speaker 2This week, you may be wondering how we can justify an episode about magpies on a show about monsters, and these aren't even proper European magpies. They're Australian and they're not even corvids. But they fall into our monster adjacent content because they're the victims of that most powerful of all human inventions, scary stories. Now you might think bombs or guns are our most deadly creations, but I would seriously argue their stories are far more dangerous. You can't kill stories, and they are often the motivation behind tragedy
Speaker 2and horror, witch trials, pigrams, wars, mobs. They're always started by stories. Stories can turn a harmless immigrant into a vicious criminal in the minds of a public unequipped to evaluate such claims, and we hope that the methods of inquiry that we talk about on this show help individuals think about such matters critically, because it's simply impossible to stop the spread of stories, and the best hope I've been able to come up with is teaching people to ask whether such claims are true and how to evaluate
Speaker 2them on one's own, which brings us to our topic. The Australian magpie, a bird much maligned by folk wisdom and story, and there's other reasons I think today's interviews within our bailiwick, but we'll discuss those explicitly during the interview. I have too many intellectual interests, but the fact that your listening suggests you probably do too. I used to watch BBC documentaries every Sunday night on PBS, and David Attenborough was like my kind biology teacher who never gave homework.
Speaker 2Now there's a lot of myths about these birds, so let's go find out what's real, what's made up, and whether bigfoot hunting could qualify as citizen science. MORBs Trutle welcome Grania Cleary to Monster Talk. Would you mind introducing yourself to our listeners and telling us a little bit about who you are and what your relationship is with birds?
Speaker 1Okay, my name's Grona Cleary.
Speaker 5I am come from Ireland still, even though I'm now an Australian citizen. I moved over to Australia into thansand and seven with my husband. I got my PhD in badger ecology in Ireland and moved to the one continent that doesn't have five.
Speaker 1Years, Australia.
Speaker 5And once I was here, I still worked with mammals in universe. You have New South Wales Sydney University. But the birds always kind of caught my eye. It's factually because like Australia had such fantastic birds. I mean, if you want to study birds, if you want to see birds, come to Australia. Go to Africa for your big game, Australia.
Speaker 1For your birds.
Speaker 5So I'm over here doing field work on rodents, on rats, and I just noticed the birds all the time. You know, they just you just can't help pronounce them. So that really sparked my interest. And I came out of academia and worked for not for profit organization and I was doing citizens science, so engaging the public in what's going on in their back garden, and I did it with birds, and I was looking at the use of water in the backyard and what birds were visiting, and what was the different species and how often would they stay for and the passion that people had for their birds, and
Speaker 5the questions they came back and after me and the pictures they would show me. I Oh, the envy I would get and like that really united it because I wanted, you know, I wanted to know more, and you know, they wanted to tell me the big question that always came back to was can I feed my birds? Because in Australia that the hard line don't feed birds, and that's not good enough because we have been feeding birds since.
Speaker 1Before the farming.
Speaker 5Revolution, like before the agricultural revolution. We have engaged in birds. People are going to do it. It's in our DNA, so we need to do it properly. And that was kind of the start of my journey with birds, where like people are going to interact with birds and are going to feed birds regardless of you know what bird life says.
Speaker 1You're always going to get people who are going to do it.
Speaker 5So let's give them the skills, which is what they came to me asking for, so we can do this properly. So you know, don't feed the magpie min's meat, you know, look at feeding the meal worms. You know, don't feed them every time they fix, and you just need little guidelines to help them engage with the birds more healthy.
Speaker 4Wow, that's such a fantastic story.
Speaker 6I just love how you came to studying birds and everything that you've done.
Speaker 4And as you can hear, I grew up in Australia.
Speaker 6And I really miss our unique birds, iconic birds, Rosella's and Koka.
Speaker 4Bars and Laura keats and of course magpies.
Speaker 6And so the reason I found you and tracked you down was that when I was about eight years old, I was walking with my mother and we were somewhere in Sydney and a magpie swooped at us and attacked my mother and we had to go and see an ophthalmologist, and she had some eye issues for a while. And it was just quite recently, so maybe a couple of months ago, that I was going for a walk myself and I was swooped by one of our local birds, a blackbird now I think as a red winged blackbird,
Speaker 6and it reminded me of what happened when I was a kid, and I mean throughout my life growing up there. I lived in rural parts of Australia too, and going and putting washing on the line as you do in Australia, not so much here in the States, but certainly there you get attacked by magpies who you swoop. And so I thought, I want to talk to someone about magpies because there's such interesting birds. We've got a lot of questions to ask you, But could we start with talking a bit about what exactly in Australian magpie is and
Speaker 6are they really magpies?
Speaker 5Okay, so they come from a songbird first of all, like a lot of our birds are. So we compare them to the European magpie. The European magpie is also black and white like the Australian magpie. Now, when the first settlers, all the Europeans, came over to Australia in the seventeenth century, they saw the magpie. They what wasn't you didn't even have a name. The Aboriginals had their own name for it. I was based more on the song I believe, but they they immediately said, oh, sure, it looks like the magpie back home, we call it
Speaker 5the magpie. But it's actually more it belongs to a different family. It's not a Covid. Now, Covid is what the European magpie belongs. It belongs to, and a lot of the other magpies, I think also in America belonged to the Corvid family. The Australian magpie was just called that because it looks like in European magpie.
Speaker 1So we have the.
Speaker 5Magpie lark here, which is a corpd and it's called a magpie log because it looks like a smaller magpie.
Speaker 1They really had no imagination those first settlers.
Speaker 5It looks like a magpie that looks like a smaller magpie. So that's not called that a magpie lark more based on that black and white coloring than anything else.
Speaker 1Is by god it's name, but.
Speaker 5It's actually more While I say, both of the songbirds, corvids aren't known to sing, but the Australian magpie is a well known singer. As you know, it is the sound of Australia and it's just you.
Speaker 1You can't help but listen to it.
Speaker 5And they're also known as the policeman of the bush because when you're out in the bush, it's always the magpie watching you. You know, will be silent, but it will be there watching you as you walk around.
Speaker 1So they're just fabulous birds.
Speaker 2Well you know, crows don't sing, but they have just cause. So these birds, they're black and white. I have only seen one picture of them in preparing for the show, but I've seen the European magpies. Now there's similarities. I assume is this due to conversion evolution, and does that conversion evolution also include like a higher cognitive capacity, and
Speaker 2I imagine that's not even related to the coloring. But I'm just wondering, are they smart light magpies and are they colored for similar reasons or do we know?
Speaker 1You know, yes and yes.
Speaker 5So if you think about the urban environment, birds of certain colors do very well, and colors such as black and white or boat colors that are produced by the.
Speaker 1Melonin in the skin, So it means that the feather.
Speaker 5Structure is very robust, it can deal with wear and tear so and it also gives good camouflage. It's effective camouflage in dappled light or contrasting surfaces, so that black and white is a good adaption and it's good for urban areas because of the traps, including the wear and tear on the feathers.
Speaker 1So if you think.
Speaker 5About European magpie, he is black and white, but eat his tail and even some of its dark and feathers have iridescence in it of olives and kind of all of these greens and purples. The Australian magpie not so much. It's much more just the two colors, and for the.
Speaker 1Conversion evolution it's more so conversion evolution Just for those who might be too sure.
Speaker 5It's a process where unrelated species evolve similar traits independently, and it's often due to adaptions to similar environments or ecological natures, so such as the urban environment. Like the two types of magpies. Also think about wings on bats, in sects, birds, they all develop the type of wing to fly, So that's conversion evolution.
Speaker 1So the adaption to urban.
Speaker 5Areas with the smartness as you mentioned, Yes, magpies are very very smart, and as are the core fits the European magpie. And this intelligence seems to go hand in hand with being able to live and do well in urban area.
Speaker 1Yes, because this is not your natural habitat.
Speaker 5We are cutting down trees, we are building houses, we are playing you know fully rugby on the oval. When they want to be foraging, they have to adapt to us. So you constantly have to be tinking about what's the bloody human going to do now, also while looking at other birds and having to adapt to their surroundings, and that drives intelligence.
Speaker 5You're told, you know, don't get stuck in unproductive patron thoughts. You know, change your thinking to adapt your circumstances. Highly cognitive birds do this, your ravens, your pros, your magpies, your parents, your cockatoos. They are our top intelligent birds on that pyramid if you wanted to imagine, just as we are the top of our primates. And then you kind of look at gorillas and orangutans and that I think you mean pyramid.
Speaker 2Sorry, I can see how this is going to go.
Speaker 4We've got a.
Speaker 6Bunch of questions, but you've just touched upon something that I'd like you to expand on a little bit. And that's just how incredibly smart magpies are. So they're not bird brains, but I've heard that they can actually recognize people.
Speaker 4Is that true? And how much can they recognize people? To what extent?
Speaker 5So this is great work coming out of Western Australia on the magpie populations over there in urban areas. And one of the things that looked at is audio memory. So audio memory is identifying somebody by remembering what that voice sounds like. So you know, we the three of us, all are very distinct voices and it's our spectral temporal envelope that this defines that voice like, you know the rhythm of my rhythm being a bit faster. You know him from Georgia, a bit of a slow talker. You
Speaker 5know how all these things change. Birds are the same, so they can identify. Magpies can identify each other by their call. So they'll hear a colum they'll say, oh, yeah, the vocal signature in that call relates.
Speaker 1To you know, Jimmy over there, who I met this morning.
Speaker 5So they had so they have it does them well remember who was calling.
Speaker 1And it's the same with people.
Speaker 5So this study in w A looked at people who provided food for magpies to people who the magpies never had experience with, and they sure enough, the magpies were quick to learn the voices the call of those people who had fed them food.
Speaker 1So they we could remember.
Speaker 5Distinct voices depending on their experience with those people. You know, it does a bird weld remember who's feeding them, because you know, food can be a limited resource and it can really you know again again aids five in the urban area, so they definitely remember.
Speaker 1You can recognize voices, and it's the same with faces.
Speaker 5Although there hasn't really been good studies done on magpies and Pacific. We have seen it in corporates, especially crows where and ravens where they'll remember an experimenter who wears a nasty mask and interacts badly with the with the ravens and then comes back where the different masks. The bird responds differently with the nasty masks. They see it as a threatening you know, this was the individual that hurt me, so you know it will it will kind of display threatening behaviors. While when the experimental wore a neutral mask, the ravens didn't recognized you know, the ravens
Speaker 5looked at face and didn't recognize the you know, the mask, so didn't attack it.
Speaker 1So there are we have seen it in.
Speaker 5Other birds that they can so I do believe that the magpie will be able to do this. And you have so many citizens scientists talking about that magpies recognizing even the sound of the car when they're coming home from work.
Speaker 4Fascinating.
Speaker 2You know you mentioned citizens scientists. This comes up a lot. You know, our show is monster Talk, and a lot of our I guess the people in the field of crypt's wology. You know, we're a skeptical show, but a lot of people like to go out and look for bigfoot, and you know, and they think they're doing research, and maybe they are to an extent, but you know, most of them aren't trained in how to keep logs, you know, and actually pay attention to the times and the situation and what they're seeing. And there's so much data that you can collect that kind of gives you an indications
Speaker 2of why wildlife's behaving certain ways, and if you sort of share that data, it becomes useful for drawing conclusions. Are seeing correlations anyway, right, And so I take it that birders are a little bit like amateur astronomers, that the level of the citizens' science is a little stronger than maybe coming out of what's in Bigfoot.
Speaker 1I love, I know, I love, I love love that question.
Speaker 5So with the citizens science, so like the experiments I've run, it would be based around the bird bat in people's back gardens, So they would be told to monitor once a day for twenty minutes and record the number of species a visit.
Speaker 1So that twenty.
Speaker 5Minute window, it means that I can compare your data to someone else who also conducted the study for twenty minutes on their bird bat, their comparable studies. So something like going out to track bigfoot. If they did transact lines and they did it, maybe not at the same time each day, because it's bigfoot in a certain area, and if you go randomly, maybe you're just going to miss them and only seeing one out of ten times.
Speaker 1But if you actually did it at it more, you know, if you.
Speaker 5Taught about it more critically and thought, okay, if I checked this area at this time for you know, such a period of time and then change the time to see you know, you kind of have to think about like that instead of just doing it randomly and then you see them.
Speaker 1But there's no trant, do you get me?
Speaker 2Yeah, finding trends over times, youation, weather, all that stuff.
Speaker 1Yeah, absolutely, exactly, exactly.
Speaker 6Well, if I may, I'll get to the crux of why I wanted to talk about magpies, and that is why do they swoop at people? And are they just being mean or is there a particular reason for it, or is it something that both males and females do or just one of the sexes or tell us all about the swooping.
Speaker 5So, first of all, I am speaking on the side of the magpie.
Speaker 1I represent the Australian magpies.
Speaker 5And they are being unfairly portrayed in the media, such as your open comments about them swooping from the air.
Speaker 1Americans from coming.
Speaker 7Over here, don't take the magpies are coming out of the sky to kill them and take the babies. Swooping behavior is something a lot of birds do, especially birds that live in groups. So you might remember noisy miners, those honey eaters, that brown birds or gray birds with the yellow eye.
Speaker 5They're very prolific and they hang out in little mobs and they'll swoop you. And so swooping isn't is a mechanism birds use to deter other birds or deter predator.
Speaker 1So you might sometimes see on Facebook, like a fox or a cat getting.
Speaker 5Harassed by birds. The birds are following them. That's that swooping behavior talking about. So it's something that's present.
Speaker 1In nearly all birds. It's just a bit behavior response to a treat.
Speaker 5Now, we talked about how your magpies are living in urban areas, and there are a lot of trats in urban areas. So you're dealing with cats, you're dealing with dogs, you're dealing with foxes, you're dealing with people, and you're dealing with other magpies trying to.
Speaker 1Get your tree.
Speaker 5We're under the assumption that all magpipes get to set up home every spring.
Speaker 1That's not true. The cream of the crop gets the nest.
Speaker 5A lot of magpies don't get to secure a tree because then you know, they're not territorial territorially strong enough, or they can't you know, they can't defend the tree, or they can't drive off another magpie to gain their tree. So you'll have individuals that will nest every year and they'll use the same tree, and they've got to defend this tree every single year. During breeding season, which is when we see a lot of the swooping, it will often be the male and the female is on the nest with chicks or with eggs.
Speaker 1So it's a.
Speaker 5Highly vulntable time when when the risk of these eggs or these chicks dying is very high. That father is having to look after the chicks. He's got to look after his missus. He's got a defend from the cats, he's got the fan from the foxes, he's got a defend from other magpies coming in trying to run his missus off.
Speaker 1He's got a defend from you walking down the street not noticing him.
Speaker 5He gave you a warn He was like, hello, and you see me, and you acknowledge me.
Speaker 1You and your man were chatting away to each other.
Speaker 5What if you guys had stopped and acknowledged or looked at the magpie, you know, it would know that you saw and it was kind of that that magpie is smart enough to know that you're not going to threaten it. So that's one of the messages we're trying to send people is throughout the year, make friends with your magpie. And again, something like less than ten percent do this, and it is something that happens, you know, in a highly urban area and most of the time, you know, if you're talking to the magpie during the year and it gets to know you, especially if you're doing a
Speaker 5walk and you're walking past the same individuals.
Speaker 1They do get to know you, and they won't see you as a treat.
Speaker 5This swooping is very much because that magpie is like feeling very threatened by you and he just wants to protect his baby and his missus.
Speaker 1Things your fault, you know right there, You know.
Speaker 6That makes that makes sense. That's thank you for that inside. That really does make sense.
Speaker 2I was thinking, So the birds that don't get a tree, do they are these? I mean, that's that sounds like a pretty small percentage you're making it. Or do the others find somewhere else or or are they I don't know, n cells.
Speaker 5So so what usually happens is that hang out in a bachelor flock and they'll just try each year. They will sometimes when you have a pair, they'll try a different tree. But if the nest is lost, like if there's a bad storm and the last get blown out of the tree, they won't tend to try again in that area.
Speaker 1They'll try and look for another tree.
Speaker 5So you will have individuals who will just try but won't succeed, or you know, they use the wrong material, will have a lot of rain and the nests will get waterlogged. So there's all these things that you got to consider from the back point of view. Location, location, location, and once you find that tray, you defended.
Speaker 1And if you've got to swoop.
Speaker 7That little girl with pigtails, by god, it raggs, you.
Speaker 5Know, but it is it is about sharing our space and understanding it from the bird's point of view.
Speaker 6Yeah, sure, that's why we, Yeah, we wanted to bring you on into set the record straight.
Speaker 2Poor bachelor flocks, all of them having a place to stay, having to shop at Megpika.
Speaker 5It's going to try to drive out Bruce from that big gum trade.
Speaker 1My god, is he?
Speaker 5So?
Speaker 1Yeah, Bruce is very wild up this season. And the other thing is to be like leave the bird alone. Just take a different route.
Speaker 5You know, we are route as they say over here, you know, just just give them the bird space. It only happens for a very short period, and again it's very unlikely to happen. I'll tell you my story about being swooped by a magpie I live with. I have I keep and I live with them because it's like I do live with them to glass. So glass are type of coppertoo over here that the ones with the beauty I think you call them pink and gray cockatoos. That got the beautiful pink and the gray bats. So we have them on little harnesses and we walk them around our local park. And there was this female, yeah,
Speaker 5and there was this female magpie and she was feeding away on the grass and she saw us coming and she swooped me. And that swoop was very much this is my area. I'm feeding here.
Speaker 1You and your.
Speaker 5Glass move on because glass will forage in simple in similar areas. So the magpie and you know it wasn't me stupid, he was telling me move on, keep walking.
Speaker 8Love.
Speaker 2Yeah, Well do they really do they steal shiny things? Or is that just a myth?
Speaker 1Okay?
Speaker 5So this again is admit and it's related to the European magpie. And where this myth came from was in the eighteen fifties, a French play was written and the French play was about this servant girl who was about to face the gallows because her master accused her of stealing his silverware, only for the last minute for it to be found out that it was actually the local magpie that became a famous plane was turned into an opera that was highly successful in the late eighteenth century,
Speaker 5kind of around that time, and.
Speaker 1That started the myth.
Speaker 5And because ravens across magpies corvids are very intelligent, they're inquisitive. They look at things and go what's that. So they are known to kind of you know and you know, investigate objects, but they don't actually collect them. They don't keep them in the nest for the shiny treasures that that that's very very much omit gotcha?
Speaker 2Is it the Oh my gosh, there is a bird down there that does collect and build these elaborate Yeah.
Speaker 4Well that's a power blue thing, that's right. Yeah, and that.
Speaker 1Does that far.
Speaker 5So originally that would have been it's like feathers and flowers, it would have gathered and it's to do.
Speaker 1With attracting the female.
Speaker 5So that's part of its kind of you know, to attract the mating female. And now with European settlement and all that and all rubbish, that's sudden to collect plastic blue plastic objects as well. But it's used for the same same message as the feathers and the flowers, which is to try to attract the female.
Speaker 6Interesting, well, I want to ask a couple of biological questions too, just about their diet, what do they eat, and how long do they live? And it seems like they do pair up.
Speaker 1It's not good for and the thing is the female. So we we from our research is needing.
Speaker 5Us to believe a lot of the groups here are dominated by the females. So don't us can have an easier time by kind of hanging around in the flock in that you know area, so I'll hold the territory. And within the territory, you'll usually have one dominant male. He'll have a white back sometimes too, and you'll have females and juveniles.
Speaker 1The females are you she won from the.
Speaker 5Previous year that's allowed to stay, or they sometimes can be in, you know, ones that come in as well to try to mate with the male.
Speaker 1But it's usually just.
Speaker 5A dominant female that will achieve the mating and the female will actually suppress the other females for mating. So that's a dominant male and dominant female and they'll hold the territory throughout the year. And the carling we hear is very much their group song, and it's their song to define their territory, to mark that territory into show group cohesion, which means we are a group and we will work together and defend this territory together. Now, to a listening bachelor group, they're like, oh, well, jeez, they're gonna not gonna mats with them.
Speaker 1You know that there's too many of them, and you know they're.
Speaker 5Very much gonna work together, and we think it still has to be proven, but I will put my money on it that there's vocal signatures in the songs, which means the group can be recognized by other groups as being Oh, look it's the O'Brien's the singer. They're up early today and in the group.
Speaker 1Actually in the field.
Speaker 5Vitual birds, individual birds have their own voice that are recognized by others.
Speaker 1This is vocal signatures.
Speaker 5It's still there's still controversy around it, but it makes sense. This song is so important to them. It functions for so many different reasons. And the warbling we hear, it's actually remember that warbling you love and the magpie Yeah, I.
Speaker 2Tell you another bad motivator.
Speaker 1Look, that's a form of vocal practice.
Speaker 5So songbirds not just magpipes, but songbirds learn that vocalization the same way babies learn to speak.
Speaker 1They listen to that caregivers.
Speaker 5They spend the time just memorizing the tone, the sound of the voice and slowly dada, the spectral temple of the words over you know, two years is narrowed down to when the baby dn't think can actually speak. Songbirds do the same, but they also have to practice. If you don't practice your language, you lose it. And magpies, like most songbirds will practice that song and in Australian magpies is the warbling song and that's them actually practicing and they are fairly happy they do it, you know,
Speaker 5happily it gives them a dolphin and dolphin hits like you know we also when we sing.
Speaker 6Well, I've heard about sinsitive periods in birds. There's a lot of theory about that, or critical periods, first language acquisition, that's my area. But so talking about birds, I hear a lot of birds, songbirds and magpies.
Speaker 4Do you have that sensitive period? And if they miss that window, they.
Speaker 5Never learn how to sing the exactly And I have a book coming out called Why Do Birds Singing? Coming out September the second, and that's all about that that critical learning period. Yeah, so things like ches and zebra inches, it has studied and we can say it's I can't do like it's two weeks after since hatching. And if you have a bird and it's not exposed to song, you know, if it's not exposed to the vocal recording or an infacial bird being there, it won't learn that its song. And after that critical period it can be very difficult. It can reopen.
Speaker 1But you know, if the bird doesn't get exposed to song as a nestling and never really learns it no incredible.
Speaker 2I know Karen's field is linguistics. For me, this comes down It makes me think on information theory, like you know what information is being conveyed? You know how much did it is signal? How much of this noise? What can they accomplish with these songs? I mean, I suspect everybody knows most animal vocalization is about mating, But what else? What else did they do it? Do they? Is it? They else? Food? I know crows do a lot of things, but that's quite different, I guess.
Speaker 1So yeah, I love this question.
Speaker 5We have the song, which is as you said, for mark and territory attracting mate. There two big messages and it can also be used for group coersion and for keeping a pair of birds together. You know, they sing and they feel reunited, but they also have calls, and calls are the private conversations they have with each other. So it's not loud, it's not far another bird and you know, a foreign bird to listen to with forrest partner to listen to or forrest nestlings to listen to and those calls can give a variety of information depending
Speaker 5on how the bird is feeling.
Speaker 1And again this has.
Speaker 5Been done a lot with you know, experiments done on the sebra finches where they have looked at you know, when the bird is hungry that will be louder, or when it's happy and content and you know it will be kind of softer.
Speaker 1So again that goes back to that spectral temple.
Speaker 5The tone, the volume of the call will signify how the bird is feeling. They'll also do mobbing calls, so in the Australian magpie, the Australian magpie can actually do use different calls depending on whatnot is seen an ego too, seeing a raptile on the ground like a lace monitor and other birds have learned to listen for the difference in these two different alarm calls and will look up when it does the eagle call and will look look.
Speaker 1Down when it does the guana or the lizard call.
Speaker 5So there are differences in the call that give out information about different predators. And that's only the touch of the ice boat birds. Yeah, yeah, it's a very and other birds learning it. And but back to the magpies, and the magpies will will point at the guana or point up at the eagle, and other magpies will join it and also point so it doesn't when it sees the predator, it does doesn't just flee like a chicken wood or a smaller prey bird. It will actually go and say, okay, this is an eagle. If I, you know,
Speaker 5call for this, get me mates around.
Speaker 1We point to it. We say we see you, We see you. When your back off, we see you.
Speaker 9Go on.
Speaker 1Wi the predator. Because the predator has been caught, they've all seen it.
Speaker 5So yeah, the location and yeah, there's so many clever experiments to try to determine what the birds is seen.
Speaker 1Yeah, so it looks like they do, and they.
Speaker 5Can combine calls the even sand defy messages, you know, such as the guana first.
Speaker 1It's the eagle call. Yeah. I could go on, I could go on, but stop myself.
Speaker 4Oh no, it's amazing.
Speaker 6I've read studies about a Vervet monkeys and Diana monkeys and how it's gotten to the point where sometimes birds can recognize the monkeys calls and monkeys can recognize the birds calls. It's really amazing.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's eavesdropping.
Speaker 6Yeah, well, I think we could talk about magpies all day, you know so much. This is just so so much fun. But we should start to wind up soon. And some of the final questions we have, I guess we'd like to learn a bit more about how to deal with magpies then how to live with magpies. If we have one in our yard, should we be feeding it or avoiding it or something else has should we live with them?
Speaker 5So my big message is embrace what comes into your back garden. Your back garden can provide great habitat for our urban wildlife, So never underestimate what your little pocket of land can do. And if you do have birds in your back garden, provide water. Think about keeping a bird bat And it doesn't have to be anything fancy, even an old pot that you just put on top of a table. The birds will thank you for it. Give them time to find it, don't expect, you know, a beautiful diversity of birds the next day. You know
Speaker 5they will find it. And once they find it, they will continue to use it. And don't discriminate. Don't be a bird racist. Don't just want to fancy. Once your pigeon needs love as well. Your local prone needs love as well. These are birds that are living with you in a harsh, brutal world, you know, so do embrace them. And feeding does provide a lot of joy for people. Just please don't feed bread. Be cautious of what your feeding them. You know, think about the bird and what the birds need in terms of habitat and nesting areas
Speaker 5are always welcome, either in the form of nest boxes or even different shrubs at different sizes.
Speaker 1Think about different structures.
Speaker 5Of vegetation in your back garden where different birds can hide, and you have smaller birds, Put a bird back close to the bushes and put a rock in the center of it so small birds don't feel as exposed and they can just jump up and down onto the rock and then into the habitat, into the vegetation. Because a wet bird can be you know, he can be fluntable to a predator. So smaller birds like to bathe and then go and hide very quickly.
Speaker 1So think about that.
Speaker 5Think about the birds in your area, think about what you think they would need.
Speaker 1You know, go to your local council.
Speaker 5That's information out there and you'll be so rewarded because it really does bring life into your garden and those birds rely on you, and it's the type of connection you can make with a wild species that's really.
Speaker 1Beautiful, especially in this you know, this in this time when.
Speaker 5The world seems the on the edge of destruction, and so you know, em raise your birds.
Speaker 4You know, that's wonderful advice.
Speaker 2Yeah, I've got one more bird question before we close down this. I'm going to preface it with this really short story. I'm not a bird, but I have recently gotten really interested in mocking birds, and they have this behavior called flashing, so they raise their wings almost like their own ratchets, and and biology that there's not one hundred percent certainty for why they do this, but there's some belief that maybe it has to do with feeding behavior, like it somehow does something to make insects, you know,
Speaker 2more available. And so once I found out it was a mystery, I started thinking about all these experiments to try to like help, you know, kind of narrow that down, because what I'm really curious about is how do insects perceive the flashing, What does it do to them to make this a good, you know, eating behavior.
Speaker 1I love that question.
Speaker 5Over here we have really wagtails again European wally wagtail.
Speaker 1Yeah, so he has.
Speaker 5There's they'll work together and they'll move on horses and cattle, and as the cattle walk, the insects will move up from the grass from the soil to a ford being trampled on. The magpies will then go, you know, to with the hoofs of the cattle is and start taking these little magpies as the cattle move. So that's that's what they're doing with the flashing. What that can be on a dull day, So a dull day when the clouds are moving, this doesn't work. On a bright, hot day, the insects will perceive the magpie shadow of what it is,
Speaker 5a predator. But on very overcast days, when the light is staffled anyway, the mag the wagtail can use its tail to flush out by using shadow to scare the magi to scare the insects up and really.
Speaker 2Need but you see that there's a dark and light band.
Speaker 1It's really exactly.
Speaker 2But the actual question I have was are there any sort of similar mysteries about mag pies out there or are there things people should be looking for or wondering about when they see these birds that are still a hot topic in ornithology. I think the kids are going it.
Speaker 1Probably at the moment.
Speaker 5It is around their focal vocalization. When you're in different areas do the bird? Does the magpipe calls sound slightly different? So all the changes depending on where you know accents for the want of a better word, do different magpipes have slightly different calls and different areas?
Speaker 1You can it be a good one?
Speaker 5Do you othertain though it's a little bit more depressing is with climate change and our summer's getting hotter, there seems to be a cognitive point where they'll stop interacting. They'll stop marking territories because they have to keep themselves cool, So they spend a lot of time just showing you know that gaping the wings, plays the feathers you're drooping, and they won't actually engage in things like foraging, marking territory, grooming, interacting.
Speaker 1With each other.
Speaker 5So the thing so there are yeah, there's a lot for the citizen scientists to watch out with. And you guys have the Cornwell Aunitology labs over there. They do some great work, so it hit them up as well, and think about getting involved in citizen science projects around birds banks.
Speaker 4Yeah, some so much food for thought.
Speaker 6And thank you again for all of your insight into these wonderful birds. And you've really give me a different perspective on them growing up with them as I did. But we've got one final question for you, which we ask all of our guests a signature question. What's your favorite monster?
Speaker 5I love this, I love it so my one and this is a real one. This one would have to be the banchee. So yeah, the banshee is an old of course, with all of these, that's different, you know, stories told. But the story I grew up with was an old woman who with long, long hair, and just before someone was going to die in your family, three days, three nights before they were going to die, she'd perch on your roof and she'd comba long hair, and she'd weigh and she'd have red eyes from crying so much.
Speaker 5And when I'd go out, like when i'd be out the next day as a kid, and I'd find a comb on the ground, it'd be like, oh God, the benchi was in the AIRA was going to die. And she particularly targeted people with oh and mac in the name because they're very ancient Irish names. So she wasn't so much interested in these newcomers like the FitzGeralds, you know, more rage than the Irish themselves. They had no booker off your Normandy and you never got English in your blood. She was after the old, old Orish, so those would oh Sullivan, Macmarrow, MacDonald where her real targets. So I
Speaker 5had two friends, and old Sullivan and a Macmarrow. And as children I used to tormentum, have you heard the Banshee? You know you're going to hear the benchie when your mammy died, because you're an old Sullivan, she'd be sitting there on your garage pushing along.
Speaker 1Oh my god, tormented them.
Speaker 5I know.
Speaker 2We've talked a lot about ghosts, and some of them seem like they're suffering, but the Banchees are always doing whale.
Speaker 1Yeah you that someone's going to die? Yeah, stop frightened.
Speaker 6I think in all the years we've been doing this, that's the first time that we've had that answer to the Banchies.
Speaker 4I believe so perfect, absolutely perfect. Given you a heritage, Really, that's the profle banche come up.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, no, Well, we've talked about Banshee's before, but it's never been someone's favorite.
Speaker 4Monster favorite yeah until yeah.
Speaker 9A quick insert here. Technically, Chris Woodard did mention the Banshee in her interview about Women in Black, but did not explicitly say it was her favorite, merely that she's partial to it. I know this because of the incredibly helpful work that listener Joseph Scales has done to catalog all of this favorite monster data. I have failed to make his work public because I was struggling to get it into a format that would show up in a useful way on our website. But I finally got a notion of how to make it accessible and hopefully visually useful. So that's something I'll be working on. Maybe I'll be
Speaker 9able to knock get out soon. We'll see. But I want to thank Joseph for what I find to be an incredibly helpful reference source.
Speaker 2Ah.
Speaker 5Yeah, Well, the other one I would have picked been ourriichh and I did my A lot of my education in Scotland would have caused been lock netting, the locknet monster.
Speaker 1But the one she got me, the one that you know as the kids, the one that I have see the code, I'll be like, oh Jesus.
Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, yeah, they stick with you for sure. This is delightful.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's been a real treat. And you're so enthusiastic about science and we love that.
Speaker 4Oh yeah, it makes us feel passionate to an enthusiastic thank you.
Speaker 1Oh that's so good. That's so so good. I'm so pleased.
Speaker 4Where can people find you and find your books and your website.
Speaker 1I have two books out at the moment. You can get them on Amazon.
Speaker 5It's the first one was Your Backyard Birds, and that was my first book, and that was kind of like, you know, you just kind of put it out and see what happens, like the first Pancake.
Speaker 8But the second book, oh, the second book that was the best seller, guys. That's called Why Do Birds Do That? And it's all very much questions and answers. You know, why the birds stand on one legs, why the birds have feathers? Why do birds?
Speaker 9You know?
Speaker 1Any question about why the birds? It's going to be in there. And my third book is Why the Birds Sing, And again it's done around questions and answers. And I look a lot at the brain, so I look at the personality around in birds, so like the neocortex, and you know, can they count? Can they categorize?
Speaker 9You know?
Speaker 1How do they learn to sing? Can the death bird learn to sing? How do they sleep? Do they dream? What they dream of? She had a little little spoiler. They dream and song They.
Speaker 5Actually when the young birds learning, so that night it will actually dream of as far the song and that helps it learn at the next morning. And tell you this book why the birds Sing? And they have my Australian magpies on the cover. I said, this book needs Australian magpie. Sort of given me two Australian magpies singing at a bird bat and I love it.
Speaker 2I am so excited. This is right up.
Speaker 4We're going to have to bring you and September, I think to talk about this.
Speaker 5This is really interesting to us have the read of the book because it's all around language, and I talk about the importance of female song that's often ignored we look the male song.
Speaker 1So yeah, and I would yeah, happily Chatawaitius about it.
Speaker 2I mean, I mean some people may actually think it's a stretch for us to be talking about this topic on Monster Talk, but think about it. I mean the stories that we tell about monsters are are very similar to the stories that birds telling song about. Look out here comes danger, you know, it's it's exactly, this is so primal, it's so probably yes, so core, just what it means to be alive, because in our world some people eat you know, and maybe you don't want to be eaten.
Speaker 5You know, when you're in a forest, are you somewhere and it's no song and it's just quiet, Yeah, yeah, there's no bird song. And even the idea of the raven on the castle wall or on the big cathedral and it's foggy out like it just makes you feel chills, like the ultimate setup for any horror movie.
Speaker 2Bird they are, Yeah, cor fits on the.
Speaker 1Next one when the book comes out. And monsters that fantastic.
Speaker 4Yes, definitely lots to talk about, so we'll keep it.
Speaker 2They have a lot of potential.
Speaker 6Oh yeah, I didn't didn't meant to warn you about the punk I with a plasant surprise.
Speaker 1You didn't ruin it.
Speaker 2It's fantastic. All right. Well I'm gonna let us go then, have a.
Speaker 4Good night, good day, good day, lovely Saturday. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
Speaker 3You've been listening to Monster Doc, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner.
Speaker 2You just heard an interview with doctor Grana Cleary about Australian magpies. I found her delightful to talk to and really want to check out her Bird books, especially the new one coming out in September. Writing books is hard work and often doesn't pay very well at all, but when you have one in your heart, the best you can do is to get it out there. Karen's in England this week on a promotional book tour for her latest bitch, The Journey of a Word, and she's got a free copy of the audiobook version of that, which I will be giving away to one of our Patreon listeners next week. This is open to any Patreon subscriber
Speaker 2at any level. If you're on the list, you're entered. It's not a contest. I'm just gonna randomly select one of you Patreon subscribers and send a book to you. I'll let you know who won it next week. We hope you enjoyed this episode of Monster Talk. Our goal here is to bring you the best in monster related content with a focus on scientific skepticism and critical thinking. If you enjoy our show and want to support our mission, start out by visiting monster talk dot org forward slash Support. That's monster talk dot org forward slash Support. There you'll
Speaker 2find links to our Patreon page, as well as a donate button if you'd like to just make a one time contribution. A great way to support the show is to buy books from our Amazon wish list. These are books that directly help with our monster research. We love used books very much, so don't feel compelled to buy new ones, and we're also very fond of kindle editions because of their easily searched content and without spending any money at all. You can support and raise the profile of the show by leaving a positive review at iTunes or wherever you get your podcasts. Positive reviews help keep
Speaker 2us visible in iTunes, which is a great way to help us find you listeners. Finally, remember to share episodes you really like with your friends and family. You can help make Monster Talk the nightlight that keeps monsters away from someone you love. Monster Talk theme music is by Peach. Stealing Monkeys twenty twenty five is now officially halfway over. I don't know about you, but I can't wait to see what's next.
Speaker 1This has been a Monster House presentation.
Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...
Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...
Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...
🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...
Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...