Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

MonsterTalk

MonsterTalk artwork

S04E36 – Nefarious Stealth Evangelicalism?

Jun 9, 202550 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

We’re joined by Matt Baxter to discuss what we thought was a horror film but turned out to be something quite different.Warning: This film and episode deal with suicide, murder, abortion, politics, religion, and pretty much most of the hot potato topics we generally try to eschew. Hopefully we do a decent job of discussing it. Nefarious (streaming) - Affiliate Link More on Blaze Media Some reviews: 7th Day Adventist review A Christian review with interesting comments Reddit tackles Nefarious Horror Obsessive - really didn’t care for the “bait & switch” Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Monster House presents.

Speaker 2Okay, James, we offer up a series of temptations, gradually increasing in terms of duration and intensity, degree of moral and equity. Essence of baptism in this case allows us to begin work long before the age of reason. At three dis five maybe at theft of a toy car can do a great deal. Then we go into bigger and better things at eight. Grandmother's gifts of a Ouiji board gives immediate access to his decision making. So we began steering them without them all, calling into question exactly who's doing steering enough? Yes, isn't few enough?

Speaker 3Nos?

Speaker 2Gives increasing rights over the victims physical and mental processes. Did that track, James?

Speaker 3It seems random almost. I'm focused.

Speaker 4Well, that's what we want you to think.

Speaker 2We have a letle of focus beyond your comprehension.

Speaker 5It's actually quite unlike anything.

Speaker 2We've ever looking before.

Speaker 4A giant, hairy creature, part ape, part Matt in Luckness, a twenty four a mile long bottomless lake in the Highlands of Scotland.

Speaker 6It's a creature known as the Luckness Monster. Monstertal.

Speaker 4Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith.

Speaker 5And I'm Karen Stolsner.

Speaker 4There's lots of stuff going on here at Monster Talk Manor and I'm working on some classic cryptid content, but we're a little pressed for time this week, and Karen's husband Matt suggested that we check out a movie he was getting a lot of algorithmic nudges on, and that turned out to be quite the ride. Spoilers. It was packaged as a horror film, but it turned out to be more of a stealth evangelical project. It's a twenty twenty three indie film called Nefarious, and well, I can't exactly recommend the film is horror, it certainly gave us

Speaker 4lots of stuff to talk about, so some warnings. The film deals with the death penalty, abortion, suicide, murder, religion, and politics, so there's going to be discussion that will touch on many of these topics as well. So I know we tend to steer away from stuff like this, but hopefully we managed to navigate these with respectfulness and you'll find our discussions of interest. Let's get to the Mobsterutle. We were looking for what to record this week and I had some ideas, but you problemted us with this film.

Speaker 5So we blame him.

Speaker 4You know, I didn't know what to expect because it's not exactly it's not one of our based on a true stories exactly, but it is an interesting film for a lot of reasons, and it's I'm curious before we get into what it's about, I'm curious, how did you hear about it?

Speaker 5Yeah?

Speaker 3Well, here's the thing. When I'm at work, often I'll be playing YouTube videos and they go from one video to the next, and YouTube kind of chooses what I see next, but based on and often I leave my office and I'm doing things and I come back and now YouTube believes that I like all this stuff that I've never even seen. So it's been telling me this week, you really do like this movie.

Speaker 5You really like this movie, so it's advertising for you.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 3I thought, well, okay, if if you know, YouTube says, so it's got to be true. And I thought, hey, let's you know. I got kind of the gist of it from watching one short clip. I thought, Okay, this sounds monstrous and we should talk about it.

Speaker 4So it's not just an algorithm, it's your good plgorithm.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 6I had the impression that was a kind of modern day Exorcist, and I guess I had some parallels to.

Speaker 3That, a few and a lot of really stark differences that. Yeah, I'm going to love highlighting because we've got, you know, several movies that came to mind as I was watching this, And should we mention what movie it is we're talking about or should we just keep all the way through it.

Speaker 5Nefarious? Nefarious?

Speaker 4A twenty twenty three indie horror film. Yeah, no, I have to say the film.

Speaker 5I didn't know that it's such good quality.

Speaker 4Well, it's got some money behind it. It's got some money behind it. It's not like it's not two guys in their parents' credit cards. It's it's it's.

Speaker 5What I think of when I think of Indie.

Speaker 4Yeah, what I noticed when I looked at the cast before I hit play on this film, I said, oh, that's interesting, and beck is in it. That's weird.

Speaker 3So yeah, we were using the same brain cell.

Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, I was like, that's a strange casting. But it actually all makes sense. But I think maybe let's let's let's spoil it after the after let's let's discuss it. Like, okay, first of all, there's go to these spoilers let's talk about the film for a little while then piecing together what did we just say? What the hell does happened?

Speaker 5Yeah?

Speaker 4Right, right right?

Speaker 5Oh.

Speaker 4The other thing I noticed before we watch it is the reviews are like critics are at like thirty three percent and audiences are at ninety six percent, which is yeah, yeah, yeah, and we'll discuss that too.

Speaker 3Well, you know, and I personally think that that you know, high number really does carry through for most of the movie. And it wasn't until the ending that I lost my high rating of the movie. So you know, as long as I ignore the ending, and I did it. They had a lot of great things about it and a lot of really scary, scary scary things about it, and.

Speaker 5In the psychological sense and social yes, facing.

Speaker 3You know, the reality of the world we're living in. Uh. And you know, I mean we've all seen the Peace Soup and Spinning Heads version of possession.

Speaker 5Uh that's the real version.

Speaker 3Yeah, we've seen the real thing. But in this case, you know, it's just yeah, we have to ask that question. Does evil always have to be you know, loud and grotesque? And what if it's rational, yeah, even likable? You know, then Uh, that's pretty frightening in itself, right there, So he thought, you know a time semon.

Speaker 4Charming.

Speaker 3Yeah, I did adore the Demon at times.

Speaker 4Yeah, I mean so, I guess we should let me lay down the plot. The basic plot is there is a man named Edward Wayne Bray, not to be confused with the comedian and Wayne Brady. He is played by Sean Patrick Flannery, who people may know from The Bunda Saints among other things, and he's being interviewed because he's going to be executed, and according to the plot, they need to do a last minute make sure he's not

Speaker 4actually mentally ill, he's competent to actually be executed. I don't think this is like how things normally would go. You wouldn't do this like hours before the execution, but what do I know. Yeah, but the regular psychiatrist who's supposed to be coming in jumps off a building right before the movie really gets going, and so Sean Patrick sorry Jordan Belfi is brought in as sort of the last minute replacement doctor. Only it turns out that this

Speaker 4was all very well orchestrated by the Demon. If we're to believe the story anyway, The question is, is this guy crazy or is he really saying but he's possessed by a really evil entity.

Speaker 3Now I noticed that, you know, the other movies or pieces of literature that kind of came to mind while watching this was, of course, The Exorcist, and I'll explain why in a moment. But there was that. There was Anne Rice's Memnoch the Devil, and there was Fallen with Denzel Washington.

Speaker 4Yeah, Fallen especially, I thought, yeah.

Speaker 3And have you ever read or do you know about the Screwtape Letters.

Speaker 4You know, it's a shame that I haven't, but I know the C. S. Lewis wrote them, and that I think John Cleese did a performance of them. It's supposed to be quite good.

Speaker 3Oh M to look for that, because you know, it is heavy on the satire. But the demon reminds me of Screwtape. And basically what happens in the Screwtape Letters is you've got this demon named Screwtape who is basically counseling his nephew, Wormwood on how to tempt humanity and how to get them going down that path. And there was just a little bit of that personality in there with this with this demon, and and it was. It

Speaker 3was really interesting. I mean because there was a real uh, there was a lot of propaganda in this this. You know, when The Exorcist came out, the Catholic Church had a huge number of people converting to Catholicism, and I think sort of, you know, right wing Christians were really hoping for the same kind of effect with this.

Speaker 4Yeah, this is heavy on the proselytizing.

Speaker 3Yes, it is definitely heavy.

Speaker 6Well, you've mentioned a number of books that focus on exorcisms and demonic possession.

Speaker 5But what I thought of was Sybil.

Speaker 6So the book, oh, the movie, I thought of that because they were the personality is Actually yeah, they did actually mention the disorder disassociated identity disorder. It used to be known as multiple personality disorders. Yes, so where someone experiences too or more distinct personalities or identities as a different different characters. And because we kept seeing this switch between Edward and the Demon, that was what I kept thinking of. I guess we'll get into this more too,

Speaker 6just talking about Edward and the Demon, the different characters. But I certainly felt a lot of empathy for Edward at times, and even though he's this serial killer who's killed at least six people, possibly many more. You could really see as this fiction is playing out that he's the victim.

Speaker 3Yes, yeah, and it is, you know, heart wrenching at times when you get to see how much joy Nefarious gets out of his continued torturing of Edward, even down to the double cheeseburger.

Speaker 5Uh yeah, I want let him, let him have his final meal.

Speaker 3Yeah, it's it's it's it is really sad. I mean there was a lot of things that were very confronting about this movie. Oh yeah, And I mean you've got things like, let's let's talk about Fallen just for a moment. A Zazel in Fallen I think really reminds me a bit of COVID. You know. It was this thing that would would just transfer by touch, and it was all about destroying its host, you know, and so it's really indifferent.

Speaker 3You know the whole way through, Uh, the Exorcist Pazuzu was about kind of destroying innocence and and you know, making you feel that despair. Uh, And so it had a slightly different thing. Now you've got Nefarious, who is all about making you just kind of forget and not notice and just numb, numb to what's going on right in front of you, and not really pay attention to it or think of it as evil. And I think that that really unintentionally, I think that it really highlights

Speaker 3the world we're living in right now and how we are constantly every day being numbed to Yeah, and the things that are going on, you know, around us, and we're just kind of you know, it's all theater. It's all theater to us, and it's it shouldn't be. And that's the part that hit me hard, even though that wasn't even in the message. You know. The message was you know, if you'll, if you'll allow me, you are all infected with the woke mind virus and you think

Speaker 3that these non Christian things are okay, but they're not, and it's all part of the demon coming to get you. That's the bottom line of this whole movie. But the things that I think we pick up from watching it in our current you know, a climate is far more scary than what they were intending to scare us with.

Speaker 5Well, how could they have learn a couple of years ago?

Speaker 4Yeah?

Speaker 3How could they from twenty sixteen on? How could they have known.

Speaker 5Twenty twenty three? Yes, even more has happened.

Speaker 4It's interesting that the film itself. Okay, so I kept getting this vibe. I was like, this reminds me of the sort of thing when I was growing up. They would have movies where they would bring them into the church and they would have like a movie night, and it would be like some Christian values film would be shown instead of instead of like, instead of in a movie theater, you'd show it at.

Speaker 3The church, a very special episode of Family Times.

Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, but I I I'm not far off. I mean to say, you know, it's heavy handed propaganda, like I mean it, I don't there's a very strong It's weird to me because there's absolutely a very strong Christian message here, but it's not exactly to the level I would have expected given the people who put it together. Right, So it turns out the directors here, Carrie Solomon and Chuck Consulman, are the people behind God's Not Dead and

Speaker 4that that those fine cinema features and you know, and so our protagonist in this film, the psychiatrist, is portrayed as being an atheist, and the demon goes to this whole thing about you know, you'd have to invite me in and He's like, Okay, you know, come on in, you know, and then I'm going to spoil it. At the end of the film, there's a very tense moment where it seems like maybe the demon has taken over and take it. He's he's gonna actually cause him to suicide,

Speaker 4which makes no sense because he told him he was going to publish his book, and like, so his whole thing was he wants to publish a book, which is them.

Speaker 6You know. That was an interesting kind of contrast to the Bible. I loved him referring to the Carpenter.

Speaker 4Yeah. Yeah, but it's like I don't understand, Like it's so simplistic in a way. It's like, hey, you know, you guys have your Bible. We're going to do our dark evangelism, and we're going to have this book about me the demon nefarious and how you know how to take over the world? Right, that's and it's going to be a book, because when you want to change the world, you definitely want a book. That's how you do it.

Speaker 4People love to read. People are always sitting down and reading their books.

Speaker 6Yes, I guess around for thousands of years, he is.

Speaker 4Not caught up. He should be on TikTok is I guess what I say.

Speaker 3And that's the thing, you know, being around for thousands of years, the amount of time that we've been exposed to TikTok is a very short so he's still just a little behind.

Speaker 6I think the whole film was was simplistic and intended to be that way. I mean, it all centers on the psycho, one room, one table, prisoner sitting there. I mean, that is that's hard work for from a writing perspective and an acting perspective.

Speaker 4I mean, Sean Patrick Flannery was I mean knocking it out of the park. But you know it's it's not Jordan Belfie's fault, I guess, but he felt like he was on a TV show, and Flannery felt like he was going for the Oscar. I don't know he was really.

Speaker 6I mean he could tell when he was the Demon because he had that twet yeah.

Speaker 3Yeah, if and the Heath Ledger joker dry mouth yeah yeah.

Speaker 5I mean yeah.

Speaker 4He brought a lot of really clear acting to it. I mean like he made character tics and like gave you clear indications when he was hopping back and forth between his two roles. I don't know. I was very impressed by him, not so much by the script. And again I'm super open minded to it doesn't bother me if a film has, you know, religious undertones or whatever or overtones if it's a good movie. And I think what happened at the end, as you say, it sort of collapsed into a hyper simplistic, predictable conclusion that kind

Speaker 4of spoiled where it seemed like it was going. I don't know, That's just my take, but I definitely got the vibe that this would be a thing that you could have shown at a church, and maybe people did, and that the ninety six percent approval ready for the audience is probably Christian love bombing on the review.

Speaker 3Oh yeah, I think so. I think so. I mean, but but you know, being a demonic possession fan that I am, as we all are, yes, I did enjoy a lot of aspects of it, you know, I enjoyed the points where the demon was leading him down the path of this is all fake, I'm you know. In the Book of the Exorcist, uh Pazuzu did that to

Speaker 3Father Karras where they found evidence in her room that she had been reading about cults and everything, so her knowledge about this was was not diabolical. Uh, And so he's thinking this whole thing, I can't do an exorcism, this is not you know, this is not real. This girl is is faking. And you know, the demon does the same thing here. We're calling doubt, you know, into his mind. And I really appreciated the fact that they kind of kept that kind of personality or that thought

Speaker 3process of a demon what I And I liked it too when he said, you know, invite me in, come on, invite me in. And then he doesn't take him up onto it and take him up on it, you know, kind of a much too vulgar display of power. And he just said, you know, patience, And of course I knew what was going to happen the minute he said patience. I knew what was coming. But the fact that this diabolically intelligent being set things up so beautifully to fail so stupidly disappointed me, because you know, if he was

Speaker 3really that diabolically intelligent, it would not have ended the way it did, and we would have been in much more despair, such as at the end of Fallen you know where the demon keeps going. Now, it did show us that the demon was still there and still going. But then it makes you wonder what was the point of the whole display.

Speaker 4Yeah, it really.

Speaker 6Well, it could have gone lots of different ways. I was wondering if the demon was going to be transferred into the psychiatrist. I just wasn't really sure what was going to happen. But what I did like was the.

Speaker 3And that's what the foreshadowing told us.

Speaker 6Well, yeah, I think it did lead us astray a number of times, and one of those times was when the priest came in. I really thought he was going to factor more into the rest of the movie, but I thought it was interesting the way that threw a self balance with him coming in and the demon was very worked up and fearful of him, but then he just assured him, Oh, well, these kinds of things don't exist.

Speaker 5I don't do exorcisms, and he just dismissed all of that.

Speaker 6So I don't know what his his religious background was, but he certainly didn't.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 3Yeah, I mean that whole thing to me just kind of showed that the even the church has been infected, you know, with this.

Speaker 5You know, bor skepticism.

Speaker 3Yeah, you know, this whole just numbness of what's going on in front of them. They've all been infected with it. You know. It's like one of the great quotes bottom line.

Speaker 2As you're done, it's over. That's it. And we did it all right to your face, James, And now there's evil everywhere and no one even cares. Yeah, I don't agree, proving that we achieved our goal slowly with your movies, your TV and your media, which sensitized you, redirected your worldview to the point that you can't even recognize evil when it's right in front of your face. More to the point, James, you can't even feel it when you're doing it. And that's for winners and losers, Bobo. That

Speaker 2gets decided at the time of death. These act numbers are closely guarded secret. But there are more of you ending up in my master's house than with the enemy, a lot more.

Speaker 3I mean, you know, evil didn't barge in. It just asked nicely and waited quietly, you know. And that's much more intelligent and terrifying, I think than just this monster comes stomping in to have it be really brilliant and play chess with you, And this demon played chess so well throughout this movie untill the end.

Speaker 4But why Okay, So this has been a problem with the whole demonic possession Faustian bargain thing from the very beginning. I never understood this exactly, the idea that you would need to bargain for your soul with the devil in order to get benefits. Okay, because at least the way I was brought up as an evangelical, the idea is because of original sin, if you haven't made a relationship with Christ and accepted him as your personal ordered savior,

Speaker 4then you're already doomed to hell. So to what advantage is it to the devil to give you when he bargained, because he's already got your soul. So it really doesn't I mean, that has never made any theological sense to me that you might be able to bargain it away unless you had given your you know, your heart to God and now you're like pulling it back to sell it, you know, like you know, maybe that would make sense. I don't know, but I mean, in this case, the demon specifically talks about how that he got this guy,

Speaker 4he got control of Brady, because it started out with his parents failing to baptize him, and then from there it was just a series of decisions after decisions until he had won him over completely and taken control. And it's like, well, you know, I mean as a metaphor, sure, yeah, that works great, but from theologically it doesn't really work great for me.

Speaker 3Right now, we do have to have a nothing another spoiler here, and that is that this movie is being reviewed by three atheists.

Speaker 4Oh yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 6Well I have to say at this point, I'm really glad that I was raised in a mostly secular country.

Speaker 5You have to think about things like this, and it's just what it wasted.

Speaker 3Well, you know, we talked about last week about how with with the Bothy's, how you know, they would make up stories about a Bothy to keep people away, and these days they make up stories to draw people in. And it really kind of makes us, you know, wonder what numbs us more because I remember they used to say, you don't don't watch horror films, you're just going to get numb to it all. And you know, horror films or or are going to you know, make it so

Speaker 3you don't see what's coming because you think it's all fake and all that kind of stuff that in the eighties, I was hit with that a lot. But I have to wonder what numbs us more horror movies or headlines, because it seems like we're in an age now where we're just constantly being numbed. And that's kind of what Nefarious was telling us. You know, you're being bombarded all the time with all this stuff that makes everything you do okay. You know when he says, when when the

Speaker 3psychiatrist says to him about the whole you know, abortion part of it, trigger.

Speaker 5Warning, there a few of those content warnings.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, uh, he says, it's complicated. And that's like the best, you know, excuse for anything that you don't want to face is to just say it's complicated. And you know, of course Nefarius loved that answer, just laughed hysterically, and you know, and I love how he said, what was it, uh, hate crimes or hate speech.

Speaker 6Speech that we invented that ourselves, that wasn't even of Satan.

Speaker 3Yeah, it's like we love you for that, you know. So yeah, there was a lot of interesting things. And it's funny because I think a lot of Christians believe that they've got the market cornered when it comes to morality. And the thing is is that that the morality over that higher ground is often pretty immoral, you know, they you know, looking into which a future topic will be haunted cheets, and itzza looking at how the religious leaders

Speaker 3there mirrored Christianity in terms of keeping people uneducated, keeping people you know, in their place through promises or fear, so they right, so they can usurp all the power. And that's where the the you know, the the morality doesn't lie, you know, is is there is the fact that the these these religious leaders throughout history have always

Speaker 3kept truths from the people so they could hold the power. And so I think it's interesting that you've got this this Christian group basically making this movie, putting it out there as another big warning that don't get smart, don't go get an education now because.

Speaker 4Let's you're exactly right, the psychiatrist is an atheist, and that seems to put him in special jeopardy, right, yes, because he's he's ill equipped to fight a demon, although I think he actually holds his own pretty well. But what's really confusing to me is at the end when he's in that Glenn Beck cameo moment, which I assume means he died and went to Hell, because otherwise, why does he hang out with glenb Bag exactly.

Speaker 6A hah.

Speaker 4But Glen Glenn's like, you know, well, how did you get through all this? And he's like, well, I'm still trying to work all that out, you know, And he's like, well, you know, if you keep at it, you'll get there. You know. What he basically means is, you know, or he seems to be implying, you will come to understand that God is real and that Christ loves you, and that this is how you've escaped, Except that that doesn't make any sense because when we last saw him prior to that jump cut, he was struggling with the police

Speaker 4and was trying to off himself. And the next thing we know, he's successfully published this book but does not appear to have reconciled himself with God in any way.

Speaker 5So, oh no, he was wearing a sweater.

Speaker 4Yeah, well, okay, well here is that That's a good point. I didn't think about that. Is that coding for he's accepted Christ.

Speaker 3I think one of the big problems with this review was we only had a chance to watch it once, you could watch it more than once, you would notice things like the sweater.

Speaker 4That's a good point. It seemed like he was still on a path towards trying to figure things out.

Speaker 6And maybe that's why he encountered the demon again on the way out. Yeah, maybe unfinished business.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 4Now, I guess we should point out that the author of this the novel is Steve and I think he's pronounced d de a ce and he is a conservative talk show host on Glenn Beck's Blaze Network. So the novels published. I don't actually know who published the novel, but he's obviously using the Glymbec Blaze production company stuff for the for the making of this film, so it seems.

Speaker 4And again from a business perspective, I cannot argue against consolidating and collaboration and all that stuff that's good. I just I don't like these films where they're heavy on the proselytizing and heavy handed. And I guess I don't mind a film outing a positive message, it's just I don't want it to be so preaty.

Speaker 5You know.

Speaker 6Well, if I may, I went and looked up the book just then, and so the publisher's Post Hill Press, so I haven't heard of them before, but their ranking is that it is. It's listed under political fiction, and that's literature and fiction and American literature, So I.

Speaker 5Think that that's a little bit of a giveaway.

Speaker 6I mean, wow, the ratings are really high on this here, twenty two hundred reviews and almost five stars, So yeah, I think there's some nefariousness going on behind it.

Speaker 3Well, you know, I have to say that there was a lot of good stuff in this in this film in terms of entertainment and being thought provoking and things like that. But the bottom line is, is is it a supernatural thriller a thriller? Or is it a theological pamphlet disguised as a horror film? And I think it's kind of both.

Speaker 6Sorry, I'm looking at the reviews and the editorial reviews of by Ted Cruz Ben Shapiro, So yeah, I think that tells us which way they swink. But oh, Kirk Cameron, Oh yeah, I told her what this movie was about.

Speaker 4She's like, oh, is Kirk Cameron in it?

Speaker 6And I'm like, no, right, wait, he's the biggest one great comfort. Yay, what do you think this movie hasn't it then for our listeners, for skeptics.

Speaker 4It's not as heavy handed as God's not dead, So there's that, But.

Speaker 3I still found it to be, like, is that pretty entertaining? And I enjoyed a lot of the aspects of you know, other horror films that I enjoyed being you know, sort of a called upon in a sense, and so it was it was a different take on a demon. It was a kind of a good warning to don't get numb to the injustices being held right in front of you in the headlines on the social media every single day.

Speaker 6They're trying to say too. I mean, that's the irony. I think that that's how they see us.

Speaker 3Yes, yes, it's there. They're you know, in a sense, looking in a very you know, damaged, dirty mirror. But it is a mirror, so you know, they're not quite we're not seeing each other quite the way we should be. But well, I met there's some similarities.

Speaker 4I never like it when a movie talks about atheists though they're they're immoral or amoral, and I'm like, no, I mean also with any Christian based, you know film, there's a lot of them have that sort of subtext that oh, by the way, if you're not one of us, you're evil. And yeah, by the way, that means, oh, I don't know, four fifths of the world is evil, you know. I mean like there's a lot of people out there who are just simply never exposed to Christianity

Speaker 4and that's never going to be a religion for them, and so by Christian's theology, they're doomed to hell. So I mean, it's there's religions complicated. This is why we usually don't talk about it very much on here, because I don't believe in it, and I think it's important, but I don't. I think it's culturally important, and I understand the comfort people get from it, but it doesn't work for me. Yeah.

Speaker 3So well, you know, if we step back and go, okay, well I just watched Lord of the Rings. Do I believe in Hobbits?

Speaker 2No?

Speaker 3Did I enjoy Lord?

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 4I wouldn't let me read the line the witch in the wardrobe because I had wits in it.

Speaker 3My mom wouldn't because it had Turkish delight in it.

Speaker 4I'm just telling you, what what does that mean to you? Diabetes? What exactly? No?

Speaker 7I mean, well, we have you right where we want you then, you know, it's I just think that you know, I love demonic possession movies, and I think the fact.

Speaker 3That this is, like I said, a bit of a a pamphlet for you know, theology. Uh, it is not that big of a deal to me because I saw it for what it was in that sense, but the story itself with the you know, I like, I like demons, and I like people fighting against them, and I think it's fun and I I always like dialog.

Speaker 4There's lots of good dialogue, great dialogue.

Speaker 3So there's no reason you can't enjoy this movie and and feel like you have to run out and get baptized. It's just just sorry.

Speaker 4Do you remember so before Snopes kind of blew up in weird ways, they used to have a whole section called Blurges, which would be like someone takes a story and then they would like not it up to another level of like over heavy handed, sympathetic or treakily kind of content. So it's like a thing could be okay and interesting, but to make to make it go that extra mile, they would like pump like fifteen to twenty

Speaker 4pounds of extra heartstrings into a five pound sack, right, it felt like that at the end, like it was really rare. Mpened it up at the end, and I think if it had stuck with more ambiguity and maybe not quite gone so heavy handed in the end, I think that would have been really cool. I think there was a lot of good to work with here, and Briggan hell Sean Patrick Flenny did a great job with the acting so and.

Speaker 5Things I do well he did.

Speaker 6And I just want to raise just how many topics are in this film. We're very disturbing a lot of the topics that they raised, but I think most of all just the death penalty and for me that the moral and ethical concerns.

Speaker 5About that, and.

Speaker 6It seemed to be a good example of wrongful conviction as well, and just coming from a country where this is outlawed, it was just very confronting and horrifying to hear about the nature of this form of execution and just.

Speaker 5Be exposed to that. I could love that during those scenes.

Speaker 3It was very disturbing, the depiction of the the Uh, the execution was harsh. It was definitely harsh, and uh, you know, it's not the only movie that that's done it. Again. We can talk about Fallen for that as well. But yeah, especially when you're I think, yeah, yeah, it really was. I mean the fact is that a human life was being taken is one thing. Another thing is feeling like

Speaker 3that human life. The human in there was innocent, he.

Speaker 6Was going to be the one left to suffer, and the demon just enjoyed watching and not being well, he actually enjoyed those experiences.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, that was that was rough. That was rough, definitely.

Speaker 6But yeah, I don't know what you stand on things like maybe we didn't want to go down that philosophical.

Speaker 5Group, but yeah, I mean the violation of the right to life.

Speaker 4Well, the film dealt with abortion and the death penalty and euthanasia. It may really crammed a whole lot of uh, you know, socially challenging issues in a in a in a real small package, and you know, it took the well, this is a sin, so therefore it's wrong kind of ground, which I guess the point of the atheist character would be. No,

Speaker 4you know, in your world it's a moral question, and other people's it's an ethical question. In other ways it's it's you know, it doesn't the mom have you know, there's all these questions, right.

Speaker 3It's complicated.

Speaker 4It's complicated. It is complicated. So you know, in the simplistic world of of this moral universe, it isn't complicated. It's there's very clear delineation between what's a sin and what's not a sin, except that that's not really true either. I mean, the truth is it sins them get quite complicated, and the way people work around them gets quite complicated. The way people self justify gets quite complicated. It's almost like you need some deity to come around and sort

Speaker 4it out, you know, It's almost it is almost like that.

Speaker 5Yeah, so I.

Speaker 4Applaud them for trying. I don't know the I again, it was a little too heavy handed and proselytizing or heavy handed is the thing I keep coming back to. It was just a little over the top. But I really like something.

Speaker 5Lost towards the end. Yeah.

Speaker 3Well, you know, one of the things that I want to kind of relate those to and my personal enjoyment of the film is, you know, Karen had written a book years ago called God Bless America, and one of them that yes, yes, this is a thinly veiled pamphlet for Karen's books. Now, the thing is with this we went and we sat in on various different religious gatherings,

Speaker 3you know, from scientology to Amish to you know, various things along the way and right right, But the thing about it was we knew what to expect when we went in, so we weren't surprised by anything that happened. And damn if we didn't have a good time. And I think that that's how this film needs to be looked at. You know what it is, you know what's going on, but you know what it is, a fun, dirty, bumpy ride. Go for it. It's fiction. Yeah, so, and

Speaker 3and you know, as long as you don't sort of fall into their trappings anymore than they claim we've fallen into trappings, just enjoy the film.

Speaker 5And anyway, it was not any kind of theological alway.

Speaker 6I really just hoped it was going to be more along the lines of The Exorcist.

Speaker 3The Exorcist converted some people. This film is not going to convert anybody.

Speaker 5Yeah, I don't see how it could, but you never know. In this country.

Speaker 4Well, if you saw it in a church where it was followed up by some.

Speaker 5Think they would really show something like this.

Speaker 4Yeah, right.

Speaker 3But the thing is is, if you're already in the church. You're not going to get by this film.

Speaker 5Yeah, I guess it's just going to reinforce your belief exactly.

Speaker 4There's a section in the bookstore that's called Christian fiction and this always makes my wife laugh, but anyway, that it's full of litology, you know, and there's different sort of epithets for it. But things like left Behind, you know, these kind of stories set in an apocalyptic setting. Uh, you know there basically leaning and heavy on you know, congratulations, you've made it to Revelations. You know, Well, you're.

Speaker 5Making me think.

Speaker 6You're making me think of Bob Larsen, and he's kind of Christian porn his books.

Speaker 5Yeah, what were those coming up for air or something? Who is books?

Speaker 3Then you head one about a radio DJ on the air it was.

Speaker 8A satanic panic, Yeah yeah, yeah, but yeah, I mean he has all of his books and it's difficult to tell the difference between his fiction and his supposed reality.

Speaker 5Yeah, his non fiction books, it's all the same.

Speaker 4Like I Martin, I mean, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 6Larson's Book of Spiritual Warfare. But yeah, it does remind.

Speaker 3Me of that, Yes, that that book was called Dead Air, Dead.

Speaker 5Air, Yeah, coming up wanted to do after this movie.

Speaker 4Yeah that's funny, but yeah.

Speaker 6It's just just through interesting different perspectives. Is to me, this would just be wholly inappropriate to really show in any kind of group environment, unless you're just hanging out with inappropriate.

Speaker 3You know, you took the words out of my mouth. I was going to ask that same question.

Speaker 5Well again, I think.

Speaker 6Really glad I grew up in mostly secular environments and yeah, that's just.

Speaker 4These are all big issues. I mean, the the thing about Christianity or any religion I guess that has these prescriptions for behavior is if they're right, Like, you know, the implications are quite serious, right, so you know I don't believe them because there's so many religions and uh, you know I I my parents got upset with me because you know, I came out as an atheist and my dad was like, well, maybe you just need to study the Bible more. And I'm like, no, no, no, I

Speaker 4think you misunderstand. I didn't become an atheist by studying the Bible rarely. I became an atheist because I read a lot about the Bible and read the Bible. It's like, you know, I'm overread, not underread. Yeah exactly.

Speaker 3But there is a reason that we have Pascal's wager, and that's I mean, that's where we stand with this whole thing. Is it's I'm not sure better safe than sorry, which is a terrible version.

Speaker 6Yeah, well, yeah, I think a lot of people are prone to that. But yeah, certainly I'm starting to have discussions with our.

Speaker 5Son about that. Right now.

Speaker 6I'm talking about all of the various religions in the world, the world religions and indigenous ones, and they all think that they're right. How can they all possibly be right with all the conflicting plans and that they all have that righteousness and well, and it.

Speaker 4Can't seem to be left alone at personal choice. It's these people want to get political power and then and make their moral choices into the legal choices for everyone else. And that's that's hardly fair. So if if it was just about personal, you know, your own beliefs, I don't think I would care what people believe so much. But it's when they have their beliefs and now they want to inflict them on me, that's why I really get bothered by it.

Speaker 5So separated.

Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, allegedly, Yeah, it's Anyway, I don't like politics, and I don't really like discussion religion because it's so divisive, and I think we've done a good job of talking around some of that stuff. And again I don't I'm not an evangelical atheist. I just that's where I've landed is in the non believer world. But I still enjoy going to religious meetings, and I love camaraderie and the friendship of many Christian communities, and I appreciate.

Speaker 5A lot of the things too.

Speaker 4So I just I don't hate Christianity. I just I'm just I. Yeah, it's not I. I have come down real hard is I don't believe in this and I'm not inclined to change.

Speaker 6And both of you have unique perspectives. Yeah, not much has changed for me, but for you guys, certainly.

Speaker 3We've come from some very interesting places in our past to get to it.

Speaker 4Stealthy evangelicism through cinema is one of those recurring things, and I guess this sort of fits into that, Melu. But as these things go, I enjoyed this one a lot more than anything I've seen with Kurt Cameron or Kevin Sorbo or any of these other things. So it's certainly not the worst. How about that? Well, anyway, I think that concludes Nefarious You've been forewarned, is forearmed.

Speaker 5And various film in many ways.

Speaker 4Yeah, all right, anyway, thanks for listening. We'll see you again next week.

Speaker 5Thank you. Mortle.

Speaker 4You've been listening to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters.

Speaker 3I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner.

Speaker 4So you just heard Matt Baxter, Karen and myself discussing the twenty twenty three film Nefarious. A link to the film and some articles about it will be in the show notes. Was it a horror movie? It was so close, But like Matt, I think the ending underminds both its premise and its potential. We hope you enjoyed this episode of Monster Talk. Our goal here is to bring you the best in monster related content with a focus on scientific skepticism and critical thinking. If you enjoy our show

Speaker 4and want to support our mission, start out by visiting monster talk dot org forward slash support. That's monster talk dot org forward slash Support. There you'll find links to our Patreon page, as well as a donate button if you'd like to just make a one time contribution. A great way to support the show is to buy books from our Amazon wish list. These are books that directly help with our research. We love used books very much, so don't feel compelled to buy new ones, and we're also very fond of kindle editions because of their easily

Speaker 4searched content and without spending any money at all. You can support and raise the profile of the show by leaving a positive review at iTunes or wherever you get your podcasts. Positive reviews help keep us visible in iTunes, which is a great way to help us find new listeners. Finally, remember to share episodes you really like with your friends and family. You can help make Monster Talk the nightlight that keeps monsters away from someone you love. Monster Talks theme music is by Pete Stealing Monkeys.

Speaker 1Mh, this has been a Monster House presentation.

Speaker 6You said that you would prove to me your redeemon, but all you've done is waste my time, my turn.

Speaker 3I want to talk to Edward Wayne Brady.

Speaker 5Is Wayne Brady going to have the choke a bit

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S06E07 Elizabeth Taylor and the Burton of Truth

    Nov 16, 202655 minAudio

    Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S06E06 🐈⬛Evil Cats and Revelatory Revenants👻

    Nov 9, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S06E05🎃 Live 2026 Halloween Show

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S06E04 🍿Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈 Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S06E03 🎥 Capturing Bigfoot 🫈with Marq Evans

    Oct 19, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...

    Credit the people on this episode