Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

MonsterTalk

MonsterTalk artwork

S04E21 The Cave of the Winds

Feb 24, 202548 minAudio

Is the cave of the winds near Manitou Springs, CO HAUNTED!? Matt Baxter has investigated and he joins us to talk about what he found. Related Links: Spooky Science Sisters - Roanoke episode with Karen In Research Of… The Lost Colony - Blake & Jeb Card discuss the In Search Of… episode about Roanoke. Eclectic Shopping options in Manitou Springs The history of Manitou Springs The Cave of the Winds (Official Site) The Manitou (1978 film) Manitou - the spirit Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/monstertalk--6267523/support. Some product links may be affiliated with Amazon revenue sharing.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Monster House presents.

Speaker 2Around the world.

Speaker 3People report monsters.

Speaker 2But are they real? Join the detective of the impossible, Joe Nickel as he walks you through investigations to reveal often surprising natural explanations behind some of the most famous cryptids in legendary animals ever reported. Using scientific skepticism, meticulous field work in historical deep dives, Joe Nichols seeks out hidden clues and real world candidates that sometimes reveal that even the most unlikely monster stories may have a basis in reality. The Science of Monsters is the first book

Speaker 2from Monster House LLC, the publisher of science shows, Monster Talk and in research of The revised edition is now on sale and includes corrections and suggestions from you, our listeners and now readers. Sales of The Science of Monsters directly benefits Monster House and its podcast thanks to the generosity of its author. Pick up The Revised Science of Monsters today at Amazon dot com, available in paperback and kindle editions.

Speaker 4It's actually quite unlike anything we've ever seen before.

Speaker 3A giant, very creature, part ape, part mat.

Speaker 5In Luckness, a twenty four mile long bottomless lake in the Highlands of Scotland.

Speaker 4It's a creature known as the Luckness Monster.

Speaker 3Monster Talk.

Speaker 2Welcome to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner. The little city of Manitou Springs, Colorado, was founded in eighteen seventy two by General William Palmer and doctor William Bell, and was envisioned as both the resort community for the wealthy and a refuge for those seeking relief from tuberculosis at a time when tuberculosi's treatment was rudimentary. The town's crisp alpine air and high altitude provided a therapeutic environment, attracting patients who

Speaker 2often lived in specially designed teebe huts to maximize the fresh air intake. Beyond this reputation for healing, Manitou Springs also became famous for its natural carbonated mineral springs. This effervescent water, rich in minerals like calcium and magnesium and zinc, bubbled up around town and was once bottled and sold, reinforcing Manitou's spa allure. The focus of the spring fits in with the fad of water cures that became a decades long healing fad from the mid eighteen hundreds into

Speaker 2the very early nineteen hundreds. The town's most enduring legends centers on a person named Emma Crawford, a gifted musician who came to Manitou Springs hoping to cure her TV. She lived there for about two years before the city's healing powers failed to provide her a cure. After her death, she was buried atop Red Mountain, and local lore claims that a storm later swept her coffin into town, spawning the now legendary Emma Crawford Coffin Race, where costume participants raced decorated coffins through downtown each fall. The city's now

Speaker 2more of a whimsy filled tourist community with amusements and diversions along with lots of shopping opportunities, and there are also nearby archaeological sites, as well as an allegedly haunted cavern, which will be the focus of this episode. Karen's husband and frequent guests of the show, Matt Baxter, did some investigating and dropped in this week to tell us what he found. I should mention that Matt and I are both I don't know if fans is the right word, but we like to about the absolutely trippy nineteen seventy

Speaker 2eight supernatural horror movie The Manitou, which is about a woman who has a cancer diagnosis that turns out to be less of a cancer and more of the spirit of a diminutive indigenous wizard trying to open a portal into another dimension by emerging back into our world through this poor woman's neck lump. The film has Tony Curtis and Burgess Meredith, along with Susan Strasburg as the hapless bearer of this portal tumor. So if you hear Matt and I cracking jokes about The Manitou, we're mocking that film, but not mocking the beliefs of Algonquins or other indigenous people.

Speaker 2It's not a great movie, but it certainly is a boring And with that little bit of silliness explained, let's get down to some Mobsturtal, I appreciate you joining us, Matt. This is really cool and problem quite the lifesaver, because I know Karen's super busy with her bookwork, and I've had one of those days where I basically have been NonStop programming, which is really cool, and I am completely cognitively depleted. I don't know what's going on. So what

Speaker 2are we talking about tonight, Matt.

Speaker 5Well, I thought tonight that we could talk about the haunted Cave of the Winds of South Parks of South Park fame.

Speaker 2It's been a while since I've watched South Park, so I'm not familiar with that episode.

Speaker 4It's a cave of the Winds. I haven't been there myself, but over the years Matt has told me a lot about the place, and it just I do love caves, and I have investigated stories of other haunted caves in the past. We can get into that a little bit later, but Matt Wanning's start by telling us a little bit about the history of the place and where it is as well.

Speaker 3Well.

Speaker 5It's located in Manitou Springs, and that's about an hour or so south of Denver, Colorado, and it was formed in the Williams Canyon about four hundred and fifty million years ago. Now note it was not called Williams Canyon at that time. I think the name back then is lost to history. But before it was Williams Canyon, it was Manitou Canyon. So I was looking up, you know,

Speaker 5things about the word Manitou because we all have our favorite movie, right about the Manitou.

Speaker 2Sometimes I think of it as Manitumor because it's right right, right, yeah.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 5But the thing is is that you know, as you guys know the sort of group of indigenous peoples known as Algonquin because of the uh oh, what was the episode you guys did on Roanoke That was some Algonquins there, But they're they're a huge group of Oh yeah, that's right, caring you spoke about Yeah, did you? I'm blank?

Speaker 4And I need to cover that too.

Speaker 3Yeah, I think so.

Speaker 4I think so episode is worth listening to. It's like a memoth kind of three hour episode that we did.

Speaker 2You know it would be. I think we did these two things here say. One we did cover it on our sort of sister podcast in research of and two the Spooky Science Sisters have a book out now, so we'll probably should put a link in the show to that. Yes, definitely groovy, all right, but yeah, yeah, so we will have to come back to Roanoke kiro Munster talk for sure.

Speaker 3Yeah. Well there's you know, there's a.

Speaker 2Ton of things to say about it, exactly.

Speaker 5Well, there's there's also a huge number of Algonquin languages spoken by different indigenous peoples of North America. Manitou actually equals the force from star wars.

Speaker 3Uh.

Speaker 5It's you know, this this sort of force that binds things together. It's this mysterious thing that's you know, interweaves with all living things.

Speaker 3And it's really interesting that China.

Speaker 5Well a little bit, but this has a little bit more of a personality behind it that it makes it a little a little more.

Speaker 2Different, a little bit more a little sentient, yes, a little.

Speaker 5More, a little a little more apt to you know, grow as the tumor and in someone's neck.

Speaker 2So yep.

Speaker 5Now, now that the cave was named for this kind of moaning sound that happens from the wind blowing across the main entrance, and and it happens with a lot of different caves. You know, it gets that kind of well a moaning sound, and it almost sounds human or other worldly at times. Now, the Apache people encountered the cave at some point, and it was claimed that they felt it housed the great spirit of the wind, and

Speaker 5this the spirit would cause you know, whirlwinds and tornadoes, dust devils and all those kinds of different wind based phenomenon. And the main passage, though, was discovered in modern times in eighteen sixty nine.

Speaker 3By Arthur B.

Speaker 2Love.

Speaker 5He had homestead near there. Now, he never actually went into it, he just kind of discovered that first main passage. Now, it didn't get really discovered discovered until a little bit later by a couple of brothers. And'll talk about them in a moment. But over the next one hundred and fifty years, the cave was opened and expanded and closed and reopened for commercial use, which is tours. And the first time they were charging like a dollar a tour,

Speaker 5and that was like way too expensive for people, and they ended up going out of business. So later on they opened it again and went for fifty cents and they did a little better. Now the caves really feature some beautiful mineral structures. And in nineteen twelve the entrance was smashed open by burglars who, yeah, you guessed it. They stole all of the gorgeous lamps that were on

Speaker 5the inside on the tour.

Speaker 4I wonder what they were expecting to find.

Speaker 3Yeah, I don't know, but they stole lamps.

Speaker 5Now it's interesting because during World War Two in the nineteen forties, the Cave of the Winds was listed as an official air raid shelter by civil defense authorities.

Speaker 3So that was kind of interesting, big.

Speaker 2Enough that yeah, it's gonna say how many people can fit in there?

Speaker 5Yeah, oh I don't have an exact number, but more than four.

Speaker 3Okay, okay, a lot.

Speaker 5Yeah, there's you Like, I'm well, I mean you're talking about like like during World War two and then like was it also like after because I know around here we have a.

Speaker 2Saltpeter Cave it is what they call it, but it was at one point it was designated as a fallout shelter kind of thing, and yeah, that would be bad because unless you stock it with like dry goods and water and other things, you just make it a big pile of dead people underground, which you know.

Speaker 4Yeah, catacombs. I was going to mention them a bit later on too. In Paris also a bit of people that are exactly yeah, six million to be.

Speaker 5Precise, a lot precisely anyway. So yeah, that's kind of a very short history. I mean, there's a lot to the place, and it's it's constantly being expanded. More and more corridors and tunnels are being found and opened up and it is an incredibly beautiful cave system, There's no doubt.

Speaker 3Meat.

Speaker 2I went and looked at the website and it looked very very well, it looked very very commercial, but it looked very pretty. And a lot of these, you know, we have a lot of these places up in Tennessee and Kentucky too, where people turn a beautiful geographical, geographical, geological feature into a trade. I mean, there's one attached to the Belwitch Cabin, like on the same property, there's a there's a what is it called Lost Sea, a giant underground lake, and then of course mammoth caves and

Speaker 2yeah it's interesting.

Speaker 4But oh yeah, some ones in St. Louis as well, where they the breweries used to store beer and all kinds of gangster related stories and corruption and oh it's important part of American history, I think, just the cave system and how it's interwoven into a lot of dog in the past here.

Speaker 2Yeah, well, why would we're here to talk about them in terms of ghost stories?

Speaker 3Though? So?

Speaker 2Why why would these caves be haunted? Did people die there or is it like just they get captured by the I don't know what the spirit.

Speaker 3The manitou.

Speaker 5Well, the thing is is, let's back up just a moment anytime. That's thank you for the alerts.

Speaker 3It was very convincing.

Speaker 5One of the things is like if you're driving down the street and you see this old house that you know just has a spooky look to it. If you're not us, you go, oh, that house is hot, definitely haunted. The ambiance well, yeah, it's that. I mean, you walk in and you know it's dangerous. The floor could cave in on you, or a you know, homeless person could jump out and you know, stab you, or something you just don't know, and so you're you're completely on guard and you're very nervous, and it can just give you

Speaker 5this feeling of there's something unexpected that could happen, and a lot of times we translate those feelings into this place is haunted, must be haunted.

Speaker 3Oh that's a ghost.

Speaker 5And if you imagine what it's like to be in a cave underground, it is not familiar to you know, your your psyche to be in that situation. So even if nobody died in there, even if you know there were no stories of things that had happened there, you would still think, oh, this place is definitely haunted, and I think that just kind of goes along with most of the cave systems in the world. Uh there, they

Speaker 5all are creepy when you get down to it. They're they're damp, they're cool, and and I mean temperature cool, they're as well, they're pretty cool.

Speaker 4But cold spots, right, yes.

Speaker 5Yes, you're feeling cold spots like crazy.

Speaker 2I bet our monster Talk listens we would expect it to be cobalts or Tommy Knockers, not ghosts.

Speaker 3But I'll go with you.

Speaker 5I'll go with your idea here. What right, is there something paranormal going on? Yeah, that's that's That's all I can say.

Speaker 3Now.

Speaker 5As for the Cave of the Winds, there supposedly, uh there was a caver who absolutely loved the place and he was, you know, going through a really uh small corridor, you know, on his on his belly, you know, climbing through and got stuck and uh died there and they they found him quite some time later, like mummified pretty much.

Speaker 3And also, uh they supposedly.

Speaker 5Found uh a an indigenous uh American that was in their Mamma fight as well. I don't know if these are actually true because a lot of these stories get told over and over and over, and they grow and they change. I've heard of people going through on the tours and noticing that the tour behind them they could overhear them being told a different story, so that tends

Speaker 5to happen. I know that, you know, whether you go through the Winchester Mystery House or regardless of what you're going through the Stanley Hotel, the stories are you know, malleable, and that's kind of the same same here.

Speaker 3Now.

Speaker 5Some of the main claims that are heard from people that are on tours and also the tour leaders is that there's people that are always unaccounted for.

Speaker 3You know.

Speaker 5It could either be tour group members or guides themselves that are just like where did you come from? Kind of thing and then they vanish. Sometimes a guide like wearing a uniform and everything would be following a group of tour goers and all the working guides would be accounted for and they would have no idea where this this extra you know, guide came from. There was one cabin trip where I was in the Grand Cavern in

Speaker 5there and the entire group heard another group closing in behind them, which is not all that odd and when this happens often the guides of the front group will go back and say, hey, do you want to consolidate and just join us and we'll just make it one big group. So the guide went back to offer to consolidate the groups and there was no other group, so, you know, and the thing about these is they are very creepy, but at the same time, you don't have

Speaker 5them connected to something that actually happened. You know, they're just creepy stories. So there was a guy that was walking down the path and he encountered the silhouette of a person on the path in front of him, and so the person was backlit by a stationary lantern up ahead, and as the closer walked to the figure just vanished. They have another thing where they have these safety call boxes situated along the tour routes, you know, just in

Speaker 5case something happens, they can call for help and things like that. Now, there have been times that calls have come in from those boxes after hours when all there were no tours being conducted, as if someone was calling for help. But you know, the lights are on, but nobody's home. So at other times, some of the phones have been intentionally left off the hook during off hours just out of careuriosity, so the employees could like listen in for anything strange. And they have reported the sounds

Speaker 5of people walking through the caves, so of course you always get the shadow people in caves. That makes you know, makes sense why you'd be kind of having those illusions. But they go all the way through the caves and even into the gift shop, so follow the ghosts to buy your souvenirs.

Speaker 4Well, I think a lot of fears of caves and cabins go back to the common phobia of claustrophobia, and it's pretty common phobia that a lot of people have. And Matt, you might remember our son became obsessed for a little while with the Nutty Putty.

Speaker 3Cave Nuoty Putty Caves, Yes.

Speaker 4Yeah, which is a set of caves in Utah, And there was a particular incident there with a guy who was tracking through the caves and it got stuck in there. John Jones, that's right, and yeah, so he had a lot of nightmares about that. I think that that's a common fear and just interwoven with all the other kind of phenomena that's at play. In a place like that. As you you were discussing that, just the sounds and the creepiness in general.

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, my son has he watched an episode of Fireman Sam, which is like a UK show for kids, and there was an episode where a kia was crossing a field and fell into an underground pit and it traumatized him. Like he's still even now, he's like twenty two now and he still gets kind of worked up about crossing a field for fear of just random cave ins.

Speaker 4Hmm. Yeah, I think those things are formative, you know, we get exposed to these stories.

Speaker 2Yes, childhood fear can really warp you. Yeah. Spiluncophobia is apparently the formal name for the fear of caverns, which is a little on the nose, but yeah, yeah, yeah, Oh.

Speaker 4That's so interesting.

Speaker 3It is it is.

Speaker 5I one time tripped on a gopher hole, yeah, and I was traumatized from that.

Speaker 4But when you think about sinkholes and still the stories you hear about the houses getting sucked into the earth and Florida and various Yeah, yeah, I mean these things do happen. They're unlikely to happen to the average person, but.

Speaker 2You're so afraid of the unlikely, though, aren't we. I mean, you see some really weird thing that's extraordinarily unlikely, and it will haunt you. Our our focus on anecdotal weird incidents, and then we'll go hop in the car without thinking about it, and that's where most of us will die.

Speaker 4Like we're thinking about that once more.

Speaker 3Next episode, Matt.

Speaker 4I am wondering why you investigated there and why. I don't know who governs these kinds of things. I know in some countries, like in Australia and New Zealand, a lot of caves are owned now by the indigenous people who lived on those lands. But I'm wondering who kind of runs these caves, or specifically Cave of the Winds, and why would they let you guys in there or anyone, because I know how fragile these stalact types, mites and

Speaker 4columns are. I know in a place like I was going to talk later about the Jenolan caves in Australia near the Blue Mountains, and they used to hold they have orchestras play in there, and just various kinds of events and plays and things held in there. And I think it's closed at the moment though, because of flooding they had last year. But these places are just so fragile and delicate. Why would they let a group into go ghost hunting.

Speaker 5Well, it is done on a cave by cave basis, and.

Speaker 2That's nice.

Speaker 5It's you know, and that's the ownership of these places, you know it it is It could be anybody, you know, it could be big corporations that own it. It could be a family that owns it, or it could.

Speaker 4Be that's strange to be.

Speaker 5Yeah, yeah, it's because it is a commercial, you know business, and it is absolutely and in our case, they were getting you know, lots of different reports from the lantern haunted lantern tours that they do.

Speaker 3So I was lucky enough to be.

Speaker 5The first paranormal investigator to go into the caves and do it an actual investigation and did it twice. Well, but then you know, they ended up in you know, Caving magazine did a story about it, and I think several news local news networks did stories about it, and it upped their business just like they hoped, and soon lots of paranormal groups came a knocking. If there's one thing that paranormal groups can do it's get these places

Speaker 5shut down because they leave a mess behind and they are they don't treat things well. And I can't speak for every group, but I have watched it happen with a lot of places where you know, they come in and they just they litter and they don't have any respect for anything. So to be one of the first and treat it with respect and everything is something that I am proud of, and it's cool to get to do things like this. So the way I did investigations

Speaker 5at that time was a little more in line with what you saw on TV.

Speaker 3Now.

Speaker 5I didn't do it that way because I thought I was going to catch a ghost. I did it that way because I recognized that it's what was expected. If you showed up with equipment, and you showed up with you know, you know, ready to do a stakeout and every thing, well, suddenly you were legitimate, you know, if you showed up with a pad and a pen and you were just going to like interview and get some information and leave, which is really how it should be done. They don't you know what we showed up at one

Speaker 5place and all of our equipment wasn't enough. They were like where's your camera crew? They thought they were going to be on TV wow. So but by kind of playing the game in a sense, I got to go into a lot more cool places, such as the cave of the winds Now. We did have the typical you know things. We had computers and security camera systems and audio recording setups and tables and ground coverings and blankets and food, and there was no actual power that we

Speaker 5could plug into really far back because they sent us to the very back of the caves, and we had to bring eight hundred and sixty feet extension cord. And you have no idea how heavy eight hundred and sixty feet of extension cord is until you have to carry it down very long corridors that are keyhole shaped and very very short, so you're having to bend at the knees to walk through these and carry stuffed at chess level.

Speaker 5You can't carry things at the side because there's no room. It was a workout that was an absolute nightmare.

Speaker 4What did you guys find or not find?

Speaker 5Rather well, when we first got there, they took us on on a tour to show us where, you know, where things were sighted and where they kind of wanted us to concentrate. And one of the really cool places was the concert hall, and like you were saying, Karen, this place they would have concerts there. And one of the interesting things is once we got all set up and ready play, they play.

Speaker 2They played minuettes exactly.

Speaker 3Now.

Speaker 5You know, we took temperature readings and everything in the temperature readings were at a steady fifty four degrees fahrenheit.

Speaker 2That's pretty nice.

Speaker 5Yeah, all the time. It didn't change one hundred percent humidity.

Speaker 3Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 5So it was interesting because when we got back there in the concert hall, it's you could hear a violin, Like after a few minutes of just being in the silence, you could hear a violin, but it seemed like it was coming from behind the walls of the cave. So it was really confusing. Then a little while later it sounded like there was like an engine running or something in one of the caves, and it just got really

Speaker 5a lot of the things were confusing. Now, we did have one of the members on the group that we took back there, they had recorded the sound of it sounded like a train, you know, And I'm not talking about the chug a chug apart, but the train whistle, and and they were they were completely freaked out when they when they heard this, and they recorded it and they we didn't hear it, but they played it for us,

Speaker 5and it was one of those strange things where when they played it for us, I broke out laughing. I thought it was hilarious, and they couldn't understand why why did I think this was so funny? So I'm gonna play it for you here really quickly. Now, now this doesn't have the same reverb of the caverns and if you imagine, you know, a couple of caverns over, you know, the sound was in the distance, but this is it?

Speaker 4Will and said it, But what is it? Can you describe it?

Speaker 3Yeah?

Speaker 5It was an Apple startup tone. So yeah, we were starting up our computers and someone heard it several caverns away and thought it was a train, a ghost train, but they were working with PCs and they weren't familiar.

Speaker 3With the sound.

Speaker 2Oh well that would do it, which.

Speaker 5Brings up a really important thing. If you hear something you're not familiar with, you know, your mind will go to the nearest thing it can come up with.

Speaker 2Yeah, that's true, we're always we humans don't like unexplained things. We enjoy finding an answer for stuff, even.

Speaker 4If it's the wrong one.

Speaker 2Right, well, we talk about it all the time. Ghosts are not a mystery. Ghosts are an explanation. You know. The mystery is what all the other stuff is, what's causing these various phenomena. But once you say ghosts, then everything becomes part of a haunting, you know, and so then there is no mystery. You know, the answer it's a ghost exactly exactly.

Speaker 5Now, the so to to the places that I investigated, where the concert hall, which was just big, you know, huge room, very very beautiful, but you know, uh, a part of the phenomenon that was reported in there were these these flashing lights that would happen. Now you know, we had our lights and stuff on in there, and we didn't see anything flashing. So we turned off the

Speaker 5lights and we waited, and lo and behold, prisoner cinema popped right into action.

Speaker 2Oh wow.

Speaker 5And if you don't know, not to be confused with prisoner's dilemma. It's totally different.

Speaker 4But right, right, exactly do you want to explain that to us? So I think we have talked about it before.

Speaker 5Yeah, well you know you and I experienced it and researched it for your book Haunting America, talking about uh, the Silver Cliff Cemetery. And basically, when you are in this situation of sensory deprivation, like being inside of a cavern, your your eyes do some interesting things and and and your ears do as well. You hear things and it

Speaker 5really is an interesting thing. But you've got phosphienes, uh, you know, in your in your eyes and it's uh.

Speaker 4The description of those when you sneeze and you sometimes see kind of lights and swirls and flashes of color. I think that's a good comparison.

Speaker 5It is, it is, it's it's exactly that.

Speaker 3It's you know, any kind of pressure.

Speaker 5So like if you you're rubbing your eyes or if you sneeze things like that, you can see the little things happen. And it's different from when you get hit on the head really hard and you see things.

Speaker 3That's different.

Speaker 5This is more of a sensory deprivation type of situation that you will see these most often.

Speaker 4Yeah, and if you're not familiar with what that is or how that's caused, that can appear to be a paranormal thing.

Speaker 5Absolutely, and it's interesting because you try to see if we're all seeing the same thing. So we try to even use like laser pointers to try to like track things we were seeing, and everybody's in complete agreement with what they saw, and you just can't immunal reinforce, exactly, communal reinforcement. It just wasn't wasn't happening. So went into

Speaker 5another cavern called Lover's Lane, and this one has a story about a woman that for some reason was jilted. But why would she be in a cave out in a Yeah, it makes no sense, It makes no sense. But supposedly the story is if you go in there and you say anything chauvinistic or anything like that, she will she.

Speaker 4Will come at you, and so you got into trouble.

Speaker 3I got into troll.

Speaker 5I went in there and it's like, I'm not saying anything, so just for fun, I said some really choice things, and I'll be darned if the hair didn't stand up on the back of my neck, and it felt like something was coming for me. But it was absolutely just the psychological effect of being in there and expecting something. Yes, So it wasn't actually anything that was.

Speaker 3It was fun. It was fun as what it was.

Speaker 2I mean, you know, speaking just for myself, I'm a very skeptical person, especially around around the paranormal. But you know, when I'm in my basement, which is where I spent a lot of my time, and I have to come upstairs at night, there's that really crazy echo effect where your sound of your step gets bounced off the ceiling and back at you with just a little bit of delay. Yes, and it sounds so much like something's right behind you coming for you.

Speaker 3Yes.

Speaker 2And you know, as a kid that would terrify me. As an adult, I know exactly what it is, and it still bothers me. It still freaks me out.

Speaker 3Yeah, it gives you a little spring in your step. Yeah, it really is like a little faster.

Speaker 2With these old arthritic knaws.

Speaker 3That's impressive.

Speaker 5So, you know, after a certain amount of time in this deprivation, you know, you would force yourself to.

Speaker 3Go all the way back.

Speaker 5Out to the entrance just to get some you know, fresh air and and you know, have the real world still be there waiting for you. And so I was returning from one of these breaks and going back and just as I was getting to just before the concert hall, they have a place called the Monument Room, and I was just getting to the Monument Room and there was this man standing there and it didn't look familiar, and

Speaker 5so I I, you know, it was like hey, hello, and went up to talk to him and he vanished. Now again, it's it's one of those things where your your eyes play with you a little bit.

Speaker 3And seeing is simply not believing, you know.

Speaker 5It's you can't trust your senses in a place like that.

Speaker 3You just can't.

Speaker 5But it was it was really cool to get to do this over several weekends, uh, to get to go and do this more than once. And almost everything, uh that that we looked into can be explained through normal human physiology and psychology. But it was an absolutely amazing place. And I did do one thing that you might consider unethical,

Speaker 5and that is.

Speaker 3One stole the cavern one on one that I'm going to tell you about anyway.

Speaker 5This is the one unethical thing I'm actually going to admit to, okay, and that is I covertly brought a few things with me into the cave. So when I was alone in uh, one of the caverns and one of our cameras was set up. I put on some bear ears and a pig nose and I was man bear pig.

Speaker 2Oh oh, then you're totally serious, right, super serial, super serious. I do remember this, Okay, Yes, yes, yes, so I.

Speaker 5Actually did catch I caught man bear pig on video. You were lucky to Yes, yes.

Speaker 4Yes, half man.

Speaker 3Have a pig.

Speaker 5But yeah, so I admitted I did do that. But the thing is is, you know, I have been in different caves in different you know areas, and you know, like mine shafts and stuff like that from old gold mines. I live in Colorado, so it's not a big surprise. And I have to say that all these these caves are so similar, you know, in the way they feel and the structure of them. And you know, Karen, you had asked earlier about why would they let us in,

Speaker 5you know, with all that they're so fragile and everything.

Speaker 3Well we were. We were sort of.

Speaker 5Escorted by a very experienced caver. And the places that the main places that we went were pretty It was just limestone, and so much of it was smooth on the walls from just people's hands steadying themselves over the years, and they do they power wash you know, the limestone at the end of every season. Really wow, yeah, they do, but that there were there were parts in there that

Speaker 5you know, we weren't going to get close to because of the damage. Now in the concert hall, they had these beautiful like ribs that had formed coming down the walls, but they could. They would play those, you know in the concert hall with you know, the like string sections and everything. They would play those like a xylophone, and that.

Speaker 2They would be very disconcerting.

Speaker 5Yes, and it was beautiful sounding, but when you go in there now half of them are broken because of that, and so it's disappointing to see that kind of thing. But no, we were incredibly careful, respectful, and they kept us away from anything that we could, you know, stupidly damage.

Speaker 3So yeah, that's.

Speaker 4Why good to hear.

Speaker 2I did go to their website. Even if you're not into the supernatural, it seems like it'd be pretty spooky to do this. They offer handheld lantern tours where you can just hold an old lantern in front of yourself and wander around. That sounds kind of fun, I mean, yeah, it does, yeah, because I mean, even if there's nothing supernatural going on, you're still walking around in.

Speaker 3A dark, dark space.

Speaker 2That's that's that's Uga Booga territory. For sure.

Speaker 4Yes, it would be worth visiting.

Speaker 5And you're hearing scary, scary stories from the tour guides at the same time, and it's thick. The atmosphere is very thick.

Speaker 4Well, And this is a thing worldwide, And I want to touch upon just a couple of other places, because there are hundreds of caves around the world and they're open to not only historical tours and geological tours, but also ghost hunting tours as well. And on my a list of places to visit is the Catacombs in France. And I know you guys both know about this place, these underground osies in Paris that hold the remains of more than six million people. And so they were built

Speaker 4back in the late eighteenth century and they were built to relieve overcrowding in cemeteries at the time and to address sanitation issues as well. And there are some pretty famous people buried there. All their remains are there, like Robespierre was buried there, oh wow, and other are victims of the French Revolution. And so the Catacombs are about sixty five feet, which is twenty meters or so deep. So that's about the height of a five story building,

Speaker 4which I think is incredible. And so it's open through tours and it is considered to be one of the most haunted places in the world.

Speaker 2In Paris see the Eiffel Tower and the Awful tour.

Speaker 4But they have lots of stories of people seeing apparitions and hearing voices and that sensation of feeling touched which Matt was talking about to this feeling like there are other people around you. But from my own personal experience, a place that I have been to going back, I've got been twice, but this is going back decades ago. The Jenolan Caves in New South Wales in Australia, so that's west of the Blue Mountains, and Matt, I think you and Blade would love to go there someday. It's really beautiful. It's closed at the moment, as I said,

Speaker 4because of flooding and landslips that took place last year. But yeah, it's got a reputation for being haunted again, stories of ghostly apparitions and mysterious lights that turn off and on by themselves, and security gates that rattle for no reason as well. And a lot of these stories are linked to a caretaker that used to work there, a guy named James, and apparently he was so devoted to the caves that he chose never to leave. So that's the story behind that.

Speaker 3James.

Speaker 4And in New Zealand too, I went to the Whiteomo Caves and you guys have to get there someday. It's a little village on the North Island of New Zealand and it's known for this really extensive underground system of caves. But in particular it's known for the thousands of glow worms that light up the caves there.

Speaker 3Oh that sounds cool.

Speaker 4Oh, it's just beautiful. Go and google it. Have a look. They've got waterfalls and limestone formations. It's really beautiful. And that is in the general area where they filmed The Hobbit.

Speaker 2I was about to say, it's like to go see the caves and the Hobbit holes. Yeah, yeah, and there's I've heard I've heard that a lot of the Hobbit holes were just a door stuck on the side of a hill. You can't actually go inside. Yeah, I know it's fake. What it was a documentary ridiculous.

Speaker 4But so I have been to these caves. I didn't stay. There's a hotel nearby, and apparently that is meant to be equally wanted too. It's known for a lot of paranormal activity, and people took about bath tubs that drip blood, so that that would be an interesting thing to see. But perhaps I don't know things like that in some hotels up stadium, Yeah, i'd.

Speaker 2See some rusty pipes do some pretty similar things.

Speaker 4Point.

Speaker 2Yeah, absolutely, And you stay in as many cheap hotels as I have, and it's been.

Speaker 4A lot, say no more. But there's a dining room in that hotel that apparently has lots of cold spots, and there are stories of a Maori princess that haunts the hotel as well, and people get a feeling of sensation something walking through them, and just you know, the usual grab bag of haunting claims of moving lights and objects and laughter and screams, both extremes there.

Speaker 2But same as in cheap motels, this is all something really familiar.

Speaker 4Yeah, it's sounding very very natural. What's the natural explanations? Yeah, but anyway, yeah, I think that you know, for our listeners write to us and tell us if you've visited caves, gone on haunted tours of caves and and what you've found or what stories you've heard. Are always interested to hear about these kinds of tales.

Speaker 5And I do want to say, just really quickly in my defense of the stakeout, you know, it's not just about you know, doing what's expected, but it's also about sometimes the equipment you bring can help you determine what the real cause of the phenomenon was. It can help you also catch people that are trying to you know, hoax. So there is some you know, real world good reasons

Speaker 5to do it as well, but it is it does help with the expectation.

Speaker 3Side of things.

Speaker 4Oh yeah, and we've talked about that before. I think it's definitely worth mentioning again as well. But yeah, certainly there is that expectation that you have that equipment, but to use it for the purposes for which it's designed and then to disprove the claims that other people have and to show that their natural explanations for phenomena is very powerful.

Speaker 5The paranormal groups that went in there after I did certainly found a lot more ghosts than I.

Speaker 4Did, not surprised.

Speaker 2Yeah, well, thanks for sharing this story with us.

Speaker 4Yeah, that's a good one so much.

Speaker 5I was glad to be a part of it, and I appreciate you guys having me on.

Speaker 2Ormsle you've been listening to Monster Talk, the science show about monsters. I'm Blake Smith and I'm Karen Stolsner. You just heard an interview with Matt Baxter about his experiences researching the allegedly haunted manitouc Caverns near Manitou Springs, Colorado. Be sure to check out our show notes for links to the many of the things that we mentioned, and if you have a haunted or spooky cave you'd like to tell us about, drop us a line or hit the comments at Patreon. Hey Blake here. I'll be sitting sailed this July with Brian Dunning of the Skeptoid podcast

Speaker 2as part of his Skeptoid Adventure series. If you want to join us, check the show notes or google Skeptoid Adventure, but you need to book passage.

Speaker 3By April to be a part of it.

Speaker 2You'll get lots of details about the Bermuda Triangle while traveling in the Bermuda Triangle, and I'll be doing a live reading of a spooky nautical ghost story at sea, And if you sign up for the day trip to Key West, I'll tell you all about Robert the Doll and then you can see him for yourself. I hope you can join us. Monster Talk theme music's by Beach Stealing Monkeys.

Speaker 6You see, there is something out there which threatens our very existence and maybe the into the human race as we know it. I'm talking, of course about Man Bear Pig.

Speaker 1Maybe this has been a monster house presentation.

Speaker 5Is basically equals the Force from Star Trek or Starry Star.

Speaker 2Wars, and you're fired. Send your mail to Matt at Must You Talk dot org.

Speaker 3Yeah, lost my card, lost my card right there,

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S06E07 Elizabeth Taylor and the Burton of Truth

    Nov 16, 202655 minAudio

    Karen sets up this episode, joined once again by Matt Baxter, with a question that has nagged her since childhood. Sometime in the 1990s, on Australian television, she saw a reenactment of Elizabeth Taylor and Richard...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S06E06 🐈⬛Evil Cats and Revelatory Revenants👻

    Nov 9, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen welcome back historian Dr. Joseph Gagné, a specialist in New France who teaches the colony's history at Université Laval, for a seasonal visit to the winter of 1704. That year, a French and allied...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S06E05🎃 Live 2026 Halloween Show

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Blake, Karen, and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter gather on Halloween eve for MonsterTalk's annual live show. The agenda: micro-horror, meaningful coincidences, a stranger who would not stop calling, and the most...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S06E04 🍿Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    🍿 S06E04 - Capturing Bigfoot Reaction 🫈 Last week Blake and Karen spoke with director Marq Evans before any of them had seen his film. Now they have. Karen Stollznow and paranormal investigator Matt Baxter join Blake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S06E03 🎥 Capturing Bigfoot 🫈with Marq Evans

    Oct 19, 202647 minAudio

    Blake and Karen interview Marq Evans, directory of the new documentary Capturing Bigfoot - a new film that hits streaming October 20th, 2026 and features stunning new evidence that the Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot Film may...

    Credit the people on this episode